The Candice Malcolm Show - June 10, 2022


Trudeau’s narrative on the use of the Emergencies Act continues to crumble

Topics
Hosted by
Mentioned
Trudeau and Singh should be shaking in their boots over Conservative membership numbers Pierre Poilievre vindicated as Bank of Canada admits his criticisms were legitimate

Episode Stats


Length

45 minutes

Words per minute

185.41

Word count

8,355

Sentence count

447

Harmful content

Misogyny

5

sentences flagged

Toxicity

10

sentences flagged

Hate speech

1

sentences flagged


Summary

Summaries generated with gmurro/bart-large-finetuned-filtered-spotify-podcast-summ .

The Trudeau government s narrative about its decision to invoke the Emergencies Act continues to crumble, and the strain of derangement syndrome reaches a new level in the legacy media. It s Fake News Friday with Candice and Harrison Faulkner.

Transcript

Transcript generated with Whisper (turbo).
Misogyny classifications generated with MilaNLProc/bert-base-uncased-ear-misogyny .
Toxicity classifications generated with s-nlp/roberta_toxicity_classifier .
Hate speech classifications generated with facebook/roberta-hate-speech-dynabench-r4-target .
Topics generated with Qwen2.5-3B-Instruct.
Hosts, guests, and mentioned names generated with spaCy (en_core_web_sm), reconciled against Wikidata.
00:00:00 The Trudeau government's narrative about its decision to invoke the Emergencies Act
00:00:03 continues to crumble, and poly of derangement syndrome reaches a new level in the legacy
00:00:08 media.
00:00:09 It's Fake News Friday, I'm Candice Malcolm, and this is The Candice Malcolm Show.
00:00:24 Hi everyone, thank you so much for tuning into the podcast this week, and as usual,
00:00:28 I am joined by my colleague Harrison Faulkner, producer at True North and a journalist as
00:00:33 well.
00:00:34 Harrison, welcome to the program.
00:00:35 Thanks for having me, Candice.
00:00:37 So we have a couple of announcements, some big changes, big news happening here at True
00:00:42 North.
00:00:42 We continue to grow, we continue to reach more and more Canadians every single week, every
00:00:46 single month.
00:00:47 The growth that we've seen so far in 2020 is truly astonishing.
00:00:50 We've nearly doubled our size since last year, and last year was also a great year for us.
00:00:55 We covered the election, we continue to grow, we hit all kinds of things.
00:00:58 So we just continue to grow.
00:01:01 I think there's so many Canadians out there who have an appetite for something different
00:01:05 from the legacy media.
00:01:06 They like the independence of True North.
00:01:08 They don't want to have talking points crammed down their throat, and they see that there
00:01:13 is something wrong with the way that the media tells a story.
00:01:15 So just to say we're really happy with the direction True North is going, and again, to
00:01:21 the audience, people tuning in, just thank you so much for your support, for continuing
00:01:26 to tune in, to share our stories, those who financially support us.
00:01:29 We are incredibly grateful.
00:01:31 We receive all of our money from our viewers.
00:01:33 We don't take money from the government.
00:01:35 We don't take the Trudeau government's bailout grants.
00:01:37 We're not involved in any of those schemes.
00:01:39 So the way that we are funded is entirely by people who appreciate our journalism, enjoy
00:01:43 our reports, and put their wallets where they're, back it up with their wallets.
00:01:49 And we truly do appreciate that.
00:01:51 So Harrison, we have a couple of new podcasts that we are introducing.
00:01:56 Folks might have seen Rupa Subramania.
00:01:59 She launched her own podcast.
00:02:00 We're incredibly overjoyed to be joined by her at the network.
00:02:04 She's a writer over at the National Post and a freelance journalist, and she does some
00:02:08 great work.
00:02:08 She lives in Ottawa, and she covered the Trekker Convoy, I think, better than just about anybody.
00:02:13 So she had her first episode this week.
00:02:15 If you haven't tuned in already, go check that out right after you watch this show.
00:02:19 It was really, really great.
00:02:20 She talked about the World Economic Forum and sort of drilling down into what they do,
00:02:25 what they want to do.
00:02:26 And same with the World Health Organization, talking about these two supposedly taboo topics
00:02:30 that we're not supposed to talk about.
00:02:32 These really, you know, powerful lobby groups, essentially, that want to coordinate global
00:02:37 policy.
00:02:38 So Rupa does a deep dive into that.
00:02:39 And then we're really pleased yesterday to release another brand new show.
00:02:44 This one hosted by you, Harrison.
00:02:46 Harrison Faulkner, Ratioed.
00:02:48 So why don't you tell us a little bit about your new show, Harrison?
00:02:50 Yeah, so it is basically going to be a social media commentary show.
00:02:56 We're going to go into some of the worst takes of the week, some of the cringiest social media
00:03:00 posts.
00:03:01 We're going to laugh, make fun of some of these posts, and we're also going to provide some
00:03:05 much-needed commentary.
00:03:06 I made this point on the show yesterday, Candice, that social media really is the new cultural
00:03:12 battleground for these issues.
00:03:13 And I think True North recognizes that and wants to make sure that our audience can get
00:03:20 some good coverage on what's going on on these social media feeds.
00:03:22 Because, I mean, there's just so much content.
00:03:25 As you know, when we have this show every week, we pretty much have too much content to get
00:03:29 into.
00:03:29 So we're going to try and tackle that issue by creating this new show, Ratioed.
00:03:35 So I'm super excited to have the opportunity and really looking forward to having the show
00:03:40 grow and be a serious part of what we offer here at True North.
00:03:43 Well, we're all really excited about it, Harrison.
00:03:46 You're part of Generation Z, or I don't know what you call yourselves, Gen Z or iGen.
00:03:51 And I think part of the interesting thing about your show is tapping into the sort of zeitgeist
00:03:57 among your generation, pointing out some of the sort of very extreme woke ideology that
00:04:03 does exist in your age group, which is, I don't think, the norm.
00:04:06 I don't think that's sort of where the average, moderate, young Canadian is.
00:04:12 But sort of seeing the sort of stuff that they put out there about themselves and sort
00:04:16 of how out of tune it is with the rest of the Canadian population.
00:04:21 Tell us about the title, Ratioed.
00:04:23 What does that mean?
00:04:24 Well, so Ratioed is basically when a social media post gets way more comments or way more
00:04:30 quote tweets than likes.
00:04:33 So it basically is the one big indicator that you miss the mark on social media if your post
00:04:38 gets ratioed.
00:04:39 And I think, Candace, you raise a good point there about how this is what our generation
00:04:44 is talking about.
00:04:44 We are paying attention now to what these, I mean, frankly, you could call them, there
00:04:50 are radicals out there that are pushing very extreme political agendas on social media,
00:04:55 and they have no shame in putting it out there.
00:04:57 So we just want to try and talk about it, show people what is being said.
00:05:02 And I think the rise of accounts like libs of TikTok, if you've seen them on Twitter,
00:05:06 posting these videos of these teachers talking about gender ideology or what else, whatever
00:05:12 sort of radical political movement is in style, usually it gets picked up by these accounts.
00:05:19 And there's a real appetite for people to talk about these things and to show people just
00:05:23 how insane things are getting in this generation.
00:05:25 So like I said, I mean, I think it's what our audience wants.
00:05:29 It's a new opportunity for us to break into a new audience group as well, a new demographic,
00:05:34 which I think is valuable for everyone.
00:05:36 And I think it's just much needed content, really looking forward to it.
00:05:40 Well, one of the things that I find really interesting is that the media has really picked
00:05:44 up on this woke culture and they've sort of channeled it.
00:05:47 And a lot of them have taken it on, you know, not just media, but big corporations, corporate
00:05:51 Canada, you start to see these strange phenomenons where, you know, people put their pronouns in
00:05:56 their bios and, you know, all of these sort of woke critical race theory concepts creeping
00:06:03 into corporate governance.
00:06:05 But at the same time, I noticed that when it comes to polling, right, young Canadians, people
00:06:10 in their 20s were very against the lockdowns.
00:06:13 They were very, they were the most, the group most likely to support the truckers and support
00:06:18 the sentiment behind the truckers.
00:06:20 And we've seen with just someone like Pierre Polyev, the huge reach that he's been able
00:06:23 to have with this sort of younger group of Canadians.
00:06:26 So I wonder, Harrison, do you think the woke culture sort of represents your generation or
00:06:32 do you think it's a deviation and that it's unfair to categorize all sort of Gen Z Canadians
00:06:38 as part of this woke tribe?
00:06:40 So I think it's definitely unfair to put us all into the extreme woke category, because
00:06:46 I think that there's a huge rebound effect with all of this.
00:06:50 The more extreme you go, the more people will eventually, I guess, get off the ship and realize
00:06:55 just what, just what a disaster it was.
00:06:57 And you push people to the edges.
00:06:59 And I've seen polling and data that shows that the younger generation, a generation even
00:07:04 below me is supposed to be one of the most conservative because they've been, they've
00:07:08 been forced to listen to teachers, tell them insane things, or they're forced to watch things
00:07:13 on TV that they know is just not right.
00:07:16 So I think that there's definitely a rebound effect, right?
00:07:19 If you, if you keep pushing too far, eventually people are going to come to their senses and
00:07:23 realize actually, hold on, this is, this is actually insane.
00:07:26 This is not at all what, this is not at all what we want for our society and for our life.
00:07:31 And you were right about the trucker convoy, because of course, young people have to get 1.00
00:07:36 out, they have to get jobs, and they're not going to be getting corporate cushy jobs where
00:07:40 they can work from home necessarily.
00:07:42 Usually that requires them to maybe working in retail or work at a restaurant.
00:07:47 And if you shut everything down, or you force people to, for example, take a vaccine to get
00:07:53 a job, that is going to have some sort of negative backlash.
00:07:56 And of course, younger people are going to take issue with it when they're the ones that
00:08:00 end up paying the price.
00:08:01 So I know you've talked about this on your show about how actually the younger generations
00:08:06 are oftentimes the most affected by these lockdowns, by these policies.
00:08:10 I know that when you talked to Matt Strauss, he said that as well.
00:08:13 And I think it's the case that there is, you know, if tapping into the nerve of younger
00:08:20 Canadians who are really frustrated, really disappointed by the direction of the country,
00:08:24 there's a lot to be done there.
00:08:26 And there's a lot of people that want this sort of content.
00:08:29 Well, that's so great.
00:08:30 Ray showed with Harrison Faulkner, we're so excited to be hosting that.
00:08:33 It's going to be every Thursday.
00:08:35 So after you check out this episode, after you check out the Rupa Supermania show, go check
00:08:39 out Ray showed with Harrison Faulkner is going to air every single Thursday here at True
00:08:44 North.
00:08:45 And so just final bit of announcements here at True North.
00:08:49 So before for the last year and a half, the Candace Malcolm show has run every single day,
00:08:53 Monday to Friday, and we've had so much fun putting that together.
00:08:56 We are scaling the show back for the time being.
00:08:59 So the Rupa Supermania show will fill the block on Tuesday, Ray showed with Harrison Faulkner
00:09:04 on Thursday.
00:09:05 We're going to be bringing in some new content as well to fill those slots.
00:09:09 And part of the reason why is because I'm excited to announce my husband and I are expecting
00:09:14 baby number three at our household.
00:09:16 And so I will be taking time off starting this summer to be with my family, with my newborn
00:09:22 and with my two other little kids.
00:09:24 So that is why Candace Malcolm show won't be every day, won't be won't be on at all after
00:09:29 July.
00:09:30 And we're going to fill the slot in with lots and lots of other content at True North.
00:09:35 And then I'll be back on the channel sometime later this year or early next year.
00:09:40 And so we're all very, very excited.
00:09:43 And we're going to continue to provide lots and lots of content to True North viewers.
00:09:47 So with that, let's get to fake news Friday, Harrison.
00:09:50 I think the big, big story of the week was that the Trudeau government's narrative around
00:09:56 the Emergencies Act and around the trucker convoy just continues to crumble every single
00:10:02 week, every single day with this, with this national inquiry, we learn things that just
00:10:06 don't match with what the liberals were saying at the time, don't match with the liberal media
00:10:12 narrative that was being spouted at the time.
00:10:14 And we have yet another example this week.
00:10:16 So this story just came out yesterday, Marco Medicino, the public safety minister, the media
00:10:24 tells us that he was, he was just misunderstood.
00:10:26 He was misunderstood when he said that the police asked for the Emergencies Act.
00:10:30 So you will recall that Marco Medicino repeatedly told us that the reason that the government
00:10:35 invoked the Emergencies Act wasn't because of Trudeau, it wasn't because of a liberal
00:10:38 decision, it had nothing to do with partisanship, nothing to do with Trudeau's personal hatred
00:10:42 for these truckers.
00:10:43 It was all just the liberals were taking advice from law enforcement.
00:10:48 And so really, it was a law enforcement that made the decision and not the political operatives
00:10:52 in the liberal government.
00:10:54 Well, we have heard over and over again now that that's not true.
00:10:57 Every single law official, law enforcement official that has taken the stand in this
00:11:02 national inquiry has said, no, that's not the case.
00:11:04 And so the headline this week isn't that Marco Medicino was wrong.
00:11:08 It wasn't that he lied and he misled the public and he misrepresented the situation.
00:11:14 It wasn't even that he misspoke.
00:11:16 It's that he was misunderstood.
00:11:18 So he didn't have a misunderstanding.
00:11:21 You did.
00:11:21 He was misunderstood.
00:11:22 And this is according to an official in the bureaucracy in his department.
00:11:27 Everyone is covering for this liberal government.
00:11:29 It is truly wild.
00:11:31 So we put together some clips for you.
00:11:34 First of all, this is a clip of Marco Medicino, who repeatedly said that the reason that the
00:11:39 government invoked the Emergencies Act is because they were just following what the law enforcement
00:11:44 said.
00:11:44 Here is that clip.
00:11:45 We invoked the Act because it was the advice of nonpartisan professional law enforcement.
00:11:53 That's the reason why we had to invoke the Emergencies Act, and we did so on the basis
00:11:57 of nonpartisan professional advice from law enforcement.
00:12:00 We were following the advice of various levels of law enforcement, including the RCMP.
00:12:07 After calling upon the police forces, we invoked the Emergency Measures Act.
00:12:11 We wanted to be sure at bottom that we were giving law enforcement all of the tools and
00:12:17 the resources that they needed.
00:12:20 It was only after police told us that they needed this special power.
00:12:25 The Ontario Association, the Canadian Association, law enforcement was very strong.
00:12:33 I don't want to speak for every last serving member of law enforcement, but there was a very
00:12:38 strong consensus that we needed to invoke the act.
00:12:41 A strong consensus that we need to invoke the act.
00:12:43 You can hear him say it over and over again, that it wasn't his decision, Harrison.
00:12:47 It wasn't the liberal government.
00:12:48 It wasn't anything to do with petty politics.
00:12:50 He was just taking advice from the people who run the law enforcement side of things.
00:12:56 Do you think he was misunderstood?
00:12:57 What do you think of this take from the media?
00:13:00 Well, Candace, I don't know how many times you can be misunderstood before it turns on the
00:13:04 person saying it.
00:13:06 It's not us who is misunderstood about what he's saying.
00:13:09 He seems to be mistaken about the actual course of events that he was a part of.
00:13:13 I mean, how many times have we seen this?
00:13:15 I've been all over the inquiry and posting clips on my Twitter trying to get the message
00:13:19 out there.
00:13:19 Because one thing I've noticed is that aside from what we're covering here, Candace,
00:13:23 there's not a lot of coverage happening on the inquiry.
00:13:26 People are not reacting to the fact that, as you said at the beginning, Trudeau's narrative
00:13:30 is totally crumbling apart.
00:13:32 And just because you can, you know, the minister can say that he acted on the basis of law
00:13:38 enforcement and the request of law enforcement.
00:13:39 But if the RCMP commissioner, if the Ottawa police chief, the former Ottawa police chief
00:13:44 who was fired because he wasn't doing enough, and the Gatineau mayor all say that they didn't
00:13:50 request the government to invoke the Emergencies Act, and they confirm it in the inquiry, then
00:13:56 it's clear, Candace, that this narrative is obviously just not the case.
00:14:01 What Trudeau is trying to do is find a scapegoat.
00:14:03 What the minister is trying to do is find a scapegoat other than himself to pin the blame 0.79
00:14:08 on this horrible mistake, to invoke this ridiculous measure.
00:14:13 I think, unfortunately for Marco Mendicino, he may be the one that gets thrown under the
00:14:18 bus, because this inquiry has definitely not gone the way the liberals wanted it to.
00:14:23 It seems that they're going into it.
00:14:25 They appointed the liberal justice, right, the former liberal staffer who's now a judge
00:14:29 to head the inquiry, and they had this probably mapped out in their minds about how they're
00:14:33 going to get out of it.
00:14:34 They're going to immediately start pinning the blame on the far right, on the extremists,
00:14:40 as they tried many times, and it hasn't gone that way.
00:14:43 The Bloc, the NDP even, and the conservatives, of course, and even the senators, almost all the
00:14:50 senators on the inquiry have been taking the liberals to task over this and expose their
00:14:54 narrative.
00:14:55 Well, we have a clip of those officials that you did mention, so you can juxtapose what
00:15:00 the minister is on camera saying repeatedly, that it was law enforcement that advised him,
00:15:04 and then now let's look at what those law enforcement agents say when they were asked to testify in
00:15:10 front of this inquiry.
00:15:10 Here's that clip.
00:15:11 As a law enforcement agency with primacy for national security, did you ask the government
00:15:16 or representatives for the invocation of the Emergencies Act?
00:15:19 No, there was never a question of requesting the Emergency Act.
00:15:24 There was a question that we consulted with.
00:15:26 Sorry, I don't mean to interrupt, but I'm sorry.
00:15:28 So you never asked for it.
00:15:30 Do you know of any other police leadership that asked specifically the government for
00:15:34 the invocation?
00:15:36 No, we actually reached out to various police agencies when there was talk about some of
00:15:40 the authorities within that they were proposing, and of course, we were consulted.
00:15:45 Did the Ottawa police make a request to the federal government to invoke the Emergencies
00:15:49 Measures Act, yes or no?
00:15:50 So we were involved in conversations with our partners and with the political ministries.
00:15:58 We didn't make a direct request for the Emergencies Act.
00:16:02 I'm wondering if you could confirm whether the city of Catano or its police services requested
00:16:09 the federal government to invoke the Emergencies Act during the Freedom Convoy.
00:16:19 Thank you very much for my question.
00:16:24 No, the city of Catano did not declare an emergency request to the Act, but it did provide
00:16:31 considerable support to the RCMP.
00:16:33 Did yourself or anyone in the OPS request the invocation of the Emergency Act?
00:16:40 I did not make that request.
00:16:42 I'm not aware of anybody else in the Ottawa police service who did.
00:16:44 So no one made the request?
00:16:46 No one's aware of anyone who made the request?
00:16:48 And to me, it kind of comes back to media coverage, because at the time, no one was holding
00:16:53 this government to account.
00:16:54 They had all bought into this idea that there was some kind of a January 6th moment coming 0.93
00:16:58 in Canada, and that these people were truly reprehensible, they were white supremacists, 0.98
00:17:02 they were probably all murderers, and they didn't need to stop. 0.97
00:17:06 So the media allowed them to get away with this.
00:17:09 And now, where it's time for some accountability, you're right, Harrison, they hardly cover this,
00:17:14 right?
00:17:14 It's not prime time.
00:17:15 It's not being covered on the news.
00:17:17 You go to CBC, National Post, Globe and Mail, any of these websites, they barely ever talk
00:17:22 about it.
00:17:23 And when they do, they run stories like this.
00:17:25 So this was over in the Canadian press, and they just repeat what the liberals want everyone
00:17:30 to know.
00:17:30 Mendicino was misunderstood when he said, please ask for the Emergencies Act, according to this
00:17:35 official.
00:17:36 It's all misunderstanding.
00:17:37 So they can't even bring themselves to say Mendicino is contradicted.
00:17:41 Mendicino is caught in a lie.
00:17:42 Mendicino's dishonesty is coming out.
00:17:44 No, none of that.
00:17:45 Just, again, very mild, very, you know, understated.
00:17:49 He was just misunderstood.
00:17:50 It wasn't even him that had the misunderstanding.
00:17:53 It was you, the public, or you, the, you know, the media, or it was someone else.
00:17:58 It was Canadians who misunderstood, not the minister.
00:18:02 So absolutely no accountability from the legacy media in the way that they are covering
00:18:07 this.
00:18:08 And you made this point a couple weeks ago on the show, Harrison, I think it's worth
00:18:11 repeating, that if this was in the US, if there was some kind of a unprecedented use
00:18:17 of the authority of the federal government, suspending civil rights as much as you can
00:18:22 in this country, using the entire force of the federal government, suspending all kinds
00:18:28 of other charter issues and everything.
00:18:31 And then there was an inquiry into it.
00:18:33 It would be prime time.
00:18:34 It would be on all of the news channels.
00:18:36 It would be a huge story, especially if it was against a conservative government or a
00:18:40 Republican government in the US.
00:18:42 I mean, we have an example of this right now.
00:18:44 There is a inquiry in the US into the January 6th riots.
00:18:49 This happened 18 months ago.
00:18:51 We pretty much have already gotten to the bottom of it and litigated it.
00:18:54 A bunch of people have gone to jail. 1.00
00:18:56 You know, 200 idiots stormed the Capitol. 1.00
00:18:59 And, you know, they're still dwelling on it, right? 1.00
00:19:01 And it is prime time.
00:19:02 The Democrats down there are trying to make it into this huge midterm election issue.
00:19:06 Again, compare that to here in Canada, where the Trudeau government did something really
00:19:11 unprecedented.
00:19:12 This emergency act had never been used before.
00:19:15 It's supposed to be there for wartime, you know, for an invasion or some kind of internal
00:19:21 uprising.
00:19:22 And yet, basically, no accountability.
00:19:27 It's such a stark difference in how the media treat liberals versus how they treat conservatives.
00:19:33 Completely.
00:19:34 And again, going back to the narrative that the law enforcement requested the act.
00:19:39 If the US government told the Canadian government to do this, or if the province of Ontario told
00:19:45 the Canadian government to do this, why not say that?
00:19:47 Just say to Canadians, in fact, we were instructed by the provinces and we were instructed by the
00:19:53 United States to do this.
00:19:54 Would that be fair justification?
00:19:55 Likely not.
00:19:56 But if that's the justification, if that's the truth, come out there and say it.
00:20:00 Like, don't pin the blame on the cops, who will then just tell the actual truth to the
00:20:05 people and say, no, we didn't request it.
00:20:06 And like you said, Candace, again, if this was a January 6th style committee, then the
00:20:11 liberals would be doing a lot better than they are.
00:20:14 I mean, the January 6th committee, to this day, are, I mean, they just basically shackled
00:20:19 a former Trump office administrator in an airport and did it in public and brought him in, basically
00:20:25 put him into, into the, into the brig because he was subpoenaed by the January 6th committee
00:20:31 and didn't show up.
00:20:32 So again, there's, there's a total difference, right?
00:20:35 The media coverage of the January 6th committee and the actions of that committee are, are
00:20:40 basically taking place and they're actually, you know, making serious headway, if you want
00:20:45 to call it that.
00:20:46 And this committee, which I think was designed to prop up the liberal narrative is totally
00:20:50 failing.
00:20:51 I mean, it's just exposing the entire, the entire debacle that was the emergencies act.
00:20:56 And throughout this whole time, Candace, we have to go through this long list of, of narratives
00:21:01 that the liberals have put out there about the emergencies act or about the events in
00:21:05 Ottawa that have since crumbled.
00:21:07 I mean, we can just go down the list.
00:21:08 Let's start with the wealthy donors from March 18, 2022, Blacklocks reported that in fact,
00:21:14 the, the wealthy foreign donors, Blacklocks reported that in fact, it was Canadians who donated
00:21:18 this line about it all being from America, from the American ultra rich right wing is
00:21:23 not the case.
00:21:24 It was proven false.
00:21:26 Another one, the RCMP saw no evidence of terrorist financing.
00:21:29 So again, we were told this is a, this is a terrorist act of foreign funding to, to incite,
00:21:34 cite some sort of government over, you know, government takeover turned out to be false.
00:21:40 Again, the next one, the convoy was funded by Canadians, not foreigners.
00:21:44 Like I said, they said, they said the convoy was funded by the Americans and by people
00:21:47 from around the world.
00:21:48 And it was actually just funded by the grassroots FinTrack, the financial advisor, they said
00:21:53 that, that they told the government that there was no ideologically motivated, violent
00:21:58 extremism that was funding, funding the event.
00:22:02 I mean, just, I'm not even going to go down the list.
00:22:04 I mean, there's so many of them, the firearms at Coutts, the arson attempt in Ottawa, the woman
00:22:09 who danced in the war monument.
00:22:10 Again, all of these sorts of things, all the, all the attempt by the liberals to paint this
00:22:14 convoy as something it wasn't are all starting to unravel.
00:22:19 Well, there was never anything there, there anyway.
00:22:21 And we knew that in real time, we were watching the convoy, the media reporting on it was like
00:22:26 a totally different event.
00:22:27 Whatever they were watching, they were cherry picking the craziest people they could find
00:22:30 and blowing stories out of proportion that were easily debunkable at the time.
00:22:34 And they have since been debunked.
00:22:36 And I'm very grateful for True North for going through and documenting that so that
00:22:40 we have it on record that, you know, just about every major narrative that the lead, that
00:22:44 the legacy media spun up from the Tucker Convoy has turned out to be wrong.
00:22:48 And right, when they created this national inquiry, the point was, why did the Trudeau government
00:22:53 use this tool that should have never been used?
00:22:56 Let's look into why the government used it.
00:22:59 Of course, Trudeau and his liberal spin doctors and his friends in the media painted it as if,
00:23:04 no, no, the purpose of this inquiry is to look into the truckers and try to find out what their
00:23:08 motives were and their ties to violent extremism and terrorism or whatever.
00:23:12 And so they set it up that way in the media, as if this was a national inquiry into the
00:23:18 truckers rather than a national inquiry into the politicians who used the full force of
00:23:22 government against the truckers.
00:23:25 And then to your point that you made about how Mark Manichino maybe get, maybe ending up
00:23:30 being thrown under the bus, it's like, you know, they created this show trial and it's
00:23:34 kind of backfiring on them because all of the information that comes out just keeps, they
00:23:38 keep shooting themselves in the foot.
00:23:40 It keeps becoming incredibly evident and obvious to Canadians that there was no real justification,
00:23:46 that it was all spin.
00:23:47 It was all smoke and mirrors.
00:23:49 And they continue to play this game.
00:23:51 Harrison, the latest this past week again, is that the government is now hiding behind cabinet
00:23:56 confidentiality.
00:23:57 So we've seen this over and over again, Harrison, where first we had the Attorney General, David
00:24:03 Lamedi, who basically just refuses to answer questions.
00:24:06 And whenever he's pressed, he says, look, that's cabinet, that's confidential, it's part
00:24:09 of, it's protected under cabinet confidentiality.
00:24:12 I guess I thought that line works so well that even Brenda Luckey, who is the RCMP commissioner,
00:24:17 tried to use it.
00:24:18 The only problem, of course, is that Luckey is not part of cabinet, so she wouldn't have
00:24:22 cabinet confidentiality.
00:24:23 We have some clips here of, as you can see, just more obfuscation, refusing to answer basic
00:24:29 questions, refusing to be clear and honest with the public about why they used, again,
00:24:36 this unprecedented tool in the government powers.
00:24:40 And fortunately, getting called out a little bit by conservatives on the committee.
00:24:46 So let's play that clip.
00:24:46 Is that correct?
00:24:47 I'm not going to betray cabinet confidence.
00:24:50 And so the financing measures came into place.
00:24:53 In those consultations, did you consult with provincial attorneys general?
00:24:58 There were, we did have a consultation report.
00:25:03 And there were, again, I'm not going to betray cabinet confidences.
00:25:09 I would ask that you undertake to provide the analysis and the information that you were
00:25:17 made aware of, that you relied upon to, you know, to be part of making the invocation
00:25:26 for this particular emergencies act, sir.
00:25:29 Thank you, Mr. Motz.
00:25:30 I understand the sentiment behind the question, and I certainly share the goal of transparency.
00:25:35 I think Canadians will understand that cabinet confidence is a critical part of our cabinet
00:25:42 governance system.
00:25:44 You know, we, we, I can't get into the details of specific discussions, but I can say that,
00:25:51 yeah.
00:25:51 Why can't we get into the details, Commissioner?
00:25:53 Sorry.
00:25:55 Well, because they were within cabinet, and I'm bound by that cabinet confidence.
00:26:01 But I can, I can talk about in general.
00:26:03 I provided the situational report, which would have provided them, uh, the details that
00:26:07 they needed to, uh, come up with some of the measures.
00:26:10 Are you still maintaining solicitor and client privilege?
00:26:13 Are you willing to waive that?
00:26:16 Well, I'm also bound by cabinet confidence as well.
00:26:19 You're not part of the cabinet.
00:26:21 You're not part of that confidence.
00:26:24 No, but I am when I provide them information in cabinet.
00:26:27 To be continued.
00:26:29 Oh, do I?
00:26:31 Seconds.
00:26:31 Oh.
00:26:31 Go ahead.
00:26:31 You're not part of cabinet.
00:26:35 You're not an elected official.
00:26:38 So why are you hiding behind cabinet confidentiality?
00:26:41 Canadians want to know.
00:26:43 I would just request that the, um, questions go through the chair rather than directly to
00:26:48 the witness.
00:26:50 I didn't think we were that formal, Madam Chair, that we had to say through the chair.
00:26:54 We weren't before the badgering, but now we are.
00:26:56 Can the witness answer the question?
00:26:58 Uh, we stopped the clock.
00:26:59 Okay, we'll go ahead.
00:27:00 It was 37 seconds.
00:27:02 Why do you feel you are bound by cabinet confidentiality as an unelected official?
00:27:07 When I'm providing information within cabinet, I'm bound by the rules of cabinet.
00:27:15 Are you part of the Liberal government, Ms. Lucky?
00:27:18 Not at all.
00:27:19 Are you a donor to the Liberal Party?
00:27:22 No.
00:27:23 You sure about that?
00:27:24 I'm sure.
00:27:25 Are you still citing cabinet confidentiality?
00:27:32 Yes.
00:27:32 So, Candace, as you can see there, they just have no interest in wanting to get to the bottom
00:27:37 of the facts.
00:27:38 They have no interest in trying to tell the truth.
00:27:40 You saw David Lametti there basically say the same thing in maybe five different ways
00:27:45 that, yeah, he understands that you want the answers.
00:27:48 He understands Canadians deserve the truth, but he's not going to give it to us.
00:27:51 He's going to hide behind cabinet confidence, cabinet confidentiality, as he says.
00:27:55 He doesn't want to divulge or break cabinet confidence.
00:27:59 And again, right at the end, you saw RCMP Commissioner Brenda Lucky try to hide behind
00:28:03 cabinet confidence, too, almost as if she kind of wishes she was a part of cabinet.
00:28:08 But she's not.
00:28:08 That's just the truth.
00:28:10 She's a public servant, unelected, and whose job it is to do good by the people of Canada,
00:28:15 not to serve the prime minister at the time.
00:28:18 That's not the role of the RCMP Commissioner.
00:28:20 The RCMP Commissioner's role is to basically lead the Federal Police Service
00:28:25 and protect Canadians.
00:28:27 And part of that is telling the truth.
00:28:29 And rightly, Larry Brock of the Conservative Party, who's a part of the committee,
00:28:34 and I have to say as well, both conservatives on the committee,
00:28:36 Glenn Motts and Larry Brock have both done an excellent job at trying to hold people's
00:28:40 feet to the fire here.
00:28:42 He just basically told Brenda Lucky straight up, you're not part of cabinet.
00:28:46 Why do you think you can hide behind cabinet confidence?
00:28:49 You're not actually bound by this cabinet confidence, so you have a duty to tell the truth.
00:28:53 But again, that doesn't work for Brenda Lucky. 1.00
00:28:56 And then, of course, Candace, they tried it one too many times.
00:28:59 Chalk it up as another win for the truckers.
00:29:01 The committee, headed by a liberal justice, as we talked about before,
00:29:05 is now telling the government that actually, we are going to request these documents.
00:29:10 We do have a duty to understand what the government knew at the time
00:29:14 and why they invoked the act.
00:29:16 So as you can see here, on June 3rd, True North wrote about the fact that the public inquiry
00:29:21 was now telling the government, we're going to request these documents from you.
00:29:25 We have to get to the bottom of what's going on.
00:29:27 So again, it's another L for Trudeau and the Liberals.
00:29:31 Their narrative is crumbling.
00:29:33 And their attempts to obfuscate, their attempts to hide,
00:29:36 are being called out by the liberal justice they handpicked to lead this process.
00:29:40 So it's really all falling apart for them, Candace.
00:29:42 Well, it's good to see someone is holding the liberal government to account.
00:29:47 It's too bad that our legacy media have no interest in covering it,
00:29:50 and which is why, again, I'm grateful for True North.
00:29:53 Well, Harrison, I want to talk about polyev derangement syndrome.
00:29:56 We had an entire episode of the show on it a few weeks ago, and it continues to thrive.
00:30:01 And so I covered this in my show earlier this week, an interview with Hamish Marshall,
00:30:05 where we talked about how the conservative numbers have just blown everyone's figures out of the park.
00:30:10 600,000 members, Pierre Polyev claims 311,958 on his website alone.
00:30:17 This is dwarfing any previous leadership race, any previous number of memberships sold by a political party.
00:30:25 And it's so interesting to see how the media narrative has been proven wrong, Harrison,
00:30:29 because remember, at first, when we saw those big rallies at the Pierre Polyev campaign,
00:30:34 the media sort of tried to downplay it.
00:30:36 They tried to dismiss it.
00:30:37 At first, they said that, oh, these big rallies are really just, you know, riding the coattails of the trekker convoy,
00:30:44 that these people aren't partisan, they're never going to sign up for members,
00:30:47 that Pierre's campaign is really disorganized, and they wouldn't be able to have the groundwork.
00:30:52 Well, that was all proven wrong, based on this claim from Jenny Byrne, Polyev's campaign advisor,
00:30:57 that no, no, all of those things are wrong.
00:31:00 Of course, my favorite narrative about the Pierre Polyev rallies with the media said that they were too white,
00:31:06 and that somehow discredited them because of the people,
00:31:09 the skin color of the people who go to your rallies apparently can be discrediting.
00:31:13 And so it's really interesting, of course, to compare how Polyev and the conservative leadership race in general,
00:31:19 you know, you see the media downplay it, compare it to how they covered Justin Trudeau.
00:31:23 A lot of people have been talking about this because back in 2013, Justin Trudeau claimed that his campaign
00:31:29 had signed up 150,000 to 160,000 people, and the media were, like, blown away.
00:31:34 They were celebrating.
00:31:35 They thought this was, like, a tremendous feat and that it showed how energetic Trudeau's fan base was
00:31:40 and how he was so engaging and how he had this big, all this momentum, right?
00:31:46 Recall that the liberals don't charge anything for their membership,
00:31:49 so all you really had to do was just, like, get someone to write down their name and email address,
00:31:53 and they didn't have to put any skin in the game, right?
00:31:55 Compare that to Pierre and the conservative party where you have to pay at least 15 bucks,
00:32:00 so you're not just some random person off the street.
00:32:02 You have to have that level of commitment to say,
00:32:04 I'm willing to part with some of my own money to show that I support this candidate.
00:32:08 So just so many aspects of what the media had said all along proving to be false,
00:32:13 but the media being the media, they just can't let it go,
00:32:16 and so they continue along this line, along this reasoning.
00:32:20 Almost all of the news stories that I saw about the conservative numbers,
00:32:24 they always say conservatives claim, or, you know, you see it right built into the headline
00:32:30 that this is a claim, that it's not verified, never trusted politician.
00:32:33 Don Iveson had a piece over in the National Post, and he said that no one really knows the real numbers.
00:32:39 It's a good rule of thumb in journalism to never believe anything that politicians or political parties say.
00:32:44 You have to be professional skepticism.
00:32:45 That's all well and good, and that is all true.
00:32:47 You do need to preface it, but the emphasis is there, right?
00:32:50 Just compare this to even just a story we just talked about, right?
00:32:53 Mendicino's out there changing a story, being contradicted left, right, and center,
00:32:57 and the media still runs with whatever the liberals say, that's the fact.
00:33:00 And then whenever a conservative says something, they always say allegedly,
00:33:03 or conservatives say, or candidates claim, having that suffix there just to say,
00:33:09 well, we just plant some doubt in the reader's mind, like, we don't really believe this.
00:33:13 This is just what they're saying.
00:33:15 And that double standard is there.
00:33:18 And then we have another piece, Harrison, from our friend Gary Mason over at the Globe and Mail.
00:33:21 He wrote the most arranged piece a couple of weeks ago about Pierre Polyev.
00:33:26 Well, he continues down that line, so I'll read a little bit from this column.
00:33:30 He says,
00:33:30 His campaign is a well-oiled machine, so he's sort of reluctantly saying that Pierre Polyev is good at his job.
00:33:43 Can't help but throwing in that apparently his policies range from disturbing to bonkers.
00:33:47 Okay. 0.98
00:33:47 And he says, basically, Pierre Polyev's good fortune his supporters don't see his own hypocrisy.
00:33:53 He says, this is my favorite line from the piece, 0.85
00:33:55 Mr. Polyev is also a phony when it comes to his policies.
00:33:59 His oft-stated intention to make Canada the freest country on earth 0.75
00:34:02 certainly had an appealing ring to the mostly white protesters
00:34:05 who participated in the self-described freedom convoy earlier this year,
00:34:08 to whom he pandered shamelessly.
00:34:11 So you can't even come up with anything neutral or, I mean, this is just flat-out
00:34:16 anti-conservative hatred and bigotry masquerading as journalism.
00:34:21 What do you make of all this, Harrison?
00:34:23 Well, it totally is, Candice.
00:34:25 And, I mean, this is just what we've come to expect over these past few months.
00:34:28 One thing I just don't really understand, though, is that you're seeing the same amount of,
00:34:33 you know, you're seeing the same sort of vitriol and the same amount of negative coverage
00:34:37 from the legacy media that you would see directed to people like Maxime Bernier.
00:34:42 Pierre Polyev's campaign is staffed by pretty establishment figures in conservative politics,
00:34:48 people who have been around for many years, who have names inside conservative politics,
00:34:52 and journalists know that.
00:34:53 Pierre Polyev is not running some outsider anti-establishment campaign.
00:34:58 He's very much running from the inside of the conservative party.
00:35:02 And it just so happens to be that right now, Canada is going through a major moment where
00:35:07 we have a leader that has essentially, you know, severely damaged the trust of government
00:35:12 and people and has shown them that their charter rights, frankly, aren't that protected.
00:35:17 So, of course, a good candidate is going to jump on that and make it part of his campaign.
00:35:21 But it's just it's just kind of weird to me that the legacy media have decided to attack
00:35:27 Pierre Polyev so much and almost go go as far as to put him in the same category as someone
00:35:32 like Maxime Bernier.
00:35:34 It's kind of surprising to me knowing who's a part of Pierre's campaign.
00:35:37 And of course, you know, we get the usual content from the Canadian press about how it's just
00:35:43 a claim that the conservatives could be lying about this or they could not be telling the
00:35:47 truth.
00:35:48 And of course, when you compare that to the coverage that Justin Trudeau gets or the
00:35:53 coverage that the liberals will get when they have some sort of event like this, it's
00:35:56 never the same.
00:35:57 And of course, the media wants to take some sort of negative tone toward the conservatives,
00:36:01 because as your as your show title on Wednesday really pointed out, this is frightening for
00:36:07 the liberals.
00:36:08 I mean, this is this is frightening for the legacy media, for liberals, for the establishment
00:36:12 in Canada.
00:36:13 They have to reconcile with the fact that I think people are fed up with what they've been
00:36:17 given by these people.
00:36:18 They don't want to see this sort of this sort of constant negative press about them in the
00:36:23 media.
00:36:24 They don't want to see the government treat them this way.
00:36:26 People are fed up and I think they know their time is coming to an end shortly.
00:36:29 Absolutely.
00:36:30 I think that so much of the momentum behind the poly of campaign and the conservative
00:36:33 movement more broadly is just an absolute dismay and disgust over this liberal government,
00:36:40 over the way that they've been propped up by the NDP, an unelected coalition, the way
00:36:45 that the legacy media lies and covers for this government and the attitude of the Trudeau liberals.
00:36:50 I think there are so many Canadians who are apolitical or nonpartisan, who watch from
00:36:55 afar, and they've just had enough.
00:36:57 They're sick of it.
00:36:58 And that is part of the reason why there is this huge movement.
00:37:01 And it's like these elites and these gatekeepers and these Laurentians who, you know, they're
00:37:07 grasping onto their control of the country and they're seeing it slip away because people
00:37:11 are really waking up to this idea that somehow the Trudeau government is a well-run, respectable
00:37:20 government.
00:37:20 It certainly isn't.
00:37:21 Well, Harrison, we wanted to end this show on a bit of a lighter note.
00:37:25 I don't know if this is a lighter, if this is depressing or if it's funny.
00:37:29 I find it kind of funny.
00:37:30 But the Treasury Board of Canada is promoting this weird new concept that we should all put
00:37:37 our pronouns into our email.
00:37:39 So this is what the Federal Treasury Board of Canada, the people who, you know, basically
00:37:45 the people who let inflation run wild and, you know, look at the state of the finances
00:37:50 in our country.
00:37:52 You're wondering what is going on over at the Treasury Department.
00:37:54 Well, this is what the brain trust over there are spending their time on, you know, informational
00:38:00 videos shaming Canadians and teaching us these good lessons about how we need to be more
00:38:06 inclusive.
00:38:07 So let's play this clip.
00:38:37 So there you have it, Harrison.
00:38:49 We would all be better off if we just, you know, left the ambiguity aside and left the
00:38:55 ambiguity aside and put our pronouns right out front and center so that we can all participate
00:39:01 in this weird identity game of sort of, you know, the whole gender, non-binary, gender
00:39:09 ideology that's all the rage on the far extreme left.
00:39:12 Well, now it's reached the Treasury Board.
00:39:15 What did you think when you saw this tweet?
00:39:17 It's such a strange corporate phenomenon, Candice, that basically everyone in a corporate gig or
00:39:24 a government gig needs to display their preferred pronouns by their name.
00:39:27 I think in pretty much every big company that is the policy, if you are, if you refuse, if
00:39:32 you hold out because you don't believe that you have to disclose whether or not you're
00:39:36 you, whether you go by he, him, or she, her pronouns like a normal person.
00:39:40 If you hold out like that, you're going to be, you're going to basically be for, you're
00:39:45 going to be pressured into doing it, or you're going to be shamed for not, for not adopting
00:39:49 this, uh, this so-called, well, it's, it's, it's in the name of inclusivity, of course,
00:39:53 but you're, you're not allowed to not do it.
00:39:55 And now the government is telling you that you have to do it.
00:39:57 It's just such a strange thing.
00:39:58 I think, I think in, in, hopefully in my lifetime, at some point, we're all going to look back
00:40:04 at this moment in time and just question what we were thinking.
00:40:07 I, I really hope this is not something that exists for forever and maybe we can kind of
00:40:11 get out of this weird moment that we're living through.
00:40:14 And I hope that we do have some time to reflect and say, wow, that's just very strange.
00:40:19 Just very strange that we're doing this all of a sudden.
00:40:22 Well, first of all, I find the idea of pronouns like fundamentally arrogant and narcissistic
00:40:27 because you're basically telling other people who you work with or whom you may interact
00:40:31 with, this is how you will refer to me when I'm not around, right?
00:40:34 This is, this is how like, like you will, you will refer to me as she and her.
00:40:39 You will not refer to me in any other way for 99.9% of the population.
00:40:43 It's, it's pretty obvious when you interact with someone and include, this includes trans
00:40:47 people, because if you were a man who wanted to appear like a woman, you would dress like
00:40:51 a woman and you would want people to refer to you using female pronouns. 1.00
00:40:56 So the vast, vast overwhelming majority of people fall into a very easily identified category,
00:41:02 he or she, and, and, and, you know, it's up to the discretion of the person.
00:41:06 Sure.
00:41:06 Sometimes there's some awkward interactions like the example of the treasury board where
00:41:09 someone has a gender neutral name, an ambiguous name.
00:41:14 Okay.
00:41:14 You know, fine.
00:41:15 You have an awkward little interaction like this email that we, that we saw, you know,
00:41:19 how is it the end of the world?
00:41:21 This, this more, this idea that, that everyone must call me what I say, you know, I thought
00:41:26 it was a passing trend on social media from a couple of years ago, like when the whole
00:41:29 Jordan Peterson, uh, you know, I refuse to be compelled to use pronouns.
00:41:34 I, I, I really thought that it was kind of going to come and go, but it seems like now
00:41:39 it's, it's, you know, it's not just the woke activists, but it's becoming more, like you
00:41:42 say, mainstream and corporate and government circles.
00:41:45 So we had the treasury board here.
00:41:47 Why don't you tell us a bit about this, uh, WestJet story.
00:41:49 That's, um, that's also making the headlines in the news.
00:41:53 Well, so of course we prep for the, we prep for the show, Candace, uh, the prep has to
00:41:59 be, you know, you do have to do a CBC scroll through because if you're ever short on content,
00:42:04 just hit the CBC website and you'll find something immediately.
00:42:07 And sure enough, before going to the air, we found this, this really strange CBC article
00:42:11 where a transgender advocate calls out WestJet for forcing passengers to identify as male
00:42:18 or female.
00:42:18 Uh, she's very upset about the fact that a WestJet is not allowing, uh, this, I, I, this
00:42:25 woman, I said, she, I don't want to misgender anyone.
00:42:28 So I want to be careful here, of course, be horrible to offend someone.
00:42:31 Uh, but she says that it's, it's a problem because she can't put X on her as her gender. 1.00
00:42:37 And that because of this WestJet is violating her human rights. 0.99
00:42:41 Now I have to say, I'm, I'm a bit of a fan of WestJet over these past few days.
00:42:45 The WestJet CEO has been pretty vocal about trying to drop Canada's totally punitive and
00:42:50 ridiculous travel restrictions.
00:42:52 Um, and then here, the CBC, maybe they're trying to get at WestJet for taking shots at
00:42:57 the government.
00:42:58 Uh, well now apparently they're violating, uh, people's human rights because they're not
00:43:03 allowing them to put X as their gender.
00:43:05 God forbid.
00:43:06 They, they just, they just want to keep it male and female. 0.77
00:43:09 Um, not allowed to do that in mainstream Canadian culture anymore, Candace.
00:43:12 It, you know, you're right that the CBC is so out of touch.
00:43:16 It's so easy to just pop on over to the site and you could do an entire episode just on
00:43:19 whatever's on the front page there, but really trying to push these very extreme niche issues.
00:43:25 I think turning most Canadians off in the process because no one's really, uh, you're jumping
00:43:30 up and down saying, yes, someone's human rights are being fundamentally violated because
00:43:34 they're not allowed to identify as gender X.
00:43:37 Uh, that's, that's not really the top, uh, you know, of all the things going on in the
00:43:41 world, we've got inflation, we've got a looming recession, we've got a government with out
00:43:45 of control spending.
00:43:46 We, we have a fundamentally unserious prime minister, you know, for all the things to
00:43:50 worry about in Canada, um, oh, not, not to mention any of the COVID stuff.
00:43:55 Uh, I don't think that, that someone not being able to mark X as gender on a WestJet
00:43:59 website, uh, is really top of mind to most Canadians.
00:44:02 Well, I think that's a good point to end it, Harrison.
00:44:04 Thanks for joining fake news Friday.
00:44:06 We're really excited about your new show ratioed with Harrison Faulkner, which airs every Thursday
00:44:10 here at true north.
00:44:11 So Harrison, great to have you on the show.
00:44:12 Thanks for joining us.
00:44:14 Thank you, Candace.
00:44:15 All right.
00:44:15 That's Harrison Faulkner.
00:44:16 I'm Candace Malcolm.
00:44:17 It's fake news Friday on the Candace Malcolm show.
00:44:34 Yeah.
00:44:36 Bye.
00:44:37 Bye.
00:44:39 Bye.
00:44:39 Bye.
00:44:40 Bye.
00:44:40 Bye.
00:44:45 Bye.
00:44:45 Bye.
00:44:47 Bye.
00:45:00 Bye.
00:45:00 Bye.
00:45:01 Bye.