The Candice Malcolm Show - February 10, 2025


What Trudeau’s hot mic comments really reveal

Topics
Hosted by
Mentioned
DEFUND Foreign Aid Is Canada’s independence at risk?

Episode Stats


Length

1 hour and 1 minute

Words per minute

198.74

Word count

12,196

Sentence count

553

Harmful content

Misogyny

1

sentences flagged

Toxicity

2

sentences flagged

Hate speech

7

sentences flagged


Summary

Summaries generated with gmurro/bart-large-finetuned-filtered-spotify-podcast-summ .

Candice Malcolm is joined by Paige Mcpherson to discuss Justin Trudeau's so-called "hot mic moment" at an economic summit, the media's reaction to it, and why Mark Carney is gaining ground in the polls.

Transcript

Transcript generated with Whisper (turbo).
Misogyny classifications generated with MilaNLProc/bert-base-uncased-ear-misogyny .
Toxicity classifications generated with s-nlp/roberta_toxicity_classifier .
Hate speech classifications generated with facebook/roberta-hate-speech-dynabench-r4-target .
Topics generated with Qwen2.5-3B-Instruct.
Hosts, guests, and mentioned names generated with spaCy (en_core_web_sm), reconciled against Wikidata.
00:00:00 Hi, I'm Candice Malcolm and this is The Candice Malcolm Show. Thank you so much everyone for
00:00:11 joining us. I hope you had a wonderful weekend. Hopefully you had a chance to reconnect, to have
00:00:15 some downtime with your family and with your loved ones. Okay, we have a ton of news to get
00:00:20 to. I'm going to run through everything that's happening in the world of Canadian federal news.
00:00:24 We're going to talk about Justin Trudeau and his so-called hot mic moment on Friday. We'll
00:00:29 talk about Pierre Polyev's reaction, talk about Mark Carney and how he's gaining in the polls,
00:00:34 talk about the media reaction to everything that's happening because I think a lot of it
00:00:38 is being manufactured to benefit the Liberal Party of Canada, to benefit Mark Carney and to make sure
00:00:43 that we continue to have liberal rule in this country. And we're going to talk about the liberal
00:00:50 leadership race as well. And for this episode, I'm really pleased to be joined by a friend of mine
00:00:55 named Paige McPherson. Paige is the Associate Director of Education Policy at the Fraser Institute.
00:01:00 Prior to joining Fraser Institute, you might remember her. She was the Alberta Director of
00:01:03 the Canadian Taxpayers Federation, went on to become the Atlantic Director because her family moved from
00:01:09 Alberta all the way out to the East Coast. And prior to that, another Sun alumni joining the show,
00:01:14 Paige McPherson was a TV host and a politics reporter back in the day at the Sun News Network. So Paige,
00:01:20 thank you so much for joining the podcast today. Yeah, thanks so much for having me. I'm happy to
00:01:24 be here. And Paige and I are part of a very special club because we are both moms of four kids,
00:01:30 four little kids as well. I think Paige, your newest is only three months old. So congratulations
00:01:34 on that. Yes, thank you. It's the best club to be in. It is. I know. I love being a mom. I think being
00:01:41 a reporter, being a journalist is like the best job. But being a mom is just like the most important
00:01:46 thing that a woman can do and definitely the most important part of my life. So we'll get to that.
00:01:50 Well, we're going to talk about mom stuff later in the episode, but let's start by talking about
00:01:54 politics. So I'm going to start by walking the viewers through what has happened. So Friday,
00:01:59 we had our interview with Preston Manning. Go check out that episode. It was really interesting to hear.
00:02:05 I think Preston is like the godfather of populism and the sort of grassroots conservative movement in
00:02:10 Canada. So many of the things happening in the U.S. I think have already happened in Canada,
00:02:13 like a great populist awakening happened in Canada in the 90s. And it's happening with Trump and the
00:02:19 America Make America Great Again movement. So anyway, interesting episode. I encourage you to
00:02:25 check that out. Yes, around the same time as we were filming, Justin Trudeau was speaking to an
00:02:31 economic summit in Toronto. So he was speaking to nearly 200 business industry and union leaders.
00:02:38 At one point during this conference or summit, he told the media to get out of the room. So he ushered
00:02:44 media out. And then he basically told the crowd what he really thought. And we call this a hot mic
00:02:50 moment, even though I think that it was all deliberate. I think that he knew that someone
00:02:54 in the audience would be recording or that the media would find a way to continue to record him.
00:02:58 That's exactly what happened because pretty much every media outlet reported it right away. They
00:03:02 didn't have, you know, it perfectly on screen in a camera. We're going to show it to you. But everybody
00:03:07 got the audio. So Trudeau can be heard saying that when President Donald Trump is talking about annexing
00:03:15 Canada and making Canada the 51st state, it is not a joke. He is serious. He actually really does want
00:03:21 to absorb Canada. And the reason is his desire to obtain our country's critical minerals. So here is
00:03:30 how the CBC put it together. You'll see Justin Trudeau up on stage and you'll see how he tells the media
00:03:35 to go. And then they have the audio footage of what he said at that point. So let's play that clip.
00:03:41 Ask our friends from the media to please.
00:03:46 But Mr. Trump has it in mind that one of the easiest ways of doing that is
00:03:51 and it is the real thing in my conversation with him on.
00:03:58 With the RBC Avion Visa, you can book any airline, any flight, any time. So start ticking off your
00:04:09 travel list. Grand Canyon? Grand. Great Barrier Reef? Great. Galapagos? Galapago? Switch and get up to
00:04:19 55,000 Avion points that never expire. Your idea of never missing out happens here. Conditions apply.
00:04:26 Visit rbc.com slash Avion.
00:04:32 You could hear him say, and I know it was kind of hard to see, but he's basically saying that Trump
00:04:37 is serious. And in his conversations, he's serious about it. He says that I'd suggest that not only
00:04:42 does the Trump administration know how many critical minerals we have, but that may be very much a part
00:04:48 of why they keep talking about absorbing us and making us the 51st state. And so you can see our
00:04:55 friend JJ McCullough, he commented about this on X and he said this, he said, this is deranged
00:05:02 conspiracy mongering from Trudeau. I expect, I suspect he has absolutely zero evidence for believing
00:05:10 this. And so you kind of have to wonder why is Trudeau out there talking about this all of a sudden?
00:05:17 Because recall that over the last month, whenever it came to talking about Trump,
00:05:21 he would just kind of laugh it off. He would say that Trump isn't being that serious,
00:05:25 that this is just part of the negotiation. And he didn't take it that seriously. And then here,
00:05:30 all of a sudden, you know, February 7th, he's out there saying, no, no, no, this is actually really
00:05:34 serious. And they want Canada because they want our minerals. I think that it has something to do
00:05:39 with Steve Bannon. So I mentioned this on my show with Preston Manning on Friday. On Thursday,
00:05:45 Steve Bannon, who was a former senior Trump advisor, sort of one of the main leading people in the
00:05:51 MAGA movement back in 2016. He's not really involved in the campaign from best I can tell
00:05:55 or in the administration at this point, but he was quite involved before. He was on Global News in
00:06:00 Canada. And he was talking about how Canada, especially the Arctic and the North, is what
00:06:05 it's all about. The geopolitical war or whatever we're shaping up here between the great superpowers of
00:06:13 the world, China, Russia, the United States, it's all going to be about access to the North. And he
00:06:18 was talking about the geopolitical importance, the strategic importance of the North and about
00:06:23 Canada. So I want to play this clip. This is from Thursday, February 6th. China and Russia, the great
00:06:30 powers and the United States fighting it out over the Arctic with the vast resources of the Arctic is
00:06:37 going to be the new great game of the 21st century. Canada, you are thrust into the middle of that.
00:06:41 And quite frankly, you are the greatest, I don't know, target or prize. You're the great prize of
00:06:49 that. So that's Steve Bannon, we can cut it there. That's Steve Bannon talking about it. And it was
00:06:54 just the very next day, right, that Trudeau was out there saying that actually it's all about minerals
00:06:58 and we should take Trudeau, we should take Trump very seriously when he's talking about annexing Canada.
00:07:05 Now, I think personally, I think that this is all sort of manufactured and drummed up. I think that the
00:07:09 media would much rather be talking about Donald Trump that, you know, we're coming into an election,
00:07:14 presumably an election is going to happen very soon. And I think that the elites, the media,
00:07:19 the liberals would all rather be talking about Trump than talking about Canada, than talking
00:07:25 about what has happened in our country over the last 10 years under Justin Trudeau liberal rule,
00:07:29 whether it's crime, whether it's safety on our streets, immigration, cost of living, inflation,
00:07:36 whether it's talking about spending and balancing the budgets and the outlook for our economy.
00:07:41 I don't think that they want to talk about any of that because on any of those issues,
00:07:44 conservatives win. But if the issue of the election is about Donald Trump, is about who can
00:07:51 stand up for Canada, polls actually show us that Canadians trust the liberals more on this issue.
00:07:57 So the Global Mail put out a piece on Friday saying that Canadians believe that Mark Carney would be
00:08:02 better than Pierre Polyev in dealing with Trump. And so that was a poll conducted by Nanos Research
00:08:08 in the field from January 31st to February 3rd. It showed that about 40% of Canadians believe that
00:08:13 Mark Carney is the most qualified to negotiate with Trump. Only 26% of Canadians consider Mr. Polyev the best
00:08:20 for that role, and then 12% for Chrystia Freeland. So it really makes you wonder that is this whole thing
00:08:28 just kind of manufactured. It seems like it was pretty coordinated that Trudeau decided,
00:08:32 hey, I'm going to make it about, I'm going to talk about minerals. I'm going to talk about how the
00:08:36 fact that the United States are actually serious about taking us over. It just so happens that that's
00:08:41 an issue that the liberals do very well on. Now, I know, Paige, you focus on education policy at the
00:08:45 Fraser Institute, and probably, you know, I don't know if you want to comment on all of the politics
00:08:51 behind it. But what do you take about the idea that Canadians are heading to the polls, heading to
00:08:55 the election, presumably? Like, what do you think the main issue facing Canadians should be?
00:08:59 Yeah, it's really interesting, you know, as sort of a policy wonk type observing this discussion that's been
00:09:05 going on, and all the kind of hysteria over the sort of the trade issue, and the back and forth and how it's
00:09:12 been covered in the media. And it's obviously no secret that in Canada, we, we like to really heavily focus on
00:09:17 what's happening in the US and focus on Donald Trump, we're so culturally influenced. But when
00:09:22 this trade tariff issue was going on, for example, I think there was a few of us that were sort of
00:09:26 banging our heads against the wall, saying a number of things, you know, like, wouldn't a pipeline be
00:09:31 nice right now, you know, pipelines that were not approved, that would make us more energy
00:09:35 independent as a country, and make it easier as well for us to export our product to other markets,
00:09:42 we're heavily dependent on the United States. Wouldn't that be nice right now? But that goes to,
00:09:48 you know, years and years of regulatory policy around the oil sands around mining, all of these
00:09:55 different projects, you know, that don't get off the ground because of government intervention, because
00:09:59 it isn't really an investment friendly environment, stuff like that. There's also, you know, supply
00:10:03 management in Canada, like, wouldn't that be a nice thing to talk about the supply management of our
00:10:08 dairy products that makes dairy products for Canadian families so much more expensive,
00:10:12 than families in the United States that have a more open market? Why aren't we talking about that?
00:10:17 There's also interprovincial trade barriers. I mean, it's pretty frustrating that we're talking
00:10:21 about trade with the US, which is obviously extremely important. It's our largest trading partner, but we
00:10:25 have, you know, barriers that exist between our own provinces. Let's talk about tearing some of those
00:10:31 down. And then of course, the issue of taxes, and just the fact that we have a real challenge around
00:10:38 economic growth in this country, that we need to get a hold of. And, you know, we've got out of control,
00:10:45 inflation as a result of government spending, and that really just has not been controlled in a number of years. And
00:10:52 that goes to all levels of government. But there's also the tax environment where we do see a really high tax burden
00:10:59 relative to other jurisdictions. And that brings into question, you know, why would businesses invest
00:11:04 in Canada, versus other places. So there's all these different policy issues that are happening, you know,
00:11:09 here at home. And, you know, the media covers often what's kind of sexy and what's in your face. But there
00:11:16 are, I think, really important considerations that people have here at home. And ultimately, what I think,
00:11:20 you know, the people that we talked to in our lives, but also just looking, I think it's pretty common
00:11:25 sense here in Canada, that that cost of living is the big thing for Canadians, whether it's housing,
00:11:30 or groceries, or the tax burden, you know, at the Fraser Institute, we look at the tax burden on
00:11:36 Canadians, and that being actually higher than the necessities of life, that Canadians are actually paying
00:11:41 more taxes than they're spending on the other necessities of life. So those things have really
00:11:46 snowballed out of control. And I think, you know, there's a lot of politics, but that's really what I think
00:11:50 boils down to for the average family around the country table. I hope you're right. I think that
00:11:55 when Canadians go to the polls, and I think it might end up being sooner than we previously thought,
00:12:00 and we'll get to that in a minute, I hope that they go to the polls and vote based on who can make
00:12:06 your life better in terms of standard of living, in terms of all of the terrible economic policies
00:12:11 that we've endured for the last decade. I mean, it's remarkable for me, Paige, to look at. I think
00:12:16 one of the Fraser Institute reports showed all of the North American jurisdictions, so all of the states
00:12:20 and all of the provinces. And the Canadian provinces are all taxed at a much higher rate than even the
00:12:26 most high-taxed American jurisdictions. And then when you look at the sort of cost of living, the
00:12:31 average income, the average GDP per capita, the American states almost all do better than even
00:12:37 the wealthiest of the Canadian provinces. And it's just so sad to see what's happened to Canada over
00:12:42 just a decade. It wasn't that long ago when Stephen Harper was a prime minister that Canada was
00:12:47 lauded as this middle-class paradise. We had the richest middle class in the world. And it seems
00:12:51 like that slipped away. I hope that Canadians remember that when they go to the ballot box. But
00:12:55 seeing, you know, specifically this one poll where, you know, Canadians do maybe perhaps prefer someone
00:13:02 like Mark Carney, someone who has a lot of experience sort of in the top role, the governor of the Bank of
00:13:08 Canada, and involved in the World Economic Forum, I guess to 40% of Canadians, that's a positive. And 0.72
00:13:14 that's the kind of person that they want negotiating with Trump. Now, I want to show a CTV compilation.
00:13:20 This was put together by X user called Government Corrupt. And he put together this little compilation
00:13:25 of CTV News, kind of promoting this idea that this will be the ballot box issue, who can best handle
00:13:31 Trump and who can better negotiate a deal here. And they also suggest that Mark Carney is going to be
00:13:37 the one to pull the plug and force an election, that it's not going to, you know, we've been talking
00:13:43 a lot on the show about theories that maybe Mark Carney will become prime minister, make a deal with
00:13:48 Jagmeet Singh, try to govern for a year, maybe before calling an election. People on CTV are suggesting
00:13:55 that's not what's going to happen. Mark Carney is reading these polls, he's seeing that he's,
00:13:59 this is, this might be as good as it gets for him. And we might be going into an election very soon.
00:14:03 So let's play this clip. This is all from Sunday, February 9, by the way.
00:14:08 I guess the question I have for you, Nick, is you also did some polling on how Canadians view who is
00:14:13 best suited to handle Trump. How much do you think that does end up being the ballot box question?
00:14:19 And how much does that depend on timing? Well, I think it probably will be the ballot box question
00:14:24 in the next federal election, because the thing is, is that for Canadians, they know that our
00:14:28 relationship with the U.S. is critical. And I think, who knows, maybe people in the next election
00:14:34 are not going to vote for a party that they like, might not vote for a leader that they trust or
00:14:37 whatever, but they just might vote for whoever they think might be best able to manage that situation.
00:14:43 The next liberal leader will be elected on March the 9th,
00:14:46 may choose to take Canadians to the polls right away.
00:14:49 Okay, so you can see her saying they might choose to take her to the polls. Right after that,
00:14:56 Vassie said that she's also hearing that if Mark Carney wins and when he wins, he is not even going
00:15:01 to go back, not even going to reconvene the House of Commons. He's just going to call an election
00:15:05 right away. I think that they have been looking at the polls and seeing that, you know, when it comes
00:15:11 to this issue of negotiating with Trump, they trust the liberals more. I want to take this to what Pierre
00:15:16 Polyev had to say on Friday. So shortly after that video of Trudeau happened, Pierre Polyev was
00:15:23 on an interview with the Toronto Sun's Brian Lilly. And in this interview, he said that he has always
00:15:29 taken Trump seriously. And that basically, this is a real thing, we really need to be concerned
00:15:37 over the idea that Trump wants to annex Canada. So let's play that clip.
00:15:40 Well, I've always taken it seriously. And I've always clearly and consistently condemned it.
00:15:46 Canada will never be the 51st state. We will be a strong, independent, sovereign country when I'm
00:15:52 prime minister. That's exactly why it's so unfortunate that the Carney Trudeau liberals have made us so weak
00:15:59 and reliant on the Americans. Their radical tax increases have driven a half trillion dollars into
00:16:05 the American economy out of Canada, including many of Mr. Carney's own investments.
00:16:11 The headlines coming out of that interview were the beginning part of that, where Polyev says he's
00:16:19 always taken Trump's threats seriously. And when I saw that, I thought, okay, he's kind of playing
00:16:25 into this narrative that the liberals and the media have so cleverly created, that this election needs,
00:16:30 the focus needs to be on Trump, needs to be on this annexing, and not on the actual issues facing
00:16:36 everyday Canadians with our pocketbooks in everyday life. You can see in the second part of that clip,
00:16:42 I think Pierre did quite well, where he was emphasizing the cost of living and how the liberals really
00:16:47 hurt Canada, and how that's hurting our pocketbook and our bottom line. But of course, the headline coming
00:16:53 out, Pierre takes this threat seriously. And I don't know that that is the best message for the conservatives.
00:17:00 So, Paige, I'll put it to you. Like, how do you think that the conservatives should be managing
00:17:06 this? And I know you don't want to talk too much about politics. But what do you make of this whole
00:17:10 situation? I think so. Here's what I hear from people when I'm talking about, because obviously,
00:17:15 this is dominating the news. Does Trump really want to take over Canada? Is this really going to
00:17:20 happen? Like, how seriously, you know, should we take him? I've read The Art of the Deal myself,
00:17:25 you know, that a book that Trump wrote years ago on his sort of tactics that he uses in negotiations.
00:17:30 I know you've talked about that on the show before, Candace, and sort of that was my take on it as
00:17:34 well, was this is a negotiation. He's doing what in sort of the policy or advocacy world sometimes
00:17:41 called, you know, shifting the Overton window, let's shift the goalpost of the conversation,
00:17:45 I'm going to come out way over here. And we're going to meet somewhere in the center,
00:17:49 but the center is going to have shifted closer to what I really want the outcome to be.
00:17:53 So it was sort of always my impression as I'm observing Trump, and seeing that situation going
00:17:59 on. But what's funny to me, when I talk to people just, you know, who are also watching the news and
00:18:05 trying to gauge whether or not they should take it seriously is everyone's like, Oh, gee, well,
00:18:09 I really don't want to be a 51st state. But gosh, those tax levels would be great. Or I, you know,
00:18:14 I don't really want to be a 51st state. But gosh, I'd love to be able to choose my kids school,
00:18:18 or I'd love to, you know, have more choice in grocery stores and stuff like that.
00:18:22 Like those things where Canadians are cognizant of those quality of life differences,
00:18:29 the United States is so close to us. And, you know, just, you know, the some of the stats that
00:18:34 you and I were talking about, you know, just a couple minutes ago, you can see that, you know,
00:18:40 the purpose in GDP is doing better, their take home pay is better, their taxes are lower, but their
00:18:46 services are not impacted on so many different levels. And, and so that to me is sort of the
00:18:52 great irony. And all of this is that, you know, when I think Canadians are sort of thinking about
00:18:57 the idea of our neighbor to the south, and, you know, in sort of a comparative way, there are so
00:19:03 many things that we could capture and accomplish here in Canada as well, while also having the added
00:19:09 bonus of realizing that, you know, we are competing with our neighbor for investment, and creating a
00:19:14 better environment for investment is going to create more growth, create more jobs, bring more
00:19:19 people to Canada who want to create those jobs. And ultimately, that's going to be better for,
00:19:24 for everybody, or just allow people, you know, here in Canada to create those jobs in ways that they
00:19:29 may not be able to now because it's just too cost prohibitive. So that's what you know, I always,
00:19:34 I always obviously hope that policy is going to dominate elections, but it doesn't always a lot
00:19:40 of times there is this kind of like heated rhetoric and nationalism that gets, let's say trumped up,
00:19:47 and, and that's what ends up being the dominating issue. But, but if, you know, politicians of all
00:19:54 stripes, can bring it back to the fact that we really are facing very economically challenging times
00:19:59 in Canada, and there needs to be pretty significant policy shifts on a whole bunch of fronts,
00:20:03 um, to bring that growth back, because growth really is the big challenge.
00:20:07 Um, that's, you know, that's ultimately what I would like to see. But here I am,
00:20:12 I don't know, that's what the outcome is going to be, because you and I know politics very well, and
00:20:18 the sober policy conversations are not always what wins the day.
00:20:22 Well, I think that this all just benefits the liberal, I'll just say it again, because
00:20:25 there is sort of this like irrational, like, like you're talking about how people at the end of the
00:20:30 day might look at the United States, and say, wow, there, there's a lot more competition, I could
00:20:34 probably get a better cell phone plan, I could probably get cheaper flights, if there was more
00:20:37 competition, like all of these different areas, they're very much dominated in Canada, by these
00:20:42 sort of conglomerate or monopolies that are made up because they're Canadian, we would have a lot more
00:20:48 access to competition. So when you're thinking kind of rationally, it's like, oh, having some kind of a
00:20:53 deeper integration economically, or an economic union would be good. But the irrational side is
00:20:58 like the patriotism, like the like, in your heart, in your soul, like I love Canada, and I and it drives
00:21:04 me crazy to hear this American President talking about taking us over. And I think that that's what
00:21:08 the liberals are tapping into that irrational side saying, like, how dare he, we love Canada. So like,
00:21:14 forget about the actual improvements that could happen if we had more economic union. You know,
00:21:21 think about, I don't I don't know how many people are seriously thinking about the 51st state thing.
00:21:25 It is interesting, though, Paige, the True North did a poll, and it found that especially young men,
00:21:30 nearly half of young men said that they would take American citizenship if Trump offered it to him,
00:21:34 according to our poll. And there's been other polls that have put that out there. And it's interesting
00:21:38 because when I posted on social media, a lot of the replies, especially from people on the left and
00:21:43 liberals, they say, oh, these young men are traitors, like, how dare they turn their back on their
00:21:48 country. But I think that that at the end of the day, many people, especially younger men,
00:21:52 that younger demographic are not thinking about it in the irrational, like love of country nationalism
00:21:58 or patriotism sense. They're literally just thinking, how can I have a good life for myself
00:22:03 and my family? And maybe looking around at the cost of living cost of buying a house in Toronto or
00:22:08 Vancouver, it's just not in the cards. And so you think about the fact that, hey, if I moved to Utah,
00:22:13 I could probably buy a house for like $300,000, I could get a job that pays me more, I'd have less
00:22:17 taxes, it might actually be good, it'd be sad to leave Canada. But at the end of the day, you know,
00:22:24 economics is a driver of a lot of decisions. So I do kind of wonder, like, you know, I think that the
00:22:30 political wedge of Trump and the 51st state is really good for the liberals. And that's why the
00:22:34 liberals and the media are playing it up so much. But you know, at the end of the day,
00:22:38 you know, the economics of it could become more compelling. I'm going to keep going with the news
00:22:45 here, because I want to get to all of this. So to add even more elements to this, and to make it even
00:22:52 more interesting. Donald Trump himself commented on this. So yesterday was the Super Bowl, I don't
00:22:56 know if you watch the Super Bowl page. But it was Super Bowl Sunday, and the President did a special
00:23:02 sit down interview, I guess it's been many years, since there was an actual Super Bowl Day
00:23:07 interview with the President Biden declined to do it. And Trump went to the Super Bowl, I guess he's
00:23:12 the first president ever to go to the Super Bowl. So it was kind of a fun cultural moment happening
00:23:16 down in the States. But during this whole day of festivities, Trump sat down with Fox News's
00:23:23 Brett Baer for a special pre Super Bowl interview. And Baer asked Trump specifically about Trudeau,
00:23:30 about this comment that he made on the hot mic, and asked Trump to respond to it. So we're going to play
00:23:36 that clip for you. You know, the Prime Minister said this weekend to a group of Canadian businessmen,
00:23:41 he was a private meeting, he said that your wish for Canada to be the 51st state is a quote,
00:23:47 real thing. Is it a real thing? Yeah, it is. I think Canada would be much better off being a 51st state,
00:23:53 because we lose $200 billion a year with Canada. And I'm not going to let that happen.
00:24:01 Page, Trump doubles down. I don't think he's going to walk away from the comments,
00:24:04 right? So Trudeau wants us to think that this is real. And Trump says, you bet it's real.
00:24:09 And then he goes back into his statement that he said many times, that basically,
00:24:16 we lose $200 billion a year to Canada. I'm not going to let that happen. It's too much.
00:24:20 Why are we paying $200 billion a year, essentially, it's subsidies to Canada. Now, if they're the 51st
00:24:25 state, I don't mind doing it. So playing into all this, and then again, it leads us to this idea,
00:24:30 like, do we take this literally? Obviously, we should take it seriously because he keeps talking
00:24:34 about it. But does he literally want to take our country? Senator, Republican Senator Ted Cruz
00:24:40 waved it all off on a podcast over the weekend. He's just calling us an epic troll. And he says all
00:24:45 about yanking Trudeau's chain. Meanwhile, gave Mark Carney the opportunity to swoop in and do apparently
00:24:51 what Canadians think he does best. He wrote on X saying, what part of no, don't you understand? No,
00:24:57 we will never give in to a bully. Canada will always be the true North strong and free. And then
00:25:05 while flying to the Super Bowl, so he's on the plane on Air Force One flying from, I guess,
00:25:10 Washington DC down to New Orleans. Trump again was asked about this question. He talks about how
00:25:16 the United States is about to get even larger, again, alluding to this idea that they're going
00:25:20 to take over Canada. Let's play that clip. We're making our country larger. We're making our country
00:25:26 stronger. And in the case of Canada, if this should happen, I don't know how they can do it without us.
00:25:33 Because without the US, Canada really doesn't have a country.
00:25:39 Canada doesn't really have a country without the US. I think he's talking militarily. I don't
00:25:44 know exactly where he gets the $200 billion subsidies. I don't know if you have any comment on that page.
00:25:49 I don't know. I don't know. I also am curious about that comment as well. I'm not really sure
00:25:53 if he's talking about, you know, Canada's maybe NATO commitments not being met or, you know, the US,
00:25:59 you know, having the military might that Canada certainly doesn't have. And that's kind of
00:26:03 benefiting from that reliance and that relationship. I'm not sure. And again, it's, you know, I don't,
00:26:08 I'm not well suited to know if this is him negotiating. And this is a negotiation tactic.
00:26:16 And he's just going to play it out until they're, you know, because he knows that he's not ultimately
00:26:21 going to be negotiating with our current prime minister. He's going to be negotiating with somebody
00:26:24 else. Maybe he's stretching it out to that. I don't know. But what I do know, or what I, you know,
00:26:29 what would be nice is if this sparked a conversation about how, you know, how can we be stronger as a
00:26:36 country? And ultimately you have to, can't save the world if you can't pay the rent, right? So you,
00:26:42 you have to get your economic house in order. And that's what I'm hoping that Canadian policymakers
00:26:47 of all stripes will take away from this is that if you want to be in a position of strength,
00:26:51 if you're feeling that there's a bully in this situation, then get your economic house in order
00:26:55 and, and get Canadians who have a large share of household debt as well, that are facing Canadian
00:27:01 families, get, get them in a position of strength, allow them to, to feel that, that strength as well,
00:27:07 and then share the, the benefits of some economic growth by getting better policies in line, because
00:27:13 right now we're quite behind the times, you know, relative to the US and especially, you know,
00:27:19 as, as president Trump moves forward with he's reducing the size of government in some ways,
00:27:24 you know, he's, he's reducing what he sees as sort of redundancies in the bureaucracy or in government
00:27:31 programs. I'm talking about creating a better tax environment. I'm not exactly sure where he's going
00:27:35 to go in terms of the mix between tariffs and other taxes, but certainly he's talking about reducing
00:27:41 the tax burden on Americans. So these are things that, you know, if Canadians in this 51st state
00:27:46 conversation, let's get our house in order. Let's, let's focus on some tax relief and policies that 0.98
00:27:53 are going to better Canadians as well. If you're feeling, you know, that, that there's a bully,
00:27:59 that's a, that's a good response. Well, I just think that this is the perfect
00:28:03 wedge issue against the conservatives that the liberals have been hoping and praying for,
00:28:07 because you're right. Canada is basically at the weakest that I think we've been in a very,
00:28:12 very long time. And Trump senses that. So Trump sees a weak country. Trump sees a divided country.
00:28:18 Uh, Trump sees the, the, the drastic shift in cost of living, um, and standard of living that we've
00:28:23 been talking about page. And I think that he is picking up on that and tapping into it. And whether
00:28:27 you call that a bully or a wise, uh, shrewd businessman and negotiator, uh, whatever it is,
00:28:33 I think he's tapping into something. And the best thing for Canada that we can do to stand a chance,
00:28:38 um, in fighting off this, you know, whether it's, whether it's a real threat or not, I,
00:28:42 I don't think it is. I think it's all part of the negotiation. Um, but whether it is the best thing
00:28:46 we can do is create a stronger country. Um, but again, just to go back to that idea that, um,
00:28:52 with Mark Carney, um, with this one issue, the media is really, really going into
00:28:56 overdrive to make Canadians think that this is a serious imp impeding, um, threat that's going to
00:29:03 happen that, that kind of like Canada is like Czechoslovakia and it's March, 1939,
00:29:08 and we're about to be invaded. Um, and that, and I think that that is the best thing for the
00:29:13 liberals and we see it. So if you just look at the recent polls, um, the liberals have, um, risen,
00:29:19 uh, this is just since January, this is pretty incredible. Um, so eight points, um, the, uh, sorry,
00:29:26 an eight point gain for the liberal party since January. Um, and the conservatives saw a five point
00:29:32 drop. So of course the conservatives are still in majority territory, according to these polls,
00:29:36 41% and 28% for the liberals. Um, so it's not like the liberals would step in and win a, win a majority.
00:29:44 Um, but you know, that shift that's happening, you know, uh, whatever it is, a 13 point swing in just
00:29:49 a month. Like if those trends continue, uh, we very might much might see another liberal minority
00:29:55 government. If we were to go to the polls right away, I want to move on over to the, uh, liberal
00:30:01 leadership campaign. Cause there was an interesting story over the weekend, um, that we learned that
00:30:05 a Chinese linked, um, malicious WeChat campaign against Christia Freeland, uh, was alerted.
00:30:11 This was also happening on Friday. Um, so you can see the national post headline here,
00:30:16 which is that, uh, China is basically trying to interfere with the liberal leadership race.
00:30:21 We've been warning about this potentially happening on the show, uh, for weeks now. And here we see that it
00:30:26 actually has happened so that, um, Canadian, uh, ministry of democratic institutions put out a
00:30:32 statement on Friday, um, as follows. It says rapid response mechanisms, Canada detects international
00:30:38 operation, targeting a candidate for the leadership campaign of the liberal party of Canada. And then,
00:30:45 uh, we learned that it was a Christia Freeland, basically a bunch of targeted, um, messages that
00:30:50 were seen by apparently millions of Canadians, 3 million Canadians, um, that were not true. I don't
00:30:56 know exactly what they were saying, but Freeland responded by saying, um, responding to the revelation
00:31:01 on X, she wrote, I will not be intimidated by Chinese foreign interference. Having spent years
00:31:06 confronting authoritarian regimes. I know firsthand the importance of defending our freedoms.
00:31:10 Canada's democracy is strong. My thanks to our national security agencies for protecting it.
00:31:16 And then it gave Mark Carney the opportunity to jump in as well. He wrote this on X. I fully support
00:31:21 Christia Freeland and her campaign in light of this disturbing report. I am fully committed to
00:31:25 defending the integrity of this race and stand firm against any attempts to undermine our democracy.
00:31:31 My deepest gratitude to the national security intelligence officials who lead this important work
00:31:36 to sustain trust in our democratic process. Not really sure page that this gives us a lot of
00:31:41 hope in our democratic institutions and the process, but I will just point something out.
00:31:45 That this was happening in Canada during the 2021 election. We know that there were coordinated
00:31:51 WeChat campaign, uh, attacks against conservatives and against Erin O'Toole that potentially even
00:31:57 swayed the results of that election in 2021. And there was no rapid response. There was no government
00:32:03 pointing it out in real time saying, Hey, we just caught the Chinese trying to do this. Um, they just 1.00
00:32:08 ignored it, let it happen, let the election play out. And then we found out about it later on in reports.
00:32:13 So it's kind of interesting that when it comes to a liberal, the federal bureaucracy is so willing
00:32:18 to swing in, um, and, and stop it in real time. Um, and then also sort of the broader issue that the
00:32:25 Chinese are actively trying to sway our elections. Um, as a Canadian, like what, what do you think 1.00
00:32:31 when you, when you hear stories like this? Yeah, I mean, honestly, this, this is pretty above my pay grade.
00:32:38 Um, but I, I do think that, um, there are just so many of these stories that, you know, I think that
00:32:44 a lot of people are seeing this and it's, it's almost noise in the background and it's sort of
00:32:48 disconnected from like, these are like larger geo geopolitical issues, but it is a bit disconnected
00:32:54 from, I think what Canadians are experiencing every day. And that's what, you know, I hope that there is
00:33:01 just more of a focus, like renewed focus. It does feel that in the last short while we have really,
00:33:07 um, that there was a lot of talk, even from the liberal leadership candidates about, about things
00:33:12 like cost of living, about the things that Canadians are facing day to day. And the conversation has
00:33:17 shifted quite dramatically in the last few weeks. Um, and I'm hoping that, you know, the former does not
00:33:22 get lost, um, in all of this. Um, but again, it probably comes down to, you know, what we were just
00:33:27 talking about, which is that like, we really need to get our house in order and we need to, um,
00:33:31 regain strength as a country. Um, and that would give, I think Canadians some renewed faith in all
00:33:36 of these different institutions. Um, but in terms of commenting on the specifics of this,
00:33:41 again, a little bit outside my purview. Well, I mean, it is kind of interesting that all of the
00:33:45 stories in the news right now have something to do with Canada's, uh, integrity as a country and our
00:33:50 sovereignty. Um, and I think that really it's, it's, it's a sad reflection on, um, just how weak
00:33:57 Canada is in so many ways. Uh, people on X and Canadians were also quick to point out that Mark
00:34:03 Carney himself has some ties to communist China and Xi. So almost immediately after the hack story came
00:34:11 out, um, this photo started circulating on X. Here is Steven Taylor, a conservative activist,
00:34:17 uh, reminding everybody that Mark Carney had met with, uh, Chinese premier Xi Jinping. Um, so just for
00:34:24 some more context, that meeting happened back in March of 2024, back when Mark Carney was the governor
00:34:30 of the Bank of England and they met, um, during basically some kind of a CEO, uh, retreat. And so,
00:34:39 uh, you know, not, not a great look, I think for, uh, Mark Carney when he's trying to become a Canadian
00:34:45 prime minister, trying to sound tough on China, trying to talk about how, um, you know, he fully
00:34:50 supports Christia Freeland as her campaign is being targeted by misinformation or disinformation from
00:34:55 the Chinese. Um, and that picture is circulating around, uh, not the best look. Okay. I want to move 1.00
00:35:00 on, Paige, because I know that you focus on education in your day job. You've got four, uh, great little kids.
00:35:05 And so it's obviously a pressing matter for you. I saw this video circulating. Apparently it was, uh,
00:35:11 a year old, but still, I think this, the story still remains kind of shocking, um, to see a bunch
00:35:16 of Canadian Marxist teenagers, um, and, and young people just cheering and celebrating, um, the, uh,
00:35:25 some kind of a Marxist, um, school. So, uh, let, let's play this clip for it, for you.
00:35:41 Yeah. So, um, on the one hand, you know, they're pretty happy. I, I, it's, it's nice to see optimistic
00:36:04 young Canadians. You know, I, I hear from so many Canadians that are filled with, with sort of despair
00:36:10 and, and grief about the future. So on the one hand, it's great to see some jolly young people
00:36:14 in Canada. Uh, but on the other hand, I just can't believe how brainwashed these students are
00:36:20 to, to, to be, you know, joyously celebrating Marxism. Uh, what do you make of all that, Paige?
00:36:25 Yeah, not the school that I would pick for my children, um, the Marxist school, but, um, it's so,
00:36:31 yeah, this is interesting because what we focus on at the Fraser Institute primarily is K to 12
00:36:38 education or P to 12. So kindergarten or primary to grade 12 education. But of course, that is just
00:36:42 the precursor and what feeds into post-secondary education. And that's where you do end up seeing
00:36:47 a lot of these types of wild videos or campaigns or things that go on, um, at, you know, on university
00:36:54 and college campuses in Canada. And of course, this is the, the, everybody can relate to an extent
00:37:01 to, you know, you're not quite got maybe one foot in the real world. You're not quite there. You're not
00:37:04 quite paying taxes yet. You maybe don't have that full reality check. Um, it might be, you know,
00:37:10 your, uh, the, the days when you are maybe most vulnerable to the, the messages of, of Marxism,
00:37:17 but there is, you know, politicization that happens at the K to 12 level, um, in Canadian schools as well.
00:37:24 And, um, and I think the, the, really the central issue here is for parents from the parent perspective
00:37:32 is do I have a way to avoid this? Do I have a way to choose some kind of an education that is just
00:37:39 quite simply neutral that'll, you know, sets my kid up for success in the basics. So in K to 12,
00:37:44 that might be, you know, reading, writing, math, history, history, understanding that kind of,
00:37:50 those kind of core foundational building blocks, and then into university where they're going to
00:37:54 choose a more specialized stream where they're not just going to be kind of flushing their money down
00:37:57 the toilet, something that really sets them up for life. Um, or at the very least, um, isn't,
00:38:02 you know, structured in some kind of like a Marxist indoctrination camp sort of a way.
00:38:07 Um, and I think that, you know, what, what we have seen at least at the K to 12 level,
00:38:12 when we have done surveys at the Fraser Institute, for example, we did a survey last year, um, 2024 with
00:38:18 Leger, um, for the Fraser Institute asking about how parents feel about controversial issues.
00:38:25 Um, so that might be responses to climate change or things, um, like, like sex and gender,
00:38:31 those kinds of conversations. How do you feel about those, um, issues in your kids K to 12 schools?
00:38:37 76% of parents believe that kids should be presented both sides of controversial issues.
00:38:44 91% of parents, this is sort of, um, Canadian average say that, uh, the appropriate age,
00:38:50 appropriate materials are the only things that should be taught in K to 12 schools.
00:38:54 And 81% of parents believed that they should receive advanced notice if controversial topics
00:39:00 are being raised in their kids' schools. But we know that that doesn't always happen.
00:39:03 I'm sure that your, um, viewers and listeners remember not too long ago,
00:39:08 uh, it made headlines that there were Toronto area schools where kids were shipped to a protest
00:39:14 that turned into, it was supposed to be kind of like an indigenous rights, uh, protest,
00:39:18 um, or rally. And it turned into, uh, an anti-Israel rally. There were Jewish students there who reported
00:39:25 being very uncomfortable, but were made to stay. This is the kind of stuff that parents are sometimes
00:39:30 finding out after the fact. We know that this is happening, you know, obviously at the university
00:39:35 level, students have more autonomy, but, but what are the sort of the building blocks? What are the
00:39:39 the foundation stones of this? And do parents have a choice to opt out? And the reality is that,
00:39:44 for example, in that case in Toronto, where there was that, that protest that the kids were taken to,
00:39:50 no, not really. Like, unless you are of financial means, um, you have some choice within the public
00:39:55 system in Ontario. You could choose to attend an English or French public school or English or French
00:39:59 public Catholic school. But outside of that, unless you can afford to pay the full tuition at an
00:40:03 independent school or have one parent stay home and homeschool your kids, there really isn't an opt
00:40:09 out option. Um, and I think that's the real challenge here, um, for, for Canadian families,
00:40:14 at least in terms of, um, how our surveys reflect this, because this is really the concern. You're
00:40:19 setting kids up with this politicization, um, in schools, instead of just teaching them the basics
00:40:24 of reading, writing, math, where we know kids are actually falling behind right across the country.
00:40:28 What is that setting them up for then in university? And it's certainly at the very least makes these
00:40:33 kinds of videos less surprising to see. Oh, there's so much to unpack their page. Okay. So
00:40:38 like when I look at the universities, like just my high level reaction is that these students are
00:40:43 being brainwashed and I don't understand why we're subsidizing them. Like, you know, I, it's been 15
00:40:48 years since I was in university, but when I was there, it was overwhelmingly Marxist. Like the professors
00:40:54 in the political science department, the university of Alberta were overwhelmingly pushing Marxism. If they
00:40:58 weren't outright Marxist, I can't imagine how much that's increased and intensified in the last 10 or
00:41:04 15 years. Um, I guess it's been 10 years since I was in university. Um, but still like the, the idea
00:41:10 that our taxpayers are funding these students to go get a higher education that we believe is necessary
00:41:16 to have a career and a successful life in Canada. Um, but a lot of times, especially if they're studying
00:41:22 in the liberal arts in areas like, you know, political science or humanities, they're, they're
00:41:28 actually just getting brainwashed and I don't understand why we're funding it. Is there any
00:41:33 movement or any political talk or any sort of think tank work pointing towards the idea that we should,
00:41:38 we just shouldn't fund these universities. I think that that, that conversation is happening
00:41:42 more in the United States. Um, I think it should happen in Canada. Like I think that, um, individual
00:41:48 young Canadians should get some kind of a grant from the government, whether they want to go into 0.67
00:41:53 trade school, whether they want to start a business, whether they want to go get an
00:41:56 academic education, that's up to them. But to me, I don't understand why we're choosing
00:42:00 one area to subsidize. We're, we're helping them pay for their university, but we're not helping them
00:42:06 in other areas. Um, so I want your thoughts on defunding the universities and then we'll get into some
00:42:11 of the other, uh, K to 12 issues. Right. So I do think that is a conversation that is definitely
00:42:16 happening much more, uh, in the United States than it is in Canada. But what I can say is that
00:42:21 there is a demand for different ideas that is perhaps not being met by traditional universities,
00:42:26 which are very heavily subsidized in Canada. So at the Fraser Institute, we have, we run education
00:42:31 programs. Um, and those education programs are often focused on sort of just like a basic education
00:42:38 and economics and, and public policy. So you'll hear from people, um, like myself and other staff and
00:42:44 senior fellows that are associated with the Fraser Institute that give you an understanding of like,
00:42:49 you know, I would talk about education policy that might be specific, um, policy topics,
00:42:52 but also just that kind of like basic understanding of economics. Um, that really is a prerequisite to
00:42:59 understanding the kind of broader political conversations that we just had. You can't really
00:43:05 put those things in context unless you have an understanding of economics, unless you have an
00:43:09 understanding of how the economy works, you know, and, and all these sort of different areas. And that's what
00:43:14 the education programs at the Fraser Institute seeks to provide students and also teachers.
00:43:20 Um, and, and there is a demand for it. You know, there are lots of students out there, um, that,
00:43:25 that want to have that kind of an education that just are not accessing that kind of educational
00:43:29 material through their traditional universities. So, you know, take from that what you will, um,
00:43:36 should there be some more diversity, you know, in, in how things are funded? I think that's a really
00:43:40 interesting question, but I can tell you that for sure the demand is there for some diversity of ideas.
00:43:46 Well, I hope, I hope the next government, whoever it is, will, will, will take this on because
00:43:50 again, like university is not for everyone. And I think more and more it's, it's not, it's not only
00:43:55 not beneficial, but it's actually harmful, um, to having a happy, successful life. Um, I want to go
00:44:01 back to what you're talking about a little bit with sort of radical ideologies taking over
00:44:05 K to 12 education. I know at true north, we cover a lot of these kinds of stories and I'm
00:44:10 constantly blown away by some of the stuff that's happening, especially in Ontario, especially in
00:44:14 around Toronto. And I always kind of wonder like, why do parents put up with this? Like, why is it
00:44:19 like, how, how is it, especially in some of these areas page where when you look at the, the, the photos
00:44:24 that are taken or things that leak out of classrooms, a lot of the kids in the classroom are, um, from
00:44:29 immigrant families and, and they're, they're, they're like people who probably have much more
00:44:32 conservative political values, um, than, than we do in Canada. And I, I don't understand why there's
00:44:39 just so much radical ideology. And I'm talking about the gender confusion that's posted on kids,
00:44:44 this idea of like that, that, that Canada is somehow like a racist, genocidal country or that 0.99
00:44:49 white people are inherently bad and evil. I just, I see so much of it and it, it kind of blows me away. 1.00
00:44:54 Like what, what, what can be done? You know, you talked about how parents can choose to pull their kids
00:45:00 out. Uh, but if, if we're looking at like really trying to rid this ideology out of schools,
00:45:05 like where would we even begin? Well, so part of the reason that we conducted the survey that
00:45:11 we did last year in the first place is because we were hearing so many of these stories, right?
00:45:14 There was a story out of New Brunswick. Um, I live in Nova Scotia, so next door to where I am,
00:45:19 where parents found out after the fact that an outside group had come to present to the kids.
00:45:25 Um, uh, it was about sort of gender and sex. That was like the dominating, um, ideas in this assembly
00:45:32 and that just a lot of parents, and I think very reasonably believe that it was not age appropriate
00:45:38 material, um, that was being delivered to their children, but they had no advance notice. So I think
00:45:43 that, you know, that's why we started asking these questions, you know, should you have advance notice?
00:45:47 Should you be able to pull your child out? Um, if you, you don't agree with the material being
00:45:53 presented after you've received this advance notice and the majority of Canadians do, you know,
00:45:57 there is support, um, for, for these things, should the material be, um, age appropriate and should
00:46:04 both sides be presented. So that's what most Canadians want. Um, Canadian parents with kids in K-12
00:46:10 specifically want, um, and of course, parents can go to their schools and they can say, you know,
00:46:16 this is, this is what I want and, and hope for the best. But if you don't have, if you don't have
00:46:22 the kind of influence that you want to have over, um, your kid's school, if you don't have a system
00:46:29 that facilitates parents of all income levels to be able to be informed customers of their kids'
00:46:35 education, right? So be involved in their kids' schools, be an active participant, know what's
00:46:40 happening if they want to, um, and, and ultimately be able to leave the school if it's not aligned
00:46:46 with what they want and have their tax dollars follow, or at least a portion of their tax dollars,
00:46:50 which is how it works in five out of 10 Canadian provinces, follow their child to a different school
00:46:56 of their choice. So British Columbia, Alberta, Saskatchewan, Manitoba, and Quebec all allow parents
00:47:02 to send their child to an independent school and a portion of their tax dollars will follow their
00:47:07 child to that school that at least, you know, it doesn't make it accessible for every family,
00:47:11 but it at least gives parents some ability to move their child and their child's tax dollars
00:47:16 that are associated with that kid to a different school. Um, so having those kinds of policies in
00:47:20 place, I think really helps. That's of course the opt out option in terms of the, you know,
00:47:25 do I stick with it and make my voice heard within, um, the school? Um, I think, you know,
00:47:31 parents are doing their best at the local level. And, and obviously that's why we think it's
00:47:35 important to ask these questions and sort of broadcast this information from a public education
00:47:40 point of view at the national level to remind schools, um, and provincial, um, education ministries
00:47:46 and school boards that these things actually matter to parents and that it is your role to teach kids
00:47:52 the basics, you know, in education. It's not your role to have a political point of view. Um, but
00:47:57 oftentimes that is so lost. I, I remember there was a post once by Chanel Pfaff, who's a great,
00:48:03 uh, she's, she's a former, um, educator and now she's sort of a whistleblower at all. And she,
00:48:08 she showed, I think it was a grade three or grade four classroom exposing a teacher really just
00:48:13 promoting radical ideology. And I, I, I, I shared the post and the thing that I was most outraged
00:48:18 by, obviously I was outraged that they were teaching eight and nine year olds about sex,
00:48:21 which is, I think very inappropriate. Um, but the, the math that was on the board was like so basic
00:48:28 that my four and five year old could do it. It was like basic addition. And I'm like,
00:48:31 why are they doing this in grade four? Um, that, that, that's outrageous that the academics are
00:48:36 just not keeping up. Uh, I want to tie it into this news story that True North is covering. Um,
00:48:41 also on your neck of the woods, uh, page just next door in Prince Edward Island. So a PEI counselor
00:48:47 was sanctioned, uh, for putting up a mass graves is a hoax lawn sign and the court is seeking the
00:48:52 review. Now, if you look at the sign that they put up there, uh, Sean, if we could just leave that back
00:48:57 on, it says, um, truth, mass graves, hoax, uh, reconciliation is to redeem Sir John A's
00:49:05 legacy or sorry, integrity, um, redeem Sir John A's integrity. And I think that's such an interesting
00:49:10 point. Like good, you know, first of all, good for this counselor for, um, speaking up and, you know,
00:49:15 maintaining his freedom of speech and the Canadian constitution foundation for representing him in the
00:49:19 Supreme court right now. Um, but to get to the issue that he's talking about, um, part, part of the major
00:49:26 irony of hearing the liberals and the left right now, celebrate team Canada and talk about their
00:49:31 deep and unabiding, um, and you know, unwavering love of Canada, um, is in the wake of the last five
00:49:37 years when they've done everything they can to shame Canadians, to try to erase, uh, our history,
00:49:41 shame us about our legacy and try to, uh, take away Sir John A McDonald's accomplishments,
00:49:47 particularly in school. So now young Canadians are taught that Sir John A is the villain and the bad
00:49:51 guy. Um, so I think that, you know, part of this conversation, uh, really does need to be like,
00:49:57 what can we teach our kids? What should kids know about Canada? Um, that, that Canada is not this
00:50:03 irredeemably racist country. Canada is actually a great country and we should be celebrating that.
00:50:08 Right. Yeah. So one of the projects that we did, um, last year or the year before at the Fraser
00:50:12 Institute was undertake a review of the curricula, the history curricula from K to 12 in Ontario and
00:50:19 British Columbia and just see how much mandated content was in there. So content being names,
00:50:26 dates, facts, providing, you know, context around historical events, just simply teaching kids what
00:50:33 happened in a way that makes sense, chronological sense that kids can conceptualize it. Right.
00:50:39 And what we found is that there is shockingly little mandated content in social studies curricula
00:50:47 in both, um, BC and Ontario in BC, really the only consistent theme, um, of the history content that
00:50:54 was taught, uh, was Canadian wrongdoing essentially was a, was a theme that came up. So, so different
00:51:01 points of history in which the Canadian government has done something wrong, which don't get me wrong,
00:51:06 the Canadian government has done something wrong lots. That's an important part of history. Um, but there
00:51:11 were not a lot of other kind of mandated names, dates, facts, things that kids need to learn.
00:51:16 So why does this matter? Because if you ask a child about Sir John A. Macdonald and you ask,
00:51:24 should we be protesting him? Should we be tearing down his statue? Um, should we be doing these things?
00:51:30 Do they know who he is? Do they know what he did? Do they know the context in which, you know,
00:51:35 the time in which he lived? Do they know what other people were doing? What historical events led up to the
00:51:39 things that he did? What historical events followed? If you don't know this information,
00:51:44 then you are not able to properly put it into context and understand it. So then you don't
00:51:49 really have any understanding and you don't really have an informed answer to those questions around
00:51:54 what should be done with Sir John A. Um, and, and any of those policies that have, you know, anything
00:51:59 that we're dealing with today, how it reflects the policies of that time. And so that's why, you know,
00:52:05 it's, it's really unfortunate that curricula, uh, in Canada have moved away from those really
00:52:11 foundational building blocks of understanding. You need to know how to do the basics. You need to
00:52:16 know how to do your time stables, for example, until, and then you can move on to more complex
00:52:21 math. You need to know, um, the names and dates of things, and then you can write a critical essay.
00:52:26 Um, you know, saying that Sir John A. was a horrible person for such and such a reason, but you need to know
00:52:31 what happened first if, you know, and that's what we've moved away from. And I want to just also,
00:52:35 just on that note, circle back to something that you mentioned, um, right before you brought up this
00:52:40 issue, which was around the math that was on the chalkboard. So from 2003 to 2022, 2022 being the
00:52:47 most recent year that we have, um, programmed for international student assessments, which is
00:52:52 sort of the gold standard, um, skills standardized test, um, internationally speaking, and Canadian
00:52:57 students at 15 years old, write this test, um, Canadian students math, uh, the average from 2003
00:53:05 to 2022 has dropped by almost two years of learning. So, so basically the PISA equivalent of two years of
00:53:14 learning have been lost in that period. So Canadian students in terms of their math competency at age 15
00:53:20 are, um, you know, like two years behind where they were in 2003 and in reading about one year behind.
00:53:27 So when you ask these questions about, you know, how much of the day is being spent on this kind of
00:53:32 like politicized content in schools, even if you're going to teach that kind of stuff, which Canadian
00:53:38 parents don't seem to really agree that you should be, um, why aren't you spending more time bolstering
00:53:44 Canadian kids' knowledge of math and of reading and all of these skills that are so critical and what
00:53:49 school is supposed to be about where we're actually falling so far behind?
00:53:52 It's so unbelievable. I just, I can't even, I mean, one of the saving kind of graces about
00:53:59 there, there is a massive political politicization, um, of school, but when you look at Canadian students'
00:54:05 academics, they're still stronger than so many other G7s and I can't, or G20s. And I kind of almost
00:54:10 wonder if that is because of immigrant kids coming here that still put that emphasis, you know, Chinese
00:54:15 and Indian families put that emphasis on math in their own homes. And it's not necessarily the 0.70
00:54:20 Canadian schools. When you hear data like that, it's, it's kind of scary. Like the whole point of
00:54:25 school should be making sure that kids understand the basics, math and literacy. And the fact that
00:54:31 we're getting away from that is a concern. Well, Patriots have a few minutes left on the show
00:54:35 here and I want to, uh, talk about what's happening in the States. I know we talked a little bit more,
00:54:41 um, earlier in the show about Trump and how, you know, when it comes to conservatives or even just
00:54:46 Canadians, there's a lot of things that are happening down there that we're excited about that
00:54:49 we think are good. Like taking a zero-based budgeting approach to the government and cutting
00:54:53 all kinds of wasteful programs. I know, uh, Pierre Polyev was up in, um, up in the north today and he was
00:54:59 taught, he was asked about foreign aid and he, he talked about how we should be spending our money
00:55:03 in Canada and not abroad. Uh, one of the things I'm most excited about when it comes to what
00:55:08 the Trump administration is doing is the Make America Healthy Again movement and the involvement
00:55:14 of Robert F. Kennedy Jr. or of KJ. Um, I think there's a big awakening happening in the culture.
00:55:20 So not just in the United States, but across Canada too, where, uh, people are being, uh, a lot,
00:55:25 just a lot more aware of what we're eating, the things that are in our food, the things that we're
00:55:29 giving to our kids, like the dyes that are put in so many of the kids' foods, the amount of sugar
00:55:34 and processed grains and seed oils in kids' foods, um, you know, questions about vaccines,
00:55:39 questions about schools. It's really making a lot of people aware, um, of what is happening.
00:55:44 And I know you're sort of interested in this topic along with myself. Do you see a movement
00:55:49 like Make America Healthy Again happening in Canada? Um, did you hear a lot about these issues from
00:55:54 your mom friends? I hear a lot about it from my mom friends, especially, um, well, a lot of things,
00:56:00 you know, the health stuff, but also concern about the radical left-wing woke ideology that's,
00:56:06 that's being inserted into schools. Um, so I'm wondering, uh, what your thoughts are on, on this
00:56:10 movement. I do think that there is a shift that, that does seem to be happening where people are just
00:56:15 wanting, um, information. So on the school side, I think it actually started during, um, COVID lockdown,
00:56:22 schools being shut down for such a long period of time in Canada, which by the way is, is likely,
00:56:28 like likely accounts for why kids have, have been at least partially why kids are so set back,
00:56:34 um, in Canada, but also in the other countries that you're talking about, other developed countries,
00:56:38 which, which we, uh, compare our, our test scores. Um, but basically what happened was schools shut down,
00:56:44 people were at home with their kids. They were watching what their kids were, were learning,
00:56:48 um, on screens, right? When you had this sort of virtual school, which didn't go very well for,
00:56:53 for a large number of children and parents kind of started to clue in and realize, gee, like,
00:56:59 I don't really, I can't, I can't believe that you're, you're not sort of hitting these sort of basic
00:57:03 foundational building blocks, um, in your education and started to kind of wake up a little bit to maybe
00:57:09 what their kids were learning in schools and where the deficits were. Since then, I do think that there
00:57:14 has been sort of a growth in, um, I guess you could call it an awakening, right? Where, where
00:57:20 certainly my mom friends and what we hear from, uh, from people on the ground is that I really didn't
00:57:25 realize that it was like this in school. And now I want to be a much more informed customer. Um,
00:57:31 I'm not exactly, maybe it was the same thing that triggered this movement, um, in the U S, um, around
00:57:37 this sort of make America healthy again, movement and, and the similar movements that we're seeing in
00:57:41 Canada where people are realizing like, gee, I didn't really realize that, um, these products
00:57:47 were so unhealthy. Um, and then it's just so difficult to find products on the shelves that
00:57:52 don't have these ingredients, these additives in them, um, whether it's dyes or seed oils or whatever
00:57:57 it is. Right. And, and just parents. And even if people, you know, are fine with consuming those,
00:58:01 I do think that there is sort of a shift where people wanting to know just, I just would like to
00:58:05 know the ingredients please. Um, and, and that is certainly something that, um, is different. I mean,
00:58:12 I have always been the, uh, a read the ingredients mom, but, uh, but I do think that, that I, I feel
00:58:19 less, um, less fringe in that regard. Um, as of late, I feel almost helpful, helpless when I go into a
00:58:26 grocery store, like just even for instance, trying to buy bread. I remember once I was walking through the
00:58:30 grocery store, all I wanted was bread that had like less than 10 ingredients. And I literally,
00:58:36 I was at a healthy grocery store, uh, just outside Toronto and I picked up like 40 different loaves
00:58:42 of bread and I couldn't find anything that didn't have a bunch of additives that I couldn't pronounce.
00:58:46 I didn't know what they were. And that, that, that was some point where I'm like, okay, I guess I have
00:58:50 to bake my own bread. And I do, I have my own sourdough starter on the counter. I do it with the kids.
00:58:55 They love to get involved in it. It's a lot of work, uh, but it's fun and I like it.
00:58:59 Um, and, and it just, it got to that point where I'm like, you know, so many of the things that we
00:59:03 assume are kind of healthy aren't. And if you don't want to give those things to your kids,
00:59:07 it's, it's harder to, I'll tell you what radicalized me. Um, and I know we just have a
00:59:11 minute left here. Um, you might not want to comment on this, but I was always very high trust when it
00:59:16 came to my doctor and my hospital. I really, you know, when it came to my labors and pregnancies,
00:59:21 I put a lot of trust into my OB, my doctor. And it was after COVID when they were recommending
00:59:26 that my three month old baby get the COVID vaccine. And that was like a moment of like,
00:59:32 well, wait a minute. I, as a journalist, I report a lot on this. I've read the research. I understand
00:59:36 the data. Little kids don't get COVID. And if they do, it doesn't harm them. Like the risk of death
00:59:42 is so small for a child to get COVID. The fact that you're recommending that I get this COVID vaccine
00:59:47 for my child, which now, you know, the Alberta government, uh, put out that report last week that
00:59:51 said that they don't actually recommend it for kids. Um, but the fact that my own doctor and my
00:59:55 hospital were recommending that really made me stop and think like, if I don't trust you on this,
00:59:59 and I think you're giving me bad advice on this, like what else, uh, should I not trust you on?
01:00:04 And I think that that is, is maybe what led a lot of parents, um, to, to, to, to say, I have to take my
01:00:10 health and my kids health into my own hands. And I'm optimistic that they'll make some positive
01:00:15 changes in the U S and hopefully that'll have a downstream effect on us in Canada as well. Did you have
01:00:20 any, any, any last words on that one page? I just think it was the same with schools, right? When,
01:00:24 when people were saying you can't have your kids in school because of this, there was a lot of people
01:00:29 maybe like you and like me who work with data all the time. And we're looking at it and thinking
01:00:33 the risk to my kids of, of this many years of lost learning is high. The risk to my kids of this virus
01:00:40 seems low. Um, and unfortunately a lot of people came to that realization after the fact. Um, but,
01:00:46 but here we are and that's, and I do think that was the springboard, you know,
01:00:49 those little moments for each family might've been different specific issues,
01:00:53 whether it was schools or health products or whatever. Um, but just, you know, wanting to
01:00:58 become more informed and, uh, and just a more informed consumer.
01:01:04 Excellent. Well, Paige McPherson, such a pleasure. Thank you so much for joining us on the show today.
01:01:07 Really appreciate the conversation. Yeah. Thank you so much.
01:01:11 All right. And thank you so much for tuning in. I'm Candace Malcolm. This has been the Candace Malcolm
01:01:15 show. We'll be back again tomorrow with all of the news. Thank you. And God bless.
01:01:19 Thank you.