The Candice Malcolm Show - December 26, 2023


Will there FINALLY be an election in 2024？

Topics
change in leadership for Liberals
Hosted by
Candice Malcolm
Mentioned
Justin Trudeau Pierre Poilievre Hamish Marshall Chrystia Freeland Dominic LeBlanc Stephen Harper Andrew Scheer Jagmeet Singh Melanie Jolie Erin O'Toole Mark Carney Bill C-63
The biggest fake news HOAXES of 2023 Top Stupid Things Politicians Said in 2023

Episode Stats


Length

14 minutes

Words per minute

191.28

Word count

2,783

Sentence count

156

Harmful content

Hate speech

1

sentences flagged


Summary

Summaries generated with gmurro/bart-large-finetuned-filtered-spotify-podcast-summ .

Canadians are desperate for change, and polls are showing that if there was an election this winter, Justin Trudeau would lose in a historic landslide. So the question is, when will the election finally take place? In this episode, Candice talks with Hamish Marshall, who was our in-house pollster during the 2021 election, and is now a partner at One Persuades, a government relations and strategy firm.

Transcript

Transcript generated with Whisper (turbo).
Hate speech classifications generated with facebook/roberta-hate-speech-dynabench-r4-target .
Topics generated with Qwen2.5-3B-Instruct.
Hosts, guests, and mentioned names generated with spaCy (en_core_web_sm), reconciled against Wikidata.
00:00:00.000 Canadians are desperate for change, and polls are showing that if there were an election this winter, Justin Trudeau would lose in an historic landslide defeat.
00:00:08.560 So the only real question that remains is when will the election finally take place?
00:00:12.820 I'm Candice Malcolm, and this is The Candice Malcolm Show.
00:00:24.840 Everyone, thank you so much for tuning into the podcast today.
00:00:27.320 Don't forget to like this video, subscribe to our True North channel if you're new around here.
00:00:30.960 Don't forget to leave us a five-star review if you're listening to this podcast and you enjoy the show.
00:00:34.720 And head on over to our website, tnc.news, to sign up for our newsletter so you never miss a story.
00:00:39.320 If you want to support our journalism, please consider hitting that donate button and becoming a True North insider.
00:00:44.440 So we all know that Canadians have had enough of Justin Trudeau.
00:00:47.480 After nine long years of woke, virtue signaling, endless embarrassing scandals, ruinous economic policies,
00:00:54.160 Canadians are telling us they want change.
00:00:55.840 Poll after poll after poll show us that the overwhelming majority of Canadians want Trudeau to go.
00:01:02.600 And like I said, if there was an election held today, Trudeau's main opponent, opposition leader Pierre Polyev,
00:01:07.500 would win a sweeping historical landslide in an election.
00:01:11.620 But the only question is, is there going to be an election anytime soon?
00:01:14.800 We know that there is a minority government situation, so the government could fall at any time,
00:01:19.520 but it could also remain intact for another almost two years.
00:01:22.540 So to help us gain some insight on this topic, I'm joined by my guest today, Hamish Marshall.
00:01:27.560 You may remember Hamish.
00:01:28.740 He's contributed to True North in the past.
00:01:31.180 He was our in-house pollster during the 2021 election.
00:01:34.260 He's also a partner over at One Persuades, which is a government relations and strategy firm based in Ontario.
00:01:40.300 Hamish is well known in conservative circles.
00:01:41.820 He ran the national campaign for the Conservative Party in 2019.
00:01:45.500 In 2017, he ran Andrew Scheer's winning leadership campaign.
00:01:49.620 And previously, prior to that, he worked for Stephen Harper and was his pollster during the successful 2008 federal election.
00:01:56.380 So, Hamish, welcome to the program.
00:01:58.320 Great to be here, Candace.
00:01:59.940 Okay, so basically in this situation, the balance of power is held by the NDP.
00:02:05.200 The NDP is the one that gets to decide whether or not we have an election,
00:02:08.320 whether they're going to continue to prop up the Trudeau liberals.
00:02:10.660 So, let's start with the NDP.
00:02:12.780 Do you think that they are ready for an election?
00:02:15.180 And how much longer do you think they're going to prop up the Trudeau government?
00:02:17.880 I don't think they're ready for an election right now.
00:02:19.700 Their fundraising hasn't been that great, which is always a good indicator of how ready they are.
00:02:24.620 Elections cost an awful lot of money.
00:02:26.420 I mean, the spending limit will be a little over $30 million whenever the election happens.
00:02:32.480 And the NDP don't have anything like that amount of money or have really the capacity to get there in the short term.
00:02:38.760 But more to the point, they're also not doing particularly well in the polls.
00:02:43.540 They're not doing particularly badly either.
00:02:45.420 But in order for them, right now, things are going okay for them.
00:02:48.940 They're more or less maintaining where they've been in the polls.
00:02:51.040 And they like being in the catbird seat and making the liberals jump up and down.
00:02:57.200 One of the things, of course, is the liberal government is kind of out of ideas.
00:03:01.440 And as a result, the NDP is actually probably gaining, have more influence today than they did, say, a year ago.
00:03:07.660 Or back when the deal was first signed in 2022.
00:03:12.860 Because with the liberals running out of ideas, the NDP can now just sort of suggest ideas.
00:03:17.340 And they're more likely to be taken and implemented.
00:03:20.660 So I think the NDP feels they're in a pretty good position.
00:03:22.580 And they're not going to rock the boat in the short term.
00:03:25.300 Well, it's interesting you say that because I did notice some news, first of all, that the NDP is starting to hire digital organizers, regional organizers out in British Columbia.
00:03:35.880 Say about that what you will.
00:03:36.980 But to your point, the party's broke.
00:03:38.260 Why are they hiring for jobs for an election unless there's something coming?
00:03:41.520 Party treasurer recently said that the NDP expects to be debt-free in 2024.
00:03:46.840 So, you know, do you think any of those are point of signs that maybe an election might be coming maybe later in 2024?
00:03:55.000 Well, I mean, look, there's always a possibility.
00:03:57.760 But, you know, if they're trying to be debt-free in 2024, that means then they have to start saving their nest egg for the next election before they take on another ton of debt for the next election, right?
00:04:06.840 So that, to me, sounds more like they want to get clear in 2024 so that they can, you know, save a few million bucks and go into 2025.
00:04:16.980 The other thing that they, you know, right now, despite the best efforts of the conservatives, they have not been terribly tagged with the sort of association with the liberals, right?
00:04:29.500 Like this liberal NDP deal has not really dragged their poll numbers down.
00:04:35.200 You know, Trudeau's lack of popularity and increasing lack of popularity hasn't dragged the NDP down yet.
00:04:42.020 The closer they get to an election, the greater the chance of that happening and the more chance I think they'll have of pulling the plug.
00:04:49.900 It's interesting. Some polls that you see show the liberals quite a bit ahead of the NDP.
00:04:54.700 Others, I've seen some polls that show them neck and neck and even some showing that Jagmeet Singh could become the leader of an opposition.
00:05:00.920 You never know what could happen in an election, but given Trudeau's negatives and given Canadians' fatigue with Justin Trudeau, it's possible that he could get wiped out.
00:05:09.540 Let's talk about Trudeau a little bit. He's made it clear that he intends to stay on as leader and to fight, but so many of these polls are saying that even among liberal voters, they don't like Trudeau.
00:05:18.100 And if there were a new leader, not Trudeau, that they would be more likely to show up and vote.
00:05:23.260 So what do you think is the future for our prime minister?
00:05:26.820 Well, I think he's sticking around. I think he believes he's got a mission to save Canada from Pierre Polyev. 0.91
00:05:33.300 He cannot. He's a good campaigner. Give him full credit. He's good at campaigning.
00:05:37.340 But fundamentally, his view of the country is that a candidate like Pierre Polyev can't possibly win a majority government.
00:05:47.540 And therefore, if he sticks around and runs a good campaign, he'll be able to beat him.
00:05:50.720 But, you know, I think the polls are increasingly showing that's that's not true.
00:05:55.560 And the really big thing that matters more than the ballot question of, you know, who you're voting for is those personal numbers.
00:06:03.580 And what we've seen is over the last few months, Pierre Polyev's numbers have just kept going up and up.
00:06:07.940 And Justin Trudeau's numbers have kept going down and down.
00:06:10.940 And that's a real problem for the prime minister.
00:06:13.560 So as far as the liberals go, do you think that the liberals would be better off with Justin Trudeau, given Canadians tired view of him?
00:06:22.600 Or do you be better off starting fresh?
00:06:24.640 I mean, there are some other names being bounced around, like Mark Carney, who is a former governor of the Bank of Canada, and perhaps Chrystia Freeland, who's a deputy prime minister.
00:06:32.640 Do you think either of those names would would give the liberals more hope or give them a boost in the polls?
00:06:37.920 Well, I think change is always is always a risk with change.
00:06:41.560 I think the desire for change is so great in Canada right now that a new leader would be interesting to Canadians.
00:06:49.700 There'd be a lot of focus on that leadership race.
00:06:51.400 And whether we ended up with either the people you mentioned or, you know, Melanie Jolie or Champagne or somebody else, that would be a way of the liberals trying to change the channel.
00:07:02.600 And I think at least for a few months, it probably would quite successfully change the channel because the liberal party would be electing a prime minister.
00:07:10.320 And that would drive everyone's interest in politics.
00:07:13.280 And the focus would be on that leadership race.
00:07:15.740 Whether that new prime minister would be able to persuade Canadians after that, that they're fundamentally different from the Trudeau government that they probably were deeply connected with is another story entirely.
00:07:26.420 But I think it would in the in the short term, it would work.
00:07:29.160 But there's really no mechanism for it.
00:07:30.840 You know, I don't Trudeau himself.
00:07:32.080 I don't believe he's going anywhere.
00:07:33.460 And liberal liberal caucus isn't going to throw him out.
00:07:35.940 We're not going to see an error, you know, a revolt the same way that Aaron O'Toole in the liberal caucus.
00:07:41.340 The liberal caucus is overwhelmingly made up of people who were elected after Trudeau became leader, whose entire experience in politics is with Trudeau as leader.
00:07:53.060 And many of whom don't have sort of deep institutional roots in the liberal party and activism that predates him as leader.
00:08:00.680 You know, I went and looked at it the other day of the 150, I think, 655 liberal MPs are right now.
00:08:09.840 There's only 19 that were elected before Trudeau as leader.
00:08:12.560 And Trudeau is one of those.
00:08:14.880 So it's a very, very small percentage of them.
00:08:19.040 Those are the sort of people, those experienced people would have probably been nucleus for any kind of revolt against them.
00:08:23.900 But it's a very small number, and many of them are actually diehard loyalists of Trudeau, people like Dominic LeBlanc.
00:08:30.520 So I think the chances of anything coming out of the liberal caucus and getting rid of Trudeau is very, very low.
00:08:37.420 These are people whose political career exists entirely in the Trudeau universe, and it's difficult for them to imagine what life would be like with a different leader.
00:08:45.020 Well, it totally makes sense.
00:08:45.860 I mean, Trudeau has completely remade the liberal party in his image.
00:08:49.060 I mean, it used to be sort of a centralist, rather fiscally conservative party.
00:08:54.040 Trudeau took over, first of all, he kicked out anyone who wasn't militantly pro-abortion out of the party.
00:08:59.440 And then he moved the party far, far to the left, in some ways even more to the left than the NDP.
00:09:05.500 And like you said, his success is all that these people know because, as we remember, Hamish, in 2011, the liberals were decimated.
00:09:14.060 The party was in shambles, and it was barely even there.
00:09:16.160 It was a shadow of its former self.
00:09:17.600 Trudeau brought it back.
00:09:19.060 So when you look at some of these polls, you're actually kind of seeing the liberals just return to pre-Trudeau levels.
00:09:25.920 I want to just ask you quickly about that because we saw a little bit of caucus dissent.
00:09:29.380 We don't often see this in Canadian politics.
00:09:31.720 But a few MPs spoke out against the Trudeau government's decision to call for a ceasefire against Hamas in Israel.
00:09:38.440 You saw a couple MPs saying that they disagreed with that on social media.
00:09:43.660 Do you think there's anything deeper to that?
00:09:45.720 Do you think that'll get anywhere?
00:09:46.480 No, and my understanding is that that was a very deliberate tactic, that they called for a ceasefire in order to deal with the pressure they're getting internally from constituencies with vocal Muslim populations.
00:10:01.220 And then they went to the MPs that represent areas of substantial Jewish populations and say, say what you need to say.
00:10:09.040 We're going to do this.
00:10:09.760 If you go and disagree with it, that's fine.
00:10:12.200 And it was very much a deliberate way.
00:10:13.960 It was their way of squaring the circle.
00:10:15.420 So I think it's emblematic of nothing more than issues management.
00:10:21.340 Well, it sounds like very traditional, liberal, transactional vote banking politics.
00:10:26.320 Let's tack back and talk about Pierre Polyev.
00:10:28.600 You mentioned that Trudeau believes that it's impossible for a conservative government led by someone like Pierre Polyev to win a majority government.
00:10:37.120 What do you think is the path for victory for conservatives?
00:10:40.280 Do you think that it is possible for Pierre Polyev to win a majority government?
00:10:43.500 No question.
00:10:44.500 There's absolutely no question that the conservatives can win the next election.
00:10:49.500 The number of seats that are necessary isn't, you know, it's really only winning 50 more seats effectively.
00:10:59.120 And the numbers in Ontario are such that the conservatives should be on track for that for across the country.
00:11:06.700 So, you know, basically the conservatives have to do better in the suburbs.
00:11:10.380 And the desire for change in the suburbs is very, very high.
00:11:13.500 And Pierre Polyev's message has been resonating.
00:11:16.500 The affordability, the incredible thing about the affordability issue is as much as people sort of say, well, maybe inflation will go down or things will change or whatever it is.
00:11:26.280 The affordability is bigger today as an issue than it was a year ago or two years ago when Pierre Polyev was really first sounding, I guess, two and a half years ago when he was still sounding the alarm and even bigger than it was when he was running for leader.
00:11:39.180 It's a bigger, stronger issue.
00:11:40.920 And it's dominating things.
00:11:43.200 And the fact of the matter is, is that the government has had basically has done nothing that has given them any credit on this issue.
00:11:50.060 People are not feeling that people are feeling things are getting worse, not better.
00:11:53.640 Well, to Pierre Polyev's credit, he's been sounding the alarm about inflation for a very long time before it was really, you know, an issue that was affecting Canadians every day at the grocery store and the gas pumps.
00:12:06.340 He's one of the most knowledgeable people that I've spoken to and I've had him on the show to explain it when it comes to these topics.
00:12:12.400 So he knows his file and he's really carved out a niche for himself.
00:12:17.580 I'm wondering if you were advising Pierre Polyev, you know, you have the legacy media say that his tone is nasty and that he's unelectable and that Canadians won't like his combative nature.
00:12:28.720 We've seen him push back against some reporters sometimes and not necessarily take the most, you know, friendly relationship with the legacy media.
00:12:38.000 Do you think that's going to hurt him if you were advising him?
00:12:41.180 What would you tell him with regards to media relations?
00:12:44.360 No, I don't think it's hurting him at all.
00:12:45.980 I think that he's realized that the vast majority of Canadians don't get really get their news from their legacy media in a normal in the way that they would have 10 or 15 years ago.
00:12:55.640 People might watch a little bit of the news, see the article in the newspaper, see a whole bunch of different things or clips online.
00:13:03.780 And, you know, Pierre Polyev is the first politician in Canada to really, truly understand how to deliver messages built for social media.
00:13:14.120 I mean, you know, the number of shares he gets on videos on Instagram or YouTube are remarkable, the number of views he gets.
00:13:22.180 He's getting far more views for most of his videos than nightly newscasts would be.
00:13:30.500 He's already really gone around them and doesn't need them in the traditional sense.
00:13:35.960 And frankly, the, you know, things like the Liberal Bill C-18, you know, killing the sharing of news links on Facebook has actually helped someone like Pierre because his videos aren't getting blocked on social media.
00:13:52.600 But, you know, news stories about him from CTV or CBC or whatever are getting blocked.
00:13:58.200 And it's only accelerating the decline of the traditional media.
00:14:03.260 Well, isn't that interesting?
00:14:04.220 I'm sure that the legacy media are unhappy with Trudeau about that, although I'm sure they're happy about all the money that they are getting from the Liberal government.
00:14:11.160 Okay, final question for you, Hamish.
00:14:13.000 Yes or no, will we have an election in 2024 or will Canadians have to wait until 2025 to get a new government?
00:14:18.120 2025.
00:14:18.520 Well, you will be disappointing many with that answer, but we appreciate your insight and your honesty and your analysis.
00:14:26.440 So, Hamish Marshall, thank you so much for joining us and thank you so much for tuning in.
00:14:31.200 I'm Kenneth Malcolm and this is The Kenneth Malcolm Show.