The Critical Compass Podcast - July 09, 2025


Bruce Pardy: "This is a CONTEST Between Individualism and Collectivism" in Alberta


Episode Stats

Length

4 minutes

Words per Minute

149.41869

Word Count

694

Sentence Count

1


Summary

In this episode of the podcast, I sit down with and to discuss s vision for a new country, what a new country looks like, and how to get there.


Transcript

00:00:00.000 are we looking at the collective are we looking at like empowering individuals right and then
00:00:06.740 with empowering individuals comes a certain amount of personal responsibility that this is a
00:00:12.820 big shift in thinking so if the alberta independence movement is going to get a clear majority there's
00:00:20.820 a lot of people in the middle and you will also need people on the left to drastically rethink
00:00:27.820 this whole collectivist based framework that we have because it seems like this didn't emerge out
00:00:37.140 of nowhere this feels like it's more or less in the fabric of canada and still in the fabric of
00:00:43.240 alberta even though alberta has mirrored a little bit more of the spirit of what america was built on
00:00:50.080 it's still highly progressive yes yes very well put i think so we could frame this question the
00:01:00.780 question of alberta independence in exactly that way we could say this is a contest between
00:01:07.300 individualism and collectivism do you want a government that protects the individual
00:01:13.120 individual or do you want a government that protects collectives groups and because the
00:01:19.040 canada we are in right now is is more and more trending to the to the groups and that's one of
00:01:25.400 the big problems with it it's one of the reasons why alberta is in the position of saying this is not
00:01:31.640 working people this is this is this is a bad scene and what the what a future alberta ought to look
00:01:38.940 like in terms of its government and how it works and what its policies are can can be discerned from
00:01:45.280 that contest so if you create a new alberta and the alberta is again a free one and by the by a free
00:01:53.000 one i mean it protects the ability of individuals to decide their own affairs it's based upon the idea
00:02:00.440 of intuitive autonomy the ability of you to make your own decisions about your own life your own career
00:02:05.580 your own money your own property your own family your own children if that's the kind of alberta we
00:02:11.100 mean then we can tell the kinds of things that have to go by whether they are consistent with that
00:02:17.580 vision or whether or not they belong to the collectivist thinking that you refer to right so
00:02:23.980 here's here's a big one for a lot of albertans i think which is single-payer public health care
00:02:28.700 single-payer public health care is a collectivist program it's a socialized program of health care
00:02:36.460 if albertans mean it about being a new and free country single-payer public health care has to go
00:02:47.840 because it is inconsistent with the vision now a lot of albertans think well but i want to keep my
00:02:53.640 health care because they're scared to wander into the unknown of what a future different health care
00:02:59.880 system might be i'm sorry the one that you have does not match the aspirations you're identifying
00:03:09.080 so so again you have to have to walk into the walk into the unknown and trust that the principle upon
00:03:16.840 which your new country is based will provide will provide for health care provide for for needs of
00:03:23.560 all kinds you know food and housing everything that's important is provided by a free market in a
00:03:30.920 country where people have independent rights that that's the way it works and it is a centralized planned
00:03:38.840 country that is determined to dictate the outcomes on all those things first right so one of the
00:03:46.600 challenges is to get albertans to get out of the mindset of how government's supposed to work
00:03:52.120 government is not supposed to plan ahead and provide for things it's supposed to back off get his hands
00:03:59.160 off the market and let people figure things out for themselves and that is from what i can tell
00:04:06.760 is an idea that lies deep in the heart of a lot of albertans self-sufficiency independence your own
00:04:13.480 decisions by your own hands and if there are enough of those people then you got a shot otherwise
00:04:20.120 if we're stuck on the on the central planning you know collectivist thinking then this is going to go
00:04:25.000 nowhere
00:04:38.120 you