The Critical Compass Podcast - April 01, 2026


"It's Time to Abolish the CRTC" | John Carpay

Topics
Mentioned
What Exactly is 'Canadian Content'? | John Carpay of the JCCF Keith Wilson: "Alberta Should Be The Most Prosperous Nation on Earth"

Episode Stats


Length

59 minutes

Words per minute

147.3

Word count

8,813

Sentence count

419

Harmful content

Misogyny

1

sentences flagged

Toxicity

12

sentences flagged

Hate speech

8

sentences flagged


Summary

Summaries generated with gmurro/bart-large-finetuned-filtered-spotify-podcast-summ .

In this episode, Mike and James are joined by John Carpe of the JCCF to discuss a new report that asks the question: Is it time to abolish the Canadian Radio, Television and Telecommunications Commission (CRTC)?

Transcript

Transcript generated with Whisper (turbo).
Misogyny classifications generated with MilaNLProc/bert-base-uncased-ear-misogyny .
Toxicity classifications generated with s-nlp/roberta_toxicity_classifier .
Hate speech classifications generated with facebook/roberta-hate-speech-dynabench-r4-target .
Topics generated with Qwen2.5-3B-Instruct.
Hosts, guests, and mentioned names generated with spaCy (en_core_web_sm), reconciled against Wikidata.
00:00:00 Back in 1997, the CRTC gave a license to Playboy Channel so that you could watch pornography.
00:00:07 But they said no to Christian religious stations that wanted to have radio and TV stations.
00:00:15 You know, like does a rural, like Montana hunting show, is that an American content that, you know, diverts away from Canadiana, so to speak,
00:00:26 in a way that's significantly more egregious
00:00:28 than a, say, a drag queen story hour show
00:00:33 based in Ottawa?
00:00:34 Like, is that Canadian by virtue
00:00:36 of just being based in Canada?
00:00:38 But we don't need a new CRTC.
00:00:41 We don't need somebody to tell us
00:00:42 what's Canadian or not Canadian
00:00:44 and to manipulate algorithms.
00:00:56 Hi, guys. Welcome back to the Critical Compass. My name is Mike and we're with James and we are
00:01:07 very pleased to be joined again by returning guest. He just happens to like us, I guess,
00:01:12 because he keeps showing up Mr. John Carpe of the JCCF. Mr. Carpe, thank you again for
00:01:18 joining us. We're here primarily to discuss today a new report that was just released on the JCCF
00:01:24 site uh mission creep is it time to abolish the crtc and the subtitle here how a federal regulator
00:01:30 controls what canadians share discover and consume online uh this is a great document it looks like um
00:01:37 primary author nigel hannaford uh did a great job here we we read through it the other day and and
00:01:42 we have questions for you and i'm sure you have lots of things you want to discuss about it so
00:01:46 please sir the floor is yours well glad to be with you guys again with your viewers and listeners
00:01:54 It's a bit of a radical. I'm not aware of other groups or organizations that have called for the abolition of the CRTC, but we think it's long overdue. It started out in 1968 as a regulator of radio and television, and the purpose was to minimize how much Canadians got exposed to American television and American radio.
00:02:22 So they said, well, if you want to have a radio or TV station, you need to have a license.
00:02:25 But if you want to have a license, you have to agree to our conditions.
00:02:28 And conditions were things that, you know, in prime time, say between 6 p.m. and 11 p.m., whatever prime time was, you had to have, you know, 70 percent Canadian content.
00:02:40 And there have been arguments over the years, what is Canadian content anyway, because maybe somebody in downtown Toronto would have a very different perspective over what it means to be Canadian compared to somebody in rural Saskatchewan or somebody in Nova Scotia might have a different idea of Canadian than somebody in Montreal.
00:03:05 all. Anyway, they had these Canadian content rules where they're in charge of that. And the
00:03:12 purpose was to keep the, to minimize exposure to American radio and television. Now with the
00:03:20 internet, that's changed things a lot. In 2023, two and a half years ago, we got the Online Streaming
00:03:29 Act, which actually gave the CRTC, so Canadian Radio,
00:03:33 Television and Telecommunications Commission, right?
00:03:37 So it's a government body, uh, quasi independent from the federal government.
00:03:42 So it's not directly controlled by say the prime minister and the cabinet
00:03:46 ministers, but they do appoint the people to it.
00:03:48 So they're going to appoint people that agree with them and, you know,
00:03:53 do what they want, but there's no direct control.
00:03:55 So the CRTC with Bill C11 in 2023 got legal authority over the internet and what they've been doing the last two and a half years is manipulating algorithms to push to the forefront that which they deem to be Canadian and it's not outright censorship but it's certainly kind of, you know, I'm giving the microphone to you but not to you and it gives increased exposure to what they deem to be Canadian.
00:04:25 Which, by the way, one of the debates back in 1997, the CRTC gave a license to Playboy Channel so that you could watch pornography, which I guess was somehow very Canadian, and a golf channel.
00:04:41 But they said no to Christian religious stations that wanted to simply have radio and TV stations, right?
00:04:49 Which nobody would be forced, if they had received the licenses, nobody's forced to listen to that.
00:04:54 If you're not interested, you turn it off or you don't tune into it in the first place.
00:04:58 Anyway, there is an example, right?
00:05:00 This is what happens when you give a government body the power to decide what is Canadian.
00:05:06 They say yes to Playboy and they say no to Christian broadcasting. 0.84
00:05:11 So is that partially, like it's ridiculous and it's in practice, you're seeing where this falls or like where it falls apart under its own logic. Is that partially because of how it classifies different types of media, which then there's arbitrary rules because now faith-based channels are under a different subset than like the adult entertainment.
00:05:37 And I know some of this can get into a tricky place because some of these underlying principles are that we want all groups to be represented.
00:05:47 We want to be nice to everybody.
00:05:50 We want to make sure that we don't have Christians more represented than other faiths. 1.00
00:05:56 So I can see how they would, with that underlying ideology that informs many of the people in these positions, do you think there's an ideological component informing this decision-making?
00:06:16 Oh, absolutely.
00:06:17 I mean, the CRTC, like most government bodies, like most universities, pursues equity, diversity, inclusion, which means the LGBTQ rainbow agenda to, you know, continue to, whatever, that's a whole ideology that is kind of the opposite of, say, Orthodox Judaism or conservative Christianity or Islam.
00:06:42 kind of a sexual libertine agenda. That's part of the ideology. They promote the idea that 0.98
00:06:52 our legal rights should depend in part on our race or ancestry. So you got special legal rights
00:06:59 for aboriginals that the other 95% of Canadians are not entitled to. You've got equity, diversity,
00:07:06 inclusion. You've got the so-called anti-racism. You've got, this is their whole ideological bent
00:07:15 that we are seeing all around us, which is why the less power that government bodies have to
00:07:22 enforce that ideology, the better. It should swim or sink. It should rise or fall on its own
00:07:30 on its own merits, right?
00:07:33 And not have that government support.
00:07:36 And we're in an internet age
00:07:38 where you've got millions,
00:07:41 if not billions of different websites.
00:07:45 Everybody could start up
00:07:46 their own YouTube channel
00:07:48 or podcast without the CRTC,
00:07:51 which is why their long-term goal,
00:07:54 of course, they'd like to see,
00:07:56 and they have this on the books, actually.
00:07:58 if the CRTC wanted to regulate this, the critical compass, they could do it. They just haven't
00:08:05 exercised their power yet. But they have that power under Bill C11, the Online Streaming Act.
00:08:10 They could get you to fill out paperwork and report annually on how much Canadian content you have.
00:08:19 And they could do all kinds of things. They couldn't outright censor you, but they could
00:08:24 get you to jump through a whole bunch of different hoops. And if you did not jump through those
00:08:28 hoops, then they would say, okay, well, we're taking your license away, which is why I would
00:08:33 encourage you to never register, just remain unregistered. I mean, the moment you register
00:08:38 yourself with the CRTC, you're asking to be dominated and subjugated and put in your place.
00:08:46 Yeah, interesting. That's, you know, right before we got on here, James and I were talking,
00:08:51 and james i'm just gonna straight up steal your example because it was so good do it uh he we were
00:08:56 we were uh musing on the on the thought like what exactly does it mean to be canadian content you
00:09:02 know like does a does a um a rural uh like montana hunting show for example from the u.s that
00:09:10 you know you've got hunters uh on the same land essentially that's in alberta and saskatchewan
00:09:15 hunting the same animals that are in alberta and saskatchewan is that is that an american content
00:09:21 that uh you know diverts away from canadiana so to speak in a way that's significantly more
00:09:27 egregious than a uh say a a drag queen story hour show based in ottawa like what is that canadian 0.92
00:09:34 by virtue of just being based in in canada like what what do these terms really mean mr carpe
00:09:40 please define them well you got this like downtown toronto ndp liberal lgbtq equity
00:09:51 diversity inclusion mindset. It's gotten worse in recent years. That's always been their definition
00:10:01 of Canadian. You're not going to get much in the way of, you know, firearms owners that are
00:10:09 hunting deer, you know, or conservative Christians that are, you know, worshiping at church. I mean,
00:10:20 And it's really, it's got kind of the left-wing downtown Toronto slant to it.
00:10:27 And there's almost Canadian.
00:10:31 We've talked a little bit about this over the last year,
00:10:34 just partially because we've been having so many conversations about what Canada used to be and what Canada is now.
00:10:42 And I feel like that's the difference, is that there are many people who are somewhat nostalgic for the,
00:10:50 The culture and the things that Canada and the way that Canada used to function.
00:10:56 And in a way, now, this Canadian spirit is a surface level.
00:11:02 I've used the term like a maple syrup branded Canadian identity where it's superficial.
00:11:09 Essentially, what you have with some of these, with the programming that they're prioritizing is you have something that looks like it could take place in Los Angeles just from the stories being told or just the ideological framework, except it's just filmed in Ottawa or Toronto.
00:11:30 So, and it just has a Canadian backdrop with the most surface level, like identifying things that makes, maybe there's a bit of snow, maybe there's that little bit of an accent.
00:11:43 But other than that, the framework behind it is no different than like New York or Los Angeles from what it's drawing upon from a cultural standpoint.
00:11:54 And I would ask the question, like, why do we need a government body to, you know, help us out, so to speak, when we can listen to the, you know, watch a TV show, just decide for ourselves what TV shows we want to watch, what radio stations we want to listen to, without somebody that, you know, we're paying millions of dollars to the, what, nearly 700 employees that they have.
00:12:23 And why are we doing this in the first place?
00:12:26 Why do we need that supervision, that regulation in the first place? 1.00
00:12:36 Does it imply that Canadians are too stupid to be able to choose what they want to watch? 1.00
00:12:42 Or we're too fragile that if not for this benevolent organization, we would be harmed? 1.00
00:12:52 automatically harmed by consuming too much American content or American.
00:12:58 Well, that seems to be the underlying premise, right?
00:13:02 This is why, again, we've had this around now for 57 years, the CRTC.
00:13:06 Before the CRTC was created, even going back to the 1930s, we had a radio broadcasting act,
00:13:14 which was federal legislation.
00:13:16 And then in the 30s, we got Replacement Broadcasting Act and the Canadian Broadcasting Corporation, the CBC was created, was probably, I would make an assumption, it was probably more mainstream at that time and hadn't been taken over by Marxist, woke ideologues.
00:13:40 I'm making an assumption. I haven't looked at what the CBC was producing in the 30s, 40s, 50s and so on. But definitely there's this idea that, yeah, Canadians are fragile. We need to be protected from American content. Otherwise, we're somehow going to lose our identity.
00:13:59 And I think there's a kernel of truth in that. If you would, you might remember the late Ted Byfield, who died within the past four or five years and ran Alberta Report magazine.
00:14:17 And he was 70 years old in 1993, I forget his exact age, but he was born, I think, in 1920-ish.
00:14:32 And he said in his youth, and until Pierre Elliott Trudeau took over, took power in 1968,
00:14:40 eight, uh, until pure Elliot Trudeau became prime minister, Canada's identity was British.
00:14:48 We were British North America, according to Ted Byfield. And we had the Royal mail and the Royal
00:14:54 this and the Royal that and the Royal everything. And, uh, at movie theaters, people sang God save
00:15:01 the queen, uh, long before old Canada became popular as back in the day, you just, uh, apparently
00:15:08 the, you know, when people gathered in a movie theater, it was kind of like a public meeting.
00:15:13 So people would sing the national anthem, which was God Save the Queen. And so everybody was very,
00:15:20 very, very British. The country had a British feel to it. We drove on the left side of the road at
00:15:27 one point in history, although I think it was quite a long time ago that we switched to the right.
00:15:31 Uh, but so we were, we were this British North America is what Canada was and
00:15:37 Pierre Elliott Trudeau didn't like that.
00:15:39 And so he successfully repudiated that British heritage and came up with ideas 0.99
00:15:47 of biculturalism, you know, French, English, and then multiculturalism.
00:15:52 And then his son, Justin Trudeau told us, you know, Canada's a post national
00:15:57 state that we don't really, I think he might be.
00:16:01 Correct, or at least partially correct, right?
00:16:04 Like when you repudiate the, the, the, the old British heritage and you don't really
00:16:11 have anything too definitive to replace it with, you're down into this post national
00:16:16 state and then all you have left is sort of this knee jerk anti-Americanism.
00:16:20 Well, what is a Canadian?
00:16:21 Well, we're not American.
00:16:22 Okay.
00:16:23 But what is a Canadian?
00:16:23 Well, we're not American.
00:16:26 So that's, that's where we're at today.
00:16:27 We're not American.
00:16:29 Yeah.
00:16:29 Well, that's, that's, that's.
00:16:31 Kind of the heart of the matter, isn't it? I mean, how are you supposed to, how are you supposed to have anything resembling an objective definition of what Canadiana or Canadian content means? If you, if your prime minister deems the country to be a post-national state, like you say, I mean, it's not, you're not, this is a, this has been a concern that a lot of our guests have, have talked about.
00:16:54 And we've talked about as well in that Canadians, at least in the modern conception and, you know, say in the last 10, 15 years, it's become very overt, this negative definition of what a Canadian means.
00:17:09 Like you say, it's not American. That's what a Canadian is. We live sort of in the same area and we speak the same language and we're sort of the same demographics for the most part, but we're not them. We're just not. 0.58
00:17:24 Well, yeah, if you're not making a positive claim on what you actually are, how are you meant to defend that as some sort of cultural institution?
00:17:34 And essentially, we're just in this shared economic zone, which, again, all this sets—
00:17:41 Not so much shared as much these days, but yeah, I agree with you.
00:17:45 That's what Canada is turning into, is a shared economic zone for people to immigrate to.
00:17:53 So part of this, like the withering down of the identity has opened the doors to a type of immigration that doesn't have the cultural glue where you look at where immigration started from.
00:18:09 there is a high bar of assimilation and the the amount of assimilation that somebody would have
00:18:18 to go through is much higher and you'd see people integrate in a way that is not happening in the
00:18:25 last 10 years to the same degree and I think that goes hand in hand with the more surface level a
00:18:33 national identity becomes, the less assimilation you're expecting. You've essentially lowered the
00:18:41 bar that all it takes is to just walk on this magic soil for a certain amount of time, and then
00:18:48 you get a piece of paper, and then you are that thing. I can't disagree with you. It's a change
00:18:58 an identity as well. Ted Byfield would have said, and I think this is historically accurate,
00:19:05 that Canada was not known as this peace-loving, anti-war nation. There's this notion of, well,
00:19:16 Canada, Americans are a bunch of warmongers. They're always going to war. But we Canadians,
00:19:23 we're more sophisticated. We're more enlightened. We just really love peace.
00:19:26 First of all, I don't know if that's necessarily true, but if it was true, it's a very recent thing.
00:19:35 Because in World War I, the tens of thousands, possibly hundreds of thousands, I don't have the numbers in front of me,
00:19:43 but Canadians volunteered en masse to go fight for king and country.
00:19:49 And they wanted to fight against the Germans in World War I.
00:19:55 Now in 2017, three quarters of the way through the war, conscription was made mandatory and they started forcing people, although even that fact too, right?
00:20:05 First you have waves of volunteers and then the government says, okay, now we're going to force other people who didn't volunteer, we're going to force them to go to Europe and to fight.
00:20:15 So we were very warlike in World War I. And that's maybe part and parcel being part of the British Empire. And so when England was under attack by Germany, I mean, indirectly, they were at war. The Germans were not invading England, but they were at war. And everybody felt like, we're going to go fight for king and country.
00:20:36 And then in World War II, Canada was one of the first in, I think it was just a few hours or a day or two after Britain and France declared war on Nazi Germany. And then Canada was very quick to also declare war on Nazi Germany.
00:20:53 We also declared war on Imperial Japan, even though it wasn't, you know, it was Pearl Harbor.
00:20:59 It was the Americans who got bombed on December the 7th, 1941, not Canada.
00:21:03 But we declared war on Japan.
00:21:04 We declared war on Germany. 0.54
00:21:05 And we fought, and we fought hard.
00:21:08 And so we were this very militaristic nation that was fighting battles.
00:21:15 We fought in Korea.
00:21:17 So this whole idea that we're, you know, kind of this anti-war, you know, peace lovers that won't fight, that's just fairly recent in Canadian history.
00:21:29 Yeah. And, and, you know, people forget too that the, um, for decades, you know, the PPCLI and the JTF2 have been considered like world-class forces. I think JTF2 is, is maybe only beyond, uh, maybe only behind, um, I can't think of the name right now of the, uh, the Israeli special forces, but they're, they're considered like even deadlier than the Navy SEALs.
00:21:52 I mean, it's a very, very, very highly advanced and lethal force.
00:21:57 So, yeah, no, Canadians, I remember reading a write-up
00:22:00 about how Canadians were actually volunteering
00:22:04 in pretty high numbers to take the place of Americans
00:22:07 who were draft dodging during the Vietnam War as well.
00:22:11 Like, that was even going up into the 60s and 70s.
00:22:13 You know, that's not that long ago.
00:22:19 Yeah, well, and we, yeah, I've,
00:22:22 I apologize. I don't know the specific nature of the Canadian government's, um, stance on, on Vietnam. We were not, uh, forcing people to go on and, uh, fight there. There was not a draft or, or conscription, but, um, yeah, now it's like anybody that comes here, you just, you, you be who you want to be, you do what you want to do. And we're all Canadians, you know, but let's not really, let's not please ask the hard questions of what that actually means.
00:22:50 yeah yeah it's uh well and and so a lot of this when i was reading the document it feels like
00:22:59 with the history of when the crtc started a lot of this was maybe invisible like it's kind of
00:23:07 running in the background where okay you don't you we know about the 30 canadian content but we
00:23:14 the average person doesn't really they don't really see the in and out of all the regulations
00:23:20 that shape the way that content's made or who gets access or how it's distributed.
00:23:26 They're not aware of all of that back end.
00:23:29 So for the most part, it's this layer that's running invisibly shaping the bubble that Canadians kind of exist in.
00:23:36 And then this is where you get kind of the average CBC viewer has a very curated view of the world.
00:23:43 You try to talk to them outside of issues that they've seen on CBC or some other mainstream news.
00:23:48 and it's like it never existed in the first place.
00:23:53 So these bubbles are partially crafted.
00:23:57 And I think the online streaming act
00:24:00 was maybe one of the first times
00:24:02 that it became a little bit more obvious
00:24:04 where people would go to something
00:24:06 and it would pop up on their phone
00:24:07 and they can't actually access it
00:24:09 because now they're noticing
00:24:11 that it's blocked in Canada
00:24:13 where before it was a little bit more invisible.
00:24:16 But do you think the awareness from the average person is high enough that they see the CRTC as a problem? Or is there more awareness and more of a cultural shift that needs to happen to change some minds?
00:24:32 Well, I think it's the latter. I would venture a guess that the overwhelming majority of Canadians, 60, 70, 80%, you know, might not even have heard of the CRTC or know what the CRTC does.
00:24:50 And in the big picture, you know, it's one federal body with 700 employees, so it's not as big of a fish as others.
00:25:03 You mentioned the CBC. You probably heard of our report two months ago on the rising euthanasia, where it's the fourth leading cause of death in Canada.
00:25:18 And it's gone from rough to like 16,500 people died by assisted suicide in Canada.
00:25:30 And I think if that assisted suicide program continues to expand the way it is,
00:25:37 in Alberta now, the government's introduced legislation to make it either illegal or more difficult
00:25:44 for the healthcare people to push for assisted suicide.
00:25:49 We've had so many reports where people are, you know,
00:25:54 they're going in for back surgery or something,
00:25:56 and it's, oh, by the way, do you want MAID?
00:25:58 You know, it's just presented as, 0.97
00:26:00 do you want to kill yourself?
00:26:01 It's just presented repeatedly as an option.
00:26:04 So provincial government stepping in saying,
00:26:06 you can't, you have to wait for the patient to bring it up,
00:26:08 which I think is a very wise measure.
00:26:11 Why did it go on to assisted suicide?
00:26:13 It's because the number of, if the, if the rates of assisted suicide keep on escalating the way that they are, there's not going to be too many CBC watchers left over in a few years.
00:26:25 And the CBC viewership is going to decline even further than what it has now.
00:26:29 But even with a little bit of viewership numbers going down, it's still, you're still going to get a billion dollars going to CBC every year.
00:26:37 Oh, I'm sure. I'm sure. I mean, the CBC is a propaganda machine for a big government, anti-freedom, woke ideology. And if there was a CBC person joining us right now, they'd be pounding the table saying, we are strictly nonpartisan, to which I would say, yeah, you're strictly nonpartisan as between the liberals and the NDP.
00:27:00 But it's the philosophy that the CBC promotes that I think has a big influence to get people to vote for the Greens and the Bloc and the Liberals and the NDP.
00:27:16 The parties of the political left have got daily support from the CBC because its coverage is so slanted.
00:27:24 It's always, they always interview people.
00:27:26 when Charlie Kirk got assassinated, okay, the CBC did a smear job and said that he was a fascist
00:27:33 and he was far right. And just simply by who they interviewed, they would go and they interview
00:27:39 people who said, you know, Charlie Kirk's probably a racist. He's far right. He's fascist.
00:27:44 That's a smear job that they do because they only interview those people. They're not going 0.89
00:27:48 to interview somebody who says that Charlie Kirk was a great hero. They're not going to interview
00:27:54 somebody who understands the difference between conservatism and fascism. Sure, fascism has a lot
00:28:01 more in common with socialism than what it does with conservatism, but they're not going to
00:28:05 interview people that see it that way. But everything's kind of, you know, far-right,
00:28:10 neo-Nazi. If you don't agree with the CBC, you are far-right. And there's just no distinction
00:28:16 for them between conservatives and fascists. It's all kind of, you know, part of the same
00:28:21 evil grouping. So that's their daily ideology. So it's unfortunate, but yeah, they might still
00:28:30 get lots of money, but their viewership, as their viewership declines, they have less and less
00:28:34 influence, which is beautiful. I'm glad. Yeah. Oh man. Just to clarify a point I made earlier
00:28:42 before I asked you a different question, in case I misspoke, what I meant to say was the,
00:28:48 there were Canadians who volunteered to fight on behalf of American forces to compensate for the
00:28:54 American draft dodgers. So I just looked it up to verify. And apparently there was between 20 and
00:29:00 30,000 American draft dodgers who moved to Canada to avoid the Vietnam War. And they estimate up to
00:29:06 40,000 Canadians volunteered to fight for the U.S. Armed Forces in replacement. So that's just an
00:29:13 interesting tidbit of history but that's your elbows up history moment yeah but I couldn't help
00:29:20 but notice John when I was reading the report it seems to me like the thing that kept popping into
00:29:27 my head when I was reading this is that it feels to me like a similar thing that the CRTC does to
00:29:34 what we do in the dairy cartel in this country and it feels like under the guise of you know
00:29:43 protecting consumers and making sure that, you know, whatever flowery language you want to use,
00:29:47 it really actually is just simply a control mechanism to prop up an industry that would
00:29:53 otherwise fail because of, you know, whatever variables you want to say. Is that an oversimplification
00:29:59 of what the modern CRTC does, or is that kind of on point, you think?
00:30:03 well the difference is that the the dairy cartel keeps the prices high for canadian consumers and
00:30:14 and uh every every year they they pour millions of liters of milk down the drain that could be going
00:30:21 to poor people or food banks or whatever and and they keep the prices a lot higher than what they
00:30:26 would be. So yeah, and they restrict competition. If I wanted to, you know, start up a dairy
00:30:36 operation and buy a few cows and milk them and sell the milk, I wouldn't be allowed to do that
00:30:41 unless I, you know, first had to, you know, spend a lot of money to buy quota. So the CRTC is
00:30:50 is different in so far as it's not going to prevent me from starting a podcast or a videocast
00:30:57 or setting up a new website. So not, you know, it's not really blocking the entry.
00:31:08 It is costing us more money though, because as the paper describes, right, it reduces competition.
00:31:17 It's got all these rules in place that basically allow TELUS and Rogers and Bell to remain dominant because it's very hard for smaller companies to break in.
00:31:29 So in that sense, the CRTC is very similar to the dairy cartel in that they make it, the CRTC makes it very difficult for newcomers to come in there and compete effectively.
00:31:40 It's like, well, that's very hard to do.
00:31:42 So, yeah, with that element of both them controlling content and then you have the restriction side and then you have the grant side, which another government program where they're subsidizing certain types of content and not subsidizing.
00:32:00 When you add those two together, the suppression through selective distribution and then the amplification, that's quite a significant tilt.
00:32:15 And with those two in play, so you will always have people that are ideological.
00:32:23 But if a system is structured in a certain way, some systems enable corruption more than others, and it will enable people with ideology to take hold of that system.
00:32:37 So if we abolish the CRTC and put in something else, what essential roles would this new, like this new regulator, what should they do? And what is a structure that would help prevent any future corruption?
00:33:02 I would replace it with nothing. I think the only restrictions on the Internet should be when people are violating the criminal law. So if somebody is producing, creating, selling, distributing child pornography, the law enforcement, the authorities need to get in there and find out who is doing it and where they live.
00:33:27 And they should throw the book at those people and, you know, get the search warrants, get whatever they need to, you know, do surveillance on people.
00:33:38 If you have reasonable and probable grounds that somebody's breaking the law, the police can go to court.
00:33:42 They can get a court order to do surveillance.
00:33:44 So I don't believe in an absolute total free-for-all on the Internet insofar as I think we should stop the child pornography.
00:33:53 And if it was up to me, I'd place restrictions on other pornography as well, because I think it causes an awful lot of damage, although, you know, it's a bit of a tricky issue.
00:34:08 I believe in individual choice as well, so I have conflicted feelings about that whole issue.
00:34:14 But we don't need a new CRTC. We don't need somebody to tell us what's Canadian or not Canadian and to manipulate algorithms so that Canadians will more likely see more of some things and less of other things.
00:34:35 We just don't need that at all, in my view.
00:34:40 So I don't think we—we need to ensure that there's competition, okay?
00:34:43 So we've got the Competition Act federally, and this makes it illegal for parties, for large companies to collude with each other and keep the small guy out.
00:34:55 So we've got competition law.
00:34:57 That should be enforced.
00:34:59 So that's the role of government is you have a Competition Act.
00:35:03 You punish collusion. You make sure that there's no unfair barriers to new people trying to enter a market and crack down on crime.
00:35:17 And that's it. I don't think we need a federal body to be regulating these things.
00:35:24 Yeah, that pretty much aligns with where James and I stand a lot on, you know, just the general, more of a libertarian stance on those sort of things, I suppose, if you wanted to label it.
00:35:38 I wanted to ask you, there's a section in the report where it talks about the kind of the gradual expansion of what the CRTC controlled, starting off obviously just with radio and television expanding in the 80s, in the mid-70s, you know, to include telecommunications companies in the 80s with regard to cable TV services and channel offerings, things like this.
00:36:07 But when, uh, the internet, you know, became a thing and became quite, quite popular and obviously exploded in popularity, uh, the, they did take a, they initially took a much more, um, maybe a cautious approach, I guess you could say.
00:36:22 Um, there's a section here where it talks about how, um, Stephen Harper, uh, favored minimal internet intervention, believing that governments should adapt to the open free internet rather than regulate it.
00:36:35 I remember personally in in the 2015 federal election. Now, try not to hit quit on this interview, but I voted for the NDP during that election. And I specifically remember why I voted for them, because Tom Mulcair, as the leader of the NDP, was the only one of the major party leaders to come out very much in favor of net neutrality.
00:36:59 And he was very, he seemed at the time very committed to the principle of net neutrality. He thought that the negotiations surrounding the Trans-Pacific Partnership at the time were going to allow a backdoor for ISPs to regulate internet traffic unjustly and all sorts of things.
00:37:16 So I liked that at the time I was thinking about these sorts of things. Now, it seems to me that somebody on the left side of the political spectrum, a liberal or specifically an NDP voter, they seem to me to be the people who are most in favor of heavily regulating the Internet.
00:37:31 What, what do you make of this sort of cultural shift that we see now, where it seems like it's conservatives who are approaching this, you know, it's not new anymore, but it's ever expanding. Conservatives seem to be approaching this technology from a much more progressive and libertarian perspective.
00:37:48 Now, supporters of big government are typically extremely short-sighted, and it doesn't occur
00:38:00 to them that that same government machinery could be flipped around and used against them.
00:38:06 So right now, you'd find people on the political left would love the idea of giving the Canadian
00:38:14 Human Rights Commission the power to prosecute discriminatory speech. So this is not criminal
00:38:21 hate speech, but it's speech that's discriminatory. We had this provision in the Online Harms Act,
00:38:27 which fortunately died with the 2025 election. The federal government keeps on saying they're
00:38:33 going to bring the Online Harms Act back. And one of the provisions in there is to empower the
00:38:39 Canadian Human Rights Commission to prosecute discriminatory speech with penalties of up to
00:38:45 $50,000 paid to government, up to $20,000 paid to a complainant. And not to mention the tens of
00:38:54 thousands of dollars in legal bills, you're going to be out of pocket to defend yourself against
00:38:58 prosecution. And people on the left think this is great because then we can punish supposedly bad
00:39:06 people like Barry Neufeldt in British Columbia, who publicly speaks out against the transgender
00:39:13 ideology and says we shouldn't be harming children by teaching them that it's possible
00:39:20 to become a member of the opposite sex. And so the BC Human Rights Tribunal has ordered
00:39:28 Barry Neufeld to pay $750,000 to a small group of, uh, LGBT teachers in Chilliwack.
00:39:38 So it's just, um, you know, it's just, it's just crazy that way, but people favor this,
00:39:44 but it doesn't occur to them that if, if the government, uh, if the cultural tides change
00:39:51 And you get a, uh, maybe you get a Muslim dominated government that, uh, is going to punish, uh, Islamophobia and blaspheming the prophet Muhammad.
00:40:04 And they're going to, uh, crack down on LGBTQ speech. 0.88
00:40:09 And they're going to say that that's, it's a perversion and it's, uh, it's unnatural and it's sick and it's this and it's that.
00:40:16 Then what do you do then?
00:40:18 then you've got big government that can direct its guns against you.
00:40:22 But this is not what people think about.
00:40:24 It's just like, yeah, go, go, go.
00:40:25 You know, let's, let's have the hate speech restrictions.
00:40:28 Let's bring back the online harm act.
00:40:30 Uh, let's have the government deciding what's true and false, uh, by way of,
00:40:34 you know, promising to protect us from hate and disinformation, misinformation.
00:40:40 It's just short, short sightedness is a big part of it.
00:40:43 These people can't imagine that the machinery of the state would ever be
00:40:47 used against them doesn't occur to them.
00:40:50 Can I, can I admit a crime on this podcast right now?
00:40:53 Uh, this morning I, uh, I conducted a hate crime.
00:40:57 I had some bacon and well, like I joked, but that could be considered like under the
00:41:06 right, if the right people get in power, they could, that could be part of some, some, that
00:41:11 that could be a symbol of hate they could i could even imagine if people troll on the internet
00:41:17 enough and use the bacon like emoji in a hateful way i could see that kind of a meme being
00:41:26 treated as like a hate as a hate offense hate simply of like a hate symbol of you're you're
00:41:33 trying to make fun of somebody's religion and um since they can't eat bacon that is now a hateful
00:41:41 symbol and you can see how ridiculous these things get when taken to the logical extent of
00:41:49 just measuring it based on hurt feelings because an emoji could hurt feelings and they could
00:41:54 maybe they they want to ban an emoji because it's used by enough people that's how any word turns
00:42:02 into something hateful or a slur it's just it's common enough use that it comes ingrained culturally
00:42:09 And then at some point they said, like, well, now that's a bad word and you can't say it.
00:42:16 You know, the biggest threat or one of them, one of the biggest threats to free speech is just this notion that we, that people are entitled to not feel hurt or offended.
00:42:29 Now, I'd be the first to say that as a matter of civility, as a matter of politeness, as a matter of courtesy, we should try to get our points across as much as possible without being really awful, nasty, vicious towards people who disagree with us.
00:42:53 So, you know, we should focus on arguments and so on.
00:42:58 Having said that, invariably, all speech is going to offend at least somebody, okay? If an atheist says that religion is stupid and all religious followers are naive, gullible, credulous, misguided, anti-science, whatever, look, you know, I've got a thick skin. Most of us have a thick skin. We're not going to lose sleep over it. 0.99
00:43:27 but there will be people who are deeply hurt, you know, so why this atheist is calling religious 1.00
00:43:30 people stupid? Well, you know, people criticize Islam, people criticize Judaism, people criticize 0.99
00:43:37 Israel. You're always going to have people that feel hurt or offended by something, 0.62
00:43:49 whether it's a huge number or a small number, you're going to have people hurt.
00:43:53 And so what's disturbing is that you, a lot of Canadians will say, well, I support free speech as long as it's not offensive.
00:44:01 It's like, uh, everything, you know, certainly in the realm of religion and politics, uh, but I would say even in every realm, you know, you could have two, you could be running an interior design company and, and criticize a certain style of, of, uh, interior decorating or something.
00:44:22 can't, you know, somebody's going to be offended. So you can't have this, uh, I support free speech,
00:44:28 but, uh, as long as it's not offensive. No, free speech necessarily includes a right to offend.
00:44:37 Not that offending people is your goal. It's sort of a by-product, but it has to include that right
00:44:43 to offend. Because the moment you say that, that, you know, I have a right to not feel offended,
00:44:47 you have a right to not feel offended, you no longer have free speech.
00:44:52 That's so true.
00:44:53 You know, it's a, they say, you know, Jordan Peterson has said this, many, many, you know, various free speech warriors say, you don't need, you don't need provisions for freedom of speech for uncontroversial speech.
00:45:06 It's specifically only the controversial speech that is the purpose for why free speech laws exist.
00:45:11 And I think that maybe, uh, points to a, a grander problem right now in our, in our specifically Western culture in general, where, you know, they call this, um, I just, I just looked it up and I, I, apologies if I'm wrong.
00:45:29 I think this is right. There's an American writer named Rob Henderson who coined a term called luxury beliefs. And and this is a this sort of describes this, you know, this conflation of, you know, words are violence and insult is, you know, to be insulted is the same thing as to be physically harmed.
00:45:47 And these are things that only people with truly privileged existences can spend time thinking about and worrying about. And I think that, you know, I don't know if you've done much thinking or talking about, you know, this notion of a decadent culture sort of at the pinnacle of its influence, a culture in decline where they, you know, that starts to hyper focus inward on feelings as the walls crumble around them.
00:46:16 So this is maybe a broader philosophical topic, but do you, do you sense, do you get that sort of feeling you're in your, maybe in your personal, in your day-to-day life of, of that's the sort of culture we're living in, which leads to us having to have conversations about this?
00:46:32 Any culture that has the word microaggressions as part of its vocabulary is a pretty decadent culture, you know?
00:46:42 It is. We've become, well, frankly, we've become a bunch of sissies. I mean, you looked at the whole lockdown experience where, you know, previous generations have understood that death is part of life and it's normal for people to die. 0.99
00:47:03 and it's especially normal for older people to die and in prior years, yeah, and I'm not 0.99
00:47:11 trivializing it or making light of it. I mean, when my grandmother died when I was 21 years old,
00:47:18 I was devastated. It was horrific. She and I were extremely close. So I don't make light of
00:47:25 old people dying. I do say that it's a part of life that people generally die and
00:47:33 Most of the deaths are people in their 70s and 80s and 90s, more so than people in their 20s, 30s and 40s.
00:47:41 That's just a fact of life.
00:47:42 And so COVID comes along and all of a sudden we have this narrative that seems to be predicated on the idea that nobody ever dies.
00:47:50 And COVID's the first time in human history that people are dying and that this is somehow unacceptable.
00:47:57 And so you have, you know, elderly people who in prior years were dying of cancer and heart disease and stroke and emphysema and whatever, all these different causes and, you know, not featured on the six o'clock news and the five o'clock, four o'clock, three o'clock news, you know, not sort of an hourly reporting on death.
00:48:23 And then we get COVID and all of a sudden it's as if nobody has ever died before and old people have never died before. And now we're all shocked and terrified that there's people who are already old and have multiple health conditions that are in their last few months or their last year of life and they're dying.
00:48:44 and there's just this incredible fear of death that I don't think that they could have pulled
00:48:55 a stunt like this in the 1950s. In fact, we had more severe viruses. The Asian flu of 1957,
00:49:02 the Hong Kong flu of 1968 were more deadly than COVID and life went on. People said, well,
00:49:08 it's unfortunate, you know, we've got more flu deaths this year. These were global pandemics
00:49:13 and they were more deadly than COVID. And people, of course, they were sad when grandma and grandpa
00:49:20 died, but they didn't have, they kind of said, well, you know, life goes on, old people die,
00:49:28 and you didn't have lockdowns. And so we had a bunch of lockdowns, which there's no evidence
00:49:34 placed before courts by governments to demonstrate that lockdown saved any lives. But yeah. So it is,
00:49:41 There is sort of a heightened sensitivity that wasn't there in the past.
00:49:44 And it's especially a sick result of the absolute madness that took over the society,
00:49:53 Western societies in particular, but the whole planet really, that would simultaneously claim
00:49:59 that they were enacting these draconian policies to protect the elderly, while at the same time
00:50:07 letting them die alone in nursing homes with bags of hot water filled medical gloves to hold instead
00:50:15 of their loved ones hands you know like it's i'll never personally i'll never forgive them for that
00:50:20 i'll never get over it i don't think the way that that yeah so many people had to die alone and uh 0.95
00:50:29 yeah without their loved ones they're in some sort of a sick perverted twisted disgusting rhetoric
00:50:36 about how we've got to, yeah, you know, we have to protect these people from COVID.
00:50:42 Therefore, they all have to die alone because it was illegal to visit your loved ones in a nursing home. 0.81
00:50:47 It was disgusting.
00:50:49 And the lockdowns didn't prevent COVID from getting into the nursing homes.
00:50:52 I mean, this was the population.
00:50:54 The only, if you were under 70 and not in a nursing home and you're sort of, you know, average, reasonable health,
00:51:03 your risk of death or injury from driving in a motor vehicle,
00:51:08 either as a driver or passenger, either way,
00:51:10 your risk of death or injury from driving a car
00:51:15 was higher than your risk of death or injury from COVID.
00:51:19 And it was just, and everybody's driving their cars,
00:51:21 nobody's giving it a second thought, as it should be.
00:51:24 And yet, this COVID thing gets dressed up
00:51:30 as being far worse than what it is.
00:51:31 And the lockdowns didn't protect the elderly who were in the nursing homes.
00:51:38 They're the ones who took the brunt of COVID.
00:51:42 And lockdowns didn't stop COVID from getting into the nursing homes.
00:51:49 So it's just a lot of unnecessary suffering to have these seniors for weeks on end, months on end,
00:51:55 being confined alone to their rooms and illegal to see their loved ones.
00:51:59 What an evil thing to do.
00:52:02 And it's only possible with a media framework that essentially just defaults to a handful of experts with the same ideology.
00:52:13 You didn't have any fact checks of when Dina Hinshaw claimed that a youth died of COVID, but it was a terminally ill cancer.
00:52:24 um it was like stage four cancer teenager with stage four cancer who died with a positive test
00:52:34 and that fact check like the media if it was doing its role it would have fact checked that
00:52:41 and it would have dug deeper um so you're seeing the same kind of the lack of questions asked
00:52:49 and just rubber stamping these articles.
00:52:52 You're seeing that in COVID
00:52:54 and you're seeing that now
00:52:55 with a lot of the fears of the border,
00:52:59 like crossing the border,
00:53:00 this anti-American rhetoric
00:53:02 where they point to one case in Texas
00:53:05 about a wife and husband getting deported
00:53:09 after overstaying their visa,
00:53:12 but they fail to mention
00:53:14 that there's previous criminal charges
00:53:17 for assault on a minor.
00:53:19 And like all these other details that would shift them from just a random family that just happens to overstay a visa by a month to a high priority case where a lot of the times the surface level gut reaction is somebody reading a headline or they read quickly read a headline and another headline and they didn't die deep.
00:53:41 And the thoughts have already been planted there. The seeds have been planted. And even if a correction comes out, you don't undo those impressions that are trickled out over time.
00:53:55 So I feel like this is just another reason to abolish the CRTC, especially that it's now enabling overt censorship with these additional bills that are coming out.
00:54:09 Um, so it's, it's necessary that there's change and I'm glad that this article is published now, especially that it's more necessary than, than ever to, to have some of these tough conversations.
00:54:27 So.
00:54:29 Well, the good news is the, uh, the, the CBC viewership is, is decreasing.
00:54:36 Even other government-funded media, a while back, I was having coffee with one of the donors to the Justice Center, and he told me that his grandson has never heard of global news.
00:54:49 Good.
00:54:50 You know, his 20-year-old grandson, to be specific.
00:54:53 His 20-year-old grandson gets 100% of his media comes from X and TikTok, and he doesn't know what global news is.
00:55:01 He's never heard of it.
00:55:01 uh, you know, the, the, the younger people are so far removed from a generation where,
00:55:07 uh, and I remember I'm, I'm 58. I grew up in the seventies. And like, if you wanted to watch the
00:55:13 news, you'd make sure you got home by six o'clock to turn on the six o'clock news. Right. And then
00:55:19 there'd be another news at 10 and at 11. And, uh, that, that was the only way to get it. Right.
00:55:26 And, and it was, it was through the television and radio and newspapers as well. But now with
00:55:31 the internet and social media.
00:55:32 Um, so the good news is that these government funded media are slowly
00:55:37 dying a well-deserved death and, uh, every, every month, uh, I think, you
00:55:44 know, independent podcasters and video casters like yourselves, and we've got
00:55:50 independent media like the rebel and Juno news and the Epoch times and the
00:55:55 Western standard and a black locks, a reporter based in, in Ottawa, uh, all of
00:56:02 these are growing and it's wonderful.
00:56:06 And it actually makes it harder for totalitarian dictator to take power
00:56:12 because, you know, if you can't control, right, this is, if you can't centrally
00:56:20 control information, uh, you've got all these pockets of, of resistance.
00:56:25 it's harder to be a tyrant than what it would have been
00:56:30 in the 60s and 70s and 80s,
00:56:32 when if you controlled the TV stations,
00:56:35 the people would only be getting one thing at 6 p.m.
00:56:38 And that was what you wanted the people to hear.
00:56:41 There were no other television stations, right?
00:56:43 It was CBC, CTV, I think Global came later.
00:56:48 Anyway, so this is good.
00:56:50 It's very good.
00:56:51 And so James and I are both 36,
00:56:54 And I think being kind of smack dab in the middle of the of the millennial, maybe on the I think they define the millennial generation is from approximately 1980 to 1995.
00:57:05 I think we are probably the last generation that would have ever grown up with our primary news source, at least in our childhood, being on the TV and newspapers.
00:57:16 And Gen Z, Gen Alpha, I think, is a little bit too young still.
00:57:20 But Gen Z, having grown up with primarily Internet-based news and social media news, is by far the most conservative generation in 100 years, they say.
00:57:30 So I don't think that that's a coincidence that once you stop being propagandized directly by your government-funded media that that would happen.
00:57:39 So, Ms. John Carpe, do you have, just to be respectful of your time here, do you have any events coming up, any speaking engagements, anything you'd like to plug before we let you get on with your evening?
00:57:51 Well, the winner of the George Jonas Freedom Award for 2026 is Candice Malcolm, who heads up Juno News.
00:58:02 And so we are going to have an event in Toronto in July, Vancouver in August, and then Calgary will be September 24th to honor Candice Malcolm.
00:58:15 I am 90% sure that I will be in Edmonton.
00:58:21 We're looking at a public meeting on Thursday, April 30th in Edmonton.
00:58:27 I'll email you more information about that.
00:58:30 And for those who are interested, the Justice Centre, if you want to sign up for an email newsletter,
00:58:38 we send it out only twice a month, so you're not going to get inundated.
00:58:42 But if you go to our website, JCCF, Justice Centre Constitutional Freedoms, jccf.ca,
00:58:49 sign up for our newsletter and that will keep you posted as well if we do have events from time to
00:58:54 time we do geographical email blast to people in that in the area of the event so yeah we're
00:59:07 going to keep on fighting till we win you know times are dark things might get worse
00:59:10 but we just the only thing necessary for evil to triumph is for good people to do nothing
00:59:15 and so we press on
00:59:18 and we're going to keep on
00:59:20 speaking truth to power
00:59:21 and keep on fighting
00:59:24 until we win.
00:59:25 Well, we're very, very glad
00:59:27 that there are people
00:59:27 like you behind the movement.
00:59:28 We thank you for taking the time
00:59:30 to discuss these things
00:59:32 with just a couple of goose
00:59:34 from Edmonton
00:59:34 and always appreciate
00:59:36 having you on the show
00:59:38 and hopefully next time
00:59:40 you guys have a big report
00:59:41 you'll let us chat with you
00:59:43 about it again
00:59:43 and yeah, thank you, sir.
00:59:45 We'll look forward to that
00:59:46 Great to have you on
00:59:49 Have a great rest of the night