The Critical Compass Podcast - December 11, 2025


Martyupnorth on Why Albertans Are Built Different： Mindset, Freedom, and Standing Strong in Canada

＂Why Can't Alberta Have Nice Things？＂ Martyupnorth on the Pipeline MOU ＂Nothingburger＂ ALBERTA INDEPENDENCE SUPPORTERS： This is How We Will Win

Episode Stats


Length

5 minutes

Words per minute

187.29

Word count

1,050

Sentence count

1

Harmful content

Hate speech

1

sentences flagged


Summary

Summaries generated with gmurro/bart-large-finetuned-filtered-spotify-podcast-summ .

In this episode, we talk about the importance of having a strong government in the province of Alberta, and why it's important to have one in your home province. We also talk about some of the challenges facing the province, and how to deal with them, as well as what it means to live in a province that's governed differently than the rest of canada.

Transcript

Transcript generated with Whisper (turbo).
Hate speech classifications generated with facebook/roberta-hate-speech-dynabench-r4-target .
00:00:00.000 with independence looming in the background we don't know if it's a guaranteed thing so
00:00:07.060 if you're enacting if we're making wins along the way even if it doesn't work out we're in a better
00:00:12.620 position so yes in a game of chess this is what we want to be doing essentially yeah uh just before
00:00:20.200 you jumped on me and mike were talking about you know in uh in engineering terms we often draw these
00:00:25.320 um these diagrams these wishbone diagrams where you the you always have a positive negative and
00:00:31.560 then positive negative so you have to think of something not happening i mean people talk about
00:00:35.860 the referendum as if it will automatically win it no you have to put a a yes no possibility right you
00:00:42.940 can so in the grand scheme of things everything that danielle's advancing for us right now is is
00:00:49.500 useful period my my ideal win is a separate alberta but if i can't be a separate alberta i certainly
00:00:55.000 do want a really really strong one within canada i just worry you know it's a topic that comes over
00:01:00.680 and over and over i mean i still worry the fact that they outnumber us out east man they're they're
00:01:05.380 there's you know 25 million to our five and they can always vote against us and i i get pushback from
00:01:12.840 this but i think it validates in the agm and other places we are different the other one we talked about
00:01:18.820 was like uh repealing the no fault you know alberta is getting ready to do no fault insurance and we and
00:01:24.500 the membership clearly said no no no no no no no we don't want that i mean that's a fundamental
00:01:28.120 difference from the rest of most of canada almost everywhere else in canada insurance is a provincial
00:01:33.380 and b no fault so we have private at fault insurance uh gun rights are different here like we we we are
00:01:41.000 promoting if if if the other the to the canadians who argued with me online that they're the same as
00:01:47.500 us then why are you doing things differently like the proof is well completely we're just governed
00:01:54.280 differently i'm like you're governed differently because you're electing people and you're telling
00:01:57.820 them to do things differently i'm showing you that we are do we think differently and we act
00:02:02.880 differently we we bring 4 000 people to the agm and we vote on policies and we make our government
00:02:08.620 change direction so there's no excuse so if you're different than the rest of canada then show it by
00:02:14.120 doing things differently yeah it's it's a it's a mindset that people don't really grab like people
00:02:19.900 think that we're being like you know we said it before like oh we're being redneck albertans or we're
00:02:25.440 being like cocky or being arrogant or whatever but no like if you've done any traveling or if you've
00:02:30.440 lived anywhere else in the country you know that there just is something fundamentally different about
00:02:34.880 the mindset of an albertan versus a nova scotian or a pei islander uh you know there's just there is and
00:02:42.940 even even a an ontarian or a quebecer like there is there is something that happens fundamentally 0.91
00:02:48.680 when you grow up in a province like alberta that has always been an economic engine for a country
00:02:54.900 versus an economic recipient and more of a uh the the the holding place of a managerial or a or an
00:03:04.740 administrative type class like they get used to to things being a certain way because they're allowed
00:03:09.720 to have that benefit because of the work that's done elsewhere that they don't see and so they
00:03:15.760 don't develop that mindset fundamentally and it and it's measurable now it's not just it's not just
00:03:21.860 anecdotal it's measurable right like today there was a today or yesterday this week there's a
00:03:27.380 sure it's a report from the fraser institute say what you want whether you like them or not but it's a
00:03:31.860 report from the fraser institute that shows the economic freedom of of all whatever 87 jurisdictions in
00:03:39.460 north america and alberta is the only one that's a second tier jurisdiction when it comes to economic
00:03:44.900 freedoms compared to other provinces and people go what does that mean economic freedom i just gave
00:03:49.220 you an example i'm free to choose whatever insurance i want if you live in other places you're not free
00:03:53.700 god in quebec they're so restricted i mean in quebec if you enter into a lease you can only enter into a
00:03:58.840 lease from july 1st to july 1st like that's in the law you rent an apartment in quebec it's from july
00:04:03.820 and so if you leave your you know and rent control and things like that like those are examples right
00:04:09.400 like when you can enter in contracts ages that you can do it the the number of crown corporations i
00:04:15.620 mean alberta has less crown corporations than any other province so those are all those all contribute
00:04:20.600 to your economic freedom and then that economic freedom directly translates to uh gdp per capita and
00:04:27.640 wealth and other things so um the the the differences between canada between alberta and other provinces
00:04:33.540 are not just anecdotal they manifest themselves in a lot of data a lot of places you see it when
00:04:39.480 everything becomes either a restricted choice let it be a government decided choice or a regulated choice
00:04:47.500 or it's it's decided for you at that point somebody may be happy with all these government programs
00:04:54.780 what happens if they're run by liberals what happens if they're run by another party so essentially if
00:05:01.220 you if you have more choice and it's the private sector you will get a choice that aligns with your
00:05:08.800 values or the way or the kind of service that you want and you're not gonna run into that counterparty
00:05:15.740 risk of somebody you don't like having to make that choice for you and you see this right now in alberta
00:05:21.880 the ndp voters are not very happy with the ucp doing anything but they also don't want private to do
00:05:29.380 anything they just want their guys to do it with the orange flag
00:05:34.380 you