The Critical Compass Podcast - May 10, 2024


Mixed Public-Private Healthcare & Canada's Struggling System ｜ A Critical Compass Clip

Realism & Radicalism in the Immigration Debate ｜ A Critical Compass Clip Shifting Viewpoints During COVID ｜ A Critical Compass Clip

Episode Stats


Length

4 minutes

Words per minute

145.24

Word count

609

Sentence count

3

Harmful content

Toxicity

1

sentences flagged


Summary

Summaries generated with gmurro/bart-large-finetuned-filtered-spotify-podcast-summ .

In this episode of the podcast, we talk about the new documentary about Canadian health care. We discuss the differences between Canada and the United States in terms of public vs private health care, the benefits and drawbacks of the two systems, and what we can do to improve them.

Transcript

Transcript generated with Whisper (turbo).
Toxicity classifications generated with s-nlp/roberta_toxicity_classifier .
00:00:00.000 well with we like to think that our health care system is something to be envied
00:00:07.580 and actually in the western world it's one of the worst and we're not ready to have that
00:00:15.640 conversation as a country because we've we've based so much of our national identity on this
00:00:20.600 this notion of free health care people just don't have the the context to understand how bad our
00:00:27.520 health care is compared to most other civilized western nations specifically uh the nordic
00:00:32.780 countries in europe so when when you hear this this documentary is definitely worth watching
00:00:36.860 because he interviews a lot of people from uh from european health agencies where they talk about how
00:00:42.540 like a lot of people don't know but most modern western health agencies have a mixed private public
00:00:50.320 system uh and this amongst other things amongst other reasons uh serves to make both significantly
00:00:59.400 better and so when we talk about you know even the notion sometimes of having any sort of uh dual
00:01:06.000 system in canada is is poo-pooed immediately and you're you're accused of wanting to bring you know
00:01:10.600 american style health care to canada and there's just the reality is there's just so much uh in
00:01:16.040 between those two systems the u.s system has its benefits for for certain people if you you know
00:01:21.360 viva fry talked about recently on a prod on a podcast about how you know because he lives part
00:01:27.660 time in florida now he says well you can you can you pay a lot of money for private health insurance in
00:01:33.960 in the u.s uh and you get you get decent care or you could pay a lot of money in taxes to fund
00:01:39.780 a shitty health care system in canada so it'll it'll end up working out about the same
00:01:44.500 but the specifically the the northern european countries with their with their mixed private 0.83
00:01:49.980 public system they are so so superior to ours and in almost every way the the public system
00:01:56.820 functions so much better yeah you get a base level of guaranteed coverage yeah and then the overflows
00:02:05.500 um i i think the the key part is that it's not they have some restrictions on that like a doctor
00:02:14.360 cannot dedicate a hundred percent of their time to a private clinic they must balance out some of
00:02:20.000 the hours so it's not like they're poaching talent they have they're not punished for making some money
00:02:26.360 in the private um there's still incentives for the like for these small clinics to to start up and
00:02:34.780 now you have a expanded capacity because one of the restrictions in canada right now is that
00:02:41.400 you've got a certain amount of funding and if surgery beds if you funded all your surgery beds
00:02:48.680 you could have two open beds the beds are physically open you have somebody willing to
00:02:54.260 do a surgery on that bed but they can't fund it therefore you have capacity that can't be met with the
00:03:02.100 funding that you have and there are people that well they have to wait eight months for a surgery
00:03:08.160 they would pay money to fund their own service so you you have a mismatch between the demand and the
00:03:16.980 supply and it's kind of just being blocked in the middle so there there is some in between that could
00:03:25.060 be approached and the problem is you mentioned that the conversation gets gets distorted and again that
00:03:34.420 you mentioned that thought terminating cliche of american-style health care or american-style
00:03:41.780 politics or when you build an ethos around these terms um it's easy to demonize
00:03:49.980 things so
00:04:05.540 you
00:04:11.160 you