The Critical Compass Podcast - July 16, 2025


＂Systems Are Being Completely ABUSED＂ - Daniel Tyrie on Canada's Immigration and Integration Crisis

Bruce Pardy on Political Uncertainty, Blind Justice, & How an Independent Alberta Could Save Canada Creating Sustainable International Remigration Agreements (w⧸ India, China, Philippines)

Episode Stats


Length

4 minutes

Words per minute

147.23

Word count

722

Sentence count

1

Harmful content

Hate speech

2

sentences flagged


Summary

Summaries generated with gmurro/bart-large-finetuned-filtered-spotify-podcast-summ .

In this episode of the Canadian History Project, we are joined by the author of the new book, "The Great Immigrants: How Canada Lost Its Identity: The Story of a Country That Lost Its People" to mass immigration. In this episode, we discuss the history of mass immigration in Canada, its impact on the economy, and the impact of mass migration on the social fabric of the country.

Transcript

Transcript generated with Whisper (turbo).
Hate speech classifications generated with facebook/roberta-hate-speech-dynabench-r4-target .
00:00:00.000 but i i think where you're coming from is you're looking at the almost like the supply and demand
00:00:07.480 like it's a numbers game aspect of like well we only have so much space in our hospitals we only
00:00:13.900 have so many houses we only have so many things and we currently are a welfare heavy country
00:00:20.160 and all these social programs the more you feed into it the more these programs are strained and
00:00:27.440 they have not grown proportionately with the population and this is a large influx of people
00:00:33.800 who are there's no pressure to fully assimilate so this is like a different flavor of immigration
00:00:39.800 than what was happening even in like the 80s and 90s where you have people fully integrating and
00:00:46.860 adopting canadian values in a way that we're not seeing now and it's interesting that you bring up
00:00:52.500 the the kind of 80s and 90s because this is really when in my book mass immigration started
00:01:00.200 so under brian mulroney who was prime minister in the in the 80s um he transformed our style of
00:01:07.220 immigration uh before then we had what was kind of colloquially known as a tap on tap off style of
00:01:13.980 immigration so when the economy was hot and we needed more workers uh government quotas would go
00:01:20.520 up and we'd bring in more people when the economy was stagnating or or doing badly they would turn
00:01:25.740 off the taps and there would be very little to no immigration now that these factors have been taken
00:01:31.020 off completely we've seen a gradual change now we're in in this radical period where things are
00:01:35.600 completely out of hand as you're saying the systems are being completely abused um and a lot of it is is
00:01:41.800 pushed uh to the uh to the next level by these temporary programs foreign students temporary foreign
00:01:49.040 workers which have really grown obscenely since since the period we're indicating but that's why i
00:01:54.540 wanted to bring it back to that period um this completely different style of immigration allowed for
00:01:59.840 better integration into socially and into our economy these things are intertwined um whereas now
00:02:07.780 especially with this burden of temporary uh migrants who you know have even less incentive to 1.00
00:02:14.320 to integrate into our society because they're not even going to be here uh permanently um we're seeing
00:02:21.520 really uh much larger social impacts so uh to bring it back to to the original question around uh
00:02:29.500 remigration uh remigration is a kind of term that's been taking off mainly in europe where uh where
00:02:35.560 they've seen uh many many of these european countries are a little bit ahead of us uh as a regard of
00:02:41.340 waves of migration and migrant crises that have impacted those countries uh simply put it's it's
00:02:47.820 kind of an umbrella term including a wide variety of policies with the general ends of uh returning
00:02:56.500 foreigners to their homeland but it's rooted in this uh idea that mass immigration has not only caused 0.99
00:03:04.940 economic problems which it definitely has um but also uh it's rooted in the concept that
00:03:13.600 a country is more than just economic boundaries with uh with laws and an economy countries are based
00:03:22.580 based on nations and and strictly speaking uh a nation like these while they're often used as synonyms
00:03:30.840 as country nation it's it's not exactly accurate a nation is a group of people with common ancestry a
00:03:39.000 common history a common culture a common language um it's really the the next building block beyond the
00:03:46.240 the family unit um the nation is is really an extended family um and uh remigration is kind of rooted in this
00:03:56.340 idea that uh mass immigration especially but immigration policies in general uh when they when
00:04:04.780 used irresponsibly uh have an impact on the ethno-cultural identity of the nation and fundamentally
00:04:11.340 transforms them into something else and we've been seeing this especially in in uh areas and even
00:04:17.540 cities that have become at the ghettos uh the common ones people point to are things like brampton
00:04:22.840 and surrey um so uh remigration is not just to to protect the economic interests of canadians or
00:04:31.660 or whatever nation that we're focused on it's also to preserve the the culture and identity of those
00:04:37.880 nations for the long term
00:04:52.840 you