The Critical Compass Podcast - February 04, 2025


This is Not the Greatest Live Stream in the World.

Mentioned
Fixing Edmonton w⧸City Council Candidate Jason Bale | A Critical Compass Discussion Understanding The Tariffs with Martyupnorth

Episode Stats


Length

19 minutes

Words per minute

154.85

Word count

3,047

Sentence count

—

Harmful content

Misogyny

2

sentences flagged

Toxicity

8

sentences flagged

Hate speech

2

sentences flagged


Summary

Summaries generated with gmurro/bart-large-finetuned-filtered-spotify-podcast-summ .

In this episode, we discuss the current state of de-education in Canada and how it relates to the Trump administration, the ongoing trade war with the US, and the potential impact on de-funding for Canadian universities.

Transcript

Transcript generated with Whisper (turbo).
Misogyny classifications generated with MilaNLProc/bert-base-uncased-ear-misogyny .
Toxicity classifications generated with s-nlp/roberta_toxicity_classifier .
Hate speech classifications generated with facebook/roberta-hate-speech-dynabench-r4-target .
Hosts, guests, and mentioned names generated with spaCy (en_core_web_sm), reconciled against Wikidata.
00:00:00 here that looks like we're live on x yeah looks like we are let's double check uh see if youtube's
00:00:09 good i don't know how to tell actually through your channel um there is a live tab yeah it looks
00:00:18 it shows on our on our home page anyway there we go the uh yeah this is not the greatest live stream
00:00:26 this is this is just this is just a test um yeah nice to nice to have this rolling and
00:00:34 i guess for us to be able to unpack certain topics in real time um
00:00:40 yeah so i guess i don't want to talk about the terrace because we're going to talk about
00:00:47 stuff tomorrow indeed with a special guest that the special guest that our fans are are familiar
00:00:53 with a guest who occasionally gets spicy which is great um i did want to bring up i was kind of
00:01:02 musing on some some ideas of in the u.s we're seeing dei getting dismantled more by force
00:01:12 through the executive orders and then canada we have no such thing and i'm curious on like
00:01:20 what will happen as there's more pushback well it's like in the united states it's you're not
00:01:28 going to be able to call it dei so they're going to either rename or try to like sidestep it some
00:01:34 way and then i'm curious like what are the pressures like how is that going to translate
00:01:39 into canada because i i feel like these frameworks are very much inbuilt and they've started from the
00:01:47 universities and these HR trained individuals are the ones upholding a lot of the DEI with their 0.68
00:01:55 body of bullshit literature. Yeah. So I don't know, like in some ways I'm optimistic about the 0.98
00:02:03 DEI shift potentially, but I don't know if it's going to happen as quickly or as cleanly as I
00:02:12 think some some are thinking well i mean i think we're and it's i'm blanking right now but i know
00:02:19 for sure there are uh a few i don't know like maybe university or university adjacent institutions
00:02:26 that are they're saying that they're you know closing dei uh offices and job positions and
00:02:34 stuff but a lot of them are just renaming like you say or are um there are even some institutions
00:02:39 that are doubling and tripling down on their initiatives um i don't think canada has i mean
00:02:47 i'm of two minds of it because there it's a good question because there are you know sort of you
00:02:53 know as goes the u.s so goes you know the rest of the western world so that it could just kind of
00:02:59 by osmosis kind of filter down to our general cultural zeitgeist and and we could see a move
00:03:07 away from it but then what's kind of been made clear the last few days here in the uh in the um
00:03:13 wake of the again we're not going to talk about it but the tariff announcements is this whole like
00:03:18 team canada horse shit that you know there's there's uh andy lee was talking about it a couple 0.76
00:03:25 other um another friend of the channel um and a few others have been talking about how like 0.99
00:03:31 canada canadians have a long storied history of just identifying in the negative against like
00:03:39 you know we defining themselves by the fact that they're not americans
00:03:44 so i would be curious to know if we see a um you know a doubling and tripling down at a national
00:03:53 level just to say hey we're not we're not like trump in the u.s even though you know the
00:03:57 generally speaking the people are very similar you know we we share a lot of the same
00:04:03 ways of living and same general ideas um as as most americans i would say uh yeah the tds could
00:04:12 even amplify it here in canada because uniting over the we're not the bad orange man up here
00:04:20 they could say well look how terrible and how racist of a place it is in the states now without
00:04:26 DEI and that's why we need
00:04:28 DEI in Canada
00:04:30 and that's why we need to
00:04:32 ramp it up like it could go the other
00:04:34 direction yeah it
00:04:36 could you know it's
00:04:37 it's a very
00:04:39 it's a
00:04:43 tough thing because I don't see us having
00:04:46 the political will
00:04:47 that the US has
00:04:50 because I
00:04:52 saw that you know
00:04:53 we viewed it immediately
00:04:55 in how badly Polyev fumbled the messaging from the Conservatives.
00:05:00 He could have easily been, you know,
00:05:04 he could have said what he was supposed to say,
00:05:08 which was, hey, let's strengthen the border.
00:05:11 Let's stop the fentanyl.
00:05:12 Let's stop the illegals. 1.00
00:05:13 You know, that's, let's just do what, you know,
00:05:17 Trump asked us a month ago, over a month ago,
00:05:20 two months ago, just about.
00:05:21 uh but he kind of parroted the same kind of fake like tough guy routine that the Trudeau liberals
00:05:28 were were pulling and it was just sort of unappealing so yeah I don't I don't I don't see
00:05:33 you know Canadians are have a long history of uh you know trying to appear moderate and
00:05:46 as uh gad sad might say like employ suicidal empathy and how we approach these sort of issues
00:05:53 so i just don't see it i don't i don't really see it happening to the same degree and i think it
00:05:58 which is a shame because i think it kind of needs to like i think watching what trump is able to do
00:06:03 with executive orders is pretty uh i'm i'm pretty envious of it of it actually but with it being an
00:06:11 executive order will it be undone in four years yeah yeah i mean they're sort of relying on i
00:06:19 think i think a lot of the steps that they're taking and a lot of the this like how heavy
00:06:25 handed the the eos have been so far they're sort of i think uh banking on a jd vance presidency
00:06:35 like potentially getting another four to eight years out of this um which you know there was
00:06:42 some talk previously of like oh you know who is it going to be like is is vivek going to be
00:06:48 okay with you know because obviously the the idea is going to be to run jd as the presidential
00:06:54 candidate knowing that trump can't run again and having him already be in the vice presidential
00:06:59 office for four years, but, you know, always Vivek going to be okay being, you know, a VP
00:07:04 potentially candidate or some, some other, you know, Secretary of State or something, and then
00:07:10 waiting another potentially eight years for his shot. But now that's no, there's no, I mean, I
00:07:16 don't think there's any real consideration of that right now. I think they're just, they're
00:07:21 planning on having another, you know, potential, you know, decade plus of being able to ride this.
00:07:28 And if they, you know, if they get the results out of it that they're, you know, it's sort of at least hoping to get with with the DOG, it may be an easy ride for them.
00:07:40 There may not be. I don't think that the I don't think that the Democratic Party has the will currently to get their house in order in time to really mount any significant challenge.
00:07:52 I mean, four years is a long time, but I just don't see it happening.
00:07:55 yeah so you may see the same hopefully in canada you have the same kind of thing as if the liberals
00:08:04 get out with them will be tied some of these well some of these ideas of let it be the dei
00:08:12 and like these outwardly discriminatory practices and maybe the obsession with
00:08:19 kind of the gender ideology um that might be tied to like well these are dying ideologies with a 0.77
00:08:28 dying party yeah and you may have that still tied together in association but that will also require
00:08:35 the conservatives to like really speak up and take a hard stand on these and not just like
00:08:44 poke their heads above water when it's convenient yeah yeah and not just be like the historical like
00:08:50 you know i don't know if we have any americans watching right now or who will be watching this
00:08:56 but um like our our conservative party is well to the left of the republican party like or i'm sorry
00:09:07 of the um um of the democrat party like they're they're uh they're still on the grand scheme of
00:09:15 thing are a very left of center party so it's not like you know we have a real uh any any real risk
00:09:22 in canada of having a of a modern uh you know maga movement in in this country it's just not
00:09:28 it's just not in us at the moment unfortunately so sorry there's a fire alarm in the background but
00:09:36 that'll happen why don't you talk for a second to the to the people and go make sure my apartment's
00:09:40 not burning down yeah good to check these things the uh yeah so we're also seeing
00:09:47 um a few more like protests pop up um in the pro or not even protests like a few protesters
00:09:58 saying like we'll deport them
00:10:01 they must go
00:10:04 and we've seen some like counter protests as well
00:10:07 and I'm curious if that will start ramping up
00:10:10 and to what extent
00:10:12 to what extent that will grow
00:10:18 and these protests
00:10:20 I feel like they're always
00:10:23 they're always speaking to some of the ideas that people have
00:10:27 but they get misrepresent so or they get misrepresented and often it's they're painted
00:10:33 like well if somebody says um yeah so with these it's a no fire what did i miss no my wife just
00:10:44 told me told me to tell our viewers that it's just her cooking it's not a it's not a not a fire
00:10:49 not a fire yet
00:10:51 the night is young
00:10:52 what did I miss?
00:10:56 I was basically just pointing
00:10:58 out that we have seen
00:11:00 a few different protesters pop up
00:11:02 and like let it be
00:11:04 the like deport
00:11:06 them all or they must go home
00:11:07 and then we've had counter protesters as well
00:11:10 and they do speak
00:11:12 to some of these sentiments
00:11:14 and on one side it speaks to
00:11:16 people worried
00:11:18 about endless immigration
00:11:19 so that's one side of things and then the other side is well the people counter protest and saying
00:11:25 diversity is our strength are the ones fully encapsulated by the this dei mentality of like
00:11:34 well we must equalize outcomes and it's our moral duty to extend a helping hand and welcome everybody
00:11:41 in and um so you see these kind of polar opposites in these in these views yeah yeah and there's a
00:11:49 There was a, people were noticing that on the, you know, it was a fairly small turnout for the, you know, deport them all kind of thing.
00:11:56 And I'm not fully convinced that it wasn't a, some sort of operation.
00:12:02 It gets very convenient.
00:12:05 Like it turns into a very convenient set of CBC articles.
00:12:10 Yeah, that's right.
00:12:10 Just prior to a, to a, to an inauguration, right?
00:12:14 Yeah, it's, it's a bit of a, yeah, it's a bit, bit convenient for me, but.
00:12:19 um but in the but people were noticing that in in the counter protest the you know diversity is
00:12:26 our strength protests not a not a canadian flag to be seen hey just just trans flags gay flags
00:12:33 uh uh palestine flags that's you know i don't know if i don't know how many palestinians are
00:12:40 in edmonton but it can't be much to but it's just like a it's a interesting observation that it
00:12:47 seems to be that the um the choices are either you're a uh you're a proud canadian or you're a
00:12:58 sensitive progressive liberal who wants to welcome diversity like it's it couldn't possibly be there
00:13:05 couldn't possibly be some shade in between there you're either a a nazi or a or a or an ally right
00:13:12 Yeah, they are incapable of a nuanced view in that way.
00:13:20 And even, like, we're still running the issue of, like, they're not representing their position very well. 0.99
00:13:27 It's all the leftists in North America who are taking whatever legitimate concerns of the Palestinian people or the legitimate cases of, let it be, the potential war crimes in Gaza, and they are making it very easy for them to be dismissed because they're acting completely idiotic. 0.88
00:13:54 they are they are not making themselves look good so i i feel like they don't fully understand 0.98
00:14:02 the optics of them just being idiots in canada and like what that's they're they're not helping 0.98
00:14:09 their cause so i feel like it's more self-serving than it is them actually making a difference they 1.00
00:14:14 are yeah it's performative yeah performative virtue signaling they care about doing the good
00:14:22 thing and signaling that they are doing the good thing yeah i don't i don't know that you would be
00:14:27 able to have necessarily a nuanced or or any any kind of like really interesting or
00:14:34 enlightening conversation with any of these people i don't think that they have try i try
00:14:40 all the time yeah and i'm pleasantly surprised at at how they are unable to like i i try to at
00:14:48 least give them the benefit of the doubt yeah um and then like ask well what do you think about this
00:14:54 what do you think about that and i'm open to being i would love for them to show me like a little bit
00:15:02 of nuance or for them to like actually either steel man the other side or do any of that but
00:15:10 they don't and so my hope's not not the highest that way so we'll see yeah yeah i mean there's
00:15:19 only so many i i don't know how it's not more uh noticeable that you know there's it only ever goes
00:15:29 one way like it only ever works there is never a conservative voice or any sort of like dissident
00:15:37 type of conservative voice is never at risk of ever being you know legitimately in good faith
00:15:43 offered a conversation from a from a leftist media outlet or or a commentator you know on on
00:15:50 twitter or wherever any sort of news outlet where you constantly you know it doesn't take any
00:15:57 searching it's like you're constantly seeing invitations for people to it's like it's from a
00:16:04 even if nothing else from a like a competitive or challenge sort of standpoint you know like come
00:16:10 like you know let me i want to feel smarter than you or whatever at least it's like at least the
00:16:15 offer is made you know even if it's not like even if it's in a competitive kind of way like
00:16:20 you know uh like a i'm imagining like the online equivalent of steven crowder or or charlie kirk at
00:16:28 change your change my mind yeah or like you know debate you know an active sort of debate challenge
00:16:34 like at least the the attempt is being made at a conversation so so and and we've mentioned this
00:16:41 before that the left will they will narrow they will keep on narrowing what they're accepting
00:16:48 of what you're able to like either discuss or talk about or what opinions you're allowed to have
00:16:55 through media and if you have an opinion outside of that they won't invite you back but those
00:17:01 people want it like this is how we have a whole group of left of center commentators and
00:17:08 intellectuals who have not been invited back on anything any left mainstream programs so that now
00:17:17 they talk to somebody in the middle or on the right and then that's used as evidence of here
00:17:23 That's why we can't invite you back because you're on the right now.
00:17:27 You're right adjacent or you're platforming, you're amplifying these terrible people on the right.
00:17:34 It's like how Dave Smith describes how liberal news outlets play at attempting to talk about the other side.
00:17:46 is they'll invite they'll invite another liberal on and ask them what the conservative response to
00:17:53 some issue would be instead of just asking a conservative in the first place because it's like
00:17:57 i don't know but um might as well get it from the source but well yeah if they get it from the
00:18:04 source though then they risk then they risk having a compelling argument being being heard on their
00:18:09 platform and that's that's antithetical to the messaging because yeah like you say it's you know
00:18:14 they they legitimately i don't know if it's legitimate all the time but they will view the
00:18:21 even the expressing like it's if they view it in terms of good and evil i mean you can't it's not
00:18:30 it's not a matter of like having two competing ideas in the marketplace it's a you know it's a
00:18:36 matter of good versus evil so that's you can't if you're a good person you can't let evil even
00:18:41 risk propagating right because they view themselves as a as the gatekeeper of of evil yeah exactly so
00:18:48 that's something we can definitely unpack a little bit more in the future but i feel like as a as a
00:18:55 test this is a good test i think so yeah a good 20 minutes we got uh yeah i was keeping track we
00:19:00 had a maximum of seven viewers so that's very nice for a first stream nice to have a couple just poke
00:19:06 their heads in and we'll see how the
00:19:09 comments and or some of the
00:19:10 interactions happen as we do these
00:19:12 more but yeah yeah tomorrow we have
00:19:14 Marty up north joining us we're gonna
00:19:16 unpack some of the spoilers about
00:19:19 tariffs yeah I think spoiling it for
00:19:22 six people is not not the worst I
00:19:25 expect all six of you back five now yeah
00:19:29 that's sweet okay man well yeah thanks
00:19:32 for setting this up we'll we'll do this
00:19:33 again tomorrow and yeah it looks like
00:19:35 we're looks like we're good yeah all right cheers my friend cool cheers buddy see ya