The Critical Compass Podcast - February 11, 2024


What is Gender？ ｜ A Critical Compass Clip

Is Transgenderism a Disorder？ ｜ A Critical Compass Clip Danielle Smith, Transgenderism, & The Coutts Four ｜ A Critical Compass Discussion

Episode Stats


Length

5 minutes

Words per minute

155.18

Word count

889

Sentence count

1

Harmful content

Misogyny

3

sentences flagged

Hate speech

3

sentences flagged


Summary

Summaries generated with gmurro/bart-large-finetuned-filtered-spotify-podcast-summ .

In this episode, we discuss gender and its role in our society, as well as the controversial topic of transgenderism and gender identity. What does gender mean, what does it mean to be transgender, and what does that mean to us as a society?

Transcript

Transcript generated with Whisper (turbo).
Misogyny classifications generated with MilaNLProc/bert-base-uncased-ear-misogyny .
Hate speech classifications generated with facebook/roberta-hate-speech-dynabench-r4-target .
00:00:00.000 I have a theory and I don't know I don't think I've stolen this from anyone I think
00:00:09.240 but other people may have reached the same conclusion I I believe actually that me and
00:00:14.920 maybe this is extreme of me but I actually don't think that the word gender has any useful meaning
00:00:20.180 I feel like when people say gender if they're not using it as a synonym for sex male or female
00:00:29.640 and they separate those then what I believe they mean what they actually mean when they say
00:00:36.300 gender either it boils down to one of two things either a a sexuality like a sexual proclivity or
00:00:44.040 preference or to a personality trait and and I've challenged people to this on on x before and they
00:00:54.160 I again like I same as you I don't really get a clean answer to it or a concise answer to it but
00:01:00.520 I would challenge anyone maybe anyone listening who disagrees with me on this if you can if you
00:01:07.080 can describe your gender that isn't um that doesn't boil down to just either a personality trait or a
00:01:14.100 sexual proclivity I would be very interested to know because that's all that I hear about it when
00:01:19.460 somebody says they're you know usually what they're referring to like say that they're um you
00:01:24.640 know maybe a gender you know well probably that means if you're a woman maybe you're a little bit 1.00
00:01:31.900 bisexual and maybe you present a little bit more um androgynous it may be the same for a man for a man 0.52
00:01:38.600 too a gender is just one that came to mind but there's no doubt countless examples but that's my
00:01:44.440 theory I'm sticking to it until proven otherwise well if if there's a word that's commonly used
00:01:53.400 in our society and it interacts with the way people live their lives we would want a clear definition
00:02:00.500 of that word we want to make sure that we all know what it means and we're all using it in the same ways
00:02:06.360 and if gender is sometimes used for sex and then sometimes used for just describing how people feel
00:02:13.460 based on traits or personality then it doesn't really describe the the usefulness of that word
00:02:21.520 is it's useless except for people's feelings about themselves so if somebody says well I identify as
00:02:32.120 female great they just told us that they maybe act or feel a little bit more feminine well what does that
00:02:41.660 mean like how do we navigate do we treat them differently now just because they they have a
00:02:49.140 few more feminine traits like or are we at this point where differences in some of these big five 1.00
00:02:57.360 personality traits don't really matter as much on a day-to-day basis like you'll naturally find
00:03:03.440 people who maybe in like a heterosexual relationship the high assertiveness in a male
00:03:10.380 in males is still like still a desirable trait from women when they're dating like men in a relationship 0.99
00:03:18.940 they still look for these things so in those cases these these personality traits maybe if they fit these
00:03:27.120 traditional kind of averages across the like when we sample our population like it maybe it's more
00:03:34.960 stable in those circumstances but on the fringes you'll always have tomboys and you always have
00:03:42.400 like feminine men and yeah yeah and there's even look at like the artist community like there's all
00:03:51.440 kinds of misfits uh personnel like well and that's where you get we're both members of that of that
00:03:57.980 misfit artist community so we know it's it's absolutely true but and the the point of it is 1.00
00:04:02.760 too that um look i i hate that you know we have to do this because if anyone knows this in real life
00:04:11.220 they know that we're not you know we're not judgmental people we're not um you know we aren't
00:04:16.020 we don't go out seeking to you know be rude to people or disrespectful or mean or anything like that
00:04:21.760 so i hate that i have to say it but what this ultimately comes down to is i and i know you would
00:04:29.140 agree don't believe that there's any right or wrong way to be a boy or a girl or a man or woman there's
00:04:36.540 just the way that you are and and and that's fine and you should be able to have a community that you
00:04:42.000 can you know have friends and relationships in and and be accepted for exactly who you are
00:04:48.680 i think that actually that's that's much less sexist and uh divisive and exclusionary i think
00:04:58.940 that's a word uh then then being the other way where you know if you have to take it back to the
00:05:04.840 schools if you have an activist teacher who who looks at a at a little boy who maybe is more
00:05:08.780 interested in playing with uh the stereotypically girls toys or the or a little uh girl who's more
00:05:15.280 interested in playing you know sports or something more stereotypically boyish or masculine to suggest
00:05:22.680 that those little boys or girls are uh exhibiting signs of transgenderism or or are truly the opposite
00:05:30.360 sex or whatever that seems to me to be very regressive and sexist and and not accepting of
00:05:36.740 the differences of in personality that everyone has
00:05:39.420 you