Corporate Press LOSES IT After Meta NUKES Their Ability To Censor Conservatives & HELP Democrats
Episode Stats
Words per Minute
174.62517
Summary
In December of 2016, after Donald Trump had been elected, a third party fact-checking service called PolitiFact launched. Almost immediately after, due to pressure from the mainstream media, saying that there was too much misinformation, there was criticism that fact-checkers played a role in disseminating some of this false information or fake news. And now, with Trump about to re-enter office, Mark Zuckerberg took to social media to say we are ending the third-party fact checking program. We ve reached a point where it s just too many mistakes and too much censorship. So we re going to get back to our roots and focus on reducing mistakes, simplifying our policies, and restoring free expression on our platforms.
Transcript
00:00:00.480
Manage expenses with the TD Low-Rate Visa Card.
00:00:03.960
With a low annual interest rate, the TD Low-Rate Visa Card can help find some balance.
00:00:15.160
Their entrance makes the bingo balls rumble in fear.
00:00:19.800
The free space is free out of respect for them.
00:00:25.440
They're not just grandmas. They're grandmasters.
00:00:29.180
It's Betty, Dolly, Martha, queens of Delta Bingo, haulers of the haul.
00:00:35.840
And they're here to teach the next generation of players.
00:00:39.800
Learn what it takes to be a bingo master at grandmasters.ca.
00:00:45.280
In December of 2016, Facebook launched its third-party fact-checking service.
00:00:51.120
Almost immediately after Donald Trump had been elected,
00:00:53.820
due to pressure from the mainstream media saying that there was too much misinformation.
00:00:58.640
There was a criticism that Facebook played a role in disseminating some of this false information or fake news.
00:01:06.700
We're looking at things like working with third parties, helping to label false news.
00:01:11.400
Misinformation is something we take seriously, really seriously.
00:01:15.140
Everyday Americans had their posts visibility limited, and many lost their accounts entirely.
00:01:19.740
As the government was putting increasing pressure on social media companies to fact-check and de-platform right-wing voices,
00:01:26.180
the right were finding their voices stifled in the new town square.
00:01:29.460
Now, real quick, before we get into the rest, check out castbrew.com.
00:01:37.200
Maybe you want a bag of two weeks till Christmas, despite the fact it's two weeks from Christmas.
00:01:41.820
But either way, it's delicious gingerbread coffee.
00:01:44.500
And you get a picture of Phil Labonte, of all that remains, dressed as Santa Claus.
00:01:48.560
But everybody's favorite, Appalachian Nights, is available, as well as Ian's Graphene Dreams.
00:02:01.060
Mark Zuckerberg took to social media to say we are ending the third-party fact-checking program.
00:02:06.620
We've reached a point where it's just too many mistakes and too much censorship.
00:02:10.860
The recent elections also feel like a cultural tipping point towards once again prioritizing speech.
00:02:16.820
So we're going to get back to our roots and focus on reducing mistakes, simplifying our policies,
00:02:22.260
and restoring free expression on our platforms.
00:02:25.380
More specifically, here's what we're going to do.
00:02:27.880
First, we're going to get rid of fact-checkers and replace them with community notes, similar
00:02:35.700
After Trump first got elected in 2016, the legacy media wrote non-stop about how misinformation
00:02:44.060
We tried in good faith to address those concerns without becoming the arbiters of truth.
00:02:49.040
But the fact-checkers have just been too politically biased and have destroyed more trust than they've
00:02:55.560
They will allow more speech by lifting restrictions on some topics that are a part of mainstream
00:03:00.340
discourse and focusing on enforcement of illegal and high-severity violations.
00:03:04.940
They're also going to take a more personalized approach to political content so that people
00:03:11.340
A big component of the controversy was that Mark Zuckerberg said we are going to downrank
00:03:17.520
That's right, if you like sharing political memes or information pertaining to the goings
00:03:22.380
on of the world, they actually restricted your ability to share this information.
00:03:28.480
Meta's decision affects contracts it has with 10 fact-checking partners in the U.S.
00:03:33.120
Its website shows it has similar business arrangements with fact-check organizations in about 119 countries,
00:03:45.780
Now, the fact-checkers are pointing the finger back at Meta.
00:03:48.900
PolitiFact is claiming that bias isn't the problem because they were following Meta's
00:03:53.880
And in one of the most hilarious headlines, the New York Times wrote that Meta says the
00:03:59.120
fact-checkers were biased, but fact-checkers say, no, we weren't.
00:04:03.800
I love it because it's like the, we've investigated ourselves and found we did nothing wrong.
00:04:08.180
In this post from Aaron Schrockman, who is leading the Poynter Institute, which basically
00:04:14.280
decided who was going to be in this program, he says, PolitiFact will have more to say on
00:04:20.600
The decision has nothing to do with free speech or censorship.
00:04:23.800
PolitiFact is an original partner and has been working on this project for eight plus
00:04:27.400
The statement reads, the decision to remove independent journalists from Facebook's
00:04:31.520
content moderation program in the U.S. has nothing to do with free speech or censorship.
00:04:35.600
Mark Zuckerberg's decision could not be less subtle.
00:04:38.960
PolitiFact is one of the five original partners who worked with Facebook to launch a fact-checking
00:04:45.920
And our journalists have worked on the project for more than eight years, publishing thousands
00:04:52.860
The decision to remove or penalize a post or account is made by Meta and Facebook, not
00:05:01.040
The role of PolitiFact and other U.S.-based journalists has always been to provide additional
00:05:04.680
speech and context to posts that journalists found to contain misinformation.
00:05:09.380
The role of Facebook and Meta has always been to decide what to do with that information.
00:05:13.400
Facebook and Meta solely created the penalties that publishers faced and the warning labels
00:05:19.740
It was Facebook and Meta that created a system that allowed ordinary citizens to see their
00:05:24.140
posts demoted but exempted politicians and political leaders who said the very same
00:05:29.000
In case it needs to be said, PolitiFact and the U.S. fact-checking journalists played no
00:05:34.260
role in the decision to remove Donald Trump from Facebook.
00:05:37.300
Today, if they chose, Facebook and Meta could remove the penalties publishers face from posting
00:05:42.040
false claims and create a system that allows independent journalists to provide additional
00:05:46.620
information and speech to users looking to understand the entire picture.
00:05:50.980
The great thing about free speech is that people are able to disagree about any piece of
00:05:56.660
You can see all of our work online at PolitiFact.
00:05:59.340
We don't use anonymous sources and we provide a bibliography of sorts to all the information
00:06:05.140
When we make an error, there is a process to correct those mistakes.
00:06:08.440
And there is also a process to make sure Facebook and Meta receive the correct information.
00:06:12.920
That's how the information cycle is supposed to work.
00:06:15.300
If Meta is upset it created a tool to censor, it should look in the mirror.
00:06:20.100
Signed, Aaron Sharkokman, PolitiFact Executive Director.
00:06:25.460
I think he meant to say Aaron Sharkokman, but maybe he has a typo.
00:06:30.120
The journalists are saying, hey, we didn't downrank anybody or flag them or accuse them
00:06:36.160
All we did was say that these posts contained misinformation.
00:06:43.060
For many publications like the Daily Wire, the Babylon Bee, and even Timcast, when they
00:06:48.180
would flag our content as false, they would put a big old label on the front saying that
00:06:54.540
Manage expenses with the TD Low Rate Visa Card.
00:06:58.620
With a low annual interest rate, the TD Low Rate Visa Card can help find some balance.
00:07:10.020
When we didn't, often the stories that we published were either satire in the case of
00:07:14.600
the Babylon Bee or with the Daily Wire, Timcast, and many others, we were 100% correct.
00:07:20.480
The reality is these third-party fact-checking organizations were massively biased.
00:07:25.840
Take a look at this list of 10 third-party fact-checking organizations that had contracts
00:07:31.000
You've got AFP, Check Your Fact, FactCheck.org, Lead Stories, PolitiFact, Science Feedback,
00:07:38.880
Reuters, Televisia, Univision, The Dispatch, and USA Today.
00:07:42.180
There was only one partner with Meta that could even be considered right-leaning.
00:07:49.680
So let's take a look at the fact-check bias chart.
00:07:52.940
One of the original partners, PolitiFact, had issues with left-leaning bias dating back
00:07:59.180
University of Minnesota School of Public Affairs had actually done a survey of PolitiFact,
00:08:03.560
and they evaluated all 500 statements that PolitiFact had rated from January of 2010
00:08:09.560
They found that of the 98 statements that PolitiFact had rated false, 74 of them were
00:08:16.340
Duke University found that among PolitiFact's most prolific fact-checkers, there is a heterogeneity
00:08:21.980
in their relative ratings of Democrats and Republicans that may suggest the presence of
00:08:27.460
But hey, let's not just assume third-party analysis is correct.
00:08:31.980
Let's actually show you many times they got it wrong and dangerously wrong.
00:08:41.320
In 2020, Facebook and Twitter took action to halt the spread of an article by the New
00:08:45.200
York Post based on leaked emails from a laptop belonging to Joe Biden's son, Hunter Biden.
00:08:49.660
Initially, Facebook reduced the visibility of the news stories, adding a note saying,
00:08:54.380
If we have signals that a piece of content is false, we temporarily reduce its distribution
00:09:01.280
There was a lot of attention on Twitter during the election because of the Hunter Biden laptop
00:09:14.940
I mean, basically, the background here is the FBI, I think, basically came to us, some
00:09:20.800
It was like, hey, just so you know, you should be on high alert.
00:09:24.660
We thought that there was a lot of Russian propaganda in the 2016 election.
00:09:30.060
We have it on notice that basically there's about to be some kind of dump that's similar
00:09:40.560
The distribution on Facebook was decreased, but people were still allowed to share it.
00:09:47.480
So when you say the distribution has decreased, how does that work?
00:09:51.360
Basically, the ranking in News Feed was a little bit less.
00:09:54.180
So fewer people saw it than would have otherwise.
00:09:59.880
I don't know off the top of my head, but it's meaningful.
00:10:03.080
I don't know if the answer would have been don't do anything or don't have any process.
00:10:12.340
But obviously, you don't want situations like that.
00:10:14.840
Facebook later undid the bloc, which it said had stemmed from concerns around Russian
00:10:19.520
But the decision to suppress the story while waiting for it to be fact-checked caused major
00:10:28.700
As coronavirus spread around the world, suggestions that the virus could have been man-made were
00:10:34.240
An opinion column in the New York Post with the headline, Don't Buy China's Story, the
00:10:38.200
coronavirus may have leaked from a lab, was labeled as false information.
00:10:42.180
The decision infuriated the U.S. newspaper, which insisted the piece just discussed the theory
00:10:46.920
rather than making a definitive claim one way or the other.
00:10:50.180
It was months later that further doubts emerged over the origins of coronavirus.
00:10:54.940
We do not definitively know where the virus came from.
00:10:58.120
Intelligent Report in 2023 said its agencies had been unable to determine the precise origin
00:11:05.240
Claims the virus may have leaked from a lab in Wuhan are false, although some scientists
00:11:10.580
In 2021, Facebook lifted its ban on claims the virus could have been man-made.
00:11:15.780
Obviously, as it pertained to COVID, the whole thing was suppressed in favor of a mainstream
00:11:24.340
Famously, Fauci said early on, you don't need to be wearing a mask, but then later said,
00:11:30.940
And then, of course, mask mandates became the thing.
00:11:33.200
The confusion was largely due to these companies and the narrative machine telling you what you
00:11:38.960
could or could not say, to where famously, Bill Burr, the comedian, said, I just turn
00:11:49.820
Now, I don't think that's necessarily the fault of fact checkers, but we cannot live in
00:11:54.640
a reality where you have massive tech platforms, leaving everybody just scrambling, completely
00:12:03.140
Perhaps it's a good reason to say, maybe we should just let the people decide.
00:12:08.100
And hey, obviously, the COVID stuff gets a little crazy.
00:12:11.940
A lot of misinformation, a lot of confusion, a narrative machine trying to tell us what
00:12:19.960
Kamala has never been referred to as the borders are, they claimed.
00:12:23.160
How about Biden wandering away from world leaders at the G7 meeting?
00:12:27.080
And we can't forget the very fine people hoax statements from Trump in 2017 that took until
00:12:33.280
June of 2024 for a fact checker to confirm Donald Trump never called neo-Nazis and white
00:12:42.280
It would seem that fact checking for political advantage was the name of the game.
00:12:45.800
Just take a look at when most of the fact checking occurred and the types of ratings
00:12:49.760
Republicans were the party out of power, implying that PolitiFact should have found more lies
00:12:58.400
These left-wing fact checkers were paid big money to silence Americans.
00:13:03.060
Two fact checkers, LeadStories and FactCheck.org, disclosed their 2019 funding from Facebook.
00:13:08.560
LeadStories was paid $359,000 in 2019 by Facebook.
00:13:19.860
Manage expenses with the TD Low Rate Visa Card.
00:13:23.280
With a low annual interest rate, the TD Low Rate Visa Card can help find some balance.
00:13:34.540
For more than half of all of the Facebook content review by U.S. FactCheckers in January of 2020,
00:13:40.540
Facebook's total investment in 2019 would be about $2 million.
00:13:48.840
You're sitting here watching a YouTube video on a channel that routinely calls out lies from
00:13:54.080
But we often do rely on the corporate press for this news.
00:13:57.140
One of the biggest conundrums in the fact-checking space
00:14:00.880
is that outlets like the New York Times, ABC News, and CBS are considered de facto true
00:14:10.240
How do these third-party fact-checkers determine
00:14:15.500
They simply cite a news source that they think is always correct.
00:14:23.420
If the New York Times reports something, it is presumed true.
00:14:26.760
If Breitbart.com reports something and it wasn't cited by the New York Times, they'll
00:14:34.760
Although, to be fair, often, even if you do cite Politico, they'll still claim it was
00:14:40.680
Here's one of my favorite examples of how prominent corporate news outlets are lying
00:14:46.660
In a story from 2017, Ukrainian effort to sabotage Trump backfires.
00:14:51.780
The story was written January 11th, 2017, and it opened by saying,
00:14:56.620
Ukrainian government officials tried to help Hillary Clinton and undermine Trump by publicly
00:15:03.660
They also disseminated documents implicating a top Trump aide in corruption and suggested
00:15:08.200
they were investigating the matter only to back away after the election.
00:15:11.920
And they helped Clinton's allies research damaging information on Trump and his advisors,
00:15:19.540
That story is still publicly available today without fact check, without correction.
00:15:24.960
So we can just assume Politico was telling the truth, right?
00:15:30.000
In a subsequent article for Politico, they wrote how a Russian disinfo op got Trump impeached.
00:15:36.620
The Kremlin may have been laying the groundwork for blaming Ukraine for 2016 as early as 2015.
00:15:46.060
Three weeks after the election day in 2016, the Kremlin officially floated a theory
00:15:50.480
that would ultimately lead to only the third presidential impeachment in U.S. history.
00:15:55.600
Ukraine seriously complicated the work of Trump's election by planting information
00:15:59.020
aimed at damaging his campaign chairman, Paul Manafort.
00:16:02.240
A spokeswoman for Russia's foreign ministry told reporters on November 30th, 2016,
00:16:06.820
accusing the Ukrainian government of scheming to help elect Hillary Clinton.
00:16:10.880
President-elect Donald Trump by this time was busy staffing up his incoming administration
00:16:14.120
and some of his top advisors, including his son-in-law Jared Kushner
00:16:17.000
and incoming national security advisor Michael Flynn,
00:16:21.380
in hopes of establishing a diplomatic back channel to Moscow.
00:16:24.340
Russian officials offered no evidence on that day or any other day
00:16:27.160
that it was really Kiev, not Moscow, that meddled in the 2016 election.
00:16:31.280
Nor have U.S. intelligence agencies backed off on their collective finding
00:16:34.220
that the Kremlin orchestrated a major effort to help Trump win office.
00:16:37.360
I don't care what your opinion is on Russian interference.
00:16:40.240
My question for you, or I should say the facts as presented,
00:16:42.840
how can Politico simultaneously have two stories live right now on their website,
00:16:52.260
and another story saying actually it was Russian disinformation?
00:16:55.900
The reality is fact checkers simply decide which one they want to be true at what time.
00:17:03.820
The truth is the corporate press has a narrative.
00:17:06.680
Individuals who work for these platforms, work for these outlets,
00:17:11.340
know that there are editorial mandates and there are certain things that they can or cannot report.
00:17:16.840
Famously, Max Kaiser, who had a BBC show, posted he left because everything that he was going to talk about
00:17:25.780
Well, of course, the BBC is state-sanctioned, right?
00:17:28.180
So how do you figure out what is actually true?
00:17:35.140
Some people are going to believe insane things no matter what.
00:17:38.460
They're going to think the moon is made of cheese or that extradimensional beings are coming to Earth
00:17:46.480
Certainly don't think the moon is made of cheese,
00:17:48.100
and I don't got any evidence about extradimensional beings,
00:17:49.820
but people are going to believe what they think makes the most sense.
00:17:53.360
Perhaps the best thing we can do is advocate for a robust, meritocratic, independent media
00:17:59.960
so that those who actually do the work and can prove what they say rise to the top.
00:18:06.240
I firmly believe that if you're a news outlet and you lie all the time,
00:18:13.760
I do think some people will probably still watch fake news outlets and still read them,
00:18:18.780
but most people will try to find something that makes more sense.
00:18:27.000
Some of these big news platforms are laying off their staff in droves because they are untrustworthy.
00:18:40.180
As more and more people come to watch our shows, check out what we have to say
00:18:43.460
because we try our best, though we are often wrong.
00:18:47.460
We try our best to crack through the fake news and actually inform you on what's happening.
00:18:53.960
Now, the corporate press is going to tell you that you're morally wrong.
00:18:59.060
Manage expenses with the TD low-rate Visa card.
00:19:02.260
With a low annual interest rate, the TD low-rate Visa card can help find some balance.
00:19:13.340
Half the time when you have an opinion, ignore it.
00:19:18.180
We certainly don't get everything right all the time.
00:19:20.020
But the truth is, the fact-checkers were biased.
00:19:25.900
And it was for political advantages, largely, of the Democrats.
00:19:37.600
We've got the live show Friday mornings on this channel.
00:19:40.300
Welcome to the Culture World, ladies and gentlemen.
00:19:41.900
You can follow me on X and Instagram at TimCast.
00:19:47.580
Manage expenses with the TD low-rate Visa card.
00:20:01.340
With a low annual interest rate, the TD low-rate Visa card can help find some balance.