The Culture War - Tim Pool - October 23, 2026


Fired To Frontman： How Shane Gillis TOOK OVER Comedy

Hosted by
Tim Pool Phil Labonte Hannah Claire Brimelow
Mentioned
Shane Gillis Joe Rogan Bud Light-style Lorne Michaels Matt McCusker Kevin Hart Casey Anthony Donald Trump Theo Vaughn Martha Plimpton Beautiful Dogs Dylan Mulvaney Sidney Sweeney Dave Chappelle Simone Biles Dan Levy Sparks
Trump DOJ Just ARRESTED Top DEEP STATE Democrat, IT HAS BEGUN

Episode Stats


Length

17 minutes

Words per minute

154.78

Word count

2,706

Sentence count

249

Harmful content

Misogyny

11

sentences flagged

Toxicity

17

sentences flagged

Hate speech

7

sentences flagged


Transcript

Transcript generated with Whisper (turbo).
Misogyny classifications generated with MilaNLProc/bert-base-uncased-ear-misogyny .
Toxicity classifications generated with s-nlp/roberta_toxicity_classifier .
Hate speech classifications generated with facebook/roberta-hate-speech-dynabench-r4-target .
Hosts, guests, and mentioned names generated with spaCy (en_core_web_sm), reconciled against Wikidata.
00:00:00.000 growing businesses deal with the same problem too many tools too much back and forth and not
00:00:05.280 enough time odoo helps bring it all together it's an all-in-one business management platform
00:00:11.300 fully integrated from sales and accounting to inventory and marketing so your team can spend
00:00:16.340 less time chasing information and focus on growth whether you're in retail manufacturing or service
00:00:22.240 odoo gives you one place to manage your business visit odoo.com to book a demo it's odoo.com
00:00:29.860 At CIBC Business Banking, our advisors basically become part of your team.
00:00:34.120 In fact, an advisor is helping this audio engineering business by recording this ad.
00:00:38.900 They're getting a little carried away.
00:00:41.120 Earn up to $2,600 when you get a CIBC Business Banking Bundle.
00:00:44.880 Conditions apply. CIBC. Your business is our business.
00:00:49.140 Saturday, October 10th, 2026.
00:00:52.740 Shane Gillis walks out onto stage at Studio 8H to host Saturday Night Live for the third time.
00:00:59.860 A few minutes into his monologue, he talks about going back to the gym, and he says this. 1.00
00:01:06.040 Also, I haven't been to the gym in so long, I didn't know women just dress like whores now. 1.00
00:01:11.520 Look, I'm sorry, there's no other way to describe. 1.00
00:01:14.500 Have you seen it? I've seen it. The shorts?
00:01:17.620 Within 72 hours, The View, CBS Mornings, and Dan Levy all condemned him.
00:01:23.800 A Hollywood actress blamed Lorne Michaels personally.
00:01:27.860 Fitness brand's top marketing executive trolled him on LinkedIn.
00:01:31.740 Casey Anthony, the woman acquitted in 2011 of murdering her own daughter,
00:01:37.040 posted a note on Substack telling men to, quote,
00:01:39.680 get it together, do better.
00:01:41.740 Here's the thing.
00:01:43.080 Three months earlier, 73,946 people had packed into an NFL stadium
00:01:50.360 in Philadelphia, to watch this man tell jokes. That's a Guinness World Record, the largest
00:01:57.280 audience for a comedian in history. So how does this guy, SNL fired in disgrace, become the biggest
00:02:05.380 comedian in America? And why does it seem like every time they try to cancel him, bigger? This
00:02:12.200 is the Shane Gillis story. It starts in Mechanicsburg. Shane Gillis, born December 11th,
00:02:19.960 1987 in Pennsylvania, small town just outside Harrisburg, the kind of place where the high
00:02:26.160 school football team matters more than anything happening in New York or L.A.
00:02:30.340 Shane started doing stand-up in 2012, grinding open mics in Harrisburg and Philadelphia.
00:02:35.340 31-year-old stand-up comic Shane Gillis.
00:02:37.980 I took skull out of my mouth to come up here, and I didn't vote for Donald Trump.
00:02:44.800 Makes me like the Nelson Mandela of central Pennsylvania.
00:02:47.480 In 2016, he started a podcast with his friend, Matt McCusker.
00:02:52.440 They called it Matt and Shane's Secret Podcast.
00:02:55.200 It was crude, unfiltered, and completely unpolished.
00:02:58.260 The kind of thing you'd hear at a bar at one in the morning.
00:03:01.160 By the summer of 2019, it was starting to pay off.
00:03:04.780 He was named one of the new faces at the Just for Laughs Festival in Montreal.
00:03:09.260 That's the showcase the industry watches to find the next big thing, or one of them.
00:03:13.240 And on September 12th, 2019, he got the call every comedian dreams about.
00:03:19.420 Saturday Night Live announced Shane Gillis as a new cast member for season 45.
00:03:25.820 He made it four days.
00:03:28.520 Tonight, a Saturday Night Live comic is out just four days after he was introduced as a new cast member.
00:03:34.600 Within hours of the announcement, clips from an old episode of his podcast started circulating online.
00:03:40.480 In one, Gillis used a slur for Chinese people and mocked Chinese accents.
00:03:46.900 In another, he used gay slurs to describe comedians he did not like.
00:03:51.700 The clip spread.
00:03:53.080 Journalists wrote the stories.
00:03:54.960 Commentators demanded action.
00:03:57.360 This was 2019.
00:03:59.380 And as AOC said, Woke One was crazy.
00:04:02.520 So the outcome was never really in doubt.
00:04:05.000 On Monday, September 16th, the spokesperson for Lorne Michaels released a one-line statement,
00:04:11.100 quote, talking with Shane Gillis, we have decided that he will not be joining SNL.
00:04:17.600 We would benefit from being more forgiving rather than punitive. The show opted otherwise,
00:04:23.140 announcing his removal on Monday, saying we were not aware of his prior remarks.
00:04:27.840 The language he used is offensive, hurtful and unacceptable.
00:04:31.780 Gillis didn't fight it.
00:04:33.060 He didn't hire a crisis PR firm.
00:04:35.320 He didn't do a tearful apology tour.
00:04:37.940 He put out a statement that said in part,
00:04:39.880 I respect the decision they made.
00:04:41.940 Honestly, grateful for the opportunity.
00:04:44.720 Years later, he told Theo Vaughn it was traumatic.
00:04:48.060 But he also said something most people in his position never would.
00:04:51.840 I don't argue me getting fired.
00:04:54.260 Those are today's rules.
00:04:56.660 The industry assumed that was the end of Shane Gillis.
00:05:00.340 And for a while, it looked like they were right.
00:05:03.480 Except, they weren't.
00:05:06.700 So what do you do when the biggest institution in comedy throws you out?
00:05:10.620 Shane Gillis went straight to the audience.
00:05:13.060 And I was like, whatever, I'll do...
00:05:15.160 If I just...
00:05:16.660 If I get fired here, whatever, I'll just go do Joe Rogan next week and I'll be fine.
00:05:20.680 The podcast that got him fired became the thing that saved him.
00:05:23.800 Matt and Shane's secret podcast was on Patreon,
00:05:26.240 where fans paid directly for those bonus episodes.
00:05:30.640 And after the firing, the audience didn't leave.
00:05:32.940 It grew.
00:05:34.120 He didn't need a network, a studio executive, or anyone's permission.
00:05:38.400 And then, September 7th, 2021, almost exactly two years after SNL fired him,
00:05:44.360 he did something comedians just didn't do back then.
00:05:48.100 He took a full stand-up special called Live in Austin,
00:05:51.680 and instead of selling it to Netflix or HBO,
00:05:54.240 put it on YouTube for free but a Fox News dad that's a good can you imagine if
00:06:01.680 you had a MSNBC dad there's some guy every night at dinner like we need to 0.96
00:06:07.620 start focusing on renewable energy like you dude I didn't know dad was gay
00:06:13.500 that special has now been watched nearly 59 million times think about what that
00:06:20.640 means. The gatekeepers said no, so he went around them, and the audience showed up anyway. In numbers
00:06:27.620 most network specials never reach. Once you prove you can fill rooms without them, the gatekeepers
00:06:35.120 come back to you. In September of 2023, Netflix released his special Beautiful Dogs. In May of
00:06:41.220 2024, Netflix premiered Tires, a comedy series he co-created and stars in, got renewed for a second
00:06:48.160 season and then a third. And then the most improbable twist of all, Saturday Night Live,
00:06:54.720 the show that fired him came crawling back. Lorne Michaels would later say the 2019 decision
00:07:01.360 come from NBC executives and that he was angry about it. February 24th, 2024, Shane Gillis
00:07:09.480 walked onto the same stage he'd been kicked off of five years earlier, and he addressed it head on.
00:07:16.140 Most of you probably have no idea who I am. I was actually, I was fired from this show a while ago, but if, you know, don't look that up, please. If you don't know who I am, please don't Google that.
00:07:31.040 The critics hated it. Vulture called it cringey, and The Hollywood Reporter said he looked visibly anxious.
00:07:38.800 NBC kept inviting him back. He hosted SNL again in March of 2025.
00:07:44.980 In July, he hosted the ESPY Awards.
00:07:48.200 It's not bad. Simone Biles is 4'8 and has 7 gold medals. She's short and has a lot of gold.
00:07:54.660 When she's not competing, she leads a quiet life at the base of a rainbow. 1.00
00:07:58.400 Oh. It's a leprechaun joke.
00:08:03.260 May of 2026, he hosted the roast of Kevin Hart.
00:08:07.420 Here's a fun fact about Kevin. Kevin has a 44-inch vertical leap.
00:08:11.120 And I know that because he can kiss his wife on the lips.
00:08:17.320 The man who supposedly could never work in this business again was suddenly one of its biggest stars.
00:08:23.740 And here's my favorite part of the whole comeback.
00:08:25.660 Remember Bud Light?
00:08:26.920 In 2023, the brand imploded after its Dylan Mulvaney promotion.
00:08:31.880 Sales cratered.
00:08:33.240 Who did Bud Light turn to when it wanted its audience, its customers back?
00:08:39.380 Shane Gillis.
00:08:41.000 Partnered with him on a stand-up tour, and his face ended up in Bud Light commercials.
00:08:49.120 Excuse me.
00:08:50.060 Just gonna hop in here.
00:08:51.140 Pardon me.
00:08:51.980 Whoa, whoa.
00:08:52.420 Don't even think about it.
00:08:53.400 Would you like a beer, a Bud Light? Bud Light, please.
00:08:55.720 He even joked about it in this month's monologue. 0.98
00:08:58.760 My fat rock bottom sucked this year.
00:09:00.540 I was in a Bud Light commercial every 10 minutes. 0.97
00:09:03.480 I'd look up and see it on screen. 1.00
00:09:05.120 I'd be like, oh, no, I look like a lesbian. 0.99
00:09:09.280 Think about that. 1.00
00:09:09.840 The guy who got canceled in 2019
00:09:12.340 became the guy corporate America hired to get them uncanceled.
00:09:18.560 Pose when you prove you can do it, you're the go-to guy.
00:09:23.400 And then, July 17th, 2026, Lincoln Financial Field in Philadelphia, home of the Eagles.
00:09:32.200 And Shane is a diehard Eagles fan, so they tell me.
00:09:34.780 This isn't a theater or an arena.
00:09:37.360 It's an NFL stadium.
00:09:39.880 On that night, it was sold out for one man, Shane Gillis.
00:09:44.520 According to the stadium, 73,946 people were there.
00:09:49.340 Two world records that night.
00:09:51.200 The largest audience ever for a comedian.
00:09:55.360 Most tickets ever sold for a comedy show by a solo comedian.
00:10:00.700 That sink in.
00:10:02.220 Seven years earlier, SNL decided the public couldn't handle Shane Gillis.
00:10:08.600 Then, public bought more tickets to see him than anyone in the history of stand-up comedy.
00:10:15.840 You know, Shane told me he was going to play in the stadium.
00:10:19.180 and I thought to myself, like, why?
00:10:23.080 Everything's going so good. 1.00
00:10:25.060 Shane, this shit was great tonight. 1.00
00:10:26.920 Thank you. 1.00
00:10:28.220 This is the reality of Woke 1.0.
00:10:32.180 When the institution said you were dangerous,
00:10:35.120 we can't hire you, you'll cost us money.
00:10:39.320 Time and time again,
00:10:41.320 people like Shane Gilles have proven them wrong.
00:10:45.320 People did not want cancel culture.
00:10:49.180 So this brings us back to October 10th, 2026.
00:10:54.920 Shane's third time hosting SNL.
00:10:58.060 The gym joke went off like a bomb.
00:11:01.080 And here we go.
00:11:02.560 2019 all over again.
00:11:05.220 Or so these people had hoped.
00:11:07.860 CBS Mornings ran a segment on his monologue,
00:11:10.500 Sparks' larger conversation about misogyny in comedy. 0.93
00:11:14.680 Women wearing short shorts to the gym does not make them whores. 0.98
00:11:20.600 It makes the men calling them whores misogynists. 0.98
00:11:26.520 Men need to be defending women more. 0.94
00:11:29.240 This is not a women's issue.
00:11:30.880 This is an everybody issue.
00:11:32.820 Actress Martha Plimpton blamed Lorne Michaels directly, 0.96
00:11:36.480 saying Lorne needs some more women in that room making decisions.
00:11:40.740 Gymshark's chief brand officer took a shot at him on LinkedIn.
00:11:44.100 telling anyone looking for the shorts that they were unapologetically available on Gymshark's website.
00:11:50.420 Unaired footage even showed Gillis leaving the stage before the good nights were over
00:11:54.960 after apologizing for an F-bomb he'd let slip in a sketch.
00:12:00.320 And then came the moment that told you exactly how unhinged the outrage machine had gotten.
00:12:05.760 Casey Anthony, a woman acquitted for murdering her own daughter, posted a note on Substack.
00:12:11.700 It didn't name him, but it landed right in the middle of the backlash. 0.99
00:12:14.900 Women can dress however they want. 1.00
00:12:16.560 Men, get it together.
00:12:18.420 Do better.
00:12:19.560 When Joe Rogan read that on his podcast, he could barely believe it.
00:12:23.340 He also pointed out what the outrage mob missed.
00:12:26.060 Really, the joke is on Shane, because the joke is that he looks like a creep in the
00:12:31.140 background of all these TikToks watching these ladies that are wearing nothing doing these
00:12:36.060 exercises. 0.97
00:12:36.980 Well, he also didn't call them whores. 1.00
00:12:38.420 He just said they dress like it. 1.00
00:12:39.540 Yes.
00:12:40.460 Completely different thing.
00:12:41.540 I mean, you know, Rogan said something else worth hearing real misogyny actually exists like real women who hate or real men rather who hate women do exist.
00:12:53.360 And so when you see a guy joking around about a woman dressing like a whore, you connect it to horrible thoughts, like horrible actions, like real, actual evil men that actually because like there's a lot of men that genuinely hate women.
00:13:08.440 Shane Gillis is not one of them.
00:13:10.360 And he's a great guy.
00:13:11.620 It's just a joke.
00:13:12.440 Growing businesses deal with the same problem.
00:13:15.180 Too many tools, too much back and forth, and not enough time.
00:13:19.080 Odoo helps bring it all together.
00:13:21.240 It's an all-in-one business management platform,
00:13:23.820 fully integrated from sales and accounting to inventory and marketing,
00:13:27.500 so your team can spend less time chasing information and focus on growth.
00:13:32.220 Whether you're in retail, manufacturing, or service,
00:13:34.720 Odoo gives you one place to manage your business.
00:13:37.480 Visit odoo.com to book a demo.
00:13:40.200 It's O-D-O-O dot com.
00:13:49.700 And through it all, NBC, SNL, and Lorne Michaels said nothing. 0.94
00:13:55.520 Notice how the coverage labeled him, too.
00:13:57.120 The Daily Beast didn't just call him a comedian.
00:13:59.160 It called him the MAGA-friendly SNL host.
00:14:02.880 Never mind that in August, he told Rogan he regretted supporting Trump and hadn't voted for him.
00:14:07.140 He went to the UFC event at the White House in June, and he skipped the photo op.
00:14:11.120 He hangs out with Rogan and Theo Vaughn.
00:14:13.340 For a lot of people in media, the joke was never really the problem.
00:14:17.160 The problem was who was telling it and who was laughing.
00:14:20.740 This moment, with this controversy, one thing that made it kind of funny
00:14:25.680 is that it's coming off the heels of the Sidney Sweeney story,
00:14:29.120 where many women were outraged because she was sexualizing her body,
00:14:33.640 and it was bad for women.
00:14:35.520 Then when Shane Gillis comes out and says, 0.96
00:14:37.660 I've noticed women are doing the same thing. 0.98
00:14:40.860 You had all of these women, maybe not the same ones, 1.00
00:14:43.640 but many women come out and say, Shane, no, how dare you?
00:14:46.300 So which is it? 1.00
00:14:47.460 Was Sydney Sweeney wrong for sexualizing her body?
00:14:50.840 Was Shane Gillis wrong for telling women that they do?
00:14:55.700 So in the end, here's what the Gillis story is telling us. 0.99
00:14:59.360 In 2019, cancel culture worked.
00:15:02.580 One set of old clips, one news cycle,
00:15:05.120 and a guy lost the biggest job in comedy in four days.
00:15:09.840 But in 2026, that exact same playbook ran
00:15:13.400 with the same outlets, the same outrage, and the same demands,
00:15:16.760 and nothing happened.
00:15:18.300 In fact, he's still booked, and he's probably bigger than ever.
00:15:22.420 He's still selling out stadiums.
00:15:24.040 His YouTube special is still ragging up views.
00:15:26.560 The outrage didn't cost him a single fan.
00:15:29.300 if anything, it made his fans more loyal. What changed? It wasn't Shane. He's still telling the
00:15:36.280 same jokes. And it isn't just him. Look at Dave Chappelle, who got the same treatment over his
00:15:40.980 Netflix specials and kept selling out arenas. Look at Rogan himself, who got hammered during COVID
00:15:46.860 and ended up with the biggest podcast on earth, them trying to shut him down. What changed?
00:15:54.200 Gatekeepers lost the gate. When the comedians can go straight to the audience on YouTube,
00:15:58.580 when news and opinion commentators
00:16:01.000 can go straight to the audience.
00:16:03.200 We don't need the institutions.
00:16:06.100 Whether it's Patreon,
00:16:07.940 a football stadium,
00:16:09.620 thin post, whatever.
00:16:11.180 You don't need the machine anymore.
00:16:14.220 An op-ed doesn't mean anything.
00:16:16.180 Even a statement from Lorne Michaels
00:16:17.800 doesn't mean anything.
00:16:20.220 My friends,
00:16:21.520 you decide now.
00:16:23.200 We decide.
00:16:24.700 And the audience has decided.
00:16:26.640 Seven years after Saturday Night Live
00:16:28.120 fired him. Shane Gillis is the biggest comedian in America. And every time they try to cancel him,
00:16:33.680 they just make him bigger. So they can come for you. They can come for me. And they certainly
00:16:39.960 have tried to come for Shane. But this is a new era. And we will not live under the boot of the
00:16:48.460 woke scolds, of these moralists who are telling us no more naughty words. The truth was always
00:16:56.520 allowed. And jokes were always allowed. Even if we had a bad time for a few years, the times are
00:17:03.520 changing for the better, my friends. If you like these videos, I'm doing these special mini docs
00:17:09.460 Saturdays and Sundays to make sure I'm doing everything I can for you guys. So smash that
00:17:14.480 like button, share the show with everyone you've met. Special shout out to Shane Gillis. Don't know
00:17:20.440 him personally, but I'm a huge fan. He really is the best. And to everybody else, thank you so much
00:17:25.000 for watching. Stick around, we've got more to come, and we'll see you all next time.