Mamdani Socialism BACKFIRES On NYC, Mayor Threatens To RAISE Taxes On Working Class
Episode Stats
Words per Minute
170.64566
Summary
The new mayor of New York City, Zoran Mamdani, is having a pretty rough go at it. A series of scandals have erupted throughout the city over improper waste management, animal waste all over the place, and now a threat of a wealth tax on the middle class and working class from the mouth of the mayor himself.
Transcript
00:00:22.140
So, whatever you think is going to happen in the future,
00:00:35.180
A series of scandals have erupted throughout the city
00:00:47.260
and the working class from the mouth of Zoran Mamdani himself.
00:00:52.100
What he's saying is that if they don't get their wealth tax,
00:00:59.680
The only problem is neither of these plans actually make sense.
00:01:03.060
And it's resulted in an economic and political crisis in New York City
00:01:06.900
for which everybody is making fun of Zoran Mamdani.
00:01:10.640
And I'm going to do something that may surprise many of you
00:01:16.900
By all means, I am going to criticize his plan on the wealth tax.
00:01:20.480
We're going to go through these numbers and talk about what's actually happening
00:01:23.320
happening as we are seeing a mass exodus from New York City already.
00:01:31.140
But I want to make sure this is absolutely clear
00:01:48.400
That being said, I can cut him some slack on these policy proposals
00:01:57.560
Seemingly, as soon as he got in, something did change.
00:02:07.800
I think that something was being done by the previous mayors
00:02:11.800
that they did not adequately inform Zoran Mamdani about.
00:02:15.360
And now we are seeing a bubbling up of a serious crisis.
00:02:18.900
That is, guys, when we are looking at the streets filled with dog waste
00:02:24.500
all over the place, I mean, the videos are crazy bad.
00:02:28.620
Okay, something different is going on because we did not see this
00:02:33.740
in the same way previously, indicating it looks like people
00:02:39.860
He may have won for one reason or another, but it seems like maybe
00:02:45.520
Now, what we're going to do here is we're going to break down
00:02:47.040
the proposals from Zoran Mamdani, and he is getting a lot of heat right now
00:02:50.360
because he is outright stated they have two choices.
00:02:57.900
We're going to take money from retiree health care.
00:03:00.880
We're going to tax the middle and working class, or we're going to tax the rich.
00:03:06.720
And to all the liberals of New York City and the leftists, they're saying,
00:03:11.420
The problem is it has already been reported over the past several years.
00:03:16.320
The top 10% of wealthy individuals in the city have already fled.
00:03:22.100
And many of these companies are taking jobs away as well.
00:03:32.700
She did not understand that a tax benefit was not giving tax dollars.
00:03:40.700
Amazon said, we want to bring $30,000 to Queens.
00:03:47.780
The city was basically saying, we're going to give you a discount on your taxes.
00:03:50.420
You'll save $10 billion in taxes if you come to us.
00:03:54.180
Because the increase in jobs, the increase in workers, and the taxes paid by Amazon,
00:03:58.680
though at a discount, would still be a massive boon to the city,
00:04:01.900
which they needed to fix their crumbling train and public transit infrastructure.
00:04:07.420
Well, AOC led a protest in the financial district, and Amazon ultimately said, fine, we out.
00:04:11.940
But she actually was quoted as saying she thought they were going to be giving Amazon money to do it.
00:04:22.320
They genuinely do not understand these policies.
00:04:26.300
I'm going to play the videos for you so you can hear it straight from Zoran's mouth himself
00:04:30.520
about how he is planning on taxing the working class.
00:04:41.120
What this means is he is legitimately telling you their only path forward is to tax the working class.
00:04:49.820
Before we get started, my friends, make sure you go to gasbrew.com.
00:04:56.640
Appalachian Nights, a dark roast, everybody's favorite,
00:04:58.800
followed by Ian's Graphene Dream low-acidity coffee.
00:05:02.480
You guys are putting Ian through college, and you know he needs it.
00:05:06.020
I hope you realize he's not literally going to college.
00:05:09.880
He gets a portion of the revenue from his coffee.
00:05:16.380
But also, smash the like button, subscribe right now to this channel if you haven't already,
00:05:25.460
Not everybody, but a lot of people did share it.
00:05:29.140
So if there's one thing you can do, if you believe in the work that I'm doing,
00:05:33.180
and the extra hours that I put in every single day,
00:05:35.000
just copy the link to this video, post it on your social media.
00:05:42.820
So you guys, thank you all so much for doing that.
00:05:45.800
Considering it again, if you really do want to help.
00:05:47.780
And let's get started with the video right from Zoran himself.
00:05:51.940
Then I'll play the longer video for you, but let's cut to the meat and potatoes here.
00:05:55.060
At the heart of this path is a property tax increase.
00:06:00.220
This would effectively be a tax on working and middle-class New Yorkers
00:06:06.340
The second path also requires us to raid our reserves.
00:06:09.960
It would mean withdrawing $980 million from our city's rainy day fund in fiscal year 2026,
00:06:16.220
and $229 million from the retiree health benefit trust in fiscal year 2027.
00:06:25.600
but only in moments of extraordinary external crisis.
00:06:32.020
because wealthy people who pay a disproportionate amount of taxes are leaving.
00:06:37.640
Mayor Bloomberg's response to the 2008 financial collapse
00:06:40.280
and Mayor de Blasio's response to the enormous revenue shortfall caused by the pandemic.
00:06:45.540
We do not want to have to turn to such drastic measures to balance our budget.
00:06:51.880
But my friends, let's also play this video from the New York Post.
00:06:56.260
We've also just received information that new data in the state's school aid formula
00:07:00.500
will bring an additional $97 million to New York City on a recurring basis.
00:07:06.100
All of that brings the fiscal deficit down to $5.4 billion.
00:07:10.680
But I want to be clear, $5.4 billion is still a very steep mountain to climb.
00:07:22.320
and a second one with significant pain that we deeply hope to avoid.
00:07:26.380
The first path, I just, for the love of all that is holy,
00:07:30.760
taxing the rich will not cover $5.4 billion in a deficit.
00:07:42.340
This man is either as dumb as a box of rocks or he is lying.
00:07:46.620
You cannot overcome a yearly $5.4 billion deficit by taxing the rich.
00:08:00.220
You will depress economic activity, and you will not recover that money.
00:08:08.320
There's the structural imbalance between the city and the state.
00:08:11.540
We want to work with Albany to raise personal income taxes by 2%
00:08:15.080
on the 33,000 New Yorkers earning more than $1 million a year,
00:08:19.400
and to raise corporate taxes on the most profitable corporations.
00:08:24.740
New Yorkers have given far more to the state than what we have received in return.
00:08:33.500
we will be forced onto a much more damaging path of last resort,
00:08:37.080
one where we have to use the only tools at the city's disposal,
00:08:41.500
raising property taxes and raiding our reserves.
00:08:47.720
We will continue to work with Albany to avoid it.
00:08:51.060
This first path will deliver the structural change that we need
00:08:54.060
to recalibrate the relationship between the city and the state.
00:08:58.200
Because as we know, New Yorkers contribute 54.5% of state revenue,
00:09:05.640
Heavens me, it sounds like you're figuring out the problems with federalization,
00:09:30.440
than some of the people in other parts of the state.
00:09:38.800
They are taking more from you than you are getting back.
00:09:47.840
At the same time, New York City's portion of the state's GDP
00:09:57.160
Once again, I am calling for Albany to end the drain.
00:10:00.600
There is no third option of failing to balance the budget.
00:10:04.280
By law, ever since the fiscal crisis of the 1970s,
00:10:07.100
which placed the city on the brink of bankruptcy,
00:10:09.860
New York City has been legally required to balance its budget.
00:10:16.960
the only option we have remaining is the second path.
00:10:30.520
targeting those with the median income of 122,000.
00:10:34.880
we don't want to do it, but we're going to do it.
00:10:43.280
You're talking about targeting a finite and small group of people
00:10:48.000
when they have the freedom not to work or to leave.
00:10:51.040
We do not live in a world where you can force people
00:11:01.440
Let me tell you what's wrong with that first and foremost
00:11:03.300
before we get into a big philosophical debate on communism.
00:11:05.880
I work 16 hours a day and somewhat on weekends.
00:11:20.000
so I was working double shifts Monday through Friday