The Culture War - Tim Pool - May 17, 2026


Tim Pool SPEECH At The University of Chicago

Topics
Hosted by
Mentioned
CHUD CHARGE WITH ATTEMPTED MURDER SPENCER PRATT IS GOING TO SAVE LA

Episode Stats


Length

37 minutes

Words per minute

197.35

Word count

7,487

Sentence count

336

Harmful content

Misogyny

2

sentences flagged

Toxicity

4

sentences flagged

Hate speech

15

sentences flagged


Summary

Summaries generated with gmurro/bart-large-finetuned-filtered-spotify-podcast-summ .

In this episode of the American Identity Summit, we sit down with journalist Tim Stanley to talk about his experiences covering the Occupy Wall Street protests and how they changed the way Americans view wealth and income inequality. Tim is a regular contributor to the New York Times, CNN, NPR, and many other media outlets. He is also the host of the podcast American Identity, which focuses on the fundamental tenets of American identity.

Transcript

Transcript generated with Whisper (turbo).
Misogyny classifications generated with MilaNLProc/bert-base-uncased-ear-misogyny .
Toxicity classifications generated with s-nlp/roberta_toxicity_classifier .
Hate speech classifications generated with facebook/roberta-hate-speech-dynabench-r4-target .
Topics generated with Qwen2.5-3B-Instruct.
Hosts, guests, and mentioned names generated with spaCy (en_core_web_sm), reconciled against Wikidata.
00:00:00 There is a great deal of these prominent personalities that I would specifically single
00:00:04 out as part of the conservative movement who don't believe a thing they say, they get paid
00:00:08 to say it. We saw this when a bunch of conservatives started promoting buying soda on welfare.
00:00:14 Conservatives advocating for welfare to buy Coca-Cola, that makes no sense.
00:00:18 They got paid to do it. So they're advocating for India, America first, 0.93
00:00:23 pull the foreign trade, all of a sudden now advocating for India as a great,
00:00:27 They got paid to do it. And more recently, when I rejected money to promote the film Animal Farm
00:00:32 by Angel Studios, which is an anti-capitalist retelling of the story, which makes no sense.
00:00:37 And tons of right-wing individuals promoted the film because they got paid to do it.
00:00:43 Well, Tim, thanks for being here. We're very excited to have you. Welcome back to Chicago.
00:00:48 I'm sure you're happy to be here in the city. How was your trip been?
00:00:54 Great.
00:00:54 I just got Portillo's.
00:00:55 Great.
00:00:56 Is that a main say for you?
00:00:57 Of course.
00:00:58 If you live in the city, you know it.
00:00:59 I mean, there's smaller places that everybody knows about.
00:01:02 And, you know, my boy Brandon right here, we're both from here.
00:01:04 And we were talking about going to Nicky's on Archer and Austin.
00:01:07 But it's hard to get down to the Midway area where we're from and then come down here.
00:01:11 So we settled with Portillo's.
00:01:13 And Kellen, our producers, he's from D.C., he's never had it.
00:01:16 So we were like, we have to go.
00:01:17 You have to.
00:01:18 Have to do it.
00:01:19 How about deep dish pizza?
00:01:21 That's tourist pizza.
00:01:21 Everybody knows that.
00:01:22 Okay.
00:01:23 Everyone knows that.
00:01:23 You've got to get a Chicago Tavern pizza, you know, square cut.
00:01:26 I like giardiniera on mine.
00:01:27 Great.
00:01:31 Once again, thanks for being here.
00:01:33 You know, this event, the American Identity Summit, it's our second edition.
00:01:36 And really, we want to answer some fundamental precepts, meaning primarily what are the fundamental tenets of the American identity?
00:01:44 How are they changing over time?
00:01:46 Obviously, we're at the 250th anniversary of the country this year.
00:01:49 There's been vast changes on all fronts.
00:01:51 and so how are those changing and then what does that mean for the next 250
00:01:55 years of our country so all these panels we've had a diverse array of subject
00:02:00 matter that we've discussed from foreign policy to economics to AI and crypto to
00:02:07 to just a legal theory all kinds of subject matter and so I we are really
00:02:14 glad to have you I want to talk a little bit about some of the experiences that
00:02:18 that you've had, because you've been all over
00:02:19 and you've done some really interesting things
00:02:22 that I think most people haven't had the chance to do.
00:02:25 So I wanna use those as windows into your view
00:02:28 on the American identity and the fundamental concepts
00:02:31 that our country holds dear.
00:02:34 So I'd like to really look at one of your first
00:02:37 bigger initiatives, which was going to cover
00:02:39 the Occupy Wall Street protests,
00:02:41 just very early on in your career.
00:02:43 And that really touches on the notion of wealth inequality,
00:02:46 which is different in the United States.
00:02:48 It's treated differently than in other countries.
00:02:51 I think the capitalist system that we've had
00:02:54 has promoted human flourishing.
00:02:55 Maybe capitalism's not my religion,
00:02:57 but I think it's probably the best system
00:02:59 that we can conceive of.
00:03:02 The way I see it is wealth inequality
00:03:04 is something that people have been frustrated about
00:03:07 to some extent, but the standard of living in this country
00:03:09 has been heading up steadily for, let's say, 100 years,
00:03:13 at least, so I wonder what your thoughts are
00:03:15 on kind of what you saw in those protests,
00:03:18 how are things changing with regard
00:03:20 to how people view wealth inequality?
00:03:23 There's a bigger question with Occupy Wall Street
00:03:25 in that you have the perception
00:03:28 it was about wealth inequality,
00:03:30 and that is the nature of history
00:03:31 and what we think we know
00:03:32 and what we think we're learning,
00:03:33 and I would describe Occupy Wall Street
00:03:35 as having been there and watched it all
00:03:37 as having nothing to do with wealth inequality.
00:03:39 Certainly, the narrative that had emerged early on
00:03:43 was that we are the 99% against the 1%.
00:03:46 And there was this surface level,
00:03:48 the powerful elites, you know,
00:03:50 they're getting bailouts.
00:03:51 But at the heart of it was an activist class
00:03:54 that was not so much interested in wealth inequality,
00:03:59 but of attaining wealth for themselves.
00:04:01 And I'm not trying to say something as so naive
00:04:04 as like everybody's trying to get rich.
00:04:06 No, no, these were activists who explicitly stated
00:04:08 they wanted to flip the pyramid over.
00:04:10 And to the average person when they would say that,
00:04:13 they imagine a world in which the working class is above the only thing is if you think logically
00:04:19 about what happens to a pyramid when you flip it over is that it crumbles into a pile of rubble 0.68
00:04:24 reshaping a more crude pyramid with still a few at the top and many on the bottom so uh in
00:04:32 one of these activist meetings i explicitly asked i you want to flip the pyramid over but
00:04:36 the analogy there is that the bricks will crumble down forming a crudely
00:04:39 shaped pyramid with you at the top and they said yes exactly so for a lot of people that were there
00:04:47 it was not about there are people who are rich they're too rich CEOs are getting paid too much
00:04:52 it was more so about this system I personally don't like based on my views I should have the
00:05:00 power and that was a that was a large portion of what it was which I would argue is I wouldn't
00:05:06 call it overwhelmingly formative for my
00:05:08 worldview, because I'd been around activist groups, and I'd
00:05:09 worked for many non-profits. I've seen
00:05:11 the corruption from, you know, non-profit
00:05:13 organizations, and many of the biggest ones in the
00:05:15 world are just lying about everything, but
00:05:18 I would say I'm not, I wasn't particularly
00:05:20 surprised to see the
00:05:21 message and the actions were
00:05:23 incongruent, right?
00:05:25 And so, what that means
00:05:27 for wealth and equality in general,
00:05:30 I
00:05:32 don't know that there's actually,
00:05:33 let me put it this I personally think there's an issue when you know CEO pay is a thousand fold
00:05:39 the the smallest worker but there's also a question of is is that ratio as an extreme
00:05:46 a product of larger corporations whereas you go back 100 years maybe a company had a thousand
00:05:51 workers now they have 60,000 or 100,000 so of course you're going to have a greater curve
00:05:56 At the same time, however, it does lend itself to, I don't want to be so blunt and just say jealousy, but some form of that.
00:06:09 So one example I make, a lot of people on social media, a lot of people on the progressive left will say billionaires shouldn't exist or they blame wealthy elites for their problems.
00:06:19 The issue is the existence of luxury and wealthy elites doesn't change their circumstance one way or the other.
00:06:25 We recently saw Zoran Mamdani criticize Ken Griffin's penthouse.
00:06:30 The existence of his penthouse doesn't do anything negative for the most part.
00:06:34 It creates jobs.
00:06:36 I don't know if that's a great thing, if it's meaningful,
00:06:39 but there's money, there's taxes, there's things being spent on this.
00:06:42 If we did not have that penthouse, what would change?
00:06:45 People would work somewhere else, I guess.
00:06:47 So there's an obvious positive and negative to higher wealth classes.
00:06:52 I think political instability is the biggest risk from human nature.
00:06:58 Humans, I think it's, what I find absolutely fascinating is that I was talking to my buddy the other day about how we don't need to work anymore.
00:07:08 We really don't.
00:07:09 You know, people talk about universal basic income, and I'm like, we're there.
00:07:12 Go a thousand years in the past and tell a, you know, a serf or somebody working on a farm that in the year 2020,
00:07:19 there are people who dance and they make a hundred thousand dollars a year like
00:07:23 what does that mean no no they literally people watch them dance for
00:07:27 three minutes they do that a couple times a day and they're making their
00:07:31 they have a house and they have food whenever they want and they're gonna be
00:07:34 like but if we don't work we die it's like yeah not in the year 2000 you know
00:07:38 in the year 2000 if you don't work you live with your parents or something I
00:07:41 don't know we live better than our king we live better than kings do and I'm not
00:07:46 saying it's something that people want to strive for to live with their parents
00:07:48 but we're at a point now where the amount of value
00:07:51 you have to put into a system to get value out
00:07:53 is ridiculously low.
00:07:56 The real problem with wealth inequality
00:07:57 is that you might have someone who's got clean running water,
00:08:00 refrigerator, air conditioning, they can take a hot shower,
00:08:03 but compared to other people, they're in poverty.
00:08:07 But if you compare them to Rockefeller 100 years ago,
00:08:09 they got better dental care,
00:08:10 they got heating and air conditioning,
00:08:11 they got chlorinated water,
00:08:12 they have better circumstances now.
00:08:15 To be fair, I mean, certainly there are still benefits
00:08:17 being wealthy 100 years ago. But so I think, I think largely the idea pushes forward a politics
00:08:24 based on envy, which can result in political instability, which is the real problem when the
00:08:29 system collapses because people are unsatisfied with their conditions. Yeah, no, I completely
00:08:34 agree. And I think that, as you said, the monarchs of Europe of yesteryear didn't have air conditioning.
00:08:40 And now basically everybody has that. You can eat food. There are basically no hungry people
00:08:47 in terms of scarcity in the United States, which is a miracle.
00:08:50 Does anybody in this room know how many people died
00:08:52 to get black pepper from India to Europe?
00:08:55 It's like 50,000 people were killed
00:08:57 so that a king could sprinkle pepper on his steak.
00:09:00 And now it's on every table at every diner and no one touches it.
00:09:04 Yeah, it's a great point.
00:09:07 I'd also like to ask you a little bit about your time in Sweden.
00:09:11 So moving on maybe from wealth inequality
00:09:13 and into more the discussion between, let's say, a creedal versus a cultural nation.
00:09:18 And so maybe you saw in recent days, Justice Gorsuch commented on this subject,
00:09:23 and he went in the direction of this is primarily a creedal nation,
00:09:27 meaning if someone comes to the United States and they buy into these ideas, they accept them,
00:09:32 really very little else matters, and they are now an American.
00:09:36 And many people were frustrated by that comment and just had a different opinion.
00:09:39 And so I wonder, you saw the enclave-like nature of migration into Sweden and what that brought about for the Swedish people, the native Swedish people, as well as for those migrants.
00:09:51 In the context of what you saw there, how do you think that America needs to interpret the sort of promises and responsibilities on both ends of immigration? 0.53
00:10:01 I actually half agree with that statement.
00:10:04 If you agree, if you believe in America and you're not from here and you're from somewhere else and you dream of being here because of our values and ideals, because of the things that we've built, because you like baseball and the Simpsons or whatever it might be, then you can come here and join us.
00:10:16 And I think that's fantastic.
00:10:18 That being said, there are people who did that, sacrificed everything so that their children could grow up and have the American dream.
00:10:26 And so this means that the descendants of those people expect more than just people showing up on an H-1B or something like this.
00:10:31 As it pertains to Sweden, the reference you're making is, my discovery in Sweden was that they had brought in a bunch of refugees in the 90s.
00:10:39 I believe it was Somalia.
00:10:40 It's been a few years since I, this is almost 10 years ago now.
00:10:43 It was 2017.
00:10:44 And when they brought these people in, they said, we're here for you.
00:10:49 We've got resources for you.
00:10:51 Welcome to Sweden.
00:10:52 What these people did was they were moved into or moved into enclaves.
00:10:57 And then by the time I got there, you had neighborhoods that were entirely not Swedish, but still Swedish.
00:11:04 That is, there were people who were born in that country from Somali parents who were viewed by the government and by the people at large as immigrants, despite being born there.
00:11:13 And if they tried to go back to their parents' native country, because it's not their native country, they were called Swedes because they were not from Somalia. 0.59
00:11:20 And so they basically were stateless.
00:11:22 When the police would come in, these people would say, you have no jurisdiction here.
00:11:26 You are not our people.
00:11:27 We are something else.
00:11:28 You've cast us out.
00:11:30 So this leads to gang violence, crime.
00:11:33 I think it's important to, how you should understand this is, from the perspective of
00:11:37 somebody who lives in an enclave like this, the people outside of it are not part of their
00:11:41 community.
00:11:42 And let's just imagine for a second, they don't exist.
00:11:44 So what does that mean?
00:11:45 They're not concerned about interacting with you for the most part.
00:11:48 They don't expect to get a job from you.
00:11:49 They don't expect to buy or trade with you.
00:11:51 but there's another enclave on the other side of town these people they do interact with and
00:11:56 sometimes they disagree so we end up seeing in sweden is uh these these the children of these 0.94
00:12:01 refugees throwing grenades at each other uh when i went there in 2017 it was actually late 2016 0.73
00:12:06 a grenade had detonated on the balcony injuring a british child who was there with his family as
00:12:11 tourists as collateral damage in these in these gang fights where they're buying these weapons
00:12:14 but we don't need to look at Sweden to see the problems of enclaves you can
00:12:20 come to Chicago Chicago is fascinating in that every neighborhood in the in the
00:12:25 in Brandon Johnson's mayoral election voted based on race so if you look at
00:12:29 the initial voting data this is when it was the full field not just the runoff
00:12:35 you can look at a neighborhood and see its racial demographics and guess what
00:12:39 their top candidates are going to be the same racial demographic so we have that
00:12:43 same problem here in the United States. And we can talk about the history of this country and 0.98
00:12:48 why that exists with, say, redlining and blockbusting. But it doesn't matter if you're 1.00
00:12:54 bringing new people in or you have people who are here. You create enclaves. You will create
00:12:58 animosity between these people. So a good example that I like to cite is I grew up in the Midway
00:13:05 area. And my buddy and I, who's actually chilling right here, Brandon, we were only a few blocks
00:13:10 away from the Leclerc courts, which has been bulldozed and destroyed. It's gone now.
00:13:15 It was almost entirely, I think it was 100% black, maybe
00:13:18 some Latino. And then right across 47th of the South, it was
00:13:22 largely white with some Latino, and it was largely Polish immigrants. 0.65
00:13:26 I mean, yeah, it was racial violence all the time. Because you have two distinct communities that identify 0.99
00:13:30 each other immediately based on their race, and they have these enclaves.
00:13:35 I think ultimately what this leads to in the United States,
00:13:38 not with the VRA, that we have to stop. It may be difficult, but I think that if we pursue
00:13:45 politics based on race continually, like they've, like, look, with all due respect to the Democrats
00:13:50 for whatever they deserve respect for, advocating that we create congressional districts based on
00:13:54 race is going to exacerbate this. Because you're asking a group of, you're telling everyone in the
00:13:59 room, split up based on race, find what unifies you based on what you look like, and then argue
00:14:04 with someone else about what you deserve okay well then you're going to have a guy immediately is
00:14:09 going to look at a white guy's gonna look at a white guy and say okay you and i have something
00:14:12 to fight for then because we were told we have to live this way we need to we need to stop this we
00:14:17 need to let people live next to each other be neighbors and politics should be based on the
00:14:21 economics of a region the geography of a region what the people need not how we look yeah no i
00:14:27 think that our body politic cannot continue in that way obviously it's it's anathema to what the
00:14:32 the founders felt and especially what the sort of feel-good politics of
00:14:37 yesteryear were sort of about. We just don't really, we can't rely on a racialized society 0.66
00:14:45 and racialized politics. It's just not something we can do. Another sort of segmented racialized
00:14:50 place is Los Angeles. And the other week I was listening to your show and you had talked about
00:14:55 how you spent some time in Los Angeles and you actually worked with non-profits and dealing
00:14:59 with the homeless area and so I'm I'm from LA County is California is my home
00:15:04 I love it and it's very frustrating to see of course the mismanagement on so
00:15:09 many levels but I think that the people are nice the weather's fantastic there's
00:15:14 so much history and in terms of people but also businesses that have come out
00:15:19 of California it's a very culturally significant place and so I wonder what
00:15:22 you think about what's going on in California in LA
00:15:26 Politically and also regarding the homelessness crisis you spoke about what you think that the true character of the homelessness problem
00:15:33 Yes in terms of whether it's dealing with mental health problems or with addiction or with economics
00:15:39 Can you talk to what you think the crux of the issue is with with homelessness and how that's in the politics in California?
00:15:44 In general is a really interesting thing to point out about California is I'm sure you know this
00:15:48 There are oil pumps hidden as buildings all over this all over the city and county
00:15:51 That people who aren't from there they don't realize this you'll see a church with a tall steeple
00:15:55 it's actually fake and behind it is an oil pump. But that's just a point I want to make about
00:16:00 perception. The reason is you mentioned mismanagement and on the issue of homelessness
00:16:05 the only reason you'd characterize it as mismanagement is that you're part of the
00:16:10 outgroup. Because if you're part of the homeless industrial complex as it's called it's not being
00:16:13 mismanaged. It's functioning actually exactly as intended which is to funnel money from the hopeful
00:16:19 but ignorant masses and government into the pockets of people who do nothing. Which I think
00:16:23 we've seen too much of in this country. The scale of fraud in this country is not just as it's
00:16:29 described at the federal level by Republicans or whatever. I would describe it as the homeless
00:16:34 shelters in Los Angeles tend to be empty. I don't speak for every single one. The ones that I've
00:16:38 experienced with empty, yet they will tell you when they ask you for money, they're at capacity
00:16:44 or they're full. Why? Why would you donate money to a shelter that nobody wants to be at?
00:16:49 If they came to you and said, well, we literally have no homeless people coming to our shelter,
00:16:52 they don't use it it's well then what do you need the money for keep the lights on i guess well why
00:16:57 you're not helping the homeless well the issue is the homeless don't want help there's a there's a
00:17:01 lot of issues with homelessness especially in my experience uh working with a non-profit
00:17:06 specifically on the issue of homelessness and it's that the overwhelming majority that are
00:17:10 long-term homeless either choose to be or incapable of not being the people that we encounter who are
00:17:16 down on their luck, maybe lost their job or hardship drove them into a dark place.
00:17:23 Instantly, instantly solved. You find a guy who got laid off from his job, burned his savings and
00:17:28 got evicted, holding up a sign saying, I'm trying to make it work. You walk up to him and you say,
00:17:32 we're going to put you in a house. We're going to buy you some clean clothes and we're going to
00:17:35 find you a job. He will say, thank you. He will go with you. He will do exactly as told. And within
00:17:39 two weeks, he's working a job. He's now moved on from the principal shelter to a halfway house.
00:17:44 I don't know if halfway house is the right word, but they have houses owned by shelters
00:17:48 that are three bedrooms, and then there will be people living together as roommates.
00:17:51 They start paying rent, get apartments, problem solved.
00:17:55 They might receive disability or unemployment from the government, which does help, and
00:17:58 I am in favor of.
00:18:00 However, 80 to 90 percent, we run into drug addicts, the mentally ill, and people who
00:18:06 choose to be homeless, and I mean literally choose.
00:18:09 So you'll come up to a man and a woman sitting in a tent.
00:18:13 You will ask them, how are you doing?
00:18:16 And they're going to say, couldn't be happier.
00:18:18 And you'll say, oh, is there anything to get you?
00:18:21 No.
00:18:22 You sure?
00:18:23 Yeah, I'm good.
00:18:24 You got any money?
00:18:25 Well, I'm not going to give you money.
00:18:26 I'm good.
00:18:27 We got food.
00:18:27 We got shelter.
00:18:28 Have a nice day.
00:18:29 So the city can't get these people to leave because they don't want to.
00:18:32 Then you run to the issue of people who, no matter what you give them, they're going to
00:18:35 spend it on drugs.
00:18:36 And that is an issue.
00:18:37 And it's very difficult to solve, especially for LA.
00:18:40 the reason why the homelessness is so bad there and they consider it to be worst and the worst
00:18:44 of the developed world is that it's just so nice the weather's so good if you're somebody who
00:18:49 intends to sleep outside la is the place to be for for two big reasons year-round good weather
00:18:55 you're not going to die in winter and the government's going to give you free stuff
00:18:58 and you never have to change and then for these government programs for these uh non-profits they
00:19:04 call it the homeless industrial complex they're happy to get multi-million dollar grants from the
00:19:08 federal and state government that they know they will never solve any problem with but hey you
00:19:13 got a three hundred thousand dollar a year job right now to sit around and claim you're fighting
00:19:16 the good fight why do anything differently yeah no I completely agree and I've I've been out and
00:19:22 I've gone out to help the homeless actually in my area and I've run into the same exact
00:19:26 dispositions of people no we're fine we're fine they're very pleased to do it I mean like you
00:19:30 said it's basically a paradise free stuff everywhere and it's again it's you know and
00:19:35 to say positively about this country we have a lot of resources and there's not the scarcity issue
00:19:39 but it creates this problem where um of course the sort of residual presence of the homeless is
00:19:46 is a nuisance especially when there's drugs involved which is basically always i think i
00:19:50 think maybe we're too nice an example is i knew a guy uh this is like 20 years ago now he would
00:19:55 sleep on on state street and he would put a folgers tin can in front of him and go to sleep
00:20:01 and he would wake up and it would be full or he'd wake up periodically check go back to sleep
00:20:05 so i i see him there one day i meet him where i'm talking to him and he was probably in his
00:20:10 late 20s and he said he does about 200 bucks every every day he goes to sleep doesn't do
00:20:16 anything he literally just puts a can out falls asleep he wakes up it's full of change he would
00:20:20 walk into the local bank pour into one of those coin star machines what do they call them these
00:20:23 days and then then he'd have 200 bucks only problem is he was a heroin addict and so i was
00:20:29 like bro you're doing 200 bucks a day you're not like you must be living really well and he goes
00:20:33 nah I just spend it on heroin man and I was like okay well there's your problem but there's a
00:20:39 bigger problem in that regular people are just so nice they they they want to help and it's not
00:20:44 because they they want a virtue signal or appear to be good it's because they genuinely want to
00:20:48 help and they feel bad and uh so they see somebody who seems down in their luck and they're like
00:20:53 I can spare a few bucks the only problem is the people are never going to change
00:20:57 So maybe we're trying to be nice, but it's the old give a man a fish, feed him for a day, teach a man a fish, feed him for the rest of his life.
00:21:05 Maybe to actually help these people, we have to be more stern and say the help we give you comes with certain requirements.
00:21:12 There's this phrase in California politics that is get help or get out.
00:21:16 Basically, get help or get out.
00:21:19 This current sort of middle state is not an option.
00:21:23 So some people, like you say, they end up perpetuating the problem.
00:21:26 And in fact, some of them acknowledge that they're perpetuating the problem.
00:21:29 Just, I think if they want to have drugs and be an addict, that's their choice in life.
00:21:34 There are people, I think, an increasing number of people who actually kind of accept that premise.
00:21:38 But like you said, the majority of people don't understand that they're actually facilitating.
00:21:42 And it doesn't mean we can't facilitate charity.
00:21:45 We believe in charity.
00:21:46 That's a fundamental tenet of this country.
00:21:48 But it gets to the point where, obviously, you're exacerbating the problem of addiction, which is deeply twisted.
00:21:53 this is interesting as it plays into the idea of the American identity in how the identity of
00:21:58 America changes. That is, if you say socially, I don't care if you're a drug addict, you are allowed
00:22:05 to live your life to hurt other people. What ends up happening is it becomes visible. It becomes
00:22:10 cultural. So you end up with drug addicts everywhere. You end up with children seeing
00:22:16 drug addicts. And, you know, it's the inverse of out of sight, out of mind. They see something,
00:22:20 they see the possibilities they ask questions about it and some people will fall into it
00:22:23 should you say no public disorder as it pertains to drug use and addiction will not be tolerated
00:22:32 you will have less people growing up living in that world so the question of this is you know
00:22:37 the neighborhood where i grew up in with a lot of gangs i mean chicago gangs are everywhere
00:22:40 how is it that a kid in my neighborhood ends up murdering a couple people well because the gangs
00:22:46 were everywhere. They were tolerated. The police said, and well, look, you know, if they're on the
00:22:51 street corner, we'll, we'll, if they're doing something like they set a tolerance very high.
00:22:55 If they say, if we see them waving guns, we're going to stop them. But otherwise the gangs are
00:22:59 there. What are you going to do about it? Okay. Then what happens is a 13 year old kid walks by
00:23:02 and the gang bangers yell out to him. Next thing you know, this kid's hanging out with gang bangers.
00:23:06 Next thing you know, they say, if you want to join the gang, go shoot these people from the 0.99
00:23:08 rival gang or rival drug dealers. You're creating the gangs or make you're persisting them or you're 0.87
00:23:14 making them persist there's a challenge in that what do we do as a society then
00:23:17 that I think eventually will come to a reckoning do we then crack down and go
00:23:23 hardcore broken windows style nope we don't care we're shutting this down and
00:23:27 removing it from visibility in the public it's a challenge that I think
00:23:30 we're you know as the question of what happens next for America we're going to
00:23:35 have to reconcile with the fact that we have a fractured culture it is bifurcated
00:23:40 down the middle. There are two principal factions in this country at this point with
00:23:44 massively morally divergent worldviews. And I think one side has a willingness to use violence
00:23:52 and force, one side less so. But the end result is if you sit back as gangs grow,
00:24:00 force children to join or bring them in and sell drugs, eventually life gets bad. And when it does,
00:24:07 violence breaks out response to these black markets, to, you know, a lot of the shootings
00:24:11 that we see in Chicago aren't related to drugs, which is a misconception. It's honor. It's a young
00:24:16 guy insulted another guy's girlfriend, things like that. If we tolerate these things, the end
00:24:21 result is people living in different neighborhoods, viewing each other as entirely different peoples,
00:24:28 and then solving their problems with violence, which I think we have a problem of in Chicago.
00:24:33 Yeah. Among other places, of course. That's right. That's actually very true.
00:24:37 is that it is sometimes, you know, construed in different ways, but it's a real issue.
00:24:41 And in fact, the students here, you know, of course, it's known we have to be careful just of the activity on campus.
00:24:46 And the thinker has reported extensively on criminal activity just in the area.
00:24:50 It is a pervasive issue and it shouldn't be understated.
00:24:55 I think a lot of the people in the conservative movement, which that's actually a very nebulous term, of course,
00:25:02 you know, and it's, I think, become increasingly nebulous over the last seven or eight years.
00:25:05 But people in the conservative movement would be opposed to big government encroachment on freedom of association.
00:25:13 That's kind of a fundamental tenet of American identity is being free to do what you want and to engage with who you like.
00:25:20 And there have been developments to the American identity throughout the 20th and 21st centuries that have redefined that.
00:25:28 Now, I think so that that goes back to what we were talking about, about gang violence and how do you actually break these up?
00:25:34 I think ultimately the United States has been seen as a high-trust society.
00:25:41 It's a high-trust society.
00:25:42 And so a system of self-governance is possible when people literally govern themselves.
00:25:47 When you no longer have that cohesion and that degree of trust, it becomes very difficult to do that.
00:25:53 John Adams famously said the Constitution is suited for a moral and religious population.
00:25:59 It is wholly unfit for any other.
00:26:00 The way I see it, you have the option to have sort of a liberty-minded self-governance, you have totalitarianism, like let's say in China or Russia, and then you have the option of just anarchy.
00:26:13 The end result is going to be totalitarian either way because you cannot have two distinct moral worldviews occupying the same nation.
00:26:20 So you mentioned the conservative movement.
00:26:22 What does that mean?
00:26:22 Well, the conservative movement exists, but that's like, I guess, the traditional conservative movement would be like Daily Wire.
00:26:30 And if I were to sit down with someone like Ben Shapiro, we're going to disagree on most policy-related things,
00:26:36 but amicably and in the American tradition with smiles on our faces and a cup of coffee or maybe a beer.
00:26:43 But we disagree a lot.
00:26:44 However, if you zoom out at the national level, people would argue that he and I occupy the same space.
00:26:50 So the bigger picture is there is a constitutional Republican movement, that is the tradition
00:26:55 of America, and there's a multicultural democracy movement, and that is the new world, the new
00:27:01 vision for progressivism.
00:27:02 Both of these moral worldviews exist, and they cannot coexist.
00:27:07 So the question I ask to exemplify this would be for you, do you believe that parents should
00:27:12 have the final say on the medical decisions of their children?
00:27:15 Yeah, absolutely. 1.00
00:27:16 So if a parent says my child is trans and should have their genitals removed at 13, you would say that's allowed. 1.00
00:27:25 Right. Well, then I draw a distinction between medical decisions and decisions that get into the realm of ideology, 1.00
00:27:30 which I think is something that may have to be.
00:27:32 You're still giving them a moral position of what ultimately comes down to a medical doctor's opinion.
00:27:39 So conservatives, you know, I suppose with the typical liberal, these conversations have been harder.
00:27:49 But I bring this up to conservatives to point out that there's two distinct, there's two answers they would give depending on context,
00:27:54 which shows it's a moral worldview, not a principled one.
00:27:57 That is, if you believe that the parents have the final say on the medical decisions of their children,
00:28:02 then you would conclude if the parents decide the child is trans and should get hormone blockers
00:28:07 double mastectomy at you know 13 or whatever then that's the parent's decision however conservatives
00:28:12 are going to say absolutely not that's not medicine it's like lobotomy oh hold on you see
00:28:18 you've got another half of the country that would argue a doctor has prescribed this treatment
00:28:21 out of fear of the mental well-being of this child and it is a treatment you disagree the
00:28:27 inverse is vaccination. So in a similar instance, when the parents would say that the state wants
00:28:37 to mandate, so I'll put it like this. If you think the parents cannot have their children
00:28:42 get a sex change, then you would say the answer is government intervention. But then you have the
00:28:47 same decision on the government trying to mandate vaccination and the parents saying no, now you're
00:28:52 saying the government can't enforce. The government can't make a decision on the medical
00:28:57 decision of a children or they can't it's it's not identical you know i was having a conversation
00:29:02 with brett weinstein he described it as whichever affects the body of the child so you can you know
00:29:07 have a distinction there that's not necessarily uh you know an incongruent moral worldview but
00:29:12 my point ultimately is what we're dealing with this country right now in terms of these dual
00:29:17 political factions is completely distinct ways of reading reality as scott adams described it
00:29:22 it's one screen with two movies playing. We can't change that. I think this is born of
00:29:28 cultural development at youth for the millennial and younger generations. When you look at the Pew
00:29:35 research data, you can see that boomers are almost entirely aligned on their political worldview,
00:29:40 which is why when Donald Trump got elected, a lot of the older conservatives joined with
00:29:44 Democrats because they mostly agree and they oppose Trump. Each younger generation, I believe,
00:29:49 will become more and more entrenched in a bifurcated worldview that cannot solve their
00:29:54 problems because they fundamentally disagree on what is. So the end result I see there is,
00:30:01 I don't see how you get anything other than physical violence and conflict, especially right
00:30:04 now when we're looking at a midterm that will not be decided based on the popularity of party,
00:30:09 but based on the institutional power they wield. That is, Republicans have just flipped, I believe
00:30:14 it's nine or 10 seats. That's a 20 point swing gained, not because they have the right ideas,
00:30:19 but because they controlled enough states to eliminate Democrat districts.
00:30:22 Democrats try to do the same.
00:30:24 They're both going to blame, both factions will blame each other,
00:30:26 but the end result is who will gain the institutional power,
00:30:29 and then what happens to the minority group when they refuse to be governed by someone
00:30:32 they believe to be morally repugnant.
00:30:34 Right, and we had a civil war because one party won over the other,
00:30:38 and they believed that just governance by the majority party was not going to work.
00:30:42 I don't think that's where we're headed, honestly, in terms of an all-out coming to blows,
00:30:46 But like you said, two different movies, two different realities.
00:30:50 How can we coexist as one nation if we used to have different visions of how to get to the same end,
00:30:56 but now we also actually have different ends entirely?
00:30:59 I would agree with you on the possibility that we don't get there for one reason.
00:31:04 Charlie Kirk was shot in the neck and killed less than a year ago, and nobody rioted.
00:31:09 So you can have George Floyd and whatever your opinion is on that,
00:31:13 And it results in nationwide riots where thousands rip the barricades down at the White House, throw firebombs under the White House lawn, set fire to St. John's Church, force the president into a bunker.
00:31:25 And the response from our media establishment is bunker boy.
00:31:29 And then you can have January 6th, probably substantially worse, but still very bad.
00:31:34 And the narrative is inverted.
00:31:37 So May 20th, 2020, you can have thousands of people injure hundreds of police officers
00:31:43 and set fire to a church, and you don't get a Wikipedia article about it.
00:31:48 You don't get academic review of the failures of democracy.
00:31:51 It is considered acceptable.
00:31:52 So where I would agree with you that it's not going to come to the extreme blows is
00:31:55 that should the more extreme elements of the left be marginalized, they will kill with
00:32:03 impunity, and the right will do nothing to stop it.
00:32:06 And should the right be marginalized, they will accept it.
00:32:09 And I think it also comes back to the distinction you made
00:32:11 between a more or less worldview and a principled worldview.
00:32:16 I think people who adopt either of those both exist
00:32:20 in what we're calling the conservative movement.
00:32:22 It's sort of an older conservative, even maybe before the United States,
00:32:26 sort of a traditional conservative view that there is an objective right and wrong
00:32:30 and government should probably exist, at least in large part,
00:32:34 to effectuate the degree of virtue that is most possible for a country.
00:32:40 The United States was founded more on a Lockean pretense of
00:32:44 let's let people pursue the good on their own.
00:32:46 They can probably make better decisions for themselves
00:32:48 than the government can make for them.
00:32:50 That's sort of a foundational idea of ours,
00:32:53 but as we lose the fundamental morals that we used to have in common,
00:32:58 is it still feasible, is what I wonder,
00:33:01 to have a system where we genuinely can enable people to live the way that they want
00:33:07 and trust that this whole system will continue to function?
00:33:10 No. The Civil War proved that.
00:33:13 The idea that the Confederate states, they break away from the Union
00:33:17 and they want to enshrine slavery in their constitution.
00:33:21 The idea that you can have two distinct moral worldviews occupying the same nation,
00:33:26 it's just a mathematical impossibility.
00:33:29 And so I take a look at what's happening right now.
00:33:31 And a great example is, back to the point about whether or not this comes to blows.
00:33:36 And I would argue there's a great possibility and tendency toward it.
00:33:41 But when you look at the issue of abortion, I think this hits the nail on the head with
00:33:43 the hammer in that conservatives will tell you that abortion is murder.
00:33:47 They will also tell you that in the event a man is about to murder another man, they 0.97
00:33:52 will shoot the attempted murderer. 0.65
00:33:53 But in the event an abortion doctor is about to perform an abortion, they will not shoot 0.96
00:33:57 the doctor shows.
00:33:58 they don't actually hold that value, in which case, as we're seeing, say, Oklahoma ban abortion
00:34:04 outright. Colorado has abortion to the point of birth. The right will do nothing to stop it,
00:34:08 but the left will keep pushing as hard as they can. Yeah. Tim, to close, I want to ask you about
00:34:12 the future of the conservative movement. Charlie Kirk's killing about a year ago was really,
00:34:19 really significant and impactful on the congruence, on the togetherness of the conservative
00:34:26 movement, both in the media apparatus and just politically, it's actually really incredible
00:34:32 to think about the influence that one man had over our movement.
00:34:36 It's really profound.
00:34:38 But seeing as though time keeps moving on, we keep moving forward, how can we begin to
00:34:43 reconcile a cohesive political movement that is going to continue to be effective in the
00:34:49 wake of such bitter disagreements and disputes, many of which seem utterly personal, actually,
00:34:55 and not based on principle at all?
00:34:56 I don't know that you can. Charlie was feared, respected, and valued tremendously. People saw
00:35:05 him as someone who was honorable, honest, but also empowering. He would help you out with
00:35:11 whatever you needed, whenever you needed. I always say this, the weirdest thing is how busy the guy
00:35:16 was. I could text him, I'd get a response in like 20 seconds, and I'm sitting there being like,
00:35:20 I swear to God, he's got like three staffers at his phone answering, pretending to be him,
00:35:24 because there's no way. But it's him. It was him. And so what happens is there are a lot of people
00:35:29 that saw Charlie as someone who could help them, and they respected that, but they also respected
00:35:34 him for the work that he did. And so when Charlie said, we're in this together, stop fighting,
00:35:39 people said, for you, Charlie, yes. With Charlie gone, these people are basically saying, you know,
00:35:44 as we can see with the AmFest last year, they're on stage fighting with each other, Ben Shapiro and
00:35:49 Steve Bannon going at each other, and now you've got, you know, Candace Tucker and everybody's at
00:35:53 each other's throat. I think you see, you know, I learned something really interesting. And I knew
00:36:00 this to a certain degree, but getting real confirmation of it is magic, I would describe it.
00:36:05 There is a great deal of these prominent personalities that I would specifically
00:36:09 single out as part of the conservative movement who don't believe a thing they say, they get paid
00:36:13 to say it. We saw this when a bunch of conservatives started promoting buying soda on welfare.
00:36:18 conservatives advocating for welfare to buy coca-cola that makes no sense they got paid to do
00:36:24 it started advocating for india america first pull the foreign foreign trade all of a sudden
00:36:31 now advocating for india is a great they got paid to do it and more recently when i rejected money
00:36:35 to promote the film animal farm by angel studios which is a it's an anti-capitalist retelling of
00:36:41 the story which makes no sense and tons of right-wing individuals promoted the film because
00:36:47 they got paid to do it. So I think a strong possibility that we just see this conservative
00:36:52 movement, whatever it actually is, fracture as it is continually because, you know, for the likes
00:36:57 of Candace Owens, it feels good to be talked about. You make a lot of money. She doesn't
00:37:02 actually care about policy. I can quote her as saying, as a quote, we don't care about your
00:37:07 midterms. She doesn't actually care about whether or not policy changes. She cares about whether or
00:37:12 not she has a big show and she's making a lot of money, even at great personal risk to herself with
00:37:15 lawsuits people like her exist in great deals on the left and the right and I 0.99
00:37:21 will say maybe these people will be our saving grace because they will expose 1.00
00:37:25 the machine for being a bunch of grifters and then people will walk away
00:37:28 from that fight saying you know maybe these people were lying to us for money
00:37:31 and maybe that calms things down well Tim it's been so great to have you we
00:37:36 wish you the best thank you for for engaging and for joining us at the
00:37:39 American Identity Summit we appreciate it and we again wish you all the best in
00:37:43 in your fight for journalistic integrity.
00:37:46 Thanks for having me.
00:37:53 Thanks for having us.
00:37:54 It was awesome.
00:37:55 Yeah, good fun.