The Debrief With MyronGainesX - July 06, 2026


Former Fed Explains Tyler Robinson Prelim Hearing In Charlie Kirk Murder Case!

Topics
Hosted by
Mentioned
FBI Wiretaps Newsom? Dean Withers v 20 MAGA Women, Tucker Launches 3rd Party! Charlie Kirk Murder Hearing Day 2, RIP Connor Murphy, US Bombs Iran, Trump In Turkey, ICE Shooting!

Episode Stats


Length

7 hours and 42 minutes

Words per minute

162.94

Word count

75,377

Sentence count

3,892

Harmful content

Misogyny

92

sentences flagged

Toxicity

778

sentences flagged

Hate speech

587

sentences flagged


Summary

Summaries generated with gmurro/bart-large-finetuned-filtered-spotify-podcast-summ .

In this episode, we discuss what a preliminary hearing is, the rules, and what to expect from this preliminary hearing. We also discuss the case against Ms. Robinson and Ms. Kirk and the charges they are facing.

Transcript

Transcript generated with Whisper (turbo).
Misogyny classifications generated with MilaNLProc/bert-base-uncased-ear-misogyny .
Toxicity classifications generated with s-nlp/roberta_toxicity_classifier .
Hate speech classifications generated with facebook/roberta-hate-speech-dynabench-r4-target .
Topics generated with Qwen2.5-3B-Instruct.
Hosts, guests, and mentioned names generated with spaCy (en_core_web_sm), reconciled against Wikidata.
00:00:00 Thank you.
00:00:30 to permit representatives of the news media to use portable electronic devices during the
00:00:35 preliminary hearing is respectfully denied. The request to permit counsel for the news media to
00:00:41 use portable electronic devices during the preliminary hearing is granted. What's up,
00:00:46 guys? Good morning. Good morning. I don't know why it's coming out one side, guys. Let me fix,
00:00:52 let me try to see if I can get a better audio feed. I'm gonna see if I can get a better audio
00:00:57 feed for you guys right now the request to permit counsel for the news media to use portable
00:01:03 electronic devices yeah it's only coming out the left-hand side these guys can never get it right
00:01:06 witnesses court staff members of the public who are present the court is also mindful of the duty
00:01:12 to protect and uphold the constitutional rights of both mr. Robinson and miss Kirk to serve those
00:01:19 important interests the court reminds all persons who will be in attendance so he's basically going
00:01:25 over formalities right now guys i apologize for the audio i don't know why it's only coming out
00:01:29 one side um i'm looking at all the different news people that are covering this thing
00:01:33 and um you know it is what it is hopefully we can like you know we'll bounce around and see
00:01:39 what we can get but yeah that's where we are portable electronic devices will not be permitted
00:01:43 in the courtroom or on the fourth floor in addition he's just going over the rules
00:01:48 and attendance will be afforded the dignity and respect due to them,
00:01:52 and pursuant to the standing decorum order,
00:01:55 all spectators shall be quiet, civil, and orderly.
00:02:00 Spectators shall not engage in any distracting, disruptive, provocative,
00:02:04 disrespectful, uncivil, or threatening behavior of any kind.
00:02:09 Spectators shall not make any audible comments of any kind,
00:02:12 shall not shake or nod their heads,
00:02:15 shall not otherwise make any gestures during the hearing.
00:02:18 and the court recognizes that this hearing may invoke emotion from all different from everyone
00:02:29 all right once we get some more people in here i'm going to explain to you guys
00:02:31 what a preliminary hearing is what they're doing and we're going to cover this in detail you guys
00:02:35 came to the best channel to break this down so uh welcome but uh i'm gonna let i'm gonna let
00:02:41 more people come into the stream and then i'm going to start talking about what a preliminary
00:02:43 hearing is what's going on here and we'll do that all right let me turn the volume up too
00:02:52 for you guys but yeah even law and crime don't got the audio on point bro so let me let me uh
00:02:59 i'm gonna look and try to find a better feed for you guys pins buttons signs clothing or
00:03:04 photographs expressing support for or against any person related to this case
00:03:10 or the status of this case as a capital offense of the Constitution.
00:03:15 You need to help all parties.
00:03:16 Okay, it looks like.
00:03:17 In every engagement that you treat each person you engage with,
00:03:21 with the dignity and respect they are inherently due.
00:03:24 Looks like May and Kelly got the best version.
00:03:26 I want to turn also to objection.
00:03:30 Ah, Sirius, that's why, Sirius XM.
00:03:33 The format that I wish to follow if that objection.
00:03:37 Yeah, way better.
00:03:38 Okay, let me turn this volume up for you guys.
00:03:39 I think we got the best audio version.
00:03:41 We'll rock out here on Megyn Kelly's channel.
00:03:45 ...are made.
00:03:47 There we go.
00:03:48 When an objection is made, all parties shall pause so that the objection may be heard.
00:03:53 Yeah, all the different channels are having crappy audio.
00:03:56 They just started this thing like a minute, like 10 minutes ago.
00:03:58 He's just going over like, you know, formalities and stuff like that.
00:04:00 Speaking objections are not permitted.
00:04:03 If any party believes that an extended argument is necessary, particularly on sensitive matters, that party may request to approach the bench, and all parties will approach the bench.
00:04:16 Both sides will be afforded an opportunity to be heard for or against the objection, after which I will issue a ruling either sustaining or overruling the objection.
00:04:27 Once the ruling has been made, direct or cross-examination may resume.
00:04:33 I anticipate that we will begin each morning at 9 a.m. with the exception of Wednesday.
00:04:39 We will begin at 1 p.m.
00:04:41 We will take a 15-minute morning break and a 15-minute afternoon break.
00:04:46 If there is a situation that necessitates a break, please approach the bench and we can address that.
00:04:55 We will recess for lunch at noon for one hour each day with the exception of Wednesday.
00:05:00 They're two hours behind, guys. It's 9 a.m. over there, if you guys are wondering.
00:05:05 And court will resume at 1 p.m. and continue until 5 p.m. each day.
00:05:11 Does either party need the benefit of the record?
00:05:19 Thank you, Ms. Nestor.
00:05:20 No, no, thank you.
00:05:22 Thank you, Mr. Grenander.
00:05:24 Do either party wish to invoke the exclusionary rule?
00:05:27 Defense invokes, Your Honor.
00:05:28 All right. The fence has invoked the exclusionary rule. I ask that all witnesses, if present, be excused from the courtroom and ask that each party monitor the courtroom to ensure your witnesses aren't present, as I'm not familiar with who they are.
00:05:44 Of course, victim representative is excluded from that rule, as is the case manager pursuant to the.
00:05:52 So I saw Brandon Tatum there. I'm assuming Megan Kelly is here. A lot of people are there, guys, out there in Utah covering this.
00:05:58 Okay, and I anticipate that from here on out that they're just going to come to the lectrum, so.
00:06:16 Okay, so just for the benefit of the record, to the questions, yes or no questions,
00:06:24 well, the parties have entered their appearances
00:06:27 and they're all present
00:06:30 and neither party wanted the benefit of the record.
00:06:34 Ms. Nestor invoked the exclusionary rule
00:06:37 and Mr. Grunander, if you'd like to approach the electrum
00:06:41 as the microphones at the tables are not activated.
00:06:45 Thank you, Judge.
00:06:46 We anticipated that the defense would invoke the exclusionary rule.
00:06:49 um we met with we consulted with defense for just a couple of minutes prior to the
00:06:55 start of this hearing we essentially have two case agents your honor um david hull and brian
00:07:01 davis both from the state of utah um the defense i told you guys that this is going to be a state 0.94
00:07:06 case this is not a federal case do not listen to the morons okay this is not an fbi case it's not 0.88
00:07:11 an atf case this is a state case guys okay uh these guys are from the state police criminal 0.98
00:07:16 investigation major crimes unit has consented that both of them can be present so one is seated
00:07:22 at my table uh the front table there are going to be the ones that probably present most of the
00:07:27 testimony here um in this preliminary hearing this is brian davis agent which i'm going to explain
00:07:33 for you guys what a preliminary hearing is once we fill this thing up a little bit davis and agent
00:07:37 hull is seated on the bench just on the other side of the bar um he will be present for this
00:07:44 hearing as well both of these agents will be testifying as part of the hearing thank you
00:07:48 Ms. Nestor uh and your microphone's dead if you want to come forward and and it sounds like you've
00:07:55 stipulated but just for the best so he's the prosecution that's the lead prosecutor right
00:07:59 there that guy that spoke and I fit the record we have stipulated your honor for purposes of
00:08:02 this hearing only thank you all right so agents Davis and Hull are permitted to remain in the
00:08:09 courtroom during the duration of the preliminary hearing. Any other business
00:08:15 that we need to address before we turn to the business of witnesses?
00:08:24 Mr. Novak. Thank you, Your Honor. Richard Novak for Ms. Robinson. Your Honor, the
00:08:29 court had issued an order, maybe it was early last week, asking the parties to
00:08:37 meet and confer about the question of whether exhibits will be published.
00:08:46 And we did, and we can either deal with this as a general matter or we can deal with it
00:08:55 on an exhibit-by-exhibit basis, but I just wanted to make sure that we didn't lose track
00:09:00 of that issue. The court had earlier
00:09:04 entered an order granting in part
00:09:08 the defense motion to exclude
00:09:11 I'm just going to say technology in the courtroom
00:09:16 because it's a shorthand for video cameras and photography and microphones
00:09:19 because the parties had earlier stipulated that none of the
00:09:24 exhibits would be available from the preliminary hearing would be
00:09:28 available for inspection or copying. I understand that
00:09:32 publishing the exhibits in the courtroom may technically be
00:09:36 different than that, but whenever the court is ready to deal with that
00:09:40 issue, we just want to make sure
00:09:41 that we do so before it's too late.
00:09:49 That's always the right time to do it.
00:09:52 Okay, thank you. Turning to the state
00:09:54 And in defense, do we anticipate this being a long argument, or is it something that we can handle,
00:10:03 that there are some stipulations that we can address right now,
00:10:07 and then the remainder we can address on an exhibit-by-exhibit basis?
00:10:12 Mr. Grunander.
00:10:14 Judge, I don't know that we have any stipulations, but with that said, it is correct.
00:10:19 Mr. Novak is correct.
00:10:20 We did meet and consult on this issue.
00:10:23 I wanted to give the court just a brief roadmap, but part of that was exhibits 7, 8, and 9
00:10:29 that we propose introducing will be graphic in nature.
00:10:35 And those were the exhibits I was referring to at the last hearing
00:10:38 where we would like to take a short break before they were published, if they are published.
00:10:44 That's probably going to be pictures of Charlie's body.
00:10:47 Be by way of video and or audio.
00:10:52 Judge, I don't see any TVs or monitors here in the courtroom today with respect to publishing something that would go beyond council table and your honor's bench.
00:11:04 So I don't know how much of an issue this is going to be anyway, at least with respect to pictures or video.
00:11:12 Thank you.
00:11:13 That's a great point.
00:11:16 And the courts thought about this issue in regards to publication of exhibits.
00:11:20 Obviously, the court will entertain all motions before any, but after considering it, here's the two points that I wish to address.
00:11:32 In regards to the exhibits, there is benefit to publication of certain exhibits, but I also do not, and this is going to the camera operator, do not want them to be displayed on TV.
00:11:45 I believe it is important that the parties know that the exhibits are being viewed by the judge in real time and in open court.
00:11:57 However, what I will do is have the monitor placed against that wall to reduce the possibility of it being broadcast.
00:12:05 and so um on the exhibits that the court grants to be published in court and not going to mr
00:12:14 novak's point not to be given copies to and the court is trying to be mine yeah that's probably
00:12:19 this is more than likely going to be pictures of the body guys uh from obviously autopsy etc
00:12:24 the crime scene the blood uh that's probably what they're referring to here that if it's shown on
00:12:32 TV, that's essentially giving a copy to. And so the court is taking Mr. Novak's point in
00:12:39 consideration. And so the anticipation is, and I know I'm catching staff a little bit off guard,
00:12:45 is placing that television right behind Jeff, our bailiff, to minimize the accidental capture
00:12:52 by the camera and allowing it to be displayed. I recognize that that is not the ideal spot for
00:13:00 viewing but I'm also trying to balance the rights and important considerations
00:13:06 that defense has made and again this will be on an exhibit by exhibit basis
00:13:10 on what is published or what is not but the for the for the exhibits that the
00:13:15 court rules can be published in open court that is going to be the location
00:13:21 of the monitor and and again the court spent a bit of time weighing what should
00:13:28 be done, where the monitor should be placed to accomplish the purposes of publication
00:13:35 at the same time protecting, especially as it may relate to sensitive material if the
00:13:42 court deems that to be publishable in the courtroom.
00:13:46 Any questions that I can address from either side or clarification needed or thoughts that
00:13:51 you wish to share?
00:13:52 No, I think I understand completely.
00:13:55 All right.
00:13:56 Thank you.
00:13:57 All right.
00:13:58 Mr. Grunander, as it relates to that, are we anticipating the possibility of that coming up very soon
00:14:07 in regards to publishing potentially exhibits?
00:14:13 Not real soon, but today certainly I would anticipate, Judge.
00:14:18 For the course information, we anticipate presenting four witnesses.
00:14:21 They're all law enforcement witnesses.
00:14:23 officer chris bagley he's now with spanish fork police department he was with utah valley
00:14:30 university police department he'll be the first witness the second witness will be agent
00:14:35 david hull and those exhibits seven eight nine we anticipate coming in through him
00:14:41 third witness will be agent brian davis again with the state of utah a case agent who's here
00:14:48 yeah these guys are all from this agency right here guys state bureau investigation okay get
00:14:52 familiar with this agency this is the lead agency that's running this thing it's not the fbi it's
00:14:55 not the atf this is the state bureau investigation their detectives are called special agents but
00:15:00 they're not federal they're state um they're the ones running this thing okay uh that's why there's
00:15:05 two the two agents that are there for sbi are more than likely the they're both the case agents on it
00:15:10 like they're the ones that writing up the affidavits doing the interviews etc presently
00:15:15 And lastly, Sergeant Jennifer Fowl-Moina, also of the Utah Department of Public Safety.
00:15:23 And we do anticipate admitting between 40 and 50 exhibits.
00:15:29 Thank you.
00:15:32 All right, Mr. Grunander, I apologize.
00:15:34 You walked away before I got my question out.
00:15:37 If we anticipate taking a break around 1030, do you anticipate any potential exhibits for publication being requested prior to 1030?
00:15:48 I do, Judge. I do. I think the first several exhibits should be published.
00:15:53 All right. Well, let's do this. I want our preliminary hearing to move smoothly and with the least amount of delays as possible.
00:16:02 So let's take a brief break to allow the placement of that monitor.
00:16:05 All right. Perfect.
00:16:07 a brief task to make sure it's working, and then we can be seamless in moving forward.
00:16:11 One quick question, Judge, for counsel's benefit.
00:16:14 Are the monitors at the tables going to be turned on?
00:16:18 The monitors are, and that's why I wanted to give that instruction early on
00:16:23 for each party to monitor their monitor.
00:16:27 Because if the camera is doing a wide-sweep picture of the courtroom,
00:16:32 I can't prevent the accidental capture.
00:16:35 Obviously, the decorum order anticipates not focusing in to the point that it's focused on your monitors.
00:16:42 But I ask all the parties to be mindful, especially as it relates to the sensitive material that may be published or may not.
00:16:50 But please, just take a look at that and be mindful of that.
00:16:56 But I will leave it to you.
00:16:57 So I believe it's important that all parties see what is before the court.
00:17:02 So if you have objections, it's right there.
00:17:04 you can say okay i see what the court's saying i have ejection or not okay so um they're going to
00:17:09 take a break here or whatever okay so what is happening right now let's go back
00:17:14 september 10th we hear a shot ring out charlie kirk is tragically killed right i'm not going
00:17:23 to get into all the conspiracy theories i'm going to give you guys the official narrative so you
00:17:25 guys understand what's happening here because they're not going to go into conspiracy theories
00:17:28 they're going to talk about the official narrative so for the purposes of me breaking this down so
00:17:31 you guys understand the facts i'm going to go off the official narrative basically this is what the
00:17:35 government is alleging or in this case the state okay case of the state case i explained to you
00:17:41 guys before the sbi is running it to uh special agents with the sbi probably from their major
00:17:45 crimes unit or some other type of um sophisticated unit is running the investigation they're the ones
00:17:50 that are responsible presenting all the evidence writing the affidavits etc okay teller Robinson
00:17:55 was arrested a few days after the alleged shooting. And what ended up happening was
00:18:01 they found a rifle. Okay. They found the rifle on the top of the building
00:18:07 with his DNA on it. Excuse me. No, no, I'm sorry. They found the rifle in the woods. So basically
00:18:16 they got footage, right, of Tyler Robinson running off of the top of a building. I'm
00:18:22 going to show you guys that real quick let me show you how this jog some of your guys memories
00:18:27 about what's going on here and again we're going off the official narrative here because that's
00:18:32 what is pertinent to what we're talking about uh here it is hold on make it big for you guys
00:18:42 let me get myself out the way hold on
00:18:52 okay so as you guys can see here right
00:19:22 So you saw him running, right?
00:19:26 So the camera comes.
00:19:27 This is a building you shot from, allegedly.
00:19:30 And you're going to see a figure run across.
00:19:34 So here he is right here.
00:19:36 Just follow my mouse.
00:19:38 Right?
00:19:39 And as he comes here, the camera's going to zoom in.
00:19:44 Now, you can see him place something down.
00:19:47 Okay, like a long-type object with something draped over it, a towel.
00:19:50 okay and he hangs off the side of the building drops down and runs right and you can see that
00:20:00 he has something stiff on his arm right and then he kind of disappears so
00:20:07 and then before the shooting and again i'm refreshing you guys's memory on the facts
00:20:15 the case here of the official narrative um before the shooting you guys remember this infamous
00:20:24 footage we also have a suspect they're walking in the so here he is walking right and if you can see
00:20:31 the person is walking with a limp there and it is believed to be because that person has a rifle
00:20:40 in the pants and they are walking very difficult because of that object that has got now here's
00:20:47 the famous surveillance footage of him going up stairs right now the important thing to realize
00:20:53 guys right is um i know there's a lot of theories out there whatever but again i'm going off the
00:20:57 official narrative what the police and the government is claiming is this he had a mauser
00:21:03 rifle he had it broken in two different parts one side he was holding on this side and then the
00:21:08 other side he was holding on the other side so in other words the stock and the barrel were
00:21:12 separated okay the the firearm was disassembled he gets upstairs okay now that you guys are now
00:21:18 i'm jogging your guys memory right so basically he had it like this one side of his body had the
00:21:26 rifle one side of his body had like the stock portion of the rifle and then the other side of
00:21:32 his body had like the long barrel so he had the gun in two pieces that's why he was walking simple
00:21:37 like this okay once he gets upstairs he lays down a towel that he had his backpack
00:21:45 pulls the rifle from his clothing and he assembles it with a screwdriver
00:21:50 okay he already had the scope zeroed in or whatever it may be takes the shot then we see
00:21:58 him running off the roof here's the problem he left the screwdriver there okay so he leaves
00:22:05 a screwdriver there runs off the roof goes into the woods when he gets to the woods he realizes
00:22:12 he left a screwdriver on top of the building so he can't disassemble the gun that's why he left
00:22:17 the gun in the forest again i'm going off the official narrative i don't want a bunch of
00:22:21 conspiracy morons in here dude okay i'm telling you guys the official narrative for the purposes
00:22:25 of this preliminary hearing okay this is not the theory episode we could do this another time 0.98
00:22:29 anyway so he has to leave the gun there that's when the police find it and that's why he was at
00:22:38 a like a dairy queen or whatever like later on that night because he was trying to figure out
00:22:42 what he was going to do because he was about two to three hours away from uh where where where the
00:22:48 where the shooting happened where the for he was like two to three hours away from the university
00:22:52 so um that's a general gist of the official narrative okay now what is the preliminary
00:23:01 hearing okay um oh my god what do we got low iq people in the chat bro i told you guys already
00:23:07 dude like yo shut up like do not come in here and talk to me about the conspiracy theory we're not
00:23:11 here to talk about the conspiracy theories we're watching the preliminary hearing based off the 1.00
00:23:16 official narrative please shut up dude please shut the hell up holy crap man i get it i understand 0.97
00:23:22 30 out six yeah like there's no way fair i've heard the alternative theories but for the purposes 0.98
00:23:28 of this coverage okay i'm giving you guys the official narrative so you understand
00:23:33 what they're going to be talking about okay please stop being low iq okay now
00:23:40 obviously a couple of days he uh he like confesses to some friends he turns himself in
00:23:50 they find some discord chat with his you know lover who i guess is of questionable gender we
00:23:56 don't know we're on tiktok so i'll keep it nice and clean right and there's some shady stuff there
00:24:02 however that's not that that's all going to come on their preliminary hearing but that's the
00:24:07 evidence against him in general so they have his dna they have the gun they have the dna on the
00:24:12 screwdriver they have a somewhat confession from his family okay uh i don't know if they have phone
00:24:20 evidence they're probably going to present all of this right so why are we here now so
00:24:26 a preliminary hearing guys is a hearing where you establish probable cause
00:24:31 now i know what you guys say wait myron that doesn't make sense didn't they arrest him because
00:24:34 they already had the probable cause? Yes. Now, what they're doing now is they're formalizing
00:24:40 that probable cause with a preliminary hearing. Now, I'm going to be very honest with you guys.
00:24:44 The fact that they're running a preliminary hearing almost a year later, remember, Charlie
00:24:48 was killed September 10th, 2025. We're in July of 2026, 10 months to do a preliminary hearing.
00:24:56 Unheard of. Unheard of. But here's the thing. The state is extremely...
00:25:02 i'll just be honest they're very slow and incompetent okay the federal system bro you
00:25:08 you arrest them out you got two weeks to indict them like well what are we doing here
00:25:11 other conversation um so they're doing a preliminary hearing now if i have to speculate
00:25:18 i'm assuming it was a defense saying we need more time because obviously you got every agency under
00:25:23 their under the sun helping out you got the fbi you got the atf you have an enormous amount of
00:25:27 you know, evidence, voluminous terabytes of data.
00:25:30 So obviously the defense team
00:25:32 had to go through everything to prepare.
00:25:35 And now they're saying,
00:25:36 we want to do a preliminary hearing.
00:25:38 So they want the government,
00:25:39 or in this case, the state,
00:25:41 to provide the probable cause.
00:25:47 Now, remember guys,
00:25:48 they just need to establish probable cause.
00:25:51 That's it.
00:25:51 Probable cause is a very low standard.
00:25:53 Okay?
00:25:54 But what I'm assuming,
00:25:56 the the reason why the defense is doing this is because they want to see what's going to come out
00:25:59 during trial okay so the state is going to have to be strategic here where they're going to want
00:26:07 to share enough evidence to make their case solid but they also don't want to share too much so that
00:26:16 the defense can prepare for trial better okay and keep in mind guys this preliminary hearing
00:26:21 the burden is on the state, not on Tyler and his defense. As a defendant, you have no
00:26:28 responsibility to present the case. Your job is to defend against the case, okay? Your job is to
00:26:38 create reasonable doubt. That's all the defense has to do, create reasonable doubt, distill the
00:26:43 water a little bit, make people think, ah, maybe it wasn't him. Now, I do think also, if I'm just
00:26:50 going to put on my you know thinking cap here all of these different conspiracy theories that have
00:26:58 been out right that people have given different alternative narratives this is going to help the
00:27:02 defense obviously and they're you best believe they're definitely watching like all the different
00:27:07 people giving their theories whatever and they're going to use that right to create reasonable doubt
00:27:13 in this case and i predict this is another reason why the government is going to go have to go the
00:27:17 well, the state, the state's going to have to go a bit harder than they usually would.
00:27:20 Dude, five days for a preliminary hearing is insane.
00:27:24 Insane.
00:27:26 You're talking to a guy who's testified hundreds of times at preliminary hearings.
00:27:31 Okay.
00:27:33 A five-day preliminary hearing is nuts.
00:27:36 Any lawyer or law enforcement officer in here will tell you that.
00:27:39 So we'll see what happens.
00:27:42 But that's where we are.
00:27:44 So we're here to establish probable cause, guys.
00:27:46 five days to establish probable cause and for the prosecution it's going to be a delicate balance of
00:27:53 establishing enough probable cause to be taken seriously right and kind of hit the defense
00:27:59 hard enough but at the same time you don't want to knock them out and give all your best information
00:28:04 because then they can prepare properly for trial so they're going to have to
00:28:11 be convincing but not give all their cards up does that make sense guys because we still got a trial
00:28:15 I don't even know if this case has been indicted yet
00:28:17 I don't think this case went to a grand jury
00:28:19 so that's why there's a no actually you know what
00:28:21 I know that hasn't gone to a grand jury because they're doing a preliminary hearing
00:28:23 if this case went to a grand jury they wouldn't be doing
00:28:25 a preliminary hearing
00:28:26 so yeah guys
00:28:29 that's where we are it looks like they're still doing a recess
00:28:31 here
00:28:33 I guess I'll read some chats while I wait
00:28:35 give me ones if that don't make sense for you guys
00:28:37 you guys came to the
00:28:39 best channel by the way to cover this smart 0.75
00:28:41 gentlemen smart ladies and gentlemen in the house
00:28:43 y'all literally can't be the best person
00:28:46 appreciate you guys
00:28:48 appreciate you guys
00:28:49 now again
00:28:50 if we have some time
00:28:51 we can talk about the conspiracy theories
00:28:53 but for the purpose of this preliminary hearing
00:28:55 I'm giving you guys the official narrative
00:28:56 so you guys understand
00:28:58 what they're going to be arguing
00:28:59 and what they're going to be presenting
00:29:01 okay I'm sorry
00:29:02 but the conspiracy theories
00:29:03 are not going to do us any justice
00:29:04 in this preliminary hearing
00:29:05 we need to know what the official narrative is
00:29:07 because that's what they're going to be talking about
00:29:08 fair?
00:29:10 okay
00:29:10 awesome
00:29:11 uh wrestlers viking says sorry off topic yo maren asked you this the other day but didn't
00:29:17 mention specific details my younger brother is being reckless drinks too much hasn't gained
00:29:21 status no state crypto nothing he cheats on his girl that has been very loyal to him i mean he's 0.97
00:29:25 a loser bro what do you want me to do like you the only thing you can do bro is you have to be 0.94
00:29:30 successful yourself viking and then you got to wait for him to come in and say okay yo how do 0.99
00:29:34 you do it he's got to get his hand burned on the stove brand he's got to get his hand burned on the
00:29:40 stove men are very hard-headed so um he's not going to change more than likely you can have
00:29:48 that talk with him but if he doesn't listen then you just got to be the example and when he messes
00:29:53 up and he's uh receptive to the information then you got him so i appreciate you dude you're hot
00:29:58 you're always high iq content we all have to listen uh uh we all have content to listen to
00:30:07 while at work or while running errands.
00:30:08 Thanks, man.
00:30:09 I got you, man.
00:30:09 No worries.
00:30:10 Never mind, I'm pure Koju in TikTok.
00:30:12 Can I get a mod to send these guys to the Shadow Realm?
00:30:16 Let me see here if I can.
00:30:19 Let me go on TikTok real quick.
00:30:24 I see that you're in the OSS, so I'll give you a thing.
00:30:26 I know we got a lot of, we got some haters probably in the chat on TikTok.
00:30:32 We always do.
00:30:33 um let me uh let me jump in here in this chat okay let me see who else is here um
00:30:41 all right koju go ahead do me a favor and uh type in chat real quick so i can find you
00:30:49 oh one chest you can mount them up all right one chest mount up all the oss guys in there bro
00:30:55 please take care of that for me because i can't look at all these chats at the same time
00:30:57 okay let's go uh what do we got here uh status awa good morning myron uh my mom recommended
00:31:02 and I am considered to take Andrew Tate's real-world course.
00:31:05 Yeah, go for it, man.
00:31:08 Go for it.
00:31:12 Okay, he said one hit you two one more time.
00:31:15 No.
00:31:15 Okay.
00:31:16 But yeah, Restless Viking, dude. 1.00
00:31:18 Yeah, bro, your brother is going to be a moron. 1.00
00:31:22 It's going to take him getting burned for him to wake up, dude. 1.00
00:31:24 So you just be ready when that crash inevitably happens
00:31:28 because he clearly hasn't listened to you.
00:31:29 You've asked me about him a couple times
00:31:30 and he seems like he's very hard-headed and stubborn.
00:31:32 All right, we're back.
00:31:33 I'm going to make a brief report on discovery updates,
00:31:36 and then just inform the court that the state has provided copies of all exhibits for today's proceedings to the defense in advance of this hearing.
00:31:45 So all rights.
00:31:45 Mr. McBride.
00:31:50 Yes, Your Honor.
00:31:51 My report of the last hearing is the latest report.
00:31:54 As of June 18th, we had provided approximately 100% of the material in our possession.
00:31:58 over the last week we have received additional materials from sbi due to preparation for this
00:32:04 hearing those materials have not yet been provided but they will he said sbi guys sbi state bureau
00:32:09 investigation that's the state's equivalent of the fbi will be as soon as this hearing is complete
00:32:14 thank you defense i require the benefit of the record no your honor thank you miss nester and
00:32:21 in case the mic didn't pick that up she declined all right turning to the state you may call your
00:32:25 first witness all right here we go it's time chat the other state calls officer chris bagley
00:32:33 i think this is one of the campus cops officer bagley if you'd like to come forward
00:32:39 looks like he's being brought into the courtroom
00:32:43 oh yeah um i forgot to tell you guys this the witnesses cannot sit in the courtroom so when i
00:32:50 had to testify, they made me wait outside when I was an agent. So they can't, they can't hear
00:32:55 each other's testimony. So they're bringing him in. All right, Officer Begley, if you wouldn't
00:33:16 mind coming forward uh past electrum and being sworn in yeah they're gonna swear him in
00:33:21 you just only swear that the testimony you shall give in the case now pending before the court
00:33:30 will be the truth the whole truth and nothing but the truth so help you god
00:33:33 all right officer bagley if you wouldn't mind having a seat at the light at the witness table
00:33:40 sorry guys my dog sheds every now and then
00:33:42 and after you're situated to your left is a bottle of water and if you wouldn't mind
00:33:51 bringing the microphone toward you to ensure that it picks up your guys i can't tell you
00:33:56 how many times i sat in that chair testifying dude with a full courtroom oh man voice
00:34:02 can you hear that i can thank you mr grunander your witness thank you your honor good morning
00:34:10 sir. Good morning. Will you please state your name for the record and spell your last name?
00:34:15 Christopher Bagley, last name spelling B-A-G-L-U-Y. And how are you employed? I'm employed at the
00:34:22 Spanish Fork Police Department as a police officer. As a police officer. What is your position or your
00:34:27 rank there? Just a senior officer. Senior officer, okay. How long have you been with the Spanish Fork
00:34:32 Police Department? About five months. Five months. How long have you been a police officer? 26 years.
00:34:39 Oh, wow.
00:34:41 Will you briefly describe, for the court's benefit, your training, what you did to become a police officer?
00:34:48 So this is standard, guys.
00:34:49 They always ask what's your professional background, give us your experience, et cetera, your rank.
00:34:53 They're kind of – they're showing the expertise of the witness.
00:34:57 This is very important.
00:34:58 Now, keep in mind, this is a state witness, so this is what's called direct examination.
00:35:02 They're going to ask him questions about what went down,
00:35:05 and then the defense is going to come in and do cross-examination where they try to trip him up.
00:35:07 Police officer.
00:35:09 I did the Utah Post Academy, which is about 600 hours of training for basic things to become a police officer,
00:35:17 report writing, arrest control, stuff to that effect.
00:35:19 When you say Post Academy, is POST an acronym?
00:35:22 It is.
00:35:23 What does that stand for?
00:35:24 Police Officer Standard Training.
00:35:26 Okay.
00:35:29 Were you certified through POST?
00:35:31 I was.
00:35:32 Okay.
00:35:32 And what did that certification require?
00:35:34 going through that post and graduating.
00:35:38 And look, guys, for all the conspiracy theorists, guys, in here, no problem, bro.
00:35:41 You guys can go ahead and, again, I love people that want to ask questions.
00:35:45 I'm just saying for the purposes of this, you know, episode, this stream,
00:35:49 I'm sticking to the official narrative because that's what they're talking about.
00:35:52 It's not going to do good if I start talking about Egyptian planes in here, dude.
00:35:55 It's just it's not going to make sense because this is not going to be really brought up
00:35:58 during this preliminary hearing.
00:35:59 so that's why i'm keeping it to the official narrative so you guys understand what's going
00:36:03 on here like i said before we can entertain the conspiracy theories after but for the purpose of
00:36:08 this preliminary hearing making sense for you guys i'm trying to keep it official narrative only
00:36:11 so don't confuse you guys academy all the credits that you get up with hours and then
00:36:17 physical fitness stuff to that effect and then graduating from that to earn the certificate
00:36:22 was there also testing involved there was at the academy yes okay um were you employed in september
00:36:29 of 2025? I was. And where were you employed then? Utah Valley Police Department. And how long did
00:36:36 you work for the Utah Valley University Police Department? Five years. Five years, okay.
00:36:45 And do you recall what your position or your rank was there? Senior officer there. Senior officer,
00:36:50 okay. Describe, if you would, just your general duties as a police officer at Utah Valley
00:36:57 university basically campus police chat campus police which blows being campus cop blows there
00:37:04 at utah valley university we patrol the campus if you want to chill you don't want to do anything
00:37:08 great job but if you want to actually like you know get your feet wet and make some cases happen
00:37:12 terrible walk around we patrol we would do investigations if there was crimes to that effect
00:37:17 we'd make sure that students or staff if they needed something we'd be there for them so
00:37:21 basic police kind of like a school resource officer community oriented policing okay was
00:37:27 this a full-time position it was okay um did you work in law enforcement prior to uvu i did and
00:37:34 where did you work i worked at utah valley or sorry utah county sheriff's office for 13 years
00:37:41 before that i worked with springville city police department for six years and also with the salt
00:37:47 lake county sheriff's office for a year oh bro's been everywhere what were your smash that like
00:37:52 one for me guys on YouTube you guys are watching on YouTube positions with those departments varies
00:37:58 I did canine I did SWAT I did motors I senior officer FTO officer detectives okay while you
00:38:11 were at Utah Valley University did you have access to the video surveillance system on campus yes I
00:38:17 did um and how so i was a it was at our desktop where our police station is uh we have desks and
00:38:25 on our desktops we'd have access to it there or we'd go into dispatch and they'd have okay i think
00:38:30 i know why they're making him the first witness but i'm gonna let it play a little bit more and
00:38:33 we'll discuss the wall full of camera systems that we could look at how familiar did you become with
00:38:39 that system uh very familiar uh can you describe how you became very familiar um like i said it
00:38:46 It was one of our daily routines that we'd go in there.
00:38:48 If we were looking for somebody or tracking something back,
00:38:50 we'd go in.
00:38:51 We'd go back to that time frame.
00:38:53 We could trace somebody to track somebody through campus.
00:38:58 I'd also turn around and make some maps
00:39:00 so it was easier for dispatch or somebody
00:39:02 to click on an area in the campuses,
00:39:03 where the buildings were, and be able to click a little bit
00:39:06 easier and get a faster response.
00:39:08 So made some maps and stuff like that.
00:39:10 And how often did you use this system?
00:39:12 Every day.
00:39:13 OK.
00:39:16 Did you become familiar with the campus at Utah Valley University when you were working there?
00:39:21 Yes.
00:39:21 And explain how you became familiar with it.
00:39:24 Like I said, we'd walk around.
00:39:26 I would train other officers.
00:39:27 We'd make sure that we knew all the ins and outs, the back doors.
00:39:31 We'd make sure we knew where every classroom was, where every entrance and exit was.
00:39:36 We'd secure the building.
00:39:38 And when you're patrolling the same campus over and over, like, dude, you know it like the back of your hand, you know?
00:39:43 Neighborhoods, we patrol around campus, and then we also have off-site campuses that we drive to and make sure that they're secure also.
00:39:51 Okay, you mentioned that you patrol the neighborhoods?
00:39:53 Yes.
00:39:53 Surrounding campus?
00:39:54 Yes.
00:39:55 What about the neighborhood to the north and east of campus?
00:39:58 Yes.
00:39:59 Okay.
00:40:01 What was your purpose for patrolling those neighborhoods as an officer for UVU?
00:40:05 One, it was right next to UVU, so we patrolled it.
00:40:08 Sometimes people would run up in that area or be walking up that way.
00:40:11 We'd have stolen bikes, stuff like that.
00:40:13 So we'd go into the areas, look for stuff.
00:40:15 Also, with Orem Police Department, we'd go back up them quite a bit for other calls and allow what would be in the area.
00:40:21 Okay, so back up just a little bit.
00:40:23 So Utah Valley University is located in what city?
00:40:26 Orem, Utah.
00:40:27 Orem, Utah.
00:40:27 Okay.
00:40:30 How familiar did you become with the buildings on campus?
00:40:34 Very familiar.
00:40:35 And the walkways?
00:40:36 Very familiar.
00:40:37 You mentioned the entrances and exits to the buildings?
00:40:40 Yes.
00:40:41 What about parking?
00:40:41 Okay, so based off the question that this prosecutor is asking, it's very clear that this guy more than likely probably has the best knowledge of the video surveillance system, the landscape of the campus, and he probably was on scene.
00:40:55 So prosecutors a lot of times when they're getting their witnesses for prelims or whatever, they want to get witnesses that are really good at one thing or very knowledgeable about something that's extremely pertinent to the case.
00:41:07 So in this case, obviously, we saw the surveillance footage, right?
00:41:10 we understand it's a college campus so they're bringing in the guy that's the most knowledgeable
00:41:14 this guy's a senior police officer he's worked for many different agencies i saw someone write hey
00:41:18 why do you work for so many departments so guys when you work for the state a lot of the times
00:41:22 you can easily just transfer from police department to police department probably pay
00:41:25 or you know disgruntled or whatever it may be so um but it's not uncommon for uh police officers
00:41:31 to leave departments to go to other ones for better opportunities structures yes um same answer
00:41:37 for that yes okay um and anytime i give commentary and stop it guys i'll just speed it back up so we
00:41:42 catch up to where we were before i got y'all ninjas man make sure i like the video you guys
00:41:47 are gonna get the best breakdown if you guys are watching on tiktok smash the the hard button you
00:41:51 guys are watching on youtube smash the like button and you guys came to the best channel by far to
00:41:55 break this thing down you got a former federal agent breaking this down with y'all ninjas so
00:41:58 smash the like video like button are you familiar with the courtyard or the outdoor amphitheater
00:42:04 amphitheater on campus i am and generally speaking where is that located on campus it's
00:42:09 more of the central it's an outdoor area centered by a bunch of buildings on the around it so it's
00:42:13 in the center of campus pretty much okay can you describe um what it looks like this courtyard this
00:42:18 amphitheater it's kind of like an amphitheater that's where charlie was shot guys so you got
00:42:22 some grass a couple steps that go up you've got some cement on top with some bushes and flowers
00:42:26 you've got places where people can sit and eat they come out and study and relax on the grass
00:42:29 and there's a waterfall with a little pond that comes down into a stream.
00:42:33 Okay.
00:42:35 Are you familiar with the surroundings, the buildings around the amphitheater?
00:42:38 Yes, I am.
00:42:39 Okay.
00:42:39 In relationship to this amphitheater, this courtyard,
00:42:42 where is the Hall of Flags located?
00:42:44 It would be directly west of the courtyard.
00:42:45 Okay.
00:42:46 Is it part of the courtyard or is it just off of the courtyard?
00:42:49 It's kind of the courtyard, like bus up right against the courtyard,
00:42:51 so it'll be the west side of the courtyard.
00:42:52 Okay, so to the west of the courtyard.
00:42:54 Is there a walkway across the Hall of Flags?
00:42:55 There is.
00:42:56 There's an inside one and an outside one.
00:42:57 Okay, so what is the Hall of Flags then?
00:42:58 The Hall of Flags is kind of like a bridge between two buildings that all the flags throughout the world are represented in there are some chairs where people sit down and relax with windows so you can see through all the way to the Utah Lake.
00:43:07 Okay. What are those two buildings that are connected by this Hall of Flags?
00:43:09 The Fugle Building over to the Science Building area.
00:43:12 Okay. So you mentioned the Fugle Building. Where is the Fugle Building located in relationship to this courtyard?
00:43:17 It's to the south of the courtyard.
00:43:19 Okay. Does it run up against the courtyard?
00:43:21 It does.
00:43:22 The building? Okay. What about the Woodbury Business Building? Where is that in relationship to the courtyard?
00:43:25 It's kind of southeast and it runs up right against the courtyard also.
00:43:27 okay and in relationship to the fugal building where's that sorenson or excuse me that so he's
00:43:31 making sure what he's doing what the prosecutor is doing here guys is he's establishing credibility
00:43:35 of this police officer of the witness that he's aware of all the most pertinent locations that
00:43:40 are involved in this murder in this murder you guys notice every single one of these places he's
00:43:45 naming are extremely pertinent and important uh during the course of this investigation so that's
00:43:50 why they brought him senior officer could testify knows the campus well understands the surveillance
00:43:55 footage so you're able to uh you know kill multiple birds with one stone with bringing
00:43:59 this guy in that's why he's the witness that business building the witness representing the
00:44:04 university more than likely so that's why he's asking all these questions all of these different
00:44:08 areas he's naming are going to be very important for the course uh for the trial in in the future
00:44:12 well it's going to be very important for the preliminary hearing excuse me the trial doesn't
00:44:16 start until the end of this year guys this is right directly east of the feudal okay um what
00:44:23 about the sorenson center where is that located with respect to this courtyard the sorenson center
00:44:27 is going to be kind of like a northeast uh of the courtyard okay does it again run up against
00:44:33 this courtyard yes it does okay and where is it in relationship to the business building
00:44:36 woodbury business building is just directly south of the sorenson directly south okay someone said 1.00
00:44:40 it looks like two idiots are agreeing with each other um no idiot uh it's because the prosecution 1.00
00:44:44 okay is direct examining his witness so he's gonna ask a lot of leading questions like that 1.00
00:44:50 because it's his witness come on bro like uh-oh retard alert man why do we got some slow people 0.90
00:44:59 in chat man um the low c center are you familiar with that building i am where is it located on 0.88
00:45:03 campus uh directly east of the courtyard theater area okay does it run up to the courtyard the
00:45:10 center no not really okay so i'm right up against it so the source of building is kind of like right
00:45:14 between the closer okay in relationship to the sorenson building what direction is the low c
00:45:17 building? East. East, okay. Are you familiar with the LDS Institute building on campus?
00:45:22 Yes, I am. Where is that located? That is going to be located north of the Loci
00:45:27 building and just kind of like northeast of the courtyard. Okay. And is there a
00:45:33 parking structure next to this Institute building? Yeah, there's there is. And where
00:45:37 is that? It's going to be, so you mentioned that Institute building is
00:45:40 going to be north of the Loci Center. There is a parking structure that has
00:45:43 several levels of parking. It's going to be directly west of the Institute
00:45:45 building and then they also have a parking structure not parking structure
00:45:48 parking lot to the north of that across the road okay with respect to that
00:45:52 parking structure can you describe for the court how one would enter this
00:45:55 parking structure driving and even walking how do you enter and exit that
00:45:58 structure so on the north end of the parking structure is campus drive you
00:46:02 can drive in and exit on the level one so that's a ground level that's where
00:46:04 you'd enter if you're driving in or exiting back out on campus then goes up
00:46:07 to level two and on level two exit it's what's called heat plant road in between
00:46:11 the institute building and the garage is a little road and there's an exit right
00:46:15 there they can drive out you can also if you're parking there you could walk out
00:46:19 right there that exit only where I was talking about on that south east side
00:46:22 you can walk out there or on the north end of that garage there are some stairs
00:46:26 that go up all the levels and it goes down to the bottom level and across the
00:46:29 street through a tunnel to the LDS Institute building and then when you pop
00:46:31 up on level two you can walk over to the Institute building okay can you
00:46:36 describe how long of a walk it would take from that parking structure to get
00:46:39 to the courtyard on campus approximately a couple of minutes because when you go
00:46:43 to that far southeast exit you can walk directly almost to the courtyard you can also walk along
00:46:49 the south end of the ldsn's to building up porcelain okay officer i'm going to turn your
00:46:54 attention to state's exhibit number one okay here we go first piece of evidence that they're gonna
00:46:58 present uh in the preliminary hearing uh guys again smash the like button if you're watching
00:47:02 on youtube uh smash that follow button on tiktok if you guys don't follow me i do true crime stuff
00:47:07 like this all the time i don't just make fun of women's okay we're the most diversified channel
00:47:13 by far we cover everything true crime politics wars conflicts we do it all should come up on
00:47:21 to be honest with you you know talking about women all day gets boring so i'd rather do stuff like
00:47:25 this let me know when you shout out to castle club clan you can see that i can see it just for
00:47:36 stuff let's go ahead and not publish it until it's admitted into evidence so we're going to
00:47:40 take it off the monitors but for the witness uh he should be able to see the exhibit
00:47:45 that's fine so thanks for sharing the live stream guys let's get as many people in here as we can
00:47:54 on tiktok man the table monitors witness but not the main monitor thank you all right mr grunetter
00:48:00 thank you thank you judge do you see that plaintiff's exhibit number one officer i do
00:48:03 And do you recognize that exhibit?
00:48:05 Yes, I do.
00:48:06 And what is that?
00:48:07 This is an area of the buildings plus the courtyard in the middle of all the grassy area.
00:48:11 So this is an area of the campus at Utah Valley University.
00:48:13 Is it a photograph?
00:48:14 Yes, sir.
00:48:15 Okay.
00:48:16 Are you familiar then with what's depicted in this photograph?
00:48:18 Yes, I am.
00:48:20 Does it fairly and accurately portray this area of campus?
00:48:24 Yes, it does.
00:48:25 Okay.
00:48:26 Can you tell the court what direction the camera is facing when this photograph was taken?
00:48:30 It's kind of facing north and a little to the east.
00:48:32 okay does it depict a number of the buildings that we've talked about today yes it does
00:48:38 for example um the hall of flags does it show the hall of flags yes it does the walkway of it
00:48:43 of the hall of flags um what about the sorenson center does it show that yes it does uh the
00:48:48 woodbury business building yes it does the fugal building yes and what about the losi center can
00:48:54 you see that from this photograph yes is this photograph a fair and accurate depiction of this
00:48:59 area of UVU campus on September 10th, 2025. Yes. You're on the state offers
00:49:03 states exhibit one. It is a little bit tricky because that microphone. Sorry
00:49:11 about that. Your Honor we would object to an ability to authenticate there's not
00:49:16 been a foundation laid that this officer took this photo can verify when it was
00:49:22 taken or by whom it was taken so we would object. Mr. Grunhander. Bruh. Oh
00:49:28 Oh, man.
00:49:29 Would you like us to argue now or approach the bench?
00:49:31 Well, as it relates to this, I'll hear argument.
00:49:33 Okay.
00:49:34 Judge, first of all, it's very clear, well-established law that the person who took the photograph is not required to be present to lay the foundation for it.
00:49:41 What's required for foundation is that the witness has knowledge of what's depicted in the photograph and can testify to it.
00:49:48 There's Tyler Robinson right there.
00:49:50 It's accuracy, and that's exactly what this officer has done.
00:49:53 We laid an ample amount of foundation about this area of campus.
00:49:56 he's confirmed that yeah the defense is not messing around chat the defense isn't messing
00:50:01 around the fact that she came in with that objection right away there there there uh
00:50:06 there's a reason why they requested this preliminary hearing and they didn't waive it
00:50:10 it depicts this area of campus that was previously described he confirmed the buildings that he can
00:50:15 see there he also confirmed that it was this is not a trial chat this is a preliminary hearing
00:50:20 to establish probable cause that's it accurate depiction of his onset yeah tyler robinson is
00:50:25 balding you guys notice that he has way less hair bro must be stressed september 10th 2025
00:50:31 thank you any further argument ms nesser we did file a um standing objection at the very beginning
00:50:40 of the hearing i would just refer to our standing objection as well um i know this is not a there's
00:50:45 no written testimony in this but just out of an abundance of caution i want to um also refer to
00:50:49 our standing objection thank you translation let me just throw it and see if it sticks let's see
00:50:53 what happens doesn't hurt to object and try right that's good all right having considered the
00:50:57 arguments i find i'm going to overrule the objection and admit exhibit one
00:51:01 and this was worth a shot it was worth a shot this has first-hand knowledge of the location
00:51:09 as well as the building locations that foundation has been laid he also stated it was a fair and
00:51:14 accurate representation of what's being depicted here and for those reasons the defense objection
00:51:18 is overruled. States Exhibit 1 is admitted into evidence and may be published
00:51:22 to the courtroom.
00:51:24 So the state would move to publish that to the courtroom?
00:51:30 It is so granted.
00:51:35 Officer Bagley, are you able to see the monitor that's
00:51:38 here in the court that's pointed towards the gallery?
00:51:41 Yes.
00:51:44 From where you're seated, are you comfortable in describing where the courtyard is
00:51:47 on that photograph on that exhibit yes and for the record where is that located so all the grass
00:51:52 that looks like a triangle uh the amphitheater look that is going to be the courtyard amphitheater
00:51:56 area uh it's got the tent in it the white tent that's at the bottom on the far left of the picture
00:52:02 that would be the courtyard area yeah thanks for sharing the live guys that's surrounded by
00:52:05 buildings more of the grass area i'm going to approach the phone well i'm just going to when
00:52:10 you look at this this exhibit to the left of the photograph um there's a walkway there what is that
00:52:15 walkway so the red brick walkway that's going north to the top of the picture on
00:52:19 the far left is going to be the Hall of Flags the outside top of it okay on the
00:52:23 bottom of this photograph there's a white roofed building it's the largest
00:52:28 building at least as far as what's depicted on this exhibit what building
00:52:30 is that that would be the Fugle building okay and just to the right of that so
00:52:35 that would be to the east of the Fugle building what building is that the other
00:52:38 red brick pathway area that is the Woodbury business building okay and if I
00:52:43 were to walk north so left on this photograph with respect to that red
00:52:48 brick walkway area there's another building sort of triangular in shape the
00:52:52 the rooftop what building is that with that white rooftop that would be the
00:52:55 Sorenson building that's the Sorenson building and what about the low-sea
00:52:58 building you've described that where's that located on this photograph if you
00:53:01 go to that triangle white roof if you go directly to the right so the right side
00:53:04 of the picture that is going to be the low-sea building it's got several levels
00:53:07 is it to the right and up a little bit as well okay and that would be east on
00:53:12 this photograph it's got the gravel rooftop gravel rooftop okay um i referred you to the
00:53:18 lds institute building are you able to see that in this photograph yes you are and where is that
00:53:22 located that's going to just be directly north of the low sea building it's going to be that other
00:53:25 white roof building on the far top of the picture okay thank you officer we can take that down your
00:53:32 honor as far as the publication officer bagley i'm going to take you back to the date of september 10
00:53:38 2025 okay so they've established that he has an expertise on the campus he knows where all the
00:53:42 buildings are he's aware and competent of uh where different pieces of evidence were uh found laid
00:53:49 that foundation now he's going to start asking about the events of the shooting do you recall
00:53:54 that day generally i do uh were you working that day yes i was at uvu i was yes okay um do you
00:54:01 remember what time your shift started approximately yes it probably started about 11 o'clock in the
00:54:06 morning okay did you receive a specific assignment shortly after coming on to duty yes i did and
00:54:12 what was that assignment we it was to secure the top of the hall of flags on the south end
00:54:17 so we had people that were gathering on top of that that were looking down on top of the tent
00:54:21 so we wanted to secure that area so i was put up on top of the hall of flags on the south end okay
00:54:24 my apologies your honor can we have exhibit one published again go ahead and republish stage
00:54:29 exhibit one guys smash that light button for me man if you guys especially you guys that are
00:54:34 watching on youtube smash that light bun thank you you mentioned that you were securing the
00:54:39 south end of the walkway on top of the hall of flags yes and so where do we find that in this
00:54:43 exhibit officer so if you can see the tent the white tent there's that rooftop where the red
00:54:47 brick is i was on top of that there's some actually looks like yellow crime scene tape
00:54:50 that was some of our barrier that we put up so people wouldn't go above that and walk so i was
00:54:53 sitting right by those flower plots plants that were by the people on the south end so is the
00:54:57 south end on the bottom of this photograph yes where that walkway kind of begins from the bottom
00:55:00 Yes. And you've referred to a tent. Is that the white object we see inside the courtyard?
00:55:06 Yeah, that's where a white object with the tent. Okay, thank you. So you were securing that area?
00:55:10 Yes.
00:55:14 Did you have the opportunity that morning, you mentioned you checked on about 11 o'clock,
00:55:17 that morning and later to walk around campus that day?
00:55:21 Yes. Did you walk along the Hall of Flags that day?
00:55:24 I did. That walkway?
00:55:25 Yes. Did you visit the courtyard that day as well?
00:55:27 Down below, yes, on the south end.
00:55:28 I was telling it.
00:55:33 Let's see.
00:55:35 Officer, I'm going to turn your attention to States Exhibit
00:55:37 number 2.
00:55:40 And that should come up on your monitor there.
00:55:44 Let me know when you see that, if you would.
00:55:47 Your Honor, if we could maybe not have it on the lectern screen,
00:55:50 we're getting reports that the documents shown on the lectern screen are being
00:55:53 live streamed.
00:55:55 So maybe if we could just not show that one until it's admitted.
00:55:58 I'll send it to the court judge.
00:56:02 I've got copies of these for myself that I can refer to as I'm asking questions.
00:56:06 All right.
00:56:07 Well, I'll go ahead and grant the request by Ms. Nestor.
00:56:09 We'll go ahead and pour.
00:56:12 There should be a power button to turn it off.
00:56:17 Thank you, John.
00:56:20 And if at any point, Mr. Gernander, you do need to use a monitor.
00:56:28 revisit that and obviously Ms. Nestor you can renew your objection to need speed but
00:56:31 for now the monitors turn off. Let's go ahead and proceed. Thank you. Officer do
00:56:34 you see State's exhibit number two on your monitor? Yes I do. And do you recognize
00:56:37 that? I do. And what is that? This is a picture of the from the east side looking
00:56:42 west of the campus. Okay. Are you familiar with what's depicted in this
00:56:46 photograph? Yes I am. Okay and does it show for example the Loci Center that
00:56:51 we've talked about? Yes it does. Does it depict the Woodbury business building
00:56:55 that we've talked about? Yes. What about the Fugle Building? Yes. Does it show the Sorensen
00:56:59 Center? Yes. And also the Hall of Flags? Yes. In this particular exhibit, can you also see the
00:57:04 courtyard? I can. A partial of it. A partial of it? Okay. Does it fairly and accurately depict
00:57:10 this area of campus of UVU on September 10th, 2025? Yes. Okay. Your Honor of State offers
00:57:15 State's Exhibit No. 2. Your Honor, we renew our standing objection. We also argue that a
00:57:20 foundation hasn't been laid in terms of the time this was taken or who took it. Hey, she might as
00:57:24 well try maybe she might as well try baby it is you know um and at what point in time this was
00:57:31 um created in house i don't think he has any personal knowledge of that we'd object
00:57:34 same arguments judge he has testified that he's familiar with it he has personal familiarity with
00:57:38 it he's testified that it's fair and accurate um as of the day of september 10th 2025 and that's
00:57:42 what was asked of him all right i will go ahead and overrule the objection by defense
00:57:45 hey it's worth a shot right uh noting that the witness has played uh well he's expressed uh
00:57:52 This is a fair and accurate representation of what it purports to be and he's familiar with it. He was there on the day
00:57:57 On September 10th, and because that foundation has been laid state's exhibit two is admitted and may be published
00:58:03 Thank you judge state moves to publish exhibit two all right
00:58:07 Officer, I'm gonna direct your attention to this exhibit on the monitor facing the gallery of the court today
00:58:14 Can you describe there's a large building in the middle of that photograph slightly above the middle
00:58:19 but what building are we looking at there?
00:58:20 You're looking at the rooftop of the Loci building.
00:58:22 It's got two different grays, like a lighter gray and a darker gray.
00:58:25 Are you familiar with that rooftop then?
00:58:26 Yes, I am.
00:58:26 And what's it made of?
00:58:27 It's made of gravel.
00:58:28 Gravel, okay.
00:58:29 You mentioned two different grades, or did you say graze?
00:58:30 Graze.
00:58:31 Graze, okay.
00:58:33 Now, you described that you could see the courtyard,
00:58:36 but it wasn't easily visible in this photograph.
00:58:38 Where is the courtyard located on the state's exhibit number two?
00:58:40 So you've got the white roof that's going to be in the middle,
00:58:42 just to the top of the building where the Loci is.
00:58:44 I described there's a white roof there.
00:58:45 That's the Sorensen building.
00:58:46 And it's just below that you can see some grass,
00:58:47 and that's where the courtyard is, just to the left of that white roof.
00:58:51 I'm going to ask if the witness could actually come down from the stand
00:58:53 and point out where the courtyard is located in this exhibit for the court's benefit.
00:58:58 All right, do we have a second microphone so it picks up his voice?
00:59:04 Okay, Ms. Nestor, thank you for allowing us.
00:59:06 Officer, you may step down, approach the monitor,
00:59:09 and I would ask that you speak into the microphone when responding to a question.
00:59:16 Okay, can you hear me?
00:59:17 I can. Thank you.
00:59:19 So, officer, for our benefit, would you describe again where the Lossie Center is in this photograph?
00:59:23 The Lossie Center is going to be this one with the gray roofs. It's got two different colors of gray.
00:59:26 Two different colors of gray. Okay.
00:59:28 I'm blind. I can't see those two different colors from here.
00:59:32 Can you describe where the court... It looks like we went blank.
00:59:37 There we go.
00:59:38 Can you point to where the courtyard is located on that exhibit?
00:59:40 The courtyard is going to be here where this grass is in this area right here.
00:59:43 Okay. And what about the Fugle Building?
00:59:46 Fugle Building is going to be this building right here.
00:59:47 and the woodbury business building then woodbury is going to be this one right here with this
00:59:51 red brick and the sorenson center sorenson center is going to be this white roof one that's right
00:59:55 here okay now on this exhibit can you see the lds institute building and the parking structure
00:59:59 ninjas i got the map for you guys right here this is it this is the losi center uh where'd it go
01:00:05 this is it right here and this is the one that i showed you guys on the surveillance footage by
01:00:11 the way so this is it right here is what it looks like just so you guys have an idea this is where
01:00:17 i'm assuming this is where the shot came from more than likely because this looks exactly um
01:00:21 yeah yeah is where the shot came from talked about no not really you got the back side of
01:00:26 the institute building which is right here and i'll see if i get you guys a better image
01:00:29 structures over there okay mr grenander let me stop you just for the benefit of the record
01:00:33 because the record is picking up the audio when you're pointing it to and i know it may be a
01:00:37 little bit laborious to do this but as you're identifying indicate the general location on it
01:00:41 the left side right side middle uh upper lower just so the record knows to some degree where
01:00:46 you're pointing in that way because the video isn't being captured so if you
01:00:50 would do that it just creates a more complete record thank you understood
01:00:53 that's fair thank you judge so again let's point to the courtyard and if
01:00:58 you'll describe as best you can where that is located on the photograph on
01:01:02 this photograph the courtyard is going to be this grass area that's gonna be to
01:01:05 the towards the top of the pitcher the baseball field is behind it it's closer
01:01:08 to the surrounded buildings there's some grass in there that would be the
01:01:10 courtyard area okay we've talked about the Hall of Flags and the walkway above
01:01:14 that hall. Where is that located on this photograph? The hall flag is going to be right by the courtyard
01:01:18 just to the west side. There's a red brick towards the top of the picture. There's a red brick pathway
01:01:21 that goes from the Fugle Building, which is on the left of the picture, towards the right of the picture, which is the Science Building area.
01:01:26 Okay, and then the Sorensen Center, is that the building in the middle
01:01:30 with the large white roof? Yeah, it's going to be kind of towards the upper part
01:01:34 of the picture, middle of it. It's going to be a white roof. That will be the Sorensen Center.
01:01:38 Just to the north and east of the courtyard? Yes, north and east. Okay, and then finally,
01:01:41 If you would describe the low-sea building the location of that on this exhibit
01:01:44 The low-sea building could be pretty much in the middle on the right side
01:01:47 So the middle to the right I was gonna have two different colors of gray a darker gray and the lighter gray
01:01:52 There's a red pathway and that will be the low-sea center, okay?
01:01:55 You mentioned officers right here. There were different stories on the low-sea right here
01:01:59 How many stories to the low-sea building? I'm sorry there's four four stories
01:02:02 Okay, you mentioned that you were familiar with the rooftop. Do you know how to gain access to the rooftop of the low-sea building?
01:02:07 Yes, there's actually an outside stairway right here that comes up.
01:02:12 It's going to be just to the south of Losi building.
01:02:14 There's a red pathway right directly in the middle of the picture.
01:02:16 Off to the south of that on the left side of the picture is an outdoor staircase and stairway.
01:02:20 Is that open to the public?
01:02:21 It is.
01:02:22 And how would someone access the roof from that stairway?
01:02:26 They came up, they put them right here on this pathway that goes between the Losi Center
01:02:29 and down towards the computer science building.
01:02:31 There's a red pathway.
01:02:32 There's actually a little handrail, like a little guardrail, probably about a couple feet high
01:02:35 that somebody could jump over.
01:02:39 Is that area restricted?
01:02:41 Is it off limits?
01:02:41 Yes, it is.
01:02:42 There's kind of like a natural barrier with the guardrail.
01:02:44 And from there on, there's no path.
01:02:46 It's gravel roof, so it's not paved like everything else.
01:02:49 Someone could hop over that railway?
01:02:51 Yes.
01:02:51 Okay.
01:02:52 Thank you, officer.
01:02:53 You can take your seat again.
01:02:54 Thank you.
01:03:05 Officer Bagley, I'm now going to refer you to your attention to State's Exhibit No. 3.
01:03:12 That's going to come up on your monitor as well.
01:03:16 Let me know when you see that.
01:03:26 Yes, I do see it.
01:03:28 Okay.
01:03:29 And do you recognize that?
01:03:31 I do.
01:03:32 And what is that?
01:03:34 This is a drone picture of the campus, more of the courtyard looking eastward.
01:03:40 Okay.
01:03:41 I've asked you about several buildings on campus.
01:03:44 I'm going to ask you about those same buildings, whether they're depicted in this exhibit, okay?
01:03:49 Do you see where the Hall of Flags is located?
01:03:51 Yes, I do.
01:03:52 It's down towards the bottom.
01:03:53 It's a red brick pathway.
01:03:54 It would be the Hall of Flags.
01:03:55 Okay.
01:03:55 What about the Fugle building?
01:03:57 Fugle building is going to be to the right of the picture.
01:03:59 It's going to be a white roof building off to the right, directly south of the courtyard.
01:04:03 And the Woodbury Business Building?
01:04:06 Woodbury is going to be another red path that's going to be just to the east of the Fugle Building.
01:04:13 It's got a gray roof and some red paths.
01:04:15 The Sorensen Center?
01:04:17 Sorensen Center is going to be on the left of the picture.
01:04:20 It's going to have a white roof, different levels, and that would be the Sorensen Center.
01:04:25 Okay.
01:04:25 Sorry, guys.
01:04:26 Yeah, it is live.
01:04:26 Don't worry.
01:04:27 I didn't say anything.
01:04:27 It is live.
01:04:29 The Losi Center, where is that located in relationship to the Sorensen Center that you've described?
01:04:33 of the Sorensen Center, it's going to be just directly east of the Sorensen Center towards the top of the picture.
01:04:40 You can see the two different colors of grave, the gravel that's on the roof.
01:04:44 Okay. And can you see the courtyard in this photograph?
01:04:47 Yes, you can.
01:04:48 Okay.
01:04:52 Is this picture a fair and accurate depiction of this area, Utah Valley University's campus, on September 10, 2025?
01:05:01 Yes.
01:05:04 State offers Exhibit 3, Your Honor.
01:05:08 Honor, we renew the standing objection.
01:05:10 We also object, again, that this individual can't identify when the...
01:05:16 Sorry, guys, that's her mic just being super loud.
01:05:19 ...picture was made or how it was made or by whom.
01:05:25 Mr. Lee.
01:05:26 Same response, Judge.
01:05:28 And just for the record, I would also point the court to State v. Purcell, which is a Supreme Court case here in the state of Utah, 1985,
01:05:38 which essentially stands for the proposition that if a competent witness with personal knowledge of the facts represented in a photograph
01:05:47 can testify that that photograph accurately represents those facts, the exhibit's admissible.
01:05:55 He's also spoke about the date being September 10th, 2025.
01:05:59 The showing that's required here is essentially a prima facie showing.
01:06:03 We're not required to show proof beyond a reasonable doubt, for example, that it was accurate that day or even a preponderance of the evidence.
01:06:10 But we'll submit it on that, Judge.
01:06:12 All right.
01:06:13 I'm just taking a brief glance at the case you cited.
01:06:19 I can give the citation if your honor would like.
01:06:21 If you have that, I'd appreciate that.
01:06:23 It's 7-1-1, Pacific Second, 243.
01:06:30 And I'm looking at page number 245.
01:06:43 All right.
01:06:44 the court finds that the witness is familiar with the scene he testified that it is a fair
01:06:58 and accurate representation of what state's exhibit three purports to be and the court finds
01:07:05 a necessary foundation has been laid and overrules the objection states exhibit three
01:07:13 may be admitted, is admitted, and may be published.
01:07:16 State would move to publish State's Exhibit 3.
01:07:19 All right.
01:07:28 May I approach the witness, Your Honor?
01:07:29 You may.
01:07:31 Okay, do they have something else?
01:07:38 Officer, if you would come down into the well of the court,
01:07:40 I'm going to ask you a few questions about this.
01:07:43 this Exhibit 3 as well.
01:07:45 Okay.
01:07:47 Can you point out where the Hall of Flags is located and describe that for the record?
01:07:53 The Hall of Flags is going to be down here on the bottom of the picture.
01:07:56 It's going to have a red brick pathway with some flowers along the top of it.
01:07:59 You mentioned that you were securing an area of that?
01:08:02 Yes.
01:08:03 That walkway, where were you stationed?
01:08:06 I was down here by the end of the flower pots, which is down here on the south side towards the Fugle building on the far right of the picture.
01:08:12 of the picture okay um in relationship to where you were stationed where is the uh hey guys smash
01:08:17 that like button we got 584 lights we got 1500 you guys in here man let's get to 1000 or i'm
01:08:21 gonna get off youtube smash the like button i'm just gonna get off youtube bro google building
01:08:27 then the fugal building is just to the right of me so it would be on the south end of me okay
01:08:35 and so it's on the right side of the photograph there far right side of the photograph what about
01:08:39 the business building? The business building is just going to be in the middle of the picture
01:08:44 on the far right. It's going to have some red brick pathways. It's going to be multi-level
01:08:48 and that will be the Woodbury building. Okay. The Sorensen Center, where is that located
01:08:53 on the photograph? Sorensen Center is going to be middle to far left of the picture. It's
01:08:58 going to have a white roof on top of it, multi-level. Okay. And the Losey Center, where is that
01:09:02 located? Losey Center is going to be towards the top of the picture, kind of off-centered
01:09:08 it a little bit but it's gonna have the four or five floors that are the four floors that are
01:09:13 sitting right there okay um can you describe those stories what we're looking someone said
01:09:20 it's about time on but on tiktok bro i was banned off tiktok for like six years bro literally banned
01:09:25 i didn't control a tiktok account since 2020 dude just got back on here like a month ago
01:09:30 literally just got on a month ago it's been 30 days where do you find one two three four and
01:09:35 possibly five. So this is ground level where the courtyard is so this as you go over in towards
01:09:42 the low sea building inside there's an elevator that'd be ground one level one. Level two would
01:09:47 be the second one where these red ATVs are sitting on the grass right there in the middle of the
01:09:52 picture. If you go from that that would be the third level and your fourth level which is the
01:09:58 actual top level of the building is that very top one with the windows that you can see.
01:10:02 okay is there an atrium on the top of that there is an atrium it's actually it's got a little
01:10:08 sphere on the top of it it looks like a little square right on top of the low sea building that
01:10:13 would be an atrium now you mentioned two shades of gray on the rooftop of the low sea building
01:10:17 yes can you see that on this exhibit i can so where the atrium is is a lighter gray gravel
01:10:23 and on the west side um because i'm looking east on the west side there's two uh ventilations for
01:10:31 the Loci building, two vents on top of that, it's in the darker gray.
01:10:35 Okay. You mentioned you're familiar with the rooftop of the Loci Center,
01:10:40 correct? Yes. When someone is standing on the Loci Center,
01:10:43 can they see down into the courtyard? Yes, they can. And where is the
01:10:47 courtyard located? It's going to be in the center of the picture with the grass
01:10:51 and the atrium style steps. Would that be
01:10:54 west of the Loci Center then? Yes, it would be directly west of the Loci Center.
01:10:59 Okay. Now, in a couple of the other exhibits, we saw a tent that was down, set up in the courtyard.
01:11:06 Can you see that tent set up in the courtyard in this photograph?
01:11:09 You cannot. In this picture, you can't.
01:11:11 It would be where I explained where the hall of flags is.
01:11:14 It's directly underneath the hall of flags, like just on the grass right there.
01:11:18 Okay. Can someone, is there a clear line of sight between the tent and the top of the LOSI Center, the rooftop?
01:11:24 Yes, there is.
01:11:25 Okay. Is some of it obstructed?
01:11:28 Yes.
01:11:29 Obstructed by what?
01:11:30 The Sorenson Building that's right here, this white roof that's going to be,
01:11:34 this kind of obstructs a little bit of the view of the courtyard.
01:11:37 So where would you have to be standing or perhaps lying down on the Losey Center
01:11:41 to see into the courtyard where that tent was?
01:11:44 On the far south side of the Losey Building, you could have a line of sight towards the courtyard.
01:11:50 And that's the top roof?
01:11:51 The top roof, yes.
01:11:52 With a darker shade of gray?
01:11:53 Yes.
01:11:53 Okay, thank you, officer.
01:11:58 I am going to refer the witness now
01:12:13 to Stace Exhibit No. 35.
01:12:16 Be right back, ninjas.
01:12:18 And Officer Bagley, when you see that,
01:12:20 go ahead and let me know.
01:12:28 Do you recognize what that is, officer?
01:12:35 I don't have it yet.
01:12:37 Oh, okay.
01:12:45 So we don't have this in electronic form?
01:12:47 We do?
01:12:48 Okay.
01:12:51 Well, I'll refer you to the exhibit that's to your left and behind you.
01:12:58 do you see that I do and it's marked a state's exhibit 35 with a yellow
01:13:04 sticker is that correct yes I can see that on top left of the photo well for
01:13:10 the record if we can publish that on the witnesses screen thank you mr.
01:13:17 Grudenander I was just going to mention that we shouldn't display it until it's
01:13:20 been admitted in so
01:13:28 Do you see State's Exhibit 35 in your monitor?
01:13:34 Yes, I do.
01:13:35 Okay, can you, do you recognize that?
01:13:37 Yes, I do.
01:13:38 And what is that?
01:13:39 This is an aerial view of the campus and the northeast area,
01:13:43 just north of the campus neighborhoods of Utah Valley University in Orem.
01:13:47 Okay.
01:13:48 Okay. And how can you personally tell that this is a photograph of the campus and the neighborhood to the northeast of campus?
01:14:01 I can tell because I recognize all the buildings, the roads that are around it, the streets, the roundabouts, the neighborhood to the north or towards the top of the building or picture also.
01:14:12 Now, I've asked you about several buildings and landmarks on campus.
01:14:17 Are you able to see the courtyard on this exhibit?
01:14:21 Yes, you are.
01:14:23 And just for the record, can you describe where this is located on the exhibit?
01:14:28 So right in the center towards the bottom, there's a white triangle roof.
01:14:33 That's white. That would be the Sorenson Building.
01:14:35 It's the patch of grass that's just directly south of towards the bottom of that on the picture.
01:14:41 So it's kind of centered, but more towards the bottom, right in the middle.
01:14:46 On this exhibit, are you able to see the Fugle Building?
01:14:49 Yes, I am.
01:14:50 And in relationship to this courtyard, where is that located?
01:14:53 That's going to be south of the courtyard with the white roof.
01:14:58 What about the Woodbury Business Building?
01:15:00 Woodbury Business Building is going to be to the east, and it's going to have a red brick path top.
01:15:08 Okay.
01:15:11 Can you see the Hall of Flags on this?
01:15:13 Yes, you can.
01:15:15 And where is that located in relationship to the courtyard again?
01:15:18 I'm going to pull up where this Hall of Flags is because they keep mentioning it.
01:15:22 So give me one sec, chat.
01:15:24 It's directly west of the courtyard.
01:15:27 And the Losey Center. Can you see the Losey Center?
01:15:29 Yes, you can see the Losey Center.
01:15:30 Where is that at?
01:15:31 It's going to be kind of northeast of the courtyard.
01:15:35 The two patches of gray that's almost in the center of the picture,
01:15:39 just to the slight right of the center.
01:15:42 Okay.
01:15:43 I've asked you previously about the LDS Institute building.
01:15:46 Can you see that on this exhibit?
01:15:48 Yes, you can.
01:15:49 And where is that located in relationship to the LOSI Center?
01:15:52 It's directly north of the LOSI Center.
01:15:54 It's got a white roof, and it's almost directly in the center of the photo.
01:15:57 Okay.
01:15:58 And we've talked about a parking structure that's nearby the Institute building.
01:16:03 Do you see that?
01:16:03 Yes, it's just to the west or left side of the picture of the Institute building.
01:16:09 is this a
01:16:12 so this looks like
01:16:13 this is where it is
01:16:16 okay
01:16:16 I remember that people like you
01:16:20 were able to see like I think
01:16:21 you could see maybe the shooting from here
01:16:23 this one over
01:16:25 there are all the flags and countries
01:16:28 represented by the United Nations
01:16:29 but at all there's a scholarship to finance for criminal justice
01:16:32 and police
01:16:32 okay
01:16:39 Yeah, because you had a vantage point, okay, I see why, why they're using that, why they're
01:16:49 talking about it.
01:16:51 Was this thing silent?
01:17:00 Okay, let's go back.
01:17:04 and accurate depiction of Utah Valley University's campus and the surrounding neighborhood to the
01:17:11 north and east on September 10th, 2025? Yes. State offers State's Exhibit 35. Your Honor, we need a
01:17:17 standing objection and object on the grounds that there's no indication on this photograph of when
01:17:21 it was taken in terms of relation to the actual incident at issue here. Thank you, Ms. Nester.
01:17:26 Mr. Gernetto. Same response, Judge, but I would just add one more case for the court's benefit.
01:17:30 This is State v. Wager, or WAGER, W-A-G-E-R.
01:17:33 This is a Utah Court of Appeals case from 2016.
01:17:36 The citation is 372 Pacific 3rd, 91.
01:17:41 And the significance of this case, Your Honor, at issue there was a photograph of the defendant there
01:17:45 who was smoking methamphetamine, allegedly, in his bathroom.
01:17:48 The witness that was testifying laying the foundation at trial was not present when the photograph was taken.
01:17:54 Could not tell the date on which it was taken, but he had been in the bathroom before,
01:17:58 was familiar with the defendant's bathroom, and familiar with the defendant.
01:18:00 He testified to that personal knowledge, and the court found that was sufficient foundation.
01:18:03 So that case, in addition to the other case, the Purcell case, and my previous arguments,
01:18:06 and I'll submit it to the court.
01:18:08 Ms. Nestor, anything else you wish to add?
01:18:09 Hey, guys.
01:18:10 All right.
01:18:11 Yeah, she's going to object to everything, guys. 1.00
01:18:13 I couldn't tell what type of defense attorney she is. 0.99
01:18:15 She's going to object to everything. 0.99
01:18:16 I mean, look, she's trying to defend her client.
01:18:18 Given the testimony of the witness who's testified he's familiar with this location,
01:18:21 he went in detail describing the various neighborhoods and location.
01:18:24 He mentioned the roundabout and identified the buildings in State's Exhibit 35.
01:18:28 and it was noted that it is a fair and accurate representation of this campus as of September 10th, 2025.
01:18:36 The court is going to overrule the objection, and State's Exhibit 35 is admitted into evidence and may be published.
01:18:42 Thank you, Judge. The state moves to publish it, and if granted, may I approach the exhibit?
01:18:46 You may.
01:18:54 Okay, now we've got the map.
01:18:58 Officer, I've asked you about a number of the buildings located on campus.
01:19:01 I'm just going to ask you a couple of questions about those and to help orient the court to
01:19:04 what the judge is looking at and then ask you about some of the streets in the neighborhood,
01:19:07 okay?
01:19:08 Okay.
01:19:09 For the court's benefit, can you point out where the LDS Institute building is?
01:19:12 Yes, I can.
01:19:13 And I'm going to approach the witness again if you could describe where it's out on that
01:19:16 Exhibit 35.
01:19:17 Okay.
01:19:18 Okay, can you hear me?
01:19:22 Yes.
01:19:23 So you want the LDS Institute building?
01:19:24 Yes, please.
01:19:25 That is this white roof right here is the Institute building.
01:19:27 that in basically the center of the exhibit? That's almost exactly in the
01:19:30 center of the exhibit. Okay and where is the Loci Center located on that? If you
01:19:34 were to go down towards the bottom of the photo there's two different grades of
01:19:36 gravel on this roof this would be the Loci building right here. So below the
01:19:39 Institute building and to the right slightly. Can you point out for the
01:19:42 court's benefit where the courtyard is? The courtyard is going to be to the west or
01:19:46 left side of the picture. There's some grass in between two buildings. I have a
01:19:48 white roofs. There would be a grass area right there with some steps. That is
01:19:52 going to be the courtyard area and that's going to be down towards the center or
01:19:54 bottom of the photo. So that's to the left and down? Yes. Okay you mentioned
01:19:57 Where's the parking structure next to the institute building?
01:20:00 The institute building is right here in the center with the white roof.
01:20:02 The parking structure is going to be just to the left of the institute or west side.
01:20:05 There's a road in between it called the heat plant road, which is the road that goes between those two.
01:20:09 And can you point out, for the court's benefit, how one would enter that or exit that parking structure by way of vehicle or walking?
01:20:15 By entering, you can enter an exit right here on the north side of the parking structure.
01:20:19 There's an entrance and exit right here.
01:20:20 That's the level one.
01:20:21 And that's where we saw him running towards, guys, when you ran away.
01:20:24 For vehicles.
01:20:25 And I guess someone could walk in there as well.
01:20:26 Yes, if they were to park into this LDS Institute parking lot over here on the north side of that,
01:20:33 there's a tunnel that goes underneath the road that still comes out into the parking structure itself.
01:20:39 And then they can exit out here on the second level onto Heat Plant Road,
01:20:44 which is that road between the LDS Institute building and the parking structure is the heat plant.
01:20:49 They can exit there and go back towards Campus Drive.
01:20:53 So you could walk out either up here on the northeast side of the parking structure
01:20:58 and cross over to the LDS Institute, or you can come out here to the southeast side,
01:21:03 and you can exit there and walk down to the courtyard
01:21:05 or behind the LDS Institute building towards the Lossie Center.
01:21:09 Okay, thank you.
01:21:10 You mentioned Campus Drive.
01:21:12 Where is Campus Drive located on that?
01:21:15 Campus Drive starts right up here towards the top left of the picture.
01:21:18 It's almost like a T.
01:21:19 It's the curved road that comes all the way down in front of the Institute building and the parking structure.
01:21:25 And it goes all the way around campus, comes back down to the bottom of the picture where the roundabout is, and that would be Campus Drive.
01:21:32 Okay.
01:21:32 Are you familiar with where 800 South is in Orem?
01:21:36 Yes.
01:21:36 Is that depicted on this exhibit?
01:21:38 It is.
01:21:39 Where is that at?
01:21:40 It's at the top of this photo.
01:21:41 It's going to be the long straight road.
01:21:43 That's right here at the top of the photo.
01:21:44 Okay.
01:21:46 What about 850 South?
01:21:48 Are you familiar with that street?
01:21:50 I am.
01:21:50 850 South is going to be towards the right of the photo, top right of it.
01:21:56 There's going to be a street that goes east to west.
01:21:58 It looks like a horseshoe, kind of.
01:22:01 It's going to be the road that goes east to west, and in the middle of that horseshoe, it'll be 850.
01:22:05 Okay, so 850 is parallel to 800 South.
01:22:08 Yes.
01:22:09 And just below on this photograph.
01:22:11 Yes.
01:22:12 Okay.
01:22:13 Are you familiar with 600 West?
01:22:15 I am.
01:22:15 And where's that street in relationship to 850 South?
01:22:19 That would be on the far right side of the horseshoe,
01:22:21 so towards the right side of the picture,
01:22:23 and it's going to be the right side of that horseshoe.
01:22:26 And that runs north and south?
01:22:28 North and south.
01:22:29 Okay.
01:22:30 What about 720 West?
01:22:32 Are you familiar with that street?
01:22:33 Yes, I am.
01:22:34 And where's that at?
01:22:34 That's going to be to the left side of the horseshoe.
01:22:36 That runs north and south.
01:22:39 And, guys, Erica Kirk is there, and I saw Tatum there too.
01:22:44 Talmud Tatum is there.
01:22:45 Okay.
01:22:46 So I wouldn't be surprised if there aren't either.
01:22:51 Who did I see?
01:22:52 I think Jack Posobiec is there too.
01:22:55 So there's a lot of people over there, guys.
01:22:58 Guys, smash that like button.
01:23:00 Y'all got five more minutes, bro.
01:23:02 And when I hit 1,000 likes in the next five minutes, I'm going to get off YouTube.
01:23:05 We're sitting at 780.
01:23:07 1,000 ninjas or else I'm out of here.
01:23:08 And it comes down towards the bottom.
01:23:11 Okay.
01:23:12 And finally, 925 South.
01:23:14 925 south is going to be on the bottom of the horseshoe that connects those other two west.
01:23:21 Okay, so just in summary, will you describe the horseshoe and what streets amount make up that horseshoe?
01:23:29 So the horseshoe comes up off of 800 south, and directly south of that, you'll have 850 south, which is going to be running east to west.
01:23:38 On the left side is 725 West of the Horseshoe, and it comes down into 925 South,
01:23:44 which wraps back around to 600 West on the far right side of the Horseshoe, on the right side of the picture.
01:23:51 Okay. Thank you, officer. You can be seated.
01:23:54 Okay, I'm going to take you back to September 10th, 2025.
01:24:08 You mentioned you were on campus.
01:24:09 You had a particular assignment.
01:24:12 Mr. Grinando, I'm sorry.
01:24:13 We're just going to pull down the exhibits.
01:24:16 Okay.
01:24:17 Thank you.
01:24:17 You may continue.
01:24:18 Would you like me to take this exhibit down, Judge?
01:24:20 Are you referring to it in your line of questioning right now?
01:24:24 Not right now, I'm not.
01:24:25 Okay, let's go ahead and take it down.
01:24:44 So you were securing the Hall of Flags walkway, correct?
01:24:48 All right, 130 more likes to go, guys. 0.86
01:24:50 y'all niggas got a few minutes 120 likes to go on youtube if you guys want to stay on youtube 0.94
01:24:57 unless i'm going to force you guys to kick yes on the south end yes who's don jr donald trump 0.90
01:25:03 jr bro when they say don jr that means donald trump's son don jr someone in the kick chat
01:25:09 kick chat as i'm not kick chat someone in the tiktok chat asked that oh my god
01:25:15 yo yo the tiktok brain is real bro that just goes to prove like what i've always said about
01:25:23 tiktok tiktok is dominated by progressives bro tiktok is absolutely dominated by progressives
01:25:29 it's insane dude what was happening that morning that day on campus at uvu i i came in to do a
01:25:38 shift for a special event that where we had a guest speaker come in and was gonna talk to the
01:25:44 students and people around the neighborhood. Do you know who the guest speaker was? I do. And who was that? It was Charlie Kirk. Did you see Mr. Kirk that day? I did. When did you first see him? When he arrived on campus just behind the west side of the Hall of Flags I saw him pull up. And can someone access the courtyard in that through that area? Yes they can. How so? Where he pulled up underneath the Hall of Flags is a opening to where
01:26:14 You could drive a car underneath, so there's access right there.
01:26:18 You could walk or drive underneath the Hall of Flags.
01:26:21 And you saw him arrive?
01:26:23 Yes.
01:26:23 Okay.
01:26:27 Describe what you were seeing.
01:26:29 What did you observe?
01:26:31 On that day, I observed Charlie going back, doing some meet and greet with some people, getting some foes taken.
01:26:38 He then came underneath the Hall of Flags and went to his tent.
01:26:42 and he was there answering questions and talking to individuals that would ask him questions.
01:26:49 The tent you're referring to, is that the tent that we see when it was set up in the courtyard?
01:26:54 Yeah, that white square tent.
01:26:55 The white top.
01:26:56 Yes, he was under that.
01:26:59 Fast forward to about 12.20 or so, so a little bit after noon, the noon hour.
01:27:05 What happened?
01:27:06 What did you see and what did you hear?
01:27:08 I heard an individual talking to Charlie,
01:27:10 and I happened to kind of glance over the edge of the railing about that time.
01:27:16 I could see the right side of Charlie's shoulder, so not his whole body,
01:27:20 because he was underneath the tent, so I could only see probably the right side of his body.
01:27:24 He was answering a question, the kid asked him a question, and then I heard a shot fired.
01:27:30 Do you know what time that was?
01:27:32 Yes.
01:27:32 What time was that?
01:27:33 12.23.
01:27:36 What did you see?
01:27:37 Rest in peace, Charlie Kirk, man.
01:27:40 Rest in peace to Charlie Kirk.
01:27:41 I don't care what you guys think about him.
01:27:46 Horrible. 0.97
01:27:47 Absolutely horrible, man.
01:27:49 At that moment, I saw him lean to the left.
01:27:53 When you say him, you say Charlie.
01:27:55 Charlie.
01:27:55 So I saw him go to the left because I could no longer see the right side of his body.
01:28:01 So he went further underneath the tent to the north side of the tent, so left.
01:28:05 Okay. 0.99
01:28:05 Some moron says you idolize Kirk. Actually, no, me and him disagreed on quite a bit. 0.99
01:28:10 But I had the humanity to, you know, feel compassion for a man that was a father, a husband, very influential to a lot of people. 0.97
01:28:19 I'm not a moron like you and wish death upon someone just because I might disagree with them politically. 1.00
01:28:24 Idiot. 1.00
01:28:26 Can you describe the reaction of others that were there? 1.00
01:28:29 uh yeah so then um everybody started getting up and starting to run uh and more of a chaos kind
01:28:37 of situation before you continue can you describe a little bit so you mentioned mr kirk was i got a
01:28:44 good question here i'll answer this question um for you top j marklevin he says i'm sorry if you
01:28:49 answered this already but why did the state take the case was it better that that uh was it better
01:28:52 that the fbi took the case um no because uh states normally take murder cases
01:28:56 if there's no infection of if there's like no effect of interstate commerce a lot of the times
01:29:02 the state takes murder cases especially pre um premeditated murders like this state normally
01:29:08 takes them answering questions talking to individuals yes were there others present
01:29:12 yes um any idea about approximately how many how would you describe it in your terms in my terms
01:29:18 i'd say when i was up there looking down i'd say there's several thousand people because you had
01:29:22 on the grass i was jam-packed in the amphitheater sitting on the grass you had people standing on
01:29:28 the back up along the cement you had people that were on the second level the sorenson and over by
01:29:33 the woodbury building there's another level there where a lot of people were standing and watching
01:29:37 so it was it was pretty packed several thousand people and let me be clear even if someone that
01:29:42 i didn't didn't agree with like let's say hassan biker or dean withers or one of these other like
01:29:46 progressives kyle kalinsky like if something happened to them i would also say rest in peace
01:29:49 by the way fyi even my political opponents i don't wish any harm on them like it's called
01:29:55 being a human being see the problem is that this issue with a lot of you guys that say oh
01:29:59 why do you say r.i.p for charlie kirk you don't understand violence okay you probably never shot
01:30:04 a gun in your life probably never been in a fight in your life so for you you don't understand the
01:30:08 gravity and the seriousness of violence and death i do and i don't wish it upon my worst enemy
01:30:13 because i i know what it's like you ever put a gun to somebody's head saying if you yo put your
01:30:19 hands up you ever you know been in a situation where you almost pull the trigger probably not 1.00
01:30:23 so please shut up please shut up i don't want to hear from any of you fucking keyboard warriors 1.00
01:30:27 oh well why would you say r.i.p to charlie kirk he was a bigot shut the hell up shut the hell up 1.00
01:30:33 i'll extend the same courtesy to anyone regardless of their political 0.98
01:30:36 affiliation all right it's always the people that have never done anything
01:30:42 that have the most to say when it comes to you know something bad happened to someone physically
01:30:49 insane dude insane you mentioned so you mentioned you heard something what did you hear again
01:30:56 i heard a gunshot okay and can you describe the you described mr kirk's reaction
01:31:03 was that simultaneous to hearing the the gunshot yes it was when he fell to the left yes did you 1.00
01:31:10 see the reaction from the crowd yes what was that everybody it's the tiktok morons guys that are 1.00
01:31:16 like losing their minds again tiktok is dominated by libs so of course they're going to say some 1.00
01:31:21 bs about charlie they all said a lot of people were screaming standing up and starting to run
01:31:26 in all different directions away from the center of the tent okay you're a police officer helping
01:31:32 to secure the area correct yes what did you do um at that moment i recognized it as gunfire i uh i
01:31:39 left my post which was right down the south end of the hall of flags i went i proceeded to between
01:31:45 right where the fugal and the hall flags meet there's some outside stairs that i was starting
01:31:49 to run down as i was trying to get down to the bottom of the stairs people are running up people
01:31:53 were laying down on the steps i'm trying to jump over people to get to the bottom of the stairs so
01:31:57 i can help uh stop an individual that's probably shooting um what happened next um by the time i
01:32:06 got to the bottom of the stairs we i was informed on the radio that we had a shooter in custody
01:32:11 So I thought at that moment, I was like, oh, that was kind of fast.
01:32:15 Obviously, it was close range probably because we had an individual in custody.
01:32:18 Another officer came on and said we had an individual in custody.
01:32:21 That was the old man, if I'm not mistaken, that they first grabbed up.
01:32:24 That was crazy?
01:32:26 So I decided to, since the threat is gone, now I can assess for anybody that's injured
01:32:33 and start looking for any medical needs that's needed at that moment.
01:32:37 I started canvassing the area.
01:32:39 as I canvassed the area I was looking for anybody that was injured I saw a kid
01:32:44 on the ground that was on the about the second or third tier of the in the grass
01:32:48 next to a wheelchair and he was almost convulsing I thought he'd maybe been
01:32:53 shot talked to the dad as I was running over there he said that he was just
01:32:56 having a seizure that he was fine he was not injured so then at that moment I
01:32:59 observed that there was no other injuries that I could see at that moment
01:33:03 okay did was your attention drawn to anything else at that time yeah so
01:33:09 So after we got some people kind of cleared away a little bit, I thought I needed to start preserving the scene because we had a crime scene.
01:33:16 And with some of my experience and training to that effect, I decided now we need to contain the scene and help preserve as much evidence as we can.
01:33:23 So I started pushing people off the grass out of the courtyard area because I knew that's where the crime scene was.
01:33:30 So as we started pushing those guys out, my chief, Chief Long, that was right next to me.
01:33:36 I looked down and saw an empty pistol holder that was sitting just on top of the grass.
01:33:43 And at that moment, things had died down just a split second.
01:33:46 I realized that the shot I heard was more of a rifle shot and not a pistol shot.
01:33:52 And what causes you to say that?
01:33:57 Just from being around firearms through all my trainings,
01:34:01 the difference is, you know, a handgun is more of a short bang pop sound.
01:34:06 uh i'm gonna play the audio for you guys here because like you can hear the echo
01:34:10 we're gonna go to kick though i don't even want to play this on tiktok or youtube guys come on
01:34:14 over come on over i'm gonna get i'm getting off youtube i'm getting off tiktok right now
01:34:18 i'm gonna play the clip for you guys you can hear the gunshot
01:34:21 so come on over let's go i'm ending uh i'm ending youtube and uh i'm ending youtube and
01:34:29 tiktok right now coming over to kick kick.com slash myra gains x guys let's go let's go
01:34:36 ending tiktok ending youtube right now this is the kick the streams are the the link is right
01:34:41 there just join up guys it's completely free there's no ads okay completely free there's no ads
01:34:46 jump on in okay jump on in and just i'm no i'm ending tiktok because i got i'm tired of censoring
01:34:53 myself dude i seriously have to censor myself ridiculous whenever i'm on here and it's annoying
01:34:58 as hell so i'm ending tiktok right now and youtube come on over guys come on over actually 0.60
01:35:05 I'm going to end Facebook, too.
01:35:06 Facebook, TikTok, and YouTube going down.
01:35:11 Come on over, guys.
01:35:13 Kick.com slash MarioGamesX.
01:35:14 Let's go.
01:35:21 All right.
01:35:24 YouTube going down. 1.00
01:35:28 Come on over, Ninjas.
01:35:32 Why won't let me?
01:35:35 I'll keep playing this for you guys.
01:35:37 With a rifle you have more of a longer violent bang or crackle sound.
01:35:44 It's more of a violent kind of sound that's longer, so that's why I recognized it.
01:35:49 Okay. Is a rifle sound louder typically?
01:35:52 Yes.
01:35:53 Okay. Going back to when you heard this gunshot, could you tell where it came from?
01:36:03 Some direction? Yes, I knew it came to that from the east of me the east of you, okay
01:36:09 So you see this this realization comes to your mind. What did you do next?
01:36:14 At that moment when I saw the holster the empty holster
01:36:17 I turned to my chief and I said that was that was a rifle shot. He said I agree and I looked up at that moment
01:36:24 Right in the line of sight. I could see the Loci building had a direct line of sight
01:36:29 So I proceeded to go look at that and see what was going on up there
01:36:33 Okay. Can you just briefly describe your route to the Lossie Center?
01:36:38 So from the courtyard, you can go into the Sorenson Center.
01:36:41 And like I said earlier, there was, on level one, there's some elevators or there's stairs.
01:36:47 I ran up four flights of stairs, got to the fourth level of the Lossie Building,
01:36:52 and proceeded to the south of the Lossie Building.
01:36:55 There's some stairs, which is that breezeway between the Computer Science Building and the Lossie Building.
01:37:02 there's some stairs that go up to the top of that and so i went to the top of that is that stairway
01:37:07 that you previously described yes on the outside of the low seat building just okay that it's an
01:37:12 it's a public stairway yeah we have some breaking news um did you make it to the rooftop i did do
01:37:18 you know about what time you got there um i probably i got there 12 44. okay all right so here it is
01:37:32 One of my friends told me that Charlie Kirk was going to be on the campus, like slump over, and then the crowd just pushed back.
01:37:39 It was looking people.
01:37:40 If I can't see Charlie's head.
01:37:42 The last 10 years, counting or not counting gang violence.
01:37:45 Great.
01:37:46 And you can hear the gunshot echoing.
01:37:49 That's how you know it's a rifle.
01:37:50 And shot from a distance as well with the echo.
01:37:54 That's what the police officer is referring to.
01:37:57 What did you do when you got on top?
01:37:59 When I got on top, I hopped over the guardrail.
01:38:03 I noticed that there was an object which was sitting right about 10 or 15 feet in from the other side of the guardrail in the gravel.
01:38:11 That looked out of place to me.
01:38:13 And in relationship to where you hopped over the guardrail, what direction was that object?
01:38:19 To the west of the guardrail.
01:38:21 Okay.
01:38:22 And did you recognize the object?
01:38:25 I did.
01:38:26 And what was it?
01:38:26 It was a red and black screwdriver.
01:38:28 Okay.
01:38:30 Did you touch that object?
01:38:31 I did not.
01:38:32 Okay.
01:38:39 That's the court reporter, the furious typing you guys here.
01:38:41 I'm going to refer the witness on your screen, Officer Bagley, to State's Exhibit 3.1.
01:38:48 Let me know when you see that.
01:38:49 Holy, bro, how many?
01:38:50 These guys got a lot of exhibits.
01:38:52 I already heard 35.
01:38:55 Yes, I see it.
01:38:56 Do you recognize what that is?
01:38:58 I do.
01:38:58 And what is that?
01:38:59 That's a picture of the screwdriver that I saw that day on top of the rooftop of the LOSI building.
01:39:02 Okay.
01:39:03 And that's how it appeared on the roof that day?
01:39:04 Yes.
01:39:05 Remember, guys, I told you about the screwdriver that he left on top of the building?
01:39:08 Is that a fair and accurate portrayal of the screwdriver you observed and found that day?
01:39:11 Yes.
01:39:12 Around the state offers.
01:39:13 And they got a lot of exhibits.
01:39:14 Guys, this is just a preliminary hearing.
01:39:16 They're going hard.
01:39:17 State's exhibit 3.1.
01:39:19 News Naster.
01:39:19 I think the reason why the prosecution is going so hard is because of all the alternative theories out there, which obviously hurt their case.
01:39:25 and we renew excuse me we renew our standing objection and object on the grounds that there's
01:39:30 no foundation latest when the photo was taken or by home thank you that's like what the fourth time
01:39:35 she's tried this now with the foundation same response judge yeah same response judge my
01:39:41 previous arguments did you state that this was a fair and accurate representation as of september
01:39:45 10th i had said that day i'll ask it again all right to the officer officer bagley um you were
01:39:49 you saw this screwdriver you're describing on september 10th 2025 is that correct yes
01:39:53 is state's exhibit 3.1 a fair and accurate depiction of that screwdriver that day september
01:39:57 10th 2025 yes all right state moves to admit i will go ahead and admit state's exhibits 3.1 is
01:40:03 admitted based off the firsthand knowledge of this uh what this image purports to be and is a fair
01:40:08 and accurate representation as uh this item on that date of september 10th 2025 so that's the
01:40:14 second chair prosecutor right there so they got two prosecutors on this case and this he's lead
01:40:19 He's lead ADA.
01:40:21 He's second chair.
01:40:23 Exhibit may be published.
01:40:24 Your Honor, before we continue to publish it and ask a few more questions, right now might be a good time to take a break.
01:40:29 All right.
01:40:29 That's okay, Court.
01:40:30 All right.
01:40:31 Let's come back at it.
01:40:32 It's 1043.
01:40:32 Let's go ahead and come back.
01:40:33 Well, 1044.
01:40:34 Let's come back at 11 o'clock, and then we'll resume.
01:40:36 The court is in a brief reset.
01:40:38 Okay.
01:40:38 So, all right.
01:40:40 So, what do we know?
01:40:41 So, basically, the first witness is a police officer that has an intimate knowledge of the campus, knows where all the buildings are.
01:40:51 As you guys can see, he was there to paint a picture of the layout.
01:40:54 He knows the campus like the back of his hand.
01:40:57 He was probably the most senior officer that testified the most and understood the campus best.
01:41:01 So, that's probably why the state picked him as the witness for establishing the campus.
01:41:07 He also understands the camera system and everything else like that.
01:41:09 Normally when you get witnesses, you want to get a witness that you can do multiple things at once.
01:41:15 So that's kind of what went down here, and that's why they picked him.
01:41:20 I predict the next witness, well, they said the government's witness, I think they said there's four of them, if I'm not mistaken.
01:41:24 They're going to probably all be law enforcement, more than likely.
01:41:27 And again, the reason why they're going to be law enforcement is because all you're doing is establishing probable cause.
01:41:32 Hearsay, guys, is allowed in preliminary hearings, also known as probable cause hearings.
01:41:39 Let me read some of these super chats real fast.
01:41:42 One chat says, OSS 90 Day Fellows competition for $50 buy-in for the first few entries, guys.
01:41:49 First prize gets $12.50.
01:41:51 Second prize, $9.80.
01:41:52 Third prize, $5.60.
01:41:53 Fourth prize, $3.50.
01:41:54 Fifth prize, $2.10.
01:41:56 Six prize, $1.50, man.
01:41:57 So get in there, guys.
01:41:59 Got a fitness competition going in.
01:42:01 I am very racist.
01:42:01 Thanks for becoming a monthly supporter.
01:42:04 DJ says, yo, Myron, love everything you're doing, bro.
01:42:07 Been a longtime viewer of FNF.
01:42:09 you nick and your bro are the realest ones on here appreciate you keeping it real thank you bro
01:42:13 uh please mod on tiktok oss 300 members desert joe announce for him to chat so he can uh find him
01:42:21 please okay yeah desert joe uh say something in the chat so i can find you and i'll give you an
01:42:25 og uh badge it's crazy that tala rompson is going bald from the stress knowing that he did uh what
01:42:31 he did was going to have severe consequences yeah repealed 19th for pierce morgan one chess uh mod
01:42:37 on tiktok ophelia hudson oh yeah well i don't um i got on tiktok but yeah i can mod some people i
01:42:43 gotta i gotta give a bunch of um oss guys a wrench on uh tiktok it's getting outrageous on tiktok we 0.98
01:42:48 all had a fucking faggots over there so um you know it's all good uh but you know the the reason 0.98
01:42:55 why i'm on tiktok is because it's good for discovery and uh we can you know i don't know 0.99
01:42:59 how i'm going along i'm gonna last but you know it is what it is um snowyango slash modern uh
01:43:05 morning stream i got you bro uh guys get your chats in by the way right now get your chats in
01:43:11 right now guys by the way so i can um you know because i don't want to stop the show too much
01:43:17 while we're uh covering the trial even though you don't you would have wished uh that upon them
01:43:23 kyle klinski and asan piker would wish that on you and laugh at the video you're a better person 0.98
01:43:27 than them and that's why we're better than the left because even though they're fags we don't 0.98
01:43:31 wish death on them exactly exactly i've always told you guys this that progressives are more 0.99
01:43:35 violent than we are you know we can't we can't um we can't go down to their level okay we're 0.98
01:43:40 better than niggas so um so that's kind of like how i look at it you know i mean 0.99
01:43:47 progressives like think violence is cool because they're faggots so yeah while we wait i got this 0.99
01:43:57 clip here of uh some girl apparently i was drinking and driving while i wait for the uh 1.00
01:44:02 the preliminary hearing to resume this disgusting person this annoying obnoxious i don't even know 1.00
01:44:08 who this bitch is but i already know she's a thot i already know retarded pig should be permanently 1.00
01:44:16 banned off of the platform you are drinking and driving you're reading chat yeah that's crazy bro 1.00
01:44:25 yo these twitch hoes bro literally like get away with everything dude i don't even know 0.99
01:44:30 who is this girl caseytron never heard of her in my life dude never heard of her in my life 1.00
01:44:39 and you're also doing it all on stream you are a worthless garbage you have always been worthless 0.99
01:44:47 garbage but it's just somehow gotten worse over the years and seeing the massive follow-off from 0.99
01:44:55 3 000 subs down to a sub goal of 150 oh yeah that's cooked i mean that's really sad 0.96
01:45:04 it's extremely sad yeah she probably uh stopped being consistent or you know just got lazy or
01:45:13 something and i don't think you should get banned you should get arrested this is it should be
01:45:19 against the law she sued pewdiepie for what what are you doing i i hope that she stays permanently
01:45:29 banned if she does by the way i want to let you know that i will never stop talking about you and
01:45:36 keeping up with you i will never stop in 20 years i will do it i'll it will come to my mind if i'm
01:45:47 still alive in 20 years if you're still alive in 20 years it will come to mind and i'll think
01:45:54 you know what what's she up to nowadays how can i make it worse
01:45:59 i'd do it for the love of the game 1.00
01:46:03 hey respect fuck these bitches man i agree i i've noticed i don't know if you guys have noticed but 1.00
01:46:11 asthma gold has become a lot more red pill on women which i i'm here for it 1.00
01:46:17 he's off with the juice okay we got a jew pillum 0.91
01:46:22 but he's getting good with the women i remember he reacted to one of my clips 0.78
01:46:30 when i was talking about how men and women aren't equal and uh he um and i was like you know i made
01:46:38 a reaction to it maybe he watched it i don't know i know i know he watches my stuff and i watch his 0.91
01:46:42 of course um but uh yeah ever since then i've just been seeing them like dunking on these 1.00
01:46:48 fucking whores which is great because to be honest with john niggas women deserve less 1.00
01:46:54 i've already talked about this extensively they really are fucking most of these women 1.00
01:46:57 are fucking useless they really are useless dude it's fucking incredible 1.00
01:47:01 my next goal is to jupe pill him i jupe pill tectone 1.00
01:47:08 i'm gonna have to take credit for that one i think i drew a pill tectone bro
01:47:14 because he wasn't really aware when we had our conversation and i told him look bro here's the
01:47:22 problem with the jews right if you guys remember that interview that i did with him 0.96
01:47:27 you know i fucking uh went in there i was like hey bro here's the issue with the jews 0.95
01:47:36 and uh i've been looking at on twitter he's like you know bro's waking up man 0.97
01:47:41 so yeah i i'm just so you guys know let me be clear about i like osmogold
01:47:49 he's shown me love before he's reacted to my college campus debates
01:47:53 and my uh jew dancing right one of my favorite songs 0.99
01:48:02 i got my seven seven seven thousand dollars i don't give a shit about dead kids 0.97
01:48:09 you know he reacted to that and shit like that so shout out to him bro shout out to him i like 0.98
01:48:26 eyes will go like i said before i'm gonna my goal is i'm going to jupil him okay we're gonna be 0.99
01:48:34 throwing romans and saying fuck israel soon get ready niggas get ready so and honestly at this 0.94
01:48:41 point right i truly do think it's a lot of you guys in chat right now give me a one in the chat 0.99
01:48:50 if it was either me, Nick Fuentes, Sneeko, Zerka, who else?
01:48:59 Yeah, it was probably one of us four. 0.99
01:49:00 Give me a word to show if one of us fucking Jew-pilled you. 0.99
01:49:03 It was one of us four, bro. 1.00
01:49:07 There you go.
01:49:10 There you go. 1.00
01:49:12 So, and we did that shit before October 7th. 1.00
01:49:16 Okay? 1.00
01:49:17 We were doing that way before October 7th.
01:49:20 So shout out to all the guys, man.
01:49:22 Shout out to all the guys.
01:49:23 That's why I said, bro, we're NATO, man. 1.00
01:49:25 Niggas against Talmudic order. 1.00
01:49:27 Okay, NATO. 1.00
01:49:28 Niggas against Talmudic order. 1.00
01:49:35 So. 1.00
01:49:39 All right.
01:49:40 So we're still waiting on this to come back.
01:49:42 All right, let's surf next.
01:49:44 Let's see what's going on in the news. 0.99
01:49:50 uh who the fuck is this guy daniel mcadams 0.98
01:49:56 you have director on pull institute okay 0.99
01:50:01 oh he follows me all right
01:50:05 oh here we go you're right kim i here we we got some twitter drama right
01:50:20 off rip so he says please follow me or send me your content i'd like to invite you to speak at
01:50:25 our 10th annual ron paul institute dc conference i have kind of spoiled the surprise if there is
01:50:31 to be a surprise okay shout out to ron paul man you know i i like the thing i love about libertarians
01:50:38 the most is that they're anti-war okay that's what i like about libertarians the most i don't
01:50:44 identify as libertarian though because like i don't think like you know women should vote and
01:50:49 shit so i don't i wouldn't identify as a libertarian because i do think that libertarianism
01:50:54 leads to a lot of degeneracy if i'm going to be honest like libertarians are basically like 0.99
01:51:00 progressives that just don't want free shit if we're going to be all the way honest 1.00
01:51:04 right it's like ultimate liberty like we don't care you can be a whore you can be a faggot you 1.00
01:51:12 can do whatever you want to do you want to suck some cock out you know outside whatever 1.00
01:51:16 so like libertarians are like you know it's like uh it's like i call it like the atheist political 0.99
01:51:23 party you know what i mean i know some libertarians right now are probably freaking out no dude it's 0.93
01:51:29 not like that it's not like that at all man all right bro have y'all niggas smoke weed and are 0.91
01:51:38 degenerates like basically libertarians look at it like if you're not hurting anybody who cares 1.00
01:51:44 that's how libertarians look at it right you want to be a slut be a slut who cares 1.00
01:51:48 progressives want free shit though progressives want big government and they want free shit that 1.00
01:51:54 is like the main difference between a progressive and a libertarian libertarians want small government 1.00
01:51:59 autonomy um you know freedom that type of shit but they're okay with degeneracy to get it
01:52:07 so anyway so he's inviting uh but i do like ron paul though i like that like there's a lot of
01:52:14 libertarians i like by the way don't get it twisted i like ron paul i like thomas massey
01:52:18 i consider thomas massey a libertarian he's not really a republican right dave smith i like these
01:52:25 guys okay uh so kim ivers says she was ultra pro covid lockdowns shots of authoritarian by the 0.98
01:52:32 way and pro russia gay and pretty much been the wrong side of every issue except outside oh damn 1.00
01:52:36 Kim coming out with the swinging and in response, you're right, Kim. 0.97
01:52:41 I definitely felt rush again and admitted as much slash apologize for it.
01:52:43 But I think you're being unfair with COVID.
01:52:45 I support the anti-lockdown protesters who are being excretionated by our media, even though I was for the lockdowns early on.
01:52:52 And while I advocated for the vaccine, I didn't agree with punishing or denying medical care to those who refuse to get it.
01:52:58 I'm not anywhere near perfect, but I do my best to admit when I'm wrong and correct the record.
01:53:02 You were wrong about Tulsi.
01:53:03 I don't use that to discredit everything you do. 1.00
01:53:06 Damn, what a fucking mature response. 1.00
01:53:08 Holy. 1.00
01:53:09 I was still waiting. 0.99
01:53:12 I would consider someone like an...
01:53:14 So, there are some progressives that I like,
01:53:17 that I consider sensible.
01:53:19 She's one of them.
01:53:21 She's one of them.
01:53:22 Anna Kasperian.
01:53:23 So, shout out to her. 1.00
01:53:26 She tells Netanyahu, fuck you and shit like that, 1.00
01:53:31 which is good. 1.00
01:53:34 Oh, shit. 1.00
01:53:35 Look at, oh, Israel exposed. 1.00
01:53:38 Bro put out a website called Archive Genocide.
01:53:41 Bro, these dudes are losing their mind. 0.70
01:53:44 They are losing their mind, these IOs.
01:53:47 Still waiting on the recess. 0.96
01:53:49 By God willing, Israel will be ready.
01:53:52 But you literally have a population of 7 million people, of which half are women. 0.95
01:53:56 There is a recovery period we need until November.
01:53:59 I know, by God's...
01:54:05 Oh no. I pissed off the shoes. What am I gonna do now? I don't want to lose everything. Someone, please help me.
01:54:35 Oh, man. 1.00
01:54:38 Jews mad. 1.00
01:54:39 Oh, no, I said the truth, and it really pissed off the Jews, and I don't know what to do, I have way too much to lose. 0.99
01:54:53 I didn't tell any lies 0.99
01:54:56 But I need to apologize 1.00
01:54:59 I know that the Jews can easily destroy my life 1.00
01:55:07 Hey, little boy, I heard you calling 1.00
01:55:11 No need to cry, now you can stop falling
01:55:15 I can help you make it all go away
01:55:18 But you have to do exactly what I say
01:55:22 Kiss the wall, kiss the wall
01:55:26 If you want to keep it all
01:55:29 Kiss the wall, kiss the wall
01:55:33 If you want to be a soul
01:55:36 Kiss the wall, kiss the wall
01:55:40 If you know what's good for you
01:55:43 Kiss the wall, kiss the wall 1.00
01:55:47 Never forget you're ruled by Jews 1.00
01:55:50 Oh, thank you so much for being forgiven 1.00
01:55:55 I'm so happy about this choice I'm giving
01:55:58 I was just being edgy, I didn't mean to offend
01:56:02 I will get to Jerusalem and make it right on my end
01:56:05 Good little boy, I knew you'd understand
01:56:09 I'll have my contacts waiting for you in the promised land
01:56:13 And when you get there, they won't be mean to you 0.99
01:56:16 Just remind them that you're apologizing to the Jews 1.00
01:56:19 Kiss the wall, kiss the wall 1.00
01:56:24 If you wanna keep it all
01:56:27 Kiss the wall, kiss the wall 1.00
01:56:31 Old slasher chat, niggas 1.00
01:56:32 Old slasher chat, let's go 1.00
01:56:35 Kiss the wall, kiss the wall
01:56:38 If you know what's good for you
01:56:41 Kiss the wall, kiss the wall 1.00
01:56:45 Never forget you're ruled by Jews 1.00
01:56:49 Come on, man. 1.00
01:57:11 Hey, that's a banger, right? 1.00
01:57:15 Yo, they're fucking losing their minds, bro. 1.00
01:57:18 All right. 0.99
01:57:19 halftime's over it's back in session before we get started i want to clarify on the record that
01:57:28 uh pursuant to the utah constitution section one i'm sorry article one section 28
01:57:37 uh where victims and victims representatives are entitled to be treated with dignity and respect
01:57:43 that if they choose to leave the courtroom there they can come back whenever they wish they're not
01:57:49 prohibited to coming back yeah because earlier in the thing you said if you leave the courtroom
01:57:54 you can't come back but for the victims you know they can come back for obvious reasons i mean i'm
01:57:58 sure erica kirk is going to step out a few times when some of this evidence is presented solely at
01:58:03 the break so i just wanted to clarify that uh in case there was any question about that in addition
01:58:10 I want to talk about the exhibits as it relates to their admission and publication of the exhibit.
01:58:24 So whenever there is an objection to an exhibit, I would ask that the attorneys are clear specifically what they're objecting to.
01:58:32 There's basically three levels of objections that could be objected to.
01:58:38 First, the admittance of the exhibit itself.
01:58:41 Second is the publication of the exhibit to the gallery.
01:58:45 And third is the publication which is electronically captured by the media.
01:58:53 So, Council, I'll leave it to you in regards to what you object to or what you wish to respond to.
01:59:01 If no objection to the publication, Media Capture of the Exhibit, is specifically raised, the court will presume there's no objection.
01:59:10 So being that the monitor was introduced today by the court, I wanted to offer that guidance to the parties in regards to your objections.
01:59:20 With that, let's go ahead and return to the witnesses.
01:59:23 I do note for the record that the council is present and all the parties are present, and let's go ahead and proceed.
01:59:30 Mr. Gurdnander.
01:59:34 Thank you, Your Honor.
01:59:36 We left off Officer Bagley with just having admitted State's Exhibit 3.1.
01:59:41 I believe the court also granted our motion to publish 3.1.
01:59:46 So we would ask the court to publish that to the gallery, 3.1.
01:59:52 To Ms. Nester, any thoughts?
01:59:55 No, Your Honor.
01:59:55 All right, we'll go ahead and publish Exhibit 3.1.
02:00:00 Thank you.
02:00:30 Looks like it's
02:00:36 While I wait for these guys to yap
02:00:37 Guys, give me a, you know, give me a follow
02:00:40 If this is your first time watching on kick
02:00:42 Don't forget to follow the channel
02:00:44 So you guys know when I go live
02:00:45 Just taking a second
02:00:47 A lot of you guys don't get notified when I go live
02:00:48 So jump on, follow on kick ninjas
02:00:51 Two
02:00:51 Thank you.
02:01:21 All right, it looks like it's noticing a flicker on my screen here.
02:01:28 All right.
02:01:41 Yes.
02:01:48 All right, Mr. Grenander.
02:01:49 Thank you, Judge.
02:01:51 Officer Bagley, so you testified that this is the screwdriver as you saw it on September 10th, 2025, correct?
02:01:57 Yes.
02:01:58 I'm going to...
02:01:59 This is a critical piece of evidence, guys, because this was a screwdriver that was used to assemble the gun that has Tyler's DNA on it, according to the state.
02:02:08 And this was on top of which roof?
02:02:10 The Low C building.
02:02:11 And in relationship to the entrance, the stairway, and when you hopped over the rail to get there, where was it located?
02:02:19 About 10 or 15 feet in.
02:02:20 Okay. If I could, Your Honor, bring up State's Exhibit No. 2 that was previously admitted.
02:02:28 I would like to have Officer Bagley come down from the witness stand and point on that exhibit
02:02:35 approximately where this screwdriver was located and describe it for the record.
02:02:41 All right. You may step down. And if you have a microphone for him as well.
02:02:46 I think there was one up there. Oh, here we go.
02:02:50 So if you can describe where you saw that screwdriver,
02:03:00 point to that.
02:03:01 Yeah, so this is the Losey building right here with light
02:03:03 gray.
02:03:04 Here's the guardrail in the center of the picture
02:03:06 with the red brick.
02:03:07 Just over that, about 10, 15 feet in, about right there.
02:03:11 About right there.
02:03:12 OK.
02:03:12 Now on this exhibit, exhibit 3.1,
02:03:15 there's an evidence tag, yellow number five.
02:03:18 Was that present when you found the screwdriver?
02:03:20 No.
02:03:21 Okay.
02:03:21 So that was left there by an evidence tech?
02:03:24 Yes.
02:03:24 Okay.
02:03:25 All right.
02:03:26 Okay.
02:03:26 Thank you.
02:03:27 You can take your seat again.
02:03:30 So he might have been the one to find a screwdriver, too.
02:03:33 Okay.
02:03:33 Officer, I'm going to direct your attention to your monitor again
02:03:49 and have you look at State's Exhibit 3.2.
02:03:56 And if you'll let me know when you see that.
02:04:01 Okay, I see it.
02:04:02 Okay.
02:04:03 And can you tell us what that is?
02:04:06 Yes, that's a picture of the top of the Loci building looking west.
02:04:10 Okay.
02:04:11 And how do you know that that is, in fact, the top of the Loci Center looking west?
02:04:15 I can see the landmarks of several buildings, the Fugle buildings on the top left of it.
02:04:21 You've got on the right is a white roof, which is the Sorenson Building on the right side of the picture.
02:04:26 This is also the gravel area on top of the Loci building.
02:04:29 Okay.
02:04:31 Can you see the courtyard from this?
02:04:33 Exhibit?
02:04:34 Yes, a little bit.
02:04:36 What about the tent that was set up that Mr. Kirk was underneath?
02:04:39 Yes.
02:04:40 Okay, what about the Hall of Flags?
02:04:42 Yes.
02:04:48 Did you mention that this was facing west?
02:04:50 What direction are we looking?
02:04:51 We're looking west towards Utah Lake.
02:04:53 Okay.
02:04:55 Officer, is this a fair and accurate depiction of what you observed on September 10, 2025, on top of the Losey Building?
02:05:03 Yes.
02:05:05 State offers State's Exhibit 3.2, Judge.
02:05:09 Ms. Naster.
02:05:11 Your Honor, I think that we renew our standing objection.
02:05:16 There is an evidence tag here which begs the question that it's not a fair and accurate representation of how he saw it.
02:05:24 And we also don't have any indication about when this picture was taken or by whom.
02:05:29 So we object to its admission.
02:05:31 I see.
02:05:31 Thank you.
02:05:32 Mr. Grunandr. Officer, one more
02:05:35 question, Judge. Officer Bagley,
02:05:37 apart from the evidence tag, do you see an evidence
02:05:39 tag on that photograph? Yes, I do.
02:05:41 Was that present when you were
02:05:43 on top of the Lossie Center and
02:05:44 observed this? That was not.
02:05:47 Okay, otherwise, is it fair and accurate?
02:05:49 Yes. State moves to admit.
02:05:52 Anything further?
02:05:53 No, Your Honor. All right, thank you.
02:05:55 Given that follow-up question
02:05:57 noting that the evidence tag
02:05:59 appears to be number two
02:06:00 on States Exhibit 3.2 was not present,
02:06:04 but otherwise it is a fair and accurate representation.
02:06:07 As stated by the witness to States Exhibit 3.2,
02:06:12 the court will admit it into evidence
02:06:16 and it may be published at the discretion of
02:06:20 or the request of counsel.
02:06:23 You're on the state would move to publish it.
02:06:25 All right.
02:06:30 Ukraine's capital.
02:06:34 Officer Bagley, will you describe what it is that we're looking at here?
02:06:40 Yes.
02:06:40 On the top of the photo, you've got the mountain range on the back.
02:06:44 It's going to be looking west.
02:06:45 You also have Utah Lake, which is towards the top of it.
02:06:49 As you come down towards the center on the top, you've got a pond,
02:06:53 which is the ponds over at Utah Valley University.
02:06:56 I've come down from that, from where the water meets that red-bricked part,
02:06:59 More towards the center is the Hall of Flags, and just below that where you can see the grass and the white tent is where Charlie Kirk was sitting looking west, and we're on top of the Losey building.
02:07:11 And is this depicting a particular corner of the Losey rooftop?
02:07:15 Yes, it is.
02:07:16 And this is the top rooftop?
02:07:18 Yes.
02:07:20 Is it the same level where we observed the atrium that's to the north?
02:07:24 The atrium's up just a little bit higher, so this is the top level of four.
02:07:29 Level 4. Okay. And what area of the rooftop are we looking at here?
02:07:34 As far as the gravel.
02:07:36 Southwest side of the Loci building.
02:07:38 Southwest side. Okay. Is there a line of sight down into the courtyard?
02:07:44 Yes, there is.
02:07:44 In that area? Okay. What else do you observe on this exhibit that's significant to you, officer?
02:07:52 There's some disturbance in the gravel right where, and around the area where the, in the area where the yellow marker is.
02:07:59 is there was some disturbance that caught my eye there.
02:08:01 Okay.
02:08:02 And does this photograph do it justice?
02:08:08 No.
02:08:09 And how so?
02:08:11 You can't really see the impression I saw the time of when I was up there on that day.
02:08:16 I saw a distinct impression in the gravel, and this does not show that.
02:08:21 Okay, so you could see more with the naked eye?
02:08:23 Yes.
02:08:24 Okay.
02:08:25 I'm going to refer the witness to states
02:08:29 guys just so you guys get an example of
02:08:31 what Tyler Robinson saw
02:08:33 on that day allegedly
02:08:34 this is what the vantage point looks like
02:08:37 so it's a
02:08:41 clear line of sight right to it
02:08:50 so
02:08:55 let's see the other photos
02:08:58 there you go so just to give you guys a perspective of what
02:09:10 the shooter allegedly saw on that day exhibit four on your monitor there
02:09:25 And let me know when you can see that.
02:09:28 Okay, I can see it.
02:09:31 And do you recognize that exhibit?
02:09:33 I do.
02:09:34 And what is that?
02:09:35 This is a nighttime view of that same photo.
02:09:38 That was just last, same view, looking west, and I can see the disturbance in the gravel.
02:09:45 And what tells you that this is the same photograph as the last one, as Exhibit 3.2?
02:09:52 You can see the hall of flags that's direct almost the top of the photo.
02:09:56 In the middle, you've got the hall of flags.
02:09:58 You can see the tent in the grass area, the direct line of sight with the Sorenson Building,
02:10:03 and I'm on top of the gravel of the Loci Building southwest side.
02:10:07 Is there also an LDS temple that's depicted in that photograph?
02:10:10 There is. It's going to be on the top left of the photo. It's lit up.
02:10:14 Okay. Do you know who took this photo?
02:10:19 I do.
02:10:20 And who took this photo?
02:10:22 Melissa Richards.
02:10:23 And who is Melissa Richards?
02:10:26 She's the lead senior forensic for the state of Utah.
02:10:32 Okay.
02:10:33 Examiner.
02:10:34 And how do you know that she took this photograph?
02:10:39 I spoke to her.
02:10:41 Okay.
02:10:41 All right, let me give you guys, I want to give you guys a visual so you guys know what they're talking about here.
02:10:46 Okay.
02:10:46 So this comes from A.I. Telly, a very good channel.
02:10:49 concealed position to avoid close detection and maximize the chances of escape
02:10:55 here is the bullet trajectory given this altitude and again you guys can see
02:11:01 this is it real time okay assassin had but i want you guys to envision what they're talking about
02:11:09 because it doesn't do it justice because we're sitting here watching them in the courtroom
02:11:12 they're yapping about this crap it's like you guys don't have a visual so let me go ahead and 0.88
02:11:15 give you guys the visual. Clear, unobstructed line of sight directly to the stage where Charlie Kirk 0.98
02:11:21 was standing and addressing the crowd. The bullet's trajectory descended steeply and accurately
02:11:26 through open space to strike Kirk in the neck, which strongly suggests the use of a scoped
02:11:31 firearm design for long-range precision. As soon as the shot was fired, the gunman likely retreated
02:11:38 to an entrance on the top of the building. Despite security efforts, the shooter disappeared without
02:11:42 trace, climbing down from the building and blending into nearby campus structures or
02:11:46 escape routes surrounding the Losey Center. Witnesses reported that panic broke out immediately
02:11:52 after the shot. The audience scattered, seeking shelter as shouts of get down and run echoed
02:11:58 across the courtyard. Campus police and Kirk's personal security team moved swiftly to secure
02:12:03 the area and evacuate Kirk. Here is the detailed timeline of how it happened. It's 12 o'clock
02:12:10 p.m. September 10, 2025. Event begins. Charlie Kirk began the event, with more than 3,000 people
02:12:19 gathered to attend. The security detail consisted of six officers along with Kirk's personal
02:12:24 security team. 12.20 p.m. Lead up to the shooting, Kirk was seated at the debate table, answering
02:12:31 questions from students. The discussion touched on sensitive topics such as mass shootings and
02:12:36 gun violence. Kirk remained calm and composed as he responded to a question about mass shooters,
02:12:41 still holding the microphone while seated. The atmosphere was lively but controlled,
02:12:46 many sitting close to the stage while others watched from nearby balconies and standing areas.
02:12:51 12.22 to 12.23 p.m. The assassination. Suddenly, a loud gunshot echoed through the courtyard.
02:12:58 Kirk was hit in the neck while speaking.
02:12:59 within minutes immediate response campus police already on the scene quickly secured the area
02:13:08 kirk's security team rushed him to a nearby hospital all right so you guys have a better
02:13:12 vision of it but yeah that's that was the that's the line of sight with which he was using a mauser
02:13:18 okay uh it's it's basically a hunting rifle um you know a shot like that what 200 uh 200 yards
02:13:25 something like that? Not even, not easy shot to hit with a rifle like that. Not a hard, not a hard
02:13:32 shot. Um, just renew the objection to hearsay. That's an outstanding objection. Thank you.
02:13:44 Okay. Do you want to respond to the objection about hearsay? Um, yes, judge. Uh, this is a
02:13:47 preliminary hearing. You fucking retard. Hearsay doesn't matter. You can, hearsay is absolutely 1.00
02:13:51 admissible in their prelim hearing are we serious this bitch is retarded under rule 1102 hearsay is 1.00
02:13:57 admissible to establish the foundation or for or the authenticity of any 1.00
02:14:01 yo this bitch is doing anything bruh what the fuck bruh hearsay is absolutely utilized 1.00
02:14:13 has absolutely allowed to establish probable cause in a preliminary hearing are you fucking 1.00
02:14:18 serious what the fuck hearsay is not allowed in trials 0.93
02:14:26 that's found in 1102 but it is allowed in preliminary hearings where we're just trying 0.98
02:14:33 to establish probable cause uh sub b sub three um bro listed out the actual statue
02:14:40 also point out for the court that under rule 1101 which is the applicability of the rules
02:14:51 in subsection c1 the determination of questions of fact preliminary to admissibility of evidence
02:14:58 when it's determined under rule 104 which are preliminary questions the court the rules of
02:15:02 evidence do not apply 104 speaks directly to provide lane foundation for an exhibit so even
02:15:06 at trial hearsay is admissible to establish the foundation of an exhibit i would also just okay
02:15:11 i didn't even know i didn't know that hearsay could actually know it can be because if they're 0.92
02:15:15 an expert or something that makes sense but yeah to use hearsay in a fucking preliminary hearing 0.90
02:15:19 is insane point to court in a trial you got a chance but in a prelim hearing come on man 0.65
02:15:26 um to state v griffin this is a 2016 utah supreme court case um the citation is 384 pacific third
02:15:34 186, which stands for hearsay evidence
02:15:36 is admissible to establish the foundation of an exhibit, even at
02:15:38 trial. And we're at a preliminary hearing stage, Judge.
02:15:40 Anything further, Ms. Nestor, before I issue
02:15:42 a ruling?
02:15:44 I'm going to
02:15:46 overrule the objection
02:15:48 to hearsay. I note that... Hey, I gotta give her
02:15:50 credit, though. She's trying, bro.
02:15:53 She knows she throws enough shit 0.99
02:15:54 at the wall, something's gonna stick, dude. 0.99
02:15:56 The standing objection by defense.
02:15:58 I also note that rule 1102, and I also look
02:16:00 to Article 1, Section 12 of the Utah
02:16:02 constitution which states nothing in this constitution shall preclude the use of reliable
02:16:05 hearsay evidence as defined by statute or rule in whole or in part at any preliminary examination
02:16:10 to determine probable cause or at any pretrial proceeding with respect to release of defendant
02:16:14 if appropriate discoveries allowed as defined by statute or rule for those reasons i'm going to
02:16:18 overrule the objection and yo nsb thank you so much for the gift of subs bro we're almost at a
02:16:23 goal uh to get back over 3 000 thank you fn speed for all you brokies in the chat say you're a
02:16:30 brokey and someone might gift you a sub. All right ninjas. As it relates to reliable hearsay
02:16:36 in this instance. Thank you. Uh, you may proceed. Officer Bagley, did you ask Ms. Richards if this
02:16:43 was a fair and accurate depiction of this scene on the low sea building on the night of September
02:16:47 10th, 2025? Yes. And what did she tell you? She said it was. Okay. You're on the state offers
02:16:51 a state's exhibit for disaster. Just object to relying on what Ms. Richards told him in terms
02:16:57 of creating a foundation and refer back to our standing objection.
02:16:59 Yo, TPC, thank you, brother.
02:17:02 Appreciate you greatly, man.
02:17:04 Thank you, TPC.
02:17:06 For those of you guys that are wondering, TPC is my guy.
02:17:08 He's the one that did all this. 0.98
02:17:11 You know, you look at my fucking setup over here. 0.99
02:17:13 He pretty much hooked it all up, man. 1.00
02:17:16 You know, like all the shit that I got going here. 0.98
02:17:19 You guys look at all these camera angles, how crispy it is. 0.98
02:17:21 You guys like that cinematic look right there?
02:17:23 TPC set that up for me, right?
02:17:25 so shout out to him for helping uh really you know make the quality good you know i mean we
02:17:34 go hard to paint guys try to give you guys the best production quality that we can so shout out
02:17:38 to tpc the state will submit it right well as i look at state's exhibit four and again i'm just
02:17:45 looking at it before me i it said it was a fair and accurate representation um there's there's a
02:17:50 notation i mean the previous exhibits there's a marker exhibit marker and i see two but it also
02:17:54 appears to be other artifacts on this image that I haven't heard any testimony
02:17:58 about and so I will follow up judge all right
02:18:00 officer Bagley do you see an evidence tag in that exhibit yes I do a number
02:18:04 two a number two and that's yellow and black yes do you see other evidence
02:18:07 markers that are red in color yes they are to me they're orange but they're
02:18:10 triangular shaped okay were those markers the evidence tag too as well as
02:18:15 the orange or red markers present when you observe that scene that day no okay
02:18:19 were they present however when Miss Richards took this photograph yes and
02:18:23 She indicated to you that that is a fair and accurate representation of what she observed that night?
02:18:27 Yes.
02:18:28 State would move to admit, as I said before, Judge. 0.90
02:18:29 Ms. Nestor?
02:18:31 Objections, Your Honor?
02:18:31 Thank you, Ms. Nestor.
02:18:33 I'm going to go ahead and overrule the objection, noting that the marker, evidence marker,
02:18:36 as well as the red or orange markers, I can't tell which color it is, was not present originally.
02:18:42 And with those included information, State's exhibit for is admitted into evidence and may be published.
02:18:47 Thank you.
02:18:48 State would move to publish that.
02:18:49 All right.
02:18:49 and i would ask for the witness to come down to explain the exhibit all right officer if you'd
02:18:57 like to step down use the microphone and as previously noted uh describe when you're
02:19:02 describing something on the image where it is located on the image for the benefit of our
02:19:05 recording so officer will you describe for the court what it is that you're looking at
02:19:10 that's what i'm looking at is i'm on top of the lousy building which is where the gravel is on
02:19:14 towards the bottom center i'm looking west uh towards the tent which is in the upper center
02:19:18 that you got a white tent you can see the grass down there in the amphitheater you got the hall
02:19:22 of flags that's more towards the top center and behind that you've got I-15 but what I'm looking
02:19:26 at is in the disturbance of the gravels where I saw that day okay and what can you describe for
02:19:29 the record that disturbance to me when I when I got up there and I could see this disturbance of
02:19:34 gravel to me it looks like a sniper pad a person that has been laid in a prone position and you've
02:19:39 got markings of elbows knees and feet where somebody was in the line of sight of where
02:19:42 Charlie's tent was.
02:19:44 Thank you.
02:19:45 And if we could, again, take the, if we could publish
02:19:48 the state's exhibit number two.
02:19:53 You recognize that, right, officer?
02:19:55 Yes, I do.
02:19:55 Where on the low sea rooftop did you
02:19:56 observe this disturbance in the gravel?
02:19:58 You go to the center of the picture.
02:19:59 If you go to the center of the picture,
02:20:00 in the darker gray part of it, on the left side,
02:20:03 so the south side of the low sea building,
02:20:04 it would be right in the line of sight
02:20:06 of the Charlie Kirk tent that's straight in front of it.
02:20:08 OK.
02:20:08 Or the southwest side of the roof.
02:20:09 Thank you.
02:20:10 You can take your seat.
02:20:12 and finally I would direct the witnesses attention to state's exhibit number five on the monitor
02:20:23 let me know when that's there it is do you recognize that exhibit I do and what is that
02:20:35 this is gonna be a picture of the side profile of that last photo we looked at with some red
02:20:40 orange markers and a number two with also a tape that's there on top of the
02:20:44 Loci building. What was that tape that you said? There's a measuring tape it looks like.
02:20:47 Okay are you able to tell which direction the photograph is the photographer
02:20:50 was facing? Yes. And what direction is that? It's facing south. This is a
02:20:54 nighttime photograph correct? Yes. Do you know who took this picture? I do. And who
02:21:00 took the picture? It was most research. The same individual that you spoke about
02:21:02 before? Yes. Did you ask her whether this is a fair and accurate depiction of what
02:21:05 she observed that night? Yes. What did she say? She said it was. With respect to what
02:21:09 you observed that day apart from the evidence tag the yellow tag as well as
02:21:14 the orange or red markers is this a fair and accurate depiction of what you
02:21:17 observed yes what's different about what you observed as far as what's on the
02:21:21 photograph the previous exhibit compared to this you can see more of the length
02:21:26 of an individual so you can see that more there's two elbows to knee areas
02:21:30 plus also towards the far right of the photo is also a marker where like
02:21:34 somebody laid a gun down like a prone position yeah guys so he what he did was he brought like
02:21:40 a little mat for himself so he could lie on the gravel and take the shot that's what that's what
02:21:45 was that's why the the gun had the drape over it it was like that towel that he was using
02:21:50 you're on a pursuant to rule 1102 as well as other authority that's been cited today state
02:21:56 offers states exhibit five into evidence your honor we renew all the same objections we made
02:22:00 to Exhibit 4. Thank you. Given the foundation
02:22:04 that has been laid and that the witness has testified that this is a fair and accurate representation
02:22:08 of the scene, noting the tape as well as the markers
02:22:11 in that, State's Exhibit 5 is admitted into
02:22:16 evidence and may be published. State moves
02:22:20 to publish Exhibit 5, Judge. All right.
02:22:30 Before turning to what you did next on that day, taking you back to the daytime of September
02:22:39 10th, 2025, did you secure the rooftop of the Losey Building that day?
02:22:45 Yes, I did.
02:22:45 And how did you do that?
02:22:47 I put yellow police crime scene tape around the portion so nobody else would disturb that
02:22:51 area.
02:22:52 And when you say that area, what areas are you talking about?
02:22:54 I'm talking about the roof where it was the southwest side of the roof where I found the
02:22:57 disturbed gravel, where it looked like somebody had been prone out in the line of sight.
02:23:00 of the tent um somewhere there did you secure the area um as far as any of the entrance area
02:23:07 up onto the rooftop with police tape yeah so then where that natural guardrail is that was
02:23:11 the other barrier where they were advised not going any further from there other than police
02:23:14 officers okay um if we could go back to state's exhibit number two
02:23:23 if we were to zoom in on this uh photograph are you able to see the police tape that you put up
02:23:27 on the rooftop of the Lossie Center, officer? Yes, you would be able to. Kimberly, if we can zoom in.
02:23:41 Officer, I'm going to have you come down and describe for the court
02:23:45 where you put that police tape up to secure that scene, the rooftop area.
02:23:51 On the southwest corner of the rooftop. 0.99
02:23:57 So this is the top of the low C building, you've got your two different grays.
02:24:02 The southwest is towards the top, center of the picture.
02:24:06 You can see some yellow tape that spans from over here on the far right side of the picture
02:24:10 by these black pipes, goes around a silver vent, comes back down around to the corner
02:24:16 of that silver to keep everybody out of that area where that prone position was at.
02:24:19 Okay.
02:24:19 On that photograph, are you able to see where you put the tape up as far as the access way
02:24:23 to that roof near the stairway?
02:24:25 So it was right here, actually, this natural barrier where you have to climb over the guardrail.
02:24:29 So this is the other barrier that I have to set up.
02:24:31 And you put police tape on that?
02:24:32 Yeah.
02:24:32 Okay.
02:24:34 Did you eventually leave that area?
02:24:36 I did.
02:24:37 Do you recall about what time you left that area?
02:24:40 Oh, I have it in my notes.
02:24:42 It would be when I left that area.
02:24:44 It was almost 1 o'clock, about 1.03, 1.01.
02:24:47 Okay.
02:24:47 Before leaving, did you leave the scene with anyone?
02:24:50 I did not leave the scene.
02:24:51 Oh, did I leave the scene to somebody?
02:24:52 Yes.
02:24:52 Just to someone else?
02:24:53 Yes.
02:24:53 And who was that? 1.00
02:24:54 It was a county deputy a female. Did you provide instructions to her? I did and what were those instructions?
02:24:59 I advised her not to let anybody inside the crime scene. Okay without being a police officer or an investigator. Okay
02:25:05 Thank you. You can take your seat again
02:25:16 Officer upon seeing this disturbance in the gravel you've described what it looked like to you someone lying down in a prone position, correct? Yes. What did you do next?
02:25:24 So when I got to the top of the Losley building during that day, I noticed the screwdriver, kept going to the edge, found that prone position.
02:25:32 At that moment, I realized, because it was a direct line of sight, plus the disturbance in the gravel,
02:25:37 where I could see somebody laid down in a prone position or a sniper position and asked dispatch to get on the vid.
02:25:42 Then I realized that we probably didn't have our shooter in custody from that moment.
02:25:46 I asked dispatch to get on the camera system and to see if anybody was on top of the Losley building during the time of the incident.
02:25:52 Ah, okay, that's interesting.
02:25:54 So he was the one to call in and say, hey, we might have had a shooter from the roof.
02:25:58 Because if you guys remember, when the shooting first happened, they arrested some old white dude.
02:26:02 Were you advised of anything?
02:26:03 I was. Dispatch came back and advised me that there was a male individual on top of the roof that was there at the time of the shooting.
02:26:09 Ah. And that was the footage that I showed you guys earlier.
02:26:13 We also have new video of what police are looking at right now this hour.
02:26:20 TMZ has obtained new video of the before and after images of the...
02:26:26 Was it two S's? 0.78
02:26:30 Let me just put...
02:26:36 It was...
02:26:50 describe what his movements were they did they stated that he ran to the edge
02:27:05 dropped down crawled here it is right here for you guys
02:27:08 boom here he is running across
02:27:12 you can see him moving
02:27:16 here he arrives on the side
02:27:20 here he is right here zoom in
02:27:27 jumps down boom
02:27:36 gathers himself and runs off
02:27:40 got in a prone position um i'm gonna stop you right there you ran to the edge
02:27:47 what direction and what edge? Running west and southwest of the Loci building
02:27:51 so then towards the tent where Charlie Kirk was so they could get a line of
02:27:55 sight and then the individual stood up after the shooting and ran northeast on
02:28:01 top of the Loci building. Okay you mentioned that this individual on the
02:28:07 video dropped off off the edge did you did you get what happened what what else
02:28:12 was described to you? Then well at that moment so I knew that there was
02:28:16 possibly shoot her on the run.
02:28:18 Can we just have a continuing objection to all of the
02:28:20 hearsay that's being testified to here?
02:28:31 Oh, man.
02:28:33 Yo, that boy Tyler Robinson
02:28:34 just better get ready for the firing squad, bro.
02:28:39 Alright?
02:28:41 Just so you guys know, Utah
02:28:42 brought back the firing squad.
02:28:44 utah has in fact brought back the firing squad that's insane dude and judging my response to
02:28:54 that was i'm not actually offering this for the truth of the matter asserted at this point
02:28:57 um simply for the effect on the hearer so i'm not offering what's been described in the video
02:29:01 as substantive evidence all right with that clarification any thoughts
02:29:05 i'll just stand on the objection i don't i don't think i mean he's clearly offering it for the
02:29:12 truth because he's asking him to describe the route of the individual and it's based on what
02:29:16 other people told him so if he wants to circle back to it after he's put the video in i mean we
02:29:21 could do that but right now i still think it's inappropriate here say your honor all right
02:29:24 anything further mr i'll submit it to the court all right so as the magistrate as this is not to
02:29:28 a jury it's to myself as a magistrate i am not accepting that statement for the truth of the 0.97
02:29:32 matter asserted simply for uh sorry guys fucking the uh monitor turned off and that fucks everything 0.98
02:29:40 up sorry chat let me fix this shit sorry ninjas i'll fix this here in a second but yeah anyway 0.98
02:29:51 yeah that's hilarious because um literally um you know she's objecting to like hearsay in a 0.90
02:29:58 you know preliminary hearing which like i told y'all like guys remember it's the defense's job
02:30:04 to attack everything all they have to do is create doubt that's their job is to create doubt
02:30:10 You know what I'm saying? That's her job. So, you know, respect for her doing her job. 0.96
02:30:17 You know, she's probably getting all kinds of hate and death threats for even defending this fucking scumbag. 1.00
02:30:22 But but, yeah, let's get back to it. 0.99
02:30:26 What has been stated, so I'm specifically making that finding as I'm receiving this evidence and I'm not accepting it for the truth of matter asserted only as represented by Mr.
02:30:37 Grunander, and with that, the objection is overruled. Mr. Grunander, you may
02:30:41 proceed. Thank you, Judge. So you mentioned you were provided with information that
02:30:46 an individual was running north on the Losi rooftop, correct? Yes. What else was
02:30:50 described to you? At that moment, I actually knew I had responding units
02:30:55 coming into the scene. I advised other officers that I needed the Losi
02:30:59 building secured search because I didn't know exactly what way other than he
02:31:03 ran north. At that moment, I went down to the police department, which is just down
02:31:07 the stairwell and looked at the video myself and where is the police department located it's in the
02:31:12 gunther trade building just directly to the south of the low sea building okay so where i describe
02:31:16 those outside stairs the building to the left of that or south would be the gunther trade building
02:31:21 okay what's on what level is the police department it's level three level three okay upon arriving
02:31:26 at the police department what did you do next then i then look at the footage to verify for
02:31:30 myself exactly what expired on that moment where i could see an individual run to the edge get up
02:31:35 and then run off and then drop off the northeast side of the building of the
02:31:38 Loci building. Okay having viewed that what did you do next? At that moment I
02:31:45 realized I had more more crimes a bigger crime scene that I needed to contain and
02:31:49 preserve for evidence. At that moment I went and grabbed some more crime scene
02:31:53 tape and I responded to the northeast side of the building and secured an area
02:31:57 where I saw impressions of the shoe print inside the grass and also up above
02:32:02 on that northeast side of the building. I could see on the cement where someone had scuffed there and then dropped down to the shoe imprint and then finished going northeast.
02:32:09 Okay. I can take the witness back to States Exhibit 2.
02:32:19 You mentioned seeing an individual drop down. Could you come down and point that area out to the court?
02:32:24 Yes.
02:32:32 this is the low sea building again on the top right center of the photo southwest side is where
02:32:43 the individual was laying down prone in the line of sight came behind the aquarium or atrium atrium
02:32:49 came behind that on the west side of it came up to the north side of the low sea building on the
02:32:53 east on this white square piece on the far right of the picture and then he dropped off on the east
02:32:58 side of the low sea building into the grass down here below so the northeast corner yes
02:33:02 You mentioned you observed something on the grass?
02:33:04 I did. I saw a shoe imprint that was embedded pretty deep right there next to where he dropped off.
02:33:08 And this is all footage that you personally observed on the surveillance video?
02:33:11 Yes.
02:33:12 When you got to the scene, describe in as best detail as you can what you saw on the grass then.
02:33:17 So when I got to the scene, I could see that there was a shoe imprint there.
02:33:20 When I looked up onto the cement from the roof, I could see some scratching or rub marks from the top of the roof that was not there.
02:33:27 So I could see that looked abnormal.
02:33:29 I then decided to put crime scene tape around the whole area in case there was more evidence
02:33:35 that needed to be preserved.
02:33:36 On that exhibit number two, do you see where you placed the crime scene tape?
02:33:40 Yes, I do.
02:33:40 And where is that?
02:33:41 Can you describe that to the court?
02:33:42 It's going to be on the far right in the center of the picture.
02:33:44 You can see the yellow tape.
02:33:46 I came around trees, came up further out of pictures, some more trees.
02:33:48 I came down all the way down to the back side of the LDS Institute building
02:33:52 where there's a sidewalk to block everybody out of coming up that way.
02:33:55 Did you at one point leave the scene?
02:33:56 I did.
02:33:57 Did you release the scene to anyone?
02:33:59 Yes, I did.
02:33:59 And who was that?
02:34:00 There was two patient police officers that were standing there.
02:34:02 Were they in uniform?
02:34:03 They were.
02:34:04 Did you provide them with any instructions?
02:34:06 I advised them not to let anybody inside the crime scene other than law enforcement or investigators.
02:34:09 Okay.
02:34:12 You can take your seat again.
02:34:13 You know, obviously, guys, this is to protect evidence, right? 0.99
02:34:16 I remember when I would show up to a crime scene, if shit was disturbed or fucked up, I would get pissed off. 0.96
02:34:23 I would get pissed off if things weren't, like, you know, exactly preserved as much. 0.98
02:34:28 because it makes your job harder as the investigator, you know?
02:34:32 So obviously the uniform guys,
02:34:36 their job is to preserve as much as they possibly can.
02:34:42 Officer Bagley.
02:34:46 Tape it up and let the lead investigator take over.
02:34:56 You've talked about the disturbance in the gravel.
02:34:58 That was observed on the low sea building. Yes. Did you walk through those that that grab that disturbance in the gravel?
02:35:04 I did not. Did you otherwise touch it in any way? No
02:35:07 with respect to the shoe print that you observed on the grass on the
02:35:11 Northeast
02:35:13 Lawn area below the low sea building. Did you walk through that? I did not. Did you otherwise disturb that? No
02:35:26 Officer Bagley, what did you do next?
02:35:28 From that moment, I did release the scene.
02:35:31 I went down to the Fugle building and knew that where the incident command center was at,
02:35:35 so I could relay information that I had found to responding units and people in charge.
02:35:41 If I can have just a moment, Judge.
02:35:43 You, man.
02:35:44 Okay, I think it's going to be defense on cross now.
02:35:49 All right, now it's the cross-examination.
02:35:53 This is where Tyler Robbins' lawyer is going to start grilling this guy.
02:35:56 i'm gonna get my prediction i don't um i don't think there's much that she can grill him for
02:36:02 because everything here is kind of matter of fact hey give us the layout this is the layout
02:36:07 what did you see i saw this okay what did you do i cornered it off for investigators
02:36:12 okay what else did you see this like what what happened with um the video camera footage
02:36:18 i asked someone i saw him drop off obviously the footage has been shown right so um this guy is
02:36:23 very like uh matter of fact like he established a lot of like the logistical and um campus scenery
02:36:31 for for uh for the audience so like i don't know what she's really going to beat him up on but let's
02:36:36 see maybe ask elson is the clause that she knows about let's see were you aware of whether mr kirk
02:36:43 had his own security team present there with him yes did you communicate with any of those people
02:36:50 I saw one individual that was on top of the hall of flags right next to me, yes.
02:36:54 Okay, and that was before the shooting?
02:36:55 Yes, and then I saw several down in the crowds and down by him, yes.
02:36:59 And were you aware of whether that person was armed either?
02:37:02 I was aware he was armed.
02:37:03 Okay.
02:37:06 Was there any other law enforcement agency besides Mr. Kirk's private security team
02:37:12 and your six officers, including you, that were covering that event that day?
02:37:17 In other words, did you have any Provo police or Orem police or anyone that you knew of or federal agencies?
02:37:23 I don't know.
02:37:25 You never saw any that day?
02:37:26 No, not until the response came in.
02:37:29 And you did mention, I think I heard you just a few minutes ago testify,
02:37:33 you turned over the scene on the roof to a woman who was a deputy sheriff, right?
02:37:37 Yes.
02:37:37 And that you turned over the scene where the individual dropped off to, I believe you said, was it Orem police?
02:37:45 Payson.
02:37:45 Payson police, thank you.
02:37:46 Those people weren't there until after the shooting, right?
02:37:49 They were part of just a response of everybody in the area?
02:37:52 Correct.
02:37:53 Okay.
02:37:58 Did you receive any type of briefing materials, written materials, prior to the event that talked about who would be covering what or anything like that?
02:38:08 No, not that morning.
02:38:09 Like I said, it started getting hectic, so we were trying to get down there to secure the area and push people away from the top of the tent.
02:38:13 now when this event was over um you prepared a report is that right i did and in the report it
02:38:24 covers a lot of what you testified to with mr grenander doesn't it yes and i think you said
02:38:29 you attended what 600 hours of post training it's around 600 hours yes and i'm sure somewhere in
02:38:35 that training you were taught the importance of your police report yes and how it will be relied
02:38:41 on years later to recreate events like it's being done right now.
02:38:45 And so you know it's really important to be as accurate as possible in your
02:38:49 report. Can we put up Bagley
02:38:53 1? Alright, let's see
02:38:57 what she's going to do here. Let's head over to the defense table, please. Thank you so much. 1.00
02:39:04 And
02:39:04 show it only to the witness.
02:39:11 all right do you see that report in front of you i do and is that the report that you prepared
02:39:24 or did you prepare this report i didn't i did a supplement on it i didn't prepare the report so
02:39:31 like because the incident was a big agency assist so obviously it says
02:39:37 It has all the responding officers to that effect.
02:39:40 Oh, we need to go to the page.
02:39:42 Thank you for pointing that out.
02:39:43 Can we please move to page three or five, maybe?
02:40:03 Man, there is a firestorm on Twitter right now.
02:40:07 between Candace Owens and Andrew Colbert, man.
02:40:09 Holy.
02:40:11 They've been going back and forth for days.
02:40:14 But there's a firestorm going on right now with this hearing.
02:40:21 All right.
02:40:21 Now, let me ask the question again.
02:40:23 Sorry, we just had the cover sheet up.
02:40:26 Is that your report?
02:40:27 Yes, this is.
02:40:28 All right.
02:40:29 And did you prepare that?
02:40:30 I did.
02:40:31 When did you prepare this report?
02:40:34 It looks like it was done the next day, either that day or the next day,
02:40:41 because I wanted to make sure that I had it done,
02:40:43 where everything was fresh on my mind.
02:40:44 And do you have a copy of it in front of you?
02:40:46 I do, as a matter of fact.
02:40:47 May I just step in and just make sure that it's the same one?
02:40:49 May I approach, Your Honor?
02:40:50 You may.
02:40:55 I hope you're good.
02:41:03 We've got to ask this now.
02:41:09 Did you use AI to help you prepare your report?
02:41:12 I did not.
02:41:13 Okay, good.
02:41:16 When you prepared your report, you referenced when you first heard the shot, don't you?
02:41:21 Yes.
02:41:22 And what is the time that you say that you heard the shot?
02:41:25 12.23.
02:41:26 Right. And when you wrote that report, you did not state in your report the direction you heard that shot come from, did you?
02:41:36 No, apparently not.
02:41:38 And take your time and look at the whole report and see if there's anywhere in there where you ever mentioned that it came from the east or to your right.
02:41:49 OK, interesting. Let's see what happens here and I'll get my commentary after.
02:41:56 I don't see a direction.
02:42:06 Okay.
02:42:07 And you also, I believe, in your report, you also don't state whether or not,
02:42:16 you don't mention anything about thinking it came from the low C building or anything like that, right?
02:42:21 Later on when I recognize where the, when I see all the empty holsters, when I, I think I actually said that in there,
02:42:27 where I see the empty holster that I realized the line of sight.
02:42:30 Okay.
02:42:30 So let's talk about that holster for a minute.
02:42:33 So you heard the shot and you only heard one shot, correct?
02:42:38 Yes.
02:42:39 And then you came down from the walkway above the tent, right?
02:42:46 Yes.
02:42:46 And you came down to really the grassy area that we've all been looking at, the courtyard.
02:42:51 Yes.
02:42:52 And there was kind of chaos, people running around.
02:42:55 Yep.
02:42:55 Yes.
02:42:56 And while you were down there, you saw what you said was an empty holster.
02:43:03 Yeah, as I was clearing people out and making sure that the evidence was preserved,
02:43:07 about towards the top, after a little bit, I saw an empty holster sitting there.
02:43:11 And when you say towards the top, can you be specific and tell us where you were?
02:43:15 So on the south side in the courtyard, there's some tiers of seating where the grass is different levels.
02:43:23 And it was towards the top, maybe just right before the cement is where everybody's standing.
02:43:27 So there's different levels towards the top on the grass.
02:43:30 And when you saw the holster, can you describe to me what it looked like?
02:43:34 An empty concealed holster.
02:43:37 For what type of weapon?
02:43:38 For a pistol.
02:43:39 Okay.
02:43:40 And did it have any markings on it?
02:43:42 I didn't even, no, not that I noticed.
02:43:44 And what happened to that holster?
02:43:46 I have no idea.
02:43:48 Did you ever take custody of it?
02:43:50 No.
02:43:50 Did you ever tell anyone else to take custody of it?
02:43:54 No.
02:43:54 You just left it on the grass?
02:43:56 I did.
02:44:00 Was it ever fingerprinted to your knowledge?
02:44:02 I have no idea.
02:44:04 Okay.
02:44:04 at some point um there were drones in the air is that right did you become aware of that yes i was
02:44:18 made aware of that right do you know who put the drones in the air i'm going to assume state police
02:44:24 uh sergeant cam nelson with the pro police department right so it wasn't uvu no did you
02:44:30 Hell no, UVO doesn't have that, man.
02:44:32 You don't even have drone capability?
02:44:34 Did you have a drone on campus that you used?
02:44:36 No.
02:44:37 Yeah, it's a small campus PD.
02:44:39 They're not going to have that.
02:44:44 So someone would have had to bring one after the shooting onto campus
02:44:47 because you wouldn't have had one there.
02:44:49 True.
02:44:57 All right.
02:44:57 you mentioned that as you were coming down into the grassy area from the top above the tent you
02:45:06 come down the hall of flags you come into the grassy area you mentioned that you heard i guess
02:45:11 on your radio that they had a suspect in custody yes and so how long do you think between the
02:45:19 shot being fired did you hear that i was in like i said trying to get yes this woman is the defense
02:45:24 you guys she's on cross-examination get down the stairs jump over people try not to step on people
02:45:30 as people were fighting up within 30 seconds maybe all right so they pretty much instantly
02:45:36 had someone in custody yes and that's why i was quite quite surprised were you aware of where the
02:45:42 person was taken into custody uh right down the by where charlie kirk was sitting by his tent
02:45:47 somewhere down there hey thomas this is reese's brother all right so in the courtyard area the
02:45:53 The person would have been in the courtyard area at the time of the shooting.
02:45:57 Yes.
02:45:57 Was that person in or near or around the holster in any way?
02:46:02 No.
02:46:02 You don't know?
02:46:03 No, he wasn't.
02:46:04 Where the holster was was up on the top level up there,
02:46:07 and it was when the incident happened, when Charlie got shot,
02:46:11 within seconds the other officer that was down by him said that he was in custody with a prisoner of the shooter.
02:46:17 So that happened right there.
02:46:19 But you didn't, at that time, it was your understanding, the person they took into custody was close by Mr. Kirk.
02:46:31 Is that right?
02:46:31 Yep.
02:46:32 But it didn't occur to you that, well, that's not where I heard the shock come from.
02:46:36 They must have the wrong person.
02:46:37 I should talk to somebody.
02:46:38 During the chaos moment, no.
02:46:40 They said they had a person in custody.
02:46:42 I figured those guys saw something I didn't see.
02:46:44 They took the person in custody, and I thought that was him.
02:46:46 Okay.
02:46:46 i actually i'm this would be a good stopping place because i'm about to start another
02:46:54 section okay so maybe we could go five minutes early for lunch absolutely all right
02:46:59 thank you thank you officer we're going to go ahead and break for lunch we'll come back at
02:47:06 one o'clock i do want to note for the camera operator if you would just be cognizant and
02:47:13 turn off the microphone during breaks and when we break for recess uh that would be helpful
02:47:18 i do does either party need the benefit of the record before we break for lunch
02:47:23 all right we are in recess all right so they'll be back in about one hour
02:47:30 while we wait let's go ahead and cover some news got you on injus um ukraine got hit really hard
02:47:40 yesterday okay really hard so let me um let's cover that real quick while we wait came under
02:47:51 another deadly russian attack massive explosions lit up the sky overnight as ballistic yeah kiev
02:47:56 got hit really hard uh zelensky was talking about it uh let's see here
02:48:01 here's the damage
02:48:18 yeah i guess boom boom kiev
02:48:31 yeah lots of destruction
02:48:41 missiles and drones
02:48:42 hammered parts of Kyiv
02:48:44 killing at least 12 people
02:48:45 in the city itself
02:48:46 I think the final
02:48:47 I think it was 16 total
02:48:49 gone
02:48:50 64 people rescued
02:48:57 I DON'T KNOW WHAT I WANT TO
02:49:00 TAKE.
02:49:01 I DON'T KNOW WHAT I WANT TO
02:49:04 TAKE.
02:49:05 11 PEOPLE.
02:49:06 IS THAT WHAT HE SAID?
02:49:08 HE TWEETED THIS 10 HOURS AGO.
02:49:11 MISSILES AND DRONES HAMMERED 0.97
02:49:14 PARTS OF KYIV KILLING AT LEAST 0.53
02:49:17 12 PEOPLE IN THE CITY ITSELF. 0.98
02:49:20 LET'S GET MORE FROM CLARE
02:49:22 SEBASTIAN JOINING ME. 0.52
02:49:23 WHAT ARE WE HEARING ABOUT
02:49:26 Yeah, Paolo, Zelensky had warned that another big attack was incoming on Sunday night.
02:49:31 And here we have it, the second attack on a very large scale, targeting mainly the capital Kiev.
02:49:37 In about four days, last week on Thursday, we saw the deadliest attack on the capital so far this year.
02:49:42 At least 30 people were killed in a massive drone and missile barrage.
02:49:46 This one seems to have been—
02:49:48 Guys, get your superchats in. I'll read superchats after this Ukraine part.
02:49:51 It's slightly smaller in scale. Obviously, they're all terrifying for the Ukrainian people having to live through this. But we're hearing of 68 missiles, 351 drones. The key thing to know there, though, is that while the Ukrainians were able to shoot down 37 missiles, they did not manage to avert any of the ballistic missiles that were fired.
02:50:11 And Zelenskyy saying openly that was because of an insufficient supply of interceptor missiles.
02:50:16 So that is going to be a key question going into the NATO summit this week,
02:50:20 is will allies be able to step up and provide more of those supplies to Ukraine?
02:50:24 And another thing to note, though, is that this isn't just now on the Russian side
02:50:28 that we're seeing these overnight attacks.
02:50:29 We're seeing an escalating tip for tack on both sides.
02:50:32 The Russian Ministry of Defense saying that they shot down or averted some 519 Ukrainian drones
02:50:38 over multiple different regions.
02:50:40 One of the key targets appears to have been the Leningrad region, home to Russia's second city of St. Petersburg, where the governor is reporting damage to infrastructure around several key oil ports, more rolling power outages also seen in Crimea and Russian-occupied Crimea. 0.76
02:50:56 So, again, tip for tat escalation on both sides. We're seeing a more aggressive posture, I think, from Russia in many ways. 0.73
02:51:02 and over the weekend Putin and Trump spoke on the phone on July 4th and a clear attempt I think
02:51:08 from Putin to wrestle the narrative back. You've seen more sympathy from Trump towards the Ukrainian
02:51:13 side recently so we're seeing more of those attempts from Russia and Putin trying to claim 0.99
02:51:17 again that this is a these are terrorist attacks from Ukraine and that Russia is confidently in
02:51:22 the words of the foreign ministry in Russia advancing on the front line. So the questions
02:51:26 going into the NATO summit is I think number one air defenses for Ukraine and secondly will this
02:51:31 be the moment given the successes that we're seeing from yeah the problem with this war guys
02:51:36 is that both sides have like maximalist demands so this war is not going to end anytime soon
02:51:42 unfortunately guys it's kind of a black pill but like it's just not going to end anytime soon
02:51:47 um like russia wants to be able to wants ukraine to recognize the territory that they've taken
02:51:55 ukraine refuses to do that and they also don't want them to join nato ukraine refuses to do that
02:52:00 So it's like, you know, it's a very, both parties are making maximalist demands, and they refuse to concede.
02:52:11 From Ukraine, will it be the moment that the U.S. decides to further tighten the screws on Russia?
02:52:16 President Trump is set to head to Ankara Monday night.
02:52:19 He spoke to both the Russian and Ukrainian presidents over the weekend.
02:52:23 How might this reverberate through the summit?
02:52:26 I think because President Zelenskyy will be here in person and he's a powerful and emotionally
02:52:37 connected figure, you know, with these NATO leaders, he will be pressing the point that
02:52:43 NATO needs urgent air defense.
02:52:45 Yeah, we do it all over here, Chad.
02:52:46 We do it all, baby.
02:52:48 News, politics, wars, trials, true crime.
02:52:54 We do it all, baby.
02:52:56 we do it all i mean just look at what happened overnight
02:53:00 last night 66 ballistic missiles 29 of them
02:53:03 got through ukraine used to be able to do better than that partly
02:53:07 russia has got more sophisticated faster jet propelled
02:53:11 ballistic missiles uh that that can penetrate
02:53:14 uh where they couldn't penetrate before 350 drones
02:53:18 uh 18 of them landed as you say 12 people killed in key five in the
02:53:22 in the key region as well so it is a pressing need a president selensky really wants to be able to
02:53:28 produce and get license for making patriot missiles defensive missiles inside of ukraine
02:53:34 it's not clear that it's going to get that but there is a defense investment fund uh forum
02:53:40 meeting here tomorrow where there's expected to be a financial significant billions and billions
02:53:47 tens of billion dollars financial commitment to ukraine to to support them this year next year
02:53:54 in the war against russia so that's what president zielinski will be looking for
02:53:57 president trump is going to be coming in here looking for something else he's going to be
02:54:01 looking to make sure that his nato european partners that has been leaning on for a long time
02:54:06 to up their defense spending uh five percent of gdp is what is required by agreement last year of the
02:54:14 the Hague Declaration from the Hague Leaders Summit of 5% GDP by 2035. So President Trump's
02:54:20 going to be looking to see who's doing that, who isn't doing it. And I think it's going to be
02:54:24 very interesting to see how he deals with countries like Spain that aren't stepping up and haven't so
02:54:29 far made a commitment to getting to that level of spending over the next nine years. And I think
02:54:37 there's anxiety here. When President Trump walks into a NATO summit these days, there's worry. It
02:54:41 It was only a few months ago that he wanted to take Annex Greenland, which is part of Denmark, which is a NATO allies country.
02:54:49 And then on top of that, President Trump's been frustrated with the way his NATO allies have not, in his opinion,
02:54:56 stepped up sufficiently during Epic Fury, the U.S.-Iran war.
02:55:00 He wanted more support.
02:55:01 So all of that is in the mix here.
02:55:05 President Zelensky will be very focused on what he needs.
02:55:09 president trump undoubtedly very clear and determined to get what he wants out of it as
02:55:14 well i think uh this summit takes on a huge let me raise some super chats real quick
02:55:19 so they don't pile up too too much um gg channel says uh i'm on tiktok as well the black gotcha
02:55:26 gamer can i get a wrench yeah when i start tiktok back up maybe i'll start up tiktok right now 0.61
02:55:31 maybe i'll maybe i'll start up tiktok uh again here in a second the only thing that sucks bro 0.98
02:55:38 is i gotta like watch my language on tiktok it's so fucking gay bro uh crazy house nico's trying to 0.97
02:55:42 go at nick the whole time during the debate with you and riyadh thank you for not turning on nick 0.97
02:55:46 i don't know if he was trying to go at nick he didn't even mention him one time but uh tl says
02:55:51 hey what's up myron any chance of you and the valhalla guy doing a club he's on right now
02:55:55 with uh one of the youtube gun experts talking about the trial no expert believes charlie was
02:56:00 shot by 30 out six the damage would have been gruesome yeah i see here that he's live let's
02:56:04 see here let's take a look there's probably something in in the process right now oh i bet
02:56:08 there is yeah some too huge propaganda piece i don't know who this guy is but you're saying
02:56:12 he's a gun expert bro looks like mr clean but the asian version like what is what um
02:56:22 i don't know man like i said i don't mind um i think i might be too controversial for him though
02:56:30 so i need some advice i call four lenders one deal fell through due to dealership and
02:56:35 bank uh colliding issues uh one only offers an efa loan with no extra principal payments
02:56:44 and the other two want 20 to 45 percent down with 18 to 23 percent interest what
02:56:48 with 18 to 23 percent interest that's can't be right bro what would you do my situation seems
02:56:55 i can't get nothing to single digits in rates i'm trying to get the semi truck to increase my 0.65
02:56:59 income with 22k in savings uh bro your credit score must suck if you're getting interest rate
02:57:03 That's not correct.
02:57:09 Are we talking about a house?
02:57:11 What are you trying to get a loan for?
02:57:15 This is like for a semi-truck.
02:57:17 Okay, this is for a vehicle.
02:57:19 Hit up Fresh, bro.
02:57:21 Hit up Fresh.
02:57:22 Fresh knows about cars.
02:57:24 Hit up Fresh.
02:57:24 That's his expertise. 0.99
02:57:26 Martin, will Syria girl be on FedReacts or FNF? 0.99
02:57:29 And it actually makes me hate. 1.00
02:57:31 Yeah, well. 1.00
02:57:33 Yeah, she was going hard in the paint. 1.00
02:57:35 Got me dancing at the office, but had to close the door.
02:57:37 Yeah, bro, you got to, don't get caught.
02:57:39 Ken Rose, thumbs up, thank you.
02:57:41 Russell Viking is former FBI.
02:57:42 Could you do a highlight summary?
02:57:43 What did you think about the trial so far?
02:57:45 Not former FBI, former HSI.
02:57:49 And what I think about the trial so far,
02:57:51 it's not a trial, it's a preliminary hearing.
02:57:52 All they got to do is establish probable cause.
02:57:55 BB says, why did they break that attorney was cooking? 1.00
02:57:59 Because she didn't want to get into, 1.00
02:58:00 she didn't want to have to stop.
02:58:03 So they'll do it often.
02:58:04 When they're getting into something that might take longer,
02:58:06 they'll break for lunch early
02:58:07 so that she doesn't get interrupted.
02:58:09 Happens all the time.
02:58:10 Chatsamari, keeping us all sharp enough today.
02:58:12 Got you. 1.00
02:58:12 Do women at least deserve bare minimum? 1.00
02:58:15 No, probably not. 1.00
02:58:17 Free men die free.
02:58:18 I think their angle is trying to prove Robinson's presence
02:58:21 and railroad him without proof of him
02:58:23 holding the weapon at the scene.
02:58:25 It's starting to look like that, too.
02:58:26 I think he might be on to something.
02:58:27 We'll see, though.
02:58:29 All right, this is you.
02:58:31 What's up, AJ?
02:58:32 point the cart hit the cart point the court point the cart hit the cart point the court 0.65
02:58:40 don't know aj's i don't know some stuff love you buddy don't know what the hell you're talking
02:58:45 about there dear jen uh all right we have a second microphone so entering you can enter
02:58:52 and exit right here on the on the north side of the of the parking structure there's an entrance
02:58:57 an exit right here that's for the level one for a vehicle for vehicles and i guess someone could
02:59:02 walk in there as well uh yes if they were to park into this lds institute parking lot over here on
02:59:07 the north side of that there's a tunnel that goes underneath the road that still comes out into the
02:59:13 parking structure itself um and then they can exit out here on the second level onto heat plant road
02:59:19 let's go back to ukraine russia bro huge significance specifically for zelensky i mean
02:59:24 I mean, obviously, we hear time and time again how much Russia continues to really try to put
02:59:28 pressure on the Ukrainians. For President Trump, some of the words that he's used
02:59:34 in the sort of recent past has been, you know, we should somehow find an end to this war. We
02:59:40 should get Russia to knock it off. Obviously, Zelensky at this point is really looking for 0.95
02:59:45 America's resolve, not just words here. We know that Trump spoke on the phone to Vladimir Putin
02:59:50 and Zelensky, as I mentioned, over the weekend in honor of July 4th. What does Trump need to do at
02:59:55 this point to really change things just in terms of ensuring that there is some kind of momentum
03:00:02 when it comes to a peace deal here? Look, I think that, first of all, Russia's attacks,
03:00:09 in addition to being deadly and devastating for the people and for Ukraine, are also intended
03:00:15 clearly to be very provocative, the timing there. And with President Trump, it's very difficult to
03:00:21 know. As we know now, we've been watching him since 2015, 2016. It's very difficult to know
03:00:29 how he responds to that provocation. He travels to the NATO summit. He clearly has a personal
03:00:37 fondness for Erdogan. And so that's good for NATO. And he's also in the past had a personal 0.96
03:00:45 fondness for Putin. But having that provocation on the eve of the NATO summit could lead President
03:00:52 Trump to do what he should do, which is to double down on NATO's demonstration of unity. I mean,
03:00:59 after all, this is a summit. You know, you could say it's only a summit. So it really is about
03:01:04 signaling. It's about NATO signaling unity, coherence, and not division. And that provocation
03:01:13 by Vladimir Putin should be an invitation to President Trump to demonstrate the strength,
03:01:21 the resilience, and the commitment of the NATO alliance. Whether he will take that invitation
03:01:28 is very difficult to anticipate. You know, you can imagine a scenario where he pushes hard
03:01:34 on Zelensky and says, you know, you two have to help to end the war. But let's hope that that's 0.97
03:01:41 not what he does. China is watching. Iran is watching. And this comes at a very difficult
03:01:47 time for the United States and Europe, where President Trump feels personally affronted
03:01:52 that the Europeans did not step up immediately to support the U.S. in its war with Iran.
03:02:00 Yeah. I mean, you mentioned a few key points, not just the fact that President Trump is sort
03:02:07 of angry at European allies for not stepping up
03:02:09 when it comes to the war with Iran, but this idea- 0.96
03:02:12 Yeah, I mean, NATO's useless, bro.
03:02:14 I think our NATO usage has kind of ran out at this point,
03:02:19 if I'm gonna be very honest about it.
03:02:22 I think it's really ran out, dude.
03:02:24 There's not much benefit to it anymore.
03:02:27 ...the idea that one of the main reasons
03:02:29 why President Trump-
03:02:30 We put all the money in, got dragged in 1.00
03:02:33 and it's a stupid-ass war, pay all this money. 1.00
03:02:35 Like, bro, what are we doing here, man? 1.00
03:02:37 Like, what are we doing here?
03:02:39 I said that he's attending this meeting in the first place
03:02:42 is because of his close ties.
03:02:44 I mean, obviously he does seem to love strong men,
03:02:46 his close ties with President Recep Tayyip Erdogan.
03:02:49 And it comes at a time, not just in terms of this important bilateral relationship
03:02:54 between Erdogan and President Trump,
03:02:57 but also at a time when the president has repeatedly talked about
03:03:00 pulling and drawing down U.S. forces in Europe
03:03:03 and sort of scaling back America's role in NATO.
03:03:06 Just talk to us about how all of that changes the dynamics and the calculations within NATO itself.
03:03:14 Well, we've seen across. 1.00
03:03:17 Got stupid fucking Russia hawks. That's the problem. 1.00
03:03:20 We're going to be all the way honest. 1.00
03:03:23 Retarded fucking Russia hawks that thought, yeah, we could get in a war with these guys. 1.00
03:03:29 Who cares? Stupid, dude. 1.00
03:03:32 man uh what's one our truth uh what some might call a black belt that you reflected on and 1.00
03:03:38 ultimately had to come in terms of yourself uh the brifles a lot women only give a shit if you 1.00
03:03:42 provide value jimbo you won't believe it credit score is uh 740 and yes 22k in savings it's a 1.00
03:03:49 loan for a semi truck that costs 84k a lot of banks won't finance me because i'm a first-time
03:03:53 commercial buyer so far two banks approved me for those insane rates and down payments seems 0.96
03:03:57 impossible to get this type of loan i'm also 24 yeah that's also gonna fuck you up too because 0.57
03:04:02 you probably don't have um a diverse repertoire of credit lines uh talk to fresh bro talk to fresh
03:04:07 fresh will know way more than i do on that topic i i am not a car guy whatsoever i think cars are
03:04:14 gay i get it it's a semi truck it's different but fresh will know a lot more jayzacar thank you very
03:04:20 much demon reaper says i'm a redneck from the sticks it damn sure wasn't a 30 odd six mine 0.98
03:04:31 what is your opinion on being the other guy the bitch wants you with i've been on both sides uh 0.99
03:04:36 both ends of it and i'm thinking i don't want the karma from that later on you know none wrong with 0.95
03:04:40 that dude none wrong with that don't be the other guy then edgar g fit i watched the video this
03:04:43 weekend about some wild allegations in the smash community that i hadn't heard about before it
03:04:48 cover several cases but the most shocking one happens at the 5-11 mark it describes a female
03:04:53 commentator allegedly had a relationship with a minor while also seeing other partners it's 0.98
03:04:57 honestly hard to believe yeah bro women are whores it's like yeah you're headed i'm back 0.96
03:05:04 from overseas trip i'll have a southern lebanon update soon thanks dude 1.00
03:05:07 yeah bro women are whores why do you think they're getting caught 1.00
03:05:12 having sex with all these teenage niggas recently across europe across nato's european members 1.00
03:05:17 a real push to increase their spending to try to increase you know the number one i think barrier 0.99
03:05:24 to europe being stronger within nato is that interoperability that cohesiveness that
03:05:30 joint defense procurement all sorts of internal mechanisms in addition to just the
03:05:36 raw spending calculation that will allow all right woman talking no care okay let's go into
03:05:43 erica kirk break silence ahead of explosive hearing yeah but basically what you guys need to know
03:05:47 Summary
03:05:49 Russia launched a deadly attack on Ukraine yesterday
03:05:51 On Kiev
03:05:52 Roughly 12 deaths
03:05:54 Huge damage
03:05:56 The war is raging on
03:05:58 And there's no end in sight, bro
03:06:00 Honestly
03:06:01 Also, what I might do for you guys
03:06:06 Let me know if you guys would be interested in this
03:06:08 I've always wanted to watch this
03:06:09 And I think I might do it
03:06:11 But Oliver Stone 1.00
03:06:13 The Jew 0.98
03:06:14 Did a bunch of interviews with Putin back in the day
03:06:16 okay um if you guys want i can do those on oss and watch them with you guys 0.89
03:06:26 and we'll break them down do it on oss if i do it on youtube i get fucking hit with a copyright
03:06:33 but yeah news alert because these could be very tense and emotional moments inside a utah courtroom 0.60
03:06:42 this morning for the very first time jason car myron after hours tonight uh i don't think i 0.94
03:06:48 mean not for me bro i'm tired as fuck man guys i haven't slept yet i've been on all night 0.98
03:06:51 literally been on all night 0.98
03:06:54 time charlie kirk's widow erica and his parents are set to come face to face
03:07:10 at a preliminary hearing with the man accused of killing him.
03:07:14 Matt Finn is outside the courthouse in Provo, Utah, with more. Hi, Matt.
03:07:19 Hi, Dana. This week will mark 10 months since Charlie Kirk was assassinated here in Utah,
03:07:25 and his alleged assassin, Tyler Robinson, has yet to even enter a plea.
03:07:30 Robinson's defense team tried multiple strategies to get the possibility of the death sentence off
03:07:35 the table and delay the beginning of the preliminary hearing that's scheduled to begin
03:07:39 this morning and last all week now in utah a preliminary hearing is used to determine if
03:07:44 there's probable cause to move forward with a murder trial late last week uh they got enough
03:07:50 probable cause bro that's that's not even the question they got more than enough probable
03:07:54 cause this hearing honestly is just a formality and i think the the real strategy from the defense
03:08:00 here is um they want to see what the prosecution has that's the real reason but they got more than
03:08:05 not enough probable cause dude more than enough the defense is just trying to delay the trial
03:08:11 see what the prosecution has and keep their client from getting a death penalty so we'll see what
03:08:17 happens though the utah supreme court denied probable cause guys does not have a threshold
03:08:24 three appeals by robinson's legal team which paved the way for the prelim to begin today
03:08:30 with the camera in court tyler robinson is charged with aggravated murder in the assassin
03:08:35 um i think that the process the defense is definitely going to use like all the people
03:08:40 that like um you know have like alternative theories i think i me just speaking out loud
03:08:46 here i do think that the defense is going to use that maybe not for the prelim but for the trial
03:08:52 for sure for sure assassination of charlie kirk in court this week the state has indicated it's
03:09:00 going to present a video that shows
03:09:02 Robinson's former roommate. Because remember
03:09:04 guys, the defense's job is to create
03:09:06 reasonable doubt.
03:09:11 So,
03:09:12 a lot of these alternative theories
03:09:13 are going to absolutely be used
03:09:16 to defend
03:09:18 Tyler Robinson and create reasonable doubt.
03:09:20 You best believe
03:09:22 that they're going to use it.
03:09:24 Mike Dixie with the big 25 gifted.
03:09:26 thank you brother thank you thank you thank you thank you man
03:09:34 let me see if we pass or did we pass our goal of uh 3 000
03:09:38 what's that 32 50 but let me look here
03:09:43 29 38 all right hey for all the brokenness chat say you're a brokie maybe somebody will gift you a
03:09:55 sub shout out to mike dixie i appreciate you bro guys i haven't slept yet i've been going all night
03:10:00 for y'all so if you want to show your boys some love feel free to um to donate some subs because 0.88
03:10:09 i'm fucking cooked over here we're still i'm still going for y'all niggas and lover lance twigs 0.98
03:10:17 telling police 0.99
03:10:25 Bro.
03:10:27 All right.
03:10:30 That Robinson confessed that he assassinated Charlie Kirk,
03:10:36 who was murdered last September 10th at Utah Valley University.
03:10:40 Investigators say Tyler Robinson shot Kirk with a rifle from a rooftop
03:10:44 and then text messages confessed to his roommate lover.
03:10:49 Pattern Star, David, thank you for the gifted.
03:10:52 Appreciate you, bro.
03:10:52 lance twigs twigs texted why robinson replied why did i do it twig said yeah robinson explained i
03:11:03 had enough of his hatred some hate cannot be negotiated out if i'm able to grab my rifle
03:11:09 unseen i will have left no evidence now a lot of people are saying that this is um doctored text
03:11:16 messages all right what i will say though is that progresses one is dead i'll say that
03:11:24 um miles bartley thoughts on 30a and florida panhandle have you ever considered investing
03:11:33 in real estate here um if the deal makes sense then yeah nicklin thank you very much for the
03:11:40 gift of sub appreciate you man yeah all you broke he's better say you're broke he's somebody
03:11:44 who will gift you a sub and hook you up hopefully now the prosecution hubba milk the cow subscribe
03:11:50 for four months thank you bro has indicated it's prepared to forewarn the families of tyler
03:11:56 robinson and charlie kirk if graphic video or testimony is about to be discussed in court
03:12:02 and this morning we have a brand new statement hey sammy 626 thank you so much for the five
03:12:07 I appreciate you guys, man.
03:12:10 ...statement from Erica Kirk and Charlie's family.
03:12:13 It reads in part,
03:12:14 every court proceeding serves as a painful reminder of his death
03:12:18 and the loss that has irrevocably impacted our lives
03:12:21 and the lives of his children.
03:12:23 The prosecution has indicated the plans to call witnesses,
03:12:26 including state investigators and Utah Valley University police.
03:12:31 Dana, Bill.
03:12:32 Matt Ben, thank you.
03:12:33 So I want to bring in James Gagliano,
03:12:34 My own retired FBI supervisory agent, Fox's contributor, also there in Utah.
03:12:38 And James, good morning to you.
03:12:40 Based on what I read here, the prosecution's case is this.
03:12:43 They've got overwhelming evidence, and they're set to prove it.
03:12:46 How do you see that? 0.95
03:12:48 Well, there's a reason why the preliminary hearing took almost a goddamn year to do, bro. 0.92
03:12:56 They had a lot of evidence that they had to turn over during discovery, and the defense needed the time. 0.85
03:12:59 yeah and bill the standard is so low in a preliminary hearing remember you're not trying
03:13:06 to prove beyond a reasonable doubt you're just trying to show enough of the evidence so that
03:13:11 the judge can then go ahead and allow the trial to commence and look utah's a peculiar place in that
03:13:17 in their criminal court system you don't even get arraigned before this so we haven't even gotten a
03:13:23 plea yet from tyler robinson that may happen this week but may happen afterward at a separate
03:13:28 arraignment here okay it sounds yeah no indictment no nothing dude i think all they did was file an
03:13:32 information if i'm not mistaken to me james that this is like a grand jury proceeding
03:13:39 that usually is done in private and not in public am i right on that definition or
03:13:45 yeah but this is going to be in public and as part of the pre-trial you know uh maneuverings
03:13:52 what's going to happen is there are going to be witnesses are going to be called by both the
03:13:55 prosecution and the defense the defense are going to call three dna and forensics experts from out
03:14:01 of state and then the prosecution is going to call four state bureau of investigation folks
03:14:06 that collected the evidence as well as a utah valley university police officer that was there
03:14:11 when the when the that's the guy that testified uh first or is testifying right now as a matter of
03:14:16 fact on cross when the firing happened and also they're going to call to the stand which is going
03:14:22 to be pretty explosive but they're going to do it through something called an 1102 statement
03:14:26 lance twigs lance twigs is a romantic partner and the roommate of tyler robinson he's being
03:14:32 allowed to testify through audio visual means and not actually be in the courtroom today okay here
03:14:37 is erica kirk interesting this is november of 2025 and how public this case has been from the
03:14:44 beginning there were cameras all over my husband jimbo says messages are fresh on ig appreciate
03:14:50 you once again myron no problem dude if you can't get a hold of them just book a council with them
03:14:53 it'll be worth it what do you think about idaho new law death by firing squad i literally talked
03:14:58 about it um based do you think gas prices will go up since iran war is still not officially over
03:15:04 yeah it will because we're running out of um uh we're running out of strategic reserves bro
03:15:09 or sorry excuse me uh yes we're running out uh yeah we're running out of our strategic reserves
03:15:15 me and nick had a deep conversation on it castle club with the big 45 get it
03:15:20 thank you my friend and for all you guys that want to join oss and then spicy eg taco thank
03:15:30 you for the five gifted as well victor and true thank you for all you guys that want to join the
03:15:37 um the oss castle club clan hooks people up with free um subs he's one of our he's one of our
03:15:44 successful guys gotta gotta shit together so um so yeah well uh for all you guys that want to 0.94
03:15:51 join oss you poor niggas you bums um give castle club clan your email and he can gift you a sub on 0.99
03:15:59 oss so shout out to castle club clan man long time supporter a g a fellow racist and bigot 0.99
03:16:12 okay so it's great when he was murdered
03:16:16 he's in the kick chat cameras all over my friends and family
03:16:22 morning we deserve to have cameras in there this is uh i remember this interview this was november
03:16:28 17th so two months after her husband was killed why not be transparent there's nothing to hide
03:16:35 Let everyone see and know how it happened, how it even got to this point.
03:16:43 This is something that could impact a generation and generations to come.
03:16:47 James, she's getting her wish in the following way.
03:16:51 It's going to be as public as our legal system allows, and that is cameras in the courtroom for all of us to watch.
03:17:00 Yeah, the judge has been very resistant to defense motions to disallow this.
03:17:05 And look, you know, as Justice Brandy said, you know, sunlight is the best disinfectant.
03:17:11 And I think it's more about the ideology, the perverse ideology that Tyler Robinson was beholden to comes out.
03:17:18 It clearly establishes a motive.
03:17:20 And lastly, Bill, there is evidence beyond evidence beyond evidence.
03:17:25 We've convicted murderers on probably 10 percent of what the state has right now.
03:17:29 The question is, what does the state choose to show now?
03:17:34 And this is what I told you guys about before.
03:17:36 You know, you don't want to blow your load at the preliminary hearing.
03:17:38 All you need to do is establish probable cause.
03:17:42 You know what I mean?
03:17:43 That's all you need to do is establish probable cause.
03:17:46 I'll be interested to see how the cross-examinations of witnesses go.
03:17:49 Okay, so we're going to see a lot now, and it's all going to be there on camera.
03:17:53 A preliminary hearing that's going to last five days, starting in a few hours.
03:17:57 James, good to have you on scene.
03:17:59 Thanks for coming on today.
03:18:01 Thanks, Bill.
03:18:01 Okay, Dana.
03:18:03 Be sure to like and subscribe for all the five.
03:18:06 All right, let's see what else we got.
03:18:16 Let's see if there's anything else with Erica Kirk here.
03:18:23 Oh, yeah, this was earlier.
03:18:25 For the record, the court also recognizes the presence of Miss Erica Kirk.
03:18:30 Miss Kirk, good morning.
03:18:33 First, with respect to courtroom protocol, to maintain security and decorum, any individual
03:18:41 who exits the courtroom during proceedings will not be permitted to re-enter until the
03:18:46 recess.
03:18:48 All counsel are expected to take reasonable measures to safeguard confidential communication.
03:18:54 Such measures may include the use of screen protections on electronic devices and care
03:18:59 to avoid the inadvertent capture of privileged or private discussions by recording equipment or by
03:19:05 those present in the courtroom in addition the microphones at your tables i didn't realize we
03:19:12 had a bunch of y'all ninjas watching on x bro shout out to all you guys watching on x skeletal
03:19:16 being thank you for the uh for the five um shout out to all you guys watching on x bro we had a
03:19:24 we had we had a lot of y'all ninjas on here like a thousand people watching on x right now bro
03:19:29 Watching live, which you guys know
03:19:31 X is not really known for live streaming
03:19:33 They're trying to make it more about live streaming
03:19:35 But
03:19:36 Shout out to all you guys that are watching on X
03:19:39 Even though it's owned by 1.00
03:19:41 Julan fucking bitch ass nigga Musk 1.00
03:19:43 But 1.00
03:19:44 I hope you guys are having a good time
03:19:46 Go ahead and get engaged in the chat guys
03:19:49 I opened up the chat for you guys so you guys can yap in there
03:19:51 So 1.00
03:19:54 I'll say what's up to all you niggas 1.00
03:19:57 i'm acknowledging you ninjas my bad i never look at the fucking twitter chat because twitter's 1.00
03:20:05 filled with faggots dude and um and elon musk is a faggot have been turned off i call him julon 1.00
03:20:12 musk again an attempt to try to minimize but now you guys are going to see all the people on x so 0.99
03:20:17 if you guys are watching on x right now do me a favor type in a chat now everybody's going to see
03:20:21 you guys in here i see a couple of you ninjas in here what's up guys yeah now we can see the
03:20:29 ex-ninjas on here it's the possibility of any of the communications being captured for the record
03:20:35 the court also recognizes the presence of miss erica kirk miss kirk good morning all right let's
03:20:41 see what else we got here with the trial um let's go to law and crime real quick see what they got
03:20:54 let's go kirk let's see here
03:21:11 yeah people are just uh what was this i never heard this girl before in my life
03:21:26 you know what let's go ahead you guys the conspiracy people will go ahead and go on
03:21:35 here for you guys because you guys you guys wanted the uh the different theories here we go
03:21:39 And there is one person responsible for what happened here, and that person is now in custody and will be charged soon and will be held accountable.
03:21:53 After an over 30-hour manhunt, authorities say they've got the man who shot and killed political activist Charlie Kirk on the campus of Utah Valley University.
03:22:03 because as the frantic search was ramping up, there has been a lot of chatter and misinformation
03:22:08 and theories surrounding Charlie Kirk's death. We're taking some time to discuss some of these
03:22:14 theories that have been spreading quite quickly online and in the media, as well as brand new
03:22:18 information on the suspect. Welcome to Sidebar, presented by Law & Crime. I'm Jesse Weber.
03:22:27 Federal and state authorities in Utah say they have arrested the gunman, the man who allegedly
03:22:31 took the life of political activist and media personality Charlie Kirk, identifying him during
03:22:37 a news conference this morning as 22-year-old Tyler Robinson, who actually, by the way,
03:22:43 lived hours away from Utah Valley University. But authorities say he is the man. They say he
03:22:50 is the one who brought a bolt-action rifle to the top of a campus building and fired one shot
03:22:56 at Kirk, who, by the way, was speaking in this debate-style event in front of thousands of
03:23:01 people. That bullet, and I'm sure you've seen the videos, that bullet hit Kirk in the neck.
03:23:07 He was rushed to a hospital, but the married father of two young children was pronounced dead
03:23:12 at just 31 years old. Good morning, ladies and gentlemen. We got him. On the evening of September
03:23:19 11th, a family member of Tyler Robinson reached out to a family friend who contacted the Washington
03:23:26 County Sheriff's Office with information that Robinson had confessed to them or implied that
03:23:32 he had committed the incident. Robinson, he was taken into custody around 10 p.m. He was booked
03:23:38 into jail. According to FBI Director Cash Patel, after surveillance images and video of this suspect
03:23:44 was released to the public, they received thousands of leads. While he said that they're
03:23:50 going to follow up on all those leads, even though there's an arrest, there are still so
03:23:55 many theories about what happened here. And you wonder, is it really going to quiet that
03:24:00 conversation? We're talking misunderstandings. We're talking misinformation. We're talking up
03:24:05 conspiracy theories, general theories. That is what we want to get into right now.
03:24:11 because now speaking of conspiracy conspiracy theories um there is a war going on on twitter
03:24:17 right now guys okay you guys know i don't comment on drama like that um but they've this has been
03:24:24 nuts i i've this has been going on for days chat literally for days um you guys can see here uh
03:24:33 candace posted this earlier today three hours ago one more fight charlie i don't fear these demons
03:24:38 we will win right a lot of uh support and then here's jeremy boring the demon is you canis or
03:24:45 is in you the demon is tyler romerson or was in him the demon is not charlie's wife the demon is
03:24:51 not charlie's closest friends the demon is not the organization charlie bled to build and grow 0.98
03:24:55 the demon is not israel who has nothing to do with any of this okay nigga 0.95
03:24:59 or the egyptians or the french or any of the other people in institutions you have 0.98
03:25:04 slandered for money and fame your narcissism and sociopathy uh and self-interest and resentment
03:25:11 and grief have all commingled into something truly sinister which you have become in which
03:25:17 you have done can only be answered in the blood of the very christ jesus you bless them for cheap
03:25:23 points and clicks you are playing games with your soul candace and with people's lives it is a game
03:25:30 you lose automatically just by playing you sit on top of the world of fame but you are failing
03:25:35 no falling into the pit of hell itself you're leading others there too and being cheered on by
03:25:40 those already lost god have mercy on your soul and it's kind of been the um the mantra of the
03:25:47 people that dislike candace you know people from daily wire people from tp usa relentless going
03:25:55 after i guess this guy says you're the demon um you know so you can see people like just like
03:26:03 you know point us up a bunch of stuff uh is this stacy sheridan walking in with ck's parents 0.68
03:26:09 can somebody give me the background of this chick i know she used to work for turning point usa but
03:26:13 like what's the relevance here oss alex with the 10 gifted thank you my friend appreciate you bro
03:26:20 and then uh shout out to all you guys following the channel by the way as well shout out to all
03:26:25 ninjas hope you guys are enjoying the broadcast should i start going live earlier in the middle
03:26:29 of the day like this more i'm gonna have to i'm gonna have to go live in the middle of the day 0.95
03:26:34 like this seems like you guys really enjoy this shit you were not charlie's friend you were not 0.99
03:26:42 his defender you were his tormentor and now you torment his wife an organization he built 1.00
03:26:46 candace you're a fraud oh he's quoting andrew colbert yeah so 0.98
03:26:50 Andrew Colvin and Candace have been going at each other crazy the past several days I haven't really 0.99
03:26:58 said anything about it because you know whatever um but obviously with this hearing going on
03:27:03 you know emotions are high you know no one's really happy that Charlie got killed bro like 1.00
03:27:10 nobody like you know you got to be a sick piece of shit to cheer on um for Charlie's assassination 0.99
03:27:17 you know um and obviously you know emotions are very high right now because this is the first time 0.99
03:27:23 that we're actually like getting any type of legal progression in this case 0.97
03:27:27 right for you know you guys remember charlie got killed on september 10th guys 2025 it's fucking 0.51
03:27:34 july 6 2026 like it took 10 months right for us to hear anything so obviously this is a very
03:27:43 emotional day it's a very important day um for everybody so um yeah I'll read I'll read this
03:27:51 for you guys a little bit here he goes um so he's responding to Candace's comment here with
03:27:56 Charlie right there from this photo and he says uh hold on let me let me finish reading these
03:28:03 super chats so I make sure I don't uh welcome to the OSS urban legend have you seen that Andrew
03:28:07 Wilson wants to debate Candace Owens about Charlie Kirk's assassination conspiracy around it yes I
03:28:11 I did see some buzzes about that.
03:28:13 Yes, I did.
03:28:14 Hey, man, I just want to say that I appreciate everything you do for us.
03:28:16 Feel bad I lucked out on the $250 merch,
03:28:18 but made the decision to get all my debts paid off.
03:28:20 I'm $4K away from credit and loan payment.
03:28:24 I'm on track to finish it by late November.
03:28:25 Absolutely, bro.
03:28:25 No problem.
03:28:26 No problem.
03:28:27 I'd actually rather you pay off your debt than buy a hoodie for me, bro.
03:28:29 I'd actually rather you pay off your debt, so don't worry about it.
03:28:32 Send a message.
03:28:33 It's a rush on IG.
03:28:33 Okay, we're caught up.
03:28:35 All right.
03:28:36 Cool.
03:28:38 If you really want to support, the best way to support, guys, is the OSS.
03:28:40 Joining the OSS is only a dollar to join the first month.
03:28:43 You keep doing daytime streams.
03:28:44 Get us nine to five workers through the shift. 0.99
03:28:48 Damn, is it really that bad? 0.98
03:28:52 Are there, like, no good streamers that go on in the middle of the day? 0.99
03:28:55 Chat?
03:28:58 Are there really no, like, I could maybe adjust and do middle of the day like this
03:29:02 if y'all really want it, but are there, like, no good, like, oh, really? 1.00
03:29:08 What, are all the faggots on during the day? 1.00
03:29:10 Who's on during the day? 1.00
03:29:23 Los Pollos?
03:29:26 Oh, man. 1.00
03:29:28 Los Botos, you mean? 1.00
03:29:30 Los Botos, the fat fuck that watches Netflix and fucking gambles all day, that fucking faggot? 1.00
03:29:37 Fucking piece of shit, bro. 1.00
03:29:40 Fucking piece of shit, man. 1.00
03:29:43 Anus and Reach, them niggas don't stream. 1.00
03:29:45 A.K.A. Abort and Preach. 1.00
03:29:48 Osman Gwaislop?
03:29:50 Look, Osman's good, man.
03:29:52 Osman's good. 1.00
03:29:53 The only thing with Osman is, like, he's super blue-pilled on the Jews. 1.00
03:29:58 That's his only problem. 0.96
03:29:59 He's super blue. 1.00
03:30:00 He's too blue-pilled on the Jews, bro. 1.00
03:30:02 Way too blue-pilled on the Jews. 0.92
03:30:05 Tim Pool? 0.81
03:30:06 Nah, Tim doesn't go on during the day. 0.99
03:30:08 I mean, I know he has a day show, but, like, that's not his main shit. 1.00
03:30:10 His main shit is IRL. 0.99
03:30:17 Yeah, Nelk is on, I know. 1.00
03:30:18 But them niggas don't work, bro. 1.00
03:30:20 They could jump on stream like once a fucking blue. 1.00
03:30:23 You know what I mean? 0.99
03:30:26 You know?
03:30:29 So, all right.
03:30:31 Maybe I might have to switch my timing.
03:30:32 I don't know what time I would go, though.
03:30:35 Somebody said Patrick Starved David.
03:30:37 He goes on in the morning.
03:30:38 he goes on
03:30:41 he goes on in the morning
03:30:42 so
03:30:44 um
03:30:46 yeah so 1.00
03:30:47 so none of the base niggas are on during the day 0.99
03:30:49 Adam Green stopped being spiritually conquered 0.99
03:30:58 by Jews 1.00
03:30:58 what the fuck 1.00
03:31:00 I don't know what the hell you're talking about 1.00
03:31:06 but okay 0.67
03:31:06 uh let's see what else we got here
03:31:11 most streamers most streamers trash just slop well here's the thing bro uh the problem is that 0.89
03:31:24 like um most streamers are scared to talk about certain topics bro niggas don't want to lose their 0.89
03:31:28 money guys you guys got to understand this bro shout out to the ogs and the oss yep shout out to 0.99
03:31:32 you niggas kb was there's plenty of sick pieces of shit who are happy about it they could use an 0.99
03:31:37 ass whooping yeah the only good streamer during the daytime hours on occasion is andrew wilson 1.00
03:31:43 and jake rattlesnake oh they go on during the day i thought they went on at night they go on
03:31:48 during the day okay thanks to you marion i was able to get a job as a laborer for a plumbing
03:31:52 company and your streams helped me get through the day all right what was the invisalign company
03:31:56 you use uh it's clear correct ever brawn got to give your boy mario now fall credit going hard
03:32:02 to paint these days yeah yeah yeah he does like a bunch of interviews i don't know what he's
03:32:06 going to do in the war's end though uh you know uh when you rely too much on guest power you
03:32:15 because it creates issues all right andrew covet uh candace you and charlie were not friends he
03:32:20 managed you he kept things light and polite so you wouldn't turn on the organization tell me
03:32:25 any proof of genuine friendship for the last 12 months of this of his life from the last 18 months
03:32:29 from the last 24 months, not some 2018 text, something recent. You gave him anxiety whenever
03:32:36 you called or texted asking, parentheses demanding, to speak at our events. He made me or Justin deal
03:32:42 with you and George. This is why when you tried to hire me in February 2024 for PR, I agreed to go
03:32:48 along with it against my better judgment because Charlie asked me to keep you close and protect the
03:32:52 work from you. The publicist I tried to hire to run point prayed about it and felt the Lord told
03:32:58 or affirm no and so i ultimately declined this is your central foundational lie you're not his
03:33:04 friend you are not his defender you were his tormentor and now you torment his wife in the 0.92
03:33:09 organization he built candace you're a fraud and they've been going back and forth like this 0.86
03:33:14 for a while um let's see what candace has to say um oh yeah this is when she was in moscow
03:33:21 uh 19 minutes ago just responded here andrew the reason i didn't i don't share too much of the
03:33:27 Gibby C
03:33:29 thank you so much
03:33:29 for the five gifted
03:33:30 appreciate you man
03:33:33 appreciate you
03:33:34 appreciate you greatly
03:33:37 shout out to all the ninjas
03:33:38 showing love to the stream
03:33:39 I've been up all night
03:33:41 no sleep for you guys
03:33:42 we hit our 3000
03:33:44 if we could hit our
03:33:48 3250
03:33:50 that would be awesome
03:33:51 but let's keep on
03:33:55 let's keep on going on to going on.
03:34:09 Okay.
03:34:11 The reason I don't share too much of the recent stuff
03:34:12 is because it's got a lot to do with Israel
03:34:14 and the people that were radically supporting it.
03:34:17 Funny memes mocking people,
03:34:18 but with your permission, we could go max today.
03:34:20 Do you want me to keep sharing? 0.99
03:34:21 Oh, shit. 1.00
03:34:22 was this in response to 1.00
03:34:26 oh wow okay did she just put this stuff out andrew's been recently seeding the narrative that
03:34:38 charlie distanced himself from me here's andrew in his own words on a text chain with me and
03:34:43 charlie in may of 2024 denying that charge charlie had my back 100 his donors were the ones pressuring
03:34:49 him and he always expressed to me that he thought the daily wire was behind the sudden push
03:34:54 truth wins yeah that is true a lot of people don't know that that um charlie kirk and ben
03:34:59 shapiro didn't really get along like that so here she goes showing this and here well here's a
03:35:07 i guess a chain with them geez we're not dissing ourselves from you we have a bunch of donors that
03:35:12 want us to but we deal with them one-on-one and this website is resource explaining things most
03:35:16 of them are fine once we sit and talk with them i wonder if it's been ben personally or daily wire
03:35:20 pretty dirty can't swear with you 100 yeah there you go she got the receipts
03:35:25 charlie had so much anxiety about our friendship that he was the one
03:35:29 updating me on the farce of october 7th really weird to continually initiate convos with someone
03:35:36 you're scared of idf knew of a monster planet kidnap 250 before october 7th attack oh man 0.56
03:35:44 oh oh well well well well well well well well well well well well well you know jews doing jewish 0.99
03:36:02 shit hey andrew the reason i don't share too much of this stuff is uh okay 0.99
03:36:07 so yeah this is what she was pushing 0.97
03:36:14 who's this guy i'm glad you finally came to the surface right your previous employees told me
03:36:25 it was you and erica that were teaming up with the youtubers to put out the utterly fake narrative
03:36:30 that charlie and i were not friends and he had anxiety you also worked together to lie about his
03:36:34 pull towards catholicism and put out the deranged narrative that i secretly loved charlie and hadn't
03:36:39 spoken to him since 2019 despite me touring with him through to may 2024 here i'll just play this
03:36:45 clip relationship with who's this guy chat and again i apologize for my not knowing guys i have
03:36:53 not been i keep it a thousand with y'all bro i have not been keeping up with like you know
03:36:57 the tp usa and canada's drama i just you know obviously i'm visiting it today for the first
03:37:02 time even though i did see it on my timeline here and there like this like me actually like
03:37:08 looking at it now um because my thing was like i was like you know what dude i just want to see
03:37:13 the trial i just want to see the evidence you know i'm not going to get too much into
03:37:17 the back end stuff candace owens she's a great friend you know look i don't agree with everything
03:37:23 candace says but you know what i don't do i don't stop being friends with people just because people
03:37:28 morally blackmail me i don't do that you shouldn't either honestly i traveled the country with
03:37:31 candace i went to her wedding i saw her meet her husband i went to israel with candace which is a
03:37:36 fun story i'll tell you at some point i i think the world of candace she's a great mother she
03:37:40 certainly has very very fun opinions at times and she's a great talent she says a lot of stuff that
03:37:47 sometimes i don't agree with but that's what makes the relate our relationship and our friendship
03:37:51 in relationship with candace owens no she's a great yeah so they're going back and forth man
03:37:56 feel free guys to um you know go through the the lore
03:38:02 Serac No Diddy celebrates their subscription for five months.
03:38:07 Welcome, sir.
03:38:09 Welcome, welcome for five months.
03:38:15 So let's see what else we got here.
03:38:21 Because this was nine months ago, so this is kind of old.
03:38:24 I want to find something a bit more recent here.
03:38:26 okay here we go let's see what we got here here's a recap of what went down
03:38:35 this drive where's campus drive located on that campus drive starts right up here towards the
03:38:42 top left of the picture it's almost like a t and it's the curb road that comes all the way down
03:38:47 in front of the institute building and the parking structure and it goes all the way around campus
03:38:52 It comes back down to the bottom of the picture where the roundabout is, and that would be Campus Drive.
03:38:57 Okay.
03:38:58 Are you familiar with where 800 South is in Orem?
03:39:02 Yes.
03:39:02 Is that depicted on this exhibit?
03:39:04 It is.
03:39:05 Where is that at?
03:39:06 It's at the top of this photo.
03:39:07 It's going to be the long straight road.
03:39:09 That's right here at the top of the photo.
03:39:10 Okay.
03:39:12 What about 850 South?
03:39:14 Are you familiar with that street?
03:39:16 I am.
03:39:16 850 South is going to be towards the right of the photo, top right of it.
03:39:22 there's going to be a street that goes east to west. It looks like a horseshoe, kind of. It's
03:39:27 going to be the road that goes east to west in the middle of that horseshoe. It'll be 850. Okay,
03:39:31 so 850 is parallel to 800 south. Yes. And just below on this photograph. Yes. Okay. Are you
03:39:39 familiar with 600 west? I am. And where's that street in relationship to 850 south? That would
03:39:45 be on the far right side of the horseshoe, so towards the right side of the picture, and it's
03:39:49 be the right side of that horseshoe and that runs north and south north and south okay what about
03:39:56 720 west are you familiar with that street yes i am and where's that at that's going to be to the
03:40:01 left side of the horseshoe that runs north and south and it comes down towards the bottom okay
03:40:08 and finally 925 south 925 is going to be on the bottom of the horseshoe that connects
03:40:15 those other two Wests. Okay so just in summary will you describe the horseshoe
03:40:21 and what streets amount make up that horseshoe? So the horseshoe comes up off
03:40:27 of 800 south and directly south of that you'll have 850 south which is going to
03:40:31 be running east to west. On the left side is 725 west of the horseshoe and it
03:40:39 comes down into 925 south which wraps back around to 600 west on the far
03:40:43 right side of the horseshoe on the right side of the pitcher. Okay. Thank you, officer. You can be
03:40:50 seated. Okay. I'm going to take you back to September 10th, 2025. You mentioned you were
03:41:05 on campus. You had a particular assignment. Yes. Mr. Gernander, I'm sorry. We're just going to
03:41:10 pull down the exhibits. Okay. Thank you. You may continue. Would you like me to take this exhibit
03:41:16 down, Judge? Are you referring to it in your line of questioning right now? Not right now, I'm not.
03:41:21 Okay, let's go ahead and take it down.
03:41:40 So you were securing the Hall of Flags walkway, correct?
03:41:44 Yes.
03:41:45 On the south end?
03:41:46 Yes.
03:41:50 What was happening that morning, that day on campus at UVU?
03:41:55 I came in to do a shift for a special event where we had a guest speaker come in
03:42:00 and was going to talk to the students and people around the neighborhood.
03:42:04 Do you know who the guest speaker was?
03:42:06 I do.
03:42:06 And who was it? 1.00
03:42:07 Damn, bro. 1.00
03:42:08 Why is everybody coming at fucking Sneaker right now, bro? 1.00
03:42:10 what the fuck man like well uh yeah i know sneco and i could just tell you living on the internet 1.00
03:42:20 every single day and doing everything that you do for clicks and attention will lead to brain rot 1.00
03:42:25 and just evidence sneco um there's a reason that all the guys that he was once friends with once
03:42:31 that he admired once that he allegedly according to andrew trade tried to hit on him i have no
03:42:35 longer uh want to associate with him i have nothing to do with him as they say he's crashing 0.98
03:42:39 out let's just say hey man i'm still here sneaker's my guy you fucking jew so you know it's 0.96
03:42:48 kind of funny as these american flags around here this is an israel first guy so jr tate did a whole 0.98
03:42:54 expose basically saying there's one guy that i will not deal with ever again and that's sneaker
03:42:58 shocking that someone named sneak oh sneaky sneaker turned out to be a snake nicholas the
03:43:03 second person is nick fuentes nick fuentes says he's a brown clown after being good friends with
03:43:07 them those two guys basically hate each other at this point it just basically shows that what
03:43:11 america stands for is not compatible with what the amen they'll reconcile one day okay
03:43:19 islamic uh isis type mentality stands for and then obviously destiny is basically destroyed 0.99
03:43:26 multiple times but this is evidence you know you say you could be book smart but life dumb 0.97
03:43:30 sneaker is actually uh neither he's not smart and he's not uh full of wisdom but he's just 0.86
03:43:36 playing for clicks on the internet and be uh just understand that you'll get what you pay for the
03:43:40 bottom line is this thank you snico for revealing yourself for the the main thing of saying in
03:43:44 mamdani's new york in the islamic republic of new of new yorkistan as he called it uh islam
03:43:50 inshallah will take over every single house so i just want to thank you for revealing yourself 0.70
03:43:54 burry's rage baited these guys so much man you know everyone is losing their minds man
03:43:58 it's like i think it was like a trending thing on twitter this clip
03:44:03 uh let me look here this still trending 0.98
03:44:07 yep holy shit 141 000 posts holy 0.84
03:44:15 hey 0.99
03:44:23 say what you want to say but that's a lot of fucking eyeballs on this content man so 0.98
03:44:31 and if anything it's just gonna galvanate you know his muslim fans even more he's just gonna 0.97
03:44:37 get more support so uh you guys can go ahead people can hate on him or whatever but um all 0.99
03:44:45 it's gonna do is rally his fan base even more so shout out to sneak i stand by him i don't go fuck 0.99
03:44:49 what these faggots say you know what i mean he's my guy you know i mean we could disagree on some 1.00
03:44:57 shit we had a whole discussion about mom donnie and socialism the other day i don't agree with it 1.00
03:45:01 but i'm not gonna fucking like just bash him when everyone else is bashing him i don't do that to 0.99
03:45:06 any of my friends bro when they came at nick i'm not gonna fucking you know oh he's a fed get the 1.00
03:45:12 fuck out of here with that bullshit oh sneeko is saying this so i get the fuck out of here with 1.00
03:45:17 this bullshit oh say he's a rapist get the fuck out of here with this bullshit you know i mean 1.00
03:45:21 i'm not gonna switch up on my friends because it's the popular thing to do 1.00
03:45:26 That's gay 1.00
03:45:27 It's faggotry 1.00
03:45:30 It's bullshit 1.00
03:45:31 Yes, it sucks that my friends aren't getting along 1.00
03:45:33 Yes, it does suck 0.97
03:45:34 Big in the middle 0.95
03:45:35 But maybe one day I can, you know 0.98
03:45:38 Fucking bring everybody together 0.98
03:45:41 But yeah, no 0.99
03:45:42 He's, you know, this is
03:45:44 This is huge marketing for Sneeko, man
03:45:48 So I'm happy for him 0.99
03:45:49 He has some people fucking mad 0.97
03:45:52 He definitely has some people pissed off 0.98
03:45:56 that's for sure uh let's see here what else we got
03:46:04 now they're saying most abakamani attended the funeral
03:46:10 i don't know about that that'd be very dangerous to do that
03:46:20 guys apparently 20 million people 20 million people showed up to this funeral bro
03:46:25 biggest funeral ever
03:46:28 yeah this is correct by the way i read this um
03:46:39 this is very this is very correct what nick said about like when it comes to activism
03:46:44 i agree with nick on um you can't show your power level dude take it from me dude take it from me
03:46:54 a guy that used to work for the federal government a guy that you know was out here catching criminals 0.99
03:46:58 and you know had a clearance and all this shit man take it from me dude um hide your power level man 1.00
03:47:04 i get it you're aware that women are stupid i get it you're aware that blacks commit crime 1.00
03:47:13 i get it you're aware that fucking trainees shouldn't have guns blacks are criminals 1.00
03:47:19 Asians are good at math 1.00
03:47:21 And eat dogs 1.00
03:47:23 Right 1.00
03:47:24 White dudes can't dance 0.99
03:47:27 And are corny 1.00
03:47:29 White women are whores 1.00
03:47:30 I get it 1.00
03:47:31 You know
03:47:31 Fantastic 1.00
03:47:32 Hide that shit man 1.00
03:47:34 Okay 1.00
03:47:35 Hide that shit 1.00
03:47:37 Hide that shit dude 1.00
03:47:40 We live in a very 1.00
03:47:41 Pussified society dude 0.83
03:47:43 So like if you show any 0.98
03:47:45 Like baseness
03:47:46 Like people are gonna ostracize you
03:47:48 Like I'll give you an example bro
03:47:50 There's an agent I used to work with back in the day
03:47:52 I talked with him like
03:47:56 Like two days ago
03:47:57 Bro's like oh
03:48:00 You out in the Klan hood
03:48:02 Okay
03:48:04 It's a joke 0.97
03:48:05 Hey bro that was fucked up it's not funny to me 1.00
03:48:08 Bitch ass nigga 1.00
03:48:09 This is a dude I used to joke with and shit like that man 1.00
03:48:14 But everyone's fucking soft and gay 1.00
03:48:16 Now dude 1.00
03:48:18 So, you know, even people that you make jokes with, people that you rock with, they might become woke faggots later, bro. 1.00
03:48:24 So you just got to hide your power levels, guys. 1.00
03:48:27 You got to hide your power level. 0.91
03:48:29 I don't want y'all, like, showing your power level and then you fucking lose opportunities. 0.94
03:48:35 So I 100% agree with Nick on that. 0.97
03:48:37 100%. 0.99
03:48:38 I don't want you guys to get fucking canceled like me. 0.98
03:48:41 And I'm sure Nick doesn't want you guys to get canceled like him. 0.97
03:48:49 Take it from a guy that went to a good school.
03:48:51 This is what you guys do.
03:48:55 You work really hard in high school. 0.99
03:48:57 Okay, you work really fucking hard. 0.97
03:48:59 You do extracurricular activities. 0.99
03:49:01 You stay away from drugs.
03:49:03 You stay away from alcohol. 1.00
03:49:04 You don't get no bitches pregnant. 1.00
03:49:07 You study for your SATs or ACTs. 1.00
03:49:11 You get into a good fucking school. 1.00
03:49:15 Preferably Ivy League. 1.00
03:49:16 I'm giving you guys the fucking game right now 1.00
03:49:18 Listen up faggots 1.00
03:49:19 Pay attention 1.00
03:49:23 Pay attention
03:49:24 As someone that went to a top tier university
03:49:26 With a 6% acceptance rate
03:49:28 I'm telling you guys what you have to do
03:49:29 You want to have power
03:49:32 You want to have influence
03:49:33 You want to have motion
03:49:34 This is what you do 0.99
03:49:36 You work really fucking hard in high school 0.99
03:49:40 Okay 0.99
03:49:41 You learn to write well
03:49:43 You learn to read well
03:49:45 you study for your SATs
03:49:47 take as many AP classes
03:49:49 as you can
03:49:50 okay
03:49:52 do extracurricular activities
03:49:54 play a sport especially
03:49:56 if you can
03:49:57 if you can't, join band
03:49:59 learn an instrument
03:50:01 do something that will give you an edge 1.00
03:50:04 fucking learn fencing, I don't give a shit 0.99
03:50:06 the Ivy League's have division one fencing 1.00
03:50:08 then
03:50:11 I want you to
03:50:12 and then I also want you to get a tutor that's going to prep you
03:50:15 to go to an Ivy League school. 0.99
03:50:17 You're going to apply to all the fucking Ivy League schools. 0.99
03:50:19 You're going to apply to all the top private universities 0.99
03:50:21 in the country.
03:50:23 Okay? 1.00
03:50:24 So all the Ivies, 0.95
03:50:26 Stanford, 0.97
03:50:27 Northeastern,
03:50:28 Northwestern,
03:50:30 right?
03:50:32 Avoid schools in the South.
03:50:33 I'm not going to lie. 1.00
03:50:34 Schools in the South is for stupid faggots, dude. 1.00
03:50:36 I'm going to be very honest with y'all. 1.00
03:50:38 All the top schools are in the fucking Northeast, dude. 0.98
03:50:41 I'm going to keep it a million with y'all. 1.00
03:50:43 all the top schools are in the fucking northeast all right the schools in the south are for fucking 1.00
03:50:48 stupid retards and sluts and motherfuckers that want to play sports and just like oh yeah i want 1.00
03:50:53 a tailgate if you really want to acquire power the top schools are in the northeast ivy league 1.00
03:50:58 especially okay rub elbows with the jews pretend that you like them okay and there's gonna be some 1.00
03:51:05 cool ones of course but pretend you like the zionist ones keep your nose down work hard get 0.99
03:51:12 a fucking job get into power and then you infiltrate from within but you have to get within 1.00
03:51:19 before you can infiltrate the problem is you guys fucking show your power levels too early 1.00
03:51:24 and you get fucking cooked MIT is another fantastic school yes 0.99
03:51:28 yeah Duke's okay 0.98
03:51:33 but there's better schools uh up north so yeah guys that's that's what you guys got to do
03:51:43 that's what you guys got to do work really fucking hard to get into an ivy league school
03:51:48 if you really want to take over okay and the beating with the ivy league schools guys 0.84
03:51:55 is like for example harvard um harvard for example like they got a financial aid system
03:52:02 where, like, you could damn near go to school for free.
03:52:04 It's, like, based off how much your parents make.
03:52:07 All the Ivy's have, like, really good financial aid packages
03:52:10 for their students.
03:52:13 And let me tell y'all something.
03:52:16 It's not good that going to an Ivy League school
03:52:18 is, like, going to give you a better education.
03:52:20 That's not why you go to these schools. 0.99
03:52:23 You go to these schools because they have elite fucking networks. 0.99
03:52:25 Let me make that clear, too. 1.00
03:52:28 These schools have elite networks.
03:52:30 How do you guys think I got a job with HSI?
03:52:32 you guys ever think about that the school i went to okay had an intern program called the co-op
03:52:39 program a lot of top the top brass at hsi went to northeastern
03:52:45 so i come in i got good grades i'm a division one athlete i speak arabic picked up
03:52:56 i got the internship and then i was able to become an agent after that why did i get that 0.94
03:53:01 opportunity because i went to a good fucking school here's the thing with college you can't 0.96
03:53:10 go to a low tier or shit tier or a mid-tier university anymore those days are done there 0.99
03:53:14 used to be you could go to some shitty ass state school and get a good job those days are done 1.00
03:53:18 faggots those days are done you have to go to an elite institution nowadays if you want to get a 1.00
03:53:22 job fresh out of college or get a good job because it's all about networks that's what it's about 1.00
03:53:26 now it's all about networks and the good schools have the networks all right anyway uh let's get 0.97
03:53:36 back the trial's back let's get back to it but that's how you do it guys okay i want y'all niggas 0.97
03:53:43 to win uh let's clear up this fucking shit a little bit i got a lot of tabs open 0.95
03:53:49 give me once in the chat if that makes sense give me once in the chat if that all makes sense for 0.98
03:53:58 you guys didn't know okay and you also mentioned that you've done SWAT in the past yes um were you
03:54:06 a were you a sniper I was I worked well with them but I was not a sniper okay
03:54:10 so when you all right awesome I'm glad that that can help some of you guys because I know we got
03:54:16 a lot of young you guys in here man so yes for the most part to summarize college is a scam for
03:54:22 most schools and for most people but if you go to a good school get good grades especially ivy league
03:54:26 schools that's where you get the opportunities because you get fantastic networks that's what
03:54:30 you're really paying for when you go to these ivy league schools that's why they are so hard 0.99
03:54:33 to get in you're guaranteed a fucking gig because they control the fucking world 0.99
03:54:36 you okay just strike that 1.00
03:54:39 also we talked where was myron 10 years ago hey man i was on the southwest border nigga 1.00
03:54:46 you guys could thank your fuck you guys could thank your lucky stars that i'm on the internet 0.99
03:54:51 now though sharing this sauce with y'all talked about the holster the holster that was found 1.00
03:54:56 are you aware there were any other guns confiscated on the scene that day i'm not
03:55:01 you don't know one way or the other i don't know
03:55:05 All right, and I want to go through with you your timeline.
03:55:14 You mentioned that you started at the Hall of Flags, right?
03:55:20 And then you came down, it took you a minute to kind of navigate the stairs with the crowd
03:55:24 and the chaos and everything, and then you were in the grassy area of the courtyard
03:55:30 for a bit.
03:55:31 Is that right?
03:55:32 Yeah, so about 30 seconds to get down the stairs, and then I went right down to where the tent was.
03:55:36 And that's where you found the holster?
03:55:39 No, the holster was up higher.
03:55:42 So I went down by the tent, so it was lower level.
03:55:44 So as I came down towards where Charlie Kirk was shot, I went down towards the tent to see what was going on down there
03:55:51 because I didn't know exactly what.
03:55:53 I heard the gun shot, didn't know exactly what was going on because I was above the tent.
03:55:56 I'm sorry, I missed that you went down to the tent.
03:55:57 So let me ask you about that.
03:55:59 So what did you do when you got down to the tent?
03:56:01 When I got down to the tent, Charlie was gone.
03:56:03 They put him in an SUV and left.
03:56:07 At that moment, there were still some people running around,
03:56:09 so I decided to preserve the scene as much as I could with trying to escort people out,
03:56:14 and that's when I went back in and started pushing people off the grass area
03:56:17 to conserve any ammunition or any casings or anything to that effect that would be around.
03:56:22 I wanted to make sure people were off, and there was as much evidence preserved as possible.
03:56:26 So just to be clear, by the time you got to the tent,
03:56:28 Mr. Kirk had already been removed and taken from the scene. Is that right? Yes, okay
03:56:35 So in your professional opinion, what was what was the perimeter of the crime scene?
03:56:42 What do you mean by a parameter so the perimeter like how far did this crime scene stretch?
03:56:47 Like where did you want people to move off of well first? I wanted them all off the grass because like I said is I
03:56:54 Thought we had a suspect in custody. So to me would be a close encounter
03:56:57 So I was trying to push everybody off the grass in case there were shell casings or to that fact that I got on the grass
03:57:02 So after I pushed them off to that part
03:57:05 And getting up to the top where I saw that empty holster
03:57:09 When I saw that empty holster is when it things start slowing down for me a little bit
03:57:13 All the chaos and stuff is that's when I realized that was a rifle shot not a handgun shot
03:57:17 Okay, and that's when you saw the low C building and it occurred you should go check it out. Yes
03:57:22 it was right in my line of sight and
03:57:25 Correct me if I'm wrong, but
03:57:27 And you, the whole time that this is going on, you had an active body camera on your, I guess your collar, is that right?
03:57:36 I was right on my chest, yes.
03:57:37 Okay, and it was on?
03:57:38 Yes.
03:57:40 And it appears to me from reviewing your body camera that there was another individual who was...
03:57:46 And just so you know, that's why a lot of police officers aren't going to put too much detail in their police reports because there's no need to do it.
03:57:52 FYI.
03:57:53 Okay?
03:57:54 the reason why his police report might not have certain details like where the shot came from
03:58:00 or whatever is because you can literally see it or you can see everything with the body cam
03:58:04 so it's actually better to keep your police report fairly vague and let the body cam handle
03:58:10 everything else with you that went to the low c building who was in civilian clothing but
03:58:16 appeared to have a gun who's that i i don't know who he was exactly like when i used to interview
03:58:21 bad guys what i would do is i would give like a quick little summary like bullet points and then
03:58:25 i'd say for the full interview here's the video attached to evidence boom that's it
03:58:29 exactly he had a badge on and i had somebody with me to back me up as i ran up the stairs
03:58:36 to make sure i had somebody with me so you don't know what agency he's from or where he's from no
03:58:41 and he it looked like he had a pistol yes is that right a handgun yes a handgun yeah um and so the
03:58:49 two of you go to the low c building yes did when you uh mr goodfell says mine's the big bro we
03:58:57 wish we had appreciate the wise words brother got you guys man gotcha man i want you guys to win 0.98
03:59:00 dude not get in trouble or ruin opportunities man don't talk about jews blacks and women 1.00
03:59:06 in public bro those are the three groups of people that will get you fucked up or fags 1.00
03:59:11 don't talk to about don't don't talk shit about any of those groups of people publicly bro 1.00
03:59:16 You will get in trouble. 0.99
03:59:18 Reviewed the videotape at the police department later.
03:59:21 Did you check to see if anyone had been on the low C building after the shooting,
03:59:28 after this individual had jumped off that you've already talked about?
03:59:31 Was there anybody else on the roof?
03:59:32 Did you check and see in that gap of time?
03:59:35 In that gap of time, no.
03:59:36 So once I put up the barrier, I only walked up to about that point.
03:59:40 Then I went down and reviewed the video from that moment on.
03:59:43 So were you able to see, are you able to say for one way or the other if anyone else had been on that roof in between when the person jumped off the building and when you came on the roof?
03:59:54 Are you able to say one way or the other?
03:59:56 There was people up there looking for an individual that ran that way because when I first got told the individual ran heading north, we didn't know where the shooter was.
04:00:04 So we started climbing up and looking, clearing the building.
04:00:07 And it wasn't until I went to the PD and actually saw him jump off of the building that I knew he was off the building.
04:00:12 let me rephrase that because i think i'm i either asked it badly or you misunderstood me so let me
04:00:18 let me go back again so from the time that the individual that you spot if you guys appreciate
04:00:23 that advice that i gave you guys the best way to support show love back join the oss guys
04:00:27 that is the best way to show love back i'll drop the link in here for you guys just use the code
04:00:34 um l youtube those are the two best ways to support the mission you can either give the
04:00:42 up or join oss dollar the first month 10 bucks after that that's how i'm able to do what i do 1.00
04:00:47 and say what i say despite the fact that youtube has me demonetize those fucking kike faggots 0.99
04:00:51 bought it on the video jumped off the roof right the individual that you thought was in the prone 0.99
04:00:57 position okay between that and when you got on the roof did you ever check to see if anybody else
04:01:03 had been on the roof in that period of time yeah and i didn't see anybody so you didn't link is in
04:01:08 did you look on the video to see that entire okay that's what i'm asking so you did not
04:01:17 review the video to see if there was someone between you that individual jumping off and you
04:01:22 coming on if anybody had been on or disturbed that scene in any way okay but once you put the
04:01:27 tape up you're then we're confident from that point on the scene was preserved right um by the
04:01:34 where did you get that tape officers responded on the scene that he was down
04:01:39 on the bottom threw it up to me so okay so you didn't have it on you no and you
04:01:45 didn't leave the scene to go get it no someone threw it up yes great
04:01:54 all right
04:01:57 while you were on the roof did you encounter any spent casings as a matter of fact no that's why
04:02:05 when i i saw the prone position where the person would be laying down a sniper uh oh guys by the
04:02:11 way um for twitter chat i made it where everyone can comment my bad i think i had it on verified 0.97
04:02:16 only before so all you and on fucking losers can comment in there too so feel free to jump 0.98
04:02:23 to chat faggots being around guns and snipers all the time i was looking for a spent shell casing i 1.00
04:02:27 couldn't see one i was looking over the edge looking all over the place making sure the gravel 0.99
04:02:31 wasn't disturbed and i couldn't find a shell casing at that moment and that would be the reason
04:02:35 you would be looking for that was because some types of guns when they shoot eject a casing
04:02:40 automatically right some do some don't yes all right um and then you also didn't find any
04:02:47 unshot bullets? No. Okay.
04:02:51 Are you aware of there being a bullet found on another roof?
04:02:55 I'm not aware. In the vicinity? Were you aware of
04:02:58 another bullet being found on the scene, not on the roof of the Losey building? I know.
04:03:05 Alright, your body
04:03:06 cam footage that I reviewed appears to end
04:03:10 while you're still on the roof. Do you know why that is?
04:03:14 I think the battery went dead. It was just right at that moment.
04:03:17 Okay. And do you know, did you ever turn it back on that day or go get it, I don't know, what do you have to do, charge it or stick a new battery in it? I don't even know.
04:03:27 Usually dock it, but no, I didn't go back. I was too, it was too chaotic running around.
04:03:32 So that 27 minute and 35 second body cam that starts when you're at the Hall of Flags and ends while you're still on the roof, but haven't put the crime tape up yet, that's the only body cam you have that day?
04:03:46 Yes.
04:03:47 You mentioned when you went to the police department, you watched the video where you saw an individual up on the roof, right?
04:04:00 And that individual was in the vicinity where you saw the disturbance in the gravel.
04:04:05 Yes.
04:04:08 And when you looked at that video, were you able to identify the individual's face?
04:04:14 I know.
04:04:14 Were you able to identify any markings on their clothing?
04:04:18 No.
04:04:19 Were you able to identify their height?
04:04:22 No.
04:04:23 When you all, when we looked at the picture of the, I think you called it the sniper perch,
04:04:30 so I'm going to use your words, it looked like there was a measuring tape laid out next to it.
04:04:36 Did you ever, were you present when they measured, like, the distance, like how long,
04:04:40 how tall that person would have been?
04:04:41 I was not.
04:04:42 So you don't know what that is?
04:04:44 I don't.
04:04:47 Were you able to tell the person's weight from the video that you saw?
04:04:51 I can tell he wasn't heavy set.
04:04:54 Okay.
04:04:54 More of a skinnier person.
04:04:57 Could you identify what shoes they were wearing?
04:05:01 I could not.
04:05:01 Could you identify anything about a hat or what was on their head?
04:05:06 At the moment, no, I couldn't.
04:05:08 Okay.
04:05:08 and did you see a gun in the video i saw a long black object in the left hand as he was running
04:05:21 over across the roof and in fact did you describe that in your report as a bag i don't know i have
04:05:28 no idea i don't know why all right let's pull that report back up please
04:05:34 and what she's referring to guys is the video um which i'll show you guys quickly here um
04:05:48 hold on
04:05:55 i'll show you guys it real fast um it was uh yeah there we go tyler
04:06:01 bob and some roof
04:06:04 I'll just have this just saved
04:06:06 so you guys can look at it
04:06:08 you guys can see
04:06:17 there he is right there
04:06:27 oh
04:06:28 never mind
04:06:28 I don't think you mentioned what you saw
04:06:30 So in your report, let's do pull that back up, please, page five on the Bagley one.
04:06:39 So looking at the second page, you're actually going to have to go to page six, I think.
04:06:47 You talk about what you saw in the video where they jumped off the roof.
04:06:52 And again, I'm going to remind you of our conversation we had before about you understand how important these reports are.
04:06:58 And do you mention anywhere in this report that you saw a gun?
04:07:05 I did not. I just had an object.
04:07:07 Did you mention that you saw that object? Is that on here?
04:07:12 No.
04:07:13 Okay, so you left that out.
04:07:16 Now have you looked at that over and over again?
04:07:19 The video? No, I've only seen it twice.
04:07:22 Oh, really? When's the last time you saw it?
04:07:24 It's been months.
04:07:25 Okay. The last time you saw it, were you able to tell what that object was in his hand?
04:07:31 Yes. Well, not tell what it is. I can see there's an object in that left hand, yes.
04:07:35 And could you, knowing what you know about the case today, do you have an idea about what that object was?
04:07:40 It looks like a rifle or something to that effect along.
04:07:44 Here, let's go ahead and go through it.
04:07:46 So here he is running.
04:07:51 I'm going to give you guys full screen here. Let me get my face out the way so y'all can see it.
04:07:55 in full. Hold on. Rewind a little bit.
04:08:08 See, I placed something down. It looks like something is draped over something that's rigid
04:08:13 or stiff. He grabs it again. Jumps down.
04:08:18 adjusts it
04:08:21 and then uh takes off
04:08:25 but this is the video that she's uh that the uh defense attorney is referring to
04:08:44 long object it looks like a rifle like a long object like skinny long you can see it's like
04:08:54 almost like it's covered over something so you saw the cover which was the towel right yes and
04:09:00 the shape of it is long okay so you can see a towel but you can't see an act i don't know if
04:09:05 it was a towel or blanket i don't know what it was but you can't see an actual gun no like an object
04:09:11 like a form of a gun, like a long object.
04:09:14 Okay.
04:09:19 All right. 0.98
04:09:25 She's running out of steam.
04:09:27 At the end of that day, what time did you leave the campus?
04:09:32 It was probably like 9 o'clock that night, maybe somewhere around there.
04:09:35 And did you come back the next morning and work some more?
04:09:38 I came back the next morning, yes.
04:09:39 and you worked all day the next day uh on and off when you left at 9 p.m did you or anyone else
04:09:48 know who the shooter was on that day i know not that i know and when i mean he's just a campus
04:09:53 cop at the time they're not going to know anything at that point it was the case was had been handed
04:09:57 over to um the state bureau investigation uh part of the state police and fbi and etf at that point
04:10:04 this guy he he had no oversight of the investigation whatsoever you came back the
04:10:11 next morning and worked that afternoon all that day did you anybody you or anybody on that campus
04:10:16 know who the shooter was uh not that i know of yeah patrolmen are not going to be privy to that
04:10:21 at all like once he put out that crime tape investor comes in and takes over it's over dude
04:10:30 they're like you know honestly they could tell they could have even told like the the campus 0.93
04:10:37 police like fuck off because i'm sure this campus this campus police department probably had like 0.84
04:10:40 a couple detectives they could have even told them like we're not going to share anything with 1.00
04:10:44 you guys it's our case now so you know and that's a detective from his police department
04:10:50 let alone a patrolman he's not going to know anything dude once that crime scene tape goes
04:10:55 off they check out okay so nothing that you found that day or anyone else to your knowledge
04:11:04 on campus was able to identify who the shooter was and that they know right well during the time
04:11:12 I was there now that I knew I just want to talk to you about that giant picture that was showed
04:11:17 to you. Do you know, exhibit 35, I think? Yes, it's exhibit 35. Do you know who took that picture,
04:11:26 where it came from? I do not. Do you know how old it is? I have no idea. Okay.
04:11:36 And the pictures you were shown, exhibits one, two, and three, that you got up and kind of talked
04:11:41 about and showed all the buildings and everything. Do you have any knowledge about where those
04:11:45 pictures came from? Yes, they were drone footage just taken from a drone. Do you know who was
04:11:50 operating the drone? Sergeant Ken Nelson from Provo Police Department. Provo Police Department.
04:11:55 Had you seen those pictures before today? Before today, yes. When did you see them? A couple weeks
04:12:01 ago. And that was just in preparation for testifying? Yes. Prior to that, had you ever seen those
04:12:07 pictures? Can I have the court's indulgence for just a moment, Your Honor? You may, Mr.
04:12:24 got some big news in the middle east guys that just dropped uh i'll talk about it
04:12:36 during the next break
04:12:37 one last uh thing i want to clarify we heard you testify that
04:12:54 ms richards or i don't know if she's deputy richards she's a she's a state employee for 0.98
04:12:58 the frenzy lab so ms richards um she which is common um you know local police departments
04:13:05 typically don't have like you know crime labs so what ended up happening is like you know the
04:13:09 state will come in and give assistance because the state police labs are always very good hell
04:13:13 i used the dps lab all the time when i was an agent in texas he is the one who took those night
04:13:17 the Texas DPS lab time pictures of this stuff on the roof yes and it you testified that she told
04:13:24 you that that was what they looked like that day yes when did you meet with her I talked to her on
04:13:30 the phone it was several weeks ago in preparation for the trial so prior to a couple weeks ago you
04:13:35 never discussed those pictures because I'd never seen them oh so a couple weeks goes the first time
04:13:39 you saw them all right and did you write any kind of supplement to your report to add on to your
04:13:46 report other than what we've gone through today that one report you wrote have you ever written
04:13:51 another one i have not okay that's all i have thank god i tender the witness thank you miss
04:13:56 okay um now we're going to get the second witness i think this next witness is going to be a lot
04:14:01 better this is probably going to be one of the um one of the case agents so let's see who the
04:14:06 who the prosecutor is going to call mr grunander redirect just one question i believe judge all
04:14:12 Okay, so yeah, the prosecutor's going to do a redirect.
04:14:19 He's going to come in and clarify anything that the defense attorney might have, you know, was able to get him to trip up on, which honestly, it wasn't much.
04:14:27 Officer Bagley, if we could pull up State's Exhibit 1.
04:14:29 But like, witnesses like this are like, you know, he's just a patrolman.
04:14:34 What are you going to argue with him about?
04:14:35 The layout of the campus?
04:14:37 Where the buildings are located?
04:14:39 What he saw as a first responder?
04:14:42 Can't really, like, grill these guys that much.
04:14:44 Let's do that.
04:14:53 You've talked about this handgun holster that you observed on the grass in the courtyard.
04:15:00 I'm going to ask you if you would approach the monitor when it comes up
04:15:04 and point out as best you can where you observed that holster, okay?
04:15:11 your voice and that's where i could see straight up where oh finally nice sight was okay thank
04:15:35 you nothing further judge all right all right may this witness be excused yes your honor yes
04:15:41 he's like thank god get me out of here
04:15:44 just for the benefit of those in attendance that you may have noticed i drink some water please
04:15:54 if you have water and what's been previously approved don't hesitate yours you can drink
04:15:58 just don't spill it um and let's go to the states uh ready to proceed with your next witness thank
04:16:03 you judge this day calls david hull all right all right david hull is the uh second witness
04:16:09 I'll turn to Jutu back on here in a little bit.
04:16:13 Would you like to come forward and be sworn in?
04:16:16 You just always pray that the testimony you shall give
04:16:17 in the case now pending before the court
04:16:18 will be the truth, the whole truth,
04:16:19 and nothing but the truth, so help you God.
04:16:21 All right, if you'd like to be seated right here.
04:16:23 I'm speeding it up, guys,
04:16:24 so we can catch up to the live.
04:16:26 And once you're situated,
04:16:27 there's a bottle of water to your left.
04:16:29 And if you wouldn't mind, after you're seated,
04:16:30 bringing that microphone closer to you
04:16:32 so it picks up your voice.
04:16:35 All right, counsel, I'm going to be ready.
04:16:38 Good afternoon.
04:16:38 afternoon uh would you please state your full name and spell your last david hall h-u-l-l
04:16:42 and are you employed i am yes who are you employed by i'm employed by the department of public safety
04:16:46 okay department of public safety how long have you worked for the department of public safety
04:16:49 i'm in my 12th year are you uh are you a peace officer i am yes are you post certified i am yes
04:16:54 when did you receive your certification uh 2015. and since that okay so he's he's a sworn law
04:16:59 enforcement officer time as your certification remain intact in other words has it lapsed or
04:17:02 been taken away or anything like that no it's been continuous you uh you said you're in your
04:17:07 your 12th year did you already say that you're 12th year with the dps uh have you worked for any
04:17:11 other law enforcement agency besides the dps no just the state of utah okay so he basically works
04:17:15 for the department of public safety state police what is your current assignment with the public
04:17:19 safety currently positioned as an investigative sergeant at peace officer stands in training
04:17:22 was that all right peace what is your current assignment with the public safety currently
04:17:27 positioned as an investigative sergeant at peace officer stands in training okay a peace officer
04:17:31 uh investigator sergeant okay was that your assignment in september of 2025 no it was not
04:17:36 What was your assignment then?
04:17:37 I was under the State Bureau of Investigations.
04:17:40 Okay, he was with SBI back then.
04:17:42 Major Crimes Division is an investigator.
04:17:43 Okay, Major Crimes Division.
04:17:45 I told you guys it was Major Crimes that is running this.
04:17:47 For those of you guys that don't know, SBI is the state version for Utah.
04:17:52 Okay?
04:17:53 That is their state police.
04:17:56 Well, it's a component of the state police that does investigations like this,
04:18:00 Major Crimes.
04:18:01 So that's why he was a special agent with SBI.
04:18:04 Is SBI an acronym that's commonly used to describe the State Bureau of Investigation?
04:18:10 It is, yes.
04:18:10 I can refer to it as the SBI, and we're all on the same page, right?
04:18:12 Yep.
04:18:12 Okay. How long were you with the SBI?
04:18:15 A little over seven years.
04:18:17 And what exactly did you do? What was your assignment with the SBI?
04:18:20 I spent just under a year in the Alcohol Bureau and the undercover unit,
04:18:23 and then the remainder of that time was with major crimes.
04:18:25 Major crimes. What did that entail?
04:18:28 Predominantly investigating crimes that are considered to be major in nature.
04:18:32 Predominantly violent crime, including homicide, sexual assault.
04:18:34 In some cases, fraud cases kind of covered a whole gambit of things, but predominantly violent crime.
04:18:40 Basically, sexy cases that prosecutors want to take.
04:18:44 And throughout your career with the DPS, have you done any training related to murder investigations specifically?
04:18:49 Yes, I have.
04:18:50 And could you just briefly describe what that specific training entailed?
04:18:52 I've done internal and external courses around lead homicide investigation, officer-involved critical incidents,
04:19:00 child deaths and unexplained deaths in children, aquatic homicide.
04:19:04 and then just continuing investigations related.
04:19:06 This guy has like an Aussie accent, Chad.
04:19:08 To homicide itself. 1.00
04:19:10 And throughout your career with DPS,
04:19:11 have you either played a role in or led a homicide investigation?
04:19:16 I have, yes.
04:19:17 How many do you think?
04:19:19 Either directly or indirectly.
04:19:20 I've probably been involved in approximately 40 or so.
04:19:22 Yeah, so basically, you know,
04:19:25 so as you guys can see the trend here,
04:19:28 what they're doing is they're introducing the witness
04:19:31 and showing how the witness is credible and reliable
04:19:33 and is an expert in what they're about to talk about,
04:19:36 which in this case is a murder investigation.
04:19:38 That's why he's asking these questions.
04:19:39 Is that throughout the state of Utah?
04:19:40 Yes, we assist throughout the state of Utah.
04:19:43 Were you working September 10th of 2025?
04:19:45 I was, yes.
04:19:46 And did you work shifts?
04:19:49 Did you work a certain shift that day, or how does it work with the SBI?
04:19:52 Kind of worked 24-7, 365, but predominantly Monday through Thursday, office hours.
04:19:56 On that date, were you asked to respond to the campus of Utah Valley University?
04:19:59 Yeah, the same thing with special aides.
04:20:00 It's like you work whenever because, you know, you're an investigator,
04:20:03 so you're working all types of weird hours.
04:20:06 I was, yeah.
04:20:07 I was at the office in Taylorsville when I was asked to respond down to Utah Valley University.
04:20:10 Okay.
04:20:11 And what did you understand was going on at UVU that day?
04:20:13 I didn't know much.
04:20:14 I had been told that there was some kind of an event and an individual had been shot.
04:20:17 Did you have a name?
04:20:18 Someone had told me that Charlie Kirk had been shot.
04:20:21 At that point in time, were you familiar with Charlie Kirk?
04:20:23 I was not, no.
04:20:23 Okay.
04:20:24 Did you end up responding?
04:20:25 So when you found out that there was an event that it was Charlie Kirk that had been shot,
04:20:27 that was while you were still up in Taylorsville at your office?
04:20:30 Yes, we hadn't been asked to respond at that point.
04:20:32 Another agent in the office showed me a video of the shooting,
04:20:34 and I went back to work because we hadn't been asked to respond at that point.
04:20:37 At some point, though, were you asked to respond or directed to respond to Utah Valley?
04:20:40 Yes, we were.
04:20:40 We were asked to make our way down to the university to provide any kind of assistance that was needed.
04:20:44 Do you recall who directed you to come down to Utah Valley?
04:20:46 I believe it was Lieutenant Jensen.
04:20:49 And is that something responding to a scene like this, on a report like that,
04:20:54 is that something that's done frequently within the SBI?
04:20:57 Yeah, SBI functions as a supplementary investigative division for really anybody in the state who needs it,
04:21:02 whether it's a smaller local agency that just needs additional resources.
04:21:05 We often respond with the crime lab to help process crime scenes,
04:21:07 but it would be normal for us to be called out to assist another agency.
04:21:10 Okay, so we understand correctly.
04:21:11 When you were first directed to come down to Utah Valley,
04:21:13 you were just coming down to give whatever help you could provide?
04:21:16 Correct.
04:21:16 Okay. That eventually changed?
04:21:18 Yes. My assumption was we were responding to assist process a crime scene, essentially.
04:21:22 Prior to September 10th, 2025, how familiar were you with the Utah Valley University campus?
04:21:28 Not very. I think I maybe had been there once before.
04:21:30 How about from September 10th onward? Did you become more familiar with the campus?
04:21:33 Became a lot more familiar with the campus, yes.
04:21:34 And in what way or how?
04:21:36 Both in walking the campus and looking at the incident scene, in viewing surveillance video of the campus and the surrounding areas,
04:21:43 and just my general involvement in the investigation.
04:21:45 I became a lot more familiar with the buildings, the amphitheater, and the surrounding area, and the campus itself.
04:21:50 We'll come back to that here in a moment.
04:21:51 Who else responded to UVU from the SBA?
04:21:56 Originally, I thought it was just myself and a couple of others.
04:21:58 I remember Sergeant Falmina, Sergeant Bricker, Sergeant L. Schultz, Sergeant Clark,
04:22:04 Agent Brian Davis, and a number of other agents were arriving or were on scene when I arrived there.
04:22:10 Do you recall if other law enforcement agencies responded that same day?
04:22:14 Yes, there was a large law enforcement presence.
04:22:16 Federal entities, I believe the FBI, the DEA, ATF, I think some U.S. marshals.
04:22:22 There was obviously our state presence, and then there was county and city and local agencies on scene also.
04:22:26 Everybody was there, bro.
04:22:27 So have all these folks responded by the time you got here, or have they responded prior to?
04:22:30 Some could have been on scene prior to.
04:22:31 Some were arriving while I was arriving.
04:22:32 Others arrived later.
04:22:34 I know there were several forensic units from various entities, including the state crime lab and other agencies.
04:22:39 And did you interact with all these different agencies, you personally?
04:22:43 Throughout the course of the following few days, probably the majority of them, yes.
04:22:46 I think you related that originally the SBI was directed to come down just to see if you could help.
04:22:51 Is that fair to say?
04:22:52 Yeah, that was all I knew when I left the office was to go down and see what services, what can you do to help.
04:22:56 And I asked you earlier if that role changed, and I believe you said it did.
04:22:59 So let's talk about that.
04:23:00 How did your role change from what you initially came down to do to whatever it evolved into?
04:23:03 Having been on scene for a little while, there were some conversations and discussions that took place,
04:23:06 and I was informed by my lieutenant that myself and Agent Davis would be taking
04:23:11 lead on the investigation on behalf of the State Bureau of Investigations. So the
04:23:15 SBI was going to be the lead investigative agency? Correct. And you were
04:23:18 going to be the lead case agent? Yes sir. Along with Agent Davis? Okay. What does it
04:23:25 mean to be the lead investigator or the lead case agent? It depends on the
04:23:29 situation but predominantly you're responsible for kind of directing the
04:23:33 investigation coordinating information that is coming in typically seems a
04:23:36 fairly chaotic initially so you're trying to process as much information as
04:23:39 possible and make as much use of the available resources that you have kind
04:23:43 of an organizational role would probably be a good way to describe it so you you
04:23:45 played an active role in organizing in coordination with with the
04:23:49 administrations of all of the agencies that were on scene we were trying to
04:23:51 coordinate efforts and and get to put an information as quickly as possible do
04:23:55 recall whether assignments were made at least with the SBI agents that responded
04:23:58 with you yeah we have a core group within major crimes that were assigned
04:24:01 specific tasks. And do they include the agents that you mentioned just a minute ago? Yes, I believe so.
04:24:05 So each one of those agents with the SPI were given a specific assignment? Yes, with the information
04:24:09 we had, the agents were assigned to do specific things. And do you remember specifically what assignments
04:24:13 were given to who? Yes, Sergeant Faumina was asked to coordinate with the
04:24:17 State Crime Lab and the responding crime scene techs to manage and process any identified
04:24:21 crime scenes. Sergeant Mark Bricker was put in touch with UVU's
04:24:25 surveillance and operations team to start working through any available footage
04:24:29 or information that we had that had been recorded.
04:24:31 Sergeant Clark was tasked with the area canvas
04:24:35 around the campus area, looking for information.
04:24:38 Nightmare, thank you.
04:24:39 And I'll explain more of this for you guys.
04:24:40 I just don't want to interrupt too much.
04:24:41 I'll explain more of this for you guys later.
04:24:43 ...or any available information
04:24:44 from the immediate area around campus.
04:24:46 Sergeant L. Schultz was working with the SIAC
04:24:49 and other administration to try and manage
04:24:51 the flow of information that had started to occur.
04:24:54 You said that initially when you showed up,
04:24:55 things were a bit chaotic.
04:24:57 Yes.
04:24:57 Did that have something to do
04:24:58 with all the different agencies that had responded yes and i think initially there was still some
04:25:02 uncertainty as to whether we were we were working with an active an active shooter or or an active
04:25:06 crime scene the campus is spread over a large area and so so getting that um deemed to be safe is
04:25:11 quite a process and involved a lot of people yeah securing the area what it was a nightmare
04:25:15 so they had to do that first before they can actually collect any evidence seriously gotcha
04:25:19 do you know if the the campus was um deemed safe eventually eventually my understanding is the
04:25:25 campus was locked down and secured and we were able to start getting people in
04:25:28 to start processing crime scenes and doing additional things okay you said
04:25:32 it sounds like that chaos eventually subsided you got organized and
04:25:35 assignments were made what was the first thing that you did as lead
04:25:38 investigator I kind of became organized chaos but but we did have a plan and our
04:25:41 priority was determining whether we had an ability or a way to be able to
04:25:44 identify who had been involved in the shooting that was our that was our
04:25:48 primary focus at that time did that include collecting information that was
04:25:51 becoming available yes we were getting a large volume of information from the
04:25:54 general public phone tips people sending videos analysts were scrolling through
04:25:59 social media and social sites as people were posting information onto the
04:26:01 internet so there was a lot of information coming in a lot of things
04:26:05 that needed to be processed through and worked okay we're videos coming in yes
04:26:08 cell phone videos were coming in if you imagine there's 3,000 people on event
04:26:12 and everybody has a cell phone it was a lot of information that people were
04:26:14 willing to share with us right did you know whether you or someone else with
04:26:18 the SBI collected or received a video from an Amanda Wright yes yeah I know a
04:26:22 A cell phone video was collected from Amanda Wright.
04:26:24 Or Amber Wright.
04:26:25 Oh, I'm sorry, Amber.
04:26:26 Well, you tell me, Amanda or Amber?
04:26:29 Amber.
04:26:29 Okay, I apologize for that wrong first name.
04:26:32 Do you know who or how that video was collected?
04:26:35 Yeah, I spoke with Ms. Wright directly on the phone to arrange a time to go and collect that video.
04:26:38 Unfortunately, she wasn't available that day, but Agent Davis was able to go and meet with her directly and collect the video.
04:26:43 Do you recall that you actually spoke to Ms. Wright?
04:26:45 If I can refresh my recollection, I specifically...
04:26:48 Sure, let me ask you this before you do that.
04:26:49 Yes, sir.
04:26:49 So you have in front of you, what, your police report?
04:26:52 I have some notes and a timeline for my investigation that was part of discovery.
04:26:55 And referencing that timeline or those notes, will they help you recall the date that you called Ms. Wright?
04:27:00 They will, yes.
04:27:01 Okay.
04:27:01 Why don't you go ahead and refer to that?
04:27:02 Don't read from it out loud.
04:27:03 Just take a minute.
04:27:04 Let me know when you've come across that information and once you've refreshed your memory.
04:27:07 Yeah, I always would bring my report with me as well, you know, to be as accurate as I can be.
04:27:13 Your Honor, when he's done, may I take a look at the materials as well, please?
04:27:16 You may.
04:27:17 Ms. Wright was contacted on April 7th.
04:27:19 Did you want to?
04:27:20 All right.
04:27:22 Ms. Nester, would you like to come forward?
04:27:24 May I approach, Your Honor?
04:27:50 fast forward just a little bit being your the lectrum to my right your right yes it just appears
04:27:56 when the camera's uh focused on you uh just the way it's positioned it's you're you're in front
04:28:01 of the witness and we just want to make sure that yeah it's not gonna go that far i think that that
04:28:06 is sufficient so all right thank you that's a lot better are we still connected w judge all right
04:28:11 let's make sure that mr sturgill is picked up w judge thank you get out the way prosecutor and if
04:28:16 If I can make a correction to that, I think.
04:28:18 Well, let me ask you this first.
04:28:19 So he needs to ask you a question.
04:28:21 So Mr. Sergio.
04:28:22 So you've had a moment to look at your notes?
04:28:24 Did that help you remember the date that you contacted Ms. Wright?
04:28:26 It did, yes.
04:28:26 Okay.
04:28:27 Why don't you go ahead and tell us what date you contacted Ms. Wright?
04:28:29 I contacted her, I think it was April 6th specifically, but Agent Davis met with her on April 7th.
04:28:34 Okay.
04:28:34 Well, that was going to be the next question.
04:28:35 So you actually talked to her on the, was it on the phone?
04:28:37 It was, yes.
04:28:37 And did you arrange a time for either you or Agent Davis to go get the video from Ms. Wright?
04:28:41 Yes.
04:28:41 Is that how it happened?
04:28:41 Yes.
04:28:41 and then you didn't go it was agent davis that went correct okay gotcha
04:28:47 and so what if anything has been done with that video in preparation for today um my understanding
04:28:52 is that some uh edits were made by your office in order to protect some of the participants in
04:28:56 the video okay but what um let me ask you this did you or agent davis visit with miss wright again
04:29:02 yes that was in april and that was um where my correction was uh the video was originally
04:29:07 provided to agent mortenson okay so i miss i misspoke okay let's just let's let's go back
04:29:11 and let's make sure this is very clear sure okay so um someone with the sbi collect i slowed the
04:29:15 speed down to 1.25 guys i did a video yes from from uh amber wright yes agent monson contacted
04:29:21 miss wright on october 8th and a video was provided to him electronically on october 11th
04:29:26 okay and um now i'll ask the next question what if anything has been done either by you or another
04:29:32 agent with that same video in preparation for today's hearing we contacted miss wright to
04:29:37 arrange a meeting so that Ms. Wright could review the video and that we could verify firsthand with
04:29:42 her that the video was what she had taken on September 10th at the event at UVU. Okay and
04:29:47 who had that follow-up visit with Ms. Wright? That was Agent Davis. I was not able to attend. Okay and
04:29:51 you know that happened because you spoke to Agent Davis? I spoke to Agent Davis and he provided me
04:29:55 with a written statement um that Ms. Wright had completed. Okay. In 1102. Okay and so you you have
04:30:01 you have seen that written statement? I have yes. And you've read through it? I have. Does that um
04:30:06 Do you recall whether that statement was on a form or a piece of scratch paper?
04:30:10 What do you recall?
04:30:11 My recollection is that it was on an official, I believe, a State Bureau 1102 statement,
04:30:15 which is a written form that is filled out by a witness that contains the 1102 warning.
04:30:21 And by that, do you mean the advisory that the statement that's written on that piece of paper
04:30:24 is going to be used at a preliminary hearing?
04:30:26 Yes.
04:30:26 It includes that advisory.
04:30:28 Yes.
04:30:28 Does it also include a warning that if someone provides a false statement, in this case Ms. Wright,
04:30:33 that it could be punishable by a class A missionary?
04:30:35 it does yes all right so it seems to me like this woman uh right um last name right uh probably
04:30:52 provided you know probably some of the best um footage of the shooting um and what do you recall
04:31:00 is the essence of that written statement for miss right i mean what what does it basically
04:31:04 Object, Your Honor. At this point, we want to assert our standing objection to the constitutionality of allowing in Ms. Wright's statement when she is not here present in court to be cross-examined.
04:31:17 We did include those constitutional arguments in our standing objection.
04:31:21 Also, this does fall under the type of document that should be safeguarded under Rule 4-202.02-8.
04:31:31 i knew that was coming dude as soon as he started talking about her sworn statement i was like i 0.96
04:31:35 hope they have her in court and they don't knew she was gonna object to that shit erin f as in 0.83
04:31:42 frank um and and or should be classified as protected under subsection five o as in orange 0.90
04:31:49 um because the disclosure could jeopardize the life safety or property of the witness it's also
04:31:54 technically um of victims um i mean if she's present under the current theory and the
04:32:00 information she's technically could be classified as a victim of the event um so it also should be
04:32:07 protected under that um so we would object to it being read in public it would not be admissible
04:32:12 a trial in the current format that it is due to its hearsay nature um we do think yeah but this 0.98
04:32:16 is a prelim hearing man this lady is really grasping at straws here preliminary hearing
04:32:21 is just for probable cause hearsay is absolutely allowed that's why he's bringing in all these law
04:32:26 enforcement guys because the law enforcement guys know the totality of the case and they can like
04:32:30 tell you when i did this interview i got this whatever this is what other law enforcement
04:32:34 officers told me hearsay guys evidence is stuff that you get from other people that's why he
04:32:39 brought in law enforcement guys because they have all the facts of the case they're the best witnesses
04:32:42 for preliminary hearings would negatively impact our client's right to a fair trial and furthermore
04:32:48 I believe the witness herself has requested that, particularly because the video. 0.99
04:32:53 Oh, what the fuck? 0.99
04:32:54 Sorry, chat. 1.00
04:32:55 Let me.
04:32:58 Oh, gosh.
04:33:00 Coming in, I think would still fall under the protection.
04:33:04 And so for all those reasons, we would object to that coming out in public and being discussed in the public forum and being published in any way.
04:33:12 And we object to it coming in.
04:33:13 All right. So if you wouldn't mind just restating the rule that you're relying upon so I can fully look at your objection.
04:33:24 It's the UCJA, the Utah, oh gosh, Code of Judicial Administration, I just blanked.
04:33:36 The Utah Code of Judicial Administration for Rule 4-202.02, parenthetical 8, parenthetical F, as in Frank, and or parenthetical 5, and parenthetical capital O.
04:33:56 All right. Thank you. I'm just getting there. I want to review this before I hear from Mr. Sturgill.
04:34:06 All right, I've reviewed that.
04:34:17 Mr. Sergill.
04:34:21 Let me address, I guess, a couple of things.
04:34:25 Ms. Nestor actually brought up, I think, both the 1102 statement that we intend to introduce
04:34:30 and sort of referred to the video.
04:34:33 So let me address each of those one at a time.
04:34:36 With regards to the 1102 statement that was prepared by Ms. Wright,
04:34:40 Judge, it was gathered in compliance with the Utah Rules of Evidence, 1102,
04:34:44 specifically subsection B-8.
04:34:49 It's a statement that was gathered by an SBI agent.
04:34:53 It was prepared with knowledge of the advisory
04:34:57 that it was going to be used at the preliminary hearing,
04:34:59 and it also included the warning that if a false statement is given,
04:35:03 it's going to be a class A misdemeanor.
04:35:07 Judge, I don't know what additional foundation you'd like.
04:35:13 Well, that's kind of where I was going, Judge,
04:35:15 is I was trying to lay a little bit more foundation just to introduce that statement alone.
04:35:19 I haven't got yet to the video.
04:35:21 But with regards to the 1102 statement, it has been collected in compliance with Rule 1102.
04:35:28 As I stated, B3 or B8.
04:35:30 and as we all know
04:35:34 Rule 1102 allows
04:35:36 reliable hearsay
04:35:37 as does the State Constitution
04:35:39 Article 1, Section 12
04:35:41 So what exhibit
04:35:44 will this be? I want to look
04:35:46 at it not for the purposes of
04:35:48 as a magistrate
04:35:50 taking it into evidence but see if it
04:35:52 comports with Rule 1102
04:35:53 as stated because I haven't seen
04:35:56 it and I haven't done the analysis
04:35:58 to see if that
04:35:59 objection is
04:36:01 State's Exhibit 6.1.
04:36:15 Your Honor,
04:36:16 just for the record,
04:36:18 we just want to make a record, too, that
04:36:20 it's difficult for the court to make a reliability
04:36:22 finding when the individual
04:36:24 is not here to be tested and cross-examined
04:36:26 and for those same reasons
04:36:27 that we list in our standing objection.
04:36:31 We just want to reiterate to the court
04:36:32 that we think it really hampers you
04:36:34 from making that reliability determination.
04:36:37 Thank you.
04:36:39 Anything further, Mr. Sturgill?
04:36:41 Well, just that 1102 doesn't require that, Judge.
04:36:44 It doesn't require that the witness be here
04:36:46 to corroborate the statement that they've already prepared.
04:36:50 All right.
04:36:50 All right, I've had a chance to review State's Exhibit 6.1, taking into note what Ms. Nester noted, UCJA 4-202.02, in referencing the section she did.
04:37:15 And Judge, I don't mean to interrupt, but I had not yet addressed that rule.
04:37:19 I would simply just add to that that that judicial rule, it does nothing to do with admissibility.
04:37:23 It's simply publishing it.
04:37:25 And I'm sorry.
04:37:27 Okay, so let me just hear your full argument.
04:37:29 Yeah, I didn't realize you wanted to hear all of that.
04:37:31 I thought you were going to rule on the 1102.
04:37:33 Well, I want to focus on the 1102.
04:37:35 I want to keep this clean.
04:37:36 So let's focus on the 1102, and then we'll stop there, and I can make my ruling.
04:37:40 my ruling and then uh if there's any objections i just need to take it one step at a time to be
04:37:45 thorough so i'll hear all your arguments about the the 1102 statement i'll return to miss nester
04:37:52 for any final thoughts and then i'll make my ruling and then we can move to the next i appreciate
04:37:56 that yeah defense is trying to do anything at this point um you know to try to hurt or well
04:38:01 try to stop the testimony here from the lead investigator judge and i think what i've i think
04:38:06 I think I have addressed the 1102 question.
04:38:10 As far as admissibility under Rule 1102,
04:38:13 I thought that's what you wanted to rule on first,
04:38:15 and then I would address the UCJA 4-202.02.
04:38:20 And if you want me to do that now, I can do that,
04:38:22 and it's just simply that it does,
04:38:24 has nothing to do with admissibility.
04:38:26 It has everything to do with publishing that,
04:38:29 and Judge, I think if you'll look at that written statement,
04:38:33 I believe Ms. Wright's personal information, for the most part, has been redacted.
04:38:41 Other than that, and beyond that, Judge, I'll leave it up to your discretion.
04:38:45 Well, as it relates to, well, let me take it one at a time.
04:38:48 Let's start with the last statement.
04:38:50 What I have in front of me, plaintiff's exhibit 6.1, has her full information here.
04:38:56 Address, phone number, social security number.
04:39:01 Okay, Judge, I apologize for that.
04:39:02 I thought we'd provided a redacted version of that.
04:39:06 Yeah.
04:39:22 I think I've clarified what's going on here.
04:39:25 I think we provided you with an unredacted version some time ago.
04:39:29 The version that we have and are prepared to present today is a redacted version.
04:39:33 Could I have a copy of what you're intending to admit into evidence so I can consider what's before me?
04:39:48 Judge, we can bring it up electronically.
04:39:50 We don't have a hard copy of that.
04:39:51 All right.
04:39:52 I want to make sure that's not coming on screen.
04:39:54 It's just coming on my screen to review it.
04:39:58 all right okay no and that's fine it's not it's just from my that I I can look
04:40:09 it on my screen because I'm trying to evaluate so if you just want to put it
04:40:12 back on my screen all right well so what I'm doing is I'm looking at this and
04:40:21 just for clarity moving forward if there is a particular exhibit I'll ask that
04:40:27 you provide it instead of me relying upon here just so there's no misunderstanding and and i can
04:40:34 see exactly what is being moved into evidence i don't want to assume right and i want to do the
04:40:38 proper analysis all right and i appreciate that judge and i apologize i i understood that we were
04:40:43 presenting redacted copies today and okay i think there's just been a little bit of glitch so i
04:40:47 apologize for that judge all right and and miss nester i just want to make sure that you're looking
04:40:51 at this exhibit as opposed to what I was just looking at in regards to your arguments.
04:40:56 With this clarification in mind, any update to your argument or anything that you would like the court to consider?
04:41:08 The only other issue I think that exists with this that I haven't already raised
04:41:14 is that there's clearly two different authors in the body of the document.
04:41:22 One wrote something on the very top line,
04:41:25 and then it looks like Ms. Wright wrote the rest of it,
04:41:29 which we don't have any indication of who wrote that top line
04:41:33 and when they filled that in, if it was before or after she signed the document.
04:41:37 So I have some concerns about authenticity with respect to that as well,
04:41:40 and that's all I have.
04:41:42 All right.
04:41:43 And as I'm determining it, it does appear that the writing is different.
04:41:46 Did you want to lay additional foundation, Mr. Sturgill, or provide information for the court?
04:41:50 I'd be happy to do that.
04:41:53 Do you have in front of you State's Exhibit 6.1?
04:41:58 I do, yes.
04:41:59 Okay.
04:41:59 You've heard the discussion that just took place.
04:42:01 It appears as if there's two different styles of writing on that form.
04:42:04 Yes.
04:42:05 Okay.
04:42:05 I imagine that you have the writing that includes the personal information from Ms. Wright,
04:42:11 and then directly below that I think there's a there's a line there that
04:42:15 appears to be arguably writing prepared by someone else is that in fact that is
04:42:23 that in fact accurate that there that is a different that's correct author of
04:42:28 that writing what do you know about that writing on that first line just below
04:42:32 statement of incident because we were asking this right to verify a specific
04:42:36 video. The file name for that video was written on the statement in her presence
04:42:40 and then that video with that file name was then shown to Ms. Wright to verify
04:42:45 that it was in fact the video that she had provided to us. Okay and so was it
04:42:49 you or or SBI agent Davis that prepared that? Based on the writing that appears
04:42:56 to be agent Davis's writing but it's not it's not my writing. All right but that
04:43:01 is the routine or is that kind of how you commonly do this? In this case because
04:43:05 we were specifically asking them to verify a specific digital file that had
04:43:11 a specific digital name and we didn't want there to be any errors in how that
04:43:16 name was presented we wrote the file name on the document for the individuals
04:43:21 all right anything further miss Nestor with that additional information before
04:43:25 the court makes its ruling your honor all right thank you into having you
04:43:33 Could you leave that on the screen for me, please?
04:43:35 I was just, I appreciate that.
04:43:37 And scroll down to the bottom.
04:43:39 I just want to review it one last time.
04:43:43 All right.
04:43:45 And I believe this is Exhibit 6.1.
04:43:48 Is that correct, Mr. Sturgill?
04:43:49 It is, Judge.
04:43:50 And I would move to admit 6.1.
04:43:53 Thank you.
04:43:53 So considering the arguments made by Ms. Nestor and Mr. Sturgill,
04:43:59 I rely upon Rule 1102 as well as Utah Constitutional Article I, Section 12, as I previously mentioned, that final paragraph, it states nothing in this Constitution shall preclude the use of reliable hearsay as defined by statute or rule in whole or in part at any preliminary examination to determine probable cause or at any pretrial proceeding with respect to release of the defendant if appropriate discoveries allowed.
04:44:29 As defined by statute or rule, I have examined this and the clarification was made.
04:44:34 The previous version of this would fall afoul of having identifiable personal information of Ms. Wright.
04:44:45 And so that was removed.
04:44:47 And this one with the redacted portion of the...
04:44:51 Guys, I'll explain what's going on here in a second.
04:44:53 Identifiable information, personal information for Ms. Wright is before me.
04:44:58 And based off that, State's Exhibit 6.1 with redactions is admitted into evidence and may be published.
04:45:07 Thank you, Judge.
04:45:13 Agent Hull, that statement that was prepared by Ms. Wright, what does it state with regards?
04:45:19 Okay.
04:45:20 Here's what's going down.
04:45:21 Let me boil this down for you guys real quick.
04:45:23 Right now, for all you guys, because we're live on TikTok and YouTube, I'll bring you guys up to speed very quickly here, okay?
04:45:28 basically here's what's going on the lead investigator for the sbi is on the stand this
04:45:35 is the case agent this is the guy that ran the investigation this is probably one of the most
04:45:38 important law enforcement witnesses for this investigation as lead agent you are responsible
04:45:42 for dealing with the prosecutors you're responsible for liaisoning with other agencies
04:45:46 you're responsible for writing the reports talking to uh key witnesses gathering evidence you are
04:45:51 the presenter of the case this case now i do think it's important that you guys understand
04:45:54 that the lead investigator is no longer with the sbi he went off and did a more cushy detail being
04:45:59 like a trainer so that should tell you that this case probably stressed him out he said i'm out of
04:46:03 here okay i thought that was very interesting that he's no longer um with the sbi major crimes unit
04:46:08 he left now with that said um the reason why and i i predict here what's going to happen is
04:46:14 the defense is going to grill him pretty hard and the other case agent very hard there's two guys on
04:46:18 it this guy was the lead and then obviously in the beginning of the investigation he probably
04:46:23 obviously left turned it over to the other guy he's the second lead and probably like the lead
04:46:27 at this point but at the when the case began when they arrived on scene they were supposed to go and
04:46:32 give some assistance they ended up taking a case now this is very common where if you got like a
04:46:37 local police department that's overwhelmed they can't handle this like uh like university police
04:46:41 department for example where you got like a couple of cops maybe 10 cops and like two detectives they
04:46:47 don't have the capacity to handle this so the state police will often take it and that's what's
04:46:51 happening here they took it so um obviously this is very important witness for the for the state
04:46:57 that's why the defense is trying to hit them on hearsay hearsay now again this is a preliminary
04:47:03 hearing hearsay is admissible this is not a trial okay hearsay is basically like um testimony that
04:47:10 comes from other people and not the direct individual in trial we need to bring that
04:47:14 witness in if this was a trial they would have to bring that witness in that recorded the the
04:47:18 that recorded the footage that they're talking about right now.
04:47:20 But since hearsay is admissible, they can do that.
04:47:24 Now, what the defense tried to do was it seemed like there was a sworn statement,
04:47:27 and the defense was like, ah, well, you know, she's not here.
04:47:31 There's some issues here, blah, blah, blah.
04:47:32 So that's what they were fighting about a second ago.
04:47:35 So now the prosecutor is going to kind of like ask the question in another way.
04:47:39 Give me one in the chat if that makes sense.
04:47:41 Give me one in the chat if that makes sense.
04:47:45 And we'll get right back to it.
04:47:46 i hope i hope that kind of explain what just transpired there to uh the video that you showed
04:47:53 you showed her that day or i guess agent davis showed her that day so almost said what happened
04:47:57 dude i literally just explained it just rewind the video that states that she's confirmed that
04:48:01 she did review the video and that it was um a true reflection of the video okay here we go
04:48:06 statement of incident or what you know about this incident so they put the video okay so i get it
04:48:11 they put the video file here because they know what they're referring to.
04:48:15 She's not going to know it.
04:48:16 Look, there's a case number right there.
04:48:17 20, 25, 0, 9, 1, 10, uh, 9, 1, 0.
04:48:21 And then underscore something, blah, blah, blah.
04:48:23 Yeah.
04:48:23 They're, they put this here so that they can like file it in their records.
04:48:27 Then here's her statement after. 0.84
04:48:28 So yeah, there's the, see the defense attorney is just a grassman. 0.57
04:48:32 Straws, bro. 0.70
04:48:33 Yeah.
04:48:33 There's nothing wrong with writing on the top, what it's going to be.
04:48:37 They labeled what it is.
04:48:38 now if they really want it to be official you can initial it right what i would have done
04:48:44 i was i would have initialed it you know special agent amber photo right here so they know that i
04:48:48 wrote that in and then she initials her comment but you know you can see it right here that she
04:48:53 signs at the bottom well that she took on september 10th 2025 and she identified by who's in that
04:48:59 video in her statement uh herself and all you guys that are watching on tiktok do me a solid
04:49:05 guys uh double tap the screen hope you guys are enjoying the broadcast you guys are not going to
04:49:10 get better coverage on this than anyone else so make sure you uh share the broadcast double tap
04:49:15 the screen and just youtube guys like the video for me two young children
04:49:19 if we could just have a clarification on the court's ruling so
04:49:26 i understand the court i think this witness right probably provided some very important
04:49:32 footage which is why they're um they're bringing it up overruled and published and i accept the
04:49:41 ruling but i thought under the court's previous order that the media was not going to film
04:49:47 exhibits oh she's not happy because they showed it um and they are filming the ones that are on
04:49:56 that screen so i guess i just need to clarify that your honor i'm sorry no and i appreciate
04:50:02 the clarification is important what my ruling when we came back from break was if you're objecting
04:50:07 specifically to the exhibit and then to the exhibit being published in the courtroom and
04:50:13 then the exhibit being published which can be captured by media if that's not specifically
04:50:18 addressed it i am going to allow it so i didn't hear a specific um objection to that so i appreciate
04:50:26 you bringing that up but that's that's how i'm looking at every single objection uh just for
04:50:31 clarity of the record. Thank you, Your Honor. So just to make sure I correct the record,
04:50:36 we are objecting to the publication of this under the UCGAA rules for the reasons I said,
04:50:42 but I respect that you've ruled on that. And in the future, I guess we'll just make particularly
04:50:48 clear we're objecting to publication because I do think anything that's getting on that screen
04:50:52 is getting filmed. So thank you, Your Honor. Thank you, Ms. Nestor. And yeah, they definitely
04:50:56 filmed it ksl news utah i got it mr sturgill did you want to respond so yeah the guy on the stand
04:51:02 right now guide is david hole that's the guy that's uh lead investigator right here with
04:51:07 australian accent i don't know if you guys peeped it but he said he did alcohol for a while
04:51:11 um he probably worked like for the alcohol compliance people he probably did undercover
04:51:15 because because of his accent on i mean it's it's the genie's a little bit out of the bottle
04:51:22 on this particular issue, but any record you wish to make?
04:51:27 We're simply going to seek to admit each one of these exhibits,
04:51:30 and then we're going to leave it up to your Honor's discretion
04:51:32 whether to publish them beyond, well, to what extent you want to publish them.
04:51:37 All right.
04:51:38 Well, I would prefer argument on this issue from both sides.
04:51:42 I don't, this is the burden of the state,
04:51:47 So I don't want to exceed my lane by just assuming.
04:51:52 So I'll leave it to you to make the argument what you're requesting.
04:52:17 the um sorry about that so before you're moving on mr sturgill as it relates to this i want to
04:52:35 put this to bed and then we can move on are you are you were you requesting for it to be published
04:52:41 on so the three you moved into evidence which I approved it is moved into evidence but I didn't
04:52:48 hear anything in regards to publishing to the courtroom and then lastly publishing which it
04:52:54 would be captured by the the camera in the background in the back. Judge we believe these
04:53:01 are public documents so we would ask that they be published both to the audience and to the public
04:53:07 at large all right well I given that that we've we've gone past the gate on
04:53:12 this one it's been published right but I'll know I think we're all on the same
04:53:19 page in regards to how objections may be made in how the court is going to
04:53:23 consider it so we can move forward
04:53:28 thank you mr. Sturgill thank you
04:53:37 have you um have you personally watched uh miss wright's video i have yes
04:53:53 and uh what is depicted in that video uh it's a view of miss wright's position in the crowd at
04:54:00 the event on september 10th and there you go it's uh it's critical footage probably one of the best
04:54:05 vantage points and that's why they're they're uh using it it's um absent the the written statement
04:54:14 from miss right could can you at least recognize the location that's displayed or depicted uh in
04:54:20 this particular video yes it's the amphitheater at uh at the utah valley university where mr kirk
04:54:26 was doing his event.
04:54:29 Okay.
04:54:30 On your screen, is it at six?
04:54:38 Do you see anything on your screen yet?
04:54:42 Just the very beginning.
04:54:46 It's there now.
04:54:48 It's there now.
04:54:49 Do you recognize what's depicted on your screen right now?
04:54:52 I do, yes.
04:54:53 And what is that?
04:54:54 in the background is the hall of flags and then you have the the gazebo under which mr kirk was
04:55:01 presenting his event from and then the crowd between where miss wright was and the stage
04:55:07 okay but do you recognize what this is the beginning of yes this is all right for all
04:55:12 you guys that are just joining lead investigator is on from the state burial investigation from
04:55:16 utah this is the lead investigator okay what is the sbi the sbi is the fbi equivalent for the
04:55:23 state of utah who who handles uh major crimes okay the guy's name is david hole okay special
04:55:32 agent with the sbi he is the one that's satisfying right now the beginning of misrights video okay
04:55:40 in a preliminary hearing there's not a this is not the trial chat i've seen a couple of you guys in
04:55:44 the chat say it's a trial it's not a trial this is a preliminary hearing it's only to establish
04:55:48 probable cause chairs the state would move to admit uh what's been mark state's exhibit 6.1
04:55:56 if you're watching on youtube smash the like button if you're watching on tick tock smash the
04:55:59 double tap okay oh i'm sorry six i apologize into to what level
04:56:09 hold on hold on this next door i just want to get the clarification and then i'll certainly
04:56:19 turn to you so the the levels of admitting into evidence then the next level is publishing it to
04:56:26 the courtroom and then the next level is publishing it in a way that is captured yeah share the live
04:56:31 guys appreciate you guys on tiktok sharing the live by the media what is your full request
04:56:35 Judge, we'd ask that, first of all, it be admitted, that it be published here within the courtroom, and then that it also be published to the public at large.
04:56:50 All right. Now, I'm not quite sure what this particular video is showing.
04:56:54 Could you lay a little bit more foundation or proffer that what this is?
04:56:59 Sure. You've seen this video, Agent Hall?
04:57:01 Correct.
04:57:02 What's depicted in this video?
04:57:03 The crowd and the beginning of Mr. Kirk's presentation to the audience in the Amphitheater at UVU on September 10th, 2025.
04:57:14 Does it depict Ms. Wright?
04:57:18 I believe towards the end of the video it scrolls back and Ms. Wright shows the people that she's with at the event and herself, yes.
04:57:26 Is there any act of alleged violence in this particular event?
04:57:31 not judged, but
04:57:32 there is not. Okay, I just needed
04:57:35 that clarification. Mr. Nestor, I'll turn to you.
04:57:37 I just wanted to make sure I understand the full
04:57:39 scope of this exhibit and then hear
04:57:41 from your objection. 1.00
04:57:43 Southern Mom, thanks for the roses. Shout out to all you guys
04:57:45 that are showing love. Yang-a-lang,
04:57:47 Southern Mommy, Tennessee Creek,
04:57:50 top three showing love.
04:57:52 Ophelia Hudson, shout out to all you guys showing
04:57:53 love on TikTok.
04:57:55 I've been gone for a long time. I can see you guys
04:57:57 miss me. Six years, banned.
04:58:01 in the shadow realm, if any. But I'm back. Your Honor, with respect to admission, we object to
04:58:07 its admission on the grounds that it's not properly authenticated as Ms. Wright herself
04:58:12 is not present. And for all the constitutional reasons we raised in our standing objection,
04:58:19 we object to that. As far as its publication, we object to its publication.
04:58:27 it definitely is something that if you oss guys are watching on tiktok let me know i'll mod you
04:58:34 up right away any oss guys watching on tiktok let me know and i'll mod you up but in its current
04:58:41 form without her here would not be admissible in any place other than a preliminary hearing
04:58:46 um and we feel like this would really but stay in the oss chat give me your tiktok name on the
04:58:51 oss chat so i know you're actually in the oss i'm looking at the oss chat right now really impinge
04:58:56 on Mr. Robinson's right to a fair trial, and so we're asking it not be published,
04:59:00 and certainly if the court does publish it, that it certainly not be filmed.
04:59:06 Thank you.
04:59:07 Mr. Sturgill, any response?
04:59:09 Judge, Rule 901 addresses authenticating or identifying evidence
04:59:13 to satisfy the requirement of authenticating a document,
04:59:16 or I guess authenticating a piece of evidence.
04:59:19 the proponent in this case is the state must produce evidence sufficient to support a finding
04:59:26 that the item is what all right all you tiktok guys type in a tiktok chat so i can start giving
04:59:30 y'all uh wrenches so i'm gonna look on i'm gonna look at my um oss chat then i'll look at my um
04:59:37 tiktok chat and i'll give y'all wrenches if it matches up because you know people are going to
04:59:41 try to scam opponent claims it to be and then the rule goes on to explain or provide examples of
04:59:47 how this
04:59:49 rule can be satisfied and at the very
04:59:51 top under subsection B1
04:59:54 is testimony of a witness
04:59:55 with knowledge. That
04:59:57 goes on to say that
04:59:59 testimony that an item is what it is
05:00:01 claimed to be
05:00:03 satisfies this
05:00:05 authentication
05:00:08 rule. Judge, you
05:00:10 have an 1102 statement prepared by
05:00:12 the person who actually
05:00:13 caught
05:00:15 these images on
05:00:17 her her camera or on her phone and uh and so judge i think that alone sufficiently authenticates
05:00:25 the document and then even further than that you have uh agent paul who has reviewed the video
05:00:32 himself and authenticates it at least with regards to location thank you as it relates to
05:00:40 admissibility of this exhibit i believe this is state's exhibit six is that it is judge all right
05:00:45 I'm sorry to interrupt. Can I add one more thing just for the record? For purposes of publication question, under UCJA 4-202.02, parent 4, parent R as in Richard, photograph, film, or video of a crime victim are designated as private court records.
05:01:11 And I do think that based on what the state has previously referenced, they are perceiving that everyone in the audience is a potential victim.
05:01:22 And so we think it shouldn't be published under that rule.
05:01:25 Thank you.
05:01:26 Mr. Sturgill, on that final point.
05:01:27 Judge, I appreciate that argument from Ms. Nestor.
05:01:31 And we don't necessarily disagree.
05:01:33 But to that end, to protect who we believe is a victim, victims in this video, I believe their faces have been blurred out.
05:01:44 Oh, I see.
05:01:46 Ms. Nester, have you?
05:01:50 I think it's only the minor children whose faces are blurred out, not Ms. Wright, if I'm not mistaken, unless it's been subsequently altered.
05:01:59 My recollection is they've all been blurred out.
05:02:01 All right. Let me I need to view this again. So let's just put it on my monitor again.
05:02:07 I'm just trying to make sure that in order for make a ruling on this, I need to view it.
05:02:11 So let's put it on my monitor, play it without any sound.
05:02:18 OK, to my understanding is the prosecution has control of this exhibit.
05:02:23 So what I'm asking is that the sound be turned off if there is any.
05:02:27 uh oss guys keep um keep putting in your thing so i can give you guys uh mods and just go ahead
05:02:35 and play it and it's only on well it's on all the parties monitors because i all i want you all to
05:02:40 view it because that can go directly to as you've mentioned miss nester uh whether it's possibly
05:02:48 admissible so let's go ahead and play that
05:02:49 yeah uh tyler robinson is balding chat bro has been stressed
05:03:10 guys i'm only giving wrenches to oss guys that's it i'm not giving wrenches to anybody
05:03:16 unless you're an OSS bro
05:03:17 we are outnumbered on TikTok
05:03:19 we are outnumbered on TikTok
05:03:21 so I'm only giving wrenches to base dudes man
05:03:23 if you want to join OSS
05:03:28 it's only a dollar to join
05:03:29 $10 after that
05:03:30 jump on in
05:03:31 I can drop the link in there
05:03:33 use the code L YouTube
05:03:34 alright thank you
05:03:40 based off what I've watched
05:03:43 there was some blurring of faces
05:03:44 but not of all the faces
05:03:46 And so I'm going to rule that it is admissible.
05:03:59 Sure, I'll wait until all parties are ready to proceed.
05:04:09 Someone said, do I stream a lot on TikTok?
05:04:11 I'm going to.
05:04:12 I just have to keep it clean when I'm on here.
05:04:16 so anything further i just want to make sure you got a chance to watch that i did so i'm ruling
05:04:23 that it is admissible into evidence again taking into consideration of the analysis
05:04:26 yo oss guys keep typing in the um keep typing on the uh on the tiktok dude so i can find you guys
05:04:34 crash amaran you already got him yeah i gave you a mod uh salah i gave you one already
05:04:40 the court's talked about regards to 1102s and this particular piece of evidence as it relates
05:04:48 to the 1102 video the 1102 statement 6.1 and I'm going to allow it to admit into evidence and
05:04:57 because the faces of the alleged victims are not all obscured there are some that are visible
05:05:05 it's not going to be published to in court monitor and obviously not to
05:05:09 to be filmed by the media so the court will receive it into evidence the court will watch
05:05:14 it again right now and then we can continue to proceed very good thank you josh so if uh to
05:05:19 the state if you would like to play it again for me i dropped the oss link for you guys in there
05:05:22 just use the code youtube as a dollar for the first month best way to support the mission
05:05:25 because i'm demonetized on youtube i'm viewing it as it relates to consideration as a magistrate
05:05:30 your honor um this is sounds like an issue that's going to come up again i represent the news media
05:05:35 can i convert on this issue yes um dominicano you got your wrench joseph you got your wrench
05:05:41 the i just wanted to address i've tried to be quiet i just wanted to address it now because 0.85
05:05:47 it's going to keep coming up it sounds like the classification rule that miss nester is
05:05:50 citing and that your honor was just reading is not about in court exhibits that is classification
05:05:56 for records in the court file so it is a fundamentally different thing when we are in a
05:06:01 public proceeding and the state is presenting an exhibit that you are relying on and the public
05:06:06 is being denied the chance to see it that is that is a fundamental um violation of the right of
05:06:12 access and it can it's a qualified right and i recognize that but that's not the the ruling that
05:06:16 you just made you're just ruling based on the code of judicial administration which doesn't have
05:06:20 anything to do with when something is presented in a public proceeding so while i recognize there
05:06:24 are certain things where I understand that you were going to make an exhibit by exhibit
05:06:27 evaluation based on certain exhibits that may, you know, be somewhat, may cross the heavy
05:06:34 threshold of being so prejudicial that they cannot be shown in public. That is not this.
05:06:39 And so just, I just wanted to make clear that the things that are in rule 202 are not, when it is
05:06:45 presented in open court as an exhibit for you to rely on, the public is entitled to see what you're
05:06:49 seeing so that they can understand what your decision-making process is. And so this one,
05:06:53 it doesn't sound like this sounds pretty anodyne to me.
05:06:56 You know, it's just, it's not even depicting the shooting.
05:06:58 I just wanted to clarify that the classification issue
05:07:00 about when, you know, we're filing things with the court
05:07:02 and we say like this, you know,
05:07:03 maybe we file a motion to classify.
05:07:04 That's not the decision that you're making today.
05:07:06 The decision you're making today is
05:07:07 the state is presenting something to you.
05:07:08 You're watching it.
05:07:09 You're making a decision based on it.
05:07:10 And the people in the gallery have the right to see that.
05:07:13 Whether you allow EMC of it is a different question.
05:07:15 And we think that the EMC should be allowed to
05:07:17 for reasons that we briefed.
05:07:18 But I do think that it at least
05:07:20 should be published in the courtroom.
05:07:21 Thank you.
05:07:22 Thank you, Your Honor.
05:07:22 To the parties, do you wish to respond?
05:07:25 Jay, you got your wrench.
05:07:27 We'll submit it.
05:07:31 I'm sorry.
05:07:31 Hold on.
05:07:32 Okay, so we'll go to Ms. Nestor first and then to the state.
05:07:36 Mr. Sergio.
05:07:37 The only additional observation I'd make is, with regards to this video and this video only,
05:07:39 the state doesn't believe that the defense really has standing to make an argument on behalf of the victims in this case.
05:07:44 All right.
05:07:45 All right, based off of what's been presented in recognizing the argument from the media,
05:07:50 I see the differentiation.
05:07:52 and how they are differentiating the rule that was cited versus what was presented.
05:07:58 So I'm going to go ahead and rule that this may be played in the courtroom
05:08:00 but not be captured on video.
05:08:02 So to the camera operator, I just want to make sure that it's going to be playing on that,
05:08:05 but I don't want it captured.
05:08:07 I appreciate the patience of the parties as we're going through the many layers
05:08:09 that need to be addressed.
05:08:10 Okay, I passed out a bunch of wrenches, man.
05:08:12 You guys should be good.
05:08:14 I passed out a bunch to the OSS ninjas, man.
05:08:16 on exhibits such as these.
05:08:23 So we'll go ahead and,
05:08:24 once that's ready to be played,
05:08:25 let's go ahead and do that.
05:08:35 I saw a lot of people in Utah,
05:08:36 I'll tell you what.
05:08:40 Hunter.
05:08:42 Alex.
05:08:43 You know how it works.
05:08:44 Thank you, and that concludes
05:08:45 exhibit six correct thank you mr sergio you may continue
05:08:49 agent hold did you or any other sbi agent collect additional video oh yes there were other videos
05:08:55 collected what additional video did you collect um a cell phone video from mr phillips was collected
05:09:01 and do you know who uh or how that video was collected yes agent schultz made contact with
05:09:07 i clicked a bunch of um i clicked a bunch of you guys and gave you guys wrenches i mean it should
05:09:11 work maybe refresh your page mr phillips uh september 29th of 2025 and that video was provided
05:09:17 to him and subsequently in preparation for the proceedings today um myself and agent davis met
05:09:22 with mr phillips um on april 6th and he completed in 1102 and went through the same process as miss
05:09:28 wright the only difference being on this occasion because he is a minor his mother witnessed it and
05:09:32 also signed the statement okay so you personally reviewed uh mr phillips's video with mr phillips
05:09:37 Correct.
05:09:38 And you had him prepare a written statement?
05:09:39 Yes, correct.
05:09:40 Again, on this written statement, are there two different authors?
05:09:44 Yes, I believe in this instance it was myself that wrote the file name on the form.
05:09:47 Okay, so you wrote, what part of the statement did you write?
05:09:49 Just the name of the file that we were asking Mr. Phillips to verify.
05:09:51 Okay.
05:09:52 Yeah, that's for their own, like, tracking purposes.
05:09:54 Completely normal.
05:10:01 I'm going to have exhibited on your screen what's been marked State's Exhibit 7.1.
05:10:07 And this should just be for Agent Paul.
05:10:12 That's on my screen.
05:10:13 Is it on your screen? Do you recognize what that is?
05:10:15 I do, yes.
05:10:15 What is that?
05:10:16 The State Bureau of Investigation 1102 form completed by Mr. Phillips.
05:10:18 And did you gather that for Mr. Phillips?
05:10:20 I did, yes.
05:10:20 And again, does this statement include the advisory that is going to be used in the of his testimony at Freedom?
05:10:24 It does.
05:10:24 And does it also include a warning that if he makes a, well, the author makes a false statement that could be punishable by being charged with Class A misdemeanor?
05:10:30 It does, yes.
05:10:31 Anything about this exhibit look different than the day you collected it?
05:10:35 No.
05:10:35 just a state would seek to admit exhibit 7.1
05:10:39 thank you your honor
05:10:41 we would object to the admission on the grounds
05:10:43 that this video does in fact show
05:10:44 a close up view of the shooting of Mr. Kirk
05:10:47 in grievous injuries
05:10:48 in very stark relief
05:10:51 and because of that
05:10:53 we are particularly concerned about our constitutional
05:10:55 claims we have made and our standing objection
05:10:56 in terms of our ability to get a fair trial
05:10:58 so they don't want to show the video
05:11:00 guys refresh your page
05:11:02 hopefully you should have your wrench
05:11:05 refresh your page hopefully you get it public published and um i think again we have the same
05:11:12 issue with the court you know being in a position where you're having to make a reliability um
05:11:16 determination without the opportunity for this individual to be cross-examined also i do think
05:11:20 the fact this is a minor that um completed this form um does make it protected he's also
05:11:25 potentially a victim um under the same theory that has been stated form is right um and under the
05:11:31 under the UCJA
05:11:34 acts for the same reason, the UCJA
05:11:36 rules for the same reason, these
05:11:38 should be protected private court records
05:11:40 and private means it shouldn't be played to court
05:11:42 and it shouldn't be played to the public through the media
05:11:44 so we would object to its mission
05:11:46 we would object to its publication and we would object to its filming
05:11:48 thank you. Any final response?
05:11:50 Let me address, well there's two things here right
05:11:52 let me address first the 1102 statement, judge I believe
05:11:54 again that this statement was gathered in compliance with rule
05:11:56 1102 B8
05:11:57 and the agent has explained that although Mr. Phillips is a minor his mother was present
05:12:04 and that explains I believe he said the second signature on the form the with regards to
05:12:09 publishing it yeah that's one way to get it in get the parent permission 1102 statement that is
05:12:13 as we believe again the presumption is this is a public record and that it should be not only
05:12:19 admitted but published here in court and also published so the the media can record it with
05:12:26 regards while doing it address the 1102 and then we'll all move on to the video all right so we're
05:12:30 staying focused on the 1102 any final response miss nester thank you as it relates to the 1102
05:12:35 statement and to the state uh representative who is displaying it could you scroll down i can only
05:12:39 see the top half of this all right and just go to the very bottoms yeah guys i'm trying to mod you
05:12:49 through my computer it's not i don't think it's letting me do it man i don't know why oh man let
05:12:55 Let me see if I can do it on my phone.
05:12:56 I can look at the totality of it, this is 7.1.
05:13:00 All right, based off of what's before me,
05:13:01 on the state's exhibit 7.1,
05:13:03 I find that it is admissible under Rule 1102
05:13:05 and to the Utah Constitution, Article 1, Section 12,
05:13:10 to that paragraph I have referred to previously,
05:13:12 and so it is admitted into evidence.
05:13:14 And Mr. Sturgill, remind me,
05:13:18 were you requesting for it to be displayed?
05:13:20 I'm, again, focusing on 7.1.
05:13:22 Right, 7.1, Judge, with regards to the video,
05:13:24 believe it's admissible it's been authenticated properly hold on hold on
05:13:26 I'm not talking about the video I'm talking about 7.1 publishing it in the
05:13:29 courtroom versus publishing it on to be captured by the media because we think
05:13:33 that it's present the presumption is it is a court record we believe in its
05:13:36 redacted form we believe it should be published all in all three areas
05:13:40 mr. any final thoughts I'm gonna go ahead and grant that publishing of
05:13:44 plaintiffs exhibit 7.1 in courts and that the media may capture that let's go
05:13:51 ahead and do so all right let's see it's always cool down so here's the um here's the document
05:14:02 here's department of public safety voluntary statement affidavit so this was soren statement
05:14:07 uh on taken in april of 2026
05:14:10 so image i have viewed blah blah blah looks like this is the parent right here jennifer phillips
05:14:22 ty phillips
05:14:24 all right you may proceed did you admit it at some point it is admitted into evidence and it was
05:14:34 published the um have you personally watched mr phillips's video i have yes okay and what does
05:14:39 it depict? It's a graphic video. Mr. Phillips was positioned towards the front of the crowd
05:14:45 and it does depict the moment that Mr. Kirk is shot. And independent of the 1102 statement
05:14:49 prepared by Mr. Phillips, you watching that video, do you recognize at least the location
05:14:53 of this video? I do. It's consistent with the event that Mr. Kirk was presenting at UVU on
05:14:57 September 10th, 2025. To this point, the state would move to introduce or would move to admit
05:15:01 what's been marked state's exhibit number seven. We would simply ask that it be admitted. We would
05:15:05 asked however that it not be published beyond that due to the graphic nature and the sensitive
05:15:10 nature of the video all right so as to the admission the same issues that we raised as to
05:15:15 the 1102 we would raise as to um the difficult yeah defense really doesn't want this video getting
05:15:20 in chat that's what they're arguing about all this time is basically they don't want this video
05:15:24 getting in authenticating when the individual's not here at least for the prelim hearing isn't
05:15:30 um and all the same concerns um that we raised they're using the excuse that the defendant isn't
05:15:35 Sorry, the witness isn't here to testify to us, so they're trying to keep it out.
05:15:38 About the 1102 itself, Your Honor.
05:15:40 Thank you.
05:15:42 All right.
05:15:44 Considering the...
05:15:44 I'm sorry, may I have one more?
05:15:46 I apologize.
05:15:46 And also under Rule 403, we think it's more prejudicial than probative, and we would raise it for that reason as well.
05:15:51 Any final response, Mr. Sturgeon?
05:15:52 No, Your Honor.
05:15:53 All right.
05:15:54 And this is Exhibit 7, is that correct?
05:15:56 Correct.
05:15:57 Exhibit 7, Judge.
05:15:57 All right.
05:15:58 I will admit Exhibit 7 into evidence based off the foundation that's laid.
05:16:02 the 1102 is tied directly to this and so for admission purposes it is admitted i am not going
05:16:09 to authorize publication in the courtroom or obviously through media but i will have it played
05:16:16 on my screen and so i view it and i just want to make sure and please counsel given the graphic
05:16:22 nature of it please guard your screens because i believe we all should be viewing okay chad i think
05:16:28 I found a way to do it. So this is what I want you guys to do on OSS. If you're on OSS, send a
05:16:35 $1 super chat, guys, just so I don't lose your name with your username on TikTok. If you already
05:16:40 did it, don't send another one in. I'm going to go through. I'm going to find you. I found how to
05:16:45 do it on my phone. I'm going to add you manually. Just give me your TikTok username, and I'm going
05:16:49 to compare it with the OSS super chats, and I'll add you in for TikTok. So you guys can go in there
05:16:57 and moderate. Okay. I got your ninjas. If you already donated, don't donate again. This is
05:17:03 only so I can like keep it organized and I can find you guys. This, this is evidence. And I want
05:17:09 to make sure that you all are seeing what I see to ensure that that is accurate. And it's a fair
05:17:14 representation of the exhibit that you are familiar with. So whatever you need to do,
05:17:18 I'll give you a moment. And if you could just give me a thumbs up, if you're ready to proceed,
05:17:22 Again, I want to act in a way that is dignified and respecting the rights of all persons.
05:17:30 And for those reasons, I just want to make sure we are safeguarding to ensure this is not captured.
05:17:34 All right.
05:17:35 To defense.
05:17:37 Ready to proceed?
05:17:38 Yes, sir.
05:17:38 All right.
05:17:39 To the state.
05:17:40 Yes, sir.
05:17:40 All right.
05:17:42 Go ahead, and let's play Exhibit 7.
05:17:49 Is there a sound?
05:17:50 There is, sir.
05:17:50 All right.
05:17:51 Let's make sure that. Thank you.
05:18:03 Okay, so they're not going to show it, obviously, because of the graphic nature of it.
05:18:07 We don't know how. We don't know what they did.
05:18:09 And for those...
05:18:10 Yeah, Mr. Farnsworth originally provided, I believe, a flash drive to Lieutenant O'Brien with one of the local agencies.
05:18:17 And a short time after that, on September 10th, he provided downloadable versions, electronic versions to Agent Mortensen.
05:18:29 And an 1102 was collected from him on May 6th of 2026.
05:18:34 So an 1102 was prepared by someone with visual impulse?
05:18:38 Yes.
05:18:39 Terrell Farnsworth was the individual that prepared it in preparation for this.
05:18:43 I spoke to him personally regarding that statement.
05:18:45 And do you know what his association is with Visual Impulse?
05:18:49 I believe he's the owner-operator or the director of the company.
05:18:54 And then who collected that 1102 statement from Mr. Farnsworth?
05:18:59 It was Agent Monson who collected it.
05:19:02 Okay, and you know that because Agent Monson told you?
05:19:05 He provided it to me, and then, as I mentioned,
05:19:08 I subsequently spoke to Terrell Farnsworth personally regarding his statement.
05:19:11 Okay.
05:19:15 Have you had a chance to look at Mr. Farnsworth's 1102 statement?
05:19:21 I have, yes.
05:19:24 And again, does that statement include an advisory that any statement that he provided would be used at preliminary hearing in lieu of his life testimony?
05:19:34 Yes.
05:19:35 Did it also include a warning that a false statement would potentially be punished by a class A misdemeanor?
05:19:40 It did, yes.
05:19:41 Okay.
05:19:42 I'm going to have exhibited on your screen what's been Mark State's exhibit 8.1.
05:19:49 Let me know when that comes up.
05:19:53 That's come up.
05:19:57 I think it's a single page, is it not?
05:20:00 I believe it is.
05:20:12 Do you see that, Agent Hall?
05:20:14 Yes.
05:20:22 You do recognize that?
05:20:24 I do, yes.
05:20:25 Okay, and again, that is what?
05:20:27 It's the 1102 statement that was provided to me, completed by Mr. Farnsworth from Visual Impulse,
05:20:34 who is the videographer for TPUSA for the events that they do.
05:20:38 Okay.
05:20:38 Judge, the state would move to admit State's Exhibit 8.1. 0.58
05:20:43 Ms. Nester.
05:20:45 Thank you, Your Honor.
05:20:48 At this point, we renew our objection.
05:20:52 This statement is hearsay.
05:20:55 We have constitutional concerns for the reasons we raised in our standing objection.
05:21:01 We also would like to cross-examine Mr. Farnsworth about whether or not and to what extent these videos may have been altered in any way.
05:21:12 It is clear that clips were being made out of the larger videos because he sent, even his own statement says he sent larger videos and this is just a small portion of them.
05:21:22 So obviously someone made clips and we don't know who, we don't know how, we don't know what they did.
05:21:28 and for those reasons and the reasons that are standing objection we would
05:21:33 object to the admissibility of it and as well the I don't have a redacted
05:21:40 version of 8.1 but I assume there is one there is personal information on this
05:21:47 one do you have the redact okay I don't have that one all right um and we would
05:21:51 object to publication just on
05:21:53 our concerns for fair trial
05:21:55 the same issues?
05:21:59 Yeah, gotcha.
05:22:02 Yeah, I think
05:22:03 so. Thank you.
05:22:06 And for all those reasons, we would object
05:22:07 to its admissibility,
05:22:10 its publication,
05:22:11 and its ability to be
05:22:13 filmed by the media, Your Honor.
05:22:15 Ms. Nestor, I just wanted to check. Did you
05:22:17 get a copy of the redact? I was just handed it.
05:22:19 I just wanted to make sure that you had copies.
05:22:23 Thank you, Your Honor.
05:22:23 So, okay, thank you.
05:22:25 Mr. Sturgell, would you like to respond?
05:22:27 Sure, Judge, thank you.
05:22:29 With regards to the admissibility of the statement, Judge,
05:22:32 I think the foundation has been laid that this statement was collected in compliance with Utah Rule of Evidence 1102,
05:22:40 subsection B8.
05:22:42 It constitutes reliable hearsay.
05:22:45 It's a statement that's been made by a declarant that's written, and it's under oath, or not under oath, but pursuant to a notification of the declarant that a false statement made is punishable.
05:22:55 I think there's been foundation to support that.
05:22:57 In addition, Judge, Article 1, Section 12 of the Utah Constitution makes it very clear that the state at preliminary hearing can rely upon reliable hearsay.
05:23:08 All right.
05:23:09 I want to tell Brett to mod some of you guys, man, because it's taking too long. 0.66
05:23:12 um and and tiktok is not fucking helpful at all with this crap it's very annoying when i search
05:23:19 some of your guys names you guys just don't come up anything further before i make my ruling 0.95
05:23:23 thank you all right applying the same analysis from the previous exhibits as it relates to the
05:23:30 written statement under rule 1102 and also under the utah constitution article 1 section 12 in that
05:23:39 last paragraph uh i will overrule the objection and admit uh plain to a state's exhibit 8.1
05:23:47 uh let me hold off hey smash the like button for me on on uh on youtube by the way guys smash that
05:23:55 like button for me from that final phrase if you could scroll down to the state representative
05:24:00 and i'll give you all like another minute but uh smash that like button on youtube stop right there
05:24:09 Thank you.
05:24:10 I just want to make sure I fully review it before I make that ruling.
05:24:30 And if you could continue.
05:24:33 Your Honor, we would just renew our objections to authentication for admissibility purposes.
05:24:39 under 901 bro this is hilarious every objection is on hearsay in the 1102 in a prelim hearing
05:24:44 you know someone prepared these clips we don't know who we don't have that person here to cross
05:24:49 examine in terms of what it what if anything was edited and um for that reason we think it can't
05:24:56 be authenticated and we object to its admissibility and our standing objection for constitutional
05:25:00 grounds thank you
05:25:03 just one moment here
05:25:08 judge would you like me to respond
05:25:11 yes please
05:25:13 judge with regards to authentication
05:25:16 again the state must produce evidence sufficient
05:25:20 support of finding the item is what the proponent claims it to be
05:25:24 and again under subsection B1 it's sufficient
05:25:27 to provide testimony from someone that has
05:25:31 first-hand knowledge or observed uh well has first-hand knowledge regarding the authenticity
05:25:38 of that video you heard agent hold testify that he spoke to the owner of um and the director of
05:25:44 visual impulse uh visual impulse i believe hey guys double tap the live on uh on tiktok
05:25:51 double tap the live on tiktok what do we rank right now guys on uh tiktok live what are we
05:25:56 ranked i see dean has the most of 27.2 but this is like his main platform
05:26:01 what do we rank right now on the tiktok lives ninjas it was testified to that they contract with
05:26:11 tp usa to film their events this particular video of the state is going to or seeks to introduce
05:26:19 is exhibit eight was shown to mr farnsworth and that is the video that mr farnsworth authenticates
05:26:25 and says that this is video that was captured by visual impulse cameras.
05:26:30 So with regards to authentication, I think the state has sufficiently provided the court with evidence to authenticate it.
05:26:37 And this is States Exhibit 8.
05:26:40 All right.
05:26:42 I'm going to overrule the objection and admit States Exhibit 8 as it relates to publication citing to Article 1, Section 28, 1A,
05:26:53 that this is Declaration of Rights of Crime Victims in its states
05:26:58 to be treated with fairness, respect, and dignity.
05:27:02 And to those two points of respect and dignity,
05:27:05 the court is not publishing this in the courtroom,
05:27:09 nor is it being published, obviously, online.
05:27:12 But the court will watch it in court, and again, to the parties,
05:27:16 if you could protect your screens however you choose to,
05:27:21 and then i'll check to see when we're ready uh and then we'll okay it looks like they're gonna
05:27:25 fold the play the full thing here but they're not gonna show it obviously have it played so
05:27:29 turning to defense um is more time needed to okay thank you turning to the state to your screens
05:27:37 all right they all right oh so we're not in the top 100 that's bs bro how are we not in the top
05:27:42 100 with like almost 500 ninjas in here how's that even possible i see a head nod yes and let's
05:27:49 go ahead and play this video
05:27:51 only on the monitors and if there's
05:27:54 sound associated with it
05:27:55 the sound to be played as well
05:27:58 you may proceed
05:27:58 alright no audio
05:28:02 they're taking audio out they're playing the
05:28:05 the shooting
05:28:07 so
05:28:09 I'm in the 99% zone
05:28:12 yeah no audio chat
05:28:17 they're playing the video
05:28:19 So, okay, we're ranked 93 in the world right now on TikTok.
05:28:21 Nice.
05:28:22 Sweet.
05:28:23 We're number three right now.
05:28:25 Guys, keep tapping the like button while we wait for this thing.
05:28:31 Yeah, dude, we're literally, yeah, they're showing the shooting, guys.
05:28:37 Obviously, it's very graphic.
05:28:42 So, yeah.
05:28:47 That's what they're doing right now.
05:28:48 their plane remember the SBA yes the the campus itself UVU is very well equipped with with cameras
05:28:56 throughout and they were willing to work with us to provide video from those cameras and so that
05:29:02 was collected as part of the investigation also the with regards to the UVU surveillance video
05:29:11 do you know if video was collected from uh there behind where Mr. Kirk was all right guys Brett
05:29:17 Sane's going to start modding you guys up.
05:29:19 I told him to cross-reference you guys
05:29:21 and the OSS thing, and yeah.
05:29:23 ...the time that he was shot.
05:29:25 Yes, I'm aware that under the Hall of Flags,
05:29:28 there is a, I'll refer to it as a breezeway,
05:29:30 but a way for people to move from one side
05:29:34 into the amphitheater,
05:29:36 walking underneath the Hall of Flags,
05:29:38 and I know there was a camera situated in that location.
05:29:40 Okay.
05:29:41 And do you know, with regards to that camera view,
05:29:45 uh well let me ask you this so that particular camera view there was surveillance that was
05:29:51 provided to you or another agent from you to you correct okay and do you recall who provided that
05:29:57 video to you initially and who collected it um initially um i don't know specifically for that
05:30:04 video uh but i know that whole process was oh that says i got you guys bro you guys are party
05:30:10 number one i literally been doing this all for you guys because you ninjas rock with me i rock
05:30:15 with you so we're getting all you guys wrenches right now that's one of the benefits of being an
05:30:22 oss bro was overseen uh by mr olson who's responsible for that system okay do you have
05:30:30 a first name for mr olson uh curtis olson i'm sorry curtis olson okay and and do you know what
05:30:36 mr olson or curtis olson's position is at uvu i believe he's a director
05:30:41 Is it his job to basically gather and forward any video that's captured by UVU surveillance?
05:30:50 Yeah, he has a long title, but I think it's Director of Infrastructure, but he is responsible for that system.
05:30:59 With regards to this particular video, the video from underneath the Hall of Flags,
05:31:03 what, if anything, have you done with that video in preparation for today's hearing?
05:31:08 I went specifically to meet Mr. Olson, have him review the video that we had, and again, like with the others, I had him complete an 1102 statement for us describing his role and verifying the videos.
05:31:28 I did that on, actually on July 2nd of this year.
05:31:33 July 2nd of this year?
05:31:34 Correct.
05:31:34 Oh, recently.
05:31:35 Okay.
05:31:36 Give me just one moment.
05:31:38 actually that's i'm gonna correct myself on that if i can refer back to my notes
05:31:46 okay all right guys i am getting off of youtube and twitter okay youtube and twitter going down
05:31:51 youtube and twitter going down guys come on over i dropped the kick link in there for you guys
05:31:56 we're going to continue on with the lead investigator going to keep doing uh breaking
05:32:00 down this uh this trial twitter and youtube are going down come on over to kick kick.com
05:32:06 slash MarioGainesX, guys.
05:32:07 It's going down now.
05:32:09 Switch on over, man.
05:32:10 Kek.com slash MarioGainesX.
05:32:12 YouTube and Twitter are both going down.
05:32:13 YouTube and Twitter are both going down. 1.00
05:32:15 Everyone come to Kek. 1.00
05:32:17 Please, if that, yes.
05:32:19 Your notes you have there with you again?
05:32:21 Yes.
05:32:23 And referencing them will help you refresh your memory.
05:32:25 X going down.
05:32:26 Okay, so don't read from it out loud.
05:32:28 Just look at it and let us know when you've refreshed your memory.
05:32:30 July 2nd seemed a little bit too soon.
05:32:33 It was June 24th.
05:32:34 X going down now.
05:32:35 Mr. Olsen.
05:32:36 Okay.
05:32:36 And you personally met with?
05:32:37 You two going down now.
05:32:39 Mr. Olson?
05:32:40 I did, yes.
05:32:40 Okay.
05:32:41 And did you personally review this particular video,
05:32:44 or I guess the Hall of Flags video with Mr. Olson?
05:32:48 Yes.
05:32:48 Okay.
05:32:50 And he prepared a written statement?
05:32:52 He did, yes.
05:32:54 And on that statement, was that a Bureau-provided statement for him?
05:32:57 It was, yes.
05:32:58 Okay.
05:32:59 And on that statement, do you recall whether it includes an advisory
05:33:03 That his written statement would be used in lieu of his life testimony it did yes
05:33:08 Does it also include a warning that if he provided a false statement on that form that he could be punished with a class a misdemeanor it did yes
05:33:33 is there something displayed on your screen right now there is yes it should be 12.3 yeah it should
05:33:56 be what's been marked the state's exhibit 12.3 do you recognize what that is yes that's the state
05:34:02 Bureau of Investigations 1102 statement completed by Mr. Olson.
05:34:06 Does it appear to be in the same condition as when you collected it?
05:34:10 It does, yes.
05:34:14 Mr. State would seek to admit what's been marked State's Exhibit 12.3.
05:34:19 Ms. Nestor.
05:34:23 Thank you, Your Honor.
05:34:24 We would, again, renew our concern about hearsay
05:34:28 and our constitutional concerns about that raised in our standing objection.
05:34:33 Also, the concern is that the individual basically states they verified the recordings,
05:34:40 but doesn't say how, doesn't say whether they viewed it,
05:34:44 doesn't say whether someone else viewed it and told them,
05:34:46 whether someone else viewed it and told someone else who told someone else who told them.
05:34:51 There's just no explanation.
05:34:52 We don't think it's sufficient to meet your reliability analysis.
05:34:55 and we object to admission and we also object to publication.
05:34:59 This is for all the same reasons, Your Honor.
05:35:05 To the state.
05:35:07 Judge, again, the state's position is that this written state was collected in compliance with Rule 1102,
05:35:16 subsection B8.
05:35:18 It is a statement collected with both the advisory.
05:35:23 Hey, double tap on TikTok, guys.
05:35:25 make sure to double tap on tiktok let's get up to uh let's get 100 000 bro let's get 100k
05:35:31 uh double taps let's take over tiktok real ninjas are taking over and the admonition
05:35:37 from what we've heard from sergeant hole this individual curtis olson is the person that's
05:35:44 it's his job basically to handle this type of information and turn it over to law enforcement
05:35:50 All right, I'll have, uh, if the state representative can scroll through so I can review it in its entirety
05:35:59 and just stop when the majority of that handwritten statements.
05:36:03 Hey, Suleiman Almari, I appreciate you, bro, with the five gifted. Thank you.
05:36:07 Visible. Thank you. Let me review that.
05:36:20 and if you could scroll down to the bottom of the page so guys what you guys are observing here
05:36:39 right is the lead investigator as you guys know is running the case so what's up happening is
05:36:43 they're talking a lot of people they're collecting evidence they're interviewing witnesses
05:36:47 they're collecting the evidence directly you know they're indexing it etc so what's going on
05:36:52 basically here is um the defense is trying to stop this from coming in because she's like oh well
05:36:59 these witnesses that gave them this stuff aren't here to testify it creates problems it's violating
05:37:03 rights blah blah blah and again this is just a hearing to establish probable cause but the way
05:37:09 the defense looks at is like yo let's fight as hard as we can okay let's make them burn as much
05:37:15 evidence as they can so they can show their hands it's very obvious what the defense is doing here
05:37:20 they're going to be as difficult as they can be right so that it forces the prosecution to bring
05:37:27 out more and more evidence to establish the probable cause which is good for them because
05:37:31 then they have less to work with for trial day remember guys the prosecution are the ones who
05:37:38 have the burden of performance the defense has no burden of performance Tyler Robinson and his
05:37:44 attorneys can sit there silent the entire time and not do anything so she's gonna fight she's
05:37:49 gonna object she's gonna try to get things out because what ends up happening is this is gonna 1.00
05:37:55 put the prosecution in their back foot it's gonna force them to come up with more things to establish 0.95
05:38:00 probable cause so it's a battle between the two she knows they have probable cause she just wants 0.59
05:38:07 to see more of what they got and how they're going to present it
05:38:09 Thank you.
05:38:16 Under the same analysis for 1102, under Rule 1102, as well as Article 1, Section 28 of the Utah Constitution,
05:38:26 I'm sorry, that's the wrong one.
05:38:30 Under Article 1, Section 12 of the Utah Constitution, that final paragraph,
05:38:35 the court overrules the objection and admits
05:38:39 State's Exhibit 12.3 as it relates to
05:38:43 publication, Mr. Sturgill. Judge, with regards to publication
05:38:46 in this particular exhibit, it's the state's position that
05:38:50 the presumption is that it's a public record and we would ask that it be published
05:38:55 both here in the courtroom and that the cameras be allowed to capture it and publish it as well.
05:39:00 Ms. Nestor. Nothing additional,
05:39:03 Your Honor. I note the standing objection from defense and given the court's previous analysis
05:39:12 for other 1102s, the court is going to publish it both in the courtroom and so it can be captured
05:39:20 by the media. What we'll do is the same thing. We'll start at the top, pause for 10 seconds and
05:39:28 go to this middle section and we'll pause about 20 seconds because there is a little bit, it is
05:39:32 more dense and then we'll scroll down to the very bottom for about 10 seconds and then that
05:39:38 will conclude that so it's now on screen and let's go from there yeah so guys remember uh
05:39:48 pursuant to rule so 1102 every time they talk about 1102 it's rules of evidence for the state
05:39:52 of utah so anytime they talk about 1102 just memorize that it means of rule of evidence
05:39:58 All right, you can scroll down.
05:40:28 okay i've been at uvu for 25 years 10 of those as the director my department has had
05:40:37 responsibility for the video surveillance system since march 2020 i have a
05:40:42 i don't know i can't read that handled maybe multiple trainings on the management and
05:40:53 exporting a video for our system, our system records
05:40:57 by
05:41:00 oh god, I'm one of
05:41:03 two
05:41:04 masters of this system
05:41:10 all activity is recorded and logged in files, this includes all
05:41:15 okay, I gotta make this bigger chat
05:41:18 this guy
05:41:23 all modifications deletions and exports of data from all my checks
05:41:34 on september 10th and after the system has been
05:41:37 functioning properly without any tampering to the system
05:41:42 i have verified the recordings made on the 10th and all are accurate with
05:41:48 the system functioning
05:41:50 properly. I reviewed
05:41:52 State Exhibit 12.1
05:41:54 and the recordings are true and accurate
05:41:56 including
05:41:58 timestamps, dates,
05:42:00 and camera labels. The only
05:42:02 changes are some zooms
05:42:04 and red highlights which were
05:42:06 not part of the original recording.
05:42:09 To the best of my knowledge, all
05:42:10 video
05:42:11 I can't read that.
05:42:15 By myself, including
05:42:16 Exhibit 9 in the
05:42:18 okay are accurate and reflects the okay this handwriting is atrocious i'm trying chat
05:42:24 i'm really trying i think we got like 90 of it though and this comes from curtis olson
05:42:31 6 24 26 at 10 0 7
05:42:35 pause about 20 seconds because there is a little bit it is more dense and then we'll scroll down
05:42:46 to the very bottom and uh so here's the video guy move up hold on curtis olson 624 26 and then
05:42:57 to finish it says here to the best of my knowledge and video prepared by myself including exhibit nine
05:43:04 in the accurate flex the events on september 10 2025
05:43:10 five
05:43:11 all right guys uh you guys better you guys better say thank you or something man because holy
05:43:18 that was painful dude that was painful
05:43:22 oh man
05:43:28 i don't even know how i read that i don't even know how i did it
05:43:35 thank you that concludes publication of this exhibit
05:43:44 awful handwriting man thank you sir
05:43:49 the um well in in mr olson's 1102 statement he references more than one video does he not
05:44:00 He does yes, okay, so you with regards to the the hull of flags video
05:44:07 Have you have you seen that particular video? I have yes, okay, and that video. What does it depict?
05:44:15 It's a view kind of looking what would be east
05:44:19 Under the breezeway towards the back of the stage where mr. Cook was situated
05:44:24 It shows some movement behind the stage area
05:44:27 and I believe through the gaps you can see some of the crowd in the amphitheater.
05:44:33 I think I've neglected to do this twice before, so I'm going to do it right this time.
05:44:39 Would you please bring up an exhibit now?
05:44:42 Without question, play.
05:44:47 Tell me when you see something on your screen.
05:44:49 It's on my screen.
05:44:50 Okay. Do you recognize what's depicted in that still image?
05:44:53 I do, yes.
05:44:54 What is that?
05:44:55 It's the area underneath the Hall of Flags that I referred to as the Breezeway.
05:44:59 Okay.
05:45:00 And is this the beginning of the video?
05:45:03 It is, yes.
05:45:05 Okay.
05:45:05 And then Mr. Olson provided you?
05:45:07 Yes.
05:45:09 Judge, the state would see, well, the state asks or seeks to admit Exhibit 9.
05:45:15 With regards to publication, this is another video that due to a sensitive,
05:45:20 the nature and the graphic nature of the video.
05:45:25 We'd ask that it not be published here in the courtroom,
05:45:28 nor published in any way that the media camera could capture it.
05:45:32 And following your...
05:45:36 Yeah, no after hours tonight, guys.
05:45:37 I am going to do this stream and go to sleep, dude.
05:45:39 I still haven't slept all night, man.
05:45:42 Reasoning judge, out of deference to the victims and the victims' rights,
05:45:46 to have this type of information protected.
05:45:50 Ms. Nester.
05:45:52 Thank you, Your Honor.
05:45:53 We would object on our standing objection grounds, constitutional issues in terms of the concern about Mr. Robinson's right to a fair trial.
05:46:03 We agree it should not be published.
05:46:05 We object to its admissibility.
05:46:07 Thank you.
05:46:09 Based off my analysis that I apply independently to this exhibit, but it tracks with the previous exhibits, I find that it is admissible.
05:46:18 Also, guys, real quick, show some love.
05:46:21 um this is brett's uh facebook profile but we're gonna be posting content on here i'm live streaming
05:46:27 on it right now as a matter of fact give it a follow i'd really appreciate if you guys gave
05:46:31 it a follow let's get to 1000 followers he needs to take this horrible picture off though this is 0.91
05:46:36 a terrible picture look at look at how awkward this nigga looks like what is this bro what is 0.97
05:46:42 this with the corny peace sign so yeah um yeah boomer brett exactly uh but yeah brett's my right 0.99
05:46:49 guys you guys know but yeah he's um we're gonna we're gonna adjust this thing and obviously we
05:46:55 got andrew tate there when he came by uh last month or whatever but yeah we're gonna um
05:46:59 this is gonna be like the oss facebook page where we're where we're streaming so
05:47:04 give it a follow guys we're only 40 away from 1 000 followers okay
05:47:09 give it a follow i dropped it in the tiktok chat and the uh kick chat but anyway back to the trial
05:47:17 and we'll admit it into evidence this is state's exhibit i believe nine
05:47:23 mr sturgill play it no hold on i'm sorry this is state's exhibit nine right correct all right
05:47:32 as it relates to publication in the courtroom or by the media again citing to the utah
05:47:38 constitution article 1 section 28 1a it states to be treated with fairness respect and dignity
05:47:46 and to be free from harassment and abuse throughout the criminal justice process.
05:47:51 I find that this does apply.
05:47:54 And in respect to respect and dignity and the human experience,
05:48:00 I am going to not publish it in the courtroom, nor will it be broadcast,
05:48:06 but the court will watch it in open court.
05:48:09 And I note it is about...
05:48:13 How long is this video?
05:48:15 three minutes
05:48:18 all right again to the parties if you could just indicate if your screen is obscure thank you
05:48:29 miss nester and to the state are your screens secure so they're not viewable all right thank
05:48:37 you seeing mr mcbride nod his head we can go ahead to the state uh representative go ahead
05:48:43 and play States Exhibit 9.
05:48:47 And if there's sound, if you could activate sound.
05:48:49 I'm not sure if there is.
05:48:54 All right.
05:48:55 So there is.
05:48:56 All right.
05:48:57 Let's go ahead and replay it.
05:48:58 I just wanted to clarify there is no audio, so let's go ahead and restart it.
05:49:03 Thank you.
05:49:13 Thank you.
05:49:43 Definitely your choice.
05:49:45 So you are aware that the medical examiner's office did conduct an autopsy?
05:49:48 I am, yes.
05:49:49 Okay.
05:49:50 And did you...
05:49:51 Okay, now we're getting into the autopsy.
05:49:53 Did you receive a report from the medical examiner's office?
05:49:57 I did, yes.
05:49:58 Okay.
05:49:58 Detailing the autopsy that was performed?
05:50:04 Yes.
05:50:05 Prior to receiving the report, myself and Agent Davis visited with the doctor.
05:50:10 Okay.
05:50:10 You visited personally with the doctor that conducted the autopsy?
05:50:13 That's correct.
05:50:13 okay and then subsequent to that they might show images of this uh but obviously they're not gonna
05:50:19 we're not we probably won't see it did you discuss the autopsy with the doctor at that
05:50:23 point in time when you're meeting with him personally yes agent davis and i had a fairly
05:50:27 in-depth conversation yes and where did that conversation take place at the medical examiner's
05:50:32 office okay do you recall the date and time that that personal visit took place i don't i don't
05:50:37 recall was it was it was soon it was soon after within within a few days of
05:50:43 the incident of the autopsy yes okay and subsequent subsequent to that visit did
05:50:49 you receive a report from that that doctor that you visited with we did yes
05:50:54 okay and that's the dr. Guajardo that you're trying you're struggling to
05:51:00 pronounce his name is that yeah I apologize but yes that's who it is and
05:51:03 And the report that was sent to you, do you recall when you received that report?
05:51:09 I don't recall the specific date.
05:51:12 Okay.
05:51:13 Have you reviewed that report?
05:51:15 Yes.
05:51:18 Have you reviewed, have you, again, you stated earlier that this is not the first murder investigation that you've worked?
05:51:25 Correct.
05:51:25 Okay.
05:51:26 This is, I take it, this is not the first medical examiner's report you've received?
05:51:31 Correct.
05:51:31 Okay.
05:51:32 Okay. Do the reports typically look the same?
05:51:36 Yes, they're in a standard format that the medical examiner uses.
05:51:40 Okay, and this report that you received from who you believe was the doctor you spoke to
05:51:45 that conducted the medical exam, was there anything peculiar about that particular report that stood out to you?
05:51:52 No, it appeared to be a standard form as used by the medical examiner when they send us reports.
05:51:58 Okay.
05:52:02 On your monitor, Exhibit 11, I'm going to have displayed what's been marked,
05:52:07 State's Exhibit No. 11, Judge for Identification.
05:52:11 Right.
05:52:13 And I believe there's nine pages.
05:52:15 So let me know when you see that on your screen.
05:52:18 It's on the screen.
05:52:19 All right.
05:52:19 What I'd like you to do is just look at this as it scrolls down through the nine pages
05:52:25 and wait until we get to the very end.
05:52:28 And if you need us to pause or stop or slow down, let us know.
05:52:32 I want you to be able to look at all nine pages.
05:53:02 Did you get a look at that?
05:53:25 Yes, sir.
05:53:25 Okay.
05:53:26 Do you recognize what that is?
05:53:28 Yes.
05:53:29 What is that?
05:53:31 That's the medical examiner's report of examination for Mr. Kirk.
05:53:36 Do you recall, you don't recall exactly when you received that?
05:53:40 I don't, unfortunately, remember the specific date when I received it.
05:53:43 Do you remember how you received it?
05:53:45 Then provided to us electronically.
05:53:48 Okay, via email?
05:53:50 Sometimes via email, also on disk, compact disk.
05:53:53 Okay.
05:53:55 And does there appear to be anything in the exhibit before you?
05:54:00 Has that report changed? 0.63
05:54:02 Double tap the screen, TikTok people.
05:54:05 Double tap that screen.
05:54:06 We're sitting at, oh, wow, we're 132K.
05:54:08 We're cooking now.
05:54:10 We're cooking.
05:54:10 Let's get to 200K. 0.98
05:54:12 Get to 200K, ninjas.
05:54:13 Or does it accurately depict what you received initially from the doctor?
05:54:20 It accurately depicts it.
05:54:23 Does the state would seek to admit Exhibit 11?
05:54:28 Ms. Nestor.
05:54:29 Your Honor, this is an expert report without the expert being present, being offered by an individual who's not an expert in this field.
05:54:38 If they're presenting him as an expert in this field based on the limited questions about it.
05:54:43 Bro, this is what she's going to do.
05:54:46 She's going to say, oh, wait, he's not the medical examiner.
05:54:50 Get us the medical examiner.
05:54:51 it's not good enough that he's a lead agent and he interviewed all these people and he put the
05:55:01 case together nope i want the actual people he talked to hey i gotta give her credit she's trying
05:55:09 dude she's trying this is only a preliminary just to let you guys know preliminary hearings
05:55:16 at most last like one to two hours okay and that's when it's intense
05:55:19 all right this is like a mini trial almost experience and seeing previous medical exam
05:55:29 records i'd like to voir dire on his his qualifications to opine about it um this is
05:55:35 hearsay it's highly technical it should be presented only through an expert it could
05:55:41 never come in in trial in any other way um we submit that it is hearsay um and to the extent
05:55:49 they're going to ask this individual about any opinions about it um that would be improper he's
05:55:55 not qualified to do that um and furthermore we just she's correct he isn't qualified to do that
05:56:02 however when it comes to establishing probable cause which is what this hearing is for which is
05:56:10 an extremely low standard it will suffice i think that this is clearly falling under our
05:56:17 constitutional concerns about the but again she's yeah she's yeah that's what she's going to keep
05:56:22 saying constitutional concerns about tala robbins's ability to get a fair trial absence of our ability
05:56:28 to be effective to cross-examine to question the we can't even question the experts experience or
05:56:36 CV or anything that we would normally do to determine if this should even be accepted
05:56:39 or considered by the court. And so we strenuously object to
05:56:44 its admission and for all those reasons to its publication as well.
05:56:48 There is also, there's some really personal things
05:56:52 in there that shouldn't ever be published that deal with Mr. Kirk's
05:56:56 medical condition, history
05:56:59 is the condition of his body. It shouldn't be published,
05:57:04 your honor thank you to the state judge this is clearly uh reliable hearsay admissible under rule
05:57:13 1102 of the utah rules of evidence um i would direct you specifically to subsection we all
05:57:20 know what 1102 is now at this point huh and b5 um for purposes of rules of evidence for the state
05:57:28 Utah. And I'm quoting the rule for purposes of criminal preliminary examinations only. Reliable
05:57:34 hearsay includes in subsection five specifically states medical and autopsy reports and records.
05:57:40 Again that is supported by article one section 12 of the Utah constitution which states that
05:57:46 reliable hearsay can be relied upon at preliminary examination in whole or in part.
05:57:51 And to the second part in regards to publication. As far as the publication judge um we uh we
05:57:58 agree with Ms. Nester. This is a document that does
05:58:02 contain very sensitive information and information that
05:58:06 Mr. Kirk's family would appreciate it not being published.
05:58:10 So although we seek to admit it, we'd ask that it not be published here in the
05:58:14 courtroom or that it be published in any fashion or way that the
05:58:18 public can see it by virtue of a camera. Ms. Nester.
05:58:22 Your Honor, I just want to point out that even though 1102 has a provision
05:58:26 about um exams i mean the court still has the overarching mission under 1102 to make this
05:58:33 reliability finding right and and it's just completely in a vacuum being offered by someone
05:58:38 who's a police officer um so again we would just argue that you're just not it's i guess the medical
05:58:46 examiner report isn't good enough huh they need to have the person there to actually testify to
05:58:50 the report okay it's hampering you for making the analysis you need to make to admit it and we
05:58:54 object to it all right anything further yeah she's gonna object to everything they're from
05:58:59 the party it's gonna be one of those no you're wrong no sir all right so again relying upon the
05:59:06 analysis on utah constitution article one section 12 as we're at 153 k likes guys smash that like
05:59:17 button smash that like button for me on tiktok you guys better enjoy this bro because i'll tell
05:59:21 y'all right now normally i can't stream on tiktok because my content is not safe for tiktok but this
05:59:25 is safe this is true crime this is what my other expertise is that i can do so true crime i could
05:59:29 do on tiktok so enjoy me while you guys can enjoy me while you guys can follow the follow the page
05:59:36 we're growing super fast what's the follower at right now and we i started posting on this account
05:59:43 on june 4th we're at about 130 30k followers now we're sitting at 152 so
05:59:52 when i do true crime like this i can cover it on tiktok but i ain't gonna lie to you i can't
05:59:58 cover everything else i'll get banned it relates to reliable hearsay and then turning to
06:00:04 Utah Rules of Evidence, Rule 1102, B-5, specifically notes medical and autopsy reports and records.
06:00:17 The court is going to overrule the objection.
06:00:20 Get out of here.
06:00:26 B-5 is to reliable hearsay and then turning to.
06:00:31 So now that's all my reliable hearsay.
06:00:32 Utah rules of evidence
06:00:36 rule 1102
06:00:37 B5
06:00:39 specifically notes medical and autopsy
06:00:42 reports and records
06:00:44 the court is going to
06:00:46 overrule the objection
06:00:47 so they can be used
06:00:48 and admit
06:00:49 states exhibit
06:00:52 I believe it's 11
06:00:54 11 yes sir
06:00:55 citing to Utah
06:00:59 he gave her the yeet
06:01:00 it's coming in defense constitution article 1 section 28 dignity portion respect and dignity
06:01:12 it will not be published either in the courtroom or viewable on media by the the camera for the
06:01:21 reasons previously stated as it relates to the video and so the court will receive it
06:01:27 and it is admitted into evidence.
06:01:31 And that concludes that portion.
06:01:35 Mr. Sturgill, is this a good point to stop
06:01:37 to take our 15-minute afternoon break?
06:01:39 I think it would be a great idea, Judge.
06:01:41 I've just got one last question.
06:01:42 All right.
06:01:43 With respect to the medical examiner's report.
06:01:48 Agent Hole, in that report,
06:01:51 does the doctor relate cause and manner of death?
06:01:55 He does, yes.
06:01:56 okay and in that report what is the stated cause of death uh it was stated as a murder
06:02:02 and uh manner of death there's a gunshot wound to the neck
06:02:06 all right i object it's not stated i knew it i knew that was coming bro
06:02:14 it is a murder i believe it's stated as a homicide which is an important distinction
06:02:22 I'll go back and correct that.
06:02:24 All right.
06:02:24 So I'm going to sustain it.
06:02:26 Well, first of all, let me look at the report.
06:02:28 I need to see that section.
06:02:29 I need to be able to draw my own conclusion.
06:02:33 So, okay, I see.
06:02:35 Ms. Nester, are you referring to page one of this report?
06:02:39 I'm sorry, Your Honor.
06:02:40 Could you repeat that?
06:02:41 I apologize.
06:02:42 As it relates to your objection for the misstatements,
06:02:46 are you looking at page one of the report?
06:02:52 Yes.
06:02:52 All right.
06:02:54 Your Honor, I also need to make an objection on the best evidence rule, too.
06:02:58 Thank you.
06:02:59 All right.
06:03:00 So I'm going to sustain the objection as it relates to the manner of death.
06:03:04 It does not say murder, but in regards to the best evidence rule, again, under 1102 and the Utah Constitution that permits reliable hearsay,
06:03:15 it is, States Exhibit 11 is admitted.
06:03:22 Mr. Sturgill.
06:03:23 Agent Hull, I'm going to ask you.
06:03:25 So that's considered a reliable hearsay because it's a report.
06:03:27 Get a look at the first page of Exhibit 11.
06:03:32 No?
06:03:33 Yes, I see that.
06:03:34 Yes.
06:03:34 Okay.
06:03:35 So let me ask you again.
06:03:38 And you can look at it.
06:03:39 Yeah.
06:03:40 And would you mind relating what the doctor reports as the manner of death?
06:03:45 Yes, I misspoke.
06:03:46 It does say homicide.
06:03:48 And then the immediate cause of death.
06:03:50 Gunshot wound of the neck.
06:03:51 nothing further judge well at this moment i think it'd be a great idea that we take a 15 minute
06:03:57 break right we'll go ahead and go on break we'll come back at uh 3 25 and all right so 10 minutes
06:04:04 uh they're gonna so she's uh he's gonna get grilled by this defense attorney i already know
06:04:09 with this witness at that time court is in a brief recess
06:04:14 all right so we'll see what happens it's gonna be back in 10 minutes let me read some super chats
06:04:24 here okay let's uh let's go ahead here we got um oh man okay these are all the names uh people
06:04:33 that wanted to be mods jarada says idf killed in action 4 000 wounded in action 3800 uh has
06:04:38 bullet killed in action 39 to 78 wounded in action unknown tanks destroyed disabled 321
06:04:43 helos four oh wow craziness goki says i was gonna say i'm pretty sure the ruling to admit
06:04:50 and show certain evidence was dependent upon how vulgar the certain depiction was yeah
06:04:54 guzi woozi says can't donate at margainza.com three questions why did it take 10 months for
06:05:00 their preliminary hearing to begin uh was he held without bond yeah he was held without bond why
06:05:05 because it's a murder case um and then he fled for a while so they looked at him as a risk
06:05:08 and then also high profile so yeah and then as far as um can't donate a minor gains x um i'm not
06:05:15 gonna dox the guy but there was a pos that basically um did a bunch of chargebacks and
06:05:21 got my paypal account like cooked so i'm like appealing it but yeah the dude basically did 0.80
06:05:26 a bunch of fraud dude ridiculous man ridiculous dude ruins it for everybody so we'll see what 0.99
06:05:33 happens so annoying dude so annoying what a scumbag 1.00
06:05:38 if i don't get my account back i'm gonna put him on blast but yeah uh ozk says yo 0.95
06:05:51 mine appreciate what you've taught me you're the reason i went from 60k to 90k a year working 65
06:05:55 plus hours a week plus picking up side jobs any advice you have to reach 100k plus
06:06:00 um well here's the thing man you're gonna have to work more hours and then get a skill set that's
06:06:10 going to make you money that's going to make you more money so you don't have to do as many side
06:06:17 jobs uh nox says i'm uh 70 done with my computer science degree but i go to an online school
06:06:28 because of the flexibility as I work full-time.
06:06:31 My school is to get an internship
06:06:32 or my first job in tech right now.
06:06:34 Do you have any advice for me?
06:06:36 Online school is not going to really help with that, man.
06:06:41 But apply for internships.
06:06:42 Apply everywhere.
06:06:44 Apply everywhere.
06:06:48 All right, KB Moss says,
06:06:48 Andrew Wilson, on rare occasions,
06:06:50 streams during the day,
06:06:50 but Jake Rilesnake is during the day
06:06:52 because of Australia.
06:06:52 Okay, fair enough.
06:06:54 Fair.
06:06:58 uh one chest says uh don't be fat i agree jump in get with him he can help you guys with um
06:07:07 getting in shape knowledge raw appreciate you for joining the oss i appreciate you
06:07:14 appreciate you greatly if you guys uh rock with me man quick word from our sponsor
06:07:28 Under Trump, we will have no more wars, no more disruptions, and we will have prosperity and peace for all.
06:07:35 The mission of Operation Epic Fury is laser-focused.
06:07:39 The United States military obliterated Iran's nuclear weapons program with an attack on Iranian soil.
06:07:49 This is not just a war about security. It's an information war.
06:07:53 They need you to believe their stories, or else it all comes crashing down.
06:07:57 This war began decades ago, but now you have the right intelligence to guide you.
06:08:02 An army to march with, brothers to discuss with, and an admiral to lead the way.
06:08:07 Join the OSS army. 0.84
06:08:11 Yeah, so like when I get POSs that do chargebacks and bullshit like that, you guys can support the mission. 0.90
06:08:18 I appreciate y'all ninjas.
06:08:20 I'll drop the link in here for you guys. 0.99
06:08:22 Dude is a real scumbag for that, dude. 0.99
06:08:23 I'm so pissed off. 1.00
06:08:24 i was dealing with that crap this morning dude literally dude like incredible incredible what 0.99
06:08:32 a scumbag but yeah i'll see i'm uh appealing and i got all of his transactions i had to show 1.00
06:08:39 that the service is rendered and we'll go from there but yeah dude what a scumbag bro what a 0.99
06:08:45 scumbag gg season uh is this investigator british sounds like it yep this is why i've never liked 0.99
06:08:53 scammers bro oh my god dude they deserve jail on a whole other level what's up myron oss takeover
06:09:01 on tiktok i appreciate you my friend yeah uh brett should be giving you guys a bunch of uh
06:09:06 mod things and here's the thing it sucks for you guys because now you guys can't like get 0.93
06:09:10 involved in a show with myrongainsex.com because some dude decided to be a moron 0.98
06:09:13 you know what i mean he ruins it for everybody 0.99
06:09:18 so
06:09:22 not sure if you covered the air force officer that was arrested no i didn't hear about that
06:09:30 i'll take a look
06:09:38 also guys don't forget to give this facebook page a follow what are we at here
06:09:45 979 almost at a thousand so check this out israel's words isolate iran uh isolate israel instead
06:09:53 so basically the gulf man saudi's leading talks to pull iran into a regional security
06:10:02 pact a non-aggression framework built on cold war europe's helensky model less washington more
06:10:07 neighbors qatar's prime minister put it plainly part of what we are doing now as regional countries
06:10:12 is to create this regional security framework
06:10:13 between us and Iran.
06:10:15 Nothing is signed, and plenty of Gulf capitals
06:10:17 still don't trust Tehran an inch,
06:10:20 but the direction is unmistakable. 0.55
06:10:22 Iran gets drawn in, and Israel gets left standing outside.
06:10:24 Because remember, guys, 0.82
06:10:26 now their Gulf states are realizing
06:10:27 that the United States can't protect them, 0.93
06:10:29 and they're also realizing that Israel is reckless 0.82
06:10:31 and will start wars.
06:10:36 This war has been a big, big red pill
06:10:39 for um for the golf states dude big big red pill for them so a lot of them are waking up man a lot
06:10:50 of them are waking up so um let's see here what else we got let me look for this air force officer
06:11:03 that you guys messed with um army mel says don't agree with 100 of your takes but you made it to
06:11:09 the front page of rumble need more debates got to give you credit a lot of people uh do
06:11:14 do duck
06:11:17 i'm on the front page rumble right now i don't think i am dude
06:11:23 no i'm not on the front page rumble dude
06:11:31 uh
06:11:34 Let's see here.
06:11:37 Let's go Army officer, right?
06:11:43 Was it Army or Air Force?
06:11:50 Act through the Air Force Major Jason Watson
06:11:52 arrested the Capitol for calling for Trump impeachment.
06:11:57 Who do you serve? Who do you present?
06:11:59 The president and vice president must be impeached,
06:12:02 convicted and removed
06:12:03 impeach, convict, remove
06:12:17 okay, is this the guy you're talking about, dude?
06:12:22 hold on, let me just make sure I have the right one
06:12:24 shout out to all you guys on TikTok, man
06:12:27 Brett's going to take care of you guys
06:12:29 okay, Air Force officer, yeah, I think this is him
06:12:32 what did they arrest them for
06:12:41 trespassing maybe
06:12:43 thanks to all you guys that joined up in the oss just now i appreciate you guys man
06:12:58 makes me feel a little bit better about the um loser that uh did all the chargebacks
06:13:05 it's crazy because he sent in super chats and i read them all and he still did that you know 0.67
06:13:10 i mean it's like bro i i hate scammers dude i hate scammers so much 0.54
06:13:14 if if the paypal doesn't come back i am literally gonna i'm gonna we're gonna roast that dude i 0.54
06:13:25 have his email address and everything we're gonna we're gonna cook him you don't do that to people
06:13:30 dude that's literally stealing uh speedy says did you hear ben gavir cancels the trip to nyc because
06:13:35 of calls for his arrest i believe it snow young says apparently uh that hearsay law
06:13:41 same into effect your okay snow young bro please man come on guys bro i tell you guys all the time
06:13:47 in oss bro please grammar and spell check before you guys send super chats in bro
06:13:55 like please bro what is this
06:14:04 i think what you mean to say is apparently that hearsay law came into effect
06:14:10 this year in may that's what valhalla was saying not sure if it's true
06:14:14 no that that's always been the general when it comes to hearsay bro
06:14:19 yeah i don't want to put him on blast yet because i'm gonna try to get a handle with paypal
06:14:28 i don't want to come off as like vindictive or whatever but he's ruining your guys's like
06:14:33 because a lot of you guys like might not watch on kick or some of you guys don't know how to
06:14:37 super chat whatever on oss so he kind of like ruined your guys ability to ask questions
06:14:41 you know what i mean for no reason for absolutely no reason
06:14:46 yeah i i won't expose them until it's like last last resort dude i'm gonna try to i'm gonna try
06:14:54 to resolve it amicably first i'm gonna try to resolve it amicably first oh what's up frank
06:15:02 you want to say what's up to everybody come on over i'm on tiktok your favorite platform oh okay
06:15:07 you want to say what's up to everybody
06:15:10 yeah i love you too
06:15:16 how you doing you good okay all right all right
06:15:26 all right he always wags his tail
06:15:38 all right let's see okay the they're still going
06:15:46 septic fury 10 bucks appreciate you my friend
06:15:52 appreciate you guys showing love i really do
06:15:56 helps with the headaches okay um there was something else i wanted to show you guys
06:16:04 let me check uh
06:16:11 what's going on with youtube real quick
06:16:13 wait did Gideon really quit YouTube
06:16:21 yo ain't no way
06:16:24 did Gideon quit YouTube
06:16:27 folks a notorious YouTube prankster
06:16:32 and pred catcher Gideon
06:16:34 has just announced that he is
06:16:36 fully quitting streaming
06:16:37 after the backlash that's all related
06:16:40 to him getting arrested
06:16:41 oh yeah Brett
06:16:41 brett needs to drop the clip of i broke down the whole um
06:16:45 i literally broke down the the whole jideon thing
06:16:51 and yelling at the cops that he's a multi-millionaire after a video where he basically
06:17:02 yeah that was bad that's what happens when you become rich young dude you become you get me you
06:17:08 become a you become a pompous uh rude individual bro being rich young is is the worst thing that
06:17:15 can happen to you as a man bro he tried to prank a squatter out of a house went terribly wrong so
06:17:21 he just released an apology video that i think is very very interesting where he announced that he
06:17:25 is completely done with streaming forever he's never gonna stream again i don't believe that
06:17:29 i don't believe that he also said that he was gonna make like christian content
06:17:35 bro you guys gotta understand you can't when you're someone like jadeon and you're getting
06:17:40 millions of views like you can't you know his ego got the best of him you know i mean he's in his
06:17:45 20s he ain't going nowhere bro and i'll be honest with y'all like he's not really a smart guy so
06:17:50 it's like he doesn't really have any other skill sets besides like making videos you know i mean
06:17:54 like he won't be able to like convert his skill sets from like doing youtube to like
06:18:00 do something else that make sense like i'm not trying to be a jerk or whatever but it's like
06:18:04 just the truth he's been rich since his young 20s early 20s never really developed any other 0.93
06:18:10 skill sets before besides like pranking and making content like there's no way he's not
06:18:15 gonna he's gonna stop streaming uh bb says was it the one dial doing chargebacks on his ebt card
06:18:22 no it wasn't him me when i see frank now yawn uh they're saying mitch mcconnell's brain dead
06:18:32 Oh, that's horrible, man.
06:18:37 And he's basically throwing his hands up and said he was wrong,
06:18:39 and he's bowing out of the game.
06:18:41 Okay, they're back.
06:18:43 Priority was to identify the shooter.
06:18:45 We're back in, chat. We're back in.
06:18:47 And to that end, you started reviewing even more UVU video
06:18:51 than you've already described?
06:18:53 Correct, yes.
06:18:53 Okay.
06:18:54 Okay. What, if anything else, either did you do or happened initially that helped you identify who that shooter was?
06:19:11 So there was hundreds of hours of video that was reviewed, but the predominant focus, again, was on tracking the individual from the roof,
06:19:20 either after the shooting had occurred
06:19:23 or trying to trace the steps of the individual prior to the shooting.
06:19:28 And we were able to do that through a combined effort of individuals.
06:19:35 And the focus was having people reviewing video identify people
06:19:39 who could fit the original description of the individual that jumped off the roof.
06:19:45 Okay. At that point, so at this point, approximately how many hours of UVU video do you think you personally had seen or watched?
06:19:57 Myself, maybe 10 or 20 hours of video being called in to look at different camera angles and different views of individuals.
06:20:09 But there was a large team of people reviewing video.
06:20:13 Okay. Reviewing video?
06:20:14 yeah from the view or so yeah and that's common guys with cases like this like i remember for the
06:20:20 um uh the um oh my god um the boston marathon bombing case bro i was looking at video
06:20:29 like dude like you get oh it's all hands on deck when when you got something like that
06:20:34 you know i remember reviewing video uh back in 2013 when i was working for the government
06:20:40 with that with that case of them sbi agents yes correct and combined uh how much video do you
06:20:47 think you watched that first day on the 10th it would be in the tens or hundreds of hours of video
06:20:54 was reviewed okay uh did anything else come along that helped you identify who that shooter might be
06:21:00 Yeah, eventually on the evening of the 11th, we received word from Washington County
06:21:09 that an individual in that area had reached out to law enforcement
06:21:16 and was wanting to turn themselves in for the incident at UVU.
06:21:21 Okay.
06:21:22 And did you, at that point in time, did you receive a name from Washington County?
06:21:26 Yes, we did.
06:21:27 And what was that name?
06:21:28 Tyler Robinson.
06:21:30 What, if anything, did you do with that information, the name title, Robinson?
06:21:35 That information was given to our SIAC or our state information and analysis group,
06:21:41 and they put together what would be called a workup.
06:21:44 So they would look at driver's license records, DMV records to determine addresses,
06:21:50 obtain pictures of individuals, and then any associated vehicles or things like that.
06:21:55 Now, to be honest with you guys, I run my own checks. 0.99
06:21:58 I don't like giving it to analysts to do that shit. 0.96
06:21:59 that was actually one of my favorite things to do was get all their stuff right um but you know 0.99
06:22:05 you could give it to one of the analysts and do that for you they run them through all the dmv
06:22:08 records everything you got addresses utility listings all that so was that done with mr
06:22:12 robinson it was yes driver's license record was pulled yes did that include if you remember or
06:22:18 do you know did that include a photograph of mr robinson it did include a photograph of mr
06:22:22 robinson yes how about an address and date of birth there was an address and a date of birth
06:22:27 and I believe a DMV record with an associated vehicle.
06:22:31 All right.
06:22:31 So that DMV record did include a vehicle that was associated with Mr. Robinson?
06:22:36 Correct.
06:22:37 Okay.
06:22:38 Do you remember what the make and model of the vehicle was
06:22:43 that was tied to Mr. Robinson?
06:22:45 The Dodge Challenger.
06:22:47 Anything else beyond that that you remember?
06:22:50 It was silver in color,
06:22:51 and I believe there were two registered owners of the vehicle.
06:22:55 Okay.
06:22:55 And who were the registered owners?
06:22:56 Mr. Robinson and then his mother. Do you recall whether or not a date of birth
06:23:02 was included in that driver's license information that you got initially? Yeah
06:23:06 I believe the actual driver's license record was shared so it would have
06:23:10 included a date of birth. All right with Mr. well with Tyler Robinson's personal
06:23:18 information were you able to expand your search at all yes once we knew a vehicle that we were
06:23:27 looking for and we had an actual image of the individual then we were able to use that video
06:23:35 footage to to try and track that specific individual okay and I'm sorry let me clarify
06:23:40 So when I said expand your search, I'm referencing the UVU surveillance video.
06:23:48 Yes, we were able to.
06:23:49 Okay.
06:23:51 And were you able to identify in that expanded search, or did you believe you located that challenger?
06:24:00 We did, yes.
06:24:01 Okay. Were you able to determine at what time or times Mr. Robinson visited the UVU campus on September 10th?
06:24:12 Yeah, we were able to establish that Mr. Robinson had been on campus approximately four times throughout the day, twice before the shooting, the time of the shooting, and then after the shooting later in the evening into the early hours of the 11th.
06:24:31 hey tiktok people if you guys want me to stay on tiktok you guys better smash
06:24:38 that button what are we sitting at we're at 84 we need a 200k guys
06:24:42 we need 200k 200k 200k ninjas 200k
06:24:50 200k and i'll stay on tiktok a little bit longer otherwise i'm gonna go straight to kick
06:24:59 Let's go, Ninjas.
06:25:02 You said that you initially tracked the shooter forward and backward with UVU surveillance video.
06:25:11 Correct.
06:25:12 Okay.
06:25:13 Did you do the same thing with that vehicle?
06:25:16 We did, yes.
06:25:17 Okay.
06:25:17 Tracked it forward and backward?
06:25:19 Yes, using the UVU footage and additional information that was obtained, yes.
06:25:24 and I believe you said that in total Mr. Robinson visited the UVU campus four times that day
06:25:32 yes that's correct and let's just be clear that's all based on UVU surveillance video
06:25:38 is that fair to say that's correct yes okay have you um have you reviewed what's been marked
06:25:47 States Exhibit 12.1 for identification? I have, yes. Okay. And, well, let me, before we go there,
06:25:54 of the video that you have personally watched,
06:26:00 does the video include the 10th and the 11th or just the 10th? The video I've seen includes the
06:26:08 10th and then a very small portion, I think, about 030 of the 11th. Okay. And I think you said
06:26:14 initially you watched about 20 hours of video? Yes. Since that time have you
06:26:19 watched additional video? Yes. UVU surveillance video? Yes. Okay and who
06:26:24 provided the UVU surveillance video to you? It was part of the collection of
06:26:30 videos that was provided by Mr. Olson and his team that we already discussed
06:26:35 previously okay of the of all the hours of video that you've watched do you have
06:26:45 an idea of how many hours include mr. Robinson or his vehicle just with UVU or
06:26:53 just with UVU I'm sorry just with UVU
06:26:59 It would probably be about 16 hours.
06:27:03 And let's be clear, this is someone you believe to be Tyler Robinson.
06:27:08 Correct.
06:27:09 And this person that you've identified as Tyler Robinson that you've been investigating
06:27:15 and that you viewed in the numerous hours of video from UVU,
06:27:19 would you recognize that person if he were in the courtroom today?
06:27:22 Yes.
06:27:23 Is he in the courtroom today?
06:27:24 He is, yes.
06:27:25 Would you point him out and describe something that he's wearing?
06:27:27 i know we object to um of course of course we object he can't identify i'm in the courtroom
06:27:38 even though he's right next to me unduly suggestive in court identification for constitutional grounds
06:27:45 do you wish to specify an unduly constitutional
06:27:54 I'm trying to understand your objections I want to make sure I fully understand
06:27:59 your honor I think there's some you know deferred to
06:28:02 Mr. Byrd if he wants to jump in but I believe there's a long line
06:28:07 of case law that says and you ask someone to identify the defendant
06:28:11 when they're the only person, you know, sitting at the table with defense counsel,
06:28:16 that that's unduly suggestive and taints any future or past, well, definitely future, identification.
06:28:26 So we object to that happening in this fashion at this time.
06:28:30 Mr. Sturgill.
06:28:32 Judge, Agent Hull has testified that he has watched numerous hours of video.
06:28:38 Well, take a step back.
06:28:39 He has looked at personal identifying information of an individual by the name of Tyler Robinson.
06:28:46 He's looked at the driver's license record, and he's also looked at the DMV records
06:28:50 and has been able to determine what car that person drives.
06:28:54 He's also looked at surveillance video that he believes depicts this Tyler Robinson.
06:29:00 And I've simply asked him if that person that he has seen,
06:29:05 both in driver's license photos and the surveillance video if that person is here in the courtroom
06:29:12 today and i don't know that that's unduly prejudicial or suggestive it's the routine
06:29:19 i i don't know of any other way to do it other than the way i just did it judge
06:29:23 all right well i wanted to verify the format of the question i would remember it in my mind
06:29:29 But to Ms. Nestor, was that an accurate portrayal of the question that was asked?
06:29:35 Yes.
06:29:35 Okay.
06:29:38 Mr. Sturgill, anything further before I issue my ruling?
06:29:41 No, other than Judge, I believe it's worth noting that Mr. Robinson is in plain clothes.
06:29:48 Well, he's in plain clothes.
06:29:51 Counsel, please approach the bench.
06:29:59 All right, they're going to do a quick little sidebar.
06:30:02 Yeah, the defense is going to do anything, bro, to like, you know,
06:30:05 try to, you know, deflect here and there.
06:30:09 So they're obviously turning off the mic so they can talk a little bit.
06:30:29 so check this out guys
06:30:33 Scottie Pippen
06:30:34 is dating
06:30:37 hold on
06:30:44 we got like a rainstorm here or something 0.99
06:30:46 he's got a 23 year old girlfriend
06:30:50 and everyone's all mad about it
06:30:52 meanwhile his
06:30:55 ex-wife
06:30:56 52 years old ran through
06:30:58 cooked
06:30:59 all right uh here's what i'm talking about based off of what's been presented in court
06:31:11 i'm not having it back to the true crime finding that particular question
06:31:15 as previously posed as suggestive um i find for the purposes of this hearing only keep smashing
06:31:23 that like button guys that's what gets the views up i'm figuring it out let's get to 250 ninjas
06:31:28 Let's get to 250.
06:31:29 Yeah, that'd be Scottie Piven, facts.
06:31:31 The in-court identification by Agent Hull of Mr. Robinson.
06:31:35 And follow the page.
06:31:36 If you guys enjoy a true crime, follow the page.
06:31:39 Follow the page, ninjas.
06:31:41 Has been made.
06:31:42 Again, this only relates to the preliminary hearing, and you may proceed.
06:31:46 Thank you, Judge.
06:31:48 Agent Hull, have you reviewed what's been marked state's exhibit 12.1 for identification?
06:31:53 I have, yes.
06:31:55 And where did you review that video?
06:31:57 was provided to me I reviewed it on my computer in my office okay and and is
06:32:06 that the first time that you've seen this particular video footage this
06:32:11 particular version of the footage yes okay so this particular version the
06:32:14 first time but have you seen the video that that that comprises I guess exhibit
06:32:25 12.1 yeah I have seen the original videos if that's your question yes so so
06:32:30 what is state's exhibit 12.1 how would you describe it I would describe it as
06:32:35 a compilation of the video that we obtained from Utah Valley University
06:32:41 during the course of the investigation that depicts the movements of the
06:32:46 individual I believe to be mr. Robinson moving around the campus on September
06:32:50 10th 2025 into the morning of september 11th 2025 did you prepare uh this video compilation
06:32:58 i did not okay do you know who did uh yes utah county attorney's office i believe ms derfleur
06:33:04 is the one that produced the video okay do you know ms derfleur's first name kimberly okay
06:33:08 uh what if anything did you do to authenticate the video uh in this compilation i reviewed the
06:33:16 video to make sure that it was a reflection of what I understood the
06:33:21 original videos to show okay what if anything else did you do I reviewed it
06:33:30 I know that there was some some zooms and some changes to the footage okay did
06:33:36 you meet with mr. Olson with regards to this particular video yes this video was
06:33:41 also part of that original meeting with mr. Olson for the prior exhibit yes okay
06:33:45 So at the same time you sat down with Mr. Olson and
06:33:49 Discussed the the prior exhibit
06:33:52 And let's just be clear which exhibit that is
06:34:00 So I believe the well the the 1102 statement that you gathered from him is exhibit 12.3 correct? Yes
06:34:07 So the same time that you gathered that 12.3 or that that
06:34:11 Written statement that is states exhibit 12.3
06:34:14 you talked to him about this specific exhibit as well yes mr. Olson was shown
06:34:19 this exhibit and did he include that in that 1102 statement yeah I believe he
06:34:25 specifically referenced the exhibit by name stating that it was a true
06:34:29 reflection of the footage from the campus
06:34:34 and let's just go back to what you were stating earlier um to you it appears to be a compilation
06:34:47 of videos that you've already seen correct that you received as a mass dump i guess for lack of
06:34:52 we're sitting at 210 guys let's get it up to 250 let's go 250 ninjas 250 quarter quarter million
06:34:58 taps better term if you view video is that fair to say yes okay and the the
06:35:05 exhibit 12.1 does it appear to be the same as the the raw video that you've
06:35:14 seen previously it does yes are there are there some minor are there any added
06:35:21 additions or anything different about this particular exhibit there are some
06:35:24 portions of the video where um a zoom is initiated which wasn't a function of the cameras
06:35:29 i believe some specific individuals have been blurred from the footage
06:35:33 and i believe there are some red circles to show thank you guys for tapping bro we're gonna take
06:35:38 over on tiktok if i honestly if i um if i just start um doing true crime on here for you guys
06:35:46 like we'll take over bro literally we will take over if i just come over here and just do true
06:35:51 crime because i'll be honest the other stuff is going to get me banned bro i can't say the other
06:35:55 stuff i want to talk about but i could i could uh go on tiktok for the true crime poignant
06:35:59 information or individuals within the footage itself okay so other than the red circles the blur
06:36:04 and the zoom uh does it appear to accurately who was on the stand this is uh special agent
06:36:10 david ho with the uh state bureau of investigation guys sbi it's right here he was the lead
06:36:15 investigator in the beginning of the charlie kirk assassination you depict uh what you've seen in the
06:36:21 So he did a lot of the early investigative stuff?
06:36:24 I believe so, yes.
06:36:32 On your screen, I'm going to have displayed an image.
06:36:39 Let me know when you see it.
06:36:51 that image is there now it's gone again
06:37:00 is it there we're back okay we're back so do you recognize what this is yeah this is the first
06:37:11 frame of the video compilation that we just referenced and again this video portrays what
06:37:19 you believe is mr. Robinson visiting campus that day correct okay and is it
06:37:23 throughout the day it is yes and then I believe he said into the early morning
06:37:27 hours of the 11th is that right correct
06:37:37 just as the state would see there would move to admit what's been marked states
06:37:43 Exhibit 12.1. Ms. Nestor. Your Honor, we have objections to its admissibility. This is a compilation video that was put together from a bunch of different sources by the county attorney's office.
06:38:05 This individual did not create this compilation, can't testify to the accuracy of the actual materials that it was taken from.
06:38:20 And furthermore, Mr. Olson himself is just referred to by Agent Hall.
06:38:28 He specifically says people have altered these recordings.
06:38:33 They've zoomed in when the actual recording isn't zoomed.
06:38:36 They've added little circles to people they want you to pay attention to.
06:38:40 They've blurred people's faces out.
06:38:42 So, I mean, it's been clearly altered.
06:38:44 And it's not, I mean, they admit it's been altered.
06:38:47 So we have real concern about authenticity of it.
06:38:50 Furthermore, this particular video should be protected.
06:38:55 And so that deals with the admissibility factor.
06:38:57 As far as the publication factor of it, the video should be classified as protected.
06:39:03 under UCJA 4-202.02, subsection 5, J as in jelly bean, and then little I and little double I,
06:39:18 because this is going to interfere with the defense's ongoing investigation with Mr. Tyler's ability,
06:39:24 I mean with Mr. Robinson's ability to get a fair trial.
06:39:26 This is basically putting together photos that are clear with photos that aren't clear, putting them all together in such a format that it makes the case that it's all one person.
06:39:43 It would be extremely prejudicial for people that may ultimately serve on this jury to watch this video before this case goes to trial.
06:39:53 We don't believe a proper foundation has been laid, which would make it admissible at this point.
06:39:58 So the fact that it would be shown to the public would be extremely damaging to the ability to put on a defense at trial.
06:40:05 And so we object to its publication both in the courtroom and to the media, Your Honor.
06:40:12 Mr. Sturgill.
06:40:13 Judge, Ms. Nester is correct.
06:40:15 This is a compilation of a series of videos.
06:40:17 the the videos is detector of as a sergeant hole has testified to is it's
06:40:27 a compilation of raw videos that he has received from Utah Valley University and
06:40:33 he has not only seen this video but he has seen all the raw footage and by his
06:40:40 estimation or according to his testimony these are all videos that that are
06:40:45 accurate and and they depict what the raw footage depicts other than those
06:40:50 minor additions judge if you refer to mr. Olson's written statement it's
06:40:55 plaintiffs exhibit 12.3 he too has reviewed this video and he is also
06:41:04 identified this video as being accurate with the exception of those additions in
06:41:10 his words it's the zooms and the red highlights they weren't part of the
06:41:13 original recording according to Mr. Olson but other than that as he states
06:41:21 the same as Agent Hull these videos are accurate and they were captured by UVU
06:41:26 surveillance video. Do you have a version of this video that does not have
06:41:37 alterations such as zooming or circling my concern is that if the 1102 says
06:41:45 what it says about the videos these were the videos right but then it was altered
06:41:50 and typically an exhibit which has been altered and if it wasn't done by the
06:41:56 person who supplied the 1102 that that can become problematic and so do you
06:42:01 have a version of of this exhibit that does not have the zooming in or the circling again i don't
06:42:08 know all the alterations that were made but that seems to fall outside the 1102 because you don't
06:42:13 have we're sitting at 237 guys tap it up let's get to a quarter million tap it up guys let's get to
06:42:21 50 250 000 a person testifying i love no two saying i made the alterations right and so that
06:42:29 That's the concern of what Ms. Nestor was talking about as it relates to the state's evidence.
06:42:36 I have that concern about those alterations.
06:42:39 Again, I don't know when they were made, what they were made, how much was done to manipulate the video.
06:42:47 And I say manipulate to not saying in a nefarious way, but I don't know what the scope of that is
06:42:54 and how much it deviates from what was the original form.
06:43:00 Judge, to answer your first question,
06:43:01 do we have a version of this particular video that has not been altered?
06:43:06 We don't, not right now, not today.
06:43:10 I guess there's a couple of things I'd simply like to point out, Judge,
06:43:15 and that is that we have two witnesses who have watched the raw footage.
06:43:20 And Agent Hull here today on the stand,
06:43:23 and Mr. Olson in the form of his written statement.
06:43:27 They have both said that this video,
06:43:29 with the exception of these alterations,
06:43:31 accurately depicts the video that was captured
06:43:35 by UVU surveillance video.
06:43:37 Judge, I will proffer that those changes made to the video
06:43:40 were not done by either.
06:43:42 Hey, Jerry Loss, nobody cares if you think it's boring.
06:43:44 Enjoy the Shadow Realm.
06:43:45 Time to send you to the Shadow Realm.
06:43:49 The future is mine. 1.00
06:43:51 i know you can't pay attention because you got a tiktok brain
06:43:55 but enjoy the shadow room i know who that person is we could actually call that person as a witness
06:44:02 if that would cure that um and we're prepared to do that if necessary but judge i i think uh that
06:44:11 our our burden is to simply authenticate you know what this is and it is it is a video
06:44:19 that with only a few exceptions, alterations,
06:44:23 that really don't change the substance of the video
06:44:26 or the content of the video, they're accurate.
06:44:29 They depict what the cameras captured on September 10th and the 11th.
06:44:33 And we have two people who have seen that raw footage
06:44:36 and they've explained that's the only difference
06:44:38 between what we have originally in the original videos
06:44:42 and what you're seeing here today.
06:44:44 And the additions, I will submit, Judge, were only added...
06:44:47 All right, Tic Tac Ninjas.
06:44:49 come on over to kit guys bmerc thank you very much gave you two hours on on tiktok come on over
06:44:55 to kit guys it's free you don't gotta download that you can literally just click the link no
06:45:00 ads either it's better than youtube way better than youtube no ads at all drop the link guys
06:45:06 i'm ending the uh tiktok stream so i don't have to censor myself because i ain't gonna lie bro 0.96
06:45:11 i'm tired i can't swear it's really annoying i can't show you guys anything i can't fucking say 0.87
06:45:17 anything I want to say. So come on over to Kit, guys. I am getting off of TikTok. Getting off 0.90
06:45:22 of TikTok. Come on over, guys. TikTok stream is going to go down now. Trying to have to censor
06:45:28 myself. Can't swear. It's really annoying. I dropped the link in the chat. Mod dropped the
06:45:33 link in the chat. Come on over, guys, so we can uncensor ourselves. All right. Let's go and just
06:45:39 come on over. Come on over. It's that time. Now we can be finally racist again.
06:45:47 come on over ninjas
06:45:50 facebook going down
06:45:53 tiktok going down
06:45:56 link is in the chat
06:45:58 there's no ads
06:46:00 we hit the 250k
06:46:02 no ads
06:46:04 easy to use
06:46:08 very fast good latency
06:46:09 it's better than tiktok honestly for streaming
06:46:12 come on over to kick ninjas 0.99
06:46:17 all right all right let's fucking go 0.99
06:46:24 all right anything further from the parties 0.91
06:46:32 all right i'm gonna go ahead and i'm sustaining the objection uh typically in when exhibits are
06:46:40 admitted to the court it is without alteration if a party circles an exhibit a photograph
06:46:46 that's not the original format and i do not have the person who made the alteration
06:46:52 uh an 1102 to substantiate that and what i have is the original video and mr all of a sudden saying
06:47:00 this is the video minus the alterations and we have agent hall saying this is the video and
06:47:06 there are alterations but i'm missing a link and and it may be minor yeah they're going to bring
06:47:13 that guy in now but in in this type of case i want to be thorough and i want to make sure that
06:47:19 what is minor is still important and for those reasons i'm going to sustain the objection
06:47:24 and all right she got one bit to the parties on how you wish to handle the video in the future i
06:47:30 don't want to provide guys yeah they're going to bring they're going to bring this olsen guy in
06:47:33 now unless they don't need it they got more they probably got more evidence so they might not have
06:47:37 to bring him in for but for trial now they know he has to come in i didn't see the way of course
06:47:40 right but as it stands today uh this exhibit states exhibits 12.1 is not admitted okay
06:47:50 so i'm just gonna have just one moment you may
06:47:52 yeah those agents are gonna go out tonight to talk to this dude hey you got it coming tomorrow 0.86
06:47:59 buddy i already know they're about to go to that nigga's house tonight bruh matter of fact let's 0.95
06:48:05 Hold on. 0.95
06:48:06 They're sending an agent right now as we speak 1.00
06:48:09 to go talk to that fucking guy. 1.00
06:48:12 Hey, you got to show up tomorrow, buddy. 1.00
06:48:16 Oh, I can't.
06:48:16 I got work. 1.00
06:48:17 Okay, nigga, here's a subpoena. 0.99
06:48:21 Oh, man. 0.96
06:48:35 he's talking with his other prosecutor and we were able to locate the footage of his vehicle
06:48:55 on that ring doorbell camera or at least what you believe is his his vehicle the vehicle we
06:49:00 believe to belong to mr. yes and is there something about this particular video and
06:49:04 And this, I guess, vehicle that was captured that leads you to believe that it was Mr. Robinson's vehicle?
06:49:11 Yeah, the vehicle has very distinct wheels.
06:49:15 I won't say that they're wholly unique.
06:49:19 But in terms of the video footage that we were reviewing, the wheels on the vehicle are fairly unique and stand out on the video footage.
06:49:28 So again, this is video that you received early on in the investigation.
06:49:33 Yes.
06:49:34 and then in preparation for the preliminary hearing you went back out and you you met with
06:49:38 someone about this video correct who specifically did you meet with about this video met with mrs
06:49:44 noble and what did you do with miss noble uh we did what we had done before we had a specific file
06:49:50 that we wanted or files that we wanted her to verify the footage itself is is broken into i
06:49:57 believe 10 second segments so we had specific files that we had her view and confirmed that
06:50:03 they were actually from her system those were written on the 1102 as they have been before
06:50:09 okay and who wrote who wrote those file names on this particular statement i believe it would be
06:50:14 my handwriting on the 1102 all right what did you do next uh we had uh view the videos and then
06:50:21 complete a statement verifying the the authenticity of those videos on the 1102 okay was this also
06:50:27 prepared on a state bureau form i believe this was on a state bureau investigations form yes
06:50:32 and in this particular form on which miss noble provided her statement does it have the advisory
06:50:37 that it would be used in lieu of her testimony here today it does yes does it also contain a
06:50:42 warning that if she gave a false statement she would be punished or it's punishable by a class
06:50:46 a misdemeanor correct okay i'm gonna have displayed on your monitor what's been marked
06:50:58 state's exhibit number 13 for identification let me know when you see that would you
06:51:03 i can see that okay i'm going to have um my assistant scroll through that slowly
06:51:24 okay
06:51:26 you recognize that i do yes what is that it's the 1102 that myself and agent davis uh collected
06:51:34 from uh miss noble okay and it appears does it appear to be in the same condition as when you
06:51:39 collected it it does yes this is a copy right all right real quick b-merc suleiman amari um
06:51:45 n-y uh n-y-t mayor expensive eddie gbc oss alex skeletal being a skeletal being castle club clan
06:51:55 spicy egg taco sammy nicklin patrick starved david shout out to all you guys mike dixie
06:52:01 tpc films fnf speed thank you guys so much for the gift of subs bro
06:52:04 appreciate you ninjas and then as far as super chats go um blow says uh hey man right now i'm
06:52:14 fired for my old job but i'm getting a new job very soon once i start working should i do my
06:52:19 nine to five door dash to not only have six months uh to a year of savings but also to pay for a side
06:52:25 also that will make me 10k a month yeah you got to do both or should i invest in a bitcoin and
06:52:29 treat it as my emergency fund while i find another side also on the side um you just need to have
06:52:35 cash bro don't worry about crypto right now you need you just need to have money you just need to
06:52:40 have money you're poor you you just had you just got to get money right now okay um and and honestly
06:52:47 to buying a Bitcoin right now is too high
06:52:50 for you to get in. A Bitcoin
06:52:52 right now, as we speak, is like $60,000.
06:52:55 So
06:52:56 you just need to get cash. You need
06:52:58 to make as much money as you possibly can right now.
06:53:01 Yeah, Bitcoin is sitting at
06:53:02 about $64K. 0.69
06:53:04 Hamas apparently dismantled their own
06:53:06 government. I don't know if you have covered already,
06:53:08 but could you explain what that means
06:53:09 in practicality? Let me check that out.
06:53:13 Defensive 0.66
06:53:14 attorneys and badges are battling pretty hard. Yeah.
06:53:17 should a man who has one child consider marrying a woman who has two children from a previous
06:53:23 relationship particularly if she was in that relationship for 11 years she said only two
06:53:28 sexual partners in a lifetime maternity would be would he be better suited for marrying someone
06:53:33 to marrying someone who has no children fewer than five previous sexual partners okay i think i 0.99
06:53:40 understand your question it was again horribly written guys please fucking spell check your 0.99
06:53:43 questions bro what the fuck man um and grammar check your questions um to answer to answer it 0.99
06:53:52 though um look you got a kid she got two kids just be careful i'm not a fan of getting with 0.99
06:54:00 single moms but you're gonna do it anyway more than likely so you got a kid she got a kid you
06:54:07 guys can probably make it work she got two kids just uh don't go too hard to invest too much and
06:54:14 spend too much money you got to be very careful bro because you got to remember when you marry
06:54:19 a single mom and you got kids you're going to build an attachment to her kids naturally 1.00
06:54:23 so i think you're better off getting a girl that don't got kids bro 0.69
06:54:29 i think you're way better off getting a girl that don't got kids
06:54:34 but if you really want to get with a girl that already has two kids
06:54:39 you know that's on you but that's a huge risk bro huge risk you're putting yourself under
06:54:44 yes okay
06:54:47 and the personal identifying information appears to be redacted is that right it has been redacted
06:54:58 it wasn't redacted when you collected it right no no the original form was not redacted so other
06:55:03 Other than the redactions, it appears to be in the same condition as it was when you collected that.
06:55:07 That is correct.
06:55:08 State would move to admit Exhibit 13.
06:55:10 Ms. Naster.
06:55:14 I know we renew our concern about unconstitutional hearsay being admitted.
06:55:19 We also have the same concerns about the fact that Agent Hole amended this himself,
06:55:30 and there's no foundation as to when he filled that in,
06:55:34 if it was before or after she signed it.
06:55:36 And due to all those reasons, we object to its admission
06:55:39 and object to its publication as well.
06:55:43 Mr. Sturgill.
06:55:44 Judge, again, it was collected in compliance with Rule 1102
06:55:48 of the Utah Rules of Evidence,
06:55:52 specifically subsection B-8.
06:55:55 It's in writing.
06:55:57 It's on a form.
06:55:58 It includes both the advisory and the warning.
06:56:00 and it was collected by agent hole it's also collected in compliance and being
06:56:09 introduced as reliable hearsay which is lawful to do here in Utah under the
06:56:15 state Constitution article 1 section 12 do you wish to lay more foundation about
06:56:20 when the statement was written whether it was before it was signed or not I can
06:56:24 do that judge I appreciate that yes agent hold do you recall when you
06:56:28 collected this written statement from Ms. Noble? Yes, it was in April. In April, do you know what
06:56:33 day? April 6th, I believe. Okay. And you collected it, did you go to her home? I think, is that what
06:56:40 you said? Yes, myself and Agent Davis went to the residence. Okay, and did you sit there while she
06:56:44 prepared it? I did, yes. And did you witness her sign it? I did, yes. Okay. At this point, I'd move to
06:56:50 admit, Exhibit 13.
06:56:55 All right, and to the state representative, could you scroll down?
06:57:04 Okay.
06:57:07 All right, pursuant to the Utah Rule of Evidence 1102 and Article 1, Section 28, I'm sorry,
06:57:14 Article 1, Section 12, which allows for a reliable hearsay.
06:57:21 I'm going to move it into, it's going to be admitted into evidence over the objection of defense.
06:57:28 I note in particular that it states that I confirmed that the above files were taken from our Nest doorbell videos and are accurate.
06:57:38 and right before that statement is the notations that were allegedly made by Agent Hull.
06:57:50 And so for those reasons, the court finds proper foundation has been laid
06:57:56 and that this exhibit in its entirety is admitted into evidence.
06:58:03 As it relates to publication, I will authorize publication in the courtroom
06:58:08 and by the media, if they so wish to capture it in that form.
06:58:13 Again, following the same formats,
06:58:15 I have it on that first portion of the screen for about 10 seconds
06:58:21 and then scroll down to the written portion for about 15 seconds
06:58:25 and then scroll to the very bottom to ensure that the full exhibit has been displayed.
06:58:38 Okay, so here's the case number.
06:58:41 It looks like I confirm that the above files were taken from our Nest doorbell videos and are accurate videos taken on September 10th and 11th, 2025 and provided voluntarily.
06:58:57 And then this is from Cinzia DeNoble, April 6th, 2026.
06:59:08 All right, that concludes the publication of State's Exhibit 13.
06:59:26 Okay.
06:59:28 Thank you, Judge.
06:59:29 the um the video that you took with you that day when you visited with noble or miss noble
06:59:40 um had you had you previously well you've stated that the videos that you showed uh the nobles were
06:59:50 actually more than one video correct okay and i believe you said they were like 10 second clips
06:59:55 if i recall correctly short clips okay and and you showed miss noble all of those uh all of
07:00:03 those videos that are identified in that statement the one shown on the on the statement were shown
07:00:08 to miss noble yes okay have you had a chance to review what's been marked state's exhibit number
07:00:18 12.2 yes okay and when did you have a chance to review that exhibit I believe
07:00:26 that was reviewed last week I believe okay with with yourself okay and and
07:00:33 does that video is it a single video that you watched no I believe it's four
07:00:40 separate short videos okay and as far as and I understand that but as far as 12.2
07:00:46 is concerned what does that exhibit consist of I chose the vehicle believed
07:00:54 to be driven by mr. Robinson arriving in front of the residence an individual
07:00:59 exiting the vehicle and moving away from it followed by an individual returning
07:01:03 to the vehicle and unlocking it and then it shows the vehicle short time later
07:01:08 starting and leaving the area and and those are the videos that you showed
07:01:13 Ms. Noble? Yes.
07:01:22 What I have displayed on your monitor was Ben Mark's plaintiffs or States Exhibit 12.2 for identification.
07:01:29 Let me know as soon as you see should be a still image.
07:01:35 It's there. Do you recognize what's depicted there? Yeah, this is the view looking
07:01:40 what would essentially be west across the street from the nobles' residence.
07:01:46 Okay.
07:01:46 At 1238 a.m., I guess, or 038?
07:01:52 Yes.
07:01:52 Okay.
07:01:54 And what is depicted in this?
07:02:04 I think you've already described that.
07:02:05 So, Judge, I would move to admit Exhibit 12.2.
07:02:09 Ms. Nestor.
07:02:10 Your Honor, we renew our objection to allowing in 1.00
07:02:19 God damn, this bitch don't know how to use the mic 1.00
07:02:20 The evidence without the sponsoring 1.00
07:02:22 Sorry, Chad, that's her
07:02:23 I do have some concerns because I'm not totally sure if this is a compilation
07:02:30 or if this is just one of the one, two, three, four, five, at least six videos
07:02:36 they took from the nobles so if we get out of that clarification I think that
07:02:43 that concerns me about authenticity that I don't understand if this is just a
07:02:47 portion or if this is the whole thing or is this is all of them or none of them
07:02:51 and for those reasons we object to the admission and to publication. Thank you
07:02:56 Mr. Sturgill. That's a good point and I'll ask additional questions before I
07:03:00 re-seek to admit it. Agent Hull this particular video you've described taking
07:03:06 several videos to Ms. Noble and having a review them yes okay this particular
07:03:10 exhibit 12.2 you watched it in its entirety yes does it consist of either
07:03:16 some or all of those videos that you showed Ms. Noble it does yes and is it a
07:03:21 single video is it a compilation that is to say or is it four different videos
07:03:27 or a number of different videos be a number of short videos sequenced okay a
07:03:33 A number of short videos in sequence.
07:03:36 I believe that's how this one plays, yes.
07:03:39 Okay.
07:03:43 Just again, I'll speak to a minute.
07:03:45 Anything further from the parties?
07:03:48 All right.
07:03:48 All right.
07:03:49 Given my previous rulings on exhibits, I applied the same analysis and find that State's Exhibit 12.2, I believe,
07:04:02 is admitted over the objection
07:04:05 and may be published in the courtroom
07:04:07 and by the media, if so chosen.
07:04:13 Okay, so before we play this video,
07:04:16 again, what is it that leads you to believe
07:04:20 that this is Mr. Robinson's vehicle?
07:04:25 The shape of the vehicle can be clearly seen
07:04:27 as it pulls up and the distinctive wheels
07:04:30 on the vehicle also.
07:04:32 and uh what well let's go ahead and play it is there any sound associated with this
07:04:38 there is judge but it's it's night sounds it's crickets chirping and um okay i just wanted to
07:04:46 see if there was i just wanted to see if there was sound or not yeah the judge doesn't want no
07:04:50 gunshots or anything violent being shown to the press on okay all right you may play it's like
07:04:55 dude everyone's seen it already video but i get it like they're trying to make it fair
07:04:59 Here we go.
07:05:29 I don't know.
07:05:59 So on the first part of that video, what do you see?
07:06:16 The vehicle we believe to be driven by Mr. Robinson pulling up and parking across the
07:06:21 street but in front of the residence.
07:06:23 Okay.
07:06:24 And then in the next video, what do you believe is displayed in that video?
07:06:28 There's an individual who gets out of the vehicle.
07:06:31 You can hear the door close and then that individual moves away from the front of the
07:06:37 vehicle.
07:06:38 There's actually two reflective panels on a dumpster and you can see the individual
07:06:43 past those reflective panels.
07:06:46 And in the last of those series of videos?
07:06:50 The second to last one, the individual comes back across those reflective panels to the
07:06:54 vehicle, unlocks the vehicle and gets into it.
07:06:57 And then in the last video the vehicle is started and an individual drives away
07:07:21 Just one moment judge. Yes
07:07:27 We might not get a chance to hear the cross from the defense today.
07:07:32 Prosecution is really eating up all this time.
07:07:57 can we approach you may
07:08:22 all right you're doing a sidebar
07:08:24 so i guess jd on really did quit youtube huh this gotta be cat bro this is gonna be probably
07:08:45 be a lawyer prepared statement so um this is genuinely gonna be my last video ever like this
07:08:50 i'm never gonna make a video like this again but you know uh obviously you guys know what's all
07:08:56 going on you guys saw me getting arrested you guys saw a cold blues video and everything
07:09:01 and um i did a reaction to it kind of like oh no this wasn't right this is how it happened
07:09:08 but genuinely during the last few weeks i've done a lot of did you take that video down
07:09:14 because they're roasting them chat
07:09:16 And you know what's crazy guys
07:09:31 Bro is like 24 years old
07:09:34 Bro is literally like 24 years old bro 0.97
07:09:39 Nigga how do I look younger than him
07:09:44 i'm like a decade older than him bro like what bro i'm literally 10 years older than this guy 0.96
07:09:54 easily like what's going on
07:09:58 man
07:10:06 uh okay they got they took like a five minute recess 1.00
07:10:14 shit is crazy bro 0.98
07:10:20 just like in word reflection and i've been talking to my fiance a lot 1.00
07:10:27 and i just kind of came to realize you know wait fiance this nigga's about to get married 1.00
07:10:31 What I was doing 0.99
07:10:59 What I was doing wrong
07:11:00 and i also came to realize that truly your boy was spiraling you know um i was genuinely genuinely 0.85
07:11:08 genuinely losing the plot and i have to say like genuinely i feel like a hypocrite you know
07:11:14 all right we got a word counter for genuinely just a couple videos ago i was saying how what
07:11:22 alex was doing was a distraction from the bigger mission and then i come along doing what i was
07:11:28 doing and if anything it was an even bigger distraction from the mission you know what i
07:11:33 mean now i had to pay six plus figures for my lawyer fees and then my fans lawyer fees wait 0.88
07:11:41 wait wait wait oh okay for his fans okay i was about to say wait nigga why are you paying six 0.98
07:11:45 figures for a fucking misdemeanor okay but he's paying for the the dudes that he got jammed up 0.97
07:11:50 for those of you guys that didn't see it um he got two of his fans arrested too 0.99
07:11:56 by telling them to go uh into the mcdonald's
07:12:04 is in everything and that money could have been used for the betterment of society but now it's
07:12:11 being used in the legal system you know what i mean and it's just yo jadeon stop making these 1.00
07:12:18 bitch ass nigga apology videos bro like fucking stop stop this is so fucking gay they're not 1.00
07:12:27 gonna forgive you anyway they're always gonna roast you like bro just be 10 toes down get back 1.00
07:12:33 with alex rose until everybody go suck a dick do what the fuck you want to do and tell them to get 1.00
07:12:37 the fuck out of here bro you are audience captured so badly and it's fucking painful dude it has made 1.00
07:12:43 you a fucking faggot holy shit holy shit you've been on youtube this long and you've not learned 1.00
07:12:51 don't apologize to these fucking faggots bro ever what are you doing 1.00
07:12:56 it's like you're at a crossroads now you're either going to be a supplicating audience captured 1.00
07:13:03 faggot that doesn't do what they want to do and is always terrified of everything that they do 1.00
07:13:09 with the backlash or you're gonna say fuck this shit i'm gonna do what i want to do lose some 1.00
07:13:16 subscribers who cares who gives a fuck they're retarded children anyway nine out of ten of them 1.00
07:13:22 they're probably black they're probably stupid they're probably low iq they probably think like 1.00
07:13:29 racism is real they probably get offended at everything like get them out of here bro 1.00
07:13:39 thank you come again who cares who cares bro who cares just be yourself 1.00
07:13:48 okay you fucked up it is what it is 1.00
07:13:51 lose some goddamn weight you look like shit you're fat as fuck get your health in control 1.00
07:13:59 dust yourself off and get back up and stop being a bitch man what the fuck 1.00
07:14:05 like it's not that hard bro i quit that's some faggotry that's some straight faggotry 1.00
07:14:13 fucking soft bro so fucking soft that's the thing with these niggas bro it's like here's the issue 1.00
07:14:21 right this is why young streamers are like they don't fucking get it bro you have the privilege 1.00
07:14:30 of a fucking lifetime this is why becoming rich young is a fucking curse man i've been telling 0.99
07:14:38 y'all this for years the worst thing that can happen to a young man is losing the privilege 1.00
07:14:47 of fucking suffering i'm gonna say that again for all you fucking faggots that are watching 1.00
07:14:51 the worst thing that can happen to a young man is losing the privilege of suffering because when 1.00
07:14:59 you suffer you become a man okay you think if jideon went to the gym you know fucking played 0.99
07:15:08 sports for real had a real job had to build himself up he would give a fuck about what 1.00
07:15:13 some fucking retards on the internet say no he'd have more resolve he wouldn't quit over 1.00
07:15:20 some retarded fucking comments on youtube but since he never built up that fucking ability to 1.00
07:15:29 deal with adverse uh adversity as a young man and got money quickly got fame quickly he didn't build 1.00
07:15:37 up that fucking resolve now anything that hits him oh i don't know if i want to do this oh 0.92
07:15:41 and here's the thing if you guys don't believe me look at him look at him if you don't believe 1.00
07:15:49 me he's fat he's out of shape he clearly doesn't give a fuck about himself he's bald as fuck in 1.00
07:15:57 his 20s he looks like shit this is a man just straight up that doesn't give a fuck his body 1.00
07:16:06 is an outward manifestation of his fucking pussiness and laziness 1.00
07:16:10 Straight up 1.00
07:16:14 This guy's like 10 plus years younger than me 0.99
07:16:18 What the fuck is going on 0.99
07:16:23 Look, Gideon, if you see this message 1.00
07:16:26 I mean this in a fucking nice way 0.91
07:16:27 I've met you before 1.00
07:16:28 You need to stop being a fucking bitch 1.00
07:16:31 You're being a fucking bitch 1.00
07:16:33 Get your fat ass in a fucking gym 1.00
07:16:35 Learn how to deal with some adversity 1.00
07:16:37 Get your self-care taken care of 1.00
07:16:40 When you look back in the fucking mirror 1.00
07:16:42 and see that you've created a change, 1.00
07:16:44 then you'll be able to stand up to all these fucking retards 1.00
07:16:46 that bully you all over the internet. 1.00
07:16:47 Have you apologizing every other fucking day. 1.00
07:16:52 Make up with Alex Rosen 1.00
07:16:53 and know who your real fucking friends are. 1.00
07:16:56 Stop being a fucking bitch. 1.00
07:16:58 This is fucking pathetic. 1.00
07:17:00 You have the opportunity of a lifetime. 1.00
07:17:01 You got millions of followers. 1.00
07:17:03 Don't fucking quit, you pussy. 1.00
07:17:05 Everyone else is excited by this. 1.00
07:17:07 Oh, he's quitting. 1.00
07:17:08 Ha, ha, let's make content off this shit, blah, blah. 1.00
07:17:09 Man, I'm telling you, dumbass 1.00
07:17:11 You got a million people that follow you 1.00
07:17:13 You got a bright future out of you 1.00
07:17:15 But you're fucking soft 1.00
07:17:17 Go take a month off, go to the fucking gym 1.00
07:17:19 Lose some goddamn weight 1.00
07:17:20 Get some personal achievements 1.00
07:17:21 Then hit the fucking road 1.00
07:17:23 And come back on YouTube 1.00
07:17:25 But this is fucking ridiculous 1.00
07:17:29 You look like shit 1.00
07:17:30 And this is our manifestation of your fucking laziness 1.00
07:17:32 Straight up 1.00
07:17:33 You got fucking titties 1.00
07:17:34 Get your fat ass in the gym 1.00
07:17:37 improve your looks 1.00
07:17:40 get your fucking hair back 1.00
07:17:43 your fiance's gonna thank you for it 1.00
07:17:45 and come back hard and tell everybody to go fuck off 1.00
07:17:50 and stop making these bitch ass apology videos 1.00
07:17:51 make up with Alex and stop being a fucking faggot man 1.00
07:17:54 holy shit dude 1.00
07:17:55 I can't even watch this fucking video 1.00
07:17:57 so fucking pathetic 1.00
07:17:58 so fucking pathetic dude 1.00
07:18:01 the fuck out of here man 1.00
07:18:03 soft as fuck 1.00
07:18:04 holy shit 1.00
07:18:07 That's why you Gen Z niggas are fucking bitches, bro. 1.00
07:18:10 Holy shit. 1.00
07:18:11 Like, he's like my brother's age. 1.00
07:18:14 I had to bully my brother so he wouldn't become a faggot like that 1.00
07:18:16 because I knew these young motherfuckers were going to be soft. 1.00
07:18:20 As soon as I saw these niggas with fucking iPhones at seven years old 1.00
07:18:23 and iPads, I was like, yeah, these dudes are about to be some fucking bitches. 1.00
07:18:27 These dudes are about to be some fucking faggots. 1.00
07:18:29 Can't say nigger around them. 1.00
07:18:31 Can't say faggot around them. 1.00
07:18:32 Can't say fucking queer around them. 1.00
07:18:33 Can't say any of this shit. 1.00
07:18:34 Oh, my God. 1.00
07:18:35 That's so fucked up. 1.00
07:18:37 If you grow up on an iPad 1.00
07:18:43 High likelihood you're gonna be a fag 1.00
07:18:45 Straight up bro 1.00
07:18:46 Feel free to steal that shit 1.00
07:18:50 Cause it's so fucking true 1.00
07:18:52 Grow up on an iPad 1.00
07:18:53 You're gonna be a fag 1.00
07:18:54 Straight up 1.00
07:18:55 Bitch ass niggas everywhere bro 1.00
07:18:58 We live in an Uber Eats fucking society 1.00
07:19:01 We live in a DoorDash society 1.00
07:19:04 The problem though is that these fat ass niggas can't dash 1.00
07:19:06 like what the fuck is going on 1.00
07:19:09 this is something that I've realized 0.99
07:19:12 like it's really bad with this generation 1.00
07:19:14 all you guys in your fucking 20s 0.99
07:19:16 you guys born in the 2000s 1.00
07:19:18 you guys are some fucking bitch ass nigga faggots bro 1.00
07:19:20 it's very clear 1.00
07:19:23 that a lot of you have never been bullied
07:19:24 a lot of you have never been punched in the face
07:19:26 a lot of you have never dealt with any type of adversity 0.98
07:19:28 a lot of you guys never had to like work a real fucking 0.98
07:19:33 manual labor job 0.99
07:19:34 it's fucking insane 1.00
07:19:36 A lot of you motherfuckers are retarded 1.00
07:19:39 And you're just not tough 1.00
07:19:40 You're soft 1.00
07:19:41 Like really fucking soft 1.00
07:19:44 You run a mile in like 12 minutes 1.00
07:19:47 Faggotry 1.00
07:19:48 Hi you a grown ass man 1.00
07:19:52 You gotta run a fucking mile in 10 minutes 1.00
07:19:54 That's fucking gay 1.00
07:19:56 You're out of shape 1.00
07:19:57 It's fucking pathetic 1.00
07:19:59 A lot of you niggas can't even do 20 pushups 1.00
07:20:01 Can't do 10 pullups 1.00
07:20:07 How dare you tell a girl I'm going to pull up when you can't even do a pull up? 1.00
07:20:10 Get the fuck out of here. 1.00
07:20:13 I'm about to push up on this bitch. 1.00
07:20:14 You can't push up on the ground. 1.00
07:20:17 What are you talking about?
07:20:19 I'm 36 years old, bro. 1.00
07:20:21 I'm in better shape than 90% of you fucking young ass faggots. 1.00
07:20:26 I got a bad fucking back, former division one athlete, several injuries. 1.00
07:20:32 In better shape than most of these fucking 20 year olds. 1.00
07:20:34 how do i know this because i meet these niggas when we collab for real out of shape look like 1.00
07:20:39 shit on steroids can't run a fucking mile hell fucking all fucked the health all fucked up 1.00
07:20:45 blood work fucked up eat like shit do drugs what is this what's wrong with this generation 1.00
07:20:52 you guys are fucking lazy bitch ass niggas bro it's insane it's seriously insane and i've been 1.00
07:21:01 I've had this pent-up fucking frustration 1.00
07:21:03 with you fucking 20-year-old niggas for a while. 1.00
07:21:06 You fucking vape. 1.00
07:21:07 You smoke weed. 1.00
07:21:08 You do drugs.
07:21:09 You do steroids.
07:21:10 You gamble. 1.00
07:21:11 You're fat as fuck. 1.00
07:21:13 You look like shit. 1.00
07:21:14 You're fucking soft. 1.00
07:21:15 You let women walk all over you, bitch-ass niggas. 1.00
07:21:17 You've never done a manual labor job in your life. 1.00
07:21:21 You don't know how to fix shit. 1.00
07:21:22 You don't know how to swing a hammer. 1.00
07:21:23 You've never done landscaping. 1.00
07:21:26 Pathetic. 1.00
07:21:28 Fucking pathetic. 1.00
07:21:28 this generation of men you guys are some fucking 1.00
07:21:32 pussified faggots 1.00
07:21:34 we need to bring bullying back 1.00
07:21:35 we need to bring back sports 0.99
07:21:37 we need to bring back mandatory fucking competition 1.00
07:21:40 you guys are so fucking soft 1.00
07:21:42 this nigga gets a little bit of hate on his YouTube 1.00
07:21:45 multi-millionaire I quit 0.99
07:21:47 what?
07:21:50 what? 0.99
07:21:52 you know how people would fucking kill to have that opportunity 1.00
07:21:54 Jideon you fucking retard 1.00
07:21:56 you better not fucking quit idiot lose the fucking way come back as a fucking man 1.00
07:22:03 make up with Alex catch pedos stop being a bitch-ass nigga and that's the realest shit 1.00
07:22:07 anyone on the internet is ever gonna fucking tell you because everyone else is prying on 1.00
07:22:10 your fucking downfall fatty don't fucking quit holy shit man in fucking credible bro 1.00
07:22:19 in fucking credible this generation of young men dude you guys are fucking cooked man 1.00
07:22:24 It's insane how softy all niggas are 1.00
07:22:26 It's fucking insane 1.00
07:22:28 Every time I talk to these fucking 20 year old guys 1.00
07:22:31 It's just like a 1.00
07:22:34 It's like a level of laziness 0.99
07:22:36 I don't know what the fuck is in the water 0.99
07:22:37 I don't know what's going on 0.99
07:22:39 I blame the internet and the iPad 1.00
07:22:41 But it's like fuck man 1.00
07:22:45 It's like there's no shame 1.00
07:22:48 Like grown men have tendies
07:22:52 Anyway 1.00
07:22:58 Sorry guys, I've had that shit pent up for a while 0.99
07:23:02 I didn't mean to take it all out on fucking 0.99
07:23:05 Gideon, but bro, this is like, you know 0.97
07:23:08 You know, he's not the only one 1.00
07:23:10 I'm trying to tell you guys, this shit is a generational problem 1.00
07:23:12 It's a fucking generational problem, dude 1.00
07:23:15 Awkward as fuck 1.00
07:23:18 Weird handshakes 0.99
07:23:20 can't speak properly
07:23:22 can't look you in the eye 1.00
07:23:24 awkward as fuck 1.00
07:23:25 no fucking social awareness 1.00
07:23:28 you know how many fucking times 1.00
07:23:29 fuck it I'm gonna say it 1.00
07:23:30 you know how many fucking times 1.00
07:23:32 I'm at the airport with Brett 1.00
07:23:33 and some fucking person comes up to us 0.99
07:23:35 Brett's gonna know exactly what I'm talking about 1.00
07:23:37 and they're fucking weird as hell 0.99
07:23:39 they don't understand any type of 1.00
07:23:44 spatial awareness
07:23:44 their breath smells
07:23:46 they're standing right up on you like this
07:23:48 they're awkward they're weird i've had to tell a couple of these young guys hey what's wrong with
07:23:54 you well you know i'm just nervous you gotta stop that you can't you can't do that that's weird 0.99
07:24:02 that's impolite it's fucking strange i'm telling you this because i give a fuck you can't behave 0.99
07:24:08 like this this is weirdo fucking behavior no one else is going to tell you so i'm gonna tell you 0.99
07:24:13 it. The way you approached me was fucking retarded. Don't do it again. Ever. I've done 1.00
07:24:19 that before. A lot of these fucking young guys, they come up to me. They behave that 1.00
07:24:24 way. I tell them, dude, you cannot, you can't do this. I'd rather I tell you this. So when
07:24:32 you show up on a job interview or you meet someone, they don't have a fucking bad, they 0.98
07:24:37 don't have a bad perception of you. I know you niggas are weird. I accept this. I understand 1.00
07:24:42 it. So you know what? I might
07:24:44 as well tell you. Don't be a fucking fag. 1.00
07:24:46 Don't act like this. 1.00
07:24:50 Brett will tell you he's in the chat right now.
07:24:52 We've been talking about making a video about this for over
07:24:54 a year.
07:24:56 It's bad. I go to the airport.
07:24:58 I'm out and about. Brett is there with me.
07:25:00 He's like, what the fuck is this? He was shocked 0.99
07:25:02 the first time he saw it.
07:25:04 When we went out for the first
07:25:06 time to one of these schools, 0.99
07:25:08 he was fucking shocked 0.97
07:25:10 and how dudes would come up to me and be so awkward. 0.99
07:25:13 It's like, what the fuck is this? 0.98
07:25:15 I was like, yo, this happens every day. 0.99
07:25:17 What?
07:25:17 I was like, yeah, it's a problem.
07:25:19 It's a problem.
07:25:20 We got to tell these guys. 0.99
07:25:23 Gentlemen, let me give you guys some fucking tips. 0.99
07:25:26 You see someone you want to meet. 0.99
07:25:28 You see somebody that you admire.
07:25:29 Maybe you see them on the internet.
07:25:30 You walk up to them. 1.00
07:25:32 You call them by their fucking name. 1.00
07:25:34 Don't say you're the guy. 1.00
07:25:35 Don't do that. 0.99
07:25:37 That's fucking rude and impolite. 1.00
07:25:40 know their fucking name when you walk up stick out your hand firm look them in the fucking eye 1.00
07:25:46 you shake their hand you give them a compliment i'm aware of xyz work that you do thank you for 1.00
07:25:54 that you call them by their name you give a compliment or something that you admire about
07:26:01 them show thoughtfulness they'll be more likely to engage in a conversation with you don't ever 0.95
07:26:06 fucking come up you're the guy oh oh i don't know your name i've seen you somewhere don't 0.99
07:26:13 fucking do that ever know their fucking name and know something about them so you can start a 1.00
07:26:21 conversation you fucking retards every time i'm at the airport i'm walking around you awkward 1.00
07:26:28 motherfuckers come up and do that stupid shit and i have to fucking tell you don't do that 1.00
07:26:32 i probably tell them that shit but you know what a lot of you niggas that are watching 1.00
07:26:38 probably are weirdos too so look guys never walk up to someone without knowing their name 1.00
07:26:43 it could be a fucking guy that's your boss or a manager of some kind or someone that you want to 0.99
07:26:48 meet always know their name walk up shake their hand nice and firm look them in the eye give them 1.00
07:26:56 a compliment or something that you admire about them and engage in a fucking thoughtful conversations 0.52
07:27:00 Have your questions ready to go. 1.00
07:27:04 Don't waste their fucking time. 1.00
07:27:06 Make sure they're thoughtful. 1.00
07:27:08 Say thank you when you're done and you walk away. 1.00
07:27:12 Don't be a fucking retard. 1.00
07:27:18 Look, it's crazy that I have to say this, 1.00
07:27:20 but I'm realizing that this new generation of men, 1.00
07:27:25 you guys are socially retarded. 1.00
07:27:27 You're socially fucking retarded. 1.00
07:27:29 and it makes sense why so many guys struggle with women so i'm gonna do the best that i can to tell 1.00
07:27:35 you guys the tough truth because clearly no one else is telling you guys that you're a bunch of 1.00
07:27:40 retarded faggots so i gotta fucking do it it's like i gotta be the fucking drill sergeant for 1.00
07:27:44 all you niggas because your daddy's a faggot your brother's a softy liberal faggot your sister's a 1.00
07:27:49 whore your mom is dumb i don't fucking know but i guess i gotta teach y'all niggas so i'll do it 1.00
07:27:54 it's gonna be tough love because a lot of you niggas are fucking soft 1.00
07:27:58 soft belly titty having faggots bro all over the place 1.00
07:28:02 anyway pep talk done we'll go to the trial you do an unduly suggestive in court id also 0.98
07:28:12 we believe there's a lack of foundation um establishing his ability to interpret the
07:28:18 surveillance video and based on that we would object
07:28:23 all right i note that well to the state do you wish to be heard on what was just stated
07:28:29 well just i think i think we had this discussion and i think you ruled on that specific objection
07:28:34 and then after you you ruled i just neglected to come back and follow through with the question
07:28:39 and the answer that's my recollection of the the bench meeting i believe i stated for the purposes
07:28:46 of this hearing that identification by
07:28:48 Agent Hull of Mr. Robinson was made
07:28:50 I could be wrong but
07:28:52 Well and
07:28:54 I just wanted to clarify that judge because there
07:28:56 was some question about whether that in fact did happen
07:28:58 and so
07:28:59 if that's your recollection of what
07:29:02 happened and if you're willing to put
07:29:04 on the record that Agent Hull has identified
07:29:06 the defendant I think we're done
07:29:07 Does the defense
07:29:10 want to be heard?
07:29:16 Just a moment, you're on.
07:29:19 Of course.
07:29:20 No, you're on.
07:29:25 Well, for the benefit of the record and for thoroughness, if you wish to re-ask that
07:29:34 question, you certainly, well, we can see what happens.
07:29:38 If I could judge, I'd like to.
07:29:41 Would you please point him out and identify something that he is wearing?
07:29:46 they had to do it they got to do it in a certain way yeah brett's in the chat guys he'll tell you
07:29:51 man i'm being nice about it bro but man we've had some really strange individuals say some 0.99
07:29:58 dumb shit bro sometimes we happen to tell them bro you can't do this you you can't you can't do 0.99
07:30:02 this you will lose 70 opportunities in life behaving like this and i'd rather be the tough 1.00
07:30:08 asshole that tells them that this is not correct then they continue on through life acting like a 1.00
07:30:13 fucking retard, wondering why they can't get a job. 1.00
07:30:15 Wondering why no one wants to talk to them. Why they can't build 1.00
07:30:17 friends or build a network. I'd rather be the asshole and tell them. 1.00
07:30:19 You can't do this, man. 1.00
07:30:22 Yeah, I believe that Mr. Robinson 0.99
07:30:23 is, uh, between Miss
07:30:25 Nestor and other council, wearing a gray suit,
07:30:27 jacket with a dark tie,
07:30:29 and a light-colored shirt.
07:30:31 I would ask that the record reflect.
07:30:33 Yeah, bro, we'll tell you guys, bro. He's there with me.
07:30:36 He sees at least 50% of the 1.00
07:30:37 bullshit, bro. Holy. 1.00
07:30:40 That Agent Hull has a... He gets
07:30:41 mad half the time. Like, what the
07:30:43 I have no judgment. I mean, I've made my objection already.
07:31:00 Okay. I just wanted to check.
07:31:01 No, thank you.
07:31:02 All right.
07:31:03 Yo, the judge is like, he already, he was like, okay, you got to do it. Bro just waited.
07:31:08 It was a different exhibit. And we just can't prepare that in the next hour or so. So we're going to need this evening to prepare that exhibit. And we'd like to return with that. Judge, what I would also suggest.
07:31:24 Yeah, they're probably going to break here soon.
07:31:26 Well, let's, I guess, let me get your take on that, Judge.
07:31:30 All right. Does the defense wish to be heard about ending for the day? We have about 19 minutes until five o'clock.
07:31:37 Like Trev says, speak of facts, learn how to conduct yourself, young fellas. 1.00
07:31:40 Yeah, man, I'm telling you guys, bro, you have to learn this shit, man. 0.99
07:31:43 Internet's not going to save you, bro, from real-life interactions. 0.99
07:31:47 Everyone's cool on the Internet until they meet someone in public.
07:31:51 What is defensive?
07:31:52 Yeah, I know. We're happy to accommodate the state on that.
07:31:55 All right.
07:31:56 So for today, Agent Hull, you may step down.
07:32:00 So he'll be back tomorrow.
07:32:01 They're going to kick off the testimony with him, and then he's going to get crossed.
07:32:04 We'll resume with your testimony tomorrow morning.
07:32:07 So that'll be at 11 a.m. our time, guys.
07:32:10 Anything further, Mr. Sturgill?
07:32:11 Well, just one other thing, and it's a suggestion.
07:32:16 Agent Home, can you wait just one second?
07:32:18 I'm sorry.
07:32:18 Go ahead.
07:32:19 I'm sure Ms. Nestor may have a position with regards to this,
07:32:23 but, Judge, we would invite you to review the exhibit that we've been talking about today.
07:32:32 It is 12.1.
07:32:36 We suggest.
07:32:37 okay um so let me um let's see here let's read some of these chats castle club clan here's a
07:32:43 funny video from the amazing race if you ever want to view it uh during another break um thank
07:32:49 you castle club and also by the way guys uh for all you guys if you guys want to go ahead and get
07:32:53 a sub on um on oss i'm sure miss uh mr castle club here clan might hook you up if he likes you
07:33:00 mr fernand you didn't get one chest fifth element winners have answers losers have excuses facts 0.77
07:33:05 fucking facts these guys need to learn to not be weird that's from brett fitness says hating on 0.96
07:33:10 steroids you need to have discipline to use steroids bro you take steroids with no discipline 0.99
07:33:14 the steroids won't do shit don't know why you're hating on them you should know yo uh fitness shut 1.00
07:33:19 the fuck up dude how about that one shut the fuck up you're clearly a fucking retard that doesn't 1.00
07:33:24 understand that i'm talking about these young guys that use steroids before they even have a 1.00
07:33:27 foundation of going to the gym so shut the fuck up dude you're a fucking retard you don't know 1.00
07:33:32 anything. You clearly wasn't listening to what I was saying, you fucking moron. I was talking about 1.00
07:33:38 it in the context of young guys using drugs. It's not putting the work into time, you fucking 1.00
07:33:43 faggot. Holy shit, man. What? You probably poke yourself in the fucking ass using drugs. 1.00
07:33:50 Fuck out of here, bro. And honestly, if you're not a professional bodybuilder, 1.00
07:33:54 you shouldn't be using steroids. So shut the fuck up, dude. How about that one? Go suck a 1.00
07:33:58 fucking dick you retard are you a professional bodybuilder you got an IPB card or you don't 1.00
07:34:03 then shut the fuck up no one should be using drugs if you're not a professional bodybuilder bro 1.00
07:34:08 let's fuck out of here with that shit see this is the retarded shit that I'm talking about 1.00
07:34:11 this nigga's retarded that's literally what I'm talking about 1.00
07:34:14 fucking idiot and you're in the OSS too you're a fucking faggot you should know better 1.00
07:34:21 The fuck 1.00
07:34:23 This is the problem 1.00
07:34:26 This is exactly what I'm talking about 1.00
07:34:29 Fucking idiot 1.00
07:34:30 I should kick your dumb ass out 1.00
07:34:33 The fucking organization bro 1.00
07:34:34 I've kicked out so many dumb ass niggas 1.00
07:34:36 I'd rather kick you faggots out than even take a dollar 1.00
07:34:38 From y'all niggas 1.00
07:34:39 Honestly 1.00
07:34:40 I've lost 1.00
07:34:44 So much money by kicking faggots 1.00
07:34:46 Out of my organization like this fucking retard 1.00
07:34:48 Fitness 1.00
07:34:49 bro you literally got two minutes to fucking apologize for your stupid ass comment you dumb 1.00
07:34:55 ass you know the 20 year olds we got here that watch this shit the fuck you talking about 1.00
07:34:59 endorsing steroids you fucking faggot don't endorse drugs on my shit because let me tell 1.00
07:35:05 you something when they're pissing out blood or they're having the fucking trend sweats 1.00
07:35:09 or their blood pressures through the roof are you gonna be there huh you gonna take them to a doctor 1.00
07:35:14 We're not having a fucking stroke 1.00
07:35:20 Are you gonna be there you stupid ass nigga 1.00
07:35:21 No you're not 1.00
07:35:22 So shut the fuck up 1.00
07:35:23 Shut the fuck up 1.00
07:35:26 Fucking dumbass 1.00
07:35:28 Gabby says 1.00
07:35:38 Nigga lack confidence 1.00
07:35:39 Low IQ low confidence ass niggas 1.00
07:35:41 Very true 1.00
07:35:42 Seven bone surgeries
07:35:44 nine surgeries in total starting in the third grade through junior. Yeah, bro, I'm dead. I'm
07:35:48 not even kidding around with your dumb ass. Yo, fitness, you got literally four minutes to 1.00
07:35:51 fucking apologize, you bitch ass nigga. You literally got four minutes to apologize. And 1.00
07:35:55 if you don't, you're getting fucking set to the shadow room. And I'm only even giving you that 0.98
07:35:59 four minutes because you're in the OSS. So you got four fucking minutes to fucking apologize, 1.00
07:36:04 you fucking faggot. And I don't want to hear no fucking pro steroid shit from you ever again, 1.00
07:36:10 bro, ever 1.00
07:36:11 fucking dumbass, you don't even know how many young guys 1.00
07:36:14 we got in here, impressible guys, you talking about steroids 1.00
07:36:16 you fucking dickhead 1.00
07:36:17 low IQ, low confidence 1.00
07:36:23 ass niggas, okay 1.00
07:36:23 10 bone surgeries 1.00
07:36:26 9 surgeries in total
07:36:27 starting in the 3rd grade through my junior year
07:36:30 in high school, all while being a top
07:36:32 player in the country in every sport I played
07:36:34 built my body up just to have it torn
07:36:36 down through surgeries, yeah man, it happens
07:36:38 Jammo subscribe
07:36:42 Chitta Wall says I'm only 18
07:36:45 And I grew up playing sports and being outside
07:36:47 Always Gen Z and nowadays are always inside
07:36:49 These ninjas are tripping 1.00
07:36:51 They definitely are
07:36:53 Brett let me know if this 1.00
07:36:57 This faggot, I apologize if he doesn't bro 1.00
07:36:59 We just get him out of here man 1.00
07:37:00 You can kick him out bro 1.00
07:37:02 Dude comes in here fucking promoting steroids 1.00
07:37:07 Get the fuck out of here, bro. 1.00
07:37:12 Yes, you still have to work hard 1.00
07:37:13 if you're on steroids.
07:37:14 Yeah.
07:37:15 But guess what, dude? 1.00
07:37:16 These niggas aren't fucking 1.00
07:37:17 professional bodybuilders. 1.00
07:37:18 So we're not endorsing that shit over here. 1.00
07:37:21 Fucking dickhead. 1.00
07:37:25 Let's see here what we got. 1.00
07:37:35 Okay.
07:37:37 now I'm debating
07:37:43 if I should do one more segment with you guys
07:37:47 or go to sleep
07:37:50 I haven't slept yet
07:37:53 I haven't had a long day
07:37:54 let's see here
07:38:07 all right let me all right this is what I'll do because I got a warning from kick earlier
07:38:24 um we'll analyze the shooting okay we'll analyze the uh the shooting on OSS
07:38:31 Charlie Kirk shooting
07:38:33 We're going to do it on OSS
07:38:38 And then I'll
07:38:39 And then what I'll do also
07:38:42 Is
07:38:47 Let me
07:38:49 I was thinking about
07:38:52 Doing the FBI
07:38:55 Files on the Klan with y'all 0.82
07:38:56 with the KKK.
07:39:10 In 1992, a young mother was gunned down in front of her children.
07:39:26 so we're able to combine two things that we want true crime and racism um and then also uh we'll
07:39:36 break down the charlie kirk shooting um because i can't show you guys the i'm gonna i'm gonna like
07:39:41 show the actual shooting but i'm not gonna do it out of respect and then also like so i don't get
07:39:46 banned we're gonna do it on oss so so i'll uh i'll stay on a little bit longer we'll watch an
07:39:54 episode of FBI Files.
07:39:59 If you guys rock
07:40:00 with me,
07:40:02 join the brotherhood, 0.97
07:40:06 niggas.
07:40:08 Trump, we will have no more wars, 0.94
07:40:10 no more disruptions, and we will have
07:40:12 prosperity and peace for all.
07:40:14 The mission of Operation Epic Fury
07:40:16 is laser-focused.
07:40:18 The United States military 0.99
07:40:19 obliterated Iran's
07:40:21 nuclear weapons program with an attack 0.95
07:40:24 Go to radium soil.
07:40:28 This is not just a war about security.
07:40:30 It's an information war.
07:40:32 They need you to believe their stories,
07:40:34 or else it all comes crashing down.
07:40:36 This war began decades ago,
07:40:38 but now you have the right intelligence to guide you.
07:40:41 An army to march with,
07:40:42 brothers to discuss with,
07:40:44 and an admiral to lead the way.
07:40:46 Join the OSS army.
07:40:50 Under Trump, we will have...
07:40:52 Yeah, guys, just use the code.
07:40:55 It's literally a dollar to join. 1.00
07:41:01 We do get a couple of retards in there, 1.00
07:41:03 but we just kick them out like the fucking fitness retard. 1.00
07:41:08 And when you put the link in, 1.00
07:41:12 this is what pops up.
07:41:16 It gives you a discount already.
07:41:18 Makes it only one buck.
07:41:19 so um yeah i'm gonna cover the the kirk shooting we have some of the uncensored stuff here
07:41:25 and um obviously um we're gonna cover the clan and the fbi so we'll do a special true crime
07:41:34 racist episode with y'all diggers we get to combine the things we love the most
07:41:39 all right so come on over guys you rock with me you like my advice you want to support the mission 1.00
07:41:44 jump on in you're a fat faggot you don't like what i gotta say or you want to use steroids 1.00
07:41:48 like fitness the faggot well then i don't know go whack off somewhere but either way guys come on 1.00
07:41:55 over join the oss man do i know ss you can use the code l youtube or you can be a real nigga 0.99
07:42:00 just pay full price whatever seven bucks it's only ten bucks a month it's literally nothing 0.85
07:42:04 so come on over niggas we're switching over ever feel the need for more find it in the 0.90
07:42:09 ford maverick with a hybrid engine to do more of this with less of this and available all-wheel 0.96
07:42:18 drive to tackle more of this. It's more than a truck. It's a Maverick. Right now, get purchase
07:42:25 financing from 3.99% APR for up to 72 months on 2026 Maverick XLT models, plus $1,000 in Ford
07:42:32 accessories. Visit your Ontario Ford store or Ford.ca today.