The Fiamengo File - June 08, 2017


How To Write A Gender Theory Paper - TFF Episode 66

Preview: How To Write A Gender Theory Paper - TFF episode 66 Preview: Shaming Men About Housework - TFF Episode 67

Episode Stats


Length

15 minutes

Words per minute

120.85

Word count

1,818

Sentence count

79

Harmful content

Misogyny

12

sentences flagged

Toxicity

16

sentences flagged

Hate speech

7

sentences flagged


Transcript

Transcript generated with Whisper (turbo).
Misogyny classifications generated with MilaNLProc/bert-base-uncased-ear-misogyny .
Toxicity classifications generated with s-nlp/roberta_toxicity_classifier .
Hate speech classifications generated with facebook/roberta-hate-speech-dynabench-r4-target .
00:00:00 How do you get a gender theory article published? 0.50
00:00:04 That's my subject on today's Fiamengo File.
00:00:16 I'm Janice Fiamengo of the University of Ottawa, and recently two authors calling themselves
00:00:22 Peter Boyle and Jamie Lindsay, published an academic spoof of feminist man-hating called 0.82
00:00:30 The Conceptual Penis as a Social Construct. May not be quite in the league of classic academic 0.66
00:00:37 hoaxes like physics professor Alan Sokol's piece in the prestigious journal Social Text,
00:00:43 which claimed that quantum gravity was a linguistic construct. Or J.T. Dillon's marvelous essay in
00:00:52 the reputable journal American Psychologist on the emergence of the colon, punctuation mark,
00:00:58 not the internal organ, as a sign of academic authority in titles of academic articles.
00:01:03 The conceptual penis argued in overblown post-structuralist feminist cycle babble 0.99
00:01:10 that we should stop thinking of the penis as a male reproductive organ and instead understand it 1.00
00:01:16 as an expression of what else? Toxic masculinity implicated with rape, both literal and metaphorical, 0.99
00:01:23 and needing to be rethought in ways less damaging to women and the environment.
00:01:29 It's a delightful spoof of feminist man-hatred. The problem is, according to a number of critics,
00:01:36 that Cogent Social Sciences, the journal that published the conceptual penis,
00:01:40 requires authors to pay a fee to be published there.
00:01:44 In other words, it's not a top-tier peer-reviewed journal.
00:01:47 According to these critics, then, the article's publication doesn't prove
00:01:51 that the field of gender studies in general is corrupt and nonsensical.
00:01:56 Okay, that's fine, but that isn't the real issue.
00:02:01 I don't require the article's publication to prove that gender studies is corrupt.
00:02:06 There's plenty of evidence for that within gender studies itself.
00:02:12 The interesting point about this story is that anyone familiar with gender theory should
00:02:17 be able to see that the actual difference between the conceptual penis and many highly
00:02:23 respected gender theory articles and books is a matter of degree only.
00:02:30 In fact, as I'm going to show, some famous gender theorists such as Judith Butler,
00:02:36 write in a manner hardly less overheated and illogical than our two would-be hoaxers. 0.64
00:02:43 The conceptual penis should actually be read as a pastiche of academically fashionable ideas
00:02:51 and as a not unreliable how-to guide for writing a feminist theoretical essay on masculinity. 1.00
00:02:59 identity. Let's consider the abstract of the paper as a model for the typical gender 0.99
00:03:06 studies approach. Here it is, quote, anatomical penises may exist, but as preoperative transgendered 0.69
00:03:15 women also have anatomical penises, the penis vis-a-vis maleness is an incoherent construct. 0.92
00:03:23 We argue that the conceptual penis is better understood not as an anatomical organ, but 0.99
00:03:29 as a social construct, isomorphic to performative toxic masculinity. Through detailed post-structuralist
00:03:37 discursive criticism and the example of climate change, this paper will challenge the prevailing 0.53
00:03:43 and damaging social trope that penises are best understood as the male sexual organ and reassign
00:03:50 it a more fitting role as a type of masculine performance, end quote. So what does this abstract 0.81
00:04:00 tell us about how to get a gender theory paper published in an academic journal? Well, first of
00:04:07 course you start with a corrosive contempt for masculinity, but that goes without saying. Then
00:04:14 Then you add the terminology and verbal habits of gender theory.
00:04:19 To reverse George Orwell, never use a single syllable or common word if a multisyllabic
00:04:25 word will do, especially a foreign, scientific, or technical-sounding word.
00:04:31 So vis-a-vis is much better than in relation to.
00:04:37 Isomorphic is a heck of a lot sexier than something like corresponding with.
00:04:43 And trope, though it is single syllable, is still an impressively obscure piece of post-structuralist
00:04:51 lingo that can conveniently be substituted for a word like idea.
00:04:58 If you're in need of an all-purpose noun to stand in for a word like thing, reach for
00:05:04 construct, or even better, social construct.
00:05:09 also happens to function very nicely as a verb especially in the passive voice as in is constructed
00:05:17 if you're in doubt about an adjective to put before masculinity of course toxic is a pretty
00:05:21 good bet though personally i prefer hegemonic which is not only multi-syllabic and redolent
00:05:27 of the left bank but also evocatively marxist intellectual now once you've got the lingo down
00:05:36 and really it doesn't take long to master it, now tackle gender theory shadowboxing with fact
00:05:45 and logic. In other words, if you're forced to acknowledge a biological fact or widely accepted
00:05:51 social reality, do so in a doubting or insouciant manner with a kind of verbal shrug as in the 0.94
00:05:59 opening line of the abstract, anatomical penises, may exist. That's just the right amount of smirk. 0.61
00:06:08 Something similar occurs in the body of the article, where the term male is put in quotation
00:06:14 marks as if to highlight that the word is, in the Deridian sense, under erasure. In other words,
00:06:20 it continues to operate as a word, but its metaphysical underpinning has been radically
00:06:25 undermined. The article makes inconsequential points such as that a pre-op transgender woman
00:06:31 still has a penis or that some men choose not to reproduce or are infertile as proof that the 0.95
00:06:37 penis has a quote incoherent relationship to maleness though those instances are not proof 0.99
00:06:43 of that at all. The basic rule is never let historical fact, scientific evidence or basic
00:06:49 logic get in the way of your feminist genderqueer utopianism. And finally, perhaps most importantly
00:06:57 of all, you must cite the correct gender theory superstars, even if their work has little or
00:07:04 nothing to do with your argument. The authors here have this down to a T. They refer, for example,
00:07:11 to discursive criticism as their methodology, thus evoking French theorist Michel Foucault,
00:07:17 the idiosyncratic gay godfather of modern gender theory, perhaps one of the most cited and least
00:07:26 understood of theoretical forefathers and someone with almost zero interest, ironically, in women's
00:07:33 issues and someone who, as far as I understand it, would never have called masculinity toxic.
00:07:39 But never mind. In his The History of Sexuality, Volume 1, first published in 1976, Foucault
00:07:45 developed the idea that our language and systems of knowledge do not describe a pre-existent truth
00:07:53 or reality, but rather constitute or construct it. From Foucault's contention that homosexuality was
00:08:01 invented in the 18th and 19th centuries, feminists derived their foundational premise that 0.99
00:08:07 femininity and masculinity are also inventions. Foucault would almost certainly have found 1.00
00:08:14 most feminist ideas of male power risibly simplistic, but he's still a quotable expert
00:08:23 for feminists on discourse. And an even more revered authority is Foucault's American disciple
00:08:30 Judith Butler, the butch queen of gender theory, who in her 1990 book Gender Trouble,
00:08:37 first developed the idea of gender as performance, as a process, always incomplete, 0.93
00:08:44 never stable or unalterable. It's safe to say that very few theorists, perhaps not even Butler
00:08:51 herself, fully understand what she meant by that. Her own statement of the core idea is, I think,
00:08:59 pretty facile. Here it is. It's a little bit long, but hang in there. Quote,
00:09:05 If gender is the cultural meanings that the sexed body assumes, then a gender cannot be said to
00:09:12 follow from a sex in any one way. Taken to its logical limit, the sex-gender distinction suggests
00:09:21 a radical discontinuity between sexed bodies and culturally constructed genders. Assuming for the
00:09:29 moment the stability of binary sex, she's going to undermine that too, it does not follow that
00:09:36 the construction of men will accrue exclusively to the bodies of males or that women will interpret
00:09:43 only female bodies. Further, even if the sexes appear to be unproblematically binary in their
00:09:49 morphology and constitution, which will become a question, there is no reason to assume that
00:09:54 genders ought also to remain as two. When the constructed status of gender is theorized as
00:10:01 radically independent of sex, gender itself becomes a free-floating artifice with the consequence
00:10:08 that man and masculine might just as easily signify a female body as a male one, and woman
00:10:15 and feminine a male body as easily as a female one. End quote. So I won't belabor the implications
00:10:24 of this, which are fairly obvious, except to note that Butler's second sentence about the
00:10:30 radical discontinuity between sexed bodies and culturally constructed genders, end quote,
00:10:37 doesn't follow from her first sentence about gender as, quote, the cultural meanings that the
00:10:43 sexed body assumes, end quote. Just because culture shapes gender doesn't mean it shapes it from 0.98
00:10:51 nothing or in arbitrary ways. And to be fair to Butler, who's certainly no dummy, she spent her 0.60
00:10:57 next book, Bodies That Matter, trying to clarify what she meant, recognizing how problematic it
00:11:03 was. But many academics took the original statement as gospel, biologically and anthropologically
00:11:11 flimsy as it was. And in feminist hands, the idea of gender performance became a predictable paradigm 0.79
00:11:19 for demonizing heterosexual masculinity 0.99
00:11:22 and romanticizing gender transgression. 0.92
00:11:27 And the authors of The Conceptual Penis
00:11:29 have perfected a Foucavian-Boutlerian style
00:11:33 that is all too familiar to those of us
00:11:35 who've read gender theory over the past 25 years.
00:11:40 Here's a game to play with your gender studies friends.
00:11:45 Open up a piece of writing by someone influenced 0.90
00:11:48 by Foucault and Butler and lay it beside the conceptual penis. Read a passage from each and
00:11:55 ask your friend to tell you which is the real theory paper, which the parody. Want to try it?
00:12:03 Close your eyes if you don't want to see the sources identified on the screen and see if you
00:12:08 can guess. Here we go. Number one. This paper addresses masculinity as a negotiated system of
00:12:18 identities that are accomplished through the ritual display of phallic attributes
00:12:26 number two so we are reminded again that masculinity indeed all gender is always incomplete
00:12:36 but in a constant dialectic shifting in different fields and established temporarily and evasively
00:12:44 number three the male sex is socially constructed it is a political entity that flourishes only
00:12:57 through acts of force and sexual terrorism
00:13:01 number four the result of this trichotomy of roles is to place hyper masculine men both within
00:13:13 and outside of competing discourses whose dynamics, as seen via post-structuralist discourse
00:13:18 analysis, enact a systematic interplay of power.
00:13:25 And five.
00:13:28 In addition to articulating the phallus as a temporal concept in its traditional psychoanalytic
00:13:35 formulation, this book tracks alternative temporalities where one could move from castration
00:13:41 to phallus as well as in the other direction, where the lost phallus is surprisingly regained
00:13:48 or where the phallus might appear not only in the past, but as a promising future. These
00:13:54 alternatives participate in the promise of queer temporality and may even lead to queerer phalluses 0.93
00:14:02 and less anxious castrations. So, which one is the fake? You tell me. 0.84
00:14:32 Thank you for watching.
00:14:50 If you enjoyed this video, please support us on Patreon.
00:14:53 If even half of our subscribers gave us $1 per month, we'd be well on our way to
00:14:57 creating more and better content.
00:15:00 And don't forget to subscribe to us on Studio Brulee.