The Fiamengo File - November 02, 2019


Katie Hill - DV Victim and Feminist Heroine - TFF Episode 106

The Unbearable Pettiness of Academic Race and Gender Politics - TFF-105 The Big Lie of Feminism - TFF Episode 107

Episode Stats


Length

8 minutes

Words per minute

131.62

Word count

1,094

Sentence count

33

Harmful content

Misogyny

28

sentences flagged

Toxicity

2

sentences flagged

Hate speech

6

sentences flagged


Transcript

Transcript generated with Whisper (turbo).
Misogyny classifications generated with MilaNLProc/bert-base-uncased-ear-misogyny .
Toxicity classifications generated with s-nlp/roberta_toxicity_classifier .
Hate speech classifications generated with facebook/roberta-hate-speech-dynabench-r4-target .
00:00:00 According to the mainstream press, the Katie Hill scandal centers on the sexual abuse of
00:00:17 a vulnerable young woman. But that young woman is not Morgan Desjardins, the 22-year-old campaign
00:00:26 aide with whom a near decade older Hill along with her husband began a three-way sexual affair
00:00:32 when Hill was running for election to the House of Representatives. That young woman's name is
00:00:38 almost never mentioned in the mainstream news and journalists covering this story just don't seem
00:00:45 very interested in her experience of what she described as a toxic relationship. Mainstream
00:00:52 journalists seem similarly oblivious to the perspective of the young man on Hill's staff,
00:00:57 Graham Kelly, with whom it is alleged she had another sexual relationship, one forbidden under
00:01:03 House rules. Hill has denied the affair, but he has not, and most journalists seem to have decided
00:01:09 that it doesn't really matter that the young man she may have sexually exploited has not yet come
00:01:15 forward to corroborate her denial. His very existence has been airbrushed out of many
00:01:21 accounts. No, the victim in this whole drama is Hill herself, the self-describably, quote,
00:01:29 heartbroken woman who complained in her resignation statement about the, quote, pain inflicted by her
00:01:36 abusive husband and the brutality of hateful political operatives, end quote. About her own
00:01:44 unethical behavior hill had remarkably little to say quote for the mistakes made along the way
00:01:53 she quipped and the people who have been hurt i am so sorry and i am learning i am not a perfect
00:02:00 person and never pretended to be end quote there you go shame on those who expected her to be
00:02:08 perfect and caused hurt by jumping all over her mistakes hill ended her non-apologetic apology
00:02:16 ever the heroine by pledging to devote herself to defeating the cyber exploitation which has
00:02:22 victimized her and which she claimed a threat to other women all of this self-adulation and
00:02:30 deflection of responsibility are quite a feat for the woman whose campaign was a piece of me too 0.99
00:02:37 Me Too era theater from first to last, predicated on the myth that women with power have a much 1.00
00:02:44 higher ethical standard than powerful men, and who tweeted her disgust over the Supreme Court 0.99
00:02:51 nomination of Brett Kavanaugh, who was accused without any proof of jumping on a bed with a
00:02:56 girl when he was 17 years old. Hill has also somehow managed to avoid questions about her
00:03:03 iron cross tattoo and her bong smoking, but never mind that. I'm sure a lot of progressives
00:03:09 commemorate 9-11 by getting high. We're left with the story that she's been forced out of office by
00:03:16 a right-wing anti-woman smear machine, even though she is the one who resigned before the House
00:03:23 Ethics Committee could conduct its investigation. The scandal certainly makes one thing clear,
00:03:30 And it's not that women can behave in sexually irresponsible and immoral ways, though Hill 0.96
00:03:36 certainly did that. Even if her relationship with Morgan Desjardins was consensual and not 0.94
00:03:43 prohibited by ethics rules, which apparently don't forbid relationships with campaign staff, 1.00
00:03:49 even so, it breaks all the feminist rules about sexual contact between a person with power and 1.00
00:03:56 someone with significantly less power, in this case, a young woman dependent on Hill for her 1.00
00:04:02 paycheck. I'm not in favor of penalizing consensual sexual affairs of this sort, but Hill's hypocrisy 0.96
00:04:11 is staggering. There's also nothing very unusual about the fact that Hill is now fudging her 0.80
00:04:19 years-long relationship with her husband to claim that he was abusive, even though emails published
00:04:25 by the Daily Mail, paint a far more likely picture of an ambitious woman with her star on the rise,
00:04:32 growing tired of her low-status husband. It's not even really surprising that Hill has totally
00:04:39 failed to take responsibility for her wrongdoing, because that's the now standard female modus 1.00
00:04:46 operandi, no matter what the circumstances, cry victim and blame somebody else. She even had the 1.00
00:04:55 gall to tweet following her resignation, quote, to every girl and woman, to everyone who believes in
00:05:02 this fight, this isn't over, end quote. Never mind that the only fight Hill really seemed engaged in
00:05:10 was the fight to accrue power in order to use others for her ego gratification.
00:05:16 What is remarkable about this story is that Hill seems to be getting away with it.
00:05:23 Nearly every element of her scripted Poor Me resignation letter
00:05:27 has been picked up by commentators and repeated, elaborated, and magnified. 0.97
00:05:32 In an article called Targeting of Representative Katie Hill is a Warning Shot to Women, 1.00
00:05:38 CNN argued that the attack on Hill proves that, quote, a woman in charge of her sexuality 1.00
00:05:45 is a threat to the status quo, end quote. In charge of her sexuality? That's certainly a 1.00
00:05:53 unique way of describing Hill's inability to keep her hands off young people she employed. 1.00
00:06:00 Vox magazine published a lengthy article called Revenge Porn is a Tactic of Abuse. 1.00
00:06:06 Katie Hill's case makes that clear, in which two feminist attorneys couldn't care less about what 1.00
00:06:14 the photos revealed about Hill's conduct with Desjardins, which in nearly any workplace would 1.00
00:06:20 now be classed as sexual harassment, their sole interest being to portray her as a victim of
00:06:26 domestic violence and societal misogyny. They go so far as to allege that public interest
00:06:34 in the photos of Hill indicates, quote, a society gleefully receptive to the sexual humiliation of
00:06:42 a young woman who dared be powerful, end quote. One might more likely find many readers gleefully
00:06:50 receptive to the spectacle of a holier-than-thou feminist hoist with her own petard. And the 1.00
00:06:56 Guardian newspaper published an article called, This is War, Activists Mourn, Katie Hill, 0.99
00:07:02 but vow to fight for next female Democrat, the focus of that article being the cruel 0.99
00:07:09 double standards supposedly at work in Hill's treatment and the need for future female 0.99
00:07:15 Democrats to be protected from them. Nobody seems to care about protecting young campaign aides 1.00
00:07:23 from women like Hill. To be clear, I support due process for all accused, even for sanctimonious
00:07:34 types like Katie Hill. But what I dislike is the mind-boggling hypocrisy at play in which a woman 0.99
00:07:42 is to be protected and even celebrated for doing exactly what she has publicly opposed over and 0.82
00:07:51 over again and in which anyone who even raises an eyebrow at her sleazy conduct is immediately 0.97
00:07:59 accused of misogyny and worse. But feminists have always had very high standards for everyone but 1.00
00:08:08 themselves. And anyone who thinks this isn't the future of feminists in political life 1.00
00:08:15 must have been toking on Katie Hill's bong. 1.00