The Fiamengo File - May 12, 2016


Professors in Love - TFF Episode 37

The Gender Equity Boondoggle - TFF Episode 36 Professors in Love - TFF Episode 37 r

Episode Stats


Length

11 minutes

Words per minute

133.48

Word count

1,563

Sentence count

75

Harmful content

Misogyny

12

sentences flagged

Toxicity

2

sentences flagged

Hate speech

9

sentences flagged


Transcript

Transcript generated with Whisper (turbo).
Misogyny classifications generated with MilaNLProc/bert-base-uncased-ear-misogyny .
Toxicity classifications generated with s-nlp/roberta_toxicity_classifier .
Hate speech classifications generated with facebook/roberta-hate-speech-dynabench-r4-target .
00:00:00 Faculty-student erotic interaction. Is it an abuse of power? Two recent sexual
00:00:07 harassment scandals on university campuses raise the question of who gets
00:00:12 hurt when feelings override professorial dignity? That's my subject on today's
00:00:18 Fiamengo File. I'm Janice Fiamengo of the University of Ottawa. Two stories of
00:00:28 sexual harassment, one on a Canadian and the other on an American university campus,
00:00:33 are not dissimilar. At Brock University in Southern Ontario, amid now familiar claims of
00:00:40 rape culture and administrative cover-up, students are protesting the university's handling
00:00:46 of the case of a professor found to have made sexual advances to a female student.
00:00:52 According to a report by the CBC, Professor David Schimelpennink-Vanderoy
00:00:59 quote, gave the student alcohol and quote, tried to force himself on her sexually
00:01:06 after they met in his office late at night. At UC Berkeley in San Francisco, according to a report
00:01:12 in the Guardian online news site, two graduate students have launched a formal complaint against
00:01:18 their professor, Blake Wentworth, for inappropriate comments and advances, and members of the student
00:01:24 body there are infuriated by the school's failure to fire him. According to the report, Berkeley's
00:01:31 Professor Wentworth harassed the two women by, among other things, calling one of the students
00:01:37 a, quote, poor little lamb, and standing close to her, he apparently spoke of his failing marriage
00:01:44 and a night with a stripper to the other. One of the students was so devastated by his admission,
00:01:51 I'm so attracted to you, that she can now, many months later, barely get out of bed.
00:01:57 The stories follow such a standard pattern that you hardly need me to give you the particulars to
00:02:04 know the basic narrative. There's a man, of course, alleged to have used his power to take
00:02:10 advantage of vulnerable students. There are the female students traumatized by his advances,
00:02:17 literally made ill by the professor's lust. There's a small to medium-sized mob of students,
00:02:24 nearly apoplectic with outrage, and an apologetic university administration running scared.
00:02:32 These are the times we live in. My university, like most, has a sexual harassment policy
00:02:39 that condemns faculty-student relationships. Policy 67 at the U of Ottawa says that because
00:02:46 romantic or sexual relationships between faculty members and students are ones in which a power
00:02:53 differential may exist, the university therefore strongly disapproves of them and
00:03:00 expects members of its community to refrain from engaging in them." It's an interesting 0.94
00:03:07 formulation not an outright prohibition, but a statement of disapproval. It seems the university
00:03:14 doesn't really want to be in the business of prying into and punishing consensual love affairs,
00:03:20 though some universities do, but the university wants to protect itself if a student comes forward
00:03:27 with a complaint, as students are increasingly apt to do. It wasn't always like this. Even within
00:03:35 living memory professors and students were commonly involved with one another romantically
00:03:41 and or sexually they partied together drank together smoked pot together slept together and
00:03:49 even married together when i started university in the early 1980s those days were mostly over
00:03:56 but some vestiges remained three of my professors were married to former students and everybody knew
00:04:04 about the steamy student affairs of a couple of the popular male professors. Nobody, so far as I
00:04:11 know, regarded those men as abusive or exploitative. On the contrary, they were well liked. A few years
00:04:18 later, when I was a graduate student, one of my friends had an affair with his professor that
00:04:23 developed into a lifelong romantic partnership. There were no university statements then about
00:04:29 quote, differential power relationships, though those statements were on the horizon.
00:04:35 Most of us felt that a student who had an affair with a professor had something of an advantage
00:04:41 over the rest of us. I doubt many of us believed that the student was thereby vulnerable to some
00:04:46 sort of abuse of power. What power did professors have anyway? What they had was the potent allure
00:04:55 of their knowledge, which young people through the ages, especially young women, have always found
00:05:01 very attractive in older men. That's the power that gets hearts beating fast and puts the stars
00:05:07 in female students' eyes, and no amount of censorious theorizing about power inequities 0.99
00:05:13 is likely to change that. Professor Laura Kipnis of Northwestern University made some of these 0.99
00:05:21 same points in her splendid essay, Sexual Paranoia Strikes Academe, an essay published
00:05:29 in the Chronicle of Higher Education. Ironically, it landed Kipnis smack in the middle of a Title
00:05:36 IX investigation for gender discrimination when some graduate students brought a complaint against 1.00
00:05:41 her. Kipnis had argued that the whole idea of the, quote, all-powerful professor, end quote,
00:05:49 Taking advantage of his vulnerable female students was a mythical invention of 0.99
00:05:54 a feminism that, in her words, had been, quote, hijacked by melodrama, end quote.
00:06:00 All the expressions of shock and horror and outrage and debilitating fear were simply hard
00:06:08 to believe. For Kipnis, feminism had been originally about independence and freedom 0.99
00:06:13 for women and she was dismayed by all the new prohibitions on faculty-student relationships
00:06:19 because they seem to be increasing rather than decreasing female students' sense of
00:06:25 vulnerability and producing a neurotic and childlike female population. 0.98
00:06:31 I agree with much of Kipnis' analysis, though ultimately I see the behaviour of the female 0.96
00:06:37 students in these scenarios in a rather darker light than Kipnis, who seems to take the women
00:06:43 at their traumatized and trembling word. I'm more skeptical. When The Guardian reports that one of
00:06:51 Professor Wentworth's alleged victims, a 28-year-old Latina, broke down crying during her interview
00:06:59 and claimed that, quote, this place isn't made for people that look like us, end quote, I see
00:07:07 not a devastated child but a conscious actor mobilizing a pre-scripted power play to destroy
00:07:15 a man's life. Though indeed sexual harassment legislation may in some sense have weakened
00:07:21 female students, it has also provided them with a nearly fail-safe means to exploit public sympathy
00:07:30 and to make dramatic charges and exorbitant demands. Why do we keep on pretending that 0.99
00:07:37 these adult students, some of them well past the age of majority, are helpless waifs.
00:07:44 Let's look at what we know about the Brock University case. Despite the quaint language
00:07:50 in the CBC report about the professor giving alcohol to the student and trying to force himself
00:07:58 on her, the fact is that the student must have gone of her own accord to his office at night
00:08:05 and accepted the alcohol he offered. Why did she go if not out of some kind of sexual or romantic
00:08:13 interest? Are we really to believe that she was so paralyzed by timorous compliance that she
00:08:19 couldn't resist his invitations? And to switch to the Berkeley case, are we really to believe
00:08:25 there that in a time when primary school children are taught sex education and teenage girls use
00:08:32 social media to share erotic pictures of themselves, that a woman in her mid-twenties
00:08:38 would be so traumatized by a professor's comment that learning Tamil was, quote,
00:08:45 better than sex, so traumatized by that that she would have to take medical leave from her studies. 0.96
00:08:51 As a result, I'm sorry, it's just ridiculous. But the biggest farce of these stories is the 0.94
00:09:00 continued pretense that professor-student relations are wrong because the professors
00:09:06 have some kind of malignant power. What power? The two graduate students in the Berkeley case
00:09:14 claimed that they feared retaliation if they came forward. But it isn't at all clear what
00:09:20 form that retaliation could possibly have taken. In what way could a professor harm his student?
00:09:27 By giving her a bad grade? Nonsense. Every student knows of academic appeal procedures.
00:09:34 There are many avenues for redress in a case like that. So what then? Ruining her reputation?
00:09:41 Getting her expelled from the school? Wrecking her career? Well, it's the exact opposite. These
00:09:47 students know and have obviously acted on that knowledge that all the power is in their hands.
00:09:54 All they have to do is say the word, and a vast machinery designed to defend their
00:09:59 outraged dignity will go immediately into action. They will be sympathetically interviewed by
00:10:05 journalists. Other students will protest on their behalf. Administrators will assure the
00:10:11 public that the university takes their complaints seriously. And the professor will be forced to
00:10:17 defend himself against charges that, if found credible, could cost him not only his position,
00:10:25 but his entire career. He will likely never work at a university again.
00:10:31 The students, meanwhile, go on with their lives, applauded for their courage. And if they're really
00:10:37 clever, they can turn the whole story into a project for academic credit, as in the case of
00:10:42 Emma Salkowitz and her mattress. The idea that these adult women had no choice in the matter, 0.98
00:10:50 that they were helpless maidens menaced by a monster, is straight out of a fairy tale.
00:10:57 The Feminist Revolution claimed to be about freeing women from the Victorian straitjacket 0.88
00:11:04 in which women had to be protected from men. The idea that even a sensuous glance 0.99
00:11:10 could send women to the fainting couch. Now that couch has become their bully pulpit. 1.00
00:11:18 The sad fact of the matter is that an adult woman, so frail she has to take to her bed because a man 0.73
00:11:26 told her he found her attractive, well unfortunately that woman has got no business in higher education at all. 0.68
00:11:40 You 1.00