The Fiamengo File - April 28, 2016


The Ghomeshi Verdict - TFF Episode 35

Cost of Gender Studies - TFF Episode 34 The Gender Equity Boondoggle - TFF Episode 36

Episode Stats


Length

21 minutes

Words per minute

131.92

Word count

2,829

Sentence count

112

Harmful content

Misogyny

31

sentences flagged

Toxicity

3

sentences flagged

Hate speech

9

sentences flagged


Transcript

Transcript generated with Whisper (turbo).
Misogyny classifications generated with MilaNLProc/bert-base-uncased-ear-misogyny .
Toxicity classifications generated with s-nlp/roberta_toxicity_classifier .
Hate speech classifications generated with facebook/roberta-hate-speech-dynabench-r4-target .
00:00:00 Feminists were obviously disappointed by the Xi'an Gomeshi verdict in which the former
00:00:06 CBC media darling was found not guilty on sex assault charges.
00:00:13 Academic legal theory holds the key to understanding how we got to the point where the presumption
00:00:18 of innocence is under attack in sexual assault law.
00:00:23 That's my subject on today's Fiamengo File.
00:00:31 I'm Janice Fiamengo of the University of Ottawa.
00:00:34 Like many North Americans, I was spellbound by the Gameshi trial in all its lurid drama,
00:00:40 especially the light it has shed on contemporary feminist legal advocacy.
00:00:46 The trial told a story that in a sane world would have delivered a body blow to feminism,
00:00:52 revealing so much that is wrong with the believe-the-women doctrine.
00:00:58 Every single one of the complainants in the Gomeshi case was shown to have lied,
00:01:02 lied repeatedly and outrageously, so much so that only the most self-deluded of magical thinkers could claim otherwise.
00:01:12 Moreover, the complainant's behavior told a disturbing story about female complicity.
00:01:18 While stating that they had suffered shocking abuse at Gomeshi's hands, abuse so horrible
00:01:24 that it left them wanting nothing to do with him ever again, it turned out that they had all
00:01:29 pursued him ardently after the alleged abuse, singing his praises and offering themselves
00:01:36 seductively in email invitations, even when he seemed distinctly uninterested.
00:01:44 For any gal who's ever thrown herself at a man whose interest has waned, 0.85
00:01:49 the spectacle of the women's persistence was, well, embarrassing. They were like stereotypes 1.00
00:01:57 come to life—women who charged a man with sexual assault because he didn't care enough. 1.00
00:02:03 But the feminist juggernaut wasn't checked by these revelations of lies, 1.00
00:02:09 foolishness, and self-sabotage. If anything, feminists seemed galvanized using the spectacle 1.00
00:02:15 of women fawning all over the man who supposedly assaulted them to assert their unshakable faith 0.99
00:02:23 in female truthfulness. In the need to balance, which is a code word for smash, 0.77
00:02:29 the legal rights of the accused with greater protections for women, and the insistence on 0.92
00:02:35 the entire transformation of the criminal justice system so that women can convict men
00:02:41 of sexual assault just on their say-so. Every newspaper and magazine in the country
00:02:48 had a feminist writer telling us that sexual assault trauma makes women do strange things, 0.97
00:02:54 and that what women may say to a man during or after an assault may be the very opposite
00:02:59 of what they really feel. That women are conditioned to lie about sexual assault a lot of the time,
00:03:07 and do lie about sexual assault a lot of the time, but that shouldn't stop us from believing 0.85
00:03:13 what they say this time. The underlying message seems to be that a compassionate society owes it
00:03:21 to women to put men in jail, no matter what the women have done to mislead the man about their 0.68
00:03:28 desires and intentions. Emma Healy in the Toronto Star had the gall to claim 0.85
00:03:35 that the trial was really about our society's continuing inability to see women as complex 0.93
00:03:42 human beings. It was hard to believe she'd been following the same trial when she stated that,
00:03:48 quote, if a woman's reaction to trauma involves anything less than perfect behaviour, people will
00:03:56 be more inclined to dismiss that reaction." For Healy, it seemed outright lying proves a woman's
00:04:05 complexity. It's as if these women were characters in a feminist novel, rather than complainants 1.00
00:04:12 bound by legal oath and seeking to have a man locked away in jail for years. Anne Kingston
00:04:20 in Maclean's magazine used the same kind of question-begging argument, commenting that the
00:04:25 trial revealed that, quote, the responses and reactions of sexual assault survivors
00:04:32 may not conform to a scarlet letter script, end quote. Margaret Schimba in the Halifax
00:04:41 Spectator was beating the same victim drum, claiming that the trial, quote, 0.88
00:04:45 hearkened back to days of yore when women were considered vile, sinful creatures without even
00:04:52 the vestiges of a soul. What? These writers and many more seem to have imbibed so much feminist 0.99
00:05:01 theory as to be unable to respond rationally to reality. None of them seem to understand or care
00:05:10 that this was a criminal trial where legal standards exist to protect the accused from
00:05:15 wrongful conviction. Their only concern, it seemed, was to celebrate women's humanity,
00:05:22 which apparently means believing whatever any woman has to say regardless of whether she
00:05:28 perjured herself, colluded with other witnesses, or behaved in ways to completely undermine her
00:05:35 claims. Shkimba, the third writer who has taken a women and the law course at university,
00:05:42 was explicitly in favor of throwing out the presumption of innocence altogether.
00:05:48 She says, quote,
00:05:50 In sexual assault cases, we know what justice looks like
00:05:54 when innocent until proven guilty is the assumed position.
00:05:59 But what would justice look like if we believed the survivors?
00:06:05 End quote.
00:06:06 To say that it wouldn't look like justice at all,
00:06:10 but like mob rule, didn't seem to have occurred to her, or it had, and that's exactly what she wants, 1.00
00:06:17 so long as the mob is a feminist mob and isn't coming for her. But at least Skimba admitted that 1.00
00:06:25 she doesn't have any claim to legal expertise in how to remake the justice system. But not so 1.00
00:06:33 Naomi Sayers and Samantha Peters, who published in the Huffington Post on the subject of, quote,
00:06:39 reimagining how future sexual assault cases are heard. These two are really scary, not only
00:06:48 because their ideal future system would see social justice replace regular justice, but because one
00:06:57 of them, Samantha Peters, is described as a law student. Though claiming that they don't want to
00:07:04 overturn the presumption of innocence. That's exactly what they want to do, to skew the court
00:07:10 in the complainant's favor, radically altering the burden of proof such that the rights of so-called
00:07:16 survivors would be prioritized over the rights of the accused. They tell us with no sense of
00:07:23 irony or self-awareness that they, quote, believe all survivors of violence, especially sexual
00:07:31 violence." One wonders why they advocate any trial at all, perhaps only to allow the
00:07:39 survivor the chance to tell her story publicly, to display her wounds in front of a genuflecting
00:07:46 judge and jury. They want, among other unspecified transformations, special training for judges to
00:07:54 influence how judges make decisions about credibility based on intersectional feminist
00:08:01 understandings of trauma and oppression. I'm tempted to say that it's shocking that someone
00:08:08 trained in law would so happily contemplate discarding the law, but in fact it's not shocking
00:08:15 at all, since a philosophical movement intent on destroying and remaking the Western legal system
00:08:22 has had a firm place in academic legal studies for decades. And if you really want to understand
00:08:29 where so much of the thinking around the Gomeshi trial has its foundation, you should check out
00:08:36 this branch of legal theory, because it's at the base of it all. It's called Critical Legal Theory.
00:08:45 The theory draws on feminist, anti-racist, and post-colonial theories, and it was pioneered by
00:08:52 social justice legal activists within the American university system, such as Kimberly Crenshaw, 0.76
00:08:58 Derrick Bell, not coincidentally a mentor of Barack Obama at Harvard, Mary Matsuda,
00:09:06 and Richard Delgado. The fundamental premise of critical legal theory is that the Western
00:09:12 justice system is not in any way a neutral or unbiased body of laws and procedures. On the
00:09:17 contrary, the system is a tool of power set up to protect the interests of privileged white men.
00:09:26 Critical legal theorists don't want to reform the system to make it more fair and neutral. They
00:09:31 don't actually believe in the possibility of neutrality. They advocate remaking the system
00:09:37 to advance the interests of the so-called marginalized and oppressed, women and people
00:09:43 of colour in particular. Their rationale is essentially, though they would never say so,
00:09:49 legal and social revenge. They tell us over and over again that women, for example, have been 0.96
00:09:57 badly treated under the law in the past, with the implication that such bad treatment
00:10:03 authorises the bad treatment of men in the present. In fact, they feel that men, white men in 0.58
00:10:09 in particular, though Gomeshi wasn't white and that didn't help him, that men could
00:10:13 never be badly treated enough to satisfy the demands of cosmic justice.
00:10:20 Of course, they would strenuously deny that revenge is their motive.
00:10:25 What they say instead is that greater attention to social context is necessary in the application
00:10:33 of law.
00:10:34 words, uniform standards can't be applied to determine, for example, credibility or fair
00:10:42 punishment. Thus, a woman who claims to be the victim of sexual violence, or the victim of an
00:10:49 abusive husband, say, or the victim of postpartum depression, her behavior is to be judged according
00:10:55 to different standards than would be applied to a man. One of the big problems with the theory,
00:11:02 aside from its development of radically inequitable standards for different categories of people
00:11:08 is that it involves applying labels such as trauma victim or battered woman while denying the
00:11:17 standards of evidence necessary to determine whether the label fits in the first place. How
00:11:23 do we know that this woman is a victim of trauma if we can't rigorously investigate the claim that
00:11:30 she is and we see this sleight of hand already in practice with the use of the words victim or
00:11:38 survivor rather than complainant when referring to perjured witnesses as in this case part of the
00:11:45 thinking behind it all is that women and people of color etc are always already victims just by being 0.51
00:11:53 who they are and therefore they are specially deserving of belief and compensation
00:12:00 Whereas a privileged man like Gomeshi is, by definition, less deserving of belief because he has already had the experience of being thought credible just by who he is.
00:12:12 It's a terrifying vision of a designedly unequal system, a system proud of its inequality, and calling it a higher equality, a restorative equality.
00:12:26 I believe feminists have won the narrative on this one, and we see the results of their victory
00:12:34 even in the decision of the judge, who did not find Gomeshi guilty.
00:12:41 Now, like the feminist commentators I've just criticized, I don't have legal training,
00:12:46 so it may be that I am quite wrong in my reading of Justice William B. Horkin's judgment,
00:12:52 and I invite viewers to tell me if I am. But here goes anyway.
00:12:56 The judgment is, in my opinion, deeply influenced by the feminist narrative about how victims
00:13:04 of sexual trauma cannot be judged according to reasonable standards, influenced to such
00:13:11 an extent that the judgment sets a very grave precedent for future cases, perhaps even future
00:13:17 cases against Gomeshi.
00:13:20 In the case of the complainant Lucie de Coutere, it came out at trial that, after the alleged
00:13:26 choking incident at Gomeshi's home, Dukuter maintained an intimate relationship with Gomeshi
00:13:33 over the rest of the weekend, sent him flowers after the weekend was over thanking him for being
00:13:39 such a good host, sent him loving and titillating emails, and continued to pursue a relationship
00:13:46 with him for well over a year. All of this she had suppressed. When confronted with proof of
00:13:54 all that she hadn't told, she claimed that she was going to tell it all at the trial, but simply
00:14:01 hadn't had an opportunity yet to do so. The judge's comment on these suppressions is, in my opinion,
00:14:10 ominously careful. He wrote, quote, a natural assumption might be that what was actually
00:14:18 stopping Ms. de Kuterre from sharing all of this undisclosed information was the fear
00:14:24 that to some audiences this post-event socializing would reflect badly on her claims that this
00:14:32 man had in fact assaulted her. Had she genuinely feared that this sort of thinking would unfairly
00:14:39 undermine her credibility, that concern might have been an explanation worth giving careful
00:14:46 consideration. That's the end of the quotation. I don't know what to make of that. I find it
00:14:54 striking that the judge states only that Ms. de Kater's behaviour might have undermined her
00:15:01 credibility with, quote, some audiences. Surely what is germane to the case is not how some
00:15:09 audiences might react. The question is whether a reasonable person would find on balance that
00:15:15 Ms. de Kuterre's behavior drastically weakened her claim to have been assaulted by Gomeshi.
00:15:23 In focusing entirely on the withholding of the information, the judge suggests that the
00:15:30 behavior itself was less determinative than the fact of not disclosing it and that if she
00:15:38 had disclosed it with a good reason, then the behavior would not have proved anything.
00:15:44 This seems to me dangerously close to the feminist position that traumatized survivors of sexual assault cannot be judged by ordinary standards, and that their yes may well mean no.
00:16:01 In fact, they can say, yes, yes, more, please do it again, and it's still assault if they later declare it is. 1.00
00:16:11 Here, feminists demand that the law get into murky regions of the female psyche where 1.00
00:16:18 no reason-based system can or should go. Perhaps the judge felt that he didn't need to comment 1.00
00:16:25 on de Couture's behavior since her withholding of the evidence was so egregious, and given the
00:16:32 feminist insistence that no behavior on the part of an alleged victim can be seen to disqualify
00:16:38 her victim claim, maybe he simply avoided commentary that he knew would provoke ire.
00:16:45 This was safe and prudent, perhaps, but not very clear. And it seems to me crucial that in a case
00:16:54 such as this, a case receiving so much attention, the judge's verdict should have been crystal clear.
00:17:02 I think the judge didn't want to get into the whole matter of the complainant's behavior.
00:17:08 And that really worries me. Too often for my liking, in fact, this judge seemed to go out of
00:17:15 his way to acknowledge feminist positions in an improving manner. Regarding the first witness,
00:17:22 L.R., now revealed to be Linda Redgrave, the judge explicitly evoked the feminist principle that
00:17:29 victim credibility can't be judged on the basis of common sense standards. He wrote as follows,
00:17:35 quote, the expectation of how a victim of abuse will or should be expected to behave must not
00:17:44 be assessed on the basis of stereotypical models. Having said that, I have no hesitation in saying
00:17:52 that the behavior of this complainant is at the very least odd, end quote.
00:17:59 I know I'm not the only person who has found this statement quite baffling.
00:18:04 What exactly is or is not a stereotype in the judge's estimation?
00:18:12 A stereotype is, in the loosest sense, a standard model, a predictable type of behavior. 1.00
00:18:19 According to the feminists, practically any assumption of how a female sexual assault victim would likely behave is a stereotype. 1.00
00:18:28 It's a stereotype, for example, to think that a victim wouldn't romantically pursue the man who assaulted her. 0.92
00:18:35 So is the judge agreeing that this is a stereotype, but then judging LR on the basis of that stereotype anyway?
00:18:45 Or is it not a stereotype?
00:18:48 And if we are not to judge on the basis of stereotypes, how can we judge any behavior?
00:18:54 After all, judges and juries in a court of law don't know victims personally.
00:19:00 They can't judge on the basis of years of intimate knowledge. 1.00
00:19:03 Now, we know what the feminists would say. 1.00
00:19:06 We should judge on the basis of what feminist experts tell us is typical behavior of sexual assault survivors. 1.00
00:19:15 But those feminist experts would be offering stereotypes too. 1.00
00:19:19 In other words, standard models, predictable types. 1.00
00:19:22 they would just happen to be feminist stereotypes. So the judge's statement makes no sense to me,
00:19:29 and it concedes, in my opinion, far too much to a feminist theory in which women's behavior
00:19:37 can be both irrational and yet credible at the same time. And that's how law is destroyed 1.00
00:19:46 and innocent men convicted. Ultimately, I fear that the feminist narrative blaring out at us 0.87
00:19:52 from nearly every newspaper and magazine about the Gomeshi trial has been so successful in
00:19:59 undermining reasonable standards that the only hope for a male defendant in a he-said-she-said
00:20:07 trial such as this one is hard evidence of the complainant's lies. The three women who wanted
00:20:14 to destroy Gomeshi's life didn't think he would still possess those decades-old emails.
00:20:22 But future complainants, whether in the Gomeshi or in similar cases, they'll take note. And no
00:20:30 matter how bizarre future complainants' behavior, no matter how vigorously they pursued their alleged
00:20:37 attacker, no matter how often they told him how sweet he was and how they wanted to continue
00:20:44 a sexual relationship so long as they disclose it all, the pressure to believe them will
00:20:53 be, I fear, almost irresistible. 0.52
00:20:57 We're at the point now where nothing a female complainant says or does can be used to disprove
00:21:04 her allegation of sexual assault. 0.90
00:21:07 Feminists may have lost this particular case, but they have laid the groundwork for many future wins in an entirely changed legal climate where the presumption of innocence and the burden of proof have been effectively nullified. 1.00