00:10:34words, uniform standards can't be applied to determine, for example, credibility or fair
00:10:42punishment. Thus, a woman who claims to be the victim of sexual violence, or the victim of an
00:10:49abusive husband, say, or the victim of postpartum depression, her behavior is to be judged according
00:10:55to different standards than would be applied to a man. One of the big problems with the theory,
00:11:02aside from its development of radically inequitable standards for different categories of people
00:11:08is that it involves applying labels such as trauma victim or battered woman while denying the
00:11:17standards of evidence necessary to determine whether the label fits in the first place. How
00:11:23do we know that this woman is a victim of trauma if we can't rigorously investigate the claim that
00:11:30she is and we see this sleight of hand already in practice with the use of the words victim or
00:11:38survivor rather than complainant when referring to perjured witnesses as in this case part of the
00:11:45thinking behind it all is that women and people of color etc are always already victims just by being0.51
00:11:53who they are and therefore they are specially deserving of belief and compensation
00:12:00Whereas a privileged man like Gomeshi is, by definition, less deserving of belief because he has already had the experience of being thought credible just by who he is.
00:12:12It's a terrifying vision of a designedly unequal system, a system proud of its inequality, and calling it a higher equality, a restorative equality.
00:12:26I believe feminists have won the narrative on this one, and we see the results of their victory
00:12:34even in the decision of the judge, who did not find Gomeshi guilty.
00:12:41Now, like the feminist commentators I've just criticized, I don't have legal training,
00:12:46so it may be that I am quite wrong in my reading of Justice William B. Horkin's judgment,
00:12:52and I invite viewers to tell me if I am. But here goes anyway.
00:12:56The judgment is, in my opinion, deeply influenced by the feminist narrative about how victims
00:13:04of sexual trauma cannot be judged according to reasonable standards, influenced to such
00:13:11an extent that the judgment sets a very grave precedent for future cases, perhaps even future
00:13:20In the case of the complainant Lucie de Coutere, it came out at trial that, after the alleged
00:13:26choking incident at Gomeshi's home, Dukuter maintained an intimate relationship with Gomeshi
00:13:33over the rest of the weekend, sent him flowers after the weekend was over thanking him for being
00:13:39such a good host, sent him loving and titillating emails, and continued to pursue a relationship
00:13:46with him for well over a year. All of this she had suppressed. When confronted with proof of
00:13:54all that she hadn't told, she claimed that she was going to tell it all at the trial, but simply
00:14:01hadn't had an opportunity yet to do so. The judge's comment on these suppressions is, in my opinion,
00:14:10ominously careful. He wrote, quote, a natural assumption might be that what was actually
00:14:18stopping Ms. de Kuterre from sharing all of this undisclosed information was the fear
00:14:24that to some audiences this post-event socializing would reflect badly on her claims that this
00:14:32man had in fact assaulted her. Had she genuinely feared that this sort of thinking would unfairly
00:14:39undermine her credibility, that concern might have been an explanation worth giving careful
00:14:46consideration. That's the end of the quotation. I don't know what to make of that. I find it
00:14:54striking that the judge states only that Ms. de Kater's behaviour might have undermined her
00:15:01credibility with, quote, some audiences. Surely what is germane to the case is not how some
00:15:09audiences might react. The question is whether a reasonable person would find on balance that
00:15:15Ms. de Kuterre's behavior drastically weakened her claim to have been assaulted by Gomeshi.
00:15:23In focusing entirely on the withholding of the information, the judge suggests that the
00:15:30behavior itself was less determinative than the fact of not disclosing it and that if she
00:15:38had disclosed it with a good reason, then the behavior would not have proved anything.
00:15:44This seems to me dangerously close to the feminist position that traumatized survivors of sexual assault cannot be judged by ordinary standards, and that their yes may well mean no.
00:16:01In fact, they can say, yes, yes, more, please do it again, and it's still assault if they later declare it is.1.00
00:16:11Here, feminists demand that the law get into murky regions of the female psyche where1.00
00:16:18no reason-based system can or should go. Perhaps the judge felt that he didn't need to comment1.00
00:16:25on de Couture's behavior since her withholding of the evidence was so egregious, and given the
00:16:32feminist insistence that no behavior on the part of an alleged victim can be seen to disqualify
00:16:38her victim claim, maybe he simply avoided commentary that he knew would provoke ire.
00:16:45This was safe and prudent, perhaps, but not very clear. And it seems to me crucial that in a case
00:16:54such as this, a case receiving so much attention, the judge's verdict should have been crystal clear.
00:17:02I think the judge didn't want to get into the whole matter of the complainant's behavior.
00:17:08And that really worries me. Too often for my liking, in fact, this judge seemed to go out of
00:17:15his way to acknowledge feminist positions in an improving manner. Regarding the first witness,
00:17:22L.R., now revealed to be Linda Redgrave, the judge explicitly evoked the feminist principle that
00:17:29victim credibility can't be judged on the basis of common sense standards. He wrote as follows,
00:17:35quote, the expectation of how a victim of abuse will or should be expected to behave must not
00:17:44be assessed on the basis of stereotypical models. Having said that, I have no hesitation in saying
00:17:52that the behavior of this complainant is at the very least odd, end quote.
00:17:59I know I'm not the only person who has found this statement quite baffling.
00:18:04What exactly is or is not a stereotype in the judge's estimation?
00:18:12A stereotype is, in the loosest sense, a standard model, a predictable type of behavior.1.00
00:18:19According to the feminists, practically any assumption of how a female sexual assault victim would likely behave is a stereotype.1.00
00:18:28It's a stereotype, for example, to think that a victim wouldn't romantically pursue the man who assaulted her.0.92
00:18:35So is the judge agreeing that this is a stereotype, but then judging LR on the basis of that stereotype anyway?
00:21:07Feminists may have lost this particular case, but they have laid the groundwork for many future wins in an entirely changed legal climate where the presumption of innocence and the burden of proof have been effectively nullified.1.00