00:00:00There's nothing like a catfight among the sisterhood to expose feminism's bizarre rules.0.99
00:00:06That's my subject on today's Fiamengo File.
00:00:18I'm Janice Fiamengo of the University of Ottawa. Recently, there have been wild accusations of
00:00:24violence and harm and groveling apologies at a feminist philosophy journal over their decision
00:00:30to publish an article by a feminist philosopher named rebecca tuval the article was called in
00:00:37defense of transracialism and as its title indicates it argues that society should treat
00:00:42transracial people with the same acceptance that it is now considered generally right to give0.95
00:00:48transgender people for making that argument tuval was denounced by hundreds of feminist academics1.00
00:00:56one of whom called her out for quote egregious levels of liberal white ignorance and discursive0.88
00:01:04trans misogynistic violence now there are too many twists and turns to cover everything but let me0.98
00:01:12offer a recap and highlight a few points in this story of lunatic meanness and cowardice
00:01:20in defense of transracialism was published in the spring 2017 issue of high patia a journal
00:01:28describing itself as a quote forum for cutting edge work in feminist philosophy philosophy is
00:01:35of course an ancient discipline that asks such questions as how we know what we think we know
00:01:41and how we define concepts like goodness, justice, being, and truth. Hypatia is named for the 4th
00:01:50century Greek female mathematician, astronomer, and philosopher Hypatia of Alexandria. Unfortunately,
00:01:58feminist philosophy as revealed in this incident is something Hypatia herself would likely have
00:02:03found repellent the journal's home page states rather ominously that quote hypatia's commitment
00:02:11to the development of feminist philosophy entails that in all its policies and practices hypatia
00:02:17actively reflect and engage the diversity within feminism itself the diverse experiences and
00:02:24situations of women and the diverse forms that gender takes across the globe end quote diversity
00:02:32is one of those feminist buzzwords that means the opposite of what it says having very little to do
00:02:38with genuine differences of perspective and everything to do with a rigid protocol of who's
00:02:44permitted to say what tuval's paper was impermissible essentially because it was written about0.98
00:02:50race by a white woman who didn't pay the necessary homage to black female scholars
00:02:56and also raised awkward questions about trans identities and privilege at the beginning of0.99
00:03:03her paper tuval introduced the much criticized rachel dolezal the young woman who was head of0.89
00:03:09the spokane washington chapter of the national association for the advancement of colored people0.68
00:03:15until it was discovered that both her parents are white not black after which she was forced
00:03:21to resign amidst a lot of public criticism tuval compares dolezal's case with that of the much more
00:03:27sympathetically received former athlete caitlin jenner who was generally applauded when she
00:03:33appeared on the cover of vanity fair magazine in her new incarnation as a woman so why is there
00:03:39growing acceptance that jenner is a trans woman when there is almost no acceptance that rachel
00:03:45dolezal is a trans black this is the question tuval pursued she concluded that quote if some
00:03:52individuals genuinely feel like or identify as a member of a race other than the one assigned to
00:03:57them at birth so strongly to the point of seeking to transition to the other race we should accept
00:04:04their decision to change races end quote so to clarify tuval is definitely not a right winger
00:04:14not that there's anything wrong with that she is as far as i can tell a card-carrying social0.99
00:04:21constructionist leftist feminist who accepts concepts like white privilege and gender equity1.00
00:04:27she uses politically correct phrases such as assigned at birth as in the above quotation1.00
00:04:32like most feminists she rejects biology as the basis of identity she accepts feminist claims0.75
00:04:39about male privilege. At one point in her essay, in fact, discussing potential ethical objections
00:04:45to Dolezal's claim to be black, she argues that, quote, men exercise male privilege when they get
00:04:50more jobs as philosophy professors, yet we do not thereby suggest that we get rid of philosophy
00:04:56professors. Rather, we try to address gender inequality so that more women are represented
00:05:02in the discipline. Well, I don't think that's logical at all. It is not a case of privilege
00:05:07if men, quote, get more jobs. Do they really? It's only a privilege if they get the jobs
00:05:14because they are male and likewise gender equality is not necessarily served by promoting women on0.62
00:05:21the basis that they're women. Well, I suspect that Rebecca Tuval and I would agree on almost0.63
00:05:26nothing regarding the principles of feminism, but that doesn't change the fact that she deserved0.52
00:05:33an appreciative academic response, a rigorous one perhaps. She didn't deserve the lynching,1.00
00:05:41transracial metaphor intended, that she received. Well, Tuval is no dummy, and nor is she ignorant0.99
00:05:50of transgender theory. She justified her choice of subject by saying that she wasn't judging0.62
00:05:55Dolezal's particular claim to be black. Instead, she was following transgender theorist Susan
00:06:03Stryker's advice to, quote, hold open a space, academics are always talking about metaphorical
00:06:10spaces, to hold open a space for real intellectual curiosity, for investigations that deepen our
00:06:17understanding of how identity claims and processes function, rather than rushing to offer well-formed
00:06:24opinions based on what we already think we know. Aside from the somewhat pompous and grammatically
00:06:30garbled language this would seem a perfectly legitimate philosophical aim i won't go into
00:06:37all the details of tuval's argument in which she considers four basic objections to transracialism
00:06:43i encourage you to read her article which is a surprisingly jargon-free discussion of what it
00:06:49means socially to transition to an identity different from what one was born into to provide
00:06:56a flavor of her style, here's how she deals with the objection that Dolezal's act of claiming to
00:07:01be black was actually an illustration of white privilege. She responds, it is difficult to see
00:07:07how giving up one's whiteness and becoming black is an exercise of white privilege. Rather, it seems
00:07:14like the ultimate renunciation of white privilege, if by white privilege we understand an unearned
00:07:21system of advantages conferred onto white bodies. This is pretty politically correct stuff,
00:07:29but it skirts the politically incorrect. And this is why I think Tuval might have fallen afoul of
00:07:37the ideology police. Because what Tuval doesn't say, and had no intention of saying, I should
00:07:43make clear, but this is what is gestured towards, is the fact that Dolezal's choice to become black
00:07:50raises questions about the whole idea of privilege. If a white woman prefers to be black, doesn't that0.91
00:07:57at least raise the possibility that in certain contexts and certain social settings, there's0.99
00:08:03such a thing as black female privilege? Just as the fact that more men than women decide to0.99
00:08:12transition may well suggest that there's such a thing as female privilege. I wonder if the0.93
00:08:19problem with Tuval's article was not that it was offensive in itself, which it certainly wasn't,
00:08:23but that its exploration opened the door to a range of ideas that many social justice activists
00:08:28don't want explored. But regardless of what one thinks of transitioning to a different race or
00:08:36gender, the impression one receives from reading Tuval's paper is of someone following a line of
00:08:42reasoning. And this is what the practice of philosophy is supposed to involve. If Tuval
00:08:48mischaracterized relevant scholarship or failed to consider counter-arguments, other scholars
00:08:54can take the opportunity to correct her. So, no biggie. It's really hard to square the content
00:09:03of Tuval's article with the shockwaves it provoked. Literally hundreds of academics
00:09:10wrote an outraged open letter to the editors of Hypatia insisting that the harm of the article
00:09:17was so great that only a retraction, a full apology, and a sweeping transformation
00:09:24of the journal's vetting procedure, how it is that they decide to publish certain articles,
00:09:30only all of that could properly respond to that harm. Now, what was the source of the harm?
00:09:36the letter writers wouldn't say, except to insist that as a cisgender white woman,0.66
00:09:42Tuval took liberties to which she was not entitled. They say, quote, a message has been sent
00:09:48to authors and readers alike that white cis scholars may engage in speculative discussion
00:09:54of these themes without broad and sustained engagement with those theorists whose lives
00:10:00are most directly affected by transphobia and racism, end quote. To put it simply, if you're
00:10:07white and you want to, quote, engage in speculative discussion about anything to do with race,0.97
00:10:13you can do so only if you defer to the appropriate black scholars.
00:10:18Now, when it comes to the content of the article, the open letter alleges that there are supposedly
00:10:25glaring problems. But they produce a list of only four, which turn out to be mostly errors of
00:10:32propriety or protocol, rather than of fact or logic. And I want to go through them as quickly
00:10:39as I can, because it is really shocking to think that hundreds of academics thought it fit to
00:10:46publish this list of supposedly catastrophically serious problems, which turn out to be almost
00:10:53nothing at all. Correct me if I'm wrong as I go through them. The first problem, presumably one of
00:10:58the most serious since they put it first, is that Tuval's article uses the wrong vocabulary. They
00:11:04say it, quote, uses vocabulary and frameworks not recognized, accepted, or adopted by the conventions
00:11:12of the relevant subfields. For example, the author uses the language of transgenderism. Apparently
00:11:18this isn't a popular term, although there are no obvious preferred ones, and it engages in dead
00:11:24naming a trans woman. In other words, it mentions that Caitlyn's former name was Bruce, as if anyone
00:11:30anywhere in the universe wasn't aware that Caitlyn Jenner was formerly named Bruce.
00:11:36These misnamings, if they are that, have almost nothing at all to do with the substance of the
00:11:42argument using the wrong terms might indeed hurt Tuval's reputation with other transgender and
00:11:48critical race scholars, but it is not at all clear how that could harm communities affected by
00:11:55transphobia and racism, since Tuval is obviously supportive of these communities. And if the number
00:12:02one reason to claim that the article is noxious is that it was written by someone not entirely
00:12:08familiar with the naming conventions in the subfield, well, this is at most a very minor
00:12:13fault. Now, the second purported problem in Tuval's article is that, quote, it mischaracterizes
00:12:20various theories and practices relating to religious identity and conversion. For example,
00:12:26the author gives an offhand example about conversion to Judaism, end quote. This sounds
00:12:33like a serious criticism, especially if Tuval mischaracterized various theories. But it simply
00:12:40isn't true. Tuval barely mentions religious identity in conversion. The subject takes up
00:12:46only part of one paragraph, 120 words, in an 8,000-word article. The matter of conversion to
00:12:55Judaism is very briefly related. It's brought into the article to make the quick point that
00:13:00conversion involves both self-identification in this case self-identification as jewish
00:13:06and also acceptance by the community in this case acceptance by a rabbi in the jewish community
00:13:12it doesn't detract from the central argument and it is definitely not as far as i can tell a
00:13:18mischaracterization the third identified problem is that tuvel's essay quote misrepresents leading
00:13:27accounts of belonging to a racial group. For example, the author incorrectly cites Charles
00:13:32Mills as a defender of voluntary racial identification, end quote. Okay, this also
00:13:38sounds very serious, and again, as far as I can tell, it is totally unfounded. Let's look at the
00:13:44exact statement by Rebecca Tuval in relation to Mill. It's as follows, sorry, Mills. Here it is.
00:13:51Charles Mills identifies at least five categories generally relevant to the determination of
00:13:56racial membership, including self-awareness of ancestry, public awareness of ancestry, culture,
00:14:03experience, and self-identification, end quote. Clearly Tuval is not saying that Mills is a
00:14:09defender of voluntary racial identification. She says that Mills lists self-identification
00:14:16as one component of racial membership. So the writers of the open letter are either
00:14:21deliberately misrepresenting what Tuval said, or they're such poor readers that they can't
00:14:26tell what she said. And finally, the fourth reason for the terribleness of the article
00:14:32is that, quote, it fails to seek out and sufficiently engage with scholarly work by
00:14:37those who are most vulnerable to the intersection of racial and gender oppressions, women of color,
00:14:43in its discussion of transracialism. Now, this is a version, I think, of the logical fallacy0.68
00:14:49of appealing to authority. It's not clear which scholars these are that Tuval should have mentioned
00:14:56or how engaging with them would have improved or changed her argument.
00:15:00At worst, this is an error of omission, if it really is, rather than of commission.
00:15:05But it really isn't clear that it is such an error.
00:15:09Certainly, what the criticism tells us is that identity politics,
00:15:12who you are, not what you say, has entirely overtaken this branch of feminist philosophy.0.82
00:15:20If you're a white cisgender woman, you'll be attacked for being a white cisgender woman.
00:15:26So in sum, the four problems identified by the open letter turn out to be insubstantial at best.
00:15:34Now, a delicious irony about this whole affair is that the open letter itself, full of outrage, full of righteousness,0.53
00:15:44it itself came in for criticism for its own white cisgender privilege.
00:15:50privilege. A PS actually had to be added to the letter on May 1st at the 520th signature,
00:15:58apologizing for the letter's failure to engage appropriately with Black issues. This is what
00:16:05they had to say, quote, we acknowledge that this statement should have named anti-Blackness
00:16:11directly. We thank Chanda Prescod-Weinstein and others for pointing out the dangerous
00:16:19erasure of anti-blackness and the erasure of the black labor on which the rhetoric of our own
00:16:26letter is built, end quote. This moment in the controversy is classic. No matter how high on
00:16:34their high horse the letter writers felt they were in criticizing Hypatia for publishing an article
00:16:41with unacknowledged white cisgender privilege, there's always an even more racially sensitive
00:16:46person, in this case the lofty Chanda Prescod Weinstein, and check out her online profile by
00:16:53the way, there's always somebody more racially sensitive willing to call out the writers of the
00:16:58letter for their unacknowledged white cisgender privilege. Touché. So this was the letter sent
00:17:07to the editors of the journal Hypatia. Now one would hope that smart people reading this letter
00:17:12with its demands for apology and its instructions to the editors about what statements they must
00:17:19issue what steps they must take and so on you'd hope that smart people would say well thank you
00:17:25for your letter although we decline to follow your dictates we do invite all of you to submit
00:17:31cogent follow-up articles to professor tuval's piece and if your articles are more accurate
00:17:39more substantial and more logically rigorous than this open letter we will consider publishing them
00:17:46but of course they didn't perhaps the long list of hundreds of big name signatories just
00:17:55cowed the hypatia editors or at least a majority of them this majority then posted a profound
00:18:03apology on the Hypatia Facebook page in which they, quote, recognize and mourn the harms of
00:18:13the article in agonizing, embarrassing detail with repeated promises to do better in future.
00:18:23And not only do they make no attempt to defend the article or their decision to publish it,
00:18:29They even say that the vicious attacks on Rebecca Tuval for, quote, perpetuating harm were, quote, both predictable and justifiable, end quote.