The Fiamengo File - August 22, 2020


Whacky English Prof Bans Disagreement with the Left - TFF Episode 124b

Kamala Harris and Female Power - The Fiamengo File Episode 123b Man Forced to Pay Alimony to Ex-Girlfriend - TFF Episode 125

Episode Stats


Length

7 minutes

Words per minute

122.13

Word count

936

Sentence count

22

Harmful content

Misogyny

16

sentences flagged

Toxicity

1

sentences flagged


Transcript

Transcript generated with Whisper (turbo).
Misogyny classifications generated with MilaNLProc/bert-base-uncased-ear-misogyny .
Toxicity classifications generated with s-nlp/roberta_toxicity_classifier .
00:00:00 The case of the wacky English prof at Iowa State University would be funny and trivial 0.94
00:00:09 if the problems she represents were not so widespread and so corrosive to the cause of 0.88
00:00:16 higher education.
00:00:28 the course outline for a writing class called English 250 at Iowa State was leaked to the media
00:00:36 and immediately caused an uproar. In the outline, the instructor warned students that in their
00:00:42 essays, they're not allowed to disagree with certain leftist positions on penalty of dismissal
00:00:50 from the classroom. When I saw the headlines, I was fairly confident that the professor's warning
00:00:56 was without legal foundation. No professor has the authority to dismiss a student from her classroom,
00:01:04 whatever that would mean, merely for writing an essay the prof disagreed with. And almost
00:01:09 immediately, Iowa State University announced that the statement had been removed from the professor's
00:01:15 course outline and assured students that their free expression rights would be protected in all
00:01:22 Iowa State classrooms. Well, if you believe that, I've got some property to sell you
00:01:29 in Portland, Oregon. I suspect that this assurance from university officials
00:01:35 is little comfort to the students who are stuck dealing with this authoritarian teacher,
00:01:41 who's a third-rate feminist poet and all-round holier-than-thou nincompoop who shouldn't be 1.00
00:01:47 allowed anywhere near a university classroom and she alas is not unusual in the hallowed halls of 1.00
00:01:56 academe where many professors long ago gave up on the pursuit of knowledge in favor of the much
00:02:02 sexier and self-satisfying pursuit of social justice this particular instructor whose name
00:02:10 is Chloe Clark, claimed in her course outline that writing against subjects like abortion,
00:02:19 gay marriage, or Black Lives Matter is prohibited because it involves othering,
00:02:26 founded on the assumption, quote, that one side doesn't deserve the same basic human rights as
00:02:33 you do, end quote. Othering is the thing you're never supposed to do, unless, of course, the person
00:02:41 you are othering believes in the sanctity of life from conception onward. Those people are to be
00:02:48 hated. She also provides a long list of isms and phobias, including sorophobia, a new one to me, 0.58
00:02:57 that are prohibited we're also told that her course will use the idea of the monster the
00:03:04 ultimate other as a focus for discussion in class the idea being that women and ethnic minorities
00:03:10 have been made into monsters in american society and we must all atone for that well many objections
00:03:20 spring to mind, the most obvious being the problem of how anyone could be othered by a student
00:03:28 writing an essay for their professor. Who does Chloe Clark think will be damaged if someone 0.99
00:03:35 writes an essay that only she will read? It seems that it is Chloe Clark herself who can't bear 0.66
00:03:43 to read arguments that offend her sense of righteousness.
00:03:49 And Chloe Clark, as noted previously, 1.00
00:03:51 is part of the majority of leftist feminist professors in English departments everywhere, 1.00
00:03:57 many of whom have built their entire careers 1.00
00:04:01 complaining about the mostly white men
00:04:04 who built the prosperous, secure countries that pamper and support them. 0.99
00:04:10 It doesn't take a PhD to understand that Chloe Clark's stated position violated students' right 1.00
00:04:19 of free speech, which we used to think was a core value of higher education. That's now an 0.95
00:04:26 old-fashioned view that hasn't held sway at universities for a long time, and it almost
00:04:32 certainly doesn't matter to Clark or to most of her woke colleagues. Professor Clark would also
00:04:39 not likely care if it were pointed out to her that her commandment against othering is itself
00:04:45 an obvious act of othering against students with conservative, religious, and centrist
00:04:51 viewpoints who already know themselves to be widely despised and demonized in the wider culture.
00:04:58 Obviously, she's fine with silencing and shaming those who have not yet embraced
00:05:04 the principles of her anti-oppressive classroom as a teaching document the professor's words 1.00
00:05:12 showcase her bald anti-intellectualism and her utter inadequacy as a writing teacher because
00:05:20 any decent writing teacher knows that students should be encouraged as they are in debating
00:05:26 societies to experiment in their writing to try on arguments and styles of self-presentation never
00:05:33 with the assumption that the arguments being put forward necessarily reflect the real beliefs of
00:05:39 the author those real beliefs being none of the instructor's business moreover every teacher worth
00:05:47 her salary knows that students should be encouraged to engage empathetically with those who hold
00:05:53 opposing views because only when students can vividly imagine counter arguments to their own
00:06:00 position and can deeply understand the logic of their adversaries, only then can they effectively
00:06:06 defend their beliefs. This teacher though, like most woke teachers today, wants her students
00:06:15 to make monsters out of those she disagrees with. The fact that Iowa State has confirmed that Chloe
00:06:24 clark lacks the power to dismiss students from her classroom for ideological reasons is something of
00:06:31 a relief but not really she's still there probably widely supported by her like-minded colleagues 0.98
00:06:40 she's still an ideological bully anyone who disagrees will be accused of victimizing her and
00:06:47 And by the way, please don't send her an angry email because very soon, I wager, we'll have
00:06:54 to hear about the flood of death threats and rape threats she has allegedly received since
00:07:00 her syllabus went viral. 0.97
00:07:02 She may even have to take a leave of absence, poor thing.
00:07:07 Her conviction of righteous victimhood is a dangerous mindset that must lead us seriously 0.99
00:07:13 to doubt that she can ever grade students fairly or create a politically neutral space
00:07:20 for class discussion and sadly she is one of thousands teaching today
00:07:26 at universities across the english-speaking world