The Fiamengo File - June 01, 2017


When a Divinity School goes SJW - TFF Episode 65

Preview: When a Divinity School Goes SJW - TFF 65 Preview: How To Write A Gender Theory Paper - TFF episode 66

Episode Stats


Length

13 minutes

Words per minute

133.74

Word count

1,807

Sentence count

49

Harmful content

Misogyny

2

sentences flagged

Toxicity

5

sentences flagged

Hate speech

3

sentences flagged


Transcript

Transcript generated with Whisper (turbo).
Misogyny classifications generated with MilaNLProc/bert-base-uncased-ear-misogyny .
Toxicity classifications generated with s-nlp/roberta_toxicity_classifier .
Hate speech classifications generated with facebook/roberta-hate-speech-dynabench-r4-target .
00:00:00 SJWs are often nasty, but SJWs who claim to have God on their side are even worse. 0.98
00:00:08 That's my subject on today's Fiumengo File. 0.97
00:00:20 I'm Janice Fiumengo of the University of Ottawa.
00:00:24 More evidence, as if we needed it, of the university's unchecked slide into social
00:00:29 justice totalitarianism was provided recently with the news that professor paul griffiths
00:00:35 a distinguished theologian at the duke divinity school has been forced to step down after he
00:00:41 objected to his school's racial equity training the swiftness and sheer meanness with which the
00:00:49 dean of his college forced him out is amazing especially considering that she had the chutzpah
00:00:56 to cite christian principles while doing so what happened was as follows on february 6 2017 professor
00:01:05 paul griffiths a specialist in philosophical theology received an email from anathia portier
00:01:13 young a younger colleague of his at the divinity school who specializes in studies of the old
00:01:18 testament with a focus on resistance against oppression the email which was also sent to
00:01:25 all the other faculty members in the school, strongly urged him to participate in a two-day
00:01:30 training session organized by the Faculty Diversity and Inclusion Standing Committee.
00:01:37 The training was called the Racial Equity Institute Phase 1 Training, and it's billed as
00:01:42 the first step in a longer process of working to ensure that DDS, that's the Duke Divinity School,
00:01:49 is an institution that is both equitable and anti-racist, end quote. As a side note, the
00:01:56 Racial Equity Institute has a website that is well worth checking out if you want to see what
00:02:01 Griffiths was objecting to and what the Duke Divinity School was bringing in. It's a program
00:02:06 about equity, significantly, equity, not equality. It's not really about anti-racism, if by that one
00:02:14 means eliminating discrimination based on race. In fact, it advocates discrimination based on race 0.62
00:02:21 in order to pursue what it calls the plan to eliminate racial and ethnic disparities and
00:02:29 produce equitable outcomes. So this program is about creating structures essentially to
00:02:36 mandate the hiring and promotion of non-whites on the belief that any institution in which whites 0.63
00:02:41 dominate must be systemically racist. Now, so back to the email. A lot of non-SJWs receiving 0.64
00:02:50 an invitation to spend two whole days learning about systemic racism would likely grumble to
00:02:56 themselves and hit the delete button, but not so Paul Griffiths. He hit reply all, and later on
00:03:04 that same day, he sent a message back that included the following counter-exhortation.
00:03:11 I exhort you, he said, not to attend this training. Don't lay waste your time by doing so. It'll be,
00:03:18 I predict with confidence, intellectually flaccid. There'll be bromides, cliches, and amen corner
00:03:26 rah-rahs in plenty. When, if it gets beyond that, its illiberal roots and totalitarian tendencies
00:03:34 will show. Events of this sort are definitively anti-intellectual. Retrainings of intellectuals
00:03:41 by bureaucrats and apparatchiks have a long and ignoble history. I hope you'll keep that history
00:03:47 in mind as you think about this instance. Well, what a breath of fresh air. Now, an ordinary
00:03:56 person who had sent out this invitation would perhaps contact Griffiths personally to say,
00:04:02 hey, I'm sorry, you're so hostile to what I think will be a really worthwhile training session,
00:04:07 your loss, or maybe even write that publicly. But SJWs are never like that. They're the only ones
00:04:16 who can loudly resist institutional power and think it their right to do so. So a few hours
00:04:22 after Professor Griffith's email came a response from the dean of the school, Elaine Heath.
00:04:30 Heath is a professor of missional and pastoral theology, and I was fascinated by her bio on the Duke Divinity School homepage, which states that, among many other achievements, Professor Heath is the co-founder of something called the Missional Wisdom Foundation, which provides opportunities for people to, quote, learn how to live in intentional communities.
00:04:55 those are communities that form for a common purpose with shared values, learn how to live
00:05:01 in intentional communities in diverse social contexts, end quote. Well, I guess the old adage
00:05:08 about, you know, those who can do, those who can't teach applies here because Elaine Heath's response
00:05:15 to Paul Griffiths was, to say the least, not of the sort to build community. She started off her
00:05:22 email by saying how much she was looking forward to participating in the racial equity training and
00:05:29 saying how proud she was to be hosting it at the Duke Divinity School and thanking Anathia Portier-Young
00:05:35 for her part in helping to offer it. Then Dean Heath accused her colleague of being the next
00:05:43 thing to Hitler. She said, on another matter, it is certainly appropriate to use mass emails to
00:05:50 share announcements or information that is helpful to the larger community, such as information about
00:05:56 the REI training opportunity. It is inappropriate and unprofessional to use mass emails to make
00:06:02 disparaging statements, including arguments ad hominem, in order to humiliate or undermine
00:06:09 individual colleagues or groups of colleagues with whom we disagree. The use of mass emails
00:06:16 to express racism sexism and other forms of bigotry is offensive and unacceptable especially
00:06:23 in a christian institution end quote i actually have no idea what argument ad hominem which is
00:06:32 personal attack the dean is referring to as she's the only one engaging in that isn't there a
00:06:40 fascinating difference in their respective emails paul griffith attacked the presumed content of the
00:06:47 training program calling it likely intellectually flaccid and cliched and he also attacked the
00:06:53 historical context of such re-education plans but the dean went straight to name-calling
00:07:01 you're a racist now at this point if professor griffith had had any political savvy he would 0.96
00:07:08 have hired a lawyer and proceeded to sue elaine heath's missional ass sorry but that is what 0.98
00:07:17 christian gentleman scholars rarely do and from this point on he was in a battle he couldn't win
00:07:24 the dean of the school and the original sender of the email the old testament scholar of resistance
00:07:30 and oppression commenced a double pronged disciplinary action against professor griffiths
00:07:36 The dean barred him from attending faculty meetings and cut off all his research and travel
00:07:41 funding. At the same time, Anathia Portier-Young brought a charge against Griffiths through the
00:07:47 University's Office for Institutional Equity, saying he had used racist and or sexist speech
00:07:53 to create a hostile workplace. This is a claim so ludicrous that it should have been immediately
00:08:00 dismissed but of course it was taken very seriously and pursued griffith's position on the entire
00:08:08 ruckus was that none of it had anything to do with the life of the mind and spirit to which
00:08:13 professors in a divinity school should be committed regarding his own conduct as he wrote to the
00:08:20 office for institutional equity he had done nothing other than express with as much clarity
00:08:25 force, consistency, and precision as I can argued opinions, and nothing that can reasonably be
00:08:32 considered harassment." End quote. He's right, of course. And of course, being right doesn't help
00:08:42 him, because the moment Anathya Portier-Young decided to involve the Office for Institutional
00:08:48 Equity, she had Griffiths at a perilous disadvantage in a context where a white man
00:08:54 objecting to a female colleague's email about racial equity training must have something wrong
00:09:00 with him the latest news not that surprisingly published in the may 8th issue of the washington
00:09:06 times is that professor griffiths will resign at the end of the 2017-2018 academic year
00:09:15 earlier when i said that elaine heath the dean of the divinity school wrote an email that was
00:09:20 not designed to build community i was oversimplifying it's true her email was not designed
00:09:27 to build the kind of intentional community that paul griffiths thought he belonged to
00:09:32 and was fighting to save a scholarly community built around understanding christianity and all
00:09:39 of its manifestations in both theory and practice elaine heath is creating a different kind of
00:09:46 community one built around the sjw religion and she knew that paul griffiths has no place in that
00:09:55 one her willingness to do everything in her power to force him out gives us a tidy illustration of
00:10:02 what happens when an organization once centered on the christian ideal of knowledge becomes an
00:10:08 organization permeated by the feral spirit of social justice the last point what about the sjw's
00:10:18 who have won this skirmish do you think they feel any compunction for their actions of course not
00:10:26 one of griffith's fellow professors valerie cooper who studies race and religion said that
00:10:33 the university's action didn't violate its commitment to academic freedom.
00:10:38 She said on her Facebook page, quote, being against diversity isn't an issue of academic
00:10:44 freedom. It's academic malpractice. If you can't abide by Duke's policies, you shouldn't work for
00:10:52 Duke. Well, come on, Professor Cooper, you've got to do better than that. It's true that the
00:11:02 divinity school has a diversity statement on its home page a bizarre riff by the way on a well-known
00:11:09 scriptural passage about there being no longer jew or greek no longer slave or free no longer
00:11:19 male and female for all of you are one in christ jesus i'm not a biblical scholar but it seems
00:11:25 pretty clear that this is a statement about oneness, about the spiritual irrelevance of
00:11:32 differences of race, class, or gender. But Professor Cooper is right that the homepage
00:11:38 makes that biblical passage a springboard for its celebration of diversity. Well, so what?
00:11:46 Academic freedom means precisely that professors have the right to debate university policies and 0.99
00:11:52 value statements i'd love to know how valerie cooper would think about the divinity school's 0.91
00:11:59 primary mission stated in the first sentence on its home page which invokes quote service and
00:12:06 witness to the triune god that's the father son and holy spirit this professor cooper believed
00:12:14 that a profession of faith in that god be demanded of for instance the school's muslim professor
00:12:20 abdullah and tepli would she advocate that any professor who fell away from the christian
00:12:26 faith or perhaps developed a unitarian conception of god be forced to step down i really doubt it
00:12:35 but valerie cooper's statement about the kinds of professors welcome at duke
00:12:40 though deficient in basic christian charity is a useful one because it reminds us once again
00:12:49 of the true aims the real bloody-mindedness of the champions of diversity and inclusion
00:12:56 for these people no transgression is too small to be witch-hunted no method is too illiberal
00:13:05 for their use so maybe it's congratulations professor griffiths at least you got out with your soul
00:13:14 Thank you for watching. If you enjoyed this video, please support us on Patreon. If even
00:13:21 half of our subscribers gave us $1 per month, we'd be well on our way to creating more
00:13:26 and better content. And don't forget to subscribe to us on Studio Brulee.