The Fiamengo File - February 11, 2021


White Ribbon Founder Charged With Domestic Violence - TFF Episode 126

Man Forced to Pay Alimony to Ex-Girlfriend - TFF Episode 125 Yeah, A Curfew For Men - The Fiamengo File Episode 127

Episode Stats


Length

10 minutes

Words per minute

132.61

Word count

1,354

Sentence count

48

Harmful content

Toxicity

2

sentences flagged


Transcript

Transcript generated with Whisper (turbo).
Toxicity classifications generated with s-nlp/roberta_toxicity_classifier .
00:00:00 Taking pleasure in the troubles of one's ideological enemies is not something to be
00:00:08 proud of, but it's difficult to suppress at least a small degree of satisfaction in
00:00:14 the news that Andrew O'Keefe, TV host and founder of White Ribbon Australia, has been
00:00:21 charged with domestic violence.
00:00:34 I'm Janice Fiamengo.
00:00:36 Newspapers are reporting that police responded to a complaint of a violent altercation late
00:00:43 on Saturday, January 30, 2021, and charged TV host Andrew O'Keefe early in the morning
00:00:51 of Sunday, January 31, in Sydney, Australia. He is charged with one count of common assault
00:00:58 against his 41-year-old partner, Dr. Orly Lavey. O'Keefe has been a relentlessly self-satisfied
00:01:08 and self-promoting male feminist who has built a very successful career by preening for the camera
00:01:15 as the face of good masculinity, lecturing less good men on how they should conduct themselves.
00:01:23 He has encouraged men to set an example by calling out boorish blokes when they fail to
00:01:29 show appropriate respect for women. He has even recommended that men investigate, whatever that
00:01:35 would mean if they suspect domestic violence is occurring. Here he is on Australian television
00:01:41 spelling out for Channel 7 viewers the twin pillars of white ribbon masculine rectitude.
00:01:49 So the two things that we ask all men to do is A, choose non-violence in your own life. You know,
00:01:57 it's natural that you're going to have disagreements with your partner, but how do you
00:02:01 have those disagreements do you yell scream slam doors bash walls you know hit your partner call
00:02:08 each other terrible names or do you commit that in your own life you're going to work these things
00:02:13 out calmly kindly verbally but if worse comes to worst simply walk away till it all cools down
00:02:20 so in ways like that you can challenge you know abuse in your own life and also challenge the
00:02:26 violent behaviors and attitudes that you see around you by, for example, you know, picking
00:02:31 up your mates when they say something that's really denigrating towards women or calling the
00:02:36 boss out when he's sexually harassing someone in the workplace. You know, making an investigation
00:02:43 when you feel that someone may be abusing their partner. Now that is a man aglow with self-love.
00:02:52 O'Keeffe was co-founder and past chairman of White Ribbon Australia, a feminist organization
00:02:59 that defines domestic violence as male violence against women, essentially recognizing no other
00:03:06 kind. In 2017, a White Ribbon blog post about the Me Too movement explained to men in no uncertain
00:03:15 terms how they should respond online and in person to the mass accusations then occurring.
00:03:23 Number one on the white ribbon list was, quote, believe survivors' experiences, end quote. 0.98
00:03:32 And damn anyone who expressed skepticism. Men were told to, quote, support survivors by doing the hard 0.96
00:03:39 emotional labor of blocking, reporting, or engaging with hateful, misogynistic comments, end quote.
00:03:48 O'Keefe had for years been doing that hard emotional labor quite enthusiastically in his
00:03:54 role as presenter on Channel 7's Weekend Sunrise News program, a role he occupied until 2017.
00:04:02 In this capacity, he famously chastised Cassie Jay for daring to interview men's rights activists respectfully for her red pill documentary about men's rights activism.
00:04:16 O'Keefe had already tried and failed to smear Paul Elam some three years previously during an aggressive interview.
00:04:24 So with Jay, he contented himself by declaring Elam a misogynist and lecturing Jay about how concerning it was that her movie showed men's rights activists speaking for men, when we all know that only feminists should be allowed to speak for men.
00:04:42 He didn't quite say it that way, and here he is in all his disingenuous, lip-smacking virtue-signaling smarm.
00:04:51 Well, I mean, we've done a lot of reading around Paul Elam over the years.
00:04:54 In fact, we've interviewed Paul Elam.
00:04:56 And there's no denying that a lot of what he says is deeply misogynist.
00:05:00 My concern, Cassie, is that in setting up these guys as the spokesmen for the issues that men face,
00:05:11 we promote an opposition between men and feminism that's counterproductive to the genders working together to solve everyone's problems.
00:05:20 I almost forgot to mention that the most astounding thing about this interview was the fact that
00:05:26 neither of the hosts had actually seen the movie they were denouncing. O'Keeffe's non-stop
00:05:34 self-promotion as a feminist role model makes it difficult, to say the least, to fully empathize
00:05:40 with him now. In 2016, he authored an article called Why We Need White Ribbon in which he
00:05:48 he dispensed gems of profundity about gender equality and respect, at one point waxing eloquent
00:05:55 about the injustice of a world in which his daughter was allegedly not as safe as his two
00:06:01 sons. He asked, quote, why should any person be robbed of their health or their dignity or their
00:06:09 self-esteem or their kids or their life just because of the lottery of their gender, end quote.
00:06:16 He seemed genuinely not to realize, or just didn't care, that throughout history and today,
00:06:23 men are far more likely than women to lose their lives violently, with Australian men,
00:06:29 for example, making up 70% of all homicides. He also seemed unaware that men are far more
00:06:36 likely than women to be robbed through a false accusation or the simple machinery of divorce
00:06:42 of their health, their dignity, their self-esteem, and their kids.
00:06:48 So now O'Keefe has himself been accused and, not surprisingly, is getting no support at all
00:06:54 from his former employer, Channel 7, which has simply announced that he's no longer employed
00:06:59 there, or from White Ribbon Australia, which has quickly disavowed him and posted a statement
00:07:07 assuming his guilt. After mentioning that O'Keefe hasn't been involved with White Ribbon for some
00:07:13 time, the organization couldn't resist commenting on the allegation against him, saying, quote,
00:07:21 we stand in solidarity with every victim and survivor of men's violence against women
00:07:27 and believe men who use violence must be held to account, end quote. The organization even had the
00:07:37 Gaul to advise all men to use the incident of O'Keeffe's fall from grace as an opportunity
00:07:44 for penitential self-examination, saying, quote, every man should take this occurrence as an
00:07:50 opportunity to reflect on their own attitudes, behaviors, and relationships with the women in
00:07:57 their lives, end quote. So much for the presumption of innocence. Wow. O'Keeffe had better hope that
00:08:06 those who preside at his trial will not have read white ribbon literature about believing survivors
00:08:12 and condemning those who would blame them. He's already coming out swinging, so to speak, in his
00:08:19 own defense, alleging through his lawyer that he was, quote, not the aggressor in the Saturday
00:08:24 night incident. Just a few weeks ago, he would almost certainly have jeered in disbelief at the
00:08:33 idea of a woman physically attacking a man or being an equal participant in an emotion-fueled,
00:08:40 perhaps alcohol-fueled, row. I don't claim to know what actually happened on the night in question
00:08:48 or what the incident says, if anything, about O'Keeffe's years-long feminist activism. I'm not
00:08:55 that inclined to the theory, though it is an interesting one, that men adopt a feminist
00:09:00 identity as a cover for or in response to their own misogyny or abusiveness. The charge against
00:09:08 O'Keeffe is in my opinion simply proof that an allegation can happen to anyone and indeed that
00:09:14 most of us at one time or another have done things that under current definitions could be considered
00:09:20 domestic abuse. I certainly have. O'Keeffe is undoubtedly a privileged person not because of
00:09:28 lottery of his gender but because he is a wealthy powerfully connected member of australia's media
00:09:35 elite a former lawyer and the son of a new south wales supreme court judge so he'll be able to pay
00:09:42 whatever is needed to defend himself which many men can't i doubt this incident will convert him
00:09:49 to men's rights activism or even cause him to develop real understanding of men's position
00:09:56 in our man-blaming society. But he is experiencing, perhaps for the first time,
00:10:03 the loneliness of the accused man. And given his past record,
00:10:08 that couldn't have happened to a more deserving guy.