The Fiamengo File - August 13, 2015


Why I Am An Anti-Feminist - The Fiamengo File, Episode 1

The Fiamengo File Trailer Roosh V - The Fiamengo File, Episode 2

Episode Stats


Length

11 minutes

Words per minute

136.18

Word count

1,590

Sentence count

52


Transcript

Transcript generated with Whisper (turbo).
00:00:00 I'm Janice Piumingo. I'm a professor of English at the University of Ottawa and I'm an anti-feminist.
00:00:10 Many people don't like that term anti-feminist because it is adversarial and because feminists
00:00:17 have been hugely successful in equating feminism with support for women's equality. So to say you
00:00:24 anti-feminist seems to suggest that you are opposed to women's equality. But if feminism
00:00:30 ever was about equality, and that's an interesting subject for another video,
00:00:35 it emphatically no longer is. In the 21st century, feminism is about special privileges
00:00:41 and advantages for women, and special exemptions from responsibility. So I am happy to claim the
00:00:50 badge of anti-feminism because I object to an ideology and a practice that sets one standard
00:00:57 for women, supposedly because they are victims, and one harshly punitive standard for men,
00:01:03 supposedly because they are privileged. All fair-minded people should object to unjust
00:01:10 double standards. The dishonesty and hypocrisy of the feminist movement deserve to be exposed
00:01:17 and denounced every day. Three things concern me most about modern-day feminism on university
00:01:26 campuses, and they are going to be the general focus of my presentations. My first concern
00:01:32 is the irrationality that has overtaken academic feminism. It promotes the idea that women's
00:01:40 feelings are more important than objective reality or the search for truth. Claiming
00:01:46 victimhood now trumps fact, argument, and debate. According to the feminist worldview, women must
00:01:53 never be made to feel unsafe, not just physically, but emotionally and psychologically. They must
00:02:00 never be triggered, as the saying goes, reminded of trauma, or made to think about things that
00:02:06 challenge their view of themselves as permanently innocent victims. In the feminist world, women are
00:02:13 always to be believed, always deferred to, always spoken of in hushed tones of deep sympathy.
00:02:21 Although the idea of protecting women sounds benign, if a bit silly, it has become a potent
00:02:27 weapon to intimidate anyone who fails to toe the party line on a wide range of subjects,
00:02:34 including abortion, gender difference, boys' education, the criminal justice system,
00:02:39 family law and so on. When I tried to give a talk at the University of Ottawa in March of last year
00:02:46 on the presumed rape culture of university campuses, not to deny that rape exists or to say
00:02:53 that we shouldn't care about rape victims, but to argue that it is a paranoid fantasy to pretend
00:02:59 that our culture condones rape, a group of students took it upon themselves to prevent me
00:03:05 from speaking by blowing horns and banging drums and singing the Communist Internationale.
00:03:11 Why? Well, because these students believed they had the right to silence me, because what I had
00:03:16 to say, though I never got to say it, created an unsafe space for women by denying a bedrock
00:03:22 belief of feminism. If that kind of craziness in the name of protecting women sounds like a weird,
00:03:29 isolated phenomenon, unfortunately it isn't. It exists on campuses all across North America
00:03:36 and it is fast making it nearly impossible for anyone to challenge any facet of feminist dogma
00:03:43 and that's a big problem for academic debate. My second concern, which is related to the absurd
00:03:50 worry about the feelings of women, is the near total disregard for the concerns and experiences
00:03:58 of male students. Men at university are told in no uncertain terms that they are uniquely
00:04:04 guilty, prone to violence, and responsible for war, inequality, rape, domestic violence,
00:04:13 pedophilia, sexual harassment, heteropatriarchal capitalistic domination, and all that is wrong
00:04:21 in society. A young man entering university today soon learns that he's a second-class citizen in
00:04:28 terms of rights, financial aid, freedom of inquiry, and social support. His female colleagues enter a
00:04:36 pro-woman campus culture where they see positive images of women in everything from advertising
00:04:42 campaigns to course textbooks, where they outnumber their male peers by a significant margin,
00:04:49 are taught by pro-feminist teachers dedicated to female success are provided with women-only
00:04:56 spaces to meet can take advantage of a plethora of special scholarships and bursaries for female
00:05:03 students can access feminist counseling if they so desire are encouraged to learn about and to
00:05:09 write papers on women's achievements and women's issues are instructed in righteous indignation
00:05:15 against the wrongs done to women throughout history, can take self-defense classes designed
00:05:21 specially for women, are given the opportunity to celebrate female sexuality in campus productions
00:05:28 like the Vagina Monologues, and in a multitude of other ways, are told that their experiences
00:05:35 and concerns matter at the university. A young man, on the other hand, has a very different
00:05:42 experience. He will likely attend a mandatory gender sensitivity and anti-violence workshop
00:05:50 at the beginning of his first year, where he will be lectured about his propensity for sexual
00:05:57 predation. Especially if he is studying in the humanities or social sciences, he faces the
00:06:03 prospect of having most or even all of his classes taught from a perspective that denigrates
00:06:09 the actions and achievements of men. Some or many of his teachers may believe that men too often
00:06:16 dominate class discussions and should be discouraged from setting a competitive or
00:06:21 adversarial tone. Particularly if the young man challenges the feminist party line, he will often
00:06:27 be told that his maleness prevents him from fully understanding certain issues or even from having
00:06:35 the right to speak about them. Women, on the other hand, are never told that their femaleness
00:06:40 prevents them from understanding or voicing an opinion on issues. A young man will learn that
00:06:47 if he wants to be allowed to speak without harsh criticism, he will need to preface many of his
00:06:53 comments with an apologetic admission of his male privilege. He will learn that there are women-only
00:07:00 spaces where he must not intrude, and female sensitivities that he must not offend. If he
00:07:06 wishes to write a paper about men's perspectives or problems, it is unlikely that he will be
00:07:11 encouraged to do so, or will encounter an instructor who knows anything about the topic
00:07:16 or even believes in its legitimacy. Although men are a minority, in many of the courses at
00:07:23 university he will not find any special scholarships or bursaries to redress the gender imbalance.
00:07:30 If he tries to form a men's issues club or wishes to meet with other men in a male-only space
00:07:36 to discuss his experiences as a man, he will be told that he is a misogynist,
00:07:41 that his very presence on campus is a threat to women,
00:07:45 and that the final word on gender has already been determined by feminists,
00:07:50 and that he should shut up and listen to women's accounts and demands.
00:07:56 Hearing such a summation, you might be inclined to think that I'm exaggerating,
00:08:01 and it is true that not every man will claim the above as his experience,
00:08:05 but the structural inequities that I have identified are a demonstrable reality.
00:08:11 It's not a great environment for a young man.
00:08:14 Now, my third concern is that as a result of the oversensitivity to women's feelings
00:08:21 and the knee-jerk hostility or at least indifference to men's, a host of asymmetrical
00:08:27 and unjust policies and practices have been put in place on university campuses, many of which
00:08:34 not only sideline men and restrict their right to self-expression, but actually threaten their
00:08:40 well-being and livelihoods in profound ways. Most shockingly, perhaps, a zero-tolerance policy
00:08:48 for what is called sexual misconduct of even very trivial kinds, like a crude Facebook post or a
00:08:56 sexual joke, and a manic expansion of the understanding of what constitutes rape, now
00:09:03 result in much public breast-beating about male violence and harsh retribution against individual
00:09:10 male students. Young men who engage in what they thought was consensual sex confide themselves
00:09:18 accused of rape because of stringent and bizarre new affirmative consent policies.
00:09:26 Instead of letting the police and courts deal with such accusations as they should,
00:09:31 most universities have now set up quasi-judicial panels to investigate charges of sexual assault
00:09:37 or harassment. The panels are made up of members of the university community with no legal training.
00:09:46 The accused is routinely denied the right to counsel,
00:09:49 the right to know what evidence has been brought against him,
00:09:52 the right to confront his accuser, and other fundamental legal guarantees.
00:09:58 And the panels have serious power.
00:10:01 Men face expulsion, a permanent blot on their academic records,
00:10:05 an indelible stain on their reputations, and in many cases, the death of their career dreams.
00:10:12 It's almost inconceivable that this is happening now
00:10:16 in a culture that once prided itself on such principles
00:10:20 as equality before the law and the presumption of innocence.
00:10:25 In the name of making the university a safe space,
00:10:30 we are absolving women of responsibility for their actions
00:10:34 and severely compromising the legal rights and freedoms of men.
00:10:41 What a far cry from the individual and sexual liberation claimed by the student radicals of
00:10:49 the 60s. Where it will all end is anybody's guess, but it is clear that the feminist agenda
00:10:56 is incompatible with the academic ideal of truth and the social ideal of justice for all.
00:11:04 the obsession on campuses with female trauma and male aggression the constant harping on the need
00:11:12 to promote women salve their wounds and make up to them for the supposed evils of the past and
00:11:18 present all of these have almost nothing to do with the pursuit of knowledge and are not only
00:11:25 a distraction from that pursuit but are actually a serious impediment to it it is time that people
00:11:32 of good conscience took a stand against this corruption of our universities.