Gorsuch, Durbin, and Kelly Shackelford. Glenn Beck breaks it all down and explains why he thinks we should have a Supreme Court Justice with a conservative mind. He also talks about the latest in the Trump administration on immigration and health care.
00:01:25.180It is a radical promise in the history of mankind.
00:01:30.300Does that refer to sexual orientation as well?
00:01:32.560Senator, the Supreme Court of the United States has held that single-sex marriage is protected by the Constitution.
00:01:40.140Judge, would you agree that if an employer were to ask female job applicants about their family plans, but not male applicants, that would be evidence of sex discrimination prohibited by Title VII of the Civil Rights Act?
00:02:01.620Senator, it sounds like a potential hypothetical case.
00:02:04.840It might be a case or controversy I might have to decide, and I wouldn't want to prejudge it sitting here at the confirmation table.
00:02:10.780I can tell you it would be inappropriate.
00:02:12.580Do you believe that there are ever situations where the cost to an employer of maternity to leave can justify an employer asking only female applicants and not male applicants about family plans?
00:02:24.920Senator, those are not my words, and I would never have said them.
00:02:32.200Would you ask your students in class that day to raise their hands if they knew of a woman who had taken maternity benefits from a company and then left the company after having a baby?
00:02:45.180Because the first I heard of this was the night before my confirmation hearing.
00:02:49.300And we talk about the pros and the cons in a Socratic dialogue so that they can think through for themselves how they might answer that very difficult question.
00:02:58.280And, Senator, I do ask for a show of hands, not about the question you asked, but about the following question.
00:04:47.000They see what a, you know, humble, very bright.
00:04:50.760They see a judge who's going to restrain himself, who doesn't want to take over power, who doesn't want to be the legislature, who simply wants to do his darndest, to follow the law.
00:05:02.480And that's what we're looking for in our judges.
00:05:04.040So I think it's a home run, and I just wonder how long they're going to keep this show going before they realize, you know, this is really not getting us anywhere.
00:05:13.560Kelly Shackelford runs a religious law watchdog group and has done some amazing things.
00:05:21.040Currently, you can go to TrumpNominee.com and get all of the information on what's happening at the hearings.
00:05:28.460You can get the live coverage and commentary along the way.
00:05:33.040If you want to know everything you need to know about this nominee, go to TrumpNominee.com.
00:05:38.740Kelly, as they were hitting him, and I thought he responded perfectly and reasonably every single time, he's got another 11 hours to go today, does he not?
00:06:09.800I really feel like, Glenn, what they're doing is these are Democrats that are sort of going through some motions to make their base happy because they really know this is not going to get them anywhere.
00:06:22.240But it's one of those things when you go for such an extreme base, when most of the country looks at this guy and goes, oh, this is the kind of guy we want to be a judge.
00:06:34.800I mean, even the ABA gave him their highest rating.
00:06:38.680That just shows that I don't care who the nominee would be, this would be happening.
00:06:44.620And it really is sort of blowing their credibility for the next one, in my opinion, because if they're against Gorsuch, they're going to be against anybody Trump picks, no matter really what perspective they come from.
00:06:55.300It's really, I would imagine that it bothers anybody who plays politics as a game that Trump had done the whole Fox News, Russia's definitely spying on us through England.
00:07:15.620Because really, the first day and a half of this testimony was eaten up and overshadowed by that.
00:07:24.280This is really good for the conservatives to see.
00:07:28.600And I'm not sure this is the thing that everybody's talking about.
00:08:27.340I mean, I think it'll be in time to hear arguments in late April, which there are some big cases to be heard in late April.
00:08:33.800So I think he's going to be on the court to decide this travel ban issue, I bet, when it arises as well.
00:08:41.680So I think he's going to be on quickly and absent some shocker today, which, again, watching him and how he did yesterday,
00:08:50.860I think it's very unlikely that any shocker is going to occur.
00:08:53.660Kelly, can you give me the strongest argument against the travel ban?
00:09:00.540Well, I mean, I don't find a lot of strong arguments against it because of the separation of powers issues.
00:09:08.100I mean, this is this is a power that the president has.
00:09:11.040And you have additionally a congressional statute where Congress said we want the president to have this power.
00:09:17.760So it's like, you know, you've got two of the three branches of government that really have this power.
00:09:23.500And then you've got the courts coming in to think they can take take it over.
00:09:26.640It's just not a power that they have to do that.
00:09:29.020The arguments they're making are I mean, one of the main arguments is that these people are being banned solely because of their religion.
00:09:36.400Well, that's not what the order says. And so what they're doing is they're going back and looking at what candidate Trump said.
00:09:43.740And they're using that to say, well, that's really his purpose. That's really his motivation.
00:09:48.260And again, that's not the type of thing that good judges do.
00:09:51.420Good judges don't don't go back and try to recreate what they think the motivation of the president of the United States is when it's in writing exactly what he's doing and why.
00:10:02.300So I just I think the ultimate problem is going to be the the Constitution and where this power resides to make these decisions.
00:10:11.260And I think there's tremendous deference has to be given to the president when you have both the presidential power and the congressional power in his side.
00:24:53.980Nobody's going to think of this until we are right up on top of it.
00:24:58.420And I think what's going to happen is the same thing that is happened that was predicted by not Orwell, but the other one for Brave New World.
00:29:21.020Are you going to, you know, a boss or an army, a military guy, a president who won't enhance when everyone else in the world, all other militaries are enhanced?
00:29:37.820They're going to do the same thing that they're going to do the same thing that they're doing with the NSA.
00:29:41.320We have to monitor all of these things because everyone else is.
00:37:53.820If I were a Republican, I wouldn't know how to vote.
00:37:58.660Because Donald Trump was elected by two groups of people.
00:38:04.260He was, when it comes to health care and everything for everybody, those who wanted Obamacare gone, they voted for Donald Trump.
00:38:15.740Those people who wanted single-payer universal health care, they voted for Donald Trump because they both believed he was going to provide both of those things.
00:40:06.000But, Congressman, the other thing is the Republicans, the GOP yesterday, just tweaked the provision to crack down on illegal immigrants getting this health care coverage, right?
00:40:20.340They took that provision out of the bill.
00:40:23.020So they've even done more than the Democrats kind of did with this particular thing because the Democrats kept telling us,
00:40:32.140no, illegal aliens will not be a part of this.
00:40:34.440And now, as they tried to stop that from happening, it was taken out.
00:40:39.240Well, they made another small tweak that when people find out about it are not going to be happy,
00:40:43.900which is if you're a veteran and you could go to the VA, but you don't go to the VA,
00:40:51.620the tweak they made last night says you can't get the health care subsidies that everybody else gets when they go into the individual market.
00:47:10.920I think I just think he's getting bad advice on this one.
00:47:14.400And the fallout is going to be interesting because I also think he's being misled by Paul Ryan about how many votes there are to pass this thing.
00:47:24.360And maybe he'll come to realize that taking advice from Paul Ryan wasn't the best way, the best thing to kick off his president.
00:47:31.800I just can't believe, and I don't know how his supporters are going to shake out,
00:47:35.880but I can't believe that Paul Ryan, who was, you know, cancer before the election, he was cancer.
00:47:43.560Every conservative, every Republican is like, got to get rid of Paul Ryan,
00:47:46.780that he somehow or another is the savior that everybody is listening to and, you know, is shouting praises for with Donald Trump.
00:47:56.980And I don't know how it's going to shake out because Donald Trump did say he was going to make sure everybody got covered.
00:48:03.140You want it to go the opposite way than what he does.
00:48:07.840This is this awful middle ground that we're negotiating.
00:48:11.960But I don't know how his voters are going to handle it because half of his people wanted, you know,
00:48:19.160Paul Ryan and everybody out and half of his people wanted more health care from the government.
00:48:27.140Well, maybe the maybe the silver lining in this is that when Trump moves on to tax reform or immigration,
00:48:34.840these promised or taking care of the veterans, he will listen to somebody other than Paul Ryan after Paul Ryan drags him through this debacle.
00:48:42.980And hopefully the American people don't get drug through it.
00:48:46.400Hopefully this bill fails and they don't have to be subject subjected to this experiment.
00:48:52.100And in Donald Trump, listening to the swamp and coming up with policy,
00:48:57.140hopefully he'll listen to those voices from the outside like he did so well with Neil Gorsuch.
00:49:03.600I will tell you that the stock market priced in.
00:49:52.000If you go back and look at how the Democrats implemented Obamacare, they did a reconciliation bill literally a week after they did Obamacare so that they could fix it.
00:50:02.680And they included student loans in that.
00:50:05.360You can put whatever you want in reconciliation.
00:50:08.320You can double up and put more than one thing in it.
00:50:10.660It doesn't have to be health care in this reconciliation bill.
00:50:38.700It's called the walk of shame here in Congress.
00:50:41.020When somebody votes one way and then before the vote closes, they twist their arm and get them to walk down to the counter and turn in a different voting card.
00:50:50.960Hopefully we won't see too many conservatives take that walk of shame.
00:51:38.200It would be ironic if he joins the swamp creatures and goes after conservatives back in their districts.
00:51:44.360But I don't think that's going to happen.
00:51:45.820I think when this is all said and done, he may be more upset with Rince Priebus and Paul Ryan than he is with the people that supported him in his election, frankly.
00:51:59.580Now, this getting to the right mortgage, whether you're buying or refinancing, is far too important to leave to an amateur or to leave to somebody who is taking money, gets kickbacks from the bank.
00:52:12.620You need a salary-based mortgage consultant that is dedicated to make your smartest mortgage decisions that you possibly can that all align with your unique financial goals, whatever they might be.
00:52:28.520That's what you will get at American Financing.
00:54:38.200And then it would come back, roaring back to where she couldn't function.
00:54:44.460And I said, honey, first thing you have to do, first thing Monday, you've got to go to the dentist and just check, see if it's a toothache.
00:54:53.420And so she went to the dentist, and the dentist said, you're fine, just take some ibuprofen and watch it for a few days.
00:55:30.560By 6 o'clock on Friday night, she was sitting in a neurologist's office getting a diagnosis.
00:55:40.240And I have to tell you, if I were in Canada, I sat in that office, and I actually said a prayer, thank you, thank you, Lord, for having us here in America.
00:58:33.700One of the criteria used to arrive at that conclusion is the percentage of women in the Rwandan legislature.
00:58:41.040According to WEF, 64% of the seats in the Rwandan parliament are occupied by women.
00:58:48.880Just a side note, after the Rwandan genocide, 70% of their population was women.
00:58:54.860And so it seems to go to reason that it would.
00:58:58.020Anyway, one of the reasons the U.S. is listed as low as it is, is the ever-present income inequality argument.
00:59:05.820As we have discussed over and over, including by the liberal newspaper, The Washington Post,
00:59:12.360there are many extenuating factors that go into why, overall, men earn more money than women.
00:59:19.200To name a few, different professional choices, maternity leave, length of time in the job market, and a whole lot more.
00:59:25.520But boil down, when you compare men and women with similar education levels, similar job experience, length of time in a particular job, and skill levels,
00:59:35.600in other words, when comparing apples to apples, in America, men and women make virtually the same amount of money.
00:59:42.400In fact, in some industries, when those factors are considered, women's actual average income is slightly more than men.
00:59:52.460In 2010, Time magazine reported that there was 147 of the 150 biggest cities in the country,
00:59:59.800and the median full-time salaries of young single women were higher than their male peers, by 8%.
01:00:07.400Another criteria used to rate the United States lower than you might think it should be in the quality of life for women
01:00:14.640is the participation rate for women in the job force, because it's stagnant.
01:00:20.400Is there a definitive explanation for that?
01:04:35.940Severe human rights violations directed against women all over the Middle East, Africa, Asia, and other parts of the world,
01:04:44.160and virtually no one seems to focus on it.
01:04:47.340Meanwhile, in the United States, the so-called war often involves whether or not free birth control devices are available on every street corner.
01:04:56.020One told us of how embarrassed and just powerless she felt when she was standing at the pharmacy counter
01:05:03.940and learned for the first time that contraception was not covered on her insurance,
01:05:08.360and she had to turn and walk away because she couldn't afford that prescription.
01:05:13.780Women like her have no choice but to go without contraception.
01:05:18.000Just last week, a married female student told me that she had to stop using contraception
01:05:23.300because she and her husband just couldn't fit it into their budget anymore.
01:05:28.700Perspective should be the word of the year.
01:25:35.440Because at Westboro, we would include these elaborate insults when we responded to questions that people sent us by email.
01:25:41.580But on Twitter, there just wasn't space for it.
01:25:44.880And also, Twitter was just this immediate feedback loop.
01:25:48.140If I did insult somebody, I could watch the conversation just derail in real time.
01:25:53.620I could see that I wasn't getting my point across because I was too busy indulging that vengeful little voice in my head that wanted to call people names.
01:26:01.640And I feel like, I mean, we all have this feedback loop.
01:26:04.620Megan, I will tell you, I've been doing these kinds of experiments myself over the last couple of years where I've gotten in because I just stopped engaging for a while.
01:26:15.200And about two years ago, I decided, you know what, I'm just going to answer everybody and assume the best.
01:26:20.800And just answer the worst with something kind and try to be humble and kind and nice to everybody.
01:26:56.100Man, I just disagree so, so much with the idea of hopelessness when it comes to talking to people.
01:27:03.260I had grown up, you know, basically cultivating this mindset of us versus them, being wary, like specifically being wary of people's kindness.
01:27:15.920And even though I consciously was aware and trying not to be persuaded by kindness, it was still a powerful thing.
01:27:25.040And it's really interesting because over the past few years I've been, you know, thinking about this a lot, obviously, because it's only been four years since I left.
01:27:33.700So it's kind of just this huge, you know, huge event in my life.
01:27:38.520And what you're describing there about, you know, assuming the best and, you know, changing the way you respond.
01:27:45.360So if somebody comes at you angry and you respond in kindness and humility, that's called, like, non-complementary behavior.
01:27:51.740And we are, as human beings, we're wired to respond in kind.
01:27:56.920But like you said, it's incredibly difficult to do.
01:27:59.300But we can cultivate a more useful mindset.
01:28:02.920Like, one thing you said, well, my mom used to tell me that to make sure my behavior was appropriate, I should add the word judge onto the end of my sentence.
01:28:34.920I want to get to, you say there are four steps, and I want to get to those here in a second.
01:28:38.040Let me just ask you one more question, and then I have to take a quick break.
01:28:40.460Do you, are you well aware of how appropriately timed your discovery and your story is for the rest of the world?
01:28:53.660I just, I hope that, I hope that I can be a voice or that the story can be something that will help other people see the value in engaging.
01:29:04.620Because, honestly, my experience has given me so much hope.
01:30:50.140So, the company saved a ton of money, which I want to thank John for doing, and he gets the reward because I only paid $500 for something that would have cost me over $1,000 easy.
01:31:02.520And he's got the Amazon gift card that he can go spend any way he wants.
01:33:52.460I think that very few, maybe sociopaths or psychopaths or, you know, people, and even them, like people who are deliberately doing wrong, I think they're very, very, very few and far beneath.
01:34:14.460And you stop asking questions to get to the bottom of it, which is the second point, is that asking questions helps you bridge the gap between your point of view and theirs.
01:34:26.120It helps you understand where they're coming from actually.
01:34:29.360And it also signals to the people that you're talking to that you're actually listening to them.
01:34:34.480And that is a huge benefit to the dialogue because they no longer, they're not yet, they don't want to yell at you.
01:34:49.120And it matters that they're honest questions, not set up questions, not a question where I know you're going to say one thing so I can give you the scripture quote or whatever to beat you.
01:35:32.480Megan Phelps Roper, somebody that we saw on TED Talk, giving a great TED Talk on how to bring people together.
01:35:39.580She was in the, she's a Phelps, so she was part of the founding family of the Westboro Baptist Church.
01:35:47.280And she got online and started making friends with people who were friendly to her, not just yelling at her all the time.
01:35:56.760And she said there are four things that if you really want to change people's minds, four ways of engaging people so that real conversations can take place.
01:36:06.480The first one is don't assume bad intent.
01:36:08.840Instead, assume good or neutral intent.
01:36:12.340The second, ask questions as opposed to accusing.
01:36:30.400So this one is really difficult because the natural inclination is always to respond the way that somebody is speaking to you.
01:36:40.400So when somebody comes at you with hostility, the instinct is to be defensive and to respond with hostility.
01:36:46.180But that just brings the conversation to an end quickly.
01:36:50.680But if you can learn to step back, calm down, and try to diffuse the anger, and you can do it within a few ways.
01:37:03.400There are people who just, so for instance, I actually ended up marrying, my husband was one of these Twitter friends who started out as this angry, sort of insulting effort.
01:37:21.720But so what he would do, for instance, he would tell a joke or recommend a book or start talking about music.
01:37:28.400He would sort of turn away from the hostility for a minute and then come back to it later.
01:37:35.600You don't necessarily, I mean, that can be a last resort.
01:37:39.880A lot of times, just staying calm and speaking as if you're addressing a friend and not somebody that you hate and that you despise, that you can't stand to hear their words.
01:37:50.960It helps so much to keep the conversation going.
01:38:01.940And this one seems obvious, but there's this argument that seems to have taken hold on both the left and the right, and I think it stems from the hopelessness you mentioned earlier.
01:38:18.320It leaves us at loggerheads, deadlocked, and no one wants to be there.
01:38:23.220So, you make the argument because they don't understand, your opponent doesn't necessarily understand your thinking and the way that you're approaching the problem.
01:38:34.420And by making the argument, if you fail to do that, you're definitely not going to change someone's mind.
01:38:39.780You actually have to articulate the reasoning and the thought process behind your position.
01:38:45.560And there's actually a fifth point that I would have included if I had enough time.
01:40:16.080Well, it's a really strange dynamic, because obviously, I was at the church, and at Westboro, you could only marry somebody who's in the church.
01:40:26.180So, we were having these discussions, and there was nothing, it was like a Jane Austen novel, like nothing overt.
01:40:31.860Like, we couldn't say how we were feeling to each other, because it just wasn't acceptable.
01:40:36.840And he sensed that, but he also, again, saw that I was a human being,
01:40:43.160and he came to believe that I had a good heart.
01:40:46.560So, would this have worked without love?
01:40:52.560Well, I think, well, so here's the thing.
01:42:08.900So, of course, we used, you know, the verses in Leviticus and then also in Romans 1 that talk about how, you know, gays are worthy of death.
01:42:15.840And he brought up, so he's Jewish, I was really surprised that he brought up Jesus saying, let he who is without sin cast the first stone.
01:42:24.760And I didn't, I just had never connected that that was talking about the death penalty.
01:42:29.240And we thought, we're not casting stones.
01:42:35.980And David said, yeah, but you're advocating that the government cast stones.
01:42:40.600And so that, when I brought that point to other members of the church, the response was just to double down.
01:42:46.280They never addressed the passage that, you know, that contradicted us.
01:42:50.920They just reiterated the passages that supported us.
01:42:53.220And so that was the first time that, and the way that I reconciled it in my own mind was I just stopped holding the sign because I didn't know how to defend it anymore.
01:43:03.380Did they tell you to stop talking to these people?
01:43:07.260Uh, there, I don't think, I don't think people quite realized how much, I mean, they knew I was very active on Twitter, but I don't think they realized how much it was affecting the way that I was thinking.
01:43:19.340And I honestly didn't, I didn't understand it either, because in my mind, I was sort of in, I think I was in denial about it, because I, I, the church, at the church, you're, you, you are not supposed to be impacted by other people.
01:43:34.260You're, you are not supposed to be anything but preaching to them.
01:43:38.240You're not supposed to really, you know, care, I was going to say care about them.
01:43:42.840It's, it's a very strange dynamic, but I was, I was in denial about it, and I think that definitely helped it seem to others as if it wasn't really having an impact on me also.
01:43:52.880Is anybody in your family speaking with you?
01:43:55.520Do you have a relationship with anybody anymore in the family?
01:44:01.240No, but there, there has been, over the last decade or so, um, about 20 or so people who have either left or been kicked out of Westboro, and my brother actually, with the morning of my high school graduation, he's a year and a half older than me, we woke up and went down, went downstairs, and all of his stuff was gone.
01:44:21.060And so I have, I didn't get to speak with him for the eight and a half years between when he left and when I left, um, but now we're really good friends, and he's wonderful.
01:44:37.060Yeah, at 19, yeah, he, he also had, yeah, scriptural objections, um, to some things, and also just the extreme, he objected to the extreme level of control, because everybody in the church, we, we all live within, lived within two blocks or so of one another, and did everything together, and, and we're, you know, not, obviously, developing relationships with people outside, but the level of control is, is really, really, really extreme.
01:45:04.420Do they, um, um, do you think this will just die out as the family dies out, or?
01:45:11.120I, I'm actually, I thought about this, my sister and I would talk about this, about how could the church end in a way that didn't just destroy everybody, you know, on the, on the inside.
01:45:22.060Um, there, there's still about the same level of membership as there has been, because, you know, a few people, a few new converts have joined, and then, of course, my generation is now, uh, they're having kids.
01:45:34.420It's, but there's, there's not many, um, I do.
01:45:39.040How do, what kind of people join, what kind of people join this?
01:45:52.160Yeah, so, honestly, I've, I've speculated about this, too.
01:45:56.500So, I mean, so, for instance, my dad, my dad joined the church long before the picketing started.
01:46:00.240He was only 16 at the time, and, you know, his family wasn't, uh, I mean, his mom had been divorced, and I don't think he, he was attracted to the, the love and unity and connection, um, I think, in my family, um, in the Phelps family, I mean.
01:46:17.340And, and I think that's a draw for some people, and, and it really lends credence to the idea that they're doing what they're doing out of love, out of, you know, good intentions.
01:46:27.120Um, and again, some people just, I think, are drawn to that, the sense of, the idea of having all the answers, and knowing for sure what you believe, and how you're supposed to live.
01:46:41.740Like, it's, that was such a powerful thing, and when, when I left and realized, like, I, I don't, I don't have that anymore.
01:46:48.620I, I don't have that sense of, it's a very comforting sense of certainty, and, you know, nuance, and questions, and, and uncertainty are, are a lot more difficult to deal with.
01:47:01.080I think some people are attracted to that part of the church.
01:47:03.120Next time they're out protesting, what should people do?
01:47:05.760I think engaging at protests is actually not a very effective thing, because they're, on, on ticket lines, they are already in these attack, defend mindsets.
01:47:18.760I think, I think the internet is a much, you know, Twitter, there's a lot of them on Twitter now.
01:47:23.800Um, I think that's a more, more effective way of engaging.
01:47:26.660But, if you, if you do see them, and if you are moved to go and speak to them, just remember that, that responding with, you know, yelling and name calling, all those things, it, it, it just reinforces what they already believe.
01:47:42.700It's, it's, it's, it's adding to, you know, their certainty that they're doing the right thing.
01:47:47.880Um, it, it is really, um, it's really great to talk to you.
01:47:53.140Um, Megan Phelps Roper, you can find her at Megan Phelps, it's her Twitter handle, at Megan Phelps.
01:47:59.640Um, really great to talk to you, and thank you for sharing this, and I think you have an important voice that needs to be heard.
01:48:07.000And I will say, Megan, would you, would you confirm this?
01:48:09.840Because we got the fifth point out of you, we are 25% better than your TED Talk.
01:48:55.360I, I will say, I mean, another thing that's not so well known about the church, their, education was really important in my family.
01:49:02.320Most of the people there, I mean, they, my, many lawyers, people who work in healthcare and IT, and, and they're very well educated, which is partly, I think, what makes it so much more difficult for them to see outside of it.
01:49:15.420This is a, like a psychological thing where, by, by having these very strong, um, mostly internally consistent arguments, um, they, they think they're, they're so certain that they don't even question the, they don't even question it.
01:49:51.540Now you're going to be able to go to your, do an ATM, pull out cash, and this is what I can, in the next couple of weeks, they're, they're switching these over, and you'll be able to go get cash without an ATM card.
01:49:59.960You'll only need your phone with a code on it to get cash out of your account.
01:51:54.640Uh, Heat Street writes, uh, because she's vice chair of the Clinton Foundation, a foundation she only works for because her parents founded to keep their wealth flowing in the years they don't spend for running for public office.
01:52:05.840Her other endeavors, authoring books that don't sell, being snarky on Twitter, and serving on the board of several large-scale tech firms operated by major Democratic donors, were oddly left out of her official biography.