'A New Person To Hate?' (Dr. Jordan Peterson & Charlie Warzel) - 2⧸23⧸18
Episode Stats
Length
1 hour and 52 minutes
Words per Minute
165.2811
Summary
Former Broward County Sheriff's Deputy Scott Peterson resigned and retired yesterday after video surveillance showed that he was armed and stationed at the Stoneman Douglas High School while the shooting took place last week. Instead of immediately responding to the shooter, Peterson cowered behind a concrete column in a stairwell.
Transcript
00:00:17.040
Hey everybody, we have somebody else to hate today. We have somebody new.
00:00:22.500
Oh, thank goodness, because I'm getting so tired of hating the same people.
00:00:26.960
There's somebody new to hate. The former deputy, Scott Peterson.
00:00:31.940
Have you heard about him? He's the sheriff's deputy.
00:00:38.440
He resigned yesterday after video surveillance showed that he was armed and stationed
00:00:43.320
at the Stoneman Douglas High School while the shooting took place last week.
00:00:48.000
Instead of immediately addressing the target and putting an end to the rampage,
00:00:51.900
Peterson cowered behind a concrete column in a stairwell.
00:00:55.860
The sheriff of Broward County. There is something wrong with the sheriff.
00:01:05.340
The sheriff of Broward County suspended Peterson without pay pending an investigation,
00:01:10.600
but the officer beat him to it. Peterson, knowing his fate, resigned and retired yesterday.
00:01:15.680
This morning, police officers line Peterson's home.
00:01:19.180
They're guarding against anyone who wants to harm Peterson.
00:01:22.620
And that's a lot of people. The officers themselves probably don't want to protect this coward.
00:01:28.720
And I will tell you this. This is an example of the police doing their job, doing things.
00:01:35.440
They protect people all the time that they don't feel a conviction inside to necessarily defend.
00:01:44.040
I can't speak for the police, but I will tell you this.
00:01:49.160
Before we take up our pitchforks and torches and charge his door, we've got to do something he's to blame.
00:02:00.780
As much as we'd like to think that we'd be brave and execute a single kill shot to the Stoneman shooter before he could take the 17 lives,
00:02:23.260
but none of us know until we're actually in the situation.
00:02:27.460
I am not defending Peterson's gutless inaction.
00:02:33.300
I think he should have used his training to save lives that day.
00:02:37.640
But there are very brave people that go to war that think they can do it,
00:03:10.480
because he has to live with this guilt of inaction for the rest of his life.
00:03:54.660
and the way he was making really disingenuous pandering arguments to the crowd.
00:04:02.240
And did he not know when he went on stage that this security guard or,
00:04:11.000
I can't remember the type of officer he was supposed to be.
00:04:15.900
he didn't know at that time when he went on stage in front of,
00:04:27.820
that police had been called to the house 31 times?
00:04:45.920
There is something more to come out with Broward County.
00:05:08.200
he seemed to be jumping to a lot of conclusions.
00:05:11.760
the by all appearances of what we know right now,
00:05:15.060
the deputy really blew it and maybe cost a bunch of people their lives.
00:05:21.500
You outlined it well there of what that moment would be like to make those
00:05:27.680
Like it's his job to go in there in that moment.
00:05:34.560
I have sympathy for Scott Peterson only because I'm not convinced.
00:05:48.540
you're doing talk radio instead of defending us.
00:05:54.720
I don't know what his military service was exactly,
00:06:01.080
So if all is explained the way we know it right now,
00:06:25.860
all of this is what I find interesting about this is that I think everyone
00:06:30.080
reacted the same way when they heard that at least instinctively,
00:06:39.420
There's somebody inside shooting children and you sit outside for four
00:06:45.400
That all comes from the evidence we got from the sheriff who have you ever
00:06:51.700
heard a police officer instantly blame another police officer like that?
00:07:12.660
Listen to what he was doing the night before with,
00:07:25.180
that's not enough for you to take the guns away.
00:08:09.220
I'd love to hear from people from Broward County that know the sheriff,
00:08:16.040
unless that information came up the next morning,
00:08:24.160
You can't hide that on stage unless he found out right afterwards,
00:08:32.340
CNN can't be upset about it because I think it was a CNN story that I read
00:08:35.420
this morning that said that Wayne LaPierre came onto the stage
00:08:44.860
he repeated his notorious phrase that he used at Sandy hook.
00:09:03.800
You don't because you're trying just to hide it.
00:09:06.060
His notorious phrase that a bad guy with a gun is only stopped by a good guy
00:09:37.520
The bad guy could have run out of bullets again.
00:09:44.440
a good guy with a gun would show up and stop that.
00:10:00.800
it's almost always once the cops show up on the premises and they have to,
00:10:17.700
Why do you refuse to say the Hulk could be used?
00:10:21.580
The only thing you're missing is why do you hate people with green skin?
00:10:38.420
it's not always a regular citizen that has a gun.
00:10:52.780
Do you want the police officers not to have guns?
00:10:56.500
Or are you saying that all people are bad and only police officers are good?
00:11:06.280
Is that it might be a private citizen with a gun?
00:11:10.500
Because you can't accept that they're a good guy with a gun?
00:11:14.300
Or is it that you believe that only police officers are good and they,
00:11:21.360
maybe they don't stop it because they're cowering behind a concrete wall?
00:11:29.680
We just saw an example of a guy with a gun stopping a mass shooting.
00:11:33.640
It literally is like one of the most recent things in our memory.
00:11:48.020
obviously he attempted the quick change escape,
00:11:53.340
which Bill Murray movie reference for all of the 99.9% of people who didn't see that.
00:12:02.140
Then he goes inside and inside the bank changes into a normal costume with a disguise and leaves
00:12:12.340
he put his guns down and then walked out with the students and he got away.
00:12:15.760
you've given me somebody new to hate Bill Murray.
00:12:30.340
As Eric Erickson put this yesterday really well.
00:12:39.260
and the security feed was on a 20 minute delay,
00:12:48.920
We seem to have a lot of other ways to stop this guy.
00:13:00.140
Your problem with the incredible Hulk and your love for the notorious quote.
00:13:08.540
Can you imagine taking your car on a hundred day test drive?
00:13:13.820
I'd be test driving really great cars all the time.
00:13:35.400
I can't wait to get home and get out of these shoes.
00:13:44.540
Giving you a hundred nights to test drive the Casper mattress in your own home for a hundred nights.
00:13:50.080
Take a hundred nights sleep challenge a hundred night.
00:13:58.660
And they come and they pick it up and they return,
00:14:03.620
So you can go and test drive this for a hundred nights,
00:14:09.060
to a store and lay on a mattress and lay there in your clothes with your shoes and your coat.
00:14:17.920
have somebody just stare at you the whole time and say,
00:14:20.280
is that one more comfortable than the last one?
00:14:22.960
I can't tell the difference between the two anymore.
00:14:32.840
I want you to go to Casper.com and use the promo code Beck.
00:14:58.340
40% of all guns are sold without background checks.
00:15:10.220
Exposing the truth about guns on Amazon and wherever books are sold.
00:15:21.260
and we're going to teach you the facts about gun control and,
00:15:51.120
I'm a little older than what's going on there now,
00:15:55.600
you said you wanted someone to call in who knows him.
00:16:04.820
He ran for this seat and beat out a really good guy who had been in the seat for a very long time.
00:16:09.980
Sheriff Israel is best friends with Debbie Wasserman Schultz.
00:16:18.360
he is everything that's wrong with Broward County.
00:16:23.060
I constitute my family and I probably constitute the entire Jewish conservative base down here,
00:16:32.620
We probably constitute the entire conservative base down here.
00:16:53.340
I think there's something more than this because he's throwing anything,
00:17:04.960
he's throwing people to the wolves and there's these,
00:17:08.340
39 cases where he was called to this kid's house and,
00:17:29.140
if there's anything that he can do that takes the debate away from grabbing our guns,
00:17:34.760
So I think this is more of a cover our tracks so that we don't get off track as far as the narrative goes.
00:17:51.480
Broward County is physically a very large County.
00:17:54.520
he's very involved in the Southern part of the County,
00:18:03.140
He stood outside of Stoneman Douglas high school.
00:18:05.360
And the first words out of his mouth were vote for people who don't get money from the NRA.
00:18:12.640
His deputies hadn't even infiltrated the school yet.
00:18:15.560
And he's already talking about grabbing our guns.
00:18:39.900
This is your chance to be embraced by the left and the elites.
00:19:01.380
He made a big deal out of the Duke lacrosse thing.
00:19:13.500
you could tell as the caller just said that he was a leftist.
00:19:17.180
certainly at least a big chunk of him was leftist because,
00:19:26.060
he was just like trying to rally people for that cause rather than,
00:19:30.360
he wasn't acting like a law enforcement official.
00:19:43.080
because Dana had the facts and he was doing everything he could just to get,
00:20:00.820
There's something wrong with this sheriff and we'll,
00:20:05.120
we'll go back and play in case you missed that,
00:20:08.200
that exchange with the sheriff and Dana lash in just a minute.
00:20:39.920
If we feel the totality of the circumstances rises to the level where we're concerned,
00:20:47.460
We need the power to take every firearm they have away from them and bring them to a mental health facility.
00:21:06.780
I know there's one Florida statute where if he's sending messages,
00:21:26.360
The only person who could be a victim is an individual.
00:21:29.180
So if an individual was threatened and it was real,
00:21:36.060
They were threatened that they were going to bleed.
00:21:37.760
They were threatened that they were going to be killed.
00:21:42.140
And he had already taken bullets and knives to school.
00:21:50.680
And this was known to the intelligence and law enforcement community.
00:21:56.940
I'm not saying that you can be everywhere at once,
00:22:04.380
You're absolutely not the litmus test for how law enforcement should follow up.
00:22:12.020
Some of them called from other states to say there were 39 visits.
00:22:38.100
So part of it is there were 39 visits reported by CNN.
00:22:42.020
I don't know that all of them were in Broward County.
00:22:44.740
Eventually the sheriff gets to that as his 15th line of defense.
00:22:51.180
I don't think he was there for all seven years where these went on.
00:22:57.820
2016 Broward Sheriff's office deputy is told by an anonymous caller that this
00:23:02.660
then 17 had threatened on Instagram to shoot up his school and posted a photo of
00:23:35.020
possibly ingested gasoline in a suicide attempt.
00:23:43.400
a mental health counselor advises against involuntary of committing of this student.
00:23:49.260
the high school says it will conduct a threat assessment.
00:23:56.780
They take our children with a class to lookalike firearm,
00:24:22.760
investigator for the Florida department of children and families rules,
00:24:26.780
the killer is stable despite fresh cuts on his arms.
00:24:34.540
he wrote a racial slur against African Americans on his book bag.
00:24:37.980
And then recently talked about buying firearms.
00:24:43.080
as we know with the exact name of this killer posts,
00:24:46.240
a comment stating he wants to become a professional school shooter.
00:24:51.500
which fails to make the connection to South Florida.
00:24:55.000
doesn't even go through the process to send it to a South Florida,
00:25:07.380
that he had weapons and asked that police recover them.
00:25:10.720
A close family friend agrees to take the firearms.
00:25:16.820
Palm beach County families that took in this killer after the death of his
00:25:20.800
mother calls a Palm beach sheriff office to report a fight between him and
00:25:26.480
A member of the family says the killer had threatened to get his gun and
00:25:30.400
come back and that he has put guns to others heads in the past.
00:25:43.540
to report that the killer is collecting guns and knives and could be a
00:25:50.940
A deputy advises the caller to contact the Palm beach sheriff.
00:25:58.600
A caller to the FBI tip line reports that Cruz,
00:26:08.620
that this murderer had a desire to kill people and could potentially conduct a
00:26:12.500
school shooting information never passed on to the FBI's office in
00:26:18.660
this is the last batch of them with all the detail that directly,
00:26:27.520
the name is brought to the attention of the sheriff and the sheriff has a
00:26:36.020
Cause they're now released nine one one tapes about him,
00:27:07.020
they handcuff us so much when we're trying to do our job that nothing gets
00:27:58.380
it's even on a broader scale than what we're talking about now.
00:28:01.340
It's from your basic burglaries to your gun calls,
00:28:05.760
We sweep these problems under the rug because they don't want the attention
00:28:11.480
It's a negative reflection on the school to have these problems.
00:28:19.280
I used to live about 15 minutes and work about 15 minutes away from there.
00:28:53.900
it's important to confirm before we go into it.
00:29:09.600
is it possible that this was a vet that had PTSD or?
00:29:36.240
It doesn't go to the underlying problem that maybe the school should have
00:29:45.420
having to get clearances before we go into an active shooter situation.
00:30:02.480
and I've been listening to your program for a very,
00:30:10.340
we had a police officer that shot an unarmed black man.
00:30:49.980
but everybody above him would have been disciplined.
00:30:55.940
the sheriff that froze everyone above him would have been disciplined.
00:31:03.480
And the main reason for that is then someone will come in someone else and
00:31:10.080
And after years of basically every leadership getting in trouble,
00:31:14.200
leadership will start understanding that they're responsible for all their
00:31:21.580
They'll start making sure they go to the right classes.
00:31:24.140
They'll make sure they're ready instead of just throwing them out there and
00:31:32.700
would you understand if he was a vet and this was PTSD,
00:31:42.200
and not seeing that that could be a possibility,
00:31:45.120
but could you see that that is a possibility of,
00:31:57.560
obviously I have severe PTSD and I've run into situations afterwards since I've
00:32:05.240
been out where I run right towards the problem still.
00:32:12.960
but I just don't understand how you didn't run into that school.
00:32:17.540
how you didn't bust through all the kids who are obviously running out.
00:32:22.240
You didn't do whatever it took to get in there.
00:32:39.440
give you another job or we need to have you out of here.
00:32:55.780
have a chance to be free and make the case for freedom because of your
00:33:13.060
talk to you a little bit about your car or your truck.
00:33:16.780
I like to drive my trucks until the doors fall off.
00:33:21.660
it just drives and drives and drives and drives.
00:33:24.340
and when it stops working and literally I can't repair it anymore,
00:33:44.420
with fence posts and everything else with them.
00:33:52.460
That's why I have car shield because it saves me so much money.
00:33:57.420
I had a sensor go wrong on one of the trucks and it was a thousand dollars.
00:34:11.560
they have car shield has plans that cover your car's computer,
00:34:17.640
And you can have your favorite mechanic or the dealership,
00:34:27.680
get your car covered or your truck covered by car shield.
00:34:33.120
I want you to call 1-800-CAR-6100 1-800-CAR-6100 and mention the promo code
00:34:59.320
Very excited to have Jordan Peterson on with us.
00:35:02.500
he's coming up in just about 10 minutes from now.
00:35:24.560
We're going to talk to him a little bit about toxic masculinity.
00:35:34.840
That happened in Florida was toxic max masculinity.
00:35:49.060
from a guy who is not involved in American politics and is in Canada,
00:35:58.820
And the discourse that we've had here in the last week about this in particular,
00:36:09.080
We'll talk to him coming up in just a few minutes.
00:36:25.420
school district shut all the schools down and they had all of the teachers go up to,
00:36:31.340
a meeting where the superintendent and the sheriffs were there.
00:36:34.880
And the whole talk was about what we're going to do in the school and all that.
00:36:37.900
and one of the things that the superintendent comes right out and says was,
00:36:41.560
we're not going to make our schools prisons and we're not going to do such and such.
00:36:52.600
the security measures we need to take in the schools.
00:37:02.760
Anything that we're trying to protect museums are like prisons.
00:37:43.900
Marion Le Pen took the stage at CPAC yesterday,
00:37:50.360
She lamented about lost sovereignty at the hands of Brussels and advocated a new global slogan,
00:38:01.940
I searched around yesterday after she left the stage to see what people were saying.
00:38:09.500
The conservative media and voices were all but silent.
00:38:14.320
It's probably because everything she said sounded a little like the Republicans today.
00:38:40.800
and Muslim migrants are actual legitimate issues.
00:38:51.560
because he gave voice to those concerns that I hold and many in this audience hold.
00:38:58.440
they have been ignored and belittled for decades.
00:39:02.460
And so you look for somebody strong enough to battle that monster.
00:39:08.060
And the longer we're belittled and the longer we're ignored,
00:39:17.120
you saw something the new American right hasn't had in,
00:39:22.880
maybe ever a young female photogenic fire brand.
00:39:27.720
There she was at CPAC flashing that million dollar smile and giving the crowd absolutely everything they wanted to hear.
00:39:41.620
The far right in Europe has nothing in common with American conservatism.
00:39:49.800
These people and groups are ethno-nationalist populists.
00:39:57.560
The only thing they're concerned with is using real issues like trade,
00:40:19.820
they're not really interested in reducing the size and scope of government.
00:40:33.140
There is a global effort right now among the far uber ultra far right all over the world to link themselves to the success of Donald Trump.
00:40:45.940
I get that they would want to try to emulate the success and ride on coattails,
00:40:55.800
which has more in common with the neo-Nazi and alt-right than anything else,
00:41:01.880
was actually giving a speech to American conservatives yesterday.
00:41:07.440
They're being legitimized and co-opted into the American right.
00:41:15.500
This is dangerous and not the American conservative movement.
00:41:19.500
The American conservative movement does not hate immigrants.
00:41:23.700
It welcomes those who want to come to America because they see that what we have and what we have is freedom and the Bill of Rights and the Constitution and law and order.
00:41:36.040
They want to come to America because they know they can make themselves and us into something bigger and better.
00:41:52.240
We believe in the Irish being Irish and the French being French and the British and Americans being Americans.
00:42:06.600
It's why we don't really necessarily believe right now that Iran should be Iran.
00:42:12.480
We believe in personal salvation, not collective.
00:42:17.960
We believe in personal responsibility, not collective.
00:42:23.160
That is the center of the American conservative movement.
00:42:28.320
If the American right marches behind a flag instead of the Constitution and Bill of Rights, it is over.
00:42:42.720
This co-opting of the European right and the alt-right must end now.
00:43:04.400
Dr. Jordan Peterson, who would have thought that a common sense would come from a university professor from Canada?
00:43:15.800
But he is probably the biggest sensation out there now, especially with the youth and young males, because he is speaking common sense, and he's speaking it peacefully, and he's talking about God.
00:43:32.380
And he's got a best-selling book out, number one bestseller, 12 Rules for Life, an Antidote to Chaos.
00:43:52.520
I don't know where you were standing last time, but can you stand there because you're breaking up and we can't understand you?
00:44:01.700
I said, well, a Canadian and a university professor.
00:44:06.100
Yes, it is the clippity-clop of the four horsemen of the apocalypse.
00:44:13.260
We hear, and I know, I don't want to, you know, get you into politics, just common sense.
00:44:18.640
I don't know if you've been following, for instance, the CNN town hall this week and this debate that we're having,
00:44:25.340
but we have 16-year-olds that are demanding that America pretty much disregards the Second Amendment.
00:44:36.560
And we're not having sensible arguments at all.
00:44:40.040
There's no reason in the debates that we're having.
00:44:49.920
Yeah, I think that can be, well, I think that that can be, that's true on a much wider scale than merely the debate that's going on about what happened after Parkland.
00:45:05.580
Well, you know, I've been recommending, I would say that in my book, in 12 Rules for Life, in Rule 6, I outlined why such things as the Parkland school shooting occur.
00:45:20.160
And it has very little to do specifically with guns.
00:45:26.000
There's something much deeper and more horrible going on that is rather dreadful to look at.
00:45:31.580
I mean, people who are motivated to do the sorts of things that happen at Parkland are, they're possessed by a kind of ill will, an evil ill will whose magnitude is difficult to describe.
00:45:43.260
And it's a problem of disorientation and meaninglessness.
00:45:47.760
And it's expressing itself in gun violence, but it can express itself in all sorts of ways.
00:45:52.260
And the problem, the deeper problem has to be solved as far as I'm concerned.
00:45:57.880
And that's the problem of nihilism in the face of the tragedy of life.
00:46:02.280
And it's that kind of destructive nihilism that drives the actions of people like the school shooters.
00:46:09.420
So it's very difficult for us to have an intelligent conversation about that because nobody wants to look at the darkness enough to actually understand what motivates people like the shooters.
00:46:24.280
And what happens then, of course, is that the discussion gets politicized and it goes down the same rails that it's always gone down.
00:46:30.880
Democrats say their thing and the Republicans say their thing.
00:46:34.820
And it never really ends up, the discussion never really ends up being about the school shootings, for example.
00:46:40.880
So, well, you know, I've been saying all week, you know, I started the week with a monologue on, you know, nobody even wants to talk about the seven out of the nine shooters that were under 30 came from fatherless homes.
00:47:04.800
Well, there's definitely something there, I would say, because these men, these young men, they lack purpose and direction.
00:47:13.880
And that's really not a good thing because life is very difficult.
00:47:18.080
As the religious sages have always had it, life is suffering.
00:47:21.440
And you need to set something positive against that suffering or it corrupts you.
00:47:26.460
And when it corrupts you, you become vengeful and vindictive and murderous and genocidal.
00:47:33.720
And the school shooters are two-thirds of the way to genocidal by the time they perform their actions.
00:47:40.540
It's because they turn against life because life is so difficult and they have nothing to set, nothing positive to set against it.
00:47:48.940
And the fact that we're idiot, we're transforming ourselves into ideologues, both on the right and the left, is a reflection of the same problem.
00:47:56.680
It's that because people lack genuine, engaged meaning in their own personal lives, in large part because they don't understand how necessary it is to take responsibility, they turn to pseudo-solutions.
00:48:09.900
And an ideology, right or left, is a pseudo-solution to the problem of meaning in life.
00:48:19.920
We saw that in the 20th century, as you pointed out just before our talk.
00:48:23.920
How do we find meaning as a group when, I mean, especially with young men, there is a concerted effort, at least it seems, to eviscerate men?
00:48:48.340
You know, 12 rules for life, which is rule 11, bother children when skateboarding.
00:48:57.020
You know, it's kind of a tongue-in-cheek title, but it's a very, very serious chapter.
00:49:01.200
And it's about the confusion between masculine confidence and masculine terror.
00:49:09.940
You know what, we're going to have to take a break and see if we can get you to a better space so we can hear you.
00:49:26.640
It's just so frustrating when he's on with us because there's nobody I want to hear every single word of more than Jordan Peterson.
00:49:39.220
One of the chapters is speak precisely, and yet we can never hear what he's saying.
00:49:43.380
It's like, yeah, and that's really what you really need to remember.
00:49:53.280
Instead of me telling you, let me read a letter that came in from one of our listeners.
00:50:00.240
He said, I heard about Glenn talking about Blinds.com.
00:50:05.960
It had amazing service, quick delivery, and installation was a breeze.
00:50:09.840
They look fantastic, so I ordered more two weeks later.
00:50:15.500
Blinds.com, the perfect blind shutters, shades, or drapes.
00:50:20.480
You can get them to upgrade your home at an unbelievable price.
00:50:23.660
You're going to get free samples, free shipping, free design consultation.
00:50:27.300
Plus, they're going to guide you through the installation step by step.
00:50:31.260
So find out for yourself why over 20 million Americans have trusted Blinds.com,
00:50:36.260
making them the number one online retailer of custom window coverings.
00:50:40.440
And now through February 25th, what's the date today?
00:50:47.440
Save up to 20% site-wide when you go to Blinds.com slash Beck.
00:51:18.960
So, let's pick the conversation up where we were, where we left it off.
00:51:32.520
How do, how do young men find meaning in their life when society is, is tearing them down and
00:51:39.380
saying, you know, you're, you're bad, you're worthless, you're not needed.
00:51:44.760
Yeah, well, it's part of an all-out assault, as far as I can tell, in some sense, mostly from
00:51:50.760
the radical left on the idea of competence itself.
00:51:54.280
And there's a confusion between tyranny and power and competence.
00:51:59.220
You know, in, in our society, which is a pretty free society, so let's say Western societies,
00:52:04.660
most of our hierarchies are mostly predicated on competence, which means that if you can do
00:52:12.500
Now, that's contaminated a little bit with tyranny and power, of course, because no, no
00:52:19.040
And what we have is a claim, essentially, from the radical left, that male competence is
00:52:25.100
indistinguishable from male tyranny and power, and so that it should be all torn down, not
00:52:30.180
only the hierarchies, but the, but the spirit that generated the hierarchies.
00:52:34.600
And that's fundamentally the masculine spirit, even symbolically and psychologically speaking.
00:52:42.080
So what we see is an all-out assault on the masculine spirit, and that was actually, that
00:52:50.240
He called Western culture phallogocentric, phallo from phallus, and logo from logos.
00:52:56.760
So it was male-dominated and driven by logos, and, of course, that's the Christian word, and
00:53:02.680
also the root idea behind the, behind the word logic.
00:53:06.600
And so it is part of an all-out intellectual, and an all-out war of ideas.
00:53:12.540
And the people who are bearing the brunt of that at the moment are, I would say, young
00:53:23.480
Is it, I mean, is it as clear as it seems to be that it is the end goal and the, the, the
00:53:35.100
Can you, can you find any logic in there that is, that is more than that?
00:53:40.740
Look, if you buy the idea that the West is a corrupt patriarchy, and then that's the logical,
00:53:48.720
I mean, the, the more radical disciplines at the universities, women's studies and, and,
00:53:53.620
and those sorts of disciplines have said for decades that their goal was the destruction
00:53:58.780
It's like, it's very often, you know, that people tell you what they're doing.
00:54:03.900
I mean, if you read the school shooters' documents, like the kids from Columbine High School, they
00:54:08.780
told you exactly why they did what they, what they did.
00:54:11.240
If you go onto the websites and read, um, the curricula and, uh, dictates of women's studies,
00:54:18.300
uh, uh, disciplines at universities, they tell you exactly what they're doing.
00:54:23.240
If the West is a corrupt patriarchy, then the right thing to do is to tear it down.
00:54:28.580
So it's not, it's not a surprise and it's not a conspiracy theory.
00:54:32.680
It's, it's, it's just precisely what, what's, that's the doctrine, that's the dogma.
00:54:38.880
And the university, especially the humanities departments are overwhelmingly, uh, left and
00:54:46.380
So it's been well documented by people like Jonathan Haidt with his Heterodox Academy.
00:54:51.440
Jonathan is an extraordinarily reasonable person.
00:55:01.040
Who is, uh, uh, Jordan, who are the people that we should be reading besides you and your
00:55:07.400
Who are the people that inspire you or it can inspire men to be, to be men?
00:55:14.060
I think, I think that Steven Pinker is, is doing a fine job.
00:55:21.640
So Pinker's a good person to read because Pinker's making a very powerful pro-enlightenment,
00:55:27.920
pro-reason, pro-science, pro-progress case, well-documented empirically.
00:55:32.760
I mean, the empirical evidence is pretty clear, although there is some evidence that inequality
00:55:39.560
First of all, no one knows what to do about that, right or left.
00:55:42.520
There's a new book by Walter Scheidel called The Great Leveling, which I would also much
00:55:46.500
recommend it because much, because he analyzes the problem of inequality with dead seriousness
00:55:52.840
and, and traces it back thousands of years and points out quite clearly that it's a problem,
00:55:59.140
but that it can't be laid at the feet of capitalism.
00:56:04.980
And, but despite the fact that there's increasing inequality to some degree in the West, overall,
00:56:10.400
the entire world is getting richer and, and there are fewer poor people.
00:56:14.500
There are way fewer people in absolute poverty than there were 15 years ago, far fewer.
00:56:20.000
And so what's happening is our economic system is generating a lot of surplus and it's being
00:56:25.740
quite effectively distributed even to the lowest end of the socioeconomic spectrum, but inequality
00:56:33.620
And, you know, that drives a fair bit of theorizing on the left, but I would, I would very much recommend
00:56:40.000
It's, it's, it's very bright and, and then there's, there's Pinker and then, you know,
00:56:44.320
I'm very much a fan of, of, of great classic literature.
00:56:51.660
Dostoevsky's novels in particular are unbelievably profound explorations of the role of human
00:56:57.780
responsibility in the face of the tragedy and malevolence of existence.
00:57:01.800
So, and I have a reading list at jordanbpeterson.com that has about 40 books on it that I've recommended
00:57:08.640
that some of them are psychological in nature and others are literary, some are philosophical.
00:57:13.160
So, so let me take a, let me take a quick break and then I want to come back and, and
00:57:22.500
What, what is the goal to be a man and what does a good man look like when we come back
00:58:04.200
He is the author of the number one New York Times bestseller, 12 Rules for Life, an Antidote
00:58:10.220
I can't recommend that you read this highly enough.
00:58:15.380
Can you describe, uh, what we all should be shooting for as a man?
00:58:22.500
So I was thinking about an image related to that.
00:58:25.400
So there's a cathedral in Montreal called St. Joseph's Oratorio and it's built on a hill.
00:58:34.820
And then there are many, many steps leading up to it, hundreds of steps.
00:58:39.020
And pilgrims come there to, to trudge up the steps one at a time towards the cathedral.
00:58:43.780
And there's something deeply symbolic about that.
00:58:46.780
The idea that's being expressed is, is, is profound and necessary.
00:58:52.800
And that is that we all need a vision of the way that, that life and the world could be.
00:58:59.340
We want to have a vision that, that, that could be as good as it could be.
00:59:03.240
The least amount of suffering and the most for everyone and the most freedom for everyone
00:59:10.020
And the question is, how do you approach an ideal like that?
00:59:13.360
And the answer to that is by carrying your burden one step at a time up the hill.
00:59:34.340
And that way you make the world a little better instead of worse.
00:59:39.340
And that's the alternative to ideological possession and collective action and, and, and group hatred
00:59:46.440
and tribalism and all those things that tear us apart is to accept that your life is tragic
00:59:52.600
and that you'll suffer and that there's evil in the world.
00:59:55.160
And that it's your, it's your responsibility to take that onto yourself and to carry it forward
01:00:08.760
And that's the antidote to chaos and to catastrophe.
01:00:16.560
This is why, this is why we're an individualist culture.
01:00:21.140
Because we know that the individual has to be set above the group.
01:00:27.300
It's the, it's the individual in all his responsibility.
01:00:30.480
And that's the part of, of the dialogue that's missing from our culture currently.
01:00:36.000
And I believe that's why my book has become so popular and the lectures as well, because,
01:00:40.940
because I'm telling people, suggesting to people, and particularly, but not only to young men,
01:00:47.360
that they need to accept as much responsibility as they can tolerate.
01:00:52.340
And then build themselves into people who can tolerate even more responsibility.
01:00:57.920
And to be, and to, to accept that gratefully, because that's where the purpose and meaning in life is.
01:01:04.480
Jordan, I, I have, I have, I've gone from a man, you know, for a while I, I rejected that I have,
01:01:12.820
I had changed a great deal in the last couple of years.
01:01:16.640
But I, I have, and I've gone from a guy, um, that was very popular because I was certain of things,
01:01:24.600
to a guy who now really appreciates doubt, uh, and is, and, and I, I kind of view certitude as a, uh, as a,
01:01:37.200
as a dangerous thing, uh, because if I'm certain of what I believe,
01:01:42.040
then I don't necessarily believe, uh, you know, anybody else has me, has anything to teach me or, uh,
01:01:48.960
and, and yet I find, I think this is the message of Christ is, is humility.
01:02:00.500
Well, the humility is that, like, if things aren't everything they should be for you and around you,
01:02:07.420
Right, and so then you better be looking for what you don't know, and that's the opposite of certainty.
01:02:12.280
We, we, we, we are in a situation now that, um, uh, we, it almost feels like we don't trust that the truth
01:02:21.760
will eventually win, that God is, uh, on the side of truth, and so we have to engage in this warfare,
01:02:29.440
and, and we're engaging online, we're engaging in tribalism, uh, and, and the, the, the, the answer
01:02:41.500
Yeah, well, we're trying to transform the political system into a tribal battlefield.
01:02:46.280
That's what identity politics is, and that can be accepted on the right as well.
01:02:54.880
It's division into tribes, and it's a catastrophe.
01:03:03.220
Human tribes have always fought, and, and terribly.
01:03:06.860
You know, there's an old idea that the hunter-gatherer types, that the, the, the pre, the pre-materialist,
01:03:14.340
pre-capitalist hunter-gatherer types were peaceful.
01:03:18.860
They have incredibly high male-on-male homicide rates.
01:03:23.460
Tribal people are unbelievably murderous, and we're all tribal, except when we decide
01:03:29.980
And to decide not to be tribal is to decide to be an individual, but that means to take
01:03:34.440
all the weight of things onto your own shoulders.
01:03:41.400
But the, the, the paradoxical truth of the matter is, is that the more you take on that
01:03:46.500
terrible responsibility, the deeper your life becomes, and that justifies the suffering.
01:03:51.540
But the more you take on the bigger target, I want, I want to read, I want to read this
01:03:56.100
This is a, um, uh, an article out of the Mercury News in California.
01:04:00.620
Uh, these men, particular Elon Musk are not only heavily invested in who can get their
01:04:07.260
rocket into space first, but into colonizing Mars, the desire to colonize, to have unquestioned,
01:04:14.640
unchallenging, automatic access to, to something, to any type of body and use it as will is a
01:04:23.640
Um, it is the same instinctual and cultural force that teaches men that everything and
01:04:28.560
everyone in their line of vision is theirs for the taking.
01:04:32.400
They're, they're, they're destroying a guy like Elon Musk, who's like, look, I, I believe
01:04:37.740
these things and I think we can be better than this.
01:04:44.540
And, and there, see, that's a, that's a great, that's, that's your, your, your reference
01:04:51.260
You see there that confusion between male confidence and desire to, to move forward in the world.
01:05:07.640
I mean, if you can't see that he's a hero, then there's something wrong with your vision.
01:05:12.100
And, you know, in, symbolically, the author of that article is equating Mars with the unspoiled
01:05:18.320
virgin, you know, and, and Musk with the rapist.
01:05:30.280
It's all, there's nothing in that except destruction.
01:05:35.220
Good men do things for themselves and for everyone else at the same time.
01:05:42.760
When do we want to do something that's good for you and good for your family and good for
01:05:46.220
the community and good for the surrounding world all at the same time.
01:05:50.840
And that takes competence and clear vision and truth.
01:05:56.320
And those people, the people who wrote the article that you described, they're the people
01:06:00.120
who think that emasculated weak men will be good because they're harmless.
01:06:04.460
And emasculated weak men will be the Parkland shooters.
01:06:18.440
Are we closer to the end of this kind of thinking and movement, or are we closer to the end of
01:06:30.400
You know, there's been this funny idea that's been circulating on the internet about the
01:06:36.540
kingdom of Kekistan, where everything's in chaos.
01:06:41.860
Things could go very well, but they could go very badly.
01:06:45.300
And I think we're in a situation now where the decisions that each person makes at each
01:06:50.780
moment are of crucial import in a way that's not always true.
01:06:55.580
We're going to decide which way we're going to go in the next three or four years.
01:07:05.220
All the economic growth, for example, that I referred to, the fact that poverty is being
01:07:10.840
And there's about 300,000 people a day now being hooked to the power grid.
01:07:14.720
And there are a lot of really good things happening.
01:07:17.000
But there is this terrible polarization and this demand to return to a destructive tribalism.
01:07:23.340
And this ideological attempt led mostly by the universities, to my utter shame, to demolish
01:07:35.020
They're letting the fifth column diversity, equity, and inclusivity types in through the
01:07:40.700
HR backdoor, failing to see that generating an anti-capitalist fifth column within the confines
01:07:48.140
of your own organization is self-destructive in the extreme.
01:07:54.880
I've watched interviews with you in mainstream media, and they always come with an intent,
01:08:03.880
You approach these interviews without an agenda, and you're just trying to explain what you believe
01:08:08.920
based on their questions, and you always seem to win because you don't seem to have an
01:08:19.280
I have an agenda, which is to not say something stupid.
01:08:24.780
Do you believe the mainstream media has crossed the line from bias to activism?
01:08:33.860
Well, I think one of the things that might be happening is that we're in a transition period
01:08:39.100
from the mainstream media, print and television, let's say, most particularly, to online forms
01:08:51.200
And as they spiral towards their death, they become more polarized to draw attention to the
01:08:57.860
And so they're driving polarization in the broader society in an attempt to stave off
01:09:04.100
their extinction, rather than adapting to the new media.
01:09:08.000
I'm not sure that's true, but that's what it looks like.
01:09:10.420
It looks like it might be happening to me, because we are in the midst of a technological
01:09:17.440
I mean, YouTube alone now has something in the neighborhood of 2 billion people using it.
01:09:22.100
So it's, and YouTube allows the possibility of the spoken word to have the same distribution
01:09:28.800
as the written word, which is something unparalleled in human history.
01:09:32.880
So I think that part of what's happening is a secondary consequence of a technological revolution.
01:09:39.740
I don't think that the mainstream media's desperate attempts to use clickbait, let's say, to attract
01:09:48.100
additional viewership to exaggerate, for example, the danger of violent crime, and to pit the
01:09:54.540
right against the left in a manner that's more combative than the reality would indicate.
01:10:01.260
I don't think that that will stave off their demise.
01:10:05.640
But there could be a lot of collateral damage while that's occurring.
01:10:09.000
Jordan Peterson from JordanPeterson.com, also the book 12 Rules for Life, an Antidote to Chaos.
01:10:21.160
Did you ever, you have, you have, like, you're approaching a million YouTube subscribers, a
01:10:37.240
Yes, I'm number one everywhere, but on the New York Times bestseller.
01:10:45.880
Jordan, did you ever, did you ever see anything like this coming your way?
01:10:51.020
Well, I knew when I wrote my first book, this book Maps of Meaning, I was discussing archetypal
01:10:55.980
ideas and their relationship to ideological dispute.
01:11:01.980
And I knew that my students in the course I taught on that book were very, very receptive
01:11:08.220
I mean, most of the student comments I got, both at Harvard and at University of Toronto,
01:11:12.740
was that that was one of the few courses that completely changed students' lives.
01:11:18.240
And it's not surprising to me that to some degree, because of the ideas themselves, ancient
01:11:23.080
archetypal religious ideas are of absolute necessity.
01:11:28.800
And so I knew that I was talking about things that have always been of crucial importance
01:11:33.820
to people, but there was no way of foreseeing the magnitude of the effect of that.
01:11:40.500
I mean, it's, I'm still in complete shock about it on a moment-to-moment basis.
01:11:47.840
And it seems to be getting larger rather than smaller.
01:11:54.880
I pray for you, and I know what it's like to have great success come quickly.
01:12:01.800
And if there was anyone who could navigate those waters, I believe it is you.
01:12:10.420
Well, like I said, I hope I can manage this without making any catastrophic mistakes.
01:12:23.000
You can get Jordan on Twitter at JordanBPeterson.
01:12:32.060
JordanBPeterson.com is where, by the way, that reading list he mentioned earlier in the interview,
01:12:38.520
And I would say probably at the top of that reading list would be 12 Rules for Life,
01:12:46.360
I don't think I've ever interviewed a more careful man.
01:13:02.440
If you're hiring, every business needs great people.
01:13:06.800
Well, you could post your job online and pray for the right people.
01:13:12.700
ZipRecruiter learns what you're looking for and then identifies the people with the right experience
01:13:20.040
The invitations have revolutionized the way you're going to find your next hire.
01:13:24.560
80% of employers who post a job on ZipRecruiter get a quality candidate through the site in just the first day.
01:13:33.960
It also spotlights the strongest applications you receive so you never miss a great match.
01:13:44.580
Use it for free at ZipRecruiter.com slash Beck.
01:14:07.180
I want this to be the end of the Second Amendment.
01:14:10.120
The latest school shooting has ignited the gun debate.
01:14:13.320
Now more than ever, you need to know the facts.
01:14:17.160
Exposing the truth about guns on Amazon and wherever books are sold.
01:14:20.660
So, I brought Jordan Peterson to the table today.
01:14:31.020
Yeah, wrote an amazing article about something you've been talking about for a while on AI
01:14:36.180
and how it's going to change the way we get information that you're not going to believe.
01:15:05.980
Every once in a while, we need to take a step back.
01:15:07.800
Everybody right now is screaming, fake news, fake news.
01:15:14.360
We're getting to a place that soon you're not going to be able to believe your eyes and
01:15:33.020
And now he's saying, oh, yeah, yeah, yeah, yeah.
01:15:37.600
That's nothing compared to what's on the recent or near horizon.
01:15:47.640
And there's a great story about this in BuzzFeed from Charlie Warzel.
01:15:55.220
Also writes something, one of my favorite things to read, which because it's about Infowars
01:16:04.020
It's called Infowarzel, which is the greatest name of all time.
01:16:16.600
So, Charlie, I can't seem to get people to really get their arms around the idea that
01:16:27.320
soon we're not going to even know what reality is.
01:16:33.340
Well, it's it's complicated to some extent, but the best way that that I can describe it
01:16:42.880
is that the sort of hall of mirrors that we are experiencing online right now with the
01:16:49.940
as you guys were saying earlier, everyone sort of calling fake news with with sort of bad
01:16:56.720
actors acting in bad faith, putting out, you know, propaganda and content that's designed
01:17:05.100
All those things that we see, you know, in our Facebook feeds, in Twitter right now, it's all going to
01:17:13.060
potentially get far worse because the technology is going to allow it to come from people that
01:17:21.260
So the, you know, the the fake news that you're seeing, the misinformation, the propaganda,
01:17:27.540
it could start coming from, you know, a loved one.
01:17:31.840
You know, you could start getting emails from them telling you things that that didn't happen
01:17:36.400
that were, you know, generated algorithmically.
01:17:38.960
So so it's not really that that something new is going to happen.
01:17:43.120
It's that everything that's happening now, all this unrest, discord, confusion and and
01:17:49.500
difficulty sort of parsing reality is going to become so much more sophisticated because
01:17:56.200
of technology that hasn't even been invented yet.
01:17:59.000
What do you mean that you're going to get, you know, you'll get something from your loved
01:18:04.020
So Aviv, the researcher who I spoke with, alongside many others who are doing, you know,
01:18:12.320
really great work sort of understanding how these platforms work and the technology that's
01:18:19.100
Aviv has this this term and it's called laser phishing.
01:18:24.660
So regular phishing or spear phishing is when you maybe get a link from something that, you
01:18:30.520
know, an email address, that's a couple of characters off from somebody, you know, and
01:18:34.880
it's saying, hey, click this link and it and then that link asks you for, you know, your
01:18:44.180
This would sort of be something that would happen.
01:18:48.040
Laser phishing is using AI and sort of this artificial intelligence and machine learning
01:18:54.580
to understand things about you, understand the people that you talk to, the conversations
01:18:59.880
you've had across social media with other people, mine all that information and then
01:19:07.400
So instead of getting an email from someone who, who's, you know, sounds like they could
01:19:12.980
be someone, you know, the email is going to come from ostensibly someone, you know, and
01:19:17.120
it's going to have information that's pertinent to you, information you were perhaps expecting
01:19:23.260
So you're going to be so much more likely to believe this information and then offer
01:19:30.480
If you, you know, there's a lot of people, Nigerian princes on the internet for money,
01:19:35.460
but what if that person is your brother and your brother, you know, says he has had a car
01:19:40.960
accident and he's stuck and needs to, you know, repair his car because you were having a
01:19:44.920
conversation about, you know, cars and, uh, and money or something like that along the
01:19:50.040
lines. So this is being able to manipulate people at the click of a, uh, you know, a mouse
01:19:57.180
or a button, um, in this algorithm, in this, uh, you know, artificial intelligence way.
01:20:02.960
And I think that, uh, I think that we're, we're falling for, for the low tech lo-fi stuff
01:20:08.100
right now. So it's going to be hard to imagine, you know, how we can get up to speed on, on
01:20:13.160
And the future of this, Charlie's is, goes even further than just say an email. It could
01:20:16.980
be audio or video coming from the people that you know, convincing you to do something that
01:20:25.680
Absolutely. And I think you can see this, you know, not just in people asking for money
01:20:30.500
or, you know, asking you for information, but, um, you know, this can be, this can be used
01:20:35.180
to manipulate, um, government and, and, and diplomacy. Um, it's not hard to envision and many
01:20:41.940
people have sort of already been talking about this, but it's not hard to envision. Um, any
01:20:47.200
lawmaker has hundreds of hours of footage of themselves, either audio or video on, on
01:20:52.100
the internet. Um, machine learning programs can take that, can absorb it. And then what
01:20:59.160
they can, what they can do with that is, is produce very hard, hard to verify and, and
01:21:05.640
real looking video of people saying anything. So, you know, you could have a video of Donald
01:21:11.100
Trump potentially down the line, um, really antagonizing in, in, in an, in an aggressive
01:21:16.720
way, um, say in North, North Korea. Um, and, and the stakes of that get higher and higher
01:21:23.020
as you know, the reaction times are, are shorter and, and, and people have to respond. So you
01:21:29.480
could really escalate, you know, political, uh, and, and, you know, diplomatic tensions, uh,
01:21:36.500
using this kind of technology. So I was, uh, I was talking about this, um, at the beginning
01:21:41.280
of the year and, uh, I laid out just some, some crazy predictions. And, and one of them
01:21:45.380
was if not this, uh, election of 2018 by 2020, this will be used in an effective way. And we
01:21:54.840
may not know about it until after the election, but we are that close to this kind of stuff,
01:22:00.060
uh, being used. Would you agree with that? Well, I think, you know, with the, with the
01:22:05.680
artificial intelligence stuff, with the, um, you know, the video and audio manipulation,
01:22:10.320
we may be a little further down the line from that because the real worry is not just that,
01:22:14.920
um, you know, some incredibly sophisticated programmer, one-off type person's going to be
01:22:20.560
able to use this who has, you know, proprietary technology. The real thing is when it becomes
01:22:25.580
democratized when, you know, when you can manipulate when anyone with, you know, two or
01:22:30.660
three hours of, of, you know, research on the internet can, can do this. Um, and that I think
01:22:36.780
we're a little bit further off, but not too far. There are some, um, some forums. There's a forum
01:22:42.900
on the, uh, site Reddit, um, which is called deep fakes. And it is where people are manipulating,
01:22:49.680
uh, video right now. Some of it is, is awful. Some of it is, you know, is pornographic and,
01:22:55.580
and, and very disturbing, but others are just, you can go and look for yourself are funny. You
01:23:01.400
know, people, um, putting Nicolas Cage's face on Arnold Schwarzenegger. And it, and it, and it,
01:23:07.220
I don't know why Nicolas Cage gets is, is this guy, but he's on all his face is almost on
01:23:13.260
everybody. He, he's an internet, uh, sensation. Yeah, he is. But, but, but, you know, it speaks
01:23:19.580
to when people are kind of playing around with this, having fun with it, uh, doing it in their
01:23:23.820
spare time because it's entertaining. That is sort of a harbinger of something that's
01:23:29.140
very scary, which is that, you know, you could, uh, in, in two or three hours, figure out how
01:23:35.840
to do this yourself. I think we're a little bit further than, than, than I think, you
01:23:41.020
know, 2020, who knows, but it's definitely coming.
01:23:43.780
I hope you're right. Um, tell me a little bit about what Aviv, uh, talks about and describes
01:23:49.380
as reality apathy. Sure. Um, I, it's basically the, uh, the combination of all of this, uh,
01:23:56.880
that would, that we're talking about, which is these sophisticated technological tools to
01:24:03.060
sort of distort what's real and what's not to the point where you become overwhelmed by,
01:24:09.900
you know, the idea of all, say you're being laser fished by, you know, 20 people. And when
01:24:16.320
you go on line and try to click a news link, you're not sure where the source is coming
01:24:20.340
from, whether it's, whether it's something you can trust, whether it's something you're
01:24:23.300
not, you're just besieged by what you believe is misinformation, but you can't even tell.
01:24:29.800
So you start to disengage. You know, if you're, if your inbox is something where you don't,
01:24:33.840
you, where you, you don't know what you're getting, what's real or what's not, you're
01:24:38.500
gonna maybe give up. And that is sort of the, um, that, that works also with, um, with
01:24:45.140
diplomacy. If people start, um, you know, spoofing, uh, calls to Congress to lobby their lawmakers
01:24:52.360
about some, you know, political issue, uh, if that happens in a, in a spoof, spoofing way
01:24:59.160
so much that people can't, um, get through on the, on the lines, they're going to stop
01:25:04.360
participating in, in, in democracy in that particular way. They might, you know, stop going
01:25:09.640
online and sharing their own opinions or feel, uh, unsafe. They might just say, you know what,
01:25:14.420
the news, it's not worth it for me, but going the other, but that's scary, but going the
01:25:18.880
other way as well, if, if you see a bunch of stuff that is fake and you don't know what
01:25:26.040
to believe, uh, somebody in power could actually be doing some really bad stuff and nobody would
01:25:32.060
know, nobody would pay attention. They'd say, well, that's just fake because that's what
01:25:35.560
the politician would say. Yeah. I mean, an informed citizenry is a, is a cornerstone of,
01:25:41.800
of, of democracy. And so how do we inform ourselves going forward? How, who is standing
01:25:49.560
against this? How do we protect? I mean, you can't put the genie back in the bottle. What
01:25:53.880
do we do? Well, I think, you know, this is why I wanted to highlight, uh, Aviv's work
01:26:00.940
and, and, you know, I, he's becoming labeled as sort of the person who called the, you know,
01:26:06.200
the misinformation fake news crisis before, uh, before it became a thing. He's one of
01:26:12.440
many. There are, there are, you know, dozens of, of researchers like this who are lobbying
01:26:18.120
tech companies thinking about this on sort of, you know, the vanguard of this, of this movement.
01:26:23.120
And, and I think, you know, journalists, news organizations highlighting these people's
01:26:28.420
work, giving them a platform to talk about this is the first step. The second step is
01:26:33.520
really, you know, putting pressure on these technology companies and not just Facebook
01:26:39.540
or Google or Twitter, but that, you know, the hardware makers, people like Adobe who people
01:26:45.040
like, you know, potentially Apple companies that are starting, that are going to be making
01:26:49.140
this, this audio visual technology, um, and, and making them sort of understand that innovation
01:26:57.280
is okay, but we have to learn our lessons from, you know, this whole fake news situation that
01:27:05.040
we're dealing with right now and build this technology responsibly with all of these sort
01:27:09.620
of externalities baked in and understand what we can, that these things can be abused. So let's
01:27:15.940
put in the safeguards now instead of later. I think you could see it, you know, tech companies
01:27:21.540
at times, uh, be a little bit absorbed by self-interest, but they're not nefarious actors,
01:27:27.200
right? My, my issue with this is that when I try to find optimism in, in the future here,
01:27:32.720
Charlie, is that, you know, eventually, you know, state actors, uh, hacker groups, someone
01:27:39.400
with actual nefarious intent that you can't go and lobby and you can't have, you don't have
01:27:44.220
people with, with ethics trying to deal with are going to get control of this stuff and
01:27:48.100
do things that can be really harmful and maybe irreversible.
01:27:52.280
I think, I mean, that, I think that that is, is potentially true. I mean, all of this,
01:27:58.560
it's difficult because, you know, we're in speculation territory. It's difficult as a journalist,
01:28:02.700
you know, writing about this without, um, going too far or scaring people too much. Um, but
01:28:09.400
I mean, I think what this, what the last 18 months of sort of, you know, information crisis
01:28:16.540
world that we're in should be teaching us right now is that this is everyone's problem. Lawmakers,
01:28:24.040
you know, need to get smart on this stuff quick. They need to, you know, be putting pressure on
01:28:31.240
and I think they need to spend time, you know, really understanding this technology themselves
01:28:39.480
and getting the government ready. There's, there's not a lot of, you know, um, task forces here to
01:28:45.940
combat, uh, computational propaganda or misinformation. Charlie, look how we're dealing
01:28:52.020
with Russia. Nobody's, everybody's talking about, oh, well, Donald Trump or Hillary Clinton,
01:28:56.400
Russia, look at what Russia is doing. We can get to the rest of that. And, you know, if,
01:29:02.860
if somebody did something, they should go to jail, but we're missing the point that Russia has come in
01:29:09.400
and, and, and, and announced in advance what they were going to do. And they did it.
01:29:16.780
I think that state sponsored actors, all of this, you know,
01:29:22.800
it's clearly manipulatable by them. And, and I think that we, I think that that's certainly one,
01:29:31.720
one piece of the puzzle. I think that, I think that this technology, we've, we spent so long
01:29:38.300
thinking that this technology is, is a, a universal positive, um, that there's no negative externalities
01:29:44.740
to connecting the world. Um, and I think that that is, you know, that that's a naive look at this.
01:29:51.800
And I think that we need to sort of change the way that, that we message about this technology,
01:29:58.500
that it's just as much a force for, um, for evil potentially as it is a force for, for good and,
01:30:06.420
uh, and for, you know, the free circulation of information. Uh, so I think that some of it just
01:30:11.300
has to do with our mindset with this. This is, you know, a new innovation is not, uh, is not good
01:30:17.020
just by, by definition. Right. You have to, you have to earn that. Charlie, I, uh, I've been
01:30:22.200
concerned about this, uh, for a very long time and I'm, I was really glad to see your article,
01:30:28.180
um, and, and, uh, the fact that it was on Buzzfeed and, and, and people are reading it. Uh, and I'd love
01:30:34.980
to stay in touch with you and, and have you on the program again as we, as we follow this story.
01:30:39.640
Thank you very much, Charlie. Thanks for having me.
01:30:44.380
Leave you with one last quote from Aviv Ovidaya, the expert Charlie talked to.
01:30:48.500
Alarmism can be good. You should be alarmist about this stuff. We are so screwed. It's beyond what
01:30:53.960
most of us can imagine. Jeez, it's scary. Charlie, uh, Warzel, this will tweet it from at world of
01:31:01.620
stew, but he's at C Warzel on Twitter and you can get his, uh, work at Buzzfeed. Uh, it's,
01:31:07.360
it's really interesting stuff. He dives into a lot of weird worlds and it's really compelling.
01:31:13.200
Liberty safe is a sponsor that, uh, we've had for a very, very long time. Uh, and they not only make
01:31:19.460
great safes, but they make it easy to own one and they're made here in America right now at
01:31:24.440
liberty safe.com. You can buy a Liberty safe at a great price and receive 12 months interest-free
01:31:29.700
payments with zero down and zero APR. They even offer Liberty safes for as low as $20 a month,
01:31:36.120
been working with Liberty for over eight years, almost 10 years now. And I will tell you,
01:31:40.940
I've had one in my home longer than I've worked with them. And, uh, I love them. They make the
01:31:46.560
best built safe in America, bar none, peace of mind, lifetime warranty in home delivery service,
01:31:55.000
all unmatched in the industry. The biggest complaint is I should have bought a bigger one.
01:32:00.500
We have seen these survive fires where literally nothing in the house is left except to the
01:32:06.400
fireplace, the chimney and the Liberty safe. We've seen them picked up by tornadoes and dropped
01:32:12.620
a couple of blocks away and it's still closed and everything is safe. Do what I did have a Liberty
01:32:20.100
safe installed in your home for your guns, for your papers, for anything that you need to keep safe.
01:32:26.660
Now you can get 12 months interest-free payments, uh, for as low as $20 a month on approved credit,
01:32:33.060
but you need to act now and protect what you value most. Your valuables are always protected with
01:32:38.680
Liberty, liberty safe.com. Go to liberty safe.com. Glenn Beck, Mercury.
01:32:47.660
Glenn Beck. So what do you do with information like that still? What do you do with information?
01:33:02.280
I, I find it very difficult to find a path to optimism with that stuff because as I kind of
01:33:08.220
expressed to him, it's like, you know, I think we actually, I have a lot of faith in capitalism,
01:33:11.900
right? Where eventually these companies I think will try, I think we will find in our best interest,
01:33:18.140
a lot of things that will push them in the right directions with it over time. I have a much
01:33:23.880
different, uh, belief when it comes to, you know, negative actors, when it comes to terrorism, when
01:33:29.380
it comes to, uh, nation states, eventually somebody gets control of this and the information's so
01:33:35.060
powerful. Whoever can pull off that first really good fake of that politician saying that thing they
01:33:39.820
didn't say is going to be really devastating. And it's going to be, I mean, can you imagine if
01:33:43.280
someone came out like if, if, uh, you know, Anthony Weiner came out, right? And I mean,
01:33:48.420
he tried it. He said, Oh, that was just a hack. It was just a hack. Nobody believed him. Nobody
01:33:53.340
believed him. And imagine if they had him on video and, and it was lengthy and perfect. And they
01:33:59.740
hit it. Oh no, that's been hacked. That's not really me. Nobody's going to believe them.
01:34:03.660
And the first time for a while, for a while, for a few of them. And eventually we'll get to a
01:34:08.400
point where, Oh my gosh, this is happening. And then nobody believes anything, which might be
01:34:11.400
worse. Yeah. Then it's the, I mean, can you believe Stu, we're here back in the nineties
01:34:16.860
over 20 years ago? Yeah. You and I were talking and I said, there's going to come a time where
01:34:21.780
digitally you'll be able to manipulate anything. You won't believe your ears. You won't believe
01:34:26.420
your eyes. And we're here. Yeah. We're here. We're here right at the very beginning of it.
01:34:31.400
I mean, there's so many great things. We just have to weather this storm. Um, you know,
01:34:37.640
Ray Kurzweil, who has almost a 90% accuracy rate of his prediction since the 1970s. Um, he
01:34:46.280
believes that quote, all disease will be cured by 2030. Wow. All disease. We have such a bright
01:34:57.520
future that we are right on top of if we don't destroy ourselves first.
01:35:18.640
Another school shooting. The gunfire lasted less than 10 minutes, but this heavily armed with a
01:35:24.340
bulletproof vest, loads of ammunition and a powerful AR-15. Another debate about banning guns.
01:35:30.360
Keep assault rifles out of the hands of people who are going to shoot our kids.
01:35:34.680
I want this to be the catalyst. The end of the second amendment.
01:35:39.040
Now, more than ever, you need to know the facts.
01:35:43.100
Get control. Exposing the truth about guns on Amazon and wherever books are sold.
01:35:48.260
Beginning next week, we're going to start taking you through all of those, uh, arguments and, um,
01:35:52.780
and really preparing you for what is going to be that March. Uh, that's when everybody is going to
01:35:59.120
be talking about this again. And we need to be prepared with the rock solid, uh, arguments. So
01:36:06.640
we're going to be going over those beginning on Monday on this program. Welcome to Pat Gray.
01:36:12.360
Pat, we've been, we've been on the air while, uh, Donald Trump, uh, gave his speech. We have, uh,
01:36:17.400
selections from, uh, from Donald Trump where he was talking about, you know, I have proven I'm a
01:36:22.880
conservative. I have cut taxes and I have done a great job on, uh, judges, which he has. There's
01:36:30.260
a real legacy, uh, to Donald Trump on judges that I don't think people are really talking about
01:36:35.740
what, what he has done on judges, not just Gorsuch. Yeah. That one pretty much universally
01:36:40.620
praised by conservatives more than any other part of his agenda. I would say. And he, and you know,
01:36:45.040
he's out of the way of whoever is making the calls on the judges. And these are the, this is
01:36:51.760
game changing, um, the calls that he's made on, uh, on the judges. What else did he talk about?
01:36:58.740
While I was listening, he was talking about, uh, trade, the trade deficit, and we are $500
01:37:04.260
billion in, uh, deficit to China. We are a hundred billion dollars, uh, in deficit to Mexico and it's
01:37:11.980
unacceptable. And all those things are going to be redone. NAFTA it's going away. Uh, it's going
01:37:17.580
away. He's back on that. Cause he was talking about it staying for a while. He's not, he didn't
01:37:21.920
seem to be on that track right now. And the world trade organization, which created China,
01:37:27.560
he says, uh, as soon as the WTO was created, China went like a rocket ship to the top. And so that's
01:37:33.540
going to be redone. We're going to get out of that. We're going to, we're going to redo all these
01:37:36.780
things. If they won't come to an agreement, we're going to redo them all. Then we'll start over
01:37:39.920
again. You think that's negotiation or cause he hasn't really done much of that yet. I don't
01:37:44.560
think, I just think that's the part of his agenda. He hadn't gotten to yet. And I think now that's
01:37:48.580
the part he cares about. Yeah. Oh, he cares about that. Talks about it all the time. Yeah. And so I
01:37:53.560
think this is the year he gets to it cause he got to some of the other things and you know, they got
01:37:57.960
the tax, uh, cut done. Uh, they couldn't get Obamacare eliminated. Although he said we're doing it
01:38:04.620
piecemeal and maybe that's the better way they did get rid of the biggest offense. I would say the
01:38:09.820
individual mandate, which is, which is what he said that they've essentially gutted and
01:38:13.980
eliminated. Oh, I mean, we all talked about that, that you got to get rid of the mandate. And if
01:38:18.100
you have, if you get rid of the mandate, then the whole thing collapses. Yeah. Unfortunately,
01:38:21.800
it was a different scenario when we were talking about that eight years ago. Uh, now, you know,
01:38:27.240
you don't necessarily want that just to fall apart and collapse on you without something for it to
01:38:32.540
fall into like the free market system. Though the mandate is what separates Obamacare from your
01:38:37.620
typical bad program and something that is absolutely unconstitutional and is an embarrassment that it
01:38:43.700
was enacted. The fact that they got rid of the mandate does, does change that. I think it's a
01:38:48.780
big, it's a move in the right direction, no matter what happens to Obamacare. Cause we have a lot of
01:38:52.300
crap heap programs where we spend a lot of tax dollars to do nothing. I mean, we got a lot of
01:38:55.760
that. There's a million of those. And, and you know, those have been around for a while. The mandate
01:39:00.440
forcing people to purchase a product is so ridiculously unconstitutional, uh, that I'm,
01:39:07.720
I'm, I'm very happy that that is gone. I will say. And that was a big part of it. He also was
01:39:12.240
a little self-deprecating, um, which is not, I didn't hear that part. Yeah. This is a Donald
01:39:16.400
Trump talking about his bald spot. That is, this is amazing for him. Wow. That's the first time I've
01:39:35.040
ever heard him mention a bald spot. Uh, I mean, that's self-deprecating that kind of stuff makes
01:39:42.120
him more likable. No question about it. Yeah. It shows he's, you know, he doesn't take himself
01:39:47.120
too seriously. He's human. Yeah. He's human. Yeah. I guess now, you know, people are speculating that
01:39:52.980
he just finally came out and said this cause he's been asked about this for years. People grabbed
01:39:57.980
his hair in interviews. I mean, it's been, why was CPAC the place where he, I don't, the only thing I've
01:40:02.680
heard, I've been, you know, the speculation is because of that video that came out a few, a couple
01:40:07.580
weeks ago, which I did not believe it first. I haven't seen the video. You haven't seen the video.
01:40:11.760
You haven't seen the video? I don't think so. Oh, you've got to see that. Of a bald spot?
01:40:14.540
Yeah. Yeah. Look at, just, just Google, just Google Trump's bald spot. You won't believe it.
01:40:19.500
It looks like, I didn't believe it. Yeah. We thought it was fake initially. It looks like
01:40:23.620
the Phantom of the Opera. He's walking up the steps. He had to say it then, right? I mean,
01:40:28.420
that's why he kind of had to. I, well, you know, I, I, look, he, his, there's a lot of times people
01:40:33.400
say to Donald Trump, you got to say this, you got to say this, and he doesn't do it. True. And so for him to
01:40:37.340
take a step kind of in a self-deprecating manner, um, I think is a really good step. It's, it makes
01:40:42.840
him more human, you know, definitely makes him more likable. Yeah. And definitely does. So the
01:40:47.280
video, if you haven't seen it is him walking up the steps of, uh, air force one, right? And you
01:40:52.240
know, the wind is, it's on a tarmac, so it's very windy and, and a flap opens up on the back
01:40:57.300
of his head. Oh no, really? Oh my gosh. Yeah. Have you not found it? Not yet. Oh, you have to see,
01:41:02.640
I want to see your, hear your reaction. It is, it's like, it's, it's amazing. I thought
01:41:11.460
it was fake because it's so bad the way it looks. It's so bad, but he seemingly handled
01:41:17.400
it pretty well. Handled it graciously in the moment, which is odd again, really good. Yeah.
01:41:23.900
It might, maybe he's grown into this job. That would be nice. Well, he's had a good week,
01:41:28.700
man. His, I mean, his, his, his, uh, deal with the guns was much better than the CNN
01:41:34.220
version of the conversation. I mean, that was, that was the way the media betrays all Trump
01:41:40.100
rallies. Yeah, exactly. They had switched and he did a good job with that. He was being
01:41:44.260
presidential. It'll be interesting to see. I mean, cause he's, he's taking, or he's signaling
01:41:48.700
steps that I don't agree with when it comes to the second amendment. Uh, and I'm concerned
01:41:55.040
about that. Um, but he hasn't done them yet. We'll see kind of what, where that goes. I
01:41:59.760
think, you know, right now the Republican Congress, which many of them are completely spineless,
01:42:05.180
right? Are sitting back and say, and looking for permission to vote for anti second amendment
01:42:10.440
legislation. They want to be able to say to people, look, we took this seriously and the
01:42:14.660
information changed and we're, we're going at, we, we, we have, it's common sense. We had
01:42:18.320
to do it. And the only way they'll be able to justify that to their constituency is if
01:42:23.380
Trump gives them permission. If Trump comes out and supports those things, then they'll
01:42:27.060
all fall in line. I think the same thing goes, if he opposes them, they'll all oppose them.
01:42:32.140
I mean, he really does lead, lead the leash. Yeah. Well, I mean, it, I mean, let me, let
01:42:37.300
me play something. Let me play, um, Cuomo, uh, versus Charles Cook, Charles Cook, who is
01:42:43.200
great. He's on this network from time to time. And he was part of the real news. Um, uh, he's
01:42:49.120
just a great thinker. Now listen to him and he's clear with logic. He's doing math. Cuomo
01:42:57.600
is doing common core math. Listen to this. I don't understand why there'd be resistance to,
01:43:03.380
you know, especially for lawful, lawful people. Why wouldn't you have all sales applicable to a
01:43:10.760
bound background check? Well, the first argument, and I think this is always a good thing to remember
01:43:15.660
when government gets involved, whether it's the war on terror or, or drugs is that, as I say,
01:43:20.020
there isn't a great deal of evidence that it works, uh, or that sheriffs prioritize it in,
01:43:24.720
in states that have them. Um, the second reason is that, uh, if acid has been suggested thus far,
01:43:31.100
it would effectively create a gun registry. Um, and gun registries are opposed, I think,
01:43:36.100
for good reason by, uh, those who have, uh, an interest. But you already have it for the majority
01:43:40.600
of sales. This would just be making it in all transactions. Why create a loophole when you don't need
01:43:45.080
one? It's practical impact is something to consider, but as a prophylactic device,
01:43:49.620
I just don't understand a good art, a good argument against it. Well, I think, as I say,
01:43:53.820
a good argument against it is that recent studies conducted, it should be said by gun control
01:43:58.300
advocates and written up by gun control advocates have conceded that there doesn't seem to be much
01:44:02.520
evidence that it does anything. And if we're trying to improve, uh, the situation on the ground
01:44:07.380
here, then that doesn't seem to listen to this logic from Chris. Well, and the argument for it would be,
01:44:11.980
you might as well try whatever you can because you have so many guns getting into the wrong sets
01:44:16.460
of hands. But Charles, this is, yeah, go ahead. Make your final point. Well, I think that you see,
01:44:21.380
I think that's where we have to be careful here because there is this argument in the aftermath
01:44:26.540
of mass shootings. And we saw a lot of it last night. And what I thought was an unhelpful town hall
01:44:31.040
held at the wrong time. Um, we see a lot of this argument, you have to do something, but of course,
01:44:36.780
we don't all agree. We need to do anything there at Marco Rubio came out last night against the idea
01:44:41.220
of say arming teachers. Now it wouldn't be a particularly convincing response to say, well,
01:44:45.540
why doesn't he just want to do something? He did say he wouldn't do certain things.
01:44:50.120
Yeah. No, I agree. But, but, but just saying, well, why don't we just do something? Why don't
01:44:54.140
we try that? There's nothing to lose. It's not a standard we apply across the board. No,
01:44:57.940
no, that's understood. Not arbitrary things. Absolutely. There has to be a reasonable
01:45:02.180
understanding. No, but look, Charles, what I'm saying, we agree. You should do things that are
01:45:07.200
calculated to make a real difference. You should base it on debate and data and research in the
01:45:12.660
area. There's no question about that. There's no reason just to throw, throw out any kind of
01:45:16.800
solution that won't work. But look, at the end of the day, it's a debate worth having. We need all
01:45:21.120
sides. And I appreciate you being here. Take it easy. You didn't say anything. You just lost the
01:45:27.300
argument. You just lost the argument. We agree. We need to make sure that we're looking at
01:45:31.760
research and data. Right. I just told you the research and data says it does nothing.
01:45:38.160
Right. But in the end, you know, he wanted to say, but in the end, we do need to do something.
01:45:43.260
Right. And by the way, that something is the thing I want. Yeah. No other thing, because there's lots
01:45:48.960
of other things out there that I don't think we should do to do something. But the thing I want
01:45:52.480
to do should be the something we should do. And I have to tell you, Charles, his response is,
01:45:57.120
well, you know, the president said armed teachers. That's doing something. Yeah. And you could see
01:46:06.360
Cuomo like immediately his body language. It just shifted to dismiss. Well, army teachers. Well,
01:46:11.840
that's just stupid. Well, wait, why don't we just try it? Let's just do something.
01:46:24.840
Pat Gray Unleashed coming up on the Blaze Radio and TV Network just a moment. Well, we think the
01:46:29.020
thing that you're suggesting is stupid. That's why we're dismissing it. You know, it's interesting. I
01:46:33.540
keep hearing this about the teachers and arming the teachers. And I'm not saying it's my top policy
01:46:38.280
prescription for this. But stop for a second. We keep hearing these same things come out of people's
01:46:44.560
mouths, even from teachers. They're like, I mean, I'm teaching algebra. I don't want to be
01:46:47.660
I don't want to be defending kids. I don't be pointing a Smith and Wesson while I'm teaching
01:46:55.360
algebra. You're not gonna be pointing it when you're teaching algebra. You're gonna be pointing
01:46:59.160
it when an active shooter is at your door. Correct. The same thing with the security situation with
01:47:05.600
the deputy. Yeah. He's out there and they're like, this proves that security at schools won't
01:47:11.680
work. The guy just stood outside and didn't do anything. Well, first of all, yes, it is a
01:47:16.140
requirement of the policy for the guy to go inside. Yes, granted. But again, take everybody
01:47:22.960
in that situation. You're a minute and a half into that. You have a choice to make. Would you
01:47:27.080
rather have a security personnel that's armed walking up to the building who may or may not
01:47:34.020
come inside? Or would you rather have nobody? Yeah. Nobody with guns inside. Nobody with guns.
01:47:40.160
Let me just say this. Why did we not have a problem when the airlines trained everyone
01:47:48.340
on the flight deck to use a gun after 9-11? Remember that? We were gonna have our pilots
01:47:56.600
have guns. Yep. And we had our Navy SEALs and all of the experts go in and train the people
01:48:03.980
on the flight deck how to use a gun. Then we hardened the door. Air marshals as well. And
01:48:11.400
we put air marshals in. Somebody on the plane with a gun. Well, you don't want a shootout
01:48:16.420
in an airplane. Yeah. Yeah. If it means we're all gonna die or he dies, yeah, I'm gonna go
01:48:22.780
for the shootout in the airplane. What you really don't want is a one-person shootout.
01:48:28.160
Those shootouts suck. Right. Because there's nothing you can do about it. Right. When one
01:48:32.100
person starts shooting, you want a two- or three- or four-person shootout. You want bullets
01:48:37.880
flying both ways once they start flying one way. Doesn't seem to be a problem to arm our
01:48:44.160
pilots. Why is it a problem to arm and train some teachers? I don't see a problem with it,
01:48:52.600
but they may not. Look, it's not going to solve every one of these things. No, it didn't like
01:48:56.380
security on premises. That was our problem. Everything worked when it came to this shooting
01:49:01.300
as far as security goes until the guy stayed outside. And maybe sometimes people will fail.
01:49:06.420
These are impossible situations to predict how you're going to act. But I mean, don't you want
01:49:11.820
the possibility of success? They're rejecting the possibility of success for the possibility of
01:49:17.920
failure. I would just like to say that the failure is not just on Scott Peterson, the sheriff's deputy.
01:49:24.680
Oh, no, no, no. But on the sheriff himself and whoever is training to not see this as a problem.
01:49:33.100
SimpliSafe. Home security system is, I mean, this is a little teeny company a few years ago with 10
01:49:48.180
employees. They've now transformed into the fastest growing home security company in the nation,
01:49:53.600
protecting over 2 million people. I have seen them in homes. I have seen them in businesses.
01:49:59.540
It is the new and more effective and quite honestly, much more economically feasible and
01:50:08.940
just wiser way to protect whatever it is you're trying to protect. Now, the system has been
01:50:14.600
completely rebuilt and redesigned. It now protects against power outages, down Wi-Fi, cut landlines,
01:50:21.280
the all new SimpliSafe. It's been completely redesigned to be practically invisible, but it is
01:50:27.280
not silent when there is an intruder. And here's what the most remarkable thing is. After all of
01:50:33.760
the years building this system, they've added so much, you still get it for the same fair and honest
01:50:38.780
price. 24-7 protection is still only $15 a month. There's no wires. There's no contract. There's no
01:50:46.080
strings. You own the system. It's smaller, faster and stronger. Visit SimpliSafeBEC.com and order the
01:50:54.160
brand new SimpliSafeBEC now. Supplies are limited. So SimpliSafeBEC.com. Protect your home and your
01:51:20.880
You want to know why, you know, you'll never be able to stop people, especially now that there's
01:51:29.380
3D printing. Listen to this story just broke. 28 firearms, 66,000 rounds of ammunition seized from
01:51:35.100
a man who was not supposed to have any of these weapons. 13 AR-15 style weapons he had, and 11 of
01:51:41.400
them were ghost guns, which were a short barrel AR-15 style fully automatic machine guns. Now,
01:51:48.980
how did he get those? Well, these guns are firearms that are untraceable by law enforcement due to their
01:51:54.620
lack of serial numbers because they are built by an individual, not a manufacturer. So someone built
01:52:00.640
these by 11 machine guns he had. Right. And just FYI, that's somebody building them. Now that we have
01:52:10.360
the plans out on the internet and 3D printing, you can print guns.