The Glenn Beck Program - August 17, 2023


Best of the Program | Guest: Sohrab Ahmari | 8⧸17⧸23

Topics
Hosted by
Guests
Mentioned
Best of the Program | Guests: Winston Marshall & Carol Roth | 8⧸16⧸23 Who Is 'Robert L. Peters' & Should He Be in Jail? | Guests: Tulsi Gabbard & Jason Whitlock | 8⧸18⧸23

Episode Stats


Length

53 minutes

Words per minute

145.51

Word count

7,732

Sentence count

520

Harmful content

Misogyny

2

sentences flagged

Toxicity

4

sentences flagged

Hate speech

8

sentences flagged


Summary

Summaries generated with gmurro/bart-large-finetuned-filtered-spotify-podcast-summ .

Glenn Beck and Alex Blumberg are joined by the author of Tyranny Inc., Saurabh Amari, to talk about the removal of the entire Apple Podcasts catalog and why it happened. Also, the latest on Maui.

Transcript

Transcript generated with Whisper (turbo).
Misogyny classifications generated with MilaNLProc/bert-base-uncased-ear-misogyny .
Toxicity classifications generated with s-nlp/roberta_toxicity_classifier .
Hate speech classifications generated with facebook/roberta-hate-speech-dynabench-r4-target .
Topics generated with Qwen2.5-3B-Instruct.
Hosts, guests, and mentioned names generated with spaCy (en_core_web_sm), reconciled against Wikidata.
00:00:00 Hey, we have a pretty amazing update on Maui that I don't think you're hearing everywhere.
00:00:05 We also give you the update on, are we on today on Apple, the podcast?
00:00:10 I think so.
00:00:11 Yeah, they've put our whole catalog back.
00:00:13 Well, with an exception of about 1,500 podcasts.
00:00:18 But on that, it's fully restored.
00:00:20 Why is that happening, Apple?
00:00:23 What exactly was the reason yesterday?
00:00:25 Because they said in Variety magazine, well, there was a copyright dispute.
00:00:31 No, you let us know on June 28th.
00:00:34 And on June 28th, three hours after you identified the problem, we solved the problem with your people. 0.99
00:00:43 So what was the problem exactly?
00:00:47 And why aren't all 3,300 podcasts back?
00:00:52 Well, we'll continue to follow that story.
00:00:55 Also, we have Saurabh Amari on with us.
00:00:58 He is the author of Tyranny, Inc.
00:01:00 He's a guy who I usually agree with, and I agree with him on the problem.
00:01:04 His book, however, is offering a solution that I don't agree with at all.
00:01:11 I don't know if you do, but it's a conversation that we on the right need to start having,
00:01:16 or we're going to go down a path that I don't necessarily think is a good one.
00:01:22 That's Tyranny, Inc.
00:01:24 Also, the latest on Maui.
00:01:26 We'll tell you the story on Maui.
00:01:28 All on today's podcast brought to you by Relief Factor.
00:01:32 You know when you try to explain what it's like to live with pain, and somebody who doesn't live in pain,
00:01:36 they're kind of like, oh yeah, I know, I got pain in my elbow too.
00:01:42 I just suck it up, buttercup.
00:01:44 Really?
00:01:45 Thank you.
00:01:46 I've lived it.
00:01:47 I can tell you the only thing that I found completely changed things for me was Relief Factor.
00:01:53 Relief Factor, if you're dealing with pain in your life, you feel like you've tried everything,
00:01:57 will you just try this for three weeks?
00:01:59 Just three-week quick start, $19.95.
00:02:01 Take it as directed.
00:02:03 It's a trial pack, not a drug, developed by doctors,
00:02:05 and hundreds of thousands of people have ordered Relief Factor,
00:02:08 and about 70% of them go on to order more.
00:02:10 ReliefFactor.com, ReliefFactor.com, or call 800-4-RELIEF, 800, the number 4-RELIEF.
00:02:18 Feel the difference with Relief Factor.
00:02:21 Here's a podcast.
00:02:29 You're listening to The Best of the Glenn Beck Program.
00:02:36 All right, so we talk about Apple.
00:02:39 Apple.
00:02:39 Here is what's happening with Apple.
00:02:44 Apple restored the episodes to their platform yesterday.
00:02:50 In case you haven't heard, Apple totally deplatformed me yesterday at about noon.
00:02:57 They removed every last episode from Apple Podcasts.
00:03:02 It was removed with no explanation why for several hours.
00:03:06 As soon as I heard the news, I posted a video to Twitter or X or whatever.
00:03:13 I'm never going to get used to that.
00:03:14 Is anybody really going to start calling it X?
00:03:16 I don't think so.
00:03:17 They're really doing the Prince thing with it, where it's like the artist formerly known as Prince.
00:03:21 Every article is like, X, the artist for the social media site formerly known as Twitter.
00:03:26 It's like, oh, great.
00:03:28 So you've taken a six or seven letter word, whatever it is, and you've shortened it to one and then added three sentences on to explain what it means.
00:03:39 Thanks a lot, Elon.
00:03:40 Appreciate it.
00:03:41 Anyway, I got into X yesterday, and I asked you to join me in demanding answers from Apple.
00:03:47 Well, thankfully, a lot of people came out in force.
00:03:51 Yeah.
00:03:51 We were trending on X all day with people on both the left and the right calling Apple out.
00:03:57 I was so happy to see so many people on the left who would post.
00:04:03 I totally disagree with him, but this is wrong.
00:04:09 Yes.
00:04:10 Thank you.
00:04:11 Thank you for that.
00:04:12 So thank you if you did any of it, because after six hours of you raising all kinds of ruckus online, Apple restored my show to their platform.
00:04:23 Well.
00:04:24 One thousand nine hundred and fifteen episodes of three thousand plus catalog.
00:04:30 Hmm.
00:04:31 So they removed at least a decade worth of content yesterday without explanation.
00:04:40 At least until we started making noise about it today, I read an article in Variety that said the podcast was removed because of a trademark dispute and quote.
00:04:52 It has since been resolved.
00:04:54 Really?
00:04:55 Really?
00:04:56 A trademark?
00:04:57 Wow.
00:04:57 Now, over three thousand episodes all over a trademark issue.
00:05:03 That is weird.
00:05:06 Not going to get into the weeds over this, but there was a trademark dispute on one episode.
00:05:12 They let us know on, I think, June 29th.
00:05:17 It was resolved within hours.
00:05:20 We're like, not really.
00:05:22 Now, if that is the reason that's one episode, we resolved it with them within hours.
00:05:31 In hours, why would you, why would you remove over three thousand episodes for a dispute with one?
00:05:41 It's a great question.
00:05:42 Unless you were the one filing the dispute saying someone's using my name.
00:05:46 There's no real reason to pull the episodes.
00:05:48 Yeah, don't pull those.
00:05:49 Yeah, no, of course not.
00:05:51 It doesn't explain why they would remove the entire catalog.
00:05:55 At least to me, it doesn't.
00:05:58 Apple still has not responded to that.
00:06:02 Yesterday is a prime example where I learned firsthand why the blaze is so important.
00:06:10 I learned the power of these middlemen.
00:06:15 If you're a conservative, the threat of deplatforming is always there.
00:06:20 Even in the background, like the sword of Damocles.
00:06:26 Is that how you say his name?
00:06:27 Damocles.
00:06:27 You remember the guy who was holding the sword over the head?
00:06:31 This is why we built the blaze.
00:06:34 I'm not going to have a sword over my head.
00:06:37 Not going to do it.
00:06:38 The show is always available on blaze TV.
00:06:44 I've told you in the past we need a direct relationship with you.
00:06:48 I ask you, please subscribe if you haven't already.
00:06:52 We have built a pirate ship.
00:06:54 Get on the ship.
00:06:57 I may be this.
00:06:58 Companies like Apple and Google and Meta can shut down your speech, our speech, literally with a keystroke.
00:07:08 The elites have always wanted to control what you see and what you hear.
00:07:13 Now, big tech is giving them the means to do it.
00:07:16 They have done this to several of us.
00:07:20 Since the Republicans have had Congress, they've been a little more shy.
00:07:25 But I will tell you, yesterday would have been a loss of about 3 million views.
00:07:35 If you're not getting the podcast from Apple, if that's where you normally go, there's about 3 million people that do that every day.
00:07:44 Uh, that's a problem.
00:07:47 That's a real problem.
00:07:49 If we lose touch with 3 million people.
00:07:52 Please, join our ranks.
00:07:56 We become stronger and we have more ability to resist big tech censorship and deliver the truth to the American people.
00:08:05 We want to be everywhere.
00:08:07 Everywhere anyone can possibly listen.
00:08:11 Because our target audience is everyone.
00:08:13 But our subscribers allow us to be truly independent.
00:08:18 So, if you're already a Blaze TV subscriber, thank you.
00:08:22 You are what, honestly, when that happened yesterday, there was no warning.
00:08:27 There have been no strikes.
00:08:29 There was nothing.
00:08:29 Just gone.
00:08:31 And everybody started pouring into my office going, Glenn, you're off Apple.
00:08:34 What happened?
00:08:36 I'm like, I don't know what happened.
00:08:37 What are you talking about off Apple?
00:08:39 Completely deleted the entire library.
00:08:42 Kind of your life flashes in front of your eyes.
00:08:45 And you're like, holy cow.
00:08:47 Are we going to be able to get messages to our audience?
00:08:51 Thank God Elon is at Twitter or X.
00:08:55 I like what he's doing with the censorship stuff.
00:08:57 Just not as much the naming stuff.
00:08:58 Yeah, I know.
00:08:59 But, I mean, it is important.
00:09:00 Like, you know, this one is pseudo-resolved.
00:09:03 I mean, you know, again, I put pseudo in there because only about half the episodes seem to be there.
00:09:08 But, okay, maybe who knows what that is.
00:09:11 My point, though, is that there's going to be a time where these things come off and they don't come back.
00:09:15 They don't come back.
00:09:16 And if we don't have contact with you, you won't know.
00:09:22 You won't know.
00:09:23 You won't know what happened to us if we don't have a direct line to you.
00:09:29 So, please, this is the biggest discount we've offered ever.
00:09:33 It will not be censored.
00:09:34 It will save you $30 off your one-year subscription when you use it at checkout.
00:09:38 We need you with us now more than ever.
00:09:41 I will tell you that I think something is – there's just a lot of things in my life that it's always a trend.
00:09:49 You know, when you're getting close to doing something really, really big, and I don't know what that is.
00:09:55 But when you're getting close to doing something big, there's all kinds of problems that keep cropping up, and we're in that kind of a period right now.
00:10:03 And I just said to a friend of mine who is coming in to work with me today, I said,
00:10:09 I have a feeling we're on the verge of something.
00:10:14 I don't know what it is, but my gosh, look at this string of coincidence.
00:10:22 Now, yesterday – I don't know if this had anything to do with it, but yesterday's podcast was,
00:10:27 who's the real crime family, Trump or Biden?
00:10:31 We are over the target on this, and we're not going to let it go.
00:10:40 So please join us.
00:10:42 By the way, when they restore the show in its entirety, then you can let up on Apple on X.
00:10:53 That's when you can go in and say, all right, Apple did the right thing.
00:10:58 But so far, 1,915 podcasts have been restored, and we are over 3,000.
00:11:05 It's about 33 and change.
00:11:08 So what's happening?
00:11:11 Now, this is something that I talked about in Dark Future,
00:11:19 and I want to read what I wrote just recently because it applies directly to this.
00:11:28 This is the example of what I was talking about in Dark Future, and it applies to you.
00:11:35 Important question coming in from our listeners, Glenn, here is,
00:11:38 why is Glenn talking about his podcast in the voice of Count Chocula?
00:11:43 And I thought that was an interesting question.
00:11:45 There will be no questions here.
00:11:46 From Dark Future, Chapter 5.
00:11:51 In the future, you will own nothing.
00:11:53 This is from my new book, Chapter 5.
00:11:56 To most, the idea of not knowing anything probably seems like a far-off concept,
00:12:02 especially when you think about it through the lens of capitalistic,
00:12:05 consumer-centric culture that we now live in.
00:12:08 How could we possibly shift toward a society like the one that's described in the
00:12:14 You'll Own Nothing article?
00:12:15 The answer is gradually, then all at once.
00:12:20 I say this with confidence because we already see this trend playing out in a number of industries.
00:12:26 For example, one aspect of our economy where the idea of owning nothing has developed the fastest
00:12:32 is in the entertainment industry.
00:12:35 I then highlight the dangers in the book of not owning physical media by talking about the rise of popularity in streaming services like Netflix and Spotify and Apple Podcasts.
00:12:57 And I write,
00:12:58 The data printed onto a disc or recorded on a cassette are there permanently.
00:13:04 If the physical media remains undamaged, I'll have access to that data forever.
00:13:10 This is not the case when dealing with streaming services.
00:13:14 The data for the movie as it exists on a streaming service servers, like those owned by Netflix, are fluid.
00:13:21 At any time, Netflix could take down Top Gun.
00:13:25 Its copyright owners could alter the movie, and then Netflix could upload it, re-upload it, without any warning to the consumer at home.
00:13:33 They can do this because you don't own the content.
00:13:36 They do.
00:13:37 Later in the same chapter, I wrote,
00:13:44 The music and podcast streaming service Spotify also has moderated content due to the social pressure.
00:13:51 Podcasting giant Joe Rogan had more than 100 episodes removed by Spotify because of an alleged instance of misinformation,
00:13:59 which included dangerous things like interviewing Dr. Robert Malone, a scientist who helped develop the mRNA vaccines.
00:14:07 Don't expect the censors to stop there.
00:14:12 Later, I wrote in the book,
00:14:14 The point of all of this is to say,
00:14:16 When you don't own physical media, that media is susceptible to change.
00:14:22 The corporations that do own the media can do whatever they want with it.
00:14:27 If a show contains a joke that is considered too cruel or tasteless by current societal norms, delete it.
00:14:34 If a movie's depiction of a person, gender, orientation, or race is no longer socially acceptable, change it.
00:14:40 If you hold a movie, show, or even a piece of music near and dear to your heart,
00:14:47 you might want to consider owning a physical copy.
00:14:51 Because nothing is stopping the corporation that owns it from altering or destroying it completely,
00:14:57 if the political winds blow hard enough.
00:15:00 Now, you might be thinking, as the reader of this book,
00:15:04 Glenn, why are you spending so much time talking about movies and streaming services?
00:15:09 I picked up this book to read about the future in the World Economic Forum.
00:15:13 What does this have to do with property rights and private ownership?
00:15:16 Think about what control these corporations have over your media when you don't own it.
00:15:24 Then imagine what they could do in a world where you don't own anything
00:15:28 and the corporation and governments own everything.
00:15:33 What happened yesterday with the Apple podcast on my program is exactly why ownership matters.
00:15:42 It is exactly why elites in the Biden administration, Davos, Wall Street firms like BlackRock,
00:15:48 want to consolidate property.
00:15:52 That's why they need ownership.
00:15:57 It's why the government is so eager to work hand-in-hand with giant corporations.
00:16:02 If you don't own the platform, the media, the news, or opinion product,
00:16:07 then you don't control it.
00:16:09 It can be altered without any warning.
00:16:12 Like it was yesterday, deleted from history, thousands of episodes,
00:16:17 over a decade of my work, for no real reason.
00:16:23 They can cancel it.
00:16:27 This is the future that is being imposed on the world.
00:16:31 And if you don't understand it,
00:16:33 the day will soon come when the only voices you hear
00:16:37 are approved by the ruling class and corporate elites.
00:16:42 Please join us at Blaze TV.
00:16:47 Please join us.
00:16:48 By the way, I just have to say thank you to a couple of people.
00:16:53 It was really remarkable, all of the people that came out yesterday to help.
00:17:01 Looks like I may have to go elsewhere to listen to podcasts
00:17:04 if Apple is going to remove Glenn Beck's program from the podcast.
00:17:07 A whole lot of us are going to say,
00:17:09 we found issue with Apple.
00:17:10 From Mike Lee, he followed it up with,
00:17:12 Glenn Beck having such a large audience,
00:17:14 you'd think Apple would be reluctant to take this step.
00:17:17 Sometimes such behavior can be observed with companies
00:17:20 that face so little competition in a particular field
00:17:23 that they don't fear alienating millions of customers.
00:17:27 J.D. Vance also said,
00:17:28 need some answers from Apple ASAP.
00:17:31 This looks like an awful lot like a major American corporation
00:17:34 engaging in election interference.
00:17:37 Donald Trump Jr. said,
00:17:38 big tech censorship is the biggest threat to free speech
00:17:41 and free expression in America.
00:17:43 Apple's now engaging in open election interference
00:17:46 by censoring Glenn Beck for telling the truth
00:17:49 about Joe Biden's corruption.
00:17:52 Jeremy Boring from the Daily Wire wrote,
00:17:54 this must be a mistake.
00:17:55 Glenn is one of the best men in the business
00:17:57 and perhaps the greatest living broadcaster.
00:18:00 Well, he said living.
00:18:01 So he said that.
00:18:03 I was like, good God.
00:18:04 That's really sad.
00:18:05 And I saw that comment.
00:18:08 I was like, oh, that's crazy.
00:18:10 Wait a minute.
00:18:11 Wait a minute.
00:18:12 Ed Krasenstein, who noted he disagrees with me
00:18:15 much of the time, said,
00:18:17 conservative commentator Glenn Beck
00:18:19 has reportedly been banned from Apple iTunes
00:18:22 without any explanation.
00:18:24 First, I must say, I completely disagree
00:18:26 with so much of what Glenn Beck has to say.
00:18:29 And I think a lot of his politics are absurd.
00:18:31 With that said, if Beck actually has been banned
00:18:34 merely for voicing his free speech,
00:18:36 I think it's wrong of Apple to do.
00:18:38 It'll be interesting to see what reason Apple gives
00:18:41 for this banning or if it was done by mistake.
00:18:44 I'm unaware of any recent major controversy
00:18:46 or hateful over-the-top message
00:18:48 that Beck has spread over the airwaves.
00:18:49 Yeah, we haven't had one of those in like two weeks.
00:18:51 I know.
00:18:52 So what's the problem?
00:18:53 But thank you for that.
00:18:54 We have to return to the country
00:18:56 that my father always held up to me and said,
00:19:00 you know, I so disagree with what you're saying,
00:19:03 but I will fight to the death for your right to say it.
00:19:07 This is the best of the Glenn Beck program,
00:19:09 and we really want to thank you for listening.
00:19:12 I want to start with a story
00:19:15 that is up in glennbeck.com,
00:19:17 and it is all about you.
00:19:20 The wildfire that raged across Maui
00:19:23 became the deadliest fire in U.S. history,
00:19:25 claiming more than 100 lives.
00:19:27 I think that number is going to go up.
00:19:30 As search and rescue missions continue
00:19:32 throughout the burnt remains of the historic town Lahaina,
00:19:36 in times of profound tragedy,
00:19:38 Glenn's audience has rallied around those
00:19:41 enduring profound need and suffering
00:19:43 through generous giving.
00:19:45 On air this week,
00:19:46 Glenn rallied the troops again
00:19:48 to support the grieving communities in Maui,
00:19:50 challenging his audience to raise more money
00:19:52 than the U.S. government aid package.
00:19:55 And you're doing just this.
00:19:57 I want you to listen to this.
00:19:58 As of 8.52 p.m. yesterday,
00:20:02 you, Glenn's audience,
00:20:04 raised $472,824
00:20:08 for the people of Maui
00:20:10 via Glenn's nonprofit Mercury One.
00:20:13 That's nearly half a million dollars
00:20:15 raised within the first couple of days
00:20:18 to our call of action
00:20:19 to match the government's aid package,
00:20:22 which has now been raised
00:20:24 to a whopping $2.3 million through FEMA.
00:20:28 That means this audience alone
00:20:30 has done one-fifth of the lifting
00:20:33 the entire FEMA and United States government
00:20:36 has done.
00:20:37 One-fifth.
00:20:40 All of those proceeds,
00:20:42 every single penny,
00:20:43 will go towards the residents
00:20:45 as they grieve and rebuild
00:20:46 in the tough days ahead.
00:20:48 Through your committed support,
00:20:51 we are well on its way,
00:20:53 our way to surpassing
00:20:54 the government's package.
00:20:56 This is something that I said
00:20:58 when I first started Mercury One.
00:21:00 If we want the government to do less,
00:21:02 then we have to do more.
00:21:04 I would love
00:21:06 if this audience,
00:21:07 we'll never be recognized for it,
00:21:09 but it doesn't matter.
00:21:10 We're not doing it for that.
00:21:11 I would love to be able to say
00:21:13 that this audience
00:21:15 raised more for Maui
00:21:18 than the federal government did.
00:21:21 Why do we need
00:21:22 the federal government involved
00:21:24 in all of our lives?
00:21:26 Now, yesterday,
00:21:28 so you know,
00:21:29 our website was hacked into,
00:21:31 and Apple dropped my podcast.
00:21:35 So all of this was done yesterday
00:21:38 just on the power of the radio program
00:21:40 or people listening on other things
00:21:43 other than Apple,
00:21:45 the radio,
00:21:46 Blaze TV,
00:21:47 and other than Apple,
00:21:50 podcast listeners.
00:21:52 We can do so much more,
00:21:55 and I want to tell you
00:21:56 how bad things
00:21:58 really truly are.
00:22:02 I got a note yesterday
00:22:04 from somebody,
00:22:06 and they said,
00:22:08 Glenn, I just got this
00:22:09 about 10 minutes ago.
00:22:10 Things are deteriorating rapidly.
00:22:12 We have a corporate accountant
00:22:14 who does a lot of business
00:22:16 in Lahaina.
00:22:18 I sent him a clip
00:22:19 of a girl talking about
00:22:20 what was happening there.
00:22:21 Here was his response.
00:22:23 Total disaster
00:22:24 in every way.
00:22:26 Fire hydrants
00:22:27 did not work.
00:22:28 No one was evacuated.
00:22:30 No police or fire crew
00:22:32 helping evacuate.
00:22:33 I can't even file
00:22:34 insurance claims
00:22:36 for 20 businesses
00:22:37 businesses
00:22:37 as the area
00:22:38 is locked down
00:22:39 by National Guard,
00:22:41 so insurance
00:22:41 injustors
00:22:42 can't even observe
00:22:43 the ruins
00:22:44 in person.
00:22:45 Question mark,
00:22:46 question mark,
00:22:46 question mark.
00:22:48 No claim
00:22:49 can be filed,
00:22:50 question mark.
00:22:51 I've been dealing
00:22:52 with this all week,
00:22:54 and I'm told
00:22:54 their bodies everywhere,
00:22:56 and for a week
00:22:56 they've been hiding
00:22:57 the death toll.
00:22:58 No local leadership.
00:23:00 Maui,
00:23:01 now taken over
00:23:01 by the feds,
00:23:03 none of these people
00:23:04 will have enough money
00:23:05 to rebuild.
00:23:06 Too expensive
00:23:06 as everything
00:23:07 has to be
00:23:08 new building codes,
00:23:10 that'll mean rich people
00:23:11 will buy the land
00:23:12 and will be even
00:23:13 less housing
00:23:14 for locals.
00:23:15 It will end up
00:23:16 being the worst
00:23:17 natural disaster
00:23:18 in our history.
00:23:19 95% of the island
00:23:21 is untouched by this.
00:23:23 A rebuild of Lahaina
00:23:24 will take 10 years.
00:23:26 The cleanup alone
00:23:27 will take 2-3 years,
00:23:28 as there is no
00:23:29 infrastructure
00:23:30 or labor
00:23:31 to do it.
00:23:33 That's the note
00:23:34 I received
00:23:35 last night.
00:23:37 I want you to know
00:23:38 that because of you,
00:23:40 we are already
00:23:42 doing amazing things.
00:23:45 We have
00:23:46 Operation Barbecue Relief,
00:23:48 Samaritan's Purse,
00:23:49 Operation Blessing,
00:23:50 ITDRC,
00:23:52 Harvest Church,
00:23:54 which,
00:23:54 that's Greg Laurie's
00:23:55 church in California,
00:23:56 but he also has
00:23:57 Sister Church in Maui.
00:23:58 Drew Friedrich,
00:23:59 Chief Operating Officer,
00:24:01 I got a note from him
00:24:02 from Operation Blessing,
00:24:03 he said,
00:24:04 I want you to know
00:24:06 you are the first
00:24:06 organization on the ground
00:24:08 to provide aid.
00:24:10 Operation Blessing,
00:24:11 we have helped them
00:24:13 to get there.
00:24:17 Let's see,
00:24:18 Samaritan's Purse,
00:24:19 they wrote in,
00:24:21 thank you,
00:24:22 thank you,
00:24:22 thank you,
00:24:23 the generosity
00:24:24 of your audience
00:24:25 in Mercury One,
00:24:27 which has helped us
00:24:28 airlift 17 tons
00:24:29 of supplies
00:24:30 supplies to Maui
00:24:32 in the wake
00:24:32 of the deadliest fire.
00:24:34 Supplies on that DC-8
00:24:35 cargo aircraft
00:24:36 include hygiene kits,
00:24:38 solar lights,
00:24:38 cooking kits,
00:24:39 plastic tarp,
00:24:40 equipment needed
00:24:41 for us
00:24:42 to help in the aftermath
00:24:43 of this disaster
00:24:44 as residents are allowed
00:24:45 to return to their communities.
00:24:47 Samaritan's Purse volunteers
00:24:49 will help homeowners
00:24:50 sift through the ashes
00:24:51 for any sentimental
00:24:52 keepsakes
00:24:54 that may have survived
00:24:55 the flames.
00:24:56 also Operation Barbecue Relief
00:24:58 is there
00:24:59 and they provide food,
00:25:00 hot food,
00:25:01 for any of the workers
00:25:03 and also any of the families
00:25:05 who have been displaced.
00:25:08 Thank you,
00:25:09 thank you,
00:25:11 thank you.
00:25:12 The attack on our website
00:25:14 did not slow you down
00:25:16 yesterday
00:25:16 and I find it interesting
00:25:17 that two things
00:25:20 happened yesterday.
00:25:21 As I just said,
00:25:23 we want to raise
00:25:25 more money
00:25:26 than the federal government
00:25:27 because we want them
00:25:28 to do less.
00:25:29 As I was in that commercial,
00:25:32 went into that commercial break,
00:25:34 hackers hacked into
00:25:37 mercury1.org
00:25:39 and took the entire site down.
00:25:43 Luckily,
00:25:43 we have a very good security team
00:25:45 and it went right back up
00:25:47 probably within an hour or so.
00:25:50 But our staff over at Mercury1
00:25:52 just started taking phone calls,
00:25:54 people making donations.
00:25:57 This is one
00:25:58 that we really want
00:25:59 to be
00:25:59 helpful with
00:26:02 because these are not
00:26:03 rich people on Hawaii.
00:26:05 This is a
00:26:05 local
00:26:07 historic town
00:26:09 and what's being done to it
00:26:11 I think you can find
00:26:13 in Dark Future,
00:26:14 the book that I wrote.
00:26:15 But let me just give you
00:26:17 the facts
00:26:17 of what happened
00:26:19 because it is
00:26:21 not what's being
00:26:22 reported.
00:26:24 So I want to give you
00:26:24 something from
00:26:25 the
00:26:26 von Mises
00:26:27 people.
00:26:29 This is from
00:26:29 Mises.org.
00:26:30 I think it is
00:26:31 such a great
00:26:33 article that I should
00:26:34 read it
00:26:35 verbatim.
00:26:36 The most destructive
00:26:38 natural disasters
00:26:39 are never
00:26:41 100%
00:26:42 natural.
00:26:44 Human
00:26:44 choices,
00:26:45 land use,
00:26:46 and government
00:26:47 policies play
00:26:48 a big role
00:26:49 in how harmful
00:26:50 hurricanes,
00:26:50 tornadoes,
00:26:51 earthquakes,
00:26:52 flash floods,
00:26:52 and wildfires
00:26:53 are to affect
00:26:55 communities.
00:26:56 Though the details
00:26:57 are still emerging,
00:26:59 it has become
00:27:00 clear that
00:27:00 government failure
00:27:02 did much
00:27:03 to make this
00:27:04 disaster worse
00:27:05 and possibly
00:27:06 even started it.
00:27:08 While the
00:27:09 so-called
00:27:10 experts are
00:27:10 blaming climate
00:27:11 change and
00:27:12 in the process
00:27:13 demanding that
00:27:14 government grab
00:27:15 even more power
00:27:16 and authority
00:27:17 to someday
00:27:18 give us
00:27:19 better weather,
00:27:21 the destructiveness
00:27:21 of this fire
00:27:22 was the product
00:27:23 of an all-powerful
00:27:24 and all-incompetent
00:27:26 regime.
00:27:28 The specific
00:27:29 origins of this
00:27:30 fire are still
00:27:30 being investigated,
00:27:31 but there is
00:27:33 much we already
00:27:34 know.
00:27:35 The city of
00:27:36 Lahaina sits
00:27:36 on the west
00:27:37 coast of
00:27:37 Maui, Hawaii's
00:27:38 second largest
00:27:39 island.
00:27:40 It's surrounded
00:27:40 by grassland,
00:27:42 much of which
00:27:43 is owned
00:27:44 by the state.
00:27:46 This is really
00:27:46 important.
00:27:48 Nearly a decade
00:27:49 ago, Hawaii
00:27:50 Wildlife Management
00:27:51 Organization,
00:27:52 a research
00:27:52 non-profit,
00:27:53 warned the
00:27:54 Hawaiian government
00:27:55 that the area
00:27:56 around Lahaina
00:27:57 was extremely
00:27:59 fire-prone due
00:28:00 to frequent
00:28:01 downslope winds,
00:28:03 steep terrain,
00:28:04 and dry grass.
00:28:06 Little to
00:28:06 nothing was
00:28:07 done by the
00:28:08 state government
00:28:09 to address
00:28:10 these risks.
00:28:11 A subsequent
00:28:11 report in
00:28:12 2020 added
00:28:14 that an
00:28:14 invasive species
00:28:15 of exceptionally
00:28:17 flammable grass
00:28:18 was prevalent
00:28:19 in the
00:28:19 surrounding fields
00:28:21 and that
00:28:21 passing hurricanes
00:28:22 created strong
00:28:23 winds known
00:28:25 to fuel
00:28:25 wildfires on
00:28:27 the islands.
00:28:28 Early last
00:28:29 week,
00:28:30 Hurricane Dora
00:28:31 crossed the
00:28:32 ocean south
00:28:33 of Hawaii.
00:28:34 By early
00:28:35 Tuesday morning,
00:28:36 August 8,
00:28:37 winds as fast
00:28:38 as 60 miles
00:28:39 an hour were
00:28:39 blowing down
00:28:40 the slopes
00:28:40 of West Maui
00:28:42 mountains into
00:28:43 Lahaina.
00:28:44 Around sunrise,
00:28:47 a large fault
00:28:48 was detected
00:28:50 in the power
00:28:51 grid,
00:28:52 indicating a
00:28:53 downed power
00:28:54 line.
00:28:55 Twenty minutes
00:28:56 later,
00:28:56 the first reports
00:28:57 of fire came
00:28:58 in from an
00:28:59 area around
00:29:00 the road,
00:29:01 uphill and
00:29:02 upwind from
00:29:03 the city.
00:29:04 The area where
00:29:05 flames were
00:29:05 first spotted
00:29:06 is full of
00:29:08 electrical
00:29:08 infrastructure,
00:29:10 mostly operated
00:29:11 by Hawaiian
00:29:12 Electric,
00:29:14 the state's
00:29:15 monopoly
00:29:16 electricity
00:29:17 supplier.
00:29:18 This included
00:29:19 a substation
00:29:20 and a multitude
00:29:22 of power lines.
00:29:23 Most of the
00:29:24 land in the area
00:29:25 is owned by
00:29:26 the state of
00:29:27 Hawaii except
00:29:27 for a parcel
00:29:28 belonging to the 0.97
00:29:29 estate of one
00:29:30 of Hawaii's
00:29:30 last princesses.
00:29:32 This parcel
00:29:33 housed on a
00:29:34 solar farm
00:29:35 supplying
00:29:36 electricity to
00:29:37 the Hawaiian
00:29:38 electric substation.
00:29:40 Early last
00:29:41 year,
00:29:41 NPR published
00:29:42 a glowing
00:29:42 article about
00:29:43 the solar
00:29:44 project,
00:29:44 praising it
00:29:46 as the
00:29:46 direct result
00:29:47 of government
00:29:48 regulation
00:29:49 crafted to
00:29:49 help transition
00:29:50 Hawaii to
00:29:51 100% renewable
00:29:52 power by
00:29:54 2045.
00:29:55 But,
00:29:56 on the
00:29:56 morning of
00:29:57 August 8,
00:29:58 as winds
00:29:59 hammered the
00:30:00 old wooden
00:30:00 utility poles,
00:30:02 this highly
00:30:03 electrified area
00:30:04 in the dry
00:30:05 grasses above
00:30:06 Lahaina was
00:30:07 quickly becoming
00:30:08 dangerous,
00:30:09 yet no formal
00:30:11 procedure was
00:30:12 in place to
00:30:13 shut off sections
00:30:14 of the grid in
00:30:15 the face of
00:30:16 severe fire
00:30:16 risks.
00:30:17 As a result,
00:30:19 29 fully
00:30:20 energized poles
00:30:22 fell across
00:30:23 West Maui
00:30:24 that day.
00:30:25 Say that
00:30:26 again,
00:30:27 29 fully
00:30:30 energized
00:30:31 electrical poles.
00:30:34 Have you ever
00:30:34 seen one of
00:30:35 those go down?
00:30:35 they tend
00:30:37 to throw
00:30:37 sparks.
00:30:39 Even with
00:30:40 the down
00:30:41 poles in
00:30:41 the way,
00:30:42 the first
00:30:42 firefighters on
00:30:43 the scene
00:30:44 met with
00:30:44 some early
00:30:45 success.
00:30:45 Around 9
00:30:46 a.m.,
00:30:47 the county
00:30:47 fire department
00:30:48 declared the
00:30:49 fire 100%
00:30:50 contained.
00:30:51 But the
00:30:52 message to
00:30:52 residents
00:30:53 included an
00:30:54 ominous
00:30:54 request.
00:30:56 The county's
00:30:56 water pumps
00:30:57 were powered
00:30:58 by electricity,
00:31:00 much of which
00:31:01 was frantically
00:31:02 being turned
00:31:03 off to
00:31:04 deactivate the
00:31:05 down lines.
00:31:06 Officials
00:31:07 asked the
00:31:07 public to
00:31:08 conserve water
00:31:09 to preserve
00:31:10 water pressure.
00:31:12 But by
00:31:12 mid-afternoon,
00:31:13 a flare-up
00:31:14 brought the
00:31:15 fire back to
00:31:16 life on the
00:31:16 Lahaina bypass,
00:31:18 a major road
00:31:18 that heads
00:31:19 straight into
00:31:19 town.
00:31:20 The flames
00:31:21 moved swiftly
00:31:22 into Lahaina
00:31:23 at 4.46 p.m.
00:31:25 one minute
00:31:26 after the
00:31:27 county government
00:31:28 finally set out
00:31:29 an alert to
00:31:30 warn the city's
00:31:31 population
00:31:31 largely without
00:31:33 power about
00:31:34 the flare-up
00:31:35 that had
00:31:35 occurred over
00:31:36 an hour before.
00:31:38 To make
00:31:38 matters worse,
00:31:40 county officials
00:31:40 failed to
00:31:41 activate emergency
00:31:43 sirens,
00:31:44 leaving residents
00:31:45 unaware of the
00:31:46 danger bearing
00:31:47 down on them.
00:31:48 And as
00:31:49 firefighters
00:31:49 heroically rushed
00:31:50 toward the
00:31:51 flame and
00:31:52 trying to save
00:31:53 their own
00:31:53 community,
00:31:54 they found
00:31:54 that there was
00:31:55 little to no
00:31:56 water pressure
00:31:57 in the fire
00:31:57 hydrants,
00:31:58 which quickly
00:31:59 ran dry.
00:32:01 So far I
00:32:03 haven't heard
00:32:04 anything about
00:32:04 global warming.
00:32:06 With a single
00:32:07 backed up
00:32:08 highway leading
00:32:09 out of the
00:32:10 city,
00:32:10 many residents
00:32:11 of Lahaina
00:32:11 had nowhere
00:32:13 to go.
00:32:14 Some scrambled
00:32:14 into the ocean
00:32:16 to escape the
00:32:16 smoke and the
00:32:17 flames,
00:32:18 but in the
00:32:19 end,
00:32:19 many couldn't
00:32:20 get out.
00:32:21 At least
00:32:21 99 people
00:32:22 have been
00:32:23 confirmed dead,
00:32:24 and as of
00:32:25 this writing,
00:32:26 making this
00:32:26 the deadly
00:32:27 American wildfire
00:32:28 in over a
00:32:28 century,
00:32:29 in addition,
00:32:30 2,207
00:32:32 buildings were
00:32:32 destroyed,
00:32:33 with property
00:32:34 damages expected
00:32:35 to reach
00:32:35 $5.5 billion.
00:32:37 To review,
00:32:39 a power
00:32:40 company shielded
00:32:41 from competition
00:32:42 by the state
00:32:43 placed electrical
00:32:45 infrastructure among
00:32:46 highly flammable
00:32:48 state-owned
00:32:49 grass fields
00:32:50 above the
00:32:51 historic city
00:32:52 of Lahaina,
00:32:54 which the
00:32:54 government was
00:32:55 twice warned
00:32:57 were highly
00:32:57 susceptible to
00:32:58 fire,
00:32:59 and once
00:33:00 fire broke
00:33:01 out,
00:33:02 a combination
00:33:02 of defective
00:33:03 water
00:33:04 infrastructure,
00:33:05 terrible
00:33:05 communication
00:33:06 by government
00:33:07 officials,
00:33:08 and only one
00:33:09 escape route
00:33:10 doomed the
00:33:11 people of
00:33:11 Lahaina to
00:33:12 the worst
00:33:12 wildfire
00:33:13 experienced in
00:33:14 this country
00:33:14 in over a
00:33:15 hundred years.
00:33:16 This was
00:33:17 government
00:33:18 failure
00:33:19 through and
00:33:20 through.
00:33:21 In human
00:33:22 action,
00:33:23 Ludwig von
00:33:24 Mises explains
00:33:25 that on the
00:33:26 market,
00:33:26 the ultimate
00:33:28 source of
00:33:29 profits is
00:33:30 foresight,
00:33:31 the ability
00:33:32 to anticipate
00:33:33 future
00:33:34 conditions,
00:33:35 and economic
00:33:36 loss occurs
00:33:37 when market
00:33:38 actors fail
00:33:40 to anticipate
00:33:40 the future.
00:33:41 The possibility
00:33:43 of riches
00:33:43 if one succeeds
00:33:44 and the
00:33:45 guarantee
00:33:46 of painful
00:33:47 failures
00:33:48 if one
00:33:48 doesn't,
00:33:49 forces producers
00:33:50 and service
00:33:51 providers on
00:33:52 the market
00:33:52 to constantly
00:33:54 weigh risks
00:33:55 and opportunities.
00:33:57 Government,
00:33:58 however,
00:33:59 immunizes itself
00:34:00 from the
00:34:01 profit and
00:34:01 loss system
00:34:02 and therefore
00:34:03 from much
00:34:04 of the need
00:34:05 to weigh
00:34:06 risk.
00:34:07 Sure,
00:34:07 some county
00:34:08 officials may
00:34:09 resign because
00:34:09 of this,
00:34:10 and the share
00:34:11 price of
00:34:12 Hawaiian electric
00:34:12 may dip,
00:34:13 but the people
00:34:14 of Maui will
00:34:15 be forced to
00:34:16 keep compensating
00:34:17 the very
00:34:18 organizations that
00:34:19 have failed
00:34:19 them,
00:34:20 and there is
00:34:21 nothing natural
00:34:22 about that kind
00:34:23 of a disaster.
00:34:23 Now,
00:34:25 I want you
00:34:26 to take this
00:34:27 beyond Maui.
00:34:30 Why are we
00:34:31 still in the
00:34:32 financial troubles
00:34:33 that we were
00:34:34 in in 08?
00:34:35 Why are we
00:34:36 still looking
00:34:37 at banking
00:34:38 collapses?
00:34:39 I'll tell you
00:34:40 why.
00:34:41 Because the
00:34:42 banks weren't
00:34:42 held responsible.
00:34:44 No one felt
00:34:45 the actual
00:34:46 pain
00:34:47 except you.
00:34:50 Why are
00:34:51 our
00:34:51 schools
00:34:52 failing us
00:34:54 because the
00:34:55 teachers unions
00:34:56 are in bed
00:34:57 with the
00:34:57 Department of
00:34:58 Education,
00:34:58 and no one
00:35:00 is held
00:35:00 responsible.
00:35:02 Nobody pays
00:35:03 the price
00:35:03 for this
00:35:04 education
00:35:04 except you
00:35:06 and your
00:35:06 children.
00:35:08 Afghanistan.
00:35:09 Why did all
00:35:09 those people
00:35:10 die?
00:35:11 Don't know
00:35:11 because no
00:35:12 one was
00:35:13 held
00:35:13 responsible.
00:35:15 Inflation.
00:35:16 It's the
00:35:16 government in
00:35:17 bed with the 0.51
00:35:17 Fed,
00:35:18 and no one
00:35:19 is held
00:35:20 responsible.
00:35:21 Crime on
00:35:22 the streets,
00:35:23 no one is
00:35:23 held
00:35:23 responsible.
00:35:24 Crime and
00:35:25 corruption in
00:35:26 D.C.,
00:35:26 no one is
00:35:27 held
00:35:27 responsible.
00:35:29 The media
00:35:29 lies and
00:35:30 lies and
00:35:31 lies,
00:35:32 and no
00:35:32 one is
00:35:33 held
00:35:34 responsible.
00:35:36 All of
00:35:37 these things
00:35:38 is the
00:35:38 government
00:35:39 in bed
00:35:40 with private
00:35:41 corporations
00:35:42 or unions,
00:35:43 and they
00:35:45 don't have
00:35:46 to pay a
00:35:46 price because
00:35:47 the government
00:35:49 is in bed
00:35:51 with them.
00:35:52 The government
00:35:53 never has to
00:35:54 pay a price
00:35:54 because they
00:35:55 can just
00:35:56 print more
00:35:56 money.
00:35:58 The only
00:35:59 one that
00:35:59 pays a
00:36:00 price is
00:36:00 you,
00:36:01 and in
00:36:01 this
00:36:02 particular
00:36:02 case,
00:36:03 the poor
00:36:04 people of
00:36:06 Lahaina in
00:36:07 Maui.
00:36:08 Where are
00:36:09 they going
00:36:10 to go?
00:36:11 Because I
00:36:11 can guarantee
00:36:12 you if
00:36:12 Dark Future
00:36:13 is right,
00:36:14 the government
00:36:15 is going to
00:36:15 take that
00:36:16 land and
00:36:17 make it
00:36:17 into a
00:36:18 national
00:36:18 park or
00:36:19 something like
00:36:19 that.
00:36:22 Please help
00:36:24 the people
00:36:25 in Lahaina
00:36:26 today.
00:36:27 Any donation
00:36:28 is welcome,
00:36:29 but let's
00:36:31 raise money
00:36:32 and show
00:36:33 the average
00:36:34 person,
00:36:35 the people
00:36:35 who actually
00:36:36 lost their
00:36:37 homes and
00:36:38 their lives,
00:36:39 that we
00:36:40 actually care.
00:36:41 Go to
00:36:42 mercuryone.org,
00:36:43 mercuryone.org,
00:36:45 and donate
00:36:46 now.
00:36:47 A disaster
00:36:47 relief fund
00:36:48 at mercuryone.org.
00:36:51 The best of
00:36:52 the Glenn Beck
00:36:52 program.
00:36:54 Now,
00:36:54 Saurabh,
00:36:55 not often do
00:36:56 I have a
00:36:57 friend that
00:36:58 says,
00:36:58 you know,
00:36:59 Woodrow
00:36:59 Wilson was
00:37:00 great,
00:37:01 but I'm
00:37:03 making the
00:37:03 exception with
00:37:04 you,
00:37:05 and I
00:37:05 really want
00:37:06 to go
00:37:06 through your
00:37:07 book.
00:37:08 I've enjoyed
00:37:08 reading it.
00:37:09 Well,
00:37:11 thank you
00:37:11 for having
00:37:12 me back,
00:37:12 Glenn.
00:37:13 I'm happy
00:37:13 to talk
00:37:14 about old
00:37:14 Woodrow.
00:37:15 Okay.
00:37:17 So,
00:37:17 first of all,
00:37:18 outline the
00:37:19 problem that
00:37:20 you see.
00:37:22 Yeah,
00:37:23 sure.
00:37:23 It's a
00:37:24 problem of
00:37:25 economic
00:37:26 coercion that
00:37:27 ordinary people
00:37:28 face in
00:37:29 daily life.
00:37:31 We as
00:37:31 Americans,
00:37:32 but especially
00:37:33 as the
00:37:33 conservative
00:37:34 movement,
00:37:35 in the last
00:37:35 few generations
00:37:36 since Goldwater
00:37:37 Reagan,
00:37:38 has come
00:37:39 to think
00:37:39 of
00:37:40 coercion
00:37:41 and unjust
00:37:42 coercion
00:37:43 as only
00:37:44 what government
00:37:44 does.
00:37:46 In recent
00:37:46 years,
00:37:47 we've come
00:37:47 face-to-face
00:37:48 with a
00:37:50 new mode
00:37:50 of coercion
00:37:51 which is
00:37:52 either directed
00:37:54 exclusively from
00:37:55 the private
00:37:55 sector,
00:37:56 from large
00:37:57 corporations,
00:37:58 banks,
00:37:59 etc.,
00:37:59 or some
00:38:00 combination of
00:38:01 those types
00:38:02 of businesses
00:38:02 in collusion
00:38:04 with government.
00:38:05 So there are
00:38:05 really big
00:38:06 headline-grabbing
00:38:07 cases
00:38:07 that I
00:38:08 talk about
00:38:09 in the
00:38:09 book like
00:38:10 the censorship
00:38:12 of the
00:38:12 Hunter Biden
00:38:13 story by
00:38:13 Twitter and
00:38:14 Facebook where
00:38:15 I was at
00:38:15 kind of the
00:38:16 eye of the
00:38:16 storm when
00:38:17 that happened
00:38:17 and I came
00:38:18 and spoke
00:38:18 with you on
00:38:19 the show
00:38:19 about it
00:38:20 just as it
00:38:20 was unfolding
00:38:21 and the
00:38:23 debanking
00:38:24 of people
00:38:25 whose political
00:38:26 views aren't
00:38:27 acceptable to
00:38:28 the liberal
00:38:29 left,
00:38:30 etc.,
00:38:30 etc.
00:38:31 But there are
00:38:32 also less
00:38:33 visible kinds
00:38:34 of this,
00:38:34 right?
00:38:35 So for
00:38:35 example,
00:38:36 and this will
00:38:36 get us
00:38:37 into the
00:38:37 weeds and
00:38:38 I won't
00:38:38 go too
00:38:38 far into
00:38:39 the weeds,
00:38:39 but the
00:38:40 use of
00:38:41 commercial
00:38:42 arbitration
00:38:43 in the
00:38:43 workplace,
00:38:43 just to
00:38:44 give one
00:38:44 example,
00:38:45 arbitration
00:38:46 is good,
00:38:47 it's a
00:38:47 kind of
00:38:47 a neutral
00:38:48 mediator
00:38:48 comes between
00:38:49 two merchants
00:38:51 of relatively
00:38:51 equal bargaining
00:38:52 power,
00:38:53 they agree not
00:38:53 to go to
00:38:54 court if they
00:38:54 have a dispute,
00:38:55 but to
00:38:56 privately
00:38:56 resolve it.
00:38:57 That's fine,
00:38:58 that's been
00:38:58 around since
00:38:59 1925 with
00:39:00 the Federal
00:39:00 Arbitration
00:39:01 Act.
00:39:01 But in
00:39:02 recent decades,
00:39:04 increasingly
00:39:04 workers'
00:39:05 complaints are
00:39:05 corralled into
00:39:06 these types
00:39:07 of courts,
00:39:08 privatized
00:39:09 courts,
00:39:09 where like
00:39:10 Ernst & Young
00:39:10 or Bank
00:39:11 of America
00:39:11 get to
00:39:12 set the
00:39:12 rules,
00:39:13 and you
00:39:13 as the
00:39:14 worker are
00:39:14 far less,
00:39:15 you don't
00:39:15 have the
00:39:16 same bargaining
00:39:16 power where
00:39:17 you can say
00:39:17 no to this
00:39:18 or dispute
00:39:19 this,
00:39:19 and it
00:39:20 means that
00:39:20 you can't
00:39:20 vindicate
00:39:21 rights that
00:39:21 you otherwise
00:39:22 have,
00:39:23 I don't
00:39:23 know,
00:39:23 like the
00:39:24 Fair Labor
00:39:24 Standards
00:39:25 Act or
00:39:25 whatever
00:39:25 kind of
00:39:26 economic
00:39:27 rights you
00:39:27 might think
00:39:27 of become
00:39:28 blocked.
00:39:30 And so
00:39:30 that's the
00:39:31 problem.
00:39:32 I talk about
00:39:32 the kind of
00:39:33 hot headline
00:39:34 grabbing cases
00:39:34 like Amazon
00:39:36 making a lot
00:39:38 of money out
00:39:38 of the pandemic
00:39:39 because they
00:39:40 were deemed
00:39:41 essential whereas
00:39:42 lots of small
00:39:43 businesses weren't,
00:39:44 and then oppressing
00:39:45 their own workers
00:39:45 and their kind of
00:39:46 hellish Dickensian
00:39:47 warehouses.
00:39:49 I talk about
00:39:49 those, but
00:39:50 much of the
00:39:51 book is about
00:39:51 these less
00:39:52 visible kinds
00:39:53 of private
00:39:54 coercion where,
00:39:55 for example,
00:39:56 the Sackler
00:39:57 family of
00:39:58 notoriety
00:39:59 associated with
00:39:59 the opioid
00:40:00 crisis was
00:40:02 able to use
00:40:03 the coercive
00:40:04 elements of
00:40:04 U.S.
00:40:05 bankruptcy law
00:40:05 to shield
00:40:06 their assets
00:40:07 from states
00:40:09 and from
00:40:09 hospitals,
00:40:10 from insurers
00:40:11 and ordinary
00:40:11 Americans who
00:40:12 had been harmed
00:40:12 by the opioid
00:40:13 crisis.
00:40:14 So I just
00:40:14 suggest that,
00:40:15 and here
00:40:16 where the
00:40:16 kind of
00:40:17 bit that you
00:40:18 mentioned about
00:40:18 Woodrow Wilson
00:40:19 comes in,
00:40:19 that conservatives
00:40:20 used to
00:40:21 actually be
00:40:22 more attuned
00:40:23 to this
00:40:23 problem.
00:40:25 In other
00:40:25 words,
00:40:26 Wilson was not
00:40:27 the only one.
00:40:27 There was a
00:40:27 kind of
00:40:28 tradition in
00:40:29 the GOP,
00:40:30 figures like
00:40:31 Teddy Roosevelt,
00:40:32 then especially
00:40:32 after the New
00:40:33 Deal,
00:40:33 figures like
00:40:34 Eisenhower and
00:40:35 Nixon,
00:40:35 who recognized
00:40:36 that there is
00:40:37 such a thing
00:40:38 as private
00:40:38 tyranny,
00:40:39 and the way
00:40:40 to take
00:40:41 charge of
00:40:42 it or to
00:40:42 tame it
00:40:43 is by
00:40:44 greater
00:40:44 democratic
00:40:45 control and
00:40:47 sort of
00:40:47 political response
00:40:48 to giant
00:40:49 market actors
00:40:50 that otherwise
00:40:50 get to set
00:40:51 their own
00:40:51 prices,
00:40:52 their oligopolies,
00:40:53 so that their
00:40:54 prices that they
00:40:55 set,
00:40:55 how they
00:40:56 treat their
00:40:56 workers and
00:40:57 stuff,
00:40:57 is not
00:40:58 that kind
00:40:59 of free
00:40:59 market
00:41:00 arcadia,
00:41:02 that paradise
00:41:03 that still
00:41:03 was described
00:41:04 by Adam
00:41:04 Smith in
00:41:05 the late
00:41:05 18th
00:41:06 century.
00:41:07 The markets
00:41:08 are much
00:41:08 more complex,
00:41:09 much more
00:41:09 concentrated,
00:41:10 so it
00:41:10 requires
00:41:11 greater
00:41:12 state
00:41:13 efforts
00:41:13 to protect
00:41:14 us from
00:41:14 being
00:41:15 debanked
00:41:16 by a
00:41:17 large
00:41:17 bank the
00:41:17 way Nigel
00:41:18 Farage
00:41:18 was in
00:41:19 Britain.
00:41:19 So here's
00:41:21 my question
00:41:22 to you,
00:41:22 because this
00:41:23 is the
00:41:23 debate that
00:41:24 I think
00:41:25 we're
00:41:26 having now.
00:41:27 Are we
00:41:28 going to
00:41:28 go back
00:41:29 to a
00:41:30 constitution
00:41:30 that really
00:41:31 hasn't been
00:41:31 used in
00:41:32 100 years,
00:41:33 and are
00:41:35 we going
00:41:35 to reset
00:41:36 back to
00:41:37 its factory
00:41:37 settings,
00:41:38 or are we
00:41:39 going to
00:41:40 develop
00:41:40 something
00:41:41 entirely new?
00:41:42 And the
00:41:42 left has
00:41:42 already made
00:41:43 their choice.
00:41:44 They are,
00:41:45 and I think
00:41:45 you would
00:41:45 agree with
00:41:46 me,
00:41:46 I think,
00:41:48 that we
00:41:49 are right
00:41:49 now a
00:41:51 pretty fascistic
00:41:53 kind of
00:41:54 country,
00:41:54 where the
00:41:55 government is
00:41:55 in bed with
00:41:56 these corporations,
00:41:58 and they're
00:41:59 doing the
00:41:59 bidding for
00:42:00 one another,
00:42:01 so they can
00:42:01 get things
00:42:02 done.
00:42:02 And if you
00:42:03 play ball,
00:42:03 then you
00:42:04 get money,
00:42:04 and you
00:42:05 get all
00:42:05 kinds of
00:42:06 perks.
00:42:06 If you
00:42:06 don't play
00:42:07 ball,
00:42:07 you're out
00:42:07 of business.
00:42:08 Would you
00:42:08 agree with
00:42:09 that?
00:42:10 Well,
00:42:10 I actually
00:42:11 do want to
00:42:12 go back to
00:42:13 our
00:42:13 constitutional
00:42:13 tradition.
00:42:14 I would
00:42:14 only suggest
00:42:15 that our
00:42:16 constitutional
00:42:17 tradition is
00:42:18 more complex
00:42:19 than some,
00:42:21 I would
00:42:22 say,
00:42:22 doctrinaire
00:42:23 libertarian
00:42:23 free market
00:42:24 types suggest.
00:42:25 In other
00:42:26 words,
00:42:27 our
00:42:27 constitution
00:42:28 shaped men
00:42:30 like Alexander
00:42:30 Hamilton,
00:42:31 and it was
00:42:32 very much
00:42:33 seen as a
00:42:36 developmental
00:42:36 state,
00:42:37 right?
00:42:37 Because
00:42:37 Hamilton and
00:42:39 John Marshall,
00:42:40 very influential
00:42:41 Supreme Court
00:42:42 justice early
00:42:42 on,
00:42:43 they were
00:42:44 determined that
00:42:44 the United
00:42:45 States wouldn't
00:42:45 become like a
00:42:46 backwater for
00:42:47 Britain where
00:42:48 all they get
00:42:49 is natural
00:42:49 resources here
00:42:50 and they
00:42:50 treat us as
00:42:51 a captive
00:42:52 market for
00:42:53 Britain's own 0.99
00:42:54 industrial
00:42:55 development and
00:42:56 industrial
00:42:57 manufacturing
00:42:58 products.
00:42:58 So they did
00:42:59 all sorts of
00:42:59 things like
00:43:00 setting in
00:43:01 place a
00:43:02 first bank
00:43:02 of the
00:43:03 United States
00:43:03 to ensure
00:43:05 a steady
00:43:06 supply of
00:43:07 credit that
00:43:07 was disciplined
00:43:08 and wasn't
00:43:08 kind of wild.
00:43:09 They created
00:43:10 internal
00:43:13 improvements and
00:43:14 import
00:43:14 substitutions
00:43:15 and tariffs
00:43:15 and so on
00:43:16 and so
00:43:16 forth.
00:43:16 This was
00:43:17 all within
00:43:17 the founding
00:43:19 generation or
00:43:20 within living
00:43:21 memory of the
00:43:21 founding generation.
00:43:22 So the idea
00:43:23 of a state
00:43:24 that kind of
00:43:26 takes charge of
00:43:26 the economy for
00:43:27 the general
00:43:28 welfare wasn't
00:43:30 alien to the
00:43:31 founding generation.
00:43:32 And of course
00:43:33 then you have
00:43:33 like the
00:43:34 Jacksonians come 1.00
00:43:35 around because
00:43:36 then they
00:43:36 noticed that
00:43:37 that bank
00:43:38 now had
00:43:38 become the
00:43:38 second bank
00:43:39 of the United
00:43:39 States had
00:43:40 sort of become
00:43:40 a vehicle for
00:43:41 the wealthy.
00:43:42 So Andrew
00:43:42 Jackson waged
00:43:44 war against
00:43:45 it and sort
00:43:45 of said hey
00:43:46 we need
00:43:46 greater political
00:43:47 control over
00:43:48 these institutions
00:43:49 that kind of
00:43:50 can shape the
00:43:51 lives of yeoman
00:43:52 farmers and
00:43:53 workers and so
00:43:54 on and so
00:43:55 forth.
00:43:55 So because the
00:43:58 economy and
00:43:59 politics can't 0.60
00:44:00 be so neatly
00:44:00 ever separated
00:44:01 the American
00:44:03 traditions never
00:44:04 thought of the
00:44:05 economy as this
00:44:06 autonomous zone of
00:44:08 perfect freedom
00:44:09 and competition.
00:44:09 they realize that
00:44:10 it's all bound
00:44:11 up with what
00:44:12 government does
00:44:13 or chooses not
00:44:14 to do.
00:44:15 So I'm just
00:44:16 arguing for a
00:44:17 more complex
00:44:17 reading of the
00:44:18 American tradition.
00:44:19 So here is the
00:44:21 issue and I think
00:44:22 our founders came
00:44:23 down to this.
00:44:25 Where are the
00:44:26 better angels
00:44:28 now in
00:44:29 Google,
00:44:30 Facebook,
00:44:32 Apple?
00:44:33 Where are the
00:44:34 better angels in
00:44:35 Washington?
00:44:36 Where are the
00:44:37 better angels in
00:44:38 the media?
00:44:40 Where are they?
00:44:43 Well,
00:44:44 you know,
00:44:44 unfortunately,
00:44:45 I would just say
00:44:46 that the founders
00:44:47 could be pretty
00:44:48 cynical about
00:44:50 human nature.
00:44:51 And so they
00:44:51 had, you know,
00:44:52 as Madison
00:44:53 famously wrote,
00:44:54 you know,
00:44:55 if men were
00:44:55 angels, you
00:44:56 wouldn't need
00:44:56 government.
00:44:57 But as it is,
00:44:58 men are not 0.65
00:44:59 angels.
00:45:00 And so although
00:45:01 Lincoln was
00:45:03 obviously the
00:45:04 better angels
00:45:06 guy,
00:45:06 he expressed
00:45:09 that as a
00:45:09 sentiment to
00:45:10 call forth,
00:45:11 you know,
00:45:11 the best of
00:45:12 us.
00:45:13 He was
00:45:14 somebody that
00:45:16 was very,
00:45:17 very alone
00:45:18 and really
00:45:20 an aberration.
00:45:21 You know,
00:45:22 the man 0.90
00:45:24 is an animal. 0.83
00:45:26 He is an animal
00:45:27 and he is
00:45:28 driven by many
00:45:29 things.
00:45:30 At the very
00:45:30 bottom,
00:45:31 it's food and
00:45:32 water and
00:45:32 survival.
00:45:33 But as he
00:45:34 becomes more and
00:45:35 more powerful,
00:45:36 he is driven by
00:45:37 money,
00:45:38 power over
00:45:39 people,
00:45:40 fame,
00:45:41 and those
00:45:42 things all
00:45:43 corrupt.
00:45:44 They all 1.00
00:45:44 corrupt. 0.96
00:45:45 And our
00:45:46 problem is,
00:45:47 is that we
00:45:48 have everybody,
00:45:49 it seems,
00:45:50 at the top
00:45:51 has been
00:45:52 corrupted one
00:45:53 way or
00:45:54 another.
00:45:55 And the
00:45:56 reason why it
00:45:58 is corrupt,
00:45:58 I believe,
00:45:59 is because the
00:46:00 government can
00:46:02 be bought off
00:46:03 by giant
00:46:04 corporations and
00:46:05 little people
00:46:06 don't have the
00:46:07 money to buy
00:46:08 them off.
00:46:09 So there's no
00:46:09 representation.
00:46:11 The people who
00:46:13 are running for
00:46:13 office, they
00:46:14 don't care what
00:46:15 the people do.
00:46:16 They'll say
00:46:16 whatever they
00:46:17 have to to
00:46:18 get them to
00:46:19 vote for them.
00:46:20 But they don't
00:46:20 actually care or
00:46:21 like those people.
00:46:22 They're not
00:46:23 representing.
00:46:24 They're representing
00:46:24 themselves.
00:46:26 So everything
00:46:27 that is happening
00:46:28 is a corruption
00:46:29 of us not
00:46:31 putting the
00:46:32 shackles on a
00:46:34 powerful government
00:46:35 but letting,
00:46:36 quite honestly,
00:46:37 the Woodrow
00:46:37 Wilson
00:46:38 administrative
00:46:39 state,
00:46:40 where no
00:46:41 one answers
00:46:42 for the
00:46:43 wrong,
00:46:45 just letting
00:46:46 it grow.
00:46:47 Yep.
00:46:48 So, first
00:46:49 of all, the
00:46:49 bit that I
00:46:50 quote from
00:46:50 Wilson is
00:46:51 just to say
00:46:51 that during
00:46:52 wartime,
00:46:53 during World
00:46:53 War I,
00:46:54 whether you
00:46:54 agree in the
00:46:55 U.S.
00:46:55 entry into
00:46:55 World War I
00:46:56 or not,
00:46:57 he showcased
00:46:58 that you can
00:46:59 bring government,
00:47:00 labor,
00:47:01 management,
00:47:02 businesses
00:47:02 together to
00:47:03 say how do
00:47:04 we build up
00:47:06 the whole
00:47:06 economy and put
00:47:07 it on a war
00:47:08 footing and be
00:47:09 able to deliver
00:47:09 material to
00:47:10 Europe and
00:47:11 men and so
00:47:12 on and so
00:47:12 forth,
00:47:13 logistics.
00:47:14 And that
00:47:15 model is now
00:47:19 woven through
00:47:19 the American
00:47:20 tradition and it
00:47:21 finds its
00:47:22 fullest flowering
00:47:23 in the deal.
00:47:23 But then, as I
00:47:24 said, Eisenhower
00:47:25 went even further
00:47:26 on some of this
00:47:27 kind of logic of
00:47:28 government, labor,
00:47:30 workers, and
00:47:31 then management and
00:47:32 business all
00:47:32 coming together to
00:47:33 make decisions for
00:47:34 the general welfare
00:47:35 of the whole,
00:47:35 which, again,
00:47:36 because of that
00:47:37 Hamiltonian streak
00:47:38 in the founding
00:47:39 is not some
00:47:40 obnoxious and
00:47:41 weird thing.
00:47:42 But the problem
00:47:42 is that I
00:47:44 think that the
00:47:45 conservative
00:47:46 movement has,
00:47:48 because it's,
00:47:49 especially, again,
00:47:50 since Goldwater
00:47:51 Reagan says,
00:47:51 I reject the
00:47:52 administrative say,
00:47:53 all of that.
00:47:55 We don't
00:47:56 take part in it.
00:47:57 We don't, like,
00:47:58 actively try to
00:47:59 shape it.
00:47:59 So it comes
00:48:00 down like a,
00:48:00 it only comes
00:48:01 down like a
00:48:02 boot on our
00:48:02 faces.
00:48:03 And that's,
00:48:03 the frustration
00:48:04 is understandable.
00:48:05 I mean, I'm not,
00:48:06 I'm no fan of
00:48:07 vaccine mandates,
00:48:07 and I'm on the
00:48:08 record about all
00:48:09 of that.
00:48:10 But, you know,
00:48:11 the bottom line
00:48:12 is that already
00:48:15 by the 19th
00:48:15 century, we had
00:48:16 an unbelievably
00:48:17 complex economy.
00:48:18 And you had,
00:48:19 if you, if left
00:48:20 to its own
00:48:21 devices, you
00:48:21 would have very
00:48:23 few people
00:48:23 concentrating power
00:48:25 and wealth to
00:48:25 the detriment of
00:48:26 the farmer, the
00:48:27 debtor, the
00:48:28 worker, and so
00:48:29 on and so forth.
00:48:30 And that
00:48:30 complexity requires
00:48:32 equally complex
00:48:33 government, because
00:48:34 Congress can't,
00:48:35 like, regulate
00:48:37 the minutiae of
00:48:38 the railroad
00:48:38 business.
00:48:39 It can just
00:48:39 broadly say,
00:48:40 well, the
00:48:40 railroad should
00:48:41 be this and
00:48:41 that.
00:48:42 But to deal
00:48:42 with the
00:48:43 railroad business
00:48:43 at the granular
00:48:44 level, you need
00:48:45 the complexity of
00:48:47 the administrative
00:48:47 state.
00:48:49 You know, and I
00:48:49 think a lot of
00:48:50 conservatives who
00:48:50 say, well, this
00:48:52 is just all
00:48:53 unconstitutional, I
00:48:53 don't want any
00:48:54 of it, I invite
00:48:55 them to take the
00:48:56 first flight after
00:48:57 the, like,
00:48:58 Federal Aviation
00:48:59 Administration
00:49:00 has been abolished,
00:49:01 or to, you
00:49:02 know, all
00:49:02 to see what
00:49:04 their neighborhoods
00:49:05 are like once
00:49:05 police is abolished,
00:49:06 right?
00:49:07 All of this sort
00:49:07 of service.
00:49:07 Police?
00:49:08 Nobody's talking,
00:49:09 nobody in the
00:49:10 conservative side is
00:49:11 talking about
00:49:12 abolishing police.
00:49:13 Well, I mean, I
00:49:13 hear about, like,
00:49:14 you know, FBI
00:49:15 abolition.
00:49:16 Oh, yeah.
00:49:17 I'm fully on
00:49:18 board for that.
00:49:20 Fully on board.
00:49:20 So, totally.
00:49:21 I agree insofar
00:49:22 as the FBI has
00:49:23 become this sort
00:49:24 of lawless
00:49:25 agency that's
00:49:26 used to, again,
00:49:27 Glenn, remember,
00:49:28 I'm on the
00:49:29 right.
00:49:29 I know, I
00:49:30 know, no, no.
00:49:31 Right.
00:49:32 So, Rob, I'm not.
00:49:33 You know, there are
00:49:33 things that the FBI
00:49:34 does besides
00:49:35 persecuting, you
00:49:36 know, Trumpians
00:49:37 that is actually
00:49:38 pretty valuable.
00:49:39 So, we're not
00:49:40 prepared to give
00:49:40 that stuff up.
00:49:41 So, even like
00:49:42 Vivek Ramaswani,
00:49:43 who's called for
00:49:44 abolition of the
00:49:45 FBI, is calling
00:49:46 for some other
00:49:47 agency that would
00:49:48 do the things
00:49:49 that the FBI
00:49:49 is supposed to
00:49:50 do.
00:49:51 So, the point
00:49:51 is that
00:49:52 administrative state
00:49:53 is, to some
00:49:54 extent, unavoidable.
00:49:55 It's a sort of
00:49:55 extension of
00:49:56 Congress's will
00:49:57 in a complex
00:49:58 society and
00:49:59 economy.
00:50:00 How do we deal
00:50:00 with this
00:50:01 complexity?
00:50:01 Well, you've
00:50:02 got to delegate
00:50:02 it to these
00:50:03 experts.
00:50:03 But, if we
00:50:04 don't take part
00:50:05 in it on the
00:50:05 right, if we
00:50:06 don't try to
00:50:07 shape it,
00:50:07 then we get
00:50:08 So, Rob, we
00:50:09 are having the
00:50:10 same conversation
00:50:11 that our founders
00:50:12 had with
00:50:13 Hamilton.
00:50:13 This is the
00:50:14 same argument.
00:50:14 And it will
00:50:15 never go away
00:50:16 because it's
00:50:16 the original
00:50:17 argument.
00:50:19 Let me just
00:50:19 ask you this.
00:50:20 It is great.
00:50:21 I'm enjoying
00:50:22 having you on.
00:50:23 I hope you
00:50:24 don't feel
00:50:25 otherwise.
00:50:25 I know, I know.
00:50:26 How do we
00:50:27 avoid centralizing
00:50:28 power to the
00:50:29 extent that it
00:50:32 causes us to
00:50:33 be vulnerable to
00:50:34 the bad guy
00:50:35 grabbing the
00:50:36 reins?
00:50:38 Yep.
00:50:38 So, I mean,
00:50:39 I think that
00:50:39 one way that
00:50:41 certainly the
00:50:42 book, which as
00:50:42 you can tell
00:50:43 from what I'm
00:50:44 saying is heavily
00:50:45 focused on the
00:50:46 economy, is we
00:50:48 need to promote
00:50:50 a high-wage
00:50:51 manufacturing economy
00:50:53 like we had, you
00:50:55 know, in the
00:50:55 mid-century era, in
00:50:56 the mid-20th century
00:50:57 era.
00:50:58 And we were told
00:50:59 that, oh, it's
00:50:59 inevitable, we all
00:51:00 can only either do
00:51:01 services or financial
00:51:03 industry or these
00:51:04 like apps, like
00:51:06 porn apps.
00:51:06 Right.
00:51:07 And we deliberately
00:51:08 gave up our
00:51:08 own manufacturing.
00:51:09 Correct.
00:51:10 When you have a
00:51:10 high-wage economy
00:51:11 that's where workers
00:51:13 are dignified and
00:51:15 they're paid well and
00:51:15 they're skilled like
00:51:16 we did, again, we
00:51:17 did in the mid-century
00:51:18 era, they're not so
00:51:20 at the mercy of the
00:51:21 government either.
00:51:22 They're not so
00:51:23 powerless.
00:51:24 So what the problem
00:51:24 right now is we have
00:51:25 a low-wage, high-welfare
00:51:29 economy.
00:51:30 What that means is not
00:51:31 that the welfare net is
00:51:32 all that generous, it
00:51:33 actually can be kind of
00:51:34 miserly because you have
00:51:35 to pass all these tests
00:51:36 and so forth.
00:51:37 But the point is that
00:51:37 the typical worker, the
00:51:39 working poor or like the
00:51:40 bottom half of the
00:51:41 country in many ways, in
00:51:43 order to make ends meet,
00:51:44 they have to rely on a
00:51:45 high share of all kinds
00:51:46 of welfare that doesn't
00:51:48 come from their job, it
00:51:49 comes from their
00:51:49 taxpayer.
00:51:50 And that puts you at
00:51:52 the mercy, not just of
00:51:53 course of the boss,
00:51:54 because you're very
00:51:55 vulnerable, anything that
00:51:56 happens, you get fired,
00:51:57 but it also puts you at
00:51:58 the mercy of the
00:52:00 welfare administrator and
00:52:02 more broadly of the
00:52:03 administrative state.
00:52:03 So if we, I mean, I
00:52:05 think conservatives are
00:52:06 coming around to this
00:52:07 that, hey, we didn't
00:52:08 have to ship off
00:52:09 manufacturing to like
00:52:10 Vietnam and China, but
00:52:12 it's not like, it's not
00:52:13 like, you know, China's 0.90
00:52:15 brutal labor laws and
00:52:17 horrible government are a 0.99
00:52:19 natural competitive
00:52:20 advantage.
00:52:21 It's just that, it's just
00:52:22 how they run their
00:52:23 country and we made a
00:52:24 choice to ship off our
00:52:25 jobs.
00:52:26 I think here where we
00:52:27 can agree on is the
00:52:28 importance of restoring a
00:52:31 manufacturing high-wage
00:52:32 economy.
00:52:33 I mean, limits on
00:52:35 immigration help with
00:52:36 that, you know, because
00:52:37 if there's always a
00:52:39 reserve of poorly paid
00:52:41 labor who's willing to do 0.86
00:52:42 things for less, then
00:52:43 that's, you know, it
00:52:44 weakens our workers.
00:52:46 The book is called
00:52:47 Tyranny Eek, and so,
00:52:48 Rob, I hope we continue
00:52:49 our conversation.
00:52:50 I disagree with you
00:52:52 pretty wholeheartedly,
00:52:54 but I will fight to the
00:52:56 death for your right to
00:52:57 say it, and I hope we
00:52:58 can have more
00:52:59 conversations with this
00:53:00 attitude on the
00:53:02 program with you.
00:53:03 Thank you.
00:53:04 You're very kind, Glenn.
00:53:05 Thank you.
00:53:06 Bye-bye.
00:53:06 Na na na na