Andrew Klavan is a commentator, a novelist, a best-selling author, screenwriter, radio playwright, and the winner of the Edgar Award. His latest book, The Truth and Beauty, is a look into how poetry can inform our relationship with God.
00:00:00.000Today's guest I am thrilled to have on. He is human, he's conservative, and he's who I want to be when I grow up.
00:00:13.780He is brilliant. He is a commentator, a novelist in multiple genres, best-selling author, screenwriter, radio playwright, and the winner of the Edgar Award.
00:00:26.460I don't know who Edgar is, but I bet it's better than Oscar.
00:00:30.000Whoever he was. He's so good that he made a career in Hollywood as a conservative, and they started getting dicey.
00:00:38.760His True Crime book was turned into a movie directed by Clint Eastwood.
00:00:44.180Other films based on his book have featured an impressive array of actors and directors.
00:00:48.980His most recent project is The Covenant, an upcoming multi-season TV series that shows us the stories of the Old Testament without the Hollywood influence.
00:00:59.560His latest book, The Truth and Beauty, is a look into how poetry can inform our relationship with God.
00:02:39.400You are the hero of every preborn baby in this nation and the ambassador for eternal life for every mom, dad, and family that walks in to every preborn partner clinic.
00:03:27.760I don't know how many people I have told when people say, tell me interesting people you've met or, you know, who's really stuck out.
00:03:37.640And I say, always Andrew Clavin is not only intimidating because he's so smart, but he is also one of the most honest and genuine people I know.
00:04:10.640Well, this was something that ate at me for, it must have been over a year.
00:04:14.560When I started doing my podcast for the Daily Wire, I was completely inexperienced and I was making jokes, my usual kind of, you know, funny stuff.
00:04:25.040And I made a couple of jokes about you.
00:04:26.720They were jokes that I have made to your face.
00:04:28.740They're jokes that I've made on the blaze.
00:04:30.180When you started the blaze, you hired me to do satirical things.
00:04:32.680I used to do these jokes about how crazy you are.
00:04:34.820And I would say, I would say to your staff, is Glenn going to mind my calling him crazy?
00:07:23.840Instead of, you know, oh, you're just doing this because, you know, Ben Shapiro told you to or whatever it is they say, because it is offensive.
00:07:31.460I mean, at this point, I figure my reputation walks in front of me.
00:07:34.300Like anybody who knows me knows that it ain't so.
00:08:47.280It was an amazing experience, especially as it was coming up because we're all kind of packed together in a little space.
00:08:53.720And then Trump came along and there was so much to talk about, so much to figure out.
00:08:56.880Nobody had ever seen anything like him before.
00:08:58.820We were yelling at each other, screaming at each other, but it was all very friendly.
00:09:01.660And it was all, it helps you think, you know, it's, I mean, part of thinking is talking, you know, is conversation, which is one of the problems in our country right now is nobody talks to us.
00:09:10.480Right. And if, if you can't talk, if you can't question, what are we really, you know, you can't, you cannot move without questioning.
00:09:18.680The one thing that I want to, that I think makes you different is that you are a God guy.
00:10:01.480These poets specifically, these are the romantic poets for a brief period on the little island of England.
00:10:07.500Six of the greatest poets who ever lived, Keats and Shelley and Wordsworth and Coleridge and Byron, were all living at the same moment, all writing in the same moment.
00:10:15.340And they were writing in a moment, which was incredibly like this one.
00:10:20.320We had, they had the French Revolution, but we had the 60s where everything changed and we thought it was going to be paradise.
00:10:27.160It all collapsed. It all became a terror.
00:10:29.560It became, for us, it became the Cold War.
00:10:31.180For them, it became the Napoleonic War.
00:10:32.860And it was all surrounding this issue of faith, the fact that faith had gone out of the world.
00:10:38.360And these poets were basically trying to say, if the age of reason has led to a reign of terror, what did we do wrong?
00:10:49.300You know, Wordsworth was a big supporter of the revolution.
00:10:51.580And then it just became a bloodletting.
00:11:07.140And when that happens and you're not a cradle Christian, you look at some of this stuff in the gospel, you think, like, I don't know what this guy is talking about.
00:11:13.800You know, he says, turn the other cheek.
00:33:22.900I want to drive and I want it, you know, in the gym.
00:33:25.820All of it, because this is this is this life that you Keats, one of the great poets that I talk about here.
00:33:32.480He called life the veil of soul making.
00:33:35.040It is the place where you are created as a soul in life.
00:33:38.580And this is a guy who lived to be about 25, died horribly in obscurity, failed at everything he ever tried and wrote some of the greatest poetry literally since Shakespeare.
00:34:10.660Wordsworth became a conservative and was canceled.
00:34:13.100I mean, he was I mean, you talk about cancel culture.
00:34:15.120They were some of their great poems written about what a horrible person Wordsworth is because he became a conservative after the revolution.
00:34:21.840And though Keats was not really a political person at all, some of his friends were radicals.
00:34:28.200And so the conservative press came after him and he was just ripped to pieces.
00:34:32.520Some of the worst reviews you will ever read.
00:34:34.740And the last book he wrote before he died, he actually said he had trained to be a surgeon, an apothecary.
00:34:42.080And he actually said, if this book doesn't make it, I'm just going to have to go back to apothecary school.
00:34:47.700It is one of the greatest works of literature that any human being has ever produced.
00:35:33.740Well, my theory about Frankenstein, as Mary Shelley said, and many people have said that it's about a man who tries to be God by making a human being.
00:35:41.720But that's not really true, because people make human beings all the time.
00:35:45.740They use the materials they have and they make human beings.
00:35:47.840But what Frankenstein, what Victor Frankenstein makes is he makes somebody without a woman.
00:35:52.620And Mary Shelley was this lovely, young, very feminine girl who grew up with a feminist mother, one of the first feminists, Mary Wollstonecraft, and a father who was a deep, real radical.
00:36:11.740She ran off with the poet, Percy Shelley, who believed in free love.
00:36:15.380And basically, she watched as free love destroyed every woman that she had ever met.
00:36:20.720You know, I mean, Shelley left his wife.
00:36:22.180His wife drowned herself with a child.
00:36:24.480You know, it's just like free love turned out to be a nightmare.
00:36:27.500You know, they thought everybody was going to be free.
00:36:29.300And one night she and Shelley and Byron are in Italy because they've they've been basically thrown out of England and they're all getting together.
00:36:38.440And it's a summer, a really stormy summer.
00:36:41.460And there are lightning storms and they're getting together in these in Byron's mansion, which is still there.
00:36:47.220The castle, the mansion, Diodati, still out there.
00:36:51.600And they would get together and they would just talk philosophy.
00:36:54.680And Mary Shelley said, I never said anything because I was just a girl.
00:36:57.660And there were these two brilliant, two of the great, brilliant men of the age.
00:37:01.860And they're talking about bringing people back to life with electricity.
00:37:04.580And they're talking about the meaning of life.
00:37:06.020They're talking all about all this stuff.
00:37:07.220And Mary Shelley was just sitting there.
00:37:08.500And one day, Byron, they're all reading to each other from a book of ghost stories.
00:39:27.000Mothers are at the center of human life.
00:39:28.980And the feminism that has convinced women that they are just mothers, that they are just homemakers and need to really get out in business.
00:39:37.440The feminism that says to businesses, you have to take care of women by giving them daycare instead of saying by giving, paying their husbands enough so that they can actually do the work that they were given to do is, I think, has made women miserable.
00:39:50.820I mean, when I, before COVID, when I was speaking a lot in colleges, I would get up and I would say, young women look miserable to me.
00:39:58.900If I'm wrong, after I'm finished talking, get up.
00:40:04.060Not once that a young woman get up and say, no, no, we're really thrilled with the way women's lives are going.
00:40:08.920So this moment, this moment when Byron says, let's all write a ghost story, and none of them does except for Mary Shelley, is transformative because it introduces one of the real philosophical problems of a godless world.
00:40:23.140First, what do we do about the creative force of a woman's body, which is not just the giving birth, it's also nurturing a child.
00:40:32.660I talk about this because Wordsworth writes a whole poem about the interchange between a mother and a child that she's nursing and how it gives them life.
00:40:39.700And this turns out scientifically to be correct.
00:40:42.020I mean, it turns out that this interchange, this thing that happens between mothers and babies creates individuals.
00:40:48.560And why do we live in a society that not only doesn't honor it, but tells us that men can do it too, and that, yes, if I suddenly decide I want to be a woman, I'm a woman.
00:40:57.680And if I want to, you know, be in women's sports and defeat every woman around me because I'm actually not a woman, I'm a man, that's all fine.
00:41:04.880When did we lose this sense that we were made in God's image male and female, and this female part is half of the enterprise and its core to the enterprise?
00:41:15.340We have lost the respect, the awe that people felt about that when they were worshiping the Virgin Mary.
00:41:43.260Women have something men want, which is their bodies.
00:41:45.780And so there's just, it's just a recipe for abuse and cruelty and an abuse of law.
00:41:51.140But when you go back and read the literature in the West, women are treated a lot differently than you think.
00:41:57.600They're spoken about and thought about a lot differently than you think.
00:42:00.920If you look at the Bible, the first time they talk about the Ten Commandments, the last commandment is thou shalt not cover thy neighbor's wife or his house or his mule or anything that belongs to him.
00:42:14.380But the second time, hundreds of years later, when they write the Ten Commandments in Deuteronomy, they say thou shalt not cover thy neighbor's wife and thou shalt not cover his house and his mule.
00:42:28.360It took a long time because it's just too tempting to treat them as property, treat women as property.
00:42:33.980But there was this slow advance, really, from the very beginnings of Western civilization until now of women becoming people.
00:42:41.420And the era that I'm writing about, the Romantic era, this was when people started to say, well, you know, maybe women should be allowed to vote.
00:42:49.680Maybe this is when they started to think about that for reasons that I explain in the book, which are not actually just philosophical reasons.
00:45:35.820It doesn't matter what bother me when people say follow science, which means experimentation and getting things wrong and correcting things.
00:45:41.420When they say follow the science, I think I'm in The Wizard of Oz.
00:45:59.940That's what I think Mary Shelley saw, that if you can get rid of women, I mean, women are the obstacle because they are this consequence for our sexual urges.
00:47:00.360There's one for the salvation impaired, right?
00:47:02.600You know, and I think that world, that mechanical world in which we become like unto gods, but we lose our humanity, is the world that you and I are trying to avoid.
00:47:14.760You know, when I talk about all the books and movies that grow out of Frankenstein, one of them I talk about is The Terminator.
00:47:20.920And The Terminator is about a world where the machines rule, but a hero is born.
00:47:41.600She's just a girl, wants to get her hair done, wants to have dates, wants to go out and party.
00:47:44.720It is her girlness that they want to kill.
00:47:48.800And I think that when we look at this, we have to start to say, well, wait a minute.
00:47:53.480If now we understand that the stone that was thrown away, women, maybe one of the cornerstones of the temple, maybe we should start to think about how we treat the human body and how we solve the problems of birth and how we solve the problems of sex and sexuality.
00:48:09.740Those are things that maybe Christians should be thinking about without saying, you know, you're a gay, so I don't like you or all the kind of nonsense that it all boils down to when you're not really thinking it through.
00:48:32.440And I think that that is where the wisdom lies.
00:48:34.480And so I asked Ray Kurzweil, because he was he was talking about, you know, chips and implants and upgrades, you know, basically what Stephen Hawking said would be the end of the homo sapien.
00:49:42.500He said, because you won't be able to understand what we're saying because we'll have all this knowledge running through our heads.
00:49:49.460You won't be able to understand you will be a detriment to all of society.
00:49:55.480I think, you know, I think that there is something to that.
00:49:58.960And I think, you know, when I'm when I say that you have to go forward to go back, that in order to get back to your childhood, you have to move ahead.
00:50:06.700This isn't true of just individuals, true of the human race as well.
00:50:10.380We're not going to get rid of science.
00:50:12.020We're not going to say, oh, yeah, let the kids die.
00:53:36.480And I think maybe the fall of man was a trauma.
00:53:40.620I, you know, everybody has trauma in their lives and you find yourself repeating traumatic patterns and mental health is when you can break those patterns and start to do new things and start to see new things.
00:53:51.620But you're still going to have a personality.
00:53:53.340You're still going to do certain things.
00:53:54.480You know, you're not about to be, you know, you're not about to become a ballet dancer.
00:53:57.200I'm not about to become a baseball player.
00:54:07.460I'm still writing, you know, a writer and still have my personality, but I become, I think, more human.
00:54:14.020And so these patterns are going to repeat.
00:54:16.420But the one thing we can be sure of is that people who go down the wrong road are going to see bliss in front of them, but they're going to find misery.
00:54:25.220And when that misery becomes too intense, things break.
00:54:28.380And it's whether, you know, you're at the pinnacle of human culture in 1914 and you think like, let's go defend Belgium and wipe everybody, kill everybody.
00:54:39.660Or whether it's like some horrible war or whether it's a religious revival and it happens peacefully.
00:54:47.540People come back from the brink, not everybody, but some people come back from the brink.
00:54:52.480And that's a, that's part of the human pattern too.
00:54:54.920There is something in us that remembers.
00:54:56.540There's something in us that remembers who we're supposed to be.
00:54:59.380And when you are the guy in the room who remembers and people start beating you up and picking on you or shouting, crucify him or get off Twitter or whatever it is they want to do.
00:55:12.780You're just going to have to have courage.
00:55:21.300And, you know, I do believe, I think you believe that God walks with you, you know, and that it, it, it, it, it, it eases the loneliness and the pain and the persecution, but, but it doesn't take away the tragedy of life.
00:55:34.020And that's why I think we have the, we cling to the resurrection and the promise that there is some, some version of life that maybe is, is different.
00:55:41.740It makes the walk with him makes it worthwhile.
00:55:48.340I remember, cause I have a really, I have a, I have a different relationship with the Lord.
00:55:55.000He tells me stuff and I'm always like, Oh, not that.
00:57:25.440As a, as a recovering alcoholic, one of the biggest problems was of really doing the soul searching.
00:57:33.420I mean, when you are out, I had to take everything I thought I knew and take it out and examine it and then look at it and then atone for it and whatever else, whatever was in there.
00:57:46.680And then pick them up back on the table and put that one back in.
00:57:50.920Cause I understand it now, pick this one and put it in.
00:57:53.860But if they conflict, I got to take them both out because something's not right.
00:58:32.980And it's, you're afraid too, that maybe this is as good as it gets.
00:58:37.380I completely agree with that description.
00:58:39.560One of the things that I know so many artists who are afraid to get help for their problems because they're afraid their talent will go away.
00:58:45.860And, you know, of course, it all gets better.
00:58:48.480But, but I still, I still believe that in inside everybody, if you interrogated them, you had to know that that alcoholic Glenn was not the Glenn.
00:59:05.700I mean, cause that, when I look back, like I was miserable in my youth and for a long time I had that idea, oh, well, I'm an intellectual, so I, I should be, you know, it's hip to be miserable when you're young and intellectual, right?
00:59:17.380But I knew, I knew you were not supposed to be like this.
00:59:21.120This is not the way you're supposed to be.
00:59:23.860And there, and there, and I knew there was a me that had been made that I didn't have, you know, and that's still true, but at least I feel now I'm walking in that direction all the time.
00:59:34.700You know, which is just a joyful experience in and of itself.
00:59:37.740And it's weird that, like Viktor Frankl, it's very strange that even, as he said, sitting on the cart with a stack of dead bodies, a dead body, and I take an old sandwich from my pocket and I'm eating it, and I can just disappear.
00:59:56.680I'm not, I become numb until I realize nothing can destroy my happiness except for me.
01:18:24.180Who Trump drove crazy, you know, those commentators who were important and now we're just kind of off in the wilderness, babbling about who knows what.
01:18:31.420You know, I think they couldn't accept that it's time for a new thing.
01:18:35.340And Trump, like you said, in his gut, he understood that.