The left successfully weaponized the mob to storm the offices of the Senate. They chased senators into elevators. They released private information on the internet so more of the mob could follow them to their homes and call their phones. They yelled at Ted Cruz and his wife while on a date at a restaurant. They even sent a text message depicting a decapitation.
00:02:07.680This is what we know as a he said, she said case.
00:02:13.840We choose, as Americans, not to involve ourselves in he said, she said cases because we're not God.
00:02:23.880Ask every single one of these people in private.
00:02:31.860There is no way they would be doing this if they or someone in their family, or I hate to say it, but somebody on their side of the aisle was being accused.
00:03:55.940The article continues, quote, after failing to stop Kavanaugh's confirmation, Democrats wonder if it's time to be more ruthless, end quote.
00:18:23.560With a single speech, Senator Collins announcing her support for Kavanaugh has paved the way for a much more conservative Supreme Court for the next generation.
00:19:04.400They, and with Avenatti, I think you can certainly speculate, completely fabricated gang rape allegations against a man because they wanted to stop the conservative position on abortion rights, gay rights, climate change, and health care reform.
00:19:21.160And as soon as this is over, this is not about assault anymore.
00:19:25.220If it was about assault, you would say, well, look, we would accept all of the conservative things that this guy is going to do because Trump won the election.
00:21:53.720A website allegedly run by University of Washington students allows individuals to publicly accuse people of sexual assault without any evidence.
00:22:05.380The website, titled Make Them Scared UW, was first registered in November of last year, but launched in late September of this year by University of Washington students.
00:22:17.680The Daily UW campus newspaper reports that the list of accused rapists and sexual assault perpetrators has grown substantially on the site in the last weeks because of the Brett Kavanaugh scandal.
00:22:32.640Meanwhile, one student named on the Make Them Scared UW told the college fix that none of these accusations are true.
00:22:42.760According to the FAQ page on the website, Make Them Scared UW is a communal rape list intended to be an online hub for anyone who wants to expose the names of their attackers and harassers
00:22:57.800and to fill a gap left by inadequate treatment of these cases by formal institutions.
00:23:05.600One of our site's moderators will review your submission, verify your contact information, and after receiving your confirmation, publish the information you provided us,
00:23:15.500minus your personal identifying information.
00:24:27.980His accuser said no, at which point he backed off.
00:24:32.520This girl gave the investigator all at my school, literally everything, all of our Facebook messages, our Snapchat messages.
00:24:40.900She saved all of them, text messages and even my Reddit account.
00:24:45.560And I was deemed to be so not a threat to her that the investigator didn't even care if I was in the same class with her.
00:24:54.040That didn't stop, make them scared, putting his name on the rapist list.
00:25:02.120Asked if the school was aware if the website was run by students at the University of Washington.
00:25:07.820The official said, we don't know for certain.
00:25:11.680Asked if false allegations on the site made or posted by students or affiliates of the university would be treated as harassment under school policy.
00:25:21.080The school said, if the university receives a complaint that an individual was being harassed or bullied by a student,
00:25:28.440we would investigate it in the same manner as we would any other case.
00:25:32.860So being listed on a website as a rapist isn't being bullied?
00:25:40.100In an interview with a student newspaper, the Daily UW, University of Washington Law School associate professor,
00:25:47.000said that the website moderators could face considerable risks of defamation lawsuits by anyone's name they mention in connection with a criminal behavior or sexual assault that gives rise to civil liability.
00:26:00.620Personally, this is why I believe anyone who falsely accused, and I do not necessarily include Ford,
00:26:09.880I don't believe there's enough evidence to say that he did it, but I also don't think there's enough evidence that she wasn't telling of an event,
00:26:20.240saying an event that she thought Brett Kavanaugh was involved in.
00:26:25.240However, the gang rape and the boating, the boating weekends from hell, those people should be investigating.
00:26:35.340Well, probably primarily the person who made an accusation and then later recanted it on Twitter.
00:26:41.680You know, here's someone who actually admitted that they were lying about it.
00:26:46.140I mean, should you face repercussions for that?
00:26:51.620It's got to be a bigger deal in our society.
00:26:53.940The moderators of the site said, we hope that anyone whose name was inaccurately posted on our site will let us know so we can remedy the situation.
00:27:26.000The site's domain name was registered November 29th, 2017, with additional security to protect the individual or individuals that registered it.
00:27:44.260Think of the long-standing repercussions of this.
00:27:46.460Clarence Thomas went through a very public accusation of sexual harassment.
00:27:50.840The end of that story, if we don't remember, it's been a long time, but they went through all of that stuff to see if they thought he was guilty of sexual harassment.
00:28:00.500And people agreed that he was not guilty of sexual harassment, or they wouldn't put him on the court, to the point of 11 Democrats, 11 Democrats voted for Clarence Thomas' confirmation.
00:40:13.380During the last search, with their search results, and when, what did you find?
00:40:19.240Well, I had already found, uh, years before that, I'd been studying search results and I, I had already found that when search results, uh, favor one candidate or one cause for that matter, uh, that shifts opinions and it shifts votes.
00:40:37.200And, and, and I mean, dramatically so it can shift, uh, voting preferences among undecided voters by 20% or more easily and by up to 80% in some demographic groups.
00:40:56.940Well, we're bombarded, as you know, by all kinds of information, all kinds of media sources, uh, uh, you know, people ranting and raving on the radio and television and newspapers and magazines, all that stuff is competitive and people are very wary about it.
00:41:14.380You know, they, they're, they're bias detectors are kind of always working, uh, you know, even, even when they listen to their, their favorite commentator, they're still kind of, you know, it's, you see the human hand, you know, and everyone knows humans are kind of, all right.
00:41:28.980When your people are, you, yeah, of course, but when people are using, it turns out my research shows, other research shows, when people are using something like a Google search engine, they turn off the bias detectors.
00:41:41.640They automatically become very trusting because they think this is an algorithm, not that they know what an algorithm is, but this is an algorithm and I can trust it because it's subjective and impartial so that when Google answers your question about anything, uh, what, what tends to happen is if people trust what's higher up in the list, they think that the algorithm has very carefully and objectively selected it and it must be true.
00:42:07.020So if you favor one candidate or one cause or one company or whatever it may be, one product in search results, uh, people tend to believe what's ever closest to the top.
00:42:21.160And what I showed in, in a series of randomized controlled experiments, uh, that now we've now done with four national elections involving, you know, more than 10,000 people, uh, I've shown over and over and over and over and over again, that by favoring one candidate, you can shift in a country like ours, millions of votes.
00:42:44.220With no one having the slightest idea that they are being manipulated and without leaving a paper trail for authorities to track.
00:42:56.220It is you, um, you lay this out in the, in the, um, creepy line, um, about how Google has really stripped itself of all ads and everything else.
00:43:07.860So it, it looks totally clean and neutral and without an agenda.
00:43:12.820Um, and then, uh, uh, how they have, you know, when you first did it, I think one of the tests you did, you did it where you, you were clear with an agenda.
00:43:25.220Then you added one that might go in the other direction.
00:43:29.440And then you added two search results, uh, that would go in the other direction and you got it to a point to where Google is to where you don't have any idea you're being manipulated.
00:43:43.520So when we, we did this in a national study in the U S almost no one was aware that they were seeing biased or, uh, search results, search results that favor one candidate.
00:43:55.060Uh, the, this really creepy thing there was that the very, very few people who could spot the bias, they shifted even farther in the direction of the bias.
00:44:05.640So, you know, being able to spot the bias does not protect you.
00:44:09.220Uh, we did a big national study in India, right in the middle of their election there in 2014, 99.5% of people in the study, uh, could see no bias whatsoever.
00:44:21.800They couldn't see the favoritism, uh, and, and, and yet we're still getting these big shifts, uh, in their voting preferences.
00:44:29.480So, you know, this is, this is unprecedented in human history.
00:44:34.640This is, this is just, this is an ability to shift people's thinking and behavior worldwide.
00:44:42.320It's not just in the U S because Google is, is, you know, used, uh, for, you know, 90% of all searches conducted throughout the world.
00:44:51.700Uh, you know, and, and, and in other words, they have the ability to shift people's thinking, behavior, votes, purchases, attitudes, beliefs, uh, around the world.
00:45:01.760Well, they are doing so 24 seven without people knowing and without leaving a paper trail, because when you're showing something, someone's search results, that's not like a news story that just stays there for people to look at.
00:45:16.400It's, it's generated just for you on the fly at that moment, disappears, gone forever, stored nowhere.
00:45:24.500Would you, is it an overstatement to say, whether it's, um, you know, Wilson and Bernays, uh, in world war one or, or, uh, you know, Goebbels world war two, that this is the, this is the system that they would have dreamt of for propaganda.
00:45:43.860Oh, uh, this goes beyond their wildest dreams, uh, because it's not just the search results.
00:45:52.760I just published a big article, uh, called, uh, 10 ways big tech can shift millions of votes in the November elections without anyone knowing.
00:46:07.580Now, the one we're talking about, which is called the search engine manipulation effect or SEME, S-E-M-E, that's just one of 10 ways, uh, that I've identified over the years and that I've been studying.
00:46:19.700Well, I'm studying seven of them at the moment, uh, that these big tech companies have to shift votes and that are unprecedented in human history.
00:46:27.840They've never existed before, uh, and they, they, they're, I mean, some of these effects that, that, that I've, uh, discovered are among the biggest ever discovered in the behavioral sciences.
00:46:39.880And there is, and there is no doubt in your mind that Google is engaging in this.
00:46:45.440Well, in 2016, early 2016, uh, working in secret, uh, I developed a system for actually monitoring what people were seeing while they were using, uh, the Google, Bing, and Yahoo search engines that was election related.
00:47:03.860So it's as if we were looking over people's, uh, shoulders, it's called a monitoring system.
00:47:11.460And so we actually monitored for more than five months before the election in November, 2016.
00:47:17.900Uh, and we found a, you know, systematic bias in search results favoring Hillary Clinton, whom I favored by the way, as you mentioned, uh, in all 10 search positions on the first page of search results.
00:47:38.500Of course, these leaks, these leaks that we've seen recently from Google, uh, you know, they're, they're, they tell us, you know, that, yeah, people at Google have a very strong political preferences and that they act on them.
00:47:50.880And, uh, I don't think we should be surprised, uh, that we found that.
00:47:55.280And of course, now I'm working with, with business partners and academic colleagues on three continents to try to scale up monitoring systems like that.
00:48:04.100So for the first time, we'll actually be able to see what these companies are showing people all throughout the U S and ultimately throughout the world.
00:48:12.620Uh, you know, I wish we, well, I wish we could be fully up and running in time for the midterms.
00:48:25.720And, uh, at this point I'd say that's not going to happen, but, uh, we will definitely be there for, for 2020 and beyond.
00:48:33.260And, and we're looking at more than elections because it's, there, there are lots of ways in which these companies are playing with us, uh, that people are just completely unaware of.
00:48:43.980And speaking of which Glenn, am I in trouble?
00:48:50.600Well, kind of, yes, kind of, um, I have good news and bad news for you.
00:49:13.400And your email service that you use, uh, is, is you're not sharing information.
00:49:20.080You're not sharing your emails with Google.
00:49:21.940Now, interestingly enough, the New York times, the times of London, the economist, wired magazine, slate, I could go on and on and on.
00:49:31.240They share all of their emails all the time with Google and other sensitive documents too.
00:49:39.360And so reporters, when they're doing, you know, very sensitive investigations on something, they're sharing everything constantly with Google.
00:49:48.340And I wrote a piece about that in the Daily Caller a couple of months ago.
00:49:59.880And we'll come back with the bad news.
00:50:01.280Plus, the, the, the, I think he said 10 different ways that, uh, Google is influencing us.
00:50:09.020And not just Google, but these big tech companies and some of the other things that, uh, he has found, how they are monitoring our children.
00:50:18.740Uh, it is remarkable and we are running out of time, uh, before Google is the dominance that just can't be stopped.
00:50:30.660Our sponsor this half hour is Goldline.
00:50:33.320President Trump has been warning about the risk to every American.
00:50:36.900If the Republicans lose one or both houses of Congress is November.
00:50:40.380And the risks are pretty, uh, pretty dire, uh, and especially coupled with what the Democrats were saying this weekend.
00:50:48.980There are several stories out this weekend say that they have to become more radical, uh, in their, their pushback.
00:50:57.240I don't know how you become more radical than they already have been.
00:51:03.120Um, but we're not heading in a good direction.
00:51:05.580We're not heading towards stability and stability is essential.
00:51:10.380For all of us to, um, to have freedom, to have freedom.
00:51:15.980That's what we're talking about at this point is freedom.
00:51:19.760We can disagree on an awful lot of stuff, but let's not throw the baby out with the bathwater.
00:51:27.000There is a report now that, uh, Goldline has commissioned on the things that they believe, uh, will happen, uh, should the Democrats, uh, take over.
00:51:37.820And they actually deliver on some of the things, the radical things that they're talking about.
00:51:42.360Now I've read the report and I'm sharing it with people.
00:51:45.980You should share it with people as well.
00:51:48.120I buy gold and silver as an insurance against chaos.
00:51:51.460And if you have been paying attention at all, chaos is coming.
00:51:55.900Get your copy of this report right now at eight, six, six gold line.
00:54:34.500When you came out about some of this stuff, and again, you were a Hillary supporter.
00:54:38.920When you came out about this, were you, you were blocked by Google for a time, were you not?
00:54:44.520Well, when I, when my research, uh, first hit the news in the Washington Post, uh, you know, I found that starting the next day, I couldn't access any Google products.
00:55:57.260They'll start flashing suggestions at you.
00:55:59.820And Amazon, it turns out, is Google's biggest advertiser, paying them $300 million a year.
00:56:05.380And Google sends more traffic to Amazon than any other single source.
00:56:09.700But beyond that, we've learned through our experiments that Google can use search suggestions that they're flashing at you to turn a 50-50 vote among, a 50-50 split among undecided voters into a 90-10 split with no one having any idea they're being manipulated.
00:58:36.780Targeted messaging, TME, we call that, is, these are all things that we study and that we were, you know, we're quantifying and, you know, very precisely.
00:58:44.840But targeted messaging effect is really scary.
00:58:49.120This means that if a company, this would primarily be Facebook, but other companies too.
00:58:54.940But if a company like Facebook on election day, so let's go back to November 2016,
00:59:01.440if that morning Mark Zuckerberg had chosen to just, you know, hit the enter key and send out go out and vote reminders,
00:59:11.380mainly to supporters of Hillary Clinton, or exclusively, either way.
00:59:18.000First of all, no one would know that that was even occurring.
00:59:20.880No one would know it was going to some people and not others.
00:59:23.780But if it went just to supporters of Hillary Clinton, that would have given her that day an additional 450,000 votes.
00:59:32.700Now, I don't, I don't think he did that because, you know, he was very overconfident, you know, as, as were Democrats.
00:59:43.120I'm not a Democrat, I'm not, I'm a moderate and independent.
00:59:47.300But the point is, everyone thought Hillary was going to win.
01:00:06.480And think about it, no one knows if, if something like that is happening.
01:00:10.840In fact, if it's happening every single day, there, there were targeted messages going out to some people, but not others.
01:00:17.360And of course, isn't that what targeted advertising is all about?
01:00:21.900But you see targeted advertising though, is competitive, but I'm talking about what happens if the platform itself does something that's not competitive.
01:00:32.260It's completely invisible and it's not competitive.
01:00:35.620So can, I mean, this is so dangerous and it is, I mean, it's everything that a sci-fi, you know, writer has envisioned forever.
01:00:47.320Uh, and I mean, can, can, especially when we get to artificial intelligence, couldn't a system like Google be used to identify unstable individuals and wind them up?
01:01:04.200Oh yes, they can, they, in fact, they know who's unstable, they know who's undecided, they know who is Republican and who is gay and you name it.
01:02:58.780You've been one of the, one of the many things that's not on that list is you shouldn't be using Google analytics, which glennbeck.com is using.
01:03:05.680Um, so that's at the individual level.
01:03:09.520Now at the, at the organizational governmental level, there's other things, uh, you know, uh,
01:03:16.440So hang on, but you shouldn't even be using a Google Chrome browser.
01:03:21.920Um, but even if you go to, is it Microsoft browser that is powered by Google, uh, information?
01:03:29.840I mean, there's, do you know what I'm talking about?
01:04:10.920Siri is, is, you know, Apple's personal assistant.
01:04:14.040So, I mean, I could go on and on and on, but at the, at the institutional level, there are things that have to be done.
01:04:22.380Uh, one of them, which I'm helping to work on with people now, and we need money.
01:04:26.520So, you know, if you guys have money out there, you know, step up.
01:04:30.520Uh, but we, we are building monitoring systems.
01:04:33.720It's, you know, basically to look with people's permission to look over people's shoulders and see what these companies are actually showing people,
01:04:57.220That supports, uh, the research, uh, that I do, but also, uh, that's helping to provide funds to build monitoring systems, which, which must exist.
01:05:07.700I did build one in 2016, but we need large scale, permanent monitoring systems, uh, to keep all these, these creepy, arrogant people under control.
01:05:18.140So, I am very, um, concerned, um, about AGI and ASI.
01:05:30.720Um, and I'm, I'm concerned that in two ways, I feel as though we need some sort of a Manhattan project to make sure America is the one that gets it first.
01:05:45.200But on the other hand, I don't know who I trust to have it.
01:05:49.360I mean, you cannot put this genie back in the bottle, but when, when we hit AGI, we are in real trouble.
01:06:05.000If you, if you, if, no, seriously, if you, if you knew the stuff that I knew and you were looking every day at the numbers I look at, you wouldn't even get out of bed.
01:25:54.160They get crazier and crazier and crazier.
01:25:56.960And as this stuff escalates, they're going to feel justified to take more overt action.
01:26:01.580And God only knows where that ends up.
01:26:03.680I mean, it could go in really bad directions.
01:26:07.500This is, um, uh, we, we are entering a 10 year period now where our lives, you really will not recognize your country, the world, or our lives by 2030.
01:26:27.500If you, when you see the rage on the faces of the leaders of, of the left and the Democrats, and they're saying, we have to get more radical.
01:26:41.300Remember, you're already talking about a group of people that believe the ends justify the means.
01:26:47.300You're already talking about a group of people.
01:26:49.500And let's make sure we're not like this.
01:26:52.200A group of people that believe they are right to the point that the others have to just be either reeducated or eliminated.
01:27:01.120Let me ask the Democrats, you, you have 50% of the country that just does not honestly see the world the way you see it.
01:27:14.140We are just as set against what you believe is right.
01:27:19.800If you believe that socialism is the answer, capitalism should be shut down and freedom of speech needs to be curtailed.
01:27:29.260I am against that 100% and I will not comply.
01:28:45.520And we do so almost on a daily basis to all of them.
01:28:51.920Now, we are either going to readopt those and say, no, you know what?
01:28:56.880The reason why we're having so many problems is because we refuse.
01:29:02.980We refuse to go back and instill in ourselves and in those who represent us the Bill of Rights.
01:29:12.120If we don't return to those things, it will mean great and grave sorrow.
01:29:23.400There is a bright future, but only if we return to those principles, our unum, that brought all of us, all different people together with one, one idea.
01:29:42.340That man has rights and no one can take them away.
01:29:48.960All right, between fall birthdays, anniversaries, and big celebrations, there's a lot of dates to keep track of, and you're not going to remember them all.
01:29:59.280So when your back is against the wall and her birthday or anniversary is tomorrow or yesterday, trust 1-800-Flowers.com.
01:30:09.7001-800-Flowers, your go-to move in crunch time situations.
01:30:14.320They're going to get your bouquet where it needs to go for a price that you can afford and you're not going to believe.
01:30:20.200Right now, when you order a dozen red or multicolored roses for only $29.99, 1-800-Flowers will give you another dozen in a free glass vase, all free.
01:30:31.240Another dozen and the glass vase, free.
01:30:33.820Choose between a beautiful arrangement of red or multicolored roses, perfect for the holidays, anniversaries, or screw-ups.
01:31:02.600How do the people at Google sleep at night, seriously, with just what they're doing in China?
01:31:09.180I'm reading this book, Disappeared, The Disappeared.
01:31:15.740And it's a collection of essays written by people from China who were disappeared.
01:31:23.520And the torture centers that they're going on, I mean, it's all there.
01:31:29.680And Google is now helping China design the search engine, or Google China is now taking and tracking people for China and silencing dissidents.
01:31:45.760And, I mean, that's, how do you do that?
01:31:49.180How, what, I mean, how can you seriously?
01:32:29.240And you're using search results to move the people in the right, the correct direction, to the left, to be more accommodating, to all these hated groups that you believe evil people dislike.
01:32:39.760Like, you know, you could at least see the pathway to thinking what you're doing is just, right?
01:32:47.020With China, I don't know how you see it.
01:32:48.640I mean, I, you know, to, to be able to, to assist that government doing what they're doing is terrifying.
01:32:56.960And they certainly claim to not want to support it.
01:32:59.680But, I don't know, I mean, I don't know how you do it.
01:33:02.680I understand the access to that, that, that market is enticing.
01:33:06.640But, I mean, it, it seems like what you're doing is putting real people in danger.
01:33:12.960I hope we're, I, I, I hope that there are good people that are still there as code writers that are, because a giant cage is being built, just a giant cage.
01:33:28.760And it's being built by Google and Facebook.
01:33:31.960And, uh, uh, man, if, if things heat up, we just, we just, don't be a part of the problem.
01:38:43.380I thought I heard the BBC and I was like, oh, yeah, because I thought they would be, you know, they would be detached from it.
01:38:52.340And so there would be a chance to actually have a decent conversation.
01:38:56.440I sit down in the chair, I put in my headphones, and I hear CNN International, and I'm like, oh, dear God, did I say yes to CNN International?
01:39:39.980Let me, Glenn, ask you about your tweets, because this is how people express themselves oftentimes and how you build sort of a picture of someone's opinions.
01:39:53.420OK, so you can imagine Glenn Beck tweets.
01:40:56.700Did I say Democrats are not Americans?
01:40:59.620You know, you should take a breath before you just try to get yet another ratings point.
01:41:05.840I mean, they may start, they may stop doing you.
01:41:09.140She needed a, she needed an Emmy or maybe, maybe she needed an Olympic medal for the gymnastics that she had to go through to find a fence there.
01:41:21.840Democrats, you know, we should just start to, we should, we should start to be more clear perhaps.
01:41:27.680Uh, but I'm glad she was worried about policing my language as opposed to all the other tweets that are happening on the left right now.
01:42:41.760And we also saw people who were organized and that moment with Jeff Flake on the Hill, we talked to one woman who works for ultraviolet who was paid.
01:42:49.000She helped steer people in the right ways to be able to, to confront sinners.
01:42:55.080There were people who were paid by organizations like ultraviolet to, to try to harness that energy in a way that would make the viral moments that we ended up seeing.
01:44:08.060One of the things, one of the things you said is you, you acknowledge that some of the work you did on cable news contributed to this polarization.
01:44:16.400And I would love to have other voices join me, but so far I haven't had anybody.
01:44:21.280I think we're all responsible for what's happened to our country and to the republic.
01:44:26.060And it is becoming more and more disturbing.
01:44:28.600I've spoken out about it over for the last five years.
01:45:12.740Then the committee heard from Kavanaugh.
01:45:14.960Now, those who don't support his nomination say, in fact, it was all rigged in his favor that the FBI didn't talk to people who could have corroborated Dr. Ford's version of it.
01:45:26.920You know, I've heard the press ask over and over, will this be good enough?
01:45:35.900For people to not change their positions?
01:45:39.160And I don't say that just about the Democrats.
01:45:41.040I mean that about the Republicans, too.
01:45:42.940There are people that it doesn't matter what the facts are.
01:45:46.820This was not a search for facts at all.
01:45:50.460And the money outside of Washington that is being poured into this to bring people into the streets, the vitriol behind all of this has really been remarkable.
01:46:04.480You're saying this is coming from outside money?
01:46:06.980That these are not genuine protesters who are appalled by what's going on who believe that the voice of a woman is not being heard or believed?
01:46:49.140And they were talking about how this whole process, how what the Republicans did, delegitimize the Supreme Court and how dangerous that is.