Heather McDonald is a leading conservative voice on policing and criminal justice reform. She is an attorney, a fellow at the Manhattan Institute, a graduate of Yale University with a Bachelor's degree in English, a Master's from Cambridge University and a PhD from Stanford Law School, and she has written widely on the subject of policing. She has been a frequent guest on Fox News and CNN, and is a regular contributor on the Fox News Channel's Hard Knocks.
00:10:32.720And talking about the university and our colleges, our educational system, suddenly the white male
00:10:41.020in this country is not only despicable, deplorable, if you will, in the minds of the left-wing media
00:10:50.240and the neo-Marxists who now seem to be driving the ideological momentum within our society and body politic.
00:11:01.220But the reality is the white male is now underrepresented, at least in historical terms, on our college campuses.
00:11:09.760The white female is still prized because there is a box that each institution can check off to virtue signal, if you will, back to the federal government,
00:11:21.560which is the arbiter of all such things that, by golly, you know, someone is actually paying attention to those poor females in our society
00:11:31.480who historically have been ignored or suppressed at various points in our history.
00:13:36.660I want to throw up every time I hear about a new foundation initiative to get, you know, females into STEM
00:13:43.940or the idea that females somehow need more encouragement.
00:13:48.860No, it's males who are being suppressed and discredited and demoralized.
00:13:55.140And it's amazing that they succeed at all under these conditions where they are viewed as toxically masculine
00:14:02.760if they show any kind of traditional male values of self-reliance and competitiveness and courage and effort.
00:14:10.960It's the white male as an oppressed group in this age.
00:14:18.960You scratch your head as you try to assimilate what all has happened over the course of, well, since the 1960s.
00:14:27.960And why we are witnessing this now is, frankly, I struggle to comprehend it, Heather.
00:14:36.340I just, I cannot figure out, was it the war on poverty when we started differentiating by race and ethnicity and subsequently gender?
00:14:48.440What happened that we went from melting pot to multiculturalism, but with a real zinger in the midst of it,
00:14:59.660that there will be reparations, there will be, we will reach back 200 years for those reparations to those who've been oppressed or suppressed or mistreated in our society.
00:15:14.220Without even an acknowledgement for the veterans of the Revolutionary War, how about those Americans who fought to free the slaves,
00:15:24.820who died by the hundreds of thousands in the 1860s to free slaves?
00:15:31.840Where is the balance and proportionality and the sense of history as this nation has advanced?
00:15:39.420We are not the same as we were in 1776, nor certainly 1619.
00:21:03.340It's Western history that is coming under attack by people who are completely ignorant.
00:21:08.960The, you know, look around, Lou, your listeners should just look around their room or their house right now.
00:21:18.860Let their eye rest on every single surface.
00:21:22.100Every single surface was created by materials engineer, all the gadgets we've got, all the furniture,
00:21:30.280all the connectivity, all the clean water, all the clean food.
00:21:35.240It is astounding how Western civilization, with a rate of scientific discovery of amateur dabblers in science who were drawn by the desire to expand human knowledge and human progress,
00:21:53.280have transformed human existence from what was millennia of squalor and poverty and death and premature death and childbirth, child death,
00:22:08.720into something that is literally unrecognizable for somebody that was living 200 years ago.
00:22:15.760And other, of course, other civilizations have created wonderful monuments, wonderful traditions of literature and theater and art.
00:22:28.860But the fact of the matter is, is that Western civilization, with its dedication to the scientific method and to tolerance and freedom,
00:22:39.380is the driver of world progress today.
00:22:44.020And yet you have these college students abetted by their professors mouthing empty bromides about, you know, colonialism and oppression.
00:22:55.700They know nothing about what was accomplished with the Enlightenment, with the long evolution of constitutional history.
00:23:05.180They take it all for granted and want to throw it away, confident as they are, that nobody will ever destroy their own standard of living.
00:23:14.020You know, I, to my knowledge, I've never met a white supremacist.
00:23:18.640But I have met plenty of virtue supremacists of late who tell me that because they are leftists,
00:23:28.660because they are, they live in a world of advanced degrees in academia, that they know better.
00:23:38.260And suddenly, I'm finding the same thing in the Democratic Party.
00:24:10.260Is it, can we be certain that liberty and a respect for the First Amendment and free speech is enough in our DNA as Americans to prevent us from sliding into Soviet-style totalitarianism?
00:24:28.940And I don't have the answer to that question.
00:24:31.160But when I see the censorship that's being exercised now in the private sphere with the obvious sub-Rosa encouragement of the Democratic Party, it is very, very worrisome.
00:24:48.780And, you know, John Stuart Mill got it right.
00:24:53.060The marketplace of ideas is the best way to arrive at truth.
00:24:57.520If you think an idea is wrong, the solution is not to suppress it.
00:25:07.160And to your earlier assessment on the elites and their concerns about not being able to find a satisfactory explanation for enlarged gaps,
00:25:20.840when they have spent trillions of dollars trying to narrow them and to do so in ways in which they can create some sort of politically, sociologically acceptable veneer that doesn't disturb anyone.
00:25:37.740The fact of the matter is our meritocracy that was America, a public school education that was the greatest equalizer in our society, period, all now threatened by the madness of the left and the coalescence of corporate power, academic power, and the political Marxist left in this country.
00:26:02.320Well, standards have disparate impact.
00:26:05.700The most pernicious concept in our world today is disparate impact.
00:26:09.740It holds that any academic standard, any behavioral standard that has a disparate impact on blacks is by definition racist.
00:26:19.240So if you have, you know, high standards for admission to a selective high school, whether it's Stuyvesant High School in New York or some of the schools in Boston or Virginia,
00:26:31.120and that results in a student population that is not equally distributed demographically by population groups,
00:26:40.980then those standards have to go down because they're racist or if the standards for scientific laboratory work or for medical research have a disparate impact and they don't result in a team doing cancer research that is 50 percent female and 13 percent black and 15 percent Hispanic,
00:27:01.860then those standards have to go because they have disparate impact and, you know, that is, that is what's tearing everything down and it is very scary to live in a world where meritocracy is so destroyed because as you say,
00:27:20.660meritocracy is the key to, to, to progress and to human striving.
00:27:26.020But, but, but here's the dirty secret.
00:27:28.820You can have meritocracy or you can have diversity.
00:27:33.080You cannot have both given the academic skills gap.
00:27:40.120You can choose, you can choose one or the other, but, but they are, and, and diversity, they are, they are mutually exclusive.
00:27:48.880Diversity is simply a code word for racial preferences.
00:27:53.160It has become such, I think you're exactly right.
00:27:56.020And we are also in a society that is no longer talking about equal opportunity and, and finding a way forward where there is great advancement.
00:28:10.060It's happening because we have the momentum of this country's history and, and our system of government, but it is being eroded almost, almost every day by whether it be a government program, whether it be a new edict emanating from the white house,
00:28:28.380or we look to the Southern border, or we look to the Southern border where 2 million illegal immigrants have crossed over in the course of the past year.
00:28:36.440Not all of them will stay in the country, but many, if not most will.
00:28:40.300And there is an open border for sex trafficking, human smuggling, drug smuggling, and the deaths of hundreds of thousands of Americans to overdoses because of those drugs, whether it be fentanyl, heroin, marijuana, cocaine.
00:28:57.060I mean, that is upon us, is our government does not perform the basic fundamental functions of government, which is to preserve and protect the Republic.
00:29:10.120Well, Lou, I'm, I'm surprised to hear you using a sort of a utilitarian argument for border control, which is this, you know, drawing upon, well, the criminals are coming and the drugs are coming or the, or the terrorists are coming.
00:29:23.240That is all true, but it is also simply, even without that, it is a demographic change that is going to transform, is transforming our culture.
00:29:34.860I'm a Los Angeles native, I'm a Los Angeles native, I can tell you the city has changed immeasurably and unrecognizably since I grew up there in the 50s and 60s, because of large scale mass immigration, it is now a third world city, we are importing poverty, we are importing a poverty culture.
00:29:55.840And what's going on, and what's going on in the border now is absolutely terrifying, and, and we probably will not be able to, you know, have anything to, to counter that.
00:30:10.680The only counter I know, Heather, at this point is, and this, this podcast is dedicated to the Great America Show.
00:30:21.680I believe this is a great country, we are always becoming, but we have been great for centuries now, and we have to make certain that we are credited appropriately with the reality that we experience, and not be persuaded by such nonsense as being spewed by some academicians who more, are more in the business of indoctrination than education.
00:30:50.080And to understand that if we don't take control of our communities, our neighborhoods, our lives, the rest of this country will be very difficult for anyone to change, unless we begin at home, begin in our hometowns, to, to govern ourselves once again, and demand that right and responsibility for all Americans.
00:31:14.560Heather, Heather, you are always instructive, you are always fascinating, and always brilliant and spot on.
00:31:25.180So thanks for being with us, you get the last word here, as does each guest, I just want to say first and foremost, thanks so much for what has been an engaging conversation.
01:00:20.780So to say that we found something from 1700 BC that's talked about in the Bible, and 21 scientists were so astonished
01:00:28.060that in a peer-reviewed, you know, probably one of the most prestigious, certainly one of the most prestigious academic journals on the planet,
01:00:36.860they refer to Sodom and the destruction of Sodom because it's so uncanny that they have to mention it.
01:00:42.580And when I discovered this, and then, you know, first you're shocked because, I mean, I really looked into it with skepticism.
01:00:50.480And then I said to myself, and not only is this true, no one knows this.
01:00:57.480There's no, I said, this is gigantic news.
01:01:01.660And the same thing is true of, Christopher Hitchens was asked once, what's the strongest argument for God?
01:01:06.920And in a very rare moment of candor, honestly, he said, oh, the fine-tuned universe.
01:01:13.760And the argument for the fine-tuned universe that the more science discovers about the nature of the earth, the nature of the universe,
01:01:21.920the more science discovers that if anything were ever so slightly different, just a tiny, tiny bit different, no life would exist.
01:01:33.700And this is discovered daily, more and more.
01:01:37.720In other words, the more science discovers, the more it points to the idea that there's zero chance this was not created by some infinitely intelligent designer.
01:01:50.020This narrative has not been out there.
01:02:44.160And I'm thrilled you have found this new medium and honored that I get to be on it.
01:02:48.860And I just want to say that the title of the book is Atheism Dead really postulates that we have been living with a narrative and that narrative leads to socialism and Marxism.
01:03:02.980The idea that we can get rid of God and we all have to discover that it cannot work.
01:03:37.800And if we have to get to this level of wokeness and madness, you know, to the build back Brandon, you know, theme that we're just going to destroy everything and we're going to start afresh.
01:03:53.440I think, ironically, the opposite is happening.
01:03:57.160People are waking up to the things that, you know, we took them for granted.
01:04:03.940So, as I say now, I said in the beginning, I am cautiously but very seriously hopeful for this nation, not least because of folks like you.