The Jordan B. Peterson Podcast - November 15, 2026


How to Train Gratitude

Why Young Women Are The Most Miserable They've Ever Been

Episode Stats


Length

1 hour and 51 minutes

Words per minute

132.72

Word count

14,755

Sentence count

880

Harmful content

Misogyny

5

sentences flagged

Toxicity

68

sentences flagged

Hate speech

30

sentences flagged


Transcript

Transcript generated with Whisper (turbo).
Misogyny classifications generated with MilaNLProc/bert-base-uncased-ear-misogyny .
Toxicity classifications generated with s-nlp/roberta_toxicity_classifier .
Hate speech classifications generated with facebook/roberta-hate-speech-dynabench-r4-target .
00:00:00 Hello, everyone. Thank you very much for coming tonight. It's much appreciated. I'm going
00:00:16 to talk about an amalgam of ideas from, I guess, all my books. Rule 11 from Beyond Order
00:00:30 was do not allow yourself to become resentful, deceitful, or arrogant. I think I have the
00:00:38 order of those things right. And I wrote in my new book, We Who Wrestle with God, quite
00:00:46 extensively about the story of Cain and Abel, which I'd also began to investigate in my first
00:00:54 book, Maps of Meaning. So I'm going to try to meld those together. I guess I'd start by telling you
00:01:05 something about stories. So you need to know something about the importance of stories to
00:01:12 understand, for example, why I would use a story like Cain and Abel to, as an investigative tool
00:01:19 to discuss, say, resentment and deceit and arrogance. I picked those three states, let's say,
00:01:29 or spirits, because when I was a clinical psychologist, well, I guess I still am,
00:01:34 even though Canada doesn't think I should be.
00:01:39 Because I saw that triumvirate of sins, of pathology,
00:01:45 as particularly damaging to people.
00:01:48 And those things go together.
00:01:50 Resentment, deceit, and arrogance.
00:01:51 And that's exemplified in the story of Cain and Abel.
00:01:55 Now, a story has a very specific purpose.
00:02:04 And it's not one that we've understood well, technically,
00:02:10 I think before, really before the last few decades.
00:02:13 There's been a transformation that's occurred in multiple disciplines simultaneously
00:02:20 with regards to our understanding of how we understand things.
00:02:26 It was an enlightenment idea, scientific idea,
00:02:29 that we orient ourselves in the world in consequence of the objective facts.
00:02:36 And there's no doubt that there are objective facts.
00:02:40 But it's not the case that we orient ourselves in the world
00:02:43 in consequence of the objective facts.
00:02:46 And the simple reason for that is that there's too many facts.
00:02:51 There's one fact per thing or one fact per combination of things.
00:02:56 And just knowing what the things or the combinations of things are
00:03:02 tells you virtually nothing about how to orient yourself in the world
00:03:07 or how to deal with the facts.
00:03:08 Now, there's a Scottish philosopher named David Hume
00:03:12 who figured this out a long time ago.
00:03:14 He said, you cannot derive an ought from an is.
00:03:19 And what he meant by that was that
00:03:21 merely knowing the geographical details of the landscape
00:03:27 doesn't tell you how to navigate through it.
00:03:31 You still have to know where you want to go and why.
00:03:36 And then knowing the landscape is going to help,
00:03:38 you can plot your route, but without an aim,
00:03:43 without some understanding of where you are
00:03:45 and without an understanding of an aim,
00:03:47 you're going to get nowhere.
00:03:52 This is why, for example, in the story of Exodus,
00:03:55 the Israelites are lost in the desert for 40 years.
00:03:59 It's not a very long trip. 0.80
00:04:01 If you add your act together, you could make it in a very short period of time.
00:04:05 But if you're sufficiently clueless, it can take you forever to get nowhere.
00:04:10 Right. You may notice that in government, for example.
00:04:21 $12 billion to build 1,500 feet of high-speed rail.
00:04:27 That's a good example.
00:04:31 So what does a story do?
00:04:34 Or what is a story?
00:04:35 That's even more important.
00:04:37 Well, we have this proclivity to assume that stories are entertainment,
00:04:42 and entertainment is light, and light entertainment is trivial.
00:04:47 it's something that you concern yourself with
00:04:50 when you don't have anything more important to do
00:04:53 but that's not a very wise way of looking at human behavior
00:04:58 because the fact that we're so attracted to stories
00:05:03 is not merely reflective of our proclivity
00:05:07 to wish for entertainment
00:05:10 not least because
00:05:11 that theory doesn't answer the question
00:05:16 why do you find stories entertaining?
00:05:21 That's a deep, instinctive orientation.
00:05:23 If you want to teach a child something,
00:05:26 a story works.
00:05:29 Children will clamor to be told stories.
00:05:33 And the stories can really push their limit of understanding.
00:05:36 So why would they sit and focus their attention
00:05:40 so intently on something that
00:05:42 is really maybe even partly beyond them?
00:05:45 You know, if you're reading to a young child, the best approach is to read something to them
00:05:51 that's slightly beyond their ability to comprehend.
00:05:55 In fact, parents, by the way, speak naturally to their children at a level that's slightly above their current level of understanding.
00:06:03 And you can understand why, right?
00:06:05 Because that brings the child along in his or her sophistication in communication.
00:06:10 But we do that naturally, and we do that with the stories that we read kids to.
00:06:15 And they're naturally oriented to listening to a story.
00:06:21 Like a three-year-old doesn't want to listen to a story for babies, right?
00:06:24 Kids are very attentive to whether what they're being offered is in keeping with their developmental aim.
00:06:32 Adults are like that, too.
00:06:33 If you have any sense, you don't want something easy.
00:06:37 You want something optimally challenging.
00:06:39 that's way different than easy
00:06:41 we're naturally attracted to stories
00:06:46 we're so attracted to them that we can
00:06:50 we can learn through stories in some ways
00:06:54 without effort because the stories are so compelling
00:06:56 they're so naturally compelling to us
00:06:59 you'll pay to listen to a story or to watch one
00:07:03 and that seems self-evident in a way
00:07:06 you go to a movie and you'll pay to see a movie
00:07:09 and you think, if someone asks you, you'll say,
00:07:11 well, I find it enjoyable, I find it entertaining.
00:07:14 And that's like the explanation.
00:07:15 But it's not an explanation because it doesn't explain why you find it enjoyable.
00:07:20 And it particularly doesn't explain why you'd go see a horror movie
00:07:24 because it's not obvious that that's enjoyable.
00:07:30 But perhaps it's enjoyable to push the limits of your capability
00:07:38 to deal with the elements of life that are terrifying and that inspire horror.
00:07:49 And perhaps you have an instinct to master such things that's so deep
00:07:54 that you'll pay for the privilege of being voluntarily terrified in a theater.
00:07:59 That's how it works.
00:08:01 That's indicative of a very deep instinct, right?
00:08:03 It's an instinct that's so deep that it overcomes fear and disgust.
00:08:10 And it has to be a deep instinct to overcome fear and disgust,
00:08:14 because those are powerful inhibitory emotions.
00:08:21 Okay, so what does a story do?
00:08:24 Well, when you go watch a movie, for example,
00:08:27 this is how you understand people, by the way.
00:08:31 And when you go watch a movie, the director, the producer, the writer,
00:08:35 they show you the character's priorities.
00:08:42 They show you what the character attends to, what the character regards as important,
00:08:46 and how they sequence their actions.
00:08:50 And in consequence, you derive their aim.
00:08:54 And that's how you come to understand the character and identify with them.
00:08:57 And if the writer, the producer, the director is skillful,
00:09:01 they show you a number of different scenarios
00:09:04 where the character, the hero, the protagonist
00:09:07 demonstrates his priorities and his commitments.
00:09:13 You infer those,
00:09:16 and then you see the world through the eyes of the protagonist.
00:09:19 And then you experience the emotions and the perceptions
00:09:22 of the person that you're watching.
00:09:24 And that's what you do when you interact with other people too.
00:09:27 You infer their aim.
00:09:30 In consequence, you adopt their frame of reference.
00:09:34 That allows you to experience their perceptions and their emotions.
00:09:37 You read that off your own body, and that's how you understand the person.
00:09:41 So our understanding of other people is essentially narrative predicated.
00:09:47 You could think that you come to understand someone if you understand the story of their life.
00:09:52 Well, you come to understand yourself by understanding the story of your life.
00:09:56 So what does this story do?
00:10:00 It shows you how the protagonist prioritizes the facts.
00:10:07 Now there's a very large number of facts,
00:10:09 but one of the peculiarities of your consciousness
00:10:12 is that it has a very low bandwidth.
00:10:19 The bandwidth of your consciousness is estimated at something like 6 bits.
00:10:24 it's unbelievably focused when you look at the world when i look at the audience for example
00:10:32 if i want to see someone's face i can only look at one person at a time like if i look at your
00:10:37 face for example i really can't see the faces of the people here i can sort of see your face
00:10:43 you people are just basically blurs and then out about here even though i can't tell it you're in
00:10:50 black and white and I can only see you when you move that's how your visual system is set up and
00:10:54 so it's really pinpoint knowing not only when I look at someone's face I don't even actually look
00:10:59 at their face I'd likely look at one of their eyes or one of their eyes at a time I do that I
00:11:06 look at their eyes to infer their aim if I can watch what you're looking at I know what you're
00:11:11 attending to if I know what you're attending to I know what your aims are I know what your
00:11:16 priorities are, I can infer how the world looks to you, and then I can occupy your emotional state.
00:11:22 That's what we do when we go see a movie. We do that with the characters. Now, the movie is
00:11:27 distilled, right? You know, if you listen to someone who is telling you about their day,
00:11:35 there are people who are dull when they tell that story, and there are people who are interesting,
00:11:40 And the interesting people don't tell you dull things about their day
00:11:44 They distill the day down to the interesting occurrences
00:11:48 And so then you could think of a story as a distillation of
00:11:53 A distillation of the organization of attention
00:12:01 In the most interesting way
00:12:03 So when you go see an action adventure movie, for example
00:12:07 you don't spend the first 10 minutes if your protagonist wakes up in the morning
00:12:13 you don't see all the details of their breakfast and bathroom routine right but well but but and
00:12:23 that seems again it seems obvious it seems obvious because that's not interesting but it's not
00:12:27 obvious exactly it's like why is that not interesting what is it about what they do
00:12:33 that's interesting? Well, you want to see them pursue a goal that's indicative of their character
00:12:39 in a manner that's challenging. And you can certainly see that in a romantic action-adventure
00:12:45 movie, which is sort of the amalgam of the archetypal female and male plot, a romantic
00:12:51 adventure. If you have a romantic adventure hero, then you observe the optimal priority
00:13:03 of attention so that a romantic relationship can be established in the context of a compelling
00:13:15 adventure. And that's actually what you want in your life. Why should people sign up for
00:13:20 Peterson Academy? Well, at Peterson Academy, we can bring you eight-hour courses that will be
00:13:27 the best lectures that you will be able to get anywhere from the best professors in the Western
00:13:31 Bringing the best professors together, making sure they're not censored in any way,
00:13:34 giving them the audience and the remuneration and appreciation they deserve.
00:13:37 Learn about music, art, literature, mathematics, history, and biology.
00:13:42 A humanities education should enrich your experience in every direction.
00:13:48 We want to bring you the highest quality education possible at the lowest possible price.
00:13:52 Peterson Academy, if you want an actual education, join us.
00:13:56 Best possible courses, tens of thousands of people signing up.
00:13:59 Consider deeply who you could be.
00:14:02 Join our thriving, ambitious community.
00:14:12 You might think you want security, but you're not going to get it.
00:14:17 You can have it temporarily, but you're not going to get it.
00:14:20 And you might think that you want, what would you say,
00:14:24 immediate hedonistic gratification, but that's self-defeating.
00:14:27 And you might think that you want things to be easy, but if you pursue what's easy, you forego further development.
00:14:36 And so it appears that what you really want is something like optimized challenge.
00:14:41 And that's something like the heaviest burden you could bear voluntarily.
00:14:45 Those are very similar concepts.
00:14:47 So when you go see a James Bond movie, which is a romantic adventure,
00:14:52 obviously what you are watching is someone aiming at a high-order goal,
00:15:00 service to king and country, let's say.
00:15:03 Self-sacrificing service to king and country.
00:15:07 Now, is that the highest goal? Possibly not.
00:15:10 But it's a high goal, and it's sufficient to capture your attention,
00:15:14 and you want to see someone contend with vital challenges
00:15:19 in the pursuit of crucially important goals.
00:15:22 That would be on the hero side.
00:15:23 On the villain side, you want to see people...
00:15:29 I learned what the word iniquity means recently.
00:15:33 I didn't know what it meant.
00:15:34 Iniquity, it's an archaic term, biblical term.
00:15:38 Iniquity means consciously aiming down.
00:15:42 Right? That's different than stupidity. 1.00
00:15:44 It's different than ignorance. 0.99
00:15:45 It's even different than error or sin.
00:15:48 Because you can make an error. 0.99
00:15:50 You can be ignorant. 1.00
00:15:51 You can be blind. 1.00
00:15:54 In some ways, accidentally and ignorantly.
00:15:57 That's very different than aiming down.
00:16:01 I read a book once called Panzram.
00:16:05 That's quite the book. 0.99
00:16:10 Panzram, he was a mass murderer. 1.00
00:16:12 serial killer and a serial rapist. I think he raped 200 men, something like that. I don't 1.00
00:16:19 know how many he killed, but plenty. His last words, they were going to hang him. His last 0.94
00:16:24 words were, hurry up you, who's your bastard? I could kill 12 people in the time it's taken 1.00
00:16:29 you to knot that rope. Right. And so that was Panzram. And he was brutally abused when 1.00
00:16:35 he was a child, and he made a conscious vow to make everything as miserable as he possibly could. 0.85
00:16:44 And he was very smart, and he was very physically strong, and he was quite the bloody catastrophe.
00:16:52 And he met a psychiatrist in prison, offered him a cigarette, and Panzrab told him that that was
00:17:01 the only kind thing he could remember anyone ever doing for him, which may have had more to do with
00:17:09 the character of Panzram than the people around him. But he started to get to know this psychiatrist
00:17:15 and to talk to him. He warned him, though. He said, look, if you're in the prison cell with me,
00:17:20 never turn your back on me. Right? Because he had practiced malevolence to such a degree that
00:17:28 even when he regarded
00:17:30 himself as positively predisposed
00:17:32 to someone, he wasn't sure he wouldn't 0.99
00:17:34 kill them if he had the opportunity 0.60
00:17:35 in any case, the prison psychiatrist 1.00
00:17:38 convinced
00:17:40 him to write his autobiography
00:17:42 and you can read it
00:17:44 if you're inclined
00:17:45 hands-wrapped
00:17:48 he aimed down
00:17:50 and if you go see
00:17:52 a villain in a
00:17:53 when you see a villain portrayed
00:17:56 aid in a movie, let's say, in a work of fiction, you occupy the attentional space of someone
00:18:04 who's aiming down. One of the best examples of that recently, I would say, is the Heath
00:18:11 Ledger character, the Joker in the Batman series, specifically the Heath Ledger character.
00:18:15 There's one element in that movie that's particularly telling.
00:18:19 if i remember correctly the joker arranges with the local mafia to rob a series of banks
00:18:30 and the deal is they're going to split it 50 50 which they do and then the joker lights the
00:18:37 money on fire which what would you say terrifies the criminals right and that's so interesting
00:18:46 Because the thing about criminals, a criminal is sort of like you.
00:18:53 He likes money, too.
00:18:55 He just doesn't agree with you about how it's to be had.
00:18:59 And so you can actually understand a criminal because you have a car and you like it,
00:19:04 and he would like your car.
00:19:07 Now, it's a lot harder to understand the guy who would just take your car and burn it.
00:19:12 Right? Well, that's more like iniquity.
00:19:14 And that's a much more profound form of evil.
00:19:19 That's evil for its own sake.
00:19:21 That's a good way of thinking about it.
00:19:23 And that's what iniquity is.
00:19:24 And one of the things that you're doing
00:19:26 when you're occupying the archetypal landscape of villainy
00:19:33 when you're watching a movie
00:19:35 is fleshing out for yourself the attentional structure of evil.
00:19:41 Okay, so, and why?
00:19:44 well because you should know what the dark part of you is like and it's a lot worse than you think
00:19:51 you may have noticed that during covid right i mean really it was quite the bloody shock wasn't
00:19:58 it just how rapidly everything turned into a tyranny and just how many people were thrilled
00:20:03 about that right and so but then also like even if it isn't you that you have to be concerned with
00:20:11 with regards to villainy and it is you also don't want to be naive about malevolence in general
00:20:18 because in the world at large you and your wife and your husband your children you're going to
00:20:25 encounter malevolence and if you don't understand it you're a sitting duck and it's it's clearly the
00:20:33 people who don't understand evil who are most likely to be targeted by the psychopathic and
00:20:39 the malevolent. And they justify that as well. And the justification is, if you're stupid enough
00:20:45 to let me get away with what I'm doing, you deserve it. And you can take issue with that 1.00
00:20:52 argument, but it's not without its merit. In any case, that is how particularly pathological people
00:21:01 justify their predatory and parasitical behavior, let's say. And the best defense against that is
00:21:07 to understand that such impulses and such people exist.
00:21:12 And part of the way we practice that
00:21:14 is by exposing ourselves to characters like that
00:21:19 in the realm of so-called entertainment.
00:21:22 Why is that entertaining?
00:21:24 In the Harry Potter series, for example,
00:21:26 of course, that's an archetypal battle between good and evil,
00:21:30 just like the Lord of the Rings or the Hobbit,
00:21:32 Just like Star Wars, many of the epic mass entertainment spectacles
00:21:40 are battles between good and evil.
00:21:41 That's part of a romantic adventure.
00:21:49 The reason it's entertaining for us to observe and participate in the portrayals of villainy
00:21:56 is because the impetus for us to develop wisdom is so strong
00:22:00 that it overcomes our repugnance to the encounter with what's dark.
00:22:06 It overrides it.
00:22:08 And it's so strong that it overrides it and makes it gripping and entertaining.
00:22:13 And that's an indication of just how important it is.
00:22:16 It's vital.
00:22:17 And so you think, well, it's entertaining to see a movie.
00:22:19 It's like, fair enough.
00:22:20 But the story is everything.
00:22:22 if you tell someone the story of your life you're describing the manner in which you prioritize
00:22:31 the world you're describing your structure values you're describing what you attend to
00:22:38 and what you ignore you're describing what you elevate and what you denigrate you're surprising
00:22:45 You're describing what you celebrate and what you, what do you say, what you ignore.
00:22:53 You describe what you worship and are subject to and what you have contempt for.
00:22:59 That's what you experience when you see the characterization of someone in a work of fiction.
00:23:05 That's what fiction is for.
00:23:07 It distills, it's a distillation of priority.
00:23:13 You know, and you might say
00:23:19 Well, you see the world as a set of facts
00:23:24 Valueless facts, objective facts
00:23:26 And then you attribute value to them
00:23:29 And that's how you prioritize
00:23:32 But that isn't true
00:23:33 It's not true
00:23:34 You can't even perceive the world without prioritizing
00:23:39 So this is a revolutionary discovery.
00:23:43 It's really been made, again, by a variety of different investigators
00:23:47 over really about the last 50 years.
00:23:50 But the way your visual system works, for example,
00:23:56 as I alluded to, is you single out one thing
00:24:02 and you suppress everything else.
00:24:04 You can't even see the facts without prioritizing.
00:24:08 So the prioritization actually comes before the facts.
00:24:14 That's how important stories are.
00:24:19 The world reveals itself to you in accordance with your prioritization.
00:24:23 This is something stunning, stunning to understand.
00:24:28 Because one of the things that you can infer from that is that
00:24:30 if things aren't going so well for you, there's many reasons you can suffer.
00:24:34 But one potential reason is the world is making itself manifest to you as an intolerable place because your priorities are wrong.
00:24:46 Now, that's a frightening realization because it means that your error is proportionate to your unbearable suffering.
00:24:57 And that's a rough realization.
00:24:59 but the alternative hypothesis isn't great
00:25:02 which is that you're doomed to suffer
00:25:03 because the world itself is set against you
00:25:06 and that's like
00:25:07 what are you going to do then?
00:25:09 well you're going to be resentful
00:25:10 but you're not going to have agency
00:25:12 you're not going to be able to change it
00:25:14 because if the world's at fault
00:25:15 not at you
00:25:16 and not you
00:25:17 you're doomed
00:25:19 now if it's you that's at fault
00:25:21 that's a problem
00:25:22 but at least it might be one you can rectify
00:25:25 one of the
00:25:27 most profound and continual
00:25:32 one of the things that's insisted upon
00:25:39 most profoundly and continually
00:25:40 in the biblical narratives is that
00:25:43 meditation on your own faults is
00:25:47 there's nothing more productive than
00:25:49 voluntary meditation on your own faults
00:25:52 that's humility
00:25:53 why?
00:25:55 maybe you're wrong
00:25:57 And you might think, well, that's terrible.
00:25:59 It's like, no, maybe you want to find out where you're wrong.
00:26:03 Cammie mentioned in her discussion that you could be grateful,
00:26:08 peculiarly enough, if you could find out where you were in error.
00:26:11 Why grateful?
00:26:12 Well, it's painful because you have to change,
00:26:15 and that's confusing and disconcerting,
00:26:18 and it can produce a decrease in hope.
00:26:22 But God, if you can figure out where you're wrong,
00:26:24 you could stop being wrong
00:26:28 and then you don't have to repeat 0.62
00:26:30 your bloody cataclysmic error
00:26:32 and maybe that's worth a little bit 0.71
00:26:35 of short term suffering
00:26:36 well that's the hope of humility
00:26:39 where am I wrong?
00:26:46 okay now I want to illustrate
00:26:48 that, all of that
00:26:50 with a story
00:26:51 so I've been taking apart
00:26:53 the story of Cain and Abel
00:26:54 for like 40 years, which is a strange, because it's only about two paragraphs long, and you
00:27:02 wouldn't think that it could be condensed enough to bear that amount of attention for that amount
00:27:08 of time. But we already pointed out that like a movie is a distillation, right? If you watch a
00:27:15 James Bond movie, you only see the most exciting things that happen to James Bond. Everything else
00:27:20 is eliminated from consideration only what's essential to carry the story and to characterize
00:27:27 is presented to you well then you can imagine a story that people have worked on for 7 000 years
00:27:35 and then you might diligently and then you might ask well how condensed might that be
00:27:41 and the answer might be it's so condensed that every single word
00:27:47 resounds with vital meaning.
00:27:53 It's highly probable.
00:27:55 Why would it be remembered?
00:27:57 Why would it be told?
00:27:58 Why would it be transmitted
00:27:59 across the millennia
00:28:01 if there wasn't something
00:28:03 incomprehensibly profound about it?
00:28:08 Two paragraphs.
00:28:10 Okay, so here's how the story goes.
00:28:13 Now, the first thing you want to understand
00:28:15 about this story is it's the story
00:28:17 about the first two human beings.
00:28:19 Now, you could say, well, Adam and Eve,
00:28:21 speaking biblically, let's say,
00:28:23 Adam and Eve are the first two human beings,
00:28:25 but that's not exactly right
00:28:27 because they're made by God,
00:28:29 they're not born,
00:28:30 and they're situated in paradise,
00:28:34 not the profane world.
00:28:38 Cain and Abel are the first two figures,
00:28:41 the first two characters,
00:28:43 born in our world, so to speak.
00:28:46 Okay, so what do they represent?
00:28:48 They represent two ways of dealing with the world.
00:28:51 Okay, so the hypothesis in that story,
00:28:55 and this is the story that in some ways, it opens history.
00:29:00 That's a way of thinking about it.
00:29:01 It's the story that opens history after the fall.
00:29:05 So that's the history of the profane world.
00:29:07 That's our world.
00:29:08 the first hypothesis is there's two fundamental patterns of dealing with the world now you kind
00:29:17 of already know that because you know that there's good and there's evil that's two different ways of
00:29:22 dealing with the world you know that in a movie there's a bad guy and a good guy right you know
00:29:26 that superman has lex luther and batman has the joker and harry potter has voldemort and
00:29:35 And there's always this dichotomy between the hero and the, and the what?
00:29:42 The villain, the sacred and the demonic, good and evil.
00:29:46 That's the pattern.
00:29:49 The pattern of Cain and Abel is replicated by Satan and Christ at a higher level of abstraction.
00:29:57 But it's the pattern of good and evil.
00:30:01 And those are the two fundamental ways of dealing with the world.
00:30:05 Okay, so what does that pattern look like?
00:30:11 Well, it's first characterized as two different forms of sacrifice.
00:30:17 Now, this is hard for modern people to understand
00:30:22 because the manner in which the story is presented,
00:30:25 the story of Cain and Abel, is archaic.
00:30:28 It isn't obvious to the modern reader what it's referring to.
00:30:33 we can't easily identify with
00:30:38 taking the best
00:30:40 lamb from our flock
00:30:44 building an altar 0.98
00:30:45 and burning it to please God
00:30:48 that isn't something we do
00:30:50 and so to understand what that means
00:30:53 it takes some work to understand what that means
00:30:57 and it's complicated
00:30:59 so let's take that apart
00:31:02 See, Abel makes sacrifices.
00:31:07 And they're pleasing to God.
00:31:10 And Cain makes sacrifices.
00:31:13 And they're rejected.
00:31:15 Okay, so you might say, first of all, you might ask, why the hell should you care?
00:31:19 And the right answer to that is, have all your sacrifices been accepted?
00:31:27 Right?
00:31:27 And what that, well, that's, there's no difference between that question and are you successful, right?
00:31:34 Is what you're doing pleasing to you?
00:31:36 Like in a fundamental way, is it pleasing to your wife?
00:31:39 Is it pleasing to your family?
00:31:40 Pleasing and successful.
00:31:42 Is your community responding properly to it?
00:31:45 Is it something that, what would you say, brings advantage to your nation?
00:31:49 Like, what you do, there's no difference between what you do and your sacrifices.
00:31:58 Those are the same thing.
00:32:00 Well, you actually already know that in a deep way,
00:32:03 because you understand, for example, that it's necessary to work.
00:32:08 In order to live, you must work.
00:32:12 Okay, well, what does work?
00:32:15 First of all, why?
00:32:17 Well, the answer to that is, well, things just don't come to you, right?
00:32:21 You're either going to put in the effort or someone else is going to put in the effort.
00:32:24 Those are the options.
00:32:27 Effortless success does not exist, right?
00:32:30 Your basic state is one of privation.
00:32:33 And in consequence, you have to overcome that.
00:32:35 And the way that human beings overcome that is to work.
00:32:38 What does it mean to work?
00:32:41 Technically, what do you mean when you say work?
00:32:44 It's not play.
00:32:46 Work is what?
00:32:47 Work is what you have to be paid to do, let's say.
00:32:51 Right?
00:32:52 You wouldn't, if you're fortunate, maybe you have a spectacular career,
00:32:56 your interests and your work are aligned.
00:32:59 But it's very frequently the case that in order to provide for yourself,
00:33:04 you have to forego the pleasures of the present
00:33:08 for the stability of the future
00:33:11 and the service of your wife, husband, family, community, right?
00:33:17 That's a sacrifice.
00:33:19 You're sacrificing the immediacy of the present
00:33:22 for the future and the community.
00:33:26 Okay, now imagine you can do that well,
00:33:28 in which case your sacrifices will be accepted,
00:33:31 or you can do it badly, in which case they'll be rejected.
00:33:36 Well, so then that seems to make sense.
00:33:40 You know that people are differentially successful.
00:33:42 And you kind of know, I think.
00:33:49 You know that if you put everything you have into something.
00:33:52 That you're much more likely to succeed than you are if you do a second rate job.
00:33:56 I don't think anybody disputes that.
00:33:59 Now you can get bitter about that.
00:34:01 Cynical.
00:34:01 And you can say that in the final analysis.
00:34:06 Consequences aren't related to effort.
00:34:08 But the probability that you really believe that is low.
00:34:13 The probability that that's a post hoc excuse for your fundamental uselessness is very high, right?
00:34:24 See, God tells Cain that if he did well, that his sacrifices would be accepted.
00:34:33 You know, and that's one of those phrases that carries an awful lot of weight.
00:34:37 Because it implies that you're constituted such that if your attitude was appropriate and if your sacrifices were genuine and upward aiming, success of the highest quality would come to you.
00:34:58 That's a statement about the structure of the world, right?
00:35:00 And not just about the world, but about your relationship with the world.
00:35:03 it's a statement that implies that
00:35:05 you're made for the world
00:35:07 and the world's made for you
00:35:08 and that you could find your place
00:35:10 and that would be a welcoming place
00:35:11 but that would be dependent on
00:35:13 how it was that you conducted yourself
00:35:15 and it's possible that the standards
00:35:18 for quality are high
00:35:20 here's an example of that
00:35:22 in the story of Adam and Eve
00:35:25 when Adam and Eve get kicked out
00:35:27 of the Garden of Eden
00:35:28 the way to paradise is barred for them
00:35:31 and it's barred by an angel, a cherubim
00:35:35 and a sword
00:35:37 and the sword is on fire
00:35:39 and it turns every which way
00:35:41 which means you can't escape it
00:35:43 and what that means
00:35:45 it's self-evident once you understand what it means
00:35:50 nothing that's unworthy can exist in paradise
00:35:55 well obviously, right?
00:35:57 because it wouldn't be paradise
00:35:58 if something that wasn't worthy could get in
00:36:01 Well, then the way is going to be barred.
00:36:05 Well, by what?
00:36:06 By a sword that's on fire, that cuts and burns,
00:36:09 that gets rid of everything that isn't acceptable.
00:36:13 Or ideal, even.
00:36:15 That's a high standard.
00:36:17 But it's paradise you're talking about,
00:36:18 so what do you want?
00:36:19 You want a low-quality paradise.
00:36:22 That's not going to work.
00:36:24 And so, that story precedes the Cain and Abel story,
00:36:28 But there's an implication that's already built into the context that your sacrifices have to be of the highest quality in order to be acceptable.
00:36:39 Now, then you might ask, what does high quality mean?
00:36:42 That's a good question, because people differ a lot in their ability.
00:36:47 You know, imagine you have two children of very different ability.
00:36:51 One of the ways you're going to judge the quality of their offering is in consequence of their effort, right?
00:36:57 So if you have a child who happens to be intellectually impaired,
00:37:00 you're going to use a different standard for what constitutes ideal for them
00:37:06 than for a child that you have, let's say, that's more intellectually gifted.
00:37:11 The standards can be stringent in both situations,
00:37:14 even though they're adapted to the particularities of the person.
00:37:19 Okay, so now,
00:37:23 able sacrifices are characterized in a particular way.
00:37:27 So he takes care of animals, and the sacrifices that he offers are the best cuts of the best animals.
00:37:39 So he owns things of value. He has a storehouse of value. That's his flock.
00:37:47 And to demonstrate his commitment to what's highest, he indicates his willingness to offer what he has that's best.
00:37:56 Okay, so now imagine these archaic people are trying to act out something.
00:38:02 Right?
00:38:02 They're trying to act out how you adjust yourself properly to life.
00:38:08 And one of the hypotheses that they're toying with is,
00:38:14 the higher the quality of your offering, the better the world will treat you.
00:38:21 And then that's concretized.
00:38:22 It's like the best cut of the most flawless animal
00:38:26 from among the best animals in the flock.
00:38:28 But you can see the pattern there.
00:38:30 The pattern is, bring what you have of value to the table.
00:38:36 And God's offer is, that'll work.
00:38:42 Well, to dispute that, you'd have to assume
00:38:46 that there's no relationship between commitment and effort and outcome.
00:38:48 and you better pray you don't accept that argument
00:38:53 because there's nothing in that 0.99
00:38:56 that won't make you cynical, useless, and bitter, obviously. 0.99
00:39:00 Now, you know, you can be in a society that's so corrupt 0.97
00:39:04 that if you're good, you're punished, let's say,
00:39:08 but in a society like that,
00:39:11 you should aim your efforts at revamping the structure of the society.
00:39:16 Right, that's what happens if you're engaged in a totalitarian tyranny, let's say.
00:39:22 Okay, so Abel offers what he has that's best.
00:39:28 And the consequence of that is that everyone, everything works for him.
00:39:33 Right? Everything he does flourishes.
00:39:37 Women love him. The people around him are happy with him.
00:39:41 The sun is shining on Abel.
00:39:43 Whereas Cain
00:39:45 Cain's not doing so well
00:39:48 Now, there's an implication in the text
00:39:50 It doesn't say directly
00:39:52 That Cain's offerings
00:39:54 Are second rate
00:39:55 But it says directly that Abel's 0.74
00:39:58 Are first rate
00:39:59 So there's an implication there
00:40:01 That there's something lacking in Cain's offerings
00:40:04 It's not well specified
00:40:05 And I actually think that's reasonable
00:40:08 Because there's lots of ways
00:40:09 For you not to offer your best
00:40:12 There's all sorts of ways to fail.
00:40:13 Willful blindness, that's one.
00:40:15 You're not paying attention to things you should be paying attention to.
00:40:18 Your aim isn't upward, right?
00:40:21 You're in it only for your immediate selfish gratification.
00:40:26 You're trying to take advantage of other people.
00:40:28 You're playing a crooked game.
00:40:31 You offer to people something that's second rate,
00:40:34 and you know it, and you torment them if they don't accept your lie.
00:40:41 So there's lots of ways that you can game the system.
00:40:45 And it isn't obvious how Cain is doing it.
00:40:48 Although we know that he's not bringing his best to the table.
00:40:51 And we know that God is not pleased.
00:40:54 Okay, so Cain is suffering.
00:40:58 And he's suffering from failure.
00:41:02 Okay, now that's an interesting thing too.
00:41:04 Because one of the things you might say about your life is that you suffer from failure.
00:41:12 And Cain takes aim at God.
00:41:16 So Cain's conclusion from his suffering,
00:41:21 this is a resentful conclusion,
00:41:22 is that God made an error in how the world was formulated.
00:41:27 The cosmos is not acceptable in its current form.
00:41:30 And the evidence for that is that what Cain is doing isn't working.
00:41:35 Now, it shouldn't take much effort on your behalf to understand
00:41:40 what that means and why that's a tempting conclusion.
00:41:44 Because you know, when you're resentful, for example,
00:41:47 that the probability that you'll blame external forces,
00:41:54 the patriarchy, for example,
00:41:56 your wife, your husband, your parents, your friends,
00:42:02 the educational system, the capitalists,
00:42:05 the probability that you'll find some external source to blame
00:42:09 is extremely high.
00:42:11 Why?
00:42:12 Well, it's pretty convenient for you in the short term if it's someone else's fault.
00:42:17 And Cain takes that to the ultimate conclusion, which we do all the time.
00:42:21 This isn't something that's unique to this primary villain, let's say.
00:42:32 If something untoward happens to you, if tragedy visits you and you feel that it's undeserved,
00:42:40 the probability that you'll be tempted to question the validity of the cosmic order itself,
00:42:48 the validity of your own existence, the validity of the human race,
00:42:52 the validity of life, the benevolence of God,
00:42:56 the probability that you'll question that is very, very high.
00:43:00 And it's not that surprising because you can suffer a lot
00:43:04 and sometimes the reasons aren't that clear.
00:43:06 And so you can easily accept the argument that if you're failing, you will suffer.
00:43:15 And the reason you're suffering is because you're failing.
00:43:19 So that's what Cain tells God, essentially.
00:43:24 He says, look, everything's going great for Abel, and that doesn't seem particularly reasonable.
00:43:29 And here I am, you know, busted myself, working like mad, and nothing's going right for me.
00:43:36 what the hell do you think you're doing?
00:43:39 Which is, you know, really quite the question to pose to God. 0.96
00:43:43 That's why it's resentment and arrogance.
00:43:48 It's like, I see.
00:43:49 So when you fail, you're going to make the decision that
00:43:52 your parents, your family, society,
00:43:57 the natural order and God himself are at fault.
00:44:00 Well, you've got to ask yourself in that situation,
00:44:03 Just exactly who it is that's introducing such presumptuous thoughts into your mind.
00:44:13 Like, just exactly who's occupying your psyche and to what end.
00:44:20 And this is exactly what God tells Cain.
00:44:23 It's a remarkable exchange.
00:44:26 Because Cain says, essentially, or acts out,
00:44:31 I'm bitter and unhappy and angry, and the reason for that is I'm failing, and the reason for that
00:44:37 is that preference is being shown to my brother, and that's unjust. I'm miserable because of
00:44:43 injustice and failure. And God says, I'm angry, bitter, and resentful because of injustice and
00:44:53 failure. And God says, no, that's not why you're angry, bitter, and resentful. Okay, so let's take
00:45:01 that apart for a minute, because pretty much everybody accepts this hypothesis, you know.
00:45:06 So here's an example. You know, you hear about the high school shooters, and the first thing you
00:45:10 always hear is, they were bullied. As if that's a just, well, of course, if you were bullied, you're
00:45:16 gonna shoot elementary school kids. That's obvious. And then, because you were bullied, and you had 0.99
00:45:22 your reason to be bitter. It's like, well, first of all, no. Second, that's just not the case,
00:45:31 because virtually everyone is bullied. Like, I bet there's not a single person in the audience
00:45:36 who wasn't bullied for some reason as a child. I know that 75% of children are bullied because
00:45:43 of some marked physical or psychological abnormality. Abnormality. You know, a bully
00:45:51 will pick on something strange about you. And then you might say, well, bullies pick on the
00:45:56 strange kids. It's like, no, everyone's got something strange about them. Maybe it's your
00:46:02 last name. Maybe it's your best friend's last name. Maybe it's the nickname that someone gave
00:46:08 you accidentally. A bully will find something peculiar about you to pick on. And then you
00:46:13 might say, well, if you're bullied, do you learn to be a bully? It's like, no, not necessarily.
00:46:19 In fact, most people, the lesson that most people derive from being bullied is, don't bully.
00:46:28 So you might say, well, there's a causal connection between being bullied and being malevolent.
00:46:32 It's like, no, because there's also a causal connection between being bullied and being good.
00:46:38 And there's lots of people in the world who've had dreadful childhoods,
00:46:42 like pathological beyond imagining,
00:46:45 who conclude from that
00:46:47 that under no circumstances whatsoever
00:46:49 will they take that road.
00:46:51 And so here's an example of that. 0.91
00:46:54 Most people who abuse children sexually
00:46:57 were abused sexually as children.
00:47:00 Okay?
00:47:01 And you think, well, causality.
00:47:02 It's like, no.
00:47:04 Because most people who are abused sexually as children
00:47:07 don't abuse children when they become adults.
00:47:11 And we know that because if the reverse was the case,
00:47:14 in a few generations, everybody would be abusing children, right?
00:47:17 It would spread exponentially.
00:47:19 Most people's conclusion,
00:47:21 in consequence of being subjected to malevolence,
00:47:26 is to control that within themselves and to quell it.
00:47:31 And some people derive the opposite conclusion,
00:47:33 that if they're victimized,
00:47:36 and everyone is victimized,
00:47:37 although the degree to which that occurs varies,
00:47:40 if they're victimized, it's perfectly appropriate that they
00:47:43 themselves become victimizers.
00:47:47 And their justification is, well, you know, I was hurt.
00:47:50 It's like, fair enough.
00:47:52 Like, you can see the causal connection
00:47:53 and you can understand the motivation,
00:47:55 but that isn't the conclusion that most people draw.
00:47:59 And just because you can understand the conclusion
00:48:01 does not mean it's valid or inevitable.
00:48:03 And that's what God tells Cain.
00:48:05 And it's very subtle.
00:48:07 Like, it's hard to parse these things out in this story.
00:48:10 God tells Cain something very particular.
00:48:12 Kim makes this complaint.
00:48:13 I'm failing.
00:48:14 I'm bitter and resentful at a consequence.
00:48:17 Everything's going well for my brother.
00:48:19 That makes me angry and unhappy.
00:48:23 All that's evidence of the injustice of the world.
00:48:26 And God says, now you're missing an intervening variable.
00:48:35 Sin crouches at your door.
00:48:37 That's misaligned aim.
00:48:38 That's what sin means.
00:48:39 Sin means to miss the target.
00:48:41 Sin crouches at your door 0.94
00:48:43 Like a sexually aroused 1.00
00:48:46 Predatory animal 0.90
00:48:48 And you invited it in
00:48:51 To have its way with you
00:48:54 Now, there are echoes of that idea
00:48:58 In all sorts of different ancient myths
00:49:01 It's echoed, for example, in an Egyptian creation myth
00:49:04 Where
00:49:05 The spirit of evil rapes the hero
00:49:11 There's this sexual element I wanted to point to, right? 0.58
00:49:14 Because it's very stark. 0.99
00:49:16 Sexually aroused predatory animal having its way with you. 0.99
00:49:20 Okay, why sexually aroused? 1.00
00:49:24 Well, you could say, I hate to be vulgar, but because it wants to fuck with you. 1.00
00:49:28 And I'm sorry to be vulgar, but it's appropriate in this story 0.99
00:49:31 because it's pointing to what that phrase means.
00:49:36 And see, I've talked to people in my clinical practice, for example,
00:49:40 who were harboring murderous fantasies.
00:49:44 You know, it was often the case that comes to mind at the moment
00:49:47 was the case of a woman that I had in my practice for a while
00:49:52 whose family had been badly brutalized by another family member.
00:49:59 And she entertained seriously murderous fantasies for hundreds of hours.
00:50:13 Now, you know, you don't get from bullied high school student
00:50:17 to homicidal school shooter with notebooks full of plans
00:50:23 without several thousand hours of brooding.
00:50:27 Okay, so what does it mean to brood?
00:50:30 Well, that's what a hen does when it sits on an egg, right?
00:50:33 If you're trying to bring something to life,
00:50:35 if you're trying to hatch something new and monstrous,
00:50:38 you brood on it.
00:50:39 Well, what's that?
00:50:40 Well, that's a creative act.
00:50:43 It's the consequence of consorting with something you've invited in.
00:50:48 Well, what's the sexual metaphor?
00:50:49 It's a creative collaboration.
00:50:55 And that's what God tells Cain.
00:50:57 And it's like, things aren't going well for you.
00:51:00 You're bitter.
00:51:01 Okay.
00:51:02 You wouldn't have had to be bitter, let's say.
00:51:04 You could have decided that you were in error.
00:51:07 You could have foregone your deceit.
00:51:10 You could have improved the quality of your sacrifices.
00:51:13 You could have asked yourself where you were in error.
00:51:17 You could have been happy for what you did have.
00:51:20 You could have copied your brother.
00:51:23 there are lots of things you could have done
00:51:25 when failure came
00:51:27 knocking. You could have learned
00:51:29 and improved yourself so you didn't
00:51:31 fail in the future. But you decided
00:51:33 instead that you'd be bitter
00:51:35 and resentful and you'd invite
00:51:37 that in
00:51:38 and you'd enter into a creative
00:51:41 collaboration with it
00:51:43 and that's why you're 0.99
00:51:45 miserable.
00:51:47 It's like, that's how
00:51:48 See, that's what happens when you argue
00:51:51 with God. You don't win. Right. And Cain definitely does not win this argument. In fact, he hears
00:51:59 the thing he least wants to hear. And that's often how you can tell when you hear something
00:52:07 true. It's like, oh, I really wish it wasn't that, you know. And that's certainly what happens
00:52:15 in Cain's situation.
00:52:17 And then God says to him,
00:52:20 it's at that point,
00:52:20 he says,
00:52:21 if you did well,
00:52:21 you'd be accepted.
00:52:23 And that's a hard proposition
00:52:24 to accept too because,
00:52:26 and you know,
00:52:26 we could even dispute that.
00:52:32 Is it systemic injustice
00:52:34 that makes you fail?
00:52:36 Or is it the inadequacy
00:52:38 of your own efforts?
00:52:42 There's always systemic injustice,
00:52:44 right?
00:52:45 Because society is always contaminated by corruption.
00:52:50 No relationship's perfect.
00:52:52 No psyche is perfect.
00:52:53 No relationship is perfect.
00:52:55 No family, no community, no state.
00:52:58 There's always injustice.
00:53:00 But people succeed and fail in different proportions,
00:53:03 even if the level of injustice is in some ways held constant.
00:53:09 And you might say, well, it's unfair to blame the victim, Cain,
00:53:15 But then, I don't know, it isn't obvious to me that Cain is exactly being blamed.
00:53:20 What God says to him is something like, there's a lot more to you than you thought.
00:53:25 And you believe that the only lesson you can derive from your failure is misery and bitterness.
00:53:32 But you have within you the capacity to transcend even your own failure and to set yourself right and to succeed.
00:53:41 And you might say that, well, it's more difficult to succeed under challenging circumstances.
00:53:46 But then you could also say, well, the field of opportunity is much greater in challenging circumstances
00:53:51 because there's more things to set right.
00:53:54 And that's true.
00:53:56 The more problems around you, the more things you have to solve.
00:54:01 Now, that doesn't make it easy, but it's a different way of looking at it.
00:54:05 So God has this chat with Cain
00:54:10 And then Cain leaves
00:54:13 And in keeping with his nature
00:54:16 He rejects any contemplation of what he's been told
00:54:22 And it's not surprising, right?
00:54:25 Because it's a really damning judgment
00:54:27 First of all, it undermines all his rationalizations
00:54:31 You're not miserable because you're failing
00:54:34 You're miserable because you invited in the spirit of resentment
00:54:38 to possess you, and you collaborated with it.
00:54:43 And that's an interesting,
00:54:46 that's a very interesting way of viewing it, eh?
00:54:48 Because I read fairly extensively the accounts
00:54:53 of the Columbine high school shooters,
00:54:57 and the main one, Dylan Klebold,
00:54:59 if I remember his name correctly.
00:55:01 I shouldn't even say it, really,
00:55:02 but he kept quite extensive notes
00:55:06 and they really become satanic.
00:55:09 Like he writes things
00:55:10 that you can't believe anyone would write.
00:55:14 Like they're metaphysically surreal.
00:55:17 And this is 24 hours before he goes on his rampage.
00:55:22 He says something like,
00:55:23 it's surreal to contemplate.
00:55:27 While I'm in my humanly form,
00:55:30 what's about to transpire in 24 hours.
00:55:34 It's like, who the hell writes that
00:55:36 when you're 17?
00:55:38 Like, what dark abysses have you inhabited
00:55:41 for thousands of hours to come up with that?
00:55:45 And he portrays himself as well
00:55:47 as the judge of the human race.
00:55:49 Finds it wanting.
00:55:51 Would be best if everything was brought to an end.
00:55:56 That's the spirit of Cain.
00:56:01 So then what happens?
00:56:06 Cain approaches his brother Abel.
00:56:08 Now remember, Cain really wants to be Abel.
00:56:13 That's why he's jealous, right?
00:56:15 So Abel is actually Cain's ideal.
00:56:19 Cain wouldn't feel like he was a failure unless he was contrasting himself with Abel.
00:56:24 He obviously defines success as what has befallen Abel.
00:56:29 and so the reason he's bitter and resentful
00:56:31 is because he's not his brother
00:56:33 so even Cain
00:56:36 even though he's aiming down
00:56:38 let's say
00:56:38 he's perfectly capable of
00:56:40 noting what up constitutes
00:56:43 and contrasting himself unfavorably with it
00:56:46 well then he goes and makes a false bargain
00:56:49 with his brother
00:56:49 he says
00:56:50 why don't we work together
00:56:52 come out in the field with me
00:56:54 and when he
00:56:57 says that and entices his brother
00:56:59 out into the field. He kills
00:57:01 him with a rock. 1.00
00:57:04 So that's
00:57:05 kind of a rough story
00:57:07 to open history with.
00:57:11 It's very stark.
00:57:13 And then it gets worse after
00:57:15 that because
00:57:16 Cain goes to God.
00:57:19 God calls him on his
00:57:21 crime. And Cain
00:57:23 says, my punishment is more
00:57:25 than I can bear. 0.97
00:57:27 well that's an interesting phrase and why is that well what happens if you kill your ideal
00:57:33 what if you kill your ideal out of resentment i mean you could do that physically that's what
00:57:39 cain does he kills his brother but you could do it psychologically you know imagine that you
00:57:43 are dallying with the spirit of resentment because of your inability to learn from failure
00:57:49 and allow yourself to get so bitter that you become cynical about the possibility of
00:57:56 valid success itself.
00:57:59 And you use that to justify your own failures.
00:58:02 There's no such thing as real success.
00:58:04 Everybody who has anything took it. 0.97
00:58:07 They're thieves. 0.95
00:58:08 The whole system is corrupt. 1.00
00:58:11 Everyone successful is manipulative and criminal.
00:58:16 It's like, there's some truth in that.
00:58:22 some crooked people are temporarily successful.
00:58:29 What that says about marriage, family, community, city, state,
00:58:35 that's a whole different issue.
00:58:38 But if you accept that doctrine, then it means that,
00:58:41 well, then what are you going to do?
00:58:43 Does that mean everything successful you ever did was manipulative and criminal?
00:58:47 And that's all that's left?
00:58:49 There's no such thing as genuine attainment or accomplishment.
00:58:53 Well, let's say you accept that because you want an excuse for your failure and misbehavior.
00:58:58 Now you decide you're going to kill your ideal. 0.99
00:59:01 Psychologically. 1.00
00:59:04 Striving is for suckers. 0.98
00:59:07 Well, then what? 0.98
00:59:09 You got no hope.
00:59:12 There's no hope for you.
00:59:14 Because nothing is good.
00:59:16 And you might say, well, that gives you a good excuse to not be good.
00:59:20 It's like, fair enough, but nothing's good now.
00:59:23 And that's Cain's fate.
00:59:27 My punishment is more than I can bear.
00:59:29 And then something else happens to him.
00:59:31 So God marks him and has him, condemns him to wander in the land of Nod.
00:59:38 Wander alone in the land of Nod. 0.98
00:59:41 Okay, so the land of Nod, you may remember this, some of you older people.
00:59:44 Well, anyways, that's where children go when they sleep, off to the land of Nod.
00:59:50 So what does that mean?
00:59:51 Well, that's where the unconscious people are.
00:59:56 And so why is Cain unconscious?
00:59:59 Because he can't bear the knowledge of his own misbehavior.
01:00:03 And so he chooses to sacrifice his awareness rather than to be aware of who he is and what he's done. 0.88
01:00:12 He chooses to be foolishly unconscious and blind.
01:00:17 And then he wanders alone in that territory. 0.91
01:00:20 Why?
01:00:21 Well, if you're resentful and murderous and unable to cooperate and unconscious and blind, 0.68
01:00:29 you're going to be alone.
01:00:32 And you're going to wander from place to place because no one's going to be able to stand being anywhere near you.
01:00:40 And so that's Cain's fate.
01:00:42 And you might think, well, that's bad.
01:00:45 And it is bad, but it's not bad enough.
01:00:48 And the story doesn't end there.
01:00:49 It gets worse.
01:00:51 And you might think, well, how could it be worse?
01:00:53 Because that's pretty bad.
01:00:55 It's like, hell is a bottomless pit.
01:00:58 No matter how bad things are, 1.00
01:01:00 some stupid son of a bitch can figure out a way to make them worse. 1.00
01:01:04 And that might be you. 1.00
01:01:06 And so Cain has descendants.
01:01:08 He has descendants.
01:01:09 And the first order, his second order descendants, I think his grandchildren. 0.98
01:01:18 So if you bother Cain's descendants, if you challenge or annoy them, they kill you. 0.99
01:01:27 But the descendants of those descendants kill seven of you. 0.57
01:01:33 And the eventual descendant of Cain is someone named Tubal Cain.
01:01:39 And Entubalcane is the first artificer of weapons of war.
01:01:45 And so what does that mean?
01:01:47 Well, it lays out a causal pattern.
01:01:52 First you sacrifice improperly.
01:01:56 Then you consort with evil.
01:01:59 Then you become bitter and resentful.
01:02:02 Then you become murderous. 0.99
01:02:04 then your children, so to speak, become mass murderers
01:02:10 and then everything dissolves into war.
01:02:16 Right.
01:02:17 And that draws a causal sequence between failure at the individual level, right?
01:02:23 Failure to make the proper sacrifices,
01:02:25 failure to learn from experience,
01:02:27 voluntary consorting
01:02:32 with the spirit of resentment and bitterness
01:02:34 at the individual level
01:02:37 and then the degeneration of society as a whole
01:02:41 into a state of absolute warring catastrophe.
01:02:46 And I think that's right.
01:02:49 You know, one of the things we know, for example,
01:02:52 about totalitarian states,
01:02:54 this is analogous,
01:02:55 you know, we like to think of totalitarian states
01:02:58 as sort of, this is a naive view
01:03:00 freedom loving people
01:03:03 with a dictator
01:03:05 so you get rid of the dictator
01:03:09 this has happened, this has happened in Iraq
01:03:12 or Libya, you get rid of the dictator
01:03:15 and freedom arises
01:03:17 from all those people who are oppressed by the dictator
01:03:21 who've really been striving to be free
01:03:23 it's like that isn't what happens
01:03:26 What generally happens is a worse monster arises.
01:03:29 Why?
01:03:30 Well, here's one reason.
01:03:33 In a totalitarian, here's the definition of a totalitarian state.
01:03:36 A totalitarian state is not a state run by a dictator.
01:03:40 There's a dictator and his thugs, and there's hierarchies of thugs.
01:03:45 That's for sure.
01:03:47 In a true totalitarian state, every single person, every single person, lies.
01:03:55 about absolutely everything they think, say, or do
01:04:00 to everyone, including themselves and those they love
01:04:04 and everyone around them.
01:04:06 And that's the lie.
01:04:08 And the totalitarian state is the grip of the lie.
01:04:11 And so why is that relevant psychologically?
01:04:14 Well, Solzhenitsyn, the great Russian dissident,
01:04:18 man who, in some ways,
01:04:20 he was instrumental in the demise of the Soviet Union.
01:04:23 He said, one man who stops lying can bring down a tyranny.
01:04:26 Why?
01:04:27 Because the tyranny is the dominion of the lie.
01:04:30 And so, a totalitarian state, what that means,
01:04:34 you think about what that means is that
01:04:35 each person could break a tyranny if they had the courage.
01:04:40 And that's relevant in your life.
01:04:42 Like, that is absolutely relevant in your life.
01:04:44 Because you're going to be subject to your own tyranny,
01:04:49 the tyranny of your wife or husband,
01:04:51 the tyranny of your family members, your employer, your employees, your community, your state.
01:04:58 There's tyranny everywhere. There's always tyranny everywhere.
01:05:01 How do you participate in that? Well, that's a perfectly good question.
01:05:06 How do you participate in that? Because you do.
01:05:08 And maybe it's through silence, because that's the typical way.
01:05:12 But that's still participation.
01:05:17 So there's a line drawn in the story of Cain and Abel from Cain.
01:05:21 and his psychological inadequacy to genocide itself.
01:05:25 And one of the things that, one of, part of what that indicates
01:05:29 is that the line between your misbehavior and social cataclysm
01:05:34 is a lot thinner than you think.
01:05:37 I'll give you another example of that.
01:05:41 In the story of Abraham, Abraham is a sequence of adventures
01:05:45 and he transforms himself into, what would you say?
01:05:51 A hero, an adventurous hero.
01:05:54 And one of the consequences of that is that he's visited by three beings.
01:06:01 Angels or God.
01:06:02 It's not obvious in the story, but it's one of those two.
01:06:06 And they're strangers and they come to visit him and his wife.
01:06:11 And they reveal themselves as angels.
01:06:14 And there's a lesson in that too,
01:06:16 because you don't know when God is attempting to make himself manifest to you
01:06:22 in the figure of the stranger, but it's more often than you think.
01:06:27 The angels, or God, reveal to Abraham their plans to demolish the corrupt city, 0.64
01:06:36 Sodom, Gomorrah.
01:06:39 The people in the cities have turned away from the divine,
01:06:42 and in consequence, all hell is going to break loose.
01:06:45 And Abraham bargains with God.
01:06:49 That's part of the wrestling with God.
01:06:51 And he says, look, I don't think that's reasonable.
01:06:53 What if there's good people in Sodom?
01:06:57 And God says, I don't think there are.
01:07:01 And Abraham says, what if there's 50?
01:07:04 And God says, you got a deal.
01:07:08 If you go there, you find 50 good people, they're saved.
01:07:13 And Abraham, who's a pushy character, says, how about 40?
01:07:20 Because he's not so sure that there are 50.
01:07:23 And God, whose patience is being tested, says, 40.
01:07:30 And Abraham says, how about 30?
01:07:33 And he bargains God down to 10, if I remember correctly. 0.52
01:07:39 And God says, well, if you can go to Sodom and find 10 people who are good,
01:07:43 then I'll save the city.
01:07:44 And so what does that mean?
01:07:46 Well, it means that if there's 10 people
01:07:48 who are good in a city, it can be saved.
01:07:51 Well, what does that mean?
01:07:53 Well, if there's 10 people in a state
01:07:55 who can still tell the truth,
01:07:57 well, maybe it's not doomed.
01:08:00 And so what does that mean?
01:08:02 Maybe it means that you're supposed to be one of the 10.
01:08:06 In fact, it certainly means that.
01:08:08 And you might say, well, that's not so relevant to me
01:08:10 because I'm not in a doomed city,
01:08:12 which you might think again if you're from L.A.
01:08:19 Yeah, but the message is also relevant under circumstances like that
01:08:23 because when a catastrophe visits,
01:08:26 it's an open question whether it's an act of God
01:08:29 or the consequence of unbelievable blindness and carelessness.
01:08:33 And maybe on the part of everyone,
01:08:36 including the people who could see and speak but decided not to.
01:08:41 And so that's also, that's a hell of a burden, right?
01:08:45 To think that, well, you could be one of the ten in the city
01:08:47 who dared to speak the truth and save the city.
01:08:51 And what a risky venture that would be,
01:08:54 although it's not as risky as being consumed by heaven-sent fire and brimstone, let's say.
01:09:01 But it's also a testament, like a true testament,
01:09:05 to, you might say, your intrinsic quality of character.
01:09:09 and that's what's offered to Cain as well.
01:09:12 It's like, you could learn.
01:09:14 You could learn to make the proper sacrifices.
01:09:17 You could learn to humbly correct error when you encounter it.
01:09:23 You could decide to refuse the temptation of sin that crouches at the door.
01:09:32 You could forego resentment.
01:09:34 You could straighten out your life.
01:09:36 That's possible.
01:09:37 and the consequences of that
01:09:39 would be far more dramatic
01:09:40 than you could possibly imagine
01:09:42 because there's way more to you
01:09:44 than you think
01:09:45 for better and worse
01:09:47 but for worse certainly
01:09:50 but equally certainly for better
01:09:52 I'll close with this I guess
01:09:59 Cain has his reasons
01:10:03 to be resentful and bitter
01:10:04 and so does everyone
01:10:07 and they're real because there's no shortage of suffering in life and there's also no shortage
01:10:13 of suffering that seems unjust and incomprehensible and and you can imagine justifying your bitterness
01:10:22 and resentment in response to that and you could certainly talk to people who have convinced
01:10:29 themselves that that attitude is justifiable if you listen to their story you might agree
01:10:33 There are people, as we all know, who've had brutal, brutal experiences in their life.
01:10:43 And when you hear them recount their story, you can say, you can understand how that might have warped them.
01:10:50 But as I said, you also discover these people who've had equally cataclysmic histories,
01:10:56 who have decided to be far better people
01:10:59 often than you can imagine.
01:11:05 And so that's equally,
01:11:06 that's there for the taking equally.
01:11:11 How do you become one of those people?
01:11:17 You practice.
01:11:19 And this is part of,
01:11:20 Tammy referred to the practice of prayer.
01:11:22 i want to outline that for i want to make that concrete
01:11:28 one of the things i saw my wife do when she was she was told she was going to die in 10 months
01:11:36 that came as a shock as it often does to people obviously and she accepted that quite rapidly and
01:11:43 too rapidly really and probably in part because she didn't value her own life enough
01:11:51 She didn't have enough regard for her own value.
01:11:54 She changed that attitude when she saw how distressed her son was on receiving the news.
01:12:01 And one of the consequences of that transformation was that she started to practice being grateful.
01:12:08 Now, you know, you'd think that's pretty strange circumstances under which to start that practice.
01:12:13 because if you're told that you're going to die in 10 months,
01:12:17 it's not like the obvious implication from that bit of news
01:12:22 is that your gratitude should be exaggerated.
01:12:26 And it's a lot to ask from someone,
01:12:28 and if they didn't do it, that would be understandable.
01:12:32 But then you could consider the alternative position,
01:12:37 which would be, well, now you're sick, 0.90
01:12:39 and you're going to die 1.00
01:12:41 and you're bitter and resentful and miserable. 1.00
01:12:46 And so now not only are you sick 1.00
01:12:48 and you're going to die, 1.00
01:12:49 but you're in hell. 0.99
01:12:50 And that's a lot worse than 1.00
01:12:52 being sick and going to die.
01:12:56 Not that that's,
01:12:57 I'm not trying to
01:12:58 minimize the catastrophe,
01:13:02 but as I said earlier,
01:13:04 you can always make a bad situation worse.
01:13:08 And then it's an open question,
01:13:09 as well, how much better you can make a bad situation, let's say, with the right sacrificial
01:13:15 attitude. And you might say, well, that's a lot to ask of people. And that's definitely
01:13:20 true, but maybe there's a lot to people. You know, my father-in-law, his wife developed
01:13:28 frontal temporal dementia and declined over quite tragically over a 15-year period.
01:13:39 And he was kind of a fun-loving guy and kind of disagreeable.
01:13:44 You know, he was, he spent a lot of time with his friends and he,
01:13:55 and I suppose if you would have,
01:13:58 if you disliked him and you wanted to characterize one of his flaws,
01:14:03 you might've said that he was selfish.
01:14:05 I don't think that was so obvious, but be that as it may,
01:14:11 he wasn't the world's most maternal human being, let's say.
01:14:16 And then his wife got sick, and man, he just took care of her like you wouldn't believe,
01:14:21 like for 15 years.
01:14:23 He was patient, he was kind, he accepted help, he did a spectacular job.
01:14:30 It was unbelievably impressive.
01:14:32 And what did that do?
01:14:36 It reconciled him to all of his children.
01:14:39 So that was a good deal.
01:14:40 So that's what he gained when he lost his wife.
01:14:44 He made her final years much less awful than they might have been.
01:14:51 In fact, it's possible that they weren't particularly awful at all
01:14:55 because while she deteriorated, she didn't really appear to be suffering
01:15:01 And the fact that she loved him was evident in her facial expression
01:15:07 when he appeared in the room she occupied long after she lost the power of speech.
01:15:14 And so he took a pretty brutal situation and made all the appropriate sacrifices.
01:15:23 And I'm not saying that that was paradise, but it certainly wasn't hell.
01:15:28 And that's something under those circumstances.
01:15:31 And so, what do you do about that?
01:15:38 Well, you practice gratitude.
01:15:41 That's the antidote to resentment.
01:15:43 You practice it.
01:15:44 You become skilled at it.
01:15:47 You ask for it to be, that's the spirit you consort with.
01:15:51 You know, something's on your doorstep, but it's knocking to come in.
01:15:54 And maybe it's the spirit of resentment.
01:15:56 and you let that in and then you're in Cain's shoes
01:15:59 and that's not a good idea
01:16:00 or maybe what knocks and tries to enter
01:16:03 is the spirit of humility and gratitude
01:16:06 and you let that possess you
01:16:07 and you become expert at that
01:16:09 and then whatever cataclysm befalls you
01:16:13 you don't multiply with bitterness and resentment
01:16:15 and deceit and arrogance
01:16:17 and so at least you don't transform tragedy into hell
01:16:20 and how do you practice being grateful?
01:16:24 well you're not on fire
01:16:26 you know that's something to be grateful for 0.97
01:16:30 and you might think well that's ridiculous
01:16:32 it's not ridiculous if you've been on fire
01:16:35 right
01:16:36 and so
01:16:37 it is the case that you can
01:16:41 can and should
01:16:43 become expert at
01:16:45 being grateful in the manner that
01:16:50 what would you say
01:16:55 makes the spirit of
01:16:59 motivates the spirit of resentment
01:17:01 to flee from you
01:17:03 and then you might ask yourself too
01:17:05 if you were an expert at that
01:17:07 what changes would that bring about in your life
01:17:11 you know perfectly well
01:17:14 that it's
01:17:14 it's not pleasant to be around someone who's resentful
01:17:18 It's not pleasant to be in your own skin if you're resentful.
01:17:23 There's few states that are more unpleasant than being resentful or being around someone that's resentful.
01:17:31 It's really poisonous.
01:17:33 And so now if you become an expert at gratitude and you develop that skill,
01:17:38 then that's a whole cataclysm a whole abyss that you're not going to plunge into even if
01:17:50 misery befalls you and since you want to be protected from misery although you will not
01:17:58 escape it if you want to be protected from it is it not reasonable to presume that
01:18:04 gratitude is a shield
01:18:07 like a true shield
01:18:09 you can't escape from suffering
01:18:17 but maybe you could become an expert
01:18:19 in refusing to allow it to corrupt you
01:18:22 and maybe the true
01:18:25 hell in suffering
01:18:27 is the corruption of resentment
01:18:29 that could be
01:18:31 and possibly
01:18:35 it's worth the experiment to find out
01:18:37 the
01:18:38 stories that I told you
01:18:41 the story of Cain
01:18:42 makes the case that
01:18:45 the evils of the world
01:18:47 begin with the resentment of the
01:18:49 individual, that's worth
01:18:51 thinking about, you want to make the world a better
01:18:53 place, the implication of
01:18:55 that story is
01:18:56 stop consorting
01:18:59 with the spirit of resentment
01:19:01 And then there's the Abrahamic story.
01:19:04 Ten people who are good are sufficient to save the city from destruction.
01:19:12 That says a lot about the power of the human soul.
01:19:17 And it says something about you, that you could be one of those people,
01:19:21 that you're called upon to be one of those people.
01:19:23 But more than that, that you could be one of those people.
01:19:27 And if you were one of those people, that would be the pattern of sacrifice that God would find acceptable,
01:19:34 that would set your life on the proper path, your life and your community's life, on the proper path.
01:19:43 And so, do not allow yourself to be resentful, deceitful, or arrogant.
01:19:55 Right?
01:19:57 Thank you very much.
01:20:19 Thank you, everybody.
01:20:24 All right, Tim.
01:20:25 You ready?
01:20:27 i didn't thank you all for coming when i first came out here but i do want to thank you all for
01:20:44 coming? All right. Am I louder than you are? No, I think that's good. Okay. Okay. First
01:21:01 question. If someone were uncertain about the existence of God and asked you for proof
01:21:07 of God's existence
01:21:08 how would you explain that
01:21:10 God and Jesus are real
01:21:13 well the first thing I would say is that
01:21:17 it's pretty presumptuous of you
01:21:19 to assume that if you had proof
01:21:20 that you would believe
01:21:22 right
01:21:24 that's just not the case
01:21:26 that isn't how it works
01:21:27 and part of the evidence for that
01:21:30 in a sense
01:21:33 is that there's proof everywhere
01:21:34 and always
01:21:35 And the fact that you're too blind to see it doesn't mean it doesn't exist
01:21:40 It might mean that it makes itself manifest in a form that you refuse to receive
01:21:46 And I can give you some concrete examples of that
01:21:50 I'm not talking about anything that's necessarily
01:21:53 That's self-evidently miraculous
01:21:56 Although I would say in its essence it's miraculous
01:21:59 So
01:22:00 There's many ways that God is characterized
01:22:05 in the biblical stories
01:22:07 because, for example,
01:22:11 if you want proof of God's existence,
01:22:13 the first question you might settle is,
01:22:16 what do you mean by God exactly?
01:22:18 And you might think that's obvious, 1.00
01:22:20 but you're a fool if you think that's obvious 0.99
01:22:22 because nothing is less obvious than that, 1.00
01:22:25 fundamentally.
01:22:27 Well, God makes himself manifest
01:22:30 in many forms in the stories
01:22:32 that our culture
01:22:33 that are at the foundation of our culture.
01:22:37 So, for example, in the story of Noah,
01:22:42 God is characterized as the spirit of intuition
01:22:46 that comes to the wise when trouble is brewing.
01:22:52 Okay, so you might say, well, do you want proof that God exists?
01:22:56 Like, ignore your conscience when it has something to say
01:23:01 and see what happens.
01:23:03 And you might say, well, that's not the kind of proof I meant.
01:23:07 It's like, well, I'm not sure you're the one to judge
01:23:10 what form of proof might best characterize God.
01:23:17 God is characterized in the Old Testament,
01:23:19 perhaps most profoundly, as calling and conscience.
01:23:27 Right?
01:23:27 Calling is what entices you along the pathway upward.
01:23:32 and conscience is what tells you
01:23:35 when you're deviating from the proper path
01:23:37 and conscience is the still small voice
01:23:41 that Elijah the prophet describes
01:23:43 which you can ignore
01:23:46 and you might say
01:23:48 well I want the kind of miracle
01:23:49 that I can't ignore
01:23:51 but you have free will
01:23:56 and the kind of miracle
01:23:58 that you can't ignore
01:23:59 would be a compulsion
01:24:00 And there's no reason to make the presumption that that's the manner in which God would choose to make himself manifest.
01:24:08 Why not in the still small voice of conscience?
01:24:11 You shouldn't do that.
01:24:14 Right. Well, is that a miracle? Is it proof of God's existence?
01:24:18 Well, as I said, try ignoring it and see what happens.
01:24:22 Right. You might know, perhaps you won't immediately discover that God exists, but you might well discover that hell certainly exists.
01:24:28 exists. Right, and that's a start, because once you know that the abyss is real, you might become
01:24:37 more capable of apprehending, what would you say, the eternal path upward.
01:24:47 Elijah, who is a prophet of sufficient status to appear with Moses when Christ is transfigured,
01:24:55 is the prophet who defines God as the voice of conscience.
01:25:00 Is that miraculous?
01:25:02 That's a hard question.
01:25:04 It's like, because your conscience is a very strange thing.
01:25:07 It's you, or so we think,
01:25:10 but it doesn't tell you what you want to hear,
01:25:13 and you can't control it.
01:25:17 So, how is it you?
01:25:20 and if it's not
01:25:22 it's certainly not the you that you
01:25:24 normally think of as you
01:25:26 because the you that you normally think of
01:25:28 as you is something that
01:25:30 you can do something about
01:25:32 but conscience isn't like
01:25:34 that and so then you might
01:25:36 say well from where does it emanate
01:25:38 and that is a very hard
01:25:40 question
01:25:41 the classic answer to that is that
01:25:46 it emanates from above
01:25:48 it emanates from what's eternal
01:25:50 And I think that's right.
01:25:54 I think that's true.
01:25:55 Is that miraculous?
01:25:58 Well, I can tell you this, that if you listen to your conscience unerringly,
01:26:06 miraculous things would happen around you.
01:26:09 No, exactly the same way that miraculous things would happen around you
01:26:14 if you followed your calling.
01:26:15 You see that things beckon to you
01:26:18 In the story of Exodus
01:26:20 Moses
01:26:22 Is transformed
01:26:24 By his encounter with the burning bush
01:26:27 And when that story
01:26:29 Begins
01:26:29 Moses is an adult 0.97
01:26:33 Who's taken on the responsibilities
01:26:34 Of an adult
01:26:35 He has a wife, he has children
01:26:37 He has a community, he has a job
01:26:39 He's a shepherd 0.51
01:26:40 A hard, ordinary job
01:26:43 it's hard because he has to take care of the vulnerable
01:26:46 and he has to fight off the predators
01:26:49 the lions and the wolves
01:26:50 so he's tough and compassionate
01:26:53 which is a good combination of virtues
01:26:55 he's wandering out in the wilderness
01:27:00 taking care of his sheep
01:27:01 near Mount Sinai or Mount Horeb
01:27:04 which is the place where the divine reaches the earth
01:27:07 or the earth reaches up to the divine
01:27:09 and he apprehends something that attracts his attention.
01:27:19 Well, that happens to all of us
01:27:21 because some things attract your attention.
01:27:23 You're interested in some things and not others.
01:27:27 Some things call to you and other things don't.
01:27:31 There's things you want and like and need
01:27:34 and there's things that are irrelevant to you
01:27:37 And that's very particularized.
01:27:39 And you don't get to choose those things exactly.
01:27:42 You can't exactly choose what you're interested in, for example.
01:27:46 You could say, with some degree of justification,
01:27:48 that what you're interested in chooses you.
01:27:53 And if you're studying for an exam and you're a high school student,
01:27:57 you can't force yourself to be interested in the material,
01:28:00 even if you know the exam is important.
01:28:03 There are things that call to you and compel to you
01:28:06 that have an autonomy while Moses decides that he's going to go off the beaten track and investigate
01:28:14 what calls to him. That's what you do when you decide to pursue something that you're interested
01:28:20 in. Maybe at some risk. You know, maybe you have an ordinary job that's secure and stable, but
01:28:26 there's something in you that wants risk and adventure. And so you decide that you're going
01:28:32 to stake yourself on a new business, a new business venture, a new plan, because it calls
01:28:37 to you. And what's the consequence of that? If you pursue it, if it's an honest calling and you
01:28:42 pursue it diligently, your knowledge deepens and you become more than you are. And that's what
01:28:47 happens to Moses, is that he goes to investigate this phenomena. Phenomena means to shine forth,
01:28:53 this phenomena that beckons to him, this, what would you say, this conflagration of life.
01:29:03 Because that's what a burning bush is.
01:29:05 A bush is a tree, and a tree is a symbol of life.
01:29:07 And if it's on fire, then it's vital, and it's metabolizing, it's alive.
01:29:16 And so it's the spirit of life itself that's calling to Moses, and he investigates it.
01:29:21 and he approaches it cautiously and with reverence
01:29:26 and as he approaches it, he learns,
01:29:30 he begins to realize that he's increasingly on sacred ground
01:29:33 and so that means he's getting to the essence of things
01:29:36 and he takes off his shoes to signify his willingness
01:29:40 to transform and adopt a new role
01:29:44 and he investigates even more deeply
01:29:47 and the Spirit of God itself speaks to him
01:29:51 and tells him that it's his destiny
01:29:54 to face down tyranny
01:29:57 and to free those who are enslaved.
01:30:00 And Moses objects,
01:30:01 I'm not someone who can do that. 0.93
01:30:04 I can't even speak.
01:30:08 And God says,
01:30:09 that's your problem.
01:30:13 You're called upon to
01:30:15 take up your calling
01:30:18 and stand up against tyranny
01:30:23 and free those who are enslaved
01:30:25 regardless of your inadequacy
01:30:27 and there is to be no excuses.
01:30:31 And Moses says
01:30:34 when God commands him to return to Egypt
01:30:41 and face down the Pharaoh,
01:30:45 Moses says,
01:30:46 why will, what makes you think they'll listen to me?
01:30:51 And God says, tell them I sent you.
01:30:55 And you might say, well, what does that mean?
01:30:58 Well, if you're talking to someone who knows,
01:31:02 you listen.
01:31:06 And the deeper the knowledge, the, what would you say?
01:31:10 The deeper the knowledge, the closer that is to God
01:31:12 and the more compelling it becomes.
01:31:14 And if you're someone who's pursued what's called to you and you've developed the expertise and wisdom that's associated with that and you've delved farther down into the structure of things in consequence, then when you speak of those things, people will listen.
01:31:32 Because you know and they can tell.
01:31:37 So you want a miracle.
01:31:39 well it's right there in front of you all the time
01:31:44 you can attend to what compels you if you're aiming upward and you can
01:31:57 hearken to the voice of your conscience to keep you on the straight and narrow path and if you do
01:32:04 that well then you establish a relationship a covenant with the divine and the miraculous will
01:32:15 make itself evident in your life and you already know that because you know when the greatest
01:32:22 things in your life happen to you and they happen to you when you take a courageous risk in
01:32:28 relationship to what compels you. And you know that the greatest things in your life happen when
01:32:36 you have the courage of your convictions. And so then you could ask yourself what would happen if
01:32:42 you practiced that all the time. And then everything that was great would be happening
01:32:52 continually
01:32:54 and
01:32:56 then you wouldn't have any doubts
01:32:59 or at least far fewer
01:33:16 what's your favorite cut of beef
01:33:18 and how do you like it cooked
01:33:20 strip steak
01:33:29 one and a half inches thick
01:33:32 frozen
01:33:33 cooked in an air fryer
01:33:36 with salt
01:33:38 sounds good
01:33:41 yeah
01:33:41 why an air fryer
01:33:47 and why frozen
01:33:48 well air fryers are simple they don't heat up your kitchen they're easy to clean and if you
01:33:58 cook the steak frozen then it gets crispy and well still being nice and medium rare medium in the
01:34:06 middle yeah right super easy what would you change or add in the dsm-5s do you know
01:34:16 we kept up with that so the dsm that's the diagnostics and statistical manual that's used
01:34:24 by medical practitioners mostly psychiatrists to some degree psychologists um
01:34:31 i can't answer that it's too complicated okay it's too complicated it's too technical so
01:34:45 it would take too many layers of explanation to get anywhere with it so it's it's all right yeah
01:34:52 i'll ask you another one yeah how do you overcome the feeling of never being satisfied i'm not
01:34:58 saying that like you're never feeling that way but somebody's saying that how do you overcome
01:35:02 the feeling of never being satisfied always chasing something bigger and better is that a problem
01:35:08 well i would say is it a problem it can be a problem to the degree that it's a consequence of
01:35:18 let's say pride narcissism and ingratitude right it could be it could be a reflection of ambition
01:35:26 like so we talked about adventure right so you could think you know the story of sisyphus who
01:35:34 rolls a boulder up the hill and then it rolls back down and he has to roll it back up the hill
01:35:39 it's kind of a image of difficult pointless futility and cynics use that as an image of
01:35:47 life and it's there's something to it but it's not it's not uh it's cynical you could imagine
01:35:59 instead a sequence of mountains each of which is higher than the last in an unending chain
01:36:07 infinitely forward and then rolling a boulder up the first only to see the pinnacle of the second
01:36:15 and then repeating that and you might say well that's pointless because you never get to the top
01:36:19 And in a way, that's true, but not with sufficient depth.
01:36:31 Because you don't want to attain the final goal, because then you're out of adventure.
01:36:39 What you would want.
01:36:41 I got a vision of heaven at one point, and in the vision, I could see that heaven was a place where everything was perfect and getting better.
01:36:48 and you might say well that's paradoxical
01:36:51 if it was perfect it couldn't get better
01:36:52 but no that's only true
01:36:54 if you conceptualize perfection as static
01:36:57 if perfection is dynamic
01:36:58 then it could be the kind of perfection
01:37:01 that kept getting better
01:37:02 music does that
01:37:04 so we have models of that right
01:37:06 because a great piece of music
01:37:07 every moment of it is great
01:37:10 and then something better happens
01:37:12 and it just continues through the entire piece
01:37:14 so you could be in a situation
01:37:18 where you weren't satisfied because you were on to the next adventure.
01:37:23 And if you were grateful for what you had,
01:37:27 then you could regard your lack of satiation
01:37:37 as the desire for the next thing, right?
01:37:41 The next remarkable thing.
01:37:43 and I don't think that's distinguishable from appropriate ambition
01:37:48 but if you're chronically dissatisfied and unhappy
01:37:52 say because someone else has more than you
01:37:56 which is always a very dangerous thing to assume
01:37:58 you know when you assume that
01:38:00 you're making an error in attribution
01:38:03 because what you're really saying is
01:38:05 I'd like all of your advantages
01:38:07 but I don't want any of your problems
01:38:11 well like if that's what you're jealous of then you're that you'll never be satisfied because
01:38:19 there isn't anyone who has all the advantages and none of the problems and
01:38:24 generally the more you know someone the more you're happy you have your problems and not theirs
01:38:33 right right and so you could be chronically dissatisfied with what you have because you're
01:38:41 envious and jealous and resentful and bitter and ungrateful right you want to sort that you might
01:38:47 be curious but you might be curious you might be a curious person who absolutely looking for the
01:38:52 next you could be curious and adventurous and that would be the positive side of that
01:38:56 so you want to quell the bitterness and the resentment and the ingratitude and the envy
01:39:02 You know, you want to see if you're on to the next thing and if you're dissatisfied,
01:39:07 how much of that's driven by the wrong aim.
01:39:11 But the fact that you want more adventure, that can be admirable and can be indicative of a tremendous motivation.
01:39:23 What could happen next? You know, where could I go from here?
01:39:27 and it's certainly the case that part of the foundation of the american dream is exactly that
01:39:34 because part of the dream in america is that you can be successful say compared to your parents
01:39:40 but that that success could expand and then that that expanded success could expand and
01:39:46 that could happen without end and that's a vision of a world of abundance and also a vision
01:39:52 that isn't zero sum it it doesn't imply that i have to purchase my success at your expense
01:39:59 it might imply that you could be successful and i could be successful in a way that would jointly
01:40:05 increase the probability of success for both of us that's what you hope for in a marriage and in
01:40:11 a friendship and in a business partnership if you have the least bit of sense that's the relationship
01:40:16 you want to establish with your customers if you're wise and you want to have customers
01:40:22 for any length of time and so you can you can be ambitious without being resentful
01:40:29 and that's a that's a virtue that
01:40:33 it's it's useful i think to practice as well remembering even if you're ambitious to be
01:40:44 to notice and be grateful for what you also already have, right?
01:40:49 That's a good practice as well.
01:40:55 One more.
01:41:04 What advice do you have for a young couple to starting a family
01:41:07 and becoming new parents?
01:41:14 well, the first thing I would say is
01:41:18 give yourself some credit for your decision.
01:41:29 That's the first thing.
01:41:30 It's like you're choosing voluntarily to have children
01:41:34 and that's laudable and admirable and it's wise.
01:41:38 and it's laudable because it's a lot of responsibility
01:41:47 and it indicates a kind of courageous faith in the future
01:41:51 and it's pro-human in its essence
01:41:54 and it's indicative of hope in a courageous way
01:41:59 and it's, what did I say, laudable?
01:42:03 i can't remember the three words i've i used unfortunately
01:42:10 admirable and what
01:42:13 wise admirable and wise thank you
01:42:18 admirable why admirable because it'll mature you if you have any sense like you're actually not
01:42:27 mature until someone else is more important than you and the probability that'll happen
01:42:31 in the absence of children is low right it isn't zero because you could devote yourself to your
01:42:38 parents for example or your wife or your husband but it's much more probable with children and
01:42:44 you're a way better person once someone or something else is more important than the narrow
01:42:50 you you know it's not like your children aren't you they're the extended you you know and that
01:42:57 extended you is much a much better you than the you that's all about you jesus that's a dismal you
01:43:04 and if you serve that you're pretty sad creature and so it's admirable because you've you've decided
01:43:13 to mature and it's wise because
01:43:19 it's like it's it's wise in the way that a wise investment is wise
01:43:27 we've been watching this television series called landman which i would highly recommend
01:43:36 by the way it is the least politically correct show i've seen for like 50 years
01:43:44 And there's a scene in there where this rich oil man has a heart attack
01:43:49 and a billionaire he knows comes to talk to him.
01:43:53 And it's actually a cameo by an actual billionaire who made his fortune in the oil field
01:43:59 who actually says something that he means.
01:44:02 And he says that he had the opportunity to go into his business with his children
01:44:10 and that that meant more to him than anything that he accomplished on the materialist side, let's say.
01:44:18 And, you know, if you're relatively healthy in your orientation,
01:44:29 there isn't anything that you do in your life that's more valuable than the relationship that you establish with your kids.
01:44:37 like and here's why in part i mean it's in part because they'll call out the best in you they
01:44:45 they can call out the worst too but they can call out the best in you because they call on you to
01:44:51 they call on your proclivity for sacrificial service let's say but they also offer you
01:45:01 something children offer you the opportunity to have the best relationship with anyone you've
01:45:07 ever had in your life. Because that's actually what they want from you. They're the only people
01:45:11 you'll ever meet in your whole life that want nothing more than to have the best possible
01:45:17 relationship with you. And that's a really good deal. That's a really good deal. There isn't a
01:45:25 better deal than that. And so if you're wise, then you note that. And then you have that. And then
01:45:32 were so foolish in our culture. 1.00
01:45:35 You know, here I'll tell you a terrible statistic. 1.00
01:45:39 This is terrible. 0.99
01:45:42 The typical 30-year-old woman in the West is childless. 0.78
01:45:46 So childless at 30. 0.72
01:45:49 Half of those women will never have a child. 0.85
01:45:53 And 90% of them will regret it. 1.00
01:45:56 That's one woman in four. 1.00
01:45:57 That's the fate of one woman in four now in our society. 0.98
01:46:01 That's awful. 1.00
01:46:02 Why? You know, maybe your romantic career is the be-all and end-all of your life
01:46:10 when you're 20 to 30, and maybe even when you're 30 to 40. And the probability that it's going to
01:46:17 be that when you're 40 to 50, that's pretty damn low. And it's vanishingly small by the time you're
01:46:24 50 to 60.
01:46:27 What the hell are you going to do? 0.71
01:46:30 Like, you know, we live like we live till we're 30 and we die. 0.85
01:46:35 Like, we don't.
01:46:36 We live till we're 90.
01:46:40 The time from 60 to 90 is as long as your career.
01:46:45 You have no family.
01:46:46 You have no marriage.
01:46:50 You have no one who cares whether you live or die. 0.80
01:46:52 what the hell are you going to do with yourself
01:46:55 and what's going to happen to you when you're vulnerable
01:46:59 and no one's there to look out for you
01:47:03 you know your children are investment
01:47:07 you know and
01:47:07 you don't have them as children for very long 0.75
01:47:11 that's the other thing I would tell the young couple
01:47:14 it's like once you have kids
01:47:16 within six months after you have a baby
01:47:19 it will feel like you've had that baby forever
01:47:21 and that you're going to have that baby forever like it there's a kind of a timelessness about it
01:47:27 but that's an illusion man that part of your life the time that you have little kids when they're
01:47:33 really dependent say but when you're really integrally involved with them that's like
01:47:39 seven years you know if you have a couple of kids it's it's hardly any time at all
01:47:43 it's about coincidentally the same amount of time that women outlive men 0.96
01:47:48 and so you should make the make the most of that and 0.99
01:47:52 seven years if you had three kids seven years that's pretty good investment for something that
01:48:00 pays you back for the rest of your life if you're lucky you're gonna have grandkids
01:48:05 that's a good deal they like you it's like you're old you're old and some young people want you
01:48:14 around. So I would say, you know, congratulations on your commitment and courage. And I guess the
01:48:34 other thing I would say is don't let each other get lost in the shuffle. You know, one of the
01:48:40 things that often happens to people with very young kids is that they don't make time for
01:48:46 themselves as a couple you have to make that time right because once you have a couple of little
01:48:52 kids and maybe you're both working nothing that isn't planned will ever happen right so you have
01:48:59 to consciously set aside time for each other to keep your relationship intimate and strong and
01:49:09 you want to do that for your kids too because there's nothing that does your kids a greater
01:49:15 service than to see than for them to see the two of you in a you as a unit right as an integrated
01:49:22 unit and that takes well my experience as a clinician essentially taught me that
01:49:28 a couple has to spend 90 minutes a week just talking annoying as that is
01:49:37 addressing the issues that come up in the relationship and in the household if you're
01:49:46 running a small business you're going to have to spend an hour and a half a week solving the
01:49:51 problems it's exactly the same in a marriage it's also a economic relationship there are things that
01:49:56 have to be sorted out so you've got to just sort out problems for 90 minutes a week and you have
01:50:01 to spend some time as a couple about the same amount at least that much and if if you don't
01:50:08 do that then it falls apart across time that's that's not good and so congratulations on your
01:50:17 wisdom it's admirable and it was another word optimistic maybe laudable yes and uh
01:50:28 take time for each other
01:50:30 so that your kids can see you
01:50:32 as an impregnable unit
01:50:36 and enjoy it
01:50:39 because it doesn't last very long.
01:50:41 Way shorter than you think.
01:50:43 Just like life.
01:50:46 Okay.
01:50:47 Good.
01:50:48 Thank you, everybody.
01:50:50 Thanks for coming tonight.
01:50:52 Thank you.
01:50:53 That was fun.
01:50:58 good to see you everyone
01:51:09 thanks again