The Jordan B. Peterson Podcast - March 08, 2020


Our Emotions and the Social Hierarchy – Part Two


Episode Stats

Length

1 hour and 13 minutes

Words per Minute

163.53908

Word Count

12,012

Sentence Count

310

Misogynist Sentences

63

Hate Speech Sentences

10


Summary

Our Emotions and the Social Hierarchy Part 2: A Jordan B. Peterson 12 Rules for Life Lecture. Episode recorded in Brisbane, Australia on February 17th, 2019. With decades of experience helping patients, Dr. Peterson offers a unique understanding of why you might be feeling this way. In his new series, he provides a roadmap towards healing, showing that while the journey isn t easy, it s absolutely possible to find your way forward. If you're suffering, please know you are not alone. There's hope, and there's a path to feeling better. Go to Dailywire Plus now and start watching Dr. Jordan B Peterson on Depression and Anxiety. Let this be the first step towards the brighter future you deserve. Subscribe to Daily Wire Plus to get 10% off of a monthly subscription to Basis by visiting trybasis.co/JBPodcast and use promo code JBP at checkout. That s a great deal on a groundbreaking supplement you can buy right from Trybasis! That s Jordan10, and the promo code is JBP. That s 10% Off of a Monthly Subscription to JBP by visiting JBP and using promo code Jordan10. That's Jordan10! That's JBP or promo code: Jordan10 at checkout, and using the promo Code JBP! . Let s talk Meat: ButcherBox is an affordable and convenient way to get healthy, humanely raised meat around $6 a meal. With ButcherBox by ButcherBox, you get the highest quality meat around about $6 per meal, and a great way to live a full and engaged life you deserve by visiting ButcherBox.co and get a discount of $20 off of their first box of meat ordered for the life of your first box. JBP is a $6-a-piece of meat you can get the best quality meat, plus $20 of ground beef for the Life of the future you get a chance to live the best of your best day. by JBP and a discount on ButcherBox for the day of the day you deserve to be the best chance to be part of the better future you dream of? Subscribe and learn more about ButcherBox! Subscribe today! by clicking JBP Podcasts and the social Hierarchy by clicking here. and Subscribe to the JBP podcast by Jordan Peterson , Subscribe to our new podcast, Subscribe to my podcast by clicking HERE.


Transcript

00:00:00.940 Hey everyone, real quick before you skip, I want to talk to you about something serious and important.
00:00:06.480 Dr. Jordan Peterson has created a new series that could be a lifeline for those battling depression and anxiety.
00:00:12.740 We know how isolating and overwhelming these conditions can be, and we wanted to take a moment to reach out to those listening who may be struggling.
00:00:20.100 With decades of experience helping patients, Dr. Peterson offers a unique understanding of why you might be feeling this way in his new series.
00:00:27.420 He provides a roadmap towards healing, showing that while the journey isn't easy, it's absolutely possible to find your way forward.
00:00:35.360 If you're suffering, please know you are not alone. There's hope, and there's a path to feeling better.
00:00:41.780 Go to Daily Wire Plus now and start watching Dr. Jordan B. Peterson on depression and anxiety.
00:00:47.460 Let this be the first step towards the brighter future you deserve.
00:00:50.980 Welcome to episode 49 of the Jordan B. Peterson podcast.
00:01:01.140 I'm Michaela Peterson, Jordan's daughter.
00:01:03.640 No super new updates on our end.
00:01:05.840 Dad is still recovering.
00:01:07.300 We're still getting our sunshine in Florida.
00:01:09.480 We've had a lot of family come down to visit.
00:01:12.100 It's been a nice break.
00:01:13.720 I hope you enjoyed this episode.
00:01:15.520 It's called Our Emotions and the Social Hierarchy, Part 2, recorded in Brisbane, Australia on February 17th, 2019.
00:01:25.580 Let me tell you about Basis.
00:01:27.620 My dad and I have been using NAD treatments and have seen some major results.
00:01:32.000 Elysium is a health company that's at the forefront of NAD supplementation.
00:01:36.500 They translate breakthrough scientific advancements in aging research into health products you can buy right from their website.
00:01:42.780 Their flagship product is Basis.
00:01:44.480 It works by giving you more NAD and activating what scientists call our longevity genes.
00:01:50.680 Basis works at the cellular level and many of the benefits of increased NAD are things you won't feel,
00:01:55.600 including enhanced mitochondrial function, active longevity genes, and improved DNA repair.
00:02:01.180 However, you can also experience higher energy, better sleep, and more satisfying workouts,
00:02:06.020 like coffee without the caffeine crash.
00:02:08.260 I did NAD infusions earlier this year.
00:02:10.740 I'm actually doing them again in Florida here.
00:02:13.240 And they made me feel fantastic, but they take eight hours and are actually quite unpleasant to sit through.
00:02:19.540 Basis is an easier way to increase NAD.
00:02:22.300 Listeners can get 10% off of a monthly subscription to Basis by visiting trybasis.com slash Jordan
00:02:28.820 and using the promo code Jordan10.
00:02:31.560 That's trybasis.com slash Jordan, and the promo code is Jordan10.
00:02:37.440 That's a great deal on a groundbreaking supplement.
00:02:39.840 Let's talk meat.
00:02:45.520 ButcherBox is an affordable and convenient way to get healthy, humanely raised meat.
00:02:50.700 With ButcherBox, you get the highest quality meat around about $6 a meal.
00:02:55.580 They're a great company.
00:02:56.920 I order a box every time I stay in the States.
00:02:59.320 I eat beef, although recently I've incorporated wild salmon.
00:03:03.840 ButcherBox's seafood is really high quality.
00:03:05.720 Did you know that scallops are generally soaked in a preservative that causes water retention to make the scallops heavier?
00:03:14.420 It's really sneaky and really, really not cool.
00:03:18.240 ButcherBox scallops aren't soaked in preservatives, which is shockingly rare.
00:03:22.020 All of their meat is ridiculously high quality.
00:03:25.120 And right now, ButcherBox is having one of their biggest sales of the year.
00:03:29.020 They're offering new members ground beef for life.
00:03:31.740 That's two pounds of ground beef in every box of meat ordered for the life of their subscription, plus $20 off of their first box.
00:03:40.780 Just go to ButcherBox.com slash JBP or enter promo code JBP at checkout.
00:03:47.540 That's ButcherBox.com slash JBP or promo code JBP at checkout.
00:03:53.120 Our Emotions and the Social Hierarchy Part 2
00:04:02.940 A Jordan B. Peterson 12 Rules for Life Lecture
00:04:06.220 If things aren't laying themselves out in front of you the way that is necessary for you to live a full and engaged life
00:04:16.000 and not be cynical and bitter and twisted and cruel and vengeful and disappointed and all of that,
00:04:22.640 it's just possible that you're not aiming at the right thing.
00:04:27.020 And man, that is a question.
00:04:29.100 That is a question worth asking.
00:04:31.680 Well, it's a question people do ask.
00:04:33.400 It's like, well, what's the purpose of life?
00:04:35.240 Well, it's the same question.
00:04:36.680 What should I aim at?
00:04:37.840 Those are the same questions.
00:04:39.020 And, you know, if what you're aiming at is producing nothing but unrequited misery for you and everyone else
00:04:46.200 and it's a downhill bloody spiral into something approximating hell,
00:04:50.540 then there is some possibility that you should think that perhaps your aim is off.
00:04:56.320 So, and I don't want to overplay my hand on that either, too,
00:04:59.540 because I know perfectly well that, you know,
00:05:01.820 if you're suffering, if you're depressed, if you're miserable,
00:05:05.400 there might, you might be, you might just, it might be a consequence of really bad luck.
00:05:11.340 You know, like, people get sick.
00:05:13.480 And good people get sick, right?
00:05:15.060 Everyone knows that.
00:05:15.960 You know, good people, they get sick and they die.
00:05:17.960 And so you can't say, well, if you're miserable and sick,
00:05:20.640 it's because there's something, you know, bad about you.
00:05:24.060 Because then that would be the case for everyone.
00:05:27.580 Always, whenever they get ill, and you could just blame ill people.
00:05:30.700 It's like, well, it serves you right that you're sick because you're a bad person.
00:05:33.580 It happens a lot, actually, with ill people, you know, and it's an unfortunate thing.
00:05:37.680 So I know there's an element of chance to all this.
00:05:40.620 And I don't want to downplay that.
00:05:43.920 You know, we are dust in the wind, to use a terrible cliche from a 70s rock song.
00:05:51.840 We're blown hither and thither by events that are somewhat beyond our control.
00:05:56.380 But that's still not the point.
00:05:57.920 The point is that, to a large degree, you can determine the manner in which the world manifests itself to you
00:06:03.860 by changing your aim.
00:06:05.700 And so then that opens up, that opens up the entire domain of philosophy.
00:06:09.700 You think, what good is philosophy?
00:06:11.280 And people think that all the time.
00:06:12.640 What good is philosophy?
00:06:13.680 It's like, hey, philosophy is about value.
00:06:16.560 Well, what use is value?
00:06:18.040 Well, value determines your aim.
00:06:19.900 Well, who cares what your aim is?
00:06:21.360 Well, your aim determines the manner in which the world lays itself out to you emotionally.
00:06:27.720 Well, who cares about that?
00:06:29.300 No one says that.
00:06:31.420 The argument stops there.
00:06:32.700 Because no one, especially no one who's been seriously hurt or seriously depressed, like in pain,
00:06:38.180 no one ever says, oh, well, who cares about that?
00:06:40.860 Because if you can say that about your pain, all that means is you actually haven't been in pain.
00:06:46.260 Because if you're in enough pain, you will not say that.
00:06:48.760 That's for sure.
00:06:49.420 So, you need to know what to aim at.
00:06:52.860 So, now you aim at something, you've got a goal,
00:06:57.060 and then you see that you're making progress towards the goal.
00:07:01.600 That's a good thing.
00:07:03.740 That makes you happy.
00:07:06.720 It actually, technically, there's a system, dopamine system, neurochemical system,
00:07:12.000 same system, by the way, that cocaine and methamphetamine and opiates activate,
00:07:17.100 which is why people like to take those drugs.
00:07:19.420 And it tells you that you're moving forward in the manner that you should be according to the dictates of your plan.
00:07:28.460 It doesn't necessarily tell you whether you have a good plan.
00:07:31.080 That's a more complicated problem.
00:07:32.980 Because who knows if you have a good plan.
00:07:34.460 But one thing that you could know is that a plan is better than no plan.
00:07:40.220 That's a really useful thing to know, especially if you're kind of drifting.
00:07:43.680 It's like, well, I'm going to find myself.
00:07:45.580 It's like, no, just pick something and move towards it.
00:07:50.680 And as you move towards it, you're going to succeed and fail, specifically.
00:07:56.240 And then you're going to learn something about success, specifically.
00:07:59.000 And you're going to learn something about failure, specifically.
00:08:01.700 And then you can learn what you use to fix your plan.
00:08:06.640 So a stupid plan is way better than no plan.
00:08:09.440 And you're likely to have a stupid plan, or at least to be able to make one.
00:08:12.940 So that's good news for everybody.
00:08:14.360 You can make a stupid plan.
00:08:15.600 And so I would say, make a stupid plan.
00:08:18.660 And then implement it.
00:08:19.800 Not any stupider that it has to be.
00:08:21.740 You know, you could think about it a little bit.
00:08:23.300 But then implement it.
00:08:24.840 And have your successes and failures along the way.
00:08:27.780 And learn from them.
00:08:28.560 And then you can rejig the goal.
00:08:31.260 You can move the target.
00:08:32.720 That's fine.
00:08:33.880 That's part of the game.
00:08:34.920 It doesn't have to be fixed.
00:08:36.300 It's a movable target.
00:08:37.920 And maybe what you're trying to do is to move the target to an ever better place.
00:08:42.760 So you're moving towards a target.
00:08:44.500 And at the same time, you're moving the target.
00:08:46.920 Right.
00:08:47.680 And you're trying to move the target towards something like an ultimate ideal.
00:08:51.000 You're trying to find out what that ultimate ideal is.
00:08:53.440 And part of the way you figure that out is by moving towards a target.
00:08:56.520 And by learning about success and failure along the way.
00:08:59.140 Because then you can inform yourself with regards to what might constitute a reasonable aim.
00:09:04.360 And so that's the reason to go out in the world and make some mistakes.
00:09:07.940 You know.
00:09:08.460 And then you're going to.
00:09:09.900 And so it's okay.
00:09:11.480 It's okay to make the mistakes.
00:09:13.120 It's not so okay not to learn from them.
00:09:15.240 Because then you make the mistakes again.
00:09:17.120 That seems pointless.
00:09:18.080 And so you're moving towards wherever you're going.
00:09:21.000 And it's working.
00:09:21.720 And so you get some positive emotion.
00:09:25.500 You get some motivation from this dopaminergic system that adds zest to life.
00:09:31.400 It adds interest and engagement and meaning to life.
00:09:34.620 It pulls you into life.
00:09:36.080 And so and that's worth thinking about.
00:09:38.500 I would say because if you think about it.
00:09:41.540 You know you have might wonder about whether or not you should be engaged in life.
00:09:45.660 And then if all of a sudden you're doing something.
00:09:48.020 And because you're doing it you get engaged in life.
00:09:50.800 Then it seems like that might be the very definition of a good thing.
00:09:55.860 It's evidence.
00:09:56.660 The engagement is evidence that you're actually doing a good thing.
00:10:00.380 A worthwhile thing in life with all its suffering and misery and brutality.
00:10:04.720 It's like you've got a pathway.
00:10:06.340 You've got an aim.
00:10:07.120 You're moving forward.
00:10:08.120 You're engaged.
00:10:09.140 Excellent.
00:10:10.080 Your nervous system very deep down.
00:10:12.380 This dopaminergic system.
00:10:14.080 It's associated with a part of the brain called the hypothalamus.
00:10:17.060 It's a really really old part of the brain.
00:10:19.740 It's not some new thing that popped up like 15,000 years ago.
00:10:23.580 It's ancient.
00:10:25.000 It's there to orient you in the world.
00:10:27.180 It's part of the instinct for meaning that I talked about in chapter.
00:10:30.740 I think it's chapter 7.
00:10:32.020 Do what is meaningful and not what is expedient.
00:10:34.280 It's a deep deep instinct.
00:10:37.040 And way down in way down in your psychophysiological structure.
00:10:41.860 Not as far down as the serotonin system.
00:10:43.780 But like next level up.
00:10:45.920 And so if it's saying hey man you're on the right track.
00:10:48.680 It's like that's worth noticing.
00:10:52.700 It's worth noticing.
00:10:53.960 Now you can criticize it out of existence.
00:10:56.220 You can question your aim continually.
00:10:59.160 It's one of the what would you call it?
00:11:01.640 Dangers of our capacity to abstract.
00:11:04.000 But you know if you're a smart person who doubts.
00:11:07.100 You also might be smart enough now and then to doubt your doubt.
00:11:11.800 And just to notice and to pay attention.
00:11:14.600 And something I explain to my clinical clients and my students often.
00:11:17.940 And it's like if you're trying to put your life together.
00:11:20.040 Watch yourself for a couple of weeks.
00:11:21.740 Like you don't know who you are.
00:11:23.860 Because if your life isn't together you don't know who you are.
00:11:26.520 So just watch yourself like you don't know who you are.
00:11:28.700 And notice now and then if you're engaged in something.
00:11:33.240 You know and you kind of have to wake up.
00:11:35.220 Because if you're engaged in it you don't quite notice.
00:11:37.260 Right?
00:11:37.380 Because you're engaged in it.
00:11:38.700 But afterwards you might think.
00:11:40.100 Oh I just spent an hour.
00:11:42.580 And I didn't notice that it was an hour.
00:11:45.480 I was in it.
00:11:48.880 That's good.
00:11:50.220 You're in the right place at the right time.
00:11:52.100 Doing the right thing.
00:11:52.920 There's something about that that's right.
00:11:55.180 And maybe like you're not in good shape.
00:11:56.860 And that happened to you like 15 minutes once in two weeks.
00:12:00.760 It's like that's pretty dismal.
00:12:01.960 And the rest of the time it was wretched.
00:12:03.440 It's like okay fine.
00:12:04.480 Well maybe in the next two weeks you can see if you can do it for half an hour.
00:12:07.700 And then maybe for 45 minutes.
00:12:09.420 And then maybe for an hour.
00:12:10.680 Right?
00:12:10.840 You can start practicing being in that place.
00:12:14.660 That's a very useful thing to learn.
00:12:16.380 It's like oh look I'm interested in what I'm doing.
00:12:18.280 I'm engaged in it.
00:12:19.320 Now how did I get here?
00:12:20.840 Where am I exactly?
00:12:22.300 And how did I get here?
00:12:23.300 And how could I stay here?
00:12:24.880 How could I be here more often?
00:12:26.660 Those are all questions you have to ask yourself.
00:12:28.560 Well that's the beginning of philosophy as well.
00:12:30.980 And you think well why bother?
00:12:32.620 And the answer is well do you want to be engaged in your life?
00:12:35.900 Well why would you?
00:12:36.960 Well it's positive.
00:12:41.060 It's analgesic.
00:12:42.240 It fights off pain.
00:12:43.540 It quells anxiety.
00:12:45.020 It gives you purpose.
00:12:46.420 It's good for you practically speaking.
00:12:48.560 Generally speaking if you have an aim and you're moving forward.
00:12:51.040 You're moving forward to something that's psychologically valuable.
00:12:54.400 But also practically valuable.
00:12:55.940 If it's really a good aim also it's good for you now, tomorrow, the next day, the next
00:13:01.700 month because you're smart enough to generally smart enough to calibrate yourself so that
00:13:07.980 things that are really bad for you don't have that engaging quality.
00:13:12.680 Now it's not perfect especially if you've messed yourself up psychologically by lying to
00:13:17.600 yourself in all sorts of different ways.
00:13:19.520 But it's still not a bad orienting system.
00:13:22.520 And then the other thing you can also notice is well when are you doing things that make
00:13:26.640 you feel really awful?
00:13:29.280 By your own standards.
00:13:30.680 It's like oh look I just did something.
00:13:32.220 I had some interaction with someone and now I feel awful.
00:13:34.800 It's like well maybe you could not do that.
00:13:39.980 Whatever it was.
00:13:41.040 You might have to think it through.
00:13:42.400 What were the routines that constituted that ill-advised set of actions?
00:13:47.780 And maybe you're going to have to think really deeply about it you know because God only
00:13:51.120 knows how much of your personality structure is involved in that error.
00:13:55.440 But if it made you wretched, it made you feel like life wasn't worth living then that might
00:14:00.020 be a hint that that wasn't a good thing to do.
00:14:02.420 And so then maybe you could start doing more of the things that make you engaged and less
00:14:06.780 of the things that make you hate life.
00:14:08.820 And that's worthy of practice let's say.
00:14:13.460 You might think about that as a fundamental ethical requirement or I would say it's a
00:14:18.040 fundamental form of religious meditation.
00:14:20.500 That's a better way of thinking about it.
00:14:22.260 And so then you're on the path.
00:14:23.520 That's the straight and narrow path.
00:14:24.980 It's like I'm moving forward.
00:14:27.400 I've got an aim.
00:14:28.200 I'm moving forward.
00:14:29.320 As I move forward I'm engaged.
00:14:31.240 It's bloody well worth walking down this pathway.
00:14:33.980 And you know on the left of me is terror and horror and hell and pain and I'm avoiding
00:14:39.420 that.
00:14:40.180 And to the right of me perhaps is ego and arrogance and the things that can get out of control
00:14:44.140 with regards to positive emotion.
00:14:46.200 But I've got that balance right.
00:14:47.660 I'm on the right pathway.
00:14:49.040 Okay and now we think about what might constitute the right pathway.
00:14:52.080 Well I can tell you a pathway that works for me to some degree.
00:14:58.660 So this is a value structure that's characteristic of me of things I do.
00:15:05.440 I type because I write and so that's pure action right.
00:15:09.960 I type letters.
00:15:10.980 I type words.
00:15:12.080 I type phrases.
00:15:13.040 I type sentences.
00:15:14.060 I type paragraphs.
00:15:15.080 I type chapters.
00:15:16.300 I write books.
00:15:17.100 And then people and then I talk about the books and people read the books.
00:15:22.260 And the reason that they can understand the books is because we're a lot the same.
00:15:26.580 You know like there's a lot of things that have to be the same about you and me before
00:15:30.420 I can write a book that you can read.
00:15:32.500 And I have to be able to take them for granted.
00:15:35.060 And so the reason I'm telling you that is because there's an important relationship between
00:15:41.800 my hierarchy of values and your hierarchy of values if we're going to be able to communicate
00:15:46.920 and if we're going to be able to occupy the same place at the same time.
00:15:50.980 You know so if I'm writing a book like Twelve Rules for Life and it has a discussion about
00:15:55.640 what constitutes the good in it then I have to start with the presupposition that we share
00:16:03.020 some fundamental intuition about what constitutes the good or my words will fall on deaf ears.
00:16:11.040 Okay and it's partly because
00:16:13.300 and this is maybe the relationship between the social world and the psychological world
00:16:21.960 that I wanted to talk about.
00:16:23.360 As I build up my hierarchy of skill and ability, perception and emotional regulation
00:16:30.140 you know from slicing carrots upwards you know.
00:16:33.660 I'm a good cook, I'm a good parent, maybe I'm a good man, maybe I'm a good person you know.
00:16:40.320 And all of those cover a broader and broader range of abstractions and abilities.
00:16:45.200 There has to be a relationship between that and what other people think.
00:16:49.140 You know because look if you're, your kid, you teach your kid to set the table and then
00:16:55.080 he goes to someone else's house and sets the table and he gets a swat.
00:16:59.700 It's like well what's the consequence of that?
00:17:01.920 Well the consequence of that is that the kid is going to be unhappy.
00:17:06.020 Well why?
00:17:07.380 Well it's because the kid did a lot of work building up all those separate skills to undertake
00:17:14.140 that complex activity.
00:17:15.760 And it really is a complex activity.
00:17:17.420 You don't have a robot at home that sets the table.
00:17:19.800 You know you have a cell phone and it's smart but it can't set the damn table.
00:17:23.700 It's complicated to do that sort of thing.
00:17:25.540 And so your kid had built this complicated neurological structure as a consequence of reward
00:17:31.540 primarily because reward helps build neurological structures.
00:17:35.880 He built this whole structure and now what he's hoping is that all the work that went into
00:17:41.100 building that structure is something that other people will appreciate as well.
00:17:45.820 So that's where you need the isomorphism between the intra-psychic structure, the psychological
00:17:53.380 structure and the social structure which is why we have to have a shared social reality.
00:17:58.160 This is partly why I think the post-modernists went off the rails so badly with their insistence
00:18:02.920 that the world was only language.
00:18:04.580 It's like it is in some sense very important that you construe the world the same way I do
00:18:11.140 even though there's a very wide range of ways of construing the world.
00:18:14.800 We come to some negotiated agreement about what's good and what isn't so that when I do things
00:18:20.300 that I think are good you also think they're good so that I get rewarded for my good behavior
00:18:25.840 and I get let's say punished for my bad behavior because that's often a relief as well by the way.
00:18:30.380 And so we have to have our own internal structure of values that we're pursuing
00:18:35.980 because otherwise we don't have any meaning in our life and that's no damn good
00:18:40.240 and then it has to be nested inside a shared structure of values that's similar
00:18:45.780 so that when we act out what we have learned to be good we're treated by the world as if that's good
00:18:52.480 and then we have peace.
00:18:54.260 That's the definition of a functioning political system.
00:18:58.200 We've organized a moral game, a very complex one
00:19:02.700 and then we master it through reciprocal interaction with one another
00:19:07.240 we internalize it so that it regulates our emotions
00:19:10.060 then we act it out in the world and if there's a concordance
00:19:13.240 between the way we act it out and the way the world responds
00:19:16.820 then we're okay.
00:19:18.780 Because there's nothing more disturbing to you than to act out a high order moral good
00:19:24.480 let's say you're working really hard at your job for example
00:19:27.120 and you're hoping for a promotion
00:19:28.580 and let's say you deserve a promotion by all reasonable standards
00:19:32.160 and then you don't get one.
00:19:34.580 You know, it's taken, it's given to, I don't know, it's given to the boss's mistress
00:19:38.140 or some damn thing or, you know, it's given to someone
00:19:41.920 who doesn't deserve it by the canonical rules of the moral game
00:19:47.180 and all it does is devastate you
00:19:49.460 and the reason that it devastates you is because it disrupts the relationship
00:19:53.860 between the internal moral hierarchy that you've built
00:19:56.480 and the collective hierarchy
00:19:57.960 and everything you have is staked on maintaining that isomorphism.
00:20:02.460 You know, and it's the same even in intimate relationships.
00:20:06.140 You know, if you do something good for your wife or your husband
00:20:09.480 you know, you go out of the way maybe to make a nice meal
00:20:12.520 and they come home and they punish you arbitrarily for some tiny fault
00:20:17.300 maybe with the dinner
00:20:18.460 it's very disheartening
00:20:20.300 and the reason is it violates your faith
00:20:23.980 first of all in your own intra-psychic hierarchy
00:20:27.460 second in the structure of the social hierarchy
00:20:31.380 and third in the match between them
00:20:33.500 and it's the match between them that's really important
00:20:35.600 we do not like mismatch between what we expect
00:20:40.380 especially in terms of reward
00:20:42.080 especially when we've really worked at it
00:20:43.820 and what we're delivered
00:20:45.320 right?
00:20:46.200 and so that's partly how we
00:20:47.600 it's partly a complicated explanation of how we regulate our emotions
00:20:51.960 you know, we regulate them by aiming
00:20:54.080 that's important
00:20:55.280 we regulate them by walking the straight and narrow path
00:20:59.400 but then we also regulate them by being fortunate enough
00:21:03.900 to be in a situation where if we walk the straight and narrow path properly
00:21:08.740 then other people respond positively to us
00:21:11.980 and then you have this lovely harmony
00:21:14.740 and it's a right way of thinking about it
00:21:16.780 it's a musical way of thinking about it
00:21:18.320 there's you composed of this very unbelievably complex nested set of patterns
00:21:24.780 beautiful patterns that you spent forever working on
00:21:27.460 and then they're nested inside a social structure
00:21:29.800 that's also patterned in the same way
00:21:32.080 and those are working harmoniously together like a dance
00:21:35.360 and that's perfect
00:21:36.680 it's the meeting of the individual with society
00:21:40.360 and it's the secret to harmonious emotional regulation
00:21:44.840 and more
00:21:45.560 and to cooperation
00:21:46.480 and to proper competition
00:21:48.440 and to movement forward practically in the world
00:21:51.980 all of that
00:21:53.040 and so
00:21:54.260 okay, well, I'll close with just a description of what a hierarchy might look like
00:21:58.940 and a brief description of how it is that you calculate when you make a major mistake
00:22:05.560 so my hierarchy would be something like this
00:22:08.560 I type letters
00:22:10.640 I type words
00:22:11.520 phrases, sentences
00:22:12.660 paragraphs
00:22:14.220 I sequence the paragraphs
00:22:15.800 I make chapters
00:22:16.680 I write books
00:22:17.820 it's all coherently laid out towards some higher order aim
00:22:22.820 all of that
00:22:23.580 and the aim is
00:22:24.580 as far as I'm concerned
00:22:26.080 to share my clinical knowledge
00:22:28.360 and to educate people
00:22:29.680 and that makes sense
00:22:30.940 because I'm a clinician and a researcher
00:22:32.740 and a professor
00:22:33.720 and so if I was going to do that
00:22:35.140 I've decided I'm going to do that
00:22:36.920 so that's what I'm doing
00:22:38.240 and hopefully that's a good thing
00:22:40.400 and hopefully people respond to it as if it's a good thing
00:22:44.280 because then that's a good thing for me
00:22:46.140 and it's a good thing for them
00:22:47.200 and so that seems to be like the very definition of a good thing
00:22:50.580 and I'm trying to set things straight
00:22:53.620 I'm trying to set myself straight by writing carefully
00:22:57.020 I'm trying to set the culture straight by saying what I believe to be the case
00:23:02.300 I'm trying to set other individuals straighter by communicating with them
00:23:06.060 I'm trying to ensure that we can live more harmoniously in our culture and in the world
00:23:11.860 and you think
00:23:12.420 well those are good things to have at the outermost reaches of your value hierarchy
00:23:17.600 you know my friend of mine was talking to me about bricklayers the other day
00:23:21.660 and he's trying to restructure a major company at the moment
00:23:24.300 and we were talking about how to motivate people
00:23:26.540 he said well let's say you're a bricklayer
00:23:28.060 it's like you know one damn brick after another
00:23:31.140 how are you going to be excited about that
00:23:33.180 well let's say you're a medieval bricklayer
00:23:35.520 right and it's 1500
00:23:37.820 and you're working in one of the great
00:23:41.340 you're working in one of the great early renaissance cities in Europe
00:23:46.280 and it isn't a wall you're building
00:23:48.380 it's a cathedral
00:23:49.160 it's going to take 350 years
00:23:51.880 and why are you doing that
00:23:52.900 well it's for the ultimate glory of God
00:23:55.260 whatever that means
00:23:56.480 and so you're not putting one brick down after another
00:23:59.980 it's like you're involved in this unbelievably complicated moral structure
00:24:04.600 that stretches really stretches all the way up to heaven itself so to speak
00:24:08.120 and each of your minor actions you know your local actions
00:24:11.900 is imbued with the spirit of that entire moral structure
00:24:15.700 well that's a philosophy
00:24:17.480 it's like well do you have a meaning in life
00:24:20.120 what's the meaning of life
00:24:21.740 well hopefully it isn't just unrequited suffering and malevolence
00:24:27.060 we could dispense with that as much as possible
00:24:29.520 that might be a good start
00:24:30.740 but then to aim high
00:24:32.440 well that seems to be reasonable
00:24:34.200 to aim as high as you can
00:24:35.700 and we've laid out things that could be aimed at
00:24:38.060 you could constrain yourself
00:24:39.700 you know there are things you're not doing
00:24:41.540 and things that you shouldn't be doing
00:24:43.080 you stop doing the things that you shouldn't be doing
00:24:45.540 and start doing the things you should be doing
00:24:47.640 that's a good start
00:24:48.820 wake up enough so that you can set the structures around you right
00:24:52.540 it's your moral obligation as a citizen
00:24:55.300 your responsibility and your divine duty I would say
00:24:59.080 from our cultural perspective
00:25:00.800 because in the west everyone is regarded as a sovereign individual
00:25:04.680 the fate of the state
00:25:07.820 a sovereign individual
00:25:09.800 on whose shoulders rests the fate and the health of the state
00:25:15.260 right?
00:25:16.100 that's the fundamental presupposition
00:25:17.940 otherwise well why do you get to vote?
00:25:21.200 just to make a mistake?
00:25:22.640 well no that's not it
00:25:23.940 you're supposed to be awake
00:25:25.000 so that the ship of state continues to move forward in the appropriate direction
00:25:30.060 and somehow we've decided
00:25:31.460 that's up to you
00:25:33.020 why?
00:25:34.080 well because we've also decided
00:25:35.780 hey man
00:25:36.680 you can do it
00:25:38.500 and not only that
00:25:39.400 no one else can
00:25:40.860 and so that's something to know
00:25:42.900 and might be something to take seriously
00:25:45.000 it's like
00:25:45.440 who knows what the hell you'd be
00:25:46.780 if you got your act together
00:25:47.900 and I think you would be
00:25:49.300 like you'd be a force to contend with
00:25:51.340 you know
00:25:51.720 you'd have constrained the malevolence of
00:25:54.100 in your own soul
00:25:55.060 and you'd have started to take advantage
00:25:57.200 of the potential that's around you
00:25:58.780 and to build yourself out of that potential
00:26:00.940 into God only knows what
00:26:02.600 you know
00:26:03.380 and then maybe with that wisdom
00:26:06.040 you can set the structures around you in order
00:26:08.640 at least more in order than they are
00:26:10.460 or maybe to disintegrate them a bit when they need it
00:26:13.340 and to restructure them
00:26:14.340 so they're even better than they are
00:26:15.620 and you can push back nature
00:26:17.820 in its horrible form
00:26:19.700 and invite it forward in its positive form
00:26:22.360 and make things better for you
00:26:23.860 and for your family
00:26:24.940 and for your community
00:26:25.940 and you can approach the unknown itself
00:26:27.960 and you can explore that
00:26:29.660 the potential that's out there
00:26:30.980 and you can bring back the treasure
00:26:32.860 that's part of the unknown potential
00:26:35.020 and you can distribute that
00:26:36.680 and that is what you can do
00:26:38.700 and then not only that
00:26:40.060 it's what you need to do
00:26:41.440 because you need to have
00:26:43.040 a meaning in your life
00:26:44.620 an aim
00:26:46.100 a value structure
00:26:47.180 that's of sufficient potency
00:26:50.040 and magnitude
00:26:51.420 to justify the limitations
00:26:54.400 and the trouble
00:26:55.300 that life constitutes
00:26:56.540 right
00:26:56.920 it's not
00:26:57.240 this is no trivial business
00:26:58.680 that we're involved in
00:26:59.720 right
00:27:00.160 we're all in this
00:27:01.180 up to our necks
00:27:02.220 literally
00:27:02.880 it's a
00:27:03.440 it's a mortal game
00:27:05.120 you're all in
00:27:06.380 and there's
00:27:07.640 and
00:27:07.900 and to play it wrong
00:27:09.360 is
00:27:09.580 is to risk
00:27:10.880 suffering and hell
00:27:12.540 and I'm not talking about
00:27:14.000 afterlife
00:27:14.660 I'm not talking about
00:27:15.800 something metaphysical
00:27:16.760 you can generate plenty of hell
00:27:18.580 right here around you
00:27:20.040 plenty
00:27:20.720 an unlimited amount
00:27:22.380 and so
00:27:23.080 you can
00:27:23.820 move towards that direction
00:27:25.560 or you can move towards
00:27:26.580 a positive direction
00:27:27.560 and you can orient yourself
00:27:29.660 and you know
00:27:30.740 you can know
00:27:31.440 you can learn
00:27:32.260 this is why the postmodernists
00:27:33.980 are so incorrect
00:27:34.760 it's like
00:27:35.260 look
00:27:35.800 you need a name
00:27:37.120 you need a name
00:27:39.360 you cannot organize
00:27:40.680 the way you look at the world
00:27:42.960 without a name
00:27:43.780 it's not optional
00:27:45.260 and then the question is
00:27:46.760 well
00:27:46.980 what should the aim be
00:27:48.600 well
00:27:49.060 probably not to
00:27:51.920 radically increase
00:27:53.620 the amount of misery
00:27:54.660 and suffering
00:27:55.360 that you experience
00:27:56.340 in everyone else
00:27:57.140 I mean
00:27:57.440 maybe you want to go that route
00:27:58.720 but
00:27:58.960 and people do
00:28:02.600 but
00:28:02.780 I think they only do
00:28:03.920 when they become bitter
00:28:04.920 and they give up
00:28:06.080 you know
00:28:06.440 and they make mistakes
00:28:07.880 they know they're making
00:28:09.180 right
00:28:09.540 it's
00:28:09.780 it's conscious decision
00:28:11.280 to go down that route
00:28:12.340 it's not like they think
00:28:13.420 that's okay to begin with
00:28:14.800 their aim's wrong
00:28:16.540 it's like
00:28:17.540 straighten out your aim
00:28:19.220 so
00:28:19.940 there's an old idea
00:28:21.480 this idea of sin
00:28:22.580 sin
00:28:23.100 is a word that was derived
00:28:24.580 from a Greek word
00:28:25.380 hamartia
00:28:25.960 and hamartia
00:28:27.020 is an archery term
00:28:28.060 and it means
00:28:28.580 to miss
00:28:29.300 the target
00:28:30.160 and so you think
00:28:32.260 well how can you miss
00:28:32.960 the target
00:28:33.460 well
00:28:34.420 you have no weapon
00:28:36.500 well then you miss
00:28:38.640 the target
00:28:39.200 you
00:28:40.020 you have no target
00:28:42.780 you have no aim
00:28:44.300 well then
00:28:44.760 then you miss the target
00:28:45.860 you don't pick up your bow
00:28:47.980 well then you miss the target
00:28:49.420 you don't draw it back
00:28:50.660 then you miss the target
00:28:51.760 you don't practice
00:28:53.020 and
00:28:53.240 and miss
00:28:54.100 many times
00:28:55.140 right
00:28:55.460 because
00:28:55.980 you have to do that
00:28:57.320 to develop the skill
00:28:58.140 to hit the target
00:28:58.880 so you're not willing
00:28:59.920 to take the risk
00:29:00.640 to miss
00:29:01.180 you
00:29:02.200 you do none of that
00:29:03.220 and so
00:29:03.840 you miss the target
00:29:05.020 and that's the sin
00:29:06.720 and then
00:29:07.420 you miss your life
00:29:08.700 and then
00:29:09.480 what happens around you
00:29:11.240 is that
00:29:11.620 well there's far more hell
00:29:13.420 than there has to be
00:29:14.460 and there's much less heaven
00:29:15.900 than there could be
00:29:16.860 and it's on you
00:29:17.960 and that's part of your
00:29:20.520 what would you say
00:29:21.400 your divine value
00:29:22.520 let's say
00:29:23.180 that sets you aside
00:29:25.580 along with everyone else
00:29:27.480 as
00:29:27.720 as something
00:29:28.800 someone
00:29:30.100 some being
00:29:30.740 that even the law
00:29:31.900 itself
00:29:32.560 has to respect
00:29:33.640 intrinsically
00:29:34.400 and it's marked out
00:29:35.780 in our culture
00:29:36.540 by
00:29:36.860 the sovereignty
00:29:38.340 that you possess
00:29:39.320 and the notion
00:29:40.240 that
00:29:40.600 there's something in you
00:29:41.740 that's made
00:29:42.460 in the image of God
00:29:43.700 something that can
00:29:44.840 confront the unknown
00:29:45.880 and to
00:29:46.380 create
00:29:47.300 habitable order
00:29:48.660 out of chaos
00:29:49.500 and potential
00:29:50.240 and to do that properly
00:29:51.940 and that's all
00:29:53.660 true
00:29:54.380 as far as I can tell
00:29:55.680 and it's all
00:29:56.660 necessary to know
00:29:58.300 it's coded
00:29:59.280 in the deepest stories
00:30:00.440 that are at the base
00:30:01.780 of our culture
00:30:02.440 and we're
00:30:02.900 we're in danger
00:30:03.840 of not understanding them
00:30:05.460 and not believing them
00:30:07.120 and it's a big mistake
00:30:08.420 because
00:30:09.120 they're heavy
00:30:10.720 and profound
00:30:11.900 and
00:30:12.840 weighty
00:30:14.120 and fundamental
00:30:15.400 and necessary
00:30:16.960 because you have to stand
00:30:18.600 on something
00:30:19.120 that's solid
00:30:19.960 or
00:30:20.560 everything is sand
00:30:21.860 and you
00:30:22.220 you fall in
00:30:23.260 and you're done
00:30:24.420 and so is everything
00:30:25.600 around you
00:30:26.280 well
00:30:29.040 so that's
00:30:30.040 what was the name
00:30:32.100 of the talk
00:30:32.720 what was the name
00:30:34.340 of the talk
00:30:34.920 I don't even remember
00:30:36.980 what the hell
00:30:37.540 I titled it now
00:30:38.520 part of it is
00:30:41.020 yes
00:30:41.500 the relationship
00:30:42.240 between
00:30:42.760 your internal
00:30:43.660 psychological structure
00:30:44.820 and the social world
00:30:45.760 that was part of it
00:30:47.260 and then
00:30:48.040 the
00:30:49.160 manner
00:30:50.780 by which you
00:30:51.620 estimate magnitude
00:30:52.780 of error
00:30:53.260 I suppose
00:30:53.720 that's the last thing
00:30:54.500 I should say
00:30:55.120 you have a value hierarchy
00:30:58.160 we already described
00:30:59.720 what that is
00:31:00.320 ranging from
00:31:01.060 the trivial
00:31:01.720 motor actions
00:31:02.580 that you undertake
00:31:03.240 to the highest order
00:31:04.460 aims
00:31:05.040 what makes you upset
00:31:07.480 your determination
00:31:09.880 of how far
00:31:11.140 up
00:31:11.540 in the hierarchy
00:31:12.540 the error
00:31:13.580 you have made
00:31:14.460 has disrupted
00:31:15.580 things
00:31:16.160 you know
00:31:17.360 so
00:31:17.660 you tell your kid
00:31:19.220 you didn't put that spoon
00:31:21.720 on the table
00:31:22.240 quite right
00:31:22.880 and then they're a little upset
00:31:24.440 you know
00:31:24.760 but it's
00:31:25.760 whatever
00:31:26.160 you twist the spoon
00:31:28.400 it's fixed
00:31:29.100 or you say
00:31:29.840 you know
00:31:30.060 you're a rotten kid
00:31:31.120 and you've always been
00:31:32.380 a rotten kid
00:31:33.000 and I don't see
00:31:33.580 that there's much hope
00:31:34.360 for you in the future
00:31:35.200 it's like
00:31:36.260 well
00:31:36.560 well people do that
00:31:38.140 when they argue
00:31:38.700 with people they love
00:31:39.560 and they do that
00:31:40.100 quite a bit
00:31:40.680 it's like
00:31:41.160 they've taken them out
00:31:42.260 at the highest level
00:31:43.260 of their value hierarchy
00:31:44.420 right
00:31:44.740 and that makes people
00:31:45.680 really upset
00:31:46.560 and the reason for that
00:31:47.780 is
00:31:48.020 well it wipes out
00:31:49.200 their whole map
00:31:50.000 and so there's also
00:31:51.720 a relationship
00:31:52.560 this is an interesting
00:31:53.660 thing to know
00:31:54.300 between
00:31:54.880 how upset you get
00:31:56.720 emotionally
00:31:57.420 and how important
00:31:58.780 it is
00:31:59.320 how important
00:32:00.360 the thing that you're
00:32:01.180 pursuing is
00:32:01.900 that's being criticized
00:32:03.000 and it's
00:32:04.220 and with a practical note
00:32:05.580 you know
00:32:05.840 if you're arguing
00:32:06.620 with someone
00:32:07.220 here's something
00:32:08.600 you can think about
00:32:09.340 you want them
00:32:10.900 to change their behavior
00:32:11.880 the first thing
00:32:13.020 you want to do is
00:32:13.720 you want to sort of
00:32:15.340 pat them on the head
00:32:16.160 and say
00:32:16.740 you weren't horrible
00:32:20.500 all the time
00:32:21.080 in the past
00:32:21.640 and you're not horrible
00:32:22.380 all the time now
00:32:23.300 and you probably
00:32:23.860 won't be horrible
00:32:24.440 all the time
00:32:25.340 in the future
00:32:26.020 so we'll just get
00:32:27.020 that out of
00:32:27.520 out of the way
00:32:28.440 but there's a small
00:32:29.680 thing that you do
00:32:30.760 that could use
00:32:32.820 a little improvement
00:32:33.540 and
00:32:34.440 here's
00:32:35.720 how you can improve it
00:32:37.020 and I would be
00:32:38.240 satisfied and happy
00:32:39.440 with that
00:32:39.960 if you tried it
00:32:41.060 would you be willing to
00:32:42.860 and then
00:32:43.800 they improve
00:32:45.300 incrementally
00:32:46.000 and over time
00:32:47.000 maybe
00:32:47.520 if you're very careful
00:32:48.740 with such things
00:32:49.500 and you don't do them
00:32:50.180 too often
00:32:50.640 and you also allow
00:32:51.800 the other person
00:32:52.600 to do that to you
00:32:53.720 as well
00:32:54.280 then you get
00:32:55.140 incremental improvements
00:32:56.680 without taking
00:32:57.780 chopping people off
00:32:59.360 at the knees
00:32:59.880 so to speak
00:33:00.480 when you're criticizing
00:33:01.340 the way that they're behaving
00:33:02.460 all right
00:33:05.860 well how to conclude
00:33:07.200 all that
00:33:08.320 you can't look at the world
00:33:11.800 without a name
00:33:12.420 literally
00:33:14.940 you can't even
00:33:16.020 perceive it
00:33:16.620 you cannot
00:33:17.480 regulate your emotions
00:33:19.040 without an aim
00:33:19.800 the better your aim
00:33:22.740 the more precise
00:33:24.140 your aim
00:33:24.660 the more elevated
00:33:26.020 your aim
00:33:26.700 you remember
00:33:27.460 in Pinocchio
00:33:28.400 when Geppetto
00:33:29.200 wants to turn
00:33:29.860 Pinocchio
00:33:30.260 into a real boy
00:33:31.160 he wishes on a star
00:33:32.560 it's a strange thing
00:33:34.160 eh
00:33:34.360 but everybody
00:33:35.020 just accepts it
00:33:35.920 it's like
00:33:36.220 well yeah
00:33:36.600 if you've got a puppet
00:33:37.440 you just made a puppet
00:33:38.640 and you want to turn it
00:33:39.380 into a boy
00:33:40.080 the logical thing to do
00:33:41.880 is open the window
00:33:42.720 and wish on a star
00:33:43.800 everyone knows that
00:33:44.880 it's like
00:33:45.300 none of that makes
00:33:46.240 the least bit of sense
00:33:47.300 obviously
00:33:48.200 except metaphorically
00:33:49.700 but we do understand it
00:33:51.000 because we can watch that
00:33:52.080 and it makes sense
00:33:52.960 there's something magical about it
00:33:54.520 and there is something magical about it
00:33:56.340 because the truth of the matter is
00:33:57.960 is that if you want to
00:33:58.960 transform
00:33:59.620 something that's nothing
00:34:01.300 but a wooden headed puppet
00:34:02.640 into something that's a fully functional
00:34:04.760 autonomous
00:34:05.720 moral autonomous individual
00:34:07.960 then what you do
00:34:09.000 is you elevate your eyes
00:34:10.500 above the horizon
00:34:11.380 to the highest point of light
00:34:12.840 that you can perceive
00:34:13.840 and you aim at that
00:34:16.360 and that works
00:34:18.000 and that works for you
00:34:19.560 and it works for your partner
00:34:20.700 and it works for your children
00:34:21.820 and it works for the world
00:34:23.140 thank you
00:34:25.000 very much
00:34:25.940 going online without expressvpn
00:34:41.360 is like not paying attention
00:34:42.560 to the safety demonstration
00:34:43.640 on a flight
00:34:44.280 most of the time
00:34:45.420 you'll probably be fine
00:34:46.620 but what if one day
00:34:47.960 that weird yellow mask
00:34:49.180 drops down from overhead
00:34:50.200 and you have no idea
00:34:51.700 what to do
00:34:52.220 in our hyper-connected world
00:34:53.820 your digital privacy
00:34:54.920 isn't just a luxury
00:34:56.040 it's a fundamental right
00:34:57.480 every time you connect
00:34:58.400 to an unsecured network
00:34:59.580 in a cafe, hotel, or airport
00:35:01.540 you're essentially broadcasting
00:35:03.060 your personal information
00:35:04.140 to anyone with a technical know-how
00:35:06.020 to intercept it
00:35:06.840 and let's be clear
00:35:07.660 it doesn't take a genius hacker
00:35:09.200 to do this
00:35:09.840 with some off-the-shelf hardware
00:35:11.520 even a tech-savvy teenager
00:35:13.100 could potentially access
00:35:14.240 your passwords, bank logins,
00:35:16.060 and credit card details
00:35:17.240 now you might think
00:35:18.620 what's the big deal?
00:35:19.660 who'd want my data anyway?
00:35:21.200 well on the dark web
00:35:22.220 your personal information
00:35:23.480 could fetch up to $1,000
00:35:25.060 that's right
00:35:26.300 there's a whole underground economy
00:35:27.880 built on stolen identities
00:35:29.500 enter ExpressVPN
00:35:31.040 it's like a digital fortress
00:35:32.780 creating an encrypted tunnel
00:35:34.280 between your device
00:35:35.300 and the internet
00:35:35.900 their encryption is so robust
00:35:37.900 that it would take a hacker
00:35:38.920 with a supercomputer
00:35:39.760 over a billion years
00:35:41.180 to crack it
00:35:41.780 but don't let its power fool you
00:35:43.460 ExpressVPN is incredibly user-friendly
00:35:45.760 with just one click
00:35:47.020 you're protected
00:35:47.560 across all your devices
00:35:48.820 phones, laptops, tablets
00:35:50.500 you name it
00:35:51.240 that's why I use ExpressVPN
00:35:52.700 whenever I'm traveling
00:35:53.820 or working from a coffee shop
00:35:55.340 it gives me peace of mind
00:35:56.520 knowing that my research
00:35:57.660 communications
00:35:58.340 and personal data
00:35:59.580 are shielded from prying eyes
00:36:01.200 secure your online data today
00:36:02.980 by visiting
00:36:03.620 expressvpn.com
00:36:05.060 slash jordan
00:36:05.800 that's
00:36:06.520 e-x-p-r-e-s-s
00:36:08.240 vpn.com
00:36:09.300 slash jordan
00:36:09.960 and you can get
00:36:10.580 an extra three months free
00:36:11.920 expressvpn.com
00:36:13.720 slash jordan
00:36:14.500 starting a business
00:36:19.220 can be tough
00:36:19.920 but thanks to Shopify
00:36:21.020 running your online storefront
00:36:22.600 is easier than ever
00:36:23.780 Shopify is the
00:36:25.140 global commerce platform
00:36:26.280 that helps you sell
00:36:27.060 at every stage
00:36:27.820 of your business
00:36:28.340 from the launch
00:36:29.360 your online shop stage
00:36:30.460 all the way to the
00:36:31.180 did we just hit
00:36:31.980 a million orders stage
00:36:33.120 Shopify is here
00:36:34.260 to help you grow
00:36:35.140 our marketing team
00:36:36.400 uses Shopify every day
00:36:37.660 to sell our merchandise
00:36:38.440 and we love how easy
00:36:39.820 it is to add more items
00:36:41.000 ship products
00:36:41.960 and track conversions
00:36:42.920 with Shopify
00:36:44.140 customize your online store
00:36:45.540 to your style
00:36:46.480 with flexible templates
00:36:47.580 and powerful tools
00:36:48.640 alongside an endless list
00:36:50.320 of integrations
00:36:51.040 and third-party apps
00:36:52.020 like on-demand printing
00:36:53.240 accounting
00:36:53.740 and chatbots
00:36:54.700 Shopify helps you turn
00:36:56.100 browsers into buyers
00:36:57.320 with the internet's
00:36:58.020 best converting checkout
00:36:59.120 up to 36% better
00:37:00.820 compared to other
00:37:01.560 leading e-commerce platforms
00:37:02.980 no matter how big
00:37:04.260 you want to grow
00:37:04.900 Shopify gives you
00:37:05.880 everything you need
00:37:06.620 to take control
00:37:07.360 and take your business
00:37:08.360 to the next level
00:37:09.300 sign up for a $1
00:37:10.800 per month trial period
00:37:11.940 at shopify.com
00:37:13.260 slash jbp
00:37:14.380 all lowercase
00:37:15.440 go to shopify.com
00:37:17.100 slash jbp now
00:37:18.260 to grow your business
00:37:19.280 no matter what stage
00:37:20.520 you're in
00:37:20.900 that's shopify.com
00:37:22.520 slash jbp
00:37:23.660 okay well let's get
00:37:27.780 to the serious things
00:37:28.780 here first
00:37:29.540 105 of you
00:37:31.700 think that this is
00:37:33.100 of crucial importance
00:37:34.680 are you subscribed
00:37:37.020 to PewDiePie
00:37:38.080 yes as a matter of fact
00:37:45.420 he's been fighting
00:37:48.120 with some company
00:37:49.020 right for dominance
00:37:50.080 of YouTube
00:37:52.060 yeah yeah yeah
00:37:53.700 so yeah
00:37:54.180 I subscribed to him
00:37:57.820 a long while back
00:37:59.040 and tweeted it
00:37:59.720 and hopefully got
00:38:00.520 some other people
00:38:01.060 to subscribe to him
00:38:01.940 too because
00:38:02.420 what the hell
00:38:03.680 so alright
00:38:05.880 so there we go
00:38:07.880 um
00:38:08.840 where
00:38:11.780 there was one here
00:38:13.260 I thought was
00:38:13.740 quite a me
00:38:14.240 oh who would wear
00:38:15.060 when in a bare knuckle
00:38:16.220 brawl between you
00:38:17.280 Ben Shapiro
00:38:18.200 and Justin Trudeau
00:38:20.000 well
00:38:22.440 Ben's a malevolent
00:38:24.880 little creature
00:38:25.540 so
00:38:25.940 so he might have
00:38:30.100 some dirty tricks
00:38:30.880 up his sleeve
00:38:31.500 but he doesn't
00:38:32.080 he doesn't have
00:38:33.100 much of a reach
00:38:33.880 on him
00:38:34.500 um
00:38:35.360 Trudeau
00:38:37.900 Trudeau
00:38:39.580 he can box
00:38:42.300 so
00:38:43.700 he
00:38:44.500 he'd probably
00:38:46.700 get me on
00:38:47.280 technical skills
00:38:48.540 and I'm
00:38:48.940 I'm quite a bit
00:38:49.660 older but
00:38:50.220 I
00:38:52.680 I think I'd
00:38:53.460 get up a lot
00:38:54.060 of times
00:38:54.600 so
00:38:56.720 well
00:38:57.420 hopefully it won't
00:38:58.140 come to that
00:38:58.720 but
00:38:59.560 but I tell you
00:39:00.560 there is part of me
00:39:01.340 that
00:39:01.540 that thinks
00:39:02.220 it would be
00:39:02.600 interesting
00:39:03.120 all right
00:39:05.420 all right
00:39:06.040 so
00:39:06.280 and there was
00:39:06.840 137 of you
00:39:08.040 who thought
00:39:08.400 that one was
00:39:09.100 worth discussing
00:39:10.920 so
00:39:11.280 that's good
00:39:12.160 so
00:39:13.080 is the sole
00:39:15.380 purpose of
00:39:15.920 religious ideas
00:39:16.700 to propagate
00:39:17.340 the species
00:39:18.000 no
00:39:18.920 it's not
00:39:20.640 the sole
00:39:20.960 purpose
00:39:21.420 um
00:39:22.060 we
00:39:23.260 we discussed
00:39:23.780 that a lot
00:39:24.360 today
00:39:24.740 the sole
00:39:26.260 purpose of
00:39:26.800 religious ideas
00:39:27.660 the sole
00:39:28.820 purpose
00:39:29.260 let
00:39:29.600 let
00:39:29.820 first of all
00:39:30.800 the questioner
00:39:32.540 assumes that
00:39:33.080 there is a sole
00:39:33.740 purpose
00:39:34.160 and I don't
00:39:35.140 I don't think
00:39:35.660 that that's
00:39:36.080 accurate
00:39:36.480 so
00:39:36.800 you want to
00:39:37.720 be careful
00:39:38.100 about reducing
00:39:38.740 something complex
00:39:39.560 to a single
00:39:40.180 explanation
00:39:40.740 that's generally
00:39:41.500 the purview
00:39:42.120 of
00:39:42.540 ideologues
00:39:43.860 right
00:39:44.380 they have one
00:39:44.960 idea
00:39:45.360 and it
00:39:45.880 just covers
00:39:46.580 the world
00:39:47.100 and the world
00:39:48.360 is a little
00:39:49.140 bit too
00:39:49.520 complicated
00:39:49.920 to be covered
00:39:51.700 by
00:39:52.000 by one
00:39:53.160 idea
00:39:54.920 unfortunately
00:39:55.800 the purpose
00:39:59.540 of religious
00:40:00.020 ideas
00:40:00.540 as far as
00:40:01.060 I can tell
00:40:01.520 is to
00:40:01.860 remind us
00:40:02.580 who we
00:40:02.940 are
00:40:03.300 you know
00:40:04.920 we don't
00:40:05.580 live that
00:40:06.040 long
00:40:06.440 right
00:40:06.740 and
00:40:07.440 and we're
00:40:07.820 really
00:40:08.040 complicated
00:40:08.680 and it's
00:40:09.640 not easy
00:40:10.000 to learn
00:40:10.420 how to
00:40:10.680 be a
00:40:10.920 person
00:40:11.280 you know
00:40:12.120 I mean
00:40:12.360 it takes
00:40:12.700 you like
00:40:13.000 40 years
00:40:13.680 before you
00:40:14.240 can learn
00:40:14.580 to be
00:40:14.800 a person
00:40:15.240 enough
00:40:15.900 so that
00:40:16.280 you can
00:40:16.540 get out
00:40:16.840 of your
00:40:17.080 mother's
00:40:17.480 basement
00:40:17.860 so
00:40:18.900 it's
00:40:20.280 hard
00:40:20.640 that's
00:40:20.920 half your
00:40:21.300 life
00:40:21.620 before
00:40:21.980 well maybe
00:40:24.460 not 40
00:40:25.100 but certainly
00:40:26.500 sometimes
00:40:27.100 it takes a long
00:40:28.420 time to learn
00:40:28.980 how to be a
00:40:29.440 human being
00:40:29.940 and we're
00:40:31.320 very very
00:40:32.000 complicated
00:40:32.540 we're way
00:40:33.880 more complicated
00:40:34.700 than we can
00:40:35.280 understand
00:40:35.820 you know
00:40:36.580 and we've been
00:40:37.000 watching each
00:40:37.640 other for a
00:40:38.140 long time
00:40:38.720 watching ourselves
00:40:39.680 telling stories
00:40:40.400 about ourselves
00:40:41.120 trying to draw
00:40:42.280 some wisdom
00:40:43.000 from our
00:40:43.600 self-observations
00:40:44.880 to teach to our
00:40:46.020 children and to
00:40:46.700 our grandchildren
00:40:47.320 and so forth
00:40:48.100 and we've
00:40:48.720 codified them
00:40:49.500 in all sorts
00:40:50.240 of strange ways
00:40:51.160 in these
00:40:51.540 memorable stories
00:40:53.280 fairy tales
00:40:54.240 and myths
00:40:54.820 and religious
00:40:55.400 stories
00:40:55.860 all of those
00:40:56.420 things
00:40:56.740 and what are
00:40:59.120 they there
00:40:59.460 for
00:40:59.760 they're there
00:41:02.340 to remind us
00:41:02.980 who we are
00:41:03.540 because we
00:41:04.880 need to know
00:41:05.440 who we are
00:41:06.100 and you know
00:41:06.960 we talked about
00:41:07.580 that a little bit
00:41:08.220 tonight
00:41:08.500 I believe
00:41:09.420 the notion
00:41:10.540 that
00:41:10.900 I believe
00:41:12.460 the most
00:41:13.220 important
00:41:13.840 idea
00:41:14.800 that's ever
00:41:16.600 been generated
00:41:19.100 is
00:41:19.620 the idea
00:41:21.260 that men
00:41:22.340 and women
00:41:22.660 are made
00:41:23.020 in the
00:41:23.220 image
00:41:23.420 of God
00:41:23.880 I think
00:41:25.740 that
00:41:25.960 a culture
00:41:26.800 that doesn't
00:41:28.060 that isn't
00:41:28.800 predicated
00:41:29.720 on that
00:41:30.260 belief
00:41:30.860 knowingly
00:41:32.140 or unknowingly
00:41:32.980 and better
00:41:33.660 knowingly
00:41:34.280 is doomed
00:41:35.380 to absolute
00:41:36.960 catastrophe
00:41:37.840 because
00:41:39.500 there's no
00:41:41.780 reason to
00:41:42.420 assume
00:41:42.840 that there
00:41:43.240 isn't
00:41:43.540 something
00:41:43.820 about
00:41:44.180 us
00:41:44.520 that's
00:41:46.100 of
00:41:46.520 transcendent
00:41:47.460 value
00:41:47.960 I mean
00:41:49.240 if for
00:41:52.320 no other
00:41:52.820 reason
00:41:53.240 than the
00:41:54.020 fact of
00:41:54.500 our
00:41:54.660 consciousness
00:41:55.260 you know
00:41:55.760 like here
00:41:56.240 we are
00:41:56.580 we're aware
00:41:57.380 of what
00:41:59.060 there is
00:41:59.800 and it
00:42:01.120 isn't even
00:42:01.680 obvious
00:42:02.200 that there
00:42:02.760 could be
00:42:03.480 what there
00:42:04.100 is
00:42:04.480 if there
00:42:04.980 wasn't
00:42:05.400 something
00:42:05.900 that's
00:42:06.320 aware
00:42:06.660 of
00:42:06.860 it
00:42:07.060 and so
00:42:08.160 our
00:42:08.360 very
00:42:08.860 awareness
00:42:09.440 plays
00:42:10.360 an
00:42:10.560 integral
00:42:11.080 role
00:42:11.700 in the
00:42:12.140 fact
00:42:12.520 of
00:42:12.740 being
00:42:13.260 itself
00:42:13.960 you know
00:42:14.780 and metaphysics
00:42:15.620 aside
00:42:16.060 it's hard
00:42:16.540 to see
00:42:17.000 that anything
00:42:17.620 could be
00:42:18.080 more
00:42:18.540 vital
00:42:20.340 than that
00:42:20.840 more important
00:42:21.520 than that
00:42:22.020 and then
00:42:22.340 it isn't
00:42:22.920 only that
00:42:23.340 we
00:42:23.540 apprehend
00:42:24.560 reality
00:42:25.160 you know
00:42:25.860 and therefore
00:42:26.560 give it
00:42:27.060 shape
00:42:28.280 merely by
00:42:29.000 our
00:42:29.200 perceptions
00:42:29.680 it's
00:42:30.480 also
00:42:30.740 clearly
00:42:31.080 the
00:42:31.280 case
00:42:31.640 that
00:42:32.220 we
00:42:32.520 partake
00:42:33.320 and it's
00:42:33.800 shaping
00:42:34.220 and we
00:42:35.800 call ourselves
00:42:36.640 on that
00:42:37.180 you know
00:42:37.660 you know
00:42:38.540 that you
00:42:39.420 feel guilty
00:42:40.020 and ashamed
00:42:40.540 when you're
00:42:41.320 not doing
00:42:42.080 what you
00:42:42.600 could be
00:42:43.060 doing
00:42:43.360 when you're
00:42:43.820 not living
00:42:44.380 up to
00:42:44.680 your
00:42:44.820 potential
00:42:45.260 when you're
00:42:45.860 not making
00:42:46.700 the most
00:42:47.720 of what's
00:42:48.220 offered to
00:42:48.760 you
00:42:48.900 you understand
00:42:49.860 at a very
00:42:50.620 deep level
00:42:51.260 that you're
00:42:51.840 that you're
00:42:52.720 that you're
00:42:53.760 what would
00:42:54.980 you
00:42:55.080 you're
00:42:55.460 you're
00:42:55.720 breaking
00:42:56.220 there's no
00:42:57.080 other way
00:42:57.480 of saying
00:42:57.880 it
00:42:58.060 you're
00:42:58.540 breaking
00:42:58.980 a divine
00:42:59.780 commandment
00:43:00.740 you're
00:43:01.660 offered
00:43:02.140 this
00:43:02.540 unbelievably
00:43:03.980 rich
00:43:04.660 possibility
00:43:05.400 and it's
00:43:06.380 there for
00:43:06.820 you to
00:43:07.320 grapple
00:43:08.540 with
00:43:08.880 and
00:43:09.660 you say
00:43:10.960 well I don't
00:43:11.480 believe in
00:43:12.140 such things
00:43:12.920 in the divinity
00:43:14.120 of humanity
00:43:15.140 or in divinity
00:43:15.860 itself
00:43:16.440 or in the
00:43:17.400 divine for that
00:43:18.080 matter
00:43:18.340 but
00:43:18.540 you can't
00:43:20.220 fool yourself
00:43:21.260 with that
00:43:21.680 kind of
00:43:22.060 argumentation
00:43:22.800 it doesn't
00:43:23.520 stop you
00:43:24.160 from feeling
00:43:24.840 guilty
00:43:25.600 and ashamed
00:43:26.360 and worthless
00:43:27.100 and disappointed
00:43:28.000 and frustrated
00:43:28.860 and angry
00:43:29.640 and vengeful
00:43:31.000 at the fact
00:43:32.500 that you're
00:43:33.000 wasting your
00:43:33.700 life
00:43:34.100 and you're
00:43:34.820 noticing it
00:43:35.620 and that you're
00:43:36.440 making yourself
00:43:37.300 much less than
00:43:38.600 you could be
00:43:39.220 and that you're
00:43:39.880 making things
00:43:40.580 around you
00:43:41.440 worse for
00:43:42.500 everyone else
00:43:43.320 and
00:43:43.800 like
00:43:44.800 perhaps
00:43:46.380 there's a
00:43:47.880 psychopath or two
00:43:48.780 in the audience
00:43:49.480 who just doesn't
00:43:50.680 give a damn
00:43:51.420 and who is
00:43:52.360 focused only on
00:43:54.380 instantaneous
00:43:55.220 gratification
00:43:56.320 for their
00:43:57.280 most primordial
00:43:58.600 impulses
00:43:59.420 this
00:44:00.300 moment
00:44:01.000 right
00:44:01.780 but it's not
00:44:02.720 a sustainable
00:44:03.460 mode of being
00:44:04.340 and it's very
00:44:05.260 rare
00:44:05.680 and so
00:44:07.140 the purpose
00:44:09.300 of religious ideas
00:44:10.380 is to wake us
00:44:11.700 up
00:44:11.940 it's to remind us
00:44:15.460 who we are
00:44:16.060 right
00:44:17.540 it's to remind us
00:44:18.920 that we're
00:44:19.500 imbued with
00:44:20.440 with a spirit
00:44:22.380 that can be
00:44:23.420 best described
00:44:24.300 in some sense
00:44:25.180 as immortal
00:44:25.880 it's the spirit
00:44:27.400 that allows all
00:44:28.300 of us to be
00:44:28.840 conscious
00:44:29.260 that we all
00:44:30.220 participate in
00:44:31.200 simultaneously
00:44:31.900 that gives rise
00:44:34.120 to the world
00:44:34.780 and shapes it
00:44:35.720 and then to
00:44:38.200 alert us
00:44:40.680 to the
00:44:41.940 vital importance
00:44:43.940 of the responsibility
00:44:45.180 that goes along
00:44:46.080 with that
00:44:46.520 because I do
00:44:48.000 believe
00:44:48.480 that we shape
00:44:50.220 the world
00:44:50.680 we move it
00:44:52.560 towards heaven
00:44:53.240 or we move
00:44:54.840 it towards hell
00:44:55.600 and we do that
00:44:56.780 with every
00:44:57.400 conscious decision
00:44:58.560 we make
00:44:59.140 and
00:45:00.420 it moves
00:45:02.020 in the direction
00:45:03.100 that we determine
00:45:04.380 and so
00:45:06.620 that's what
00:45:07.160 religious stories
00:45:08.000 are there
00:45:08.420 to remind us
00:45:09.840 of
00:45:10.160 50%
00:45:14.700 of
00:45:14.920 Queensland
00:45:15.360 police
00:45:16.640 are now
00:45:17.320 required
00:45:17.740 to be
00:45:18.080 women
00:45:18.380 as a bloke
00:45:20.020 applying
00:45:20.460 how do I
00:45:20.940 speak
00:45:21.220 intelligently
00:45:21.940 and effectively
00:45:22.640 into this
00:45:23.320 situation
00:45:23.940 what percentage
00:45:27.020 of Queensland
00:45:27.740 police
00:45:28.260 are now
00:45:29.180 currently
00:45:29.680 women
00:45:30.020 is it
00:45:31.420 like
00:45:32.060 20%
00:45:33.080 or 10%
00:45:33.880 or does anybody
00:45:34.620 know
00:45:34.880 is it a low
00:45:35.360 percentage
00:45:35.860 it's what
00:45:37.300 it's five
00:45:39.020 okay
00:45:39.560 so this basically
00:45:40.380 means that
00:45:40.920 as a bloke
00:45:41.820 applying
00:45:42.300 you don't have
00:45:42.900 a hope
00:45:43.280 in hell
00:45:43.780 right
00:45:45.160 which is why
00:45:45.840 200 people
00:45:46.920 thought this was
00:45:47.580 an important question
00:45:48.420 well as far as
00:45:49.340 I'm concerned
00:45:49.880 it's like
00:45:50.400 what the hell
00:45:51.740 are you sitting
00:45:52.280 around for
00:45:52.840 it's time
00:45:53.560 for some
00:45:53.940 political action
00:45:54.760 there's no
00:45:55.900 excuse for this
00:45:56.620 whatsoever
00:45:57.140 there's no
00:45:58.560 excuse
00:45:59.100 whatsoever
00:45:59.820 for equality
00:46:00.900 for equality
00:46:07.380 of outcome
00:46:08.180 measures
00:46:08.740 they're ideological
00:46:10.800 to the core
00:46:11.540 and they're very
00:46:12.480 oddly applied
00:46:13.600 it's like
00:46:14.300 what percentage
00:46:15.080 of women
00:46:15.480 are bricklayers
00:46:16.320 I know I talked
00:46:17.040 about bricklayers
00:46:17.760 already tonight
00:46:18.400 but it's a good
00:46:19.480 example
00:46:19.920 I went on
00:46:20.960 the US
00:46:21.560 if you go
00:46:22.340 on the
00:46:24.000 statistical site
00:46:25.400 that's
00:46:25.780 operated by
00:46:26.620 the US
00:46:26.980 government
00:46:27.300 you can look
00:46:28.260 at occupations
00:46:29.520 by gender
00:46:30.240 and it's
00:46:31.320 an interesting
00:46:31.760 thing to do
00:46:32.440 here's an
00:46:33.660 interesting thing
00:46:34.400 you know
00:46:35.260 the most
00:46:35.720 common
00:46:36.260 occupation
00:46:36.940 for women
00:46:37.500 back in
00:46:38.000 the 1950s
00:46:38.940 was secretary
00:46:39.800 you know
00:46:41.160 what the most
00:46:41.520 common
00:46:41.860 occupation
00:46:42.420 for women
00:46:42.860 is now
00:46:43.400 it's secretary
00:46:45.340 they don't
00:46:47.160 call them
00:46:47.500 secretaries
00:46:48.100 now
00:46:48.360 it's usually
00:46:49.420 executive assistant
00:46:50.340 or something
00:46:50.780 like that
00:46:51.200 and that may
00:46:51.840 indicate
00:46:52.400 some
00:46:52.720 elevation
00:46:53.180 genuine
00:46:53.600 elevation
00:46:54.080 in status
00:46:54.600 but fundamentally
00:46:55.340 the most
00:46:57.080 common
00:46:57.440 occupation
00:46:57.880 hasn't changed
00:46:58.620 in
00:46:58.840 what's that
00:46:59.720 70 years
00:47:00.500 so that's
00:47:01.160 pretty
00:47:01.320 interesting
00:47:01.840 bricklayers
00:47:03.120 99.9%
00:47:05.140 of bricklayers
00:47:05.840 are men
00:47:06.340 okay
00:47:07.780 so
00:47:08.140 and
00:47:08.440 and then
00:47:09.060 it's the same
00:47:10.080 for like
00:47:10.460 heavy duty
00:47:11.540 construction
00:47:12.540 equipment
00:47:13.060 operators
00:47:13.580 and
00:47:14.020 people who are
00:47:15.700 working with
00:47:16.140 heavy machinery
00:47:16.780 tend to be men
00:47:17.840 people who are
00:47:18.520 building things
00:47:19.260 especially outside
00:47:20.600 tend to be men
00:47:21.380 overwhelmingly so
00:47:22.720 far more even
00:47:26.300 than engineers
00:47:27.000 there's a fair
00:47:27.940 number of female
00:47:28.580 engineers
00:47:29.060 it's like
00:47:29.760 what are we
00:47:30.540 going to do
00:47:30.860 here
00:47:31.120 it's like
00:47:31.580 we're going to
00:47:32.520 enforce
00:47:32.940 gender equality
00:47:34.380 of outcome
00:47:34.700 across the board
00:47:35.500 sex equality
00:47:37.300 of outcome
00:47:37.640 across the board
00:47:38.280 is that the
00:47:38.940 theory
00:47:39.200 and how are we
00:47:41.440 going to do
00:47:41.740 that
00:47:42.080 exactly
00:47:43.360 or are we
00:47:43.980 going to just
00:47:44.360 do it hit and
00:47:45.100 miss
00:47:45.300 it's like
00:47:45.620 oh well
00:47:45.960 it's policemen
00:47:46.680 this year
00:47:47.180 well how about
00:47:49.340 bricklayers
00:47:49.920 it's like
00:47:51.540 why don't we
00:47:52.080 pass a law
00:47:52.640 like tomorrow
00:47:53.240 that now
00:47:54.300 50% of bricklayers
00:47:55.960 have to be
00:47:56.480 women
00:47:56.760 it doesn't
00:47:57.900 bloody well
00:47:58.320 matter if the
00:47:58.920 women want to
00:47:59.460 be bricklayers
00:48:00.240 that's irrelevant
00:48:01.820 who says
00:48:02.520 anything about
00:48:03.100 want
00:48:03.600 it's like
00:48:04.640 the only reason
00:48:07.720 that women
00:48:08.220 don't want to
00:48:08.960 be bricklayers
00:48:09.720 is because
00:48:10.180 they've
00:48:10.580 internalized
00:48:11.620 their misogyny
00:48:12.840 right
00:48:14.000 well that
00:48:15.040 that's the
00:48:15.540 standard answer
00:48:16.560 for that
00:48:17.360 sort of
00:48:17.740 gender
00:48:18.020 inequality
00:48:18.620 and like
00:48:19.680 where is it
00:48:20.540 going to
00:48:20.800 stop
00:48:21.220 so
00:48:22.440 I think
00:48:23.760 I've thought
00:48:24.940 for a long
00:48:25.660 time
00:48:25.980 that the
00:48:26.500 left can
00:48:27.020 go too
00:48:27.460 far
00:48:27.820 and I
00:48:28.840 think that
00:48:29.860 if you don't
00:48:30.520 think that
00:48:30.920 the left
00:48:31.260 can go too
00:48:31.860 far
00:48:32.160 then
00:48:32.480 your
00:48:33.140 head
00:48:33.760 is
00:48:34.100 so far
00:48:35.000 stuck
00:48:35.420 down in
00:48:36.180 the sand
00:48:36.640 that
00:48:36.880 you're
00:48:37.560 that
00:48:38.220 I need an
00:48:40.460 ending for
00:48:40.960 that
00:48:41.240 metaphor
00:48:42.060 I was
00:48:43.680 thinking about
00:48:44.200 something far
00:48:45.380 ruder
00:48:45.800 and just
00:48:46.280 made it
00:48:46.660 polite
00:48:47.040 anyways
00:48:48.360 I guess
00:48:49.720 that's the
00:48:50.200 ending to
00:48:50.680 it
00:48:50.900 obviously
00:48:52.400 the left
00:48:53.440 can go
00:48:53.860 too far
00:48:54.500 the 20th
00:48:56.840 century is a
00:48:57.400 testament to
00:48:57.960 that
00:48:58.260 Venezuela is a
00:48:59.420 testament to
00:49:00.020 that
00:49:00.340 okay so
00:49:01.520 when does the
00:49:02.000 left go too
00:49:02.620 far
00:49:02.980 because the
00:49:03.660 left isn't
00:49:04.260 particularly
00:49:04.740 interested in
00:49:05.380 answering that
00:49:05.920 question
00:49:06.320 and I would
00:49:07.320 say the
00:49:07.720 left goes
00:49:08.300 too far
00:49:08.740 when they
00:49:09.100 insist
00:49:09.640 upon
00:49:10.420 equality
00:49:11.300 of outcome
00:49:12.060 legislation
00:49:12.800 now
00:49:14.040 equality of
00:49:14.680 opportunity is a
00:49:15.460 different thing
00:49:15.960 because I think
00:49:16.580 that if you have
00:49:17.100 any sense
00:49:17.840 imagine just
00:49:19.280 imagine that
00:49:20.080 you're just greedy
00:49:20.860 you know
00:49:21.520 and self-centered
00:49:22.300 and
00:49:23.120 and
00:49:23.780 that you want
00:49:24.900 the most
00:49:26.120 for you
00:49:26.720 so
00:49:27.240 we won't be too
00:49:28.900 optimistic about
00:49:29.620 your motivations
00:49:30.280 and I don't think
00:49:32.240 that most people
00:49:32.860 are like that
00:49:33.360 by the way
00:49:33.760 I think that
00:49:34.320 people are
00:49:35.320 by and large
00:49:36.520 pretty good at
00:49:37.400 reciprocal
00:49:37.800 interactions
00:49:38.520 and they do
00:49:39.380 like to have
00:49:40.020 you know
00:49:40.740 nice things
00:49:41.300 for themselves
00:49:41.880 but they're
00:49:42.300 often hard
00:49:42.860 on themselves
00:49:43.360 but they're
00:49:44.120 they care about
00:49:45.140 the people they
00:49:45.700 love and they
00:49:46.400 care about their
00:49:46.920 families and
00:49:47.480 they're pretty good
00:49:48.380 at reciprocal
00:49:49.440 interaction with
00:49:50.280 other people too
00:49:50.960 so I don't think
00:49:51.660 we are just
00:49:52.340 innately selfish
00:49:54.060 to the core
00:49:54.860 it doesn't work
00:49:56.400 but let's assume
00:49:57.660 you are for a
00:49:58.300 moment
00:49:58.540 well
00:49:59.580 and then let's
00:50:00.820 assume that
00:50:01.380 you know
00:50:02.460 there's a bunch
00:50:03.000 of things you
00:50:03.460 don't know how
00:50:03.880 to do
00:50:04.200 and there's some
00:50:04.960 people out there
00:50:05.580 who have some
00:50:06.220 talent that might
00:50:06.880 be able to do
00:50:07.420 them and if
00:50:07.860 they did them
00:50:08.840 then you'd get
00:50:09.580 to benefit
00:50:10.100 you know
00:50:10.700 like you don't
00:50:11.120 know how to
00:50:11.440 make an iPhone
00:50:12.120 well some of
00:50:12.840 you might
00:50:13.220 not the whole
00:50:14.040 thing
00:50:14.400 but you know
00:50:15.400 some people
00:50:15.940 know how to
00:50:16.320 make an iPhone
00:50:16.820 and you get
00:50:17.520 to have one
00:50:18.200 and so
00:50:18.940 stopping someone
00:50:20.460 who could make
00:50:21.360 an iPhone
00:50:22.000 from making
00:50:23.140 one for some
00:50:23.860 arbitrary reason
00:50:24.840 because of their
00:50:25.440 sex or their
00:50:26.300 ethnicity or their
00:50:27.580 race just seems
00:50:28.660 completely
00:50:29.560 counterproductive
00:50:30.600 and it's pretty
00:50:31.860 obvious if you
00:50:32.660 look around the
00:50:33.260 world and you
00:50:34.480 look at countries
00:50:35.520 that are developing
00:50:36.320 economically
00:50:37.100 here's one good
00:50:38.260 indicator
00:50:38.920 you know
00:50:39.500 the countries
00:50:40.280 that have
00:50:41.140 there's a very
00:50:43.560 high
00:50:44.060 there's a very
00:50:45.200 powerful relationship
00:50:46.200 between the rights
00:50:47.800 granted to women
00:50:48.960 and the economic
00:50:50.460 viability of a
00:50:51.760 given country
00:50:52.480 it's very tightly
00:50:53.980 associated
00:50:54.660 so that's quite cool
00:50:55.840 because it seems
00:50:56.580 to indicate
00:50:57.140 well maybe
00:50:58.000 openness to the
00:50:58.980 participation of
00:50:59.900 women in
00:51:00.720 traditional societies
00:51:02.140 is also an
00:51:03.000 indicator of
00:51:03.760 openness to the
00:51:04.680 new you know
00:51:05.400 to the novel
00:51:06.080 and so that's a
00:51:06.940 good predictor of
00:51:07.760 economic success
00:51:08.900 or maybe it's that
00:51:10.180 women have 50%
00:51:11.600 of the talent
00:51:12.300 and we could use
00:51:13.360 the damn talent
00:51:14.160 so how about we
00:51:15.440 invite them into
00:51:16.200 play too
00:51:16.860 that seems
00:51:17.700 perfectly reasonable
00:51:18.600 and the same goes
00:51:19.500 for as I said
00:51:20.440 for ethnicity
00:51:21.020 and for race
00:51:22.560 and so I think
00:51:23.540 you have to be
00:51:24.000 a damn fool
00:51:24.760 not to
00:51:25.460 open up the
00:51:28.440 hierarchies
00:51:29.280 to those
00:51:30.500 who are
00:51:30.880 competent
00:51:31.480 right
00:51:32.520 to the maximal
00:51:33.340 possible degree
00:51:34.240 and that it's an
00:51:34.880 error not to do
00:51:35.740 that
00:51:36.000 but to insist
00:51:37.180 that the outcome
00:51:37.840 is the same
00:51:38.580 it's like
00:51:39.360 it's so
00:51:40.620 it's
00:51:41.620 it's vile
00:51:42.980 as far as I'm
00:51:44.580 concerned
00:51:44.920 for a variety
00:51:45.640 of reasons
00:51:46.140 the first reason
00:51:47.160 is
00:51:47.420 there's no
00:51:48.500 indication
00:51:49.160 that any
00:51:49.700 attempt to do
00:51:50.360 that in the
00:51:50.800 20th century
00:51:51.480 ended up
00:51:52.140 in any other
00:51:53.520 manner than
00:51:54.180 catastrophe
00:51:54.880 so that's the
00:51:55.780 first thing
00:51:56.300 the second
00:51:56.960 thing is
00:51:57.500 think it
00:51:59.200 through
00:51:59.740 think it
00:52:01.860 through
00:52:02.320 it's like
00:52:03.800 okay
00:52:04.240 50%
00:52:07.160 of every
00:52:07.800 occupation
00:52:08.480 has to be
00:52:09.340 men and
00:52:09.980 women
00:52:10.220 okay you're
00:52:11.240 really willing
00:52:11.640 to do that
00:52:12.180 are you
00:52:12.540 and we
00:52:13.840 could start
00:52:14.200 with brick
00:52:14.620 layers
00:52:14.980 it's like
00:52:15.520 how are you
00:52:15.740 going to
00:52:15.900 do that
00:52:16.340 you're
00:52:18.680 going to
00:52:18.800 start
00:52:19.080 forcing
00:52:19.980 girls
00:52:20.540 when they're
00:52:20.900 like 13
00:52:21.540 to learn
00:52:22.780 to lay
00:52:23.120 bricks
00:52:23.480 and how
00:52:25.900 are you
00:52:26.060 going to
00:52:26.260 force them
00:52:26.720 to do
00:52:27.000 that
00:52:27.200 because
00:52:27.500 maybe
00:52:28.160 they're
00:52:28.340 not
00:52:28.520 interested
00:52:29.080 I can
00:52:29.740 tell you
00:52:30.060 something
00:52:30.300 that's
00:52:30.660 quite
00:52:30.840 interesting
00:52:31.220 about
00:52:31.620 the
00:52:33.320 STEM
00:52:33.580 fields
00:52:33.980 in
00:52:34.140 women
00:52:34.360 so
00:52:35.400 as
00:52:37.340 society
00:52:39.220 has become
00:52:39.640 more
00:52:39.860 egalitarian
00:52:40.540 so
00:52:41.320 their
00:52:42.020 equality
00:52:42.660 of
00:52:42.860 opportunity
00:52:43.300 legislation
00:52:44.080 is
00:52:44.900 more
00:52:45.640 widespread
00:52:46.200 and
00:52:46.780 arguably
00:52:47.320 more
00:52:47.660 effective
00:52:48.160 and so
00:52:49.120 that would
00:52:49.460 be in
00:52:49.880 countries
00:52:50.200 like
00:52:50.600 Australia
00:52:51.000 but
00:52:51.260 more
00:52:51.600 particularly
00:52:52.040 in
00:52:52.360 countries
00:52:52.680 like
00:52:52.960 the
00:52:53.280 Scandinavian
00:52:53.820 countries
00:52:54.260 because
00:52:54.620 they've
00:52:54.840 taken it
00:52:55.240 farther
00:52:55.480 than
00:52:55.740 anywhere
00:52:56.000 else
00:52:56.340 fewer
00:52:57.760 women
00:52:58.320 go into
00:52:58.820 the
00:52:59.020 STEM
00:52:59.260 fields
00:52:59.720 fewer
00:53:00.660 not
00:53:01.780 more
00:53:02.240 and so
00:53:03.560 if you
00:53:03.840 rank
00:53:04.220 order
00:53:04.520 countries
00:53:05.100 by
00:53:05.560 how
00:53:06.120 free
00:53:06.640 women
00:53:07.100 are
00:53:07.640 there's a
00:53:09.260 negative
00:53:09.900 relationship
00:53:10.620 with how
00:53:11.120 probable
00:53:11.600 it is
00:53:12.240 that they'll
00:53:12.600 go into
00:53:13.120 science
00:53:13.600 technology
00:53:14.280 engineering
00:53:14.760 and mathematics
00:53:15.320 fields
00:53:15.860 and
00:53:18.100 the
00:53:18.640 evidence
00:53:18.960 for that
00:53:19.260 is
00:53:19.400 very
00:53:19.720 strong
00:53:20.340 by
00:53:20.560 the
00:53:20.640 way
00:53:20.760 this
00:53:20.960 isn't
00:53:21.180 just
00:53:21.360 a few
00:53:21.640 casual
00:53:22.120 studies
00:53:22.660 these
00:53:23.180 are
00:53:23.300 large
00:53:23.740 scale
00:53:24.100 international
00:53:24.660 studies
00:53:25.080 with tens
00:53:25.580 of thousands
00:53:26.020 of participants
00:53:26.860 replicated
00:53:28.640 multiple
00:53:29.180 times
00:53:29.700 by
00:53:30.580 researchers
00:53:31.740 who
00:53:32.280 did not
00:53:33.020 expect
00:53:33.740 to find
00:53:34.400 that
00:53:34.760 nor
00:53:35.320 want
00:53:35.840 it
00:53:36.060 so
00:53:37.160 it's
00:53:37.360 reliable
00:53:37.980 okay
00:53:39.280 so
00:53:39.520 why
00:53:39.980 well
00:53:41.100 there's
00:53:41.300 a bunch
00:53:41.560 of different
00:53:41.960 theories
00:53:42.340 one
00:53:42.700 is
00:53:42.940 that
00:53:43.240 the
00:53:44.700 average
00:53:45.120 IQ
00:53:45.480 of men
00:53:45.880 and women
00:53:46.200 is the
00:53:46.640 same
00:53:46.980 and that's
00:53:48.200 quite clear
00:53:48.680 but the
00:53:49.380 male
00:53:49.760 curve
00:53:50.540 is flatter
00:53:51.260 than the
00:53:51.700 female
00:53:52.020 curve
00:53:52.360 and that's
00:53:52.780 the
00:53:52.980 what do
00:53:53.540 they call
00:53:53.860 that
00:53:54.100 the
00:53:54.360 enhanced
00:53:55.320 male
00:53:55.640 variability
00:53:56.260 hypothesis
00:53:56.920 which is
00:53:57.460 almost now
00:53:58.160 become impossible
00:53:58.940 to publish
00:53:59.520 on because
00:53:59.960 it's
00:54:00.160 politically
00:54:00.500 incorrect
00:54:00.940 and what
00:54:01.320 it suggests
00:54:01.840 is that
00:54:02.180 there are
00:54:02.480 more
00:54:03.000 men
00:54:03.320 at the
00:54:03.640 very
00:54:03.920 upper
00:54:04.340 end
00:54:04.760 of
00:54:05.020 the
00:54:05.260 intelligence
00:54:05.940 distribution
00:54:06.580 and
00:54:07.240 more
00:54:07.460 men
00:54:07.760 at
00:54:07.980 the
00:54:08.100 lower
00:54:08.700 end
00:54:09.220 and
00:54:09.680 that
00:54:09.840 explains
00:54:10.320 some
00:54:10.560 things
00:54:10.880 like
00:54:11.140 why
00:54:11.460 there
00:54:11.660 are
00:54:11.820 far
00:54:12.060 more
00:54:12.280 boys
00:54:12.620 for
00:54:12.800 example
00:54:13.140 who
00:54:13.300 have
00:54:13.420 learning
00:54:13.680 disabilities
00:54:14.260 than
00:54:14.480 there
00:54:14.600 are
00:54:14.720 girls
00:54:15.040 and
00:54:15.640 there's
00:54:15.860 some
00:54:16.020 evidence
00:54:16.360 that
00:54:16.580 men
00:54:16.780 are
00:54:16.920 more
00:54:17.140 neurologically
00:54:17.980 vulnerable
00:54:18.480 than
00:54:18.840 women
00:54:19.140 because
00:54:19.460 they're
00:54:19.680 more
00:54:19.860 specialized
00:54:20.460 neurologically
00:54:21.380 and
00:54:21.900 the
00:54:22.300 advantage
00:54:22.740 to
00:54:22.940 that
00:54:23.160 is
00:54:23.380 this
00:54:23.860 enhanced
00:54:24.320 variability
00:54:24.780 but
00:54:25.160 the
00:54:25.300 disadvantage
00:54:25.860 is
00:54:26.200 the
00:54:26.760 specialization
00:54:27.500 makes
00:54:27.800 them
00:54:27.960 less
00:54:28.180 robust
00:54:28.660 and
00:54:28.840 resilient
00:54:29.240 neurologically
00:54:29.980 be
00:54:30.860 that
00:54:31.080 as
00:54:31.200 it
00:54:31.300 may
00:54:31.520 that's
00:54:31.920 one
00:54:32.140 possibility
00:54:32.740 and
00:54:33.420 I
00:54:33.580 think
00:54:33.780 there's
00:54:33.940 a
00:54:33.980 fair
00:54:34.180 bit
00:54:34.340 of
00:54:34.460 evidence
00:54:34.780 for
00:54:34.980 that
00:54:35.200 and
00:54:35.720 it's
00:54:36.380 often
00:54:36.700 the
00:54:36.900 case
00:54:37.180 that
00:54:37.520 differences
00:54:38.540 at
00:54:38.860 the
00:54:39.040 extreme
00:54:39.500 even
00:54:39.780 if
00:54:39.940 there
00:54:40.080 aren't
00:54:40.240 differences
00:54:40.580 in
00:54:40.820 the
00:54:40.960 middle
00:54:41.180 differences
00:54:41.560 at
00:54:41.780 the
00:54:41.900 extreme
00:54:42.240 actually
00:54:42.600 make
00:54:42.840 a
00:54:42.940 big
00:54:43.100 difference
00:54:43.500 you know
00:54:44.140 because
00:54:44.360 like
00:54:44.540 let's
00:54:44.800 say
00:54:44.900 you're
00:54:45.020 going to
00:54:45.140 be
00:54:45.220 an
00:54:45.340 engineer
00:54:45.720 maybe
00:54:46.660 one
00:54:47.000 person
00:54:47.360 in
00:54:47.580 100
00:54:48.160 is
00:54:48.420 an
00:54:48.560 engineer
00:54:48.920 and
00:54:49.900 you
00:54:50.180 have
00:54:50.340 to
00:54:50.420 be
00:54:50.540 really
00:54:51.100 interested
00:54:51.820 in
00:54:52.140 gadgets
00:54:52.600 to
00:54:52.980 be
00:54:53.120 an
00:54:53.260 engineer
00:54:53.620 you
00:54:54.280 know
00:54:54.380 you
00:54:54.540 have
00:54:54.720 to
00:54:54.820 be
00:54:54.960 more
00:54:55.180 interested
00:54:55.600 than
00:54:55.960 99
00:55:04.340 people
00:55:05.120 have
00:55:05.340 criticized
00:55:05.760 the
00:55:06.340 male
00:55:06.960 variability
00:55:07.500 hypothesis
00:55:08.180 because
00:55:08.580 they've
00:55:08.880 looked
00:55:09.080 at
00:55:09.360 the
00:55:09.880 performance
00:55:10.320 of
00:55:10.640 girls
00:55:11.040 in
00:55:11.720 mathematics
00:55:12.380 in
00:55:12.760 junior
00:55:13.000 high
00:55:13.260 school
00:55:13.560 and
00:55:14.060 it
00:55:14.180 turns
00:55:14.380 out
00:55:14.580 that
00:55:14.760 girls
00:55:15.200 do
00:55:15.560 pretty
00:55:15.840 much
00:55:16.040 as
00:55:16.200 well
00:55:16.360 as
00:55:16.500 boys
00:55:16.780 do
00:55:17.060 in
00:55:17.420 mathematics
00:55:18.280 in
00:55:18.580 junior
00:55:19.420 high
00:55:19.660 at
00:55:20.060 the
00:55:20.260 upper
00:55:20.540 end
00:55:20.880 and
00:55:21.280 so
00:55:21.400 those
00:55:21.620 would
00:55:21.740 be
00:55:21.860 the
00:55:22.000 people
00:55:22.220 you'd
00:55:22.420 expect
00:55:22.700 to
00:55:22.860 go
00:55:22.980 into
00:55:23.100 the
00:55:23.280 STEM
00:55:23.520 fields
00:55:23.860 right
00:55:24.080 because
00:55:24.260 they
00:55:24.380 have
00:55:24.580 the
00:55:24.780 intellectual
00:55:26.700 ability
00:55:27.340 for
00:55:27.620 it
00:55:27.760 but
00:55:28.540 what
00:55:29.020 you
00:55:29.200 see
00:55:29.580 is
00:55:29.880 that
00:55:30.100 the
00:55:30.300 women
00:55:30.600 who
00:55:30.820 have
00:55:30.960 high
00:55:31.200 mathematical
00:55:31.780 ability
00:55:32.360 also
00:55:33.140 tend
00:55:33.640 to
00:55:33.820 have
00:55:34.100 high
00:55:34.380 verbal
00:55:34.800 ability
00:55:35.300 whereas
00:55:36.420 the
00:55:36.620 men
00:55:36.900 that
00:55:37.080 have
00:55:37.320 high
00:55:37.580 mathematical
00:55:38.140 ability
00:55:38.660 tend
00:55:38.920 to
00:55:39.060 have
00:55:39.260 less
00:55:39.720 high
00:55:40.160 verbal
00:55:40.760 ability
00:55:41.200 and
00:55:41.580 so
00:55:41.720 one
00:55:41.880 of
00:55:41.960 the
00:55:42.060 things
00:55:42.280 that
00:55:42.500 implies
00:55:42.900 is
00:55:43.160 that
00:55:43.340 the
00:55:43.500 women
00:55:43.760 who
00:55:43.920 have
00:55:44.120 high
00:55:44.360 mathematical
00:55:44.980 ability
00:55:45.480 have
00:55:46.100 more
00:55:46.740 vocational
00:55:48.460 choice
00:55:49.160 and
00:55:50.120 so
00:55:50.360 they're
00:55:50.680 statistically
00:55:51.220 less
00:55:51.560 likely
00:55:51.860 to
00:55:52.020 go
00:55:52.160 into
00:55:52.320 the
00:55:52.500 STEM
00:55:52.740 fields
00:55:53.220 so
00:55:53.820 that's
00:55:54.060 kind
00:55:54.240 of
00:55:54.300 an
00:55:54.400 interesting
00:55:54.860 no
00:55:55.140 one
00:55:55.260 expected
00:55:55.680 that
00:55:59.880 it's
00:56:00.500 also
00:56:00.780 extraordinarily
00:56:01.640 germane
00:56:02.240 there's
00:56:03.000 a variety
00:56:03.620 of ways
00:56:04.100 of
00:56:04.460 looking
00:56:05.180 at
00:56:05.440 the
00:56:05.720 psychological
00:56:06.200 differences
00:56:06.820 and similarities
00:56:07.560 between
00:56:08.000 men and
00:56:08.360 women
00:56:08.540 and the
00:56:08.840 first
00:56:09.040 thing
00:56:09.240 that
00:56:09.400 you
00:56:09.540 might
00:56:09.760 want
00:56:10.160 to
00:56:10.260 know
00:56:10.420 is
00:56:10.600 that
00:56:10.840 men
00:56:11.360 and
00:56:11.520 women
00:56:11.700 are
00:56:11.920 more
00:56:12.280 similar
00:56:12.760 than
00:56:13.020 they
00:56:13.160 are
00:56:13.360 different
00:56:13.780 on
00:56:14.080 all
00:56:14.380 the
00:56:14.580 personality
00:56:15.020 dimensions
00:56:15.520 so
00:56:16.240 the
00:56:16.620 overlap
00:56:16.980 is
00:56:17.180 quite
00:56:17.460 strong
00:56:17.960 the
00:56:18.360 biggest
00:56:18.660 differences
00:56:19.160 are
00:56:19.500 there's
00:56:19.780 five
00:56:20.120 personality
00:56:20.660 dimensions
00:56:21.220 I
00:56:21.600 mentioned
00:56:22.080 them
00:56:22.360 extroversion
00:56:23.300 neuroticism
00:56:24.100 agreeableness
00:56:26.200 conscientiousness
00:56:27.160 and
00:56:27.680 openness
00:56:28.160 the
00:56:28.960 biggest
00:56:29.280 differences
00:56:29.720 are
00:56:30.120 in
00:56:30.620 neuroticism
00:56:32.160 women
00:56:32.560 are
00:56:32.740 higher
00:56:33.080 in
00:56:33.240 negative
00:56:33.480 emotion
00:56:33.900 and
00:56:34.100 that
00:56:34.280 kicks
00:56:34.600 in
00:56:34.860 at
00:56:35.100 puberty
00:56:35.480 because
00:56:35.920 it's
00:56:36.180 not
00:56:36.320 the
00:56:36.460 case
00:56:36.620 for
00:56:36.760 boys
00:56:37.000 and
00:56:37.140 girls
00:56:37.400 and
00:56:38.840 they're
00:56:39.360 higher
00:56:39.760 in
00:56:40.000 agreeableness
00:56:40.880 which is
00:56:41.680 partly
00:56:42.020 why
00:56:42.260 there
00:56:42.420 are
00:56:42.540 far
00:56:42.760 more
00:56:42.960 men
00:56:43.180 in
00:56:43.340 prison
00:56:43.640 which
00:56:44.000 is
00:56:44.100 another
00:56:44.280 thing
00:56:44.500 we
00:56:44.620 might
00:56:44.780 think
00:56:45.020 about
00:56:45.260 is
00:56:45.440 like
00:56:45.600 what
00:56:45.760 is
00:56:46.080 that
00:56:46.280 is
00:56:46.920 that
00:56:47.080 gender
00:56:47.440 discrimination
00:56:48.400 precisely
00:56:49.320 I'm
00:56:50.340 bloody well
00:56:51.380 dead
00:56:51.640 serious
00:56:52.020 about
00:56:52.260 this
00:56:52.500 I
00:56:52.660 went
00:56:52.840 to
00:56:52.980 a
00:56:53.120 NATO
00:56:53.340 conference
00:56:53.900 25
00:56:54.300 years
00:56:54.700 ago
00:56:54.960 and
00:56:55.400 there
00:56:55.520 were
00:56:55.560 a
00:56:55.660 group
00:56:55.800 of
00:56:55.960 female
00:56:56.240 scientists
00:56:56.740 there
00:56:57.000 who
00:56:57.380 claimed
00:56:57.840 that
00:56:58.420 the
00:56:58.780 psychiatric
00:56:59.720 diagnostic
00:57:00.480 criteria
00:57:01.060 for
00:57:01.340 childhood
00:57:01.760 conduct
00:57:02.240 disorder
00:57:02.700 should
00:57:03.340 be
00:57:03.760 revamped
00:57:05.300 because
00:57:05.840 there
00:57:06.080 were
00:57:06.200 far
00:57:06.620 more
00:57:06.920 boys
00:57:07.540 diagnosed
00:57:08.340 with
00:57:08.620 childhood
00:57:09.000 conduct
00:57:09.420 disorder
00:57:09.940 than
00:57:10.340 there
00:57:10.500 were
00:57:10.660 girls
00:57:11.120 and
00:57:11.920 that's
00:57:12.260 the
00:57:12.380 precursor
00:57:12.900 by
00:57:13.060 the
00:57:13.160 way
00:57:13.300 to
00:57:13.480 adult
00:57:13.820 antisocial
00:57:14.420 personality
00:57:14.920 disorder
00:57:15.380 or
00:57:15.820 to
00:57:16.080 criminality
00:57:16.740 and
00:57:17.640 the
00:57:18.040 way
00:57:18.260 that
00:57:18.460 you
00:57:18.720 equate
00:57:19.720 it
00:57:19.960 by
00:57:20.400 sex
00:57:21.100 if
00:57:21.540 you
00:57:21.700 want
00:57:21.940 to
00:57:22.060 do
00:57:22.180 that
00:57:22.400 is
00:57:22.760 you
00:57:22.880 get
00:57:23.100 rid
00:57:23.300 of
00:57:23.420 the
00:57:23.580 violence
00:57:24.220 so
00:57:24.900 one
00:57:25.140 of
00:57:25.240 the
00:57:25.360 criteria
00:57:25.760 for
00:57:26.020 childhood
00:57:26.360 conduct
00:57:26.800 disorder
00:57:27.200 is
00:57:27.460 kicking
00:57:28.240 hitting
00:57:28.680 biting
00:57:29.120 and
00:57:29.400 stealing
00:57:29.800 like
00:57:30.160 criminal
00:57:32.120 behavior
00:57:32.680 if
00:57:33.440 you
00:57:33.540 take
00:57:33.980 that
00:57:34.260 out
00:57:34.460 of
00:57:34.580 the
00:57:34.740 diagnostic
00:57:35.260 criteria
00:57:35.880 then
00:57:36.660 you
00:57:36.780 get
00:57:36.940 the
00:57:37.080 same
00:57:37.240 number
00:57:37.500 of
00:57:37.660 boys
00:57:37.860 and
00:57:38.040 girls
00:57:38.360 and
00:57:39.320 that's
00:57:39.560 what
00:57:39.680 they
00:57:39.800 were
00:57:39.960 advocating
00:57:40.460 for
00:57:40.900 25
00:57:41.880 years
00:57:42.360 ago
00:57:42.580 and
00:57:42.720 I
00:57:42.820 thought
00:57:42.980 you
00:57:43.300 people
00:57:43.600 are
00:57:43.780 completely
00:57:44.320 out
00:57:44.680 of
00:57:44.860 your
00:57:45.020 bloody
00:57:45.360 minds
00:57:45.940 because
00:57:46.460 the
00:57:46.660 only
00:57:46.840 reason
00:57:47.160 that
00:57:47.300 we
00:57:47.420 ever
00:57:47.600 came
00:57:47.840 up
00:57:48.060 with
00:57:48.220 the
00:57:48.340 diagnosis
00:57:48.840 for
00:57:49.120 childhood
00:57:49.440 conduct
00:57:49.880 disorder
00:57:50.360 was
00:57:50.820 because
00:57:51.080 we
00:57:51.280 were
00:57:51.480 worried
00:57:51.960 that
00:57:52.460 the
00:57:52.660 violent
00:57:53.020 kids
00:57:53.460 would
00:57:53.680 become
00:57:53.980 violent
00:57:54.460 adolescents
00:57:55.020 and
00:57:55.320 that
00:57:55.460 they
00:57:55.600 would
00:57:55.760 become
00:57:56.020 violent
00:57:56.540 adults
00:57:57.260 which
00:57:57.580 is
00:57:57.700 exactly
00:57:58.100 what
00:57:58.320 happens
00:57:58.720 by
00:57:59.000 the
00:57:59.100 way
00:57:59.240 because
00:57:59.580 aggressive
00:58:01.020 behavior
00:58:01.440 is
00:58:01.600 unbelievably
00:58:02.320 stable
00:58:02.980 and
00:58:03.220 difficult
00:58:03.580 to
00:58:03.980 alter
00:58:04.400 but
00:58:05.340 they
00:58:05.480 were
00:58:05.620 perfectly
00:58:06.000 willing
00:58:06.320 to
00:58:06.560 gerrymander
00:58:07.240 the
00:58:07.440 diagnostic
00:58:07.940 criteria
00:58:08.500 so
00:58:13.300 utility
00:58:13.680 of
00:58:13.940 the
00:58:14.060 diagnosis
00:58:14.560 and
00:58:15.060 their
00:58:15.240 fundamental
00:58:16.800 claim
00:58:17.320 was
00:58:17.620 the
00:58:19.300 reason
00:58:19.600 that
00:58:19.760 there
00:58:19.880 were
00:58:19.980 more
00:58:20.140 men
00:58:20.340 in
00:58:20.500 prison
00:58:20.780 than
00:58:21.200 women
00:58:21.480 was
00:58:22.020 because
00:58:22.520 it
00:58:24.740 was a
00:58:24.940 form
00:58:25.120 of
00:58:26.280 arbitrary
00:58:26.720 prejudice
00:58:27.200 and
00:58:28.360 this
00:58:28.660 is
00:58:28.860 absolutely
00:58:29.940 insane
00:58:30.740 so
00:58:31.680 you
00:58:32.020 know
00:58:32.140 it
00:58:32.480 is
00:58:32.660 the
00:58:32.820 case
00:58:33.140 if
00:58:33.360 you
00:58:33.460 look
00:58:33.600 at
00:58:33.680 domestic
00:58:34.040 violence
00:58:34.520 statistics
00:58:34.980 by
00:58:35.200 the
00:58:35.300 way
00:58:35.420 women
00:58:35.700 hit
00:58:35.920 men
00:58:36.180 more
00:58:36.360 than
00:58:36.500 men
00:58:36.700 hit
00:58:36.860 women
00:58:37.180 just
00:58:37.660 so
00:58:37.800 you
00:58:37.940 know
00:58:38.200 it
00:58:39.660 actually
00:58:39.940 doesn't
00:58:40.300 matter
00:58:40.780 mostly
00:58:41.460 not
00:58:43.160 that
00:58:43.300 it's
00:58:43.460 pleasant
00:58:43.880 that
00:58:44.140 isn't
00:58:44.320 what
00:58:44.440 I'm
00:58:44.580 saying
00:58:44.980 is
00:58:45.180 that
00:58:45.320 men
00:58:45.560 are
00:58:45.720 a
00:58:45.820 lot
00:58:45.960 stronger
00:58:46.360 than
00:58:46.560 women
00:58:46.840 they
00:58:47.300 have
00:58:47.420 a
00:58:47.560 lot
00:58:47.800 more
00:58:48.080 powerful
00:58:48.520 upper
00:58:48.780 bodies
00:58:49.200 and
00:58:49.780 so
00:58:49.980 when
00:58:50.260 men
00:58:50.800 hit
00:58:51.040 women
00:58:51.440 the
00:58:52.020 consequences
00:58:53.580 tend
00:58:53.900 to be
00:58:54.140 very
00:58:54.420 dire
00:58:54.740 and
00:58:54.980 when
00:58:55.140 women
00:58:55.380 hit
00:58:55.600 men
00:58:55.900 well
00:58:56.140 they're
00:58:56.380 less
00:58:56.680 dire
00:58:57.000 and
00:58:57.160 I'm
00:58:57.300 not
00:58:57.540 saying
00:58:57.880 that
00:58:58.040 it's
00:58:58.240 okay
00:58:58.680 but
00:58:59.240 I
00:58:59.440 am
00:59:00.080 pointing
00:59:00.480 out
00:59:00.700 that
00:59:00.900 this
00:59:01.820 does
00:59:02.300 happen
00:59:02.660 it's
00:59:03.420 not
00:59:03.560 the
00:59:03.740 point
00:59:04.060 the
00:59:04.260 point
00:59:04.480 is
00:59:04.680 that
00:59:04.900 we're
00:59:13.160 harmony
00:59:13.400 of
00:59:13.600 society
00:59:14.020 and
00:59:14.300 generally
00:59:14.760 corrupting
00:59:15.920 the
00:59:16.580 integrity
00:59:16.960 of
00:59:17.180 the
00:59:17.320 state
00:59:17.680 and
00:59:18.020 so
00:59:18.140 we
00:59:18.260 put
00:59:18.420 them
00:59:18.540 in
00:59:18.680 prison
00:59:18.980 and
00:59:19.440 most
00:59:19.860 of
00:59:20.040 them
00:59:20.160 are
00:59:20.300 men
00:59:20.680 it's
00:59:21.940 like
00:59:22.100 10
00:59:22.480 to
00:59:22.640 15
00:59:23.060 to
00:59:23.220 1
00:59:23.440 and
00:59:23.560 it's
00:59:23.760 like
00:59:23.920 that
00:59:24.140 worldwide
00:59:24.760 okay
00:59:25.580 what
00:59:26.000 are we
00:59:26.140 going to
00:59:26.280 do
00:59:26.420 50%
00:59:28.480 are
00:59:29.360 now
00:59:29.500 going
00:59:29.640 to
00:59:29.680 be
00:59:29.800 women
00:59:30.060 so
00:59:32.460 seriously
00:59:33.540 look
00:59:33.980 if
00:59:34.180 the
00:59:34.540 theory
00:59:36.140 is
00:59:36.460 the
00:59:36.620 only
00:59:36.880 god
00:59:37.180 damn
00:59:37.420 difference
00:59:37.860 between
00:59:38.180 men
00:59:38.420 and
00:59:38.580 women
00:59:38.840 is
00:59:39.500 a
00:59:39.640 consequence
00:59:40.000 of
00:59:40.360 the
00:59:40.500 oppressive
00:59:40.880 social
00:59:41.320 structure
00:59:41.820 that
00:59:42.300 cuts
00:59:42.580 both
00:59:42.880 ways
00:59:43.300 and
00:59:44.380 what
00:59:44.520 that
00:59:44.720 means
00:59:44.960 is
00:59:45.120 that
00:59:45.260 if
00:59:45.460 85%
00:59:46.520 or
00:59:46.680 90%
00:59:47.240 of
00:59:47.360 the
00:59:47.460 people
00:59:47.700 who
00:59:47.840 are
00:59:47.940 in
00:59:48.060 prison
00:59:48.340 are
00:59:48.720 male
00:59:49.100 then
00:59:49.680 the
00:59:50.040 prison
00:59:50.260 system
00:59:50.640 is
00:59:50.860 unbelievably
00:59:51.820 prejudiced
00:59:52.600 against
00:59:53.000 men
00:59:53.440 so
00:59:54.640 we're
00:59:54.780 going to
00:59:54.940 act
00:59:55.160 on
00:59:55.340 that
00:59:55.640 and
00:59:56.280 how
00:59:56.620 that's
00:59:57.240 easy
00:59:57.520 we
00:59:58.140 lower
00:59:58.540 the
00:59:58.780 standards
00:59:59.280 of
00:59:59.480 criminal
00:59:59.780 behavior
01:00:00.200 for
01:00:00.480 women
01:00:00.780 until
01:00:01.260 we
01:00:01.540 equate
01:00:02.060 the
01:00:02.260 number
01:00:02.540 of
01:00:02.720 men
01:00:02.880 and
01:00:03.020 women
01:00:03.240 who
01:00:03.400 are
01:00:03.540 imprisoned
01:00:04.020 look
01:00:06.220 that's
01:00:06.660 what
01:00:06.800 you're
01:00:06.980 going
01:00:07.080 to
01:00:07.180 yeah
01:00:12.240 you know
01:00:12.640 you think
01:00:13.160 that's
01:00:13.480 funny
01:00:13.780 that's
01:00:14.560 what
01:00:14.660 happens
01:00:15.040 in
01:00:15.180 the
01:00:15.300 military
01:00:15.780 especially
01:00:16.780 at
01:00:17.040 the
01:00:17.180 higher
01:00:17.460 ends
01:00:17.820 you
01:00:17.980 know
01:00:18.100 in
01:00:18.380 the
01:00:18.940 operations
01:00:19.520 like
01:00:19.800 navy
01:00:20.120 seals
01:00:20.520 or
01:00:20.740 the
01:00:20.860 places
01:00:21.160 where
01:00:21.400 there's
01:00:21.620 tremendous
01:00:22.040 emphasis
01:00:22.500 on
01:00:22.800 physical
01:00:23.160 readiness
01:00:23.580 the
01:00:24.420 only
01:00:24.780 way
01:00:25.040 you
01:00:25.240 can
01:00:25.400 equate
01:00:25.740 by
01:00:25.940 gender
01:00:26.380 is
01:00:27.560 to
01:00:27.740 reduce
01:00:28.520 the
01:00:28.880 performance
01:00:29.500 criteria
01:00:30.160 that
01:00:30.500 the
01:00:30.680 women
01:00:30.860 have
01:00:31.160 to
01:00:31.340 attain
01:00:31.740 so
01:00:32.700 if
01:00:32.840 you
01:00:32.920 can
01:00:33.040 do
01:00:33.160 it
01:00:33.300 there
01:00:33.580 then
01:00:33.960 why
01:00:34.180 the
01:00:34.340 hell
01:00:34.520 can't
01:00:34.840 you
01:00:34.940 do
01:00:35.100 it
01:00:35.220 for
01:00:35.380 criminality
01:00:36.000 if
01:00:36.500 the
01:00:36.640 goal
01:00:36.880 is
01:00:37.100 equality
01:00:37.700 of
01:00:37.920 outcome
01:00:38.340 where
01:00:38.980 are
01:00:39.060 you
01:00:39.140 going
01:00:39.240 to
01:00:39.360 stop
01:00:39.800 and
01:00:40.740 that's
01:00:41.380 easy
01:00:41.660 if
01:00:42.100 the
01:00:42.280 goal
01:00:42.740 is
01:00:43.240 equality
01:00:43.840 of
01:00:44.080 outcome
01:00:44.600 you
01:00:46.340 stop
01:00:47.060 when
01:00:47.720 the
01:00:47.920 outcomes
01:00:48.440 are
01:00:48.760 equal
01:00:49.280 and
01:00:50.280 not
01:00:50.460 just
01:00:50.680 the
01:00:50.860 desirable
01:00:51.400 outcomes
01:00:51.940 you
01:00:52.120 know
01:00:52.220 you
01:00:52.360 hear
01:00:52.560 about
01:00:52.800 the
01:00:52.960 fact
01:00:53.220 that
01:00:53.460 well
01:00:53.960 if
01:00:54.240 you
01:00:54.340 look
01:00:54.460 at
01:00:54.560 the
01:00:54.700 C
01:00:54.920 suites
01:00:55.240 of
01:00:55.400 major
01:00:55.640 corporations
01:00:56.240 that
01:00:56.580 a
01:00:56.960 majority
01:00:57.320 of
01:00:57.520 the
01:00:57.660 people
01:00:57.900 are
01:00:58.080 men
01:00:58.400 it's
01:00:59.140 like
01:00:59.360 well
01:00:59.680 the
01:00:59.940 first
01:01:00.160 thing
01:01:00.340 I
01:01:00.500 think
01:01:00.700 about
01:01:00.920 that
01:01:01.160 is
01:01:01.340 well
01:01:01.640 what
01:01:01.920 the
01:01:02.040 hell
01:01:02.160 is
01:01:02.260 your
01:01:02.380 point
01:01:02.760 it's
01:01:04.100 like
01:01:04.280 that's
01:01:04.660 hardly
01:01:04.920 anyone
01:01:05.460 right
01:01:05.860 99%
01:01:07.700 of
01:01:08.040 men
01:01:08.460 99.9%
01:01:10.360 of
01:01:10.500 men
01:01:10.640 are
01:01:10.940 not
01:01:11.220 on
01:01:11.520 the
01:01:11.720 C
01:01:11.920 suites
01:01:12.380 of
01:01:12.580 large
01:01:12.880 corporations
01:01:13.540 so
01:01:14.220 we're
01:01:14.360 talking
01:01:14.600 about
01:01:14.760 a
01:01:14.860 very
01:01:15.000 tiny
01:01:15.280 proportion
01:01:15.720 of
01:01:15.880 the
01:01:15.980 population
01:01:16.460 and
01:01:16.880 they're
01:01:17.040 strange
01:01:17.460 people
01:01:17.940 right
01:01:18.880 they
01:01:19.680 are
01:01:19.920 they're
01:01:20.940 not
01:01:21.340 normal
01:01:21.840 people
01:01:22.320 and
01:01:23.300 the
01:01:23.520 reason
01:01:23.760 I
01:01:23.940 say
01:01:24.160 that
01:01:24.400 is
01:01:24.540 because
01:01:24.820 first
01:01:25.140 of
01:01:25.260 all
01:01:25.380 they're
01:01:25.540 very
01:01:25.880 intelligent
01:01:26.420 most
01:01:26.820 of
01:01:27.000 them
01:01:27.140 so
01:01:27.540 that
01:01:28.060 takes
01:01:28.960 the
01:01:29.160 first
01:01:29.440 slice
01:01:29.880 and
01:01:30.520 the
01:01:30.660 second
01:01:30.920 slice
01:01:31.280 is
01:01:31.560 all
01:01:32.580 they
01:01:33.020 do
01:01:33.420 is
01:01:33.820 work
01:01:34.260 like
01:01:35.400 80
01:01:35.620 hours
01:01:35.880 a
01:01:36.020 week
01:01:36.260 and
01:01:37.440 not
01:01:37.720 everybody
01:01:38.020 wants
01:01:38.300 to
01:01:38.460 do
01:01:38.580 that
01:01:38.800 and
01:01:38.960 why
01:01:39.440 should
01:01:39.720 they
01:01:39.960 it's
01:01:40.180 like
01:01:40.380 whoever
01:01:40.900 said
01:01:41.240 that
01:01:41.400 you
01:01:41.560 should
01:01:41.720 work
01:01:41.940 80
01:01:42.140 hours
01:01:42.400 a
01:01:42.540 week
01:01:42.780 but
01:01:43.260 if
01:01:43.400 you're
01:01:43.520 going
01:01:43.640 to
01:01:43.760 rise
01:01:44.100 to
01:01:44.280 that
01:01:44.480 level
01:01:44.800 in
01:01:44.980 any
01:01:45.180 profession
01:01:45.600 I
01:01:45.900 don't
01:01:46.060 give
01:01:46.220 a
01:01:46.320 damn
01:01:46.500 what
01:01:46.780 the
01:01:46.960 profession
01:01:47.320 is
01:01:47.660 if
01:01:48.100 you
01:01:48.220 want
01:01:48.380 to
01:01:48.440 hit
01:01:48.600 the
01:01:48.780 top
01:01:49.480 one
01:01:49.880 tenth
01:01:50.160 of
01:01:50.360 one
01:01:50.580 percent
01:01:51.020 in
01:01:51.460 your
01:01:51.620 profession
01:01:52.120 then
01:01:52.620 all
01:01:53.240 you
01:01:53.520 do
01:01:53.820 is
01:01:54.020 work
01:01:54.480 and
01:01:55.200 not
01:01:55.440 only
01:01:55.620 do
01:01:55.740 you
01:01:55.860 work
01:01:56.120 you
01:01:56.300 work
01:01:56.540 hard
01:01:56.820 and
01:01:56.940 efficiently
01:01:57.400 and
01:01:57.860 you
01:01:57.980 do
01:01:58.120 it
01:01:58.220 better
01:01:58.440 than
01:01:58.620 anyone
01:01:58.880 else
01:01:59.200 plus
01:01:59.720 you
01:01:59.920 need
01:02:00.160 the
01:02:00.300 talent
01:02:00.620 and
01:02:00.840 you
01:02:00.960 need
01:02:01.140 the
01:02:01.260 intelligence
01:02:01.700 and
01:02:02.000 you
01:02:02.120 need
01:02:02.300 the
01:02:02.460 luck
01:02:02.740 and
01:02:02.880 you
01:02:03.000 need
01:02:03.160 the
01:02:03.280 health
01:02:03.580 and
01:02:03.760 all
01:02:04.120 the
01:02:04.240 other
01:02:04.400 things
01:02:04.640 that
01:02:04.780 might
01:02:04.920 go
01:02:05.100 along
01:02:05.360 with
01:02:05.540 that
01:02:05.760 and
01:02:06.220 so
01:02:06.340 the
01:02:06.480 fact
01:02:06.740 that
01:02:06.960 a
01:02:07.380 majority
01:02:07.760 of
01:02:07.960 them
01:02:08.120 happen
01:02:08.360 to
01:02:08.500 be
01:02:08.640 men
01:02:09.000 that
01:02:10.380 that
01:02:10.580 says
01:02:11.000 nothing
01:02:11.520 about
01:02:11.840 the
01:02:12.140 structural
01:02:12.640 what
01:02:13.300 would
01:02:13.440 you
01:02:13.540 call
01:02:13.720 this
01:02:13.920 it
01:02:14.440 says
01:02:14.680 nothing
01:02:15.020 about
01:02:15.280 the
01:02:15.460 fundamental
01:02:15.900 structure
01:02:16.320 of
01:02:16.480 the
01:02:16.580 state
01:02:16.840 as
01:02:17.020 far
01:02:17.180 as
01:02:17.300 I'm
01:02:17.440 concerned
01:02:17.780 and
01:02:18.400 why
01:02:18.600 are
01:02:18.740 we
01:02:18.880 concentrating
01:02:19.420 only
01:02:19.740 on
01:02:19.920 the
01:02:20.040 upper
01:02:20.260 end
01:02:20.620 like
01:02:21.560 why
01:02:21.820 is
01:02:22.020 it
01:02:22.140 that
01:02:22.540 it's
01:02:22.720 the
01:02:22.880 CEOs
01:02:23.280 that
01:02:23.600 count
01:02:23.880 and
01:02:24.000 not
01:02:24.160 the
01:02:24.300 bricklayers
01:02:24.900 you
01:02:25.520 know
01:02:25.640 and
01:02:25.820 there's
01:02:26.420 all
01:02:26.620 sorts
01:02:26.880 of
01:02:26.980 things
01:02:27.180 we
01:02:27.340 can
01:02:27.460 talk
01:02:27.680 about
01:02:27.880 with
01:02:28.020 regards
01:02:28.340 to
01:02:28.500 that
01:02:28.740 that's
01:02:29.060 straightforward
01:02:29.440 okay
01:02:29.960 so
01:02:30.260 what's
01:02:30.480 the
01:02:30.580 difference
01:02:30.820 between
01:02:31.120 men
01:02:31.340 and
01:02:31.480 women
01:02:31.680 with
01:02:31.880 regards
01:02:32.180 to
01:02:32.340 occupation
01:02:32.900 okay
01:02:33.560 men
01:02:33.880 are
01:02:34.020 way
01:02:34.320 more
01:02:34.560 likely
01:02:34.800 to
01:02:34.980 work
01:02:35.180 outside
01:02:35.680 okay
01:02:36.440 so
01:02:36.600 now
01:02:36.780 half
01:02:37.220 the
01:02:37.360 people
01:02:37.680 who
01:02:37.720 work
01:02:37.940 outside
01:02:38.240 have
01:02:39.780 to
01:02:39.920 be
01:02:40.040 women
01:02:40.320 men
01:02:49.740 that
01:02:50.020 I
01:02:50.460 don't
01:02:50.560 know
01:02:50.680 exactly
01:02:51.060 how
01:02:51.240 we're
01:02:51.420 going
01:02:51.520 to
01:02:51.620 do
01:02:51.780 that
01:02:52.100 maybe
01:02:52.520 we
01:02:52.740 just
01:02:52.980 injure
01:02:53.380 women
01:02:53.740 randomly
01:02:54.420 till
01:02:57.100 it's
01:02:57.340 equal
01:02:57.720 or
01:02:58.920 we
01:02:59.120 force
01:02:59.460 them
01:02:59.620 to
01:02:59.780 take
01:03:00.020 the
01:03:00.220 jobs
01:03:00.720 and
01:03:01.620 I
01:03:01.880 don't
01:03:02.060 know
01:03:02.180 how
01:03:02.320 we
01:03:02.480 do
01:03:02.640 that
01:03:03.040 okay
01:03:03.780 men
01:03:04.980 are
01:03:05.140 way
01:03:05.420 more
01:03:05.660 likely
01:03:05.960 to
01:03:06.180 move
01:03:06.660 that's
01:03:07.180 another
01:03:07.380 thing
01:03:07.720 they're
01:03:08.100 also
01:03:08.360 much
01:03:08.660 more
01:03:08.860 likely
01:03:09.140 to
01:03:09.320 work
01:03:09.520 longer
01:03:09.860 hours
01:03:10.360 women
01:03:10.800 are
01:03:11.000 way
01:03:11.280 more
01:03:11.500 likely
01:03:11.740 to
01:03:11.900 work
01:03:12.100 part
01:03:12.400 time
01:03:12.740 that's
01:03:13.200 particularly
01:03:13.640 true
01:03:13.980 by
01:03:14.160 the
01:03:14.280 way
01:03:14.400 in
01:03:14.520 Scandinavia
01:03:15.160 and
01:03:15.560 the
01:03:15.660 reason
01:03:15.920 they
01:03:16.100 do
01:03:16.280 that
01:03:16.520 is
01:03:16.660 because
01:03:16.960 well
01:03:17.260 you
01:03:17.420 know
01:03:17.500 they
01:03:17.660 hit
01:03:17.820 their
01:03:18.000 30s
01:03:18.500 early
01:03:18.760 30s
01:03:19.220 usually
01:03:19.500 and
01:03:19.680 they
01:03:19.780 think
01:03:20.040 especially
01:03:21.300 often
01:03:22.000 if
01:03:22.200 they're
01:03:22.380 successful
01:03:22.920 I've
01:03:23.200 seen
01:03:23.360 this
01:03:23.520 happen
01:03:23.760 with
01:03:23.960 women
01:03:24.180 all
01:03:24.340 the
01:03:24.480 time
01:03:24.720 so
01:03:25.100 I
01:03:25.200 worked
01:03:25.440 with
01:03:25.600 women
01:03:25.860 in
01:03:26.300 law
01:03:28.000 firms
01:03:28.400 really
01:03:29.220 unbelievably
01:03:30.180 accomplished
01:03:30.740 women
01:03:31.060 because
01:03:31.520 the
01:03:31.700 firms
01:03:32.160 would
01:03:32.380 send
01:03:32.820 us
01:03:33.280 their
01:03:33.800 best
01:03:34.260 performers
01:03:34.900 and
01:03:35.440 our
01:03:35.640 job
01:03:35.960 was
01:03:36.140 to
01:03:36.280 see
01:03:36.440 if
01:03:36.560 we
01:03:36.700 could
01:03:36.900 make
01:03:37.380 them
01:03:37.540 a
01:03:37.640 little
01:03:37.780 bit
01:03:37.940 more
01:03:38.140 productive
01:03:38.560 because
01:03:39.020 if
01:03:39.620 they
01:03:39.760 were
01:03:39.900 high
01:03:40.160 performers
01:03:40.640 and
01:03:40.860 they
01:03:41.020 were
01:03:41.160 even
01:03:41.360 5%
01:03:42.060 more
01:03:42.260 productive
01:03:42.660 it
01:03:42.800 was
01:03:42.920 unbelievably
01:03:43.620 valuable
01:03:44.440 for the
01:03:44.840 company
01:03:45.160 and
01:03:46.220 so
01:03:46.360 all
01:03:46.620 the
01:03:46.780 law
01:03:47.020 firms
01:03:47.760 they
01:03:47.940 just
01:03:48.140 lose
01:03:48.380 all
01:03:48.760 their
01:03:48.980 women
01:03:49.280 in
01:03:49.740 their
01:03:49.880 30s
01:03:51.020 and
01:03:51.480 it
01:03:51.580 happens
01:03:51.900 everywhere
01:03:52.300 and
01:03:52.840 the
01:03:52.960 reason
01:03:53.240 it
01:03:53.420 happens
01:03:53.760 is
01:03:53.940 very
01:03:54.160 straightforward
01:03:54.660 and
01:03:54.880 all
01:03:55.100 the
01:03:55.280 female
01:03:55.600 lawyers
01:03:55.960 know
01:03:56.220 this
01:03:56.500 they
01:03:56.860 won't
01:03:57.080 talk
01:03:57.640 about
01:03:57.880 it
01:03:58.020 publicly
01:03:58.440 but
01:03:58.880 they
01:03:59.000 all
01:03:59.180 know
01:03:59.420 it
01:03:59.600 they
01:04:01.900 did
01:04:02.060 very
01:04:02.260 well
01:04:02.460 in
01:04:02.560 high
01:04:02.740 school
01:04:03.040 then
01:04:04.020 they
01:04:04.140 did
01:04:04.300 very
01:04:04.480 well
01:04:04.680 in
01:04:04.780 university
01:04:05.280 then
01:04:05.980 they
01:04:06.120 did
01:04:06.260 very
01:04:06.480 well
01:04:06.680 in
01:04:06.820 law
01:04:07.040 school
01:04:07.300 then
01:04:07.700 they
01:04:07.820 went
01:04:07.960 and
01:04:08.060 article
01:04:08.300 and
01:04:08.520 they
01:04:08.640 did
01:04:08.800 extremely
01:04:09.320 well
01:04:09.700 as
01:04:09.960 articles
01:04:10.480 as
01:04:11.320 articling
01:04:11.680 students
01:04:12.060 then
01:04:12.660 they
01:04:12.800 got
01:04:13.000 hired
01:04:13.440 as
01:04:13.600 associates
01:04:14.080 and
01:04:14.260 did
01:04:14.400 very
01:04:14.620 well
01:04:14.880 and
01:04:15.160 then
01:04:15.280 they
01:04:15.380 made
01:04:15.580 partner
01:04:16.000 and
01:04:16.440 it
01:04:16.520 was
01:04:16.600 just
01:04:16.760 like
01:04:16.920 linear
01:04:17.280 progression
01:04:17.840 and
01:04:18.700 there
01:04:18.900 wasn't
01:04:19.080 a lot
01:04:19.260 of
01:04:19.380 questioning
01:04:19.860 that
01:04:20.080 went
01:04:20.260 along
01:04:20.500 with
01:04:20.660 it
01:04:20.760 because
01:04:21.000 most
01:04:21.360 of
01:04:21.520 the
01:04:21.640 people
01:04:21.900 who
01:04:22.040 do
01:04:22.180 that
01:04:22.380 are
01:04:32.740 success
01:04:33.140 in
01:04:33.700 law
01:04:34.020 after
01:04:34.720 intelligence
01:04:35.380 and
01:04:35.820 so
01:04:35.980 you
01:04:36.120 have
01:04:36.260 to
01:04:36.360 be
01:04:36.440 a
01:04:36.560 conscientious
01:04:37.060 person
01:04:37.420 detail
01:04:37.840 oriented
01:04:38.280 and
01:04:38.520 so
01:04:38.700 if
01:04:39.060 you
01:04:39.180 happen
01:04:39.400 to
01:04:39.500 be
01:04:39.600 a
01:04:39.720 woman
01:04:39.920 like
01:04:40.180 that
01:04:40.440 extraordinarily
01:04:41.140 hardworking
01:04:41.920 very
01:04:42.240 very
01:04:42.500 bright
01:04:42.820 you
01:04:43.260 just
01:04:43.460 make
01:04:43.660 a
01:04:43.780 beeline
01:04:44.320 to
01:04:44.500 partnership
01:04:45.060 but
01:04:45.940 then
01:04:46.080 you're
01:04:46.220 30
01:04:46.600 and
01:04:48.680 that's
01:04:48.880 a
01:04:48.960 problem
01:04:49.360 and
01:04:50.660 it's
01:04:50.880 a
01:04:50.980 problem
01:04:51.180 for
01:04:51.340 a
01:04:51.440 bunch
01:04:51.600 of
01:04:51.720 reasons
01:04:52.040 the
01:04:52.220 first
01:04:52.480 is
01:04:52.760 you
01:04:54.880 hit
01:04:55.140 the
01:04:55.360 target
01:04:55.680 and
01:04:55.960 now
01:04:56.140 you're
01:04:56.360 surrounded
01:04:56.680 by
01:04:57.000 these
01:04:57.360 guys
01:04:57.720 and
01:04:58.180 women
01:04:58.460 who
01:04:59.260 are
01:04:59.800 partners
01:05:00.600 and
01:05:00.840 you
01:05:00.980 thought
01:05:01.220 that
01:05:01.400 was
01:05:01.520 a
01:05:01.620 hell
01:05:01.740 of
01:05:01.840 a
01:05:01.940 fine
01:05:02.160 place
01:05:02.480 to
01:05:02.640 be
01:05:02.840 but
01:05:03.220 when
01:05:03.340 you
01:05:03.460 get
01:05:03.620 there
01:05:03.820 you
01:05:03.960 find
01:05:04.240 out
01:05:04.440 that
01:05:04.680 it's
01:05:05.700 rough
01:05:06.120 it's
01:05:07.080 aggressive
01:05:07.540 it's
01:05:07.860 competitive
01:05:08.340 it can
01:05:08.920 be
01:05:09.060 nasty
01:05:09.500 and
01:05:10.340 most
01:05:11.020 of
01:05:11.200 the
01:05:11.320 people
01:05:11.520 who
01:05:11.640 are
01:05:11.740 doing
01:05:11.960 it
01:05:12.120 are
01:05:12.440 not
01:05:12.780 happy
01:05:13.260 it's
01:05:13.740 hard
01:05:14.040 work
01:05:14.340 I've
01:05:14.600 met
01:05:14.780 lawyers
01:05:15.180 who
01:05:15.360 like
01:05:15.600 what
01:05:15.760 they're
01:05:15.880 doing
01:05:16.060 but
01:05:16.240 they're
01:05:16.500 rare
01:05:16.820 it's
01:05:17.440 very
01:05:17.780 competitive
01:05:18.240 and
01:05:18.600 it's
01:05:18.780 very
01:05:19.140 harsh
01:05:19.520 and
01:05:20.320 you're
01:05:20.980 going
01:05:21.100 to
01:05:21.200 work
01:05:21.460 man
01:05:21.820 if
01:05:22.340 you're
01:05:22.520 paying
01:05:22.740 $750
01:05:24.160 an
01:05:24.800 hour
01:05:25.060 you're
01:05:26.140 working
01:05:26.420 whenever
01:05:27.600 there's
01:05:27.900 work
01:05:28.120 to
01:05:28.280 do
01:05:28.440 no
01:05:28.740 matter
01:05:28.920 what
01:05:29.200 else
01:05:29.420 you
01:05:29.540 have
01:05:29.760 to
01:05:29.900 do
01:05:30.120 and
01:05:30.800 you
01:05:30.920 know
01:05:31.000 you
01:05:31.140 might
01:05:31.340 be
01:05:32.180 making
01:05:32.540 $350,000
01:05:34.600 $400,000
01:05:35.380 a year
01:05:35.960 and that's
01:05:36.440 good
01:05:36.600 but
01:05:36.880 you're
01:05:37.020 probably
01:05:37.260 married
01:05:37.580 to
01:05:37.780 someone
01:05:38.020 who's
01:05:38.240 making
01:05:38.540 approximately
01:05:39.100 the same
01:05:39.580 amount
01:05:39.840 of
01:05:39.960 money
01:05:40.180 so
01:05:40.640 you
01:05:40.780 actually
01:05:41.060 don't
01:05:41.300 need
01:05:41.540 that
01:05:41.760 much
01:05:42.000 money
01:05:42.300 and
01:05:42.640 you
01:05:42.760 certainly
01:05:43.020 don't
01:05:43.280 need
01:05:43.480 more
01:05:43.820 you
01:05:44.260 might
01:05:44.420 want
01:05:44.680 it
01:05:50.980 the
01:05:51.100 right
01:05:51.280 mind
01:05:51.500 do
01:05:51.700 this
01:05:52.080 which
01:05:53.800 is
01:05:53.940 the
01:05:54.100 right
01:05:54.300 question
01:05:54.740 by
01:05:54.940 the
01:05:55.060 way
01:05:55.180 to
01:05:55.300 ask
01:05:55.600 about
01:05:55.800 the
01:05:55.960 people
01:05:56.160 who
01:05:56.320 sit
01:05:56.560 in
01:05:57.220 the
01:05:57.360 C-suites
01:05:58.020 in
01:05:58.640 major
01:05:58.880 corporations
01:05:59.460 it's
01:06:00.440 like
01:06:00.660 they're
01:06:01.660 working
01:06:01.900 70-80
01:06:02.560 hours a
01:06:03.140 week
01:06:03.360 for
01:06:03.580 30
01:06:04.000 or
01:06:04.120 40
01:06:04.340 years
01:06:04.720 you
01:06:05.140 know
01:06:05.260 that
01:06:05.440 often
01:06:05.920 they
01:06:06.140 sacrifice
01:06:06.640 their
01:06:06.820 families
01:06:07.180 for
01:06:07.400 it
01:06:07.500 and
01:06:07.580 everything
01:06:07.840 else
01:06:08.260 and
01:06:08.680 they're
01:06:08.940 a
01:06:09.240 particular
01:06:09.560 kind
01:06:09.880 of
01:06:10.000 person
01:06:10.280 who
01:06:10.420 does
01:06:10.640 that
01:06:10.880 usually
01:06:11.200 hyper
01:06:11.520 conscientious
01:06:12.280 but
01:06:12.760 like
01:06:13.000 the
01:06:13.420 question
01:06:13.880 why
01:06:14.400 you
01:06:14.600 would
01:06:14.760 do
01:06:14.960 that
01:06:15.240 is
01:06:15.520 a
01:06:15.660 really
01:06:15.840 good
01:06:16.060 question
01:06:16.560 how
01:06:17.400 about
01:06:17.680 you
01:06:17.860 have
01:06:18.080 a
01:06:18.200 life
01:06:18.600 how
01:06:19.780 about
01:06:20.040 you
01:06:20.280 have
01:06:20.880 a
01:06:21.020 partner
01:06:21.380 that
01:06:21.880 you
01:06:22.020 see
01:06:22.300 sometime
01:06:22.800 how
01:06:23.140 about
01:06:23.300 you
01:06:23.420 have
01:06:23.580 some
01:06:23.780 children
01:06:24.200 that
01:06:24.620 you
01:06:24.780 actually
01:06:25.300 get
01:06:25.600 to
01:06:25.800 see
01:06:26.160 and
01:06:26.400 take
01:06:26.640 care
01:06:26.900 of
01:06:27.160 and
01:06:27.900 so
01:06:28.040 then
01:06:28.200 you
01:06:28.320 think
01:06:28.520 well
01:06:28.680 maybe
01:06:28.900 I
01:06:29.060 don't
01:06:29.220 need
01:06:29.380 to
01:06:29.500 work
01:06:29.700 80
01:06:29.920 hours
01:06:30.200 a
01:06:30.340 week
01:06:30.520 to
01:06:30.720 continue
01:06:31.060 my
01:06:31.360 rise
01:06:31.720 through
01:06:31.940 the
01:06:32.220 upper
01:06:33.020 stratosphere
01:06:33.620 of the
01:06:34.420 law
01:06:34.560 profession
01:06:35.060 I'll
01:06:35.680 pull
01:06:36.300 back
01:06:36.700 I'll
01:06:37.040 find
01:06:37.280 an
01:06:37.420 8
01:06:37.560 hour
01:06:37.760 a
01:06:37.920 day
01:06:38.080 job
01:06:38.480 or
01:06:38.860 a
01:06:39.280 part
01:06:39.500 time
01:06:39.740 job
01:06:40.100 and
01:06:40.700 I'll
01:06:40.800 have
01:06:40.920 a
01:06:41.040 family
01:06:41.400 well
01:06:42.420 that's
01:06:42.680 what's
01:06:42.860 happening
01:06:43.160 in
01:06:43.320 Scandinavia
01:06:44.060 is
01:06:44.600 like
01:06:44.780 is
01:06:44.940 that
01:06:45.080 okay
01:06:45.480 or
01:06:46.740 not
01:06:47.080 and
01:06:48.040 if
01:06:48.120 it's
01:06:48.260 not
01:06:48.440 okay
01:06:48.700 what
01:06:48.880 are
01:06:48.960 we
01:06:49.040 going
01:06:49.160 to
01:06:49.220 do
01:06:49.360 we're
01:06:49.520 going
01:06:49.640 to
01:06:49.680 enforce
01:06:50.060 gender
01:06:50.920 equality
01:06:51.380 there
01:06:51.600 too
01:06:51.860 are
01:06:52.040 we
01:06:52.220 you
01:06:53.320 know
01:06:53.420 they've
01:06:53.740 enforced
01:06:54.080 gender
01:06:54.380 equality
01:06:54.900 at
01:06:55.520 the
01:06:55.960 board
01:06:56.720 level
01:06:57.480 in
01:06:58.120 the
01:06:58.260 Scandinavian
01:06:58.860 countries
01:06:59.300 it
01:06:59.960 hasn't
01:07:00.140 made
01:07:00.260 a
01:07:00.380 goddamn
01:07:00.860 bit
01:07:01.080 of
01:07:07.280 problem
01:07:07.720 it
01:07:08.780 wasn't
01:07:09.100 systemic
01:07:09.920 oppression
01:07:10.620 there's
01:07:11.860 a
01:07:12.000 multitude
01:07:12.340 of
01:07:12.640 reasons
01:07:12.940 that
01:07:13.180 men
01:07:13.360 and
01:07:13.500 women
01:07:13.720 take
01:07:14.400 different
01:07:14.860 pathways
01:07:15.940 in
01:07:16.520 their
01:07:16.660 careers
01:07:17.020 and
01:07:17.240 they're
01:07:17.380 becoming
01:07:17.680 more
01:07:17.960 evident
01:07:18.240 another
01:07:18.580 one
01:07:18.860 is
01:07:19.040 that
01:07:19.260 women
01:07:20.240 so
01:07:21.260 women
01:07:21.840 are
01:07:22.480 different
01:07:22.900 higher
01:07:23.780 in
01:07:24.000 negative
01:07:24.300 emotion
01:07:24.680 higher
01:07:25.020 in
01:07:25.140 agreeableness
01:07:25.660 about
01:07:25.960 the
01:07:26.120 same
01:07:26.280 in
01:07:26.440 conscientiousness
01:07:27.340 openness
01:07:28.500 and
01:07:29.040 extroversion
01:07:29.660 there's
01:07:30.140 some
01:07:30.300 differences
01:07:30.680 but
01:07:30.920 they're
01:07:31.100 relatively
01:07:31.460 minor
01:07:31.820 pretty
01:07:32.260 much
01:07:32.460 the
01:07:32.640 same
01:07:32.820 in
01:07:32.980 terms
01:07:33.400 of
01:07:33.520 intelligence
01:07:34.040 doesn't
01:07:34.560 look
01:07:34.720 like
01:07:34.900 it's
01:07:35.060 an
01:07:35.160 ability
01:07:35.520 issue
01:07:35.860 for
01:07:36.100 most
01:07:36.960 professions
01:07:37.940 with
01:07:38.480 the
01:07:38.640 exception
01:07:39.020 of
01:07:39.260 the
01:07:39.500 extended
01:07:40.280 male
01:07:40.600 variability
01:07:41.160 hypothesis
01:07:41.840 that
01:07:42.360 might
01:07:42.540 have
01:07:42.740 to
01:07:42.860 do
01:07:42.960 with
01:07:43.120 upper
01:07:43.500 level
01:07:43.800 mathematical
01:07:44.340 genius
01:07:44.800 but
01:07:45.020 we
01:07:45.160 can
01:07:45.280 leave
01:07:45.440 that
01:07:45.600 aside
01:07:45.940 because
01:07:46.360 it's
01:07:46.560 debatable
01:07:46.960 there
01:07:48.300 is
01:07:48.480 another
01:07:48.980 difference
01:07:49.440 between
01:07:49.740 men
01:07:49.940 and
01:07:50.060 women
01:07:50.240 and
01:07:50.420 this
01:07:50.560 is
01:07:50.660 the
01:07:50.780 biggest
01:07:51.020 difference
01:07:51.420 that
01:07:51.660 psychologists
01:07:52.140 have
01:07:52.380 discovered
01:07:53.040 and
01:07:53.520 that's
01:07:53.820 of
01:07:54.000 interest
01:07:54.620 men
01:07:55.900 are
01:07:56.100 more
01:07:56.420 interested
01:07:56.880 in
01:07:57.100 things
01:07:57.820 on
01:07:58.320 average
01:07:58.800 and
01:07:59.720 women
01:07:59.980 are
01:08:00.140 more
01:08:00.320 interested
01:08:00.640 in
01:08:00.920 people
01:08:01.420 on
01:08:02.120 average
01:08:02.680 and
01:08:05.160 standard
01:08:05.380 deviation
01:08:05.920 which
01:08:06.240 means
01:08:06.560 that
01:08:06.920 it's
01:08:07.480 a little
01:08:07.640 more
01:08:07.840 than
01:08:07.960 that
01:08:08.160 which
01:08:08.540 means
01:08:08.820 that
01:08:09.060 if
01:08:10.040 you
01:08:10.160 were
01:08:10.320 a
01:08:10.460 man
01:08:10.820 as
01:08:12.100 interested
01:08:12.680 in
01:08:13.180 people
01:08:14.040 as
01:08:14.560 the
01:08:14.740 typical
01:08:15.100 woman
01:08:15.540 is
01:08:16.020 interested
01:08:16.500 in
01:08:16.740 people
01:08:17.100 you
01:08:17.620 would
01:08:17.780 have
01:08:18.880 to be
01:08:19.160 more
01:08:19.440 interested
01:08:19.840 in
01:08:20.080 people
01:08:20.360 than
01:08:20.600 85%
01:08:21.660 of
01:08:21.980 men
01:08:22.340 and
01:08:23.120 if
01:08:23.280 you
01:08:23.420 were
01:08:23.540 a
01:08:23.700 woman
01:08:24.000 who
01:08:24.540 is
01:08:24.700 interested
01:08:25.440 in
01:08:25.880 things
01:08:26.540 as
01:08:26.900 the
01:08:27.140 average
01:08:27.680 man
01:08:28.100 is
01:08:28.440 interested
01:08:28.960 in
01:08:29.200 things
01:08:29.520 you
01:08:29.680 would
01:08:29.760 have
01:08:29.920 to
01:08:30.040 be
01:08:30.180 more
01:08:30.420 interested
01:08:30.760 in
01:08:30.980 things
01:08:31.260 than
01:08:31.460 85%
01:08:32.460 of
01:08:32.760 women
01:08:33.040 so
01:08:33.620 it's
01:08:33.740 actually
01:08:33.980 quite
01:08:34.220 a
01:08:34.340 big
01:08:34.480 difference
01:08:34.960 and
01:08:35.400 so
01:08:35.620 thing
01:08:36.200 interest
01:08:36.920 is
01:08:37.360 a
01:08:37.500 big
01:08:37.660 determination
01:08:38.160 of
01:08:38.880 interest
01:08:39.640 in
01:08:39.840 the
01:08:39.980 STEM
01:08:40.200 fields
01:08:40.620 and
01:08:41.000 women
01:08:41.220 just
01:08:41.500 aren't
01:08:41.860 that
01:08:42.240 interested
01:08:42.840 in
01:08:43.260 things
01:08:43.820 now
01:08:44.080 some
01:08:44.380 of
01:08:44.520 them
01:08:44.640 are
01:08:44.860 and
01:08:45.000 they
01:08:45.220 go
01:08:45.380 into
01:08:45.540 the
01:08:45.720 STEM
01:08:45.960 fields
01:08:46.260 but
01:08:46.440 most
01:08:46.700 of
01:08:46.860 them
01:08:46.980 aren't
01:08:47.320 so
01:08:47.840 what
01:08:48.440 are
01:08:48.520 you
01:08:48.560 going
01:08:48.660 to
01:08:48.700 do
01:08:48.820 about
01:08:49.060 that
01:08:49.500 so
01:08:50.920 you
01:08:51.180 know
01:08:51.260 one
01:08:51.460 of
01:08:51.560 the
01:08:51.660 things
01:08:51.880 they're
01:08:52.080 trying
01:08:52.300 to
01:08:52.420 do
01:08:52.580 in
01:08:52.740 the
01:08:52.860 Scandinavian
01:08:54.640 countries
01:08:55.060 is
01:08:55.240 they're
01:08:55.720 going
01:08:55.860 to
01:08:55.980 really
01:08:56.320 start
01:08:56.820 to
01:08:57.060 socialize
01:08:57.920 boys
01:08:58.300 and
01:08:58.540 girls
01:08:58.840 different
01:08:59.400 in
01:09:00.000 preschool
01:09:00.680 okay
01:09:01.940 so
01:09:02.100 that's
01:09:02.380 good
01:09:02.540 so
01:09:02.700 that's
01:09:02.920 what
01:09:03.040 you're
01:09:03.200 going
01:09:03.300 to
01:09:03.380 allow
01:09:03.720 is
01:09:03.920 it
01:09:04.040 this
01:09:04.220 is
01:09:04.540 the
01:09:04.680 idea
01:09:05.020 you're
01:09:05.560 going
01:09:05.660 to
01:09:05.800 discount
01:09:06.440 the
01:09:06.800 notion
01:09:07.220 entirely
01:09:08.200 that
01:09:09.120 there
01:09:09.280 might
01:09:09.540 actually
01:09:10.100 be
01:09:10.360 differences
01:09:10.800 between
01:09:11.240 men
01:09:11.500 and
01:09:11.660 women
01:09:11.900 even
01:09:12.520 though
01:09:12.700 that
01:09:12.880 wouldn't
01:09:13.160 necessarily
01:09:13.660 be
01:09:13.900 a
01:09:14.020 bad
01:09:14.200 thing
01:09:14.420 but
01:09:14.560 we're
01:09:14.700 going
01:09:14.800 to
01:09:14.940 discount
01:09:15.500 that
01:09:15.940 and
01:09:16.540 we're
01:09:16.700 going
01:09:16.800 to
01:09:16.880 assume
01:09:17.100 that
01:09:17.300 all
01:09:17.820 the
01:09:25.060 the
01:09:25.300 state
01:09:25.900 so
01:09:26.600 that
01:09:26.740 they're
01:09:26.900 going
01:09:27.060 to
01:09:27.240 transform
01:09:27.840 the
01:09:28.220 way
01:09:28.440 that
01:09:28.660 our
01:09:28.880 children
01:09:29.220 are
01:09:29.700 treated
01:09:30.740 when
01:09:31.280 they're
01:09:31.480 three
01:09:31.920 and
01:09:32.180 four
01:09:32.520 by
01:09:33.240 teachers
01:09:34.000 by
01:09:34.540 preschool
01:09:35.020 teachers
01:09:35.580 and
01:09:36.120 we're
01:09:36.300 going
01:09:36.380 to
01:09:36.480 try
01:09:36.620 to
01:09:36.780 rejig
01:09:37.300 the
01:09:37.520 entire
01:09:37.940 culture
01:09:38.480 predicated
01:09:39.080 on
01:09:39.320 that
01:09:39.540 theory
01:09:39.900 that's
01:09:41.380 the
01:09:41.600 solution
01:09:42.140 well
01:09:43.640 if
01:09:43.800 you
01:09:43.900 don't
01:09:44.100 think
01:09:44.340 that
01:09:44.500 that's
01:09:44.800 a
01:09:44.920 totalitarian
01:09:45.560 solution
01:09:46.080 then
01:09:46.740 you
01:09:47.180 are
01:09:47.360 not
01:09:47.760 thinking
01:09:48.320 and
01:10:00.580 this is
01:10:01.180 the
01:10:01.320 last
01:10:01.620 one
01:10:01.900 I'll
01:10:02.400 answer
01:10:02.900 a little
01:10:03.520 ornery
01:10:04.000 about
01:10:04.220 these
01:10:04.460 questions
01:10:04.880 tonight
01:10:05.260 apparently
01:10:06.000 what
01:10:06.380 do
01:10:06.480 you
01:10:06.580 think
01:10:06.780 of
01:10:06.900 our
01:10:07.040 state
01:10:07.320 governments
01:10:07.740 teaching
01:10:08.140 gender
01:10:08.560 fluidity
01:10:09.120 concepts
01:10:09.600 to
01:10:09.780 primary
01:10:10.140 school
01:10:10.500 children
01:10:10.860 this
01:10:11.220 is
01:10:11.360 what
01:10:11.540 I
01:10:11.700 think
01:10:11.980 I
01:10:12.400 think
01:10:12.660 if
01:10:12.900 your
01:10:13.300 damn
01:10:13.680 primary
01:10:14.500 school
01:10:16.120 teachers
01:10:16.700 knew
01:10:17.020 how to
01:10:17.420 teach
01:10:17.740 kids
01:10:18.080 to
01:10:18.320 read
01:10:18.800 they
01:10:19.240 wouldn't
01:10:19.480 have
01:10:19.640 to
01:10:19.800 bother
01:10:20.080 teaching
01:10:20.580 gender
01:10:21.080 fluidity
01:10:21.780 thank you
01:10:40.640 everyone
01:10:41.040 it was a
01:10:42.700 pleasure
01:10:42.940 talking to
01:10:43.500 all of
01:10:43.740 you
01:10:43.920 if you
01:10:46.160 found this
01:10:46.520 conversation
01:10:47.060 meaningful
01:10:47.620 you
01:10:48.020 might
01:10:48.200 think
01:10:48.420 about
01:10:48.620 picking
01:10:48.860 up
01:10:49.060 dad's
01:10:49.340 books
01:10:49.640 maps
01:10:50.020 of
01:10:50.180 meaning
01:10:50.400 the
01:10:50.600 architecture
01:10:51.100 of
01:10:51.340 belief
01:10:51.680 or his
01:10:52.480 newer
01:10:52.660 bestseller
01:10:53.280 12 rules
01:10:53.980 for life
01:10:54.440 an antidote
01:10:55.000 to chaos
01:10:55.660 both of
01:10:56.640 these works
01:10:57.100 delve much
01:10:57.620 deeper into
01:10:58.140 the topics
01:10:58.600 covered in
01:10:59.100 the jordan b
01:10:59.640 peterson podcast
01:11:00.460 see jordanbpeterson.com
01:11:03.000 for audio
01:11:03.600 ebook and text
01:11:04.500 links or pick up
01:11:05.680 the books at your
01:11:06.200 favorite bookseller
01:11:06.980 remember to check out
01:11:08.800 jordanbpeterson.com
01:11:10.080 slash personality
01:11:11.080 for information on his
01:11:12.760 new course
01:11:13.440 tag jordan or i on
01:11:15.120 instagram to share
01:11:16.060 your results from the
01:11:16.980 discovering personality
01:11:17.940 course
01:11:18.380 i really hope you
01:11:19.960 enjoyed this podcast
01:11:20.980 talk to you next week
01:11:22.520 follow me on my youtube
01:11:24.240 channel jordanbpeterson
01:11:26.100 on twitter at jordanbpeterson
01:11:28.660 on facebook at dr jordanbpeterson
01:11:31.980 and at instagram at jordan.b.peterson
01:11:35.340 details on this show
01:11:37.220 access to my blog
01:11:38.880 information about my tour
01:11:40.620 dates and other events
01:11:41.800 and my list of recommended
01:11:43.240 books can be found on my
01:11:44.980 website jordanbpeterson.com
01:11:47.680 my online writing programs
01:11:49.720 designed to help people
01:11:51.000 straighten out their
01:11:51.820 pasts understand
01:11:53.160 themselves in the
01:11:54.100 present and develop a
01:11:55.400 sophisticated vision and
01:11:56.680 strategy for the future
01:11:57.860 can be found at
01:11:58.880 self-authoring.com
01:12:00.620 that's self-authoring.com
01:12:03.140 from the westwood one
01:12:05.640 podcast network
01:12:06.960 when a woman experiences an
01:12:16.160 unplanned pregnancy she often
01:12:17.800 feels alone and afraid
01:12:19.160 too often her first response
01:12:21.180 is to seek out an abortion
01:12:22.360 because that's what left
01:12:23.900 leaning institutions have
01:12:25.080 conditioned her to do
01:12:26.180 but because of the
01:12:27.480 generosity of listeners like
01:12:28.820 you that search may lead her
01:12:30.480 to a pre-born network clinic
01:12:31.940 where by the grace of god
01:12:33.420 she'll choose life
01:12:34.480 not just for her baby
01:12:35.700 but for herself
01:12:36.940 pre-born offers god's love
01:12:38.840 and compassion to hurting
01:12:39.900 women and provides a free
01:12:41.160 ultrasound to introduce them
01:12:42.560 to the life growing inside
01:12:43.900 them
01:12:44.180 this combination helps women
01:12:45.960 to choose life
01:12:46.920 and it's how pre-born saves
01:12:48.500 200 babies every single day
01:12:50.420 thanks to the daily wire's
01:12:52.080 partnership with pre-born
01:12:53.160 we're able to make our
01:12:54.180 powerful documentary
01:12:55.260 choosing life
01:12:56.380 available to all on daily
01:12:58.020 join us in thanking pre-born
01:13:00.740 for bringing this important
01:13:01.940 work out from behind our
01:13:03.160 paywall and consider making
01:13:04.760 a donation today to support
01:13:06.080 their life-saving work
01:13:07.300 you can sponsor one ultrasound
01:13:09.120 for just $28
01:13:10.060 if you have the means you can
01:13:11.960 sponsor pre-born's entire
01:13:13.260 network for a day for $5,000
01:13:15.120 make a donation today just dial
01:13:17.660 pound 250 and say the keyword
01:13:19.280 baby that's pound 250 baby or go
01:13:22.580 to pre-born.com slash jordan
01:13:24.480 that's pre-born.com slash jordan