The Jordan B. Peterson Podcast - December 07, 2016


Reality and the Sacred


Episode Stats

Length

1 hour and 3 minutes

Words per Minute

170.42886

Word Count

10,784

Sentence Count

186

Misogynist Sentences

2

Hate Speech Sentences

11


Summary

In this episode, Dr. Jordan B. Peterson explains why he believes there is a new way of looking at reality, and why it's important to know what the sacred is. He uses a story from the Old Testament to make the point that there are certain things in the world that are considered sacred, and that are therefore untouchable. Dr. Peterson concludes with a call to action for modern people who don't understand the concept of the sacred, or don't know what it is, and who don t understand what it means to be a Christian in a secular world. Episode 1: Reality and the Sacred: A Lecture on the Sacred and the Modern World by Jordan Peterson on Christian worldviews and how they affect our understanding of the world, and how we should view reality, as well as why it is necessary for us to know that the sacred exists and that they are not to be touched by people who do not believe in them. Join us on Daily Wire Plus now and start watching his new series, "Depression and Anxiety: A Guide to Recovery from Depression and Depression" on Dailywire Plus, wherever you get your news and information. Go to Dailywireplus.ca/Dailywireplus to join in on the conversation and get immediate access to the latest episodes of his new podcast, "Psychology in theModern World: A Podcast by Dr. B.P. Today's Episode 1, "Reality and The Sacred." Subscribe to Daily Wireplus to receive notifications when new episodes are available. Subscribe on DailyWire Plus Subscribe on PODCAST, and receive notifications about new episodes of the Daily Wire PLUS Podcasts, and get access to all new episodes throughout the day, including "Daily Wire Plus. and all the social meditations and social media platforms! Subscribe and subscribe to stay up to date with the latest posts, and more information about what's going on in the future of the show. Stay tuned for real-to-beepers, your comments, tips on what's happening everywhere else on the world of Mental Health and Mental Health, including the newest episodes, and so much more! Subscribe, and more! Subscribe to stay connected with the dailywireplus! Learn more about your ad-free version of the podcast, your ad choices, your most authentic source of inspiration and tips, tips, reviews, and tips on how to get the most influential podcast? Stay connected with me on social media?


Transcript

00:00:00.940 Hey everyone, real quick before you skip, I want to talk to you about something serious and important.
00:00:06.480 Dr. Jordan Peterson has created a new series that could be a lifeline for those battling depression and anxiety.
00:00:12.740 We know how isolating and overwhelming these conditions can be, and we wanted to take a moment to reach out to those listening who may be struggling.
00:00:20.100 With decades of experience helping patients, Dr. Peterson offers a unique understanding of why you might be feeling this way in his new series.
00:00:27.420 He provides a roadmap towards healing, showing that while the journey isn't easy, it's absolutely possible to find your way forward.
00:00:35.360 If you're suffering, please know you are not alone. There's hope, and there's a path to feeling better.
00:00:41.800 Go to Daily Wire Plus now and start watching Dr. Jordan B. Peterson on depression and anxiety.
00:00:47.460 Let this be the first step towards the brighter future you deserve.
00:00:57.420 Psychology in the Modern World
00:01:04.440 A podcast by Dr. Jordan B. Peterson
00:01:07.640 Episode 1
00:01:10.380 Reality and the Sacred
00:01:12.020 A lecture recorded by TV Ontario
00:01:15.060 Dr. Peterson's self-development programs are available at selfauthoring.com
00:01:22.340 That's S-E-L-F-Authoring.com
00:01:26.360 You can also support this podcast on Patreon if you search Jordan Peterson Patreon.
00:01:35.720 I want to talk to you today about what I think is a relatively new way of looking at your experience,
00:01:44.680 but maybe even more broadly than that, a new way of looking at reality itself.
00:01:48.740 You all come to university, I suppose, to make your conceptions of reality more sophisticated.
00:01:58.580 And you want to do that because you have to live in the world.
00:02:01.720 And the more sophisticated your conceptions, the less likely you'll encounter tragic or harmful circumstances
00:02:10.400 that you will be unable to deal with.
00:02:13.120 It really matters if you know what you're thinking and you know how to think.
00:02:18.740 Over the last 20 years, I would say, there's been a revolution in psychology.
00:02:26.340 And the revolution has involved a transformation in the way that we look at the world.
00:02:30.800 And that's what I want to talk to you about today.
00:02:33.420 I entitled this talk Reality and the Sacred.
00:02:35.640 It's a strange title for a talk to modern people because we don't really understand what the sacred means
00:02:41.540 unless we live within a worldview that's essentially, I wouldn't say archaic, but at least traditional.
00:02:48.620 For modern, free-thinking, fundamentally liberal people, the idea of the sacred is anachronistic,
00:02:55.960 or if not anachronistic, at least incomprehensible.
00:02:59.160 So I want to start with a story from the Old Testament.
00:03:01.520 There's a scene in the Old Testament when the ancient Hebrews are moving the Ark of the Covenant,
00:03:06.780 and the Ark of the Covenant is a device that was manufactured in order to contain the Word of God.
00:03:14.120 And there was a rule among the ancient Hebrews which was,
00:03:16.840 you were not to touch the Ark of the Covenant no matter what.
00:03:20.220 And there's a story in the Old Testament where the bearers of the Ark of the Covenant,
00:03:25.960 they used to carry it, the bearers of the Ark of the Covenant, trip.
00:03:30.640 And a man reaches out to steady it, and when he touches it, God strikes him dead.
00:03:37.140 And modern people look at a story like that, and the first thing they think is,
00:03:41.420 that seems a little bit harsh on the part of God,
00:03:44.420 given that the man was attempting to do something that he believed was good.
00:03:49.000 But what the story is designed to indicate, in my opinion, is that
00:03:52.740 there are certain things that you touch at your peril, regardless of your intentions.
00:03:59.720 And those things that you touch at your peril, regardless of your intentions,
00:04:04.160 most cultures regard as sacred, as untouchable.
00:04:08.140 I want to make a case for you today that those things exist, and also why they exist,
00:04:12.720 and why it's necessary for you to know that they exist.
00:04:15.760 I would also say that if you're properly educated in the university,
00:04:20.000 especially with regards to the humanities, which are in some conceptual trouble at the moment,
00:04:25.220 what you are, what essentially happens to you,
00:04:27.560 is that you're introduced in a relatively secular way,
00:04:30.340 to the concept of the sacred.
00:04:32.000 You're here in the university, to learn about the eternal values of humankind.
00:04:37.620 And I think that people who tell you that those values do not exist,
00:04:41.880 or that they're endlessly debatable,
00:04:43.600 do you an unbelievable disservice.
00:04:46.420 Now, I'm going to tell you, first, how you think about the world.
00:04:50.740 I think.
00:04:52.060 So, this would be a Newtonian view of the world.
00:04:54.880 It's Newtonian and deterministic.
00:04:57.080 And it's a worldview that dominated psychology, and economics, and anthropology, and political science,
00:05:02.820 you name it, for probably 400 years.
00:05:07.120 But it's come to a crashing halt in the last 50 years.
00:05:10.000 And the consequences of that have been manifested in a number of domains.
00:05:16.240 The old world presuppositions are something like this.
00:05:20.660 The world is made out of objects.
00:05:23.400 When you look at the world, you see the objects.
00:05:25.980 There they are in front of you.
00:05:27.620 As a consequence of seeing the objects,
00:05:30.480 you think about what to do.
00:05:32.020 And after you think about what to do in presence of the objects, you act.
00:05:37.720 Now, that seems self-evident.
00:05:39.660 Because when you look at the world, there the objects are.
00:05:43.320 And it appears to you that you see them,
00:05:46.340 and then you think about them, and then you act.
00:05:49.820 But there's a real problem with that.
00:05:51.420 First problem is,
00:05:56.780 use half your brain to see.
00:05:59.940 Literally.
00:06:01.340 Human visual cortex is a very large part of your brain.
00:06:04.540 And the reason that the visual cortex is so large
00:06:06.640 is that seeing is, as far as we can tell,
00:06:09.540 actually impossible.
00:06:11.460 Now, the fact that seeing, perception, is impossible
00:06:14.340 wasn't discovered by psychologists,
00:06:16.380 and it wasn't discovered by philosophers.
00:06:17.700 It was discovered by people who were working on artificial intelligence,
00:06:23.000 and trying to make artificially intelligent machines.
00:06:26.220 The presupposition of the people who were making intelligent machines was,
00:06:30.120 the hard part of interacting with the world
00:06:32.400 is figuring out what to do once you see the objects.
00:06:35.900 But it turned out that making machines that could see objects was impossible.
00:06:40.540 And the reason for that is that boundaries between objects are not obvious.
00:06:44.520 They're not obvious at all.
00:06:45.600 In fact, it's very difficult to understand
00:06:47.740 how it is that we separate things up at all.
00:06:51.120 Now, let me give you an example.
00:06:53.520 So, if you think about yourself,
00:06:55.860 when you look in the mirror, you see yourself as an object.
00:06:58.280 You see your eyes, you see your nose, you see your face,
00:07:00.600 you see your body.
00:07:01.800 And that's pretty much what you see when you look at other people.
00:07:04.920 But that isn't all there is to you.
00:07:06.900 In fact, that's hardly any of what there is to you.
00:07:09.460 So, you could say, for example,
00:07:12.340 you exist at the level of the quantum particle.
00:07:15.200 You can't perceive that.
00:07:16.420 In fact, people didn't know that until 75 years ago.
00:07:19.520 Above that level, you exist at an atomic level.
00:07:22.460 And then a molecular level.
00:07:24.100 And then you exist at the level of complex organs.
00:07:26.820 And then the interactions between those organs.
00:07:28.620 And then you.
00:07:31.120 And then your family.
00:07:32.800 And then the groups that your family belong to.
00:07:35.460 And then the ecosystem that all your groups belong to.
00:07:40.720 And on and so on and so forth
00:07:43.100 until what it is that you are
00:07:45.240 can expand to encompass virtually anything.
00:07:49.420 Now, when you look at yourself, you don't see that.
00:07:52.680 You see yourself at a certain level of resolution.
00:07:54.940 When you look at the world,
00:07:55.740 you see yourself at a certain level of resolution.
00:07:57.540 But all those other levels are equally real
00:08:00.020 and equally relevant.
00:08:02.440 And we, in fact, have very little idea
00:08:04.280 how it is that you're only able to see what you see.
00:08:08.720 Almost nothing has obvious boundaries.
00:08:11.220 And this has real-world consequences.
00:08:13.560 It's not something that's merely abstract.
00:08:16.620 The technical term for this problem,
00:08:18.660 the problem of how to bind your perceptions,
00:08:20.820 to limit them, is called the frame problem.
00:08:23.380 The frame problem was discovered about 40 years ago.
00:08:25.900 And the philosopher Daniel Dennett
00:08:28.420 called it the most important philosophical discussion,
00:08:31.160 discovery of the last 50 years.
00:08:34.600 The frame problem emerges to cause
00:08:36.780 all sorts of trouble for people.
00:08:39.000 So, for example,
00:08:40.900 when Henry Ford invented the automobile,
00:08:44.020 well, at least invented the modern procedure
00:08:45.960 of building the automobile,
00:08:47.520 what Ford presumed was that he was building
00:08:49.220 an efficient means of transporting people
00:08:50.920 from one place to the other.
00:08:55.340 There were other unintended consequences
00:08:57.800 of Ford's discovery.
00:08:59.840 So, for example,
00:09:01.080 Ford happened to be a great supporter of fascism.
00:09:03.920 And the reason that he was a supporter of fascism
00:09:06.060 was because he regarded the fascist political structure
00:09:09.700 as a logical extension
00:09:11.160 of the efficient methods
00:09:12.600 that he'd used to assemble vehicles.
00:09:14.180 So, his mode of production
00:09:16.840 was instantly manifested
00:09:18.000 in a political philosophy.
00:09:20.220 Furthermore,
00:09:22.100 now,
00:09:23.080 2009,
00:09:24.840 100 years after the invention of the automobile,
00:09:27.320 we've discovered some other things
00:09:28.900 that the car was
00:09:29.880 other than a place to move people
00:09:31.460 from point A to point B.
00:09:33.000 So, for example,
00:09:33.820 it turns out that the automobile
00:09:35.140 and the internal combustion engine
00:09:36.780 are among the most effective technologies
00:09:39.920 ever devised
00:09:40.680 to transform the nature of the atmosphere
00:09:42.420 and to heat up the world.
00:09:44.240 Not only that,
00:09:45.060 the car has completely transformed
00:09:46.440 the nature of cities.
00:09:48.120 And these were all
00:09:48.860 unintended consequences
00:09:50.120 of the fact
00:09:50.780 that the car was far more
00:09:52.200 than what people thought it was.
00:09:54.420 And you can say that
00:09:55.100 about any technological structure.
00:09:57.800 No one knew what TV would do
00:09:59.180 to the news, for example.
00:10:00.800 No one knew what the internet
00:10:01.840 would do to the music industry.
00:10:03.760 Everything that you interact with
00:10:05.040 is far more complicated
00:10:06.060 than you see.
00:10:09.400 The most ancient ideas we have
00:10:11.300 about the nature of reality
00:10:12.440 are predicated on
00:10:14.160 a certain presupposition.
00:10:16.000 And the presupposition is this.
00:10:18.300 There's two fundamental
00:10:19.620 modes of being
00:10:21.880 that characterize reality.
00:10:23.880 One is the absolute.
00:10:25.960 And the absolute
00:10:26.540 is the sum total of everything.
00:10:28.840 So if you think about things
00:10:29.940 in their most unbounded
00:10:31.260 possible form,
00:10:32.780 if you think of things
00:10:33.700 in their infinite number
00:10:34.940 of potential variations,
00:10:36.480 you can think about that
00:10:37.500 as one pole of reality.
00:10:38.800 It appears classically
00:10:40.940 that people have regarded
00:10:41.960 their encounters
00:10:42.800 with the absolute,
00:10:44.160 which is all those
00:10:44.920 multiple levels of being
00:10:46.220 that are beyond
00:10:46.800 your perceptual capacity,
00:10:48.380 as equivalent
00:10:49.060 to an encounter with God.
00:10:51.360 Now you know
00:10:52.120 that in the Islamic religion
00:10:53.300 it's against the rules
00:10:54.300 to make a graven image
00:10:55.500 of any sort of Muhammad, right?
00:10:56.960 The idea is that
00:10:57.520 you're not supposed
00:10:58.000 to make an image.
00:10:59.080 And among the ancient Hebrews
00:11:00.080 the idea was very similar.
00:11:02.320 The Daoists say
00:11:03.120 that you shouldn't confuse
00:11:05.140 the moon with a finger
00:11:06.140 pointing to the moon.
00:11:07.140 And what all that means
00:11:08.700 is that the absolute
00:11:10.280 is always something
00:11:11.160 that transcends
00:11:12.100 the finite frame
00:11:13.400 that you place
00:11:14.040 around your perceptions.
00:11:15.680 So as soon as you start
00:11:16.880 talking about it,
00:11:17.880 representing it,
00:11:19.000 making statues of it,
00:11:20.180 or idolizing it,
00:11:21.060 you lose your connection
00:11:21.940 with the absolute
00:11:22.660 because you've turned it
00:11:23.820 into something
00:11:24.380 that's understandable
00:11:25.240 and concrete.
00:11:26.680 Part of the wisdom traditions
00:11:28.060 that the world
00:11:28.800 still maintains
00:11:30.240 make the constant
00:11:32.560 moral presupposition
00:11:35.940 that you should always
00:11:37.900 be aware
00:11:38.480 of what it is
00:11:39.460 that transcends
00:11:40.140 both your understanding
00:11:41.080 and your perceptions.
00:11:42.360 And you should keep
00:11:43.040 firmly in mind
00:11:43.780 that that exists.
00:11:45.860 Now when people talk
00:11:46.760 about God
00:11:47.360 in the modern world
00:11:48.080 they tend to think
00:11:48.740 about something
00:11:49.300 that has more
00:11:51.640 the characteristics
00:11:52.360 of a being.
00:11:53.440 And I suppose
00:11:53.940 that's where most
00:11:54.640 of the debate
00:11:55.080 about religious reality
00:11:56.020 comes in.
00:11:57.140 But the idea
00:11:57.760 that there's an absolute
00:11:58.640 that's outside
00:11:59.240 of your perceptual capacity
00:12:00.700 seems to be
00:12:01.360 merely a statement of fact
00:12:03.620 especially given
00:12:04.540 what we know
00:12:05.180 now about the nature
00:12:06.540 of perception.
00:12:07.780 That the phenomena
00:12:08.500 always transcends
00:12:09.520 the manner
00:12:10.060 in which you frame it.
00:12:12.260 We've also come
00:12:13.080 to understand that
00:12:14.040 not only does reality
00:12:15.720 have multiple levels
00:12:16.860 of existence
00:12:17.460 but in order
00:12:18.320 to perceive it
00:12:19.140 you have to
00:12:20.220 stand inside
00:12:21.840 multiple frames.
00:12:24.740 This is a picture
00:12:25.760 of a French city.
00:12:27.200 It's a walled city.
00:12:29.240 Now
00:12:29.460 the walls are there
00:12:30.960 to keep the people in
00:12:32.160 and the walls are there
00:12:33.840 to keep what isn't
00:12:34.720 in the walls out.
00:12:36.480 And so you can think
00:12:37.140 about that
00:12:37.620 as a protective structure.
00:12:39.820 Now
00:12:40.240 I want to tell you
00:12:41.620 how it is
00:12:42.400 that you still inhabit
00:12:43.580 a walled city
00:12:44.360 and exactly
00:12:45.420 what that means.
00:12:46.740 So for example
00:12:47.440 you think about
00:12:48.920 this room
00:12:49.520 and
00:12:50.800 I'm going to tell you
00:12:52.040 how it is
00:12:52.880 that this room
00:12:53.600 allows you to see
00:12:54.760 what it is
00:12:55.300 that you see.
00:12:56.520 Now when you're
00:12:57.180 interacting with a computer
00:12:58.360 you actually don't
00:12:59.580 interact with the computer.
00:13:01.280 You interact with
00:13:02.080 the keyboard
00:13:02.500 and the screen.
00:13:04.000 If the computer crashes
00:13:05.240 then you interact
00:13:06.140 with the computer
00:13:06.780 and you find that
00:13:07.720 as a general rule
00:13:08.480 very annoying
00:13:09.120 because you don't
00:13:10.040 really understand
00:13:10.640 the computer very well
00:13:11.620 and you don't
00:13:12.540 actually see
00:13:13.400 how complex it is
00:13:14.420 until it stops working.
00:13:16.340 Most of the time
00:13:17.200 when you're interacting
00:13:17.880 with the world
00:13:18.500 you're doing things
00:13:19.760 with the world.
00:13:20.700 You're interacting
00:13:21.440 with it
00:13:21.900 in a way
00:13:22.480 that produces
00:13:23.180 some consequence
00:13:24.020 that you want
00:13:24.880 and that means
00:13:25.780 in part
00:13:26.200 that
00:13:26.520 your perceptions
00:13:27.420 are always framed
00:13:28.220 by what you want
00:13:29.280 and that's actually
00:13:30.200 one of the reasons
00:13:30.760 why the world
00:13:31.280 isn't just made out
00:13:32.060 of objects.
00:13:33.040 The world is made out
00:13:33.800 of things you use
00:13:34.900 and things that get
00:13:35.900 in your way.
00:13:37.700 Now
00:13:37.980 you're always applying
00:13:39.360 a frame like that
00:13:40.120 to the world
00:13:40.520 in order to simplify it
00:13:41.540 enough so that you
00:13:42.080 can understand it
00:13:42.860 and you're aided
00:13:43.800 in this process
00:13:44.660 by all sorts of
00:13:45.580 processes you really
00:13:46.420 don't notice
00:13:47.020 because when you look
00:13:48.240 at the world
00:13:48.620 you think
00:13:49.060 well there are
00:13:49.620 the objects
00:13:50.140 but there's a thousand
00:13:51.220 things going on
00:13:52.200 before you make
00:13:52.920 that judgment.
00:13:54.260 So
00:13:54.400 we'll look at this room.
00:13:57.820 When you walk in here
00:13:58.800 the room tells you
00:13:59.460 what to do.
00:14:00.660 The reason it tells you
00:14:01.740 what to do
00:14:02.060 is because all the seats
00:14:02.820 are pointed in the
00:14:03.420 same direction.
00:14:04.520 They're all slanted
00:14:05.680 in a particular way.
00:14:07.140 When you walk in here
00:14:07.980 and there's other people
00:14:08.720 sitting
00:14:09.120 you can see that all
00:14:10.120 their faces point
00:14:10.880 to the front.
00:14:12.140 People's faces
00:14:12.880 point towards
00:14:13.740 what interests them.
00:14:14.840 The room is set up
00:14:15.600 to make you face
00:14:16.300 the front.
00:14:17.260 The theory behind
00:14:18.140 the room is that
00:14:18.720 the thing that's
00:14:19.340 interesting in the room
00:14:20.380 is happening at the front.
00:14:21.720 It's a theater.
00:14:22.980 What's happening
00:14:23.540 at the front
00:14:23.920 is a drama.
00:14:25.660 Right?
00:14:25.860 Because theater is there
00:14:26.720 to promote
00:14:27.720 and undergird drama.
00:14:30.080 A lecture is a dramatic act.
00:14:32.600 The room tells you
00:14:33.520 what to do.
00:14:34.100 So you don't have
00:14:34.500 to think about
00:14:34.920 what to do
00:14:35.340 when you come
00:14:35.860 into a room like this.
00:14:36.840 You can just do it
00:14:37.660 because the room
00:14:38.200 tells you what to do.
00:14:39.980 And then you can think
00:14:40.800 you can sit in here
00:14:44.560 in relative comfort
00:14:45.660 and listen to this lecture.
00:14:48.140 Why can you sit in here
00:14:49.300 in relative comfort?
00:14:51.220 Well, the people around you
00:14:52.200 have been relatively
00:14:52.840 carefully selected.
00:14:54.620 Right?
00:14:54.860 As a consequence
00:14:55.580 of analysis
00:14:56.380 of their 12 years
00:14:57.340 in school,
00:14:58.260 the university
00:14:58.640 has made a determination
00:14:59.460 that they know
00:15:00.400 how to sit down
00:15:01.160 and listen.
00:15:02.340 That hypothetically
00:15:03.300 they're intelligent enough
00:15:04.420 to understand the lecture
00:15:05.440 and that they're
00:15:06.380 very unlikely
00:15:07.140 to disrupt
00:15:07.940 the proceedings
00:15:08.640 with any unexpected
00:15:10.160 outburst of emotion
00:15:11.280 or motivation.
00:15:12.740 Now, if anybody
00:15:13.400 broke one of those rules,
00:15:14.720 you can be sure
00:15:15.300 that your eyes
00:15:15.860 would move very rapidly
00:15:16.800 away from me
00:15:17.480 and directly towards
00:15:18.600 the person
00:15:19.020 who was causing
00:15:19.600 the trouble
00:15:20.040 because that would
00:15:21.360 take center stage.
00:15:23.840 Now, this room
00:15:24.660 is actually supported
00:15:25.540 by a million
00:15:26.560 invisible processes.
00:15:28.160 So, for example,
00:15:28.840 while you're sitting
00:15:29.320 in here,
00:15:29.620 you don't have to worry
00:15:30.180 about whether it's raining
00:15:30.960 because there's a roof
00:15:32.540 and you don't have to worry
00:15:33.320 about whether the roof
00:15:34.080 is going to fall in
00:15:34.820 because you make
00:15:35.460 the presumption
00:15:35.980 that the people
00:15:36.440 who built the roof
00:15:37.080 are competent
00:15:37.640 and the electricity works
00:15:39.300 because the electricity
00:15:40.240 is...
00:15:40.920 the utility
00:15:41.640 is run by people
00:15:42.500 who are competent
00:15:43.000 so it's almost always on.
00:15:44.600 Buildings hardly ever
00:15:45.560 burned down.
00:15:46.440 The electricity
00:15:46.980 hardly ever fluctuates.
00:15:48.620 There's thousands
00:15:49.240 of people out there
00:15:50.320 working as hard
00:15:51.240 as they can diligently
00:15:52.300 to make this environment
00:15:53.760 constant enough
00:15:54.760 so that you can ignore
00:15:56.120 all the thousands
00:15:57.020 of things that you're
00:15:57.800 ignoring
00:15:58.160 so that you can
00:15:59.080 concentrate well enough
00:16:00.120 to attend to the few
00:16:01.020 things that you are
00:16:01.700 attending to
00:16:02.180 while you're in this room.
00:16:03.780 You're in a walled city.
00:16:05.760 There's multiple walls
00:16:07.140 and those walls
00:16:08.280 protect you
00:16:09.000 from what's outside
00:16:09.880 the walls.
00:16:10.360 you can think about
00:16:14.480 it this way
00:16:14.980 this is a Taoist
00:16:17.540 image of reality
00:16:18.540 now
00:16:20.300 people think about
00:16:21.240 this as a metaphysical
00:16:22.400 symbol
00:16:23.420 but it's not
00:16:25.700 a metaphysical symbol
00:16:26.700 it's an unbelievably
00:16:28.160 practical symbol
00:16:29.440 the Taoists
00:16:30.940 believe that the world
00:16:32.020 the reality
00:16:33.680 is made up
00:16:34.540 essentially
00:16:35.160 of chaos
00:16:36.340 and order
00:16:36.800 chaos is all those
00:16:39.200 things you don't
00:16:39.720 understand
00:16:40.260 so I would say
00:16:41.700 that chaos is all
00:16:42.500 those things that
00:16:43.020 exist outside of
00:16:43.860 your perceptual
00:16:44.560 preconditions
00:16:45.320 order is all the
00:16:47.660 things you do
00:16:48.160 understand
00:16:48.580 and all the places
00:16:49.280 you go
00:16:49.840 where the things
00:16:50.720 that you do
00:16:51.500 produce the results
00:16:52.940 that you intend
00:16:53.920 and the Taoists
00:16:55.700 would say
00:16:56.240 everywhere you go
00:16:58.080 is like that
00:16:58.680 everywhere you go
00:16:59.900 has things that
00:17:00.680 you understand
00:17:01.240 that are orderly
00:17:01.920 and has things
00:17:02.700 that you don't
00:17:03.280 understand
00:17:03.820 that are chaotic
00:17:04.760 and the chaotic
00:17:05.820 things attract
00:17:06.420 your attention
00:17:06.940 because you already
00:17:07.700 understand the
00:17:08.400 orderly things
00:17:09.100 if something
00:17:11.400 unexpected happens
00:17:12.360 your nervous system
00:17:13.060 automatically reacts
00:17:13.980 to it and orients
00:17:14.680 you towards it
00:17:15.320 and sometimes that
00:17:16.200 can be catastrophic
00:17:17.060 so this is an
00:17:18.880 experience that some
00:17:19.600 of you will have
00:17:20.200 in the next four
00:17:20.820 years
00:17:21.180 undoubtedly there's
00:17:22.400 a number of you
00:17:22.860 that want to go
00:17:23.280 to medical school
00:17:23.980 or to graduate
00:17:25.000 school
00:17:25.380 or to law school
00:17:26.680 or to business
00:17:27.900 school
00:17:28.300 and a certain
00:17:29.580 percentage of you
00:17:30.300 will take the
00:17:30.780 admission tests
00:17:31.580 that will determine
00:17:32.720 whether or not
00:17:33.240 you're able to
00:17:33.740 take that path
00:17:34.520 and a certain
00:17:36.060 percentage of you
00:17:36.840 will score below
00:17:37.780 the 50th percentile
00:17:38.920 on those tests
00:17:39.660 and that will mean
00:17:41.200 you will not be
00:17:42.000 going to those
00:17:42.560 institutions
00:17:43.120 and when that
00:17:44.460 happens
00:17:44.960 first of all
00:17:45.960 you'll shake and
00:17:46.760 tremble when you
00:17:47.380 open the envelope
00:17:48.040 to find out your
00:17:48.760 results
00:17:49.220 and second
00:17:50.260 if you haven't
00:17:51.100 achieved the score
00:17:51.760 that you expected
00:17:52.460 that you achieve
00:17:53.880 your world will
00:17:54.780 fall apart
00:17:55.380 and what that'll
00:17:57.200 mean is that you
00:17:57.780 descend from the
00:17:58.620 domain of order
00:17:59.260 into the domain of
00:18:00.060 chaos
00:18:00.440 and that happens to
00:18:01.640 people all the time
00:18:02.860 it happens to people
00:18:04.580 when they develop
00:18:05.540 an illness that's
00:18:06.220 serious that they
00:18:06.840 can't control
00:18:07.520 because then their
00:18:08.440 body stops becoming
00:18:09.600 something they can
00:18:10.240 predict
00:18:10.600 and starts to
00:18:11.420 become something
00:18:11.960 that they can't
00:18:13.080 predict
00:18:13.360 it happens to people
00:18:14.580 when they're in an
00:18:15.140 intimate relationship
00:18:15.920 and they're betrayed
00:18:17.360 they assume fidelity
00:18:19.420 and the person tells
00:18:20.680 them that they've
00:18:21.140 had an affair
00:18:21.720 that's chaos
00:18:22.920 that means
00:18:23.660 you didn't know
00:18:24.340 who that person
00:18:24.960 was
00:18:25.380 the future you
00:18:26.980 imagine no longer
00:18:27.820 exists
00:18:28.360 your perceptions of
00:18:30.420 people are erroneous
00:18:31.440 at some level of
00:18:32.180 analysis that you
00:18:32.920 don't understand
00:18:33.680 it's conceivable
00:18:34.920 that you're naive
00:18:35.800 beyond belief
00:18:36.760 and that everything
00:18:37.700 you believed about
00:18:38.460 yourself and other
00:18:39.180 people up to that
00:18:39.900 point is false
00:18:40.740 and when a revelation
00:18:42.380 occurs that knocks
00:18:43.340 out one of the walls
00:18:44.080 that supports you
00:18:44.900 and you descend
00:18:46.020 accidentally
00:18:47.120 into chaos
00:18:48.300 you'll regard that
00:18:49.400 as one of the worst
00:18:50.280 experiences of your
00:18:51.080 life
00:18:51.380 when that happens
00:18:53.340 to you
00:18:53.600 your brain knows
00:18:54.320 exactly what to do
00:18:55.300 it stops thinking
00:18:56.620 about the future
00:18:57.380 it stops saving up
00:18:58.680 resources for the
00:18:59.500 future
00:18:59.840 it puts you in
00:19:00.720 emergency preparation
00:19:01.680 mode
00:19:02.220 so that you're
00:19:02.920 ready to do
00:19:03.380 anything at the
00:19:04.340 drop of a hat
00:19:05.000 because you don't
00:19:05.820 know what to do
00:19:06.560 so your body
00:19:07.760 prepares to do
00:19:08.420 everything
00:19:08.840 it shifts your
00:19:09.980 cortisol levels up
00:19:11.040 it activates your
00:19:12.200 left and right
00:19:12.980 cortices
00:19:14.920 your limbic system
00:19:17.180 and your motivational
00:19:17.860 systems are
00:19:18.580 disinhibited
00:19:19.600 turned on
00:19:20.420 and you sweat
00:19:21.660 and you can't sleep
00:19:22.640 because the orderly
00:19:24.600 structure that you
00:19:25.360 thought you inhabited
00:19:26.260 that provided you
00:19:27.260 with security and
00:19:28.000 direction
00:19:28.400 has now disappeared
00:19:29.700 the Taoists believe
00:19:31.820 that the world is
00:19:32.800 always an interplay
00:19:33.680 between chaos and
00:19:34.540 order
00:19:34.780 and that if you
00:19:35.620 live your life
00:19:36.360 properly
00:19:36.880 you stand with one
00:19:38.140 foot in order
00:19:38.760 and one foot in
00:19:40.460 chaos
00:19:40.940 because if you're
00:19:42.360 only in order
00:19:42.940 nothing that's
00:19:43.980 interesting ever
00:19:44.720 happens to you
00:19:45.340 nothing is anything
00:19:46.780 but a repeat of
00:19:47.780 all the things that
00:19:49.260 you already know
00:19:50.020 that's the state
00:19:51.040 that fascists desire
00:19:52.300 because fascists
00:19:53.660 desire things to be
00:19:54.640 exactly the way they
00:19:55.560 are forever
00:19:56.180 and if you're in a
00:19:57.680 state that's only
00:19:58.280 characterized by chaos
00:19:59.460 you're at sea
00:20:00.500 you're overwhelmed
00:20:01.240 or things have
00:20:01.800 fallen apart for you
00:20:02.780 and there's too much
00:20:03.880 of everything for you
00:20:04.860 to deal with
00:20:05.500 now the Taoists
00:20:07.140 being very wise
00:20:07.840 people know other
00:20:08.540 things as well
00:20:09.260 they know for example
00:20:10.860 that chaos can turn
00:20:11.700 into order
00:20:12.140 that's why there's a
00:20:13.060 white dot in the
00:20:13.740 middle of the black
00:20:14.420 paisley
00:20:15.140 and they know that
00:20:16.220 order can turn
00:20:17.380 into chaos
00:20:18.080 which is why there's
00:20:19.060 a black dot
00:20:19.760 in the middle of
00:20:20.660 the white paisley
00:20:21.640 and the Taoists
00:20:22.760 believe that
00:20:23.340 a meaningful life
00:20:25.440 the optimally
00:20:26.600 meaningful life
00:20:27.280 is to be found
00:20:28.320 on the border
00:20:29.140 between chaos
00:20:30.040 and order
00:20:30.480 and I would say
00:20:31.820 that your nervous
00:20:32.340 system tells you
00:20:33.060 exactly when you
00:20:33.860 are there
00:20:34.300 and it's a kind
00:20:34.960 of place
00:20:35.460 and you can tell
00:20:36.100 when you're there
00:20:36.600 because you're
00:20:37.960 secure enough
00:20:38.580 to be confident
00:20:39.340 but not so secure
00:20:40.800 that you're bored
00:20:41.520 and you're interested
00:20:42.660 enough to be awake
00:20:43.700 but not so interested
00:20:44.860 that you're terrified
00:20:45.780 and when you're
00:20:46.820 in a state like that
00:20:47.880 when you find things
00:20:48.680 interesting and meaningful
00:20:49.720 time slips by you
00:20:51.180 and you're no longer
00:20:51.840 self-conscious
00:20:52.640 this is a medieval
00:20:54.600 christian representation
00:20:55.720 of the nature of reality
00:20:57.100 on the outside
00:20:59.420 you have
00:20:59.820 the virgin mary
00:21:00.640 inside the virgin mary
00:21:03.640 you have
00:21:04.020 god the father
00:21:04.940 and god the father
00:21:06.880 is supporting
00:21:07.440 a crucifix
00:21:08.140 with an individual
00:21:08.840 on it
00:21:09.200 the individual
00:21:09.720 in christian
00:21:10.360 thinking is christ
00:21:12.280 what does this
00:21:14.700 image mean
00:21:15.700 the walled city
00:21:20.820 divides
00:21:21.440 order from chaos
00:21:23.180 or order from nature
00:21:25.440 we think about nature
00:21:27.360 as the thing that's
00:21:28.080 outside of what we
00:21:29.040 understand
00:21:29.640 that's mother nature
00:21:31.000 mother nature gives
00:21:32.440 birth to all things
00:21:33.600 that's the idea
00:21:36.200 that's expressed
00:21:36.740 in this image
00:21:37.500 the virgin mary
00:21:39.080 is standing for
00:21:39.740 mother nature
00:21:40.380 out of mother nature
00:21:41.800 arises order and
00:21:42.900 tradition
00:21:43.340 that's true for primates
00:21:44.840 like chimpanzees
00:21:45.940 as much as it's true
00:21:46.700 for us
00:21:47.160 any social animals
00:21:48.860 that are grouped
00:21:49.320 together
00:21:49.720 have to form an
00:21:50.700 orderly structure
00:21:51.440 that they can
00:21:52.160 inhabit together
00:21:52.940 that defines their
00:21:54.020 boundaries and their
00:21:54.720 goals
00:21:55.000 because otherwise
00:21:55.760 they fight each
00:21:56.400 other to the death
00:21:57.200 so in the state of
00:21:59.080 untrammeled nature
00:21:59.980 as hobbes pointed out
00:22:01.420 it's every man for
00:22:02.600 himself
00:22:03.000 and without the order
00:22:04.900 that tradition brings
00:22:05.920 there's nothing but
00:22:07.000 chaos
00:22:07.400 and chaos is murderous
00:22:08.820 and unproductive
00:22:09.600 there's a problem
00:22:10.660 with order
00:22:11.140 if you look at the
00:22:13.680 history of the
00:22:14.160 20th century
00:22:14.880 it's a toss-up
00:22:17.300 whether mother nature
00:22:18.660 has been harder on us
00:22:19.720 or whether our
00:22:20.940 governmental traditions
00:22:22.520 have been harder on us
00:22:23.500 you know of course
00:22:25.680 that the dictatorship
00:22:27.500 of hitler killed
00:22:28.380 6 million jews
00:22:29.480 120 million people
00:22:32.140 in the second world war
00:22:33.220 you may not know
00:22:35.260 that the stalinist
00:22:37.280 dictatorships in the
00:22:38.240 soviet union
00:22:38.820 killed an estimated
00:22:40.020 60 million people
00:22:41.340 in internal repression
00:22:42.320 not counting those
00:22:43.200 people who died
00:22:43.840 in the second world war
00:22:44.740 and the internal
00:22:46.140 repression that
00:22:46.800 characterized Mao's
00:22:47.980 communist china
00:22:49.080 killed a hundred
00:22:49.900 million people
00:22:50.780 and so the problem
00:22:52.560 with tradition is that
00:22:53.740 sometimes it's a wise
00:22:55.380 king
00:22:55.700 and sometimes it's a
00:22:57.020 king that eats its own
00:22:57.880 sons
00:22:58.400 which means that
00:22:59.660 although we need
00:23:00.180 tradition to guide us
00:23:01.160 and to structure
00:23:01.920 even the manner in
00:23:02.820 which we perceive the
00:23:03.580 world
00:23:03.840 our traditions can
00:23:04.980 become archaic
00:23:05.800 and outdated
00:23:06.320 and cruel
00:23:07.400 and inhuman
00:23:08.660 and as a consequence
00:23:10.060 they can pose a
00:23:10.800 worse threat to us
00:23:11.600 than chaos itself
00:23:12.820 nature or chaos
00:23:19.260 is exactly the same
00:23:20.820 dichotomous structure
00:23:22.500 the figure on the left
00:23:25.020 is a medusa
00:23:25.720 or a gorgon
00:23:26.920 if you look at a medusa
00:23:29.780 as you probably already
00:23:30.880 know
00:23:31.200 you turn to stone
00:23:32.300 the reason you turn to
00:23:34.700 stone is because
00:23:35.440 when you look upon
00:23:36.640 nature or chaos
00:23:38.100 without your normal
00:23:39.440 veils
00:23:39.960 it paralyzes you
00:23:41.360 physiologically
00:23:42.980 just like a prey animal
00:23:45.100 like a rabbit
00:23:45.720 is terrified
00:23:46.240 if it sees a wolf
00:23:47.240 for millions of years
00:23:49.580 human beings
00:23:50.540 were prey animals
00:23:51.420 we were probably
00:23:52.760 prey animals
00:23:53.460 for large reptiles
00:23:55.200 which accounts
00:23:56.420 for example
00:23:57.260 for the reason
00:23:57.900 that it appears
00:23:58.700 that primates like us
00:23:59.740 are naturally afraid
00:24:00.660 of predatory reptiles
00:24:01.960 if you're in
00:24:04.520 the presence of something
00:24:06.460 that violates
00:24:07.460 your assumptions
00:24:08.020 of safety
00:24:08.700 you'll freeze
00:24:09.980 you freeze so that
00:24:11.520 the thing that might
00:24:12.160 eat you
00:24:12.460 can't see you
00:24:13.200 and that's what
00:24:14.060 turns you to stone
00:24:14.920 that's nature
00:24:16.780 and it's terrible
00:24:17.520 aspect
00:24:18.180 and the terrible
00:24:19.340 aspect of nature
00:24:20.120 can freeze everyone
00:24:21.020 and you can be sure
00:24:22.280 and will be seldom
00:24:23.580 taught
00:24:24.040 that you will
00:24:24.940 encounter that
00:24:25.600 at some point
00:24:26.120 in your life
00:24:26.680 the primary
00:24:29.800 buddhist dictum
00:24:30.900 is that life
00:24:32.120 is suffering
00:24:32.780 and what does
00:24:34.240 that mean
00:24:34.740 it means that
00:24:37.760 because you're
00:24:38.520 finite
00:24:39.040 and you're
00:24:40.800 surrounded by
00:24:41.420 something that's
00:24:42.100 absolute
00:24:42.680 in a sense
00:24:44.160 you're in a battle
00:24:44.820 that you can never
00:24:45.440 win
00:24:45.780 because there's
00:24:46.960 always more of
00:24:47.700 what it is
00:24:48.240 that you're trying
00:24:48.860 to contend with
00:24:49.740 than there is
00:24:50.840 with you
00:24:51.400 and worse
00:24:52.660 than that
00:24:53.240 and it's for this
00:24:54.360 reason that
00:24:54.860 tyrannies can't
00:24:55.640 last
00:24:56.060 is that the thing
00:24:57.280 that you're
00:24:57.660 contending with
00:24:58.340 isn't even static
00:24:59.660 it keeps changing
00:25:01.120 so that what
00:25:02.100 worked for you
00:25:02.680 yesterday won't
00:25:03.880 necessarily work
00:25:04.760 for you tomorrow
00:25:05.540 this is an
00:25:10.060 alchemical version
00:25:11.140 of the Taoist
00:25:11.960 yin and yang
00:25:12.540 symbol
00:25:12.880 and basically
00:25:13.440 it says something
00:25:14.160 that's more
00:25:14.580 sophisticated
00:25:15.100 and complex
00:25:15.820 it says that
00:25:16.600 the world's made
00:25:18.000 up of chaos
00:25:18.640 and order
00:25:19.160 things that you
00:25:20.120 can predict
00:25:20.600 and understand
00:25:21.240 and things that
00:25:21.880 you can't predict
00:25:22.900 and can't understand
00:25:23.840 and inside the order
00:25:25.240 there's some chaos
00:25:26.080 and inside that
00:25:26.860 chaos there's some
00:25:27.640 order
00:25:27.960 and inside that
00:25:28.700 order there's
00:25:29.180 some chaos
00:25:29.700 and so on
00:25:30.620 and so forth
00:25:31.320 and equally the
00:25:32.280 case for order
00:25:33.640 you have mother
00:25:39.620 nature
00:25:40.060 representation of
00:25:41.580 chaos
00:25:42.080 sometimes positive
00:25:43.680 sometimes negative
00:25:44.860 you have a
00:25:45.800 representation of
00:25:46.560 the great father
00:25:47.320 that's security
00:25:48.540 and tyranny
00:25:49.240 two things you'll
00:25:50.160 always have to
00:25:50.780 contend with
00:25:51.400 and finally in this
00:25:52.980 representation you
00:25:54.080 have a representation
00:25:55.460 of the individual
00:25:56.500 at least a Christian
00:25:57.780 representation of the
00:25:58.780 individual
00:25:59.140 and that's Christ
00:25:59.900 and it's a terrifying
00:26:00.700 representation
00:26:01.480 it's a remarkable
00:26:03.040 representation
00:26:03.700 because it's not a
00:26:05.340 representation of
00:26:06.820 transcendence
00:26:08.000 it's a representation
00:26:08.660 of suffering
00:26:09.560 and it's a funny
00:26:11.120 kind of representation
00:26:11.940 of suffering
00:26:12.620 because the manner
00:26:14.180 in which the story
00:26:15.020 unfolds is this
00:26:16.100 Christ as the
00:26:18.580 archetypal individual
00:26:19.880 the model for
00:26:20.620 individuals from a
00:26:21.860 psychological or
00:26:22.700 mythological perspective
00:26:23.900 knows that he's
00:26:25.200 limited and knows
00:26:26.220 that he's doomed to
00:26:27.100 both suffering and
00:26:28.000 death
00:26:28.300 in the garden of
00:26:29.920 Gethsemane the
00:26:30.640 night before his
00:26:31.340 crucifixion he has
00:26:32.160 an argument with
00:26:32.740 God and the
00:26:33.380 argument basically is
00:26:34.480 do I actually have
00:26:36.220 to do this
00:26:36.880 and the answer is
00:26:37.760 twofold
00:26:38.220 well no actually
00:26:39.160 you don't have to
00:26:39.920 accept your
00:26:40.460 suffering
00:26:40.880 but
00:26:42.020 you don't have to
00:26:45.320 voluntarily accept
00:26:46.300 your suffering
00:26:46.820 but there are
00:26:47.260 consequences if you
00:26:48.180 don't
00:26:48.560 now the Christian
00:26:49.940 story is predicated
00:26:50.760 on the idea that
00:26:51.580 if you voluntarily
00:26:52.280 accept your
00:26:52.960 suffering you can
00:26:53.660 simultaneously
00:26:54.280 transcend it
00:26:55.200 it's a remarkable
00:26:57.020 philosophy and
00:26:58.520 it's also something
00:26:59.240 that we have very
00:27:00.500 good support for
00:27:01.540 from a psychological
00:27:03.240 perspective
00:27:03.940 so for example
00:27:05.220 if I'm treating
00:27:06.700 someone who has
00:27:07.300 an anxiety disorder
00:27:08.240 a panic disorder
00:27:09.100 who can't go out
00:27:10.040 of their house
00:27:10.380 without their
00:27:10.800 heart rate elevating
00:27:11.560 and without collapsing
00:27:12.500 into a panic
00:27:13.200 stricken heap
00:27:13.840 without visiting
00:27:14.800 the emergency ward
00:27:16.260 every time their
00:27:17.060 heart rate accelerates
00:27:17.900 every time they're
00:27:18.500 in a subway
00:27:18.960 or every time
00:27:19.500 they're in a mall
00:27:20.040 so they're so
00:27:20.880 terrified of existence
00:27:21.860 they can't even
00:27:22.600 get out of their
00:27:23.140 house
00:27:23.480 the way you
00:27:24.600 cure that person
00:27:25.360 is by getting
00:27:25.980 them to voluntarily
00:27:26.760 approach the things
00:27:27.580 that they're afraid
00:27:28.120 of
00:27:28.340 and it turns out
00:27:29.600 that physiologically
00:27:30.480 if I force you
00:27:32.440 to accept a certain
00:27:33.260 kind of challenge
00:27:33.900 your body will go
00:27:34.620 into emergency
00:27:35.220 preparation mode
00:27:36.140 and you'll become
00:27:36.960 stressed
00:27:37.560 and that stress
00:27:38.540 will cause you
00:27:39.280 physiological damage
00:27:40.340 including brain
00:27:41.240 damage if it's
00:27:41.920 sustained for long
00:27:42.620 enough
00:27:42.880 but if I present
00:27:44.220 you with the same
00:27:44.780 challenge and you
00:27:45.440 accept it voluntarily
00:27:46.420 your brain doesn't
00:27:47.380 produce stress hormones
00:27:48.260 and completely different
00:27:49.120 physiological
00:27:49.660 systems kick in
00:27:50.680 and what that means
00:27:52.060 is that people
00:27:52.620 have evolved two
00:27:53.340 modes for dealing
00:27:54.020 with the unknown
00:27:54.700 one is voluntary
00:27:55.700 approach
00:27:56.260 and the other
00:27:56.940 is panic-stricken
00:27:58.720 paralysis and flight
00:28:00.700 in this representation
00:28:05.840 you can see that
00:28:06.980 there are crowds of
00:28:08.580 people
00:28:09.000 standing in the wings
00:28:11.360 of the open statue
00:28:12.340 looking at the
00:28:13.620 crucified individual
00:28:14.700 it's a very strange
00:28:15.800 thing but you know
00:28:16.480 you still see this
00:28:17.320 you still see people
00:28:18.400 doing things like this
00:28:19.480 that they don't notice
00:28:20.600 I went to a museum
00:28:23.240 in New York
00:28:24.220 and there were a very
00:28:25.420 large number of
00:28:26.040 paintings there
00:28:26.600 from the late
00:28:27.080 renaissance
00:28:27.480 and they were all
00:28:28.120 religiously themed
00:28:29.160 like medieval
00:28:30.100 paintings except
00:28:30.920 they featured
00:28:33.460 recognizable individuals
00:28:35.360 and people had come
00:28:37.560 from all over the
00:28:38.120 world to look at
00:28:38.760 those paintings
00:28:39.260 they were extremely
00:28:40.020 valuable paintings
00:28:40.920 you know
00:28:41.240 they were painted
00:28:41.980 by Michelangelo
00:28:42.800 or Leonardo da Vinci
00:28:43.920 and each of them
00:28:45.460 was probably valued
00:28:46.320 for reasons that
00:28:46.980 are very difficult
00:28:47.560 to understand
00:28:48.220 at something
00:28:49.180 approximating
00:28:49.900 hundreds of
00:28:50.460 millions of
00:28:50.960 dollars
00:28:51.340 the late renaissance
00:28:53.320 was the first time
00:28:54.180 in human history
00:28:54.920 where human beings
00:28:55.860 dared to presume
00:28:56.700 that sacred images
00:28:58.160 could be given
00:28:58.720 an individual human
00:28:59.720 face
00:29:00.140 and that idea
00:29:01.200 was actually
00:29:02.000 what launched
00:29:02.580 the enlightenment
00:29:03.720 and launched
00:29:04.880 the development
00:29:05.420 of modern culture
00:29:06.240 the late renaissance
00:29:07.300 thinkers
00:29:07.760 the artists
00:29:08.240 in particular
00:29:08.720 were the first
00:29:09.280 people to posit
00:29:10.060 that there was
00:29:10.600 some direct
00:29:11.100 relationship
00:29:11.600 between these
00:29:12.160 sacred images
00:29:13.260 and actual people
00:29:14.780 and people come
00:29:15.900 from all over the
00:29:16.480 world to look
00:29:16.980 at these paintings
00:29:17.540 even though they
00:29:18.420 don't understand
00:29:19.080 what they mean
00:29:19.860 I want to show
00:29:21.380 you some images
00:29:22.660 that describe how
00:29:23.940 the idea of
00:29:25.300 the suffering
00:29:26.520 individual
00:29:27.220 developed
00:29:28.280 and what that
00:29:29.140 means
00:29:29.520 the first thing
00:29:31.260 I want to show
00:29:31.740 you is this picture
00:29:32.480 of St. George
00:29:33.100 and the dragon
00:29:33.660 now
00:29:34.940 you know the
00:29:36.540 main street
00:29:37.720 that runs through
00:29:38.240 the university
00:29:38.680 is named after
00:29:39.360 St. George
00:29:39.940 right
00:29:40.260 this is a very
00:29:41.820 old image
00:29:42.420 the oldest story
00:29:44.580 we know
00:29:45.120 which is a
00:29:45.760 Mesopotamian
00:29:46.400 creation myth
00:29:47.260 features a
00:29:48.540 god
00:29:49.260 who confronts
00:29:50.600 a reptilian
00:29:51.660 monster
00:29:53.160 and makes
00:29:54.160 the world
00:29:54.860 as a consequence
00:29:55.980 of the conflict
00:29:56.780 he faces her
00:29:58.460 she's terrifying
00:29:59.200 he cuts her up
00:29:59.800 into pieces
00:30:00.280 and out of the
00:30:00.700 pieces he makes
00:30:01.260 the world
00:30:01.640 now the Mesopotamians
00:30:03.520 5,000 years ago
00:30:05.020 were trying to
00:30:06.200 figure out
00:30:06.620 what the nature
00:30:07.360 of individuality
00:30:08.300 was
00:30:08.620 and what the
00:30:09.160 nature of
00:30:09.520 consciousness
00:30:09.920 was
00:30:10.400 and their
00:30:11.080 presupposition
00:30:11.780 which was
00:30:12.220 dramatized
00:30:13.200 because these
00:30:13.820 people told
00:30:14.320 stories
00:30:14.660 they didn't
00:30:15.020 think the
00:30:15.400 way we
00:30:15.740 think
00:30:16.040 in explicit
00:30:17.720 philosophical
00:30:18.740 logical
00:30:19.800 with philosophical
00:30:22.520 processes
00:30:23.240 they thought
00:30:23.920 in stories
00:30:24.560 which is a
00:30:25.140 natural way
00:30:25.680 for people
00:30:26.040 to think
00:30:26.420 they came
00:30:27.680 to the
00:30:27.940 conclusion
00:30:28.340 that the
00:30:28.840 object
00:30:29.160 of their
00:30:29.520 ultimate
00:30:29.860 worship
00:30:30.480 was the
00:30:31.340 god
00:30:31.560 who
00:30:31.720 confronted
00:30:32.160 the
00:30:32.520 dragon
00:30:33.020 of
00:30:33.220 chaos
00:30:33.620 cut it
00:30:34.200 into pieces
00:30:34.760 and made
00:30:35.480 the world
00:30:35.960 and that
00:30:37.400 idea
00:30:37.780 has echoed
00:30:38.500 down
00:30:38.720 through the
00:30:39.140 ages
00:30:39.400 it's an
00:30:39.760 idea
00:30:39.960 that human
00:30:40.300 beings
00:30:40.580 have never
00:30:40.940 lost
00:30:41.300 now this
00:30:41.860 idea
00:30:42.100 is very
00:30:42.400 interesting
00:30:42.800 so
00:30:43.020 you see
00:30:43.640 the castle
00:30:44.220 in the
00:30:44.500 background
00:30:44.800 and we
00:30:45.060 already
00:30:45.200 know
00:30:45.320 what
00:30:45.440 the castle
00:30:45.840 stands
00:30:46.260 for
00:30:46.440 the castle
00:30:46.860 stands
00:30:47.220 for
00:30:47.400 order
00:30:47.760 and it's
00:30:48.560 a multi-walled
00:30:49.400 castle
00:30:49.800 because everyone
00:30:50.440 is protected
00:30:50.960 by multiple
00:30:51.560 walls
00:30:51.860 but those
00:30:52.540 walls
00:30:52.860 are constantly
00:30:53.620 breached
00:30:54.420 now young
00:30:55.500 people
00:30:55.820 especially
00:30:56.240 modern
00:30:56.640 young
00:30:56.880 people
00:30:57.140 are often
00:30:57.780 very cynical
00:30:58.400 about the
00:30:58.900 traditions
00:30:59.240 that they
00:30:59.600 inhabit
00:30:59.980 they're cynical
00:31:01.040 about them
00:31:01.460 because they
00:31:01.880 see the
00:31:02.260 fact that the
00:31:02.740 world is
00:31:03.200 theoretically
00:31:03.680 devolving
00:31:04.340 into some
00:31:04.760 kind of
00:31:05.100 environmental
00:31:05.520 catastrophe
00:31:06.100 and they're
00:31:06.460 cynical
00:31:06.700 because they're
00:31:07.260 still
00:31:07.500 war
00:31:07.780 and because
00:31:08.120 there's
00:31:08.320 still
00:31:08.520 hunger
00:31:08.860 they're
00:31:09.580 cynical
00:31:09.880 because
00:31:10.240 often
00:31:10.600 the people
00:31:11.000 who are
00:31:11.200 teaching
00:31:11.500 them
00:31:11.660 the
00:31:11.800 traditions
00:31:12.200 don't
00:31:12.500 seem
00:31:12.680 to believe
00:31:13.060 in them
00:31:13.280 themselves
00:31:13.760 and it's
00:31:14.560 very easy
00:31:15.260 for young
00:31:16.700 people to
00:31:17.180 look at
00:31:17.620 the traditions
00:31:18.240 that were
00:31:18.740 and to
00:31:19.400 notice
00:31:19.820 the breaks
00:31:20.680 but the
00:31:21.680 truth of the
00:31:22.120 matter is
00:31:22.640 is that
00:31:22.920 throughout
00:31:23.140 human
00:31:23.440 history
00:31:23.820 tradition
00:31:24.220 has always
00:31:24.680 been
00:31:24.940 anachronistic
00:31:25.780 and out
00:31:26.120 of date
00:31:26.520 and what
00:31:27.240 you see
00:31:27.540 in images
00:31:27.900 of st
00:31:28.300 george
00:31:28.580 and the
00:31:28.800 dragon
00:31:29.140 is that
00:31:29.500 the
00:31:29.640 dragons
00:31:29.980 always
00:31:30.300 breached
00:31:30.640 the
00:31:30.820 walls
00:31:31.200 which
00:31:31.920 means
00:31:32.160 that
00:31:32.360 tradition
00:31:32.720 is
00:31:32.960 always
00:31:33.240 under
00:31:33.540 attack
00:31:33.900 from
00:31:34.160 chaos
00:31:34.700 well
00:31:35.960 of course
00:31:36.360 it
00:31:36.520 is
00:31:36.720 because
00:31:37.100 the
00:31:37.260 future
00:31:37.540 is
00:31:37.660 different
00:31:37.940 than
00:31:38.120 the
00:31:38.280 past
00:31:38.720 but
00:31:39.420 that
00:31:39.560 doesn't
00:31:39.780 mean
00:31:39.940 that
00:31:40.060 the
00:31:40.180 past
00:31:40.400 should
00:31:40.580 be
00:31:40.720 abandoned
00:31:41.200 because
00:31:41.800 if
00:31:41.980 you
00:31:42.080 abandon
00:31:42.460 the
00:31:42.680 past
00:31:42.960 and
00:31:43.120 you
00:31:43.240 knock
00:31:43.440 down
00:31:43.620 all
00:31:43.800 your
00:31:43.960 walls
00:31:44.360 you
00:31:45.040 fall
00:31:45.480 into
00:31:45.720 a pit
00:31:46.100 of
00:31:46.260 chaos
00:31:46.720 and
00:31:47.140 that
00:31:47.400 classically
00:31:47.960 speaking
00:31:48.400 is
00:31:48.580 indistinguishable
00:31:49.360 from hell
00:31:51.160 and I can
00:31:52.160 tell you
00:31:52.560 that if
00:31:52.900 you spend
00:31:53.320 long enough
00:31:53.900 in that
00:31:54.200 state
00:31:54.560 you'll
00:31:55.060 become
00:31:55.320 bitter
00:31:55.740 and
00:31:56.060 cruel
00:31:56.460 because
00:31:57.260 that's
00:31:57.600 what
00:31:57.720 happens
00:31:58.060 to
00:31:58.200 people
00:31:58.440 who
00:31:58.620 suffer
00:31:59.000 endlessly
00:31:59.540 St.
00:32:01.340 George
00:32:01.580 is a
00:32:01.860 different
00:32:02.120 kind
00:32:02.400 of
00:32:02.520 individual
00:32:02.980 when
00:32:03.260 the
00:32:03.400 walls
00:32:03.720 come
00:32:04.000 crumbling
00:32:04.760 down
00:32:05.200 as
00:32:05.600 they
00:32:05.800 always
00:32:06.120 do
00:32:06.380 he
00:32:06.820 decides
00:32:07.160 to
00:32:07.300 go
00:32:07.420 out
00:32:07.580 and
00:32:07.740 to
00:32:07.880 confront
00:32:08.300 the
00:32:08.540 dragon
00:32:08.900 now
00:32:09.700 dragons
00:32:10.060 are
00:32:10.220 very
00:32:10.400 strange
00:32:10.740 creatures
00:32:11.160 as
00:32:11.420 you
00:32:11.560 may
00:32:11.700 have
00:32:11.820 already
00:32:12.100 noted
00:32:12.440 first
00:32:12.900 of
00:32:13.020 all
00:32:13.100 they
00:32:13.220 don't
00:32:13.420 exist
00:32:13.900 second
00:32:15.460 of
00:32:15.620 all
00:32:15.720 they
00:32:15.840 have
00:32:15.980 very
00:32:16.240 weird
00:32:16.580 propensities
00:32:17.320 so
00:32:17.760 for
00:32:17.940 example
00:32:18.320 they
00:32:18.540 hoard
00:32:18.840 gold
00:32:19.300 and
00:32:20.220 they
00:32:20.340 tend
00:32:20.540 to
00:32:20.680 trap
00:32:20.940 virgins
00:32:21.400 in
00:32:21.600 their
00:32:21.780 lair
00:32:22.200 which
00:32:22.740 you
00:32:23.100 will
00:32:23.260 also
00:32:23.560 admit
00:32:23.840 is
00:32:23.960 very
00:32:24.160 strange
00:32:24.440 behavior
00:32:24.860 for
00:32:25.060 a
00:32:25.220 reptile
00:32:25.780 now
00:32:28.020 the
00:32:28.160 idea
00:32:28.500 behind
00:32:28.980 this
00:32:29.220 is
00:32:35.600 you
00:32:35.760 look
00:32:35.940 to
00:32:36.080 the
00:32:36.200 right
00:32:36.360 of
00:32:36.440 the
00:32:36.520 picture
00:32:36.760 you
00:32:36.920 can
00:32:37.040 see
00:32:37.180 that
00:32:37.320 there's
00:32:37.520 a
00:32:37.640 cave
00:32:37.940 the
00:32:38.280 cave
00:32:38.480 goes
00:32:38.760 way
00:32:39.140 down
00:32:39.420 into
00:32:39.640 the
00:32:39.800 ground
00:32:40.120 and
00:32:40.280 way
00:32:40.500 down
00:32:40.700 into
00:32:40.860 the
00:32:40.980 ground
00:32:41.180 is
00:32:41.340 the
00:32:41.520 terrifying
00:32:41.940 place
00:32:42.460 that's
00:32:42.920 underneath
00:32:43.300 everything
00:32:43.940 the dragon
00:32:44.680 crawls out
00:32:45.340 from time
00:32:45.740 to time
00:32:46.080 to threaten
00:32:46.580 the structure
00:32:47.100 of everything
00:32:47.640 that's
00:32:47.940 known
00:32:48.240 St.
00:32:48.880 George
00:32:49.100 comes
00:32:49.380 out
00:32:49.540 to
00:32:49.680 confront
00:32:50.040 the
00:32:50.220 dragon
00:32:50.500 voluntarily
00:32:51.320 overcomes
00:32:52.600 it
00:32:52.800 and in
00:32:53.160 this
00:32:53.360 image
00:32:53.680 rescues
00:32:55.480 the
00:32:55.640 virgin
00:32:55.900 that
00:32:56.080 the
00:32:56.220 dragon
00:32:56.500 has
00:32:56.700 been
00:32:56.980 guarding
00:33:00.000 it's
00:33:01.360 a
00:33:01.440 very
00:33:01.580 complicated
00:33:02.040 story
00:33:02.560 it
00:33:04.220 means
00:33:04.500 that
00:33:04.720 the
00:33:04.880 things
00:33:05.140 that
00:33:05.300 terrify
00:33:05.720 you
00:33:05.920 contain
00:33:06.260 things
00:33:06.580 of
00:33:06.740 value
00:33:07.100 that's
00:33:07.980 also
00:33:08.200 what
00:33:08.380 the
00:33:08.540 image
00:33:08.760 of
00:33:08.880 the
00:33:09.000 gold
00:33:09.260 that
00:33:09.420 the
00:33:09.540 dragon
00:33:09.820 horde
00:33:10.080 represents
00:33:10.740 it
00:33:11.140 means
00:33:11.320 something
00:33:11.560 else
00:33:11.880 as
00:33:12.080 well
00:33:12.420 it
00:33:13.700 means
00:33:13.980 that
00:33:14.300 the
00:33:15.300 individual
00:33:15.840 man
00:33:16.640 who's
00:33:17.100 likely
00:33:17.800 to
00:33:18.080 go
00:33:18.340 out
00:33:18.540 and
00:33:18.700 confront
00:33:19.040 chaos
00:33:19.480 when
00:33:19.740 tradition
00:33:20.120 is
00:33:20.340 crumbling
00:33:20.660 is
00:33:21.180 more
00:33:21.380 likely
00:33:21.680 to
00:33:21.940 find
00:33:22.220 a
00:33:22.400 mate
00:33:22.720 going
00:33:27.580 online
00:33:28.020 without
00:33:28.300 express
00:33:28.760 VPN
00:33:29.100 is
00:33:29.400 like
00:33:29.580 not
00:33:29.860 paying
00:33:30.100 attention
00:33:30.420 to
00:33:30.600 the
00:33:30.740 safety
00:33:30.960 demonstration
00:33:31.480 on
00:33:31.740 a
00:33:31.860 flight
00:33:32.120 most
00:33:32.860 of
00:33:32.980 the
00:33:33.060 time
00:33:33.280 you'll
00:33:33.500 probably
00:33:33.860 be
00:33:34.120 fine
00:33:34.460 but
00:33:34.860 what
00:33:35.260 if
00:33:35.400 one
00:33:35.620 day
00:33:35.820 that
00:33:36.080 weird
00:33:36.440 yellow
00:33:36.700 mask
00:33:37.040 drops
00:33:37.360 down
00:33:37.580 from
00:33:37.780 overhead
00:33:38.080 and
00:33:38.500 you
00:33:38.760 have
00:33:38.980 no
00:33:39.240 idea
00:33:39.560 what
00:33:39.760 to
00:33:39.880 do
00:33:40.080 in
00:33:40.500 our
00:33:40.640 hyper
00:33:40.920 connected
00:33:41.280 world
00:33:41.660 your
00:33:41.960 digital
00:33:42.360 privacy
00:33:42.780 isn't
00:33:43.140 just
00:33:43.320 a
00:33:43.460 luxury
00:33:43.760 it's
00:33:44.380 a
00:33:44.520 fundamental
00:33:44.980 right
00:33:45.320 every
00:33:45.640 time
00:33:45.860 you
00:33:46.000 connect
00:33:46.260 to
00:33:46.400 an
00:33:46.520 unsecured
00:33:47.040 network
00:33:47.440 in
00:33:47.620 a
00:33:47.760 cafe
00:33:48.120 hotel
00:33:48.800 or
00:33:49.040 airport
00:33:49.400 you're
00:33:49.940 essentially
00:33:50.300 broadcasting
00:33:50.920 your
00:33:59.860 tech
00:34:00.140 savvy
00:34:00.460 teenager
00:34:00.980 could
00:34:01.280 potentially
00:34:01.700 access
00:34:02.120 your
00:34:02.340 passwords
00:34:02.880 bank
00:34:03.360 logins
00:34:03.820 and
00:34:04.140 credit
00:34:04.400 card
00:34:04.620 details
00:34:05.100 now
00:34:05.680 you
00:34:05.960 might
00:34:06.160 think
00:34:06.460 what's
00:34:06.900 the
00:34:07.000 big
00:34:07.160 deal
00:34:07.420 who
00:34:07.640 want
00:34:07.880 my
00:34:08.140 data
00:34:08.420 anyway
00:34:08.780 well
00:34:09.340 on
00:34:09.540 the
00:34:09.660 dark
00:34:09.860 web
00:34:10.080 your
00:34:10.400 personal
00:34:10.800 information
00:34:11.320 could
00:34:11.600 fetch
00:34:11.820 up
00:34:11.980 to
00:34:12.120 $1,000
00:34:12.900 that's
00:34:13.960 right
00:34:14.140 there's
00:34:14.380 a
00:34:14.500 whole
00:34:14.820 underground
00:34:15.260 economy
00:34:15.740 built
00:34:16.100 on
00:34:16.340 stolen
00:34:16.740 identities
00:34:17.360 enter
00:34:18.000 expressvpn
00:34:19.140 it's
00:34:19.680 like
00:34:19.800 a
00:34:19.920 digital
00:34:20.200 fortress
00:34:20.620 creating
00:34:21.240 an
00:34:21.420 encrypted
00:34:21.780 tunnel
00:34:22.120 between
00:34:22.440 your
00:34:22.740 device
00:34:23.140 and
00:34:23.360 the
00:34:23.460 internet
00:34:23.760 their
00:34:24.300 encryption
00:34:24.640 is so
00:34:25.320 robust
00:34:25.740 that
00:34:25.980 it
00:34:26.140 would
00:34:26.240 take
00:34:26.380 a
00:34:26.520 hacker
00:34:26.780 with
00:34:26.980 a
00:34:27.120 supercomputer
00:34:27.620 over
00:34:28.140 a
00:34:28.360 billion
00:34:28.640 years
00:34:29.020 to
00:34:29.200 crack
00:34:29.460 it
00:34:29.640 but
00:34:29.960 don't
00:34:30.220 let
00:34:30.380 its
00:34:30.520 power
00:34:30.780 fool
00:34:31.040 you
00:34:31.300 expressvpn
00:34:32.280 is
00:34:32.460 incredibly
00:34:32.960 user
00:34:33.340 friendly
00:34:33.640 with
00:34:34.060 just
00:34:34.340 one
00:34:34.580 click
00:34:34.880 you're
00:34:35.080 protected
00:34:35.420 across
00:34:35.820 all
00:34:36.140 your
00:34:36.280 devices
00:34:36.680 phones
00:34:37.320 laptops
00:34:37.860 tablets
00:34:38.340 you
00:34:38.720 name
00:34:38.960 it
00:34:39.100 that's
00:34:39.400 why
00:34:39.520 I
00:34:39.760 use
00:34:39.940 expressvpn
00:34:40.760 whenever
00:34:41.000 I'm
00:34:41.280 traveling
00:34:41.680 or
00:34:42.040 working
00:34:42.400 from
00:34:42.600 a
00:34:42.700 coffee
00:34:42.920 shop
00:34:43.200 it
00:34:43.400 gives
00:34:43.620 me
00:34:43.740 peace
00:34:43.980 of
00:34:44.120 mind
00:34:44.360 knowing
00:34:44.620 that
00:34:44.800 my
00:34:44.960 research
00:34:45.520 communications
00:34:46.240 and
00:34:46.740 personal
00:34:47.140 data
00:34:47.440 are
00:34:47.660 shielded
00:34:48.140 from
00:34:48.320 prying
00:34:48.680 eyes
00:34:49.060 secure
00:34:49.540 your
00:34:49.800 online
00:34:50.100 data
00:34:50.420 today
00:34:50.840 by
00:34:51.080 visiting
00:34:51.460 expressvpn.com
00:34:52.920 slash
00:34:53.280 jordan
00:34:53.660 that's
00:34:54.380 expressvpn.com
00:34:57.140 slash
00:34:57.480 jordan
00:34:57.800 and you
00:34:58.160 can get
00:34:58.440 an extra
00:34:58.840 three
00:34:59.160 months
00:34:59.440 free
00:34:59.760 expressvpn.com
00:35:01.580 slash
00:35:01.960 jordan
00:35:02.340 starting a
00:35:06.800 business can
00:35:07.300 be tough
00:35:07.760 but thanks
00:35:08.380 to
00:35:08.540 Shopify
00:35:08.880 running
00:35:09.400 your
00:35:09.600 online
00:35:09.920 storefront
00:35:10.440 is easier
00:35:11.160 than ever
00:35:11.640 Shopify
00:35:12.360 is the
00:35:12.980 global
00:35:13.360 commerce
00:35:13.740 platform
00:35:14.140 that helps
00:35:14.580 you sell
00:35:14.900 out
00:35:15.060 every
00:35:15.360 stage
00:35:15.660 of
00:35:15.780 your
00:35:15.880 business
00:35:16.260 from
00:35:16.740 the
00:35:16.920 launch
00:35:17.200 your
00:35:17.340 online
00:35:17.620 shop
00:35:17.920 stage
00:35:18.320 all
00:35:18.560 the
00:35:18.640 way
00:35:18.760 to
00:35:18.880 the
00:35:19.020 did
00:35:19.200 we
00:35:19.340 just
00:35:19.640 hit
00:35:19.820 a
00:35:19.940 million
00:35:20.120 orders
00:35:20.540 stage
00:35:20.980 Shopify
00:35:21.620 is here
00:35:22.100 to help
00:35:22.520 you
00:35:22.660 grow
00:35:23.000 our
00:35:23.640 marketing
00:35:23.940 team
00:35:24.260 uses
00:35:24.520 Shopify
00:35:24.860 every
00:35:25.300 day
00:35:25.500 to sell
00:35:25.860 our
00:35:25.980 merchandise
00:35:26.300 and
00:35:26.760 we
00:35:27.000 love
00:35:27.300 how
00:35:27.460 easy
00:35:27.680 it
00:35:27.820 is
00:35:27.940 to
00:35:28.060 add
00:35:28.240 more
00:35:28.420 items
00:35:28.840 ship
00:35:29.360 products
00:35:29.800 and
00:35:29.980 track
00:35:30.260 conversions
00:35:30.780 with
00:35:31.600 Shopify
00:35:31.960 customize
00:35:32.520 your
00:35:32.820 online
00:35:33.080 store
00:35:33.400 to
00:35:33.600 your
00:35:33.900 style
00:35:34.320 with
00:35:34.600 flexible
00:35:35.000 templates
00:35:35.440 and
00:35:35.720 powerful
00:35:36.040 tools
00:35:36.480 alongside
00:35:37.100 an
00:35:37.460 endless
00:35:45.360 internet
00:35:45.700 best
00:35:46.160 converting
00:35:46.600 checkout
00:35:47.000 up
00:35:47.460 to
00:35:47.600 36%
00:35:48.360 better
00:35:48.660 compared
00:35:48.960 to
00:35:49.160 other
00:35:49.400 leading
00:35:49.740 e-commerce
00:35:50.200 platforms
00:35:50.840 no matter
00:35:51.680 how big
00:35:52.120 you want
00:35:52.360 to grow
00:35:52.760 Shopify
00:35:53.240 gives you
00:35:53.720 everything
00:35:54.040 you need
00:35:54.460 to take
00:35:54.820 control
00:35:55.220 and take
00:35:55.780 your
00:35:55.920 business
00:35:56.220 to the
00:35:56.560 next
00:35:56.800 level
00:35:57.140 sign up
00:35:58.120 for a
00:35:58.420 $1 per
00:35:59.020 month
00:35:59.160 trial
00:35:59.440 period
00:35:59.780 at
00:36:00.060 shopify.com
00:36:01.100 slash
00:36:01.460 jbp
00:36:02.240 all
00:36:02.680 lowercase
00:36:03.300 go to
00:36:04.060 shopify.com
00:36:04.940 slash
00:36:05.260 jbp
00:36:05.800 now to
00:36:06.320 grow your
00:36:06.740 business
00:36:07.140 no matter
00:36:07.840 what stage
00:36:08.360 you're
00:36:08.520 in
00:36:08.760 that's
00:36:09.400 shopify.com
00:36:10.380 slash
00:36:10.740 jbp
00:36:11.460 in today's
00:36:15.660 chaotic
00:36:16.040 world
00:36:16.460 many of
00:36:16.980 us are
00:36:17.240 searching
00:36:17.520 for a
00:36:17.860 way to
00:36:18.140 aim
00:36:18.380 higher
00:36:18.740 and find
00:36:19.280 spiritual
00:36:19.760 peace
00:36:20.220 but
00:36:20.860 here's
00:36:21.180 the thing
00:36:21.540 prayer
00:36:22.160 the most
00:36:22.620 common
00:36:22.960 tool
00:36:23.180 we have
00:36:23.700 isn't
00:36:24.040 just
00:36:24.220 about
00:36:24.440 saying
00:36:24.720 whatever
00:36:25.000 comes
00:36:25.320 to
00:36:25.460 mind
00:36:25.720 it's
00:36:26.280 a
00:36:26.400 skill
00:36:26.700 that
00:36:26.980 needs
00:36:27.240 to
00:36:27.380 be
00:36:27.520 developed
00:36:27.940 that's
00:36:28.760 where
00:36:28.920 hallo
00:36:29.240 comes
00:36:29.560 in
00:36:29.820 as
00:36:30.280 the
00:36:30.420 number
00:36:30.580 one
00:36:30.820 prayer
00:36:31.080 and
00:36:31.220 meditation
00:36:31.640 app
00:36:32.020 hallo
00:36:32.400 is
00:36:32.600 launching
00:36:32.920 an
00:36:33.140 exceptional
00:36:33.580 new
00:36:33.960 series
00:36:34.280 called
00:36:34.680 how
00:36:35.060 to
00:36:35.260 pray
00:36:35.560 imagine
00:36:36.480 learning
00:36:36.840 how
00:36:37.020 to
00:36:37.120 use
00:36:37.300 scripture
00:36:37.660 as
00:36:37.940 a
00:36:38.080 launch
00:36:38.340 pad
00:36:38.580 for
00:36:38.760 profound
00:36:39.320 conversations
00:36:39.960 with
00:36:40.260 God
00:36:40.580 how
00:36:41.200 to
00:36:41.340 properly
00:36:41.740 enter
00:36:42.160 into
00:36:42.460 imaginative
00:36:43.080 prayer
00:36:43.400 and
00:36:44.200 how
00:36:44.360 to
00:36:44.500 incorporate
00:36:44.880 prayers
00:36:45.460 reaching
00:36:45.820 far
00:36:46.200 back
00:36:46.540 in
00:36:46.700 church
00:36:46.920 history
00:36:47.320 this
00:36:48.240 isn't
00:36:48.460 your
00:36:48.600 average
00:36:48.920 guided
00:36:49.240 meditation
00:36:49.720 it's
00:36:50.400 a
00:36:50.520 comprehensive
00:36:51.080 two-week
00:36:51.640 journey
00:36:51.940 into
00:36:52.240 the
00:36:52.440 heart
00:36:52.700 of
00:36:52.900 prayer
00:36:53.220 led
00:36:53.780 by
00:36:53.960 some
00:36:54.140 of
00:36:54.240 the
00:36:54.340 most
00:36:54.520 respected
00:36:55.100 spiritual
00:36:55.620 leaders
00:36:55.980 of
00:36:56.240 our
00:36:56.380 time
00:36:56.740 from
00:36:57.340 guests
00:36:57.680 including
00:36:58.080 Bishop
00:36:58.440 Robert
00:36:58.740 Barron
00:36:59.160 Father
00:36:59.700 Mike
00:36:59.960 Schmitz
00:37:00.380 and
00:37:00.640 Jonathan
00:37:01.040 Rumi
00:37:01.360 known
00:37:01.960 for
00:37:02.120 his
00:37:02.280 role
00:37:02.500 as
00:37:07.940 while
00:37:08.180 equipping
00:37:08.500 yourself
00:37:08.900 with
00:37:09.060 the
00:37:09.180 tools
00:37:09.440 needed
00:37:09.680 to
00:37:09.880 face
00:37:10.140 life's
00:37:10.560 challenges
00:37:10.900 with
00:37:11.320 renewed
00:37:11.700 strength
00:37:12.280 ready
00:37:12.920 to
00:37:13.140 revolutionize
00:37:13.840 your
00:37:14.080 prayer
00:37:14.320 life
00:37:14.680 you can
00:37:15.280 check out
00:37:15.600 the
00:37:15.740 new
00:37:15.940 series
00:37:16.360 as well
00:37:16.820 as an
00:37:17.040 extensive
00:37:17.420 catalog
00:37:17.900 of
00:37:18.180 guided
00:37:18.440 prayers
00:37:18.860 when
00:37:19.220 you
00:37:19.360 download
00:37:19.760 the
00:37:20.020 hallo
00:37:20.300 app
00:37:20.640 just
00:37:21.320 go to
00:37:21.660 hallo.com
00:37:22.520 slash
00:37:22.900 Jordan
00:37:23.220 and
00:37:23.460 download
00:37:23.740 the
00:37:23.920 hallo
00:37:24.160 app
00:37:24.320 today
00:37:24.660 for
00:37:24.920 an
00:37:25.040 exclusive
00:37:25.480 three-month
00:37:26.080 trial
00:37:26.460 that's
00:37:27.160 hallo.com
00:37:27.940 slash
00:37:28.320 Jordan
00:37:28.720 elevate
00:37:29.540 your
00:37:29.920 prayer
00:37:30.200 life
00:37:30.500 today
00:37:30.900 this
00:37:36.260 is
00:37:36.420 Jonah
00:37:36.900 had a
00:37:39.280 very
00:37:39.440 weird
00:37:39.700 experience
00:37:40.240 he was
00:37:40.540 swallowed
00:37:40.760 by
00:37:40.980 a
00:37:41.160 whale
00:37:41.420 that's
00:37:44.360 a
00:37:44.480 very
00:37:44.640 strange
00:37:44.980 whale
00:37:45.280 as
00:37:45.540 you
00:37:45.740 might
00:37:46.460 well
00:37:46.780 note
00:37:47.160 it's
00:37:47.520 a
00:37:47.620 medieval
00:37:47.900 whale
00:37:48.220 and
00:37:48.420 of
00:37:48.540 course
00:37:48.720 medieval
00:37:49.060 people
00:37:49.380 didn't
00:37:49.600 really
00:37:49.780 know
00:37:49.940 what
00:37:50.140 whales
00:37:50.420 were
00:37:50.720 and
00:37:50.940 so
00:37:51.080 they
00:37:51.240 were
00:37:51.480 guessing
00:37:52.080 what
00:37:52.320 a
00:37:52.420 whale
00:37:52.560 was
00:37:52.840 and
00:37:52.980 so
00:37:53.440 a
00:37:53.600 whale
00:37:53.780 for
00:37:53.960 a
00:37:54.060 medieval
00:37:54.340 person
00:37:54.740 would
00:37:54.920 have
00:37:55.000 been
00:37:55.200 a
00:37:55.760 big
00:37:55.920 fish
00:37:56.400 would
00:37:57.280 have
00:37:57.360 been
00:37:57.460 a
00:37:57.620 squid
00:37:58.080 it
00:37:58.540 would
00:37:58.640 have
00:37:58.700 been
00:37:58.820 some
00:37:59.040 monstrous
00:37:59.560 thing
00:37:59.740 like
00:37:59.900 a
00:38:00.040 shark
00:38:06.900 weren't
00:38:07.280 that
00:38:07.500 good
00:38:07.800 so
00:38:08.500 the
00:38:08.620 whale
00:38:08.800 for
00:38:08.960 them
00:38:09.140 was
00:38:09.340 what
00:38:09.620 lurks
00:38:10.060 underneath
00:38:10.580 in
00:38:11.000 the
00:38:11.180 darkness
00:38:11.660 right
00:38:12.120 and
00:38:12.940 the
00:38:13.040 idea
00:38:13.300 with
00:38:13.500 Jonah
00:38:13.740 was
00:38:13.980 that
00:38:14.120 now
00:38:14.340 and
00:38:14.460 then
00:38:14.620 what
00:38:14.880 lurks
00:38:15.220 underneath
00:38:15.620 in
00:38:15.820 the
00:38:15.940 darkness
00:38:16.260 rises
00:38:16.640 up
00:38:16.860 to
00:38:17.020 swallow
00:38:17.320 you
00:38:17.620 but
00:38:18.700 if
00:38:18.800 your
00:38:18.900 attitude
00:38:19.160 is
00:38:19.380 proper
00:38:19.660 then
00:38:19.860 you
00:38:19.980 can
00:38:20.120 come
00:38:20.280 back
00:38:20.500 out
00:38:20.620 the
00:38:20.760 other
00:38:20.940 side
00:38:21.200 changed
00:38:21.780 now
00:38:22.840 that's
00:38:23.080 a
00:38:23.200 story
00:38:23.440 of
00:38:23.580 redemption
00:38:23.980 so
00:38:24.280 for
00:38:24.460 example
00:38:24.840 imagine
00:38:28.960 that
00:38:29.120 you
00:38:29.240 were
00:38:29.680 in
00:38:29.800 a
00:38:29.920 bad
00:38:30.180 relationship
00:38:30.760 and
00:38:32.220 maybe
00:38:32.400 you
00:38:32.500 weren't
00:38:32.640 that
00:38:32.840 happy
00:38:33.220 about
00:38:33.460 it
00:38:33.560 but
00:38:33.660 you
00:38:33.840 know
00:38:33.940 it
00:38:34.080 was
00:38:34.180 better
00:38:34.400 than
00:38:34.560 no
00:38:34.720 relationship
00:38:35.160 at
00:38:35.360 all
00:38:35.680 and
00:38:36.740 then
00:38:36.860 the
00:38:37.000 person
00:38:37.240 that
00:38:37.380 you
00:38:37.480 were
00:38:37.540 in
00:38:37.600 a
00:38:37.680 relationship
00:38:38.080 betrayed
00:38:38.500 you
00:38:38.860 and
00:38:39.160 maybe
00:38:39.320 they
00:38:39.460 did
00:38:39.620 that
00:38:39.800 because
00:38:40.020 you
00:38:40.200 actually
00:38:40.480 weren't
00:38:40.680 that
00:38:40.860 happy
00:38:41.100 with
00:38:41.240 the
00:38:41.340 relationship
00:38:41.680 anyways
00:38:42.180 maybe
00:38:42.760 they
00:38:42.880 did
00:38:43.040 that
00:38:43.220 because
00:38:43.440 you
00:38:43.540 were
00:38:43.580 a
00:38:43.620 little
00:38:45.840 bit
00:38:46.180 too
00:38:46.340 easy
00:38:46.540 to
00:38:46.660 get
00:38:46.780 along
00:38:47.060 with
00:38:47.260 and
00:38:47.380 as
00:38:47.520 a
00:38:47.620 consequence
00:38:47.900 a
00:38:48.100 little
00:38:48.200 bit
00:38:48.340 on
00:38:48.480 the
00:38:48.600 boring
00:38:48.940 side
00:38:49.420 and
00:38:50.700 so
00:38:50.840 when
00:38:51.000 they
00:38:51.140 first
00:38:51.340 leave
00:38:51.580 you
00:38:51.700 it
00:38:51.820 a
00:38:51.940 catastrophe
00:38:52.420 because
00:38:52.780 your
00:38:52.980 world
00:38:53.180 falls
00:38:53.460 apart
00:38:53.800 but
00:38:54.600 when
00:38:54.760 your
00:38:54.920 world
00:38:55.140 falls
00:38:55.400 apart
00:38:55.660 you're
00:38:55.900 somewhere
00:38:56.200 new
00:38:56.600 it's
00:38:57.560 possible
00:38:57.880 to
00:38:58.100 learn
00:38:58.400 something
00:38:58.800 new
00:38:59.040 in
00:38:59.160 that
00:38:59.340 place
00:38:59.700 so
00:39:00.000 you
00:39:00.100 might
00:39:00.240 learn
00:39:00.440 for
00:39:00.560 example
00:39:00.900 that
00:39:01.120 you
00:39:01.260 should
00:39:01.400 be
00:39:01.480 a
00:39:01.580 little
00:39:01.680 sharper
00:39:02.080 the
00:39:02.260 next
00:39:02.460 time
00:39:02.620 that
00:39:02.720 you
00:39:02.820 go
00:39:03.000 out
00:39:03.160 with
00:39:03.300 someone
00:39:03.580 or
00:39:04.080 you
00:39:04.240 should
00:39:04.400 be
00:39:04.500 a
00:39:04.600 little
00:39:04.680 bit
00:39:04.840 more
00:39:05.060 careful
00:39:05.560 about
00:39:06.560 picking
00:39:06.920 up
00:39:07.160 on
00:39:07.320 clues
00:39:07.560 that
00:39:07.720 your
00:39:07.840 partners
00:39:08.180 bored
00:39:08.580 with
00:39:08.800 you
00:39:09.020 or
00:39:09.440 that
00:39:09.580 maybe
00:39:09.800 you
00:39:09.960 should
00:39:10.120 stop
00:39:10.520 associating
00:39:11.440 with
00:39:11.600 lying
00:39:11.880 psychopaths
00:39:12.760 and
00:39:13.160 your
00:39:13.420 life
00:39:13.980 would
00:39:14.140 be
00:39:14.280 a
00:39:14.420 lot
00:39:14.580 more
00:39:14.820 positive
00:39:15.320 and
00:39:16.000 stop
00:39:16.320 thinking
00:39:16.660 that
00:39:16.840 you
00:39:16.960 have
00:39:17.140 the
00:39:17.240 capacity
00:39:17.620 to
00:39:17.880 redeem
00:39:18.500 somebody
00:39:18.880 that
00:39:19.100 is
00:39:19.780 not
00:39:20.480 after
00:39:20.840 redemption
00:39:21.240 in the
00:39:21.600 least
00:39:21.880 and
00:39:23.220 what
00:39:23.340 that
00:39:23.500 means
00:39:23.740 now
00:39:23.960 and
00:39:24.060 then
00:39:24.200 is
00:39:24.340 that
00:39:24.500 when
00:39:24.680 you
00:39:24.840 fall
00:39:25.460 into
00:39:25.680 the
00:39:25.880 belly
00:39:26.180 of
00:39:26.360 a
00:39:26.480 whale
00:39:26.720 and
00:39:26.940 you're
00:39:27.120 swallowed
00:39:27.480 up
00:39:27.800 by
00:39:27.980 something
00:39:28.360 that
00:39:28.560 lurks
00:39:28.900 underneath
00:39:29.400 that
00:39:30.400 you
00:39:30.580 can
00:39:30.720 come
00:39:30.920 out
00:39:31.120 the
00:39:31.320 side
00:39:31.760 transformed
00:39:32.440 and
00:39:33.040 that's
00:39:33.420 actually
00:39:33.820 how
00:39:34.060 people
00:39:34.420 learn
00:39:34.840 every
00:39:35.960 time
00:39:36.240 you
00:39:36.400 learn
00:39:36.640 something
00:39:37.040 you
00:39:37.420 learn
00:39:37.660 because
00:39:37.960 something
00:39:38.480 you
00:39:38.920 did
00:39:39.180 didn't
00:39:39.500 work
00:39:39.760 and
00:39:40.100 that
00:39:40.280 exposes
00:39:40.820 you
00:39:41.020 to
00:39:41.160 the
00:39:41.280 part
00:39:41.440 of
00:39:41.520 the
00:39:41.580 world
00:39:41.740 that
00:39:41.860 you
00:39:41.960 don't
00:39:42.160 understand
00:39:42.780 every
00:39:43.560 time
00:39:43.820 you're
00:39:44.020 exposed
00:39:44.360 to
00:39:44.540 part
00:39:44.780 of
00:39:44.860 the
00:39:44.920 world
00:39:45.080 that
00:39:45.200 you
00:39:45.300 don't
00:39:45.480 understand
00:39:45.900 you
00:39:46.320 have
00:39:46.540 the
00:39:46.720 possibility
00:39:47.520 of
00:39:48.320 rebuilding
00:39:48.780 the
00:39:49.020 structures
00:39:49.380 that
00:39:49.620 you
00:39:49.780 use
00:39:50.020 to
00:39:50.180 interpret
00:39:50.500 the
00:39:50.700 world
00:39:51.020 that's
00:39:52.240 often
00:39:52.500 why
00:39:52.680 it's
00:39:52.840 more
00:39:53.000 important
00:39:53.340 to
00:39:53.560 notice
00:39:53.940 that
00:39:54.220 you're
00:40:02.440 people
00:40:02.540 that
00:40:02.700 annoy
00:40:03.040 you
00:40:03.300 on
00:40:03.620 the
00:40:03.760 off
00:40:04.040 chance
00:40:04.400 that
00:40:04.620 they
00:40:04.840 know
00:40:05.100 something
00:40:05.560 that
00:40:05.920 if
00:40:06.340 they
00:40:06.540 tell
00:40:06.820 you
00:40:07.040 you
00:40:07.420 can
00:40:07.640 use
00:40:08.000 instead
00:40:08.480 of
00:40:08.720 dying
00:40:09.240 talking
00:40:12.020 to
00:40:12.240 people
00:40:12.480 who
00:40:12.640 agree
00:40:12.880 with
00:40:13.080 what
00:40:13.240 you
00:40:13.400 say
00:40:13.700 is
00:40:14.340 like
00:40:14.540 walking
00:40:14.860 around
00:40:15.160 in
00:40:15.320 a
00:40:15.480 desert
00:40:15.840 you
00:40:16.520 already
00:40:16.820 know
00:40:17.180 everything
00:40:17.760 that
00:40:18.040 they
00:40:18.220 say
00:40:18.560 the
00:40:19.120 reason
00:40:19.380 you're
00:40:19.560 associating
00:40:20.160 with
00:40:20.360 them
00:40:20.500 in
00:40:20.600 that
00:40:20.780 situation
00:40:21.200 is
00:40:21.400 so
00:40:21.520 that
00:40:21.640 they
00:40:21.760 never
00:40:22.080 say
00:40:22.300 anything
00:40:22.560 that
00:40:22.760 challenges
00:40:23.120 you
00:40:23.340 because
00:40:23.620 you're
00:40:23.840 afraid
00:40:24.140 that
00:40:24.300 if
00:40:24.440 you
00:40:24.540 go
00:40:24.720 outside
00:40:32.440 to
00:40:33.040 face
00:40:33.420 and
00:40:33.560 overcome
00:40:33.880 things
00:40:34.260 they
00:40:34.400 don't
00:40:34.580 understand
00:40:35.080 and
00:40:35.500 not
00:40:35.720 only
00:40:35.940 that
00:40:36.380 that's
00:40:37.080 essentially
00:40:37.500 what
00:40:37.740 gives
00:40:37.960 life
00:40:38.200 its
00:40:38.380 meaning
00:40:38.680 the
00:40:39.160 Buddhists
00:40:39.560 say
00:40:39.860 life
00:40:40.420 is
00:40:40.620 suffering
00:40:41.060 and
00:40:42.000 you
00:40:42.100 think
00:40:42.280 well
00:40:42.480 if
00:40:42.800 that's
00:40:43.080 the
00:40:43.240 case
00:40:43.520 why
00:40:44.020 bother
00:40:44.420 with
00:40:44.700 it
00:40:44.880 and
00:40:45.700 people
00:40:45.980 do
00:40:46.320 ask
00:40:46.800 that
00:40:47.040 question
00:40:47.460 and
00:40:47.640 they
00:40:47.760 ask
00:40:48.040 it
00:40:48.160 in
00:40:48.380 ways
00:40:48.720 that
00:40:48.940 result
00:40:49.300 in
00:40:49.420 their
00:40:49.540 own
00:40:49.680 destruction
00:40:50.080 and
00:40:50.620 worse
00:40:50.980 in
00:40:51.140 the
00:40:51.260 destruction
00:40:51.660 of
00:40:51.880 others
00:40:52.220 so
00:40:53.360 for
00:40:53.540 example
00:40:53.920 people
00:40:54.260 who
00:40:54.420 become
00:40:54.700 particularly
00:40:55.260 cruel
00:40:55.820 particularly
00:40:56.700 in
00:40:57.040 a
00:40:57.180 genocidal
00:40:57.740 manner
00:40:58.100 are
00:40:58.700 more
00:40:58.900 than
00:40:59.040 willing
00:40:59.280 to
00:40:59.460 dispense
00:40:59.860 with
00:41:00.020 as
00:41:00.140 many
00:41:00.340 human
00:41:00.600 beings
00:41:00.900 as
00:41:01.040 they
00:41:01.400 can
00:41:01.580 possibly
00:41:02.060 train
00:41:02.480 their
00:41:02.680 sights
00:41:02.920 on
00:41:03.100 because
00:41:03.340 they're
00:41:03.560 so
00:41:03.780 disgusted
00:41:04.500 by the
00:41:04.880 nature
00:41:05.100 of
00:41:05.240 human
00:41:05.440 limitation
00:41:05.940 that
00:41:06.440 they'd
00:41:06.700 rather
00:41:06.980 eradicate
00:41:07.720 it
00:41:07.920 and
00:41:08.900 lots
00:41:09.160 of
00:41:09.280 people
00:41:09.460 become
00:41:09.780 suicidal
00:41:10.380 because
00:41:10.860 they
00:41:11.060 can't
00:41:11.340 bear
00:41:11.480 the
00:41:11.620 conditions
00:41:12.000 of
00:41:12.180 their
00:41:12.320 own
00:41:12.480 existence
00:41:12.980 and
00:41:14.200 suffering
00:41:14.560 is
00:41:14.760 real
00:41:15.120 and
00:41:15.420 it's
00:41:15.860 inescapable
00:41:16.640 so
00:41:17.620 the
00:41:17.760 question
00:41:18.080 is
00:41:18.260 what
00:41:18.540 do
00:41:18.700 you
00:41:18.780 do
00:41:18.960 about
00:41:19.220 it
00:41:19.460 you
00:41:21.220 notice
00:41:21.480 in
00:41:21.660 your
00:41:21.780 own
00:41:21.940 life
00:41:22.200 and
00:41:22.340 you
00:41:22.600 can
00:41:22.740 do
00:41:22.860 this
00:41:23.060 by
00:41:23.240 watching
00:41:23.780 your
00:41:24.040 own
00:41:24.240 life
00:41:24.560 and
00:41:24.920 I
00:41:25.000 often
00:41:25.240 ask
00:41:25.460 my
00:41:25.620 clients
00:41:25.960 to
00:41:26.140 do
00:41:26.280 this
00:41:26.560 say
00:41:27.080 look
00:41:27.340 watch
00:41:28.340 your
00:41:28.540 life
00:41:28.800 for
00:41:28.960 a
00:41:29.120 week
00:41:29.380 and
00:41:30.580 pretend
00:41:30.780 you
00:41:30.960 don't
00:41:31.100 know
00:41:31.200 who
00:41:31.340 you
00:41:31.480 are
00:41:31.700 because
00:41:32.060 you
00:41:32.280 don't
00:41:32.580 know
00:41:32.760 who
00:41:32.920 you
00:41:33.080 are
00:41:33.300 at
00:41:33.680 all
00:41:34.080 what
00:41:35.880 you
00:41:36.100 understand
00:41:36.540 most
00:41:36.840 about
00:41:37.080 yourself
00:41:37.400 are
00:41:37.680 the
00:41:37.840 arbitrary
00:41:38.340 presuppositions
00:41:39.280 that
00:41:39.500 you
00:41:39.640 use
00:41:39.880 to
00:41:40.020 hem
00:41:40.240 yourself
00:41:40.660 in
00:41:40.940 and
00:41:42.360 you
00:41:42.480 act
00:41:42.780 as
00:41:42.920 if
00:41:43.060 presuppositions
00:41:43.920 are
00:41:44.100 true
00:41:44.400 so
00:41:44.880 that
00:41:45.120 the
00:41:46.560 revelation
00:41:46.960 of
00:41:47.440 the
00:41:47.620 full
00:41:47.860 nature
00:41:48.160 of
00:41:48.360 your
00:41:48.500 character
00:41:48.880 won't
00:41:49.240 terrify
00:41:49.720 you
00:41:50.040 people
00:41:51.040 hide
00:41:51.420 in
00:41:51.600 their
00:41:51.740 own
00:41:51.960 boxes
00:41:52.400 and
00:41:53.060 it's
00:41:53.240 not
00:41:53.440 surprising
00:41:53.920 but
00:41:54.440 it's
00:41:54.600 not
00:41:54.900 a
00:41:55.020 good
00:41:55.160 idea
00:41:55.520 because
00:41:56.000 life
00:41:56.320 is
00:41:56.460 too
00:41:56.620 hard
00:41:56.900 to
00:41:57.100 hide
00:41:57.340 in
00:41:57.460 a
00:41:57.560 box
00:41:57.900 you
00:41:58.480 can't
00:41:58.900 manage
00:41:59.220 it
00:41:59.340 if
00:41:59.480 you
00:41:59.580 do
00:41:59.740 that
00:42:00.040 if
00:42:01.660 you
00:42:01.760 watch
00:42:01.960 yourself
00:42:02.240 for
00:42:02.420 a
00:42:02.520 week
00:42:02.720 you'll
00:42:02.960 see
00:42:03.180 certain
00:42:03.500 things
00:42:03.760 you'll
00:42:03.940 see
00:42:04.140 some
00:42:04.800 of
00:42:04.920 the
00:42:05.000 time
00:42:05.180 that
00:42:05.320 you're
00:42:05.500 resentful
00:42:05.980 and
00:42:06.120 annoyed
00:42:06.480 and
00:42:07.040 those
00:42:07.200 are
00:42:07.280 times
00:42:07.500 when
00:42:07.680 you're
00:42:07.820 either
00:42:08.000 taking
00:42:08.300 advantage
00:42:08.740 of
00:42:08.920 yourself
00:42:09.180 or
00:42:09.380 you're
00:42:09.540 thinking
00:42:09.800 improperly
00:42:10.540 some
00:42:11.380 of
00:42:11.480 the
00:42:11.540 time
00:42:11.700 you'll
00:42:11.900 be
00:42:12.020 bored
00:42:12.560 in
00:42:13.400 which
00:42:13.560 case
00:42:13.800 you're
00:42:13.940 either
00:42:14.120 undisciplined
00:42:14.720 or
00:42:14.900 you're
00:42:15.120 probably
00:42:15.560 pursuing
00:42:16.180 something
00:42:16.600 you
00:42:16.820 don't
00:42:17.040 want
00:42:17.220 to
00:42:17.340 pursue
00:42:17.760 and
00:42:18.740 some
00:42:18.960 of
00:42:19.040 the
00:42:19.140 time
00:42:19.320 you'll
00:42:19.560 actually
00:42:19.900 be
00:42:20.140 engaged
00:42:20.640 in
00:42:20.840 life
00:42:21.220 and
00:42:22.060 the
00:42:22.180 times
00:42:22.480 that
00:42:22.640 you're
00:42:22.840 engaged
00:42:23.260 in
00:42:23.420 life
00:42:23.580 you
00:42:23.720 won't
00:42:24.020 notice
00:42:24.400 that
00:42:24.740 you're
00:42:25.120 there
00:42:25.600 right
00:42:26.440 the
00:42:26.620 distinction
00:42:35.500 from
00:42:35.620 studying
00:42:36.020 mythology
00:42:36.520 and
00:42:36.680 from
00:42:36.840 studying
00:42:37.140 psychology
00:42:37.620 for
00:42:37.880 decades
00:42:38.380 is
00:42:39.200 to
00:42:39.360 find
00:42:39.640 a
00:42:39.760 mode
00:42:39.940 of
00:42:40.060 being
00:42:40.260 that's
00:42:40.500 so
00:42:40.680 meaningful
00:42:41.060 that
00:42:41.340 the
00:42:41.520 fact
00:42:41.800 that
00:42:41.940 life
00:42:42.140 is
00:42:42.300 suffering
00:42:42.600 is
00:42:42.780 no
00:42:42.920 longer
00:42:43.180 relevant
00:42:43.600 or
00:42:44.240 maybe
00:42:44.440 that
00:42:44.640 it's
00:42:44.780 even
00:42:44.980 acceptable
00:42:45.600 and
00:42:46.740 I
00:42:46.820 would
00:42:46.940 say
00:42:47.080 as
00:42:47.220 well
00:42:47.340 that
00:42:47.480 people
00:42:47.740 know
00:42:48.200 when
00:42:48.460 they're
00:42:48.640 doing
00:42:48.920 that
00:42:49.220 you
00:42:49.900 know
00:42:50.020 when
00:42:50.160 you're
00:42:50.280 doing
00:42:50.440 that
00:42:50.580 in
00:42:50.700 part
00:42:50.860 because
00:42:51.100 you're
00:42:51.260 no
00:42:51.360 longer
00:42:51.600 resentful
00:42:52.180 you
00:42:52.380 think
00:42:52.560 jeez
00:42:52.920 I
00:42:53.060 could
00:42:53.180 do
00:42:53.300 this
00:42:53.500 forever
00:42:53.960 right
00:42:54.660 there's
00:42:54.840 a
00:42:54.960 timelessness
00:42:55.620 that's
00:42:57.080 associated
00:42:57.620 with
00:42:57.880 that
00:42:58.060 state
00:42:58.320 of
00:42:58.460 being
00:42:58.740 from
00:42:59.320 a
00:42:59.460 mythological
00:43:00.020 perspective
00:43:00.540 that's
00:43:00.880 equivalent
00:43:01.200 to
00:43:01.420 brief
00:43:01.900 habitation
00:43:02.880 of
00:43:03.100 the
00:43:03.260 kingdom
00:43:03.540 of
00:43:03.800 god
00:43:04.180 that's
00:43:05.180 the
00:43:05.280 place
00:43:05.540 where
00:43:05.720 you
00:43:05.880 are
00:43:06.060 that's
00:43:06.320 so
00:43:06.480 meaningful
00:43:06.900 that
00:43:07.160 it
00:43:07.280 enables
00:43:07.660 you
00:43:07.820 to
00:43:07.960 bear
00:43:08.220 the
00:43:08.720 harsh
00:43:08.980 preconditions
00:43:09.580 of
00:43:09.760 life
00:43:10.040 without
00:43:10.520 becoming
00:43:10.940 resentful
00:43:11.560 bitter
00:43:11.940 or
00:43:12.220 cruel
00:43:12.620 and
00:43:13.600 there's
00:43:13.780 nothing
00:43:14.160 that
00:43:14.360 you
00:43:14.480 can
00:43:14.660 pursue
00:43:14.960 in
00:43:15.140 your
00:43:15.260 life
00:43:15.560 that
00:43:15.900 will
00:43:16.020 be
00:43:16.200 half
00:43:16.560 as
00:43:16.720 useful
00:43:17.040 as
00:43:17.280 that
00:43:17.600 your
00:43:19.520 nervous
00:43:24.660 of
00:43:24.780 the
00:43:25.020 interaction
00:43:25.680 between
00:43:26.040 chaos
00:43:26.400 and
00:43:26.560 order
00:43:26.800 those
00:43:27.160 are
00:43:27.220 the
00:43:27.300 most
00:43:27.480 fundamental
00:43:27.980 constants
00:43:28.540 that
00:43:28.760 we
00:43:28.880 know
00:43:29.180 they
00:43:29.600 transcend
00:43:30.240 the
00:43:30.760 mere
00:43:31.120 perception
00:43:31.720 of
00:43:31.960 objects
00:43:32.440 everywhere
00:43:32.980 you
00:43:33.320 go
00:43:33.560 is
00:43:33.940 chaos
00:43:34.400 and
00:43:34.600 order
00:43:34.880 traditional
00:43:36.500 Chinese
00:43:36.940 doctors
00:43:37.360 go into
00:43:37.700 people's
00:43:38.080 houses
00:43:38.380 to
00:43:38.840 diagnose
00:43:39.360 why
00:43:39.980 it
00:43:40.140 is
00:43:40.280 that
00:43:40.460 someone
00:43:40.660 in
00:43:40.800 that
00:43:40.940 house
00:43:41.140 is
00:43:41.280 suffering
00:43:41.600 and
00:43:41.980 they
00:43:42.080 walk
00:43:42.300 in
00:43:42.440 and
00:43:42.540 they
00:43:42.660 think
00:43:42.920 there's
00:43:44.280 too
00:43:44.400 much
00:43:44.560 order
00:43:44.780 here
00:43:45.040 I've
00:43:46.040 been
00:43:46.160 in
00:43:46.280 houses
00:43:46.520 like
00:43:46.780 that
00:43:47.040 that
00:43:48.280 that's
00:43:48.540 a
00:43:48.620 house
00:43:48.820 where
00:43:49.040 all
00:43:49.160 the
00:43:49.280 furniture
00:43:49.600 is
00:43:49.780 covered
00:43:49.960 with
00:43:50.140 plastic
00:43:50.600 that's
00:43:51.660 a
00:43:51.720 house
00:43:51.920 where
00:43:52.120 if
00:43:52.240 you
00:43:52.340 put
00:43:52.500 a
00:43:52.600 glass
00:43:52.940 on
00:43:53.120 a
00:43:53.320 wooden
00:43:53.720 table
00:43:54.120 the
00:43:54.860 mistress
00:43:55.200 of
00:43:55.340 the
00:43:55.420 house
00:43:55.580 runs
00:43:55.820 over
00:43:56.000 with
00:43:56.160 the
00:43:56.280 coaster
00:43:56.600 slips
00:43:57.140 it
00:43:57.280 under
00:43:57.460 immediately
00:43:57.940 and
00:43:58.340 gives
00:43:58.580 you
00:43:58.700 a
00:43:58.820 dirty
00:43:59.040 look
00:43:59.400 that's
00:44:00.380 a
00:44:00.460 place
00:44:00.660 where
00:44:00.800 the
00:44:00.940 children
00:44:01.200 never
00:44:01.540 play
00:44:01.840 in
00:44:01.960 the
00:44:02.060 living
00:44:02.280 room
00:44:02.500 that's
00:44:03.320 a
00:44:03.400 place
00:44:03.660 where
00:44:04.000 the
00:44:04.880 lines
00:44:05.600 in
00:44:05.780 the
00:44:05.920 carpet
00:44:06.240 are
00:44:06.420 vacuumed
00:44:07.200 so
00:44:07.380 precisely
00:44:08.060 that
00:44:08.400 they're
00:44:08.660 actually
00:44:09.100 parallel
00:44:10.100 that's
00:44:11.380 a
00:44:11.480 place
00:44:11.760 where
00:44:19.160 suffering
00:44:19.440 from
00:44:19.640 an
00:44:19.760 excess
00:44:20.040 of
00:44:20.260 order
00:44:20.540 and
00:44:21.380 then
00:44:21.500 you
00:44:21.640 can
00:44:21.760 walk
00:44:22.000 into
00:44:22.160 a
00:44:22.280 house
00:44:22.480 that's
00:44:22.680 completely
00:44:23.000 different
00:44:23.320 and
00:44:23.500 you
00:44:23.620 can
00:44:23.740 even
00:44:23.920 see
00:44:24.120 this
00:44:24.300 in
00:44:24.420 your
00:44:24.540 own
00:44:24.720 room
00:44:24.980 if
00:44:25.140 you
00:44:25.260 want
00:44:25.520 everything's
00:44:26.780 in
00:44:27.020 complete
00:44:27.520 disarray
00:44:28.280 you
00:44:28.900 can't
00:44:29.140 even
00:44:29.320 look
00:44:29.760 at
00:44:29.920 that
00:44:30.140 place
00:44:30.480 you're
00:44:30.920 sick
00:44:31.160 the
00:44:31.340 moment
00:44:31.680 you
00:44:31.940 cross
00:44:32.260 the
00:44:32.440 threshold
00:44:32.940 because
00:44:33.540 everywhere
00:44:33.980 you
00:44:34.300 look
00:44:34.660 there's
00:44:35.260 parts
00:44:35.620 of
00:44:35.940 untransformed
00:44:37.460 chaos
00:44:38.120 yelling
00:44:38.780 to
00:44:39.060 you
00:44:39.340 do
00:44:40.160 something
00:44:40.700 about
00:44:41.140 this
00:44:41.640 loser
00:44:42.520 if
00:44:47.480 you
00:44:47.640 walk
00:44:47.960 into
00:44:48.200 your
00:44:49.160 study
00:44:49.900 and
00:44:51.100 you
00:44:51.220 have
00:44:51.400 a
00:44:51.560 stack
00:44:51.880 of
00:44:52.100 papers
00:44:52.580 in
00:44:53.300 the
00:44:53.440 midst
00:44:53.700 of
00:44:53.840 which
00:44:54.040 is
00:44:54.200 buried
00:44:54.440 your
00:44:54.680 homework
00:44:55.300 you'll
00:44:56.160 notice
00:44:56.400 that
00:44:56.580 you
00:44:56.700 have
00:44:56.860 a
00:44:56.980 very
00:44:57.240 tough
00:44:57.840 time
00:44:58.160 looking
00:44:58.760 at
00:44:59.080 that
00:44:59.340 stack
00:44:59.700 of
00:44:59.880 papers
00:45:00.200 and
00:45:00.680 the
00:45:00.820 reason
00:45:01.080 for
00:45:01.280 that
00:45:01.500 is
00:45:01.660 that
00:45:01.860 the
00:45:02.380 stack
00:45:02.720 of
00:45:02.900 papers
00:45:03.220 that
00:45:03.480 you're
00:45:03.720 ignoring
00:45:04.180 that's
00:45:04.940 aging
00:45:05.360 and
00:45:05.940 causing
00:45:06.320 you
00:45:06.520 more
00:45:06.720 trouble
00:45:07.040 with
00:45:07.240 each
00:45:07.440 passing
00:45:07.840 day
00:45:08.180 is
00:45:08.740 a
00:45:08.940 portal
00:45:09.340 into
00:45:09.880 order
00:45:10.280 through
00:45:10.540 which
00:45:10.780 chaos
00:45:11.200 is
00:45:11.420 flowing
00:45:11.780 and
00:45:12.540 if
00:45:12.660 you
00:45:12.800 ignore
00:45:13.060 that
00:45:13.300 long
00:45:19.160 take
00:45:19.280 over
00:45:19.480 your
00:45:19.720 life
00:45:20.120 and
00:45:20.880 you
00:45:21.000 might
00:45:21.220 think
00:45:21.540 well
00:45:21.980 that's
00:45:22.500 a
00:45:22.600 very
00:45:22.760 strange
00:45:23.140 way
00:45:23.340 of
00:45:23.480 looking
00:45:23.700 at
00:45:23.920 things
00:45:24.160 and
00:45:24.540 I
00:45:24.680 suppose
00:45:24.980 it
00:45:25.140 is
00:45:25.380 but
00:45:26.040 just
00:45:26.860 as
00:45:27.080 an
00:45:27.220 experiment
00:45:27.740 to
00:45:28.180 see
00:45:28.360 whether
00:45:28.580 or
00:45:28.700 not
00:45:28.860 this
00:45:29.040 is
00:45:29.200 true
00:45:29.440 try
00:45:30.000 not
00:45:30.280 paying
00:45:30.600 your
00:45:30.780 taxes
00:45:31.200 for
00:45:31.480 10
00:45:31.740 years
00:45:32.000 and
00:45:32.200 see
00:45:32.380 what
00:45:32.620 happens
00:45:33.120 this
00:45:37.300 is an
00:45:37.540 old
00:45:37.740 representation
00:45:38.300 right
00:45:38.920 atlas
00:45:39.420 with
00:45:39.640 the
00:45:39.780 world
00:45:40.060 well
00:45:40.840 it's
00:45:41.100 a
00:45:41.200 representation
00:45:41.660 that
00:45:42.140 says
00:45:42.400 that
00:45:42.580 that
00:45:42.620 that's
00:45:42.880 the
00:45:43.060 proper
00:45:43.480 way
00:45:43.760 to
00:45:43.920 live
00:45:44.280 right
00:45:44.560 that
00:45:44.760 the
00:45:44.920 way
00:45:45.120 that
00:45:45.320 you
00:45:45.460 live
00:45:45.700 properly
00:45:46.200 so
00:45:46.460 that
00:45:46.600 you
00:45:46.720 can
00:45:46.900 withstand
00:45:47.240 the
00:45:47.560 nature
00:45:47.840 of
00:45:48.020 your
00:45:48.140 own
00:45:48.300 being
00:45:48.580 is
00:45:49.100 to
00:45:49.260 pick
00:45:49.500 up
00:45:49.680 a
00:45:49.860 load
00:45:50.160 that's
00:45:50.740 heavy
00:45:51.020 enough
00:45:51.420 so
00:45:51.800 that
00:45:51.960 if
00:45:52.200 you
00:45:52.380 carry
00:45:52.720 it
00:45:52.960 you
00:45:53.280 have
00:45:53.500 some
00:45:53.700 self
00:45:53.980 respect
00:45:54.440 that's
00:45:55.840 a
00:45:55.940 very
00:45:56.160 weird
00:45:56.480 idea
00:45:56.820 because
00:45:57.200 it's
00:45:57.660 frequently
00:45:58.060 the
00:45:58.340 case
00:45:58.580 that
00:45:58.740 people
00:45:59.000 do
00:45:59.240 everything
00:45:59.580 they
00:45:59.800 can
00:46:00.040 to
00:46:00.220 lighten
00:46:00.620 their
00:46:00.760 load
00:46:01.060 but
00:46:01.620 the
00:46:01.740 problem
00:46:02.020 with
00:46:02.180 carrying
00:46:02.460 a
00:46:02.600 light
00:46:02.780 load
00:46:03.060 is
00:46:03.220 that
00:46:03.380 then
00:46:03.580 you
00:46:03.700 have
00:46:03.860 nothing
00:46:04.140 that's
00:46:04.420 useful
00:46:04.720 to
00:46:04.900 do
00:46:05.180 and
00:46:05.680 if
00:46:05.820 you
00:46:05.900 have
00:46:06.020 nothing
00:46:06.260 useful
00:46:06.600 to
00:46:06.820 do
00:46:07.040 all
00:46:07.480 you
00:46:07.660 have
00:46:07.880 around
00:46:08.220 you
00:46:08.480 unless
00:46:09.080 you're
00:46:09.280 extremely
00:46:09.660 fortunate
00:46:10.220 and that
00:46:10.620 will only
00:46:10.960 be the
00:46:11.220 case
00:46:11.440 for
00:46:11.580 very
00:46:11.820 short
00:46:12.080 periods
00:46:12.420 of
00:46:12.560 time
00:46:12.840 is
00:46:13.340 meaningless
00:46:13.780 suffering
00:46:14.460 and
00:46:15.480 there's
00:46:15.660 nothing
00:46:16.020 worse
00:46:16.360 for your
00:46:16.720 soul
00:46:17.080 than
00:46:17.300 meaningless
00:46:17.740 suffering
00:46:18.340 if
00:46:19.760 you
00:46:19.880 look
00:46:20.080 around
00:46:20.320 you
00:46:20.480 see
00:46:20.600 the
00:46:20.740 people
00:46:20.960 that
00:46:21.140 you
00:46:21.280 respect
00:46:21.760 and
00:46:22.140 I
00:46:22.480 don't
00:46:22.640 mean
00:46:22.820 that
00:46:23.000 you
00:46:23.160 think
00:46:23.580 about
00:46:23.840 respecting
00:46:24.340 I
00:46:24.540 mean
00:46:24.760 the
00:46:25.240 ones
00:46:25.560 that
00:46:25.900 your
00:46:26.520 gut
00:46:26.920 your
00:46:27.160 whole
00:46:27.420 being
00:46:27.740 your
00:46:27.920 embodied
00:46:28.340 being
00:46:28.660 tells
00:46:29.000 you
00:46:29.140 to
00:46:29.260 respect
00:46:29.600 you'll
00:46:29.920 see
00:46:30.060 that
00:46:30.200 it's
00:46:30.360 always
00:46:30.560 people
00:46:30.900 who
00:46:31.340 picked
00:46:31.700 up
00:46:31.920 something
00:46:32.260 heavy
00:46:32.600 and
00:46:32.820 are
00:46:32.960 carrying
00:46:33.260 it
00:46:33.440 successfully
00:46:33.940 you
00:46:34.140 think
00:46:34.320 now
00:46:34.720 that's
00:46:35.200 what
00:46:35.380 it
00:46:35.540 means
00:46:35.820 to
00:46:35.980 be
00:46:36.120 a
00:46:36.260 human
00:46:36.540 being
00:46:36.960 and
00:46:38.060 when
00:46:38.240 you
00:46:38.380 see
00:46:38.560 that
00:46:38.760 you
00:46:38.900 can
00:46:39.040 think
00:46:39.260 well
00:46:39.440 perhaps
00:46:39.820 life
00:46:40.040 is
00:46:40.180 worthwhile
00:46:40.620 despite
00:46:41.420 the
00:46:41.740 fact
00:46:42.000 that
00:46:42.160 the
00:46:42.300 essential
00:46:42.680 nature
00:46:43.000 of
00:46:43.180 reality
00:46:43.500 is
00:46:43.720 suffering
00:46:44.140 there's
00:46:49.180 an
00:46:49.300 old
00:46:49.540 Jewish
00:46:49.860 idea
00:46:50.260 and
00:46:51.580 the
00:46:51.680 idea
00:46:51.940 is
00:46:52.060 that
00:46:52.200 man
00:46:52.480 and
00:46:52.640 God
00:46:52.900 are
00:46:53.080 in
00:46:53.200 a
00:46:53.320 sense
00:46:53.580 twins
00:46:54.040 it's
00:46:54.960 a
00:46:55.040 very
00:46:55.200 strange
00:46:55.540 idea
00:46:55.840 but
00:46:56.060 it
00:46:56.200 seems
00:46:56.480 to
00:46:56.680 hinge
00:46:56.940 on
00:46:57.100 something
00:46:57.380 like
00:46:57.620 this
00:46:57.920 the
00:47:00.220 classic
00:47:00.780 attributes
00:47:01.300 of
00:47:01.500 God
00:47:01.840 these
00:47:02.120 are
00:47:02.200 the
00:47:02.300 attributes
00:47:02.700 of
00:47:02.860 the
00:47:02.980 absolute
00:47:03.360 are
00:47:03.900 omniscience
00:47:04.620 omnipotence
00:47:05.520 and
00:47:05.740 omnipresence
00:47:06.460 do
00:47:07.180 anything
00:47:07.660 be
00:47:07.920 anything
00:47:08.500 can't
00:47:12.600 translate
00:47:12.900 the other
00:47:13.200 one
00:47:13.360 momentarily
00:47:13.960 there's
00:47:15.220 a
00:47:15.320 question
00:47:15.680 that
00:47:15.840 goes
00:47:16.000 along
00:47:16.280 with
00:47:16.460 that
00:47:16.740 what
00:47:18.640 is
00:47:18.760 a
00:47:18.860 being
00:47:19.080 that's
00:47:19.480 characterized
00:47:19.880 by
00:47:20.260 the
00:47:20.420 absolute
00:47:20.760 attributes
00:47:21.220 of
00:47:21.360 God
00:47:21.560 lack
00:47:21.900 and
00:47:24.120 answer
00:47:24.360 to
00:47:24.460 that
00:47:24.580 is
00:47:24.700 limitation
00:47:25.200 and
00:47:26.560 that's
00:47:26.720 an
00:47:26.820 unbelievably
00:47:27.280 interesting
00:47:27.880 idea
00:47:28.320 and
00:47:29.080 the
00:47:29.180 reason
00:47:29.360 it's
00:47:29.520 so
00:47:29.640 interesting
00:47:30.080 is
00:47:30.240 because
00:47:30.540 one
00:47:31.380 of
00:47:31.500 the
00:47:31.620 things
00:47:31.880 that
00:47:32.040 modern
00:47:32.320 psychology
00:47:32.820 is
00:47:33.020 increasingly
00:47:33.440 telling
00:47:33.820 us
00:47:34.040 is
00:47:34.160 that
00:47:34.340 without
00:47:34.900 the
00:47:35.240 limitation
00:47:35.840 that
00:47:36.280 a
00:47:36.660 creature
00:47:36.920 like
00:47:37.240 us
00:47:37.620 with
00:47:38.160 the
00:47:38.320 structure
00:47:38.620 of
00:47:38.760 our
00:47:38.880 consciousness
00:47:39.340 brings
00:47:40.060 to
00:47:40.280 bear
00:47:40.520 on
00:47:40.780 the
00:47:40.940 world
00:47:41.160 there's
00:47:41.600 no
00:47:41.780 reality
00:47:42.280 that
00:47:43.520 what
00:47:43.760 reality
00:47:44.120 is
00:47:44.440 is
00:47:44.560 an
00:47:44.680 emergent
00:47:45.040 consequence
00:47:45.600 of
00:47:45.920 the
00:47:46.020 interaction
00:47:46.460 between
00:47:46.820 something
00:47:47.200 that's
00:47:47.440 painfully
00:47:47.860 limited
00:47:51.900 is
00:47:52.280 completely
00:47:52.580 without
00:47:52.900 borders
00:47:53.380 and
00:47:53.960 what
00:47:54.100 that
00:47:54.280 implies
00:47:54.720 in
00:47:54.900 a
00:47:55.040 sense
00:47:55.280 is
00:47:55.500 that
00:47:55.760 without
00:47:56.880 limitation
00:47:57.440 there's
00:47:57.720 no
00:47:57.880 being
00:47:58.220 with
00:47:59.500 limitation
00:48:00.060 there's
00:48:00.380 suffering
00:48:00.840 without
00:48:01.780 suffering
00:48:02.320 then
00:48:02.560 there's
00:48:02.800 no
00:48:03.000 being
00:48:03.420 well
00:48:04.580 you
00:48:04.700 might
00:48:04.860 think
00:48:05.080 well
00:48:05.260 perhaps
00:48:05.560 there
00:48:05.720 should
00:48:05.880 be
00:48:06.000 no
00:48:06.180 being
00:48:06.460 and
00:48:06.960 lots
00:48:07.140 of
00:48:07.240 people
00:48:07.400 act
00:48:07.660 their
00:48:07.800 whole
00:48:07.980 lives
00:48:08.180 in
00:48:08.320 order
00:48:08.460 to
00:48:08.640 see
00:48:08.800 if
00:48:08.920 they
00:48:09.020 can
00:48:09.160 make
00:48:09.320 that
00:48:09.500 a
00:48:09.600 possibility
00:48:10.080 and
00:48:10.560 that's
00:48:10.780 really
00:48:10.960 a
00:48:11.080 luxury
00:48:11.340 we
00:48:11.560 don't
00:48:11.720 have
00:48:11.960 anymore
00:48:12.280 but
00:48:13.340 the
00:48:13.460 alternative
00:48:13.800 is
00:48:14.060 to
00:48:14.180 presume
00:48:14.480 that
00:48:14.780 being
00:48:15.420 is
00:48:15.640 worth
00:48:15.980 the
00:48:16.240 suffering
00:48:16.680 and
00:48:17.460 to
00:48:17.600 find
00:48:17.800 a
00:48:17.920 mode
00:48:18.060 of
00:48:18.160 being
00:48:18.340 that
00:48:18.500 allows
00:48:18.820 you
00:48:19.020 to
00:48:19.280 make
00:48:19.840 that
00:48:20.100 claim
00:48:20.500 in
00:48:20.960 reality
00:48:21.460 and
00:48:22.120 I
00:48:22.200 would
00:48:22.300 say
00:48:22.460 in
00:48:22.560 a
00:48:22.660 sense
00:48:22.820 that's
00:48:23.120 your
00:48:23.260 existential
00:48:23.740 destiny
00:48:24.340 and
00:48:25.220 if
00:48:25.380 you're
00:48:25.520 here
00:48:25.700 at
00:48:25.820 university
00:48:26.460 rather
00:48:26.840 than
00:48:27.020 a
00:48:27.160 trade
00:48:27.480 school
00:48:27.880 your
00:48:29.320 job
00:48:29.560 is
00:48:29.680 to
00:48:29.780 figure
00:48:29.940 out
00:48:30.040 how
00:48:30.140 to
00:48:30.240 be
00:48:30.340 a
00:48:30.460 human
00:48:30.680 being
00:48:31.040 and
00:48:31.880 that's
00:48:32.060 a
00:48:32.140 much
00:48:32.320 more
00:48:32.480 important
00:48:32.820 job
00:48:33.060 than
00:48:33.220 any
00:48:33.540 specific
00:48:34.580 time
00:48:36.700 limited
00:48:37.140 concrete
00:48:37.820 pragmatic
00:48:38.700 plan
00:48:39.380 you
00:48:44.180 way
00:48:44.540 more
00:48:44.780 powerful
00:48:45.200 than
00:48:45.440 they
00:48:45.600 think
00:48:45.900 they're
00:48:46.360 more
00:48:46.540 powerful
00:48:46.860 for
00:48:47.120 evil
00:48:47.360 but
00:48:47.540 they're
00:48:47.700 also
00:48:47.900 more
00:48:48.120 powerful
00:48:48.440 for
00:48:48.720 good
00:48:49.020 these
00:48:50.760 archaic
00:48:51.160 stories
00:48:51.540 that
00:48:51.700 I've
00:48:51.840 been
00:48:51.940 telling
00:48:52.200 you
00:48:52.360 about
00:48:52.600 they
00:48:53.320 have
00:48:53.520 something
00:48:53.800 to
00:48:54.000 say
00:48:54.200 to
00:48:54.360 you
00:48:54.540 they
00:48:55.060 say
00:48:55.440 life
00:48:56.800 is
00:48:56.960 uncertain
00:48:57.380 you'll
00:48:58.260 never
00:48:58.500 know
00:48:58.740 enough
00:48:59.140 and
00:48:59.520 not
00:48:59.660 only
00:48:59.800 that
00:48:59.980 you
00:49:00.120 never
00:49:00.360 can
00:49:00.700 know
00:49:00.880 enough
00:49:01.180 and
00:49:01.620 not
00:49:01.760 only
00:49:01.940 that
00:49:02.100 everything
00:49:02.460 that
00:49:02.700 you
00:49:02.820 stand
00:49:03.120 on
00:49:03.260 is
00:49:03.400 shaky
00:49:03.800 and
00:49:05.660 then
00:49:05.780 they
00:49:05.900 say
00:49:06.020 but
00:49:06.160 you
00:49:06.440 still
00:49:06.640 have
00:49:06.800 to
00:49:14.180 live
00:49:14.360 your
00:49:14.580 life
00:49:14.940 and
00:49:15.300 if
00:49:15.400 you
00:49:15.500 forget
00:49:15.860 those
00:49:16.180 things
00:49:16.520 or
00:49:16.860 if
00:49:16.980 you
00:49:17.080 undermine
00:49:17.400 them
00:49:17.740 you're
00:49:18.060 in
00:49:18.140 the
00:49:18.240 same
00:49:18.440 situation
00:49:19.020 that
00:49:20.280 the
00:49:20.420 unfortunate
00:49:20.800 man
00:49:21.160 was
00:49:21.480 that
00:49:22.680 I
00:49:22.800 told
00:49:23.020 you
00:49:23.140 about
00:49:23.440 in
00:49:23.760 the
00:49:23.860 Old
00:49:24.000 Testament
00:49:24.360 who
00:49:25.440 reached
00:49:25.700 out
00:49:25.840 to
00:49:26.000 touch
00:49:26.200 something
00:49:26.480 he
00:49:26.640 should
00:49:26.800 have
00:49:26.900 left
00:49:27.100 alone
00:49:27.480 to
00:49:28.840 the
00:49:28.940 degree
00:49:29.180 that
00:49:29.360 you're
00:49:29.540 human
00:49:29.960 you
00:49:31.560 have
00:49:31.780 to
00:49:31.920 abide
00:49:32.240 by
00:49:32.480 a
00:49:33.600 certain
00:49:33.840 set
00:49:34.120 of
00:49:34.260 truths
00:49:34.600 the
00:49:36.000 truths
00:49:36.220 that
00:49:36.380 I
00:49:36.480 told
00:49:36.680 you
00:49:36.800 about
00:49:36.960 today
00:49:37.280 are
00:49:38.100 as
00:49:38.260 far
00:49:38.420 as
00:49:38.560 I
00:49:38.660 can
00:49:38.780 tell
00:49:39.100 something
00:49:39.660 that's
00:49:39.900 close
00:49:40.120 to
00:49:40.260 a
00:49:40.420 minimal
00:49:40.840 set
00:49:41.380 there's
00:49:42.520 chaos
00:49:42.900 there's
00:49:44.140 order
00:49:44.460 you're
00:49:45.420 stuck
00:49:45.700 with
00:49:45.900 both
00:49:46.200 of
00:49:46.320 them
00:49:46.460 and
00:49:46.800 they
00:49:46.900 both
00:49:47.080 have
00:49:47.240 a
00:49:47.340 cost
00:49:47.680 and
00:49:47.940 they
00:49:48.040 both
00:49:48.200 have
00:49:48.340 advantages
00:49:48.800 and
00:49:49.240 your
00:49:49.380 job
00:49:49.620 is
00:49:49.720 to
00:49:49.840 figure
00:49:50.000 out
00:49:50.140 how
00:49:50.320 to
00:49:50.540 serve
00:49:51.060 as
00:49:51.340 the
00:49:51.500 appropriate
00:49:52.100 mediator
00:49:52.860 between
00:49:53.220 the
00:49:53.420 two
00:49:53.660 and
00:49:54.640 you
00:49:54.760 can
00:49:54.920 tell
00:49:55.180 when
00:49:55.360 you're
00:49:55.520 doing
00:49:55.740 that
00:49:55.960 because
00:49:56.340 when
00:49:56.960 you're
00:49:57.160 doing
00:49:57.400 that
00:49:57.740 the
00:49:58.700 dismal
00:49:59.280 circumstances
00:50:00.060 of
00:50:00.360 your
00:50:00.520 life
00:50:00.960 manifest
00:50:02.080 themselves
00:50:02.840 to
00:50:03.140 you
00:50:03.320 as
00:50:03.600 eminently
00:50:04.220 acceptable
00:50:04.840 and
00:50:05.960 it's
00:50:06.140 in
00:50:06.260 that
00:50:06.460 situation
00:50:06.880 that
00:50:07.100 you
00:50:07.220 know
00:50:07.440 that
00:50:07.700 you've
00:50:08.360 placed
00:50:09.600 yourself
00:50:10.020 in a
00:50:10.340 position
00:50:10.640 in
00:50:10.840 nature
00:50:11.100 where
00:50:11.520 everything
00:50:11.820 is
00:50:12.060 in
00:50:12.200 harmony
00:50:12.480 and
00:50:13.220 that's
00:50:13.720 the
00:50:13.900 place
00:50:14.240 to
00:50:14.420 aim
00:50:14.640 for
00:50:14.960 at
00:50:20.400 this
00:50:20.640 point
00:50:21.040 in the
00:50:21.600 lecture
00:50:21.940 there's
00:50:23.460 a
00:50:23.580 question
00:50:23.980 and
00:50:24.200 answer
00:50:24.540 period
00:50:25.020 question
00:50:27.100 one
00:50:27.500 how
00:50:29.720 do
00:50:29.880 you
00:50:30.000 take
00:50:30.280 your
00:50:30.460 ideas
00:50:30.880 about
00:50:31.200 embracing
00:50:31.720 suffering
00:50:32.260 and
00:50:32.660 apply
00:50:32.980 them
00:50:33.200 to
00:50:33.360 treatments
00:50:33.800 for
00:50:34.040 mental
00:50:34.400 illness
00:50:34.940 the
00:50:39.280 first
00:50:39.520 thing
00:50:39.700 I
00:50:39.800 would
00:50:39.940 say
00:50:40.160 is
00:50:40.320 that
00:50:40.460 if
00:50:40.620 you're
00:50:40.740 dealing
00:50:40.940 with
00:50:41.100 someone
00:50:41.300 who's
00:50:41.540 depressed
00:50:41.920 and
00:50:42.080 they're
00:50:42.200 really
00:50:42.400 depressed
00:50:42.860 you
00:50:43.200 should
00:50:43.340 try
00:50:43.580 giving
00:50:43.860 them
00:50:44.000 antidepressants
00:50:44.740 because
00:50:45.340 if
00:50:45.540 they
00:50:45.680 die
00:50:46.060 you
00:50:46.480 can't
00:50:46.800 help
00:50:47.020 them
00:50:47.260 okay
00:50:48.300 so
00:50:48.640 if
00:50:49.260 you're
00:50:49.460 suffering
00:50:49.960 you
00:50:51.040 are
00:50:51.540 obligated
00:50:52.340 in a
00:50:52.660 sense
00:50:53.000 to
00:50:53.680 hold
00:50:54.000 on
00:50:54.220 to
00:50:54.380 whatever
00:50:54.780 rope
00:50:55.180 someone
00:50:55.540 throws
00:50:55.940 you
00:50:56.140 and
00:50:57.140 one
00:50:57.300 of
00:50:57.400 the
00:50:57.480 things
00:50:57.680 I
00:50:57.800 do
00:50:57.900 with
00:50:58.020 my
00:50:58.180 clients
00:50:58.440 all
00:50:58.600 the
00:50:58.720 time
00:50:58.980 especially
00:50:59.460 if
00:50:59.640 they're
00:50:59.780 really
00:50:59.940 in
00:51:00.080 trouble
00:51:00.300 is
00:51:00.460 to
00:51:00.580 tell
00:51:00.760 them
00:51:00.920 look
00:51:01.140 I
00:51:01.740 don't
00:51:01.860 know
00:51:02.000 exactly
00:51:02.360 what's
00:51:02.580 going
00:51:02.700 to
00:51:02.780 help
00:51:03.380 you
00:51:03.600 but
00:51:04.120 don't
00:51:04.420 arbitrarily
00:51:05.020 throw
00:51:05.360 out
00:51:05.560 any
00:51:05.740 possibilities
00:51:06.320 because
00:51:06.700 you
00:51:06.880 might
00:51:07.060 not
00:51:07.220 have
00:51:07.440 that
00:51:07.640 luxury
00:51:08.060 antidepressants
00:51:09.560 help a lot
00:51:09.980 of people
00:51:10.320 and there
00:51:10.620 are
00:51:10.760 technical
00:51:11.140 reasons
00:51:11.520 why
00:51:11.720 that's
00:51:11.980 the
00:51:12.120 case
00:51:12.440 so
00:51:13.200 that's
00:51:15.080 a simple
00:51:15.400 answer
00:51:15.680 it's
00:51:15.820 not
00:51:15.980 relevant
00:51:16.360 to
00:51:16.560 what
00:51:16.720 I
00:51:16.840 already
00:51:17.080 described
00:51:17.640 except
00:51:18.360 that
00:51:18.780 if
00:51:19.100 you're
00:51:19.260 offered
00:51:19.460 a
00:51:19.600 gift
00:51:19.740 by
00:51:19.920 your
00:51:20.080 society
00:51:20.460 and
00:51:20.600 works
00:51:21.040 try
00:51:21.520 it
00:51:21.760 I
00:51:22.340 don't
00:51:22.480 care
00:51:22.660 what
00:51:22.840 your
00:51:22.980 presuppositions
00:51:23.720 are
00:51:24.040 apart
00:51:26.140 from
00:51:26.360 that
00:51:26.660 lots
00:51:30.120 of
00:51:30.240 the
00:51:30.360 time
00:51:31.120 you
00:51:32.860 see
00:51:33.040 people
00:51:33.340 who
00:51:33.480 are
00:51:33.600 suffering
00:51:34.020 with
00:51:34.600 depression
00:51:35.020 for
00:51:35.220 example
00:51:35.560 there's
00:51:35.820 a multitude
00:51:36.140 of
00:51:36.380 reasons
00:51:36.600 but
00:51:36.780 I'll
00:51:36.880 take
00:51:37.040 one
00:51:37.240 common
00:51:37.520 reason
00:51:37.820 you
00:51:39.140 can
00:51:39.260 think
00:51:39.440 about
00:51:39.660 it
00:51:39.780 as
00:51:39.940 associated
00:51:40.420 with
00:51:40.640 the
00:51:40.760 story
00:51:41.040 of
00:51:41.200 Peter Pan
00:51:41.860 Peter Pan
00:51:43.180 is
00:51:43.300 someone
00:51:43.520 who
00:51:43.680 won't
00:51:43.880 grow
00:51:44.100 up
00:51:44.320 right
00:51:44.560 now
00:51:45.040 the
00:51:45.160 problem
00:51:45.420 with
00:51:45.540 Peter Pan
00:51:45.980 is
00:51:46.120 he
00:51:46.240 gets
00:51:46.420 to
00:51:46.540 be
00:51:46.660 king
00:51:46.980 but
00:51:47.620 it's
00:51:50.600 so
00:51:50.960 being
00:51:51.720 king
00:51:51.920 of
00:51:52.040 nothing
00:51:52.320 isn't
00:51:52.600 that
00:51:52.780 helpful
00:51:53.200 well
00:51:54.400 one
00:51:54.560 of
00:51:54.680 the
00:51:54.780 things
00:51:54.980 that
00:51:55.100 you
00:51:55.200 often
00:51:55.460 see
00:51:55.700 with
00:51:55.880 people
00:51:56.120 who
00:51:56.280 suffer
00:51:56.520 from
00:51:56.760 depression
00:51:57.200 and
00:51:57.680 I'm
00:51:57.980 not
00:51:58.180 making
00:51:58.520 a
00:51:58.820 blanket
00:51:59.160 statement
00:51:59.580 about
00:51:59.820 the
00:52:00.000 cause
00:52:00.200 of
00:52:00.320 depression
00:52:00.660 because
00:52:00.960 there's
00:52:01.200 lots
00:52:01.440 of
00:52:01.560 them
00:52:01.720 is
00:52:02.260 that
00:52:02.480 people
00:52:03.340 who
00:52:03.480 don't
00:52:03.660 have
00:52:03.840 enough
00:52:04.060 order
00:52:04.320 in
00:52:04.460 their
00:52:04.580 life
00:52:04.780 tend
00:52:05.040 to
00:52:05.160 get
00:52:05.320 overwhelmed
00:52:05.840 so
00:52:06.740 for
00:52:06.920 example
00:52:07.300 if
00:52:07.780 someone
00:52:08.000 comes
00:52:08.240 in
00:52:08.360 to
00:52:08.440 me
00:52:08.640 and
00:52:09.060 see
00:52:09.260 to
00:52:09.440 see
00:52:09.640 me
00:52:09.840 and
00:52:10.220 they
00:52:10.340 say
00:52:10.460 they're
00:52:10.600 depressed
00:52:10.860 I
00:52:11.180 always
00:52:11.360 ask
00:52:11.580 them
00:52:11.760 a
00:52:12.040 very
00:52:12.280 standard
00:52:12.720 set
00:52:12.940 of
00:52:13.060 questions
00:52:13.520 do
00:52:14.940 you
00:52:14.980 have
00:52:15.060 a
00:52:15.160 job
00:52:15.420 if
00:52:17.280 you
00:52:17.360 don't
00:52:17.500 have
00:52:17.620 a
00:52:17.700 job
00:52:17.900 you're
00:52:18.100 really
00:52:18.280 in
00:52:18.420 trouble
00:52:18.640 in
00:52:18.820 our
00:52:18.940 society
00:52:19.420 first
00:52:19.920 of
00:52:20.040 all
00:52:20.180 your
00:52:20.620 biological
00:52:21.020 rhythms
00:52:21.460 tend
00:52:21.680 to
00:52:21.760 go
00:52:21.880 off
00:52:22.060 the
00:52:22.180 rails
00:52:22.380 right
00:52:22.580 away
00:52:22.820 because
00:52:23.020 there's
00:52:23.160 no
00:52:23.260 reason
00:52:23.500 to
00:52:23.600 go
00:52:23.700 to
00:52:23.800 bed
00:52:23.960 at
00:52:24.080 any
00:52:24.220 particular
00:52:24.560 time
00:52:24.820 and
00:52:24.920 there's
00:52:25.080 no
00:52:25.220 reason
00:52:25.440 to
00:52:25.560 get
00:52:25.680 up
00:52:25.920 and
00:52:26.060 for
00:52:26.420 many
00:52:26.700 people
00:52:27.080 if
00:52:27.560 they
00:52:27.700 don't
00:52:27.940 get
00:52:28.140 up
00:52:40.460 this
00:52:40.580 isn't
00:52:40.980 this
00:52:41.460 isn't
00:52:41.700 hypothesizing
00:52:42.780 we
00:52:43.460 absolutely
00:52:44.280 understand
00:52:44.980 the
00:52:45.180 circuitry
00:52:45.600 that
00:52:45.760 underlies
00:52:46.120 positive
00:52:46.480 emotion
00:52:46.860 we
00:52:47.640 know
00:52:47.860 how
00:52:48.260 it
00:52:48.440 works
00:52:48.760 almost
00:52:49.320 all
00:52:49.580 the
00:52:49.720 positive
00:52:50.000 emotion
00:52:50.340 that
00:52:50.520 any
00:52:50.680 of
00:52:50.800 you
00:52:50.900 are
00:52:51.000 likely
00:52:51.220 to
00:52:51.400 experience
00:52:51.780 in
00:52:51.980 your
00:52:52.100 life
00:52:52.320 will
00:52:52.740 not
00:52:53.080 be
00:52:53.280 a
00:52:53.400 consequence
00:52:53.780 of
00:52:54.020 attaining
00:52:54.340 things
00:52:54.720 it
00:52:55.340 will
00:52:55.460 be
00:52:55.640 a
00:52:55.900 consequence
00:52:56.300 of
00:52:56.600 seeing
00:52:56.860 that
00:52:57.040 things
00:52:57.340 are
00:52:57.880 working
00:52:58.240 as
00:52:58.680 you
00:52:58.840 proceed
00:52:59.240 towards
00:52:59.600 a
00:52:59.720 goal
00:52:59.880 you
00:53:00.040 value
00:53:00.360 that's
00:53:01.280 completely
00:53:01.620 different
00:53:01.980 and
00:53:02.180 you
00:53:02.280 need
00:53:02.440 to
00:53:02.520 know
00:53:02.680 this
00:53:02.840 because
00:53:03.060 people
00:53:03.520 are
00:53:03.660 often
00:53:03.940 stunned
00:53:04.460 for
00:53:04.640 example
00:53:05.000 they
00:53:05.180 finish
00:53:05.440 their
00:53:05.600 PhD
00:53:05.960 thesis
00:53:06.400 and
00:53:06.960 their
00:53:07.200 presupposition
00:53:07.920 is that
00:53:08.260 they're
00:53:08.420 going
00:53:08.600 to be
00:53:08.880 elated
00:53:09.280 for
00:53:09.500 a
00:53:09.640 month
00:53:09.880 and
00:53:10.060 often
00:53:10.580 instead
00:53:10.980 they're
00:53:11.220 actually
00:53:11.560 depressed
00:53:12.200 and
00:53:12.400 they
00:53:12.500 think
00:53:12.720 what
00:53:13.060 the
00:53:13.460 hell
00:53:13.620 I've
00:53:13.740 been
00:53:13.860 working
00:53:14.060 on
00:53:14.220 this
00:53:14.380 for
00:53:14.540 seven
00:53:14.800 years
00:53:15.080 and
00:53:15.240 I
00:53:15.600 handed
00:53:15.840 it
00:53:16.020 in
00:53:16.200 and
00:53:16.320 what
00:53:17.240 do
00:53:17.340 I
00:53:17.460 do
00:53:17.640 now
00:53:18.040 and
00:53:18.260 that's
00:53:18.680 what
00:53:18.800 depresses
00:53:19.220 them
00:53:19.440 right
00:53:19.640 it's
00:53:19.800 the
00:53:19.920 what
00:53:20.060 do
00:53:20.180 I
00:53:20.280 do
00:53:20.420 now
00:53:20.740 well
00:53:21.120 they're
00:53:21.320 fine
00:53:32.840 if
00:53:33.020 you
00:53:33.100 take
00:53:33.260 drugs
00:53:33.520 like
00:53:33.720 cocaine
00:53:34.080 or
00:53:34.240 amphetamine
00:53:34.720 the
00:53:34.880 reason
00:53:35.120 they're
00:53:35.320 enjoyable
00:53:35.700 is
00:53:35.920 because
00:53:36.200 they
00:53:36.460 turn
00:53:36.900 on
00:53:37.180 the
00:53:37.360 systems
00:53:37.680 that
00:53:37.840 help
00:53:38.020 you
00:53:38.140 pursue
00:53:38.400 goals
00:53:38.820 that's
00:53:39.300 why
00:53:39.420 people
00:53:39.640 like
00:53:39.900 them
00:53:40.080 so
00:53:40.500 if
00:53:40.620 you
00:53:40.660 don't
00:53:40.800 have
00:53:40.920 a
00:53:41.020 job
00:53:41.420 you
00:53:41.860 got
00:53:42.000 no
00:53:42.140 structure
00:53:42.620 that's
00:53:43.120 not
00:53:43.320 good
00:53:43.660 plus
00:53:44.280 you
00:53:44.440 tend
00:53:44.640 not
00:53:44.840 to
00:53:44.960 have
00:53:45.120 a
00:53:45.260 point
00:53:45.680 so
00:53:46.600 you're
00:53:46.840 overwhelmed
00:53:47.300 by
00:53:47.560 chaotic
00:53:48.120 lack
00:53:48.420 of
00:53:48.560 structure
00:53:48.900 and
00:53:49.140 you
00:53:49.260 don't
00:53:49.360 have
00:53:49.500 any
00:53:49.600 positive
00:53:49.900 emotion
00:53:50.280 well
00:53:50.660 do
00:53:50.780 you
00:53:50.820 have
00:53:50.900 any
00:53:51.000 friends
00:53:51.480 so
00:53:52.400 sometimes
00:53:52.740 you
00:53:52.920 see
00:53:53.080 people
00:53:53.340 who
00:53:53.460 are
00:53:53.520 depressed
00:53:53.800 they
00:53:53.920 have
00:53:54.000 no
00:53:54.140 job
00:53:54.520 they
00:53:54.860 have
00:53:54.940 no
00:53:55.100 friends
00:53:55.480 they
00:53:55.780 have
00:53:55.900 no
00:53:56.060 intimate
00:53:56.340 relationship
00:53:56.960 they
00:53:57.520 have
00:53:57.720 an
00:53:57.840 additional
00:53:58.160 health
00:53:58.440 problem
00:53:58.780 and
00:53:59.240 they
00:53:59.460 have
00:53:59.720 a
00:53:59.820 drug
00:54:00.000 and
00:54:00.120 alcohol
00:54:00.400 problem
00:54:00.860 my
00:54:01.720 experience
00:54:02.200 has
00:54:02.360 been
00:54:02.480 if
00:54:02.620 you
00:54:02.720 have
00:54:02.880 three
00:54:03.280 of
00:54:03.480 those
00:54:03.680 problems
00:54:04.200 it's
00:54:05.420 almost
00:54:05.760 impossible
00:54:06.280 to
00:54:06.540 help
00:54:06.800 you
00:54:06.960 you
00:54:07.620 you're
00:54:07.740 so
00:54:07.960 deeply
00:54:08.340 mired
00:54:08.620 in
00:54:08.800 chaos
00:54:09.060 that
00:54:09.260 you
00:54:09.380 can't
00:54:09.620 get
00:54:09.760 out
00:54:09.940 because
00:54:10.260 you
00:54:10.860 make
00:54:11.060 progress
00:54:11.760 on
00:54:11.920 one
00:54:12.120 front
00:54:12.380 one
00:54:12.800 of
00:54:12.880 the
00:54:12.960 other
00:54:13.160 problems
00:54:13.480 pulls
00:54:13.760 you
00:54:13.900 down
00:54:14.180 so
00:54:14.940 one
00:54:15.120 of
00:54:15.220 the
00:54:15.340 things
00:54:15.580 I
00:54:15.720 tell
00:54:15.900 people
00:54:16.220 who
00:54:16.360 are
00:54:16.500 depressed
00:54:16.860 is
00:54:17.060 like
00:54:17.240 don't
00:54:18.000 sacrifice
00:54:19.100 your
00:54:19.460 stability
00:54:19.960 get
00:54:21.060 a
00:54:21.160 job
00:54:21.440 even
00:54:21.760 if
00:54:21.920 it's
00:54:22.080 not
00:54:22.280 the
00:54:22.440 job
00:54:22.660 you
00:54:22.800 exactly
00:54:23.180 want
00:54:23.520 get
00:54:23.720 a
00:54:23.840 damn
00:54:24.040 job
00:54:24.340 you
00:54:24.480 need
00:54:24.640 a
00:54:24.740 job
00:54:25.000 find
00:54:25.700 some
00:54:25.980 friends
00:54:26.480 get
00:54:27.420 out
00:54:27.600 in
00:54:27.720 the
00:54:27.840 dating
00:54:28.100 circuit
00:54:28.540 see
00:54:29.240 if
00:54:29.380 you
00:54:29.500 can
00:54:29.640 establish
00:54:30.040 an
00:54:30.240 intimate
00:54:30.480 relationship
00:54:31.040 put
00:54:31.600 together
00:54:32.000 some
00:54:32.300 of
00:54:32.440 the
00:54:32.580 foundational
00:54:33.100 items
00:54:33.600 that
00:54:33.880 are
00:54:34.340 like
00:54:34.520 pillars
00:54:34.920 that
00:54:35.120 your
00:54:35.260 life
00:54:35.480 rests
00:54:35.860 on
00:54:36.180 well
00:54:36.520 that's
00:54:36.700 the
00:54:36.840 practical
00:54:37.240 thing
00:54:37.560 to
00:54:37.720 do
00:54:37.940 so
00:54:39.120 that's
00:54:39.440 one
00:54:39.620 example
00:54:40.080 with
00:54:40.360 regards
00:54:40.700 to
00:54:40.860 depression
00:54:41.360 question
00:54:47.560 two
00:54:48.000 how do
00:54:49.620 your
00:54:49.780 clients
00:54:50.180 respond
00:54:50.680 to
00:54:50.880 the
00:54:51.040 suggestion
00:54:51.540 that
00:54:51.860 they
00:54:52.000 establish
00:54:52.540 structure
00:54:53.160 in
00:54:53.400 their
00:54:53.540 life
00:54:53.880 as
00:54:54.400 an
00:54:54.540 antidote
00:54:55.000 to
00:54:55.220 depression
00:54:55.660 well
00:55:01.820 the
00:55:01.980 thing
00:55:02.180 is
00:55:02.320 you
00:55:02.420 don't
00:55:02.560 just
00:55:02.780 launch
00:55:03.180 it
00:55:03.320 on
00:55:03.500 them
00:55:03.680 you
00:55:03.820 know
00:55:03.980 you
00:55:04.300 got
00:55:04.700 to
00:55:04.800 negotiate
00:55:05.220 with
00:55:05.520 the
00:55:05.640 person
00:55:05.960 and
00:55:06.480 you
00:55:06.540 also
00:55:06.720 got
00:55:06.900 to
00:55:07.020 teach
00:55:07.220 them
00:55:07.400 to
00:55:07.520 negotiate
00:55:07.920 with
00:55:08.220 themselves
00:55:08.620 and
00:55:08.840 this
00:55:09.120 is
00:55:09.240 something
00:55:09.520 that's
00:55:09.760 very
00:55:09.960 useful
00:55:10.300 to
00:55:10.500 know
00:55:10.700 you
00:55:11.200 know
00:55:11.340 you
00:55:12.100 can
00:55:12.340 tyrannize
00:55:12.960 yourself
00:55:13.400 into
00:55:13.620 doing
00:55:13.880 things
00:55:14.180 but I
00:55:14.460 wouldn't
00:55:14.680 recommend
00:55:15.140 it
00:55:15.320 what I
00:55:15.780 would
00:55:15.920 recommend
00:55:16.280 instead
00:55:16.840 is
00:55:17.120 that
00:55:17.260 you
00:55:17.420 ask
00:55:17.700 yourself
00:55:18.020 what
00:55:18.200 you're
00:55:18.360 willing
00:55:18.540 to
00:55:18.720 do
00:55:18.960 it's
00:55:19.440 a
00:55:19.520 really
00:55:19.740 effective
00:55:20.120 technique
00:55:20.500 it's
00:55:20.680 like
00:55:20.820 a
00:55:20.940 meditative
00:55:21.380 technique
00:55:21.860 so
00:55:22.080 for
00:55:22.240 example
00:55:22.600 you
00:55:23.120 can
00:55:23.220 get
00:55:23.300 up
00:55:23.400 in
00:55:23.480 morning
00:55:23.720 you
00:55:23.880 can
00:55:24.020 think
00:55:24.280 well
00:55:25.120 you
00:55:25.260 know
00:55:25.340 I'd
00:55:25.500 like
00:55:25.620 to
00:55:25.700 have
00:55:25.820 a
00:55:25.900 good
00:55:26.060 day
00:55:26.280 today
00:55:26.520 so
00:55:26.780 I'd
00:55:26.940 like
00:55:27.060 to
00:55:27.140 go
00:55:27.240 to
00:55:27.340 bed
00:55:27.500 tonight
00:55:27.720 without
00:55:27.920 feeling
00:55:28.260 guilty
00:55:28.680 because
00:55:29.120 I
00:55:29.280 didn't
00:55:29.720 do
00:55:29.880 some
00:55:30.020 things
00:55:30.240 I
00:55:30.400 said
00:55:30.680 I
00:55:30.780 was
00:55:30.880 going
00:55:31.000 to
00:55:31.040 do
00:55:31.200 and
00:55:31.320 I
00:55:31.440 you
00:55:31.720 know
00:55:31.780 I'd
00:55:31.900 like
00:55:32.020 to
00:55:32.120 have
00:55:32.260 kind
00:55:32.460 of
00:55:32.520 an
00:55:32.580 interesting
00:55:32.980 day
00:55:33.320 so
00:55:33.780 you
00:55:33.800 got to
00:55:34.040 fulfill
00:55:34.280 my
00:55:34.480 responsibilities
00:55:35.120 and I
00:55:35.400 want
00:55:35.580 to
00:55:35.720 enjoy
00:55:36.200 the
00:55:36.360 day
00:55:36.600 then
00:55:37.160 you
00:55:37.280 can
00:55:37.380 ask
00:55:37.560 yourself
00:55:37.840 well
00:55:38.100 okay
00:55:38.980 what
00:55:53.480 torturing
00:55:53.860 yourself
00:55:54.180 to
00:55:54.340 death
00:55:54.540 for
00:55:54.740 you
00:55:55.240 know
00:55:55.340 like
00:55:55.560 72
00:55:56.280 hours
00:55:56.640 straight
00:55:56.980 and
00:55:57.200 if
00:55:57.660 you
00:55:57.720 do
00:55:57.840 that
00:55:58.060 here's
00:55:58.300 a
00:55:58.380 little
00:55:58.500 interesting
00:55:58.900 thing
00:55:59.160 you
00:55:59.300 can
00:55:59.440 do
00:55:59.640 and
00:55:59.840 you
00:56:00.180 know
00:56:00.260 maybe
00:56:00.520 this
00:56:00.940 is
00:56:01.040 a
00:56:01.080 little
00:56:01.200 obligation
00:56:01.620 you
00:56:01.860 should
00:56:02.040 clean
00:56:02.300 up
00:56:02.520 and
00:56:02.660 so
00:56:03.420 what
00:56:04.460 you
00:56:04.900 do
00:56:05.140 in
00:56:05.360 a
00:56:05.440 situation
00:56:05.780 like
00:56:06.020 that
00:56:06.260 is
00:56:06.420 you
00:56:06.540 teach
00:56:06.820 the
00:56:07.060 person
00:56:07.300 to
00:56:07.460 negotiate
00:56:07.840 with
00:56:08.060 themselves
00:56:08.440 say
00:56:09.000 well
00:56:09.120 let's
00:56:09.360 figure
00:56:09.540 out
00:56:09.740 what
00:56:09.900 your
00:56:10.060 aims
00:56:10.320 are
00:56:10.500 you
00:56:10.600 got
00:56:10.720 to
00:56:10.780 have
00:56:10.920 some
00:56:11.100 aims
00:56:11.460 whatever
00:56:12.380 they
00:56:23.480 up
00:56:23.700 that
00:56:23.960 you
00:56:24.760 have
00:56:24.960 to
00:56:25.100 pretend
00:56:25.520 you
00:56:26.100 have
00:56:26.280 to
00:56:26.400 act
00:56:26.720 the
00:56:26.900 thing
00:56:27.080 out
00:56:27.260 before
00:56:27.520 you
00:56:27.700 can
00:56:27.820 start
00:56:28.040 to
00:56:28.200 believe
00:56:28.440 it
00:56:28.620 I
00:56:28.920 mean
00:56:29.060 people
00:56:29.300 always
00:56:29.580 assume
00:56:29.840 they
00:56:29.960 have
00:56:30.100 to
00:56:30.220 believe
00:56:30.480 and
00:56:30.640 then
00:56:30.820 act
00:56:31.100 but
00:56:31.300 sometimes
00:56:32.680 that's
00:56:33.040 true
00:56:33.180 and
00:56:33.280 lots
00:56:33.460 of
00:56:33.560 times
00:56:33.740 it
00:56:33.860 isn't
00:56:34.180 so
00:56:34.900 the
00:56:35.080 trick
00:56:35.300 if
00:56:35.760 you're
00:56:35.920 doing
00:56:36.140 therapeutic
00:56:36.540 work
00:56:36.820 with
00:56:36.960 someone
00:56:37.180 and
00:56:37.340 you're
00:56:37.460 helping
00:56:37.720 them
00:56:37.920 establish
00:56:38.340 a
00:56:38.520 structure
00:56:38.800 is
00:56:38.960 to
00:56:39.080 find
00:56:39.300 out
00:56:39.440 what
00:56:39.600 they'll
00:56:39.800 do
00:56:40.060 now
00:56:41.000 if
00:56:41.700 they
00:56:41.880 want
00:56:42.240 to
00:56:42.380 get
00:56:42.600 better
00:56:43.040 which
00:56:43.480 is
00:56:43.620 not
00:56:43.820 a
00:56:43.960 given
00:56:44.220 because
00:56:45.180 there
00:56:45.660 are
00:56:45.800 often
00:56:46.100 payoffs
00:56:46.600 for
00:56:46.800 not
00:56:47.020 getting
00:56:47.300 better
00:56:47.680 that's
00:56:48.640 basically
00:56:48.940 the
00:56:49.140 payoffs
00:56:49.400 of
00:56:49.540 being
00:56:49.700 a
00:56:49.840 martyr
00:56:50.100 or
00:56:50.620 maybe
00:56:50.800 the
00:56:50.980 payoffs
00:56:51.300 of
00:56:51.460 doing
00:56:51.680 what
00:56:51.900 your
00:56:52.140 entirely
00:56:52.980 pathological
00:56:53.700 family
00:56:54.100 members
00:56:54.420 want
00:56:54.720 you
00:56:54.840 to
00:56:54.940 do
00:56:55.040 because
00:56:55.260 they
00:56:55.420 actually
00:56:55.660 want
00:56:55.880 you
00:56:55.980 to
00:56:56.100 fail
00:56:56.380 assuming
00:56:57.720 you
00:56:57.920 want
00:56:58.080 to
00:56:58.160 get
00:56:58.300 better
00:56:58.580 there's
00:56:58.820 usually
00:56:59.200 something
00:56:59.760 you
00:57:00.020 can
00:57:00.180 figure
00:57:00.460 out
00:57:00.760 that
00:57:01.180 would
00:57:01.320 constitute
00:57:01.760 a
00:57:01.960 step
00:57:02.280 towards
00:57:02.660 some
00:57:02.880 sort
00:57:03.120 of
00:57:03.220 concrete
00:57:03.620 goal
00:57:03.960 and
00:57:04.780 my
00:57:12.600 unbelievably
00:57:13.260 powerful
00:57:13.780 so
00:57:14.500 this is
00:57:15.700 another
00:57:15.920 thing
00:57:16.160 to
00:57:16.320 know
00:57:16.600 about
00:57:16.900 in
00:57:17.060 your
00:57:17.180 own
00:57:17.360 life
00:57:17.580 it's
00:57:17.740 something
00:57:17.940 I
00:57:18.120 learned
00:57:18.300 in
00:57:18.440 part
00:57:18.620 from
00:57:18.800 reading
00:57:19.020 the
00:57:19.140 writings
00:57:19.460 of
00:57:19.580 Alexander
00:57:20.000 Solzhenitsyn
00:57:20.580 who's
00:57:20.780 a great
00:57:21.180 Russian
00:57:21.860 philosopher
00:57:22.460 and
00:57:22.660 novelist
00:57:23.160 he said
00:57:24.260 you can
00:57:24.500 look at
00:57:24.800 your
00:57:24.940 life
00:57:25.240 and
00:57:25.380 you
00:57:25.500 can
00:57:25.620 see
00:57:25.980 what
00:57:26.600 isn't
00:57:27.000 right
00:57:27.280 about
00:57:27.580 it
00:57:27.800 all
00:57:28.440 you
00:57:28.560 have
00:57:28.700 to
00:57:28.800 is
00:57:28.900 look
00:57:29.200 and
00:57:30.200 then
00:57:30.420 you
00:57:30.580 can
00:57:30.740 start
00:57:31.020 to
00:57:31.180 fix
00:57:31.400 that
00:57:31.720 and
00:57:31.900 the
00:57:32.140 way
00:57:32.260 you
00:57:32.400 fix
00:57:32.600 it
00:57:32.720 is
00:57:32.840 by
00:57:33.080 noticing
00:57:34.180 what
00:57:34.640 you
00:57:34.860 could
00:57:35.320 in
00:57:35.560 fact
00:57:35.940 fix
00:57:36.460 you
00:57:37.340 know
00:57:37.420 people
00:57:37.680 are
00:57:37.840 often
00:57:38.120 trying
00:57:38.360 to
00:57:38.460 fix
00:57:38.620 things
00:57:38.840 they
00:57:38.980 can't
00:57:39.280 fix
00:57:39.540 which
00:57:39.720 I
00:57:39.820 would
00:57:39.960 not
00:57:40.200 recommend
00:57:40.560 because
00:57:40.900 if
00:57:41.080 you
00:57:41.200 try
00:57:41.400 to
00:57:41.520 fix
00:57:41.700 something
00:57:41.960 you
00:57:42.140 can't
00:57:42.420 fix
00:57:42.600 you'll
00:57:42.740 just
00:57:42.920 ruin
00:57:43.200 it
00:57:43.420 like
00:57:43.960 you
00:57:44.080 can
00:57:44.240 find
00:57:44.480 all
00:57:44.660 sorts
00:57:44.880 of
00:57:44.980 undergraduates
00:57:45.540 who are
00:57:45.720 perfectly
00:57:46.120 willing
00:57:46.440 to
00:57:46.640 restructure
00:57:47.220 the
00:57:47.540 international
00:57:49.220 economic
00:57:49.900 system
00:57:50.340 who
00:57:50.840 cannot
00:57:51.140 keep
00:57:51.500 their
00:57:51.700 room
00:57:51.940 clean
00:57:52.320 and
00:57:53.080 there's
00:57:53.240 actually
00:57:53.520 a
00:57:53.700 gap
00:57:54.060 there
00:57:54.400 and
00:57:54.960 it's
00:57:55.440 surprising
00:57:55.800 that
00:57:56.000 people
00:57:56.220 don't
00:57:56.440 actually
00:57:56.760 notice
00:57:57.120 so
00:57:57.620 I
00:57:57.780 would
00:57:57.940 say
00:57:58.200 if
00:57:58.660 you
00:57:58.780 pay
00:57:58.940 attention
00:57:59.280 you
00:57:59.520 can
00:57:59.700 see
00:57:59.980 things
00:58:00.320 that
00:58:00.460 you
00:58:00.560 could
00:58:00.720 fix
00:58:01.120 they
00:58:01.500 yell
00:58:01.740 at
00:58:01.900 you
00:58:02.100 they
00:58:02.340 really
00:58:02.640 do
00:58:02.940 we
00:58:03.340 even
00:58:03.500 know
00:58:03.720 how
00:58:03.900 that
00:58:04.100 happens
00:58:04.620 let me
00:58:05.920 let me
00:58:06.120 give you
00:58:06.340 an example
00:58:06.840 because rooms
00:58:07.600 are full
00:58:07.900 of stories
00:58:08.520 and the
00:58:09.520 stories
00:58:09.780 have
00:58:10.100 have
00:58:10.700 effects
00:58:11.220 on
00:58:11.440 you
00:58:11.560 so
00:58:11.680 here's
00:58:12.000 a
00:58:12.060 classic
00:58:12.380 experiment
00:58:12.940 so
00:58:13.880 you
00:58:14.060 take
00:58:14.380 two
00:58:14.660 groups
00:58:14.920 undergraduates
00:58:15.640 you
00:58:15.760 bring
00:58:15.940 them
00:58:16.020 into
00:58:16.180 your
00:58:16.340 lab
00:58:16.640 and
00:58:17.220 you
00:58:17.300 give
00:58:17.440 one
00:58:17.700 group
00:58:18.020 a
00:58:18.420 multiple
00:58:18.740 choice
00:58:19.120 test
00:58:19.520 that
00:58:20.040 has
00:58:20.220 a
00:58:20.300 bunch
00:58:20.480 of
00:58:20.580 words
00:58:20.800 in
00:58:20.940 it
00:58:21.060 that
00:58:21.180 are
00:58:21.260 associated
00:58:21.680 with
00:58:21.900 being
00:58:22.120 old
00:58:22.460 and
00:58:23.000 you
00:58:23.120 give
00:58:23.300 the
00:58:23.500 other
00:58:23.700 group
00:58:23.980 the
00:58:24.160 same
00:58:24.360 multiple
00:58:24.660 choice
00:58:24.980 test
00:58:25.300 except
00:58:25.600 the
00:58:25.820 words
00:58:26.020 associated
00:58:26.480 with
00:58:26.660 being
00:58:26.840 young
00:58:27.100 this
00:58:27.500 is
00:58:27.600 independent
00:58:28.120 of the
00:58:28.540 content
00:58:28.880 of
00:58:29.160 the
00:58:29.280 test
00:58:29.600 it's
00:58:30.140 just
00:58:30.320 descriptions
00:58:31.000 and
00:58:31.980 then
00:58:32.120 you
00:58:32.220 time
00:58:32.460 the
00:58:32.600 undergraduates
00:58:33.140 as they
00:58:33.420 walk
00:58:33.600 back
00:58:33.800 to
00:58:33.920 the
00:58:34.040 elevators
00:58:34.440 the
00:58:35.320 ones
00:58:35.540 who
00:58:35.660 read
00:58:35.940 the
00:58:36.460 ones
00:58:36.700 completed
00:58:37.080 the
00:58:37.240 multiple
00:58:37.500 choice
00:58:37.820 test
00:58:38.120 that
00:58:38.280 had
00:58:38.440 more
00:58:38.620 words
00:58:38.880 associated
00:58:39.280 with
00:58:39.480 aging
00:58:39.760 walk
00:58:40.220 slower
00:58:40.480 back
00:58:40.740 to
00:58:40.860 the
00:58:40.960 elevators
00:58:41.320 and
00:58:42.000 they
00:58:42.100 don't
00:58:42.320 know
00:58:42.520 that
00:58:42.780 and
00:58:43.200 they
00:58:43.480 don't
00:58:43.600 know
00:58:43.700 they're
00:58:43.820 doing
00:58:44.000 it
00:58:44.160 and
00:58:44.460 that
00:58:44.700 that
00:58:45.300 study
00:58:45.580 has
00:58:45.700 been
00:58:45.840 replicated
00:58:46.300 in
00:58:46.500 various
00:58:46.820 forms
00:58:47.180 many
00:58:47.680 many
00:58:47.900 times
00:58:48.240 you're
00:58:48.540 unbelievably
00:58:49.140 sensitive
00:58:49.640 to
00:58:49.900 the
00:58:50.060 story
00:58:50.400 that
00:58:50.580 your
00:58:50.720 environment
00:58:51.020 is
00:58:51.160 telling
00:58:51.380 you
00:58:51.580 because
00:58:52.100 your
00:58:52.260 environment
00:58:52.560 is
00:58:52.740 not
00:58:52.940 made
00:58:53.080 out
00:58:53.200 of
00:58:53.300 objects
00:58:53.700 that's
00:58:54.380 just
00:58:54.540 wrong
00:58:55.020 your
00:58:55.580 environment
00:58:55.960 is
00:58:56.140 basically
00:58:56.500 made
00:58:56.720 out
00:58:56.840 of
00:58:56.920 something
00:58:57.140 like
00:58:57.360 tools
00:58:57.680 and
00:58:57.840 obstacles
00:58:58.260 you're
00:58:58.640 a tool
00:58:58.920 using
00:58:59.260 creature
00:58:59.680 you're
00:59:00.120 a tool
00:59:00.380 perceiving
00:59:01.000 creature
00:59:01.440 the
00:59:01.920 things
00:59:02.180 you
00:59:02.340 like
00:59:02.560 if
00:59:02.700 I
00:59:02.780 take
00:59:03.020 you
00:59:03.120 out
00:59:03.220 of
00:59:03.260 this
00:59:03.400 room
00:59:03.600 and
00:59:03.700 I
00:59:03.780 say
00:59:03.900 well
00:59:04.000 what
00:59:04.140 was
00:59:04.260 in
00:59:04.380 the
00:59:04.460 room
00:59:04.720 you're
00:59:05.320 not
00:59:05.400 going to
00:59:05.600 say
00:59:05.840 you know
00:59:07.120 random
00:59:07.600 patterns
00:59:08.100 in the
00:59:08.400 carpet
00:59:08.720 because
00:59:09.120 they're
00:59:09.380 they're
00:59:09.680 real
00:59:10.000 just
00:59:10.720 as
00:59:10.860 good
00:59:11.020 an
00:59:11.100 object
00:59:11.380 as
00:59:11.560 anything
00:59:11.800 else
00:59:12.080 you're
00:59:12.480 going to
00:59:12.640 say
00:59:12.780 chairs
00:59:13.200 because
00:59:13.400 you
00:59:13.520 can
00:59:13.660 sit
00:59:13.880 on
00:59:14.040 them
00:59:14.200 and
00:59:14.380 you're
00:59:14.900 going
00:59:14.980 to
00:59:15.040 say
00:59:15.200 hand
00:59:15.440 rails
00:59:15.700 because
00:59:15.860 you
00:59:16.000 can
00:59:16.140 hold
00:59:16.400 them
00:59:16.520 you're
00:59:16.720 going
00:59:16.740 to
00:59:16.760 say
00:59:16.900 stairs
00:59:17.320 because
00:59:17.580 you
00:59:17.700 can
00:59:17.820 walk
00:59:18.100 down
00:59:18.360 them
00:59:18.580 that's
00:59:19.300 what
00:59:19.400 you
00:59:19.540 see
00:59:19.860 and
00:59:20.240 that's
00:59:20.400 what
00:59:20.500 you
00:59:20.600 interact
00:59:21.000 with
00:59:21.160 and
00:59:21.260 if
00:59:21.380 you
00:59:21.460 pay
00:59:21.640 attention
00:59:21.960 to
00:59:22.120 your
00:59:22.240 environment
00:59:22.660 which
00:59:23.320 is
00:59:23.460 you
00:59:23.680 by
00:59:23.840 the
00:59:23.980 way
00:59:24.140 extended
00:59:24.720 all of
00:59:25.600 your
00:59:25.700 experience
00:59:26.160 is
00:59:26.320 you
00:59:26.580 it
00:59:26.960 will
00:59:27.080 tell
00:59:27.280 you
00:59:27.420 all
00:59:27.520 the
00:59:27.580 time
00:59:27.820 what
00:59:27.960 you
00:59:28.080 should
00:59:28.260 do
00:59:28.520 all
00:59:28.820 you
00:59:28.920 have
00:59:29.020 to
00:59:29.120 do
00:59:29.420 it
00:59:29.560 but
00:59:29.960 then
00:59:30.120 you
00:59:30.260 have
00:59:30.460 to
00:59:30.560 decide
00:59:30.900 if
00:59:31.040 you
00:59:31.060 want
00:59:31.320 to
00:59:31.420 do
00:59:31.580 it
00:59:32.260 one
00:59:32.540 of
00:59:32.620 the
00:59:32.700 things
00:59:32.960 I
00:59:33.060 noticed
00:59:33.440 about
00:59:33.720 people
00:59:34.100 because
00:59:34.380 I
00:59:34.460 wondered
00:59:34.800 once
00:59:35.120 I
00:59:35.240 started
00:59:35.500 studying
00:59:35.840 these
00:59:36.000 mythological
00:59:36.560 stories
00:59:37.020 and I
00:59:37.320 got
00:59:37.500 this
00:59:37.720 idea
00:59:38.020 about
00:59:38.340 the
00:59:39.300 fact
00:59:39.800 that
00:59:40.080 life
00:59:40.900 can
00:59:41.120 be
00:59:41.320 meaningful
00:59:41.880 enough
00:59:42.480 to
00:59:42.700 justify
00:59:43.300 its
00:59:43.620 suffering
00:59:44.080 I
00:59:44.260 thought
00:59:44.400 god
00:59:44.640 that's
00:59:44.880 such
00:59:45.060 a
00:59:45.180 good
00:59:45.320 idea
00:59:45.660 because
00:59:46.340 it's
00:59:46.480 not
00:59:46.680 optimistic
00:59:47.200 exactly
00:59:47.840 you
00:59:48.000 know
00:59:48.080 some
00:59:48.340 people
00:59:48.580 tell
00:59:48.860 you
00:59:48.980 well
00:59:49.120 you
00:59:49.240 can
00:59:49.380 be
00:59:49.520 happy
00:59:49.880 it's
00:59:50.060 like
00:59:50.220 those
00:59:50.420 people
00:59:50.660 are
00:59:50.800 idiots
00:59:51.220 I'm
00:59:51.940 telling
00:59:52.280 you
00:59:52.480 they're
00:59:52.720 idiots
00:59:53.120 there's
00:59:53.400 going
00:59:53.540 to
00:59:53.580 be
00:59:53.740 things
00:59:54.000 that
00:59:54.120 come
00:59:54.300 along
00:59:54.580 that
00:59:54.940 flatten
00:59:55.400 you
00:59:55.620 so
00:59:55.820 hard
00:59:56.060 you
00:59:56.200 won't
00:59:56.420 believe
00:59:56.800 it
00:59:57.020 and
00:59:57.720 you're
00:59:57.860 not
00:59:58.000 happy
00:59:58.360 then
00:59:58.600 and
00:59:58.760 so
00:59:58.880 if
00:59:59.000 life
00:59:59.240 is
00:59:59.380 to
00:59:59.480 be
00:59:59.620 happy
00:59:59.960 well
01:00:00.180 in
01:00:00.300 those
01:00:00.460 situations
01:00:00.960 what
01:00:01.460 are
01:00:01.540 you
01:00:01.620 doing
01:00:01.900 why
01:00:02.240 even
01:00:02.440 live
01:00:02.840 but
01:00:04.080 life
01:00:04.360 isn't
01:00:04.960 to
01:00:05.120 be
01:00:05.320 happy
01:00:05.740 if
01:00:06.000 you're
01:00:06.140 happy
01:00:06.420 you're
01:00:06.600 bloody
01:00:06.860 fortunate
01:00:07.260 and
01:00:07.540 you
01:00:07.680 should
01:00:07.840 enjoy
01:00:08.180 it
01:00:08.360 you
01:00:08.720 should
01:00:08.960 because
01:00:09.240 it's
01:00:09.460 the
01:00:09.600 grace
01:00:09.880 of
01:00:10.060 god
01:00:10.320 so
01:00:10.500 to
01:00:10.660 speak
01:00:10.920 with
01:00:11.940 regards
01:00:12.280 to
01:00:12.580 meaning
01:00:23.400 because
01:00:24.320 other
01:00:24.480 people
01:00:24.700 want
01:00:24.900 you
01:00:24.980 to
01:00:25.060 do
01:00:25.180 other
01:00:25.340 things
01:00:25.640 and
01:00:25.820 it's
01:00:26.160 a
01:00:26.300 struggle
01:00:26.700 but
01:00:27.060 everything
01:00:27.680 is
01:00:27.840 a
01:00:27.960 struggle
01:00:28.260 and
01:00:28.740 then
01:00:28.860 I
01:00:28.980 thought
01:00:29.200 well
01:00:29.460 oh
01:00:30.220 I
01:00:30.380 get
01:00:30.560 it
01:00:30.700 I
01:00:30.820 see
01:00:31.040 why
01:00:31.320 it
01:00:31.500 took
01:00:31.640 me
01:00:31.760 about
01:00:31.900 ten
01:00:32.140 years
01:00:32.300 to
01:00:32.440 figure
01:00:32.580 this
01:00:32.760 out
01:00:32.960 people
01:00:33.440 have
01:00:33.680 a
01:00:33.760 choice
01:00:34.180 choice
01:00:34.960 number
01:00:35.180 one
01:00:35.520 nothing
01:00:36.240 you
01:00:36.440 do
01:00:36.620 means
01:00:36.940 anything
01:00:37.420 well
01:00:38.180 that's
01:00:38.360 kind
01:00:38.500 of
01:00:38.580 a
01:00:38.680 drag
01:00:39.080 right
01:00:39.380 meaninglessness
01:00:40.300 of
01:00:40.600 life
01:00:40.860 and
01:00:40.980 all
01:00:41.120 that
01:00:41.380 existential
01:00:41.940 angst
01:00:42.380 you
01:00:42.940 know
01:00:43.040 that's
01:00:43.340 kind
01:00:43.500 of
01:00:43.580 pain
01:00:43.940 but
01:00:44.300 the
01:00:44.420 upside
01:00:44.760 of
01:00:45.480 nothing
01:00:45.960 that
01:00:46.320 you
01:00:46.500 do
01:00:46.680 is
01:00:47.420 meaningful
01:00:47.800 is
01:00:48.160 you
01:00:48.820 don't
01:00:48.960 have
01:00:49.160 to
01:00:49.260 do
01:00:49.400 anything
01:00:49.800 you've
01:00:50.220 got
01:00:50.380 no
01:00:50.520 responsibility
01:00:51.160 now
01:00:51.640 you
01:00:51.760 have
01:00:51.900 to
01:00:52.020 suffer
01:00:52.280 because
01:00:52.640 things
01:00:52.920 are
01:00:53.040 meaningless
01:00:53.360 but
01:00:53.600 that's
01:00:53.820 a
01:00:53.920 small
01:00:54.120 price
01:00:54.380 to
01:00:54.520 pay
01:00:54.740 for
01:00:55.180 being
01:00:55.420 able
01:00:55.660 to
01:00:55.800 be
01:00:55.940 completely
01:00:56.560 useless
01:00:57.220 the
01:00:58.220 alternative
01:00:58.760 the
01:00:59.340 alternative
01:00:59.800 is
01:01:00.200 everything
01:01:00.840 you
01:01:01.120 do
01:01:01.300 matters
01:01:01.780 really
01:01:02.900 if
01:01:03.460 you
01:01:03.540 make
01:01:03.740 a
01:01:03.840 mistake
01:01:04.200 it's
01:01:04.660 a
01:01:04.760 real
01:01:04.900 mistake
01:01:05.440 if
01:01:05.840 you
01:01:05.960 betray
01:01:06.440 someone
01:01:07.000 you
01:01:07.420 tilt
01:01:07.760 the
01:01:07.940 world
01:01:08.180 a
01:01:08.380 little
01:01:08.540 more
01:01:08.840 sharply
01:01:09.260 towards
01:01:09.700 evil
01:01:10.020 rather
01:01:10.320 than
01:01:10.580 good
01:01:10.880 it
01:01:11.320 matters
01:01:11.820 what
01:01:12.100 you
01:01:12.240 do
01:01:12.560 well
01:01:13.200 if
01:01:13.340 you
01:01:13.440 buy
01:01:13.640 that
01:01:13.900 then
01:01:14.080 you
01:01:14.180 can
01:01:14.300 have
01:01:14.440 a
01:01:14.540 meaningful
01:01:14.780 life
01:01:15.180 but
01:01:15.860 there's
01:01:16.500 no
01:01:16.660 mucking
01:01:16.940 around
01:01:17.320 it
01:01:18.300 means
01:01:18.620 responsibility
01:01:19.280 it
01:01:19.920 means
01:01:20.120 that
01:01:20.260 the
01:01:20.400 decisions
01:01:20.720 you
01:01:20.940 make
01:01:21.160 are
01:01:21.440 important
01:01:21.940 it
01:01:22.500 means
01:01:22.720 that
01:01:22.860 when
01:01:23.000 you
01:01:23.120 do
01:01:23.580 something
01:01:23.900 wrong
01:01:24.280 it's
01:01:24.940 wrong
01:01:25.580 well
01:01:26.740 do
01:01:27.340 you
01:01:27.400 want
01:01:27.640 that
01:01:27.960 are
01:01:33.180 we
01:01:33.380 centers
01:01:33.780 of
01:01:34.140 our
01:01:34.300 own
01:01:34.540 morality
01:01:35.040 see
01:01:37.980 that's
01:01:38.220 a very
01:01:38.480 hard
01:01:38.720 question
01:01:39.080 because
01:01:39.360 people
01:01:39.640 don't
01:01:39.860 always
01:01:40.100 mean
01:01:40.300 the
01:01:40.440 same
01:01:40.640 thing
01:01:40.880 when
01:01:41.020 they
01:01:41.180 say
01:01:41.340 their
01:01:41.520 own
01:01:41.680 moral
01:01:41.920 compass
01:01:42.360 now
01:01:43.060 so
01:01:43.280 here
01:01:43.580 here
01:01:43.860 here
01:01:44.140 here's
01:01:44.300 here's
01:01:44.960 what
01:01:45.160 I
01:01:45.280 mean
01:01:45.460 by
01:01:45.620 that
01:01:45.840 technically
01:01:46.340 part
01:01:47.240 of the
01:01:47.420 way
01:01:47.640 the
01:01:47.980 reason
01:01:48.280 that
01:01:48.660 you're
01:01:48.800 able
01:01:48.960 to
01:01:49.100 distinguish
01:01:49.440 between
01:01:49.820 right
01:01:50.020 and
01:01:50.120 wrong
01:01:50.280 is
01:01:50.400 because
01:01:50.660 you
01:01:50.920 are
01:01:51.160 a
01:01:51.320 certain
01:01:51.520 kind
01:01:51.760 of
01:01:51.880 biological
01:01:52.360 organism
01:01:52.940 and
01:01:53.700 then
01:01:53.840 another
01:01:54.120 reason
01:01:54.440 is
01:01:54.740 that
01:01:55.620 your
01:01:55.840 head
01:01:56.080 is
01:01:56.220 full
01:01:56.400 of
01:01:56.500 other
01:01:56.660 people
01:01:57.020 right
01:01:58.280 all
01:01:58.440 the
01:01:58.560 people
01:01:58.740 you've
01:01:58.960 met
01:01:59.120 all
01:01:59.260 the
01:01:59.360 people
01:01:59.540 that
01:01:59.660 you've
01:01:59.820 interacted
01:02:00.220 with
01:02:00.420 they're
01:02:00.560 all
01:02:00.700 telling
01:02:00.960 you
01:02:01.160 a
01:02:01.520 way
01:02:01.740 to
01:02:01.900 behave
01:02:02.180 that's
01:02:02.440 good
01:02:02.620 and
01:02:02.740 a
01:02:02.840 way
01:02:02.960 that
01:02:03.100 isn't
01:02:03.500 there
01:02:04.660 are
01:02:04.820 circumstances
01:02:05.460 under
01:02:05.800 which
01:02:06.140 your
01:02:06.520 conscience
01:02:07.040 should
01:02:07.480 the duty
01:02:08.620 you have
01:02:09.240 to your
01:02:09.500 conscience
01:02:09.860 should
01:02:10.200 override
01:02:10.660 the duty
01:02:11.000 you have
01:02:11.440 to
01:02:11.580 social
01:02:11.900 norms
01:02:12.280 but
01:02:13.380 before
01:02:14.920 you
01:02:15.340 break
01:02:15.640 a
01:02:15.800 rule
01:02:16.020 because
01:02:17.520 you
01:02:17.720 think
01:02:17.920 you're
01:02:18.040 going
01:02:18.200 to
01:02:18.300 be
01:02:18.420 doing
01:02:18.580 a
01:02:18.720 good
01:02:18.840 thing
01:02:19.120 you
01:02:19.800 bloody
01:02:20.240 well
01:02:20.440 better
01:02:20.640 make
01:02:20.860 sure
01:02:21.020 you
01:02:21.140 have
01:02:21.280 your
01:02:21.420 head
01:02:21.580 screwed
01:02:21.800 on
01:02:22.000 straight
01:02:22.280 because
01:02:23.120 every
01:02:23.400 time
01:02:23.640 you
01:02:23.760 tell
01:02:23.940 yourself
01:02:24.320 a
01:02:24.520 lie
01:02:24.860 and
01:02:25.020 every
01:02:25.180 time
01:02:25.340 you
01:02:25.460 act
01:02:25.700 out
01:02:25.840 a
01:02:25.960 false
01:02:26.300 hood
01:02:26.520 you
01:02:27.320 disturb
01:02:28.520 the
01:02:29.080 pristine
01:02:29.860 integrity
01:02:30.460 of your
01:02:30.860 nervous
01:02:31.180 system
01:02:31.580 and
01:02:32.280 the
01:02:32.460 reports
01:02:32.920 it'll
01:02:33.120 give
01:02:33.280 you
01:02:33.400 about
01:02:33.560 the
01:02:33.680 nature
01:02:33.900 of
01:02:34.020 the
01:02:34.080 world
01:02:34.280 will
01:02:34.440 be
01:02:34.600 distorted
01:02:35.060 as
01:02:35.280 a
01:02:35.380 consequence
01:02:35.740 of
01:02:36.000 that
01:02:36.240 so
01:02:37.080 yeah
01:02:37.320 you
01:02:37.520 have
01:02:37.800 a
01:02:37.960 moral
01:02:38.160 obligation
01:02:38.620 to
01:02:38.840 follow
01:02:39.000 the
01:02:39.160 dictates
01:02:39.540 of
01:02:39.660 your
01:02:39.780 conscience
01:02:40.180 but
01:02:40.660 you
01:02:40.760 also
01:02:40.960 have
01:02:41.120 a
01:02:41.220 moral
01:02:41.500 obligation
01:02:42.180 to
01:02:42.680 make
01:02:42.880 sure
01:02:43.060 that
01:02:43.260 your
01:02:43.400 life
01:02:43.660 is
01:02:43.820 straight
01:02:44.060 enough
01:02:44.260 so
01:02:44.400 that
01:02:44.540 you
01:02:44.640 can
01:02:44.780 rely
01:02:45.020 on
01:02:45.180 your
01:02:45.300 own
01:02:45.460 judgment
01:02:45.760 and
01:02:46.360 you
01:02:46.480 can't
01:02:46.780 separate
01:02:47.100 those
01:02:47.380 things
01:03:12.180 by googling
01:03:12.980 Jordan
01:03:13.540 Peterson
01:03:14.020 Patreon
01:03:14.700 thank you
01:03:16.100 for listening