The King's Hall - March 04, 2022


Big, Fast, & Famous

Topics
Mentioned
Welcome to the King's Hall Pastoral, Plodding, & Productive

Episode Stats


Length

1 hour and 13 minutes

Words per minute

185.92

Word count

13,644

Sentence count

740

Harmful content

Misogyny

10

sentences flagged

Toxicity

41

sentences flagged

Hate speech

79

sentences flagged


Transcript

Transcript generated with Whisper (turbo).
Misogyny classifications generated with MilaNLProc/bert-base-uncased-ear-misogyny .
Toxicity classifications generated with s-nlp/roberta_toxicity_classifier .
Hate speech classifications generated with facebook/roberta-hate-speech-dynabench-r4-target .
Topics generated with Qwen2.5-3B-Instruct.
Hosts, guests, and mentioned names generated with spaCy (en_core_web_sm), reconciled against Wikidata.
00:00:00 Hey guys, Brian here with a big announcement from New Christendom Press.
00:00:03 Possibly our most important book yet is now available for pre-order.
00:00:08 It's called The Longhouse, How Feminism Conquered the West and Made Us All Miserable.
00:00:13 And in it, Eric and I take you through the dark history of feminism,
00:00:17 what it's done to everything from politics to church life to the economy,
00:00:21 and what to do about it.
00:00:23 Pre-order it today at newchristendompress.com slash longhouse.
00:00:26 And as a thank you for pre-ordering, you'll get 10% off automatically.
00:00:30 We'll also be signing the first thousand copies, so pick yours up today.
00:00:37 I am the god Thor.
00:00:39 I am the war god.
00:00:41 I am the thunderer.
00:00:43 Here in my northland, my fastness and fortress, reign I forever.
00:00:48 Force rules the world still, has ruled it, shall rule it.
00:00:51 Meekness is weakness.
00:00:53 Strength is triumphant.
00:00:55 Over the whole earth still it is Thor's day. Thou art a god too, O Galilean.
00:01:01 And thus, single-handed unto the combat, gauntlet or gospel, here I defy thee.
00:01:07 Excerpts from The Challenge of Thor, a poem by Henry Wadsworth Longfellow.
00:01:14 A little more than 1,300 years ago, the region we now know as Germany was a battleground between
00:01:20 the missionary efforts of the Anglo-Saxon Christian Church and the Germanic pagans living
00:01:25 in the Frankish Empire. These pagans were worshippers of the old Norse gods, mainly
00:01:30 known by their Scandinavian names Thor, Odin, Freya, and more. That pagan world was a bloody, 0.97
00:01:37 brutal world, full of tribal conflict, murder, warring, human sacrifice, and all manner of 0.99
00:01:44 barbaric violence. Into that world, a Benedictine monk named Boniface, along with a cohort of
00:01:50 his Christian brothers, boldly defied the pagan gods, seeking the freedom of the Germanic pagans
00:01:55 from the bloodthirsty wraiths demanding their worship. To show the supremacy of the Christian 0.95
00:02:01 god over the pagan idols, Boniface determined to walk after the prophet Elijah in his showdown 0.91
00:02:06 with the prophets of Baal in 1 Kings 18. Sometime around the year 723 in the town of Gaismar,
00:02:13 Boniface strode up to a great oak tree, a tree known to the locals as Thor's oak,
00:02:18 dedicated to the worship of the Norse god of thunder
00:02:21 and declared his intentions to chop down the tree in Christ's name. 0.92
00:02:26 The Germanic pagans laughed.
00:02:28 They knew that if anyone so much as broke a twig from their sacred tree,
00:02:32 Thor would surely strike that one down with his lightning before the branch hit the forest floor.
00:02:38 But Boniface set his face, determined to make the attempt.
00:02:42 The tree before him, he stripped to the waist,
00:02:44 took up his trusty axe and began to rain blow after blow into the trunk of the sacred tree.
00:02:51 Some accounts say that a mighty wind began to blow out of nowhere,
00:02:54 felling the tree with a great crash before Boniface could even complete the task with his axe.
00:02:59 Either way, the astonished pagans,
00:03:02 seeing the apparent impotence of their god to stand against this axe-wielding servant of Yahweh,
00:03:07 converted to the Christian faith and submitted to Christian baptism.
00:03:11 Best of all, Boniface and his companions used the timber from the mighty tree to raise a house for Christian worship,
00:03:18 right there in the green groves of the converted pagans.
00:03:22 After several decades of courageous missions work in the Germanic fields of the Frankish Empire, Boniface was martyred,
00:03:28 pouring out his blood into the dark earth of the Germanic forest, a final gift to the lost pagans,
00:03:35 in hopes that even they would turn and bend the knee to Christ. 0.67
00:03:38 Now he looks on from the great cloud of Christ's witnesses
00:03:41 as many of his spiritual descendants continue to walk in his footsteps,
00:03:46 taking up the weapons of their warfare in high defiance of the crumbling and retreating demonic empire.
00:03:52 And so, though Thor may thunder his challenge to the crucified Galilean,
00:03:57 throwing down his bloody gauntlet,
00:03:59 in the end, the Galilean's gospel proves the mightier.
00:04:03 The King's Hall podcast exists to make self-ruled men who rule well and win the world.
00:04:15 The story you just heard, the story of St. Boniface and Thor's Oak,
00:04:19 is going to serve as something of a framework for where we're going here in the first season of the King's Hall podcast.
00:04:25 So this podcast is aimed at Christendom, right?
00:04:28 it's aimed at making self-ruled men who will make godly households that will build fruitful churches
00:04:34 and businesses and villages and towns and cities and nations. And so you can think about this
00:04:38 project as something of a blueprint for building a cathedral, basically. If Christendom is a
00:04:43 cathedral, where do we start? How do you lay a foundation that will hold this thing up for a
00:04:50 few thousand years? What's a flying buttress? How do you make one? Who's going to carve the gargoyles
00:04:55 basically on this thing and how. So we're going to be talking in the first season about how to
00:04:59 build that cathedral, how we can build the next Christendom in, and maybe even with, in some cases,
00:05:06 the rubble of that last one. And that's where the Boniface story comes in, because right away,
00:05:11 you know, the first day when you pull up to the job site for this cathedral, you're going to find
00:05:16 out two things very quickly. First, that the pagans have built a bunch of shrines and they've
00:05:22 planted their green groves in high places, and generally occupied the place where we fully intend
00:05:27 to build. And we're not interested in retreating to some remote corner of the world to build this
00:05:32 cathedral. Christendom isn't going to be put up on a remote island somewhere that they haven't
00:05:38 gotten to yet in some kind of effort to avoid, you know, clashing with them. No, Christianity
00:05:43 is a religion of conquest. In the Old Testament shadows, we see God built a temple and called the 1.00
00:05:51 nations to that temple. But the New Testament substance that all of that pointed to, I could
00:05:57 say, is a people who are God's temple, and God is sending his temple to the nations now, and he's
00:06:05 making his temple out of the nation. So Old Testament, you have physical temple, come to
00:06:11 this temple and worship Yahweh. New Testament, the substance revealed by all of that shadow and type
00:06:16 is that we are God's temple. We're living stones, Peter says, built up into a structure for his own
00:06:21 possessions. And so we're sent to the nations to make this temple out of the nations. So we're
00:06:28 going to be playing offense in that plan, right? The scriptures make that plain, go and make
00:06:32 disciples of all the nations, baptizing them in the name of the father, the son, and the Holy
00:06:37 spirit, teaching them to obey all Christ commanded in all of that. That's offense talk, right? We're
00:06:43 going to play some defense along the way, but that's fundamentally offense. And so like Boniface,
00:06:49 we're going to need our acts to confront the pagan gods.
00:06:54 But there's another reason that we need Boniface and his acts, 0.75
00:06:56 because secondly, when you show up to this job site to build this cathedral of Christendom, 0.96
00:07:01 the job site is also cluttered with evangelical strip malls,
00:07:07 megachurch shantytowns, and all sorts of Christian clutter too, right? 0.95
00:07:13 There's not just pagan clutter to be confronted and removed 0.89
00:07:17 and to clear the way for this cathedral. 1.00
00:07:19 There's Christian clutter. So we've got grifters over the town square, hawking microwavable five second, you know, you know, six easy steps to Christianity sorts of things. Others are protesting the whole thing. They're mad that we're trying to build a cathedral at all because the Antichrist is coming and it's all going to burn. But it's not just pagan works that will need to be cleared away for this building project. There's a whole lot of shoddy work done by Christians, too. 1.00
00:07:45 Somewhere a while back, you could say someone put linoleum over the hardwood to mix the metaphor. 1.00
00:07:50 And so in these first few episodes, really before we get into the blueprints for this Christendom
00:07:54 cathedral, we're going to need to do some demolition work, which is Eric's favorite kind
00:07:59 of work, right? We're going to need to tear some things down. We're going to need to look back over
00:08:04 our shoulder and ask where it was that things went wrong and why, lest we repeat the same errors.
00:08:11 Judgment begins with the household of God, and so we need to start there.
00:08:15 So after we do that, then we'll turn our sights in the next episodes after that 0.95
00:08:19 on the pagan idols and ask which gods we need to poke in the eye 0.91
00:08:22 and whose oak trees we need to chop down, et cetera. 0.99
00:08:25 But first, we want to sink our acts into that strip mall 1.00
00:08:28 that the Christians have put up on our job site. 1.00
00:08:30 And so we'll be looking at some of the models of Christianity 0.99
00:08:34 that won't work going forward.
00:08:37 These models of Christianity that will not produce a cathedral, 0.79
00:08:39 will not produce Christendom.
00:08:42 And so we're not going to reform those models.
00:08:44 We're going to knock them down.
00:08:45 We're going to say no from the beginning to those models.
00:08:48 And so the first one that we're going to set our sights on,
00:08:51 you might call the big, fast, and famous model,
00:08:55 which is not original to us.
00:08:57 I think the first time I heard that was from a guy named Zach Eswine,
00:09:00 which I think he's four lady pastors and stuff,
00:09:03 so probably don't, you know.
00:09:05 But this isn't original to us.
00:09:08 The big, fast, and famous model, though, is what we're going to turn our sights on here in this first episode.
00:09:12 So, guys, what do we mean by big, fast, and famous?
00:09:16 What are some examples of this mentality?
00:09:24 In 2023, Indigo Sundries became one of our sponsors.
00:09:28 At the time, their business was little more than a side hobby, generating a couple hundred dollars a month.
00:09:32 But because of their partnership with us and because all of you chose to support them,
00:09:36 They've grown enough to make it their full-time livelihood. 0.56
00:09:38 This is what happens when Christians support Christians.
00:09:41 Our communities are strengthened and faithful businesses thrive.
00:09:43 So if you're a Christian business owner who wants to reach thousands of like-minded people
00:09:47 and grow your company, we'd love to partner with you.
00:09:50 Email us at advertising at newchristendompress.com.
00:09:58 Yeah, I think fundamentally you've got like the thousand plus member megachurches.
00:10:03 You've got celebrity pastors.
00:10:05 really what we've seen over the last couple
00:10:07 decades really starting in the 70s is sort of like
00:10:09 Hillsong worship so it's really
00:10:11 like going to a rock concert
00:10:13 and a lot of stuff that's really practical
00:10:15 like moving away from traditional
00:10:17 pastoral discipline, ecclesiology
00:10:19 but also moving
00:10:21 to things like
00:10:22 every week in church
00:10:25 if you're at Hillsong we perform
00:10:27 different music because the main
00:10:29 point of it is actually to sell albums
00:10:31 Spicy
00:10:33 Spicy, that's right
00:10:35 So I think a lot of that, too, is, you know, for my money, I think a lot of it got driven by Billy Graham, actually.
00:10:42 So really, a change in the 20th century was you had this fixation with mass media.
00:10:48 So mass media, people started to realize we can reach a lot of people really quickly.
00:10:54 And I think that's what fuels, you know, you get into people like Rick Warren in the 70s and 80s.
00:10:59 You get into Bill Hybels, and then it takes you to Mark Driscoll.
00:11:02 and really what it was all about is we can build a platform almost overnight if we have the right
00:11:07 technological yeah tools and franchise it yeah if using franchise models i think fundamentally
00:11:13 big fast and famous to me is about what happens when brand marketing comes to church oh so i'm
00:11:19 gonna leave it with that and i'm gonna kick it to dan because dan i think you could help unpack that
00:11:22 you've seen it i went to business school you're a business those two z's actually you know when i
00:11:29 When I started to define this, I realized that with any philosophy that we're going 0.98
00:11:34 to critique in these shantytowns, you're claiming they're shanties anyway. 1.00
00:11:37 Yeah. 1.00
00:11:38 They think that they're pretty great.
00:11:40 Oh, yeah.
00:11:40 You've got like the Crystal Palace or Crystal Cathedral.
00:11:43 That's right.
00:11:44 They think the linoleum belongs over the hardwood. 0.98
00:11:46 Shantytown. 0.87
00:11:47 That's what it is. 0.92
00:11:48 Shantytown.
00:11:48 No, when we're critiquing any philosophy and we're going to be critical of it, we're 0.53
00:11:53 going to have to untangle goodness and truth from badness and lies.
00:11:59 that's good it's kind of like gum in your kid's hair there are good parts and there are bad parts
00:12:06 and you're trying to untangle it and so you mean the hair is the good part uh yeah i mean you don't
00:12:11 want to yeah like your daughter you don't want to have to shave little daphne's head oh man i mean
00:12:15 those golden locks so for example you look at big fast and famous okay that's this is what we're
00:12:21 critiquing if you were to ask pastors from almost any denomination do you want your church to grow
00:12:29 they would say yes i mean almost yeah they say doesn't doesn't jesus want my church that's right
00:12:35 i want my church to grow uh so church growth is seen as a good thing and a lot of times it is it
00:12:43 is a good thing um but where things get sticky like the vending machine gumball that you should
00:12:49 not have bought that is in little Daphne's hair in this illustration yeah is how how are you going
00:12:55 to grow it how are you going to grow it and and so kind of piggybacking off of what you said Eric
00:13:01 yeah was that church growth for the sake of church growth is the ideology of cancer wow that's crazy
00:13:09 yeah because it spreads fast it spreads fast yep and it's just growth for growth's sake so you
00:13:15 really get into Dan you really get into what kind of growth is it because one of the things I thought
00:13:18 about as we were preparing for this is Mars Hill, right? We've been listening to the Christianity 0.58
00:13:24 Today podcast, hating most of it, loving a lot of what Mark did actually. But what's interesting to
00:13:30 me is 15,000 people were part of the Mars Hill, the immediate Mars Hill movement. Mark steps down
00:13:37 and it's done overnight. So I immediately said to myself, that was not healthy growth.
00:13:42 it could not have been like Redwood style, deep rooted, healthy Christian, sanctified growth,
00:13:49 right? Yeah. And so the way that these, these models typically follow is, is like a marketing
00:13:54 campaign. Yeah. And so again, this is sticky, right? Because we have things like we want to
00:13:59 be known as, as being respectable and having being well, well thought of by outsiders to a degree,
00:14:06 obviously. Um, so there's good and then there's bad cause you have branding, right? You have a
00:14:11 brand yeah uh paul the apostle had a brand he was known right but he didn't foster his brand
00:14:17 through marketing or his social media page or or whatever and so there's there's both the good and
00:14:22 the bad but i think that with this big fast famous model what you really have is these churches that
00:14:30 have turned where else are you trying to get people to buy your product it's it's in business
00:14:36 and so they have turned to the business world like you said to have marketing campaigns
00:14:41 brand management, value ads like child care, coffee shops, programs. You have entertainment,
00:14:48 dynamic speakers, music, which we'll touch on later, and even public relations campaigns through
00:14:54 painting houses or social welfare type programs that are pretty much PR campaigns.
00:15:01 Right. They're basically built on sounding the trumpet before you as you give.
00:15:06 Yeah. Yeah. I mean, that's what those are because that's what businesses do. They sound
00:15:09 the, why else would they do it? They exist to make money. That's their internal logic. So
00:15:15 of course they're going to sound the Trump. Well, and the thing is, is all of these,
00:15:19 you can see at every step, why I say, why I prefaced there's good and bad, like social
00:15:23 welfare is actually good to a point. It depends on the purpose. And so what these churches
00:15:30 incentivize, they get, right? Yeah. I mean, that's just a rule. They get customers is what they get.
00:15:36 And customers are there for socio-religious goods and services.
00:15:41 And it's really customers in a world of customers.
00:15:45 And so you can begin to see why this is more of a strip mall version of Christianity than a cathedral.
00:15:53 It's because they relate to the church as customers.
00:15:57 Yeah, it's a consumer-driven model.
00:15:59 Yes, they don't produce.
00:16:01 They basically say, okay, the pastor is essentially the CEO, and he has some other pastors on his board that are like the other executives, and they dispense religious goods and services in exchange for giving.
00:16:16 Or attendance, man.
00:16:17 Or attendance, even.
00:16:18 That's right.
00:16:19 If you've ever been in leadership at a church, the number of times people try to leverage their attendance to get you to do what they want, it's unbelievable.
00:16:27 Yeah.
00:16:28 I'll take my tithe.
00:16:29 You know what?
00:16:29 I'll take my tithe elsewhere.
00:16:30 Yeah.
00:16:31 You're like, well, can you imagine a son saying that?
00:16:34 Well, I'll take my chores elsewhere.
00:16:36 Not mine.
00:16:37 Oh, you will?
00:16:38 Oh, good.
00:16:39 No, you won't.
00:16:41 I'll help you pack your socks, as my mom said.
00:16:44 That's right.
00:16:45 Even, you know, back to Eric's point, when you were talking about the, that's not redwood tree growth,
00:16:49 talking about when Mars Hill exploded, and there was certainly some seeds that blew to the wind
00:16:54 and took up in some other congregations that were started.
00:16:57 But, you know, if you think about it, it's it's you could you could say that the trunk of the tree at Mars Hill was Mark.
00:17:05 He was the trunk. Christ wasn't the trunk. The church wasn't the trunk.
00:17:09 A guy was the trunk. And so when the guy died or when the guy gets disqualified or when the guy gets leaves in scandal or whatever, then the tree dies.
00:17:18 And the true church, it's not like that because Christ is the trunk.
00:17:22 Right. Right. He's the vine where the branch is. And so we grow off of Christ.
00:17:26 And so we're all disposable.
00:17:27 Like any of us can die.
00:17:30 And if we're doing this thing right,
00:17:33 any one of the pastors at our church should, 0.99
00:17:35 you know, should be able to die. 0.99
00:17:37 That sounds bad. 1.00
00:17:38 Should be able to die or move or, you know,
00:17:40 even Lord, you know, God forbid, be disqualified.
00:17:43 And the church should be able to continue 0.60
00:17:46 and other men step in. 0.93
00:17:48 Right.
00:17:48 Yeah, it's interesting.
00:17:49 It kind of gets into the next question
00:17:51 that we'll dive into, Brian.
00:17:52 But why is this model so toxic to future Christendom?
00:17:55 Yeah.
00:17:56 I think that you can look back at it and I've done a lot of this recently looking into the
00:18:01 Young Restless and Reform Movement, which is just one, you know, one iteration of Big Fast and
00:18:06 Famous and not always even the biggest, the fastest or the most famous. But by and large,
00:18:12 all the famous celebrity pastors that I grew up with, like they're gone. They're donezo. Yeah.
00:18:16 So, you know, you think about CJ Mahaney, you think about Josh Harris, you think about the
00:18:22 scandal that's rocked the church because of these guys you know what happened to acts 29 what
00:18:27 happened to mark mark driscoll um it's mostly bad stuff so it would seem like okay in a movement if
00:18:33 you had like one guy that fell apart you would go well you know maybe it's an anomaly yeah but when
00:18:39 you got darren patrick killing himself you've got oh yeah just a very very sad history of what
00:18:45 happened to that movement that's when i want to go back and i want to say there's something in
00:18:49 that concrete mix in the foundation that is not working because you can read the history of the
00:18:55 early church and it's not like that. Right. I think one of the things too, and Brian, I want to get
00:19:01 your take on this. It seems like this whole model of doing church, there's part of it that's
00:19:07 plausible. So I was talking to David Murrow recently, pretty interesting book really about
00:19:12 this type of church movement, which is called Why Men Hate Going to Church. But like there's
00:19:18 comments in there like he would say, you know, we need to do TED Talks and not sermons because
00:19:22 these really sell well and blah, blah, blah. Yeah. That sort of thing actually changes the
00:19:26 way that you do church and has an impact on, again, what's toxic. So I guess speak to that.
00:19:32 Why is that so toxic? Yeah. And I think once you get into the root DNA, that when you get down to
00:19:40 the foundations and you say, what's the guiding principle here? And as soon as you admit that
00:19:45 the guiding principle is something like as we're going to get as many people as possible,
00:19:49 as fast as possible, however possible. And usually they'll say short of sin. I think even like Perry
00:19:55 Noble, is that the name of the guy? Yeah. Or maybe even Rick Warren said something like that,
00:20:00 as many as possible, as fast as possible to be introduced to Jesus, however possible,
00:20:04 short of sin. It's this like normative principle on steroids, where instead of discovering
00:20:10 the foundational mission and methods of the church in scripture, and then fleshing those
00:20:16 out and simply obeying them and trusting, well, God probably knew what he was doing when he
00:20:20 established his church. Instead of that, we're saying, well, you know what, let's just sort of
00:20:25 say, what is Jesus really trying to do? Get a lot of people. Hey, you know what? Businesses do that.
00:20:32 Marketing does that. All sorts of other things do that. So let's say, oh, the scriptures are good.
00:20:37 we're still going to, we're going to incorporate the scriptures. We're going to preach the
00:20:40 scriptures still. And, you know, we're going to give advice from the scriptures, but fundamentally
00:20:44 we're just going to sort of distill down the mission and then try to pursue that mission
00:20:49 disconnected from the methods that God has established. And what happens is that very
00:20:55 quickly, I think men one overestimate in pride, the, the, their own ability to come up with
00:21:02 better methods than God's methods. That's the most proud, arrogant thing ever to say,
00:21:09 you know, God really didn't give us everything needful for the man of God to be trained in
00:21:13 righteousness and equipped for every good work, like the Bible says. But, you know, maybe we have
00:21:18 some other methods that are going to work. And so fundamentally, I think that what it does is it
00:21:22 elevates hubris. It elevates human ingenuity and pragmatism over principle. It ends up elevating
00:21:31 personalities then over communities, centralism, this mothership model built around personalities
00:21:37 over decentralization, lots of people, all of these principles you get in the scripture, like
00:21:41 leaven versus conveyor belts, right? All of these things, if you just discover the mission and
00:21:47 methods of the church in the scriptures, you'll get all of these actually, you know, the principles
00:21:54 that work. It's not like the scriptures don't work. They just take time. They say like, let's
00:22:00 let's operate on a very short time horizon. Let's think in six months, how many new attendees can
00:22:05 we get instead of, Hey, what is going to produce a church here in this city that in 100 years or
00:22:12 500 years will not only be here, but be stronger than it is today. Yeah. I think that model is
00:22:20 diametrically opposed to the normative means of evangelism within the covenant arc that God has
00:22:25 made like the way that he relates to people through the old and new covenant was not primarily through
00:22:31 those sorts of means of the mega church the big fast and famous model which is get as many people
00:22:36 in the door as possible we'll water it down so it's more palatable we'll wrap it up in whatever
00:22:40 dressings that we can yeah to make sure that people can swallow this thing and really they
00:22:44 become hucksters i mean yeah carpet baggers yeah and it's really sad because you do have gifted men
00:22:50 We're really strong leader types and they adopt a philosophy that is, 0.55
00:22:54 like I said,
00:22:55 diametrically opposed to the normative means of evangelism.
00:22:59 And here's why I think it's so toxic is this is a hot take by me.
00:23:04 Let's hear it.
00:23:04 Yeah.
00:23:04 I mean, 0.96
00:23:05 it might be garbage, 0.97
00:23:05 but the normative way that people have been converted and are united to God 0.99
00:23:12 covenantally is through fathers.
00:23:15 It's through fathers,
00:23:17 both in the old and new covenant.
00:23:19 you have instructions and promises to fathers and to their sons and so when the gospel is preached
00:23:28 even to men you know that aren't in covenant with God and they repent who becomes saved who is
00:23:34 commanded to be baptized and such it's their families and so this is kind of the the arc that
00:23:43 you see throughout scripture and and what the big fast famous model does is it neuters the
00:23:48 paterfamilias yeah it neuters the father and it replaces him yes with this personality yes and so
00:23:57 you can see why christians then turn and they support things like statism yeah it's just that
00:24:02 writ large because it becomes not a a father-son sort of relationship but it becomes who can give
00:24:10 me the best bang for my buck yeah so dan i want to ask you you said that it neuters fathers the
00:24:16 father-son relationship. My question would be how? Yeah, absolutely. So when you're buying
00:24:22 religious goods and services, you're trying to get the best value from your money and from your
00:24:26 attendance. And it does this functionally in so many ways, other than just the way that it
00:24:30 evangelizes people, is through things like programs. So we're going to separate your
00:24:35 children from the congregation for worship. I mean, that's nuts. Or how about this? Because
00:24:41 we trust the experts. We're going to send our kids to the state to be educated, right? Instead
00:24:47 of obeying Ephesians six, that says fathers raise your kids in the pie day and new thesis of the
00:24:52 Lord. Even, even growing up, I wasn't expected to attend the main congregational service until I was
00:25:00 literally on staff at the church as a worship leader at like maybe 17 or so. And that's when
00:25:06 I started attending the adult service because they had so that, you know, basically the goal
00:25:11 is if you're going to get customers, you need to make it as eat, make the customer experience as
00:25:14 easy as possible. So what's hard parenting, disciplining your kids. Let's take the little
00:25:20 kids out. Okay. You know, little kids, that's good. We've got them in kids ministry, but what
00:25:24 if we, you know, teenagers can be tough too. What if we took, what if we had a youth group
00:25:28 replicate a youth service at the same time as the adult? Well, when you're a pragmatist, you're,
00:25:32 you're trying to always speak to where the person is.
00:25:36 Even,
00:25:37 even Rick Warren said something,
00:25:39 I'm going to butcher this,
00:25:40 but essentially like people who have their needs met will come to your
00:25:43 church is,
00:25:44 is,
00:25:44 is essentially what it is as in like the people themselves know what they
00:25:48 need most.
00:25:49 Exactly.
00:25:50 Like just follow your heart.
00:25:52 Yeah.
00:25:52 Like their, 0.71
00:25:52 their,
00:25:52 their loves are properly ordered already.
00:25:55 They already know the good,
00:25:56 the true and the beautiful.
00:25:57 No,
00:25:57 no,
00:25:58 they don't.
00:25:58 Why do you think that the most popular novels sold in America today are 0.90
00:26:01 like trash romance novels. And it's because people don't know what is good. People need
00:26:07 their sensibilities and their loves and their moral values and their aesthetic values trained
00:26:13 by the really trained by the beautific vision, trained by God himself as our fountain of wisdom
00:26:22 and goodness and truth and beauty. And, you know, if you if instead you say, let's do demographic
00:26:29 studies on the culture figure out what people like and then let's let's make the church look
00:26:33 like that you know what you're doing you're literally making the church in the image of the
00:26:38 culture yeah it's literally what you're doing instead of telling all of the people you guys
00:26:44 you were jacked up you need to be made in the image of the god man right yeah totally backwards
00:26:50 yeah that's why we like this story of boniface so much yeah i mean because that's what he comes
00:26:56 into this germanic people and he says uh you all are bloodthirsty pagans and you need the the one
00:27:01 true and living god and so i'm gonna go chop down your your idol your big god tree yeah he didn't 0.91
00:27:07 say you know what these people really like trees let's make a sanctuary environment that is shaped
00:27:15 like the oak tree and maybe we could put like instead of the communion table we could have
00:27:20 like branches coming up and holding up the communion you know and it seems like these
00:27:25 germanic pagans really like face tattoos to you know celebrate the the people they've killed in
00:27:30 battle from the opposing tribes i know it sounds bad guys but maybe we should think about priestly 0.85
00:27:36 face tattoos it seems like you're saying that their culture was bad right cult human cultures
00:27:42 are bad and they need to be reformed according to this okay what this made me think of something
00:27:47 and i'm going to lose it if i don't say it so i'm just going to jack up the model the outline and
00:27:51 I'm going to say this. Why is this model so toxic to future Christendom? And I'm thinking about
00:27:55 Mark again, Mark Driscoll. And when you do everything Dan just said, and you make the,
00:28:01 you replace the father with this big centralized single celebrity figure, and whether that's Mark
00:28:07 Driscoll, Matt Chandler, Paul Washer, I mean, even take good guys, R.C. Sproul or, you know,
00:28:13 Calvin or whoever, you make one guy that that father of everybody, eventually, and then you,
00:28:20 especially if you then marry that idea to the idea that what we need is cultural influence
00:28:26 and marketing, all of a sudden, it's really easy for that guy to justify almost anything.
00:28:31 Think about what Mark allegedly did with his book. I think it was Real Marriage.
00:28:37 When they bought it onto the New York Times bestseller list with church funds, I think they
00:28:42 spent like a quarter, allegedly, quarter million dollars or something of church money to buy
00:28:46 enough copies of his book to get it on the New York Times bestseller list. Can you think about
00:28:52 how easy that line of thinking is? If success is as many people as fast as possible, well, then
00:29:00 we need cultural influence. We need to be seen as serious and important writers and thinkers and
00:29:04 authors. So you know what helps? Endorsement by the New York Times. Well, all we have to do is
00:29:08 put a quarter mil into it and we can get that. You just see how like you grease the skids in this
00:29:13 model to as many as possible as fast as possible however possible short of sin ends up dropping
00:29:19 the short of sin part pretty quickly to build the platform of the father replacement celebrity yeah
00:29:25 and then you'll basically do anything you'll just do anything i mean mark you know in you know in
00:29:31 the christianity today podcast again mark will talk about things like i am the brand yeah um and
00:29:38 he really was that's the thing he was he really was the brand but it's also interesting i think
00:29:42 from a so my background is in journalism and we used to always have a saying I know it was coined
00:29:47 by somebody big fast and famous I don't know but it was called the medium is the message right I
00:29:52 think there's a book to that title that's right but the whole point was the way you deliver the
00:29:57 message the way that you treat your people in the congregation what you're actually doing and Brian
00:30:01 you hit on this earlier you're actually changing the message right so when you're Andy Stanley
00:30:05 you know I started watching TED talks recently because I haven't really watched a lot and I
00:30:11 want to say like what is this about yeah what is when people say ted talk sermons like what are
00:30:15 what are those ted talks come out like 20 years ago we're on the cutting edge okay all right
00:30:20 bleeding edge so the other day i found ted talks i started listening to him simon cynic i literally
00:30:27 my first ted talks of all time and um i know it's so pathetic but what was interesting to me i was
00:30:33 like this is andy stanley this is what he's doing he's taking 12 minutes of your time he's telling
00:30:37 three cute stories um some insightful things he makes you laugh a little but what hit me about it
00:30:43 is it's not really deep it doesn't really challenge you in the sense of like a sermon
00:30:48 would call you to repentance yeah um and i but it's also very popular like you can sit there
00:30:54 and go oh that was clever and interesting again i think it gets to this issue of if that's going
00:30:59 to be your methodology it's going to change your message yeah just like praise and worship music
00:31:05 which entered the church, that utterly changed how we saw the worship experience from something
00:31:10 that we interact in and with, and we sing and the congregation sings. Well, now it becomes
00:31:16 something that we just stand there and watch. And now when you tell people, hey, sing, turn up your
00:31:21 volume, they're like, what are you crazy? Turn up the music. I'm not supposed to be doing this.
00:31:26 So it's utterly changed what we do. And the last thing I'll say is just this whole conversation
00:31:30 made me think about J.I. Packer. I mentioned the Redwoods earlier, but I think it's in a quest for
00:31:35 godliness he was talking about the puritans and he said our age is like frail little trees the
00:31:39 puritans were redwoods and so i think that the thing is is if you want to cultivate the kind
00:31:45 of christians that shape the culture that's not going to be a weak shallow christian right like
00:31:50 and what you see across america is we have the type of church and christians overall who are
00:31:55 like well fauci said to do it so i do it yeah we love your neighbor that's the depth of my theology
00:32:02 Yeah. A lot of this is actually, to me, centering on an idea or a contrast between two models that I think is important and that starts to get to the center of why this model is so toxic, why it tends to replace fathers with celebrity figures is because if you think about it, what we're talking about with Christendom, this cathedral of Christendom, is to shift the metaphor to the cathedral as the people of God, the temple, the living stones.
00:32:28 the temple is built out of individual bricks that are living stones, right? Individual
00:32:33 men and women and children and households. So fundamentally, this whole idea of Christendom,
00:32:40 if it's done right, isn't built on a single celebrity pope figure. It's built on lots of,
00:32:44 this is why, lots of self-ruled men who rule well and therefore win the world. Really what
00:32:50 we're talking about is decentralization versus centralization, in a sense. What we're talking
00:32:58 about with Christendom and Christianity, properly understood, is a whole lot of yeast-like
00:33:04 multiplication, where you have, the thing is a living structure built of millions and billions
00:33:11 of people, of human beings. And the health of that organism isn't going to be determined by
00:33:18 one little brick somewhere, right? Or even the model for what each brick ought to be isn't going
00:33:24 to be built by one little brick. It's going to be built by lots of households and men and women who
00:33:29 are being shaped in the image of Christ. So when you look at a lot of these models, one of the
00:33:35 tells that you'll always find is that things tend to be ultra, ultra centralized. They're a mothership,
00:33:42 not a forest right there they're they're a single big and often you know plastic redwood tree even
00:33:49 it's not real it's fake instead of this big vast forest don't you think a lot of that brian is just
00:33:55 copying corporate culture and what i mean is when you read about the history of like you know
00:34:01 businesses in america dan you could speak to this probably too but like even walmart when it first
00:34:06 started wasn't what it is today and now we've gone to this mega globo corporation that dominates
00:34:12 everything. I would argue America was actually stronger at many points when you had distributed
00:34:16 power, property, et cetera. Yeah. Well, even the foundations of democracy were dependent on
00:34:22 widespread property ownership, people who are well-educated. Yeah. The Reformation brought
00:34:27 about a lot of this. We've changed the fabric of our culture by treating people like consumers. 0.99
00:34:33 Yeah. Would you rather have 100 million households, each with a quarter acre garden,
00:34:38 growing a diverse local crops or 15 mega farms growing all the food in america it's it's the
00:34:44 anti-fragile philosophy again because centralization is very fragile it is it looks
00:34:50 strong yeah we've seen that with supply chains yeah but it's not chains yeah with like meat
00:34:55 shortages there's only a few packing houses or butchers or i i can't recall where the weak spot
00:35:00 was but essentially there are only a few of them and so all of a sudden during covid we had no meat
00:35:04 or the prices went up really high
00:35:07 because they're shutting them down
00:35:08 since it's so centralized,
00:35:10 since it's almost impossible
00:35:11 because of regulations
00:35:12 to open your own packing house.
00:35:15 And so the centralization model
00:35:17 is very fragile.
00:35:19 That's why you see one man falling.
00:35:22 The whole thing crumbles.
00:35:23 Yep, yep.
00:35:23 It's because it's so completely centralized.
00:35:26 Christianity is anti-fragile. 0.79
00:35:28 The whole thing is built on people dying. 0.97
00:35:31 Right.
00:35:31 And that's how we win.
00:35:32 Yeah, we win by dying. 0.99
00:35:33 we win by dying in fact you kill us you're helping us yes in fact anything you do to us
00:35:39 according to romans 8 28 to 36 you're actually helping us okay take away all our money well 0.90
00:35:44 he's working famine together for our good and poverty and you know kill us he's working our
00:35:48 death for our good well pardon the interruption but we wanted to give a quick shout out to our
00:35:53 first patrons first supporters of the show over on patreon nate norris emmanuel drake josh bishop
00:35:59 Thomas Stone. Thank you guys. We appreciate your support. If you want to become a supporter of the
00:36:06 Kings Hall podcast and get access to things like our after hours show that we produce with every
00:36:12 episode just for patrons, you can head to kingshall.org, click on support the show there
00:36:17 in the menu. And there are a few ways that you can do that with all sorts of benefits. But just
00:36:22 remember, you guys, we get more of what we support with our dollars, what we vote for with our
00:36:26 dollars. And if we want high quality Christian media, we have to know that, man, that takes time,
00:36:33 a lot of hours and work goes into a show like this, a lot of dollars and resources. So we
00:36:38 appreciate you guys who are supporting the show. We'd like to invite you if you're not,
00:36:42 and you enjoy the show to jump on board there. But with that said, let's get back to the episode.
00:36:48 So this also gets to one of the reasons why I think that this big, fast and famous model
00:36:55 ultimately is deeply patronizing to men particularly is because men, like if men are
00:37:01 being made in the image of Christ to be self-ruled by the spirit of God, to build households, to
00:37:07 go about their vocation Christianly, it is so deeply patronizing when you say, no, just come
00:37:14 and we've done it all for you. It's easy. You don't have to do any, you don't even have to 0.98
00:37:18 break a sweat to come to church. Like we'll give you some football jokes even to like make you feel
00:37:22 included. And it's so deeply patronizing when you give men a vision of essentially globo homo 0.96
00:37:30 statist hegemony where it's like, look, you guys just watch your TV, go to your job. It won't 0.97
00:37:37 really be that meaningful, but I mean, you have to do something with your time. And then, you know,
00:37:42 we will give you this church on the weekend that you can go to bring your family. We'll do
00:37:45 everything for you. We'll disciple your kids, your wife, you know, don't, you won't have to
00:37:50 lift a finger gents just kick back it's like to a man who actually understands what god made him 1.00
00:37:56 to be and do that's just like so deeply patronizing yeah it really is emasculating and it's interesting 0.66
00:38:03 too because again you like you think of the special forces uh it's really hard to get in
00:38:09 until people really want to be in it i've always said that with men it's like people like we just
00:38:13 need to keep lowering the bar for men and it's like i think you actually have to do the opposite
00:38:18 You have to raise the standard to what God's standard is.
00:38:21 But I'm really fascinated by this question of how we're actually reshaping the church
00:38:27 by the way that we try to be big, fast, and famous.
00:38:30 And I want to throw this out there.
00:38:32 I know, Dan, you're a Proverbs guy.
00:38:34 Yeah, sure, man.
00:38:35 All men are Proverbs men.
00:38:36 I think the manly men.
00:38:38 So one of the things I thought of, it's kind of so simple you could almost miss it,
00:38:41 but Proverbs 13, 11 says,
00:38:43 Wealth gain hastily will dwindle,
00:38:45 but whoever gathers little by little will increase it.
00:38:48 I think it could be said about the church, right,
00:38:51 that we want to build long and slow.
00:38:53 I literally had that on my screen.
00:38:55 I'm so proud of you right now.
00:38:56 Brian and I, as we talk about investing,
00:38:58 that's our like, oh yeah, yeah, short-term losses.
00:39:01 Well, you know, it's a-
00:39:02 But long-term is what it's in.
00:39:03 Yeah, that's right. 0.67
00:39:05 Russia invades Ukraine.
00:39:06 All the stonks go down. 0.97
00:39:08 Just wait, just wait.
00:39:10 Big time harassment.
00:39:10 Putin, no!
00:39:12 come on. No, you take it away, Brian. You had it written down. Well, no, I pulled it up earlier
00:39:18 when we were thinking, we were talking about this. I was like, you know what? It's like
00:39:20 Proverbs 13, 11, because there's a principle under that. He's talking about finances that
00:39:24 wealth gain hastily is going to dwindle, but whoever gathers little by little will increase
00:39:28 it. That's true of finances, but the principle underneath that stands. And it's that the fall
00:39:35 and sin, what it makes us constantly want to do is try to find cheat codes for the world that God
00:39:40 made where it's like wisdom is essentially understanding that God made a world full of
00:39:46 rules and laws and principles and patterns. He made that they're built in, they're baked in
00:39:50 just as much as math is baked in. Those are built in and wisdom understands that those exist. It
00:39:56 does the hard work of the glory of Kings to search them out. Yeah. And then it does the even harder
00:40:01 work of not just knowing them, but trying to live at peace with them. Yeah. And this is one of those
00:40:06 principles that if you try to basically parent like this, as an example, you say once a year,
00:40:14 I'm going to sit each of my kids down and I'm going to have a big, long talk with them about
00:40:17 all the bad things they did this year. It'll take about 15 minutes and then I'll give them,
00:40:22 you know, one big spanking for all that stuff because it says spare the rod, you know, spoil 1.00
00:40:26 the child. And then that'll be good. They'll get 18 or so of those before they leave my house. 1.00
00:40:32 and well I'm not talking about spanking a one-year-old anyway but the scriptures instead
00:40:38 are like no not one big thing once a year 10,000 acts of small discipline and parenting all the
00:40:44 time that's what produces godly children the dollar cost averaging into the market over a
00:40:50 long time horizon is what produces durable wealth right and so many times we don't want to do this
00:40:56 We just want to like, no, I'm going to ape into, uh, you know, whatever it is.
00:41:01 Dogecoin.
00:41:02 Jamey or yeah.
00:41:04 AMC, you know, AMC.
00:41:05 And then I'm going to diamond hands, baby.
00:41:07 But so I can be wealthy in a, in a, in a month.
00:41:09 We lost some people.
00:41:10 We did.
00:41:10 I'm sorry.
00:41:11 So let me bring it back.
00:41:12 So John Calvin said this about church growth.
00:41:15 Okay.
00:41:15 He said the excellence of the church does not consist in the multitude, but in purity.
00:41:22 It's not the number of people, but the purity of the church.
00:41:25 and what's central what is the central message of christianity is the gospel and the very thing
00:41:33 that we're trying to like sugarcoat and stuff down people's throat is the thing that the 0.79
00:41:39 scriptures say is a stumbling block for the jews and it's foolishness to the gentiles yeah and so 0.98
00:41:45 we have to actually change the central message of Christianity into something that's more 0.95
00:41:54 palatable instead of saying, no, no, this is, this is your, your job. You're, you're supposed
00:42:00 to come and die. Well, and that's Dan, that's, um, I was reading, uh, Jesus and John Wayne, 0.95
00:42:05 highly recommended, highly, highly not recommended book. Fired. We just edited out everything.
00:42:11 everything um yeah it's interesting though historically i think that she is right about
00:42:16 one thing in there where she talks about really with billy graham they started the christian
00:42:20 bookstores um christian radio and one of the things they realized was to reach all these people
00:42:26 from across all these denominations they had to find what they called a core message we might call
00:42:32 it gospel centered today but they had to find a core christian message that was basically so
00:42:37 watered down that like anybody would approve of it yeah within christendom like even loose
00:42:42 christendom anyone would approve so again it's this idea that you you actually have to change
00:42:47 the message uh it reminds me uh in seminary we were reading uh a tim keller book uh i think it's
00:42:54 called the worship matters about the worship wars yeah and that sort of thing one of the things i
00:42:59 hated most about that book though that tim keller said uh was really just like it's just a style
00:43:04 issue. Oh, so the medium is the message. Yeah. The medium is the message. It's a style issue.
00:43:11 Here's where I would, I would push back though. I would say, what is your heart? Is your heart to
00:43:16 preach the full unadulterated? We'll get into this theological maximalism. Is that what you're
00:43:22 trying to do? Or are you trying to say, look, I just want, I want this to be as palatable as
00:43:27 possible because what it drives at is you can only have one. Yeah. You can only have one Jesus. I was
00:43:34 struck by this this week Jesus John 5 says this very thing how can you believe when you receive
00:43:38 the glory from one another and you do not seek the glory that comes from the only God are you
00:43:43 in your ministry fundamentally you have two choices one of two choices you're either going
00:43:48 to serve God and seek his glory or you're going to seek the glory of men and I think correct me
00:43:54 if I'm wrong Dan but the big fast famous is all about the glory of men yeah I mean it's kind of
00:44:00 Built into the name, which some might say is unfair.
00:44:04 But the whole, when you're observing these models,
00:44:07 especially after they've failed,
00:44:09 and there are some that are still going on,
00:44:11 but it solely relies on the approval of men.
00:44:16 That's why you have to change the message,
00:44:18 is because people then approve of it.
00:44:21 I mean, maybe Brian Sauvé is not the nicest guy in the world on Twitter.
00:44:27 Maybe he's not.
00:44:28 maybe he is right though maybe he's right about a lot of these tweets that people get upset over
00:44:35 and then christianity starts to respond like the pagans with the same narratives
00:44:41 and they're so worried about the perceptions of men yeah versus fearing god
00:44:47 just to say this is one of the things i get commonly i think eric does we've probably all
00:44:53 gotten it is that a lot of people will be like, Hey, you know, brother, I agree with what you said,
00:44:58 but is it really helpful right now in this moment? Because don't you realize you're just
00:45:01 alienating a whole lot of non-Christians from the, and here's the fundamental error. It's a big, 0.65
00:45:07 fast and famous error. We're going to talk about it even in the future, as we talk about revivalism
00:45:11 and decisionism and other models that we need to knock down. But fundamentally that error is to
00:45:16 think that you can basically, by small degrees, work somebody into the kingdom, you know,
00:45:23 culminating in them bending the knee to Christ, where it's like, you basically say, let's edit
00:45:28 the message. Let's make, what is this, what is the least that somebody has to do to become a
00:45:33 Christian? What's the minimum? What is the bare minimum? The minimum, right? Absolutely. Okay.
00:45:37 And Brian is saying, chop, chop, chop. Yeah, that's right. What is the minimum we have to do
00:45:42 to get the germanic pagans to worship us well you know what they just need to let's start with
00:45:47 christ is lord and they're like okay christ is lord this is probably not germanic but christ
00:45:51 is lord alongside thor well we'll talk about that later you know no you can't they're a little
00:45:58 rough around the edges yeah you can't edit out stop sacrificing your people to the god okay let's
00:46:03 just do one sacrifice a month and then we'll we'll whittle it down and it's like what we want to do
00:46:09 is edit the edges, the rough edges off of the message until it's more palatable. And it's just
00:46:14 such a sneaky, smarmy, patronizing bait and switch. You're treating people like idiots where 1.00
00:46:20 you're like, Hey, it's like the Mormons at the door when they don't tell you about Kolob and 1.00
00:46:24 they don't tell you about how, you know, Oh, actually there's a ton of gods. And we believe
00:46:28 that God had sex with Mary and all these other things. They just tell you, we're here to tell
00:46:31 you about the Lord Jesus Christ. Another, another Testament of his gospel. You know, he died for
00:46:35 your sin on the cross. Do you want to become a Mormon? That's how they do it now. They just, 0.97
00:46:39 they round off all the hard stuff. And, and the lie there is that, is that basically you can
00:46:46 trick people into becoming a Christian and then disciple them later. And it's like, no, pretty 0.75
00:46:52 soon they're going to find out. They're going to say, wait a second. The Bible says all these
00:46:56 things about like, it seems like Romans one is saying that lesbianism is bad. You don't like
00:47:01 the gays and and and here's the thing is that instead of doing that what we should be doing
00:47:06 what we should be doing is saying uh you know something like okay where is the culture deeply 0.78
00:47:14 enslaved to false gods all right that's where we need to go because that's where they're enslaved 0.86
00:47:20 that's where we need to pronounce freedom to the captives well don't you think brian like
00:47:24 that's where we you and i particularly run into so much trouble on social media is
00:47:29 i'm actually looking for the idol like where's the idol we're idol hunting yes and i'm like
00:47:34 thor's oak where can i go poke it in the eye chop chop and most people think like you're the most 0.86
00:47:40 contentious person this is what i get from most people how dare you how the hell do you think you
00:47:47 are so so thanks mark mark driscoll throwback but like that is the response yeah but but but it's
00:47:53 interesting what you're saying though because it's it's a fundamental misunderstanding about
00:47:57 what we're trying to do yeah what we're trying to do is say world you're enslaved to all kinds
00:48:02 of wraiths and demon gods and they hate you and they're promising you freedom but they're really 0.91
00:48:07 delivering you self you know think about something like transgenderism they're saying be freed be 0.99
00:48:12 freed from the this this cage of a body that you've been given it doesn't match your inner 0.99
00:48:17 child or your inner spirit and so be freed from it and all you have to do is take these pills and 0.95
00:48:23 this hormone injections and cut off your genitals and you have to rearrange your body with plastic 0.65
00:48:28 surgery and then you will be free and happy and then the suicide rate remains the same for 0.95
00:48:34 transgender people after conversion post-conversion therapy and post-conversion so you go what what 1.00
00:48:40 the christian ought to do isn't walk in and be like let's not bring up the tranny stuff yet 1.00
00:48:43 let's not bring that up because it would alienate them let's just lead with that that's where they're 1.00
00:48:47 enslaved. That's where the shackle is. Paul, it didn't go into the, and Peter, they didn't go
00:48:54 into the town squares and say to the Jews, you know, let's not bring up the whole, they crucified
00:48:59 Jesus thing. Instead, they were like, you crucified the Messiah, right? You did. And when they preached 0.80
00:49:07 to the Gentiles, the result was that it was so clear to the Gentiles that Paul and Barnabas
00:49:11 were rebuking them for their worship of Artemis, that for several hours, they chanted nothing but
00:49:17 glorious is Artemis the fair or whatever
00:49:19 it was that they actually, I can't remember. Artemis of the Ephesians
00:49:21 something like that. Yeah, for hours
00:49:23 why? Because they understood that Paul
00:49:25 was actually telling them that
00:49:27 their God was an
00:49:29 nincompoop and that they should worship the true
00:49:31 and living God. Oh, it's huge.
00:49:33 So I want to ask a question about this because
00:49:35 it relates to something that I mentioned earlier
00:49:37 about Tim Keller's book
00:49:38 but I want to ask you guys
00:49:40 we tend to think today
00:49:43 that culture is a taste
00:49:45 issue our music yeah the way we dress uh you know you call it a dress uniform dress code whatever
00:49:52 we've gotten in trouble for talking about modesty online but but i want to ask as we get into some
00:49:57 of these specific issues why are these elements of culture music as a form of culture why is it
00:50:04 not irrelevant and the way i want to ask that is when you look at the big fast and famous model
00:50:10 it actually music changes right so right so i want to kind of like describe what music has
00:50:17 become in the church today yeah let's hear from the sweet psalmist from ogden the sweet psalmist 0.93
00:50:22 from ogden you are gay why are you gay why are you gay yeah you know the medium is the message 0.98
00:50:31 so when you walk into a church service it's just imagine follow it with me here maybe we'll do some 0.97
00:50:35 sweet you know cue some sound design you walk into a service and you know you're you're five
00:50:40 minutes late they've gotten past the cheesy announcements from the hip youth pastor with
00:50:44 the faux hawk and so they're doing the worship music and you hear a serene warm synth pad
00:50:50 playing underneath i hear it now i hear it now the angelic tones of the road and then you know
00:50:56 on top of that you hear amplified very loudly and beautifully and with perfect compression
00:51:02 this is breathy female angelic vocal coming over you call me oh wait copyright never mind i won't
00:51:08 sing it yeah don't do it and she's singing something about you know maybe like how you
00:51:12 just need to take that next leap of faith whatever it is you know because god will grant us the
00:51:18 victory and you hear that and and you you you see the people swaying to the music and you can you
00:51:24 can kind of hear them a little bit but you know you mainly just hear this band that is wow this
00:51:29 is a good band up there they're so well produced and and then the lights kick on when the tom rolls
00:51:34 kicks in and and and the the kick drum thuds on the floor and the tinkling cymbals come in and
00:51:40 and you hear and it's just feel the spirit feel it like and okay here's the thing the medium is
00:51:44 the message a lot of people want to say all of that is like the seasoning packet and and really
00:51:50 the substance is the ramen it's the brick of ramen who cares what seasoning packet you put on it man
00:51:55 as long as the lyrics are good. No, absolutely wrong. Absolutely wrong because we are not
00:52:01 Gnostic. We're not just brains floating around there thinking about the information input of
00:52:07 lyrics. It's not what we are. We're embodied souls. We have voices of eardrums. We have emotions. We
00:52:13 have a limbic system that's pumping different hormones into our brain as the result of different
00:52:17 sounds because God made a world where sounds change us. What is all of that saying? Well,
00:52:24 you know what it's not saying? It's not saying sing to one another in Psalms, hymns, and spiritual
00:52:30 songs. It's not saying the main thing I should think when I walk in and hear that the worship
00:52:34 of the church, if I'm obeying the scriptures, is the singing of people to one another, not them
00:52:40 hearing somebody else sing to them. It should be sing to one another in Psalms, hymns, and spiritual
00:52:46 songs, making melody in your hearts to God. And so what we should be hearing is the thundering of
00:52:51 voices. Fundamentally, God made it that way because we're not Gnostics. We're actually
00:53:08 changed by our contribution, by our singing. Worship is not receiving spiritual goods and
00:53:13 services from religious professionals and musical professionals. It's us coming to worship the
00:53:21 I mean, that's just one little facet of critique.
00:53:24 We could talk about the vapid, you know, the vapidity of the lyrics and all kinds of other
00:53:28 things, but I think it's one angle of critique against this musical culture.
00:53:32 Yeah, I think it's a really good point.
00:53:33 I even think of something very simple that you mentioned, like participation, right?
00:53:38 If you are required to participate and you are one of many voices carrying what's happening,
00:53:45 participatory worship is very different than spectator worship.
00:53:49 It is.
00:53:49 So, Dan, I want to ask you a question because you guys have actually, like, at the church, there's been a transition.
00:53:57 Yeah, so it's interesting me talking about the music ministry since I have nothing to do with it almost at all.
00:54:02 Other than that thundering bass.
00:54:03 Yeah, but Dan is the sweet baritone of Ogden. 1.00
00:54:08 You are gay. 0.97
00:54:09 I was like, yeah, so it's interesting. 0.94
00:54:14 I'm talking to Brian Sauve, across the table from Brian Sauve, who is, like, he does the
00:54:20 music.
00:54:20 He is a musician.
00:54:21 He's actually very, very good.
00:54:23 You should check out his music, actually.
00:54:26 Thanks, Dan.
00:54:26 He sings Psalms.
00:54:27 Where can they find it?
00:54:29 You know, you can find it other than my name, Spotify, Apple Music, iTunes, Amazon, Deezer,
00:54:33 T-Doll, all of them.
00:54:35 All of them.
00:54:35 Well, I've never heard of any of those.
00:54:36 Sign up on Patreon, though.
00:54:37 Support Brian.
00:54:38 Whoa.
00:54:39 I support Brian.
00:54:40 Brian is working on an album right now.
00:54:42 He's working on an album and he's going whole hog.
00:54:45 He is taking everything that he's made from his music and throwing it into this to actually get it produced.
00:54:54 Professionally.
00:54:55 Professionally.
00:54:56 Yeah.
00:54:56 Not just like him in the basement.
00:54:57 So I don't spend like a hundred hours producing music with YouTube videos, not knowing what I'm doing in one hour, actually writing Psalm settings.
00:55:04 Yeah.
00:55:05 Yeah.
00:55:05 So anyway, so the evolution of our singing at church has been really interesting because the target years ago, we had different leadership, was more big, fast, famous.
00:55:22 Mars Hill was the target.
00:55:24 Cool band.
00:55:25 Yeah, cool band.
00:55:26 We're talking like 2009, 2010, 2011, that time period.
00:55:30 Was there some affliction tees and like emo glasses and stuff?
00:55:34 Not only that, there was rap.
00:55:35 No.
00:55:37 There was rap.
00:55:38 No, there wasn't.
00:55:39 Cue it.
00:55:40 There was rap.
00:55:41 Mister, should I call you mister? 1.00
00:55:43 Why are you gay? 1.00
00:55:44 So that was the history of our church. 1.00
00:55:47 We have been reforming.
00:55:49 We're not fully there.
00:55:52 These guys, they got to take this seriously.
00:55:54 I'm sorry.
00:55:54 Yeah, you're right.
00:55:55 This is the first time somebody gave us the control of a soundboard, Dan.
00:55:58 Yeah.
00:55:58 Yeah, someone, you gave it.
00:56:00 You gave yourself control.
00:56:01 I said you should give me the soundboard because I wouldn't use it.
00:56:04 never use it. Brian told me to do it. Okay. So we went from singing bad music. I mean,
00:56:10 actually a lot of hymns, a lot of the, I mean, a lot of the, but again, it was the content medium
00:56:15 sort of question and where we have since gone and it is absolutely glorious. And the barrier of
00:56:23 entry is high. That's another difference is that when you enter our church service, it is robust.
00:56:30 you need a bulletin to know what is going on and it's not just Tuesday at a coffee shop right
00:56:35 where they might have some spoken word like poetry kind of garbage going on we are singing
00:56:41 in psalms hymns spiritual songs in a lot of times four-part harmonies yeah even fuging
00:56:49 and fuging different parts singing at different times and it is it is absolutely glorious yeah
00:56:56 What it is, is it is 17th century Christianity, cathedral Christianity, oil painting Christianity,
00:57:05 and not microwave popcorn Christianity.
00:57:10 Yeah.
00:57:10 And that's the difference.
00:57:11 It's not, we're singing songs that were written hundreds of years ago and are so good that
00:57:17 they're still around.
00:57:18 Yeah.
00:57:18 And David's Psalms that are 2,700 years old, 3,000, I think 3,000 years.
00:57:23 Anyway.
00:57:24 Yeah.
00:57:24 And what does that say?
00:57:25 Well, it's at the four parts.
00:57:26 what does that say it says that we want the men to be able to sing as men we don't want you know
00:57:31 you walk into if i went to a phil wickham recording one time where he's recording a live acoustic
00:57:35 album thing at costa mesa california and the guy is a musically virtuosic in his voice i mean he
00:57:41 probably has like a five octave range and then pitch perfect just brian well continue anyway
00:57:48 the guy he's a great musician and very few men could sing along with him but when you say to
00:57:56 the men. There's a barrier of entry, men. We actually won't patronize you. We think that you
00:58:00 can do hard things. We think that you can learn how to sing glorious, thundering bass parts,
00:58:05 and they're going to be written for you to sing. And all the way up, we're going to have for men
00:58:10 with God made men with higher voices to like the tenor is not effeminate. A tenor is gloriously
00:58:15 masculine when he's singing as a tenor. A soprano is gloriously feminine when she's singing her
00:58:21 part. And so we're saying this music is actually from the ground up built so that everybody can
00:58:27 sing. It's built. What else are we saying? We're saying that apparently the worship of God is
00:58:32 something that actually should require our effort. We every Tuesday at night, we get together nearly
00:58:38 every Tuesday and we work on this. We literally practice. Why? Because the whole church is a
00:58:42 choir. We're commanded. Every Christian is commanded to sing to one another. So apparently
00:58:47 instead of showing up and being like, yeah, but parts are hard. Like it's so much easier if people
00:58:54 could just like, I don't know if you could just sing like to me and I'll mumble a little bit
00:58:59 sometime, but it would sound really good if I don't do anything. What is that saying? It's
00:59:03 saying the worship of God should basically take no effort. We sing Psalm 134 in a round.
00:59:08 In a three-part canon. And the first time Brian did this, I thought he was insane. He gets up
00:59:13 front and he's like okay here's what we're gonna do you know psalm 134 behold bless the lord all
00:59:18 you servants of the lord okay we've sang it right and here's what we're gonna do this section over
00:59:23 here sing it and then repeat the last line and section two start to sing it and then section
00:59:29 three all at different times and then you'll unite at the end and it'll be great and i was like
00:59:33 this guy is nuts people are gonna leave our church well every decision we make we're like
00:59:38 how many people are we going to leave lose but anyway and the thing is it is like i get jazzed 0.94
00:59:45 i'm like psalm 134 is coming yes it is good oh yeah because as as we have practiced and everybody
00:59:51 knows like what to do and if you come in having never experienced the visitors they have no idea
00:59:56 what's going on but i guarantee you they're experiencing the same thing that we are and
01:00:01 that's where you have everybody sing the song together and then you're almost disjointed and
01:00:06 And then you reunify in worship of God, singing Psalm 134 that you said was written thousands of years ago in worship to God.
01:00:16 And we've replaced it for some chick on stage that's probably really hot and maybe not even that modest, which I've experienced singing too high.
01:00:24 She's not wearing a head covering.
01:00:25 She ain't wearing no head covering.
01:00:27 No, that's actually, so in preparation for this and stuff we've been talking about, I went back and I was watching all these, the most popular Hillsong videos on YouTube.
01:00:36 And one of the things I realized was like, you look in the audience and it's like these
01:00:40 young guys in a trance and there's this like 10 to 10 lady up front singing and you're
01:00:45 like, well, I think I actually know what's going on here.
01:00:50 Yeah, right.
01:00:51 No, that's a good point.
01:00:52 You see all these videos, the B-roll they get.
01:00:54 If I go on to our like video B-roll service and type in worship, you know what comes up?
01:00:59 Men in skinny jeans.
01:01:00 No.
01:01:01 Swaying with their hands lifted with purple lighting and smoke machines.
01:01:04 singing or, you know, like emoting along with this.
01:01:09 And guys, here's the point we're not making.
01:01:12 We're not saying that musical excellence is bad.
01:01:14 We're not saying that artistry is bad.
01:01:18 We're not saying that aesthetics are bad.
01:01:20 We're not even saying, like I would even go so far as to say,
01:01:23 we're not even saying that embodied responses to God and worship are bad.
01:01:26 David danced before the Lord.
01:01:27 But what we are saying is, and in fact, sometimes we sing that we are,
01:01:31 you know, making melody on the harp
01:01:34 and clashing cymbals.
01:01:35 Raise your hands and spin it.
01:01:36 Oh, no, different one?
01:01:37 Please, please, please.
01:01:38 Whoa, whoa. 1.00
01:01:39 You ugly. 1.00
01:01:40 I just want- 1.00
01:01:41 Absolutely, 100%.
01:01:42 See the light in-
01:01:44 Okay, now, guys, I was a staff megachurch worship leader,
01:01:49 so once Dan triggers these songs,
01:01:51 it's like a code word. 0.97
01:01:52 Should we burn him as a heretic? 1.00
01:01:53 I think we should burn him. 1.00
01:01:54 It's like a code word that goes off 0.99
01:01:55 and my Russian sleeper agent skinny jeans, 0.53
01:01:57 you know, days come back
01:01:58 and all of a sudden I'm like,
01:02:00 my glorious you know what it's it's it's almost if you watch the rise of youtube channels certain
01:02:07 youtube channels it's the same thing it's like some dude in skitty jeans and and some hot chick
01:02:12 yeah it's marketing it's just marketing and it's disgusting and we're not saying that the beauty
01:02:17 is bad to close the loop on this what what we're saying bubble gum in the hair there's good gum in
01:02:23 the hair again i'm actually saying my point isn't that we should spend less effort on the excellence
01:02:28 of the worship, but that we should spend much more because it's not eight people on a band.
01:02:32 But where is the excellence?
01:02:33 Yeah, it's the people.
01:02:34 It's the people.
01:02:35 Someone should walk into our services and they should get a sense after they overcome
01:02:39 the weirdness of it.
01:02:40 They should get a sense of the utter holiness and transcendence of God, that he is a God
01:02:45 who is worthy of a people spending a lot of their time, apparently, to do something with
01:02:49 no seemingly practical purpose, like learning four-part harmonies to produce rich vocal
01:02:54 textures to the glory of this God that they say they worship.
01:02:57 it should be like wow these people keep telling me that their worship is them ascending to the
01:03:02 heavenly mount zion surrounded by the firstborn enrolled in heaven and festal shouts of angels
01:03:07 and i could see it i can hear it i'm experiencing it right now because when i i'm i'm you know in
01:03:14 this scenario the visitor's seated right in front of dan and when psalm 98's playing all of a sudden
01:03:19 he's like the victory have won the victory have won and he's like maybe the victory has been won
01:03:26 by their God. I think he believes it. He seems to believe it. You know, what's great about the
01:03:30 centralization versus, uh, the non-centralized model then is that visitor that comes to the
01:03:36 church. Who does he ask what's going on? He doesn't ask. He doesn't have to go to the pastor.
01:03:40 He can say, Hey guy, that's sitting next to me. Why do you kneel during confession?
01:03:44 Why is there wine during communion? Why, why are you not singing the melody of this song?
01:03:49 And anybody should say the answer. They should be able to know it because we love our people
01:03:55 enough to disciple them in how to worship the holy and living God.
01:03:59 Yeah.
01:04:00 Yeah, that's huge.
01:04:01 So that's music.
01:04:02 One of the things is building too.
01:04:04 Yeah.
01:04:05 Space.
01:04:06 Talk about the difference.
01:04:08 You know, when I first read, I think, Angels and the Architecture, I thought, wow, so this
01:04:13 is Doug Wilson and who else?
01:04:15 Douglas Jones.
01:04:15 Douglas Jones.
01:04:16 Our architecture actually says something about what we believe.
01:04:19 So what's the difference between, what type of church do you typically see with a mega
01:04:23 church versus this older we're using this word cathedral right but why is that more significant
01:04:30 than just again a lot of people today will say well that's just a preference choice right but
01:04:35 it actually says something about our theology yeah it says something about who you expect to
01:04:39 come here and why they're expected to come here and and basically the mega church architecture
01:04:43 and just as a preface don't think if you're if your church meets in a strip mall or whatever
01:04:47 we understand like not everybody has 10 million dollars high school gymnasium we met in a cafeteria
01:04:51 when the church started.
01:04:52 So now we, by God's grace,
01:04:54 have this glorious 100-year-old historic church building,
01:04:57 and it's glorious, and we love it.
01:04:59 But when you think about what the megachurch architecture,
01:05:02 I'm talking about when they actually have a choice
01:05:04 and they're building from the ground up
01:05:06 with a $100 million budget,
01:05:07 what do they choose to build?
01:05:09 Well, they basically choose to build a conference center
01:05:12 crossed with a mall.
01:05:15 That's essentially what they build, right?
01:05:18 A theater conference combined with a mall.
01:05:20 I've even heard people say, I went to one church in the Midwest and I thought maybe it was like they purchased an old warehouse, but it was like a warehouse style building, concrete floors, nothing on the walls.
01:05:33 It just looked like a big box store, like a Sam's Club that was empty and they turned into a church.
01:05:38 But I talked to the pastor and the staff there and I said, why did you choose to build a church this way?
01:05:43 Because, you know, of course, I'm thinking in the cathedral model.
01:05:46 and they said to me well it was the cheapest square footage that we could we could possibly
01:05:51 build yeah and so i was thinking okay but going back to something we talked about in last episode
01:05:57 it definitely is not the type of building you walk into and you go whoa no right it's not a
01:06:02 transcendent experience no it says it says something about the ephemerality of the what
01:06:09 they're doing what are we doing well we're doing something ephemeral we're doing something that
01:06:12 is fundamentally no different from what you're doing in all of these other environments
01:06:16 Whereas if you walk into a cathedral,
01:06:19 and some of this is like there is overlap here
01:06:20 with Roman Catholicism and baggage there.
01:06:23 And so I'm not saying like one-to-one,
01:06:25 let's adopt all of this.
01:06:26 But you walk in, you say, well, there's the narthex,
01:06:27 there's the nave, there's the atrium,
01:06:30 there's the portico, there's the bima,
01:06:31 there's the altar.
01:06:32 And every single, there's the aisles.
01:06:35 Everything has a purpose.
01:06:36 And every purpose is connected to something
01:06:38 that the people are doing
01:06:40 and that they're supposed to do here.
01:06:42 And it's stuff that they don't necessarily do
01:06:44 in other contexts in their life.
01:06:47 It's saying that when we gather on the Lord's Day
01:06:49 as the hosts of God, as the armies of God
01:06:51 to worship the living God and ascend the mountain together,
01:06:54 we're doing something that is different.
01:06:56 So when people say, all of life is worship, man,
01:06:59 I can worship God on the mountain,
01:07:01 there's a nugget of truth in that,
01:07:02 and there's a huge lie buried.
01:07:04 The truth is, yes, do all of life, whatever you do,
01:07:07 eating or drinking, work hard to do it for the glory of God.
01:07:10 But when we actually say,
01:07:12 what is the corporate worship of a people?
01:07:13 That's a different thing.
01:07:14 It's actually a different thing when we come for word and sacrament and when we come for singing and fellowship, we are doing something that is actually distinct.
01:07:23 And I think the expectation there, something I've heard James Jordan say is, you know, people continually say in the seeker sensitive, the big, fast and famous model, well, we want church to feel normal.
01:07:36 We want people to walk in and feel comfortable.
01:07:38 And James Jordan would actually say, no, I want you to feel very uncomfortable here.
01:07:41 Exactly.
01:07:41 And this gets to the heart of culture building is if you're going to build a separate culture that is its own cultural engine and a driving force in the midst of paganism, it has to be robust, powerful, other.
01:07:57 It has to be in that transcendent other category.
01:08:00 That's right.
01:08:00 You should walk in and feel like, wow, I've never experienced anything like this.
01:08:04 Yep.
01:08:04 And apparently there is something about me that does not yet correspond and match this vision that's in front of me.
01:08:10 Yeah.
01:08:10 And it's beautiful and glorious and I want to be conformed to it.
01:08:13 Yes.
01:08:13 I want to be the kind of person.
01:08:15 It's like when you listen to classical music, maybe as a teenager, and if you had good parents,
01:08:20 sometimes you're like, I know my parents want me to like this, but I like other music better.
01:08:27 But I know in my heart of hearts that there's something glorious about this,
01:08:30 that if I were a more interesting person, if I were a better man, I would appreciate this.
01:08:36 Yeah.
01:08:36 And so then you work to appreciate it and you can, because it's truly glorious.
01:08:41 Sounds like legalism.
01:08:43 Daily legalism.
01:08:44 Here's the thing.
01:08:45 If I define culture, you know, the cultist being worship, right?
01:08:50 The culture is formed by your worship.
01:08:51 And so the big, fast and famous model where it fails is that it's still worshiping the
01:08:56 same thing that you worship every other day, which is consumerism.
01:08:59 Yeah.
01:09:00 It's just consuming things or observing things.
01:09:02 It's not actually changing anything about your life.
01:09:04 No, no, it's not.
01:09:04 like Brian said earlier about the men that go there and they're like,
01:09:07 don't worry, we got it all taken care of. 0.99
01:09:09 You just sit there, observe, watch your football, you know, retire and die. 0.72
01:09:13 Like that's your life mission versus what we're supposed to do is say,
01:09:17 hey, the elders, the pastors, the people leading worship
01:09:21 are actually leading the people in worship.
01:09:25 That's right.
01:09:25 They're not performing worship for your benefit.
01:09:28 You know, the people are actually doing things.
01:09:31 And that's actually one of the core problems
01:09:32 that the Reformation needed to answer 0.88
01:09:35 and where megachurch and high Roman Catholicism
01:09:38 at the time of the Reformation overlap
01:09:40 is that they were both providing
01:09:42 a fundamentally similar model
01:09:44 where you had a religious professional class
01:09:46 providing you with spiritual goods and services
01:09:48 in exchange for something.
01:09:50 And instead of the people of God
01:09:51 coming to participate robustly, 0.89
01:09:53 so yeah, of course, they're going to gatekeep
01:09:55 and they're going to say,
01:09:56 no, you cannot put the liturgy in the vernacular,
01:09:59 in the language of the people,
01:10:00 because then they would get all uppity
01:10:02 and start participating. No, they're here to observe. They're here to receive only. That's
01:10:07 not worship. Worship is sacrifice, right? Do we come before God empty-handed? No. We come to Romans
01:10:14 12.1, present our bodies as living sacrifices. So megachurch Christianity ends up repeating the 0.97
01:10:21 errors of Roman Catholicism by essentially removing the people in very important ways
01:10:28 from the worship of God and the sacrifice of the people to God.
01:10:32 Does that make, am I crazy?
01:10:33 Or do you see that?
01:10:34 No, I mean, even our slogan that we're, you know,
01:10:36 we're trying to make self-ruled men who rule well.
01:10:39 Yeah. 0.93
01:10:39 What the mega church model does, 1.00
01:10:41 the big fast famous model does is it makes ruled men. 0.92
01:10:44 That's right.
01:10:45 Not self-ruled men.
01:10:46 It makes ruled men.
01:10:47 By incompetent CEO type overlords who are not actually respectable.
01:10:52 Actually, it's still patriarchy. 0.98
01:10:53 It's an evil patriarchy. 0.60
01:10:55 Here's the thing.
01:10:55 When you get that model, again, the goal of that model is to get as many people as fast as possible by whatever means.
01:11:02 What are you trying to get them to do? 0.94
01:11:04 Again, the least possible thing to say that they're a Christian, which is what? 0.96
01:11:08 It's decisionism. 0.98
01:11:09 It's decisionism.
01:11:11 It's emotionalism.
01:11:12 It's revivalism.
01:11:13 We're going to talk about that next time.
01:11:15 Because often, that's why it's so deeply patronizing.
01:11:17 It's because it's not telling men, come into the church because we actually know what a real man is.
01:11:23 We know what a real woman is.
01:11:24 We know what, we know what a person is and we're going to equip you for all of Christ
01:11:28 for all of life so that you can now go and be a King and a queen, right?
01:11:32 Roll up your sleeves.
01:11:32 There's work to do.
01:11:33 And we need your sword.
01:11:34 Don't sit down and just receive actually here's stuff to do.
01:11:38 You're a King's man.
01:11:39 So, so next episode, we're going to be talking about that and, and to land the plane here
01:11:44 on the big fast and famous fundamentally, the reason that we would reject the big fast
01:11:48 and famous model is for no reason less than it is not the model that Christ gave to us
01:11:53 for his church. Yes, we're post-millennial. Yes, we're going to see big things happen. The kingdom
01:11:58 of God is going to be vast, but it is not going to be a plastic redwood tree. It's going to be a
01:12:05 world-swallowing forest. It's going to be a world-swallowing forest where Christ redeems
01:12:09 literally, you guys, billions of men and women, remakes them in the image of his son,
01:12:15 makes them self-ruled, able to rule themselves, godly and dignified in every way, fruitful in
01:12:20 every way. And then he will have his glory on earth. So we're thankful that you've joined us
01:12:27 again here in the King's Hall. And our hope is that the Lord would use this work for your good
01:12:32 and the good of your people. Remember this week, Festin Alente, remember to make haste slowly,
01:12:38 and we will see you next time.
01:12:50 The King's Hall
01:13:20 if you'd like to support the show and get some extra content.