00:07:47.140but it's like, how do I be a good dad? How do I discipline? Hey, I see your church. There are a
00:07:52.600lot of, a lot of kids, but there are also a lot of well-behaved kids. How do you, how do you
00:07:57.320discipline? How do you? A lot of questions about how to honor parents. We talked a ton about the,
00:08:03.460the concept of honoring up the chain of hierarchy. Yeah. How you, you know, talk to your real Zionist
00:08:08.960dad or something. And like, it's just not about converting your parents to all of your niche
00:08:13.680boutique beliefs or whatever, but just really doing a good job. So we talked about that,
00:08:18.900honoring your pastors, giving them, um, you know, the, don't go in over six months, develop like
00:08:25.92018 beliefs that are contrary to your, your normal church life, and then present them to your pastor
00:08:31.840as a fait accompli, but actually give them the courtesy of like, Hey, I've been looking at us.
00:08:36.620Tell me if you think I shouldn't, you know, whether it's patriarchy or pedo baptism or
00:08:41.000whatever. Because as pastors, we're constantly, we're real pastoral ministry. Like every once in
00:08:48.080a while, you'll have someone come to you and say, Hey, you know, for eight months, I've been studying
00:08:51.280Roman Catholicism and I'm converting. You're like, well, it would have been nice to know that like
00:08:55.960earlier. So we could talk about it. So people are sometimes surprised to hear us say this, but
00:09:03.000we are constantly telling people before Breit Hearth or the King's Hall, like brings you all
00:09:09.780the way down, whatever. And we only say what we think is true. Even so, don't be disruptive to
00:09:18.580your church. Honor your elders. Give them the opportunity to be good, honorable elders who
00:09:23.800persuade you and are involved in overseeing. And then, yeah, you can still change your mind on
00:09:28.880things and adopt new positions and even decide that I can no longer submit in good conscience
00:09:34.340in a certain church, but do it in the right order and do it in an orderly fashion that honors the
00:09:39.760hierarchies God built into the world. So all that to say the 30,000 foot view of the, of the like
00:09:46.720smoke bombs that have just been lobbed over the conference online that everyone's freaking out
00:09:52.100about and demanding denunciations from us and explanations. And so there, first of all, there's
00:09:57.500why we didn't give you instant internet play-by-plays because we were, frankly, we were
00:10:03.920busy. Okay. Serving people. We were busy, like we're busy. So, um, we had, uh, as we do every
00:10:11.860year with conferences, we have lots of different businesses and productive households from small
00:10:19.080businesses that are households to, uh, and like solo entrepreneurs to larger businesses that
00:10:24.500sponsor various auxiliary events or have a booth at the sponsor area. That's like in the next room
00:10:30.820This year we had 52 sponsors in that room and like just, man, some high quality, absolutely phenomenal family Christian businesses over there.
00:10:43.780And we had one sponsor that was there, which was a publishing house.
00:27:00.080So when I read the last lion, the three volume autobiography of him, and I've read three to
00:27:05.260four biographies of Churchill. And I can actually contextualize because I know his words, what was
00:27:13.380happening. The same can be done for Germany and in the Nazi regime and its rise and its big
00:27:20.140political thinkers and Adolf Hitler himself and all this stuff. And what happens when you actually
00:27:24.600do that work is I think two things. One, the Nazi and the Hitler of history, basically it falls
00:27:34.260apart in a lot of ways because we've as happens we oversimplify things and we we mythologize
00:27:40.120things particularly these things and so there's this there's hitler and the nazi of of popular
00:27:46.320social imagination that is it has aspects of truth but it's it's a character it's a cartoon
00:27:52.880yeah even when you factor in things like you you've read churchill but like it was weird like
00:27:57.840reading like the glowing things that he said about him early on oh yeah yeah and churchill
00:28:02.720And the glowing things Churchill said about Churchill, unsurprisingly, you know, and the things he left out were so like, you know, when Churchill's kind of working through the bombing of civilians, which Churchill kind of initiated in the war, killed hundreds of thousands of civilians and firebombing, intentionally targeting women and children and non-military targets, which just historically speaking, then Axis powers respond to.
00:28:25.600I'm not both sides did really bad, terrible, ugly things. That was one of them. So Churchill, obviously, in his memoirs. Doesn't call himself a genocidal civilian child murderer. You know what I mean? Yeah. So you can't just read him. You have to read it all.
00:28:41.780So this caricature sort of it crumbles, it changes. And then a real historical snapshot appears where you and this that is always going to be in dispute because history is always in dispute among serious historians and among lay people.
00:28:58.820um what you can do is you can re-mythologize in another direction that whole era we've talked
00:29:05.780about this before as well and end up you know coming to this core conviction where you're like
00:29:11.680nazism and hitler and all these guys were unqualified heroes and it was all like you
00:29:18.620know contramundum you know hitler contramundum and all that and and what you'll find is that
00:29:23.420there is uh in the conditions in 1930s germany some of the stuff that was going on with the
00:29:31.080communists and with bolshevism and with pornography and the first transgender clinic there in the 30s
00:29:37.640in germany that you talked about in your speech yeah magnus hirschfeld in passing frankfurt school
00:29:41.740is going on that the nazis closed and then it came to new york city where it continued to operate so
00:29:47.320again these things matter for our current date that's that's the origin story there so you'll
00:29:52.400say, oh, this is a strange sentence as a public school educated kid like me to say the Nazis did
00:29:57.680something good there. Or you start to look and say, oh, the popular support for Hitler was in
00:30:02.460the 90s in terms of voting percentages of Germans. So this very Christian Germany voted 90 plus
00:30:09.140percent for this guy. And so if you say if the cartoon is true, then all those people must be
00:30:14.400the worst people who've ever lived. But obviously they're not. You find out that history is
00:30:19.700complicated. Most of us are not great men. Most of us are products of our background culture.
00:30:26.200And we probably, most of us would have been whatever the norm was in that day.
00:30:31.380Okay. So when you read all of that stuff, some of it evaporates. So in terms of a publishing
00:30:37.920company, hypothetically, like Antelope Hill, publishing those materials, I don't have a
00:30:41.880problem with them. And I don't have a problem with them knowing that some of the publishers
00:30:46.840themselves, and maybe even a lot of people who read them will come to conclusions, whether they
00:30:53.320are to the left or to the right of me that differ in how they interpret and land the plane, you know,
00:30:59.080from Hitler was a Christian prince to hit the cartoon was true. And this is all propaganda and
00:31:04.360whatnot. So that's the process of discourse and why we think it's important in a nutshell.
00:31:09.640We've said this before. That's why when it crossed the desk in a sense, like that two seconds of,
00:31:15.420you know, here's the sponsors that we've, you know, added this, this week. And I was like,
00:31:19.820oh yeah, I have that book from them. I think they do this. Okay. So full responsibility,
00:31:24.020anybody's super pissed. Don't be pissed at any of our other speakers. Don't be mad at our staff.
00:31:28.620Like you can be mad at me and Eric added to our tab and that we need one of those, like,
00:31:33.440please take a number, please take a number. So the current wait time, the current wait time it's,
00:31:39.720it's after I'm dead, you're still waiting in the billions of years, you know, and, and, and,
00:31:45.340and I'll also be clear. Some of it deserves some of it not as, as is always true. I am neither as
00:31:50.920bad as the people who hate me think I am in some way, in the ways that they think I'm bad,
00:31:55.320nor as good as the people who like me think I am in the ways they think I'm good. The Lord knows
00:32:00.660I'm comfortable. I told everybody, you know, as this was blowing up, the two, the two people I
00:32:05.880care about people. I care about what God thinks. And then I care about what the session of refuge
00:32:10.720church thinks. And it's in that order. And, um, and obviously my, my wife and Pete, you know,
00:32:16.600the people and what that represents, but I, I don't care what the, the marionette, you know,
00:32:24.600controversy farmers on Twitter think. Um, so I want people to know that even given that I want
00:32:31.380people know what i actually think so there's what i think about the publication side of things yeah
00:32:36.960i would even just add you know we talked to people even from you know moscow and new saint andrews
00:32:42.380and they said we actually read hitler's speeches oh sure in class yeah i remember in high school
00:32:47.200reading mind conf obviously that doesn't mean you agree with every single word no and and you're but
00:32:54.000it's an important thing to do it's people have found it valuable so to look at that anything
00:32:59.140on that like that side of the thing that you want you think i'm missing no i think that's accurate
00:33:04.380obviously and some people hate what i just said and be like ah it's a super tough thing because
00:33:08.800this is such a charged issue just look at the response like before this even happened right
00:33:14.120like everyone everybody wants to call you a nazi anyway this has been part of the leftist rhetoric
00:33:19.460like um you know you're gonna get attacked for that you're gonna get attacked for anti-semitism
00:33:24.440because we don't like dispensationalism for example yeah and what we've tried to do i think
00:33:28.680throughout that process is just let's think biblically and clearly yeah let's not give in
00:33:34.840to the mob-like cancel culture well because we really do live under this gaze of post-war
00:33:42.460consensus and to your point earlier like it's become a religion yeah and and here's i think
00:33:47.680i said this to you i said i think that there's a lot of people if you like denied some orthodox
00:33:53.360doctrine about the trinity or like the second coming of christ you would catch less heat than
00:33:57.660you do for saying like, Hey, let's read, read a wide range of things and come to wise conclusions.
00:34:03.280Or if you said like, you know, for example, the Jews have been prominently involved in every
00:34:08.680ism that has dominated the 20th century, feminism, liberalism, as well as pornography,
00:34:13.600many things. And everyone would freak out at you. And then you'd said, I'm sorry,
00:34:17.120I'm just quoting Dennis Prager, right? Like the most middle of the road himself, a Jew
00:34:22.740or like things that they, so when we say things about, well, I think there's an, a Jewish culture
00:34:30.120issue and religious issue. And, and, um, again, I'm just telling you what I think is true. I'm
00:34:35.340not trying to swindle you or fake out or whatever. I'm just going to tell you what I actually think.
00:34:41.680Right. So that's our habit. That's what we try to do. And some people will violently disagree
00:34:47.860with some of the things that we think are true on these issues. And I'm okay with that. I might
00:34:52.720even think you're so wrong that I wouldn't want to, you know, that we obviously couldn't respect
00:34:57.540each other. That's fine. But what happens is that the absolute freak out related to some of this
00:35:03.580stuff ends up proving the point that, yeah, you could be a full preterist and you would get less
00:35:09.620freak out from reformed Christianity. That is a literal formal heresy denying creedal Christianity.
00:35:17.060And people will see somebody go full preterist and they'll write a mild blog post three months
00:35:22.440later, but someone shares a picture of Hitler's speeches being republished at a new Christian
00:35:27.600press conference. And oh my word, if we don't have a full denunciation of Hitler and all his
00:35:32.820works by 7 15 PM, Brian and Eric are literally Satan. And I'm like, my brothers and sisters in
00:35:41.260Christ, you are proving our point about why we need to talk about this issue and how charged
00:35:46.160it has become. And maybe why that is in terms of founding mythology for the liberal order that we
00:35:51.940all swim in and have been discipled by deeply okay so that's the historical one other note on
00:35:58.980that we shared this in the conference something we've done at our church that i think has been
00:36:02.180really helpful in navigating a lot of these things and i'm not tooting our own horn like we've
00:36:05.300how do we do how do we deal with this we've been thinking about that for like two years
00:36:08.400the race and in world or two and all this stuff we decided that what we're going to do
00:36:13.880is start a new thing called a town hall that we don't record we don't put online like it's not
00:36:19.640publicly distributed. It's for our people. And we introduce a topic. Sometimes it's the last one
00:36:26.160was parenting and child discipline. Um, but we did two in a row on, which is also, by the way,
00:36:30.880shockingly controversial sometimes. Oh yeah. We did two in a row on race and related stuff. Um,
00:36:37.120race nationalism, kind of this, we had been prepping in men's book groups. We had very
00:36:41.320free discussions about a lot of this stuff, read materials, critiques them, went through them
00:36:45.620together as men. And then in the congregation on a Tuesday night, we said, let's do a town hall.
00:36:50.240It's 90 minutes. I gave a 15 to 30 minute intro each time on race. Eric did the one on parenting.
00:36:54.780And then, um, we had 60 plus minutes of just anybody have a question, raise your hand. Okay.
00:37:01.940What's your question. And then we had a dialogue. Like I would answer the question or sometimes we
00:37:06.260have a panel of guys from the pastorate or other guys as well. And we would just, what are you
00:37:10.900actually thinking about this? And what was crazy about it is we said, we're not going to make
00:37:16.180anything taboo. We're not going to make anything transgressive. Like where if you ask a question
00:37:20.960about Hitler, it's really edgy to do. And some people do it just because it's edgy. And we're
00:37:25.920saying, let's take all of that power out of it, the transgressive power of it by just opening it
00:37:30.180up and saying, let's talk about it. And we're not going to struggle session you. If we think you're
00:37:34.880sinning, we'll tell you if we, you know, if we disagree with you, we'll tell you, I will tell
00:37:39.060you what I think about anything in a church. You could ask me the most controversial question in
00:37:43.580this setting as a churchman or, and I would say, here's exactly what I think. This is what I think.
00:37:48.980I don't know enough. I don't have an opinion or, you know, I, whatever. And the net result was that
00:37:54.380by the end of the second one, this is less than three total hours of this. We were kind of running
00:38:00.000out of stuff to talk about. Cause everyone was like, yeah, I mean there, maybe we, we have
00:38:04.360different people who think different things about some of these issues, but we were like,
00:38:09.060yeah but at the end of the day like what does it have to do with me being your brother or friend
00:38:14.660here we have pretty broad agreement on a lot of this stuff for the younger members of the
00:38:19.600congregation and stuff like i'm sorry all of the gen x and up you guys think that in trying to get
00:38:26.680everybody to freak out about somebody reading hitler speeches you think that you're like
00:38:31.960persuading people i'm telling you young millennials and zoomers and under they are unfazed by the the
00:38:38.000frank discussion of these issues and they shouldn't be. They're actually throwing off
00:38:42.380something that you've been manipulated and controlled by. Yeah. So this is an area where
00:38:47.080older generations and some in the younger generations too have been so programmed to
00:38:51.980not ask a question, is this true or not? But to ask the question, am I allowed to discuss this or
00:38:57.460not? Yeah. It is interesting because when the conversation started, like on the race issue,
00:39:02.740there was a little bit of heat. Yeah. But once we all talked through like what we actually
00:39:07.700believe what we think is biblical how it would apply in our local context yeah it was so
00:39:13.560interesting because by the second one yeah people were like done asking questions they're like kind
00:39:18.020of quiet we talk about something else like it all it takes that transgressive edge and it makes it
00:39:23.460where it's like yeah we talked about that it's really not that big of a deal so just not that
00:39:27.420exciting just so you know like our our people like going online and going oh my word there was a
00:39:33.980Hitler book. Someone was publishing the speeches of Hitler and, you know, and actually I even
00:39:40.560suspect that the guy selling it thought Hitler had a few good points. Nobody freaks out in Ogden
00:39:46.560about that. And it's not because we are overrun with people who are trying to actually resurrect
00:39:51.340the Nazi party. I know there are people who are, who are like, that's their, they think that's the
00:39:55.980big solution, all of our problems. And, but, but just, again, I'm just telling you the truth. It
00:40:01.100might disappoint some uh really base listeners and it'll definitely disappoint on the liberals but
00:40:05.580like just being honest about who we are and what our people are like and what our conversations
00:40:10.440are like we are much more in the it's important history we have varying opinions this was a good
00:40:17.240point that hitler had this was a bad thing like we don't like the t4 genocide program killing
00:40:22.300mentally handicapped people what's definitely not our thing you know like but we also think that
00:40:27.520yeah uh the the porn stuff and the weimar like all this stuff happening in the 30s was really bad
00:40:32.760and bolshevism and communism was way worse than nazism and like a lot of that kind of thing and
00:40:38.180by the way also mal was way worse than hitler and stalin was unquestionably worse than hitler
00:40:43.460in terms of the spectrum so then you ask why aren't they the big boogeyman that hit people
00:40:49.260don't like them but like why if i did a mal historical thing or like a pol pot nobody would
00:40:56.220care no one would it'd be totally different so that's that we've probably just disappointed
00:41:00.700or offended or whatever neil shenby's still concerned um owen strand is still shaking
00:41:06.300um you know all the usual suspects are still going to post their clips and whatnot and i'm
00:41:12.820not naming a lot of them because i have absolutely no i want here i have a message for you i have
00:41:17.120absolutely no respect for you as a person i think you're bad people and you are actively doing harm
00:41:22.380against the church and you should repent or you will go to hell that's my opinion of a lot of
00:41:26.080Can I just ask too, like your thoughts on, so I see this happening with a lot of people who are like well-meaning Christian people reposting people who are known accusers of the brethren.
00:41:42.200What's crazy to me though, is like you guys are being controlled like puppets.
00:41:46.660Yeah. Like these bad little Twitter accounts that are the discernment ministers of the anti-Christian nationalist crowd. They're like twitching the marionette puppet and you're going, Oh, I'm having an original thought. Oh, Oh, it's not an original thought. You're being marionetted by like skinny. Like they always call us like what we have father issues. Like I know some of these guys, I know who some of these guys are behind these anonymous accounts. I actually know who some of them are. I'm not going to dox them because that's not what we do.
00:42:12.180but like one that i know of is like a skinny unaccomplished like lower 20s guy who has
00:42:20.760no like there's nothing about him that i would say i should listen to you like you've you've
00:42:26.420earned somebody paying attention to you they just controversy farm through all this stuff and try
00:42:31.900to find what clip what thing can we use that will cast these guys that we already in a pre-rational
00:42:36.200way decided we hate for purely tribal reasons that we can signal to the liberal order, look,
00:42:42.920guys, we're not like those right wingers over here. Do you like us yet? And then the gays look
00:42:49.260at you and say, no, you still need to denounce Christ and anything relating to the objectivity
00:42:56.920of the sexes and like education of like, let us trans your kids or you are, you are still,
00:43:02.860they would still call all of you literal Nazis. You know what I mean? Like, like it's just,
00:43:08.940I want these fence riding middle of the road, third way is reformed big accounts to stop doing
00:43:14.620this thing. One of these puppeteers jerks the string and they say, I'm just asking Brian and
00:43:20.320Aaron questions. No, you're not. You have our direct messages. You are asking 200,000 followers,
00:43:26.840is not a question, but to assume a conclusion about us. Now, if, if you hear this episode and
00:43:33.640you say what you just said about all of that publication stuff, I disagree. And here's why
00:43:38.040respect it. I totally respect it. I, you can disagree with that. I think you are completely
00:43:44.040wrong on an important issue. And I think that it will have bad effects in anything that you build
00:43:50.220that you're not thinking about some of these things down to the bone, the way that you should.
00:43:54.660And we're trying to, at the same time, each one will answer to the Lord, not to me.
00:48:28.760And a lot of you need to stop looking at it.
00:48:30.860that's my position on it we're publishing a book to help you i if you can't afford it i'll give it
00:48:36.540to you for free like shoot shoot me an email because you need to stop looking at that's really
00:48:40.700gay and it's really sinful and you'll go to hell for it so that's our position on pornography i
00:48:44.660know that was groundbreaking and nobody ever would have believed that we were very disappointed to
00:48:48.740see that distributed quite frankly and and very annoyed very frustrated because here's what here's
00:48:55.240what it did. It took, we'll publish the speeches. I encourage all the people who shared all the
00:49:02.660marionette puppeteers, go watch every single thing that happened at the conference and tell
00:49:07.340me and give me a list of everything with it you disagreed with. Because it took the focus of a
00:49:12.240conference that was the war for normal, where we were for a year planning saying, what is the thing
00:49:17.080our people need to hear? And we do, we see the political theory explosion, the interest in that.
00:49:20.680And we were like, a lot of guys need to hear, you think way too much about political theory and you do way too little political action and even things prior to that in terms of your personal piety, your personal rule of your family, ruling well in your spheres of influence.
00:49:39.060And so that is what we talked about for a number of speeches for two days and panels.
00:49:45.380And that was what everybody took away.
00:49:46.960productive households how to lead in family worship that was what the conference was that
00:49:52.780is what every single person there and so i was angry with myself um for as as the one responsible
00:49:58.800eric and i are responsible i was angry at us for not for it was retarded not to think ahead on that
00:50:04.720and not go like yeah that i i should have thought we should have had a more of it's getting bigger
00:50:09.980we can't assume anymore that everybody who shows up for sponsors is going to understand our kind
00:50:15.140of unwritten rules, like the rules of politeness, like don't go to a Christian conference and
00:50:19.120actively promote paganism. That would be like a normal house rule for Christians. Um, but
00:50:24.920yeah, that I was mad at myself. I was frustrated with the antelope guys, quite frankly, which is
00:50:31.340why, again, when you have a problem with someone, what do you do? You start a rage mob on X.
00:50:38.180Is that not the correct? Oh, it's not that it's not that so close. No, we, we talked it before
00:50:44.660we talked to you guys, we talked to them. So this frustrates you guys about us. A lot of times we
00:50:50.160don't always instantly comment on stuff because believe it or not, we have the phone numbers of
00:50:53.900most of the people involved in a lot of these controversies. And most of the time we're talking
00:50:59.460to them like quite directly about stuff. Even our friends who were like, Hey man, I think that what
00:51:05.160you just did was kind of dumb, you know, like tactically or truthfully or whatever. We think
00:51:09.200you're wrong. We do that. And, and our friends could have could test a test to that. Yeah. And
00:51:15.020we're also don't do it on Twitter. Yeah. And we're also, yeah. Willing, you know, we've taken
00:51:19.640feedback and we'll take, we'll take it to the chin. So like, yeah, I was mad at myself. I was
00:51:24.440mad at that happening. And, um, those guys have apologized and, and, you know, said, Hey, we're
00:51:31.340sorry. That was, you're right. So, um, forgive them for, for doing that. But here, here's the,
00:51:37.440But the thing I was mad about, though, was that this really, really tremendous, I think, just edifying thousands of seeds sown in hundreds of fields and families and businesses and really good stuff from from some of some wise men, you know, Stephen Wolfe, Zach Garris, Adam, like our guys that we would say these we invited them to speak on this thing.
00:52:02.520and we want you to listen to them on this thing
00:52:04.180because they have things that will help you here.
00:52:06.540And every single talk was like, yes, that was so good.
00:52:10.380And everybody there was built up and edified.
00:52:14.580And I hope through the Sunday service as well
00:52:16.840on the Lord's day where we lift our eyes
00:52:18.460from earthly things and behold the heavenly things.
00:52:20.480And just that was what we were, where we were.