Ep. 1090 -Â Why Young Men Listen To Andrew Tate
Episode Stats
Length
1 hour and 5 minutes
Words per Minute
181.37686
Summary
We are suffering from a crisis of masculinity in our culture, and it s only getting worse as anyone who tries to speak up for men inevitably gets silenced. Today, we ll talk about all of this and how it relates to the Andrew Tate phenomenon. Also, the Kevin McCarthy saga enters another day.
Transcript
00:00:00.100
Today on the Matt Wall Show, we are suffering from a crisis of masculinity in our culture,
00:00:03.800
and it's only getting worse as anyone who tries to speak up for men inevitably gets silenced.
00:00:07.860
We'll talk about all of this and how it relates to the Andrew Tate phenomenon today.
00:00:11.180
Also, the Kevin McCarthy saga enters another day, but does any of this really matter?
00:00:16.660
Students at a university complain about my dangerous presence in bias incident reports
00:00:20.740
that have been made public, and they are just wonderful.
00:00:24.220
And the media has spent all week denouncing football for its violence.
00:00:27.600
But I'll explain why violent sports are actually a good and necessary part of society.
00:00:32.720
All of that and more today on the Matt Wall Show.
00:00:43.400
If you're someone who has always wanted to read and understand the Bible, but you're not sure where to start,
00:00:47.800
then check out the Bible in a Year podcast from Ascension.
00:00:50.460
The Bible in a Year podcast is currently the most popular religion podcast in the U.S.
00:00:53.660
Millions of people have listened to it, and twice it's hit the number one spot on Apple Podcasts.
00:00:57.800
In the Bible in a Year, Fr. Mike Schmitz reads the entire Bible in 365 daily episodes,
00:01:02.940
providing helpful commentary, reflections, and prayers along the way.
00:01:06.040
What better way to start the new year than this?
00:01:08.160
You can find the Bible in a Year podcast with Fr. Mike Schmitz for free in your favorite podcast app or on YouTube.
00:01:13.440
Plus, you can follow along with a special reading plan to help you better understand the story.
00:01:17.480
Unlike any other Bible podcast, Bible in a Year follows a special reading plan
00:01:20.820
that organizes the books of the Bible in a way that helps listeners understand the story.
00:01:24.340
You can get this reading plan at ascensionpress.com slash walsh.
00:01:27.280
If you want to start reading and, more importantly, understanding the Bible this year,
00:01:30.000
go to ascensionpress.com slash walsh to download the reading plan for free.
00:01:33.700
That's ascensionpress.com slash walsh to download the reading plan for free.
00:01:38.260
Today, I want to begin by talking about the crisis of masculinity in our culture,
00:01:44.500
There is an epidemic of confused, directionless, depressed, broken young men,
00:01:49.480
and it's incredibly clear to me that this is rooted largely, though not solely,
00:01:53.060
in a scarcity of male role models, specifically a catastrophic lack of present devoted fathers in the home.
00:01:59.560
This crisis is also driven by, while at the same time helping to create,
00:02:05.840
a culture which seems dedicated to demoralizing them and preying on their weaknesses.
00:02:11.200
And this problem is very personal to me because I have two sons with two more to be born sometime in the next couple of weeks,
00:02:17.100
if not a couple of days, which means I will eventually be sending four young men off into this cultural void.
00:02:24.740
And so I spend much of my day, every day, thinking about how to prepare them for it.
00:02:30.120
That is also the lens through which I view the Andrew Tate phenomenon.
00:02:34.620
Andrew Tate, of course, is the former kickboxer turned social media personality
00:02:38.220
who rose to prominence as a voice of the so-called manosphere,
00:02:41.880
with a message directed primarily at young men.
00:02:44.340
And over time, he amassed a large and devoted following within that group,
00:02:48.100
but not really becoming widely known outside of that demo until Big Tech decided,
00:02:52.760
all at once several months ago, to kick him off of every platform.
00:02:56.900
And they did this ostensibly on charges that Tate expresses outrageous and objectionable views, allegedly,
00:03:03.180
which they decided no one should be allowed to say, and more importantly, no one should be allowed to hear.
00:03:08.020
But not for the first time, however, the effort to erase and unperson someone only had the opposite effect
00:03:14.000
of making them more influential and more famous and better known than they'd ever been before.
00:03:19.580
I could say, in my case, I'm one of, I think, probably millions of people who,
00:03:24.940
before they erased him from everything, I'm not sure I'd ever even heard his name before.
00:03:28.880
So I became acquainted with him because they were trying to suppress him,
00:03:33.780
which was a positive result, in my view, if for no other reason than the fact that the censors
00:03:39.380
and de-platformers deserve to have their efforts backfire in such spectacular fashion.
00:03:44.040
So anytime they try to cancel someone and that person becomes more famous, I'm happy,
00:03:48.840
because they deserve, they, the cancelers and de-platformers deserve to have that result.
00:03:56.040
Now, the most recent update on Tate is that he was arrested last week by Romanian authorities
00:04:02.660
He says that this is simply just another attempt by the powers that be to punish and silence him.
00:04:07.840
Meanwhile, the powers that be say that he raped and sexually exploited multiple women.
00:04:13.220
Now, as for my opinion on the man, I can say nothing about the criminal charges.
00:04:17.800
I simply have no idea whether he's guilty or not.
00:04:19.700
His accusers will have to prove his guilt in a court of law.
00:04:22.320
Well, when it comes to the less serious matter of his allegedly offensive opinions,
00:04:26.780
I would say that some of his opinions are indeed objectionable, in my view,
00:04:33.520
While some of his opinions are not only correct, but insightful and important.
00:04:37.880
He's a human being, in other words, not right all the time, not wrong all the time.
00:04:40.940
I tend to concur with Ben Shapiro's take on Andrew Tate, as he expressed in his podcast a few days ago.
00:04:45.140
So, Tate is very often good at identifying some of the problems,
00:04:50.860
especially as they pertain to the situation that men face in the culture.
00:04:53.600
So, for example, here's a video he posted on his Twitter page a few days ago,
00:04:57.000
cut from an earlier interview with Tucker Carlson.
00:05:07.640
Yeah, so I think that being a man is very, very difficult.
00:05:10.200
I think that men's issues are largely overlooked.
00:05:13.940
A lot of young men growing up today that feel very disaffected, they feel invisible.
00:05:18.840
The agendas that are being forced down their throats are not agendas they align with,
00:05:23.880
or they feel affinity to, or agendas they want.
00:05:27.320
And I basically just say to men, look, it's a very hard life.
00:05:30.300
You're going to need to get up, work hard, go to the gym.
00:05:35.420
You're going to have to reject listening blindly to everything you're told.
00:05:45.140
Don't tolerate low-quality people in your life,
00:05:47.800
which means don't tolerate men who just smoke drugs and play video games.
00:05:51.600
And try and build and create a reality full of high-quality people
00:05:54.660
in which you can resist the programming that The Matrix tries to influence you with,
00:06:05.080
It's also enough on its own to get you deplatformed.
00:06:07.360
And you don't need to say anything more offensive, quote-unquote,
00:06:10.200
than what you just heard in that clip to earn the ire of the left and of our cultural elites.
00:06:15.600
But where Tate goes off the rails is in the remedy that he suggests.
00:06:20.280
Now, some of his prescriptions are reasonable and correct.
00:06:27.820
I mean, these are all—I don't disagree on any of those counts.
00:06:31.120
Yet he also brags about sleeping with many different women.
00:06:33.400
He promotes a kind of ostentatious materialism, saying that the best way to be a manly man
00:06:38.240
is to make a lot of money and buy fancy cars and show off your wealth.
00:06:41.860
He says things like this tweet a couple of weeks ago.
00:06:45.360
Genghis Khan had endless women and 200 children as reward for conquest.
00:06:59.340
Now, this is not masculinity, an over-the-top, blustering kind of ego,
00:07:04.600
declaring yourself to be the highest status man on the planet.
00:07:09.540
I mean, anytime you feel the need to announce to the public, especially on social media,
00:07:14.480
how great you are, every single time you are doing that because you are insecure.
00:07:19.260
No secure person ever feels the need to do that.
00:07:22.020
No man comfortable with his status feels the need to brag about his status.
00:07:26.140
Worst of all, Tate suggests that loyalty is a virtue of lesser men,
00:07:41.500
can sleep with a bunch of different women and discard them.
00:07:44.100
In fact, any man with not a lot of money can still do the same
00:07:47.340
if he's willing to go out and buy the affections of a $2 hooker for a few minutes.
00:07:51.160
That's not impressive, much less a sign of masculine strength.
00:07:57.060
Real masculinity and also real joy and contentment in life
00:08:00.560
is found in the man who remains loyal and devoted to his family.
00:08:09.140
but it's the more rewarding path by far on both counts.
00:08:14.620
Loyalty and humility are both virtues of the truly masculine man,
00:08:19.580
and yet they are virtues that Andrew Tate explicitly militates against.
00:08:23.840
Like, he's against those things and will say so.
00:08:26.600
So while he gives young men some good and important advice,
00:08:29.800
he still winds up leaving them, ultimately, where they began,
00:08:37.400
But the real question that we should be asking in regards to Andrew Tate
00:08:43.200
isn't whether he's right or wrong about everything he says.
00:08:47.560
Rather, the more important question, the more interesting one to me,
00:08:55.660
This is the thing the left never stops to consider,
00:08:58.120
because every time, and Andrew Tate is certainly not the first and won't be the last,
00:09:01.420
every time a new figure comes along with a message directed at men,
00:09:08.160
our cultural overlords will swoop in immediately
00:09:12.000
to discredit, destroy, and silence that person.
00:09:17.600
These self-appointed gatekeepers have never met a man with a message for men
00:09:22.840
who they didn't find problematic and misogynistic.
00:09:26.560
That's because while Tate may veer off in various wrong directions,
00:09:31.280
as far as his critics on the left are concerned,
00:09:33.900
there is no direction he could take the message
00:09:36.800
that they wouldn't consider dangerous and toxic.
00:09:43.100
I mean, if he was preaching a gospel of self-loathing to men,
00:09:45.760
if he was telling young men to hate themselves and apologize for being who they are,
00:09:58.140
He'd get glowing interviews on Good Morning America.
00:10:01.420
That is the only thing anyone is allowed to say to men.
00:10:04.980
If you're addressing men specifically, okay, in the public sphere,
00:10:08.920
if you're saying, hey, men, and then you continue to have a message for them,
00:10:13.380
the only acceptable message, as far as our culture is concerned,
00:10:16.800
is shame on you, stop being that way, be more like a woman.
00:10:21.120
And that's precisely why Andrew Tate and guys like him resonate,
00:10:25.540
and they find such an enthusiastic and devoted following.
00:10:28.000
They are speaking to men in a way that isn't resentful, isn't accusatory, isn't condescending.
00:10:33.840
And they are among the only people on the national stage doing that,
00:10:38.880
so the audience naturally goes to them, to the guy who isn't spitting in their face.
00:10:45.180
And as I said at the beginning, a huge percentage of young men are raised in homes
00:10:50.540
Often isn't a father present at all, and in so many other cases,
00:10:55.320
there might be a father physically present in the home,
00:10:57.540
but he's not present emotionally, spiritually, psychologically.
00:11:04.520
So they're not taught how to be men, how to harness their masculinity,
00:11:07.740
how to constructively use all of the energy and aggression that's brimming inside of them.
00:11:13.660
Out in society, they're greeted with accusations and scorn,
00:11:16.740
and they're told that they must suppress their masculinity, feminize themselves.
00:11:22.900
Then a guy like Andrew Tate comes along and says,
00:11:26.760
It is good to be tough and strong and masculine.
00:11:33.460
and they are justified in preferring him, considering the alternatives.
00:11:43.520
isn't to silence him and condemn his followers.
00:11:51.580
And then to follow that with a better and clearer vision of what it means to be a man
00:11:58.120
and how a man should behave, what his roles and duties are,
00:12:04.160
Because that's what these young men are looking for.
00:12:08.540
If you don't have that to offer, then just step to the side.
00:12:12.080
They're much better off listening to Andrew Tate
00:12:13.860
than to someone who believes that the best version of a man is a woman.
00:12:26.000
is that a man has a noble calling to protect and to provide.
00:12:47.240
And any man who is not that, who is not doing that,
00:12:56.720
And the worst thing that a man can be or feel is useless.
00:13:04.440
and the suicide rate among young men is increasing.
00:13:07.620
And nearly all of them, it's in part because that's how they felt about themselves.
00:13:19.240
And most men are meant to find the ultimate fulfillment and expression
00:13:23.960
of that role of protector and provider in the family,
00:13:35.320
All are meant to live their lives in service to something greater than themselves.
00:13:40.120
No man is meant to live aimlessly, wandering from place to place,
00:13:44.120
motivated merely by the drive to satisfy his desires from one moment to the next.
00:13:59.540
Because the cultural powers that be have decided that we're not allowed to show them another way.
00:14:05.340
Our culture tells men that they're not called to do anything in particular,
00:14:08.840
that their sex should have no bearing on what they do
00:14:17.620
But it's the sort of freedom you give to a man in the desert
00:14:25.720
yeah, see, you're free now to wander and go nowhere and die.
00:14:34.280
Which are two things that are very often conflated these days.
00:14:38.880
Is it any mystery that these wandering men would so eagerly follow
00:14:42.880
the first guy who comes along and seems to know where he's going?
00:14:47.320
If his map isn't as reliable as he thinks or claims,
00:14:57.660
you might as well follow whoever claims to know the way.
00:15:00.740
Even if he takes you in circles, you won't be any worse off.
00:15:03.140
And at least you'll have some company for a while.
00:15:19.600
And we have abandoned young men for far too long.
00:15:27.960
If you're looking to upgrade your style this year
00:15:46.960
you can never go wrong with a True Classic tee.
00:15:52.640
True Classic fits a bit tighter in the chest and sleeves,
00:15:59.700
But True Classic is more than just a t-shirt company.
00:16:04.200
And they just released new button-downs shirts as well.
00:16:07.080
You can build your entire wardrobe with True Classics.
00:16:12.560
with a 30-day return policy with 200,000 five-star reviews.
00:16:16.360
It's no wonder these shirts are quickly becoming
00:16:20.100
Get 25% off at trueclassic.com with code Walsh.
00:16:22.820
That's 25% off with code Walsh at trueclassic.com.
00:16:25.940
Free shipping is included with purchases over $100.
00:16:33.060
heading into third day of House voting for Speaker.
00:16:39.520
has paralyzed, paralyzed the House of Representatives,
00:16:54.800
Until Republicans have enough votes for a candidate,
00:16:56.660
all other House business remains at a standstill.
00:17:04.120
to deny GOP leader Kevin McCarthy of California
00:17:06.360
the 218 votes needed to win the Speaker's gavel.
00:17:15.220
After the chaotic process moves to a seventh ballot
00:17:33.860
in the first floor Capitol Office of Majority Whip,
00:17:36.840
the first floor Capitol Office of Majority Whip,
00:18:06.640
and you'd have the same results, if not better.
00:18:09.060
Um, and so he deserves to be enduring this humiliation
00:18:37.260
Oh, well, uh, there's this guy, Kevin McCarthy.
00:18:46.500
I got to say this again to pundits and, uh, DC media.
00:19:04.380
So that's not, that's not why I want it to continue.
00:19:15.680
it is a vote of no confidence in the establishment.
00:19:43.800
This is not something that's written in the stars.
00:19:52.220
for the, the, the Republicans who aren't backing down?
00:19:58.080
and they're supposed to vote for who they want.
00:20:21.480
And I think that is increasingly becoming not a very,
00:20:24.340
that is not a compelling argument to people anymore.
00:20:40.600
I don't even know what it is you're talking about.
00:20:42.120
It's probably, it probably is not the way it should be done.
00:20:55.340
the legislative branch of the federal government
00:21:11.660
And there's all this frantic panicking over it.