The Matt Walsh Show - March 01, 2023


Ep. 1123 - The Experts Demand That We Trust Them And Pay For Their Student Loans


Episode Stats

Length

54 minutes

Words per Minute

174.4214

Word Count

9,423

Sentence Count

298

Misogynist Sentences

34

Hate Speech Sentences

20


Summary

The over-educated, credentialed elite class has made it clear that most of us are not qualified to speak or form our own opinions, and yet somehow we are qualified to pay their student loans. Today on the Matt Walsh Show, we ll discuss. Also, I have the honor of being a part of a bill signing event in Mississippi banning gender transitions for minors. And Lori Lightfoot, the first black, gay female mayor of Chicago is also now the first Chicago mayor in decades to lose re-election. She lost because she s historically incompetent. But she blames, you ll never guess, racism. And a school shooting survivor competes on American Idol. But Katy Perry uses his trauma as a platform for pushing gun control.


Transcript

00:00:00.000 Today on the Matt Wall Show, the over-educated, credentialed elite class has made it clear that most of us are not qualified to speak or form our own opinions, and yet somehow we are qualified to pay their student loans.
00:00:11.980 We'll discuss. Also, I have the honor of being a part of a bill signing event in Mississippi banning gender transitions for minors. I'll talk about that.
00:00:18.400 And Lori Lightfoot, the first black gay female mayor of Chicago, is also now the first Chicago mayor in decades to lose re-election.
00:00:26.620 She lost because she's historically incompetent, but she blames, you'll never guess, racism.
00:00:32.380 And a school shooting survivor competes on American Idol, but Katy Perry uses his trauma as a platform for pushing gun control.
00:00:38.800 We'll talk about all that and more today on the Matt Wall Show.
00:00:49.360 You worked hard for what you have. Who do you trust to handle any and all of your financial obligations if you can?
00:00:55.860 According to a recent poll, 62% of Americans who think about their own death a lot of the time still don't have a will.
00:01:01.820 That's kind of like being afraid of drowning but refusing to wear a life jacket or learn how to swim.
00:01:06.040 Creating a will is one of the most important things you can do to ensure your belongings and your loved ones are taken care of after you pass away.
00:01:12.660 My partners at Epic Will can help you get set up with a will today, and they can do it for just $119 and in as little as five minutes.
00:01:19.600 Epic Will can help you create your last will and testament, your living will, even health care power of attorney.
00:01:24.220 Go to EpicWill.com slash Walsh to get my discount code and save an extra 10% on your complete will package.
00:01:29.820 With Epic Will's easy-to-use template, all you have to do is fill in the blanks.
00:01:33.260 Go to EpicWill.com slash Walsh to save 10% on Epic Will's complete will package.
00:01:37.300 That's EpicWill.com slash Walsh.
00:01:39.800 Well, it won't be easy to pick just one inscription to put on the tombstone of modern culture, but if we have only one that we can pick, then I think we might consider the phrase, trust the experts.
00:01:51.160 Or perhaps because it's on our tombstone, we should phrase it in the past tense, you know, like, here lies 21st century America, they trusted the experts.
00:01:58.960 Now, these days, of course, we all carry around in our pockets more information than we could hope to consume in a billion lifetimes.
00:02:07.100 And with all this information comes countless informers, billions of people all talking to each other, passing information along, back and forth.
00:02:15.060 Every technological advancement has its downsides, of course, and there's no question that the Internet has plenty of those.
00:02:20.980 We talk about them all the time, but for the elites and for the institutions they run, the downside is that all of this informational accessibility, all of this communicating that normal people are able to do with each other, marginalizes them, the elites.
00:02:35.760 They feel themselves getting cut out of the picture.
00:02:38.560 They believe that they should be in charge of what people are told and not told, of what information is shared and not shared, of what ideas are spread and not spread.
00:02:47.500 Ultimately, they wish to be in charge of what people know or think they know and therefore what they believe about the world and about themselves.
00:02:55.560 And that's why they've redoubled their efforts in recent years to combat what they call misinformation, which is their euphemism for any information that they, for whatever reason, don't want people exposed to.
00:03:07.500 Trust the experts, they declare, which is another way of saying, don't trust your own intuition, your own common sense, or your own two eyes, your own brain, your own ability to read information and process it.
00:03:19.940 Trust us instead.
00:03:22.000 These self-described experts have then used their self-appointed expert status to lead us into one calamity after another.
00:03:31.600 The experts told us to lock ourselves in our homes during COVID, to wear masks, to take the vaccine.
00:03:36.780 The experts tell us to stop having children, to start eating bugs, to stop driving cars, to stop enjoying the same modern technology that they continue to enjoy because it's destroying the planet when we do it, but not when they do it.
00:03:49.280 The experts tell us to put our kids on chemical castration drugs.
00:03:52.640 The experts tell us that men can give birth to babies, that there are 900 genders.
00:03:56.900 The experts tell us that every facet of the human condition is actually a mental illness.
00:04:02.320 The expert tells us that the nuclear family is an outmoded institution.
00:04:06.680 The experts tell us that we have no souls, that there is no God, that there is no underlying purpose or meaning to existence.
00:04:15.060 The experts wave their resumes around, flash their degrees, affix letters to the beginnings and ends of their names,
00:04:20.820 and demand that we show unthinking deference to those credentials.
00:04:25.220 When we ask why we should, they simply point back to the credential as if the credibility conferred by the credential is self-evident.
00:04:35.400 But it isn't.
00:04:37.240 Never mind that the credentialed class has been wrong about basically everything for years now.
00:04:43.620 Not merely wrong.
00:04:44.840 I mean, they're pushing the most wrong, most baseless, most destructive and outright insane ideas that the human mind has ever conceived of.
00:04:56.360 They profess a vision of the world that is entirely divorced from reality.
00:05:00.200 And the farther their vision drifts from reality, the more aggressive they must be in their efforts to discredit and shout down and censor and silence information that contradicts that vision.
00:05:11.300 The experts are very often wrong, and their wrongness has made them vulnerable, and their vulnerability has made them afraid, and their fear has made them tyrannical.
00:05:22.880 Now, of course, I happen to be a target, personally, of this credentialed elitism very often, because I have a large platform.
00:05:30.140 I take positions that contradict the elite's preferred narrative.
00:05:33.380 And I do all this without even having so much as a college degree to my name.
00:05:37.900 I graduated high school by the skin of my teeth.
00:05:40.060 I went to community college for, like, a semester and then dropped out.
00:05:44.140 And that's the extent of my academic resume.
00:05:46.260 Anyway, this infuriates them.
00:05:48.780 I mean, anyone in this category, you don't have any, you didn't even go to college, and you would dare to have opinions and ideas and to say them out loud.
00:05:58.280 It infuriates them.
00:06:00.920 Which is why their primary response to me and so many others, their first and usually only rebuttal, is to point out that I have no degrees or certificates framed and hanging on the walls in my office, while they have many.
00:06:11.740 The only framed certificate that I have in my office at Daily Wire headquarters is a printout of the top LGBT books on Amazon, when Johnny the Walrus was number one in that category.
00:06:23.520 That is the only credential that I ever boast about, and the only one I have or need.
00:06:28.040 Well, there was a fresh round of these sorts of attacks after my testimony at a Tennessee house hearing a few weeks ago, where, as we saw, a Democrat lawmaker made sure to point to my lack of academic credentials as evidence that I'm not qualified to make provocative statements like women don't have penises and you shouldn't castrate a child.
00:06:46.720 Ever since that moment, many on the left have been jumping yet again on this bandwagon, taking turns, lobbing pot shots at the high school graduate who dared to form an opinion that they did not sanction ahead of time.
00:07:00.720 This led to what is now a viral tweet from someone who goes by Dr. Ian Copeland, Ph.D., which is how he refers to himself in his Twitter handle.
00:07:10.660 Well, actually, he took the doctor off because he was getting bullied.
00:07:13.520 Everyone was making fun of him for it, and so he took that off, but he still has Ian Copeland, Ph.D.
00:07:18.100 He took a screenshot of this exchange at the hearing.
00:07:21.760 He didn't post the video, just a screenshot of the video because he didn't want people to see the video.
00:07:26.560 Screenshot, and posted this caption alongside it.
00:07:28.580 Side note, why do people listen to Matt Walsh about, well, anything?
00:07:32.920 He's a high school graduate talking about biology, sex, policy, and vaccines.
00:07:37.420 He literally yields no value on any of these topics.
00:07:42.320 I would like to respond to that, but then again, I may not be academically qualified enough to answer direct attacks made against me.
00:07:49.320 I would need to spend three years at an Ivy League graduate school studying the science of rebuttals first.
00:07:55.360 I would need to take a class with a name like The Art of the Clapback, Race and Gender in the Age of the Twitter Feud, or whatever.
00:08:04.500 But even without this kind of accreditation, I still feel the need to make a few points to these over-credentialed snobs.
00:08:11.340 First, if you want to run with the idea that high school graduates should not be taken seriously when they express their views on any topic,
00:08:19.660 that we aren't even qualified to make statements about basic biological realities,
00:08:24.180 then you're free to do so.
00:08:25.560 You could say that, but please don't insult our intelligence, however limited you might think it is,
00:08:30.900 by turning around in the next breath and pretending to be a champion of the poor and the working class.
00:08:36.620 I mean, these are the people who fix our cars and our plumbing and maintain all the buildings and the bridges,
00:08:43.360 provide you with all the food you eat.
00:08:45.840 They run and staff every store you shop in.
00:08:48.860 You'd be utterly helpless without them, and yet to you, they shouldn't be taken seriously.
00:08:54.860 They can do all these things for you, but anything they say should not be taken seriously.
00:08:59.760 Their view of the world is less than worthless.
00:09:02.460 You've waved your magic wand and discredited all of them at once, which, of course, is the whole point.
00:09:09.440 You want the masses to come crawling to you on hands and knees, heads bowed in submission,
00:09:15.380 asking for your blessing before they formulate any thoughts of their own.
00:09:19.900 Again, you're free to hold this perspective, but please don't pretend to be anything but a snide, elitist prick
00:09:24.120 peering down on the common man with contempt because that's what you are.
00:09:27.960 Now, of course, you know, not everyone who has no college degree is poor or blue-collar,
00:09:32.980 nor do we all know how to fix your cars or your plumbing.
00:09:35.120 I certainly don't.
00:09:36.340 And in my case, I used to be poor.
00:09:38.000 I'm not anymore.
00:09:39.160 These days, I earn a better living than lots of the people who have all those fancy letters next to their names.
00:09:44.840 And that really, really makes them angry because they followed the system.
00:09:50.260 I went around it and ended up ahead of them, and that infuriates them, and I'm glad it does.
00:09:58.360 But most of their anger is a defense mechanism.
00:10:00.460 They hide behind their credentials because they know that their ideas cannot stand on their own.
00:10:04.980 They have to prop them up with the pieces of paper that they plunge themselves into six-figure debt to obtain.
00:10:11.040 Now, I've already asked this question to Dr. Ph.D. Ian, and now I'll ask it again to the entire credential club.
00:10:16.280 I mean, I've been asking it.
00:10:17.420 Can't get an answer.
00:10:18.960 Taking that hearing, for example, I was at that hearing to testify against the mutilation and castration of children.
00:10:22.960 Can you explain why I'm wrong in my views on that subject?
00:10:26.820 If I'm nothing but a drooling, low-IQ dunce walking around in, like, grass-stained overalls with no shoes and five missing teeth,
00:10:34.440 you know, like we high school graduates always do,
00:10:36.740 that it should be very easy to defeat whatever arguments we say.
00:10:41.420 In fact, you shouldn't need to point out the lack of schooling.
00:10:43.900 You should be able to demonstrate my deficiencies by masterfully debunking me point by point.
00:10:48.940 You should be able to use your years of academic training to explain and defend your point of view
00:10:53.620 and provide persuasive evidence that yours is right and mine is wrong.
00:10:57.360 But you don't do that.
00:10:58.540 You don't even try.
00:10:59.220 You shrink away from any opportunity to actually demonstrate why your ideas are correct,
00:11:04.400 because you can't demonstrate it, and you know you can't.
00:11:07.560 Your degrees are supposed to act as a ring of protection,
00:11:10.380 a force field around your ideas, exempting them from scrutiny.
00:11:14.220 But many of us have noticed that the force field is imaginary.
00:11:19.060 And so we're walking right through it, and right up to you,
00:11:22.160 and demanding that you justify your unearned sense of importance.
00:11:26.560 We're just not respecting the academic hierarchy,
00:11:29.120 because it's done everything in its power to lose our respect.
00:11:32.500 So now we're flipping it on its head, and we're tossing it aside.
00:11:35.300 And that scares the credentialed people, and it should.
00:11:41.580 Now, one final point.
00:11:42.560 There have been protests in D.C. this week,
00:11:44.840 as the Supreme Court considers whether to strike down Biden's unconstitutional,
00:11:50.200 quote-unquote, student loan forgiveness plan.
00:11:54.320 The protesters insist that not only should the plan be kept in place,
00:11:58.020 but that it should go further than it already does.
00:12:02.240 They want all student debt to be erased.
00:12:05.300 And half of that debt, we should remember,
00:12:08.160 is held by people with graduate degrees.
00:12:11.140 So these are, you know, what you've got is, in large part,
00:12:16.120 people with graduate degrees, and all those fancy letters,
00:12:19.940 that are demanding that working-class people pay their debts for them.
00:12:23.740 One of those protesters was a teacher's union president, Randy Weingarten,
00:12:27.480 who was there, and she spoke.
00:12:30.120 And we can add public speaking to the list of skills
00:12:33.560 that this person doesn't have.
00:12:35.740 Listen.
00:12:35.840 And frankly, and this is what really pisses me off,
00:12:41.120 during the pandemic, we understood that small businesses were hurting,
00:12:46.640 and we helped them, and it didn't go to the Supreme Court to challenge it.
00:12:51.020 Big businesses were hurting, and we helped them,
00:12:54.040 and it didn't go to the Supreme Court to challenge it.
00:12:56.280 All of a sudden, when it's about our students,
00:13:00.720 they challenge it, the corporations challenge it,
00:13:04.360 the student loan lenders challenge it.
00:13:06.880 That is not right.
00:13:08.640 That is not fair.
00:13:10.280 And that is what we are fighting as well
00:13:12.660 when we say, cancel student debt.
00:13:15.900 I mean, it's an interesting strategy,
00:13:19.080 because you hear that, you listen to this person speak,
00:13:20.860 and you're tempted to say,
00:13:21.760 okay, I'll give you whatever you want.
00:13:23.540 Just stop talking.
00:13:24.680 Please, God.
00:13:26.160 Of course, Weingarten is a ranking member of the system
00:13:29.420 that created the student debt crisis in the first place.
00:13:33.200 And now she wants a bailout,
00:13:35.440 precisely so that they can continue doing everything they did
00:13:39.360 to cause the problem.
00:13:40.420 But I also can't help but notice,
00:13:44.920 staying on the topic here,
00:13:46.240 the connection between the trust the experts credentialism
00:13:49.560 and the push for student loan forgiveness.
00:13:53.380 Because the very people who wave their degrees around
00:13:56.720 as evidence of their superiority
00:13:58.700 now want us to pay for those degrees.
00:14:02.720 Okay, they tell us that we are not qualified to speak,
00:14:05.720 to form opinions, to debate or discuss,
00:14:08.320 and yet we are qualified, apparently,
00:14:11.020 to carry the financial burden of their own life choices.
00:14:14.980 We're qualified for that?
00:14:17.900 They talk down to us,
00:14:19.560 and they have the gumption, the gall to do it,
00:14:22.220 with their hands in our pockets.
00:14:24.680 Now, this is far from the only reason to say no
00:14:27.680 to this kind of upper-class welfare scheme,
00:14:30.540 which is what quote-unquote student loan forgiveness is,
00:14:33.020 and that really is all the reason you need to say no to it.
00:14:35.480 It is upper-class welfare.
00:14:36.940 But this is, this is, if it's not,
00:14:40.780 if it's not the only reason, it's one of them.
00:14:43.960 You cannot treat us like children
00:14:45.960 and expect us to be your sugar daddy at the same time.
00:14:51.500 If anything, it should go the other way.
00:14:53.940 If you want your loan forgiven,
00:14:56.880 if you want to, and you're saying that
00:14:58.460 we should be the ones to forgive it,
00:14:59.960 we're the ones paying for it,
00:15:02.000 well, you should have to give up, first of all,
00:15:03.720 all of your precious titles and degrees.
00:15:06.680 That's what happens if you don't pay for your car,
00:15:08.500 your house, you lose it.
00:15:11.460 To begin with, there should be a repossession.
00:15:14.800 You should have to forfeit those letters next to your name.
00:15:17.920 In fact, you should have to give your titles to us,
00:15:20.560 the people paying the bill.
00:15:23.240 Then at least it'd be a swap
00:15:24.580 instead of a straightforward theft.
00:15:26.160 If I'm paying for your PhD, I should get it.
00:15:29.520 It belongs to me.
00:15:31.720 I bought it, not you.
00:15:33.800 Look at me.
00:15:34.580 I'm the PhD now.
00:15:36.100 That's what it should be.
00:15:38.000 That's a satisfying thought in some ways.
00:15:40.180 But ultimately,
00:15:42.180 I don't think I would accept that deal.
00:15:44.120 That's a better deal than anything they've proposed.
00:15:47.180 Because I don't want anyone's useless credential.
00:15:50.140 That's their humiliation to bear.
00:15:51.740 And the debt that came with it
00:15:54.580 is their problem to solve.
00:15:56.860 I mean, you guys are so much smarter than us, right?
00:15:59.420 Well, then figure it out, geniuses.
00:16:02.140 The fact is that your degrees
00:16:03.580 do not confer the kind of qualifications
00:16:05.700 that you imagine,
00:16:07.280 but they do at least qualify you
00:16:09.060 to pay for them, okay?
00:16:10.940 That's one qualification that you do have.
00:16:14.160 And that is one credential,
00:16:16.380 the credential of debt holder,
00:16:18.740 D-H, put those letters next to your name,
00:16:20.700 that I absolutely will respect.
00:16:24.340 Now let's get to our five headlines.
00:16:31.620 Given the dreary economic forecasts that lie ahead,
00:16:34.620 you might be looking for ways to cut back on spending.
00:16:36.920 I know most of us are.
00:16:38.220 Well, Pure Talk saves the average family
00:16:40.440 over $900 a year
00:16:41.840 when they switch from Verizon, AT&T, or T-Mobile.
00:16:44.680 Get unlimited talk, text, and plenty of data
00:16:46.540 for just $30 a month.
00:16:48.120 Pure Talk is so sure
00:16:49.460 that you're going to love their service
00:16:50.560 they're backing it up
00:16:51.760 with a 100% money-back guarantee.
00:16:54.480 Stop paying a fortune to Verizon, AT&T, or T-Mobile.
00:16:57.680 Cut your bill in half with Pure Talk.
00:16:59.960 Their U.S.-based customer service team
00:17:01.540 makes the switch really easy.
00:17:02.620 Switch over to Pure Talk
00:17:03.400 in as little as 10 minutes
00:17:04.240 while keeping your phone and your phone number.
00:17:06.740 Your first month is guaranteed risk-free,
00:17:09.700 but you've got to go to puretalk.com,
00:17:11.820 enter promo code Walsh
00:17:12.840 to save 50% off on your first month.
00:17:15.380 I know I use Pure Talk.
00:17:16.680 You should use it too.
00:17:17.360 That's puretalk.com.
00:17:18.680 Promo code Walsh.
00:17:19.460 Pure Talk is simply smarter, wireless.
00:17:21.960 Restrictions apply.
00:17:22.720 See site for details.
00:17:23.500 Yesterday, I was honored to attend
00:17:26.080 the bill signing in Mississippi
00:17:27.820 of a law banning the medical transition
00:17:29.620 of children in that state.
00:17:31.320 It's a nationwide movement.
00:17:32.780 As I've been saying,
00:17:33.600 this is not just in Tennessee.
00:17:35.100 It's not just in one state.
00:17:35.860 It's one state after another.
00:17:37.340 And the governor of Mississippi,
00:17:38.640 Governor Reeves,
00:17:39.480 was nice enough to invite me
00:17:40.900 to be a part of the event.
00:17:42.620 And it was great.
00:17:43.500 I said a few words at the signing
00:17:44.580 and hung around for the press conference
00:17:46.580 where I fielded some of the questions.
00:17:50.060 Now, I will admit,
00:17:52.440 I will admit,
00:17:53.560 just to be entirely transparent,
00:17:55.540 that I was a little bit disappointed
00:17:57.200 that the leftist journalists in the room
00:17:59.140 completely folded,
00:18:01.140 just folded like a, you know,
00:18:03.720 like a lawn furniture
00:18:05.340 and didn't try to challenge me at all.
00:18:08.240 I mean, even given the opportunity
00:18:10.260 with me standing right there
00:18:12.060 and the cameras rolling,
00:18:14.440 didn't try to challenge.
00:18:15.760 Now, of course,
00:18:16.200 wasn't the point of the event.
00:18:17.520 The point is that
00:18:18.300 there's very important bill was signed
00:18:19.800 and now children are protected
00:18:21.380 in Mississippi.
00:18:23.440 But kind of hoping for the cherry on top
00:18:25.740 where the media would try to come after me
00:18:27.360 and they didn't.
00:18:29.500 Although it's been funny after the fact
00:18:31.820 to see how these people processed this
00:18:35.880 and the fact that I was there.
00:18:36.940 For example, here's a guy named Kobe Vance.
00:18:39.960 They, Them, Trans Flag and Bio,
00:18:42.860 journalist for Mississippi Public Broadcasting.
00:18:46.160 And he was there
00:18:47.140 and he did ask a question.
00:18:48.340 Before we get to that,
00:18:49.300 he kept a running thread
00:18:50.920 of everything that was going on.
00:18:51.880 And this is what he said.
00:18:53.240 He starts with,
00:18:53.740 I'm in the governor's office today
00:18:54.700 as Tate Reeves prepares to sign HB 1125 into law.
00:19:00.120 It will ban gender affirming health care
00:19:01.520 for trans youth.
00:19:02.900 Reeves is going on about side effects
00:19:04.420 of gender transition drugs,
00:19:05.760 which are well documented
00:19:06.640 and known about in the trans community.
00:19:07.880 He says conservatives are under attack
00:19:09.580 from the left
00:19:10.100 for trying to question trans rights
00:19:11.340 by being called transphobic.
00:19:13.840 I believe transphobic public figure
00:19:15.500 Matt Walsh is here in the room.
00:19:17.500 Although this is just a guess.
00:19:19.140 They look very similar
00:19:19.960 and have otherwise never seen them in person.
00:19:23.140 Then he says,
00:19:23.880 confirmed it is Walsh.
00:19:25.060 Governor Reeves introduced him
00:19:25.900 during the press conference to speak.
00:19:27.780 I asked a very specific question
00:19:29.060 about how the state will respond
00:19:30.200 to a rise in suicide for trans youth.
00:19:32.860 Reeves did answer my question,
00:19:34.140 pointing back to his policy on life.
00:19:35.560 says part of the answer
00:19:36.860 should be mental health services.
00:19:38.220 Walsh deflected the question.
00:19:40.300 Walsh points to a lack of scientific data
00:19:41.700 on trans youth
00:19:42.300 and that hormone therapy
00:19:43.160 can't improve mental health.
00:19:44.540 That wasn't my question.
00:19:45.940 I asked how losing their body positivity
00:19:47.680 could increase suicide rates.
00:19:50.740 Reeves says that he personally opposes
00:19:52.460 the idea of adults transitioning their gender,
00:19:54.200 but does not want to infringe on adults' rights
00:19:55.900 to make the medical decisions.
00:19:57.620 Says he draws the line at youth.
00:19:59.880 For most of the questions about HB 1125,
00:20:01.900 Reeves has deferred to Walsh,
00:20:03.440 that's not true,
00:20:04.480 to expound on whatever answer he gives.
00:20:06.340 Walsh has extensive experience
00:20:07.400 debating trans issues on his show.
00:20:09.020 So I just thought this was interesting
00:20:10.200 because I remember this guy
00:20:13.660 asking this question about suicide
00:20:15.860 and I answered it.
00:20:18.600 He says I deflected.
00:20:19.500 Of course, he's lying about that.
00:20:20.740 I answered the question about suicide extensively
00:20:23.040 and from several different angles.
00:20:26.880 In fact, here's just part of my answer
00:20:29.060 to that question.
00:20:29.900 This is the last minute or so
00:20:31.440 of the answer that I provided.
00:20:33.660 But enough to see that there's nothing
00:20:35.140 like a deflection going on here.
00:20:36.700 Here it is.
00:20:38.180 Not only does it defy common sense,
00:20:39.540 but I find it frankly grotesque
00:20:41.460 that the way to stop a child
00:20:43.240 from tragically hurting themselves
00:20:44.480 is to affirm their belief
00:20:46.660 that there's something wrong with their body,
00:20:50.220 that they were born in the wrong body,
00:20:51.640 that they're the wrong person.
00:20:52.920 No, the way to help anyone
00:20:54.380 who's in despair in that way,
00:20:55.900 especially a child is to help them
00:20:59.680 towards actual self-acceptance,
00:21:01.600 who you really are.
00:21:02.740 So if you're a biological male
00:21:04.140 and you're a boy
00:21:04.680 and you're 15 years old
00:21:05.540 and you feel like you're a girl,
00:21:06.960 the message should be no, you're a boy
00:21:10.920 and that's a wonderful thing
00:21:12.020 to be who you are
00:21:13.060 and we will help you to accept that
00:21:15.200 because it's wonderful to be who you are.
00:21:16.900 This is who you are.
00:21:18.080 That should be our message.
00:21:19.640 Instead, the message they get
00:21:20.620 from the medical community is,
00:21:22.080 well, okay, if you feel like
00:21:23.580 you're born in the wrong body,
00:21:24.260 then you were
00:21:24.900 and we'll start chopping pieces of you off
00:21:28.880 until the bad thoughts go away.
00:21:31.980 And I just find that to be
00:21:34.640 utterly horrific
00:21:35.940 and insane on its face.
00:21:42.740 Now, I also pointed out that before that,
00:21:45.260 that statistically suicidality
00:21:46.880 is the highest after transition.
00:21:49.240 I pointed out that the claims
00:21:50.760 that transition decreases suicide
00:21:52.340 are baseless
00:21:53.280 and must be baseless
00:21:54.360 because there couldn't possibly
00:21:55.500 be enough data to support it
00:21:57.000 given that these are
00:21:58.480 experimental treatments
00:21:59.660 that we just recently started
00:22:01.400 giving to kids at a large scale.
00:22:03.360 So, pointed out to all that
00:22:05.060 and along with what you just heard there.
00:22:09.660 That counts as a deflection
00:22:11.100 of the question somehow.
00:22:14.060 But Kobe, this journalist,
00:22:15.760 he didn't challenge me at all.
00:22:17.580 In fact, I gave this answer
00:22:18.600 and he kind of bowed his head
00:22:19.840 submissively
00:22:21.120 and then he proceeded
00:22:23.680 to tweet about it instead.
00:22:27.300 Not a big surprise.
00:22:30.240 In fact, this is
00:22:31.120 what I've, of course,
00:22:32.580 totally come to expect.
00:22:33.520 But every time it happens
00:22:36.760 that I'm in the room
00:22:38.180 with these people
00:22:39.240 claim that I'm an unqualified bigot
00:22:43.760 and have nothing of value to say
00:22:45.640 and everything that I'm saying
00:22:46.640 is wrong,
00:22:48.000 okay,
00:22:48.740 you got a chance to prove it.
00:22:51.260 You know,
00:22:51.580 now is the time.
00:22:54.760 And they never do.
00:22:55.940 They rarely even try.
00:22:56.780 And every time that happens
00:23:00.300 and they dodge like that,
00:23:02.400 yeah,
00:23:03.820 it's a little annoying
00:23:04.960 because I'm deprived
00:23:05.780 of the fun moment
00:23:06.940 to, you know,
00:23:07.660 argue with them.
00:23:08.480 But more importantly,
00:23:10.000 it's actually infuriating
00:23:13.520 because it yet again proves
00:23:15.600 that these people know
00:23:17.880 at some level
00:23:18.960 that what they're claiming
00:23:20.140 isn't true
00:23:21.080 and doesn't stand up
00:23:22.740 to scrutiny.
00:23:23.400 They know that.
00:23:26.160 They know they can't defend it.
00:23:29.620 They know that they have
00:23:31.240 staked out a position
00:23:32.140 that they can't actually defend,
00:23:34.400 which is why they will
00:23:35.520 decline almost every opportunity
00:23:38.200 to defend it
00:23:39.140 because they can't.
00:23:42.600 And that's what makes it infuriating
00:23:44.940 is when you realize
00:23:46.460 that all these things
00:23:48.460 that are happening,
00:23:49.040 this madness
00:23:49.480 that's being pushed on society,
00:23:50.980 it's not even being pushed
00:23:52.400 by people who are
00:23:53.360 confused or deluded
00:23:54.600 or who have the best intentions.
00:23:58.120 This is not a road to hell
00:23:59.340 is paved with good intentions
00:24:00.500 sort of situation.
00:24:02.120 I mean,
00:24:02.280 the road to hell
00:24:02.660 is also paved
00:24:03.180 with bad intentions.
00:24:05.000 And these people
00:24:05.660 have bad intentions.
00:24:08.340 It's not that they are wrong,
00:24:10.060 it's that they're evil.
00:24:12.000 I guess is the way to put it.
00:24:14.100 All right.
00:24:15.260 Daily Wire
00:24:15.880 has to support
00:24:16.520 Chicago Democrat Mayor
00:24:17.620 Lori Lightfoot
00:24:18.500 lost her re-election race
00:24:19.800 Tuesday after her first term
00:24:21.120 was plagued by crime.
00:24:22.260 The inability to recover
00:24:23.360 from the pandemic
00:24:24.040 and petty fighting
00:24:25.120 with officials.
00:24:26.280 Homicide rates
00:24:26.800 under Lightfoot's tenure
00:24:27.660 have skyrocketed
00:24:28.480 to generational highs
00:24:29.820 while robberies,
00:24:31.100 muggings,
00:24:31.480 carjackings,
00:24:31.980 other property crimes
00:24:32.600 have all seen
00:24:33.340 a significant increase.
00:24:34.640 The two candidates
00:24:35.500 that advanced
00:24:36.140 the runoff race
00:24:36.880 are former school
00:24:37.760 school CEO
00:24:39.020 Paul Vallis
00:24:39.880 who received
00:24:40.440 the most votes
00:24:41.060 at 35%
00:24:41.760 with nearly 90%
00:24:42.480 of the votes in.
00:24:43.360 The other candidates,
00:24:44.100 Cook County Commissioner
00:24:44.820 Brandon Johnson
00:24:45.660 who garnered 20%
00:24:46.560 of the vote.
00:24:47.300 Lightfoot only earned
00:24:48.140 16% of the vote.
00:24:49.980 The Associated Press
00:24:50.560 called the race
00:24:51.120 for Vallis and Johnson.
00:24:52.240 Vallis has tried
00:24:52.900 to portray himself
00:24:53.440 as tougher on crime
00:24:54.280 and more moderate
00:24:56.560 than Lightfoot
00:24:57.080 while Johnson
00:24:58.420 is unabashedly far left.
00:25:01.820 So it goes to a runoff
00:25:02.960 but Lori Lightfoot
00:25:03.780 is not going to be
00:25:04.960 the mayor
00:25:05.260 so she's lost
00:25:05.900 which is great news.
00:25:07.320 Great news in a lot of ways.
00:25:08.580 Lori Lightfoot
00:25:09.200 is making history
00:25:10.260 yet again.
00:25:10.920 She was the first
00:25:11.740 black gay female
00:25:13.140 mayor of Chicago
00:25:13.920 and also the first mayor
00:25:16.320 in Chicago
00:25:17.060 in decades
00:25:17.840 to lose re-election.
00:25:19.480 So she is breaking
00:25:20.500 glass ceilings
00:25:21.320 everywhere she goes.
00:25:24.200 She also has been
00:25:25.500 easily among
00:25:26.820 the worst mayors
00:25:27.880 of a major American city
00:25:29.420 ever.
00:25:30.120 I mean ever to be elected
00:25:31.320 and that is
00:25:31.840 that's not hyperbole.
00:25:34.940 When you look at
00:25:35.880 the disaster
00:25:38.200 that she has left
00:25:39.080 in her wake
00:25:39.800 it is almost unrivaled
00:25:42.480 by any other mayor
00:25:43.980 in American history
00:25:44.660 of a major American city.
00:25:45.860 So she's proven
00:25:47.440 that a gay black
00:25:49.320 female mayor
00:25:50.040 can truly achieve
00:25:51.900 things that nobody else
00:25:53.540 could possibly achieve
00:25:54.540 like a 100% increase
00:25:56.040 in violent crime
00:25:56.860 in a couple of years.
00:25:58.700 That is
00:25:59.360 it would be very difficult
00:26:01.940 to achieve that
00:26:02.500 even if you were trying to
00:26:03.720 and she was able
00:26:04.480 to do that.
00:26:05.800 Of course Lightfoot
00:26:06.480 saw the writing
00:26:07.360 on the wall
00:26:07.900 and she knew
00:26:08.580 that she was about
00:26:09.160 to lose this race
00:26:10.240 in humiliating fashion
00:26:11.240 so she set up
00:26:13.080 her excuse ahead of time
00:26:14.180 and you'll never guess
00:26:15.960 what the excuse is.
00:26:18.660 Okay actually
00:26:19.260 you will guess
00:26:19.920 because she blames
00:26:20.740 sexism and racism
00:26:21.700 obviously what else
00:26:22.800 is she going to do.
00:26:23.760 This was the Daily Wire
00:26:24.500 report from earlier
00:26:25.420 in the day yesterday
00:26:26.160 before the election
00:26:26.980 results came in
00:26:27.740 but Lori Lightfoot
00:26:29.020 was setting the stage.
00:26:32.040 Chicago Mayor
00:26:33.000 Lori Lightfoot
00:26:33.500 is facing an uphill battle
00:26:34.760 in her bid for re-election
00:26:35.640 and while she primarily
00:26:36.480 blames racism
00:26:37.520 for her plight
00:26:38.240 she also blames
00:26:39.360 Time Magazine
00:26:40.100 for failing to elevate her
00:26:41.500 the way they did
00:26:42.140 her predecessor.
00:26:42.740 While Lightfoot
00:26:44.640 conceded to Politico's
00:26:45.720 Jonathan Martin
00:26:46.340 that she had certainly
00:26:47.340 made some mistakes
00:26:48.020 during her time
00:26:48.560 as mayor
00:26:48.840 she claimed
00:26:49.560 that the real issue
00:26:50.260 was the fact
00:26:50.760 that people were quicker
00:26:51.540 to pass judgment
00:26:52.360 on a black woman.
00:26:54.280 Quote
00:26:54.460 of course you can't
00:26:55.180 have lived through
00:26:55.880 what we lived through
00:26:56.680 and say I did
00:26:57.240 everything perfect
00:26:57.920 we made mistakes
00:26:58.820 she said
00:26:59.700 pivoting to bring
00:27:00.380 former Mayor
00:27:00.920 Rahm Emanuel's
00:27:01.760 Time Magazine
00:27:02.300 spread into the conversation
00:27:03.280 I remember Rahm Emanuel
00:27:05.000 appearing on the cover
00:27:06.020 of Time Magazine
00:27:06.720 the headline was basically
00:27:07.660 like
00:27:07.980 tough guy for Chicago
00:27:09.480 no woman
00:27:10.620 or woman of color
00:27:11.440 is ever going to get
00:27:12.400 that headline
00:27:13.140 Lightfoot
00:27:15.060 the city's
00:27:15.500 first black
00:27:16.320 female lesbian mayor
00:27:17.300 made a similar complaint
00:27:18.500 during another interview
00:27:19.240 with the New Yorker
00:27:19.940 she said
00:27:20.960 I'm a black woman
00:27:21.680 and let's not forget
00:27:22.480 some folks frankly
00:27:23.540 don't support us
00:27:24.600 in leadership roles
00:27:25.620 then at an interview
00:27:27.460 last year
00:27:28.180 she was
00:27:28.720 singing a similar tune
00:27:30.960 she was asked
00:27:31.440 this question
00:27:31.940 this was the question
00:27:32.600 in recent months
00:27:34.280 there have been
00:27:34.700 questions raised
00:27:35.520 about your temperament
00:27:36.300 and your reaction
00:27:36.940 to criticism
00:27:37.560 Chicago Tribune editorial
00:27:39.280 used the term
00:27:40.120 irascible
00:27:40.920 how much of this
00:27:42.680 do you think
00:27:43.200 has to do with the fact
00:27:44.600 that you're a woman
00:27:45.240 and specifically
00:27:45.760 a black woman
00:27:46.360 her response
00:27:47.520 99% of it
00:27:49.520 look at my predecessors
00:27:50.820 do people say
00:27:51.380 that Rich Daly
00:27:52.500 held tea sessions
00:27:53.700 with people
00:27:54.120 that he didn't
00:27:54.600 disagree on
00:27:55.340 Rahm Emanuel
00:27:56.600 was a polite guy
00:27:58.580 who was a uniter
00:27:59.740 no
00:28:00.120 women and people
00:28:01.860 of color
00:28:02.280 are always held
00:28:03.080 to a different standard
00:28:04.120 I understand that
00:28:05.200 I've known that
00:28:06.180 my whole life
00:28:06.740 and she's right
00:28:09.380 obviously
00:28:09.920 I mean she is right
00:28:10.720 if you are
00:28:13.400 in particular
00:28:16.380 a leftist
00:28:17.480 and then you belong
00:28:18.920 to one of these
00:28:19.680 preferred identity groups
00:28:21.100 absolutely
00:28:22.460 you're held
00:28:22.920 to a different standard
00:28:23.680 a lower one
00:28:25.180 I mean a much
00:28:26.820 lower standard
00:28:27.560 that's what makes
00:28:28.300 these claims so ridiculous
00:28:29.260 because they are
00:28:30.740 as always
00:28:31.200 the opposite
00:28:31.800 of what's actually true
00:28:32.640 Lightfoot says
00:28:33.640 oh can you imagine
00:28:34.540 can you imagine
00:28:35.400 a magazine cover
00:28:36.440 celebrating a black woman
00:28:37.760 uh yes
00:28:39.840 because that's like
00:28:42.680 every magazine cover
00:28:44.060 oh do you mean
00:28:44.920 every magazine cover
00:28:46.240 for the past
00:28:47.240 10 years
00:28:48.260 just about
00:28:49.380 I mean a magazine cover
00:28:52.740 celebrating a white man
00:28:53.840 that's what's rare
00:28:54.380 these days
00:28:54.660 I'm actually
00:28:55.000 I'm surprised
00:28:55.740 the time magazine
00:28:56.380 did that
00:28:56.840 for Rahm Emanuel
00:28:57.520 he's a democrat
00:29:00.140 so you know
00:29:00.900 he makes it through
00:29:02.180 based on that
00:29:02.900 but the rare thing
00:29:05.280 is to see
00:29:05.760 a white male
00:29:06.520 being celebrated
00:29:07.180 by the media
00:29:08.160 at all
00:29:08.760 um
00:29:10.580 to see a black woman
00:29:12.340 or someone who belongs
00:29:13.260 to one of these groups
00:29:14.100 being celebrated
00:29:14.700 that's
00:29:15.060 that's
00:29:15.480 that's
00:29:16.000 every day
00:29:16.660 I mean that is
00:29:17.280 literally
00:29:18.040 every day
00:29:19.040 that's
00:29:19.340 that
00:29:19.580 talk about 99%
00:29:21.040 that's 99%
00:29:22.300 of what the media
00:29:23.540 in Hollywood turns out
00:29:24.500 but also note this
00:29:27.600 and this goes
00:29:28.320 this goes to a point
00:29:29.040 that I made
00:29:29.340 at the end of the show
00:29:29.780 yesterday
00:29:30.140 um
00:29:31.940 one of the guys
00:29:32.820 who beat her
00:29:33.560 Brandon Johnson
00:29:34.580 is black
00:29:36.480 okay
00:29:37.280 he's a black guy
00:29:38.420 and not only that
00:29:40.340 but
00:29:40.640 he
00:29:41.240 she was
00:29:41.760 she was
00:29:42.260 uh
00:29:43.020 defeated by
00:29:43.940 a black man
00:29:44.720 at the hands
00:29:47.260 of voters
00:29:48.040 who were
00:29:48.960 also
00:29:49.720 uh
00:29:50.720 a large percentage
00:29:51.680 of them
00:29:52.040 black
00:29:52.520 this is Chicago
00:29:53.480 we're talking about
00:29:54.260 so a lot of
00:29:55.900 black voters
00:29:56.840 voted for a black
00:29:58.260 person
00:29:58.780 instead of
00:29:59.400 Lori Lightfoot
00:30:00.100 and she
00:30:00.820 blames
00:30:01.220 racism
00:30:01.920 well remember
00:30:04.140 what I said
00:30:04.540 yesterday
00:30:04.900 personal complaints
00:30:06.580 are disguised
00:30:08.280 as group
00:30:08.700 complaints
00:30:09.220 that's the game
00:30:10.240 here
00:30:10.620 okay
00:30:12.320 every time
00:30:13.440 you hear
00:30:13.960 a leftist
00:30:14.820 who belongs
00:30:15.280 to one of
00:30:15.660 these supposedly
00:30:16.120 marginalized groups
00:30:17.060 complaining about
00:30:18.620 um
00:30:19.140 about the
00:30:20.800 the treatment
00:30:21.500 of the group
00:30:22.420 in almost
00:30:23.540 every case
00:30:24.500 this person
00:30:26.060 is really
00:30:26.580 complaining
00:30:27.060 about how
00:30:27.760 they
00:30:28.480 personally
00:30:29.320 are being
00:30:29.760 treated
00:30:29.980 or how
00:30:30.580 they perceive
00:30:31.360 their own
00:30:32.140 treatment
00:30:32.580 that's what's
00:30:34.440 actually happening
00:30:35.220 so when you
00:30:37.800 hear
00:30:38.060 how could you
00:30:38.620 do this
00:30:38.960 to us
00:30:39.420 what it
00:30:40.260 really means
00:30:41.000 every time
00:30:42.000 is how
00:30:42.740 could you
00:30:43.020 do this
00:30:43.320 to me
00:30:43.800 which is
00:30:46.040 why
00:30:46.360 Lori Lightfoot
00:30:47.080 is not
00:30:47.480 going to
00:30:47.720 take any
00:30:48.180 solace
00:30:48.660 in the
00:30:48.900 fact
00:30:49.240 you know
00:30:49.700 that
00:30:50.060 another
00:30:52.260 quote unquote
00:30:53.660 person of
00:30:54.260 color
00:30:54.560 defeated her
00:30:55.380 and if
00:30:56.480 that person
00:30:56.900 is elected
00:30:57.400 that's not
00:30:59.080 going to
00:30:59.220 stop her
00:30:59.500 from claiming
00:30:59.860 discrimination
00:31:00.460 because she
00:31:02.720 doesn't care
00:31:03.180 whether
00:31:03.500 black people
00:31:04.480 or a black
00:31:05.120 person
00:31:05.500 becomes
00:31:05.840 mayor
00:31:06.080 she doesn't
00:31:06.320 care about
00:31:06.660 that
00:31:06.920 she wants
00:31:07.620 herself
00:31:08.120 to be
00:31:08.480 mayor
00:31:08.720 there is
00:31:10.280 one specific
00:31:11.380 black
00:31:11.800 individual
00:31:12.320 that Lori
00:31:12.940 Lightfoot
00:31:13.340 is concerned
00:31:13.960 about
00:31:14.280 and it's
00:31:15.080 her
00:31:15.340 it's not
00:31:16.000 anyone
00:31:16.380 else
00:31:16.820 next we
00:31:18.800 had Biden
00:31:19.360 gave a
00:31:19.800 speech yesterday
00:31:20.340 it gave rise
00:31:21.100 to another
00:31:21.460 clip of
00:31:22.040 Biden
00:31:22.400 mumbling
00:31:22.800 incoherently
00:31:23.640 at least
00:31:25.080 that's what
00:31:25.300 people are
00:31:25.580 saying on
00:31:25.920 social media
00:31:26.440 this clip
00:31:26.840 is being
00:31:27.060 passed around
00:31:27.620 as another
00:31:28.000 Biden
00:31:28.400 word salad
00:31:29.140 let's listen
00:31:30.560 to it
00:31:31.740 by the way
00:31:38.140 you docs
00:31:39.800 are good
00:31:40.300 but if there's
00:31:40.680 any angels
00:31:41.240 in heaven
00:31:41.580 they're all
00:31:41.960 nurses
00:31:42.300 male and
00:31:42.780 female
00:31:43.060 you know
00:31:44.240 why
00:31:44.620 you guys
00:31:45.820 let us
00:31:46.200 you guys
00:31:46.760 make us
00:31:47.200 allow us
00:31:48.120 to live
00:31:48.560 nurses
00:31:49.860 make you
00:31:50.340 one of
00:31:50.660 it
00:31:50.840 you know
00:31:53.220 I don't
00:31:53.460 do this
00:31:53.680 often
00:31:53.960 I gotta
00:31:54.260 defend
00:31:54.540 Biden
00:31:54.820 on this
00:31:55.140 one
00:31:55.300 it did
00:31:55.740 take
00:31:55.960 I had
00:31:56.240 to listen
00:31:56.460 to it
00:31:56.640 three or
00:31:56.820 four times
00:31:57.160 but once
00:31:58.180 you get
00:31:58.440 it's like
00:31:59.800 an optical
00:32:00.120 illusion
00:32:00.500 type of
00:32:00.920 thing
00:32:01.180 and once
00:32:01.720 you
00:32:01.940 you don't
00:32:02.320 see it
00:32:02.560 at first
00:32:03.000 glance
00:32:03.740 but once
00:32:04.160 you see
00:32:04.540 it
00:32:04.660 it becomes
00:32:05.040 obvious
00:32:05.480 and so
00:32:06.720 what he
00:32:07.140 said is
00:32:07.980 you docs
00:32:08.940 are good
00:32:09.460 but if
00:32:09.800 there's
00:32:10.000 any
00:32:10.220 angels
00:32:10.640 in heaven
00:32:11.060 they're
00:32:11.280 all
00:32:11.520 nurses
00:32:11.900 male and
00:32:12.400 female
00:32:12.700 you know
00:32:13.100 why
00:32:13.440 you guys
00:32:13.920 allow us
00:32:14.340 to live
00:32:14.620 the nurses
00:32:14.980 make us
00:32:15.480 want to
00:32:15.900 live
00:32:16.120 now say
00:32:17.860 what you
00:32:18.020 want about
00:32:18.300 that sentiment
00:32:18.860 the sentiment
00:32:19.560 itself
00:32:19.820 doesn't make
00:32:20.200 a whole
00:32:20.380 lot of
00:32:20.580 sense
00:32:20.720 but that
00:32:21.060 is
00:32:21.220 that's
00:32:21.440 what he
00:32:21.620 said
00:32:21.760 so
00:32:22.220 it
00:32:23.920 you know
00:32:24.680 it's
00:32:25.840 it is
00:32:26.340 to say
00:32:27.040 that that
00:32:27.340 was indecipherable
00:32:28.320 word salad
00:32:29.000 is not
00:32:30.500 fair
00:32:30.840 it was
00:32:31.640 decipherable
00:32:32.600 word salad
00:32:33.220 it can be
00:32:33.880 deciphered
00:32:34.160 it takes
00:32:34.340 a little bit
00:32:34.620 of time
00:32:34.980 but you
00:32:35.760 can decipher
00:32:36.220 it
00:32:36.420 I thought
00:32:37.420 that this
00:32:37.800 clip
00:32:37.980 from the
00:32:38.240 same
00:32:38.460 speech
00:32:38.900 I thought
00:32:40.020 that this
00:32:40.380 clip
00:32:40.620 was
00:32:40.960 more
00:32:41.820 much
00:32:42.420 more
00:32:42.700 disturbing
00:32:43.200 even though
00:32:43.620 you can
00:32:43.840 understand
00:32:44.180 the words
00:32:44.600 that are
00:32:44.780 coming out
00:32:45.040 of his
00:32:45.220 mouth
00:32:45.520 you kind
00:32:47.500 of wish
00:32:47.720 that you
00:32:47.980 hadn't
00:32:48.400 based on
00:32:48.820 what he
00:32:49.020 says
00:32:49.220 listen
00:32:49.460 and I
00:32:51.200 had a
00:32:51.440 nurse
00:32:51.700 named
00:32:51.960 Pearl
00:32:52.220 Nelson
00:32:52.580 military
00:32:53.120 she'd
00:32:54.320 come in
00:32:54.640 and do
00:32:54.900 things
00:32:55.220 that I
00:32:55.460 don't
00:32:55.720 think
00:32:55.960 you'll
00:32:56.140 learn
00:32:56.300 in
00:32:56.440 medical
00:32:56.700 nursing
00:32:57.500 school
00:32:57.940 she'd
00:32:59.320 whisper
00:32:59.620 in my
00:32:59.980 ear
00:33:00.320 I
00:33:00.640 couldn't
00:33:01.140 understand
00:33:01.520 her
00:33:01.700 she'd
00:33:01.940 lean
00:33:02.620 down
00:33:03.060 she'd
00:33:04.100 breathe
00:33:04.740 to make
00:33:05.300 sure
00:33:05.540 there was
00:33:06.640 a connection
00:33:07.120 a human
00:33:07.460 connection
00:33:08.000 she even
00:33:09.080 went home
00:33:09.800 and brought
00:33:10.220 back her
00:33:10.800 pillow
00:33:11.200 from her
00:33:11.680 own bed
00:33:12.220 because
00:33:12.600 she didn't
00:33:12.980 knew
00:33:13.240 the one
00:33:13.540 I had
00:33:13.900 the one
00:33:14.160 comfortable
00:33:14.600 but I'm
00:33:15.880 not joking
00:33:16.460 what
00:33:18.820 I could
00:33:20.780 understand
00:33:21.420 I could
00:33:21.720 basically
00:33:22.040 understand
00:33:22.680 the story
00:33:23.680 that he
00:33:23.920 was telling
00:33:24.340 but the
00:33:24.740 question
00:33:25.120 is
00:33:25.540 why
00:33:26.780 he was
00:33:27.180 telling
00:33:27.440 that
00:33:27.840 and then
00:33:29.660 it raises
00:33:30.300 a whole
00:33:30.500 bunch
00:33:30.680 of other
00:33:30.900 questions
00:33:31.280 that we
00:33:31.820 don't
00:33:31.960 even
00:33:32.080 want to
00:33:32.300 think
00:33:32.420 about
00:33:32.620 so
00:33:32.760 when it
00:33:33.960 comes to
00:33:34.240 Joe Biden
00:33:34.740 that pretty
00:33:35.300 much
00:33:35.640 encompasses
00:33:36.700 everything
00:33:37.160 that he
00:33:37.480 says
00:33:37.700 it's
00:33:37.880 either
00:33:38.080 you
00:33:38.300 can't
00:33:38.700 understand
00:33:39.080 it
00:33:39.460 at all
00:33:39.960 or you
00:33:41.540 can
00:33:42.060 but you
00:33:43.100 wish you
00:33:43.540 couldn't
00:33:44.280 that's
00:33:45.200 always what
00:33:45.500 it comes
00:33:45.660 down to
00:33:45.940 this is
00:33:48.320 I want to
00:33:49.680 read this
00:33:49.960 story to
00:33:50.320 you from
00:33:50.560 Fox News
00:33:51.320 I want you
00:33:52.780 to listen
00:33:53.020 to the
00:33:53.320 story
00:33:53.680 and also
00:33:55.440 the words
00:33:56.800 that are
00:33:56.980 being used
00:33:57.520 to report
00:33:58.600 the story
00:33:59.020 by Fox
00:33:59.560 News
00:33:59.740 Hannah
00:34:01.500 Tubbs
00:34:01.920 formerly known
00:34:02.500 as James
00:34:03.180 Tubbs
00:34:03.720 discussed
00:34:04.140 a shift
00:34:04.600 in gender
00:34:05.100 identity
00:34:05.500 as part
00:34:05.880 of a
00:34:06.120 jailhouse
00:34:06.720 phone call
00:34:07.380 regarding
00:34:07.760 the defense
00:34:08.220 lawyer strategy
00:34:08.940 on how
00:34:09.300 the convicted
00:34:09.860 child molester
00:34:10.600 was being
00:34:11.060 housed
00:34:11.700 prior to a
00:34:12.800 guilty plea
00:34:13.280 in Los
00:34:13.580 Angeles
00:34:14.000 according to
00:34:14.560 law enforcement
00:34:15.140 sources with
00:34:15.720 knowledge of
00:34:16.280 the call
00:34:16.720 Tubbs is
00:34:18.640 also
00:34:19.040 speaking of
00:34:20.420 indecipherable
00:34:20.960 that's a
00:34:21.840 heck of a
00:34:22.620 run on sentence
00:34:23.220 to start with
00:34:23.740 but anyway
00:34:24.060 Tubbs is also
00:34:25.120 an accused
00:34:25.540 murderer who
00:34:26.100 allegedly began
00:34:26.820 identifying as
00:34:27.460 female only
00:34:28.060 after being
00:34:28.640 arrested in
00:34:29.100 a cold case
00:34:29.680 child sex
00:34:30.400 assault
00:34:30.680 investigation
00:34:31.120 in order to
00:34:31.660 get placed
00:34:32.120 with juvenile
00:34:32.740 girls
00:34:33.300 while awaiting
00:34:33.840 trial
00:34:34.340 Tubbs
00:34:35.500 17 at the
00:34:36.100 time of the
00:34:36.400 attack
00:34:36.760 has criminal
00:34:37.600 records in
00:34:38.080 California
00:34:38.520 Idaho and
00:34:39.380 Washington
00:34:39.820 and pleaded
00:34:40.300 guilty in the
00:34:40.940 case last
00:34:41.380 year and
00:34:42.300 involved an
00:34:42.660 assault on a
00:34:43.200 10 year old
00:34:43.720 girl in a
00:34:44.480 Denny's bathroom
00:34:45.260 on New
00:34:45.800 Year's Day
00:34:46.240 in 2014
00:34:47.480 so
00:34:47.900 you've probably
00:34:51.000 heard of this
00:34:51.560 case
00:34:52.540 this Hannah
00:34:53.440 quote unquote
00:34:54.360 Hannah Tubbs
00:34:55.080 what's his real
00:34:55.540 name again
00:34:55.900 James Tubbs
00:34:56.820 so James
00:34:57.940 Tubbs
00:34:58.360 child molester
00:34:59.220 convicted
00:35:01.120 criminal
00:35:01.640 gets arrested
00:35:03.820 and then
00:35:04.860 discovers his
00:35:06.420 true female
00:35:07.360 identity and
00:35:08.040 this is all a
00:35:08.620 scheme to get
00:35:09.240 housed with
00:35:10.020 with not just
00:35:12.020 women but
00:35:12.400 underage girls
00:35:13.240 going back to
00:35:15.180 the Fox
00:35:15.520 report
00:35:16.180 but now
00:35:17.760 Shaya
00:35:18.120 Sana the
00:35:18.760 Los Angeles
00:35:19.200 prosecutor who
00:35:19.900 led the
00:35:20.380 Denny's attack
00:35:21.160 case has been
00:35:21.760 suspended for
00:35:22.340 five days without
00:35:23.020 pay for
00:35:23.420 allegedly
00:35:23.740 misgendering and
00:35:24.820 dead naming
00:35:25.480 Tubbs by
00:35:26.600 raising concerns
00:35:27.280 that the repeat
00:35:27.720 offender may
00:35:28.740 have just been
00:35:29.420 pretending to
00:35:30.100 identify as
00:35:30.660 female to have
00:35:31.220 an easier
00:35:31.640 situation in
00:35:32.380 lockup
00:35:32.840 as Fox News
00:35:33.980 Digital reported
00:35:34.520 Friday
00:35:34.960 Sana has
00:35:35.980 argued in the
00:35:36.520 past that
00:35:36.960 jailhouse phone
00:35:37.600 calls show
00:35:38.060 that Tubbs
00:35:38.500 now 27
00:35:39.160 was attempting
00:35:40.060 to use gender
00:35:40.740 identity to game
00:35:41.620 the justice
00:35:42.100 system an
00:35:42.740 argument that
00:35:43.220 sources say
00:35:43.820 made others
00:35:44.600 in Gascon's
00:35:45.440 DA Gascon's
00:35:46.540 office uncomfortable
00:35:47.320 and led to the
00:35:47.820 suspension
00:35:48.180 however a
00:35:49.720 previously
00:35:49.960 undisclosed
00:35:50.480 January 5th
00:35:51.060 2021 jailhouse
00:35:52.120 phone call
00:35:52.680 recording
00:35:53.600 captured the
00:35:56.420 first conversation
00:35:57.280 between the
00:35:57.800 newly minted
00:35:58.440 Hannah Tubbs
00:35:59.080 and her
00:35:59.980 father according
00:36:01.300 to law enforcement
00:36:01.980 sources
00:36:02.540 hey Hannah
00:36:04.600 the father says
00:36:05.240 at the start
00:36:05.620 of the call
00:36:06.020 according to
00:36:06.660 the sources
00:36:07.020 huh Tubbs
00:36:08.060 replies
00:36:08.460 Hannah the
00:36:09.240 father repeats
00:36:09.840 Tubbs replies
00:36:10.940 with a confused
00:36:11.500 yes according
00:36:12.460 to the sources
00:36:12.900 and the father
00:36:13.820 explains he had
00:36:14.560 spoken to the
00:36:15.040 defense attorney
00:36:15.520 who called him
00:36:16.600 and said she
00:36:17.040 represents Hannah
00:36:17.860 I was like who
00:36:19.220 he replies again
00:36:19.980 with a laugh
00:36:20.760 okay so there's a
00:36:22.340 jailhouse phone
00:36:22.900 call where
00:36:23.620 you could you
00:36:24.900 could tell
00:36:25.360 first of all
00:36:25.880 that this was
00:36:26.380 uh that based
00:36:27.420 on the conversation
00:36:27.920 between the
00:36:28.320 father and
00:36:29.240 uh James Tubbs
00:36:31.280 that this was a
00:36:32.260 that this was an
00:36:32.880 identity that was
00:36:33.420 just invented
00:36:33.960 now the father's
00:36:35.000 playing along with
00:36:35.780 it um
00:36:36.880 in a in a
00:36:38.360 scheme to get
00:36:39.080 this child
00:36:39.940 molester housed
00:36:40.840 with uh with uh
00:36:41.700 with girls
00:36:42.160 but here's the
00:36:44.820 point um Fox
00:36:47.580 News article
00:36:48.420 refers to
00:36:51.220 Hannah Tubbs
00:36:52.300 as a her
00:36:53.180 that's what the
00:36:54.120 article does on
00:36:54.800 Fox News
00:36:55.260 now there have
00:36:57.420 actually been a
00:36:57.840 lot of there's
00:36:59.380 been Fox has
00:37:00.140 been on top of
00:37:00.620 this case and
00:37:01.060 has been reporting
00:37:01.600 it quite a bit
00:37:02.100 in fact most of
00:37:02.680 what I've heard
00:37:03.080 about this Hannah
00:37:03.840 Tubbs James
00:37:04.560 Tubbs case has
00:37:05.420 been from Fox
00:37:06.120 News
00:37:06.300 Fox News
00:37:06.800 um and there
00:37:09.820 are many other
00:37:10.220 examples of this
00:37:10.860 that I could
00:37:11.200 read but I
00:37:11.600 won't bother
00:37:12.040 every single
00:37:13.380 article it's
00:37:14.360 the same deal
00:37:15.000 they use the
00:37:17.100 her and the
00:37:18.100 she in the
00:37:19.080 article
00:37:19.400 now obviously
00:37:21.860 it's insane
00:37:22.800 and evil that
00:37:23.820 this scumbag
00:37:24.580 predator pedophile
00:37:25.680 is able to
00:37:26.800 have his
00:37:27.360 supposed gender
00:37:28.360 identity respected
00:37:29.540 by the court
00:37:30.100 system um and
00:37:31.980 the people are
00:37:32.340 getting suspended
00:37:33.260 for correctly
00:37:34.180 gendering not
00:37:35.080 misgendering correctly
00:37:36.280 gendering this
00:37:37.180 child molesting
00:37:37.920 piece of filth
00:37:38.660 but also the
00:37:41.260 fact that Fox
00:37:41.860 News an alleged
00:37:42.540 conservative outlet
00:37:43.440 while reporting
00:37:46.260 while reporting on
00:37:47.680 the fact that the
00:37:48.360 guy is gaming the
00:37:49.260 system by identifying
00:37:50.200 as trans they're
00:37:51.480 the ones telling
00:37:52.160 us this and yet
00:37:53.900 they still respect
00:37:55.180 the female pronouns
00:37:56.400 what they're saying
00:37:58.560 is none of this
00:37:59.600 is real he's
00:38:00.240 pretending or no
00:38:01.480 none of this is
00:38:02.140 real she is
00:38:03.940 pretending well
00:38:04.960 then why are you
00:38:05.540 using the she
00:38:06.280 now I have an
00:38:09.600 issue in the first
00:38:10.300 place with drawing
00:38:11.080 this distinction
00:38:11.760 between men who
00:38:13.340 are just pretending
00:38:15.040 to identify as
00:38:16.140 women and men who
00:38:17.280 actually identify as
00:38:18.660 women that's a
00:38:19.640 distinction without a
00:38:20.300 difference because
00:38:22.100 in both cases
00:38:22.860 they're not actually
00:38:24.020 women so really
00:38:26.080 the only the only
00:38:26.640 question is are
00:38:27.500 they consciously
00:38:29.100 lying or are
00:38:32.260 they deeply
00:38:34.400 deeply confused
00:38:35.920 about their own
00:38:36.920 identity
00:38:37.500 in either case
00:38:41.160 it doesn't change
00:38:41.900 the reality of the
00:38:42.800 situation
00:38:43.280 so drawing this
00:38:45.400 distinction between
00:38:46.280 well that's a
00:38:47.320 pretend trans person
00:38:48.620 and an actual
00:38:49.540 trans person
00:38:50.340 there is no such
00:38:52.640 thing as an actual
00:38:54.320 trans person as in
00:38:55.720 a person who
00:38:56.200 actually transcends
00:38:58.220 the gender binary
00:39:00.800 or a person who
00:39:02.220 actually you know
00:39:03.720 belongs to one
00:39:05.160 biological category
00:39:06.180 but somehow is in
00:39:07.900 this other biological
00:39:08.660 category that doesn't
00:39:09.760 exist there's no
00:39:10.580 actual there
00:39:11.280 so I don't agree
00:39:14.280 with the distinction
00:39:14.920 but it's just very
00:39:16.680 interesting to me
00:39:17.640 that Fox News
00:39:18.500 they make this
00:39:19.540 distinction and
00:39:20.260 even then they
00:39:21.600 still respect the
00:39:22.820 pronoun and you
00:39:24.340 find this with
00:39:25.260 quite a lot of
00:39:26.780 so-called
00:39:27.620 what we call
00:39:29.840 what qualifies
00:39:31.200 apparently as
00:39:31.820 conservative or
00:39:32.660 right-wing media
00:39:33.480 even reporting a
00:39:35.680 case like this
00:39:36.540 New York Post is
00:39:40.260 another example
00:39:40.880 like it says a
00:39:41.460 reputation of being
00:39:42.240 right-wing or
00:39:42.920 conservative which it
00:39:43.700 really isn't
00:39:44.340 but they report on
00:39:45.920 cases like this all
00:39:46.840 the time about men
00:39:48.900 who are being housed
00:39:49.880 with women in
00:39:51.160 women's prisons and
00:39:52.260 all the rest of it
00:39:52.900 still respect the
00:39:54.000 pronouns
00:39:54.260 you are participating
00:39:56.380 in the lie
00:39:57.640 and as long if
00:40:00.860 you're going to
00:40:01.160 continue doing that
00:40:02.020 then the reporting
00:40:02.820 is worthless
00:40:03.760 okay you're exposing
00:40:05.800 the lie but you're
00:40:06.740 participating in it
00:40:07.840 and and affirming
00:40:10.120 it at the exact same
00:40:11.060 time which is it
00:40:12.800 are you going to be
00:40:14.840 honest in your
00:40:15.400 reporting or not
00:40:16.060 that's what you have
00:40:16.580 to decide
00:40:16.960 let's get to the
00:40:18.320 comment section
00:40:18.800 Rachel says my son
00:40:34.220 just got home from
00:40:34.820 his day at our
00:40:35.380 local college the
00:40:36.320 first thing he said
00:40:37.020 was I need to turn
00:40:38.260 on Matt Walsh to
00:40:39.060 calm down the
00:40:39.940 wokeness of his
00:40:40.480 professor was driving
00:40:41.280 him crazy well
00:40:41.860 son has a good head
00:40:43.700 on his shoulder so I
00:40:44.540 think he'll do okay
00:40:45.340 that's a very
00:40:47.240 I'm biased but I
00:40:48.480 would say that's a
00:40:49.020 very encouraging
00:40:49.600 sign
00:40:50.020 Jack says my wife
00:40:53.000 and I moved about
00:40:53.540 750 miles last
00:40:54.840 year and we were
00:40:55.580 going to bring our
00:40:56.260 cats and our baby
00:40:57.220 in a plane to make
00:40:58.460 the move quicker and
00:40:59.340 easier on us but I
00:41:00.140 came to the same
00:41:00.620 conclusion as Matt
00:41:01.440 planes are for
00:41:02.020 people so I found a
00:41:02.920 way to load the
00:41:03.540 cats up in the back
00:41:04.260 of my car and I
00:41:04.940 endured the torment
00:41:05.600 of listening to
00:41:06.100 them howl for 13
00:41:07.020 hours rather than
00:41:08.260 making a hundred
00:41:08.780 strangers listen to
00:41:09.740 them for two
00:41:10.360 hours
00:41:10.740 you this this is
00:41:15.360 exactly I want to
00:41:17.140 give you credit for
00:41:17.680 the sacrifice that
00:41:18.320 you made but I'm
00:41:19.820 sure you understand
00:41:20.320 Jack that I can't
00:41:21.240 do that because you
00:41:21.920 simply this is you
00:41:23.460 you you did the
00:41:24.700 right thing this was
00:41:26.640 your obligation and I
00:41:29.540 wish that more people
00:41:30.380 would be willing to do
00:41:31.160 that and if you're not
00:41:34.640 and if you say well
00:41:35.380 it's not worth it to
00:41:36.240 drive 13 hours for my
00:41:37.460 pets well then maybe
00:41:38.200 you shouldn't have
00:41:38.540 pets
00:41:38.800 okay if you're
00:41:41.700 gonna put if your
00:41:42.620 convenience is so
00:41:43.780 important I'm not
00:41:44.920 saying this to you
00:41:45.400 because you understand
00:41:45.900 this but everyone
00:41:46.360 else if your
00:41:47.780 convenience is so
00:41:48.580 important that you
00:41:51.540 know for the sake of
00:41:53.080 your convenience you're
00:41:54.420 going to have to
00:41:55.380 expose everyone else
00:41:56.560 to your pet your
00:41:57.580 animal and make them
00:41:58.460 listen to the sounds
00:41:59.740 and of your animal
00:42:00.860 and smell your pet on
00:42:02.300 a plane because your
00:42:03.880 convenience is that
00:42:04.760 important it's more
00:42:07.200 important than your
00:42:07.800 pet that maybe you
00:42:08.400 shouldn't be a pet
00:42:08.820 owner
00:42:09.300 Nick says I walked
00:42:12.660 into Lowe's Home
00:42:13.360 Improvement the other
00:42:13.960 day and a couple had
00:42:14.920 two large dogs with
00:42:16.200 them they weren't
00:42:16.780 seeing eye dogs and
00:42:17.720 it was really annoying
00:42:18.560 I actually had to go
00:42:19.240 out of my way down an
00:42:20.920 aisle to avoid
00:42:21.660 tripping over the dog
00:42:22.540 leashes the owner
00:42:23.680 showed no mind
00:42:24.640 disrespect is what it
00:42:26.600 is yeah it's also
00:42:28.600 I've noticed this too
00:42:29.620 it's like the dogs we
00:42:31.080 already know that
00:42:31.660 they're brought on
00:42:32.160 planes all the time
00:42:33.020 but now more and more
00:42:34.680 you know these stores
00:42:37.180 big box stores are
00:42:38.200 allowing you to bring
00:42:39.100 your pet in that's
00:42:39.900 one thing if we're
00:42:40.280 talking about Petco or
00:42:41.220 something that it makes
00:42:41.960 sense but a hardware
00:42:42.880 store why do you got to
00:42:44.020 bring your pet in and if
00:42:47.200 it's an actual now there
00:42:48.740 are people who have
00:42:50.620 actual disabilities and so
00:42:53.140 they have service animals
00:42:54.460 and that's a that's a real
00:42:55.720 thing I respect that but I
00:42:59.100 would be even more in
00:43:00.100 though if I was someone who
00:43:01.080 had a disability where I
00:43:01.840 actually needed a service
00:43:02.640 animal a dog it's like the
00:43:04.120 only legitimate service
00:43:04.940 animal I'd be even more
00:43:07.980 annoyed by this because
00:43:10.900 now I'm getting lumped in
00:43:12.280 I get all these people
00:43:12.880 abusing the system and so
00:43:14.260 I'm getting lumped in with
00:43:15.140 them when I have a
00:43:16.000 legitimate reason to have
00:43:18.280 the service animal
00:43:18.940 Gage says I agree with Matt
00:43:23.080 about the babies crying
00:43:24.180 except for one public place
00:43:25.640 and that's the movie
00:43:26.500 theaters please do not
00:43:28.400 bring babies to the movies
00:43:29.660 yeah well the movies there
00:43:31.660 are a number of places where
00:43:33.240 people should not have to
00:43:34.180 hear your baby cry at all
00:43:35.840 now as I said yesterday I'm
00:43:36.900 much more tolerant of
00:43:39.900 listening to babies cry
00:43:40.840 because that is the price
00:43:41.880 of living in a human
00:43:42.920 society people have
00:43:44.040 children families exist
00:43:45.200 this is all a very good
00:43:46.200 thing it's all very good
00:43:47.720 and so part of that is
00:43:48.900 you're going to hear the
00:43:49.880 noises of babies and
00:43:51.040 children and if you have
00:43:53.280 no tolerance for that
00:43:54.400 whatsoever then that's
00:43:55.060 something wrong there's
00:43:55.720 something wrong with you
00:43:56.500 and your own soul that you
00:43:57.720 can't even tolerate being
00:43:59.200 around children at all but
00:44:01.880 that is very much your own
00:44:02.860 problem we need babies and
00:44:05.820 children to keep society
00:44:06.780 going and we can't expect
00:44:08.060 them to be like totally
00:44:09.560 segregated from polite
00:44:10.820 society until they're old
00:44:12.060 enough where they're not
00:44:12.660 being annoying anymore
00:44:14.280 especially because plenty
00:44:15.340 of adults are much more
00:44:16.380 annoying than any child
00:44:17.300 so that's how I feel but
00:44:19.220 that but there are
00:44:19.860 certainly places where
00:44:21.200 right you shouldn't bring
00:44:22.040 a baby and bring a baby
00:44:23.240 into a movie theater no
00:44:25.020 I would also say bringing
00:44:26.800 a baby into a nice
00:44:27.760 restaurant and by nice
00:44:28.820 restaurant I would kind of
00:44:29.820 I think the cutoff is if
00:44:31.460 it's the kind of
00:44:32.120 restaurant that doesn't
00:44:33.240 have a kids menu it's the
00:44:35.060 kind of restaurant where
00:44:36.000 they're not going to give
00:44:37.240 you a kids menu and a
00:44:38.940 little coloring pad with
00:44:39.980 crayons if it's if it's
00:44:41.580 that kind of restaurant
00:44:42.340 then yeah bring the kids
00:44:43.340 bring all the kids it's
00:44:44.320 it's it's designed for
00:44:46.360 families and it's designed
00:44:47.520 to be kind of loud and all
00:44:48.640 that the kind of restaurant
00:44:50.220 where they would look at
00:44:51.080 you they would look at you
00:44:52.480 like you're crazy if you
00:44:53.380 asked for some crayons that
00:44:54.640 kind of restaurant probably
00:44:56.840 shouldn't bring babies
00:44:57.800 finally Charlie says the
00:44:59.920 cuckoo bleep was hilarious
00:45:01.180 I vote for it staying a
00:45:02.580 good laugh is welcome when
00:45:03.700 talking about so many
00:45:04.680 depressing things I agree
00:45:06.740 I went back and listened to
00:45:07.740 it and it's incredibly
00:45:09.420 stupid but that's what I
00:45:12.640 like it I mean that is
00:45:15.220 hilarious and gives me more
00:45:17.580 reasons to cuss on the
00:45:18.500 podcast to cuss like a
00:45:20.400 damned
00:45:20.740 it was almost a whole year
00:45:24.080 ago that we released my
00:45:25.840 documentary what is a woman
00:45:27.200 and it's a film that we
00:45:29.860 when we were making it we
00:45:31.280 knew that it would have an
00:45:32.300 impact but I have to say
00:45:33.500 that the impact has far
00:45:34.720 exceeded my own
00:45:35.280 expectations especially now
00:45:36.620 with states all across the
00:45:38.820 country passing laws to
00:45:41.600 protect children from gender
00:45:43.120 ideology and all this has
00:45:44.820 happened you know in a very
00:45:47.120 short amount of time so if
00:45:48.660 you have not seen this film
00:45:49.960 yet you gotta head to
00:45:50.860 dailywire.com slash
00:45:52.220 subscribe to become a
00:45:53.320 member and watch what is a
00:45:54.440 woman today that's
00:45:55.840 dailywire.com slash
00:45:57.500 subscribe today now let's
00:45:59.240 get to our daily
00:45:59.940 cancellation
00:46:00.380 for our daily cancellation
00:46:05.660 we turn to American Idol
00:46:07.480 most interesting thing about
00:46:09.040 this show is that it is
00:46:10.520 apparently still on the air
00:46:12.180 I don't know if it's
00:46:13.260 indicate it's if it's an
00:46:14.400 indication that I'm out of
00:46:15.680 touch or that American Idol
00:46:16.780 is irrelevant but until this
00:46:18.480 moment I thought American Idol
00:46:19.740 was canceled years ago I
00:46:21.280 suppose that's a false
00:46:22.300 choice however I mean the
00:46:23.200 answer could be and
00:46:24.800 probably is both I'm out of
00:46:26.640 touch and the show is
00:46:28.020 irrelevant be that as it
00:46:29.400 may it was back in the
00:46:30.680 cultural conversation ever
00:46:31.740 so briefly this week but not
00:46:33.020 for anything related to
00:46:33.800 music or singing instead it
00:46:34.940 was the story of one
00:46:36.220 contestant and more
00:46:37.820 specifically a judge's
00:46:39.140 reaction to that story that
00:46:41.560 had people talking watch
00:46:42.820 in May 2018 a gunman walked
00:46:48.820 into my school I was in art
00:46:54.560 room one he shot up art room
00:46:57.280 two before he made his way to
00:47:00.060 art room one lost a lot of
00:47:05.120 friends eight students were
00:47:08.160 killed two teachers were killed
00:47:10.700 and uh it's just really been
00:47:14.220 negative man seeing a face had a
00:47:15.700 bad rap here since 2018 what you
00:47:19.400 doing Katie our country has
00:47:22.120 failed us facts this is not okay
00:47:27.900 you should be singing here because
00:47:30.000 you love music it's true not
00:47:34.960 because you don't have to go
00:47:35.860 through that I agree you don't
00:47:40.700 have to lose eight friends I hope
00:47:44.260 that you remind people that we
00:47:46.600 have to change because you know
00:47:49.060 what I'm scared too it's terrible
00:47:52.960 Katie it's horrible
00:47:54.600 now before we deal with the
00:48:02.920 substance of Katy Perry's response
00:48:04.860 to the extent that it had any
00:48:06.140 substance we cannot ignore the
00:48:07.660 incredible narcissism on display
00:48:09.940 here by her Perry has apparently
00:48:12.520 attended the you know the same
00:48:14.480 training seminars alongside Giselle
00:48:16.700 Fetterman to learn how to make
00:48:17.960 other people's traumas about
00:48:19.700 yourself he is calmly recounting his
00:48:23.040 own horrific experience
00:48:24.160 and Perry uses it as a platform to
00:48:27.300 put this put on this over-the-top
00:48:29.380 emotional performance she even
00:48:32.000 relates it back to herself somehow
00:48:33.820 I'm scared too she says as her
00:48:36.720 fellow judges comfort her they start
00:48:39.140 patting her on the back and
00:48:40.300 comforting her while the kid who
00:48:41.820 was actually in the shooting stands
00:48:44.060 there and watches here's a hint if
00:48:46.700 someone is telling you about
00:48:48.080 something awful that happened to
00:48:49.500 them your response should not
00:48:52.480 contain the words I or me unless
00:48:55.700 you're saying something like I'm so
00:48:58.000 sorry or I'm here for you but if
00:49:00.880 you're attempting to put yourself at
00:49:02.300 the center of this person's suffering
00:49:04.120 or deflect from it so that the focus
00:49:06.360 is on you and your own emotions then
00:49:09.540 you are a classic narcissist and maybe
00:49:12.620 worst of all you're creating an
00:49:13.940 incredibly awkward situation for
00:49:15.860 everyone else who has to be in the
00:49:17.540 room with your lack of self-awareness
00:49:20.000 I can only imagine how
00:49:22.120 uncomfortable it must have been for
00:49:23.080 that young man to be standing there
00:49:24.580 not sure what to say or how to
00:49:26.000 respond as Katy Perry launches into
00:49:27.820 her camera-ready monologue like she's
00:49:29.940 auditioning for a soap opera a
00:49:31.960 monologue that was planned by the way
00:49:33.480 considering that the judges would
00:49:34.700 have known ahead of time that a
00:49:36.440 contestant was coming up who'd been
00:49:38.280 in a mass shooting that fact was
00:49:40.580 certainly conveyed to Katy Perry and
00:49:42.140 her cohorts by the producers before
00:49:44.580 the kid got up on the stage she
00:49:45.780 didn't she didn't you know burst into
00:49:46.940 tears spontaneously she had all this
00:49:49.140 planned in her head ahead of time and
00:49:50.620 I understand that this is a very
00:49:52.560 cynical interpretation of events but
00:49:55.220 I've been around long enough and I've
00:49:56.580 been in media long enough and I've
00:49:57.880 met enough of these sorts of people to
00:50:00.540 justify my cynicism but what about the
00:50:03.680 actual point she was making in her
00:50:05.180 scripted diatribe she says that the
00:50:07.360 country has failed the victims and
00:50:09.260 survivors of this school shooting and
00:50:11.280 of course she means specifically that
00:50:12.400 it failed by not passing enough gun
00:50:14.600 control laws to prevent the shooting
00:50:16.060 from happening never mind that the
00:50:18.020 shooter already broke a dozen
00:50:19.540 different laws in carrying out his
00:50:21.460 crime it's unclear how exactly it
00:50:24.440 would have helped to add one or two
00:50:26.600 more laws onto the pile that the
00:50:28.440 killer was already determined to
00:50:29.880 disregard you can only make an act
00:50:32.840 illegal so many times before the laws
00:50:35.400 start to become redundant and
00:50:37.120 therefore useless yet this is what we
00:50:40.380 so often do in our culture when a bad
00:50:42.160 thing happens we declare that the bad
00:50:44.600 thing is the result of some sort of
00:50:46.120 failure it's always a systemic failure
00:50:49.060 failure of government of policy people
00:50:53.120 like Katy Perry take solace in the idea
00:50:54.900 that all tragedies are policy failures
00:50:57.340 because and really all bad things you
00:50:59.620 know they say poverty is a policy
00:51:01.560 failure too because for one thing it
00:51:04.500 gives them an excuse to push their
00:51:05.860 political agenda obviously but for
00:51:07.120 another it comforts them to think that
00:51:09.180 the right policies if we could finally
00:51:11.200 land on them would banish all the bad
00:51:14.220 things from our midst when Perry says
00:51:16.880 that the country failed because there
00:51:18.360 was a school shooting what she means is
00:51:20.160 that we ought to have a country where
00:51:22.660 there are no shootings at all and she's
00:51:26.500 right in the sense that every mass
00:51:28.460 shooting and every bad thing shouldn't
00:51:30.000 happen that's why it's a very bad thing
00:51:31.680 if there's something that's evil like
00:51:33.200 any evil shouldn't happen but Perry like
00:51:37.300 any other leftist believes that a
00:51:38.660 country without any murder without any
00:51:40.760 bad people doing bad things is
00:51:42.640 actually practically achievable and
00:51:45.460 that it can be achieved through policy
00:51:47.160 the irony of course is that the
00:51:49.760 utopianists who imagine that a world
00:51:51.740 of perfect peace and harmony can really
00:51:53.260 be achieved tend through their
00:51:55.240 policies to create a world that is
00:51:57.080 ever farther away from peace and
00:51:58.800 harmony worlds like the world of
00:52:02.060 Chicago for example people with a with
00:52:05.320 with Katy Perry's worldview run most of
00:52:08.500 our major American cities and most of
00:52:10.120 our major American cities are violent
00:52:11.520 crime and disease ridden hell holes
00:52:13.180 which actually isn't all that ironic
00:52:14.800 when you realize that effective
00:52:16.640 governance means understanding human
00:52:19.060 nature and understanding human nature
00:52:20.720 means acknowledging that bad people
00:52:23.460 will always exist and they will always
00:52:25.520 do bad things you can do a lot you can
00:52:28.100 do a much better job of containing and
00:52:30.000 mitigating the damage but you can only
00:52:32.940 do that once you've acknowledged the
00:52:34.560 fallen state of man and that although you
00:52:36.780 can mitigate the damage and try to
00:52:38.760 contain it there will always be damage
00:52:41.960 to mitigate and contain with all that
00:52:45.760 said it's still true that a school
00:52:48.220 shooting represents a failure in fact
00:52:50.220 it's a whole series of failures but
00:52:53.160 they're mostly the kinds of failures
00:52:54.360 that Katy Perry and her ilk never want
00:52:56.220 to talk about first of all it's a moral
00:52:58.960 failure of the person who carries out
00:53:00.760 the deed people have agency they have
00:53:03.900 free will they choose to do things they
00:53:08.160 should be the first people we blame for
00:53:09.760 the things that they choose to do
00:53:10.760 rather than pinning it on the country
00:53:12.640 and also very often there have been
00:53:18.740 parenting failures that help to produce
00:53:21.460 the sorts of people who would do
00:53:23.240 something like that and failures in a
00:53:26.200 culture which breeds people who have no
00:53:28.020 meaning no purpose in their lives seemingly
00:53:30.420 no capacity for empathy or love these are
00:53:35.240 all failures and they're the kinds of
00:53:37.440 failures we skip over focusing instead on
00:53:39.820 debates over gun control and that itself is
00:53:43.380 also a failure one which only ensures that
00:53:46.700 this kind of thing will keep happening with
00:53:48.840 the same or greater frequency and that is
00:53:52.600 why Katy Perry is today finally canceled and
00:53:57.780 that'll do it for the show today hope you
00:53:59.540 have a great day we'll talk to you tomorrow
00:54:00.800 Godspeed