Ep. 1207 - The Case That Proves Why Hate Crime Statistics Are Bogus
Episode Stats
Length
1 hour and 7 minutes
Words per Minute
180.86012
Summary
Recently, a group of Black teens assaulted an Asian family on a New York subway. The crime exactly fits the DOJ's standard for hate crime, and yet it will not be prosecuted as one. In fact, even the victims justified their own victimization, saying that their assailants lack, quote, "privilege." So we'll sort through this case today. Also, Target took a major sales hit thanks to the backlash against their Pride merchandise. A Hollywood actor sues Home Depot for racial discrimination. Plus, CNN publishes a guide to neo-pronouns that is even dumber than you think. All of that and more on today's Matt Walsh Show.
Transcript
00:00:00.000
Today on the Matt Walsh Show, recently a group of black teens assaulted an Asian family on a New York subway.
00:00:04.720
The crime exactly fits the DOJ's standard for hate crime, and yet it will not be prosecuted as one.
00:00:09.960
In fact, even the victims justified their own victimization, saying that their assailants lack, quote, privilege.
00:00:17.280
Also, Target took a major sales hit thanks to the backlash against their Pride merchandise.
00:00:21.560
A Hollywood actor sues Home Depot for racial discrimination.
00:00:24.180
Plus, CNN publishes a guide to neo-pronouns, which is even dumber than you think.
00:00:38.720
As central banks in countries like China, India, and Australia begin transitioning to a digital currency,
00:00:43.820
the Federal Reserve has been contemplating the same for the U.S.
00:00:46.940
With a digital currency, the government could track every single purchase you make.
00:00:50.360
Officials could even prohibit you from purchasing certain products or easily freeze or seize part or all of your money.
00:00:55.700
These are some of the reasons concerned Americans reached out to Birch Gold.
00:01:00.120
They want to have a physical asset like gold that's independent of the U.S. dollar.
00:01:04.360
You can protect your IRA or 401k by diversifying with gold from Birch Gold today.
00:01:09.240
Historically, gold has been a safe haven in times of high uncertainty, which is right now, unfortunately.
00:01:14.980
Text Walsh to 989898, and they'll send you a free info kit on gold.
00:01:18.300
With an A-plus rating with the Better Business Bureau, thousands of happy customers, and countless five-star reviews.
00:01:22.960
I trust Birch Gold to help you diversify into gold.
00:01:25.560
If a central bank digital currency becomes a reality, it'll be nice to have some gold to depend on.
00:01:32.560
Police departments nationwide regularly receive a document from the DOJ entitled Hate Crime Data Collection Guidelines and Training Manual.
00:01:40.360
And the point of the manual is to educate officers on how to identify hate crimes and how to report them to the feds for the all-important hate crime statistics that you often see in the media.
00:01:49.600
They were especially everywhere during the Trump presidency, and you still see these hate crime figures cited today, in fact.
00:01:55.420
These are the statistics that supposedly prove that white supremacy is the greatest threat this country has ever faced.
00:02:01.180
Now, given all of the reliance on these numbers, it's strange that no one ever talks about the DOJ manual.
00:02:06.640
You'd think there'd be some curiosity about how these numbers are determined.
00:02:14.680
And one of the most extensive sections of this manual, as it turns out, is the exercises section.
00:02:20.780
And these are the hypothetical scenarios that the DOJ provides to police departments to help them see, you know, how hate crimes actually look.
00:02:30.420
And one of the exercises is about two gang members who assault a random Hindu person with a baseball bat.
00:02:38.880
When taken into custody, the two juveniles reported they committed the assault because they want the Hindu people to go back where they came from.
00:02:46.420
As you probably guess, the DOJ's manual instructs officers to categorize this incident as a hate crime because of the offenders' derogatory comments about the Hindu community.
00:02:57.160
If you beat somebody up while yelling, go back where you came from, then you're committing a hate crime.
00:03:02.080
And if hate crime means anything, then that would have to qualify.
00:03:07.220
What's interesting is that a real-life version of this exercise just played out earlier this month in New York City.
00:03:13.680
51-year-old Asian-American Sue Young was traveling on a subway train in Greenwich Village, supposedly one of the nice areas of the city, with her husband and her 11-year-old twin girls.
00:03:23.920
And that's when three black teenage girls started screaming and cursing at Sue Young.
00:03:30.620
And she tried to play it off, tried to laugh it off.
00:03:33.220
Her husband suggested the girls might be uneducated, a rather plausible theory, I would say.
00:03:37.920
And then the teenagers told Sue Young to go back where she came from.
00:03:42.500
Within seconds, one of the teenagers, a 16-year-old girl, began attacking Young.
00:03:47.220
And then for good measure, that teenager beat a random bystander who was recording the incident.
00:03:52.480
Now, given all of those facts, you think it's safe to call this incident a hate crime.
00:03:57.240
It pretty much mirrors exactly the scenario in the DOJ's own hate crime manual.
00:04:01.820
Go back where you came from is an admission that the attack relates to the victim's national origin, race, or religion.
00:04:09.180
Pretty straightforward to any reasonable person.
00:04:12.300
But apparently it's not straightforward to New York police because they've decided not to charge the teenagers in this case with a hate crime.
00:04:20.340
They found them, arrested them, and they know that this teen girl told her victim to go back to her country.
00:04:40.680
New information on that disturbing video showing teens berating and then attacking a family on an F train in Greenwich Village.
00:04:48.540
16-year-old girl has been arrested and charged with two counts of assault.
00:04:52.380
The teen was one in a group of three girls who screamed at a family of four, telling them to go back to where they came from.
00:04:59.080
The situation quickly became violent, with one of the teens even assaulting the woman who captured the incident on her cell phone.
00:05:07.120
Go back where you came from, followed by a beating.
00:05:10.000
Under the DOJ's guidelines, that's a hate crime.
00:05:12.580
I mean, it's literally one of the exact scenarios they specify as a hate crime.
00:05:20.020
Now, if you're the kind of person who trusts government statistics on crime or on any topic at all, then this development is mind-blowing.
00:05:29.060
It's the kind of thing that might make you ask some unapproved questions.
00:05:32.600
For example, you might wonder, is it really true, as multiple outlets have reported, that the anti-Asian hate crime epidemic is caused by all those MAGA Republicans that secretly live in New York and San Francisco?
00:05:45.540
Are MAGA Republicans not only controlling the weather and melting the ice caps, but also patrolling the streets looking for Asians to randomly assault?
00:05:54.680
And if that's happening, then why is that never caught on video?
00:05:59.340
I mean, why is literally every video that we see of an Asian person being assaulted in an apparent hate crime, why is it in every case a black person doing the assault?
00:06:10.180
Like, why have we never actually seen the white person doing this?
00:06:14.720
Well, it might be because the real numbers are quite different from what you hear in the media.
00:06:21.480
While black perpetrators account for 27.5% of violent attacks against Asians, Asians commit less than 0.1% of violent attacks against blacks, indicating little role for proximity.
00:06:33.580
Most violent attacks against individuals of a particular racial group are committed by other members of that group, except for Asians, where a plurality is committed by blacks.
00:06:42.000
In fact, blacks are responsible for 305% more violent crime against Asians than neighborhood demographics would predict, while whites and Hispanics commit significantly fewer attacks against Asians than would be expected.
00:06:56.760
So what this suggests is that hate crime statistics are meaningless.
00:07:02.940
They misrepresent and vastly under-report the amount of anti-Asian racial violence committed by black people, especially young black people.
00:07:12.000
What happened in Sue Young's case is not as unusual as it might appear.
00:07:15.760
To be clear, now, there are many other reasons to conclude that these hate crime statistics aren't reliable.
00:07:20.840
The overwhelming majority of police departments report zero hate crimes every year, for example.
00:07:28.300
In 2019, fewer than 15% of the nearly 16,000 jurisdictions reported a single hate crime to the DOJ,
00:07:35.100
even though they participate in the DOJ's reporting system.
00:07:39.860
So this is a tiny sample size we're talking about here.
00:07:43.220
And these police departments, the few that are reporting hate crimes, they're not verifying as a legal matter that any hate crime occurred.
00:07:50.160
The hate crime statistics, they don't refer to hate crimes that have been proven.
00:07:55.820
They refer to reports of hate crimes, as the DOJ manual says.
00:07:59.940
So all it takes is a cop to code a case as hateful, and boom, you have a hate crime.
00:08:08.280
These are the gaping holes in the hate crime reporting system that you never hear about.
00:08:12.080
So you have to ask, why do we have this hate crime system if it's not producing anything remotely resembling accurate results?
00:08:19.140
And for that matter, even if we could measure this accurately, why does anyone bother recording hate crimes?
00:08:25.240
I mean, why not record crimes that are motivated by, say, greed or lust?
00:08:31.860
As I've often argued, the most dangerous people in society are those motivated not by hate, but by indifference to human life, by callous disregard.
00:08:40.780
So why don't we have a separate federal category for indifferent crimes?
00:08:45.180
Why give hate crimes this special place of honor, especially when they aren't being recorded in any kind of honest or consistent way?
00:08:53.440
Well, Sue Young and her husband offer us some clues on that front.
00:08:57.280
They've come out and given interviews absolving their attacker of personal responsibility.
00:09:09.760
They've moved on, left our city, continuing their vacation, but hoping to soon return.
00:09:14.640
Still shaken by all they've been through, but offering a message this afternoon of understanding and forgiveness.
00:09:20.780
I keep running through, oh, I should have done this, I should have done this, you know, XYZ.
00:09:28.920
Battered and bruised from her New York subway encounter, Sue Young and her husband, still shocked by how quickly taunts on the F train spun wildly out of control.
00:09:39.220
You just go into survival mode and you just want to protect, you know, yourself.
00:09:50.180
That's them on the left, riding the train with their 11-year-old twin girls Thursday night.
00:09:54.700
They say the three teens sitting across from them started laughing and pointing, and when they didn't back down, quickly became more aggressive than violent.
00:10:04.920
The woman who filmed the confrontation says one of the girls also assaulted her three times.
00:10:11.240
Started over, took me by the hair, threw me on the ground and started punching me.
00:10:15.920
The teens on video telling the family to go back where they came from.
00:10:20.160
Top officials at the MTA and the state weighing in today.
00:10:24.000
I haven't seen the video, but I'll tell you this.
00:10:29.780
This woman had no reason to be attacked whatsoever.
00:10:33.700
There is no tolerance for this in the state of New York.
00:10:36.080
But from the victims themselves, who've been talking to investigators, there's compassion.
00:10:40.900
We don't know what battles other people have in their lives, but I can imagine.
00:10:43.980
They're probably not as privileged, and that has probably a lot to do with their outlook on the world and the anger they may have.
00:10:58.720
Doesn't reach the high bar that needs to be sent for that, they say.
00:11:03.280
And they're talking to investigators here at the 6th Precinct who are still looking to talk to those three teenage girls.
00:11:08.820
We don't know what battles other people have in their lives, but I can imagine they're probably not as privileged, Sue Young's husband says.
00:11:16.620
He's apparently justifying why he allowed his wife to be accosted right in front of him.
00:11:22.240
He adds, quote, that probably has a lot to do with their outlook on the world and the anger they may have.
00:11:33.560
They're happy they took their beating instead of fighting back.
00:11:37.340
Now, what that couple is saying out loud without realizing it is the real reason hate crimes persist as a category.
00:11:43.100
The point of hate crimes isn't really to measure hate.
00:11:46.280
The point is to measure victimhood where the victims happen to be the primary voting blocs of the Democratic Party.
00:11:51.940
If you have privilege, meaning if you're Asian or white, then hate crimes can't happen to you.
00:11:56.500
If you're attacked because of your ethnicity and you're in one of those two groups, then you should rationalize it.
00:12:01.240
You should justify the actions of your attackers.
00:12:04.060
One of the many problems with this reasoning, other than the fact that lack of privilege cannot conceivably justify beating up a woman in front of her kids,
00:12:10.440
is that plenty of poor people don't commit violent crimes.
00:12:15.440
The assumption that Sue Young and her husband have, that their attacker must have had a really hard life,
00:12:20.280
is not an explanation, much less an excuse, for what happened.
00:12:23.700
The Twitter account Monitoring Bias has looked into the numbers on this.
00:12:28.880
in NYC, where the percentage of Asians who live in poverty is close to that of blacks,
00:12:32.620
the black arrest rate for murder was 13 times higher than for Asians in 2020.
00:12:37.320
So, in other words, black people aren't simply committing acts of violence because many of them are poor.
00:12:44.420
You know, the black violent crime rate is still disproportionately high,
00:12:47.260
even when you control for income level and economic class and that sort of thing.
00:12:52.280
So, the point is that these punks on the subway, they're not really angry or going through any great personal struggle.
00:13:00.200
It's like you lose the right to be pitied when you start victimizing other people.
00:13:09.420
And they've been empowered to act however they want with the knowledge that their behavior will always be excused,
00:13:19.620
And that way, they're like the rich Antifa kids who spit on cops,
00:13:22.520
or the lawyers who threw firebombs at a police cruiser during a BLM riot.
00:13:26.660
They're like the thugs who you see going into Nordstrom or the Apple Store,
00:13:30.600
They know they're not going to suffer immediate, severe, and long-lasting punishment.
00:13:37.620
They know their victims are weak and often lack the will to defend themselves.
00:13:46.200
And some people won't acknowledge it, this reality,
00:13:50.200
even when it hits them in the face many times over on the subway, in front of their kids.
00:13:55.560
They've been fed so many lies, including from the DOJ's hate crimes reporting system,
00:13:59.540
that they're incapable of diagnosing the problem, much less trying to solve it.
00:14:03.060
And what will happen is that their weakness will perpetuate violence on all sides,
00:14:09.240
because people can only take so many random subway beatings and stabbings
00:14:18.060
You know, you heard there in the clip, the Youngs were proud of themselves
00:14:21.040
for not, quote, attacking the black teens who were harassing them.
00:14:24.060
But people are growing weary of that kind of passivity,
00:14:28.760
of this submissiveness in the face of lawless, violent thugs.
00:14:36.540
And there will be a lot more Daniel Penney is coming soon.
00:14:40.440
And when that happens, the DOJ will call it hateful.
00:14:43.660
They'll call it a sign of rampant white supremacy.
00:14:47.000
What they'll never admit, what they know is true,
00:15:01.580
Before giving our dog rough greens, he was so sad and lazy.
00:15:09.140
My team keeps joking that we need to sign it up for one of those speed course dog shows.
00:15:22.480
Anyway, naturopathic Dr. Dennis Black, the founder of Rough Greens,
00:15:25.680
is focused on improving the health of every dog in America.
00:15:28.740
Little did I know, before I got Rough Greens, dog food is dead food.
00:15:31.840
Everybody knows that nutrition isn't brown, it's green.
00:15:34.220
Let Rough Greens boost your dog's food back to life.
00:15:37.860
Rough Greens is a supplement that contains all the necessary vitamins, minerals,
00:15:40.980
probiotics, omega oils, digestive enzymes, and antioxidants that your dog needs.
00:15:47.600
You just sprinkle Rough Greens on their food every day.
00:15:50.380
Dog owners everywhere are raving about Rough Greens.
00:15:52.480
It supports healthy joints, improves bad breath, boosts energy levels, so much more.
00:15:57.200
We are what we eat, and that goes for dogs too.
00:15:59.720
Naturopathic Dr. Dennis Black is so confident Rough Greens will improve your dog's health.
00:16:04.320
He's offering my listeners a free Jumpstart trial bag so you and your dog can try it.
00:16:10.020
A free Jumpstart trial bag can be at your door in just a few business days.
00:16:13.160
Go to roughgreens.com slash Matt or call 844-ROUGH-700.
00:16:17.060
That's R-U-F-F-Greens.com slash Matt or call 844-ROUGH-700 today.
00:16:21.740
For the Daily Wire, Target's sales have declined after backlash to its Pride Month collection
00:16:27.800
The company announced on Wednesday Target's quarterly sales sank for the first time in
00:16:31.400
six years, falling 5.4% in the second quarter, which ended July 29th compared to
00:16:36.020
the same period last year, according to the company's second quarter earnings report.
00:16:40.540
Online sales fell nearly twice as much, 10.5%, Target said.
00:16:45.260
The company also said the number of transactions and the average dollar amount of a transaction
00:16:50.620
Target's total revenue of $24.8 billion was 4.9% lower than last year.
00:16:55.780
The Minneapolis-based retail behemoth said that because of recent sales trends, it has
00:17:00.260
lowered its overall sales and profit expectations for the whole year.
00:17:04.080
Of course, as you know, back in May, Target faced backlash over its Pride collection, which
00:17:07.760
included a kid's swimsuit with a tag reading, thoughtfully fit on multiple body types and
00:17:14.380
And we know about the satanic stuff and the pronoun stuff and all the rest of it.
00:17:20.360
Target spokeswoman Kayla Castaneda said, quote, in late May, given these volatile circumstances,
00:17:27.680
we're making adjustments to our plans, including removing items that have been at the center of
00:17:36.220
But on Wednesday, the Target chief growth officer, Christina Hennington, said that the sales were
00:17:44.120
impacted by the, quote, strong reaction to this year's Pride assortment.
00:17:48.400
And she says, the reaction is a signal for us to pause, adapt, and learn.
00:17:53.140
So this is, should be, needless to say, a major victory.
00:18:00.820
And, you know, having Target, I mean, there's the sales hit they took, but also a statement
00:18:07.580
like that from a company like Target, only they're saying it because of backlash from our
00:18:19.280
So in almost every case, if you've got a company like Target and they issue a statement saying,
00:18:24.360
it's time for us as a company to adapt and learn and educate ourselves, in almost every
00:18:31.260
case, even if you have no context, you don't know what they're talking about, and you hear
00:18:35.560
a company put out a statement like that, you just assume that, oh, well, the left must be
00:18:39.600
mad at them for something if they're promising to adapt and learn and educate.
00:18:44.460
But in this case, no, they're saying it's because of us.
00:18:50.700
It's because we said we don't want this disgusting stuff right in front of our kids.
00:18:55.660
And now Target is saying, well, we need to learn.
00:19:02.620
That represents them bending the knee to us for change.
00:19:07.500
And you could always point out, well, they still have the pride stuff.
00:19:15.780
You know, do I think that come pride month next year that they're going to have no pride
00:19:20.700
merchandise at all, that there's going to be no rainbows?
00:19:23.200
No, of course, they're still going to have some of that stuff.
00:19:25.840
But they're going to tamp it down considerably.
00:19:30.040
And they're going to do it because we demanded it.
00:19:33.680
Now, Target is not Bud Light in that they're not going to be totally destroyed by this.
00:19:49.100
But they've lost millions and millions of dollars.
00:19:55.540
And I think the damage for them will also be long-term, if not permanent.
00:20:03.680
I mean, I can tell you that I'm never going back to Target.
00:20:13.600
And the problem for Target is that, like with so many of these companies and products,
00:20:20.700
you know, you use the product or you go to this particular store or this brand or whatever,
00:20:26.400
and you do it reflexively because it's just like part of your routine.
00:20:29.740
So for a lot of people, and this was always the big hurdle when all this first happened
00:20:35.040
And I remember I was talking about the boycott, of course, pushing for the boycott.
00:20:37.920
And I said at the time, the big hurdle we have to get over here is that, like, this is just
00:20:41.940
a part of people's lives, part of their routine.
00:20:45.740
And to get people to develop different habits, to get consumers to develop different habits
00:20:50.420
in response to your boycott campaign is very, very difficult.
00:20:57.620
And so you spend a couple, you know, you think, well, I go to Target three times a week.
00:21:03.960
It's going to be a big hassle if I cut Target up.
00:21:06.640
Well, then you do it and you realize that, okay, yeah, I don't really need to go to Target.
00:21:10.600
There's like a million other places I could go.
00:21:14.480
And you spend a couple months not going to Target.
00:21:16.700
And then it's like, why would I start going now?
00:21:22.100
And it hasn't even been a great inconvenience, it turns out.
00:21:26.340
So that's a big problem for Target now is that it's not just the boycott anymore.
00:21:33.820
It's that consumers have, you know, a sizable chunk of consumers have developed different
00:21:51.520
And it matters because no matter what anyone tells you, when it comes down to it, the old
00:22:02.120
And they are, these businesses, they want to make money.
00:22:08.740
The woke virtue signaling, the pride stuff, why do they do that?
00:22:14.920
They do it because the people running these companies, you know, they really do hate their
00:22:20.480
conservative customers and they hate conservatives in general.
00:22:23.340
And so there's some real feeling behind it on their part and some real contempt.
00:22:37.440
It does, you know, and it's, it's, it's marketing.
00:22:43.320
All these other things are contributing factors.
00:22:46.220
But for, for so many years, the company has really leaned into, uh, pride and rainbows and
00:22:55.120
And they, they really did that because they figured this is great marketing and we make money
00:22:59.160
All the other stuff, the, those are just, that, that's all, uh, peripheral.
00:23:08.320
So what these companies are now discovering is that, uh, it's not that simple.
00:23:18.140
This is not necessarily, this is not going to be a simple thing where you just throw the
00:23:21.400
rainbows all over the place and, um, it's a, it's a good, good marketing opportunity
00:23:33.320
Like there's a real cost when you decide to go that direction as a brand and there's
00:23:40.500
That's the message that these companies and these brands have now absorbed.
00:23:44.620
And they're now, they're looking at Target and they're looking at Bud Light and they're
00:23:48.340
realizing that, okay, if we do this, there's a risk.
00:23:55.840
Does that mean they're all going to stop doing it?
00:23:59.600
But they understand that there is a risk and, uh, that is a significant victory for the
00:24:08.420
I mean, it's, it actually is hard to overstate what a victory it actually is.
00:24:12.840
Um, and there's no reason to relent, no reason to let up.
00:24:23.820
Republican Representative Max Miller faced backlash this week from across the spectrum,
00:24:27.800
uh, on the political right after criticizing a woman's social media post in which she professed
00:24:34.800
The woman Republican activist Lizzie Marbach wrote on X, otherwise known as Twitter, there's
00:24:43.020
no hope for any of us outside of having faith in Jesus Christ alone.
00:24:46.020
Miller responded, this is one of the most bigoted tweets I've ever seen.
00:24:52.140
Religious freedom in the United States applies to every religion.
00:24:57.680
Now, Miller was widely criticized over the tweet from virtually every corner of the Republican
00:25:00.760
party and across the conservative political spectrum.
00:25:03.500
Daily Wire podcast host Matt Walsh said, do your constituents know you consider basic
00:25:10.620
Pro-Trump political commentator Jack Posobiec, uh, posted real talk.
00:25:14.140
You're a sitting GOP congressman, yet have zero tweets about Fannie Willis and the corrupt
00:25:17.680
prosecution of the GOP frontrunner, but instead decided to take the time today to launch an
00:25:22.000
attack on a pro-life staffer from pressing her faith.
00:25:29.540
And then Miller later apologized for the tweet after facing pushback and writing, quote,
00:25:33.400
I posted something earlier that conveyed a message I did not intend.
00:25:36.500
I will not try to hide my mistake or run from it.
00:25:38.780
I sincerely apologize to Lizzie and to everyone who read my post.
00:25:43.640
So Miller apologized, but quite, which was quite predictable.
00:25:48.300
But even so, this is, this is remarkable to me because it might honestly be the greatest
00:25:54.380
unforced error in, in the history of modern American politics.
00:26:00.080
I can't really think it might not be the most consequential one because this is just some
00:26:04.680
representative from Ohio, but I can't think of a more egregious example.
00:26:08.780
You're, you're a Republican congressman from Ohio and you go out of your way to post this
00:26:15.080
response to someone professing the Christian faith, calling them a bigot.
00:26:19.480
Now, keep in mind, this was not, this was not like in the heat of the moment.
00:26:24.760
The original tweet he was responding to wasn't even directed at Miller in any way.
00:26:30.140
He just saw it and decided it was a good opportunity to let everyone know that the Christian
00:26:35.640
You know, when you're on Twitter, especially if you're a public figure, a politician, and
00:26:40.680
you decide to do the quote tweet, there's like thought behind that.
00:26:43.480
You're thinking, well, I want to, because it's, you're not even just responding.
00:26:47.880
You're saying, I want to respond to this in a way that everyone can see.
00:26:57.540
I want to call Christians, all Christians bigots, and I want everyone to see me doing
00:27:06.520
And then all the Christian Republicans said, no, we don't love it, actually.
00:27:12.660
And then he immediately back, oh, oh, you don't want it.
00:27:15.960
You don't want me to slander the entire Christian faith as bigoted.
00:27:27.520
And that's part of the problem is that, is that Miller, yeah, he apologized, but given
00:27:31.060
that this was not something shouted in an argument in a moment of anger or whatever, given that
00:27:36.000
this was a, this was, this was a posted, this was an unsolicited, unprovoked post on
00:27:41.160
Twitter, it does reveal what he actually thinks, which is that a basic statement of Christian
00:27:47.540
So you can apologize for it, but you said it for a reason.
00:27:54.760
Because by the way, what Lizzie Marbach posted is, is just basic Christianity.
00:28:00.820
If you don't think it, you're not a Christian because that's the faith, you know, and there's
00:28:06.780
I mean, I also, I never understand that either.
00:28:09.240
People get offended when someone professes their religion and says, I believe my religion is
00:28:13.980
Well, of course you think that if, if a Mormon announces that the only true faith is Mormonism
00:28:20.000
and it's the only way to get to heaven, uh, that doesn't offend me.
00:28:23.600
I don't agree with it because I'm not Mormon, but like, I know that you feel that way.
00:28:28.900
If you weren't Mormon, then, you know, if you didn't feel that way, you wouldn't be Mormon.
00:28:34.420
It doesn't make any sense to say, well, like, what's the alternative?
00:28:36.700
The alternative is to say, Hey, I'm this religion and I believe this, but if you believe something
00:28:41.060
else that's also valid and true and everyone is right now, I know that there are some Christians
00:28:45.220
who want to be, uh, like pluralistic and ecumenical and universalist or whatever, who will say stuff
00:28:55.320
The Christian faith makes certain claims about the world and those claims are either right
00:29:01.860
If they're right, then every other religion is wrong.
00:29:05.240
You know, and that means if you're a Hindu, you're wrong.
00:29:11.020
You might not be wrong about everything you think, but you're wrong fundamentally about
00:29:15.820
If the Christian faith is true, that's the logical conclusion.
00:29:19.100
So that's what every Christian believes because it logically follows.
00:29:25.820
Um, and it makes no sense to be offended by it.
00:29:29.980
And in fact, to be offended by an authentic expression of Christian faith is then itself
00:29:36.900
You're saying that the Christian faith is somehow objectionable and should not be expressed publicly.
00:29:42.460
So you are revealing bigotry against Christians.
00:29:45.200
And that's what this representative did, which is bad, of course, for a lot of reasons, but
00:29:49.960
it's also just politically insane for a Republican in Ohio.
00:30:01.260
Ben Shapiro has been trending this week and, uh, I have too, actually.
00:30:05.440
So we're, we're always sort of competing to see who can have the most people yelling at
00:30:10.200
And for a while, I feel like I was ahead and then Ben had a great run with the Barbie stuff
00:30:14.900
And then, uh, and then I was trying to claw my way back, uh, and it's been back and forth,
00:30:19.200
but now Ben is trending partly because of, of this video that will play for you.
00:30:24.240
And this is a video from, uh, about 10 years ago.
00:30:26.220
And it shows, we're told by all the left leftists on Twitter that, that Ben is a hypocrite and
00:30:32.680
a grifter, grifter, because apparently in 2014, Ben said that he thinks presidents should
00:30:42.340
And yet he does not agree with the Democrats indicting Trump every three and a half days.
00:30:52.520
I'm not sure we can indict Washington, but I think that, uh, certainly I'm sure something
00:30:58.240
Uh, Washington was relatively clean, but if, but if you look at, you know, George W. Bush,
00:31:02.100
or if you looked at Bill Clinton, or if you looked at Ronald Reagan, sure.
00:31:05.380
I mean, the answer would be that, that you could, and people should be wary.
00:31:08.660
I mean, this is, this is sort of the case that I'm making is that we've become so comfortable
00:31:12.340
with the executive branch of the government abusing its citizens and violating our rights and
00:31:17.060
violating what they're structured to do under the law that we've just become used to it.
00:31:21.560
And if we start treating them as criminals, maybe they'll think twice before they act
00:31:32.460
That's the great grift that everyone in the Daily Wire, except for me, participates in.
00:31:35.760
Uh, but not for that, because three things, and I think this is important because a few
00:31:40.540
First of all, and these are stunning revelations.
00:31:43.280
So the first point is this, not all situations are the same as every other situation, you
00:31:53.400
So it doesn't, so you could have a situation that is one thing, and then you have another
00:31:57.800
situation that's not the same thing as that situation.
00:32:00.780
And so people will respond to the, this one situation a certain way, and then another situation
00:32:07.500
It doesn't make any sense to say, well, why aren't you responding to those situations exactly
00:32:10.160
the same, well, because they're not the same, because they're different.
00:32:14.720
So the situation where Democrats are targeting their political rival with phony charges to
00:32:20.520
stop them from getting reelected is a situation that did not exist in 2014.
00:32:25.120
So Ben has a different view about this specific situation that he didn't have back before this
00:32:32.140
I'm saying the word situation so much, it's starting to lose all meaning in my head, as
00:32:36.520
Now, second, related, circumstances also change.
00:32:41.200
So Ben in 2014 was talking about having a very strict kind of approach to politicians and
00:32:47.140
presidents, treating them like criminals if they crossed the line.
00:32:50.120
But then, of course, Obama was never prosecuted for his corruption.
00:32:54.480
So obviously, what was being advocated in that video 10 years ago was not adopted.
00:33:01.740
So he's not, therefore, going to be in favor of Trump's indictment, because this is clearly
00:33:05.640
not the kind of scenario that Ben was talking about.
00:33:07.740
In fact, you know, I've said something similar recently.
00:33:10.360
I've said that the only way I could possibly support some of these charges against Trump
00:33:17.060
is if we lived in a country that was so hostile towards politicians, so skeptical of them,
00:33:24.820
so ruthless towards them, that we took, we looked for any reason to indict any of them
00:33:33.000
Like, if we lived in a country where there are hundreds of politicians in prison right
00:33:37.480
now because we're just looking for any reason to throw them behind bars, if we were in the
00:33:42.560
kind of country that is constantly throwing ex-presidents in jail, if we lived in my fantasy
00:33:49.500
land where politicians are treated like whores with contempt and scorn, then at least the
00:33:56.500
treatment of Trump would fall right into that, and it would be consistent.
00:34:02.400
That would make all the charges correct, but at least it's like, okay, well, they're going
00:34:05.820
after Trump because that's what we do with all politicians.
00:34:07.880
He's a politician, and this is what you get, because we hate you all.
00:34:15.140
That is not even close to the country we actually live in.
00:34:19.160
In fact, every politician, at least every Democrat, is let off the hook for everything
00:34:24.220
they do, while Trump specifically is indicted every time he double dips a tortilla chip in
00:34:31.840
a bowl of salsa, which is a bad example because I actually would support people getting indicted
00:34:39.600
Anything he does, they get indicted, and also for things he didn't do, he gets indicted
00:34:42.840
So we are not holding our politicians to a high standard.
00:34:46.400
We are holding Democrats to no standard while Trump is persecuted for political reasons.
00:34:56.340
And the third point is that, in general, people are allowed to change their minds.
00:34:59.680
And I know this is like a mind-blowing thing to people these days.
00:35:02.240
We can go back, you know, because we live in the modern age, which means that you can always
00:35:07.020
go back, and there's a paper trail, especially for someone who's been in the public eye, but even
00:35:10.980
if they haven't, there's a paper trail, there's a digital paper trail of like every opinion
00:35:18.320
And so you can go back and you can sift through, it was like, what did they say 10 years ago?
00:35:22.940
So Ben, actually, I don't think what he's saying here is inconsistent at all.
00:35:28.020
But the implication is that there was, and even if there was, like, so what?
00:35:33.180
So this is stupid game we play, where someone says something, and then you pull up something
00:35:40.200
they said 10 years ago and say, well, this you?
00:35:51.100
Have you held the exact same views on every topic without change your whole life?
00:36:01.760
Like, if you have, then I guess you're in a position where you can throw stones at people
00:36:06.160
But actually, that just makes you an absolute, that makes you, you're not even conscious.
00:36:09.580
You're like a, you're an inanimate object in that, and you don't even, you're barely sentient
00:36:14.620
if you're not changing your views on things and adapting and, you know, and changing the
00:36:20.700
That's like, that's a natural part of the process of, like, growing and being a conscious
00:36:26.180
So if you haven't changed any of your views at all, then that just makes me suspect that
00:36:39.940
And it's a game that's played totally inconsistently.
00:36:50.780
We've got one other thing here from the LA Times.
00:36:57.280
Not really interesting at all, but we're going to talk about it.
00:36:59.740
Fast and Furious star Tyrese Gibson is taking Home Depot to court, accusing the home improvement
00:37:10.840
He was discriminated against and racially profiled at a Home Depot.
00:37:14.500
And the moment you think, you hear that, you might think like at a Home Depot, discrimination
00:37:23.780
That usually, I mean, any Home Depot I've been to, pretty, pretty diverse.
00:37:27.200
So just not exactly what you would expect to encounter that kind of thing.
00:37:34.220
And it gets even more surprising when you realize that the other two people who are discriminated
00:37:39.620
against, allegedly, one of them's name is Eric Mora, and the other one is Manuel Hernandez.
00:37:44.940
So we're supposed to believe that Hispanic people are being discriminated against at Home Depot,
00:37:57.220
So the core of the lawsuit is a February 11th incident in which Home Depot clerks allegedly
00:38:01.080
purposely interfered with and refused to process a transaction by Gibson, Mora, and Hernandez
00:38:07.720
based on their skin color and the craftsman's national origin.
00:38:15.660
Gibson went in with these two Mexican guys, and he tried to buy some stuff.
00:38:20.580
And apparently, based on what I'm reading so far, he was told by the store clerk, he
00:38:26.160
was told by the cashier, oh, we can't process this.
00:38:44.520
According to legal documents, Gibson and his two associates were purchasing items for a
00:38:47.600
home improvement project, but the checkout process took longer due to a glitch in the
00:38:52.780
While an unidentified employee was re-scanning the items, fans began to notice Gibson, who
00:38:56.760
stepped out of the store to avoid creating disturbance.
00:38:59.120
The lawsuit says that Gibson informed the employee that Mora and Hernandez would complete the purchase
00:39:06.220
The cashier acknowledged Gibson and said he understood.
00:39:08.660
The lawsuit says Gibson asked the cashier if the cashier needed anything further from him
00:39:13.560
The cashier said no and that Gibson could leave.
00:39:16.020
After Gibson left, the cashier refused to complete the transaction with Mora and Hernandez,
00:39:19.600
despite Gibson again authorizing the transaction via FaceTime video calls, the document says.
00:39:24.620
Gibson returned to the store and completed the transaction only after heated discussions with
00:39:28.360
The actor also asked to speak to the store's manager, who allegedly refused to speak with Gibson
00:39:34.520
The lawsuit says, quote, this is a clear and deplorable instance of discriminatory mistreatment
00:39:40.880
The treatment of Gibson, Mora, and Hernandez by the Home Depot was humiliating and demeaning.
00:39:50.300
He wanted to step out of the store and still have the thing processed.
00:39:54.660
And the cashier originally, according to him, the cashier originally said, yeah, you can do that.
00:39:58.740
But then he left and the cashier said, actually, I can't process it unless he's here.
00:40:04.960
And from that, they're extrapolating that Home Depot is discriminating against blacks and
00:40:13.240
Which, by the way, if Home Depot were to refuse to provide service to Hispanic people, they
00:40:25.800
It's like saying that Cinnabon is discriminating against obese people.
00:40:28.740
Like that's your whole, that's most of your clientele.
00:40:36.700
This is a good example of the racism framework that I'm always talking about, where if you
00:40:43.420
have the left's racism framework and you're black or you're in an approved victim group,
00:40:50.300
then every mild inconvenience will be understood based on it.
00:40:54.640
So it's more of a lens, I suppose, than a framework.
00:40:57.500
Framework makes it sound more intellectual than it really is.
00:41:02.540
And this is the lens through which they view the world.
00:41:05.280
And the lens says that you're blacks, you're a victim.
00:41:09.320
Everyone automatically is racist against you because you're black.
00:41:11.500
And so therefore, it's just anything that happens to you that you don't like is because of racism.
00:41:17.680
Nobody needs to say anything that indicates it or anything like that.
00:41:27.140
And that is as complex as the equation gets if you're looking through the racism lens, which also makes it—the more that you keep these glasses on, the more that you look at the world through this lens, it's like the more detached from reality you become, where you lose any grip on just like human nature.
00:42:00.480
Because those of us who are not wearing those lenses, we hear a story like this and we think, like, yeah, that's how it goes at these places.
00:42:07.140
You go in and, you know, you're told one thing by one customer service guy and then it doesn't work.
00:42:14.460
And then you want to talk to a manager and the manager is like, this is just—this is how it goes.
00:42:18.620
Or if there—if you go to one of these places and there's like a slight wrinkle, there's a slight complication, you want to do something that's like a little bit outside of the norm.
00:42:29.720
And in this case, he wants to process the transaction while he walks outside.
00:42:36.020
And mostly because you're dealing with a, you know, a cashier who's like a 17-year-old kid who has no idea what's going on and doesn't care.
00:42:45.460
And no one is really invested in what they're doing.
00:42:54.060
And if you don't have the racism lenses on, then you just understand that, okay, yeah, that's life.
00:43:04.980
But, of course, if you see it that way, then you can't make your—what is he going for?
00:43:10.340
You know, Tyrese Gibson, he's a star of Fast and Furious, which is a franchise that somehow has made, you know, $75 trillion at the box office.
00:43:17.300
He needs another million from Home Depot to assuage his deep emotional suffering, of course.
00:43:24.060
If you're a man, it's required that you grow up in hay with a sweet baby gang.
00:43:33.300
The second annual Daily Wire Fantasy Football Draft Party is coming up soon.
00:43:38.140
And this year, we're going to give you the opportunity to enter to be the 10th member in our league.
00:43:42.260
If you win, you'll participate with us during the live draft and go head-to-head with your favorite Daily Wire hosts throughout the fantasy football season.
00:43:49.040
To enter, go to Crane & Company's YouTube page and subscribe to their channel.
00:43:52.360
Then, like the Daily Wire Fantasy Football Sweepstakes video, comment your fantasy football team name, and fill out the Google form on the pinned comment.
00:43:59.920
Don't miss your chance to play fantasy football in your favorite host league and compete for the ultimate bragging rights and the coveted golden tumbler.
00:44:06.580
The sweepstakes are open now, but they close on August 19th at 11.59 p.m. Eastern Time.
00:44:12.380
Brian says, I think as a man, you just have to deal with a degree of loneliness, and I feel like you have to learn how to cope or accept that and turn it into an advantage.
00:44:22.580
Yeah, well, I think that's the case for humans in general, not just men, but it is an important point.
00:44:27.720
And you're right that that's part of the story that isn't discussed.
00:44:35.340
Also, yes, a certain amount of loneliness comes with being a human being, and you have to know how to cope with that.
00:44:43.240
So part of the problem, I think, is an inability to cope with loneliness.
00:44:46.580
It's not just that people are lonely, but also that people don't know how to deal with being lonely.
00:44:53.400
I say the same thing about, for example, what we're told is the bullying epidemic in schools.
00:45:00.820
That kids are being bullied all the time, and that's certainly one where I don't think there's any evidence that it's worse than at any other point in history.
00:45:09.940
And so with that, is it an issue of kids being bullied too much, and that there's too much bullying, and it's an epidemic?
00:45:14.340
Or, I mean, yeah, bullying is bad, and it shouldn't happen.
00:45:18.240
But also, there's something going on where we are not raising our kids to know how to deal with being bullied, to know how to cope with it.
00:45:26.140
So I think it's a similar thing here, because there's a certain rather profound isolation that I think is just inherent to the human condition.
00:45:39.120
Like the fact that you are an individual living in the world with your own mind, and that no other individual shares your mind or your conscious experience of the world, that very fact is, by definition, isolating.
00:45:51.620
So we are all in that sense, in the sense of being distinct individuals.
00:45:57.960
We're sort of isolated to some extent just by the nature of being human.
00:46:03.980
And so there's this kind of like baseline loneliness that's called being human, and you have to know how to deal with that.
00:46:17.820
Yeah, me and my brother-in-law, in fact, do exactly that.
00:46:34.420
We go fishing together in different kayaks, in different parts of the lake.
00:46:37.940
And also, by the way, it's not like men never talk to each other.
00:46:44.940
But we also talk about different things, and we relate in different ways.
00:46:48.780
So another recent example, this time my brother, brother-in-law, I talked to him recently a few days ago.
00:46:56.880
Well, and afterwards, it was the same thing, where my wife was asking me,
00:47:02.920
Like, ask me all these questions, like, what's going on in his life?
00:47:12.940
Well, the truth is that one of the things we talked about was whether Captain Bly or Ernest Shackleton
00:47:18.560
had the more impressive sea voyage after being stranded.
00:47:24.240
We didn't really get into, what's going on at work?
00:47:31.760
And to me, it's like unimaginable that my wife would spend any time talking with anyone in her life
00:47:43.960
And it certainly would not be the first thing she brings up after talking to a family member
00:47:54.240
Goldie says, from my personal experience, the best advice to lonely, depressed men is
00:48:06.340
Other men, toys such as motorcycles, boats, et cetera, are highly recommended.
00:48:10.280
The secret to happy life is to play, play, and play again.
00:48:13.180
I have to disagree fundamentally with so much of that.
00:48:16.200
And I would definitely say, no, do not try to assuage your loneliness by buying expensive things.
00:48:25.820
And also, you're adding bills, and you're adding financial hardship and strain.
00:48:31.140
And that's ultimately not going to make you feel any better.
00:48:37.340
I don't know about buying, just like buying things to buy them.
00:48:40.180
And I also think that that's also a more feminine way.
00:48:46.800
Like, that's what women are going to be more inclined to do, to deal with stress or whatever
00:48:59.200
You know, it's not a, it's not the primary thing, but when we're talking about the overall
00:49:04.580
issue of male loneliness and feeling directionless, not having a purpose, part of the story is
00:49:10.680
also that, yes, men don't have the same fellowship.
00:49:14.540
We don't have the same opportunities for fellowship and for all that, and to kind of go somewhere
00:49:18.340
And, and also, I think men don't have hobbies, you know, like they used to.
00:49:26.140
I think there are a lot of, a lot of men that you meet that just have like no hobbies at
00:49:35.380
They watch TV, they're on their phone, and that's kind of, everything is screen-based.
00:49:43.320
Um, but it's a bigger problem for men because we need, you, you, you just, you can't live
00:49:50.720
You need to have something that you like to do.
00:49:55.860
Um, I think all men have this, but you have to activate it, but we all, we all have this
00:50:03.620
And it could be a, just a random hobby that we, that we'd suddenly care about for reasons
00:50:13.720
I think it's really important to have something.
00:50:19.380
This is from Jay Gould says, male competition is not what's ever made me lonely or anxious.
00:50:24.120
Dealing with modern women in society does though.
00:50:26.860
I feel emotional, emotionally abused by trying to engage with modern women and that I can't
00:50:32.480
be myself for fear of attack, which is exhausting.
00:50:35.440
Making someone be something they aren't is exhausting and leads to mental anguish.
00:50:42.060
First, you're onto something when you say that women are a much greater source of stress
00:50:47.160
and anxiety, uh, for men than is competition with other men.
00:50:51.960
You know, as men competition in the male sense doesn't scare us.
00:50:58.600
And one of the many things that that, that Washington Post article was wrong about was
00:51:02.100
so dumb about it is they said that men are depressed because they're in constant competition
00:51:09.780
I mean, we literally invent dumb things to compete over.
00:51:16.000
That's why, that's why all, every sport was invented by men and it's, it exists simply
00:51:20.480
so we have a reason to compete with each other and to win something because we like to do
00:51:25.820
Um, we need that, you know, the, the interaction with pursuit of rejection by women.
00:51:33.380
On the other hand, that can be a real source of despair because it's requiring us to operate
00:51:37.460
in a gear that's not nearly so effortless or comfortable.
00:51:45.060
Competition in the masculine sense is something that I still pursue.
00:51:49.700
I'm a very competitive person, but the competition for female attention and affection, that's something
00:51:59.360
I mean, I can look back onto being in high school and playing high school sports and
00:52:04.380
I kind of missed, I missed that being, being involved in that real specific kind of competition,
00:52:09.520
organized sports, you know, men can look back and miss those days, but I don't look back
00:52:18.580
I have, I, I, I am so happy to be done with it.
00:52:21.640
Um, but leaving behind masculine competition in that sense, you never really, I mean, I'll
00:52:27.980
be 87 years old and competing with some dude at the nursing home over who can, I don't know,
00:52:37.880
So, I mean, you're onto something there and you're correct about that.
00:52:40.440
With that said, just to be real with you and to be blunt saying that you've been emotionally
00:52:48.340
abused by all modern women, I mean, this is the kind of self-pitying stuff that isn't
00:52:55.400
Um, honestly, as a man, you shouldn't even be saying the phrase emotionally abused in
00:53:00.860
Like your grandfather, I don't know who your grandfather was, but I can almost guarantee
00:53:05.220
he would have never in a million years accused anyone of emotionally abusing him, even if they
00:53:12.080
He never would have said it because your grandfather and his generation and all generations of men
00:53:16.780
before him, you know, right up until now, detested self-pity.
00:53:26.460
And we need to reclaim some of that attitude too.
00:53:29.700
So we can talk about the struggles that men face and it's very important to talk about.
00:53:34.040
The danger though, on one side of it is that is, is you lapse into this full-on really gross
00:53:46.780
And part of being a man is like, okay, you just cut that out.
00:53:56.080
It's, it's, you know, crying about it is not the way to handle it.
00:54:01.320
And once you've composed yourself, now we can have a real conversation about this.
00:54:05.740
Candace just wrapped the 10 part series, Convicting a Murderer that you don't want to miss.
00:54:11.600
You might think you're familiar with the Stephen Avery case and everything that happened in
00:54:16.720
This is especially true if you watched Making a Murderer, but it turns out the filmmakers only told you part of the story.
00:54:22.200
And coming soon, Candace Owens will unveil the shocking parts of Avery's story that were omitted in a Netflix series.
00:54:27.880
So excited to present the Convicting a Murderer trailer.
00:54:31.160
This is a collect call from an inmate at the Calumet County Jail.
00:54:36.620
The man served 18 years in prison until DNA evidence cleared his name.
00:54:40.240
The Two Rivers man was convicted of sexual assault in 1985, but exonerated with DNA evidence in 2003.
00:54:50.800
Now, two years later, he again finds himself tied to a police investigation.
00:54:56.460
Accused of murdering Teresa Hallbuck on the Avery property.
00:54:59.760
Stephen Avery's 16-year-old nephew admitted his involvement in the rape and murder of Teresa Hallbuck.
00:55:13.000
I think he intended to crush the vehicle, but ran out of time.
00:55:16.380
Avery thinks the $36 million lawsuit he filed is why he's being targeted in this investigation.
00:55:28.960
Netflix made millions of dollars from making a murderer, but the filmmakers left out very important details.
00:55:35.640
Mountains of evidence that you have not yet seen.
00:55:39.040
The most egregious manipulation from the movie.
00:55:42.720
That's when he started beating me because I told him that he's sick.
00:55:47.060
And I saw melted plastic parts of a cell phone.
00:56:12.200
I am not going to make the same mistake that the filmmakers did.
00:56:26.040
They all know that Stephen Avery committed this crime.
00:56:33.480
The evidence forces me to conclude that you are the most dangerous individual ever to set foot in this courtroom.
00:56:40.840
Well, to get the rest of the story, you have to watch Convicting a Murderer coming to you this September.
00:56:47.120
This 10-part series is exclusive to Daily Wire Plus.
00:56:49.320
So join now at dailywire.com slash subscribe to get 25% off your new annual membership.
00:56:54.460
So you can watch Convicting a Murderer when it premieres.
00:56:59.280
Today we'll deal with something that is so cancelable that there is almost no point in canceling it.
00:57:09.020
It's the kind of cancellation that will require very little thought or effort.
00:57:12.320
But sometimes you have to take a swing at the softballs that are lobbed right down the middle of the plate.
00:57:15.700
So that brings us to something posted on CNN.com this past weekend titled
00:57:23.060
This article written by a woman named Scotty Andrews, it's the kind of thing that eight or nine years ago
00:57:29.640
In fact, eight or nine years ago, if I had written this exact article as a satire of leftism,
00:57:34.100
almost everyone would agree that the satire is too outlandish and bizarre to really land.
00:57:45.140
Fast forward less than a decade and leftism has exceeded even the wildest fever dream of the satirist.
00:57:50.800
We now live in a world where something like this is written with all seriousness and sincerity
00:57:55.660
and published on one of the most trafficked news sites in the country.
00:58:05.820
Pronouns are part of speech we use to refer to ourselves and others.
00:58:09.060
They're an essential component of language and, as of the last few years,
00:58:24.180
What many of us contest, what we categorically deny, because it's insane,
00:58:28.080
is the idea that a man can or should use pronouns that actually apply to women or vice versa.
00:58:32.880
So the real issue is not the word, but the thing the word is supposed to represent.
00:58:37.360
In fact, it turns out that everyone still basically agrees that men are referred to as he and women as she.
00:58:44.520
That's why you rarely, if ever, hear anyone say,
00:58:53.300
Now, I'm sure eventually the left will get around to that kind of nonsense,
00:58:57.860
Everyone generally still agrees that she, her applies to women and he, him applies to men.
00:59:07.920
the second part of that sentence isn't really the problem,
00:59:16.200
If he was a woman, then I would certainly call him she.
00:59:19.000
He's correct that that is the pronoun that we should use for those who are women.
00:59:26.500
So this may seem like semantics, perhaps, but it's anything but.
00:59:29.640
The left likes to pretend that they're simply expanding our language,
00:59:32.960
that they're loosening the rules of grammar and so on.
00:59:34.940
But that is, that is not fundamentally the issue.
00:59:39.840
It's about the reality that the language is meant to represent.
00:59:45.940
they are insisting that we agree with the claim that the man is a woman.
00:59:50.400
They are, they are recruiting us, not into some looser conception of language,
00:59:57.000
The point is that for, for the most part, the left still abides by what they pretend to decry
01:00:08.520
They still believe that men are called he and women are called she,
01:00:11.020
but they also believe or pretend to believe that a man is a woman if he claims to be one.
01:00:16.500
But then, of course, they're all, we get to these so-called neo-pronouns,
01:00:19.340
and this is where things really do dissolve into pure gibberish.
01:00:27.000
Gender-neutral or non-binary pronouns that are distinct from the common she, he, and they.
01:00:34.560
and some of them even date back several centuries,
01:00:36.920
when they were introduced by writers as a solution for referring to subjects without assuming gender.
01:00:41.040
Now they're also commonly used by non-binary and trans people.
01:00:44.320
All pronouns indicate identity and can be used to include or exclude people they describe,
01:00:51.080
one of the foremost experts on neo-pronouns and their histories
01:00:53.940
and an emeritus professor of English and linguistics at the University of Illinois at Urbana-Champaign.
01:00:59.500
Neo-pronouns should be used and respected like any other pronoun, he told CNN.
01:01:03.700
People like to have a say in how they're identified, Barron said.
01:01:06.800
Refusing to let people self-identify is a way of excluding them.
01:01:16.580
because nobody is interfering with anyone else's ability to self-identify.
01:01:20.960
You can perceive yourself however you want to perceive yourself.
01:01:23.260
There's no possible way for me to control your self-perception of yourself, even if I wanted to.
01:01:33.700
and letting people decide how they are identified.
01:01:36.740
Okay, the latter has nothing to do with the former.
01:01:49.920
It's like, that's your, I can't stop you from thinking that.
01:01:54.080
That thought process and perception is wildly wrong,
01:01:57.420
but you're free to see yourself in a wildly wrong way.
01:02:03.660
The latter, however, how you are identified is someone else's perception.
01:02:14.220
They identify you according to their perception of you.
01:02:18.920
And just as they can't control your perception of yourself,
01:02:25.300
Now, we haven't even really gotten into the meat of the neopronoun discussion
01:02:28.040
because I keep running into incredibly stupid statements in need of correction.
01:02:32.220
Neopronouns, meanwhile, are less commonly used than those three familiar pronouns.
01:02:38.240
They're often used by non-binary, trans, and gender non-conforming people
01:02:46.840
expand the ways that people are able to indicate their gender identity
01:02:49.860
to encompass anyone who is trans or non-binary,
01:02:52.320
as well as those who choose an altogether different term to categorize,
01:02:57.400
Other neopronouns are completely original to their user.
01:02:59.620
Some may choose to select a noun to describe themselves like star or star-self
01:03:04.020
in place of binary pronouns like she or herself.
01:03:13.060
And if you prefer a more technical term, that's it.
01:03:16.340
But I'm going to skip around from here a little bit
01:03:18.360
because there's only so much of this we can take.
01:03:20.240
Eventually, we're given a handy guide on how to use this gibberish,
01:03:30.780
The teacher graded Zer paper today, and Zay got an A.
01:03:34.960
Faye told me that Fair best friend is in town this week.
01:03:40.640
A wants to bring Air camera to capture the garden for M-self.
01:03:44.040
I hope Leif knows how proud we are that Leif is getting to know Leif's self better.
01:03:51.100
You know, this reminds me of one of my kids' favorite Dr. Seuss books.
01:04:00.160
because Dr. Seuss also enjoyed making up silly words off the top of his head.
01:04:03.500
The only difference is that he didn't expect us to take it seriously,
01:04:07.380
When they talk about pronouns, it sounds like something Dr. Seuss might have come up with
01:04:10.200
if he had green hair and nose piercing and, you know, was high on crack.
01:04:15.320
But perhaps the most revealing part of this article comes from the one single example
01:04:18.760
the author can find of an actual human being using neo-pronouns.
01:04:25.720
Dua Saleh, a musician and actor who's appeared on the Netflix hit series Sex Education,
01:04:33.640
Dua Saleh told their social media followers in 2020 after Z started to use Z pronouns
01:04:41.480
that it's, quote, really affirming to find the pronouns that are right for you.
01:04:45.460
I just like the neo-pronouns, Saleh told Complex in 2022.
01:04:53.020
There's an element where I'm just like, oh, that sounds really nice.
01:04:55.980
Or it sounds nice coming out of my mouth or hearing other people say it.
01:05:01.120
You might have been wondering, how in the hell can someone identify as Xerh?
01:05:09.660
Like, how does one come to the conclusion that they are a Xerh?
01:05:19.900
Xerh and Z and the other pronouns are, as you suspected, just a bunch of nonsensical drivel.
01:05:27.220
They aren't even making a false claim about reality as a man does when he says that he identifies as a she.
01:05:37.060
Like, when someone says, I'm a Xerh, that is a claim so nonsensical that you can't even say it's false.
01:05:44.300
Because to say it's false is to say that there's, like, some coherent statement that's being made that doesn't reflect reality.
01:06:03.460
So, when someone identifies this way, it's because, as Dua Saleh says, they like the way it sounds.
01:06:15.440
Now, you might be thinking, isn't it pure insanity to assign gibberish to other people that they have to say simply because you think it sounds nice?
01:06:31.820
It is narcissism so pure, so potent, that it seems like insanity.
01:06:37.560
This is how utterly and entirely self-obsessed and high on their own fumes the left has become.
01:06:43.120
They've reached a level of self-absorption that is indistinguishable from psychosis.
01:06:50.560
It's the moment when selfish crosses over into psychotic.
01:06:59.640
They might not be clinically insane, but they are so egotistical that they might as well be.
01:07:08.500
And that is why neopronouns are today canceled.