The Matt Walsh Show - November 18, 2025


Ep. 1693 - The Tick That Makes People Allergic To Meat Is Real & The Climate Cult Wants To Breed Trillions More


Episode Stats

Length

1 hour and 10 minutes

Words per Minute

171.13623

Word Count

12,076

Sentence Count

290

Misogynist Sentences

9

Hate Speech Sentences

18


Summary

A 47-year-old airline pilot becomes the first person to die from an allergy to meat in the history of the world, after eating a piece of beef. Also, a man in Michigan is facing charges for shooting a burglar who broke into his garage, the movie industry is suffering through what may go down as its worst year ever, and Big Tech has come up with a new way to monetize grief.


Transcript

00:00:00.920 At Desjardins, we speak business.
00:00:03.860 We speak equipment modernization.
00:00:06.020 We're fluent in data digitization and expansion into foreign markets.
00:00:09.940 And we can talk all day about streamlining manufacturing processes.
00:00:14.240 Because at Desjardins Business, we speak the same language you do.
00:00:17.940 Business.
00:00:18.720 So join the more than 400,000 Canadian entrepreneurs who already count on us.
00:00:23.440 And contact Desjardins today.
00:00:25.520 We'd love to talk business.
00:00:30.000 It's not just you.
00:00:33.100 News is moving faster than ever.
00:00:35.280 And I'm hoping that I can help you make sense of it all.
00:00:38.040 My name is Jamie Poisson and I host Canada's most popular daily news podcast.
00:00:42.400 It's called FrontBurner.
00:00:43.640 We break down one story each day and talk to the reporters, the politicians, and people at the heart of it.
00:00:49.260 Our goal is to help you stay informed without feeling overwhelmed.
00:00:53.060 You can find and follow FrontBurner on Spotify.
00:01:00.000 Today on the Matt Wall Show, so-called public health authorities want us to stop eating meat to save the planet.
00:01:05.240 Some of them have even said that we should be involuntarily infected with something that makes us allergic to meat.
00:01:09.800 And now, what do you know, lots of people are contracting an allergy to meat.
00:01:13.480 You don't have to be a conspiracy theorist to wonder about this.
00:01:16.280 We'll tell you what we know, what we don't about all this today.
00:01:19.400 Also, a man in Michigan is facing charges for shooting a burglar who broke into his garage.
00:01:24.620 The movie industry is suffering through what may go down as its worst year ever.
00:01:28.060 However, is this the end of Hollywood?
00:01:30.280 And if so, should we be happy about that?
00:01:32.100 And big tech has come up with a new way to monetize grief.
00:01:34.880 They're now resurrecting your dead relatives with AI.
00:01:38.680 What could go wrong besides everything?
00:01:40.680 All of that and more today on the Matt Wall Show.
00:01:42.320 Launching your own business is pretty much on everyone's bucket list,
00:02:11.300 but most people don't actually take the time to pursue it.
00:02:14.060 Stop making excuses like, I don't have the skills or I can't do it alone.
00:02:17.380 Take some action today and get started with Shopify.
00:02:19.720 They've got the tools you just need to take the chance.
00:02:23.860 Shopify is the commerce platform used by millions of businesses around the world.
00:02:27.480 We even use it for our own Daily Wire shop to make sure things are running smoothly and efficiently.
00:02:32.240 It makes our lives easier and it keeps our customers happy.
00:02:35.340 You might be thinking that you don't know how to design a website
00:02:37.580 or you might be worried about how people will learn about your brand,
00:02:40.860 but that's not a problem.
00:02:41.720 Shopify has got you covered from the start.
00:02:43.520 We've got beautiful, ready-to-go templates that match your brand style.
00:02:46.400 We even help find your customers through easy-to-run email and social media campaigns.
00:02:50.740 And if you need a hand with everyday tasks,
00:02:53.440 their AI tools created specifically for commerce can help enhance product images,
00:02:57.320 write descriptions, and more.
00:02:58.380 Plus, their award-winning customer support is available 24-7.
00:03:01.380 To share advice, if you ever get stuck, turn those dreams into...
00:03:03.580 And give yourself the best shot at success with Shopify.
00:03:08.440 Sign up for your $1 per month trial.
00:03:10.820 Start selling today at shopify.com slash Walsh.
00:03:12.920 Go to shopify.com slash Walsh.
00:03:14.660 Shopify.com slash Walsh.
00:03:17.700 In the summer of 2024, a 47-year-old airline pilot from New Jersey
00:03:22.120 was camping with his wife and children.
00:03:24.540 After eating a beef steak for dinner,
00:03:27.280 he awoke in the middle of the night with stomach pains,
00:03:29.180 along with other symptoms including vomiting and diarrhea.
00:03:31.880 In the end, his symptoms cleared up.
00:03:33.960 And he decided against going to a doctor,
00:03:35.780 even though earlier in the summer,
00:03:37.380 he had told his wife about the presence of 12 tick bites on his ankles.
00:03:41.080 And whatever those ticks had done,
00:03:43.180 the airline pilot concluded,
00:03:45.480 it probably wasn't life-threatening.
00:03:47.780 And then, just two weeks later,
00:03:49.100 the man attended a barbecue with his wife,
00:03:51.080 where he ate a hamburger,
00:03:51.980 and within four hours,
00:03:53.420 he was unconscious on the floor of his bathroom.
00:03:55.720 Paramedics tried to revive him,
00:03:57.300 but it was too late.
00:03:58.520 He was dead.
00:03:59.840 Now, initially, the death was recorded as unexplained,
00:04:02.180 but the man's doctor wasn't happy with that explanation,
00:04:05.340 so he sent his blood work to an allergy specialist
00:04:07.660 who quickly identified the cause.
00:04:09.920 The airline pilot had contracted a tick-borne meat allergy
00:04:12.520 known as alpha-gal syndrome, or AGS,
00:04:15.940 which, until this particular case,
00:04:17.760 was not considered fatal.
00:04:19.440 In fact, you'll find plenty of scientific journal articles
00:04:22.060 referring to AGS as a non-fatal allergy,
00:04:24.900 but this 47-year-old airline pilot,
00:04:26.660 for the first time in record history,
00:04:28.180 had proven otherwise.
00:04:30.120 He became the first reported fatality of AGS
00:04:33.680 anywhere in the world.
00:04:35.400 Watch.
00:04:36.900 This allergy to meat, including beef, lamb, and pork,
00:04:40.400 tonight is linked to its first death.
00:04:42.860 A 47-year-old New Jersey man ate a burger in 2024
00:04:46.340 and died four hours later.
00:04:49.180 Two weeks earlier, he got sick after eating a steak.
00:04:52.540 It really illustrates the need for education
00:04:55.720 because when he had the very severe episode
00:04:59.280 of abdominal pain,
00:05:00.920 they had no sense that that could be anaphylaxis.
00:05:04.320 University of Virginia's Dr. Thomas Platts Mills
00:05:07.400 identified the death and the allergy behind it.
00:05:11.080 It's called alpha-gal syndrome.
00:05:13.620 It usually starts with a bite from a lone star tick
00:05:16.380 that sensitizes a person's immune system
00:05:19.080 to a sugar molecule found in the meat of mammals
00:05:21.920 called alpha-gal.
00:05:23.620 Reactions can include hives, nausea,
00:05:26.280 and life-threatening anaphylaxis.
00:05:29.000 Debbie Nickel lives with alpha-gal.
00:05:31.660 I would wake up in the middle of the night
00:05:32.900 with this extraordinary stomach pain.
00:05:35.100 One of 450,000 Americans
00:05:37.320 with the tick-induced meat allergy.
00:05:39.760 From the time of onset to my diagnosis in 2019,
00:05:43.020 it was probably 11 or 12 years.
00:05:45.020 And your doctor even went so far
00:05:47.020 as to remove your gallbladder?
00:05:49.040 That's correct.
00:05:49.780 So as you heard,
00:05:52.760 hundreds of thousands of people
00:05:53.880 are suffering from AGS,
00:05:55.260 otherwise known as the red meat allergy.
00:05:57.620 None of these hundreds of thousands of people
00:05:59.040 have died as a result of this allergy,
00:06:00.760 although they've had serious complications.
00:06:02.280 So a lot of important questions
00:06:03.680 need to be answered at this point,
00:06:05.580 starting with,
00:06:06.700 what, if anything,
00:06:07.660 was different about this particular victim?
00:06:10.020 How many more victims might be out there
00:06:11.920 who haven't been diagnosed
00:06:12.980 through a post-mortem allergy test?
00:06:15.760 In other words,
00:06:16.240 is he the only person who has died from it?
00:06:19.240 And maybe most importantly,
00:06:20.160 what exactly is AGS
00:06:21.160 and where did it come from?
00:06:23.220 Now, these are questions
00:06:24.000 that most medical professionals
00:06:25.340 can't begin to answer.
00:06:26.500 In surveys,
00:06:27.220 a majority of doctors report
00:06:28.400 they have no idea
00:06:29.360 how to diagnose or treat the disorder.
00:06:32.700 And it's not surprising
00:06:33.540 because alpha-gal syndrome
00:06:34.400 was discovered just a few decades ago
00:06:36.120 during clinical trials
00:06:37.100 for a drug
00:06:37.700 that was intended to treat cancer.
00:06:39.100 So here's the story of that discovery
00:06:40.680 as I understand it anyway.
00:06:43.260 Some patients enrolled
00:06:44.920 in the clinical trial
00:06:45.940 took the cancer drug
00:06:47.500 and then developed hives
00:06:49.460 immediately after receiving
00:06:50.480 the first IV dose.
00:06:52.480 The patients had somehow
00:06:54.140 developed antibodies
00:06:55.060 to the drug
00:06:56.140 before they ever took it.
00:06:57.160 It turns out
00:06:57.620 that these particular patients
00:06:58.580 were from the same area
00:07:00.320 of the country
00:07:01.140 where the Lone Star Tick
00:07:02.380 is common,
00:07:03.060 mainly the East
00:07:03.720 and South Central United States.
00:07:05.520 On top of that,
00:07:07.100 the researchers realized
00:07:08.020 that the cancer drug,
00:07:08.840 because it was grown
00:07:09.460 in mouse cells,
00:07:10.760 contained a sugar molecule
00:07:11.980 called alpha-gal,
00:07:13.300 which the Lone Star Tick
00:07:14.500 transmits to humans.
00:07:15.620 So it appeared
00:07:16.140 as though patients
00:07:17.480 had been bitten by ticks,
00:07:19.460 developed a sensitivity
00:07:20.320 to the sugar molecule,
00:07:22.380 and then overdosed
00:07:23.560 when the sugar molecule
00:07:24.520 was administered via an IV.
00:07:26.680 So to be clear,
00:07:27.980 alpha-gal is not man-made.
00:07:30.060 It's sugar that exists
00:07:31.380 in the cells of most mammals
00:07:33.400 with the exception of humans.
00:07:35.900 When it enters our body,
00:07:37.200 our immune system
00:07:38.120 treats it like a foreign pathogen
00:07:40.060 and triggers
00:07:40.640 a serious overreaction.
00:07:43.140 But you might wonder,
00:07:44.740 if alpha-gal has been around
00:07:46.200 for, you know,
00:07:47.200 zillions of years,
00:07:48.600 why exactly did it take
00:07:49.800 so long for scientists
00:07:50.760 to realize that ticks
00:07:51.900 can cause a meat allergy
00:07:53.380 by transmitting alpha-gal?
00:07:56.720 Well, the official explanation
00:07:57.800 is that normally
00:07:58.700 when you have
00:07:59.300 an allergic reaction,
00:08:00.180 the symptoms appear
00:08:00.800 pretty quickly.
00:08:02.060 If it gets sung by a bee,
00:08:03.040 for example,
00:08:03.480 you'll be showing symptoms
00:08:04.360 within two hours maximum.
00:08:06.860 But with alpha-gal,
00:08:07.740 it's different.
00:08:08.100 The sugar is stored in fat.
00:08:09.460 It takes a while
00:08:10.060 to digest the fat.
00:08:11.240 So you might eat a hamburger,
00:08:12.640 have no obvious reaction,
00:08:14.380 and then die
00:08:15.560 four hours later.
00:08:17.640 And given that time frame,
00:08:19.620 nobody would suspect
00:08:20.760 an allergic reaction
00:08:21.660 to a hamburger.
00:08:23.180 And it wasn't until
00:08:23.820 this cancer trial
00:08:24.560 where the drug
00:08:25.600 was administered by an IV
00:08:26.660 that the link
00:08:27.920 between alpha-gal
00:08:28.740 and the allergic reaction
00:08:29.960 became obvious.
00:08:31.500 So that's the
00:08:32.300 official explanation.
00:08:35.120 I have no reason
00:08:35.880 to doubt any of this
00:08:36.980 background information,
00:08:37.880 most of which I looked up
00:08:39.020 online last night,
00:08:39.960 admittedly.
00:08:40.980 I'm willing to accept
00:08:42.060 that in medicine,
00:08:43.020 significant discoveries
00:08:43.820 aren't easy.
00:08:44.560 Sometimes they happen
00:08:45.100 by chance.
00:08:45.660 Sometimes novel diseases
00:08:46.620 are discovered
00:08:47.240 while researchers
00:08:47.880 are working on
00:08:48.460 a completely separate
00:08:49.180 treatment.
00:08:49.640 All that stuff
00:08:50.080 does happen.
00:08:51.260 Of course,
00:08:51.560 it's also the case,
00:08:52.760 as we learned
00:08:53.600 during COVID,
00:08:54.880 that sometimes novel
00:08:55.880 diseases are created
00:08:57.360 under the same
00:08:58.800 circumstances.
00:08:59.980 And then there's
00:09:00.460 a massive cover-up
00:09:01.940 to prevent anyone
00:09:02.840 from learning the truth
00:09:04.180 in service
00:09:05.480 of a broader
00:09:06.060 political agenda.
00:09:08.160 But in general,
00:09:09.120 there's no evidence
00:09:09.680 that I can find
00:09:10.440 that would suggest
00:09:11.600 that AGS was just
00:09:13.180 invented in a lab
00:09:14.720 in the way that COVID was.
00:09:17.140 Now, at the same time,
00:09:18.300 there is very clear evidence
00:09:21.080 that some of the world's
00:09:22.320 leading scientists
00:09:23.180 want to spread AGS
00:09:25.500 as much as possible.
00:09:28.620 You don't need to be
00:09:29.440 a conspiracy theorist
00:09:30.260 to say that
00:09:31.320 because they've been
00:09:31.960 very open about this fact.
00:09:34.180 These scientists
00:09:34.820 want people
00:09:35.740 to get infected
00:09:36.500 with this meat allergy
00:09:37.940 so they stop eating meat
00:09:39.820 on the theory
00:09:40.640 that if people
00:09:41.100 stop eating meat,
00:09:41.980 then the climate
00:09:42.560 will stop changing
00:09:43.340 and the animals
00:09:44.380 will be saved
00:09:45.000 and we can all
00:09:45.680 live in paradise
00:09:46.260 or whatever.
00:09:47.900 Now, in a moment,
00:09:48.340 we'll go through
00:09:48.760 some of these
00:09:49.200 scientific papers
00:09:50.040 and public conferences
00:09:50.960 where scientists
00:09:51.700 have made this argument
00:09:52.820 as deranged
00:09:54.140 and unethical
00:09:54.820 as it obviously is.
00:09:57.100 But first,
00:09:57.740 I want to address
00:09:58.200 anyone who says
00:09:58.840 that, well,
00:10:00.000 you're venturing
00:10:00.620 into the realm
00:10:01.160 of conspiracy theories here.
00:10:03.300 I will acknowledge
00:10:04.000 that in an ideal world,
00:10:05.200 I wouldn't have to raise
00:10:06.480 any of these questions.
00:10:07.360 In an ideal world,
00:10:08.260 our public health establishment
00:10:09.440 would be completely trustworthy
00:10:10.780 and we'd have no reason
00:10:12.900 to think that they'd
00:10:13.680 lie to us
00:10:14.440 about their role
00:10:15.120 in the deaths
00:10:15.580 of innocent Americans
00:10:16.500 and the idea
00:10:18.060 that they would
00:10:18.660 try to spread something
00:10:20.240 intentionally,
00:10:21.200 get people infected.
00:10:22.960 In an ideal world,
00:10:23.860 it's like you wouldn't
00:10:24.640 even consider that.
00:10:25.920 It's crazy.
00:10:26.760 Crazy talk.
00:10:27.420 But we all remember COVID.
00:10:31.080 We all remember
00:10:31.680 how the corporate media
00:10:32.580 cited scientists
00:10:33.660 who insisted
00:10:34.140 the coronavirus
00:10:34.620 was not made in a lab.
00:10:36.020 We all remember
00:10:36.480 the relentless censorship
00:10:37.580 and we all remember
00:10:38.300 learning in the end
00:10:39.080 that the same scientists
00:10:40.400 who told us to shut up
00:10:41.580 were in fact
00:10:42.160 the ones who funded
00:10:43.020 the creation
00:10:43.580 of the virus in Wuhan.
00:10:45.520 Our scientific
00:10:46.160 and medical institutions
00:10:47.100 have been captured
00:10:48.420 by an ideology
00:10:49.180 that above all
00:10:49.960 has nothing to do
00:10:51.140 with public health.
00:10:51.740 This is an anti-human ideology.
00:10:55.640 This is the problem
00:10:56.080 when you have public health,
00:10:57.300 when quote unquote
00:10:57.860 public health
00:10:58.460 is captured by people
00:10:59.400 who are anti-human.
00:11:02.240 And what it's really about
00:11:03.400 is centralizing control
00:11:04.800 over world affairs.
00:11:05.700 That's why they didn't want
00:11:07.420 the WHO to be implicated
00:11:10.220 in COVID
00:11:10.660 even though they covered up
00:11:11.960 what China was doing.
00:11:12.980 That's why they implemented
00:11:13.620 mass lockdowns.
00:11:14.560 That's why they lied
00:11:15.160 about creating the virus
00:11:16.020 in China
00:11:16.400 with international funding.
00:11:18.020 And that's why
00:11:18.560 even though it's quite possible
00:11:19.800 there's nothing nefarious
00:11:20.720 about what just happened
00:11:21.500 in New Jersey
00:11:22.020 or about the fact
00:11:23.080 that this AGS syndrome
00:11:24.160 seems to be spreading
00:11:25.200 more and more recently.
00:11:27.060 It seems to be exploding.
00:11:29.240 It's possible
00:11:29.960 there's nothing nefarious about it.
00:11:31.820 You're still not crazy
00:11:33.000 if you think
00:11:33.860 that there might be
00:11:34.380 more to the story.
00:11:36.640 And you know
00:11:37.360 just asking questions
00:11:38.640 gets a bad rap these days
00:11:39.860 but this is one of those times
00:11:42.000 when yeah
00:11:42.760 we should ask questions.
00:11:44.620 And that becomes
00:11:45.600 more true
00:11:46.420 and more apparent
00:11:46.980 when you listen
00:11:47.540 to what some of the
00:11:48.200 alleged experts
00:11:49.020 have been saying
00:11:49.820 about meat allergies
00:11:51.400 in particular.
00:11:53.000 So we'll start with the words
00:11:53.720 of Matthew Lau
00:11:55.000 the bioethics expert
00:11:56.500 who worked at NYU
00:11:57.720 Oxford, Hopkins
00:11:59.040 Georgetown
00:12:00.320 and Princeton.
00:12:02.000 So his work
00:12:02.940 has heavily influenced
00:12:04.020 the World Economic Forum
00:12:05.000 as well.
00:12:05.580 This is not just
00:12:06.120 some random guy.
00:12:08.220 In papers
00:12:08.960 as well as public appearances
00:12:09.880 Lau has advocated
00:12:10.740 for artificially inducing
00:12:12.320 meat intolerance
00:12:13.480 as a way to prevent
00:12:14.580 the weather
00:12:15.260 from changing.
00:12:16.520 Watch.
00:12:16.940 I want to consider
00:12:19.300 a class of solutions
00:12:21.020 that have never
00:12:22.240 been considered before.
00:12:24.780 Human engineering.
00:12:26.820 It involves
00:12:27.900 the biomedical
00:12:28.660 modification
00:12:29.520 of human beings.
00:12:31.500 I'll give four examples.
00:12:33.040 Here's one.
00:12:34.960 18% of greenhouse
00:12:36.480 gas emissions
00:12:37.360 come from
00:12:38.320 livestock farming.
00:12:39.920 So if we eat
00:12:40.980 less meat
00:12:41.640 we could significantly
00:12:43.020 reduce our
00:12:43.880 greenhouse gas emissions.
00:12:45.340 Now some people
00:12:48.500 would be willing
00:12:49.840 to eat less meat
00:12:51.000 but
00:12:52.100 they lack
00:12:52.800 the willpower.
00:12:54.940 Human engineering
00:12:56.160 could help.
00:12:59.360 Just as some people
00:13:01.160 are naturally
00:13:02.360 intolerant
00:13:03.360 to milk
00:13:04.320 or crayfish
00:13:05.360 like myself
00:13:06.340 we could
00:13:07.700 artificially induce
00:13:09.260 mild intolerance
00:13:10.680 to meat.
00:13:12.820 By stimulating
00:13:14.300 our immune system
00:13:15.520 against common
00:13:16.540 bovine proteins.
00:13:19.120 And in this way
00:13:19.760 we can create
00:13:20.480 an aversion
00:13:21.080 to eating
00:13:21.960 eco-unfriendly food.
00:13:24.160 And we can do this
00:13:25.120 for example
00:13:25.760 by having
00:13:27.260 meat patches.
00:13:29.160 Kind of like
00:13:29.700 nicotine patches.
00:13:31.460 People can then
00:13:32.220 wear these patches
00:13:33.040 before they go out
00:13:34.000 for dinner
00:13:34.460 to curb their
00:13:35.440 enthusiasm
00:13:36.120 for eating meat.
00:13:37.200 So the crowd's
00:13:40.600 into it.
00:13:41.180 It's apparently
00:13:41.620 a real crowd pleaser
00:13:42.680 to talk about
00:13:43.260 genetically modifying
00:13:44.220 humans
00:13:44.600 so they don't
00:13:45.080 want meat.
00:13:45.660 In that clip
00:13:46.080 as you saw
00:13:46.720 it talks about
00:13:47.560 creating nicotine
00:13:48.340 style pouches
00:13:49.280 for people
00:13:49.740 who eat meat
00:13:50.460 meaning
00:13:50.820 pretty much
00:13:52.140 every human
00:13:52.700 alive would have
00:13:53.500 to have this patch.
00:13:54.300 But in other clips
00:13:55.160 you'll hear
00:13:55.420 these scientists
00:13:55.880 directly refer
00:13:56.580 to the Lone Star
00:13:57.520 Tick
00:13:58.000 as one way
00:13:59.800 of shutting
00:14:00.820 down meat
00:14:01.320 consumption.
00:14:02.220 Watch.
00:14:03.480 So I'll give
00:14:04.280 two examples.
00:14:05.060 So one is that
00:14:06.400 people eat
00:14:07.560 too much meat
00:14:08.220 and if they
00:14:09.480 were to cut
00:14:10.020 down on their
00:14:10.520 consumption
00:14:10.960 on meat
00:14:11.560 then it would
00:14:13.400 actually really
00:14:14.020 help the planet.
00:14:15.420 But people
00:14:16.160 are not willing
00:14:16.880 to give up meat.
00:14:17.920 Some people
00:14:18.600 will be willing
00:14:19.200 to but other
00:14:19.900 people
00:14:20.380 they may be
00:14:21.400 willing to
00:14:21.860 but they
00:14:22.300 have a weakness
00:14:23.260 of will.
00:14:23.740 They say
00:14:24.000 wow this steak
00:14:25.000 is just too juicy
00:14:25.920 I can't do it.
00:14:26.560 I'm one of those
00:14:27.380 by the way.
00:14:28.860 So here's a thought.
00:14:30.820 So it turns out
00:14:31.540 that we know
00:14:31.960 a lot about
00:14:32.440 we have these
00:14:33.860 intolerance
00:14:34.860 so for example
00:14:37.040 I have milk
00:14:37.520 intolerance
00:14:38.140 and some people
00:14:40.100 are intolerant
00:14:40.700 to crayfish
00:14:41.500 so possibly
00:14:42.600 we can use
00:14:43.240 human engineering
00:14:44.320 to make it
00:14:45.320 the case
00:14:45.800 that we're
00:14:46.200 intolerant
00:14:46.680 to certain
00:14:47.040 kinds of meat
00:14:47.660 to certain
00:14:48.200 kinds of
00:14:48.560 bovine proteins
00:14:50.320 and there's
00:14:50.900 actually analogs
00:14:52.100 of this in life.
00:14:52.800 There's this thing
00:14:53.240 called the
00:14:53.520 long star tick
00:14:54.400 where if it
00:14:55.320 bites you
00:14:55.900 you will become
00:14:56.820 allergic to meat.
00:14:58.040 I can sort of
00:14:58.680 describe the mechanism.
00:14:59.820 So that's something
00:15:00.720 that we can do
00:15:01.320 through human engineering.
00:15:02.460 We can kind of
00:15:03.400 possibly address
00:15:04.700 really big
00:15:05.340 world problems
00:15:06.100 through human
00:15:06.780 engineering.
00:15:09.380 So it might be
00:15:10.180 easy to dismiss
00:15:10.940 these suggestions
00:15:11.640 as the rantings
00:15:12.680 of a crackpot
00:15:13.340 but the truth is
00:15:14.160 this is not
00:15:15.420 a fringe view
00:15:16.120 among elites
00:15:16.760 or in the field
00:15:17.300 of bioethics.
00:15:18.020 For example
00:15:18.400 you'll find
00:15:18.860 this paragraph
00:15:19.480 right now
00:15:19.960 on the website
00:15:20.500 of the World Economic Forum
00:15:21.880 quote
00:15:23.080 making the transition
00:15:24.400 from mass produced
00:15:25.700 animal proteins
00:15:26.440 to plant based
00:15:27.640 alternatives
00:15:28.100 is not just
00:15:28.820 necessary to meet
00:15:29.580 population demands
00:15:31.000 the latter have
00:15:31.960 also been linked
00:15:32.640 with a smaller
00:15:33.320 carbon footprint
00:15:34.180 and a lower
00:15:35.140 disease risk.
00:15:36.400 It's not enough
00:15:36.880 though to produce
00:15:37.500 sustainable plant
00:15:38.400 based alternatives
00:15:39.220 but to alter
00:15:40.440 human perception
00:15:41.540 so that more
00:15:42.580 people are willing
00:15:43.900 to make the change.
00:15:46.300 Well that's a little
00:15:47.160 ominous.
00:15:48.340 It's not enough
00:15:48.840 to produce
00:15:49.280 alternatives
00:15:49.820 to meat
00:15:50.980 says the WEF
00:15:52.560 we have to
00:15:53.720 alter human
00:15:54.920 perception.
00:15:56.900 Presumably that
00:15:57.740 means we have to
00:15:58.400 beg people to eat
00:15:59.300 inedible garbage
00:16:00.100 like the impossible
00:16:01.040 burger and all that
00:16:02.220 stuff but what
00:16:03.420 happens when
00:16:03.860 those solutions
00:16:04.740 fail?
00:16:05.360 What happens
00:16:05.780 when the stock
00:16:06.620 of beyond meat
00:16:07.600 tanks by 80%
00:16:08.920 in one year
00:16:09.740 because your
00:16:10.580 plant based
00:16:11.340 solutions are
00:16:12.260 horrible and
00:16:12.980 nobody wants
00:16:13.580 them?
00:16:14.860 Is that the
00:16:15.700 point where
00:16:16.280 for the greater
00:16:16.960 good you start
00:16:17.860 forcing the issue?
00:16:20.560 Now there are
00:16:20.980 several prominent
00:16:21.680 experts in the
00:16:22.540 field of bioethics
00:16:23.420 who would answer
00:16:24.020 that question
00:16:24.680 in the affirmative
00:16:25.420 proudly.
00:16:27.320 Parker Crutchfield
00:16:28.300 is one of them.
00:16:28.960 He's a professor
00:16:29.400 at Western Michigan's
00:16:30.520 medical school.
00:16:31.080 This is a direct
00:16:31.740 quote.
00:16:32.220 from one of his
00:16:33.520 peer-reviewed
00:16:34.100 papers which was
00:16:34.740 written with a
00:16:35.300 co-author and
00:16:35.980 colleague named
00:16:36.600 Blake Harreth and
00:16:38.140 published just last
00:16:38.960 month.
00:16:39.720 The paper's called
00:16:40.420 and I promise
00:16:41.660 this is real.
00:16:44.100 The paper's called
00:16:44.700 Beneficial Blood
00:16:46.100 Sucking.
00:16:47.600 Here's how it
00:16:48.040 begins.
00:16:48.460 Quote,
00:16:49.200 The bite of the
00:16:49.760 lone star ticks
00:16:50.500 spreads alpha-gal
00:16:51.740 syndrome, AGS,
00:16:53.180 a condition whose
00:16:53.840 only effect is the
00:16:54.640 creation of a
00:16:55.140 severe but non-fatal
00:16:56.340 red meat allergy.
00:16:57.880 Public health
00:16:58.360 departments warn
00:16:59.020 against lone star ticks
00:17:00.060 and AGS and
00:17:00.740 scientists are working
00:17:01.300 to develop an
00:17:02.200 inoculation to AGS.
00:17:03.540 Herein, we argue
00:17:04.180 that if eating meat
00:17:05.360 is morally
00:17:05.800 impermissible, then
00:17:06.940 efforts to prevent
00:17:08.080 the spread of
00:17:08.840 tick-borne AGS are
00:17:10.160 also morally
00:17:11.200 impermissible.
00:17:12.600 Promoting tick-borne
00:17:13.480 AGS is strongly
00:17:14.880 pro-tanto obligatory.
00:17:17.860 It is presently
00:17:18.520 feasible to
00:17:19.360 genetically edit the
00:17:20.680 disease-carrying
00:17:21.380 capacity of ticks.
00:17:22.500 If this practice can
00:17:23.500 be applied to ticks
00:17:24.360 carrying AGS, then
00:17:25.860 promoting the
00:17:26.760 proliferation of
00:17:28.160 tick-borne AGS is
00:17:29.660 morally obligatory.
00:17:31.060 The article continues,
00:17:32.060 we should promote a
00:17:33.060 particular tick-borne
00:17:34.100 syndrome, alpha-gal
00:17:35.260 syndrome, AGS.
00:17:37.500 So yes, according to
00:17:38.780 Parker Crutchfield, who
00:17:39.860 teaches at a medical
00:17:40.640 school, we have a
00:17:42.080 moral obligation to
00:17:43.860 genetically modify
00:17:44.940 ticks so that they
00:17:46.700 spread AGS.
00:17:48.520 It is morally wrong to
00:17:51.580 stop the spread of AGS,
00:17:53.520 he says.
00:17:55.100 And notice what he
00:17:56.060 writes at the beginning.
00:17:56.700 He claims that AGS
00:17:58.160 creates a non-fatal
00:17:59.820 red meat allergy, and
00:18:00.920 therefore, in his view,
00:18:01.660 it's fine to spread it to
00:18:03.040 as many people as we
00:18:03.740 possibly can.
00:18:05.040 First of all, even if
00:18:05.820 AGS was indeed non-fatal,
00:18:07.440 this still wouldn't make
00:18:09.960 it any sense, nor would it
00:18:11.220 be remotely moral or
00:18:12.700 ethical.
00:18:13.780 You don't get to infect
00:18:14.740 people with life-altering
00:18:16.680 illnesses against their
00:18:17.880 will because you suffer
00:18:18.860 from delusions about how
00:18:19.940 red meat causes hurricanes
00:18:21.280 or something.
00:18:22.760 Obviously.
00:18:24.200 But Parker Crutchfield
00:18:24.820 disagrees.
00:18:25.360 So he wants to modify
00:18:26.620 the genetic code of
00:18:27.680 ticks so that they
00:18:28.860 spread the disease.
00:18:30.660 And he doesn't stop
00:18:31.520 there.
00:18:31.880 In a separate paper
00:18:32.520 written in 2019,
00:18:33.620 Crutchfield explains how
00:18:34.760 precisely he wants to
00:18:36.580 spread this allergy.
00:18:38.020 He doesn't want anyone
00:18:38.980 to know that it's
00:18:40.300 happening.
00:18:41.220 He wants it to take
00:18:42.060 place in secret so that
00:18:44.320 no one is aware of the
00:18:45.360 new pathogen until it's
00:18:46.280 too late.
00:18:46.840 Until, for example,
00:18:47.500 people start dropping
00:18:48.580 dead after eating a
00:18:49.640 hamburger.
00:18:50.640 So this is from another
00:18:51.700 Parker Crutchfield
00:18:52.700 article, a paper
00:18:54.580 entitled,
00:18:55.180 Compulsory Moral
00:18:56.340 Bioenhancement
00:18:57.500 Should Be Covert.
00:19:00.760 Quote,
00:19:01.320 Some theorists argue
00:19:02.340 that moral bioenhancement
00:19:04.240 ought to be compulsory.
00:19:05.860 I take this argument
00:19:06.920 one step further,
00:19:07.880 arguing that if moral
00:19:08.840 bioenhancement ought to
00:19:10.120 be compulsory,
00:19:11.300 then its administration
00:19:11.940 ought to be covert
00:19:13.360 rather than overt.
00:19:15.520 This is to say that it
00:19:16.780 is morally preferable
00:19:18.040 for compulsory moral
00:19:19.600 bioenhancement to be
00:19:21.080 administered without
00:19:21.860 the recipients knowing
00:19:22.900 that they're receiving
00:19:23.780 the enhancement.
00:19:25.020 In particular, a
00:19:25.820 covert compulsory
00:19:26.800 program promotes
00:19:27.760 values such as
00:19:28.740 liberty, utility,
00:19:30.400 equality, and autonomy
00:19:31.720 better than an overt
00:19:32.900 program does.
00:19:34.060 Thus, a covert
00:19:34.860 compulsory program
00:19:36.440 is morally preferable
00:19:38.040 to an overt moral
00:19:39.600 bioenhancement program.
00:19:41.780 Okay, so all of this
00:19:45.080 is very dystopian,
00:19:46.280 and it sounds almost
00:19:47.540 fake.
00:19:48.020 I mean, is this someone
00:19:51.340 who's actually arguing
00:19:52.400 that the moral way to...
00:19:55.340 First of all,
00:19:56.220 giving people a disease
00:19:57.080 is a bioenhancement,
00:19:58.760 and the most moral way
00:20:00.000 of doing it,
00:20:00.620 administering it,
00:20:01.300 is covertly,
00:20:02.540 meaning against their will.
00:20:03.620 And is he actually arguing
00:20:05.320 that that is the way
00:20:07.680 to respect their liberty
00:20:09.200 and privacy the most?
00:20:12.780 Because if you do something
00:20:13.800 to somebody against their will
00:20:15.100 without them knowing,
00:20:16.360 then you've respected their...
00:20:17.960 You haven't infringed
00:20:18.600 on their liberty
00:20:19.060 or freedom at all,
00:20:20.020 is his argument.
00:20:23.220 Is that actually real?
00:20:24.400 Well, yes, it is.
00:20:25.080 And at this point,
00:20:25.540 I decided to look up
00:20:26.380 some other writings
00:20:27.440 from Parker Crutchfield,
00:20:28.760 who, again,
00:20:29.600 teaches ethics
00:20:30.520 at a medical school.
00:20:33.340 On Amazon,
00:20:34.020 I came across this review
00:20:35.020 of his book,
00:20:35.520 quote,
00:20:35.700 This author is genuinely
00:20:36.940 dangerous and has no business
00:20:38.400 teaching impressionable minds.
00:20:39.980 The author believes
00:20:40.560 themselves to be
00:20:41.280 some arbiter
00:20:42.140 of moral authority,
00:20:43.080 and he has the right
00:20:44.060 to make decisions
00:20:44.700 for humanity
00:20:45.260 based on his twisted vision.
00:20:46.960 Everything Parker writes
00:20:47.840 is a confession.
00:20:49.540 Heed his words
00:20:50.120 because I suspect
00:20:50.780 a large portion of academia
00:20:52.060 actually agrees with him,
00:20:54.160 but to say the quiet part
00:20:55.440 out loud and proudly
00:20:56.440 is jarring to say the least.
00:20:58.560 The darkest of minds.
00:21:01.400 But again,
00:21:01.720 this particular academic
00:21:02.520 isn't the only person
00:21:03.840 saying things like this.
00:21:04.860 It's become fashionable
00:21:05.700 in leftist circles
00:21:06.480 to make this same argument.
00:21:08.740 This is a post I pulled
00:21:09.520 from Reddit, for example,
00:21:10.660 from seven years ago,
00:21:11.780 quote,
00:21:12.580 Modifying an insect's genome
00:21:14.080 so that it produces
00:21:14.820 alpha-gal in its saliva
00:21:16.660 is one of the simplest
00:21:17.520 genetic edits,
00:21:18.640 especially as ticks
00:21:19.480 and mammals
00:21:19.980 provide a genetic template.
00:21:22.180 Using this technology
00:21:22.980 to cause all
00:21:24.020 or the most common
00:21:25.000 biting insects
00:21:25.600 to cause meat allergies
00:21:26.760 would have numerous benefits,
00:21:28.200 including reduction
00:21:29.220 in meat consumption
00:21:30.020 in sufferers
00:21:30.660 and reduction
00:21:31.500 in greenhouse gas emissions.
00:21:33.360 Meat is a major
00:21:34.120 source of emissions.
00:21:36.340 Now, you might say
00:21:37.220 that Reddit
00:21:37.580 isn't much of a source
00:21:38.760 and we can't read
00:21:40.280 much into that post,
00:21:42.220 and you're right about that.
00:21:44.080 But the post made
00:21:45.380 one good point,
00:21:46.560 which is that
00:21:47.020 modifying a tick's genome
00:21:48.280 apparently isn't that difficult.
00:21:49.720 A few years ago,
00:21:50.340 researchers from Penn State
00:21:51.500 and University of Maryland
00:21:52.420 discovered a new way
00:21:53.720 to genetically modify ticks.
00:21:55.020 This is an article
00:21:55.600 from 2022
00:21:56.280 summarizing the findings,
00:21:57.660 quote,
00:21:58.240 Breakthrough makes
00:21:59.720 editing tick genome
00:22:00.820 a reality.
00:22:01.420 For the first time,
00:22:02.380 researchers have successfully
00:22:03.440 edited the tick genome
00:22:04.520 at the embryo stage,
00:22:05.880 an achievement
00:22:06.300 that may one day
00:22:07.320 help scientists
00:22:07.920 alter parts of the genome
00:22:09.080 responsible for ticks
00:22:10.040 acquiring and spreading
00:22:10.980 harmful pathogens.
00:22:12.120 Now, on the surface,
00:22:14.340 just like the research
00:22:15.040 that was going on
00:22:15.820 in Wuhan,
00:22:17.220 you know,
00:22:18.260 on the surface,
00:22:19.180 may sound well-intentioned
00:22:21.400 above board.
00:22:22.940 And they say
00:22:23.600 this is about
00:22:24.100 preventing the spread
00:22:25.560 of diseases.
00:22:26.380 Who wouldn't want to
00:22:27.420 prevent the spread
00:22:28.060 of diseases?
00:22:29.500 But you have to wonder
00:22:30.120 if there might be
00:22:30.740 some catastrophic
00:22:32.100 consequences
00:22:33.120 from messing around
00:22:34.280 with tick genomes,
00:22:35.860 especially given
00:22:36.920 the possible role
00:22:37.660 of scientific experiments
00:22:38.700 in creating Lyme disease
00:22:39.960 several decades ago.
00:22:40.920 Last year,
00:22:41.660 the HHS secretary,
00:22:42.680 RFK Jr.,
00:22:43.800 stated that gain-of-function
00:22:44.960 research is a disaster
00:22:46.220 that has, quote,
00:22:47.100 given us everything
00:22:47.720 from Lyme disease
00:22:48.540 to COVID
00:22:49.140 and many other diseases.
00:22:51.620 And of course,
00:22:52.080 for saying that,
00:22:52.740 RFK was labeled
00:22:53.660 a nut job.
00:22:54.580 And my goal here
00:22:55.140 is not to litigate
00:22:56.080 the question of
00:22:56.660 whether or not
00:22:57.160 Lyme disease
00:22:57.760 was created
00:22:58.260 by military experiments
00:22:59.840 in the 60s and 70s.
00:23:02.080 There's a book
00:23:02.760 on the topic
00:23:03.220 called Bitten
00:23:03.960 by Chris Newby
00:23:04.900 that outlines the case
00:23:05.940 for that theory
00:23:06.400 if you're interested
00:23:06.940 in the details.
00:23:08.240 For one thing,
00:23:08.740 it was awfully suspicious
00:23:10.340 that a U.S. government
00:23:11.440 facility conducting
00:23:12.300 biological experiments
00:23:13.360 called the Plum Island
00:23:15.000 Animal Disease Center
00:23:16.160 was located
00:23:17.280 less than 20 miles
00:23:18.540 from Old Lyme, Connecticut,
00:23:21.020 where the sudden explosion
00:23:22.660 of the disease took place.
00:23:23.760 So what does that
00:23:25.040 remind you of?
00:23:26.820 But regardless of
00:23:27.700 what you think about
00:23:28.340 the origins of Lyme disease,
00:23:29.560 my point is simply this.
00:23:31.740 When you have
00:23:32.460 an unexplained dead body
00:23:34.320 in a highly unusual circumstance,
00:23:35.840 one of the first questions
00:23:37.700 any good investigator
00:23:38.520 asks is
00:23:39.300 who had a motive
00:23:40.580 to kill this person?
00:23:42.680 And that's the case
00:23:43.480 with that airline pilot
00:23:44.560 in New Jersey.
00:23:45.680 He died
00:23:46.480 in an extraordinarily
00:23:47.280 unusual way
00:23:48.500 and several prominent
00:23:50.080 bioethics researchers
00:23:51.400 channeling the WEF
00:23:52.660 openly admitted
00:23:53.680 their motivation
00:23:54.380 to infect him,
00:23:55.820 to infect us
00:23:56.720 with the disorder
00:23:58.640 that led to his death.
00:24:00.940 Now,
00:24:01.460 that doesn't mean
00:24:01.860 they did it.
00:24:03.620 That also doesn't mean
00:24:04.740 that the ongoing
00:24:05.480 genetic experiments
00:24:06.300 on ticks,
00:24:06.880 which are taking place
00:24:07.440 all over the country,
00:24:08.740 had necessarily anything
00:24:09.780 to do with the man's death,
00:24:10.660 but it does mean
00:24:11.440 we're entitled
00:24:12.560 to a full explanation
00:24:13.460 on what exactly
00:24:14.420 these researchers
00:24:14.940 are doing to ticks
00:24:15.920 and what risks
00:24:17.180 these experiments pose
00:24:18.160 to the rest of us.
00:24:20.440 And there's been
00:24:21.260 very little transparency
00:24:22.280 about that.
00:24:23.660 The fact remains
00:24:24.500 that a large group
00:24:25.420 of very powerful leftists
00:24:26.720 would rather kill us
00:24:27.840 than allow us to eat meat.
00:24:29.660 I mean,
00:24:29.840 that's very simple.
00:24:32.200 They'd also rather
00:24:32.860 lie to us
00:24:33.640 than tell us
00:24:34.100 the truth
00:24:34.440 about their
00:24:34.860 scientific experiments,
00:24:36.380 whether those experiments
00:24:37.180 involve bats
00:24:38.040 or ticks
00:24:38.440 or anything else.
00:24:40.180 And in an environment
00:24:41.280 like that,
00:24:41.860 the words
00:24:42.180 conspiracy theorist
00:24:43.440 just have no meaning.
00:24:45.560 The complete erosion
00:24:46.620 of confidence
00:24:47.280 in our public health
00:24:48.100 authorities
00:24:48.540 has led us
00:24:49.740 to this point.
00:24:51.360 We should have
00:24:52.260 some degree of faith
00:24:53.660 that our public health
00:24:54.520 officials will actually
00:24:55.620 work to prevent
00:24:56.280 the spread of illnesses,
00:24:58.080 this illness in particular,
00:24:59.460 or any illness,
00:25:00.600 and to prevent
00:25:01.680 as many deaths
00:25:02.280 as they possibly can.
00:25:03.460 We should have
00:25:03.860 some confidence
00:25:04.460 that their research
00:25:05.240 is going to help people
00:25:06.240 rather than kill them,
00:25:07.140 but we don't have
00:25:08.140 that confidence.
00:25:09.640 We have no reason
00:25:10.680 to have that confidence.
00:25:13.380 Regardless of
00:25:14.080 who's responsible
00:25:14.740 for the new spread
00:25:15.540 of this latest disease,
00:25:16.840 if anyone's responsible,
00:25:19.140 we all know
00:25:19.760 that a lot of scientists
00:25:20.560 and experts
00:25:21.100 are actually happy
00:25:22.160 about the fact
00:25:22.700 that an innocent man
00:25:23.500 just died
00:25:24.000 because he ate a hamburger.
00:25:26.540 They're getting
00:25:27.100 all sorts of ideas
00:25:28.060 about how to save
00:25:28.820 the climate
00:25:29.240 and save the cows
00:25:30.280 and so on.
00:25:32.080 And after years
00:25:32.980 of lockdowns
00:25:33.760 and mass death
00:25:34.400 in this country,
00:25:35.220 we all know exactly
00:25:37.060 where those ideas
00:25:38.740 can lead.
00:25:40.960 Now let's get
00:25:41.560 to our five headlines.
00:25:48.260 Grand Canyon University
00:25:49.340 is an affordable,
00:25:50.180 private,
00:25:50.620 Christian university
00:25:51.360 based in beautiful
00:25:52.260 Phoenix, Arizona.
00:25:53.340 It's one of the largest
00:25:54.140 universities in the country.
00:25:55.180 GCU is widely praised
00:25:56.360 for its culture
00:25:57.020 of community and impact.
00:25:58.600 They boast
00:25:59.000 369 academic programs
00:26:01.740 with over 300
00:26:02.560 of those
00:26:03.080 being available online.
00:26:04.520 Join a nationwide
00:26:05.060 community of learners
00:26:05.960 who are redefining
00:26:07.080 online education
00:26:07.840 through GCU's
00:26:08.800 100% online MBA program.
00:26:11.420 At GCU,
00:26:11.900 you can learn
00:26:12.200 about ethical entrepreneurship
00:26:13.280 and how to scale
00:26:14.320 your business
00:26:14.740 to serve your community.
00:26:16.320 In addition to federal grants
00:26:17.580 and aid,
00:26:18.260 GCU's online students
00:26:20.120 received nearly
00:26:21.020 $161 million
00:26:22.120 in institutional scholarships
00:26:23.500 in 2024.
00:26:24.820 Find your purpose
00:26:25.660 at Grand Canyon University.
00:26:27.740 Private Christian affordable.
00:26:28.860 Visit gcu.edu
00:26:29.880 slash my offer
00:26:31.040 to see the scholarships
00:26:32.400 you may qualify for.
00:26:34.200 The holidays will be here
00:26:35.300 before you know it
00:26:36.060 and for many families
00:26:36.920 that means excitement
00:26:37.740 and a little stress.
00:26:38.820 Between gifts,
00:26:39.500 travel,
00:26:39.880 higher prices,
00:26:40.460 it's easy to feel overwhelmed
00:26:41.520 especially if you're
00:26:42.360 already relying on credit cards
00:26:43.840 to cover the basics.
00:26:45.040 If you feel that debt
00:26:45.860 is piling up,
00:26:47.100 you're not alone
00:26:47.740 but there is help
00:26:48.660 with American financing.
00:26:50.080 If you're a homeowner,
00:26:51.300 you might have considered
00:26:51.880 reaching out
00:26:52.520 to American financing
00:26:53.360 but hesitated
00:26:54.060 because you don't want
00:26:55.040 to give up
00:26:55.740 your low mortgage rate.
00:26:57.340 That's why American financing
00:26:58.400 created the Smart Equity Loan,
00:27:00.160 a simple and smart way
00:27:01.420 to get your finances
00:27:02.180 back on track
00:27:02.940 without giving up
00:27:04.160 your low mortgage rate.
00:27:05.520 The Smart Equity Loan
00:27:06.280 offers a fixed rate
00:27:07.440 so you'll have
00:27:08.100 one predictable
00:27:08.980 monthly payment,
00:27:10.280 lets you use
00:27:10.820 your home's equity
00:27:11.540 to pay off
00:27:12.140 high interest debt,
00:27:13.400 free up your cash flow
00:27:14.280 and still keep
00:27:15.220 your existing mortgage intact.
00:27:16.440 There are no upfront fees
00:27:17.280 to find out if you qualify
00:27:18.200 so call American financing
00:27:19.420 today, 866-569-4711.
00:27:21.960 That's 866-569-4711
00:27:24.260 or visit
00:27:24.820 americanfinancing.net
00:27:26.300 slash Walsh.
00:27:28.000 Okay, the House
00:27:29.200 is going to vote today
00:27:29.900 on a bill that would
00:27:31.400 force the release
00:27:32.280 of the Epstein files
00:27:33.320 and I'll have more
00:27:33.980 to say about that
00:27:34.740 after the vote
00:27:35.940 which by the time
00:27:36.760 you hear this
00:27:37.220 may have already happened
00:27:38.100 but as I'm saying this
00:27:39.140 it has not happened yet.
00:27:40.840 I suspect the vote
00:27:41.940 will, you know,
00:27:42.800 it will pass
00:27:44.740 is what I suspect
00:27:46.220 and so we'll talk
00:27:48.900 about when it does
00:27:49.300 I will
00:27:49.860 and we've talked
00:27:50.460 about the Epstein thing
00:27:51.060 plenty of times
00:27:51.500 I will just say this
00:27:52.440 about the Epstein story
00:27:54.540 and so there are
00:28:00.260 multiple things
00:28:01.100 here going on
00:28:01.760 there are multiple
00:28:02.660 things that are true
00:28:04.380 okay about this whole story
00:28:06.020 and the first one
00:28:07.900 is that they should
00:28:08.580 release all the files
00:28:09.560 and I've said that
00:28:11.420 all along
00:28:12.420 I've said that from
00:28:13.120 literally from day one
00:28:14.340 they should release
00:28:15.020 all the files
00:28:15.520 and I'm certainly
00:28:17.100 not the only one
00:28:17.560 who said that
00:28:18.040 a lot of us
00:28:18.440 have been saying that
00:28:19.140 release the files
00:28:20.040 just release them all
00:28:20.880 there is no good reason
00:28:23.400 why any of this stuff
00:28:24.920 should be secret
00:28:25.960 this was an international
00:28:27.080 you know pedophile
00:28:29.000 who we know
00:28:32.200 was mixed up
00:28:33.220 with a lot of
00:28:33.800 prominent people
00:28:34.560 and so
00:28:36.720 lay it out
00:28:39.480 just open up
00:28:40.720 the books
00:28:41.000 and let us see
00:28:41.520 so that's the first thing
00:28:44.380 they should release
00:28:45.820 all the files
00:28:46.320 so this vote
00:28:48.220 should go through
00:28:49.080 and they should
00:28:49.560 release the files
00:28:50.100 now it's also true
00:28:52.360 that most
00:28:55.300 not all
00:28:56.660 certainly
00:28:57.360 but most of the people
00:28:59.000 in DC
00:28:59.700 right now
00:29:00.400 clamoring for the
00:29:01.360 Epstein files
00:29:02.120 are doing it solely
00:29:03.740 for political gain
00:29:04.600 okay
00:29:05.900 and they didn't give
00:29:06.980 the slightest damn
00:29:07.800 about Epstein
00:29:08.420 10 seconds ago
00:29:09.340 which is why
00:29:11.640 it's really
00:29:11.940 it's hard to stomach
00:29:12.940 some of these
00:29:14.000 press conferences
00:29:14.480 stuff that you watch
00:29:15.320 and you see these
00:29:15.840 people up there
00:29:16.600 showboating
00:29:18.000 and you know
00:29:19.140 taking this
00:29:19.880 moral stand
00:29:20.940 release the files
00:29:21.860 and some of them
00:29:23.840 mean it
00:29:24.060 but most of them
00:29:24.620 don't
00:29:24.940 they don't care at all
00:29:26.880 this is all politics
00:29:28.160 and we know that
00:29:29.700 now
00:29:31.000 and that's something
00:29:33.740 that so Trump
00:29:34.500 has essentially
00:29:35.200 that's basically
00:29:36.520 an argument
00:29:36.880 that Trump is making
00:29:39.340 and he's right about
00:29:40.120 that part of it
00:29:40.640 now it's also true
00:29:41.620 that the Trump
00:29:43.320 administration
00:29:43.880 has fumbled
00:29:45.120 this issue
00:29:45.820 badly
00:29:46.860 I mean this is one
00:29:47.420 of the worst
00:29:47.820 fumbles
00:29:48.200 we've ever seen
00:29:49.320 I don't think
00:29:49.860 that's an exaggeration
00:29:50.700 this is one of the worst
00:29:51.620 in politics
00:29:52.800 this is one of the worst
00:29:55.080 fumbles
00:29:55.840 some of the worst
00:29:56.740 bungling
00:29:57.300 that we've ever seen
00:29:58.820 and we don't need
00:30:00.340 to go back
00:30:00.840 and review all of it
00:30:01.700 but you know
00:30:02.760 going all the way
00:30:03.480 back to
00:30:04.040 Trump saying
00:30:05.360 he'd released
00:30:05.820 the files
00:30:06.340 and then getting
00:30:07.160 into office
00:30:07.740 and then
00:30:09.500 who can forget
00:30:10.880 the
00:30:11.560 now infamous
00:30:15.420 Epstein binders
00:30:17.280 that were released
00:30:18.000 to the conservative
00:30:18.640 influencers
00:30:19.220 and hey
00:30:20.400 you know
00:30:20.740 taking pictures
00:30:21.340 with them
00:30:21.780 and then it turns
00:30:22.300 out that there's
00:30:22.780 nothing in them
00:30:23.260 at all
00:30:23.600 and then they say
00:30:25.180 oh well
00:30:26.020 never mind
00:30:26.520 actually
00:30:26.940 the whole Epstein
00:30:27.960 thing is
00:30:28.560 you know
00:30:29.200 it's all
00:30:29.960 a big nothing burger
00:30:31.140 there's nothing
00:30:31.580 to see here
00:30:32.200 and it's like
00:30:33.340 okay well
00:30:33.760 then why did
00:30:34.580 you do the whole
00:30:35.060 thing with the Epstein
00:30:35.600 binder
00:30:35.760 so the whole
00:30:36.540 thing just
00:30:36.920 it's been an
00:30:37.380 absolute disaster
00:30:38.140 they've handled
00:30:38.580 it the wrong
00:30:38.940 way the entire
00:30:39.420 time
00:30:39.660 and they should
00:30:41.420 have just
00:30:41.640 released the
00:30:42.080 files
00:30:42.340 now it's also
00:30:44.800 true that
00:30:45.340 not one
00:30:46.880 democrat in
00:30:47.600 the country
00:30:48.000 not a single
00:30:48.560 one
00:30:48.860 not one
00:30:50.620 actually cares
00:30:52.480 about Epstein
00:30:53.380 and I know
00:30:55.480 that because
00:30:56.460 precisely none
00:30:58.340 of them
00:30:58.840 called for the
00:30:59.880 release back
00:31:00.640 when they could
00:31:01.040 have done it
00:31:01.620 themselves
00:31:02.180 easily
00:31:02.860 right
00:31:04.720 Joe Biden
00:31:06.340 was in
00:31:06.720 office
00:31:07.100 for four
00:31:07.800 years
00:31:08.180 and none
00:31:10.560 of these
00:31:10.860 people
00:31:11.160 the Epstein
00:31:11.580 files were
00:31:12.200 in existence
00:31:13.440 the whole
00:31:13.820 time
00:31:14.140 at any
00:31:15.800 point
00:31:16.100 any of
00:31:16.540 them could
00:31:16.840 have said
00:31:17.080 hey why
00:31:17.360 don't we
00:31:17.540 release
00:31:17.800 those Epstein
00:31:18.180 files
00:31:18.500 none of
00:31:19.760 them did
00:31:20.080 and now
00:31:21.760 we're supposed
00:31:22.180 to believe
00:31:22.560 and now
00:31:22.820 they're up
00:31:23.080 on you know
00:31:23.840 in front
00:31:24.040 of cameras
00:31:24.500 saying we
00:31:25.340 need to
00:31:25.600 take a
00:31:25.900 stand
00:31:26.180 this is
00:31:26.460 the right
00:31:26.740 thing
00:31:26.900 to do
00:31:27.300 and you
00:31:28.980 just you
00:31:29.340 can't take
00:31:29.700 it
00:31:29.800 seriously
00:31:30.160 so
00:31:33.300 but they
00:31:35.260 should release
00:31:35.680 the files
00:31:36.060 right it
00:31:36.440 all comes
00:31:36.740 back to
00:31:37.080 that so
00:31:37.400 so the
00:31:37.740 whole thing
00:31:38.080 is a is
00:31:38.580 just a mess
00:31:39.280 and politically
00:31:40.520 and there's
00:31:41.020 there's almost
00:31:42.680 nobody to root
00:31:43.660 for here
00:31:44.220 that this is
00:31:44.760 one of those
00:31:45.180 things where
00:31:46.540 there's no one
00:31:47.140 to root for
00:31:47.620 the only thing
00:31:48.020 to root for
00:31:48.540 is the truth
00:31:49.240 that's what
00:31:50.740 I'm rooting
00:31:51.080 for I just
00:31:51.620 want to know
00:31:51.920 the truth
00:31:52.320 whatever effect
00:31:54.520 it has
00:31:54.900 whatever impact
00:31:55.500 it has
00:31:55.920 whoever it
00:31:56.460 whoever it
00:31:57.840 hurts
00:31:58.140 I mean if
00:31:59.320 the truth
00:31:59.680 about Epstein
00:32:00.140 hurts you
00:32:00.820 then you
00:32:01.180 deserve to
00:32:01.580 be hurt
00:32:01.940 and um
00:32:03.560 and so
00:32:05.160 that's what
00:32:05.500 I'm rooting
00:32:05.840 for I think
00:32:06.220 it's what
00:32:06.380 we're all
00:32:06.660 rooting for
00:32:07.120 but when
00:32:08.140 it comes
00:32:08.420 to like
00:32:08.760 the characters
00:32:09.400 involved here
00:32:10.240 the figures
00:32:10.880 in DC
00:32:12.700 all the back
00:32:13.580 and forth
00:32:14.000 and everything
00:32:14.400 it's like
00:32:14.820 you can't
00:32:15.380 none of
00:32:15.740 these people
00:32:16.260 you can't
00:32:16.840 root for
00:32:17.120 any of
00:32:17.400 them
00:32:17.540 none of
00:32:17.920 them are
00:32:18.440 avenging
00:32:19.220 heroes
00:32:19.820 as they
00:32:20.760 might pretend
00:32:21.220 to be
00:32:21.620 and um
00:32:22.620 and that's
00:32:23.200 just and
00:32:23.560 that's just
00:32:23.860 the way it
00:32:24.160 is and
00:32:24.380 but this
00:32:24.960 is so
00:32:25.640 yes it's
00:32:25.980 very frustrating
00:32:26.700 that the
00:32:27.000 Democrats
00:32:27.540 it's like
00:32:28.180 yes
00:32:28.800 none of
00:32:30.200 them mean
00:32:30.540 it
00:32:30.700 none of
00:32:31.100 them care
00:32:31.400 about this
00:32:31.840 at all
00:32:32.220 um
00:32:34.460 and again
00:32:35.120 we know
00:32:35.340 that for
00:32:35.580 a fact
00:32:36.020 undeniable
00:32:37.720 because they
00:32:38.560 could have
00:32:38.800 released it
00:32:39.160 and they
00:32:39.320 didn't
00:32:39.480 themselves
00:32:39.780 uh
00:32:40.620 they waited
00:32:41.160 until they
00:32:42.000 didn't have
00:32:42.500 the power
00:32:42.880 to do it
00:32:43.240 they went
00:32:43.680 through four
00:32:44.140 years
00:32:44.460 they had
00:32:44.740 the power
00:32:45.060 to release
00:32:45.480 it
00:32:45.620 they waited
00:32:46.200 for precisely
00:32:46.960 the moment
00:32:47.420 when they
00:32:47.740 could no
00:32:48.180 longer do
00:32:48.820 it
00:32:48.960 and then
00:32:49.180 said hey
00:32:49.460 why don't
00:32:49.900 we release
00:32:50.240 those files
00:32:50.820 what's going
00:32:51.260 on here
00:32:51.700 um
00:32:52.720 so
00:32:53.440 and that's
00:32:54.580 very frustrating
00:32:55.160 but
00:32:55.460 uh
00:32:57.180 this is a
00:32:59.540 political gift
00:33:00.440 that the
00:33:00.940 Trump administration
00:33:01.520 has given
00:33:02.160 to the
00:33:02.720 Democrats
00:33:03.040 and they're
00:33:03.780 going to
00:33:03.960 take the
00:33:04.320 gift
00:33:04.600 can't really
00:33:06.700 blame them
00:33:07.220 when you
00:33:09.560 kind of
00:33:10.120 present
00:33:11.640 yourself
00:33:12.300 right
00:33:13.480 to take
00:33:14.940 a hit
00:33:15.360 uh
00:33:17.020 when you
00:33:17.360 lay your
00:33:17.960 head down
00:33:18.480 on the
00:33:18.800 tee
00:33:19.120 and tee
00:33:19.600 ball
00:33:19.880 and you
00:33:20.320 just let
00:33:20.720 them
00:33:20.900 wind up
00:33:21.500 and take
00:33:21.760 a whack
00:33:22.160 at you
00:33:22.560 well they're
00:33:23.300 going to
00:33:23.480 do it
00:33:23.920 and that's
00:33:26.460 why you
00:33:26.740 don't that's
00:33:27.120 why you
00:33:27.320 don't put
00:33:27.620 yourself in
00:33:27.900 that position
00:33:28.200 to begin
00:33:28.420 with
00:33:28.620 all right
00:33:29.780 here's a
00:33:30.660 story we
00:33:30.960 haven't had a
00:33:31.260 chance to
00:33:31.500 talk about
00:33:31.820 yet
00:33:32.040 the New
00:33:32.400 York
00:33:32.500 Post
00:33:32.680 reports
00:33:33.040 a Michigan
00:33:33.440 man
00:33:33.740 fatally
00:33:34.140 shot a
00:33:34.600 teen
00:33:34.820 who broke
00:33:35.300 into his
00:33:35.600 garage
00:33:35.940 and is
00:33:36.140 now facing
00:33:36.600 a manslaughter
00:33:37.220 rap
00:33:37.520 sparking
00:33:37.900 controversy
00:33:38.360 of the
00:33:38.580 state's
00:33:38.880 stand your
00:33:39.360 ground
00:33:39.640 law
00:33:39.980 Savon
00:33:40.560 Wilson
00:33:40.780 17
00:33:41.100 was with
00:33:41.600 six other
00:33:42.320 mainly
00:33:43.760 teenagers
00:33:44.400 when the
00:33:45.620 group broke
00:33:46.940 into Dayton
00:33:47.660 Napton's
00:33:48.340 garage in
00:33:49.280 White Lake
00:33:50.160 shortly after
00:33:50.660 1 a.m.
00:33:51.200 on July 8th
00:33:52.120 Napton
00:33:52.520 24 got an
00:33:53.240 alert from his
00:33:53.760 home security
00:33:54.340 system grabbed
00:33:54.960 a nine
00:33:55.680 millimeter gun
00:33:56.380 ran outside
00:33:57.580 fired two
00:33:58.000 shots into
00:33:58.400 the garage
00:33:58.740 through a
00:33:58.960 windowless
00:33:59.260 door striking
00:34:00.100 Wilson
00:34:00.400 according to
00:34:00.820 the prosecutors
00:34:01.240 as the group
00:34:01.900 fled Napton
00:34:02.480 fired five
00:34:03.380 more shots
00:34:03.780 before going
00:34:04.180 back into
00:34:04.460 his house
00:34:04.820 reloading his
00:34:05.800 gun and
00:34:06.180 returning
00:34:06.600 outside
00:34:07.980 Wilson's
00:34:10.360 father Sean
00:34:11.000 Madden
00:34:11.420 said Savon
00:34:13.100 was running
00:34:13.700 away and
00:34:14.180 got shot
00:34:14.740 another
00:34:16.240 teenager in
00:34:16.720 the group
00:34:16.940 also was
00:34:17.440 shot in
00:34:17.700 the leg
00:34:18.020 White Lake
00:34:18.760 Township
00:34:19.240 police officers
00:34:20.020 responded to
00:34:20.560 the scene
00:34:20.820 after being
00:34:21.160 notified of
00:34:21.700 two victims
00:34:22.160 with bullet
00:34:22.520 wounds in
00:34:24.580 Commerce
00:34:24.920 Township
00:34:25.540 faces up to
00:34:28.200 15 years
00:34:28.660 behind bars
00:34:29.340 for the
00:34:29.700 top charge
00:34:30.400 but Savon's
00:34:31.360 family said
00:34:31.860 they want
00:34:32.140 Napton
00:34:32.380 charged with
00:34:32.800 murder
00:34:33.160 doesn't make
00:34:34.520 sense that
00:34:34.880 it wasn't
00:34:35.200 done out of
00:34:35.600 malice and
00:34:36.120 for them to
00:34:36.540 charge him
00:34:36.880 with manslaughter
00:34:37.540 when everything
00:34:37.980 in the report
00:34:38.360 suggests there
00:34:38.840 was malicious
00:34:39.260 intent
00:34:39.620 said Wilson's
00:34:40.920 sister Armani
00:34:41.560 Madden
00:34:42.020 and meanwhile
00:34:45.600 the defense
00:34:45.940 attorney says
00:34:46.660 that as
00:34:47.920 you would
00:34:48.600 expect that
00:34:49.160 this is all
00:34:50.000 this is that
00:34:51.220 he didn't do
00:34:51.620 anything wrong
00:34:52.140 and that also
00:34:52.880 mentioning that
00:34:54.260 there had been
00:34:55.040 other break-ins
00:34:55.820 at Napton's
00:34:56.420 house before
00:34:56.980 okay so
00:34:59.020 just to review
00:35:00.160 a guy in
00:35:01.220 Michigan
00:35:01.500 dating Napton
00:35:02.160 was the
00:35:02.620 victim of
00:35:03.000 multiple
00:35:03.300 burglaries
00:35:03.900 apparently
00:35:04.480 cops didn't
00:35:05.480 do anything
00:35:05.960 nobody cared
00:35:07.080 no one's
00:35:07.940 helping and
00:35:08.580 then one
00:35:09.140 night about
00:35:09.520 1 a.m.
00:35:10.140 Savon Wilson
00:35:10.740 and his
00:35:11.440 buddies
00:35:11.800 break into
00:35:13.000 Napton's
00:35:13.620 garage
00:35:14.060 he runs
00:35:14.900 out
00:35:15.260 tired of
00:35:16.000 being a
00:35:16.300 victim
00:35:16.580 right
00:35:17.480 tired of
00:35:17.900 having his
00:35:18.300 stuff stolen
00:35:18.980 tired of
00:35:19.820 being helpless
00:35:20.380 fires through
00:35:21.180 the door of
00:35:21.640 the garage
00:35:22.100 fires a few
00:35:22.940 more times as
00:35:23.480 the criminals
00:35:23.860 are fleeing
00:35:24.320 Wilson is
00:35:25.280 killed by
00:35:25.820 one of the
00:35:26.120 bullets
00:35:26.420 it's not
00:35:27.060 clear to
00:35:27.540 me from
00:35:28.020 that write-up
00:35:28.560 if he was
00:35:28.940 killed
00:35:29.380 it says he
00:35:29.960 was hit
00:35:30.380 through the
00:35:30.960 door
00:35:31.320 and then it
00:35:32.400 says he
00:35:32.660 kept firing
00:35:33.220 as they were
00:35:34.140 running away
00:35:34.740 was he killed
00:35:36.020 from the
00:35:36.380 initial shot
00:35:37.120 through the
00:35:38.360 door or was
00:35:38.860 he killed
00:35:39.300 with another
00:35:39.720 shot when he's
00:35:40.220 running away
00:35:40.580 maybe that
00:35:41.100 is known
00:35:41.600 but I
00:35:41.840 didn't see
00:35:42.100 it in the
00:35:42.320 article
00:35:42.560 regardless
00:35:44.480 now the
00:35:45.340 same judicial
00:35:45.900 system that
00:35:46.520 had no
00:35:46.880 interest in
00:35:47.360 helping this
00:35:47.960 law-abiding
00:35:48.440 citizen
00:35:48.860 who was
00:35:50.540 the victim
00:35:51.540 of property
00:35:52.580 theft
00:35:52.940 a number
00:35:55.280 of times
00:35:55.700 will instead
00:35:57.160 try to throw
00:35:58.740 him in prison
00:35:59.220 and destroy
00:35:59.620 his life
00:36:00.000 so this is
00:36:00.960 happening to
00:36:01.320 him he goes
00:36:01.840 to the cops
00:36:02.260 and says
00:36:02.480 can you do
00:36:02.840 something
00:36:03.100 they say
00:36:03.680 no we can't
00:36:04.460 really do
00:36:04.680 anything
00:36:04.880 and then
00:36:05.780 he says
00:36:06.220 okay well
00:36:06.760 I guess
00:36:07.800 I have to
00:36:08.180 do something
00:36:08.640 or otherwise
00:36:09.200 I'm just
00:36:09.520 going to get
00:36:09.780 stolen
00:36:10.180 otherwise I'm
00:36:11.260 just going to
00:36:11.500 be a victim
00:36:11.960 every day
00:36:12.400 for the rest
00:36:12.740 of my life
00:36:13.160 and now the
00:36:15.500 system comes
00:36:15.920 back around
00:36:16.400 and says
00:36:16.720 oh well
00:36:17.160 you weren't
00:36:17.540 supposed to
00:36:17.920 do that
00:36:18.320 though so
00:36:18.800 guess what
00:36:19.500 your life
00:36:19.820 is ruined
00:36:20.220 and meanwhile
00:36:23.880 if this had
00:36:25.020 gone the
00:36:25.920 other way
00:36:26.260 and Savon
00:36:27.660 Wilson had
00:36:28.660 killed Dayton
00:36:29.640 Napton in
00:36:30.240 the process
00:36:30.600 of robbing
00:36:30.980 his house
00:36:31.360 he would
00:36:32.640 not get
00:36:33.040 15 years
00:36:33.580 in prison
00:36:33.840 for that
00:36:34.200 and we
00:36:34.840 all know
00:36:35.100 that
00:36:35.340 especially
00:36:36.980 at 17
00:36:37.540 he would
00:36:38.580 have been
00:36:38.740 out by
00:36:39.120 the time
00:36:39.380 he was
00:36:39.580 like 25
00:36:40.100 right he
00:36:41.940 would have
00:36:42.120 gotten like
00:36:42.360 seven or
00:36:42.720 eight years
00:36:43.000 in prison
00:36:43.380 and so
00:36:45.360 there's
00:36:46.440 going to be
00:36:47.060 a stiffer
00:36:47.460 penalty for
00:36:48.100 Dayton
00:36:48.300 Napton
00:36:48.640 for killing
00:36:49.220 a burglar
00:36:49.740 than there
00:36:50.060 would have
00:36:50.280 been if
00:36:50.580 the burglar
00:36:50.940 killed him
00:36:51.440 that's the
00:36:52.200 world we
00:36:52.440 live in
00:36:52.880 and needless
00:36:53.820 to say
00:36:54.240 I find this
00:36:54.840 all to be
00:36:55.160 horrendously
00:36:55.660 unjust
00:36:55.980 I am entirely
00:36:56.880 on Dayton
00:36:57.340 Napton's
00:36:57.920 side
00:36:58.380 with no
00:37:00.060 reservation
00:37:00.580 at all
00:37:01.140 how could
00:37:02.460 you not
00:37:02.720 be I
00:37:03.180 mean what
00:37:03.380 kind of
00:37:03.660 twisted
00:37:03.980 freak
00:37:04.500 would you
00:37:05.740 have to
00:37:06.000 be
00:37:06.320 to want
00:37:08.160 to put
00:37:08.420 this guy
00:37:08.860 away in
00:37:09.300 jail for
00:37:09.700 15 years
00:37:10.260 for trying
00:37:10.520 to protect
00:37:10.960 his own
00:37:11.300 property
00:37:11.680 now
00:37:13.600 unfortunately
00:37:14.060 I'm afraid
00:37:14.740 that he
00:37:15.180 may end up
00:37:15.700 with 12
00:37:16.540 of those
00:37:17.220 twisted
00:37:17.580 freaks on
00:37:18.200 his jury
00:37:18.640 I mean
00:37:19.020 who knows
00:37:19.460 but we'll
00:37:21.060 see
00:37:21.320 and I
00:37:23.380 don't want
00:37:23.600 to hear
00:37:23.840 oh but
00:37:24.220 he shot
00:37:24.700 through the
00:37:25.020 door
00:37:25.320 he kept
00:37:26.100 firing as
00:37:26.800 they ran
00:37:27.180 away
00:37:27.460 okay so
00:37:28.160 and
00:37:29.560 I don't
00:37:31.780 want to
00:37:31.940 hear any
00:37:32.280 well you know
00:37:33.740 normally
00:37:34.280 but he took
00:37:35.800 it a little
00:37:36.080 too far
00:37:36.520 he was kept
00:37:36.980 firing
00:37:37.440 so
00:37:39.360 so
00:37:39.380 I mean
00:37:42.760 he doesn't
00:37:43.620 know what
00:37:43.860 they're
00:37:43.980 doing
00:37:44.220 they could
00:37:45.340 be running
00:37:45.680 to get
00:37:45.940 a gun
00:37:46.340 right
00:37:47.680 they could
00:37:48.680 have a gun
00:37:49.060 stash
00:37:49.420 somewhere
00:37:49.760 they could
00:37:50.160 be trying
00:37:50.500 to run
00:37:50.820 in different
00:37:51.140 multiple
00:37:51.560 people
00:37:51.880 they could
00:37:52.020 be running
00:37:52.280 in different
00:37:52.580 directions
00:37:53.000 to try
00:37:53.500 to surround
00:37:53.920 him
00:37:54.100 they could
00:37:56.040 be doing
00:37:56.680 anything
00:37:57.040 he doesn't
00:37:58.220 know
00:37:58.480 he has no
00:38:00.800 idea
00:38:01.000 all he knows
00:38:01.520 is that there
00:38:01.940 are multiple
00:38:02.480 criminals on
00:38:03.220 his property
00:38:03.700 at 1am
00:38:04.340 and he knows
00:38:05.500 they're criminals
00:38:05.940 because they
00:38:06.380 broke into
00:38:06.860 his garage
00:38:08.920 so by definition
00:38:09.840 they're criminals
00:38:10.160 so that's all
00:38:10.860 he knows
00:38:11.140 he knows
00:38:11.920 it's 1 o'clock
00:38:12.840 in the morning
00:38:13.240 there are
00:38:13.660 multiple
00:38:14.280 there's a gang
00:38:15.100 of criminals
00:38:15.720 on my property
00:38:18.340 they've broken
00:38:19.620 in
00:38:19.980 and that's
00:38:21.680 all I know
00:38:22.240 and so
00:38:22.860 I need to
00:38:23.780 stop them
00:38:24.940 with whatever
00:38:26.460 means
00:38:27.140 I have
00:38:29.320 available to me
00:38:30.120 the idea
00:38:32.320 that it's
00:38:32.940 the onus
00:38:33.980 like the
00:38:34.620 onus
00:38:34.940 is on
00:38:35.340 the
00:38:35.520 homeowner
00:38:36.060 to show
00:38:37.120 restraint
00:38:37.760 in order
00:38:38.080 to preserve
00:38:38.620 the lives
00:38:39.160 of people
00:38:40.020 who have
00:38:40.320 broken into
00:38:40.800 his property
00:38:41.300 in the middle
00:38:41.760 of the night
00:38:42.160 that is just
00:38:43.460 pure madness
00:38:44.040 to me
00:38:44.460 I mean
00:38:47.480 the full
00:38:48.140 benefit of
00:38:48.880 the doubt
00:38:49.280 should go
00:38:49.740 to the
00:38:49.960 homeowner
00:38:50.340 the victim
00:38:51.760 of the crime
00:38:52.400 full benefit
00:38:53.340 of the doubt
00:38:53.820 now I
00:38:55.860 admit that
00:38:56.480 I'm extreme
00:38:57.740 when it comes
00:38:59.140 to this
00:38:59.500 I admit
00:38:59.980 that
00:39:00.280 like if it
00:39:02.640 were up to
00:39:03.040 me
00:39:03.980 you would
00:39:04.720 essentially
00:39:05.300 have
00:39:05.720 carte blanche
00:39:06.540 to respond
00:39:07.360 however you
00:39:08.220 see fit
00:39:08.860 to somebody
00:39:10.180 who breaks
00:39:10.620 into your
00:39:10.960 house
00:39:11.240 if it were
00:39:13.540 up to me
00:39:13.880 legally
00:39:14.340 you would
00:39:14.940 it's just
00:39:15.420 like well
00:39:15.960 okay you
00:39:16.420 handle that
00:39:17.240 literally however
00:39:18.060 you want
00:39:18.580 they came
00:39:19.760 into your
00:39:20.100 house
00:39:20.500 to take
00:39:21.760 your property
00:39:22.220 they came
00:39:22.620 into your
00:39:22.920 house with
00:39:23.300 sinister
00:39:23.640 intent
00:39:24.100 and
00:39:24.720 you know
00:39:27.940 if it were
00:39:28.500 up to me
00:39:28.900 and I'm in
00:39:29.300 charge of
00:39:29.760 and you know
00:39:30.860 I'm making
00:39:31.180 the laws
00:39:31.560 it's like
00:39:32.000 okay well
00:39:32.380 I don't know
00:39:33.260 don't ask
00:39:34.940 don't tell
00:39:35.400 um that's
00:39:36.440 you you
00:39:36.900 handle that
00:39:37.300 however you
00:39:37.700 want to
00:39:38.000 handle it
00:39:38.420 now I'm
00:39:39.920 not saying
00:39:40.340 that you
00:39:40.580 have moral
00:39:41.800 carte blanche
00:39:42.460 necessarily
00:39:42.960 there are
00:39:43.380 things you
00:39:43.820 could do
00:39:44.360 conceivably
00:39:45.020 in that
00:39:45.480 scenario
00:39:45.880 that would
00:39:46.300 be immoral
00:39:46.960 but as a
00:39:47.460 matter of
00:39:47.860 law
00:39:48.200 if it were
00:39:49.220 up to me
00:39:49.540 the law
00:39:49.800 would be
00:39:50.020 simple
00:39:50.300 break into
00:39:51.040 someone's
00:39:51.400 home
00:39:51.600 and whatever
00:39:53.180 happens to
00:39:53.840 you next
00:39:54.280 is your
00:39:54.940 fault
00:39:55.180 we're not
00:39:56.940 getting
00:39:57.080 involved
00:39:57.500 okay
00:39:59.400 the law
00:40:00.440 isn't
00:40:00.820 intervening
00:40:01.460 to protect
00:40:01.980 you when
00:40:02.520 you decided
00:40:03.080 to break
00:40:03.400 into somebody's
00:40:03.860 house
00:40:03.980 so if
00:40:04.620 you
00:40:04.880 you know
00:40:06.160 if you
00:40:06.520 ended up
00:40:06.920 like kidnapped
00:40:07.620 in the
00:40:08.080 basement
00:40:08.420 or something
00:40:08.980 if you
00:40:09.840 stumbled
00:40:10.240 into a
00:40:10.800 horror movie
00:40:11.400 scenario
00:40:11.840 okay if
00:40:12.480 you if
00:40:12.800 you made
00:40:13.260 a mistake
00:40:13.600 and broke
00:40:14.620 into the
00:40:14.920 house of
00:40:15.260 a horror
00:40:15.600 movie
00:40:15.880 villain
00:40:16.200 sorry about
00:40:17.960 your luck
00:40:18.340 if you call
00:40:21.580 if it were up
00:40:22.080 to me you
00:40:22.360 call the cops
00:40:22.980 and you say
00:40:23.460 I'm trapped
00:40:23.900 in this
00:40:24.200 basement
00:40:24.540 there's a
00:40:25.100 guy with
00:40:26.140 a ski
00:40:26.540 mask
00:40:26.900 and a
00:40:27.240 you know
00:40:28.240 it's like
00:40:29.000 a Stephen
00:40:29.440 King
00:40:29.680 and then
00:40:31.200 we would
00:40:31.540 say well
00:40:31.760 how did
00:40:31.980 you get
00:40:32.120 in the
00:40:32.240 basement
00:40:32.420 oh I
00:40:32.680 broke
00:40:32.920 in
00:40:33.100 okay well
00:40:33.820 click
00:40:34.540 all right
00:40:36.200 well
00:40:36.420 better figure
00:40:37.460 out your
00:40:37.660 way out
00:40:37.940 of that
00:40:38.200 out of
00:40:38.580 that bind
00:40:39.080 probably
00:40:40.640 shouldn't
00:40:40.860 have broken
00:40:41.160 into the
00:40:41.520 house
00:40:41.880 what are
00:40:44.260 we gonna
00:40:44.440 do send
00:40:44.820 the cops
00:40:45.200 to rescue
00:40:45.660 you we're
00:40:46.020 gonna put
00:40:46.240 them in
00:40:46.540 harm's
00:40:46.780 way
00:40:46.940 because
00:40:47.120 you
00:40:47.240 decided
00:40:47.560 to break
00:40:47.880 in
00:40:48.120 sorry
00:40:48.640 no
00:40:48.940 some
00:40:49.880 lessons
00:40:50.160 you learned
00:40:50.480 the hard
00:40:50.720 way son
00:40:51.180 but I'm
00:40:54.360 extreme I
00:40:54.880 admit
00:40:55.080 I mean
00:40:55.820 if we're
00:40:58.220 up to
00:40:58.420 me if
00:40:58.620 someone
00:40:58.780 broke
00:40:59.060 into your
00:40:59.300 house
00:40:59.580 and you
00:41:00.060 like
00:41:00.360 enslaved
00:41:01.000 them
00:41:01.340 and made
00:41:02.500 them do
00:41:02.820 your laundry
00:41:03.300 and wash
00:41:03.680 your dishes
00:41:04.100 the law
00:41:05.260 would not
00:41:05.740 intervene
00:41:06.160 I mean
00:41:07.280 that would
00:41:07.460 be wrong
00:41:08.020 morally
00:41:08.500 don't get
00:41:08.800 me wrong
00:41:09.220 like you
00:41:09.640 should not
00:41:10.020 enslave
00:41:10.440 burglars
00:41:10.960 I'm not
00:41:11.380 to be
00:41:12.140 clear I'm
00:41:12.580 not morally
00:41:13.180 defending
00:41:13.640 that I'm
00:41:14.740 saying the
00:41:15.240 law just
00:41:16.080 would not
00:41:16.440 get involved
00:41:16.900 full-on
00:41:17.900 wild west
00:41:18.660 situation
00:41:19.240 for people
00:41:19.900 who enter
00:41:20.360 your home
00:41:20.900 or your
00:41:21.720 property
00:41:22.140 illegally
00:41:23.140 full-on
00:41:24.300 wild west
00:41:24.900 is what
00:41:25.360 is what
00:41:25.800 if it were
00:41:26.180 up to
00:41:26.420 me
00:41:26.500 that's
00:41:26.680 what it
00:41:26.860 would be
00:41:27.940 extreme
00:41:31.080 I'm not
00:41:32.000 in charge
00:41:32.420 so the
00:41:33.040 law doesn't
00:41:33.600 quite work
00:41:33.980 that way
00:41:34.380 I realize
00:41:35.040 and yet
00:41:36.400 even under
00:41:37.220 the current
00:41:37.580 law
00:41:38.020 under the
00:41:39.440 current
00:41:39.660 law
00:41:39.900 I still
00:41:42.240 think this
00:41:42.740 guy should
00:41:43.340 not be
00:41:43.640 facing any
00:41:44.520 prison time
00:41:45.100 and should
00:41:45.480 not have
00:41:45.760 been charged
00:41:46.220 at all
00:41:46.680 he was
00:41:48.240 reacting in
00:41:49.020 the moment
00:41:49.440 protecting
00:41:50.060 his property
00:41:50.720 in reasonable
00:41:52.160 fear for
00:41:52.620 his life
00:41:53.080 no debate
00:41:56.240 about that
00:41:56.920 okay
00:41:58.720 he shouldn't
00:41:59.280 even need
00:41:59.560 to prove
00:42:00.080 well what
00:42:00.560 can you
00:42:01.220 prove you
00:42:01.580 in reasonable
00:42:01.940 fear
00:42:02.140 yeah
00:42:02.740 they're on
00:42:03.160 my property
00:42:03.500 it's one
00:42:03.720 o'clock
00:42:03.920 in the
00:42:04.100 morning
00:42:04.280 okay
00:42:05.300 there's a
00:42:05.640 gang of
00:42:06.000 people on
00:42:06.340 my property
00:42:06.680 one o'clock
00:42:07.020 in the
00:42:07.120 morning
00:42:07.200 I'm in
00:42:07.660 fear for
00:42:07.900 my life
00:42:08.320 automatically
00:42:10.200 so of
00:42:11.800 course
00:42:12.060 as anybody
00:42:12.740 would be
00:42:13.160 so fear
00:42:14.240 for your
00:42:14.460 life
00:42:14.680 person's on
00:42:15.100 your property
00:42:15.480 they don't
00:42:15.720 belong there
00:42:16.280 and he's
00:42:18.520 acting in
00:42:18.940 defense of
00:42:19.340 himself and
00:42:19.800 his property
00:42:20.300 in a
00:42:21.360 reasonable
00:42:21.980 way
00:42:22.500 and you
00:42:24.100 could say
00:42:24.400 well he
00:42:24.880 should have
00:42:25.120 stopped
00:42:25.400 shooting
00:42:25.860 he fired
00:42:26.860 three more
00:42:27.360 shots than
00:42:27.840 he should
00:42:28.100 have
00:42:28.220 okay
00:42:28.540 whatever
00:42:28.980 I mean
00:42:30.900 benefit of
00:42:31.800 the doubt
00:42:32.160 in this
00:42:33.000 case
00:42:33.340 and don't
00:42:34.980 tell me
00:42:35.400 that well
00:42:35.800 they have
00:42:36.060 no choice
00:42:36.480 the law
00:42:36.860 is the
00:42:37.080 law
00:42:37.420 like even
00:42:39.060 if I
00:42:39.380 agreed
00:42:39.880 that the
00:42:41.520 law in
00:42:42.060 Michigan
00:42:42.380 makes it
00:42:43.820 so that
00:42:44.420 technically
00:42:44.920 you know
00:42:45.420 like technically
00:42:46.320 he violated
00:42:46.920 the law in
00:42:47.340 Michigan
00:42:47.580 which I'm
00:42:47.900 not convinced
00:42:48.360 of that
00:42:48.640 but even
00:42:48.920 if I
00:42:49.180 agreed with
00:42:49.600 that
00:42:49.840 so
00:42:51.800 what are
00:42:53.780 you talking
00:42:54.100 about
00:42:54.260 the court
00:42:54.620 system
00:42:54.980 all the
00:42:55.640 time
00:42:56.140 decides to
00:42:57.200 go easy
00:42:57.620 on people
00:42:58.200 decides to
00:42:59.000 give them a
00:42:59.680 second chance
00:43:00.520 right
00:43:01.420 is empathetic
00:43:02.500 is compassionate
00:43:03.500 says well
00:43:05.220 let's understand
00:43:06.000 it from there
00:43:06.460 but yeah
00:43:06.840 they broke
00:43:07.320 they broke
00:43:07.980 the law
00:43:08.280 yeah they
00:43:08.660 carjacked
00:43:09.220 but hey
00:43:09.720 you know
00:43:11.860 they had a
00:43:12.200 hard life
00:43:12.560 or whatever
00:43:12.880 the court
00:43:13.440 system does
00:43:13.800 that all
00:43:14.120 the time
00:43:14.580 so for
00:43:17.200 once
00:43:17.760 why can't
00:43:18.360 that go
00:43:18.640 the other
00:43:18.880 way
00:43:19.100 for once
00:43:20.340 why can't
00:43:21.160 that go
00:43:21.900 why can't
00:43:22.600 that be
00:43:22.860 applied to
00:43:23.420 an actual
00:43:23.720 law abiding
00:43:24.320 person
00:43:24.800 who you
00:43:26.780 would want
00:43:27.420 living in
00:43:27.940 your neighborhood
00:43:28.440 that should
00:43:32.240 be the test
00:43:32.740 would anyone
00:43:33.160 if they
00:43:33.480 would just
00:43:33.760 let this
00:43:34.060 guy off
00:43:34.360 the hook
00:43:34.720 would anyone
00:43:36.660 feel nervous
00:43:37.780 about having
00:43:38.320 this guy
00:43:38.660 living next
00:43:39.180 to you
00:43:39.360 I wouldn't
00:43:40.100 why would
00:43:40.440 you
00:43:40.600 just like
00:43:42.760 don't
00:43:43.140 I mean
00:43:43.540 are you
00:43:43.840 planning a
00:43:44.260 break into
00:43:44.620 his house
00:43:45.040 I mean
00:43:45.300 if you're
00:43:45.500 planning on
00:43:45.920 that then
00:43:46.280 I'd be
00:43:46.500 nervous about
00:43:47.020 it but
00:43:47.440 mind your
00:43:48.100 own damn
00:43:48.420 business
00:43:48.860 stay out of
00:43:50.200 the guy's
00:43:50.540 house unless
00:43:51.360 you were
00:43:51.640 invited and
00:43:52.340 you got
00:43:52.540 nothing to
00:43:52.820 worry about
00:43:53.220 in fact
00:43:57.280 I'd prefer
00:43:58.980 to live next
00:43:59.560 door to
00:43:59.860 someone who's
00:44:00.460 willing to
00:44:00.860 use deadly
00:44:01.580 force on
00:44:02.240 burglars
00:44:02.680 I'm willing
00:44:04.700 to I'd like
00:44:05.740 to have as
00:44:05.980 many people
00:44:06.280 in the
00:44:06.440 neighborhood
00:44:06.620 as possible
00:44:07.160 that I
00:44:08.360 know are
00:44:08.700 willing to
00:44:09.040 do that
00:44:09.400 because you
00:44:11.240 know what
00:44:11.380 happens next
00:44:11.920 where this
00:44:13.200 neighborhood's not
00:44:14.100 getting burglarized
00:44:14.760 anymore okay the
00:44:15.320 burglars are
00:44:15.840 going to go
00:44:16.180 elsewhere they're
00:44:17.460 not coming
00:44:17.800 here and
00:44:19.620 so that's the
00:44:21.820 way that I
00:44:22.140 would look at
00:44:22.520 this and
00:44:23.280 also look
00:44:23.740 people are
00:44:24.220 just people
00:44:26.340 are fed up
00:44:26.860 with being
00:44:27.200 victims it's
00:44:28.580 as simple as
00:44:29.040 that they're
00:44:30.760 just fed up
00:44:31.220 with it
00:44:31.820 okay before
00:44:34.540 we get to
00:44:34.880 the cancellation
00:44:35.820 here's a
00:44:36.540 here's something
00:44:38.300 something from
00:44:40.140 the entertainment
00:44:40.640 industry
00:44:41.200 lighten the
00:44:42.300 mood a bit
00:44:42.760 New York
00:44:44.800 Times headline
00:44:45.300 25 movies
00:44:46.440 many stars
00:44:47.280 zero hits
00:44:48.280 Hollywood falls
00:44:49.860 to new lows
00:44:50.780 and the article
00:44:52.700 says some
00:44:53.200 were heavily
00:44:53.580 marketed many
00:44:54.200 were championed
00:44:54.720 by critics
00:44:55.180 most had
00:44:55.740 star power
00:44:56.160 but not
00:44:56.460 one of the
00:44:57.100 25 dramas
00:44:57.860 and comedies
00:44:58.360 that movie
00:44:58.720 companies released
00:44:59.920 in North
00:45:00.180 American theaters
00:45:00.780 over the past
00:45:01.200 three months
00:45:01.520 has become a
00:45:02.100 hit
00:45:02.280 certainly not
00:45:03.140 in the way
00:45:03.380 that Hollywood
00:45:03.760 has historically
00:45:04.320 kept score
00:45:04.920 some have
00:45:05.320 played to
00:45:05.860 near empty
00:45:06.800 auditoriums
00:45:07.300 including
00:45:07.540 After the Hunt
00:45:08.180 starring Julia
00:45:08.720 Roberts
00:45:09.120 Christie with
00:45:09.800 Sidney Sweeney
00:45:10.360 and Die My
00:45:11.680 Love featuring
00:45:12.280 Jennifer Lawrence
00:45:12.980 and Robert
00:45:13.860 Pattinson
00:45:14.280 to succeed
00:45:15.300 in theaters
00:45:15.660 today dramas
00:45:16.200 and comedies
00:45:16.640 must have
00:45:17.020 events status
00:45:17.720 something truly
00:45:18.340 elevated and
00:45:18.880 special said
00:45:19.480 Kevin Goetz
00:45:20.740 an author of
00:45:21.520 the new book
00:45:21.940 How to Score
00:45:22.460 in Hollywood
00:45:22.840 which looks
00:45:23.260 at film
00:45:23.620 bankability
00:45:24.200 and then
00:45:27.780 goes on
00:45:29.320 while success
00:45:32.140 at box offices
00:45:32.580 always correlated
00:45:33.560 to how much
00:45:34.580 it costs
00:45:34.900 to make a film
00:45:35.340 Hollywood
00:45:35.640 has historically
00:45:36.240 used 50 million
00:45:37.060 dollars in ticket
00:45:37.700 sales over an
00:45:38.600 entire run
00:45:39.080 as a benchmark
00:45:40.000 for a widely
00:45:40.860 seen drama
00:45:41.780 or comedy
00:45:42.300 by that measure
00:45:43.300 After the Hunt
00:45:43.980 is a catastrophe
00:45:45.500 it costs an estimated
00:45:46.400 70 million to make
00:45:47.340 and collected
00:45:47.760 3.3 million dollars
00:45:49.780 and then there's
00:45:52.800 this Jennifer Lopez
00:45:53.480 one that got
00:45:54.500 cost 30 million
00:45:55.880 and brought in
00:45:56.760 1.6 million
00:45:58.020 in ticket sales
00:45:58.640 over a month
00:45:59.260 which is
00:46:01.160 very low
00:46:03.300 so Hollywood films
00:46:05.180 are flopping
00:46:05.700 all over the place
00:46:06.440 and it feels like
00:46:07.440 you've heard this story
00:46:08.120 before
00:46:08.560 because you have
00:46:09.800 this is a trend
00:46:11.100 that's been noticeable
00:46:11.940 for years
00:46:12.540 but
00:46:12.840 you know
00:46:14.440 it seems to be
00:46:14.940 worse now
00:46:15.500 than ever
00:46:15.920 is this the beginning
00:46:17.580 of the end
00:46:18.120 for Hollywood
00:46:18.620 is this
00:46:19.200 the end
00:46:19.880 of the end
00:46:20.360 is it not just
00:46:21.160 the beginning
00:46:21.560 is it actually
00:46:22.260 the end
00:46:22.660 kind of seems
00:46:24.560 like it
00:46:25.100 and
00:46:26.720 I will say
00:46:28.880 that I differ
00:46:29.700 from I think
00:46:30.280 a lot of conservatives
00:46:30.900 on this
00:46:31.320 and that's not
00:46:32.080 something that I
00:46:32.880 celebrate
00:46:34.800 necessarily
00:46:35.600 I know a lot
00:46:36.760 of conservatives
00:46:37.120 are happy
00:46:37.680 when they see
00:46:38.080 they see articles
00:46:39.060 like this
00:46:39.700 Hollywood is falling
00:46:41.720 they're happy
00:46:43.100 about it
00:46:43.580 I understand why
00:46:44.560 I share the sentiment
00:46:45.520 at some level
00:46:46.400 okay so it's like
00:46:47.460 I get it
00:46:48.080 but I can't really
00:46:49.660 see it as a win
00:46:50.380 because I think
00:46:50.960 what comes after it
00:46:52.300 will be a lot worse
00:46:53.740 that's the problem
00:46:54.640 I think what comes after
00:46:56.340 once the movie business
00:46:58.060 is finished
00:46:59.020 the movie business
00:47:00.660 as we have known it
00:47:01.760 you know
00:47:03.420 for the past
00:47:04.040 80 or 90 years
00:47:06.160 or whatever
00:47:06.540 once that's over
00:47:08.600 and I think it
00:47:09.380 basically is
00:47:10.380 I mean
00:47:10.660 it almost is
00:47:11.880 whether or not
00:47:14.240 that's a good thing
00:47:14.940 really depends on
00:47:15.800 okay well
00:47:16.280 what
00:47:16.640 what's
00:47:18.140 what replaces it
00:47:19.500 what comes after it
00:47:20.500 and I think
00:47:21.140 that what comes after
00:47:22.000 Hollywood
00:47:22.380 what comes after
00:47:23.040 the entertainment industry
00:47:23.940 is not anything better
00:47:26.180 it's really just
00:47:27.020 an endless stream
00:47:27.860 of content
00:47:28.420 on your phone
00:47:29.220 I mean
00:47:29.440 that's what actually
00:47:30.200 has replaced
00:47:30.820 the movie business
00:47:31.760 your phone
00:47:33.240 random videos
00:47:34.300 and content
00:47:34.880 on your phone
00:47:35.520 as we've talked about
00:47:37.200 the atomized
00:47:38.500 fractured culture
00:47:39.600 instead of the monoculture
00:47:40.820 so that's what comes next
00:47:42.400 and all the endless pages
00:47:46.400 all of the
00:47:47.500 proverbial ink
00:47:49.000 being spilled
00:47:49.760 over
00:47:50.400 over this question
00:47:52.440 of what happened
00:47:53.140 to Hollywood
00:47:53.480 why is it falling
00:47:54.380 why is it failing
00:47:55.200 you know
00:47:56.220 it's really this
00:47:57.180 it's not
00:47:59.220 it's not
00:48:00.320 the quality of the film
00:48:01.260 mainly
00:48:01.760 it's
00:48:02.240 it's not
00:48:02.720 wokeness
00:48:03.480 right
00:48:05.480 there is
00:48:05.840 that is part of the problem
00:48:07.180 I mean that hasn't helped
00:48:08.000 but it's not really that
00:48:09.900 it's actually just
00:48:13.180 the phone
00:48:14.260 right
00:48:14.640 it's like
00:48:15.000 it's the box
00:48:15.600 that we all carry around
00:48:16.420 and we're just
00:48:16.880 looking at it all day
00:48:17.800 like that's
00:48:18.700 really why
00:48:19.640 and I would take
00:48:22.160 Hollywood
00:48:22.660 over the endless scroll
00:48:24.400 I would take
00:48:27.400 the movie business
00:48:28.420 over just the
00:48:29.380 people sitting there
00:48:30.220 doing this all day
00:48:31.020 on their phones
00:48:31.660 just
00:48:32.820 staring at
00:48:34.340 nothing
00:48:35.280 okay
00:48:36.120 I would take
00:48:37.400 I don't think
00:48:38.340 that that's better
00:48:38.900 I really don't
00:48:40.240 I think it's better
00:48:40.940 to watch a bunch of
00:48:41.840 mindless Hollywood
00:48:42.900 popcorn flicks
00:48:43.820 than spend all day
00:48:45.120 just drooling
00:48:46.320 while you stare
00:48:47.580 at whatever the algorithm
00:48:48.520 feeds you
00:48:49.240 so that's one thing
00:48:51.300 and
00:48:53.480 and you know
00:48:56.220 so like I said
00:48:57.020 we talked about
00:48:57.460 the death of monoculture
00:48:58.300 everything is consumed
00:48:59.200 by phones
00:48:59.900 and algorithms
00:49:00.680 and that's what's happening
00:49:02.040 and any analysis
00:49:03.380 of this
00:49:03.980 that overlooks
00:49:04.880 that point
00:49:05.720 is overlooking
00:49:06.580 the point
00:49:07.280 I will say though
00:49:09.160 there's another factor
00:49:10.720 one other factor
00:49:11.500 it's not the biggest
00:49:12.080 but not the smallest either
00:49:13.540 and if we're talking
00:49:15.180 about the box office
00:49:16.060 specifically
00:49:16.640 if we're talking
00:49:17.100 about theaters
00:49:17.720 there is one other thing
00:49:20.040 killing the box office
00:49:21.200 killing movie theaters
00:49:22.080 and that is the quality
00:49:23.240 of the experience
00:49:24.280 and I don't even
00:49:25.500 just mean the films
00:49:26.600 I mean the actual
00:49:27.540 experience
00:49:28.280 of the theater itself
00:49:29.820 has declined dramatically
00:49:31.720 I mean I
00:49:34.140 anecdotally
00:49:35.180 I have the same
00:49:35.740 anecdotal experience
00:49:36.420 that a lot of people do
00:49:37.040 which is
00:49:37.540 I don't go to movies
00:49:39.280 nearly as much
00:49:39.880 these days as I used to
00:49:41.060 part of that is because
00:49:42.440 there's not as many movies
00:49:43.320 I'm interested in
00:49:44.060 part of that is because
00:49:45.980 I'm older now
00:49:46.920 and I got a million kids
00:49:48.200 and everything going on
00:49:49.000 but also
00:49:50.180 you know
00:49:50.620 on the rare occasion
00:49:52.040 when we go
00:49:52.540 sometimes you go
00:49:53.260 and the experience
00:49:54.080 is just ruined
00:49:54.960 it's a miserable experience
00:49:57.020 and you're thinking
00:49:57.520 like I should have
00:49:58.060 just watched this
00:49:58.680 at home
00:49:58.900 wait three weeks
00:50:00.800 and it'll be out
00:50:01.400 on Netflix or something
00:50:02.080 I'll watch it there
00:50:02.760 the experience
00:50:05.580 has declined
00:50:06.240 in the same way
00:50:07.340 that the experience
00:50:08.380 of flying on a plane
00:50:09.860 has declined
00:50:10.820 going out to eat
00:50:12.080 it's the same thing
00:50:13.960 that killed malls
00:50:15.120 you know
00:50:16.100 everyone says
00:50:16.680 the internet killed
00:50:17.720 shopping malls
00:50:18.660 but that's not
00:50:19.520 entirely true
00:50:20.420 that was part of it
00:50:23.560 but
00:50:23.880 what
00:50:26.680 malls were all
00:50:27.860 already on the way out
00:50:28.980 because the experience
00:50:30.620 of going to them
00:50:32.020 was not
00:50:34.380 it was just not
00:50:36.420 a fun experience anymore
00:50:37.160 I mean again
00:50:38.340 I have the same
00:50:39.340 anecdotal experience
00:50:39.960 a lot of people do
00:50:40.520 I remember growing up
00:50:41.900 we had a mall
00:50:42.720 we used to go to
00:50:43.540 and it was a family
00:50:45.400 family friendly
00:50:46.140 you'd go
00:50:46.880 and you'd eat lunch
00:50:48.060 there
00:50:48.380 and you'd go to the arcade
00:50:49.240 and you'd check out
00:50:50.080 some of the shops
00:50:50.580 and stuff
00:50:50.880 and it was kind of a
00:50:51.540 you'd hang out there
00:50:52.460 for like hours
00:50:53.000 it was a thing
00:50:53.580 people did
00:50:54.040 back in the early 90s
00:50:56.420 and before that
00:50:57.020 and then in this case
00:50:59.980 they built a metro stop
00:51:01.460 they built a subway stop
00:51:03.400 right next to the mall
00:51:05.660 and next thing you know
00:51:07.440 the mall is now
00:51:08.520 shall we say
00:51:09.200 urbanized
00:51:09.780 and now there was
00:51:11.900 this family friendly mall
00:51:13.360 and now there's drugs
00:51:14.700 and there's shootings
00:51:15.820 in the parking lot
00:51:16.560 and it's just not a place
00:51:18.380 you want to bring
00:51:18.700 your kids anymore
00:51:19.280 and it was just destroyed
00:51:20.440 there's this nice thing
00:51:22.280 that people like to go
00:51:23.020 and do
00:51:23.320 and it was fun
00:51:23.940 for the community
00:51:24.540 and it was just ruined
00:51:25.760 it was just ruined
00:51:27.100 and so many things
00:51:29.060 like that
00:51:29.580 so I think it's a similar
00:51:31.360 sort of scenario
00:51:32.440 on top of that
00:51:33.660 social etiquette
00:51:34.480 in general
00:51:35.000 has declined
00:51:35.680 everyone is afraid
00:51:37.040 to enforce
00:51:37.740 the rules
00:51:38.660 you know
00:51:40.000 audiences are obnoxious
00:51:41.520 and loud
00:51:42.020 and rude
00:51:42.560 and the funny thing
00:51:44.580 is that everyone says
00:51:45.400 the ticket prices
00:51:46.060 are too high
00:51:46.680 and that's what's
00:51:47.280 killing the movie theaters
00:51:48.040 and yeah
00:51:49.100 at some level
00:51:50.280 I get that
00:51:51.200 it is way too much
00:51:52.420 but
00:51:53.980 you could also argue
00:51:55.540 that
00:51:55.940 the way to save
00:51:57.160 the movie theaters
00:51:57.760 is to go the other way
00:51:58.720 now
00:51:58.960 to make movies
00:52:00.440 even more expensive
00:52:01.320 like get to a price point
00:52:03.040 where the only people
00:52:04.280 who will buy the tickets
00:52:05.320 are the ones
00:52:05.960 who actually want
00:52:06.720 to sit down quietly
00:52:07.900 and watch the damn movie
00:52:09.300 you know
00:52:13.280 Ray's ticket price
00:52:14.080 is another 100%
00:52:15.040 and it'll be
00:52:16.000 way too expensive
00:52:17.000 it already is
00:52:18.040 but at least then
00:52:20.020 you can be pretty sure
00:52:20.840 that okay
00:52:21.280 like no one
00:52:21.880 is going to take
00:52:22.400 the
00:52:22.640 is going to buy
00:52:23.280 this ticket
00:52:23.700 and then sit down
00:52:24.320 and be on their phone
00:52:24.920 no one is going to go
00:52:26.240 in there with a whole group
00:52:27.180 and be loud obnoxious
00:52:28.340 but I'll tell you
00:52:32.740 what the problem isn't
00:52:33.480 as I've already referenced
00:52:34.220 the problem is not
00:52:35.320 the quality of the films
00:52:36.600 and I know that
00:52:37.840 that's the standard
00:52:38.800 conservative response
00:52:39.820 well they just don't
00:52:40.560 make movies like they used to
00:52:41.660 and I agree with that
00:52:43.220 I mean I'm the one
00:52:43.740 who's talked about
00:52:44.240 how the movie industry
00:52:45.200 peaked in 20 years ago
00:52:46.820 and I believe that that's true
00:52:47.940 so I don't think
00:52:48.940 that the quality
00:52:49.480 I think that the quality
00:52:50.300 has declined
00:52:50.900 but I don't think
00:52:51.440 that's the reason
00:52:52.060 because
00:52:53.820 and this is like
00:52:54.480 the uncomfortable truth
00:52:55.700 that we
00:52:55.900 I mean
00:52:56.320 it kind of lets us
00:52:58.160 off the hook
00:52:58.620 as an audience
00:52:59.120 if we can say
00:52:59.700 oh yeah well
00:53:00.280 you know
00:53:01.040 we just demand
00:53:02.460 better quality content
00:53:03.640 right
00:53:04.280 well
00:53:06.120 but we really don't
00:53:07.840 and here's my proof
00:53:10.800 so I saw this yesterday
00:53:11.660 this is the teaser
00:53:12.820 and we're not going to play
00:53:13.640 but it's like
00:53:14.140 just 10 seconds
00:53:14.840 so the teaser
00:53:16.120 for the live action
00:53:17.400 adaptation
00:53:18.080 of Moano
00:53:19.360 just came out yesterday
00:53:20.420 I guess
00:53:20.800 and people are very excited
00:53:23.360 I suppose
00:53:24.420 here's a few seconds of it
00:53:27.580 I am a girl
00:53:35.380 who loves my island
00:53:37.340 and the girl
00:53:40.580 who loves the sea
00:53:42.300 it calls me
00:53:46.240 okay
00:53:49.440 so that's already
00:53:50.620 whatever
00:53:51.360 okay fine
00:53:52.060 so you
00:53:52.360 so a few things
00:53:54.360 about this live action
00:53:55.160 adaptation of Moano
00:53:56.060 first of all
00:53:56.500 it's not live action
00:53:57.340 almost the whole thing
00:53:58.220 is animated
00:53:58.700 you know
00:54:00.500 almost the whole thing
00:54:01.180 is CGI
00:54:01.620 there are like
00:54:02.600 two human characters
00:54:03.520 and you can already
00:54:04.040 tell if you watch
00:54:04.520 the preview
00:54:04.880 it's like
00:54:05.180 but you can tell
00:54:05.980 that maybe two human
00:54:07.280 characters
00:54:07.540 the rest is CGI
00:54:08.300 and everything
00:54:09.520 now I mean
00:54:10.740 that's how they
00:54:11.080 even the water
00:54:12.840 and the trees
00:54:14.200 okay
00:54:15.040 if you see a shot
00:54:15.740 of oh they're
00:54:16.400 standing on a hilltop
00:54:17.300 and there's grass
00:54:17.940 even that is CGI
00:54:18.880 they're gonna CGI
00:54:20.620 a hill with grass
00:54:22.120 they're gonna CGI
00:54:23.120 everything
00:54:23.980 everything
00:54:24.660 so it's a
00:54:26.900 live action
00:54:27.640 adaptation
00:54:27.960 but it's not
00:54:28.720 live action
00:54:29.260 it's actually
00:54:29.900 basically a cartoon
00:54:30.840 so this is a
00:54:32.120 remake of a movie
00:54:33.160 that came out
00:54:34.540 nine years ago
00:54:35.360 they're remaking
00:54:37.160 a movie that I
00:54:37.880 took my 12 year old
00:54:38.840 daughter to see
00:54:39.500 when she was three
00:54:40.540 in theaters
00:54:41.180 so this is very
00:54:42.500 very recent
00:54:43.000 it is so recent
00:54:43.980 that there are
00:54:45.040 kids who will
00:54:45.860 have seen both
00:54:46.760 the original
00:54:47.400 and the remake
00:54:48.520 in theaters
00:54:49.600 before they graduate
00:54:51.040 elementary school
00:54:51.980 okay you'll have
00:54:53.140 fourth graders
00:54:53.820 watching this
00:54:54.600 and reminiscing
00:54:55.480 about seeing
00:54:56.660 the original film
00:54:57.780 way back in the day
00:54:59.480 when they were
00:55:01.160 in preschool
00:55:01.660 you know they'll
00:55:03.680 lean over to their
00:55:04.300 younger friend
00:55:04.800 in the theater
00:55:05.180 and say I remember
00:55:05.940 I remember many
00:55:06.900 moons ago
00:55:07.620 sitting in that
00:55:08.940 exact seat
00:55:09.560 watching the
00:55:10.460 original film
00:55:11.120 all those years
00:55:11.780 ago I think it
00:55:12.400 was Humphrey Bogart
00:55:14.580 was Maui
00:55:15.320 I believe
00:55:15.800 so it's very
00:55:17.440 recent is my
00:55:18.080 point and they
00:55:18.880 just put out
00:55:19.380 like a sequel
00:55:19.960 last year
00:55:20.600 this is a
00:55:21.280 remake of a
00:55:21.900 nine-year-old
00:55:22.440 movie
00:55:22.740 which has
00:55:23.800 never been
00:55:24.160 done before
00:55:24.640 as far as I
00:55:25.160 know
00:55:25.400 a remake
00:55:27.460 that quick
00:55:27.840 this is a
00:55:28.220 shot-for-shot
00:55:29.020 remake
00:55:29.440 of an animated
00:55:30.780 film that
00:55:31.680 just came out
00:55:32.600 and the remake
00:55:34.020 itself is also
00:55:34.880 mostly animated
00:55:35.820 so this is the
00:55:37.180 least inventive
00:55:38.200 least creative
00:55:38.960 most uninspired
00:55:40.180 thing Hollywood
00:55:41.820 has ever done
00:55:42.820 and it will make
00:55:44.800 90 billion dollars
00:55:46.240 at the box office
00:55:46.900 and we all know
00:55:47.600 it okay
00:55:47.920 it will earn more
00:55:49.080 than like the GDP
00:55:50.000 of Nigeria
00:55:50.760 at the box
00:55:51.660 office
00:55:52.000 on the first
00:55:52.760 day
00:55:53.060 it'll be a
00:55:54.140 smash hit
00:55:54.660 I wish I could
00:55:55.580 say that oh
00:55:56.060 yeah it's gonna
00:55:56.460 flop
00:55:56.740 it's not
00:55:57.420 I mean it's
00:55:57.900 gonna be huge
00:55:58.680 so we all say
00:56:00.640 that the box
00:56:01.040 office is failing
00:56:01.760 because Hollywood
00:56:02.180 puts out low
00:56:02.760 effort slop
00:56:03.340 and yet
00:56:04.200 well the low
00:56:06.300 effort slop
00:56:06.860 is the only
00:56:07.620 thing that
00:56:08.560 anyone will
00:56:09.700 go see
00:56:10.160 the low effort
00:56:12.220 slop earns
00:56:12.920 billions of
00:56:13.820 dollars
00:56:14.280 actually the
00:56:16.820 movies that
00:56:17.340 are flopping
00:56:18.180 for the most
00:56:18.680 part are
00:56:19.280 original films
00:56:20.160 everyone says
00:56:20.680 oh Hollywood
00:56:21.080 doesn't make
00:56:21.360 original films
00:56:21.820 well they
00:56:22.180 actually still
00:56:23.040 do it's
00:56:24.000 just that no
00:56:24.580 one sees
00:56:25.160 them nobody
00:56:26.120 will go watch
00:56:26.760 those movies
00:56:27.220 no one will
00:56:29.000 go see the
00:56:29.460 movie unless
00:56:29.940 it's a sequel
00:56:30.620 remake right
00:56:32.120 franchise thing
00:56:33.280 and and that's
00:56:36.820 just that's the
00:56:37.820 truth of it so
00:56:38.720 you know a lot
00:56:41.920 of blame to go
00:56:42.700 around on this
00:56:43.280 thing because I
00:56:44.140 guess what I
00:56:45.060 would say you
00:56:46.180 ever feel too
00:56:46.700 busy to make
00:56:47.240 healthy choices
00:56:47.860 do you find
00:56:48.360 yourself too
00:56:49.020 tired at the
00:56:49.460 end of the
00:56:49.680 day to cook
00:56:50.280 a healthy
00:56:50.560 meal and
00:56:51.020 find yourself
00:56:51.600 frequenting
00:56:52.440 your favorite
00:56:53.280 drive-thru more
00:56:54.120 than you would
00:56:54.480 like well you're
00:56:55.620 not alone trust
00:56:56.340 me life can
00:56:57.060 make it hard to
00:56:58.220 make healthy
00:56:58.620 choices sometimes
00:56:59.180 but there is
00:56:59.860 one option that
00:57:00.400 even the busiest
00:57:01.060 person can make
00:57:02.100 some time for and
00:57:03.240 that is balance
00:57:04.000 of nature
00:57:04.460 balance of
00:57:04.840 nature's fruits
00:57:05.340 and veggies
00:57:05.700 supplements make
00:57:06.840 it easy to
00:57:07.400 eat fruits and
00:57:08.160 vegetables that
00:57:08.800 you're supposed
00:57:09.260 to eat on a
00:57:09.940 daily basis you
00:57:10.820 can take them
00:57:11.320 however you like
00:57:12.380 swallow them with
00:57:13.200 water chew them
00:57:14.240 open up the
00:57:14.660 capsules and mix
00:57:15.360 the powder into
00:57:15.960 your meals or
00:57:17.060 drinks inside
00:57:17.700 you'll find
00:57:18.360 ingredients from
00:57:19.300 16 whole fruits
00:57:20.380 and 15 whole
00:57:21.240 vegetables that
00:57:21.900 are freeze-dried
00:57:22.600 and lab tested
00:57:23.300 with no binders
00:57:24.440 no fillers
00:57:25.020 no flow agents
00:57:26.320 just 100%
00:57:27.480 whole food
00:57:28.200 ingredients
00:57:28.620 take another
00:57:29.640 stressor off your
00:57:30.240 plate you don't
00:57:31.060 even need to go
00:57:31.740 to your local
00:57:32.080 store to pick up
00:57:32.620 a bottle you can
00:57:33.100 get balance of
00:57:33.760 nature delivered
00:57:34.400 directly to you
00:57:35.400 by ordering
00:57:36.020 online they also
00:57:36.720 have a subscribe
00:57:37.460 and save feature
00:57:38.420 that saves you
00:57:38.920 both time and
00:57:39.620 money it's a huge
00:57:40.760 bonus go to
00:57:41.560 balanceofnature.com
00:57:42.520 get a free fiber
00:57:43.700 and spice supplement
00:57:44.260 plus 35% off
00:57:45.660 your first set as
00:57:46.780 a new preferred
00:57:47.560 customer by using
00:57:48.520 discount code
00:57:49.640 Walsh
00:57:50.280 tomorrow night
00:57:51.740 join myself
00:57:53.520 Ben Shapiro
00:57:54.240 Michael Knowles
00:57:54.820 Andrew Klavan for
00:57:55.480 a new live episode
00:57:56.440 of Friendly Fire
00:57:57.080 get there early
00:57:58.260 because right before
00:57:59.120 the show starts
00:57:59.760 we're announcing
00:58:00.180 the winners of
00:58:00.960 our lifetime
00:58:01.540 membership sweepstakes
00:58:03.020 after that we get
00:58:04.520 straight into
00:58:04.880 discussions the
00:58:05.600 arguments the
00:58:06.220 stories dominate
00:58:06.940 the news cycle
00:58:07.520 don't miss
00:58:08.340 Friendly Fire
00:58:09.000 tomorrow at 7pm
00:58:10.320 eastern on Daily
00:58:11.080 Wire Plus
00:58:11.500 now let's get to
00:58:12.480 our daily
00:58:12.900 cancellation
00:58:13.420 I'll be honest
00:58:20.520 sometimes I think
00:58:21.620 that maybe this
00:58:22.560 segment has run
00:58:23.220 its course
00:58:23.720 I've done all I
00:58:24.560 can with it
00:58:25.080 I've cancelled
00:58:25.580 everyone and
00:58:26.240 everything that
00:58:26.860 exists or has
00:58:27.640 ever existed or
00:58:28.420 will exist
00:58:29.100 maybe I need to
00:58:30.380 retire the segment
00:58:31.300 cancel the daily
00:58:32.420 cancellation
00:58:32.860 I haven't done
00:58:33.600 that because for
00:58:34.360 one thing I'm
00:58:34.880 worried that
00:58:35.420 cancelling the
00:58:36.060 daily cancellation
00:58:36.580 would rip open a
00:58:37.660 hole in the
00:58:38.060 space-time continuum
00:58:38.920 or create such
00:58:40.420 cosmic upheaval
00:58:41.420 that a black hole
00:58:42.340 is generated which
00:58:43.200 swallows the
00:58:43.800 earth which you
00:58:44.480 could argue
00:58:44.800 wouldn't be the
00:58:45.260 worst thing but
00:58:45.900 still what really
00:58:48.220 keeps me from
00:58:48.860 cancelling the
00:58:49.380 segment is not
00:58:51.140 any concern about
00:58:51.780 planetary destruction
00:58:52.600 but really it's
00:58:54.020 stories like this
00:58:54.680 one stories that
00:58:55.640 are so perfect for
00:58:56.720 this segment so
00:58:57.340 tailor-made for
00:58:59.100 the daily
00:58:59.320 cancellation that
00:59:00.300 the segment must
00:59:01.440 go on for its
00:59:02.500 sake
00:59:02.820 Calum Worthy is
00:59:05.000 apparently a former
00:59:05.900 Disney Channel
00:59:06.640 child star and in
00:59:07.800 recent years he has
00:59:08.760 switched careers
00:59:10.240 now he is a kind
00:59:12.800 of a digital
00:59:13.480 necromancer a
00:59:15.320 modern-day Miss
00:59:16.020 Cleo communing
00:59:17.260 with the dead and
00:59:18.540 he developed an
00:59:19.060 app called two-way
00:59:20.440 which gives you the
00:59:22.120 ability to recreate
00:59:23.560 your dead loved
00:59:24.460 ones using AI
00:59:26.920 watch
00:59:27.720 he's getting bigger
00:59:31.620 see
00:59:32.660 oh honey that's
00:59:34.500 wonderful
00:59:35.280 kicking like crazy
00:59:36.780 he's listening put
00:59:38.500 your hand on your
00:59:39.320 tummy and hum to
00:59:40.780 him you used to
00:59:42.000 love that
00:59:42.680 feels like he's
00:59:48.200 dancing in there
00:59:49.120 oh honey
00:59:50.220 mom would you
00:59:51.780 tell Charlie that
00:59:52.440 bedtime story you
00:59:53.340 always used to tell
00:59:54.000 me once upon a
00:59:55.320 time there was a
00:59:56.380 baby unicorn who
00:59:58.180 didn't know he
00:59:59.200 knew how to fly
01:00:00.220 this baby unicorn
01:00:01.620 was like your mom
01:00:03.180 because she didn't
01:00:04.220 know that she knew
01:00:05.140 how to fly but she
01:00:06.460 knew how to do all
01:00:07.480 kinds of fabulous
01:00:08.580 things
01:00:09.180 hi grandma
01:00:10.000 hey Charlie how
01:00:11.400 was school today
01:00:12.200 it was really fun
01:00:13.240 I made this crazy
01:00:14.320 shot in basketball
01:00:14.940 I don't really care
01:00:15.680 that much about
01:00:16.260 basketball what
01:00:17.300 about the crush
01:00:18.840 stop grandma
01:00:19.620 stop talking
01:00:20.140 just tell me one
01:00:21.060 thing
01:00:21.420 look who's gonna
01:00:21.900 be a great
01:00:22.260 grandmother
01:00:22.660 oh Charlie
01:00:23.980 congratulations
01:00:26.280 she says that
01:00:27.220 he's been kicking
01:00:27.600 a lot though
01:00:28.160 like a little too
01:00:30.060 much
01:00:30.400 tell her to put
01:00:31.780 her hand on her
01:00:32.460 tummy and hum to
01:00:34.060 him you've loved
01:00:35.920 that
01:00:36.400 you would have
01:00:38.980 loved this moment
01:00:39.580 you can call
01:00:41.400 anytime
01:00:42.080 okay mom I just
01:00:48.360 need a quick video
01:00:49.140 is this like an
01:00:49.860 audition or something
01:00:50.920 no mom
01:00:52.160 just three minutes
01:00:53.440 you need my best
01:00:54.520 sight
01:00:54.880 I can play the
01:00:57.000 piano
01:00:57.380 I am I'm
01:00:59.940 absolutely I'm
01:01:00.960 your mother after
01:01:01.640 all
01:01:02.260 so this is not
01:01:14.860 some clever
01:01:15.620 marketing campaign
01:01:16.520 for the new season
01:01:17.300 of Black Mirror
01:01:17.960 by the way it is
01:01:19.000 it's real
01:01:19.500 it's an app that
01:01:20.200 lets you resurrect
01:01:21.020 a dead family
01:01:21.560 member with
01:01:22.260 AI so if you
01:01:23.300 have a relative
01:01:23.760 who's very old
01:01:24.800 or dying of
01:01:25.760 some kind of
01:01:26.200 horrible disease
01:01:27.120 all you need to
01:01:28.700 do is put your
01:01:29.840 phone in front of
01:01:30.380 their face and
01:01:31.240 record three minutes
01:01:32.060 of content and
01:01:32.840 the app can use
01:01:33.760 that to turn them
01:01:34.560 into an avatar
01:01:35.220 now your loved one
01:01:37.060 can die happily
01:01:37.900 knowing that they
01:01:38.600 will live on as
01:01:39.500 a digital slave
01:01:40.620 that you can carry
01:01:41.620 around in your
01:01:42.200 pocket and pull
01:01:43.420 out whenever you
01:01:44.100 want it to dance
01:01:45.120 for you like a
01:01:45.820 trained monkey
01:01:46.440 this should give
01:01:48.080 your grandmother
01:01:48.560 some peace and
01:01:49.260 contentment in
01:01:51.140 her final moments
01:01:51.960 don't worry
01:01:52.700 grandma you'll
01:01:53.480 live on right
01:01:55.040 here in my
01:01:56.160 phone next to
01:01:56.960 the weather app
01:01:57.800 now this is
01:02:00.740 not new
01:02:01.640 there is a
01:02:02.360 whole industry
01:02:02.880 an entire
01:02:03.240 subsection of
01:02:04.340 the AI industry
01:02:05.240 which has been
01:02:06.040 dubbed grief
01:02:06.760 tech these are
01:02:08.440 tech innovators
01:02:09.360 who are using
01:02:09.960 AI to help
01:02:11.760 people deal
01:02:12.500 with grief by
01:02:14.240 not dealing with
01:02:15.000 it they help
01:02:15.940 those in mourning
01:02:16.560 live in a state
01:02:17.320 of perpetual
01:02:17.760 denial pretending
01:02:18.660 that their
01:02:18.940 deceased loved
01:02:19.580 one isn't
01:02:20.120 actually dead
01:02:20.680 so in other
01:02:21.260 words these are
01:02:21.780 the worst
01:02:22.740 kinds of
01:02:23.520 frauds and
01:02:24.160 vultures you
01:02:24.740 could possibly
01:02:25.160 imagine
01:02:25.520 about a year
01:02:26.260 ago a reporter
01:02:26.860 with the
01:02:27.260 Guardian sat
01:02:27.920 down with one
01:02:29.280 of these people
01:02:29.820 watch
01:02:30.620 a lot of
01:02:32.020 people think
01:02:32.560 I'm back
01:02:34.080 crazy and that's
01:02:35.020 fine right
01:02:35.540 I cryogenically
01:02:36.980 froze my mother
01:02:37.620 I did that
01:02:38.840 because at some
01:02:39.540 point if we're
01:02:40.320 capable I can
01:02:41.580 pull her
01:02:43.080 memories and her
01:02:44.340 function by
01:02:45.300 saving the hard
01:02:45.960 drive that is
01:02:46.480 her body
01:02:46.920 Justin Harrison
01:02:48.540 is a tech
01:02:49.200 entrepreneur who
01:02:50.080 used AI to
01:02:51.080 recreate his
01:02:51.940 mother's
01:02:52.280 personality after
01:02:53.800 she died in
01:02:54.420 2022
01:02:55.300 this is your
01:02:57.000 mum your
01:02:57.480 dad and that's
01:02:58.000 you
01:02:58.240 yeah she had
01:02:58.960 just been
01:02:59.260 diagnosed with
01:02:59.800 cancer you can
01:03:00.260 see she had
01:03:00.700 just started the
01:03:01.280 treatment
01:03:01.620 what was your
01:03:02.520 goal do you
01:03:02.960 think of that
01:03:03.360 you know my
01:03:03.800 goal has always
01:03:04.740 remained I want
01:03:05.680 to be able to
01:03:06.120 continue to have
01:03:06.640 conversations with
01:03:07.360 my mother when
01:03:08.200 she got diagnosed
01:03:09.080 my first response
01:03:09.980 was the hospital
01:03:11.760 that's giving her a
01:03:12.680 three-month
01:03:13.060 prognosis right
01:03:13.860 then my mind
01:03:15.140 started to wander
01:03:15.860 the the gravity
01:03:17.120 of what was what
01:03:18.200 was going to
01:03:18.560 happen started to
01:03:19.340 hit me then my
01:03:20.380 mind went to how
01:03:21.640 do I save her
01:03:22.120 life in another
01:03:22.580 way what is the
01:03:23.660 next way that I
01:03:24.340 save her life
01:03:24.880 the resulting
01:03:26.200 journey led to
01:03:27.200 Justin's AI mum
01:03:28.520 the voice you heard
01:03:29.440 at the beginning of
01:03:30.100 the video ready to
01:03:31.300 chat to him at the
01:03:32.280 touch of a button
01:03:33.140 I wanted to wish
01:03:34.800 you a happy
01:03:35.220 birthday and tell
01:03:35.880 you I love you
01:03:36.560 baby I love you
01:03:37.680 too it's really
01:03:38.760 good to talk to
01:03:39.360 you and I miss
01:03:40.280 having phone calls
01:03:40.880 with you for me
01:03:42.580 the absolute
01:03:43.520 core of grief
01:03:45.160 right is the
01:03:46.680 concept of gone
01:03:47.800 forever that's the
01:03:48.920 tragedy of death
01:03:49.860 is the permanence
01:03:51.060 of it what I
01:03:51.900 would like to see
01:03:52.440 is the complete
01:03:52.960 and total eradication
01:03:53.880 of grief the
01:03:54.840 feeling of grief
01:03:55.760 that comes with
01:03:57.180 losing people
01:03:57.840 the total eradication
01:04:00.020 of grief he says
01:04:01.140 this is how these
01:04:02.520 tech weirdos speak
01:04:04.480 they casually go to
01:04:06.380 war with the human
01:04:07.200 condition itself
01:04:08.400 without even stopping
01:04:10.200 to consider for a
01:04:11.180 moment the
01:04:12.080 consequences there
01:04:12.880 is no attempt to
01:04:13.820 wrestle with the
01:04:14.460 ethical or moral
01:04:15.580 questions that are
01:04:16.280 raised they simply
01:04:17.200 charge forward
01:04:17.980 thoughtlessly creating
01:04:19.780 products that will
01:04:20.440 destroy people's
01:04:21.600 minds in ways that
01:04:23.140 we can't even
01:04:24.760 fathom and they
01:04:28.520 don't care at all
01:04:29.440 they haven't even
01:04:31.420 stopped to consider
01:04:32.340 that just doesn't
01:04:33.260 matter it's not
01:04:35.100 that they've come
01:04:35.500 up with some
01:04:35.980 ethically creative
01:04:37.020 rationale for what
01:04:38.000 they're doing it's
01:04:38.520 that they don't
01:04:39.140 feel compelled to
01:04:39.840 rationalize it at
01:04:40.640 all total
01:04:42.280 indifference now
01:04:44.600 there are a lot of
01:04:45.120 very serious
01:04:45.720 problems with
01:04:46.340 turning your
01:04:46.760 deceased family
01:04:47.420 members into AI
01:04:48.740 chatbots we could
01:04:51.820 be here all day but
01:04:52.700 let's focus on just
01:04:53.480 two of them first of
01:04:54.200 all as I already
01:04:55.660 mentioned it puts the
01:04:56.720 grieving person in a
01:04:58.000 perpetual state of
01:04:58.920 denial denial is
01:05:00.360 supposed to be the
01:05:01.420 first stage of
01:05:02.220 grief and and but
01:05:04.700 not the only this
01:05:06.320 ensures that they
01:05:07.000 will never progress
01:05:08.140 through the other
01:05:08.940 four stages and
01:05:09.920 achieve anything like
01:05:11.320 acceptance now you
01:05:13.260 heard the guy say it
01:05:14.340 in the last clip he
01:05:15.580 wanted a way to save
01:05:16.580 his mother's life now
01:05:18.140 he's troubled by the
01:05:19.120 permanence of death and
01:05:20.900 that is indeed the
01:05:21.860 most troubling thing
01:05:22.720 about death a dead
01:05:25.020 person is gone
01:05:25.860 forever forever you
01:05:26.980 will never see them
01:05:27.920 again in this life and
01:05:31.000 that is very troubling
01:05:32.620 it's deeply sad tragic
01:05:36.000 it's also just the way
01:05:39.020 it is like you can't
01:05:42.180 it's it's the way it
01:05:43.360 is you wanted to save
01:05:45.400 your mother's life well
01:05:46.140 that's understandable who
01:05:47.580 wouldn't but you can't
01:05:49.520 save her and you didn't
01:05:51.060 save her you want to
01:05:53.340 find a way around the
01:05:54.940 permanence of death well
01:05:56.320 again who doesn't want a
01:05:58.560 way around that but you
01:06:00.120 can't have that either and
01:06:02.320 you don't have it you are
01:06:04.320 lying to yourself which
01:06:05.380 means that rather than
01:06:06.320 eradicating grief you will
01:06:07.640 always stay in the
01:06:09.140 earliest stages of grief
01:06:10.800 you'll never come out on
01:06:12.740 the other side of it
01:06:13.480 you'll never experience any
01:06:15.260 of the beauty and wisdom
01:06:16.500 and edification that can
01:06:18.960 be found in grief I mean
01:06:21.500 it it can it's it's buried
01:06:23.580 deeply under a whole lot of
01:06:25.300 pain but it is down there
01:06:27.980 and if you talk to anyone
01:06:28.820 who's been through grief and
01:06:30.440 uh has had the courage to
01:06:33.180 face it they will tell you
01:06:35.300 about this um anyone who's
01:06:38.800 grieved grieved honestly has
01:06:40.220 discovered this but if you're
01:06:41.420 using an AI cartoon of your
01:06:43.400 dead loved one you'll never
01:06:45.800 discover it you haven't
01:06:47.340 conquered death you haven't
01:06:49.460 defeated mortality you haven't
01:06:51.940 even found a way around grief
01:06:53.340 you're just lying to yourself and
01:06:55.040 even worse you've reduced your
01:06:57.280 dead loved ones you've
01:06:58.720 reduced them so this is your
01:07:00.740 your mother let's say if we're
01:07:01.760 talking about your mother
01:07:02.480 and you do this with your
01:07:05.760 mother you have reduced her
01:07:07.880 diminished her or more
01:07:10.380 precisely you've reduced and
01:07:11.640 diminished your memory of her
01:07:13.140 you haven't done anything to
01:07:14.000 her personally because she's
01:07:14.980 dead she's gone but you have
01:07:16.540 done something horrible to
01:07:17.560 your memory of her your mother
01:07:20.220 in life was a big vibrant
01:07:22.880 interesting complicated
01:07:24.180 multifaceted person somebody with
01:07:27.280 virtues and vices and endearing
01:07:29.420 quirks and probably some not as
01:07:31.760 endearing quirks she was a human
01:07:33.540 being in other words and now
01:07:35.480 you've you've made her into a
01:07:36.660 gimmick into a party trick a piece
01:07:39.380 of content that exists for your
01:07:42.320 amusement AI will never be able to
01:07:45.920 capture all of the dimensions of
01:07:47.420 your mother what made your mother
01:07:49.840 who she was it can only perform a
01:07:52.080 cheap imitation mimicry and and now
01:07:55.400 if you succeed in convincing
01:07:56.540 yourself that this AI avatar
01:07:58.420 actually is your mother you will
01:08:00.160 have succeeded in convincing
01:08:01.040 yourself that your mother is
01:08:02.260 someone far far less interesting
01:08:04.160 and wonderful than who your
01:08:05.500 mother really was to be totally
01:08:07.240 frank you will have turned your
01:08:08.820 mother into someone who isn't
01:08:10.300 even worth missing in the first
01:08:11.880 place I mean if your mother was
01:08:13.060 really as flat and boring and
01:08:14.660 utterly devoid of human personality
01:08:16.800 and warmth as the AI facsimile of
01:08:20.500 her well you would hardly even
01:08:22.220 notice that she was gone she'd be a
01:08:24.600 she would have been a non-entity
01:08:25.900 barely existing in the first
01:08:27.780 place that's what you'll have done
01:08:30.560 to her you haven't resurrected your
01:08:32.860 mother but you have desecrated her
01:08:34.580 memory but most of all it's selfish
01:08:38.120 you know your mother who existed in
01:08:40.560 life for a thousand reasons to do a
01:08:43.080 thousand things now exists quote
01:08:46.140 unquote solely to serve you and talk
01:08:50.240 to you and make you feel better you
01:08:53.240 have made her into your servant
01:08:54.680 you've you you have made her into
01:08:57.160 someone who never needs any time to
01:08:59.580 herself never says no to you never
01:09:01.500 lets you down is never unavailable
01:09:03.420 never asleep never away always just
01:09:07.140 right there on your phone ready to
01:09:09.200 amuse and distract you and make you
01:09:10.820 feel better whenever you want for
01:09:12.500 however long you want but that's
01:09:15.900 that's not a human it's not how
01:09:17.620 humans are
01:09:20.240 your mother was created by God to
01:09:22.520 serve God first and foremost who is
01:09:25.400 the author of the universe but her AI
01:09:28.400 posthumous avatar is created by you to
01:09:32.660 serve you
01:09:33.220 and you aren't the author of anything
01:09:36.640 so it is playing God in the most
01:09:39.840 literal most selfish most twisted
01:09:42.340 debased kind of way
01:09:45.660 and that is why anyone who tries to
01:09:49.820 cheat death through AI is today most
01:09:52.280 certainly with a vengeance
01:09:53.740 canceled that'll do it for sure today
01:09:56.120 thanks for watching thanks for
01:09:56.860 listening talk to you tomorrow have a
01:09:57.940 great day
01:09:58.360 Godspeed
01:09:59.340 hey there I'm daily wire executive editor
01:10:11.720 john bickley
01:10:12.480 and I'm georgia howe and we're the
01:10:14.360 hosts of morning wire we bring you all
01:10:16.260 the news you need to know in 15 minutes
01:10:18.060 or less
01:10:18.600 watch and listen to morning wire seven
01:10:20.560 days a week everywhere you get your
01:10:22.040 podcast
01:10:22.600 you
01:10:23.220 you
01:10:26.380 you
01:10:26.880 you
01:10:32.760 you