The Matt Walsh Show - January 21, 2026


Ep. 1721 - Democrats Are Doubling Down On Their Anti-White Agenda. Here's The Proof.


Episode Stats

Length

1 hour and 14 minutes

Words per Minute

158.26335

Word Count

11,728

Sentence Count

795

Misogynist Sentences

19

Hate Speech Sentences

47


Summary

The Democratic Party is doubling down on its anti-white agenda. Also, Hollywood actress claims she personally witnessed lynchings when she was growing up. And is AI about to completely take over the film industry? Ben Affleck weighs in on that question on Joe Rogan. We ll talk about all that and more today on the Matt Walsh Show.


Transcript

00:00:00.000 Today on the Matt Walsh Show, the Democrat Party is doubling down on its anti-white agenda.
00:00:03.860 If you look at the new Democrat administrations in New York City and Virginia, that is very clear.
00:00:08.660 Also, Hollywood actress claims that she personally witnessed lynchings when she was growing up.
00:00:12.840 That would make sense, maybe, if she was, say, 120 years old or so, which she isn't.
00:00:18.260 And is AI about to completely take over the film industry?
00:00:20.960 Ben Affleck weighs in on that question on Joe Rogan.
00:00:23.460 We'll talk about all that and more today on the Matt Walsh Show.
00:00:30.000 We'll be right back.
00:01:00.000 It's a state now led by a CIA officer and sociopath named Abigail Spanberger.
00:01:06.300 Since taking complete control of the state, Democrats have raced to eliminate penalties for a series of crimes from illegal migration to robbery to DUI for the benefit of the non-white population that commits most of those crimes.
00:01:19.140 In fact, DUIs will no longer carry mandatory prison time in the state.
00:01:23.760 And Spanberger has issued an executive order ending police cooperation with ICE.
00:01:27.740 So it's a real win-win for Virginia's illegal alien community, who, as we know, are big fans of drinking, driving under the influence.
00:01:38.140 Democrats have also moved to formalize anti-white discrimination in government contracting.
00:01:42.800 They're planning to raise taxes on basically everything, including sports facilities, dry cleaning, landscaping, home repairs, digital services.
00:01:50.760 They're adding a new 20-cent tax to every single Amazon delivery and installing surveillance cameras across the state to generate more revenue by fining motorists.
00:01:59.740 They're also dramatically raising income taxes on wealthy individuals who are mostly white in order to fund free education for illegal aliens.
00:02:07.160 They've commenced a new home-based child care provider startup grant program so that more taxpayer money can be funneled to their own, you know, Somali leering centers.
00:02:17.940 They took one look at Minneapolis and decided, hey, we want that in our state.
00:02:23.840 Basically, to sum it up, that's what they're doing.
00:02:26.640 Here's a quote from just one of the bills that Virginia Democrats have introduced to give you an idea.
00:02:32.080 The small SWAM business procurement enhancement program is hereby established to facilitate the participation of small SWAM businesses in state procurement.
00:02:45.260 The goal of the program shall be the achievement of a 42% small SWAM business utilization rate.
00:02:51.920 And the bill continues, quote, the program shall include a small SWAM business set aside for the purchase of good services and construction by executive branch agencies and covered institutions.
00:03:02.160 Purchases up to $100,000 shall be set aside for award to small SWAM businesses.
00:03:09.160 Now, you might be wondering, what is a SWAM, S-W-A-N, and what's a small SWAM?
00:03:17.480 Well, if you go back and look at the definitions, here's what the bill will tell you.
00:03:22.360 Quote, small SWAM business means a small business certified by the department as being small, any subcategory of small, small women-owned, small minority-owned, or small service-disabled veteran-owned.
00:03:36.040 Meanwhile, quote, SWAM means a small women-owned or minority-owned or related to a small women-owned or minority-owned business.
00:03:44.480 So this is one of those cases where they've clearly messed up the acronym.
00:03:48.520 They're talking about small SWAM businesses.
00:03:53.400 They're saying small, small minority-owned businesses.
00:03:56.980 That's what a small SWAM is, a small, small minority-owned business.
00:04:01.300 Not merely small minority-owned business.
00:04:04.240 It's a small, small business that is owned by minorities, whatever all that means.
00:04:10.300 No one ever accused Marxists of being intelligent.
00:04:12.440 But the intent of the bill is clear.
00:04:14.320 The state of Virginia wants more taxpayer money that will flow to minorities.
00:04:18.640 And not because those minorities are the best candidates, but simply because they are not white.
00:04:24.640 If you're a white guy who runs a large business, then you're going to be shut out of contracts under $100,000.
00:04:30.540 A minority-owned business will take that contract from you, unless, of course, you want to hire them as a subcontractor.
00:04:35.940 So if you pay the racial equity fee, then you can get the job.
00:04:40.540 These are policies that, as contractors already know, are the norm in many cases.
00:04:44.620 It's already standard in federal contracting, thanks to the civil rights era.
00:04:48.580 And now Virginia wants to drastically expand this kind of discrimination.
00:04:53.020 Now, it's obviously bad policy that's eventually going to lead to some very obvious, potentially catastrophic outcomes, and already has across the country.
00:04:59.940 And therefore, just to make sure that they never lose power again, Virginia Democrats have also introduced legislation that would make it illegal to count machine-readable ballots by hand,
00:05:10.880 as well as legislation that makes it much easier to obtain and submit absentee ballots without identifying yourself,
00:05:16.760 along with legislation that allows people who are incapacitated to the point that they need a conservatorship to cast ballots.
00:05:24.900 In other words, they're enabling voter fraud on a massive scale.
00:05:28.600 And there are dozens more bills like this.
00:05:32.240 The account Nova Campaigns has cataloged many of them.
00:05:35.760 Now, if you live in Virginia, or if you did live in Virginia as recently as 2018 or so,
00:05:40.820 all of this way back then would have seemed hard to imagine.
00:05:46.200 Democrats in the state were considered to be relatively moderate, all things considered.
00:05:51.980 They certainly weren't anywhere near as far left as, say, California.
00:05:55.040 But that changed when every moderate in the Virginia State House was primaried in 2019 and in the state Senate a few years later.
00:06:03.760 The party is now under the complete control of California Marxists.
00:06:08.360 And now that they've assumed power, they're not wasting any time transforming the entire state to fit their deranged vision.
00:06:17.760 Now, the other day we spent most of the show discussing how leftists continue to destroy the American entertainment industry
00:06:23.700 with terrible writing and communist messaging, pushing DEI and all that.
00:06:29.800 But at the same time, you know, no one takes those shows seriously anymore.
00:06:33.520 They become parodies of themselves.
00:06:35.720 Look all over the internet.
00:06:36.540 You're not going to find, or it will be a challenge to find, a single serious video or post praising the new Star Trek show that we talked about, for example.
00:06:47.640 All the comments on the show's YouTube premiere are negative, and very few people watched it.
00:06:55.340 Although they did premiere it on YouTube and leave the comments on, which is a bold move.
00:06:59.560 And that's just one of many, many indicators that wokeness, to a large degree, has peaked.
00:07:05.580 Axios just asked two dozen prominent Democrats whether men can become women.
00:07:10.720 And like we talked about, virtually all of them ducked the question.
00:07:14.320 The party is trying to move away from some of the fringe, deranged messaging that cost them the last election.
00:07:22.520 But in turn, they're replacing that kind of wokeness with something much more deeply rooted.
00:07:29.560 And more insidious, and potentially much more harmful.
00:07:33.180 And the state of Virginia is exhibit A for what they're planning.
00:07:36.560 Because Democrats have decided to go all in on anti-white hatred.
00:07:42.020 Which every institution in this country has deliberately fostered for at least 60 years now.
00:07:47.560 So it's not going away anytime soon.
00:07:50.520 As the left kind of tries to awkwardly move away from transgenderism, some of the other excesses of the LGBT movement.
00:07:59.560 They are doubling and tripling down on the racial narrative.
00:08:04.180 And we're seeing that in the streets of Minneapolis right now.
00:08:06.780 As they're harassing random white people who just commit the crime of walking down the street or driving.
00:08:14.440 And that racial narrative has proven far more enduring and far more effective.
00:08:19.900 And we know this is a much broader party-wide strategy based on how top Democrats are talking right now.
00:08:27.280 Michelle Obama, for instance, just stated that buying clothes from white designers and white-owned companies is wrong.
00:08:35.180 You need to start practicing wardrobe equity when you're buying your clothing.
00:08:40.480 And this is a clip.
00:08:42.500 This is not a clip from 2020.
00:08:44.040 This is not from the summer of Floyd.
00:08:45.760 This is just this week.
00:08:48.280 Watch.
00:08:50.300 If I hear of someone whose fashion that I like and I know that they're a person of color, I try to make it a point.
00:08:57.780 But the clothes have to be available.
00:09:00.940 You know, I think we can all do some work to think about that balance in our wardrobes.
00:09:06.380 You know, what does our closet look like and who's in it?
00:09:10.740 Who are we supporting in it?
00:09:13.280 Right.
00:09:13.540 You know, and I think if you have the money to buy Chanel, then you have the money to buy everybody.
00:09:19.620 Right.
00:09:20.460 And so let us be mindful, I think, would be my advice.
00:09:25.340 Yeah.
00:09:28.040 So the women all nod as if it's a completely normal thing to say, which for these people it is.
00:09:33.160 You're not allowed to avoid black owned businesses.
00:09:36.960 If you're an Uber driver and you try to avoid high crime areas because you don't want to get carjacked and shot.
00:09:43.120 Your account will be suspended for racism.
00:09:46.200 But if any other race wants to openly discriminate against whites, the Democrat Party will support them wholeheartedly.
00:09:51.780 So before you convince yourself that wokeness has gone away, well, consider the fact that, you know, it's still perfectly acceptable and encouraged to talk about how you want to prioritize patronizing black owned businesses.
00:10:08.720 And yet, even in our age, which is supposedly post woke or whatever, if somebody gets up and says, you know what, I really want to support white owned businesses.
00:10:20.740 That's really important to me because I'm white.
00:10:22.600 I want to support my people.
00:10:23.960 Nothing against anybody else.
00:10:26.200 But, you know, before I buy clothing or go to a restaurant, I just want to make sure that it's owned by a white person.
00:10:31.460 Now, we all know the reaction to that kind of comment.
00:10:37.600 We know how that will go.
00:10:40.120 And it's true, of course, that Democrats have been talking like this for a very long time.
00:10:43.300 But unlike traditional wokeness, they're doubling down on this kind of rhetoric.
00:10:47.180 Everywhere they seize power, they're implementing an anti-white platform.
00:10:51.860 That's why Zoran Mamdani just appointed Afua Atta Mensah to be the chief equity officer of New York.
00:10:59.300 Just a nice, nice traditional American name there.
00:11:03.180 Afua Atta Mensah.
00:11:06.460 Bet you there are a bunch of those fighting in the Revolutionary War.
00:11:09.640 The New York Young Republicans Club has found several posts in which this woman openly attacks white people,
00:11:15.480 which, of course, is the entire reason that Mamdani hired her.
00:11:19.700 In this post, for example, somebody posted his thoughts on the television show Succession.
00:11:24.880 And Mamdani's new equity director responded by saying, quote,
00:11:27.800 quote, tax them to the white meat.
00:11:31.540 Yes, tax them to the white meat.
00:11:35.480 This woman also frequently talks about her comrades and how they're going to dismantle white supremacy and so on.
00:11:42.760 She also reposted and endorsed the message stating, quote,
00:11:45.880 there's no moderate way to black liberation.
00:11:50.340 And guess what?
00:11:51.020 None of this is scandalous in the Mamdani administration because they all think this way.
00:11:55.360 That's why his platform called for raising taxes on richer and whiter neighborhoods.
00:12:01.560 And as Sia Weaver, Mamdani's director of tenants, put it, they're going to impoverish the white middle class.
00:12:07.580 The white middle class, specifically.
00:12:10.140 They're going to declare that homeownership is a weapon of white supremacy.
00:12:13.360 And Mamdani himself has confirmed all of this.
00:12:16.800 If there was any confusion, watch.
00:12:20.040 And realize there's a policy proposal that says your plan, and I'm going to quote it for folks,
00:12:24.980 is to shift the tax burden from overtaxed homeowners in the outer boroughs to more expensive homes in richer and whiter neighborhoods.
00:12:33.880 Explain why you are bringing race into your tax proposal.
00:12:37.660 That is just a description of what we see right now.
00:12:41.420 It's not driven by race.
00:12:42.580 It's more of an assessment of what neighborhoods are being undertaxed versus overtaxed.
00:12:45.980 So no plans to change that language on your website.
00:12:49.500 The focus here is to actually ensure a fair property tax system.
00:12:53.540 And that, the use of that language is just an assessment of the neighborhood.
00:12:56.580 So it's reminiscent of the defenses we saw concerning those South African kill the boar chants.
00:13:02.440 Remember how the New York Times ran cover for that?
00:13:04.960 What exactly did you mean when you said, kill the white farmer?
00:13:10.040 Well, it's just a common expression.
00:13:12.700 It's just a figure of speech.
00:13:14.840 It doesn't really mean anything.
00:13:17.680 Actually, when you come out and say that you're going to raise taxes on whites to their white meat,
00:13:22.820 everyone understands exactly what you're doing.
00:13:26.180 The left has committed to full-on racial warfare.
00:13:29.200 And they're going to win using this strategy unless the Republican Party stops playing the same game in reverse.
00:13:40.140 You know, a big part of the reason why Republicans lost the governor's race in Virginia,
00:13:45.120 that has set up all this stuff to happen in Virginia,
00:13:47.080 is that they selected an anti-Trump candidate from Jamaica and patted themselves on the back
00:13:52.980 for their commitment to diversity.
00:13:56.540 And she spent most of the campaign talking about being an immigrant who won in a black district.
00:14:02.240 District.
00:14:02.780 And, you know, and how she can win more of the black vote.
00:14:07.120 Watch.
00:14:07.600 Let me tell you about me.
00:14:10.520 My name is Winsome Sears, and I served in the United States Marine Corps.
00:14:14.860 I was the first Republican to win a seat in the House of Delegates in a majority black district since 1865.
00:14:21.820 In the General Assembly, I had a 100% pro-life and pro-Second Amendment record.
00:14:27.460 I became the national chairman of black Americans to re-elect President Trump,
00:14:31.560 and we turned out more black voters for any Republican president since Reagan.
00:14:36.040 Now our country's falling into chaos.
00:14:39.680 But I still believe in the America that has accepted me as an immigrant
00:14:44.380 and gave us a shot at the American dream.
00:14:47.380 So that was four mentions.
00:14:49.700 That was about a 30-second or a minute ad,
00:14:53.720 and that was four mentions of black or immigrant, or maybe five, if I lost count.
00:14:59.000 Four or five mentions of black or immigrant in, you know, whatever, a 45-second ad.
00:15:04.220 And so this is still, and they lost.
00:15:08.100 What a shocker.
00:15:09.980 Now we're seeing this kind of thing replicated by Republicans across the country in other elections,
00:15:14.500 and the results will be the same.
00:15:19.240 Because this is still the Republicans' bright idea.
00:15:21.920 This is still their, oh, I know.
00:15:23.820 So if we find our own minorities to run,
00:15:29.880 and we run them regardless of whether or not they're the best fit,
00:15:33.000 and then they spend the whole campaign talking about how they're minorities,
00:15:37.080 then we'll win the minority vote.
00:15:40.900 It's never worked that way.
00:15:44.640 That strategy has never worked.
00:15:47.600 But if Republicans insist on running political campaigns on the left's terms,
00:15:54.640 the left's terms, like, which is adopting the premise that somehow being black or being an immigrant
00:16:02.080 is a qualification for office,
00:16:06.840 those are the left's terms.
00:16:08.960 And as long as Republicans adopt those terms,
00:16:12.440 they'll lose every time.
00:16:13.980 And the reason this is a losing strategy is that the left doesn't actually care
00:16:19.020 about the demographics of their candidate,
00:16:20.860 or at least that's not their primary concern, or even close to it.
00:16:24.200 Instead, the left is principally concerned with selecting candidates
00:16:27.240 who will ruthlessly and efficiently disenfranchise
00:16:30.620 and bankrupt and incarcerate
00:16:32.820 and ultimately destroy
00:16:34.520 white conservative men.
00:16:37.760 That's why they elected Joe Biden,
00:16:39.260 who allowed FBI SWAT teams to arrest,
00:16:41.060 and in some cases kill,
00:16:42.060 conservatives who offended the left on the internet.
00:16:45.280 That's why they rallied around Abigail Spanberger,
00:16:47.900 an extraordinarily dull and uncharismatic white woman.
00:16:51.500 She promised to rig all the government contracts against white men
00:16:54.620 to let the illegal aliens out of prison
00:16:56.720 to take jobs from white men
00:16:57.920 to make it easier to rob white men,
00:17:00.120 and so on.
00:17:01.380 And now she's delivering on those promises,
00:17:03.040 along with every Democrat in Virginia.
00:17:05.960 Left unchecked,
00:17:06.940 this anti-white fervor
00:17:08.220 will lead to cases like this one
00:17:09.840 out of Ontario, Canada.
00:17:11.300 A 19-year-old woman
00:17:12.500 who left her 14-month-old toddler
00:17:15.200 unattended in a full bathtub,
00:17:17.020 resulting in the child's death,
00:17:18.260 just received a mere three-year prison sentence.
00:17:22.580 And that's because,
00:17:24.560 according to the judge,
00:17:26.060 there was systemic racism
00:17:28.140 identified in the community
00:17:29.740 that explains the woman's conduct
00:17:33.380 in this case.
00:17:34.160 Yes, systemic racism,
00:17:38.220 i.e. white people,
00:17:39.640 evil white people,
00:17:40.960 explains why the woman
00:17:42.060 left her toddler alone
00:17:43.800 in a full bathtub
00:17:45.500 for five to ten minutes
00:17:47.540 without any kind of chair
00:17:50.000 or support whatsoever,
00:17:51.880 even though he couldn't walk,
00:17:53.900 and even though she had been
00:17:55.040 warned by the government
00:17:55.900 on two occasions
00:17:56.660 to never leave her child unattended.
00:17:59.540 So race, in effect,
00:18:01.080 now excuses murder in Canada.
00:18:04.160 The logic used in this case,
00:18:05.820 of course,
00:18:06.180 justifies reduced sentences
00:18:07.340 for any homicide,
00:18:08.800 including acts of violence
00:18:09.840 committed by black criminals
00:18:11.840 against whites,
00:18:12.600 which are extremely common.
00:18:13.620 In fact,
00:18:13.900 84% of interracial crimes
00:18:15.600 involving black and white people
00:18:17.140 are black-on-white crimes.
00:18:19.340 In places like Canada
00:18:20.720 and Virginia
00:18:21.580 and New York
00:18:22.100 and Minneapolis
00:18:22.640 and every other jurisdiction
00:18:23.760 controlled by leftists,
00:18:25.280 those anti-white crimes
00:18:26.300 will soon be excused
00:18:27.380 if they aren't being excused already.
00:18:30.440 We can't allow this to continue,
00:18:32.060 but Democrats will continue
00:18:34.320 racking up wins like this
00:18:35.960 unless we start
00:18:36.740 fielding candidates
00:18:37.840 that will recognize
00:18:38.680 what the left is doing
00:18:40.020 and call it out openly
00:18:41.540 and pledge to defend
00:18:44.040 white men
00:18:44.720 from the onslaught
00:18:46.300 of racial discrimination
00:18:47.280 that they will face
00:18:49.160 if and when Democrats
00:18:50.380 regain power.
00:18:53.140 You know,
00:18:53.700 Republicans that are not afraid
00:18:55.040 to say,
00:18:55.780 to explicitly say that.
00:18:57.420 these people hate white men
00:19:00.300 and want to punish them
00:19:02.360 for their,
00:19:03.620 for the,
00:19:04.020 for the sin,
00:19:05.100 for their perceived sins
00:19:06.360 and we're going to stop
00:19:08.680 that from happening.
00:19:11.320 We need Republicans
00:19:12.320 who are willing
00:19:12.840 to just say that out loud.
00:19:16.300 You know,
00:19:16.820 we've mostly defeated
00:19:17.660 the trans agenda,
00:19:18.580 which would have been,
00:19:19.860 you know,
00:19:20.680 would have had civilization
00:19:21.820 ending consequences
00:19:22.760 if we had failed
00:19:23.680 and now we have to confront
00:19:24.800 the left's anti-white agenda
00:19:26.320 which as the rise
00:19:28.620 of Democrats
00:19:29.260 across the country
00:19:30.120 demonstrates
00:19:30.740 will be a
00:19:32.440 much harder campaign
00:19:34.200 to vanquish.
00:19:36.980 Now let's get
00:19:37.740 to our five headlines.
00:19:44.360 Skip the life overhaul
00:19:45.700 in 2026.
00:19:46.580 Just swap your snacks
00:19:47.780 for ones with real ingredients
00:19:49.180 like our sponsor,
00:19:50.500 Massa.
00:19:51.060 It's clean eating
00:19:51.600 without the massive diet.
00:19:53.380 Massa's chips
00:19:54.040 are refreshingly simple
00:19:55.160 organic corn sea salt
00:19:56.660 and 100% grass-fed beef towel.
00:19:59.000 That's the whole ingredient list.
00:20:00.340 No ingredients
00:20:01.000 that you'd need
00:20:01.640 a chemistry degree
00:20:02.420 to pronounce.
00:20:04.040 Massa chips
00:20:04.480 are genuinely delicious
00:20:05.640 like you're not making
00:20:07.020 some noble sacrifice
00:20:08.260 for your health here
00:20:09.180 and my favorite flavor
00:20:10.420 is their original.
00:20:11.880 Of course,
00:20:12.120 I like to keep it simple.
00:20:13.360 I think the chips are great.
00:20:14.140 We always have a bag at home.
00:20:15.000 Plus,
00:20:15.620 they're sturdy too
00:20:16.520 so, you know,
00:20:17.420 you can actually dip them
00:20:18.740 and they won't fall apart
00:20:19.500 in the dip.
00:20:20.440 Massa chips
00:20:20.960 actually leave you
00:20:22.060 feeling good.
00:20:22.960 No crash,
00:20:23.440 no bloat,
00:20:24.300 none of that heavy
00:20:25.040 why-did-I-do-this-to-myself
00:20:26.580 regret.
00:20:27.100 Plus,
00:20:27.320 you'll actually feel full
00:20:28.420 instead of instantly
00:20:29.120 craving another bag
00:20:30.100 five minutes later.
00:20:31.580 Ready to give Massa a try?
00:20:32.740 Go to massachips.com
00:20:33.860 slash Walsh
00:20:34.500 and use code Walsh
00:20:35.240 for 25% off
00:20:36.020 your first order
00:20:36.480 or simply click the link
00:20:38.260 in the video description
00:20:39.240 or scan the QR code
00:20:40.420 to claim this delicious offer.
00:20:42.220 Don't feel like ordering online.
00:20:43.620 Massa is now available
00:20:44.540 nationwide
00:20:45.080 at your local
00:20:45.700 Sprouts supermarket.
00:20:47.260 Stop by,
00:20:47.880 pick up a couple of bags
00:20:48.780 before they're gone.
00:20:50.220 We'll start with this.
00:20:51.280 Pam Greer,
00:20:53.400 Jussie Greer
00:20:54.140 as she's known now,
00:20:55.140 Pam Smollett.
00:20:56.520 She has many names.
00:20:58.900 She used to be an actress.
00:21:00.880 She appeared on The View
00:21:01.780 and I don't know
00:21:03.640 what she's up to
00:21:04.320 these days
00:21:05.060 aside from apparently
00:21:06.160 eating a lot of cheesecake
00:21:07.240 from the looks of it,
00:21:08.880 which is fine.
00:21:09.900 She's in her 70s.
00:21:10.740 I've already said
00:21:11.400 I fully support people
00:21:13.180 over 65 getting fat,
00:21:15.060 which is what I plan to do.
00:21:16.920 But, you know,
00:21:17.820 so that's not the problem here.
00:21:20.500 The problem is this story
00:21:22.280 that she told
00:21:23.160 from her childhood
00:21:24.060 that seems a little bit
00:21:25.920 dubious, let's say.
00:21:29.340 Listen.
00:21:31.060 You faced a lot of racism
00:21:32.620 growing up in Columbus, Ohio.
00:21:35.280 How did that shape you?
00:21:38.460 Whew!
00:21:39.080 Well,
00:21:39.980 the military wouldn't allow
00:21:42.520 black families
00:21:43.120 to live on the base,
00:21:43.940 so you had to live
00:21:44.580 in an apartment.
00:21:45.060 and you couldn't
00:21:46.740 take a bus,
00:21:47.640 you couldn't afford a car,
00:21:48.740 you walked,
00:21:49.160 your dad's walked
00:21:49.860 to the base.
00:21:51.480 And, whew,
00:21:52.140 sometimes we would go
00:21:53.680 from, you know,
00:21:54.780 tree shade to shade
00:21:56.300 to get back
00:21:56.920 to the apartment,
00:21:58.020 my brother and I,
00:21:59.140 my mom,
00:21:59.620 with bags,
00:22:00.860 and my mom would go,
00:22:02.080 don't look, don't look,
00:22:02.820 don't look,
00:22:03.280 and she'd pull us away.
00:22:04.620 Wow.
00:22:05.900 Because there was someone
00:22:06.860 hanging from a tree.
00:22:08.280 Aw.
00:22:09.240 Hmm.
00:22:10.240 And they have
00:22:11.020 a memorial for it now
00:22:12.240 where you can see
00:22:14.960 where people were
00:22:15.980 and left.
00:22:17.220 Mm-hmm.
00:22:17.760 And,
00:22:18.320 it triggers me today
00:22:21.680 to see that
00:22:24.120 a voice can be silenced.
00:22:26.880 Mm-hmm.
00:22:27.380 And if a white family
00:22:28.440 supported a black,
00:22:29.440 they're gonna get burned down
00:22:30.600 or killed
00:22:31.060 or lynched as well.
00:22:32.140 Yeah.
00:22:32.420 Yeah.
00:22:34.720 Now,
00:22:35.380 I don't know why
00:22:37.460 she's dressed like
00:22:38.240 Carmen Sandiego.
00:22:40.580 That's one question.
00:22:41.620 And more importantly,
00:22:42.460 she makes a claim here
00:22:43.620 that is just not true.
00:22:47.300 Of course,
00:22:47.920 this incredibly dumb audience,
00:22:50.260 they hear her say this
00:22:51.240 and they say,
00:22:52.320 oh, my gosh.
00:22:54.100 You hear the gasp
00:22:55.040 in the crowd.
00:22:57.080 You know,
00:22:58.240 which she might as well
00:22:59.600 have said,
00:23:00.500 I remember being a child
00:23:02.420 and growing wings
00:23:06.520 and flying through the air.
00:23:08.640 and the audience goes,
00:23:11.780 oh,
00:23:12.440 you did?
00:23:14.400 Whoa.
00:23:16.480 No,
00:23:17.080 it's,
00:23:17.420 that is just as credible
00:23:18.720 as believing that
00:23:20.020 story she just told.
00:23:23.280 The last lynching
00:23:24.600 in Columbus, Ohio
00:23:25.740 was never,
00:23:27.440 actually,
00:23:27.800 there was,
00:23:28.140 there's never been
00:23:28.960 a recorded lynching
00:23:29.800 in Columbus, Ohio,
00:23:30.940 ever.
00:23:31.220 The last lynching
00:23:32.720 in the state of Ohio
00:23:34.120 in the entire state
00:23:36.180 was like 19,
00:23:38.280 I mean,
00:23:38.560 there's some people online
00:23:39.440 say it was 1911,
00:23:40.960 although I think
00:23:41.440 in that case
00:23:42.120 the police intervened
00:23:43.440 and the person
00:23:44.120 was not killed.
00:23:46.520 the last person
00:23:48.540 to actually be lynched
00:23:49.640 and left to die,
00:23:51.020 like hanging from a tree,
00:23:53.020 was in Ohio,
00:23:54.020 the entire state,
00:23:54.740 not in Columbus,
00:23:55.560 where this,
00:23:56.400 as far as we know,
00:23:57.120 never happened,
00:23:58.400 but the last time
00:23:59.560 in Ohio
00:24:00.160 that happened
00:24:00.800 was the 1890s.
00:24:04.700 And if you look up
00:24:05.840 how many lynchings
00:24:06.900 occurred in the entire state
00:24:08.280 in its history,
00:24:09.140 ever,
00:24:10.400 you'll get varying numbers,
00:24:12.320 but at most,
00:24:13.280 the highest estimate
00:24:15.140 that I could find
00:24:16.320 was like 28.
00:24:19.280 Nobody estimates
00:24:20.260 more than 30.
00:24:22.260 So let's go with that.
00:24:22.980 I mean,
00:24:23.100 it's probably more like
00:24:23.840 23 or 24,
00:24:24.760 but let's just say 30.
00:24:27.200 Rounding up,
00:24:27.920 there were 30 lynchings
00:24:29.340 in the entire history
00:24:30.720 of the state of Ohio,
00:24:33.200 ever,
00:24:34.080 from when it was founded
00:24:34.980 in 1803
00:24:36.640 to today.
00:24:39.320 And the last
00:24:40.360 fatal lynching,
00:24:42.400 we'll say,
00:24:42.660 was in the 1890s.
00:24:45.460 So really,
00:24:46.180 there were 30 lynchings,
00:24:47.240 all of them
00:24:47.640 in the 19th century,
00:24:48.720 over the span
00:24:49.320 of 100 years.
00:24:50.620 And if you count
00:24:51.520 the one in 1911,
00:24:52.940 then that's 30
00:24:53.800 over 110 years
00:24:54.820 or 11 decades,
00:24:55.960 which averages out
00:24:56.960 to about three a decade
00:24:58.460 in the whole state
00:25:00.200 for 110 years.
00:25:03.080 And over the 120 years-ish
00:25:05.380 from since 1911,
00:25:08.120 there have been
00:25:08.940 zero lynchings.
00:25:10.580 But Pam Greer's
00:25:12.600 lies even worse
00:25:13.420 because she's not
00:25:14.980 claiming, right,
00:25:16.580 that she witnessed
00:25:17.480 one lynching.
00:25:20.100 That would be
00:25:21.020 bad enough.
00:25:22.540 She tells the story
00:25:23.840 as though this was
00:25:24.660 a common occurrence
00:25:25.980 because you notice
00:25:27.940 how she phrases it.
00:25:28.960 She says,
00:25:29.460 we'd be walking along
00:25:31.440 and my mom
00:25:32.680 would tell us
00:25:33.520 to look away
00:25:34.260 because there were bodies
00:25:35.180 hanging in the tree.
00:25:35.860 That's not what you say
00:25:38.360 when you're referring
00:25:39.060 to one specific incident,
00:25:41.220 which also didn't happen.
00:25:43.500 She's claiming
00:25:44.300 this was a regular thing.
00:25:46.000 I think she said
00:25:46.960 sometimes, right?
00:25:48.140 Sometimes.
00:25:48.800 Sometimes we'd
00:25:50.040 be walking home
00:25:51.600 and there's just bodies
00:25:53.820 hanging in all the trees,
00:25:56.200 like tree ornaments.
00:25:57.480 In the 1960s,
00:25:59.380 in Ohio,
00:26:01.860 there were just
00:26:02.360 black people
00:26:03.960 hanging from trees
00:26:04.880 all over the place.
00:26:09.620 That's what she's claiming.
00:26:10.680 This is an egregious,
00:26:13.180 verifiable lie
00:26:14.460 by a famous,
00:26:16.560 well, relatively famous,
00:26:17.540 used to be famous person
00:26:18.760 on network TV.
00:26:22.280 And she lies like this
00:26:23.680 because she knows
00:26:24.420 that she has cover.
00:26:25.260 She knows that nobody
00:26:26.080 in the mainstream media
00:26:27.040 will call her out.
00:26:29.660 And yet it's still remarkable
00:26:31.280 I mean, why do this?
00:26:33.380 Why humiliate yourself this way?
00:26:35.040 What do you gain from this?
00:26:37.800 Well, you know,
00:26:38.660 it's for a leftist,
00:26:39.860 of course,
00:26:40.180 the desire to be a victim,
00:26:41.680 the desire to be pitied.
00:26:44.680 That's the desire.
00:26:45.720 It's the desire to be pitied
00:26:47.260 is what animates them.
00:26:49.760 It's what drives them.
00:26:51.840 Now, sure,
00:26:52.320 they use the victim status
00:26:53.820 to gain power,
00:26:55.240 to gain prestige
00:26:56.720 in their circles.
00:26:57.960 It's all a power game.
00:26:59.300 We know that.
00:26:59.880 But they do also
00:27:01.980 on an emotional level
00:27:03.400 when you talk about,
00:27:05.600 well, what's their emotional,
00:27:06.820 what do they get out
00:27:09.160 of this emotionally?
00:27:10.600 What's the emotional incentive?
00:27:12.880 And the answer is
00:27:13.740 they deeply desire
00:27:14.960 to be pitied,
00:27:16.480 which is the sickest,
00:27:18.640 weirdest,
00:27:19.480 most pathetic thing
00:27:21.500 for a person to want.
00:27:24.640 Right?
00:27:25.280 Pity should be
00:27:25.980 the last thing you want.
00:27:27.160 Even if you're in a position
00:27:29.260 and something has happened
00:27:30.520 to you
00:27:30.980 that is deserving
00:27:32.640 of pity,
00:27:33.620 you still shouldn't
00:27:35.560 want it.
00:27:39.000 That's how any
00:27:39.680 normal person is.
00:27:41.060 A normal person says,
00:27:42.020 I don't want your pity.
00:27:43.180 I don't want that.
00:27:46.320 And, yeah,
00:27:46.880 you have these leftists
00:27:47.720 that are
00:27:48.300 going out of their way
00:27:52.680 to come up with
00:27:55.980 reasons to be pitied.
00:27:57.720 But we should keep in mind,
00:27:58.720 you know,
00:27:59.140 claiming that there were
00:27:59.980 black people getting lynched
00:28:01.140 all over the place
00:28:01.940 in Ohio
00:28:02.460 in the 1960s
00:28:03.660 is crazy.
00:28:05.700 It's not as crazy
00:28:06.840 as
00:28:08.460 saying,
00:28:10.980 on the other hand,
00:28:11.740 that
00:28:12.080 people are being lynched
00:28:13.840 today,
00:28:14.480 which is what
00:28:16.460 leftists will say.
00:28:19.820 So,
00:28:20.480 a lot of people
00:28:21.240 have been talking about this
00:28:22.000 saying,
00:28:22.240 well,
00:28:22.320 this is,
00:28:22.820 that's nuts,
00:28:23.660 that didn't happen
00:28:24.160 in Ohio
00:28:24.560 in the 1960s.
00:28:26.080 That is nuts,
00:28:27.180 but these people
00:28:28.420 will say that
00:28:28.980 this is happening
00:28:29.740 today,
00:28:30.380 that there are
00:28:30.780 people today
00:28:31.640 who could have
00:28:32.660 this same experience
00:28:33.760 of walking down
00:28:34.880 the street
00:28:35.300 and seeing
00:28:36.040 black people
00:28:37.820 hanging from trees.
00:28:39.320 Here's,
00:28:39.900 for example,
00:28:41.400 here's Jasmine Crockett
00:28:42.600 on this point.
00:28:44.480 They're not even going,
00:28:46.080 honestly,
00:28:46.740 they're about to outlaw
00:28:47.820 the idea of
00:28:49.340 white supremacy
00:28:50.100 and white hate.
00:28:51.200 Like,
00:28:51.340 they are about to be like,
00:28:52.460 oh,
00:28:52.600 that's not a thing.
00:28:53.920 Forget the fact
00:28:54.820 that you're talking
00:28:55.980 about getting rid
00:28:56.800 of,
00:28:57.380 like,
00:28:58.360 the classification
00:28:59.000 for nooses
00:28:59.720 in a time in which
00:29:01.360 we have seen
00:29:02.680 these random
00:29:03.680 black bodies
00:29:04.500 be strung up
00:29:05.280 down south.
00:29:07.120 Also,
00:29:08.440 seemingly
00:29:08.980 at a time
00:29:10.280 in which
00:29:10.620 you're back in office
00:29:11.800 because what you do
00:29:12.720 is you embolden
00:29:13.660 the hate.
00:29:14.960 You embolden
00:29:15.620 everybody
00:29:16.220 to take off
00:29:16.880 their hoods.
00:29:17.940 That is what
00:29:18.480 he has done.
00:29:22.480 They're not even
00:29:23.320 going,
00:29:23.940 they're not even
00:29:24.940 going,
00:29:25.540 they're not even
00:29:27.160 going to be talking
00:29:27.820 about no white
00:29:28.460 supremacy.
00:29:29.840 Child,
00:29:31.300 these publicans,
00:29:33.160 they ain't even
00:29:33.940 going to talk
00:29:34.600 about.
00:29:36.960 So,
00:29:37.580 Congresswoman,
00:29:38.300 by the way,
00:29:39.320 so she says
00:29:41.120 random black
00:29:41.940 bodies are
00:29:42.560 getting lynched,
00:29:43.400 which is,
00:29:45.620 I mean,
00:29:46.880 look,
00:29:47.140 we're so used
00:29:47.600 to it at this
00:29:48.100 point,
00:29:48.480 but think
00:29:49.920 about what
00:29:50.440 you're claiming.
00:29:52.080 This is a
00:29:52.880 member of
00:29:53.360 Congress.
00:29:55.860 Just making
00:29:56.700 it up.
00:29:58.100 Totally made
00:29:58.880 up.
00:30:01.000 Random,
00:30:01.660 but really,
00:30:02.920 Jasmine,
00:30:03.260 where is that
00:30:04.060 happening?
00:30:05.400 Why have we
00:30:06.240 not seen
00:30:06.900 that?
00:30:07.720 You're telling
00:30:08.440 me everything
00:30:09.140 ends up on
00:30:10.080 social media
00:30:10.620 these days?
00:30:11.680 Okay,
00:30:11.960 if somebody
00:30:12.600 has an
00:30:13.220 unpleasant
00:30:13.680 interaction
00:30:14.380 with the
00:30:15.980 cashier at
00:30:16.540 McDonald's,
00:30:17.180 we're going
00:30:17.420 to see it
00:30:17.880 on Twitter,
00:30:18.660 but we
00:30:19.100 don't see
00:30:19.540 that.
00:30:21.460 There are
00:30:22.080 places where
00:30:22.620 there are
00:30:22.860 black bodies
00:30:23.620 hanging from
00:30:24.220 trees because
00:30:25.060 they were
00:30:25.340 lynched,
00:30:26.060 and there
00:30:26.520 are no
00:30:26.860 images of
00:30:27.320 that on
00:30:27.560 social media
00:30:28.040 whatsoever.
00:30:28.780 Anywhere.
00:30:32.640 Fascinating.
00:30:33.080 Fascinating.
00:30:34.440 No,
00:30:35.320 the last
00:30:35.740 lynching in
00:30:36.620 this country
00:30:37.080 was more
00:30:37.520 than 40
00:30:38.040 years ago.
00:30:38.840 There has
00:30:39.280 not been a
00:30:39.960 single case
00:30:40.660 in my entire
00:30:41.340 life,
00:30:41.840 and I'm
00:30:42.260 old as
00:30:42.600 hell.
00:30:43.680 And that
00:30:46.280 one case
00:30:47.020 was the
00:30:47.340 only one
00:30:47.860 for the
00:30:48.780 several
00:30:49.100 decades
00:30:49.560 preceding
00:30:50.120 it.
00:30:51.540 And by
00:30:52.160 the way,
00:30:52.380 here's one
00:30:52.640 other point
00:30:53.080 I want to
00:30:53.360 make since
00:30:53.800 we're on
00:30:54.060 the subject
00:30:54.480 of lynching.
00:30:57.280 Clearly,
00:30:57.960 anyone claiming
00:30:58.600 that it
00:30:58.960 happens today
00:30:59.620 is insane
00:31:00.580 or lying
00:31:01.260 or both,
00:31:02.180 and same
00:31:02.560 goes for
00:31:02.920 anyone claiming
00:31:03.460 that it
00:31:03.760 happened in
00:31:04.200 Ohio in
00:31:04.760 the 1960s.
00:31:05.900 But there
00:31:06.380 is another
00:31:06.680 point,
00:31:07.080 which is
00:31:07.300 that when
00:31:08.800 we hear
00:31:09.080 about lynching
00:31:09.640 in American
00:31:10.040 history,
00:31:10.700 back in a
00:31:11.360 time and
00:31:11.760 in a place
00:31:12.200 where it
00:31:12.520 did happen,
00:31:14.100 historically it
00:31:14.960 did happen.
00:31:16.500 But I
00:31:18.160 think it's
00:31:18.420 worth pointing
00:31:18.860 out because
00:31:19.240 this is one
00:31:19.760 of those
00:31:19.980 things that's
00:31:20.520 used to
00:31:21.400 prop up the
00:31:22.760 narrative of
00:31:23.240 white guilt.
00:31:23.960 It's worth
00:31:24.420 pointing out
00:31:24.920 that even
00:31:26.640 in the,
00:31:28.380 I guess we
00:31:28.860 would say,
00:31:29.340 heyday of
00:31:29.980 lynching,
00:31:30.420 it was
00:31:31.020 not common
00:31:32.760 and it
00:31:33.340 was also
00:31:33.780 not always
00:31:34.900 racially
00:31:35.440 motivated.
00:31:36.520 In fact,
00:31:37.200 it often
00:31:37.740 wasn't.
00:31:39.200 And this
00:31:39.520 is what the
00:31:39.860 left does
00:31:40.380 with history.
00:31:41.120 Either they
00:31:41.720 fabricate stuff
00:31:42.680 that never
00:31:43.080 happened or
00:31:45.000 they take
00:31:45.420 some event,
00:31:46.660 they take
00:31:46.940 some data
00:31:47.700 set,
00:31:48.080 they take
00:31:48.320 something that
00:31:49.240 does reflect
00:31:50.140 a thing that
00:31:51.180 actually happened
00:31:51.640 but they frame
00:31:52.340 it in a
00:31:53.440 misleading way
00:31:54.280 and then they
00:31:55.240 play this
00:31:55.620 gaslighting game
00:31:56.580 where you're
00:31:57.680 not allowed to
00:31:58.260 correct them
00:31:58.940 because if
00:31:59.460 you do,
00:32:00.060 they can just
00:32:00.840 say whatever
00:32:01.100 they want
00:32:01.420 about lynching
00:32:01.960 and if you,
00:32:03.480 especially as a
00:32:03.900 white person,
00:32:04.440 come along and
00:32:04.940 say,
00:32:05.160 well,
00:32:05.340 that's not
00:32:05.820 actually what
00:32:06.740 happened,
00:32:07.400 then they'll
00:32:07.720 go,
00:32:07.940 what are you
00:32:08.720 justifying
00:32:09.700 lynching?
00:32:10.340 Why do you
00:32:11.580 have to say
00:32:11.980 anything?
00:32:13.520 What are you
00:32:13.900 justifying it?
00:32:16.000 This is what
00:32:16.620 they do with
00:32:17.000 slavery,
00:32:17.580 which we talk
00:32:18.520 about in
00:32:18.860 Real History,
00:32:19.520 which is
00:32:19.840 available now
00:32:20.680 on Daily Wire.
00:32:21.760 So,
00:32:22.480 with lynching,
00:32:25.240 you know,
00:32:25.660 even though we're
00:32:26.320 not supposed to
00:32:28.260 correct it,
00:32:29.540 it's like,
00:32:29.920 yeah,
00:32:30.300 black people
00:32:30.860 were lynched
00:32:31.380 all the time
00:32:32.280 and it was a
00:32:32.720 terrible thing,
00:32:33.020 it was always
00:32:33.320 racist,
00:32:34.440 it was never
00:32:35.200 justified,
00:32:36.360 it was like,
00:32:36.920 just go with
00:32:37.720 it,
00:32:38.000 don't say it,
00:32:39.000 just go with
00:32:39.580 it,
00:32:39.720 that's the
00:32:40.080 attitude,
00:32:41.520 but,
00:32:43.140 because I
00:32:44.300 got to be
00:32:44.560 the guy
00:32:44.880 always,
00:32:46.400 to just point
00:32:47.100 out,
00:32:47.360 I got to be
00:32:47.680 that guy,
00:32:49.080 that,
00:32:50.220 in fact,
00:32:51.660 with lynching,
00:32:52.620 something like
00:32:53.300 a thousand or
00:32:54.280 more of the
00:32:55.220 lynching victims
00:32:56.080 from like
00:32:58.200 the 1860s
00:33:00.000 to the 1930s
00:33:00.940 or so,
00:33:01.360 which is
00:33:01.580 during the
00:33:01.980 time when
00:33:02.400 this sort
00:33:02.680 of thing
00:33:02.820 was happening,
00:33:03.760 about a
00:33:04.100 thousand of
00:33:04.640 the victims
00:33:05.080 were white.
00:33:07.480 It's a
00:33:08.040 large percentage.
00:33:09.440 It's probably
00:33:10.120 about 25 to
00:33:10.900 30 percent,
00:33:11.960 not a small
00:33:12.400 percentage.
00:33:13.820 White people
00:33:14.480 got lynched
00:33:14.960 too.
00:33:15.700 And what
00:33:16.060 does that
00:33:16.340 tell you?
00:33:16.680 Well,
00:33:16.780 it tells you
00:33:17.340 that lynching
00:33:19.180 is not
00:33:19.860 synonymous
00:33:20.440 with racial
00:33:21.780 terrorism.
00:33:22.600 Sometimes it
00:33:23.080 was,
00:33:23.700 that did
00:33:24.200 happen,
00:33:24.560 but what
00:33:26.700 lynching
00:33:27.120 really means
00:33:28.080 historically
00:33:29.180 in this
00:33:29.640 country is
00:33:30.820 an extra
00:33:31.360 judicial
00:33:31.800 killing
00:33:32.580 by hanging,
00:33:34.500 you know,
00:33:34.800 in the most
00:33:35.320 technical sense.
00:33:37.040 And for a
00:33:37.740 portion of
00:33:38.260 U.S.
00:33:38.540 history,
00:33:38.980 especially out
00:33:39.500 on the
00:33:39.720 frontier,
00:33:40.320 out in
00:33:40.520 the Old
00:33:40.760 West,
00:33:41.980 this kind
00:33:42.500 of killing
00:33:42.900 was relatively
00:33:44.880 common
00:33:46.620 because they
00:33:48.040 didn't have
00:33:48.380 a court
00:33:48.700 system and
00:33:49.280 they didn't
00:33:49.500 have much
00:33:50.580 of it.
00:33:50.840 They didn't
00:33:51.620 have a
00:33:51.880 sophisticated
00:33:52.320 court system
00:33:53.300 or law
00:33:53.680 enforcement
00:33:54.060 that could
00:33:55.680 handle
00:33:56.360 some of
00:33:57.540 this stuff.
00:33:58.500 And so
00:33:58.820 you ended
00:33:59.180 up with
00:33:59.620 kind of
00:33:59.900 this mob
00:34:00.440 justice.
00:34:02.280 So you
00:34:03.120 could get
00:34:03.500 lynched
00:34:04.120 if the
00:34:05.000 townsfolk
00:34:05.620 thought that
00:34:06.220 you were
00:34:06.660 a murderer
00:34:07.140 or a
00:34:08.080 rapist
00:34:08.520 or a
00:34:08.860 horse
00:34:09.080 thief.
00:34:09.340 That was
00:34:09.560 a big
00:34:09.760 one.
00:34:11.380 And so
00:34:12.880 when we
00:34:13.600 talk about
00:34:14.160 the total
00:34:14.840 number of
00:34:15.300 people where
00:34:15.800 this happened,
00:34:16.500 it's like,
00:34:16.940 well,
00:34:18.840 a significant
00:34:21.460 portion of
00:34:22.200 that had
00:34:22.860 nothing to
00:34:23.480 do with
00:34:23.680 race.
00:34:24.480 And some
00:34:25.040 of them
00:34:25.200 weren't
00:34:25.360 even
00:34:25.520 black.
00:34:29.240 There were
00:34:30.240 racially
00:34:30.700 motivated
00:34:31.180 lynchings.
00:34:31.660 That did
00:34:31.880 happen,
00:34:32.240 too.
00:34:32.620 But if you
00:34:33.600 look at
00:34:33.880 the estimates,
00:34:34.540 which obviously
00:34:35.820 are not
00:34:36.300 exact,
00:34:37.320 but most
00:34:37.760 people estimate
00:34:38.440 that something
00:34:39.300 like 4,000 to
00:34:39.920 5,000 people
00:34:40.820 were lynched
00:34:41.360 in America
00:34:41.780 total in the
00:34:43.040 entire history
00:34:43.540 of the
00:34:43.760 country,
00:34:44.400 not a large
00:34:45.460 number.
00:34:46.640 Well,
00:34:47.020 about 1,300
00:34:47.660 of those
00:34:48.180 victims were
00:34:48.720 white.
00:34:49.020 that leaves
00:34:50.900 like 3,000 to
00:34:51.400 4,000 on the
00:34:52.220 entire history
00:34:52.640 of the country
00:34:53.080 who were
00:34:53.460 black,
00:34:53.840 who were
00:34:53.960 lynched.
00:34:54.920 And,
00:34:55.260 well,
00:34:55.880 if white
00:34:56.200 people were
00:34:56.560 lynched for
00:34:57.240 non-racial
00:34:58.000 reasons,
00:34:58.460 obviously,
00:34:58.900 then it
00:34:59.140 stands to
00:34:59.520 reason that
00:34:59.880 there were
00:35:00.100 also cases
00:35:00.720 where that
00:35:01.040 happened to
00:35:01.300 black people
00:35:01.700 because they,
00:35:03.380 in fact,
00:35:03.740 committed a
00:35:04.160 crime or
00:35:04.500 they at
00:35:05.140 least were
00:35:05.560 accused of
00:35:06.600 it,
00:35:06.980 just like the
00:35:07.720 white people
00:35:08.080 who were
00:35:08.300 lynched.
00:35:09.040 So now you
00:35:09.800 take out the
00:35:10.240 people who
00:35:10.680 were lynched
00:35:11.120 not for
00:35:11.560 racial reasons,
00:35:12.180 but as a
00:35:12.760 form of
00:35:13.420 justice for
00:35:14.420 serious crimes
00:35:15.160 in times and
00:35:16.280 places where
00:35:16.680 they didn't
00:35:16.900 have a
00:35:17.160 sophisticated
00:35:17.540 legal system.
00:35:19.660 And so now
00:35:20.980 you're narrowing
00:35:21.460 it down,
00:35:21.800 narrowing it
00:35:22.100 down,
00:35:22.340 and now you
00:35:22.860 have the
00:35:23.520 percentage,
00:35:24.400 whatever that
00:35:24.760 percentage is,
00:35:25.240 I don't know,
00:35:26.920 where,
00:35:27.580 okay,
00:35:27.740 now those are
00:35:28.500 the people
00:35:28.880 who were
00:35:29.280 actually victims
00:35:30.500 of racially
00:35:31.500 motivated
00:35:32.180 terrorism.
00:35:34.540 But it's
00:35:35.140 not all
00:35:35.880 5,000,
00:35:36.720 not even
00:35:37.600 really close
00:35:38.080 to all
00:35:38.540 5,000.
00:35:39.380 Even if it
00:35:39.840 was,
00:35:40.240 that's still
00:35:40.620 a small
00:35:41.160 number over
00:35:41.620 the entire
00:35:42.120 history of
00:35:42.520 the country.
00:35:44.080 that doesn't
00:35:49.140 tell the
00:35:49.380 whole story.
00:35:49.780 And I
00:35:49.920 realize,
00:35:50.500 and look,
00:35:50.980 I realize
00:35:51.440 that everything
00:35:51.860 I'm saying
00:35:52.240 right now,
00:35:52.680 this is going
00:35:52.940 to get
00:35:53.120 clipped,
00:35:53.700 it's going
00:35:53.980 to end
00:35:54.180 up,
00:35:54.400 media
00:35:54.540 matters or
00:35:54.980 whatever,
00:35:55.260 it's going
00:35:55.440 to end
00:35:55.560 up on
00:35:55.880 X and
00:35:56.640 people,
00:35:57.160 oh,
00:35:57.360 he's
00:35:58.220 justifying,
00:35:58.800 he's saying,
00:35:59.400 he's justifying
00:36:00.180 it.
00:36:01.280 Because this
00:36:01.880 is the game
00:36:02.280 they play.
00:36:02.700 They just
00:36:03.000 say things
00:36:03.500 about history
00:36:04.000 that are
00:36:04.540 not true
00:36:05.500 or are
00:36:06.200 out of
00:36:06.560 context or
00:36:07.520 it's like
00:36:09.260 there's more
00:36:09.840 to the story
00:36:10.400 that needs
00:36:10.800 to be said
00:36:11.380 and you're
00:36:11.780 not allowed
00:36:12.340 to correct
00:36:12.840 it.
00:36:14.080 Because if
00:36:14.660 you correct
00:36:15.200 it,
00:36:16.560 that's their
00:36:17.760 attitude.
00:36:18.740 And they'll
00:36:19.060 almost tell
00:36:19.520 you this.
00:36:21.320 Because if you
00:36:21.940 start correcting
00:36:22.600 them on something
00:36:23.180 like this,
00:36:23.720 they'll say,
00:36:24.460 yeah,
00:36:24.960 whatever.
00:36:26.420 Okay,
00:36:26.940 fine,
00:36:27.280 whatever.
00:36:27.680 But we don't
00:36:28.320 need to talk
00:36:28.780 about that.
00:36:29.540 Just let us
00:36:30.320 do this.
00:36:31.360 That's their
00:36:31.900 answer to their
00:36:32.600 historical lies.
00:36:33.620 Just let us
00:36:34.200 do this,
00:36:34.540 okay?
00:36:35.300 We came up
00:36:36.000 with this
00:36:36.240 narrative and
00:36:37.280 this is the
00:36:37.860 thing,
00:36:38.120 this is what
00:36:38.400 we're saying,
00:36:38.820 it's very
00:36:39.120 simplistic,
00:36:39.600 it's not
00:36:39.860 totally true,
00:36:40.520 but just let
00:36:41.580 us do this
00:36:42.000 because it
00:36:42.360 makes us feel
00:36:42.860 good.
00:36:43.100 And when
00:36:44.120 you start
00:36:44.420 questioning it
00:36:44.960 a little bit,
00:36:45.460 it makes us
00:36:45.860 feel bad,
00:36:46.320 so shut up.
00:36:46.880 That's their
00:36:47.220 argument.
00:36:48.920 Getting a
00:36:49.460 wide variety of
00:36:50.080 whole food
00:36:50.400 ingredients into
00:36:50.960 my diet is
00:36:51.680 key for me
00:36:52.120 this year,
00:36:52.680 and our
00:36:52.920 sponsor,
00:36:53.440 Balance of
00:36:53.860 Nature's
00:36:54.300 Whole Health
00:36:54.860 System makes
00:36:56.380 it simple.
00:36:57.140 With their
00:36:57.420 convenient blends
00:36:58.320 of fruits and
00:36:59.000 vegetables and
00:36:59.660 easy-to-take
00:37:00.280 capsules, I can
00:37:01.120 ensure I'm
00:37:01.640 getting essential
00:37:02.260 nutrients every
00:37:02.980 day without
00:37:03.700 the hassle of
00:37:04.400 prep work or
00:37:05.060 meal planning.
00:37:05.640 It's an
00:37:06.220 effortless way
00:37:06.760 to support
00:37:07.740 wellness while
00:37:08.460 maintaining a
00:37:09.180 busy lifestyle.
00:37:10.220 Balance of
00:37:10.460 Nature's Whole
00:37:10.960 Health System
00:37:11.480 supplements are
00:37:12.400 incredibly versatile
00:37:13.220 and easy to
00:37:14.000 work into your
00:37:14.620 daily routine.
00:37:15.440 The fiber and
00:37:15.940 spice supplement
00:37:16.460 blends smoothly
00:37:17.480 into your
00:37:18.060 favorite drinks,
00:37:18.680 and if you
00:37:19.120 prefer, you can
00:37:20.120 even open up
00:37:20.760 the fruits and
00:37:21.240 veggies capsules
00:37:21.980 and mix the
00:37:23.160 powder directly
00:37:24.160 into a smoothie
00:37:24.840 or sprinkle it
00:37:25.540 over your meals.
00:37:26.280 What makes these
00:37:26.700 supplements special
00:37:27.420 is that they're
00:37:28.080 packed with 47
00:37:29.100 ingredients from
00:37:29.860 100% real
00:37:30.700 whole fruits,
00:37:31.820 vegetable spices,
00:37:32.560 and fibers,
00:37:33.220 everything from
00:37:33.740 flaxseed to
00:37:34.540 cinnamon, mango to
00:37:35.780 pineapple, and
00:37:36.560 spinach to kale.
00:37:37.900 Simple way to
00:37:38.580 give your body the
00:37:39.220 nutrition it needs
00:37:39.960 every day.
00:37:40.720 I personally love
00:37:41.240 it because of
00:37:41.940 its convenience
00:37:42.820 when I'm traveling
00:37:43.440 for work or
00:37:44.000 trying to keep
00:37:44.460 up with the
00:37:44.760 kids.
00:37:45.420 It gives me a
00:37:45.720 simple way to
00:37:46.220 make sure I'm
00:37:46.700 getting all the
00:37:47.340 essential nutrients
00:37:48.100 in my diet.
00:37:48.920 This new year,
00:37:49.900 lock in 50% off
00:37:51.160 for one year when
00:37:51.920 you subscribe to
00:37:52.600 the Whole Health
00:37:53.180 System supplement
00:37:54.120 as a preferred
00:37:54.960 customer.
00:37:55.420 Go to
00:37:55.640 balanceofnature.com.
00:38:00.320 All right,
00:38:00.980 let's take a
00:38:01.540 look at
00:38:02.000 at this.
00:38:07.060 Here's a quick
00:38:07.480 thing.
00:38:08.100 Well, not really
00:38:09.840 a quick issue,
00:38:10.360 but I'll touch
00:38:10.680 on it quickly.
00:38:11.100 CBS News,
00:38:11.880 President Trump
00:38:12.380 had set January
00:38:13.540 20th as a
00:38:14.700 deadline for
00:38:15.600 credit card
00:38:16.140 companies to
00:38:17.420 lower their
00:38:17.960 interest rates
00:38:18.740 to 10% for
00:38:20.400 one year.
00:38:21.600 And now that
00:38:22.040 the date has
00:38:22.480 arrived, most
00:38:23.640 banks and
00:38:24.140 card issuers
00:38:25.500 have largely
00:38:27.700 kept their rates
00:38:28.400 on change while
00:38:29.060 also pushing
00:38:29.540 back against an
00:38:30.940 idea that they
00:38:31.480 say lacks key
00:38:32.260 policy details
00:38:33.140 necessary for
00:38:33.700 them to comply.
00:38:34.840 Mr. Trump
00:38:35.160 announced the
00:38:35.640 cap on January
00:38:36.300 9th, giving
00:38:37.160 banks and
00:38:38.160 issuers just
00:38:38.940 11 days to
00:38:39.880 meet his
00:38:40.280 demand of
00:38:42.160 getting the
00:38:42.620 rates down
00:38:43.400 to 10%.
00:38:44.720 But so far,
00:38:47.020 so the deadline
00:38:47.600 has arrived and
00:38:49.220 a lot of
00:38:49.880 these, nobody
00:38:51.060 has complied
00:38:51.620 with it and
00:38:51.980 nothing has
00:38:52.260 happened to
00:38:52.520 them so
00:38:52.760 far.
00:38:53.700 So I think
00:38:57.160 this is an
00:38:57.540 interesting thing
00:38:58.280 and I
00:39:01.100 support the
00:39:01.660 idea if it's
00:39:02.620 ever actually
00:39:03.140 implemented
00:39:03.580 because a lot
00:39:05.440 of these credit
00:39:05.840 cards, 20%,
00:39:06.900 30% interest
00:39:07.760 rates, and
00:39:08.840 those are
00:39:09.240 insane, that's
00:39:10.040 immoral, usury
00:39:11.140 is a sin, and
00:39:13.160 bringing those
00:39:13.700 down is a good
00:39:14.300 idea.
00:39:15.660 But it doesn't
00:39:16.360 really get to the
00:39:16.840 heart of the
00:39:17.140 problem, which
00:39:17.720 is that Americans
00:39:18.980 are increasingly
00:39:19.900 basically living
00:39:20.880 their whole lives
00:39:21.820 on credit.
00:39:23.680 This is something
00:39:24.340 that Charlie
00:39:25.060 Kirk talked
00:39:25.600 about with
00:39:26.100 Tucker, and
00:39:28.280 I saw a clip
00:39:28.900 floating around
00:39:29.600 again after it
00:39:32.720 was posted
00:39:33.100 originally by, I'm
00:39:33.960 not sure who,
00:39:35.360 Captive Dreamer,
00:39:36.180 I think, posted
00:39:36.640 originally.
00:39:37.380 So Charlie was
00:39:38.260 talking about what
00:39:39.340 we've discussed
00:39:39.840 here, which is
00:39:40.780 the scourge of
00:39:41.680 BNPL, which is
00:39:43.160 buy now, pay
00:39:43.880 later.
00:39:44.640 And this is a
00:39:45.440 system that's
00:39:46.320 technically
00:39:46.780 not credit, so
00:39:48.400 it's not
00:39:48.780 regulated the
00:39:49.600 same way, but
00:39:51.380 it allows you
00:39:52.200 to defer
00:39:52.880 payment for
00:39:54.200 something or
00:39:54.880 to break up
00:39:55.520 payments into
00:39:56.440 increments.
00:39:57.860 And this is
00:39:58.840 not a new
00:39:59.480 invention.
00:40:00.940 What is new
00:40:01.780 is that now
00:40:03.440 you can do
00:40:03.920 this with
00:40:06.000 everything.
00:40:07.880 Right?
00:40:08.420 You can do
00:40:09.060 it with any
00:40:09.480 retail product,
00:40:10.380 you can do
00:40:10.680 it with
00:40:10.960 electronics,
00:40:11.900 furniture,
00:40:12.360 appliances, all
00:40:14.060 of that has
00:40:14.700 been the case
00:40:15.080 for a while,
00:40:15.520 but now also
00:40:16.300 groceries,
00:40:18.800 fast food,
00:40:20.540 pizza,
00:40:22.060 Uber Eats,
00:40:23.180 Instacart.
00:40:24.760 So increasingly
00:40:25.280 we now live in
00:40:25.980 a country where
00:40:26.720 not only is
00:40:27.980 everyone crushed
00:40:28.780 by debt all
00:40:30.840 the time, but
00:40:31.560 also nobody
00:40:33.780 owns anything.
00:40:35.520 And that
00:40:36.360 to me is the
00:40:39.420 core of the
00:40:39.900 issue.
00:40:41.680 I mean,
00:40:41.880 there are
00:40:42.400 people,
00:40:43.980 adults in this
00:40:44.520 country who
00:40:45.020 don't own
00:40:45.800 anything,
00:40:47.900 like anything
00:40:49.020 at all.
00:40:51.360 So now we
00:40:52.000 could be in
00:40:52.240 a spot where
00:40:52.700 you might not
00:40:53.160 even own the
00:40:53.960 burrito you're
00:40:54.700 eating because
00:40:55.680 it's on a
00:40:56.120 payment plan.
00:40:58.440 Even that has
00:40:59.200 to be paid
00:40:59.620 off.
00:41:00.900 So just imagine
00:41:01.800 this scenario,
00:41:02.720 and there's
00:41:03.440 plenty of people
00:41:03.840 who don't have
00:41:04.220 to imagine it
00:41:04.820 because they
00:41:05.180 live it,
00:41:05.440 but a
00:41:06.160 person,
00:41:06.600 a young
00:41:06.860 person in
00:41:07.600 particular,
00:41:10.280 sits down
00:41:11.920 in his
00:41:12.160 house at
00:41:13.600 his table
00:41:14.080 to eat
00:41:15.780 his Chipotle
00:41:16.560 dinner.
00:41:18.400 Well,
00:41:19.080 the house
00:41:19.640 is rented
00:41:20.140 or it's
00:41:22.600 on a 50
00:41:23.080 year mortgage,
00:41:24.280 which is
00:41:24.700 something Trump
00:41:25.680 wants to do.
00:41:27.020 The table
00:41:27.840 and chair
00:41:28.360 still being
00:41:30.160 paid off,
00:41:31.280 and so is
00:41:32.540 the burrito
00:41:33.120 bowl that he's
00:41:33.820 eating.
00:41:35.440 He doesn't
00:41:36.160 even own
00:41:36.520 the fork
00:41:37.000 that he's
00:41:37.300 eating it
00:41:37.620 with.
00:41:39.580 So there's
00:41:39.880 this common
00:41:41.860 scenario where
00:41:44.380 you would look
00:41:44.880 at that and
00:41:45.140 you think,
00:41:45.340 well, okay,
00:41:45.620 he owns all
00:41:46.040 that stuff.
00:41:48.020 This is a
00:41:48.560 guy who at
00:41:49.000 least owns a
00:41:49.600 table, a
00:41:50.000 chair, a
00:41:50.620 burrito bowl,
00:41:51.300 and a
00:41:51.460 house.
00:41:53.000 Well,
00:41:53.340 increasingly,
00:41:53.940 no, he
00:41:54.140 don't own
00:41:54.400 any of it.
00:41:54.940 All of it's
00:41:55.560 either on
00:41:56.140 credit or
00:41:56.840 it's on a
00:41:58.460 payment plan.
00:42:00.720 And that's
00:42:01.280 the problem.
00:42:01.560 The problem
00:42:01.800 here isn't
00:42:02.220 just the debt,
00:42:03.520 although that's
00:42:03.940 a big part
00:42:04.360 of it.
00:42:04.620 The problem
00:42:05.540 is a
00:42:05.980 generation that
00:42:07.140 doesn't own
00:42:07.580 anything and
00:42:08.500 therefore has
00:42:09.120 no steak in
00:42:11.820 the country.
00:42:12.900 Every January,
00:42:13.920 people set big
00:42:14.820 goals about
00:42:15.460 eating better,
00:42:16.340 being healthier,
00:42:17.140 and then reality
00:42:18.020 hits.
00:42:18.480 Work gets busy,
00:42:19.360 life gets chaotic,
00:42:20.120 and suddenly everyone's
00:42:21.400 back to the same
00:42:22.320 tired routine of
00:42:23.900 wondering what's
00:42:24.700 for dinner.
00:42:25.520 That's where our
00:42:26.400 sponsor,
00:42:26.980 Cook Unity,
00:42:27.960 comes in.
00:42:28.620 They bring
00:42:28.940 restaurant-level
00:42:29.720 flavors straight to
00:42:30.640 your door with
00:42:31.420 chef-designed dishes
00:42:32.340 that balance
00:42:33.000 nourishment,
00:42:33.720 creativity,
00:42:34.080 and everyday
00:42:34.780 luxury.
00:42:35.680 Choose from
00:42:36.040 collections like
00:42:36.780 Mood Boosting,
00:42:37.620 Better for Sleep,
00:42:38.340 and Protein Forward,
00:42:39.300 whatever goals you're
00:42:40.520 chasing this year.
00:42:41.260 No cooking,
00:42:42.080 no shopping,
00:42:42.860 no meal planning.
00:42:43.840 Everything arrives
00:42:44.540 fully cooked.
00:42:45.480 All you need to do is
00:42:46.300 heat it up in as
00:42:47.080 little as five minutes.
00:42:48.540 Choose from over
00:42:48.980 300 rotating
00:42:50.020 seasonal meals with
00:42:51.020 chefs like Marcus
00:42:52.320 Samuelson and
00:42:53.220 Michelin star Rick
00:42:55.080 Bayless.
00:42:56.060 I can be picky about
00:42:56.740 good food, and Cook
00:42:57.640 Unity actually gets
00:42:58.720 it right.
00:42:58.960 I ordered the
00:42:59.540 Renwine Bray
00:43:00.320 short rib with
00:43:01.020 mac and cheese,
00:43:01.720 and it was
00:43:02.040 ridiculously good.
00:43:03.140 The chefs clearly
00:43:03.740 know what they're
00:43:04.140 doing, and the
00:43:05.040 variety means that
00:43:05.800 I'm not eating the
00:43:06.600 same boring thing
00:43:07.440 every week.
00:43:08.020 It's a service that
00:43:09.000 doesn't make
00:43:09.600 convenient taste like
00:43:11.160 cardboard.
00:43:11.820 Plus, Cook Unity
00:43:12.600 offers flexibility
00:43:13.600 when you need it.
00:43:14.740 Skip, pause, or
00:43:15.540 cancel anytime.
00:43:17.100 Taste, comfort, and
00:43:17.920 craftsmanship in
00:43:18.560 every bite from the
00:43:19.380 award-winning chefs
00:43:20.220 behind Cook Unity.
00:43:21.420 Go to cookunity.com
00:43:22.380 slash Walsh or
00:43:23.500 enter code Walsh
00:43:24.240 before checkout to
00:43:25.020 get 50% off your
00:43:25.900 first order.
00:43:26.860 That's 50% off
00:43:27.540 your first order by
00:43:28.060 using code Walsh.
00:43:28.960 We're going to
00:43:29.600 cookunity.com
00:43:30.920 slash Walsh.
00:43:33.140 All right, The
00:43:33.460 Independent has this
00:43:34.540 report.
00:43:34.860 Iowa Republican
00:43:35.540 Senator Chuck
00:43:36.740 Grassley has
00:43:37.540 signaled a
00:43:38.080 possible break
00:43:39.960 with President
00:43:41.620 Donald Trump over
00:43:42.220 the passage of
00:43:42.860 the Safeguard
00:43:43.620 American Voters
00:43:44.920 Eligibility Act,
00:43:46.360 the SAVE Act,
00:43:47.540 which would require
00:43:48.200 proof of
00:43:48.720 citizenship to
00:43:49.420 vote.
00:43:50.340 The president has
00:43:50.960 complained since
00:43:51.580 his defeat in
00:43:52.080 2020 about voter
00:43:55.040 fraud.
00:43:55.500 Texas Republican
00:43:57.060 Representative
00:43:57.740 Chip Roy
00:43:58.860 introduced the
00:43:59.680 SAVE Act last
00:44:00.380 January,
00:44:01.480 proposing to
00:44:02.200 amend the
00:44:02.700 National Registration
00:44:03.480 Act and block
00:44:04.980 non-citizens from
00:44:06.020 voting.
00:44:06.820 And it passed the
00:44:07.620 House of Representatives
00:44:08.400 by 220 to 2208,
00:44:11.520 sends the bill to the
00:44:12.180 Senate.
00:44:12.760 If passed,
00:44:13.260 the bill would,
00:44:14.080 and this is,
00:44:14.560 now I'm just reading
00:44:15.180 the Independent,
00:44:16.620 this is how they
00:44:17.240 describe it.
00:44:17.880 If passed,
00:44:18.460 the bill could
00:44:18.860 disenfranchise millions
00:44:19.920 of eligible voters who
00:44:21.060 lack easy access to
00:44:22.220 identification documents
00:44:23.280 and would upend how
00:44:25.360 states register people
00:44:27.240 to vote online or
00:44:28.140 through automatic or
00:44:29.040 same-day registration.
00:44:31.600 In a letter to a
00:44:32.660 constituent posted on
00:44:33.340 social media by
00:44:34.080 MAGA activist Scott
00:44:35.520 Pressler,
00:44:36.200 Grassley,
00:44:36.780 the Senate's 92-year-old
00:44:38.160 president pro-tempo,
00:44:39.880 has expressed sympathy
00:44:41.420 for his correspondent's
00:44:42.460 stated concerns about
00:44:43.760 election security,
00:44:45.660 but then added that he,
00:44:48.780 I have opposed partisan
00:44:49.780 efforts in Washington,
00:44:50.560 D.C. to federalize
00:44:51.460 elections in order to
00:44:52.200 undermine election
00:44:53.060 integrity.
00:44:54.000 I do not believe that
00:44:54.980 Iowa and other states
00:44:55.940 need politicians in
00:44:57.000 Washington dictating and
00:44:58.720 controlling how states
00:45:00.160 run their elections.
00:45:01.960 All right,
00:45:02.480 now obviously this bill
00:45:03.380 should pass.
00:45:04.300 We need voter ID.
00:45:05.880 I don't think I need to
00:45:06.760 go through all the
00:45:07.360 arguments or point out
00:45:08.640 how ID is already
00:45:10.140 required for many of
00:45:11.980 the other things that
00:45:12.880 normal adults do on a
00:45:14.060 day-to-day basis,
00:45:15.000 like driving or opening
00:45:16.660 up a credit card or a
00:45:18.500 bank account or anything.
00:45:19.540 You cannot be a
00:45:20.740 functional adult in
00:45:21.840 America and not have
00:45:24.260 ID.
00:45:26.080 We all know that,
00:45:27.060 or at least the
00:45:27.760 reasonable people among
00:45:29.160 us already know that.
00:45:30.160 And the article tells us
00:45:31.460 that the act would
00:45:32.300 disenfranchise millions
00:45:33.900 of Americans who lack
00:45:36.160 easy access to ID.
00:45:37.780 Well, the second part of
00:45:38.840 that is false.
00:45:40.300 Every American has easy
00:45:43.020 access to ID.
00:45:44.260 No matter where you
00:45:46.060 live, no matter where
00:45:47.960 you live, in modern
00:45:49.680 America, you have easy
00:45:51.180 access to ID.
00:45:53.080 Unless you live out deep
00:45:55.580 in the Alaskan wilderness,
00:45:57.380 okay, unless you're doing
00:45:58.900 an into the wild thing
00:46:00.260 where you're living in an
00:46:01.380 old bus off the grid in
00:46:03.100 the wilderness hunting
00:46:04.340 moose until you eat the
00:46:06.740 wrong kind of berry and
00:46:08.000 die, unless that's your
00:46:10.000 situation, you have easy
00:46:11.500 access to ID.
00:46:12.360 And this claim is
00:46:13.240 especially absurd
00:46:14.120 because, as we all
00:46:16.320 know, it's not talking
00:46:18.000 about people living in
00:46:19.380 the wilderness in
00:46:19.980 Alaska because those
00:46:20.880 people will tend to be
00:46:21.920 white.
00:46:23.460 No, this is referring
00:46:24.800 specifically to black
00:46:26.240 people.
00:46:27.420 And most of them live in
00:46:29.760 urban environments where
00:46:32.420 not only is there going
00:46:33.380 to be a DMV a few blocks
00:46:34.780 away, but there's public
00:46:36.840 transportation to get you
00:46:38.060 there.
00:46:38.280 So, we all know that.
00:46:42.020 Will voter ID disenfranchise
00:46:43.780 millions of Americans?
00:46:45.980 I hope so.
00:46:48.800 Hopefully it will.
00:46:51.300 You know, when I read
00:46:52.000 something like that, well,
00:46:52.940 this will disenfranchise
00:46:54.300 millions of, God, music to
00:46:56.920 my ears.
00:46:57.780 God, I hope so.
00:47:00.260 And that's just me.
00:47:01.060 Okay, all the voters who
00:47:03.380 are so dumb and so
00:47:04.900 helpless and so
00:47:05.920 incompetent that they
00:47:08.400 don't have IDs and can't
00:47:10.840 figure out how to obtain
00:47:12.340 one, I am very glad to
00:47:16.200 disenfranchise all of
00:47:17.740 them.
00:47:19.020 So, when someone's
00:47:20.360 counterargument is, yeah,
00:47:21.720 look at all these helpless
00:47:22.780 morons who don't know how
00:47:25.740 to participate in society as
00:47:27.880 adults.
00:47:28.340 What about them?
00:47:29.800 This will disenfranchise
00:47:30.960 them.
00:47:31.340 I hear that and I say,
00:47:33.040 good.
00:47:34.760 Yes.
00:47:36.940 That's exactly the point.
00:47:39.360 At least to me.
00:47:41.240 I mean, yes, it's, we want
00:47:42.300 to safeguard election
00:47:43.240 integrity.
00:47:43.720 We don't want voter fraud.
00:47:45.280 But, also, if it's, if
00:47:49.940 this has the effect of
00:47:51.320 excluding the dumbest and
00:47:53.480 most incompetent people in
00:47:54.980 the country from being able
00:47:56.500 to vote, I see that as a
00:47:58.340 major bonus.
00:48:02.120 Like, they should already
00:48:03.220 be disenfranchised just
00:48:04.880 based on their incompetence
00:48:06.140 and lack of intelligence to
00:48:07.860 begin with.
00:48:09.700 So, if this is the way that
00:48:11.800 we achieve that, I think,
00:48:13.560 very worthwhile goal, then
00:48:15.820 that works for me.
00:48:19.040 Works for me.
00:48:19.780 Even if you could convince me,
00:48:23.620 even if you could argue that,
00:48:25.720 well, this isn't going to do
00:48:26.460 anything to help prevent
00:48:27.860 voter fraud, which I don't,
00:48:29.660 I don't think that's true,
00:48:30.560 just to be clear.
00:48:31.240 I think it will help prevent
00:48:32.240 voter fraud.
00:48:33.340 But even if you could make the
00:48:34.740 argument that it won't help
00:48:36.020 with that, I would still
00:48:37.280 support it.
00:48:39.940 Because it will weed out the
00:48:42.220 dumbest and most incompetent
00:48:43.660 people in the country who should
00:48:45.280 not be voting and should not have
00:48:47.340 any say in the direction of
00:48:49.180 this country.
00:48:52.160 But putting all that to the
00:48:53.240 side, I just want to think
00:48:54.320 about this part, where it says,
00:48:57.960 again, in a letter to a
00:48:58.780 constituent posted on social
00:48:59.720 media, Grassley, the Senate's
00:49:01.480 92-year-old.
00:49:04.000 That's it.
00:49:04.540 I just want to focus on 92,
00:49:05.900 92 years old.
00:49:09.240 Why in God's name are we
00:49:10.840 allowing 92-year-olds to serve
00:49:13.580 in any position in government,
00:49:15.280 let alone in the Senate?
00:49:18.180 I mean, I've been calling for
00:49:19.260 age limits in Congress and in
00:49:21.240 the White House for years now.
00:49:25.040 Can we at least agree on 90 as
00:49:29.680 a cutoff?
00:49:30.380 Can we do that?
00:49:31.120 Can we start incrementally?
00:49:34.200 Like, can we at least say that
00:49:35.460 when you're 10 years away from
00:49:37.060 being a century old, it's time to
00:49:39.860 retire?
00:49:40.260 Now, I want to make the age
00:49:43.440 limit for Congress and the
00:49:45.300 presidency, 70, 75.
00:49:48.980 That's what I would like to do.
00:49:51.740 But if we can't agree on that,
00:49:53.200 I'll take anything I can get.
00:49:54.400 Okay?
00:49:54.700 I'll take anything I can get on
00:49:55.960 this.
00:49:56.420 So can we, let's start, let's
00:49:58.040 start really easy.
00:49:59.920 How about 90?
00:50:01.400 Can we make the cutoff 90 just to
00:50:03.540 start?
00:50:07.100 But there are people who would
00:50:08.080 oppose that too.
00:50:08.800 Okay?
00:50:10.260 I could say, can we set the age
00:50:11.700 limit at 150?
00:50:13.420 I mean, can we at least, there
00:50:15.020 are people that say, well, why
00:50:16.260 should we?
00:50:17.880 What if a mummy wants to be in
00:50:20.320 Senate, in the Senate?
00:50:21.680 Should we exclude all the mummies?
00:50:25.240 That's ageist.
00:50:28.220 Okay, when you're, when you're,
00:50:30.080 when you're so old that you're
00:50:33.260 Pope old, when you're too old,
00:50:36.680 yeah, like when you're so old that
00:50:37.900 you would be old for a Pope.
00:50:39.200 Then you're too old to be a
00:50:41.700 politician.
00:50:43.320 You know, I, I think we should be
00:50:45.520 able to say that that's because
00:50:47.380 that's how I, I don't know if I'm
00:50:48.420 the only one who does this, but
00:50:49.440 this is kind of how I look at
00:50:50.720 aging.
00:50:53.520 Where I look at it based on
00:50:55.040 professions.
00:50:57.020 So for me, I probably am alone in
00:50:59.380 this.
00:50:59.600 I'm obviously mentally ill, but I,
00:51:03.120 I, so I, I recently, I recently
00:51:04.980 became NFL quarterback old.
00:51:06.920 That was a big moment in my life
00:51:08.920 where if I, now at the age of 39,
00:51:11.700 if I was in the NFL, I would be
00:51:13.380 ancient.
00:51:14.240 I would be like a wily old veteran.
00:51:16.080 I'd be, I'm grandfather age for the
00:51:18.040 NFL.
00:51:19.280 However, if I ran for Congress,
00:51:20.780 then I'm, I'm an energetic,
00:51:23.500 spry, rambunctious youngster at the
00:51:25.940 age of 39.
00:51:27.520 So I'm NFL old, but I'm Congress
00:51:29.380 young.
00:51:30.580 And then you can kind of do that.
00:51:31.660 And then when you get into your
00:51:32.420 sixties, well, you're old in a lot
00:51:34.620 of context, but now you're president
00:51:36.300 young and you're sixties and you run
00:51:38.280 for president, you're like the young
00:51:40.720 upstart.
00:51:42.040 And then once you get into your
00:51:43.160 seventies, you're old in all areas of
00:51:44.980 life, unless you become Pope.
00:51:47.460 If you become Pope at 70, people will
00:51:50.500 look at you and say, wow, it's nice to
00:51:52.660 have a young Pope.
00:51:54.080 It's nice to have a young Pope.
00:51:55.400 This is, this is, this is great.
00:51:56.820 Pope Leo is 70 and people were said
00:51:58.700 that about him.
00:51:59.260 So my only point is that we have people
00:52:02.200 in Congress right now that would be
00:52:04.420 old for a Pope.
00:52:05.540 They're old in all contexts.
00:52:08.760 They would be old for a nursing home.
00:52:12.560 There are people in Congress right now
00:52:13.860 that are so old that if you saw them
00:52:15.540 in a nursing home, they would stand
00:52:18.080 out for how old they are.
00:52:20.480 If you went to a nursing home to visit
00:52:22.280 your grandmother and you saw Chuck
00:52:23.660 Grassley, you would go, wow, that guy's
00:52:24.960 old.
00:52:25.720 You'd look around at all the people in
00:52:28.660 nursing home and you, and he would
00:52:30.020 stand out.
00:52:30.520 You go like, that guy's really old.
00:52:31.920 That's, that's an old guy in this
00:52:33.540 nursing home.
00:52:36.100 And he's in the Senate.
00:52:39.540 Well, I, there's no reason to it.
00:52:41.820 Like there's no good argument for
00:52:43.220 allowing this.
00:52:44.440 No one has ever made it.
00:52:46.260 No one's ever been able to explain
00:52:47.960 why it's important that we allow
00:52:51.280 people who are decrepit, like at a, at a,
00:52:57.400 at a decrepit and senile stage in the
00:53:01.420 aging process, why, why it should still
00:53:04.060 be okay for them to, you know, be
00:53:06.820 representing us in public office.
00:53:10.320 No one's ever been able to explain
00:53:11.520 that.
00:53:12.720 This episode is sponsored by done with
00:53:14.640 debt, drowning a credit card and loan
00:53:16.240 debt.
00:53:16.580 Well, you're not alone, but here's
00:53:17.820 something most people don't know.
00:53:19.040 Now it's actually the best time to
00:53:20.440 negotiate with your lenders, credit
00:53:21.980 card companies and lenders desperately
00:53:23.680 need to clear problem accounts from
00:53:25.540 their books before audits begin.
00:53:27.440 This creates a narrow window where
00:53:29.480 they're far more willing to cut deals
00:53:31.280 than any other time of year.
00:53:32.400 Done with debt has cracked the code on
00:53:34.040 this timing advantage.
00:53:35.340 They know exactly which companies are
00:53:36.660 most motivated to negotiate right now.
00:53:38.740 They use this insider knowledge to get
00:53:40.340 results.
00:53:40.820 You can't achieve on your own best part.
00:53:42.740 No bankruptcy, no, no, no, no new
00:53:44.260 loans, no credit damage.
00:53:45.600 In fact, most clients end up with more
00:53:47.400 money in their pocket within the first
00:53:48.880 month because they're no longer
00:53:50.620 drowning in minimum payments.
00:53:52.080 But this window won't stay open
00:53:53.560 forever.
00:53:53.980 Lenders will tighten up again and your
00:53:55.740 leverage disappears.
00:53:56.640 Get started now, but you still have
00:53:58.200 time.
00:53:58.740 Go to donewithdebt.com, talk with one
00:54:00.720 of their specialists for free.
00:54:01.880 Visit donewithdebt.com, donewithdebt.com.
00:54:05.260 Finally, I mentioned yesterday Ben
00:54:06.800 Affleck and Matt Damon on Joe Rogan.
00:54:09.760 I thought it was a good episode.
00:54:11.020 I listened to the whole thing, which I
00:54:12.380 rarely do with any podcast.
00:54:13.580 And they were actually there to promote
00:54:14.580 their new movie called The Rip, which
00:54:17.180 I watched with my wife last weekend.
00:54:20.900 And it was pretty good.
00:54:22.040 It was like a solid little action flick.
00:54:23.780 So good first act, a good second act.
00:54:27.840 The movie suffers, though, in the same
00:54:29.360 way that movies of this type often
00:54:31.820 suffer, where the tension ratchets up,
00:54:34.420 you know, through the first act and the
00:54:35.800 second act.
00:54:36.900 And then it has to lead somewhere.
00:54:40.380 And in an action movie, it almost always
00:54:42.080 leads to like a big shootout or a car
00:54:44.360 chase.
00:54:46.800 And that relieves the tension sort of by
00:54:50.060 definition.
00:54:50.500 The most tense part of a standoff, which
00:54:54.540 means the most interesting part to watch,
00:54:56.480 is when people are not shooting.
00:54:58.780 It's the threat of shooting that makes it
00:55:00.860 really tense and interesting.
00:55:02.220 The moment they start shooting, the
00:55:04.360 tension releases and it becomes a little
00:55:06.200 less absorbing and a little less
00:55:07.500 interesting.
00:55:08.840 And so anyway, it's pretty good, though.
00:55:12.120 But during the conversation, Affleck
00:55:13.900 started talking about AI in the film
00:55:15.700 industry.
00:55:16.280 You know, this is an issue that I care
00:55:17.480 about AI in general and in particular,
00:55:20.940 AI in the arts.
00:55:23.420 We talk about it a lot on the show.
00:55:25.100 And so there's been some discussion about
00:55:26.460 this clip online and Affleck's take on it.
00:55:30.840 Let's listen.
00:55:33.060 What I see is, for example, if you try to
00:55:35.140 get ChatGPT or Claude or Gemini to write
00:55:38.660 you something, it's really.
00:55:40.140 And it's because by its nature, it goes
00:55:43.760 to the mean, to the average.
00:55:45.600 And it's and it's not reliable.
00:55:47.880 And it's I mean, I just can't stand to see
00:55:50.220 what it writes.
00:55:51.020 Now, it's a useful tool if you're a writer
00:55:52.820 and you're going, oh, what's the thing?
00:55:55.020 I'm trying to set something up where
00:55:56.360 somebody sends someone a letter, but it's
00:55:58.200 delayed two days and gets and it can give
00:56:00.040 you some examples of that.
00:56:01.500 I actually don't think it's very likely
00:56:03.580 that it can it's going to be able to write
00:56:05.860 anything meaningful or in particular that
00:56:08.960 it's going to be making movies like from
00:56:11.060 whole cloth, like Tilly Norwood, like that's
00:56:12.500 I don't think that's going to happen.
00:56:14.360 I think it's I think it actually turns out
00:56:16.420 the technology is not progressing in
00:56:18.100 exactly the same way they sort of presented
00:56:20.580 it. And really what it is, it's going to be
00:56:22.520 a tool just like sort of visual effects.
00:56:25.280 And yeah, it needs to have language around it.
00:56:26.980 You need to protect your name and likeness.
00:56:28.640 You can do that. You can watermark it.
00:56:30.600 You're those laws already exist.
00:56:31.940 You can't I can't sell your picture for money.
00:56:34.280 I can't. You can sue me, period.
00:56:35.860 It kind of feels to me like the things
00:56:37.940 I'm talking about earlier where there's a
00:56:39.060 lot more fear because we have the sense
00:56:41.360 this existential dread is going to wipe
00:56:43.260 everything out. Right.
00:56:44.300 But that actually runs counter in my view
00:56:46.460 to what history seems to show, which
00:56:48.980 is a adoption is slow.
00:56:50.760 It's incremental.
00:56:52.800 I think a lot of that rhetoric comes
00:56:55.080 from people who are trying to justify
00:56:56.920 valuations around companies.
00:56:59.280 They go, we're going to change everything.
00:57:00.900 In two years, there's going to be no more
00:57:01.940 work. The reason they're saying that is
00:57:03.880 because they need to ascribe a valuation
00:57:06.340 for investment that can warrant the capex
00:57:08.980 spend they're going to make on these data
00:57:10.320 centers with the argument that like, oh, you
00:57:12.820 know, as soon as we do the next model, it's
00:57:14.740 going to scale up three times as good, except
00:57:17.300 that actually chat GPT-5, about 25 percent
00:57:20.960 better than chat GPT-4 and costs about four
00:57:24.140 times as much in the way of electricity and data.
00:57:26.560 So those nice things that it's like plateauing.
00:57:29.340 The early AI, the line went up very steeply
00:57:33.120 and it's now sort of leveling off.
00:57:37.140 So I agree with most everything he says there.
00:57:40.520 There are two points I want to add.
00:57:42.700 And so you know that I'm very, very opposed
00:57:45.760 to the idea of AI art, quote unquote art.
00:57:49.660 And I'm very opposed to AI in many other contexts,
00:57:52.160 not all, but in many other contexts.
00:57:53.740 I think the chance that AI basically destroys
00:57:56.680 human society is much higher than the chance
00:58:01.880 that it proves to be any kind of net positive
00:58:04.760 for humanity.
00:58:07.080 I think both of those results are possible,
00:58:13.800 but I think the result of it causing civilization
00:58:19.360 level destruction, I think that that is much
00:58:22.900 greater, but I'll add this.
00:58:24.620 First, I differ with Affleck on one thing.
00:58:26.340 He says that in the context of art, writing,
00:58:29.400 filmmaking, it can be a useful tool,
00:58:31.380 but I don't think it's a tool at all artistically.
00:58:34.580 It can be a tool in other ways,
00:58:36.420 but in the creation of art, it is not a tool.
00:58:43.460 Because, and a lot of people want,
00:58:45.060 I was arguing about this again today on X,
00:58:47.100 and a lot of people want to believe that it's a tool
00:58:52.160 because they use it, and they might use it
00:58:54.740 for some artistic things, for some creative things,
00:58:57.200 and they want to believe that they are the artist
00:59:01.660 using a tool, but that is not the case.
00:59:05.460 Because AI does the task for you.
00:59:10.240 Tools are objects that you use to accomplish a task
00:59:17.480 that you are doing.
00:59:19.780 AI just does the task.
00:59:22.700 And this is easy to understand if you think
00:59:25.480 in terms of actual tools.
00:59:27.140 So if there was a hammer where you could press a button
00:59:31.580 and it would just hammer all the nails for you,
00:59:34.720 not even like it makes it easier to hammer the nails,
00:59:36.880 but you can sit on the couch and drink a beer
00:59:39.200 and this thing will hover, you know,
00:59:42.040 and around and just nail all the stuff for you.
00:59:47.200 Well, in that case, it would be inaccurate to say
00:59:51.260 that you used the tool to hammer the nails.
00:59:54.660 You didn't do anything.
00:59:55.820 You did not hammer the nails.
00:59:57.700 The thing did all of that.
00:59:59.960 You didn't even have to be there.
01:00:02.820 You could have left the room.
01:00:04.100 You could have gone to lunch and come back
01:00:05.980 and all the stuff would be nailed.
01:00:08.820 It's very convenient.
01:00:10.100 I can see the appeal of something like that,
01:00:13.760 but you can't have your cake and eat it too here.
01:00:16.700 You can't use this thing to do the task for you
01:00:20.860 and then also want to take credit for it
01:00:23.080 and say, oh yeah, that's a good bit of construction
01:00:27.980 that I just performed.
01:00:28.720 You didn't do it.
01:00:29.780 You did not do it.
01:00:31.700 The thing did the whole thing.
01:00:33.140 On the other hand, if you use like an actual hammer,
01:00:36.540 a regular hammer, yes, that is you using this thing
01:00:42.000 to accomplish the goal, but it could not happen without you, right?
01:00:47.580 And that's what AI does creatively,
01:00:50.520 which is why I hate it so much in any kind of creative context.
01:00:55.880 And even if you aren't asking AI to generate,
01:01:00.320 say, a whole screenplay for you or make a whole movie or whatever,
01:01:05.240 even if you're just asking it to help with some part of the writing process,
01:01:09.320 whatever that part is, it's doing it for you.
01:01:12.940 It is not a tool assisting.
01:01:14.900 It's just doing it.
01:01:16.820 It is a cheat.
01:01:18.040 It's a shortcut.
01:01:18.740 And to whatever extent you use it in the creation of art
01:01:22.040 is the exact extent to which the final product is not fully art.
01:01:30.880 So, you know, in the world of filmmaking,
01:01:38.280 say, think about like special effects, computer graphics, whatever.
01:01:41.160 Well, without AI, you know, you want to have Godzilla
01:01:47.380 knock over the building in your movie.
01:01:49.580 Well, it's all going to be CGI.
01:01:51.740 I mean, back in the day, they used to use some practical effects for this,
01:01:54.160 but those days are long past.
01:01:56.700 And so now it's going to obviously be CGI.
01:02:01.340 But that requires humans.
01:02:03.360 It requires actual human beings to use computers as a tool
01:02:06.840 to compose those images.
01:02:08.680 And it requires talent.
01:02:11.040 And some humans are better at it than others,
01:02:12.900 which is why some movies look terrible,
01:02:15.800 have terrible CGI and terrible special effects.
01:02:18.720 And other movies have much better
01:02:20.840 because they have better talent behind it.
01:02:23.720 It's an art form.
01:02:25.660 Well, AI takes the building,
01:02:27.900 takes the composing part out of it entirely.
01:02:31.700 Now you just type in,
01:02:33.660 like there's a big difference between using a computer to create,
01:02:37.700 right?
01:02:37.960 You are creating the image of Godzilla knocking the building over.
01:02:41.200 That's one thing.
01:02:42.320 It's an entirely different thing to type into a prompt,
01:02:46.320 generate an image of Godzilla knocking over a building,
01:02:49.700 and then just hit enter.
01:02:52.520 Okay?
01:02:52.700 That's not an artist using a tool.
01:02:55.280 At best, in that case, you're not an artist.
01:02:57.980 You are not an artist.
01:02:58.980 At best, you are a manager delegating a task.
01:03:05.580 And now art is not art.
01:03:07.460 It is management.
01:03:08.520 It is delegation.
01:03:11.400 And I cannot think of a worse fate for art than that.
01:03:15.680 For art to become management.
01:03:20.140 For art to become this, like, bureaucratic delegation of tasks.
01:03:26.900 That is the worst fate imaginable.
01:03:28.900 I would rather that art just disappear entirely.
01:03:32.520 I would rather it be banned by some kind of fascist dictator government.
01:03:36.880 Takes over the world and bans you from ever making any more art.
01:03:41.560 All music, everything is banned.
01:03:43.320 I would prefer that over all art just becomes managers
01:03:49.140 who are dictating prompts to inhuman algorithms.
01:03:56.980 It's like if I commission a painting, right?
01:03:59.280 I am not the artist.
01:04:01.840 If I tell a painter to paint me a picture of a, whatever, a lighthouse,
01:04:07.700 and they paint the picture, and it's beautiful,
01:04:11.020 and I hang it on my wall, and somebody comes to my house,
01:04:13.780 and they see it hanging there in the living room above the fireplace,
01:04:16.660 and they say, wow, great painting.
01:04:19.820 Who painted that?
01:04:21.140 It would be a lie for me to say, well, I did.
01:04:24.180 Oh, that's right.
01:04:25.300 Thank you very much.
01:04:26.180 That's my, actually, I did that.
01:04:28.000 That's my painting.
01:04:29.520 I'm the artist.
01:04:31.640 Right?
01:04:32.020 If they looked at the painting and said, oh, wow, that's amazing.
01:04:34.440 Who's the artist?
01:04:35.960 You would be a godforsaken liar if you said, well, it's me.
01:04:40.420 Because you didn't paint it.
01:04:42.140 You delegated the task to someone.
01:04:44.180 You told them.
01:04:44.820 Even if you kind of described, well, give me a lighthouse that,
01:04:48.560 on a misty morning, and the light is shining, and the waves are crashing,
01:04:54.240 that doesn't make you the artist.
01:04:56.300 That's not art.
01:04:57.180 That's just you saying what you want.
01:04:59.260 The art is in the creating part of it.
01:05:01.340 It's not in the thinking of what you want.
01:05:04.640 Just thinking of what you want.
01:05:06.340 I mean, that's like saying, if you can, I mean, we think of a thousand examples.
01:05:10.200 If I go to a chef and say, here's the meal that I'd really like.
01:05:15.460 You know, I'm really hankering for this.
01:05:18.940 I really want a delicious, you know, steakhouse-quality steak, medium rare.
01:05:25.760 I want some asparagus on the side.
01:05:27.320 I'd like to have some mashed potatoes.
01:05:28.840 You know, I am not cooking the meal.
01:05:32.460 The chef is doing all of it.
01:05:33.880 And, again, if somebody comes in, they take a bite of the steak, and they say, wow, who made this?
01:05:39.400 I would be a liar to say, I made it.
01:05:43.960 And it's no good to say, yeah, but I gave the prompt.
01:05:46.440 I gave the prompt for the steak.
01:05:48.560 I described what kind of steak I would like.
01:05:52.140 Anyone can do that.
01:05:53.200 A five-year-old can do that.
01:05:55.880 Just imagining what you want is not the hard part, right, of this.
01:06:02.760 Of this.
01:06:03.580 It's the actual creating part.
01:06:05.440 I mean, I can imagine in my head, I can easily imagine a really beautiful statue.
01:06:10.280 I could come up with that in my head.
01:06:11.220 Anybody could.
01:06:12.660 In my head, I can generate, in my mind, the most amazing sculpture anyone has ever seen.
01:06:19.320 I can think of a sculpture that, if it existed in the real world, would be the most amazing sculpture of all time.
01:06:24.900 That doesn't make me an artist.
01:06:27.200 The artist is the one who would actually do it, who can actually create it.
01:06:32.760 And, yes, the same thing goes for movies.
01:06:36.580 This is why, like, you know, you get into making movies a little bit, and you talk to people.
01:06:45.520 Everybody has an idea for a movie.
01:06:47.540 Everyone has ideas.
01:06:49.940 I got to tell you my idea.
01:06:51.420 Here's a great idea.
01:06:52.300 And the thing is, you know, a lot of times the ideas are terrible, but sometimes you hear the idea and you're like, that's a decent idea.
01:06:58.880 That'd be a good movie.
01:07:00.320 That doesn't make you a filmmaker.
01:07:02.360 It doesn't make you an artist.
01:07:04.760 Can you go do it?
01:07:06.320 Can you actually write that movie?
01:07:08.200 Can you be involved in a reel?
01:07:10.320 Can you act in it?
01:07:11.220 Like, can you actually be involved in the creation of the thing?
01:07:16.520 And the other point is where Affleck says that, you know, you're never going to be able to just prompt the AI to generate a whole movie out of whole cloth.
01:07:27.800 Well, I think he's wrong.
01:07:31.140 I mean, AI can do that now, really.
01:07:33.580 AI could generate a whole movie right now.
01:07:35.720 It's not a matter of AI developing the ability to perform that task.
01:07:42.260 It has the ability right now, but the difference is that right now the audience would not accept it.
01:07:49.820 So he's right in a sense.
01:07:51.620 There is no totally AI-generated movie that can be made right now that anyone or any sizable portion of people would want to watch.
01:08:01.860 The question, then, for the future is not whether AI will be able to make a movie.
01:08:08.220 It's not whether we'll be in a spot one day where you could just type into a prompt, make me a movie about this.
01:08:13.320 Here's three sentences of the plot.
01:08:14.900 Make the movie.
01:08:15.760 I think we're already kind of there.
01:08:18.420 Or we're at least very close to it.
01:08:20.900 And, I mean, you can already do a shorter version of that.
01:08:23.840 You can have AI make, like, a three-minute video.
01:08:25.620 If it could do three minutes, it could do 90 minutes.
01:08:27.580 There's no reason why it can't.
01:08:30.020 So I think we're already there.
01:08:31.420 We're very close to being there.
01:08:33.440 That's not the question.
01:08:35.200 The question is whether audiences will eventually come to accept it.
01:08:39.900 In other words, will audiences become so numb and so soulless and have such little respect for themselves that they will settle for something like that?
01:08:52.680 Will audiences eventually say, yeah, you know what?
01:08:55.860 I'll sit down and watch a film that was made by no one and generated by an algorithm with no heart or soul or purpose or meaning at all?
01:09:09.300 Well, that's going to be the question.
01:09:15.400 Because that is, as I've said so many times, you know, that is art.
01:09:19.420 Not to be, I was talking about this yesterday and someone said to me, you know, well, that's a romantic view of art.
01:09:26.280 You have a really romantic view of art.
01:09:28.040 Well, of course I do.
01:09:28.760 It's art.
01:09:29.180 If you don't have a romantic view of art, then you don't understand art.
01:09:33.500 That's what art is.
01:09:35.140 What other view of it would you have?
01:09:40.880 But that's what art is, an expression of the human heart.
01:09:44.500 And it's a language spoken and that can only be spoken and only be understood by beings with rational souls.
01:09:55.540 That's what makes it art.
01:09:57.140 And that's what separates it from mere distraction or mere spectacle or even just mere entertainment.
01:10:05.720 Art can be entertainment, but it's not just entertainment.
01:10:10.360 And that's what separates it.
01:10:14.040 So, and that will always be the case, which is why AI will never be able to create art.
01:10:17.240 It will never happen.
01:10:17.940 It cannot happen by definition.
01:10:20.860 For the same reason that AI will never be able to love you.
01:10:24.040 I don't care how advanced it gets.
01:10:26.240 It may get so advanced that it can fool you, if you're a really gullible person, into thinking that it loves you.
01:10:35.460 But it will never be able to actually love.
01:10:38.460 Because it lacks the essential components of love, which is the human soul consciousness.
01:10:47.740 And the question there, too, is not, well, will AI be at a point where it can love a person and you can get married to AI?
01:10:57.320 The answer is no.
01:10:59.240 Will people ever become so degraded that they will settle for, like, marrying a computer?
01:11:07.280 Or will people ever become so degraded that they will settle for watching a piece of art that is not art because it was generated by an algorithm?
01:11:17.060 That's the question.
01:11:17.560 And I think, I hope the answer is no, but all indications are that the answer is yes.
01:11:23.500 That's what scares me.
01:11:25.120 And that is what will do it for the show today.
01:11:28.100 Thanks for watching.
01:11:28.640 Thanks for listening.
01:11:29.220 Talk to you tomorrow.
01:11:30.940 Great day.
01:11:31.500 Godspeed.
01:11:39.800 What was it like, Merlin, to be alone with God?
01:11:47.560 Is that who you think I was alone with?
01:11:55.380 Merlin, I knew your father.
01:11:57.780 I am yet convinced that he was not of this world.
01:12:02.900 All men know of the great Taliesin.
01:12:06.260 You are my father.
01:12:07.440 That the gods should war for my soul.
01:12:10.620 Princess Garrus, savior of our people.
01:12:13.560 I know what the bull god offered you.
01:12:18.720 I was offered the same.
01:12:20.640 And?
01:12:22.200 There is a new power at work in the world.
01:12:24.260 I've seen it.
01:12:26.320 A god who sacrifices what he loves for us.
01:12:29.020 We are each given only one life, Singer.
01:12:31.760 No.
01:12:32.940 We're given another.
01:12:33.680 I learned of Yazoo the Christ.
01:12:39.060 And I have become his follower.
01:12:40.940 He's waiting on a miracle.
01:12:42.460 And I think you can give him one.
01:12:44.500 Trust in Yazoo.
01:12:45.840 He is the only hope for men like us.
01:12:48.760 Fate of Britain never rests in the hands of the great light.
01:12:51.780 Great light.
01:12:52.920 Great darkness.
01:12:54.380 Such things mattered to me then.
01:12:56.760 What matters to you now, mistress of lies?
01:13:00.560 You.
01:13:02.040 Nephew.
01:13:02.520 The sword of the high king.
01:13:09.360 How many lives must be lost before you accept the power you were born to wield?
01:13:17.100 Circling to the promises of a god who has abandoned you.
01:13:20.340 I cannot take up that sword again.
01:13:23.240 You know what you must do.
01:13:26.620 Great light, forgive me.
01:13:32.520 The time has come to be reborn.
01:13:38.580 The time has come to be reborn.
01:13:38.600 The time has come to be reborn.
01:13:40.840 The time has come to beorsun.
01:13:43.240 It's not a total of a fast forward.
01:13:44.380 The time has come to be overcome.
01:13:45.740 The time has come to be reproduction.
01:13:46.400 The time has come to be reborn.
01:13:47.380 The time has come to be forbidden.
01:13:48.520 The time has come to be reborn.
01:13:49.440 The time has come to be reborn.
01:13:50.140 And for when we are born, we want to be madeynn 사람이.
01:13:51.320 And for you to be reborn.
01:13:52.420 And for you guys are Centre for� cultureم.
01:13:54.240 That money must be reborn.
01:13:56.720 It's about as long as everyone is born.
01:13:58.580 It gets accountant.
01:13:59.660 W tells us to be reborn.
01:14:01.360 The time has come to be reborn automatically.
01:14:02.960 The time has come to be reborn.
01:14:03.860 And we don't please.
01:14:04.920 I can only dig into part of the life.