Ep 260 - The Tide Is Turning
Episode Stats
Words per Minute
184.2236
Summary
A law in Alabama would outlaw abortion in almost every case, making no exceptions for rape. The left, of course, is panicking over this. I sense that a tide might be turning in America. Am I being too optimistic? Well, that would be a first, but we ll talk about it. Also, someone asks if conservatives are putting their heads in the sand when it comes to gun violence. Are we? Is that true?
Transcript
00:00:00.000
Today on the Matt Wall Show, a law in Alabama would outlaw abortion in almost every case,
00:00:04.920
making no exceptions for rape. The left, of course, is panicking over this. I sense that a tide might
00:00:10.680
be turning in America. Am I being too optimistic? Well, that would be a first, but we'll talk about
00:00:16.020
it. Also, someone emails and asks whether conservatives are putting their heads in the
00:00:20.480
sand when it comes to gun violence. Are we? Is that true? I'll address that question today on
00:00:26.620
the Matt Wall Show. Welcome to the show, everybody. Thanks for being here. Thanks for
00:00:32.640
listening. I'm in Chicago right now because I was at Northwestern University last night for an event
00:00:40.420
there speaking to the students, and it was a great event. It was a lot of fun. I thought it was a good
00:00:46.020
turnout even though there was some, I'm sure, totally coincidental issues with the university
00:00:54.440
approving the event. I mean, they had been trying to get approval. YAF had been trying to get approval
00:00:58.780
for weeks, and the university coincidentally didn't approve the event until like three days before it,
00:01:06.400
which meant, again, totally coincidentally, that they weren't allowed to advertise it until right
00:01:11.000
before the actual event. But we still filled the room, and it was a good time. What I want to talk
00:01:17.080
about is, speaking of good times, the tide is turning, I think, in America. Now, I don't want
00:01:23.240
to be, I don't want to jump the gun here. I don't want to be overly optimistic. I'm not someone who's
00:01:28.320
known for being overly optimistic, but I think that maybe the tide is turning and people are waking up,
00:01:34.060
and we're going to talk about that in light of this new law that was just passed through the
00:01:38.920
state senate in Alabama. So we're going to get into that. But first, I got to tell you about
00:01:44.100
Bowlin Branch. You know, we're never going to agree on everything as a country, as a society,
00:01:50.340
but the one thing that we all have in common is that we like to sleep, and we, unless you're my
00:01:56.480
kids. My kids hate sleeping, but everyone else in the world, all other humans love to sleep, except
00:02:00.480
for my kids. Everyone else loves to sleep, and we could all use more of it, and getting a great night's
00:02:06.060
sleep is easier than ever, thanks to the world's softest sheets brought to you by Bowlin Branch.
00:02:11.080
Everything Bowlin Branch makes, from bedding to blankets, is made from pure, 100% organic cotton.
00:02:17.640
It's the best material you can find for bedding and blankets, which means they start out super
00:02:22.720
soft, and they get softer with time. Everyone who tries Bowlin Branch sheets loves them. That's
00:02:27.500
why they have thousands of five-star reviews. Just listen to what the customers have to say,
00:02:31.480
and you could look at Forbes, The Wall Street Journal, Fast Company. All of them are talking
00:02:35.080
about Bowlin Branch. They want you to love your purchase, too, so they offer a no-risk,
00:02:39.000
30-day trial, free shipping, so you've really got nothing to lose at all, and you're not
00:02:44.660
going to want it. You can send them back, but you're not going to want to send them back
00:02:46.880
once you sleep on these sheets. You're not going to want to sleep on anything else.
00:02:50.320
So, to get you started right now, my listeners, get $50 off your first set of sheets at BowlinBranch.com.
00:02:56.500
Promo code MATT. Go to BowlinBranch.com today for $50 off your first set of sheets. That's
00:03:02.940
B-O-L-L and Branch.com. Promo code MATT. You know how to spell that. M-A-T-T. BowlinBranch.com. Promo
00:03:10.260
code MATT. All right. Now, from LifeNews.com, an Alabama bill that would make aborting unborn
00:03:15.400
babies a felony passed in the State House on Tuesday. State House Bill 314, sponsored by
00:03:20.520
Representative Terry Collins, would make an abortion and attempt an abortion a felony.
00:03:25.780
Exceptions would be allowed if the mother's life is at risk. Mothers would not be punished for
00:03:29.300
having an abortion under the legislation, which would make killing a baby in an abortion a Class
00:03:33.180
8, or Class A, I should say, felony, punishable by life or 10 to 99 years in prison for abortionists
00:03:39.540
who kill them. Lawmakers approved the ban on a 25 to 6 vote, and it now heads to pro-life
00:03:43.980
Governor Kay Ivey, who's a Republican. The legislation will take effect six months after it gets signed.
00:03:51.280
So, this is just on the heels of the law in Arkansas. So, we've got two major pro-life
00:03:57.020
legislative wins in the span of a week, which means, among other things, that probably Roe v.
00:04:05.180
Wade is going back to the Supreme Court. I think that's where this is headed. And pro-abortion people
00:04:11.500
are terrified of that. That's the last thing they want, because they know that the Roe v. Wade
00:04:15.660
decision was, they know, if they have any knowledge at all about that decision, and they understand how
00:04:24.740
the Constitution works, they know that the Roe v. Wade decision is a total travesty and a joke, a really
00:04:32.180
bad joke. But no matter how you feel about abortion, the idea that they were able to find a right to
00:04:37.560
abortion in the Constitution is obviously absurd. So, that's where it's going. Now, I don't, I talk about
00:04:46.200
being optimistic about the tide turning, and I am. Am I optimistic that the Supreme Court,
00:04:52.240
with its current makeup, would actually vote to overturn Roe? No, I'm not. But there's a chance
00:04:58.780
anyway. There's more of it, there's at least a chance if it makes it there. But as I said, the pro-death
00:05:04.000
crowd is growing very afraid. Cosmo had a headline yesterday. Their headline was, they put it very
00:05:09.320
simply. It was, it's time to freak the F out about abortion. And NARAL's abortion extremist group put
00:05:18.340
out a tweet, said, this is not a drill. The goal is not just to outlaw abortion in certain states,
00:05:23.260
it's to outlaw it everywhere, all caps. Yes, you're damn right. You are damn right. We are going to
00:05:29.900
outlaw it everywhere. That's the goal. And you should freak out. If you are pro-death, you should
00:05:34.320
definitely be freaking out because the tide is turning. I'll tell you what seems to be happening
00:05:39.660
here from my perspective. This is just my sense of things. All right, this is not, this is not based
00:05:44.120
on any survey data or poll data, just my own observations. Do with them what you will. It seems
00:05:52.340
to me that there has never really been a point when a majority of the country was avidly pro-abortion.
00:05:58.780
I don't think that's ever existed. I don't think there's ever been a majority pro-abortion
00:06:04.200
you know, country. The avidly pro-abortion crowd has always been small. They've been small,
00:06:12.540
but powerful. Powerful because they're in positions of power and because they have the indifference of
00:06:18.980
the American public on their side. So no matter what people say when they're surveyed by, by pollsters,
00:06:25.880
the fact is that most of the country is, has been, still is indifferent. Most people just don't care
00:06:33.900
that much. So when the pro-abortion people shriek and demand their right to kill babies, everyone in
00:06:38.880
the middle just goes, eh, sure, yeah, whatever. And that's the dynamic that has allowed abortion to
00:06:44.740
continue in this country. That's what has protected the so-called right to abortion. The problem
00:06:50.040
pro-lifers have faced is that they have this indifferent mass to deal with. And then even,
00:06:57.640
even the ostensibly pro-life people on their own side, relatively active and aware and involved
00:07:04.660
conservatives, people who are pro-life, but even a lot of those people haven't really considered
00:07:11.560
abortion to be an important topic. Now they agree with the pro-life cause, but they just don't feel
00:07:15.820
like fighting for it. And that's what pro-lifers have been contending with. Here's what seems to be
00:07:22.320
changing. The rabidly pro-abortion people are still rabidly pro-abortion. Uh, that, that hasn't
00:07:28.540
changed. That's not going to change. But what I sense is that people in the middle and then the
00:07:34.100
disinterested conservatives, I think some of them are starting to wake up. That's what I see happening.
00:07:41.220
That, uh, finally, some of those other people who have always been up for grabs by pro-lifers,
00:07:47.980
finally, they're starting to come into the light. I got a sense of that in Philly at the rally. Um,
00:07:55.000
even though, you know, it's a thousand people compared to the entire population of the country
00:07:59.100
isn't much, but I really believe that what we did in Philly, we would not have been able to do that
00:08:06.320
five years ago or 10 years ago. I think this is a reflection of a change. Um, and much of it,
00:08:14.300
as I said, is, um, is among conservatives, conservatives, you know, for, for, for decades,
00:08:20.240
there has not really been a wide conservative pro-life coalition. Pro-lifers have always been
00:08:28.040
sort of a subset of conservatism. While mainstream conservatism, most conservatives would look at the
00:08:34.940
pro-life cause and say, eh, you know, yeah, I agree with you, but I don't feel like arguing about that.
00:08:40.600
I think that is really changing now. And conservatives are starting to see, uh, they're
00:08:46.640
starting to see two things. Number one, this really does matter because life, uh, human life is at stake.
00:08:54.320
And I think they've been helped to that realization in seeing the increasing radicalism of the pro-abortion
00:09:01.180
side. When you've got these other laws in other States where we, okay, we can kill babies through all
00:09:06.000
stages of pregnancy. And you've got, you've got Democrats coming out and saying, uh, okay,
00:09:10.400
let's kill babies after they're born. Or, uh, you know, we're going to kill, we're going to kill the
00:09:15.000
kids either way. Remember that's what that one Democrat said, we're going to kill them either
00:09:18.840
way, put them in the electric chair, kill them in abortion, either way. So that kind of stuff,
00:09:23.120
I think has jolted some conservatives out of their stupor. And they're saying, wow, I mean,
00:09:27.900
this is really a, these people really just want to kill babies. We, we, we can't allow this. This is,
00:09:32.700
this is horrible. Um, it, when, when the pro-abortion case is stated honestly and taken to its logical
00:09:45.080
conclusion, which is what we've been seeing a little bit more frequently recently, it shocks
00:09:51.000
the conscience. And so it's good that pro-abortion people have been doing that because I think other,
00:09:57.080
I think conservatives and some of the folks in the middle have had their consciences shocked
00:10:00.780
and that's what's happened. So that's part of it. The other part of it is that I think also
00:10:05.320
conservatives are starting to realize that this is a winnable, it's a very winnable issue
00:10:09.780
because our argument is so unassailable, is so self-evident, um, is so just plain right
00:10:20.760
that we're standing up and saying, don't kill innocent human beings. That's our point.
00:10:26.100
It's, it's, it's the most simple and, um, unbeatable argument you can possibly make.
00:10:36.820
And that, that I think is how things are changing. Now, a couple of things about this Alabama law.
00:10:41.300
First, uh, much is being made to the fact that it was passed through the state Senate by exclusively
00:10:45.680
white males, which of course is irrelevant. Um, you know, I always wonder when people say,
00:10:50.560
oh, these pro-life laws are passed by a bunch of men. Well, what's your point that,
00:10:53.880
are you saying that men are the only ones with the moral intelligence to see that killing babies
00:10:58.000
is wrong? Well, here's the good news. We're not the only ones. Um, now if we were the only ones,
00:11:03.820
that would not really be an insult to us, would it? It'd be an insult to everybody else,
00:11:07.380
but we're not the only ones. Millions upon millions of women are pro-life. Um, and as I pointed out many
00:11:15.180
times, the pro-life movement is led by women. You know, I've been in this movement a long time.
00:11:20.640
I've been to pro-life events in dozens of different States. I've done, you know, countless rallies and
00:11:28.160
fundraisers and everything else. Uh, I've met and talked to thousands of pro-lifers. I can say
00:11:34.720
from experience, I can tell you for sure that this is a movement led by women. Uh, you know,
00:11:40.940
as a man in the movement, I take a back seat and I'm fine with that. This is a movement led by women.
00:11:47.720
Um, but at any rate, the, the gender of the person making the argument is of course irrelevant
00:11:54.700
because those awful sexist men are making the case that it's wrong to kill innocent and
00:12:01.860
defenseless human life. So, uh, you know, once you get past, once you get done with your tantrum
00:12:06.340
about their gender, maybe you could try to engage with the argument. Yeah, I get, oh, well,
00:12:11.800
they're men, they're men. Okay, whatever. Fine. Yeah. They're men. All right. We've established that.
00:12:15.900
Oh, the bad, bad men, tsk, tsk. It shouldn't be men. That's bad to be men. Okay, fine. I'll agree
00:12:22.240
with you there. Let's for a sake of argument, let's agree. They're men. They're terrible.
00:12:25.720
They're sexist, blah, blah, blah. Fine. Good. Okay. We've established that. Now let's talk about
00:12:31.260
what they're actually saying though. Can we, can we, can we engage with that? Second, the other point
00:12:37.540
being harped on is that this law does not allow exceptions for rape. And so the pro-abortion
00:12:43.800
side is, is making this all about that. They're, um, this is all they want to talk about this. Oh,
00:12:48.360
the law forces women to carry their rapist baby. Now, as if this law was specifically designed with
00:12:56.860
that in mind, which of course it wasn't, but that's all they want to do. They want to talk
00:13:00.680
about the hard cases. They don't want to talk about the 98 or 99% of cases that have nothing at all to do
00:13:04.820
with rape. And that's what we should be talking about mainly because that is mainly what this law deals
00:13:11.000
with. And the vast majority of cases are, uh, have, have nothing to do with rape. Now, as for the
00:13:18.140
cases of rape, which are rare and in a very small minority, but as for them, there are two things to
00:13:23.860
keep in mind. Number one, abortion helps rapists cover up their crimes. Abortion, rapists love abortion.
00:13:32.020
Rapists love, Planned Parenthood is the, is, is, is a rapist's best friend. Um, because
00:13:38.600
you, if when a rapist rapes someone and creates a baby, most of the time they didn't, that's not
00:13:46.140
what they had in mind. They, they weren't trying to create a baby. And if this is a, you know,
00:13:50.660
uh, uh, what here, the, the people that are coming up with these, you know, hard case hypotheticals,
00:13:57.560
well, what if a 13 year old girl is raped and now she's forced to carry your baby? Well, if a 13 year
00:14:02.580
old girl is pregnant, that's a very good indication that probably a crime occurred. Um, and once you
00:14:14.200
have the baby, you know, you can do a DNA test and find out who the father is. And if that father
00:14:21.640
is a, is an adult, then that person is going to jail. So now we can prove, we can prove that a, that a
00:14:28.920
rape occurred. That's why rapists would rather just send the victim off to Planned Parenthood,
00:14:36.420
have the pregnancy taken care of, and the evidence thrown into a medical waste dumpster.
00:14:42.300
And Planned Parenthood, by the way, is more than happy to help with this. They're more than happy
00:14:46.780
to just take the money from the rape victim, throw out the evidence, not call the cops are more than
00:14:50.900
happy to do it. They do it all the time. So that's the first thing. Second thing is, it's a very simple
00:14:57.040
concept here. Um, I of course have nothing but compassion for rape victims and I have nothing
00:15:05.120
but contempt for rapists. And if you wanted to talk about a law that enacts abortion for rapists,
00:15:13.580
if we're talking about executing rapists, then I'm all ears on that discussion. We could talk about
00:15:19.020
that. Um, but it is immoral to punish an innocent third party. Uh, that child didn't do anything.
00:15:32.620
The child's not guilty. So punish the rapist, but to punish the rapist child is completely and totally
00:15:42.360
immoral and wrong. Obviously. Um, and it's not going to help anything. It's, it's not going to
00:15:51.780
help the woman heal. It's not going to undo what is done, what was done. And it's not going to help
00:15:58.000
bring about justice. It's going to make it harder to achieve justice. All right. Uh, so that's,
00:16:05.100
that's the law in Alabama. Um, let's see here. I wanted to share this with you yesterday. I wrote
00:16:14.040
something, uh, trying to explain the left's gender theories. And I tried to put myself into the
00:16:21.440
mindset of a leftist and, uh, which is, it's a, it's a very weird place to be, but I wanted to kind
00:16:26.640
of explain gender, gender dynamics from their perspective. It's bewildering and it makes your
00:16:33.160
head hurt. But, um, if you didn't see that piece, let's, let's try to go through this. Okay.
00:16:38.700
Let's, let me see if I can do this from their perspective, because there are a lot of seeming
00:16:43.520
contradictions and people are very confused about, you know, what, what is, what, what exactly is the
00:16:48.940
left's gender theory now? It seems like they, they, they say a lot of first they're saying one
00:16:52.980
thing, then they're saying something else that contradicts the thing they just said. So let's see if
00:16:56.000
we can, let's see if we can go through this. All right. Um, again, from, from their perspective,
00:16:59.960
just explaining it to you, right-wing bigots. So the first thing that we have to understand
00:17:05.920
is that gender is a social construct, right? Uh, woman and man are concepts that are arbitrarily
00:17:12.280
invented by society. They have nothing to do with reality. Um, a child is assigned one of these
00:17:17.800
labels randomly at birth by primitive backwards thinking doctors who for no good or objective
00:17:23.780
reason have decided that a human child with a penis must be a boy and a human child with a vagina
00:17:28.720
must be a girl. These words are interchangeable. The body parts are interchangeable. None of it means
00:17:33.520
anything, but remember that the generic people we meaninglessly call women are beautiful and
00:17:41.360
powerful and their arbitrary womanhood should be constantly celebrated all the time. Uh, women
00:17:47.000
have to band together and lift each other up. Women must be represented equally in all of our
00:17:51.560
institutions. Women are truly wonderful, splendid, special creatures, but remember there is nothing
00:17:58.700
special about women. Literally anyone can be a woman. A woman is not anything in particular. A
00:18:03.040
person with a penis can be a woman. A person with a vagina can be a woman. If a bucket of sand came to
00:18:07.240
life and wanted to be a woman, it could be a woman too. Anyone could be a woman. So there is no aspect of
00:18:12.340
womanhood that is ingrained or biological or inaccessible to males. And womanhood certainly has nothing at all
00:18:18.340
to do with your body parts. That's the most important thing. But if you don't have a uterus, then you
00:18:23.640
shouldn't be giving your opinion on abortion. Uh, no uterus, no opinion. That's the motto, right?
00:18:28.700
We're tired of men making decisions about women's bodies, but there is no such thing as a woman's
00:18:34.880
body. Trans women are women. Uh, remember a trans woman is just as much a woman as a, as, as any other
00:18:40.160
woman. There's absolutely no difference between the two and to suggest otherwise is the height of
00:18:45.140
bigotry. Okay. But anti-abortion laws are sexist because they specifically target women, uh, who are
00:18:52.060
the ones having the babies. If men could have babies, abortion would be completely legal everywhere,
00:18:57.660
right? But men can have babies and women can be fathers and fathers can be mothers and mothers can
00:19:04.420
be men and a man can be a woman and women can be men who are mothers. I mean, what's so confusing
00:19:09.480
about this? How many times do I have to say it? It's, it's, it's, it's very simple. Men and women are
00:19:14.040
exactly the same in every way. And anyone who belongs to one group can just as easily belong
00:19:18.920
to the other because there is absolutely nothing at all that objectively distinguishes these two
00:19:23.060
categories. And therefore you cannot say something about the one category that does not apply just
00:19:27.980
as much to the other. But women are especially oppressed in our society. Men don't know what it's
00:19:33.800
like for women in this country. Uh, men have privilege and institutional power and they can't
00:19:38.740
possibly relate to the struggles of women. That's why it's so important to make sure that women
00:19:43.880
are given every chance to succeed without being hampered by the, you know, by the unfair advantages
00:19:48.840
that are given to men. But males should be allowed in female sports. It is unthinkable to oppress a
00:19:55.760
biological male by refusing him entry into female sports. If the other girls don't like it, then you
00:20:00.580
know what? They should check their privilege and shut their bigoted mouths. But women must stand up and
00:20:07.640
speak out against unfairness. They must be able to claim their own spaces. What belongs to them
00:20:13.080
must not be appropriated. But drag queens are gorgeous and amazing. There are few things more
00:20:21.080
beautiful than the sight of a man in women's clothing and fake breasts dancing around on stage. But men are
00:20:27.720
scum. But men are women. But patriarchy. But social construct. But girl power. But I'm confused. It's all
00:20:40.940
very confused. It's all incoherent. Do you know why? Because coherence is for bigots. Okay, that's what this
00:20:48.540
comes down to. Now, do you understand? Hopefully you do. I'm glad that I could clear that up for you. All right.
00:20:58.220
Before we get to emails, I was planning on talking about this story. I had set aside like 20 minutes for it
00:21:07.260
because it's so great. But I feel like the rug's been pulled out from underneath me there. Maybe you saw this
00:21:12.560
online. It was kind of going viral over the last few days. There's a story out of South Africa about a
00:21:17.560
man who reportedly had been going to KFC. I don't know if it was the same KFC or different KFCs, but
00:21:26.120
he had been going to KFC for a year, eating for free, claiming to be a food inspector from the head
00:21:32.940
office who had been sent there to inspect the chicken and taste it. And that was the story anyway.
00:21:40.260
And it is apparently the guy had been arrested, which is totally unjust. But then as I was just doing a
00:21:46.960
little bit of background research to talk about it, I saw that apparently this story has been called into
00:21:52.340
question. And now KFC has denied that such a thing ever happened or that such a person exists. Now, I don't
00:21:59.100
know if that's just them covering their tracks because they're so humiliated. I don't know. Maybe we'll never
00:22:04.780
know. But we can only just hope that this man is out there somewhere. This mythical legend of a man
00:22:14.060
who, you know, you could say all you want that it's dishonest, it's stealing. And yeah, it's all
00:22:19.880
those things. But this is a man who believed in something. You know, this is a visionary.
00:22:28.140
This is someone who had an idea and where other people would say, oh, that's crazy. You can't do
00:22:34.840
that. He said, I'm going to do it. And he did. Unless he doesn't exist. But let's just assume
00:22:41.800
that he does. Wonderful and inspiring story. All right, let's get to some emails. MattWalshow
00:22:46.700
at gmail.com. MattWalshow at gmail.com. This is from Michael. Says, hi, Matt. I'm 23 years old
00:22:51.080
and have been a type one diabetic since I was 17. I work in an office buying parts and find my job
00:22:56.720
absolutely miserable. Since I was little, I've dreamed of serving my community and putting my
00:23:01.340
body on the line in order to protect my community and the country I love. I spoke with three different
00:23:04.900
military recruiters during my time in college, but the conversation never lasted longer than a few
00:23:08.680
minutes. Once they found out about my condition, I plan on applying for my local fire department in
00:23:13.420
the fall, but I'm worried I'll have the same result. I know I will find value in raising and
00:23:19.220
practicing raising and protecting a family someday, but I don't know how much longer I can work in an
00:23:24.400
office. Do you have any advice about vocation or about finding meaning in remedial jobs that don't
00:23:29.540
seem to impact the greater good? I'm struggling to see how I'm making a difference. You're incredible.
00:23:34.540
Thanks for all you do. First of all, I think your desire to have a job where you're protecting your
00:23:41.900
community is very noble. And so you should be commended for that. And, you know, I don't know.
00:23:48.000
Maybe I'm not sure what the rules are in fire departments, as opposed to the military, what
00:23:52.460
their, you know, uh, what their physical standards are or whatever, but, uh, it's quite possible that
00:23:58.420
that could work out. Um, but as for the job that you have now, I think that it is, and I'm not,
00:24:06.480
I'm not just, I'm not just saying this. I really do believe that to go into an office and work,
00:24:12.560
what you refer to as what are you, a remedial job, um, which isn't the word I would use for it, but
00:24:19.760
to work a job like that in an office, working a job you don't really like that, that also is a noble
00:24:26.460
pursuit. And, um, that takes, that takes, uh, determination that takes, um, you know, I would
00:24:37.220
even say, you know, it takes courage in a way to, to go doing a job that you really don't like
00:24:44.120
and that you hate doing, but to go in every day and do it anyway, because you know, it's your
00:24:49.280
responsibility. And because you want to have a family one day. And then when you have a family,
00:24:53.080
you continue doing it to, to protect them and, and to provide for them. Um, because there are a
00:24:59.600
lot of people, there, there are plenty of people in our country today who will say, ah, you know,
00:25:02.500
I don't want to do this job. I don't want to do that one. So I'm not gonna do any job. I'll just
00:25:05.360
live off the government or I'll live off my parents or whatever. I don't want to, because if I don't
00:25:09.700
want to, I don't want to spend my time doing something I don't want to do. So I have a lot
00:25:14.160
of respect for someone who says, okay, I'm going to go, I don't like doing it. Um, but I'm going to
00:25:18.220
go in and do it anyway. And so I think you can find, I think you can find some real nobility in that.
00:25:24.460
Um, and I think that you are impacting the greater good in that sense.
00:25:32.500
Uh, that you're fulfilling your obligations. You know, you're doing your duty and that certainly
00:25:39.500
contributes to the, to the greater good. And that also provides an example to others around you. So
00:25:44.680
what I would say is obviously keep, keep doing that job for now. Um, but how old did you say you
00:25:52.220
say you're 23 years old? Well, look, I mean, you're doing that job. You have the sense of duty. So
00:25:56.880
that's a great sign. Um, there's no reason to assume though, that you're going to be in this
00:26:03.620
job for the next 40 years. I mean, these days, nobody stays in one job for 40, even if you like
00:26:07.680
the job and want to stay there, you probably won't. So yeah, your whole life ahead of you.
00:26:11.460
And I would say, keep doing this job and, uh, keep whatever your dream sort of job is and whatever
00:26:16.760
you really want to do, keep pursuing that. In the meantime, don't give up on the job that you have,
00:26:21.060
keep that, but also pursue, um, the sort of job you want. So don't give up on that dream.
00:26:28.000
I think that you'll, you'll find it. You're only 23. I mean, it's, you, you still got, uh,
00:26:32.580
quite a lot of time to find that job and, um, you know, and invest yourself in a vocation that
00:26:40.440
is really meaningful to you. And I have confidence that you will, you will find that.
00:26:46.040
This is from Gareth says to the future, unquestioned King, Emperor, and Grandmaster of this and all other
00:26:50.400
worlds. Recently, I've been asking questions about what will happen when you take your power
00:26:54.020
rather than add to the growing list of your, of those incurring your wrath by questioning your
00:26:58.440
plans. I'd like to offer my service as your Lieutenant and helping you to subdue the masses
00:27:02.320
and setting up your theocratic dictatorship. I vow to crush your enemies, to drive them before you
00:27:07.200
and fill your ears with the lamentations of their women. Thank you for reading this, this, uh,
00:27:11.440
unworthy letter. Okay. May you live forever. Gareth, um, your desire to serve beside me makes me
00:27:18.560
concerned that you are planning to sabotage and overthrow my regime. Now, of course,
00:27:23.360
if you did not want to serve me, then I'd be concerned that you're disloyal and rebellious.
00:27:27.280
So basically either way, you're off to the gulag. Sorry about that. Um, fortunately in my abounding
00:27:32.680
mercy, first time offenders will only have to serve 35 years of forced labor, uh, unless you've been
00:27:39.380
accused of treason, which is what I'm accusing you of, in which case it's a hundred years. So, um,
00:27:44.480
you know, but those are the rules. I really, I can't do anything about it. Well, I could do
00:27:49.900
something about it, but I don't want to because of my cruelty, um, uh, cruelty and mercy. You know,
00:27:55.800
it's a, it's an interesting combination. Let's see. It says, dear Matt, I would first of all,
00:28:01.240
like to thank you for the work you do and especially for the clear and helpful arguments you make about
00:28:04.260
why abortion is evil. As a new mother and human being, that issue was especially close to my heart
00:28:08.220
and it's been sickening to watch the events in New York and Virginia unfold. So thanks for fighting
00:28:12.500
the good fight. Um, I'm from Hungary and moved here last July to join my husband, who's an American.
00:28:19.000
I say all this to give a little context. I'm a Christian and a conservative, and I've really
00:28:24.080
enjoyed listening to podcasts about American politics. And I found my views line up with most
00:28:28.340
of those professed by the, by the smart, thoughtful, and well-read conservative thinkers I look up to.
00:28:32.880
However, the one area in which I feel there's a lack of nuanced solution finding is gun violence.
00:28:37.560
What I see is what we call ostrich politics because apparently ostriches, when sensing danger,
00:28:44.400
dig their heads into the sand, not realizing that just because they can't see the danger anymore,
00:28:48.380
it hasn't evaporated. Um, how they're still not extinct is beyond me, but I digress.
00:28:53.980
That's kind of what, you know, two-year-olds will do also when they're playing hide and seek,
00:28:57.360
they'll cover their eyes and they think that they, they have disappeared and you can't see them
00:29:01.200
anymore. So it's a similar sort of thing. So what I see is slightly disappointing to me because
00:29:05.300
every time the topic comes up, the right seems to restate their stance and then use the
00:29:08.800
aforementioned tactic and end the discussion. I have no idea what solution, what a solution might
00:29:12.760
be, but I'd like to at least hear conservatives discuss the issue. Wouldn't it be our duty to try
00:29:17.260
to find ways to minimize the chance that a horrific incident like a school shooting might occur?
00:29:21.660
Even if we think perpetrators can turn their knives, turn to, turn to knives or other means of
00:29:26.160
inflicting harm. The analogy that came to mind for me is this. You have electrical outlets in the
00:29:30.980
house and also a child who routinely starts crawling towards them and poking at them. What do you do?
00:29:34.780
You clearly can't remove the outlets. They're a given, they're here to stay. But do you say,
00:29:38.800
meh, if I stopped the kid from poking this one, he'll still find another one. And even if I stopped
00:29:42.640
every attempt, he would still fall down the stairs and hurt himself that way or get hit by a car,
00:29:46.340
whatever. If it's going to happen, it's going to happen. I would hope not. And if it's mental
00:29:50.040
illness and not the guns, there's got to be something that could be at least attempted to try
00:29:53.720
to address that. By the way, I cannot believe that the reason there's basically no gun violence in,
00:29:58.080
for example, Hungary is because there just aren't as many mentally ill people. The country has been
00:30:02.100
completely ravaged by the world wars and Soviet rule. It was just emerging from communism when I
00:30:06.800
was born and healthcare is a mess. I have to think guns have something to do with it. But let's say
00:30:10.680
that that's even beside the point because of the second amendment. So guns are here to stay. Okay.
00:30:15.060
Is there really nothing further to be said after that? If there, is there nothing we can try to do
00:30:19.300
as a society, even if it falls way short of stopping every single shooting? Is it really more guns? I feel
00:30:24.220
very uneasy about that solution. Also just an added question, because I hear this a lot. If the government
00:30:28.660
comes for you, you have to be able to protect yourself. Students in Budapest led an uprising
00:30:33.940
against communist rule in 1956, and they did quite well, right up to the point where the Russians sent
00:30:38.560
in their tanks. If the government wants to get you, they will not be deterred by any arsenal of guns you
00:30:43.140
might have, however impressive. Or am I not seeing something? I hope the letter isn't too long to get
00:30:48.880
tossed in the spam right away. No, I have no problem with long letters. I don't mind reading.
00:30:56.660
Either way, I very much appreciate your integrity and spine, something that's a very rare trait these
00:31:01.080
days. Best wishes that I give this person's name. Lilla from Lilla, I think is how you pronounce it.
00:31:06.920
All right. Lilla, hopefully I'm pronouncing your name right. I appreciate that email. And I think
00:31:13.900
what you express is very coherent and intelligent and thoughtful. And there's nothing wrong with
00:31:20.680
saying. And I think that there are some, there are probably many conservatives who are so dogmatic
00:31:27.780
about guns that even what you just said there, they're just going to shut you down and say,
00:31:33.240
I'm not even how, you know, you're a heretic for even saying that. I don't take that approach.
00:31:38.420
And I believe in gun rights. I am a pretty hard line on that, but I'm not dogmatic in the sense that
00:31:44.540
we can talk about it. I mean, I can understand there are, it's, it's not like it's unreasonable
00:31:50.160
to make an argument and say, well, maybe we should restrict that or this or that gun.
00:31:54.320
I'm probably going to disagree with the argument you make, but it's not an unreasonable argument.
00:31:59.720
And, uh, I think this is one thing we have to just, I don't want to get sidetracked and not
00:32:04.200
address your question, but you know, one of the reasons why discussions, our discourse in this
00:32:12.120
country is so fruit, often so fruitless is that we treat every opposing argument as totally
00:32:18.880
unreasonable. And we don't realize that it's possible to be, to be reasonable and wrong.
00:32:25.000
And if someone is reasonable and wrong, then we need to, we should just talk to them and have a
00:32:29.400
human discussion and we don't need to treat them like they're, like they're morons. Right.
00:32:34.460
So that's the issue. Now there's, there are some arguments that really are completely
00:32:39.040
unreasonable. Like the argument that a man can be a woman. Well,
00:32:41.900
that's an unreasonable, ridiculous argument. And so we can't treat it like it is reasonable.
00:32:46.920
We should engage with it and try to explain why the person is wrong, but we cannot treat that
00:32:50.620
argument like it's intelligent or reasonable, or like we understand their point of view because
00:32:55.060
it's not intelligent. We don't understand it. Um, it's, it's because it's not understand. It's,
00:32:59.580
it's, it's not a coherent, rational argument. There is nothing to understand.
00:33:04.440
So that's, that's the point there. Um, as for the issue of guns,
00:33:09.480
here's, here's, here's where I stand on this. I agree with you that we do need to do something
00:33:17.280
focusing in on the school shooting thing. I do get uncomfortable when you have conservatives who
00:33:23.820
will constantly point out that, Oh, you know, actually there aren't really, there, there hasn't
00:33:30.260
been an uptick in mass shootings. That's just a kind of a figment of our imagination because of the
00:33:34.880
way the media reports this stuff. And if you look at the statistics, it's, you know, it's not any more
00:33:38.520
common now than it is that it was back then. And kids aren't any, aren't at any more risk today for
00:33:43.420
the school shooting than they were say 30 years ago. I mean, statistically that might be true,
00:33:48.180
but it's, we're not imagining things. I mean, you do have these school shootings that happen every
00:33:55.840
single year now. And I don't think it's always been that way. I remember when, when Columbine happened
00:34:03.340
and the reason why Columbine sticks out to us, why it was this, this event, this kind of history
00:34:11.380
changing event is because no one had really seen anything like that before. Uh, now it's, it seems
00:34:18.280
like every couple of years, there's a, there's a shooting like that. And that's not normal. And if it
00:34:24.840
is normal, it shouldn't be. So we do need to accept that there's a very real problem here.
00:34:32.780
Um, we need to do something in my opinion, and you might not like this answer based on what you're
00:34:39.540
on your email there. My opinion is the most direct way to address that problem is to protect our
00:34:47.960
children in school. Because the fact, what you said there about, well, guns are reality. They're there
00:34:53.200
anyway. That really is true. Now you do have the second amendment, which is not a small thing.
00:34:58.740
It is, it's the, it's the second, it comes right after free speech. Obviously our founding fathers
00:35:02.960
found it to be very important and you can't just toss it out the window. Even if you could prove to
00:35:08.700
me in a crystal ball that, well, if we could just get rid of the second amendment, then it would cause
00:35:13.260
mass shootings to go down. Well, still the amendment still exists. We still have that liberty. We still have
00:35:18.820
that freedom. It's just like, if you could prove to me that, well, if we get rid of, uh, free speech, it would,
00:35:24.540
it would have this and that positive effect. Uh, yeah, but we still have that freedom and it's still there.
00:35:31.860
So we can't, we can't ignore it. We just can't do that. It's law. It's liberty. We can't ignore it.
00:35:38.340
But even aside from that, um, the fact is there are tens of millions of guns out there. And it is
00:35:45.560
true that if somebody gets it into their head, that they want to kill mass numbers of people,
00:35:52.940
they have the desire to do that. We talked about this last week about desire and opportunity.
00:35:58.060
The reason why most of us are never going to do a school shooting is because we have absolutely no
00:36:04.360
desire to do that. And we never will. There are people, whether through spiritual evil or mental
00:36:11.300
illness, whatever you want to say, who find in themselves that desire to kill mass numbers of
00:36:16.860
people. And then once they have that desire, all they're looking for is the opportunity.
00:36:22.800
And there simply is no law that's going to deprive them of that opportunity. That's the fact,
00:36:30.760
which it seems like, you know, so do we say, Oh, well, they're going to do it anyway. There's
00:36:36.300
nothing we could do. Absolutely not. I think we need to be taking proactive steps to defend and
00:36:42.120
protect our children in these schools. We need to be doing real things, real active measures.
00:36:50.260
Um, and one of those things is to make sure that every school in America has armed security.
00:36:56.340
And I know we might like that. We might say, well, we, we shouldn't have to live. We shouldn't live
00:37:01.060
in a country where you need armed security in a school. Yeah, we shouldn't, but we do. And so we
00:37:05.500
should have it. There's armed security in pretty much any other government building you can think
00:37:10.440
of. Public schools are government buildings. And in pretty much any other government building you
00:37:14.120
can think of, there's armed security. You go to the social security office. Uh, I went there with,
00:37:18.820
you know, I, when I got married, we went there for, with, uh, my wife and I went there and, uh,
00:37:25.160
just a little small office with a few people sitting there in the waiting room. And there's
00:37:28.660
an armed guard sitting there and to protect what documents, papers. So if we've got armed security
00:37:37.680
to protect documents and papers and armed security to protect politicians in Washington, then I think
00:37:44.160
we, our children who are in government buildings also deserve that same protection. So that's what I
00:37:50.760
would do. And that's not, that's not an ostrich in the sand that is taking real active steps
00:37:56.200
because going back to opportunity. Now there's nothing we could do about the fact that people
00:38:01.560
are going to develop this desire. Um, that's going to happen. We can't stop that from happening
00:38:06.920
as far as depriving them of opportunities. Well, a law is not going to take the opportunity
00:38:13.860
because a law is just a, it's just a concept, right? Um, in terms of from a preventative
00:38:21.180
perspective, like if I want to kill someone, you say, well, there's a law against killing
00:38:25.960
people. Okay. But I, it's not, it's not going to physically stop me from doing it. That will
00:38:30.780
allow you to punish me after the fact, which is good, but it's not going to physically stop
00:38:35.580
me. I think what we need to do on top of having laws is we need to have actual physical barriers
00:38:42.040
that may prevent, may hinder my opportunity to do the bad thing. And that physical barrier
00:38:52.540
in this case would be armed guards. I think it would be very difficult to argue that, you
00:39:01.780
know, a school shooting where there's an armed guard is, is likely to be just as deadly as
00:39:07.520
a school shooting where there is no guard. I think about Sandy hook. I mean, those kids,
00:39:13.960
those poor kids were just sitting there in the classroom, utterly defenseless until the
00:39:21.280
police arrived. I think it's, I think it's immoral and wrong to leave our kids defenseless
00:39:27.600
like that. And so that's what I would, that's how I would address it. Um, and I think that,
00:39:33.920
I think that is a proactive step that we can take. Thanks for the email. Uh, I guess we
00:39:41.460
will leave it there. Thanks for watching everybody. Thanks for listening. Godspeed.
00:39:45.880
Hey everybody. It's Andrew Klavan, host of the Andrew Klavan show. You know, repealing Roe v. Wade
00:40:03.880
would be a good thing because it might be a step on the way to not killing so many babies,
00:40:07.960
but it would also be good for the left. And I'll explain why on the Andrew Klavan show.