The Matt Walsh Show - April 02, 2026


The Real History of the American Indians

Topics
Hosted by
Mentioned
Ep. 1760 - Ketanji Brown Jackson Needs To Be Impeached. This Dangerously Idiotic Dissent Is PROOF. Ep. 1761 - This VIRAL Video Shows What We've Lost -- And It's Devastating

Episode Stats


Length

1 hour and 5 minutes

Words per minute

169.04

Word count

11,107

Sentence count

518

Harmful content

Misogyny

5

sentences flagged

Toxicity

8

sentences flagged

Hate speech

90

sentences flagged


Summary

Summaries generated with gmurro/bart-large-finetuned-filtered-spotify-podcast-summ .

The Trail of Tears is one of those stories that's beaten into our collective consciousness starting in grade school. We're taught, in no uncertain terms, that Native Americans were forcibly removed from their ancestral lands by the U.S. government between 1830 and 1850, and that thousands of Indians died in the process.

Transcript

Transcript generated with Whisper (turbo).
Misogyny classifications generated with MilaNLProc/bert-base-uncased-ear-misogyny .
Toxicity classifications generated with s-nlp/roberta_toxicity_classifier .
Hate speech classifications generated with facebook/roberta-hate-speech-dynabench-r4-target .
Topics generated with Qwen2.5-3B-Instruct.
Hosts, guests, and mentioned names generated with spaCy (en_core_web_sm), reconciled against Wikidata.
00:00:00 If you grew up in the United States in the past 50 years, then you know about the Trail of Tears.
00:00:06 It's one of those stories that's beaten into our collective consciousness starting in grade school.
00:00:11 We're taught, in no uncertain terms, that Native Americans were forcibly removed from their ancestral lands by the U.S. government between 1830 and 1850,
00:00:20 and that thousands of Natives died in the process.
00:00:23 The government did this so that white men could seize Indian land and the valuable resources that it sat on. 0.79
00:00:30 In case you missed that lesson in the classroom, you might have caught it in the 2006 documentary narrated by James Earl Jones
00:00:37 or the sprawling national park with signs that note that the Indians did not want to leave
00:00:42 or the endless amount of online propaganda about it.
00:00:45 Much of what they're saying is a myth.
00:00:48 As it turns out, none of the Cherokee Indians who traveled the Trail of Tears
00:00:53 had ever heard of the Trail of Tears. That's because from 1830 to 1850 almost no one used the
00:00:58 phrase. The term was popularized a full seven decades after the Cherokees moved to Oklahoma
00:01:04 and even then it wasn't truly a household name. That didn't happen until the 1960s,
00:01:08 more than a century after it took place. But it isn't just the name that's at issue here,
00:01:14 It's the details that are so often omitted from the actual story.
00:01:18 The story begins in 1830 when President Andrew Jackson signed the Indian Removal Act.
00:01:23 The law did not authorize the U.S.
00:01:25 government to forcibly remove Indians or march them westward against their will.
00:01:30 Instead, the law authorized the president to negotiate legally binding treaties
00:01:35 with the various tribes in which those tribes would be awarded compensation.
00:01:39 a new territory west of the Mississippi,
00:01:42 in exchange for voluntarily vacating the territory
00:01:45 that they currently lived on.
00:01:46 In accordance with that law,
00:01:47 many Indian tribes agreed to terms to relocate.
00:01:50 The first major treaty was the Treaty of New Echota in 1835.
00:01:55 In school, this treaty is presented as a fraudulent agreement
00:01:59 in which a tiny number of Cherokees
00:02:01 signed away all Cherokee lands in the Southeast, 0.85
00:02:04 allowing the U.S. government to obtain a pretext
00:02:06 to forcibly remove the Cherokees to Oklahoma, 1.00
00:02:09 resulting in the deaths of 4,000 Indians.
00:02:11 Well, every aspect of that narrative is false.
00:02:15 The first lie is that 4,000 Indians died.
00:02:18 That figure comes from a letter
00:02:19 written by Dr. Eliza Butler,
00:02:21 a member of the American Board of Commissioners
00:02:23 for Foreign Missions,
00:02:25 was hired by the Cherokees to embed on the relocation.
00:02:28 He admitted later that the number, quote,
00:02:30 was based on hearsay and guesswork.
00:02:33 Now, the actual figure is likely 10%
00:02:36 of what we were taught in school.
00:02:38 Although it's true that the Cherokee's chief,
00:02:40 John Ross, opposed the treaty,
00:02:43 it's also true that he was extensively involved
00:02:45 in negotiations, and though he opposed the version
00:02:48 of the treaty that got finalized,
00:02:50 it didn't stop him from enriching his family from it.
00:02:53 When the government started enforcing the treaty in 1838,
00:02:56 they allowed Cherokee to conduct their own removal. 0.76
00:02:59 13 of the 16 groups that went to Oklahoma
00:03:02 were managed by the Cherokee, not the army,
00:03:04 and the contract to handle removal logistics
00:03:07 went to Chief Ross's brother, Louis Ross.
00:03:09 He made about $65 per person,
00:03:11 which totaled hundreds of thousands of dollars
00:03:14 and was meant to make the journey more humane.
00:03:16 The money was intended for wagons, food,
00:03:19 medical care, provisions.
00:03:22 It was to ensure that there wouldn't be much of a death toll.
00:03:25 And that brings us to another lie
00:03:27 that the Indians were ripped off.
00:03:29 Well, in fact, the US federal government
00:03:31 paid the Indians $5 million or roughly $184 million
00:03:35 in 2025 dollars for seven million acres.
00:03:39 That is a far better price per acre
00:03:41 than Russia received for selling Alaska
00:03:43 to the United States in 1867,
00:03:45 or the French received in exchange
00:03:47 for selling the Louisiana Purchase.
00:03:49 The Indians received something like 70 cents an acre,
00:03:52 while Napoleon received just three cents an acre,
00:03:56 and Russia received two cents per acre.
00:03:58 In the words of Andrew Jackson, quote,
00:04:00 how many thousands of our own people
00:04:02 would gladly embrace the opportunity
00:04:03 of removing to the West on such conditions.
00:04:06 If the offers made to the Indians were extended to them, 0.85
00:04:09 they would be hailed with gratitude and joy.
00:04:12 So what are the odds that a central tenet
00:04:15 of anti-American history just suddenly popped up
00:04:18 in the 1960s, just as left-wing radicals
00:04:20 seized control of American universities?
00:04:24 Very high, it turns out.
00:04:26 As a matter of fact, one thing that left-wing academics
00:04:28 know very well is that historical narratives matter.
00:04:32 Who your people look up to matters.
00:04:35 The events that shape the country matter,
00:04:38 and it all can be very useful.
00:04:40 One group that found the Trail of Tears narrative useful
00:04:43 were the thousands of professional activists
00:04:45 who went to Washington in the early 1970s
00:04:47 and held a week-long occupation
00:04:49 of the Bureau of Indian Affairs building.
00:04:52 Protesters barricaded themselves inside with furniture,
00:04:54 fashioned makeshift weapons,
00:04:56 issued defiant statements to the press.
00:04:59 One leader reportedly told the New York Times
00:05:00 that Indians had taken a vow to fight to the death, 0.87
00:05:03 while another declared war on the United States.
00:05:07 Within days, President Nixon sent representatives
00:05:09 to hammer out a compromise.
00:05:10 He granted immunity to the militants
00:05:12 and paid for their trips home.
00:05:14 He signed legislation that handed millions of acres of land
00:05:17 over to Indian tribes, particularly in Alaska and New Mexico.
00:05:20 He lent his support to the Indian Self-Determination
00:05:23 and Education Assistance Act,
00:05:25 which would eventually become law.
00:05:26 The legislation allowed Indian tribes
00:05:28 to take over the administration of some federal programs,
00:05:31 which was a major coup
00:05:32 for the so-called American Indian Movement.
00:05:35 The Trail of Tears is often presented
00:05:36 as the ultimate symbol of American injustice,
00:05:39 but it is just one part in a much larger body
00:05:42 of pervasive myths that have shaped
00:05:45 our understanding of American history.
00:05:46 These myths amplified in schools and media
00:05:49 almost always portray American Indians
00:05:50 as peaceful, noble victims, stewards of the land,
00:05:54 overwhelmed by an unstoppable wave
00:05:56 of Imperial European and American forces
00:05:58 armed with superior technology.
00:06:00 Any violence on their part, we're told,
00:06:02 is merely a reaction provoked by white people.
00:06:05 We're told that as Americans, we live on stolen land
00:06:08 and that the US government perpetrated a literal genocide
00:06:11 against native nations. 0.55
00:06:13 These narratives are not only wrong,
00:06:14 but they're also a form of intellectual warfare
00:06:17 designed to dishonor our ancestors
00:06:19 and to foster a sense of collective guilt
00:06:22 that would undermine American confidence and unity.
00:06:25 And well, the thing is, it's working.
00:06:27 One poll sponsored by the Manhattan Institute
00:06:29 found that 45% of high school students were taught in class
00:06:32 that America was built on stolen land.
00:06:34 And another 22% heard it from an adult at the school.
00:06:38 Over the course of this video,
00:06:39 we will dismantle one by one,
00:06:42 the biggest myths about the Native Americans.
00:06:45 This is the real history of the American Indians.
00:06:49 So we need to start with a central, critical, and load-bearing myth that supports all the
00:06:58 others.
00:07:00 The widespread belief that the Indians were peaceful.
00:07:04 Nothing could be further from the truth.
00:07:06 Before we dismantle this claim, I have to warn you that to accurately convey the reality
00:07:10 of inter-tribal and frontier warfare, I have to use real historical examples.
00:07:15 And many of these accounts contain graphic violence.
00:07:18 The Indians were brutal to settlers and to each other. 0.99
00:07:20 Some of these details may be unsuitable for young children,
00:07:23 but they don't have any choice but to present them.
00:07:26 After all, this video is in pursuit of historical truth
00:07:30 rather than comforting myth.
00:07:32 Since the end of World War II,
00:07:34 American academics have pretended 0.83
00:07:35 that pre-modern humans lived in a state of peace.
00:07:39 Academic dishonesty was so out of hand by the 1990s
00:07:43 that according to archeologist Lawrence H. Keeley,
00:07:46 the most widely used archeological textbooks
00:07:48 contained no mention of war before civilization.
00:07:52 Some of the biggest names in anthropology,
00:07:54 archeology, and history have gone out of their way
00:07:56 to pretend that life before civilization
00:07:59 was actually pretty great.
00:08:01 This might be because so many post-World War II academics
00:08:04 deliberately ignored war.
00:08:07 In one case, academics were in such denial
00:08:09 about pre-modern warfare
00:08:11 that they pretended battle axes were a form of currency.
00:08:14 Now, you might be thinking, who cares about intellectuals?
00:08:18 Well, the myths they made ended up appearing downstream
00:08:21 in our mass culture.
00:08:23 Around the same time that references
00:08:24 to the Trail of Tears were rising,
00:08:27 Hollywood started portraying Indians 0.99
00:08:29 as peaceful and noble.
00:08:31 Dances with Wolves portrays, of all people,
00:08:34 the Lakota Sioux as a peaceful, harmonious community
00:08:38 living in balance with the land and the buffalo.
00:08:44 The Powhatan in Pocahontas 0.92
00:08:45 were peace-loving environmentalists
00:08:47 who sang about living in harmony with nature.
00:08:51 And the list goes on, of course.
00:08:52 None of that is accurate.
00:08:54 According to the book, War Before Civilization
00:08:56 by archeologist Lawrence H. Keeley,
00:08:59 somewhere between 90 and 95% of known societies
00:09:03 in all of human history were warlike.
00:09:06 The less civilized you were as a rule,
00:09:08 the more violent you were.
00:09:10 Two thirds of primitive societies were at constant war
00:09:12 compared to 40% of civilized states.
00:09:16 Now, at this point, you might say, but what about the peaceful tribes?
00:09:19 Not all of them were at war.
00:09:21 According to Keeley, those tribes are the exception that proves the rule.
00:09:25 Some 96% of American Indian tribes engaged in warfare.
00:09:29 And some tribes were more violent than others.
00:09:31 The most violent tribes were the Klamath-Modok, the Thompson tribe, the Navajo, the Apache, 1.00
00:09:37 Mojave, the Yuma, Iroquois, the Sioux, and, of course, the Comanche. 0.92
00:09:41 If you happen to be in their neighborhood, you probably spend a lot of time at war.
00:09:46 In most cases, primitive warfare consisted of surprise raids on enemies' villages or camps.
00:09:52 This is true for groups around the world, from Eskimos in the Bering Straits to natives in New Guinea.
00:09:58 This kind of warfare generally consisted of quietly surrounding enemy houses under the cover of night,
00:10:03 throwing spears through the walls, lighting the structures on fire, and shooting arrows through the doorways.
00:10:10 The killing was often indiscriminate, and civilians, including women and children, frequently died.
00:10:15 According to Keeley, the East Cree of Quebec slaughtered any Inuit Eskimo families they encountered, taking only infants as captains.
00:10:24 Neither age nor sex was any guarantee of protection from primitive raids.
00:10:29 Among Western U.S. Indian tribes, 86% were raiding or resisting raids undertaken more than once each year.
00:10:36 Now, in some cases, violence was small scale, but even if most battles may have had a small number of casualties, almost every male was participating.
00:10:44 In one small-scale Eskimo community in northern Canada, every single male had killed someone at some point.
00:10:52 Among prehistoric Illinois villagers, archaeological evidence suggests that the homicide rate would have been 70 times that of the U.S. in 1980.
00:11:00 So it turns out that bloodshed in Chicago is, in fact, an ancient phenomenon.
00:11:05 So just how savage were the Indians? 0.99
00:11:08 We'll get into specific details of some of these raids, but for now we can focus on perhaps the most gruesome detail of all.
00:11:14 evidence of cannibalism among American Indian tribes.
00:11:18 According to Keeley's book, War Before Civilization,
00:11:20 at 25 sites in the American Southwest,
00:11:23 anthropologists have discovered cannibalized human remains
00:11:26 dated from roughly the year 900 to 1300,
00:11:29 hundreds of years before Columbus arrived.
00:11:31 We know they were consumed because the assemblages
00:11:33 of disarticulated bones share a number of features,
00:11:37 butchering cut marks, skulls broken,
00:11:40 long bones smashed for marrow extraction,
00:11:43 bones burned or otherwise cooked and disposal with other kitchen refuse one colombian chief
00:11:49 quote consumed the bodies of a hundred enemies in a single day following a victor in another
00:11:55 chiefdom war captives were kept in special enclosures and fattened before consumption
00:12:00 many of these groups smoked or otherwise preserved human meat to be eaten later the ancerimo tribe 0.69
00:12:06 in colombia used human body fat as lamp fuel in their gold mines many groups in the americas
00:12:12 ate the hearts of slain enemies to absorb the latter's courage or to achieve an extended form
00:12:17 of revenge as recently as the 1800s american soldiers and texas rangers were witnesses to
00:12:23 cannibalism the takawa tribe in texas which allied with the us army in its mission to take on the
00:12:30 brutal comanche tribe often ate their victims one white captive named herman lehman who lived with 0.99
00:12:36 the comanches and eventually became a comanche warrior wrote about his experiences in a book
00:12:40 titled Nine Years Among Indians. The Comanche had been locked in a genocidal war with the Tonkawas 1.00
00:12:46 for decades, and by the time Lehman encountered them, they were, in his words, nearly exterminated.
00:12:51 But upon finding a Tonkawa outpost, Lehman wrote, we took possession of the camp and what do you
00:12:57 suppose we found on that fire roasting? One of the legs of a Comanche, a warrior of our tribe.
00:13:03 Whipped into a furor at the sight of their fellow warrior being eaten, the Comanches massacred
00:13:08 the tankawa lehman writes a great many of the dying enemy were gasping for water
00:13:13 but we heeded not their pleadings we scalped them amputated their arms cut off their legs
00:13:19 cut out their tongues and threw their mangled bodies and limbs upon their own campfire 1.00
00:13:24 put on more brushwood and piled the living dying and dead tankawas on the fire
00:13:29 some of them were able to flinch and work as a worm and some were able to speak and plead for
00:13:34 mercy piled them up put on more wood and danced around in great glee as we saw the grease and 0.97
00:13:41 blood run from their bodies and were delighted to see them swell up and hear the hide pop
00:13:46 as it would burst in the fire after the battle of plum creek in texas tonkawa allies cut up the body
00:13:52 of an enemy comanche and skewered it on sticks over a bonfire the texas rangers were there with
00:13:59 them and likely would have witnessed this so it's clear that the indians were very violent engaging 1.00
00:14:06 in raids on one another murdering women and children burning entire villages committing
00:14:11 genocide in some cases eating each other which brings us to our next myth
00:14:18 one common myth perpetuated by historians is that the american indians only became violent after
00:14:23 exposure to Europeans. One advantage academics have in perpetuating this myth is that the Indians
00:14:29 didn't keep a log of their own history, so we don't have written accounts of Indian battles from
00:14:35 the 1300s. Luckily, archaeological evidence doesn't require written history. This is what we know.
00:14:41 Almost all new settlements formed in eastern North America from 900 to 1400 AD were fortified,
00:14:48 and this is because around that time, Mississippian Indians from the Midwest and the
00:14:53 south were moving east and in constant conflict with the tribes they were encountering. Before
00:14:58 Columbus had even sailed the ocean blue, Oneota Indians were chasing other Indians out of northern 1.00
00:15:03 Illinois. Tribes like the Anasazi and the Hohokam were vacating their farms in Arizona and New 1.00
00:15:10 Mexico because their settlements were getting destroyed. Archaeologists at Crow Creek in South
00:15:15 Dakota discovered a mass grave with the remains of more than 500 people, including women and
00:15:20 children. They had been, according to Keeley, slaughtered, scalped, and mutilated during an
00:15:25 attack on the village a century and a half before Columbus's arrival. The attack seems to have
00:15:29 occurred just when the village's fortifications had been rebuilt. All the houses were burned,
00:15:34 and most of the inhabitants were murdered. Knife marks on the tops of their skulls and bone
00:15:39 fragments is how they know that they were scalped and mutilated. Not only were the Indians committing 0.98
00:15:44 atrocities against each other before europeans arrived but they also got less violent after the
00:15:51 white man got them according to keely the percentage of burials in coastal british
00:15:55 columbia bearing evidence of violent traumas was actually lower after european contact 13
00:16:02 from 1774 to 1874 and the very high levels 20 to 32 evidence in prehistoric periods as you'll see
00:16:10 later in this episode some tribes including the vicious warlike ones like the apache actually
00:16:15 sought protection from european powers but we'll get to that later first more on what indian on
00:16:22 indian violence was like according to sc guinn's book empire of the summer moon quote enemies
00:16:27 meanwhile were enemies and the rules for dealing with them had come down through a thousand years
00:16:32 comanche brave who captured a live ute would torture him to death without question it was 0.53
00:16:37 was what everyone had always done. What the Sioux did to the Cinnaboyne, what the Crow did to the 1.00
00:16:42 Blackfeet. A Comanche captured by a Ute would expect to receive exactly the same treatment, 1.00
00:16:46 which was why Indians always fought to their last breath on the battlefields. Often this 0.98
00:16:50 led to a tit-for-tat where one raid would lead to another ad infinitum. Those early Indian raids 0.97
00:16:56 were brutal and included tribes widely celebrated as advanced by modern historians. Consider the 1.00
00:17:02 case of the Iroquois were often presented as a sophisticated tribe who, according to the
00:17:08 documentarian Ken Burns, influenced America's founding fathers. Long before 13 British colonies
00:17:14 made themselves into the United States, the six nations of the Iroquois Confederacy, Seneca,
00:17:21 Cayuga, Onondaga, Tuscarora, Oneida, and Mohawk, had created a union of their own that they called
00:17:30 the Haudenosaunee, a democracy that had flourished for centuries.
00:17:35 Somehow, strangely enough, Ken Burns forgot to tell us that when the Iroquois captured
00:17:40 an enemy combatant, the combatant was not immediately executed, but instead tortured
00:17:45 during the war party's return to camp.
00:17:47 They made it back to the village.
00:17:49 The hostages were given to the families of dead Iroquois soldiers, adopted by the families
00:17:54 and given the names of the dead Indians, and then, according to Keeley, quote,
00:17:58 tortured to death over several days.
00:18:01 The prisoner was dead.
00:18:02 Some parts of his body were eaten,
00:18:03 usually including his heart, by his murderers.
00:18:06 These kinds of misrepresentations are completely pervasive.
00:18:10 The Mendocino Land Trust in California
00:18:13 has land acknowledgments celebrating the Yuki
00:18:16 and Kato tribes that once lived on land
00:18:19 now occupied by rich liberal Californians.
00:18:23 The land trust claims that these tribes
00:18:24 were stewards of these lands for millennia,
00:18:27 and we mourn the atrocities committed against them
00:18:30 in the past while recognizing
00:18:31 that these injustices continue today.
00:18:34 But they failed to mention
00:18:35 that the two tribes hated each other.
00:18:37 When Yuki Indians discovered that Katos were encroaching 0.99
00:18:41 on their obsidian mine and plant-gathering territory,
00:18:44 they retaliated by killing four Kato girls.
00:18:47 Such violence was par for the course
00:18:49 in pre-modern California.
00:18:51 At a thousand-year-old excavation site
00:18:53 in central California, 5% of human skeletons
00:18:56 were embedded with arrowheads.
00:18:58 The Indians regularly massacred their rivals
00:19:00 and burned their villages before Columbus arrived.
00:19:03 The archeological evidence is overwhelming
00:19:04 and runs along the Missouri River in South Dakota
00:19:07 and throughout the American Southwest.
00:19:09 In 1280, the Pueblo at Sand Canyon
00:19:12 was destroyed in a massacre.
00:19:13 Artifacts were smashed and stolen
00:19:15 and a defensive wall was totally burned.
00:19:17 The Pueblo of Coahuwa in New Mexico
00:19:20 was plundered and destroyed in 1400.
00:19:22 No tribe blows up the peaceful Indian myth more than the Comanches, who ruled 1.00
00:19:28 the southern Great Plains for centuries and even beat back the Spanish Empire,
00:19:32 which had no problem conquering the Aztecs or the Incas. The Comanche would 1.00
00:19:36 quote, attack whole villages and burn them, raping, torturing and killing their 0.99
00:19:40 inhabitants, leaving young women with their entrails carved out, men burned 0.99
00:19:45 alive, they skewered infants and took young boys and girls as captives. Now
00:19:50 Now they did this to almost everyone they encountered.
00:19:53 The Comanche were always brutal, 1.00
00:19:54 but it wasn't until they were introduced to the horse,
00:19:56 which was brought by Europeans, that they hit their apex. 0.95
00:20:00 Because they were highly mobile
00:20:02 and brilliant at horsemanship,
00:20:04 the Comanche could move hundreds of miles faster
00:20:07 than anyone else.
00:20:08 Their nomadic lifestyle meant
00:20:09 they could launch attacks from anywhere.
00:20:12 By the mid 1700s, everybody feared them,
00:20:14 from the Tonkawa in Texas, to the Blackfeet in Wyoming,
00:20:18 the Utes in New Mexico, to the Pawnee in Kansas.
00:20:22 Comanche attacks on Hickorya Apaches were so brutal 1.00
00:20:26 that they begged for and received Spanish protection.
00:20:30 The Comanche were such a force that by the mid 18th century, 1.00
00:20:33 powerful tribes like the Cheyenne
00:20:35 refused to breach Comanche territory.
00:20:37 This episode is sponsored by Balance of Nature.
00:20:40 Since we were kids, we've always been told
00:20:41 to eat our fruits and vegetables,
00:20:43 but nobody ever explained what you're actually after
00:20:46 in those foods, phytonutrients.
00:20:47 Phytonutrients are natural compounds your body uses to adjust, repair, and respond every single day.
00:20:52 The more we try to improve food and factories, the further we've gone from what your body actually recognizes as food.
00:20:58 That's why I like Balance of Nature.
00:21:00 They take real produce and run it through a tailored vacuum-cold process that stabilizes its phytonutritium
00:21:06 instead of nuking it with heat and chemicals.
00:21:08 Their whole health system bundle includes their fruits and veggies and fiber and spice supplements,
00:21:13 giving you 47 ingredients of whole food and their phytonutrients in a simple, consistent routine.
00:21:18 You've even rolled out brand new freeze-dried snacks that go through a similar process
00:21:21 so you're not trading convenience for quality.
00:21:24 I personally love Balance of Nature because of its convenience.
00:21:27 When I'm traveling for work or trying to keep up with the kids,
00:21:30 it gives me a simple way to make sure I'm getting all the essential nutrients in my diet.
00:21:34 Save over 30% when you subscribe on balanceofnature.com.
00:21:38 Join hundreds of thousands of customers in one simple routine that's changing the world.
00:21:42 as radical college professors were rewriting history to create the myth of the peaceful
00:21:50 indian others were willing to acknowledge native american violence but blame that on white people
00:21:55 in 1969 an indian author and activist named vine deloria argued that scalping was introduced prior
00:22:03 to the french and indian war by the english framing it as a european invention that confirmed
00:22:09 suspicions of Indians as wild animals to be hunted and skinned.
00:22:13 Well, in fact, scalping was one of the many ancient traditions meant to cripple victims
00:22:19 in the afterlife.
00:22:20 As Lawrence Keeley notes, the custom of scalping enemy dead was observed at first contact among
00:22:25 tribes ranging from New England to California and from parts of the subarctic down to northern
00:22:31 Mexico.
00:22:32 Scalps and scalping were embedded in the myth and rituals of so many tribes that the customs
00:22:36 indigenous roots in north america are beyond serious question defiling an enemy's body
00:22:41 supposedly denied them a place in the afterlife it was humiliating this photo shows the corpse of a
00:22:48 u.s calvary been killed and mutilated by the southern cheyenne in 1867 tribes in colombia
00:22:55 kept the entire skins of their dead enemies some tribes turned their enemies bones into flutes
00:23:01 women commonly flayed the victims and at least one tribe treated their victims like we treat
00:23:06 trophy bucks they had them stuffed waxed and prominently placed in their homes different
00:23:11 plains tribes mutilated their foes corpses in different ways and their traditions went back
00:23:16 centuries anthropologists working the site of the crow creek massacre which happened in the mid
00:23:21 1400s in central south dakota found mutilated skeletons after the battle of little bighorn
00:23:26 more than 400 years later indian women used marrow cracking mallets to pound the faces of the dead 1.00
00:23:32 soldiers into pulp. Name the tribe and I will tell you their preferred method of mutilation. 0.99
00:23:38 The Cheyennes slashed their enemies arms, the Arapaho split their enemies noses, 0.98
00:23:43 Sioux slit their enemies throats. Indian warfare was dominated by superstitions and traditions and 0.99
00:23:49 mutilations and scalps weren't the only way to prove yourself as a soldier.
00:23:53 On the Great Plains, the Indians had a tradition called Counting Coup and it involved demonstrating 0.76
00:23:57 extreme bravery by touching or striking a living enemy warrior in battle with a hand bow whip or
00:24:04 special coup stick and then escaping unharmed this act was considered the highest honor in
00:24:09 inter-tribal warfare often more prestigious than killing from a distance because it required getting
00:24:14 dangerously close proving superior courage and skill while humiliating the opponent as recently
00:24:20 as world war ii an american indian named joe medicine crow completed the four traditional crow
00:24:26 war deeds he counted coup by overpowering a german soldier in hand-to-hand combat he captured an
00:24:32 enemy's weapon by taking the soldier's rifle in the scuffle he led a successful war party on a
00:24:38 mission to capture explosives and he stole his enemy's horses on a raid on an ss camp and this
00:24:44 made him eligible to be a warchief some of these traditions are admirable and impressive no doubt
00:24:50 joe medicine crow was an american hero but the ancient practice of scalping enemies and mutilating
00:24:55 their bodies to deny them a place in the afterlife is of course appalling the unfortunate reality is
00:25:01 that in some cases whites usually in mobs and militias participated in scalping but this is
00:25:08 vastly overstated especially cases in which the government supposedly encouraged scalping for
00:25:12 example one professor from the university of texas claims that in california scalp warfare driven by
00:25:18 scalp bounties eliminated nearly 90 percent of some tribal populations this view became pervasive
00:25:24 in the 1990s but it's almost totally false in 2023 a professor at california state university
00:25:30 chico discovered that in fact quote indian scalp bounties remained extremely rare in gold rush
00:25:35 california and were seldom offered anywhere except in a scattered handful of isolated and
00:25:40 unincorporated rural communities he further emphasized quote so routinely are these
00:25:44 allegations made they now go largely uncontested and appear to have one nearly universal acceptance
00:25:50 has established historical facts. These facts, however, are false. The state of California never
00:25:55 offered, let alone actually paid, cash bounties for Native American scalps, heads, or other body 0.81
00:26:01 parts. We can safely say that the idea of systematic state-sponsored scalp bounties
00:26:06 as a primary driver of depopulation is now debunked as a modern myth.
00:26:11 Another pervasive myth about Native Americans combines two contradictory ideas into one.
00:26:21 Native Americans had no concept of property rights, particularly over land, and that Europeans stole 1.00
00:26:26 the land from them. Well, obviously, these two claims cannot both be true. If the Indians truly 1.00
00:26:32 lacked any notion of property rights, then the land, by definition, could not have been stolen
00:26:37 in from them because theft implies the violation of rightful ownership.
00:26:41 Yet the same narrative often asserts both points simultaneously
00:26:45 without recognizing the logical contradiction.
00:26:48 This inconsistency reveals a deeper issue.
00:26:51 The first claim is frequently used to justify displacement
00:26:54 by portraying native land used as primitive or communal
00:26:58 in a way that didn't count as real ownership under European legal standards.
00:27:03 The second claim, meanwhile, appeals to modern moral sensibilities
00:27:06 about injustice. Holding both ideas at once allows the narrative to shift between them depending on
00:27:12 the argument being made while avoiding the underlying incompatibility. The way the revisionists
00:27:17 frame this debate is like a rigged game. There's no way to win if you accept the premise. And so
00:27:23 we don't accept the premise. The Indians, like the average toddler, absolutely had a notion of 1.00
00:27:29 property rights. They often went to war over them. In the 1830s in the Alexander Valley in northern
00:27:36 california pomo indians stole an acorn stash from an oak grove belonging to the wapo tribe 1.00
00:27:43 that was not a good decision the wapo immediately raided massacring the pomo and burning one of
00:27:48 their villages the remaining pomo then fled the area for the safety of other pomo villages 1.00
00:27:53 farther away from the wapo the wapo eventually occupied some of the abandoned villages and
00:27:59 just like that a dispute over territory led to a war and the winning tribe expanded its territory
00:28:04 as property rights. Those kinds of disputes happened literally all the time. They were
00:28:11 very, very violent. Surprise attacks in California Como villages killed between 5 and 15 percent of
00:28:18 the population. When the first Spanish explorers encountered the Barberay Neo Chumash in California,
00:28:23 the tribe had just had two of their villages massacred and burned, killing 10 percent of the
00:28:28 tribe. According to the anthropologist Lawrence Keeley, in California were tribes depended heavily
00:28:33 on gathering wild plant foods and on hunting or fishing,
00:28:37 conflicts over resource poaching were very common.
00:28:40 He continued that, quote,
00:28:42 many California tribes often granted outsiders the right
00:28:44 to exploit their hunting and gathering grounds
00:28:46 when they were properly asked or awarded with gifts,
00:28:50 yet they would fight any group that poached.
00:28:52 The people who live in Northern California today
00:28:54 are much more communist than the American Indians 0.99
00:28:57 they replaced.
00:28:58 It's a shame they don't just give the land back.
00:29:01 But California tribes weren't the only ones going back and forth about property.
00:29:05 The Plains Indians continuously waged war over horses, which was their key metric of wealth.
00:29:11 Indians in the Pacific Northwest fought over water and fishing access.
00:29:15 Tribes in the Midwest fought for centuries over who got access to rice fields and hunting grounds in places like Minnesota.
00:29:22 Different tribes had different ways of allocating land, but they all had ways of doing it.
00:29:26 Most tribes had defined territories for hunting, fishing, gathering, or farming with boundaries recognized intertribally.
00:29:33 On the Great Plains, the Lakota allocated hunting grounds to families in the Pacific Northwest.
00:29:38 Tribes held potlatches to establish hereditary claims rooted in oral histories and legal traditions.
00:29:44 The Pueblo at Iroquois, who actually had farms, necessarily gave family their own plots for cultivation.
00:29:51 How exactly are you supposed to farm if everything is communally owned?
00:29:55 This is yet another myth that's easily debunked.
00:30:04 On the morning of May 19th, 1836, on the vast, untamed frontier of the newly declared Republic of Texas,
00:30:11 there was a small wooden stockade known as Parker's Fort.
00:30:14 It was very literally on the edge of civilization.
00:30:18 Built by the extended Parker family, the fort huddled along the Navasota River in what is now Limestone County, Texas.
00:30:25 Inside its log walls were homes, a garden, and 30 settlers working the surrounding fields.
00:30:31 And they included a pregnant 17-year-old named Rachel Plummer.
00:30:36 That morning, as the men worked outside the gates, a large band of warriors, primarily Comanche Indians, appeared on the horizon.
00:30:44 They carried a white flag signaling peace, but it was a ruse.
00:30:48 In moments, the fields erupted in chaos.
00:30:50 the Comanche warriors riding on horseback and covered in war paint charged the fort. Five
00:30:56 settlers were killed immediately including the family patriarch. Inside the fort Rachel witnessed
00:31:02 the carnage with her toddler. She tried to flee but was overtaken and dragged away. For the next
00:31:08 21 months she was held as a Comanche slave. That October she gave birth but the infant made her 0.99
00:31:14 less productive. Comanche's wouldn't have that. This is an actual excerpt from her memoirs.
00:31:21 Quote, my child was some six or seven weeks old when I suppose my master thought it was too much
00:31:26 trouble as I was not able to go through as much labor as before. One cold morning, five or six
00:31:32 large Indians came where I was suckling my infant. As soon as they came in, I felt my heart sink. 1.00
00:31:38 My fears agitated my whole frame to complete state of convulsion. My body shook with fear
00:31:44 indeed nor my fears vain or ill-grounded one of them caught hold of the child by the throat
00:31:50 and with his whole strength like an enraged lion actuated by its devouring nature
00:31:56 held on like the hungry vulture until my child was to all appearance entirely dead
00:32:02 but they didn't satisfy the comanche so they continued to attack the baby quote they by force
00:32:08 took the infant from me and threw his body up in the air and let him fall on the frozen ground
00:32:14 until he was apparently dead now miraculously the baby survived the strangling so the comanche quote
00:32:20 tied a planted rope around the child's neck and drew its naked body into the large hedges of
00:32:25 prickly pear cacti which were from 8 to 12 feet high they would then pull him down through the
00:32:32 pears this they repeated several times one of them then got on a horse and tying the rope to his
00:32:38 saddle rode around a circuit of a few hundred yards until my little innocent 0.90
00:32:44 one was not only dead but literally torn to pieces. This is how the Comanche and 1.00
00:32:51 many Indians fought. For the most part, wars between pre-civilized people are
00:32:56 almost always fought like total wars. Like Sherman marching to the sea or the
00:33:01 U.S. bombing of civilian targets in Germany in World War II, the Indians
00:33:05 would commonly engage in tactics like wringing fruit trees,
00:33:08 stealing or destroying herds and crops,
00:33:11 burning houses and canoes,
00:33:13 stealthily slaughtering individuals in small groups,
00:33:15 and gradually abrading a foe's manpower
00:33:17 in very frequent but low-casualty battles.
00:33:20 Often the Plains Indians would steal horses 1.00
00:33:22 from expeditions, leaving Americans alone in the prairie
00:33:25 with no way to get home.
00:33:27 One sub-Arctic tribe, the Kuchin, 0.88
00:33:29 annihilated its enemies, the Mackenzie Eskimos,
00:33:32 by surrounding their encampment and killing all but one male.
00:33:35 Their survivor, as he came to be known,
00:33:38 was all that was left,
00:33:39 and his purpose was to tell other tribes what had happened.
00:33:42 The anthropologist Lawrence Keeley claims, quote,
00:33:44 primitive warfare was much deadlier
00:33:46 than its modern counterpart.
00:33:47 An average Indian massacre killed 10% of the population.
00:33:51 An equivalent attack on the United States today
00:33:53 would kill more than 32 million people.
00:33:55 In other words, Indian tactics were extremely effective.
00:33:58 Throughout the 20th century,
00:33:59 Wars and their associated consequences,
00:34:02 such as famine and disease,
00:34:03 claimed an estimated 100 million lives.
00:34:06 This staggering toll reflects the devastating cost
00:34:08 of a world organized into nation states,
00:34:11 whose conflicts repeatedly escalated
00:34:12 into large-scale industrial violence.
00:34:14 But according to Keeley,
00:34:15 that figure is an estimated 20 times smaller
00:34:18 than the losses we would have experienced
00:34:20 if we fought like the Indians.
00:34:22 This is because modern civilized warfare is ritualized.
00:34:26 There are layers and layers of international law
00:34:28 that nation states are expected to fight by.
00:34:31 Not so for native population.
00:34:33 Concepts like prisoner exchange, parole,
00:34:36 the release after assuring the enemy
00:34:38 you won't take up arms again, and surrender are modern
00:34:43 and rely on agreements between opposing parties,
00:34:45 which almost never existed in pre-modern warfare.
00:34:48 Wave the white flag in a modern civilized war 0.65
00:34:51 and you're probably gonna be fine.
00:34:53 Not so with the Comanche. 1.00
00:34:55 Their language had no word for surrender.
00:34:57 For decades, the Comanche Indians raided settlements 0.80
00:35:00 of other Indians or Spanish and Texan colonizers.
00:35:03 According to the Empire of the Summer Moon,
00:35:05 which is an excellent history of the Comanche people, quote,
00:35:07 the logic of Comanche raids was straightforward.
00:35:09 All the men were killed and any of the men
00:35:11 who were captured alive were tortured to death
00:35:13 as a matter of course, some more slowly than others. 0.69
00:35:16 The captive women were gang raped,
00:35:17 some were killed, some tortured.
00:35:19 The portion of them, particularly if they were young,
00:35:21 would be spared.
00:35:23 Though vengeance could always be a motive
00:35:24 for slaying hostages, babies were invariably killed
00:35:27 while pre-adolescents were often adopted
00:35:29 by Comanches or other tribes.
00:35:31 Torture at the hands of Plains Indians 1.00
00:35:33 was so brutal and so common
00:35:34 that veteran Indian fighters preferred suicide
00:35:37 over capture and usually saved a bullet for themselves.
00:35:40 Their brutal tactics were far more effective
00:35:43 than the way Europeans fought.
00:35:45 That's how tribes like the Comanche and Apache
00:35:47 held off the Americans, the Mexicans, 1.00
00:35:49 and the Spanish Empire for more than three centuries,
00:35:52 the last of which took basically no time at all
00:35:54 to conquer the much more developed Aztecs 0.65
00:35:57 in central Mexico.
00:35:58 In 1758, the Comanche drew Spain 0.99
00:36:01 into its greatest military defeat in the New World
00:36:03 in a battle near a Spanish mission
00:36:06 at Santa Cruz de San Saba near present-day Menard, Texas.
00:36:10 There, the Indians stripped, murdered, mutilated, 1.00
00:36:13 and decapitated priests.
00:36:15 One early Spanish expedition to take out Plains tribes
00:36:18 from Mexico was wiped out by the Pawnees in Nebraska.
00:36:22 As a rule, the US Army often suffered major defeats
00:36:24 if it was outnumbered in battle,
00:36:26 and not just against the impressive
00:36:28 calvaries of the Plains Indians.
00:36:30 In 1835, Major Francis L. Dade led a column
00:36:34 of about 110 US soldiers from Fort Brook near modern Tampa
00:36:38 to reinforce Fort King near modern Ocala.
00:36:41 They were ambushed by about 180 Seminole warriors
00:36:44 near present day Bushnell, Florida.
00:36:47 It had all the hallmarks of a classic Indian attack. 1.00
00:36:50 Seminoles used surprise covered from tall grass
00:36:54 and superior knowledge of the terrain
00:36:56 to overwhelm the column.
00:36:57 They killed Major Dade and nearly all his men,
00:37:00 leaving only three survivors.
00:37:02 The Seminoles had basically no casualties.
00:37:04 The attack shocked the nation,
00:37:06 and today it's known as the Dade Massacre.
00:37:08 The U.S. launched a six and a half year punitive war
00:37:11 against the Seminoles.
00:37:12 The outcome of the war was indecisive.
00:37:15 In a description of his 30-year career,
00:37:17 Colonel R.B. Marcy complained that, quote,
00:37:20 the modern school of military science
00:37:22 are but illy suited to carrying on a warfare
00:37:25 with the wild tribes of the plains.
00:37:27 The vast expanse of desert territory
00:37:29 that has been annexed to our domain
00:37:31 within the last few years is peopled by numerous tribes
00:37:34 of marauding and erratic savages
00:37:36 who are mounted upon fleet and hardy horses,
00:37:38 making war the business and pastime of their lives
00:37:41 and acknowledging one of the ameliorating
00:37:43 conventionalities of civilized warfare.
00:37:45 Their tactics are such as to render the old system
00:37:48 almost wholly impotent.
00:37:49 The Indians, he continued, were here today
00:37:52 and there tomorrow, who at one time
00:37:53 stampedes a herd of mules upon the headwaters of the Arkansas,
00:37:57 and what next heard from is in the very heart
00:37:59 of the populated districts of Mexico,
00:38:01 laying waste to haciendas and carrying devastation,
00:38:03 rapine, and murder in his steps,
00:38:05 who is everywhere without being anywhere,
00:38:07 who assembles at the moment of combat
00:38:09 and vanishes whenever fortune turns against him,
00:38:11 who leaves his women and children far distant
00:38:13 from the theater of hostilities,
00:38:15 and has neither towns nor magazines to defend,
00:38:18 nor lines of retreat to cover.
00:38:20 In August 1854, a Lakota Indian named High Forehead
00:38:24 was waiting for an annuity payment
00:38:26 from the federal government when he killed a cow
00:38:28 being moved by a Mormon wagon train on the Oregon Trail.
00:38:32 Brevet 2nd Lieutenant John L. Groton,
00:38:35 a 24-year-old fresh from West Point
00:38:37 who hated the Indians
00:38:38 and didn't have much experience on the frontier,
00:38:40 volunteered to resolve the matter.
00:38:42 That was a mistake.
00:38:44 Leading 29 soldiers, two howitzers,
00:38:46 and a drunken interpreter,
00:38:48 he marched into the vast Lakota encampment
00:38:50 demanding the surrender of High Forehead.
00:38:53 The drunk interpreter started taunting the Lakota leader,
00:38:56 Conquering Bear, and a nervous U.S. infantryman
00:39:00 accidentally discharged his gun.
00:39:02 Groton then ordered his men to fire away,
00:39:05 killing Conquering Bear.
00:39:07 The Indians, infuriated by the attack and the insults,
00:39:10 laid waste to Groton and killed his entire detachment.
00:39:13 During the Civil War, Apache bands overcame 0.99
00:39:15 ruthless uprising involving U.S. troops, citizens, and tribes that had settled on reservations.
00:39:21 Because government forces were consumed with war, the wild nomadic tribes like the Comanche 1.00
00:39:27 waged total warfare against the tribes that had taken up farming on the reservation. Chickasaw,
00:39:31 Choctaw, and Creek Indians were the primary targets, and many were chased off the reservation
00:39:37 altogether. The U.S. government was incapable of stopping it. Even after the Civil War, American 0.69
00:39:41 forces were regularly getting outsmarted outmaneuvered and in some cases defeated by
00:39:46 supposedly inferior american indian forces but after the civil war defeats kept coming in 1866
00:39:51 an army captain named william fetterman was led into an ambush by oglala su chief red cloud which
00:39:57 led to a 20-minute battle that ended with the massacre of 80 u.s troops a post-massacre report
00:40:03 noted that their eyes were ripped out noses and ears cut off teeth removed brains scooped out
00:40:10 genitals severed and some of the men had been pulverized by hundreds of arrows.
00:40:15 In the treaties of 1868, the U.S. government conceded the Bozeman Trail and the Powder
00:40:19 River Country to the Sioux and Cheyenne warriors under Chief Red Cloud. On June 25, 1876, the most
00:40:26 famous and devastating defeat in the Indian Wars happened at the Battle of Little Bighorn, where
00:40:31 in less than an hour, George Custer and every man under his immediate command,
00:40:35 and almost 300 soldiers lay dead on the slopes
00:40:38 now known as Last Stand Hill.
00:40:40 So how then did we beat the Indians? 1.00
00:40:43 Well, it's simple.
00:40:44 It required embracing the tactics of the Indians. 1.00
00:40:47 In the end, their tactics were superior,
00:40:49 and the only way to beat them was to fight just like them.
00:40:53 In 1677, a New Englander acknowledged
00:40:56 that traditional tactics were pointless.
00:40:58 In our first war with the Indians,
00:41:00 God pleased to show us the vanity of our military skill
00:41:03 in managing our arms after the European mode.
00:41:06 The guerrilla tactics they acquired from the Indians 1.00
00:41:08 proved essential in the later fight
00:41:10 against the British in 1776.
00:41:12 Campaigns against the nomadic, horse-riding plains Indians
00:41:15 were the most difficult because, quite frankly,
00:41:17 they were the most talented light cavalry on Earth.
00:41:20 White soldiers stood no chance of finding Comanches 1.00
00:41:23 without Indian guides, and even by the mid-1800s,
00:41:26 U.S. Army campaigns were generally pointless expeditions.
00:41:30 The first to figure out how to track them
00:41:32 were the early Texas Rangers,
00:41:33 who historian S.C. Gwynne described as
00:41:36 dirty, bearded, violent, and undisciplined men 0.60
00:41:38 wearing buckskins, serapes, coonskin caps, sombreros, 0.97
00:41:41 and other odd bits of clothing,
00:41:43 who belonged to no army, wore no insignias or uniforms,
00:41:47 made cold camps on the prairie,
00:41:49 and were only intermittently paid.
00:41:51 They owed their existence to the Comanche threat. 1.00
00:41:53 Their methods, copied closely from the Comanche, 0.96
00:41:57 would change frontier warfare in North America.
00:42:00 Under one legendary leader named Jack Hayes,
00:42:02 the Rangers adopted a totally different strategy
00:42:04 for fighting Indians.
00:42:06 The only strategy that ever proved effective, 0.87
00:42:08 use Indian tactics against the Indians.
00:42:11 Under Hayes, the Rangers moved in small groups,
00:42:14 trained to fight on horseback, and traveled without tents.
00:42:18 They used saddles for pillows and carried a rifle,
00:42:21 two pistols, a knife, a Mexican blanket,
00:42:24 and a pouch with salt, flour, tobacco, and hardtack.
00:42:27 They slept outside, traveled at night,
00:42:29 and attacked by surprise.
00:42:31 And yet the fight was still very one-sided.
00:42:33 One ranger estimated that about half the rangers
00:42:36 were killed off every year.
00:42:38 These outcomes disprove the myth that guns and technology
00:42:41 guaranteed European or American victory over the Indians.
00:42:44 In fact, for centuries, the firearms the Europeans 0.97
00:42:46 were using put them at a disadvantage
00:42:48 against the Plains Indians.
00:42:49 A Comanche warrior could fire 30 arrows per minute
00:42:52 from a bow, often while riding horseback at full gallop.
00:42:55 The Plains Indians used shields made of thick buffalo hides
00:42:59 that could stop bullets, even from muskets and rifles.
00:43:02 The lances they used against U.S. forces
00:43:04 were also used to hunt 3,000-pound buffalo,
00:43:07 which they did at full gallop.
00:43:08 According to S.C. Gwynne's book, Empire of the Summer Moon,
00:43:11 their lances were unmatched
00:43:12 by anything the white man had at close range.
00:43:15 And to make matters worse, they were better riders
00:43:18 and had better horses than the U.S. Army.
00:43:20 It took hundreds of years for white men 0.98
00:43:22 to match the speed, accuracy, reliability,
00:43:25 and rate of fire of the Indians.
00:43:27 When the Spanish first encountered the Plains Indians
00:43:29 in the mid-1500s, their primary firearm was the harkabas,
00:43:34 which was a big, heavy, impractical muzzleloader
00:43:37 who fired a lead ball using a slow-burning match
00:43:39 to ignite gunpowder.
00:43:41 Because they were over five feet long
00:43:42 and weighed close to 12 pounds,
00:43:44 they couldn't be reloaded on horseback.
00:43:46 It had to be fired from the ground,
00:43:48 and they didn't work in the rain.
00:43:49 In the 1600s and 1700s,
00:43:51 the Spanish upgraded to flintlock escopetas,
00:43:55 which were better to operate
00:43:56 but were still single-shot muzzleloaders.
00:43:58 And they also didn't work in the rain.
00:44:00 After Mexico gained independence from Spain,
00:44:02 they inherited those single-shot muskets,
00:44:04 but also upgraded to pepper-box handguns
00:44:07 and double-barreled shotguns for frontier defense
00:44:10 in the early 1830s and 1840s.
00:44:13 The early Americans commonly used
00:44:14 the Springfield Model 1842,
00:44:16 a cumbersome musket that was difficult to carry on horseback
00:44:20 and, assuming you were an experienced shooter,
00:44:22 could only get two to three rounds off in a minute.
00:44:24 It wasn't until the 1860s that breech-loading
00:44:27 single-shot rifles, which were easier to load
00:44:29 and could get 10 to 15 shots off per minute,
00:44:32 became standard.
00:44:34 In the 1860s and 1870s, lever-action rifles emerged,
00:44:38 including many brands we know today,
00:44:39 Henry Spencer, Winchester,
00:44:41 which were much more reliable and accurate
00:44:43 than the predecessors,
00:44:44 allowing multiple shots without reloading.
00:44:47 In 1836, a New Jersey inventor named Samuel Colt
00:44:50 introduced his first production revolver,
00:44:52 the Colt Patterson.
00:44:53 This was the first time, a full 300 years
00:44:57 since the Spanish arrived,
00:44:58 that someone had finally leveled the playing field.
00:45:01 The Republic of Texas immediately realized its value
00:45:04 and placed a large order.
00:45:05 The gun wasn't nearly as good
00:45:07 as the revolver as we have today.
00:45:08 It was fragile, needed to be disassembled for reloading,
00:45:12 had a folding trigger,
00:45:14 but critically, it introduced repeating fire.
00:45:16 Jack Hayes and the Texas Rangers always carried two,
00:45:19 meaning they could get 10 shots off very fast.
00:45:22 Ten years later, one of Hayes' top aides, Samuel Walker,
00:45:25 collaborated with Colt to design the Colt Walker,
00:45:28 a massive five-pound, six-shot, 44-caliber revolver
00:45:32 with a nine-inch barrel
00:45:33 and a fixed trigger guard loading lever.
00:45:35 It was the most powerful revolver for nearly a century
00:45:37 until it was displaced by the .357 Magnum
00:45:40 during the Great Depression.
00:45:41 However, the U.S. government didn't catch on
00:45:44 nearly as quickly as the Texas Rangers.
00:45:46 As late as 1849, the U.S. Army was still attempting
00:45:49 to use infantry to fight Plains Indians on foot.
00:45:52 They were complemented by U.S. Army dragoons
00:45:54 who wore white pants and blue jackets with orange camps
00:45:57 and armed with single-shot pistols
00:45:59 that were totally worthless against Plains Indians. 0.56
00:46:02 But even with faster-loading rifles and revolvers,
00:46:05 the U.S. was still occasionally losing battles.
00:46:07 On November 29th, 1872, U.S. troops attempted to force
00:46:10 a band of MODOK Indians back to a reservation.
00:46:14 The Indians, who included about 50 warriors,
00:46:16 plus their families, retreated to a natural fortress
00:46:19 in lava beds south of Tule Lake in California.
00:46:23 And incredibly, the Indians held their ground
00:46:25 for five months and fought U.S. forces to a stalemate,
00:46:29 even though they were vastly outnumbered.
00:46:31 It ended when the MODOK chief, Captain Jack,
00:46:34 assassinated General Edward Camby during peace talks.
00:46:37 Captain Jack was eventually captured and executed for murder.
00:46:40 The Indians repeatedly proved that their tactics 1.00
00:46:43 could overcome superior weapons.
00:46:45 On June 17, 1876, a U.S. Army column
00:46:47 more than a thousand soldiers led by Brigadier General George Crook set off to find an Indian
00:46:53 village. And that morning, while stopping for breakfast, an equally large group of Lakota and
00:46:58 Cheyenne warriors led by Crazy Horse ambushed Crook and his men. They battled for six hours and
00:47:04 though both sides had equal numbers of casualties, the Indians had stopped Crooks' advance
00:47:08 and forced him into a retreat. His column was neutralized for months. Eight days later,
00:47:14 many of the same warriors defeated George Custer at Little Bighorn. The next year in 1877,
00:47:20 the Nez Perce Indians proved again that superior tactics could still overcome the Americans' newly 1.00
00:47:25 minted and technically superior weapons. On August 9th, the U.S. Army's 7th Infantry Regiment
00:47:31 launched a surprise attack on a Nez Perce village. Miraculously, the Nez Perce warriors repelled the 1.00
00:47:37 attack and they captured a howitzer and forced the Americans to retreat. As late as the 1870s,
00:47:43 it seemed like nothing could stop Comanche raids on settlers in Texas. In 1871, Indian raids against
00:47:48 civilian targets were so brutal, vicious, and numerous that some American military leaders
00:47:54 expected all the settlers to leave. Colonel Randolph Marcy, who was on tour with William
00:47:59 Tecumseh Sherman, wrote, if the Indian marauders are not punished, the whole country seems in far 1.00
00:48:05 way of becoming totally depopulated. By 1874, Comanche raiders were hitting towns from southern
00:48:10 Colorado to Kansas to the Texas frontier. Pioneers were terrorized over thousands of miles.
00:48:17 On July 26, President Ulysses S. Grant gave General Sherman permission to crush the tribes.
00:48:22 Control of the reservations was transferred to the Army, and the Army was to subdue all Indians 0.98
00:48:27 who offered resistance to constituted authority. The peace policy was over, and a man named
00:48:33 Reynald McKenzie was unleashed on the Indians. Reynald Slidell McKenzie was known to the Indians
00:48:38 as bad hand because of injuries he suffered in the civil war he was tough and mean his soldiers hated
00:48:44 him but he was brutally competent and he knew better weapons were not going to guarantee victory
00:48:49 so he decided like the early texas rangers to fight like an indian he extensively used tonkawa
00:48:55 scouts he emphasized aggressive mobility moved at night and engaged in deception including leaving
00:49:01 campfires going in places that they were leaving rather than fight them in direct battle the way
00:49:06 european powers would mckenzie relentlessly pursued the indians burned their villages 0.72
00:49:11 killed their livestock when he captured comanche horses he killed them often thousands at a time
00:49:17 it was total war in every single successful western campaign the u.s army had to use primitive
00:49:22 methods and indian scouts to defeat the natives as mckenzie was subduing the comanche general
00:49:28 george crook was doing the same thing against the apache who were also raiding and pillaging
00:49:32 settlements across the southwest cook used small mobile units consisting of indians and supplied
00:49:38 himself by mule rather than wagon trains which were extremely vulnerable the decline of the yavu
00:49:44 pi the western apaches and the chiricahua followed a total war campaign by the u.s military that
00:49:50 involved pursuing them through the winter and burning their teepees the real reason the u.s
00:49:55 conquered the indians had very little to do with supposedly superior technology and it certainly 1.00
00:50:00 wasn't tactics as you've seen the indians tactics were far more effective the difference was that
00:50:05 the u.s army was backed by a massive and growing country it was richer more populous had more
00:50:11 access to mass transportation and technology the u.s had better agriculture and could mass produce
00:50:17 weapons it could move quickly by train economic strength and better logistics is what helped
00:50:22 america conquer the west but it was also by accident the final defeat of the sioux the cheyenne the
00:50:28 the Comanche and the Apache, almost directly coincided with the decline of the great northern
00:50:32 and southern bison herds. Between 1868 and 1881, buffalo hunters killed 31 million buffalo.
00:50:39 And perhaps more devastating than anything else, the American Indians were wiped out by
00:50:43 infectious disease. My show is proud to be sponsored by Grand Canyon University. It's an
00:50:48 affordable, private, non-profit Christian university based in beautiful Phoenix, Arizona.
00:50:53 At GCU, academically rigorous, industry-driven programs are built to provide you with practical skills and career readiness.
00:51:00 They believe education shouldn't be a privilege but an affordable path forward.
00:51:04 Because of this, GCU has kept tuition at the same rate on its traditional campus for the past 17 years and will continue into the 26-27 academic year.
00:51:13 Plus, they awarded over $404 million in institutional GCU scholarships last year to support and encourage education.
00:51:19 Grounded in Christian truth, GCU works to empower the next generation to lead with integrity, serve with purpose, and help transform their communities.
00:51:27 So take action and find your purpose at GCU. Visit gcu.edu to learn more.
00:51:36 When Christopher Columbus arrived in the New World in 1492, he didn't really understand how diseases spread.
00:51:42 Back then, Europeans generally believed that people got sick from bad air.
00:51:46 There were some indicators that if you spent time around sick people, you'd get sick too, but that was it.
00:51:52 People didn't know diseases spread from germs.
00:51:54 They certainly didn't understand concepts like inoculation.
00:51:58 When the natives started getting wiped out by disease, and they truly did get wiped out,
00:52:03 the Coquistadors saw this as a sign from God that he was on their side.
00:52:06 By all accounts, diseases absolutely devastated the natives.
00:52:10 It was much more brutal than warfare.
00:52:12 An estimated 100,000 Aztecs were killed during the Spanish conquest.
00:52:16 In the decade that followed, 8 million more died from infectious disease.
00:52:21 Most tribes lost anywhere from a third to a half of their population.
00:52:25 Before 1820, roughly 30 epidemics hit the Plains Indians, including measles, malaria,
00:52:30 whooping cough, and the flu.
00:52:33 Mexican raids in 1816 led to a resurgence of malaria and introduced syphilis.
00:52:38 In 1839, smallpox returned when it was brought back by Kiowas. 0.99
00:52:43 Thousands died.
00:52:44 Cholera, which is basically a form of extreme diarrhea,
00:52:47 was especially brutal for the Plains Indians.
00:52:49 The disease first appeared in India in their early 1800s
00:52:53 and then made its way to Europe
00:52:54 and in 1832 arrived in the United States.
00:52:57 Cholera killed a lot of white people too, of course.
00:53:00 The Indians were exposed to it from wagon trains
00:53:02 full of pioneers on the Oregon and Santa Fe trails.
00:53:05 Thousands of pioneers and 49ers died.
00:53:08 The Plains Indians were decimated.
00:53:10 Half of the Kiowa and Southern Cheyenne died.
00:53:13 In school, we're taught that smallpox was used
00:53:15 as a bioweapon against American Indians. 0.77
00:53:18 This is considered a well-settled fact
00:53:20 among many historians, government officials, and activists.
00:53:23 Many of us were taught that white colonizers
00:53:26 deliberately gave Indians blankets from hospitals
00:53:29 that were treating smallpox patients.
00:53:31 Those blankets, the story goes,
00:53:33 caused a smallpox epidemic among the Indians.
00:53:36 It's repeated ad nauseam in the media today.
00:53:38 Before the discovery of the smallpox vaccine,
00:53:40 Smallpox was in fact used as a weapon.
00:53:43 The problem with the story is that it never happened.
00:53:46 In 1736, Indians were sieging Fort Pitt,
00:53:50 which was located near present day downtown Pittsburgh.
00:53:53 The fort was about to be overrun,
00:53:55 and as if that wasn't bad enough,
00:53:57 the fort's hospital was home
00:53:58 to an increasing number of smallpox patients.
00:54:01 This is an important point.
00:54:02 At the time, smallpox was killing
00:54:04 nearly half a million Europeans every single year.
00:54:06 If this was bioterrorism, they were doing it wrong.
00:54:10 When Sir Geoffrey Amherst, commander-in-chief
00:54:12 of the British forces in North America
00:54:15 during the French and Indian War, learned of the Indian siege,
00:54:18 he sent a letter to one of his colonels.
00:54:20 Quote, could it not be contrived to send the smallpox
00:54:23 among those disaffected tribes of Indians?
00:54:25 We must, on this occasion, use every stratagem
00:54:28 in our power to reduce them.
00:54:30 The colonel wrote back that he would try
00:54:32 to infect the Indians with blankets, 0.98
00:54:33 taking care, however, not to get the disease myself.
00:54:37 They weren't the first to think of it.
00:54:38 A fur trader named William wrote in his journal in 1763
00:54:43 that the British had given blankets from the smallpox war
00:54:46 to two Indian diplomats.
00:54:48 Quote, out of our regard to them,
00:54:50 we gave them two blankets and a handkerchief
00:54:52 out of the smallpox hospital.
00:54:54 I hope it will have the desired effect.
00:54:57 Reportedly, Trent also submitted an invoice
00:54:59 for blankets to the British government.
00:55:01 Quote, to replace in kind those which were taken
00:55:04 from people in hospital to convey the smallpox
00:55:07 to the Indians.
00:55:08 So it's true that a couple of British officers
00:55:10 and a trader wanted to spread smallpox through blankets,
00:55:14 but there's no evidence that they succeeded
00:55:16 in causing an outbreak.
00:55:18 Had it worked, the siege would have ended
00:55:19 and the Indians would have moved to healthier areas, 0.94
00:55:21 but it lasted for many more months.
00:55:24 When the dignitaries at Fort Pitt met
00:55:25 to discuss terms of surrender,
00:55:27 the Indians who had received the blankets
00:55:29 did not have smallpox.
00:55:32 It's worth noting that smallpox rarely ever spreads
00:55:35 on surfaces, and when it does,
00:55:37 it's substantially less dangerous.
00:55:39 George Washington knew this.
00:55:40 During the Revolutionary War,
00:55:42 Washington ordered the first mass immunization campaign
00:55:44 in American history,
00:55:46 where doctors rubbed small amounts of smallpox virus
00:55:49 into the incisions that they cut in soldiers' arms.
00:55:53 That wasn't always effective, and it was certainly dangerous.
00:55:56 But in general, the campaign worked.
00:55:58 Some historians credit the inoculation campaign
00:56:01 for winning the war.
00:56:02 This is a virus that, as Washington later demonstrated,
00:56:05 is substantially less dangerous
00:56:06 when it's not inhaled into the lungs.
00:56:08 Even when you deliberately rub the virus
00:56:10 into a soldier's bloodstream via the skin,
00:56:13 it's more likely to inoculate him
00:56:15 than to cause any kind of adverse effects.
00:56:18 And on top of that, it's a virus
00:56:19 that doesn't last very long outside the body.
00:56:22 In human conditions, when it's contained
00:56:23 in saliva or blister fluids,
00:56:25 say when it's on a blanket belonging to a smallpox patient,
00:56:29 the smallpox virus will often die within just a few hours.
00:56:33 The fact is smallpox killed a lot of Indians,
00:56:35 killed a lot of everybody,
00:56:37 but they didn't catch it from blankets.
00:56:39 Philip Randlett, a historian at Hunter College,
00:56:42 put it this way, quote,
00:56:43 since as it appears the smallpox at Fort Pitt
00:56:45 originated with the Indians,
00:56:47 the blanket gambit had to have been a complete failure.
00:56:49 Trying to infect Indians with smallpox
00:56:51 that came from them in the first place was doomed to fail
00:56:54 because the Indians vulnerable to the disease
00:56:56 had just been exposed to it.
00:56:58 He also noted that, quote,
00:56:59 plenty of evidence suggests that the smallpox virus
00:57:01 already dead on the unpleasant gifts and if fort pitt had been saved by the blanket stratagem
00:57:07 trent would have done some gloating only one conclusion could be drawn the plan flopped
00:57:13 in august of 1762 a year before the smallpox blankets were supposedly distributed the american
00:57:19 military engineer thomas hutchins wrote the following journal entry from fort miami in ohio
00:57:24 the 20th the above indians met and the chief spoke in behalf of his and the kikapaua nations as
00:57:30 follows brother we are very thankful to sir william johnson for sending you to inquire into the state
00:57:35 of the indians we assure you we are rendered very miserable at present on account of a severe
00:57:40 sickness that has seized almost all our people many of which have died lately and many more likely
00:57:46 to die the 30th set out for the lower shawnees town and arrived 8th of september in the afternoon
00:57:52 could not have a meeting with the shawnees the 12th as their people were sick and dying every day 1.00
00:57:57 It's true that beginning earlier in the spring, an outbreak of smallpox was underway in the Ohio Valley and Great Lakes region.
00:58:04 That's according to Gershom Hicks, who was held captive by the Indians at the time and described what he saw in a letter to his regiment captain, William Grant.
00:58:13 According to Hicks' eyewitness testimony, quote,
00:58:15 The smallpox has been very general and raging amongst the Indians since last spring.
00:58:20 It's killed many Mingos, Delawares and Shawnees. 0.60
00:58:23 But there's no reason to believe that blankets caused this outbreak
00:58:26 because the outbreak preceded the distribution of the blankets by several months.
00:58:30 So that's it.
00:58:31 That's the sum total of the evidence that white colonizers massacred the Indians
00:58:35 by using smallpox blankets as a bioweapon.
00:58:39 Hundreds of years ago, a mercenary trader and a couple of British officers
00:58:42 had suggested giving smallpox blankets to the Indians,
00:58:45 and the mercenary claims he actually followed through on the attempt.
00:58:50 The smallpox blanket myth is yet another central story involving the American Indians
00:58:54 that we can officially say is now debunked.
00:59:00 The purpose of this report is not to whitewash history or present a mirror image
00:59:04 of the cartoon version of Indians were taught in schools.
00:59:08 The reality is that the Indians were victims of some horrible things,
00:59:11 including unnecessary and inhumane massacres, sometimes at the hands of the U.S. Army.
00:59:15 In 1864, with the federal government consumed by the Civil War, Sioux, Comanche, Kiowa, Cheyenne,
00:59:21 and Arapahoes were regularly raiding and murdering white settlements across the West.
00:59:26 Hundreds of white settlers were dead, some were kidnapped.
00:59:29 Wagon trains heading West were under constant siege.
00:59:32 Obviously, this was a major issue for the fledgling and isolated city of Denver.
00:59:37 That November, along the banks of Sand Creek in southeastern Colorado territory,
00:59:41 A village of Cheyenne and Arapaho people, led by Chief Black Kettle, who had raised both an American flag and a white flag of truce in hopes of peace, awoke to the thunder of approaching hooves as U.S. Army Colonel John M. Chivington brought a force of over 675 Colorado volunteer soldiers in a brutal, unprovoked assault on the encampment of mostly women, children, and elders.
01:00:04 What unfolded over the next few hours was a scene of unimaginable horror. Soldiers charging through
01:00:10 teepees, firing indiscriminately, mutilating bodies, slaughtering more than 230 Native Americans,
01:00:17 the vast majority who were women and children. This was despite promises of protection extended
01:00:22 by U.S. authorities just weeks before. The citizens of Denver were elated and saw
01:00:27 Shivington as a hero. He paraded through the city with Indian scalps. The entire event, 1.00
01:00:33 of course, was a disgrace. But some of Chivington's own officers were appalled by the massacre.
01:00:38 Their accounts led to shock and moral outrage in East Coast newspapers among the public.
01:00:43 There was a military commission and there were two congressional investigations into the massacre.
01:00:48 The territorial governor was forced to resign from office. The final congressional report
01:00:53 called it a foul and dastardly massacre which would have disgraced the various savage among
01:00:58 those were victims of this cruelty the sand creek massacre deserves to be condemned but it's easy
01:01:04 to forget the circumstances that white settlers were living under it's easy to look down on what
01:01:10 happened today now that there's no risk that your wife and kids are going to be scalped on their way
01:01:14 to the local grocery store but life back then was very different in 1871 general william tecumseh
01:01:21 sherman whose middle name notably is a tribute to a legendary indian chief was traveling across the
01:01:27 salt creek prairie when he was spotted by indian warriors he got lucky a medicine man called off 0.99
01:01:33 the raid on his caravan a few hours later a less lucky convoy of 10 wagons loaded with corn and
01:01:40 supplies for fort griffin rumbled westward along the same route the comanche massacred according
01:01:47 to captain robert g carter who witnessed the aftermath quote the poor victims were stripped
01:01:52 scalped and horribly mutilated several were beheaded and their brains scooped out their
01:01:58 fingers toes and private parts have been cut off and stuck in their mouths and their bodies now 0.75
01:02:03 lying in several inches of water and swollen or bloated beyond all chance of recognition
01:02:09 were filled full of arrows which made them resemble porcupines their bowels had been gassed with knives
01:02:15 and carefully heaped upon each exposed abdomen had placed a mass of live coals now of course
01:02:22 extinguished by the deluge of water which was still coming down with a tarantial power almost
01:02:26 indescribable one wretched man samuel elliott fighting hard to the last had evidently been
01:02:32 wounded was found chained between two wagon wheels and a fire having been made from the wagon pole
01:02:38 had been slowly roasted to death burnt to a crisp and he was still alive when the fiendish torture
01:02:44 was begun was shown by his limbs being drawn up and contracted congress never condemned the attack
01:02:50 probably because they were so common the indian chiefs involved were captured convicted and
01:02:55 sentenced to death but their convictions were commuted and they were eventually paroled
01:03:00 overwhelmingly the cruelest attacks on the indians came from vigilantes on april 30th 1871
01:03:05 near camp grant in arizona a peaceful encampment of apache indians mostly women and children and
01:03:11 elderly they were asleep and under the supposed protection of a federal treaty but 148 tucson
01:03:16 citizens, Anglo-Americans, Mexican-Americans, and American Indian allies, infuriated by ongoing
01:03:22 Apache raids, massacred more than 100 Apache, kidnapped 28 children to sell into slavery,
01:03:27 and left a horrifying scene of devastation. President Ulysses S. Grant was infuriated
01:03:32 and demanded a trial. The defendants, though, were acquitted. That was, by and large,
01:03:37 the sad saga of the conflict between Indians and settlers. But in the end, the United States
01:03:42 government never committed genocide to the extent that tribes or bands were killed to extinction or
01:03:47 near extinction as was the case with the yaki and yuki in california it was at the hands of
01:03:52 local militias or rogue pioneers and those events were usually condemned by the u.s government
01:03:58 rather than committing genocide against the indians the u.s federal government and the
01:04:02 taxpayers who supported it did something radically different it offered them land
01:04:07 This must have been shocking to a Comanche or Sioux chief.
01:04:10 When they won wars, as we've repeatedly demonstrated, 0.55
01:04:13 they tortured and executed the losers.
01:04:16 Villages were pillaged and burned. 0.99
01:04:18 The women were enslaved and, depending on the tribe, raped. 0.66
01:04:22 Enemy warriors were eaten.
01:04:24 But when the U.S. finally won the Indian wars,
01:04:27 the treatment was quite different.
01:04:29 The Comanche, which was one of the last tribes to go to the reservation,
01:04:33 ended up with millions of acres of prime cattle land.
01:04:36 Their chief was a mixed-race man named Quanah Parker.
01:04:39 He spent his youth murdering white settlers and committing horrifying atrocities,
01:04:43 but Quanah Parker was never put on trial or executed for crimes against humanity.
01:04:48 The women and children he undoubtedly killed and scalped were never avenged.
01:04:53 Instead, he moved to a massive tract of valuable cattle land and became friends
01:04:57 with General Mackenzie, the Indian warrior who subdued the Indians by fighting like an Indian.
01:05:02 Rather than live out his life as a prisoner of war, Quanah Parker became a celebrity.
01:05:06 He lived in a 10-room mansion.
01:05:08 He dined with President Roosevelt,
01:05:09 spent time lobbying lawmakers on Indian affairs.
01:05:12 According to the book Empire of the Summer Moon,
01:05:14 Tawana had one of the first residential telephones in Oklahoma.
01:05:17 He owned a car, an ambulance, had a bodyguard,
01:05:19 frequently traveled on a railroad that was named after him.
01:05:22 He appeared in a Western movie called The Bank Robbery
01:05:25 and rode in Teddy Roosevelt's inaugural parade,
01:05:28 along with Geronimo, two Sioux chiefs, and a Blackfeet chief.
01:05:32 Life on the reservations was never perfect,
01:05:34 But it was better than what would have happened if they'd lost the war to a rival tribe.
01:05:39 And that's what they don't teach you in school.