Blue Origin "Mission" Brutally Mocked, and Defamation Case Against NBC, with Batya Ungar-Sargon and Stacey Evans | Ep. 1050
Episode Stats
Length
2 hours and 6 minutes
Words per Minute
175.48683
Summary
On today's show, Megyn talks about the latest in the Abrego Garcia case, the latest on the Women s Space Flight trip to space, and how Hollywood is celebrating Jeff Bezos's sexual fantasy rocket ride. Plus, a call-in from the lawyer for the disgraced doctor who recently settled his massive defamation case against NBC News.
Transcript
00:00:02.840
Make sure your team is taken care of through every twist and turn
00:00:05.980
with Canada Life Savings, Retirement and Benefits Plans.
00:00:09.660
Whether you want to grow your team, support your employees at every stage
00:00:13.120
or build a workplace people want to be a part of,
00:00:16.200
Canada Life has flexible plans for companies of all sizes
00:00:19.400
so it's easy to find a solution that works for you.
00:00:22.840
Visit canadalife.com slash employee benefits to learn more.
00:00:31.240
Welcome to The Megyn Kelly Show, live on Sirius XM Channel 111 every weekday at New East.
00:00:42.780
Hey everyone, I'm Megyn Kelly. Welcome to The Megyn Kelly Show.
00:00:47.600
Later, we've got the lawyer for the doctor who recently settled his massive defamation case
00:00:53.840
She will join me to explain exactly what they did on The Rachel Maddow Show,
00:01:02.080
and on MSNBC.com with people like Jacob Soberoff
00:01:06.700
that wound up costing NBC some undisclosed amount of money
00:01:10.980
with which the plaintiffs say they are, quote, very happy.
00:01:25.380
Democrat senators making absolute fools of themselves now,
00:01:28.340
going to bat for the illegal immigrant suspected MS-13 gang member.
00:01:32.180
This is their poster boy on the left now who was sent to El Salvador.
00:01:37.040
OK, there was the removal order saying don't remove him there because he might face gang violence.
00:01:47.020
What we did was send him back to his home country.
00:01:57.540
between the Trump administration and this judge.
00:02:08.760
literally they're talking about it like it was Apollo 11.
00:02:21.860
All these Hollywood celebs are going on Instagram and elsewhere
00:02:26.060
and expressing their disdain for what these women did
00:02:33.940
Wait until you hear how they talked about their 10-minute trip
00:02:48.260
free press columnist and author of Second Class,
00:02:50.760
How the Elites Betrayed America's Working Men and Women.
00:03:00.020
If you miss the April 15th deadline or still owe back taxes,
00:03:05.640
and every day you wait might make things worse.
00:03:16.420
The good news is there's still time for Tax Network USA to help.
00:03:25.540
Tax Network USA specializes in cleaning up financial chaos
00:05:02.540
that are appropriate for referral to the U.S. DOJ
00:05:20.740
and then in applying for a mortgage for that house,
00:05:50.520
knowing that this was not her primary residence,
00:06:06.140
Then they're saying she had a place in Brooklyn
00:06:08.000
that she was going to get a special mortgage for
00:33:57.160
This is why Democratic women, wealthy, middle-aged
00:34:00.080
Democratic women made, you know, third-trimester
00:34:32.860
It's about the dignity of the average American.
00:34:38.840
lost touch with that great American middle, have
00:34:43.240
to invent ways in which they are the ones who are
00:34:48.240
Hence the magical slippery slope that if Donald Trump
00:34:51.920
deports an alleged wife beater or somebody who supports
00:34:56.480
Hamas, people who are not American citizens and don't
00:34:59.900
have the rights of American citizens, that he could be
00:35:02.620
coming for you, you wealthy people at Coachella.
00:35:16.960
It's going to work with the top 10 percent because that's
00:35:19.220
really what they want to hear, that they are the true
00:35:21.860
But this is going to get the Democrats nowhere.
00:35:24.580
You know, there's a meme I keep thinking about, you
00:35:26.660
know, this anime meme of the young man standing like
00:35:29.280
this and there's a butterfly, you know, it's like he's
00:35:32.280
the Democrats and they're looking at like, you know,
00:35:35.160
these these ne'er-do-wells, you know, these illegals who
00:35:37.760
came here illegally broke the law, you know, and they are
00:35:42.380
And I just keep thinking this is them like being like, is
00:35:46.960
No, it's not how you get back the working class.
00:35:50.240
No, 73 percent of men who voted for Trump, men who are
00:35:59.240
He found that 73 percent of non-white men who voted for
00:36:10.940
Their American dream was put on hold so that the Democrats
00:36:14.180
could walk around white knighting for illegal migrants and
00:36:19.040
And that number, Megan, is growing and growing and
00:36:23.060
I mean, I care about the working class and I want them to
00:36:27.140
But I also care about the safety of young women like
00:36:31.080
Laken Riley, like this 37 year old mom, Rachel Morin, who's
00:36:35.420
killed on a jog, mother of five by an illegal who was harboring
00:36:44.340
And Caroline Levitt was making this point perfectly the other day
00:36:49.000
I think it was yesterday about how they're very, very concerned
00:36:52.700
about Abrego Garcia getting his proper due process.
00:36:56.440
They don't say one word, not one word about the Laken Riley's or
00:37:04.660
The Democrat in media outrage over the deportation of Abrego
00:37:08.020
Garcia, an MS-13 El Salvadorian, illegal alien criminal who is
00:37:13.380
hiding in Maryland, has been nothing short of despicable.
00:37:16.840
Based on the sensationalism of many of the people in this room,
00:37:20.140
you would think we deported a candidate for father of the year.
00:37:23.760
That's because, unfortunately, many in this country care more
00:37:26.920
about this quote unquote Maryland father, a legal alien MS-13 gang
00:37:31.760
member than a Maryland mother and an American citizen who was
00:37:35.760
brutally murdered at the hands of a different illegal alien.
00:37:43.420
Where was the Maryland senator's trip on her behalf, showboating on her
00:37:50.480
Where was Chris Murphy speaking out so that we all understood the dangers
00:37:54.200
of Joe Biden's illegal immigration policy, that actual American women were
00:37:59.860
being killed as they go for a jog to try to stay fit where I don't remember
00:38:07.840
And is that because what bigotry of low expectations?
00:38:11.280
They just expect these guys are, you know, they're they're animals.
00:38:16.660
If so, why would you why would you on an open border?
00:38:19.960
It's like none of it is congruous other than they see in a story, as you
00:38:24.320
point out, and they see an opportunity to advance themselves.
00:38:32.000
I mean, these people at this point, they would give a kidney to get a retweet
00:38:37.000
This is they've decided this is the direction that the party is going in.
00:38:41.260
I think that she's very genuine and really believes what she has to say.
00:38:44.640
If the Democrats cannot figure out that illegal immigration is a huge problem that came at
00:38:50.900
the expense of people who used to be their voters and now are Trump's voters because
00:38:55.620
he looked at them and said, you have a right to demand better.
00:38:58.900
They're never, ever, ever going to be competitive again.
00:39:02.680
You know, they have a lot of like, you know, they seem to understand that they have a problem.
00:39:08.040
But this is the one thing that they just will not they can't quit illegal immigrants.
00:39:14.480
And I think, Megan, the reason for that is like, unlike Donald Trump, who very successfully
00:39:19.120
sidelined the elites of his party over the last 10 years, and especially during the last
00:39:23.660
campaign, all of the Democratic funding is now bound up with very privileged white progressives
00:39:32.180
who really support the open border, both for economic and for social reasons.
00:39:37.020
But also, you know, the Soros Foundation, the Ford Foundation, all of these NGOs that have
00:39:52.840
And of course, this is the most elite thing possible.
00:39:56.420
There are millions of Americans who the only thing they have in their life that gives them
00:40:04.460
They are proud to belong to this, the greatest nation on planet Earth.
00:40:10.220
And that is the thing that the elites cannot stand for them to have, that they want to rob
00:40:16.840
And of course, the way you rob them of that is you dilute it by having an open border and
00:40:20.940
having a marketplace that welcomes in millions of people to compete with working class people
00:40:28.580
The idea that you could have somebody here who is, you know, claiming to have the same
00:40:33.680
legal protections as a citizen is a way of saying the citizenship itself should not count
00:40:40.880
And I think all good people should say no to that.
00:40:46.460
But before I get to it, I just want to point out if again, we haven't independently verified
00:40:54.080
Fox News is reporting them now at least to one from 2021 from 2021 in which Jennifer Vasquez
00:41:01.880
is accusing a man who has the same name, Kilmar Abrego Garcia, and it shows his birthday is
00:41:11.200
I mean, maybe there are two couples that are that unite Jennifer Vasquez and Kilmar Abrego
00:41:24.160
So that would have been a 2020 and a 2021 domestic violence incident bad enough to make her go
00:41:29.280
in and seek a protective order against him alleging serious domestic violence.
00:41:33.060
He, his, when he was found, uh, alleged, allegedly engaging in some sort of activity that led them
00:41:39.960
to believe he was arrestable and part of MSN 13 was 2019.
00:41:46.100
He was found to be part of this gang of the appellate court in the immigration system,
00:41:52.960
And then he, you know, pleaded for mercy saying, well, please just don't deport me to El Salvador.
00:41:58.700
And of course we said, okay, fine, you don't have to go.
00:42:03.700
The first incident would have been within months of us going soft on him, of, of our
00:42:16.380
And then if, if this dovetails the way it looks like it does, according to these documents,
00:42:20.540
he was wailing on his wife in 2020 and then again in 2021, and then he gets arrested and
00:42:26.580
sent out by Trump and it's back to, oh, poor guy.
00:42:32.440
But I want to get to your bigger point because it's important about how these, these, these
00:42:37.820
judges are trying to take the matter in hand, that the Democrats are trying to stop the Trump
00:42:43.300
agenda of removing the millions that Joe Biden willingly, happily, purposefully allowed in.
00:42:51.900
On Monday, a federal judge halted the Trump administration's plan to revoke the legal status
00:43:00.680
and work permits of more than half a million migrants from Cuba, Haiti, Nicaragua, and Venezuela,
00:43:12.060
We flew here under a Biden era, quote, parole program.
00:43:17.640
He flew them in saying, I'll give you legal protection and I will let you work in the United
00:43:25.460
And no sooner had he begun that program than they are.
00:43:31.180
Some data from the program showing evidence of fraud.
00:43:34.020
One review found that at least 3,200 people applied to sponsor immigrants.
00:43:41.400
And it's really supposed to be like a direct relationship, but they sponsored over 101,000
00:43:46.440
So it's clearly these government NGOs or dare I say the Catholic church saying, I'll be responsible
00:43:54.520
But 3,000 people cannot monitor 101,000 as alleged here.
00:43:59.300
The Trump administration looking at this program also alleges that it was very poor vetting.
00:44:06.980
Almost 3 million of these applications were filed, excuse me, as of last August, including
00:44:12.320
80,000 from aliens living in countries other than those that I listed.
00:44:19.980
This is all according to a House Judiciary Committee report.
00:44:23.660
And concerns of fraud were so bad that they even led Biden's Department of Homeland Security
00:44:28.800
to suspend temporarily this program for several weeks last year.
00:44:37.600
You might be able to suspend their legal status here, Mr. Trump, if you give them an individual
00:44:44.600
case-by-case review, which no one got on the way in.
00:44:49.760
But now we want, they just want to tie him up for the next four years with all of this
00:44:59.200
They got flown in summarily and they can be flown out summarily.
00:45:07.100
I think they're wrong on the, on the legal merits.
00:45:09.740
John, you were saying yesterday, you made a really good point, which is that this parole
00:45:13.520
program is always at the request of the president and can be revoked at any moment.
00:45:20.080
They just want to keep them in court, keep them from enacting the agenda that the president
00:45:24.620
was put in office to enact by the voters of this country.
00:45:30.560
You know, Megan, I keep thinking if this was 2016, back then the Democrats sort of mass
00:45:36.740
media approach to opposing the Trump administration worked a lot better.
00:45:43.320
Remember the whole like family separation thing, you know, that was in the New York Times and
00:45:49.880
And suddenly, you know, the Trump administration had to back off because there was this huge
00:45:54.660
And I think today we are just in a totally different moment because the voters, the electorate,
00:46:00.400
the American people was able to see what happens when you have somebody like Joe Biden
00:46:04.660
just basically decriminalized illegal border crossing, which is what he did, which is what
00:46:09.120
he promised he was going to do during the campaign.
00:46:14.020
And the most horrifying part about it is this to me.
00:46:17.220
I mean, obviously, the crimes that are committed against American citizens, I agree with you,
00:46:25.900
It's because American corporations were desperate for workers in the post-pandemic labor crunch,
00:46:32.060
and they didn't want to pay American workers what they were asking for.
00:46:35.980
And so Biden partnered with the cartels to open the border and provide American corporations
00:46:43.260
with slave labor to the tune of millions and millions and millions of illegal immigrants.
00:46:49.860
And when that chaos threatened his reelection campaign, they said, you know what?
00:46:56.080
We're just going to legally start importing these people to these corporations so they
00:47:00.700
can pay them slave wages and not have to pay Americans more money.
00:47:04.680
I think Biden felt, well, this will bring down inflation.
00:47:08.040
Now, the problem with this is that, you know, we actually should want working class Americans
00:47:18.180
We have to control immigration because a tight labor market uses the free market in order
00:47:24.820
to raise wages for working class people and give them dignity.
00:47:29.040
And that's why in the 70s, most Americans were middle class because people who worked in
00:47:34.900
meatpacking plants and people who were manicurists and people who worked in construction were able
00:47:43.480
They were able to make a middle class wage, working and working class jobs.
00:47:49.540
And now thanks to the Democrats who still have the chutzpah to cosplay as the side of labor,
00:47:56.300
we shipped all these good manufacturing jobs overseas to China to build up their middle class.
00:48:01.400
We imported millions and millions of low wage illegal immigrants to work in the jobs here,
00:48:07.420
radically reducing the wages that working class people could ask for.
00:48:11.060
And it was Donald Trump, a Republican, who showed up and said, you do not have to live
00:48:23.440
People will say, oh, well, if we pay working class people a living wage, then all of these
00:48:29.980
Well, notice that what Donald Trump has done is he took a bunch of very pro-worker policies
00:48:35.520
like tariffs and controlling the border to raise the wages of working class people.
00:48:40.620
And he has paired them with a host of very pro-business things that are coming down the
00:48:51.400
We're going to have cheap energy because of drill, baby, drill.
00:48:57.180
And he has promised anybody who reshores manufacturing that he will drop their corporate taxes to
00:49:03.720
That combination of being pro-business on the one side and pro-worker on the other side,
00:49:11.280
And this is why the Democrats can't stand him because they didn't think of this first.
00:49:17.940
They came to it too late and then tried to steal it as their own, but they haven't been
00:49:23.920
Um, March, 2025 numbers at the border, lowest crossings in U S history.
00:49:39.480
And when it comes to those we have, uh, apprehended and, um, yeah, those that we've apprehended.
00:49:46.800
And by the way, March of 2024, that was right around when Joe Biden actually did try to start
00:49:51.420
making an effort at the Southern border because he realized his reelection chances were going to
00:49:56.880
Um, in March of 2024, the numbers crossing the border were about 4,500 a day under Joe Biden.
00:50:04.560
Now it's less than 330 a day, uh, for the entire month.
00:50:10.860
It was a hundred and about 40,000 for the month under Trump is about 8,300.
00:50:22.760
He just didn't have the will stand by more with Baja after this quick break.
00:50:26.700
These days, it feels like nothing surprises us anymore, but not in a good way.
00:50:32.100
The future feels uncertain and so much is out of our control.
00:50:35.280
But one thing you can take control of right now is your family's financial future with life
00:50:40.000
insurance through select quote, whether you need 500,000 or 50 million in coverage, select
00:50:46.620
quote makes it easy to find the right policy for your unique needs.
00:50:49.880
They have helped over 2 million people find more than 700 billion in coverage since 1985.
00:50:55.800
And they do it fast, often in as little as 15 minutes.
00:50:59.340
Other life insurance brokers might push generic overpriced plans, but select quotes, licensed agents
00:51:07.760
Even if you have a preexisting condition like high blood pressure or diabetes, select quote
00:51:13.540
partners with carriers who can still offer coverage.
00:51:16.880
And if you're healthy, you could get same day coverage with no medical exam required.
00:51:22.180
What if consider taking a step to secure your peace of mind, get the right life insurance
00:51:26.580
for you for less at select quote.com slash Megan that select quote.com slash Megan select
00:51:42.400
But what if you or a partner needs to step away?
00:51:45.300
When the unexpected happens, count on Canada Life's flexible life and health insurance to
00:51:50.540
help your business keep working, even when you can't.
00:51:53.540
Don't let life's challenges stand in the way of your success.
00:51:58.360
Visit Canada Life dot com slash business protection to learn more.
00:52:12.660
Judge Boesberg, who thinks that he's the president of the United States, he's the chief district
00:52:18.500
court judge for the district of Washington, D.C.
00:52:30.540
He said he would launch proceedings to determine whether to hold the Trump administration, its
00:52:36.340
officials in criminal contempt for defying his order not to remove Venezuelan migrants
00:52:42.700
from America based on the wartime alien enemies act.
00:52:46.020
This is all based this he's drunk on his own power.
00:52:50.360
This is all based on the fact that Trump decided to use the alien enemies act, which,
00:52:57.420
by the way, the Supreme Court has already implicitly said, OK, that's good.
00:53:02.280
I mean, we're not going to we're not going to chastise him on that.
00:53:09.320
And the ACLU ran into court before Judge Boesberg because they knew they could get a sympathetic
00:53:15.560
They did not go into Texas where the detainees were that they were allegedly representing
00:53:23.300
That's what the U.S. Supreme Court ultimately held.
00:53:25.180
They went to D.C. because they knew they could get a judge.
00:53:32.760
And they got a ruling from him saying, first of all, he said, no, no plane should take off
00:53:43.900
This is Marco Rubio's call and President Trump's call on whether the foreign policy of the
00:53:50.840
United States requires these people to be deported and whether the safety and security
00:53:54.240
of the American people requires that they to be deported.
00:53:56.620
And the commander in chief ruled that they were part of an incursion or an invasion and
00:54:03.700
Judge Boesberg said, no, I'm higher than you are on the totem pole.
00:54:10.480
And there is a real question about whether any sort of temporary restraining order has
00:54:16.140
Wasn't put in writing until several hours later that day.
00:54:19.720
Two planes were already in the air and in international airspace, and they refused to
00:54:26.740
It did take off much later from the written order, but it didn't have anybody on it pursuant
00:54:32.440
So it's really less relevant, but he's getting ready to hold them in criminal contempt for
00:54:42.480
And for allowing them to take off in the first place.
00:54:47.060
We talked about this with our lawyer panel the other day about you, but like, I don't
00:54:50.140
know how you hold, I don't know how you hold the president in criminal contempt.
00:54:56.080
So are we in a world where like the Democrats want a Brigo Garcia free and Trump jailed?
00:55:05.600
I keep thinking like, you know, they tried to get him on 91 counts and like, look at where
00:55:15.380
You know, this Khalil Mahmoud guy, they hold him up as some sort of, you know, oh, he's
00:55:25.520
And then it turns out if you had just waited like, you know, 10 minutes, you would have
00:55:29.440
found out that this guy actually lied on his visa application, right?
00:55:34.860
This Garcia fellow who they're holding up as this Maryland father.
00:55:39.040
Well, maybe wait a minute and find out, you know, a little bit more about this person before
00:55:43.940
you decide to nominate him for like, you know, the avatar of the Democratic Party.
00:55:48.260
And they just can't seem to understand that there is a real logic here.
00:55:58.240
But everything he has done since he got into office has been unbelievably intentional.
00:56:04.820
You know, they lost in 2020 and they sat at home and for four years they plotted.
00:56:09.680
I feel like you can really see this with Jason Miller, right?
00:56:12.840
And with that, with Stephen Miller, this is a guy who sat at home for four years and plotted
00:56:19.960
how he was going to restore America to its greatness through using legal avenues to enact
00:56:27.680
the Trump agenda that is wildly popular with the American people.
00:56:33.720
And the Democrats are acting like it's 2016, people are shooting from the hip and that you
00:56:39.240
can get a story in the New York Times and shut down the agenda.
00:56:45.480
I think Trump was really changed by the assassination attempts on him.
00:56:48.920
But also, Megan, I think he was changed by the level of support that he sees from the people.
00:56:56.160
You know, in 2016, he knew that what he wanted to do was popular, but he couldn't quite
00:57:02.100
In 2025, he knows that what he wants to do is popular and he knows that the people know
00:57:08.680
And I think that that confidence is really coming across and it is forcing the Democrats
00:57:15.280
into unforced error after unforced error after unforced error.
00:57:19.420
I mean, you don't need a consultant to tell you, don't white knight for the criminal illegal
00:57:32.640
I made this point when I was arguing with somebody on the show about it, but I was like, they
00:57:36.660
They did not go and arrest all of the students at Columbia University who were taking part
00:57:42.560
of those protests or all the students at Harvard who were taking part of those protests or any
00:57:47.360
They targeted a few who were the leaders, the instigators who took an extra role and were
00:57:58.280
We didn't try to kick out American citizens where people committed crimes.
00:58:01.720
They got charged with whatever it was, larceny or vandalism.
00:58:09.120
He was a guest in our house and he behaved like an animal.
00:58:12.260
And I don't care that he didn't actually commit violence on Columbia's campus.
00:58:15.620
He was the spokesperson for the group that held the hostages on campus.
00:58:20.340
The entire campus was held hostage thanks to that group he represented.
00:58:24.080
And by the way, he worked for the Hamas arm of the UN.
00:58:27.940
That's the lie you're referring to on his visa application.
00:58:31.300
Mysteriously, he forgot to disclose that when he asked us if he could come into our country.
00:58:40.540
But yes, the left is now the party that makes statues of George Floyd and won't stand for
00:58:46.060
little DJ Daniel at the State of the Union and won't mourn Rachel Morin or Lakin Riley
00:58:52.520
and will send senators to prisons in El Salvador to go gin up empathy for an accused wife abuser
00:59:00.540
and MS-13 gang member who's from El Salvador, by the way.
00:59:05.200
Like we sent him to like the middle of Siberia.
00:59:12.680
Now, it's it's coming back to haunt them, though, because they were the ones they were
00:59:19.660
the ones to unleash the dear friend letter during the Obama administration to start using
00:59:30.040
And of course, the universities were only too happy to comply.
00:59:33.680
And Barack Obama used the dear friend letter through his ridiculous secretary of education,
00:59:42.560
You eliminate due process for young men who are accused on college campuses or you get
00:59:53.060
If you don't yank their right to counsel, yank their right to cross examine, yank their
01:00:01.340
That was his big cause to try to completely eliminate due process rights for young men on
01:00:08.340
And by the way, there's virtually no rate of appeal.
01:00:10.220
You can try to file in a federal court after you've been found guilty as a sexual assault or
01:00:17.300
And even when it does, the university won't help you.
01:00:21.600
We saw this in the case at Amherst, where they completely dropped the ball on this one
01:00:25.520
They didn't care when it was all said and done.
01:00:27.440
It's very hard to get review when you've been fucked over, sorry, by your college campus
01:00:40.100
It has a duty under the various federal statutes that are out there, whether it's Title
01:00:43.580
Nine to protect women or Title Six to protect any minority group that's become the subject
01:00:48.180
of harassment on college campuses, to step in and try to stop it.
01:01:01.040
You cannot act in a discriminatory or harassing fashion.
01:01:08.100
And the government, it's their job to enforce legality.
01:01:12.300
But they crossed it with all those absurd protests where they were chanting Hamas slogans
01:01:17.200
at Jews, harassing them, in some cases, physically berating them or hurting them.
01:01:21.320
And Trump is trying to bring justice now, saying this will never happen again.
01:01:29.680
And here's how we're going to make sure it never happens again.
01:01:31.760
You're going to issue certain reforms on your campus or you're going to lose your federal
01:01:36.420
Now, this is exactly what Obama did, his threats on Title IX.
01:01:41.100
And by the way, what he did to many police stations across the country, you will hire
01:01:46.040
more black and brown people or we will take over.
01:01:49.060
In fact, they did take over many police stations and say, we're running your police station now.
01:01:53.380
We think you're too racist based on, you know, sometimes very scurrilous allegations.
01:01:57.300
In any event, so now Trump says to Harvard, you will do all these things.
01:02:04.140
And the list of things is actually quite good, I have to say.
01:02:12.620
The university must adopt and implement merit-based hiring policies, cease all preferences based
01:02:17.600
on race, color, religion, sex, or national origin.
01:02:20.080
They should be able to say they'll do that because it's unlawful not to, but they won't.
01:02:24.100
Merit-based admissions reform must adopt and implement merit-based admissions and cease all
01:02:30.160
preferences based on race, color, national origin, or proxies, et cetera.
01:02:33.160
That too should be a no-brainer given the Supreme Court decision on affirmative action.
01:02:41.500
You have to reform the way you recruit and screen international students who are hostile
01:02:51.560
Then there's, um, reform programs with egregious records of antisemitism or other bias.
01:02:57.220
You have to commission an external party to audit these programs that have been particularly
01:03:01.620
pernicious and fuel the most antisemitic harassment.
01:03:07.120
And you have to discontinue DEI, which of course is at the root of a lot of this Jew hatred
01:03:12.440
Um, they said, no, Trump said, say goodbye to $2.2 billion that you're getting now through
01:03:19.440
And that may, may not be all that may not be all.
01:03:22.180
We actually may look into your tax exempt status.
01:03:25.600
If you want to play hard ball, let's play hard ball.
01:03:27.820
He said, maybe Harvard should lose its tax exempt status and be taxed as a political entity.
01:03:32.680
If it keeps pushing political ideological and terrorist inspired sickness, remember tax
01:03:37.560
exempt status is totally contingent on acting in the public interest.
01:03:40.920
If that happens, then Harvard's endowment income tax rate could soar from 1.4% to the
01:03:46.460
standard 21% corporate tax rate, potentially translating to a $525 million annual reduction
01:03:54.500
Who decides to weigh in on how inappropriate this is to use the federal government to threaten
01:04:05.580
Yeah, it's truly amazing because he doesn't weigh in often.
01:04:11.880
And then when he does weigh in, it's always on the side of the elites of the elites of the
01:04:17.220
elites in the most unpopular way on the, like to me, Trump has already won because he got
01:04:23.360
Harvard to say, no way, Jose, we will not stop importing people who hate America and hate
01:04:31.740
Like whatever happens, he has exposed them for what they are, which is an institution
01:04:38.360
not of higher learning, but which confers status on people.
01:04:42.980
And the higher status you are is based on how much you hate America and recently how much
01:04:49.440
Like this is very clear at this point that these institutions are no longer places that give
01:05:01.600
And of course, it was Barack Obama who defunded vocational training in high schools, right?
01:05:07.900
The idea was everyone's going to go to college.
01:05:12.720
Why would he block millions and millions and millions of young men of finding their way
01:05:17.800
into the middle class by working with their hands for a living?
01:05:20.680
Well, of course, because the number one predictor for whether you'll be a Democrat is whether you
01:05:24.640
have a college degree, you know, so they were funneling people into college.
01:05:28.780
And so your ability to achieve the American dream, thanks to Barack Obama, became contingent
01:05:35.660
on how much anti-American, anti-Semitic, post-structuralist, post-modernist crap you had been exposed to.
01:05:44.100
And of course, you could see how this directly leads to these activist judges.
01:05:47.680
They've been exposed to it for 12 years, right?
01:05:50.420
So they've been exposed to it for many, many, many more years than even just your average
01:05:58.420
This is, of course, totally, totally ridiculous.
01:06:06.460
Certainly, if it cannot prove that it has the best interests of the United States of America
01:06:10.740
at heart, it's not owed the tax dollars of hardworking Americans.
01:06:14.740
But also the whole system that was built by Obama, the system in which you only get access
01:06:23.420
to the American dream if you walk the gauntlet of these anti-American institutions, which are
01:06:29.580
nothing more than status conferring operations in which elites confer status and a lot of wealth
01:06:43.160
I want us to stop seeing a Harvard degree as something to be proud of.
01:06:47.880
I want us to stop worshipping at the altar of these institutions that hate us and hate
01:06:55.620
And for the cost of $400,000 a year, teach young Americans who are going to be wealthy
01:07:01.200
to hate the people who they're going to employ.
01:07:06.740
Like, however this drama plays out, I think Harvard's going to cave very, very quickly.
01:07:10.920
I think the Trump administration's letter was an opening salvo.
01:07:14.880
I don't think they're going to insist on every aspect of this list.
01:07:17.500
They want certain things very clearly more than others that investigate all teachers for
01:07:22.860
That's probably I mean, I was also reading that and I was like, they'll never do that.
01:07:27.480
But we really have the power as Americans to say, just no.
01:07:34.480
Like, as Trump always says, you don't have to live like this.
01:07:38.620
We don't have to give people respect just because they have a Harvard degree or a Princeton
01:07:44.100
We can say, actually, this proves to me you spent four years being exposed to the most
01:07:49.700
It's already happening because corporate America already knows that a Harvard degree
01:07:52.820
isn't what it used to be and it means something else.
01:07:56.040
And I'm sorry, but this is what the left has done.
01:07:58.340
If you happen to be a minority and you're at one of these top elite universities and you
01:08:05.040
They're going to look at you and think that Harvard accepted you because of your skin color.
01:08:12.100
And it's unfortunate that you went there in a time of exploding DEI where they've changed
01:08:21.300
You have yourself a Harvard degree and now you have yourself a healthy amount of skepticism
01:08:25.280
from all employers because they're wondering whether you really deserve to get in or whether
01:08:34.300
So Barack Obama, just for the record, what he said was Harvard has set an example for other
01:08:39.420
higher institutions by rejecting, uh, this deal, rejecting an unlawful and ham handed
01:08:48.780
That's, that's really his history supports his commitment to pure academic freedom without
01:08:54.360
any governmental ham handed attempt to interfere the nerve, by the way, the best, the best tweet.
01:09:00.040
And really this guy might be my favorite follow on Twitter.
01:09:02.760
And that's saying a lot because I have a lot of people I love.
01:09:09.080
This is, um, a commentator who goes by red steez.
01:09:12.080
Um, he says, Obama, you know, who needs us to defend them right now?
01:09:17.420
Harvard, Bernie, you know who I need to go speak to about income inequality?
01:09:26.060
I have to keep going because there's so much news about you.
01:09:28.440
I'm I, if I don't get to spend enough time on blue origin, I'm going to be very sad and
01:09:32.960
I have to mention quickly, quickly that on the legal front, Pam Bondi just fired the,
01:09:42.960
So the main governor, she had her little tête-à-tête with Trump like, I'm not doing it.
01:09:51.140
She caved almost instantly on the universities because she couldn't lose the money and she
01:09:57.360
And so now Pam Bondi just filed a lawsuit saying, you will cave, you will cave because
01:10:07.160
It's in short referred to as title nine and you're violating it by letting boys play in
01:10:14.040
And by the way, there was just, this is not in our country, but just not for nothing.
01:10:18.320
The UK's Supreme Court, their highest court in the country, just ruled today unanimously
01:10:24.740
that the definition of a woman in equality legislation refers to a biological woman and
01:10:32.340
to biological sex and so-called trans women who are, that's not a thing.
01:10:40.880
They can call themselves whatever the hell they want, but legally they're not women.
01:10:45.620
And that's the problem that this main governor is going to have as this lawsuit goes forward.
01:10:50.400
So good for you, Pam Bondi, totally behind you all the way.
01:10:53.840
But we've got to get to blue origin because it's over the top.
01:11:00.060
We made fun of it on Monday because it was just so ridiculous the way some of the media
01:11:03.620
were covering it, the way they were like self-congratulatory.
01:11:09.800
First of all, can we, can we pull, I want to hear the lead.
01:11:13.360
I don't know which soundbite it is, you guys, but the, the montage of them about them.
01:11:29.200
Flowers for me, I believe are, are like God's laughter and God's smile.
01:11:35.440
And I brought a Daisy because I have so much love for my daughter, Daisy, and I have so
01:11:43.720
It just says to me, if I can do this, I was telling, I was telling these guys, I might even
01:11:50.080
I've never gotten my ears pierced because that hurts.
01:11:53.080
I hope they can, um, see the unity, um, that we modeled and replicate that and understand
01:12:13.740
Gail King upset because there's been a lot of blowback and I'll play it in a minute,
01:12:19.940
but like from Hollywood leftists and not just people like you and me, but like Hollywood
01:12:25.960
These are the people who are supposed to love them, who are ripping these women to shreds.
01:12:32.640
And Gail King is upset and had a few things that she needed to explain to those of us who
01:12:45.160
Whenever a man goes up, you have never said to an astronaut, boy, what a ride.
01:12:49.940
You know, we duplicated the same trajectory that Alan Shepard did back in the day.
01:12:58.100
It was called a journey because a ride, a ride implies that it's something frivolous or
01:13:03.900
There was nothing frivolous about what we did and, and the machine, and the machine that
01:13:09.360
we were on and what it took for the people to get that machine up and running, to get
01:13:15.980
So, you know, I'm very disappointed and very saddened by it.
01:13:19.300
And I also say this, the, what it's doing to inspire other women and young girls, please
01:13:27.220
So many women and young girls reach out to me and men too, by the way, men too, that
01:13:31.880
say, wow, I never thought I could do that, but I see you doing it at this stage of my
01:13:42.820
First of all, Alan Shepard walked on the moon, Gail.
01:13:47.260
You're, you're, you didn't do the same thing as Alan Shepard.
01:13:49.400
And by the way, when he did his first space flight, it was the first space flight.
01:14:01.220
It wasn't with some woman with her tits hanging out who needed a little extra attention.
01:14:08.220
Secondly, there's nothing frivolous about what we did.
01:14:14.520
Let's see how it went on board the blue origin spacecraft.
01:14:43.280
You guys, I have to tell you, look at the moon.
01:15:31.760
Like, they admired the universe and what they were expecting was for us to admire the fact
01:15:38.340
that they were rich enough and famous enough to have been granted this utterly, utterly vacuous
01:15:45.940
experience from which they learned absolutely nothing.
01:15:51.080
And it's just like, I mean, this is the Democratic Party, right?
01:16:01.680
I mean, this was exactly what Kamala Harris's entire campaign was like.
01:16:11.380
She said she's heard from women and girls who have said to her, I didn't realize this
01:16:18.300
Because it's not something they could do because they're not friends with Jeff Bezos, right?
01:16:25.580
Their message for women was take up space like us.
01:16:30.620
Like, the reception they got was like the right corrective.
01:16:40.720
Where is the sense that we owe something to the society that has made us so unbelievably
01:16:50.840
What they are giving back is their celebrity, the right for us to admire them.
01:16:58.460
It's not just women, although, of course, like, women do this so much worse because we
01:17:08.600
I don't remember who it was that went to space.
01:17:10.560
Yeah, I think it was Bezos and William Shatner.
01:17:11.720
He came back and he said, wow, you know, we're so small vis-a-vis the universe.
01:17:19.100
Like, the most banal, like, totally, like, really, you went to space.
01:17:26.040
And it's just like, these people are so bored, Megan.
01:17:30.520
They have nothing in their lives that they consider to be of value.
01:17:35.520
And what's amazing to me is that it seems like Hollywood knows what time it is, even
01:17:41.960
Like, you really did see people coming out and being like, what the heck is this?
01:17:48.940
Um, I, okay, yeah, the, the, just, I'm still stuck in the fact that Gail King actually used
01:17:55.240
the word astronauts in reference to like, we're just like, like an actual astronaut.
01:17:59.380
You are there on a vanity project of Jeff Bezos and his fiance.
01:18:04.320
You've done absolutely nothing to deserve this.
01:18:09.120
And if you don't want people to think it's frivolous, Gail, then don't have the fucking
01:18:14.580
Kardashian's craft side as you take off and Oprah that it, that might have something to
01:18:22.540
do with our reaction to this as a non-serious event, a PR stunt.
01:18:30.020
Back to the blowback, Olivia Munn, she's an actress.
01:18:36.120
And, uh, I think she speaks for a lot of us when she's trying to espouse why so many on
01:18:41.560
the left and the right had a visceral reaction to this.
01:18:44.580
Like, what are you guys going to do up in space?
01:18:49.280
I mean, it's, by the way, they're going for 11 minutes.
01:18:53.940
I think they're going to float around a little.
01:18:57.820
Like you're just going up space mountain, more appropriately space mountain.
01:19:01.880
Think about, I know this is probably obnoxious, but like, um, like it's so much money to go
01:19:09.740
And there's, we, there's a lot of people who can't even afford eggs.
01:19:15.800
And I think, um, I just think there are the cover of Elle magazine.
01:19:22.500
Space exploration was to, to like, to further our knowledge and to help mankind.
01:19:27.860
I mean, what are they going to do up there that has made it better for us down here?
01:19:34.960
I'll give you one more, um, model Emily Ratajkowski, uh, who did a little Instagram post after the
01:19:43.920
At space mission this morning, that's in time shit.
01:19:47.740
Like this is beyond parody thing that you care about mother earth and it's about mother
01:19:52.080
And you're going up in a spaceship that is built and paid for by a company that's single-handedly
01:19:58.360
destroying the planet get the state of the world and think about how many resources went
01:20:02.620
into putting these women into space for what, for what, what was the marketing there?
01:20:07.300
And then to try to make it like, I I'm disgusted.
01:20:14.780
Where's her protest on how many carbon emissions we had to suffer just so that Gail could be
01:20:20.980
Uh, Olivia Wilde reposted an image of Katy Perry kissing the ground.
01:20:26.660
Honestly, truly, she was asking, she was acting like she got back from Apollo 13, um, kissing
01:20:31.400
the rat and she captioned it billion dollars, bought some good memes, I guess.
01:20:36.200
Here was Amy Schumer doing her own version of making fun of these women.
01:20:40.540
Guys, last second, they added me to space and I'm going to space.
01:20:56.880
Um, it has no meaning to me, but, um, it was in my bag and I was like on the subway and I
01:21:04.020
got the text and they were like, do you want to go to space?
01:21:06.620
So I'm going to space and thank you to everyone who got me here and I'll see you guys in space.
01:21:21.940
I mean, like it's, that's what gets them upset.
01:21:24.680
That's why Gail did that little, we're inspirational and we're astronauts.
01:21:32.400
First of all, that's the funniest I've seen Amy Schumer in maybe 10 years, 15,
01:21:39.140
Um, I think that this is kind of a turning point, Megan.
01:21:44.860
Like a year ago, you would not have seen the left, like openly admitting, like, this is
01:21:51.500
It's almost like these women in their space mission admitted a little bit too much.
01:21:56.280
You know, they became, they went from being like the apotheosis of what the leftist elites
01:22:01.440
and Hollywood and entertainment represents to just like exposing it a little bit too much.
01:22:06.820
Like if the message had been like slightly better, nobody would have come out against
01:22:10.540
But now it's very interesting to see the cracks in the very elites that these women come
01:22:25.840
There's no purchase for that ostentatious, liberal, vacuous, empty culture anymore.
01:22:33.780
And I think we're going to look back on this moment as maybe the moment that we started
01:22:37.940
to realize that we were in full on woke lash and people wanted to return to substance and
01:22:43.940
to unifying messages and to actual entertainment, actual culture that has real meaning for people.
01:22:53.800
And I also think there's the element of it's got it's got a little bit of a stolen valor
01:22:58.220
feel to it where we revere our astronauts, our actual astronauts who actually do put themselves
01:23:11.960
And we've seen astronauts, actual ones die in the name of this service.
01:23:18.700
We've seen even civilians like Kristen McAuliffe when, you know, people of my age were in middle
01:23:23.180
school and we all watched that flight take off the space shuttle and and burn in the
01:23:34.080
They go through real training, not two days of learning how to buckle your seat belt, which
01:23:40.600
That's what they're touting as their training, buckling the seat belt, getting in and out of
01:23:44.460
the vessel and learning how to press the button so they could speak to mission control.
01:23:48.020
That is not that doesn't make you an astronaut.
01:23:50.480
Not OK, sorry, Gail and everybody else on board.
01:24:06.500
And so I like she and they actually seem to have expected a Neil Armstrong type welcome
01:24:14.460
And I'm really uplifted by the fact that left and right, because I think you and I have
01:24:19.980
probably zero in common with Amy Schumer and certainly Olivia Wilde, other than our ability
01:24:30.460
One more quick point, which is I forget his name, the astronaut who Elon Musk just rescued
01:24:42.680
He went to church services every Sunday from space.
01:24:48.460
I can't remember the last time I heard something so inspiring.
01:24:53.780
This man was in space and he did not miss a single Sunday service.
01:25:03.360
But he brought his spirituality and his faith up into space with him.
01:25:11.420
The idea that even there, when you're so close to the heavens and you have this perspective,
01:25:16.940
what he was longing for, what his soul needed was to be tied to his faith community here
01:25:24.240
And these women went up there in search of meaning and came down just as vacuous as they
01:25:31.500
The meaning they came back with was, I am important and I am your hero.
01:25:44.980
And again, I mean, my guest made this point yesterday.
01:25:48.060
It was a very good one, which is, I think it was, who was it who was making this, Walter
01:25:51.760
or on Monday, about how they completely ignored all these same news stations who want us to
01:25:56.720
celebrate these women, completely ignored Elon Musk's rescue of those two astronauts on
01:26:04.680
They'd been stuck up there for the better part of a year.
01:26:08.440
But this vapidity celebrated like the second coming.
01:26:23.940
And thank you for everything you do for this great nation and for the Jewish people.
01:26:30.960
Coming up next, we're going to have the lawyer for the doctor.
01:26:35.400
A doctor and a lawyer walked into a courtroom that the lawyer for the doctor who just sued
01:26:40.540
NBC News for defamation and they settled it because the judge had said, you have to go
01:26:51.920
And they were supposed to start that trial on April 22nd.
01:26:56.440
They say they're very happy with the settlement.
01:27:01.620
We live in a world our biology just was not built for.
01:27:04.820
Artificial light, seed oils, microplastics, chronic stress.
01:27:10.400
These modern stressors disrupt our cells' ability to function the way they should, impacting gut
01:27:19.080
Armra Cholestrum, that's Armra, is a bioactive whole food that helps restore cellular signaling
01:27:28.900
It's packed with over 400 powerful nutrients that work to reinforce your immune barriers,
01:27:34.420
fortify your gut, rev up metabolism, and even support stronger skin and hair.
01:27:47.540
Just go to tryarmra.com slash Megan or enter the code Megan at checkout.
01:27:57.280
There's a lot of talk about government debt, but after four years of inflation, another real
01:28:03.500
Some people are working harder than ever and still drowning in credit card debt and overdue
01:28:10.640
Done with debt has unique escape strategies to help end your debt fast, so you keep more
01:28:17.600
Done with debt does not try to sell you a loan or bankruptcy.
01:28:20.780
Their tough negotiators go one-on-one with your credit card and loan companies with one
01:28:24.800
goal in mind, to drastically reduce your bills, eliminate interest, and erase penalties.
01:28:30.500
Most clients wind up with more money in their pockets month one, and they don't stop until
01:28:43.300
Some of their solutions are time-sensitive, so you will need to move quickly.
01:28:54.480
Make sure your team is taken care of through every twist and turn with Canada Life savings,
01:29:01.240
Whether you want to grow your team, support your employees at every stage, or build a
01:29:05.480
workplace people want to be a part of, Canada Life has flexible plans for companies of all
01:29:10.680
sizes, so it's easy to find a solution that works for you.
01:29:14.080
Visit canadalife.com slash employee benefits to learn more.
01:29:22.820
I'm Megan Kelly, host of The Megan Kelly Show on SiriusXM.
01:29:27.040
It's your home for open, honest, and provocative conversations with the most interesting and
01:29:31.920
important political, legal, and cultural figures today.
01:29:35.020
You can catch The Megan Kelly Show on Triumph, a SiriusXM channel featuring lots of hosts you
01:29:40.200
may know and probably love, great people like Dr. Laura, Glenn Beck, Nancy Grace, Dave Ramsey,
01:29:49.480
You can stream The Megan Kelly Show on SiriusXM at home or anywhere you are, no car required.
01:29:59.320
It has ad-free music coverage of every major sport, comedy, talk, podcast, and more.
01:30:07.100
Go to SiriusXM.com slash MKShow to subscribe and get three months free.
01:30:13.960
That's SiriusXM.com slash MKShow and get three months free.
01:30:26.500
Last week, we told you about a confidential defamation settlement between NBCUniversal and
01:30:33.260
This after MSNBC ran multiple reports in September 2020 with allegations that this doctor performed
01:30:40.500
mass hysterectomies at an ICE detention facility.
01:30:47.000
It started with an advocacy group called Project South, and they released an open letter to the
01:30:53.140
Department of Homeland Security criticizing conditions at the Irwin County Detention Center
01:30:58.600
in Georgia, which at the time was run by ICE and had detained immigrants staying there.
01:31:04.840
The letter was primarily about the lack of COVID precautions there, but it also included
01:31:09.500
shocking allegations from a nurse named Dan Wooten claiming, Don, I should say, not Dan,
01:31:15.880
that's our friend, Don Wooten, claiming that a doctor was performing hysterectomies on nearly
01:31:21.500
every patient that he saw, calling him, quote, a uterus collector.
01:31:27.580
Well, MSNBC took up the story the very next day with Nicole Wallace, Chris Hayes, and Rachel
01:31:38.740
The nurse who contributed to this whistleblower complaint explains it like this, quote,
01:31:42.160
quote, everybody this doctor sees has a hysterectomy, just about everybody.
01:31:46.080
He's even taken out the wrong ovary on one detained immigrant woman.
01:31:49.600
She was supposed to get her left ovary removed because it had a cyst on the left ovary.
01:31:56.780
She had to go back to take out the left, and she wound up with a total hysterectomy.
01:32:00.240
She still wanted children, so she has to go back home now and tell her husband that
01:32:04.880
She said she was not all the way out under anesthesia and heard the doctor tell the nurse
01:32:10.940
The nurse says she and her fellow nurses, quote, questioned among ourselves, like, goodness,
01:32:25.300
Everybody he sees, he's taking all their uteruses out, or he's taking their tubes out.
01:32:34.600
Dr. Mahendra Amin only performed two medically necessary hysterectomies on detainees at that
01:32:40.760
ICE facility, and he was not happy with this report.
01:32:44.500
The guy spent his whole life helping underprivileged communities, volunteering his time, helping people
01:32:50.900
who cannot pay, and he got viciously smeared originally by this nurse who worked at the
01:33:01.840
And The Good Doctor filed a $30 million defamation lawsuit against NBCUniversal in September,
01:33:12.460
They settled after discovery in this case showed that even internally at the news organization,
01:33:18.240
they had significant doubts about whether this was true, even as they presented the allegations
01:33:25.320
to their audience without reflecting those serious doubts.
01:33:35.360
Here now to explain more is Stacey Evans, Dr. Amin's attorney.
01:33:41.680
Thank you so much for having me and sharing the story.
01:33:44.280
Yes, you're, I'm told, a Democratic lawmaker in the state of Georgia, and that many people
01:33:49.600
would not expect you to be suing MSNBC, which is beloved by a lot of Democrats.
01:33:54.740
So did you have any hesitancy in taking this case?
01:33:59.760
I definitely thought in my mind this could hurt me politically.
01:34:05.780
You proclaimed to be this progressive champion.
01:34:11.320
And I said, well, it's very easy because he didn't do these terrible things that the media
01:34:15.760
is claiming that he did, that MSNBC is claiming that he did, that this alleged whistleblower
01:34:22.300
And for me, whether it's a Democratic-leaning media or Republican-leading media, you've got
01:34:30.000
I mean, the media is a very important part of our systems, of government, really.
01:34:37.940
And so it's my job, I feel like, as a defamation lawyer to hold anyone accountable who's not
01:34:42.280
telling the truth, whether that's the network I watch or another network.
01:34:53.100
Just so the audience can understand how this got started, I mentioned this nurse who works
01:34:58.400
Here she is talking to NBC's Jacob Soberoff and making these allegations against Dr.
01:35:06.680
You're quoted in the complaint as saying, that's his specialty, he's the uterus collector.
01:35:17.480
That's how the detainees refer to this physician.
01:35:22.360
They referred to him as, I had a detainee to ask me, she said, well, what is he doing,
01:35:30.900
And I just looked at her puzzle, because I didn't have an answer.
01:35:34.740
Later, the Department of Homeland Security inspector general would conduct an investigation.
01:35:50.220
And they released a report finding, based on its medical records review, the National
01:35:55.140
Commission on Correctional Healthcare Resources team determined women's healthcare provided
01:36:03.080
So they're basically saying that, well, he's not mentioned by name, nothing untoward happened
01:36:08.780
there, nothing that wasn't medically necessary.
01:36:19.560
They said that Dr. Amin performed mass hysterectomies, high number of hysterectomies, and that they were
01:36:28.380
And the court even found in her summary judgment order, Judge Wood of the Southern District
01:36:32.340
of Georgia, found in a 108-page order, very clearly, there is no evidence of mass hysterectomies,
01:36:38.580
no evidence of high numbers of hysterectomies, and no evidence that Dr. Amin is a uterus collector,
01:36:44.100
and also relayed information to make clear that Don Wooten was not telling the truth, and MSNBC was
01:36:52.980
When she said all these detainees called Dr. Amin the uterus collector, I took deposition
01:36:58.020
after deposition after deposition of women who had been formally detained at Irwin County
01:37:03.160
Detention Center and others who had been there, and no one heard him be called the uterus collector
01:37:09.380
until after MSNBC's news reports, which the detainees obviously had access to watching television
01:37:17.000
But no one admitted to ever using that phrase, and no one even heard it until after the report.
01:37:22.260
So MSNBC took these allegations, which were salacious, and it was right in the middle
01:37:30.240
We were six weeks before the 2020 election, and they ran with it, and they tried to tie
01:37:36.240
Dr. Amin, an immigrant himself, to what they portrayed as terrible, atrocious things that
01:37:43.180
were happening to immigrants during the Trump administration.
01:37:48.020
I mean, the child separation policies, there were these administrators who were tracking
01:37:54.860
Rachel Maddow said that Dr. Amin, my client, a man who's been practicing medicine for over
01:38:00.340
35 years, devoted himself to these underserved areas, took on these cases of this of the detainees
01:38:09.800
For most of his career, he's been the only or one of only a few OBGYNs in a very wide
01:38:17.920
So they said this man, my client, Dr. Amin, one of the most gentle people you'll ever meet,
01:38:23.100
was the next chapter in this saga of immigration abuse that's happening in our country.
01:38:28.720
Again, an immigrant himself tied him to that without not only not looking as deep as they
01:38:35.960
needed to, but the surface level that they did look into told them that these allegations
01:38:41.420
from this alleged whistleblower were not corroborated.
01:38:48.240
And I appreciate you mentioning the election because it's very interesting.
01:38:50.460
I mean, we've seen this so many times where mistakes, mistakes, or intentional misstatements
01:38:57.660
get made in service of a political narrative that somebody finds important.
01:39:02.640
And I think, obviously, MSNBC was guilty of that here.
01:39:10.360
It would hurt him on one of his key issues, you know, immigration.
01:39:15.700
He's basically got a Joseph Mengele in there taking out uteruses for fun.
01:39:24.320
But that's one of the things I wanted to get into because it wasn't just MSNBC.
01:39:28.640
The Guardian, some other publications, mostly left-wing, ran with these same allegations
01:39:35.640
And there is a reason that you zeroed in on NBC and MSNBC.
01:39:43.020
Well, there were some earlier sort of lesser known print, maybe online publications that
01:40:05.060
And then they were the only broadcast media to run with the story.
01:40:11.760
And they did it again in the face of, on the same day that they were up reporting, I was
01:40:17.000
telling them, we've only got records of two hysterectomies being done at this facility
01:40:23.880
At the time, they didn't know if there were other doctors that may be treating women at
01:40:29.080
That's what MSNBC did, which was very reckless.
01:40:31.540
They had the biggest microphone, the biggest camera, and they blasted his name and blasted
01:40:40.100
And that from their own investigation, they had feedback telling them it wasn't there.
01:40:46.020
Their own internal people saying, we don't have it.
01:40:48.960
And I know we may talk about that more if you want me to go into some of the things that
01:40:55.900
I'm running out of time on my SiriusXM live show, and we're going to continue this over
01:41:00.400
So I'll start something a little, I'll keep us on something less deep, because that's
01:41:05.680
But yeah, so he had multiple news organizations, but MSNBC and NBC was the worst, and the ones
01:41:11.740
with the biggest microphone reporting this about them.
01:41:15.040
Can I ask you before, in the time we have, do we know why this nurse made these allegations?
01:41:19.980
Because I saw some reference to she had an ax to grind.
01:41:22.080
Well, she had, she definitely had some issues employment wise with the facility.
01:41:30.840
But she was very upset about her status as an employee and being, her hours being cut
01:41:36.420
And she was mainly concerned about COVID protections at the facility.
01:41:42.580
She was complaining that the safety protocols weren't being followed.
01:41:46.580
And she had some, her own health issues that she was worried about and being forced to work
01:41:54.340
You know, this 26 page letter, I believe it was total, only one little paragraph about
01:42:00.480
But her advocates through this advocacy organization have been trying to get attention on COVID for
01:42:12.020
And why she chose to say that he did this, I'll never know.
01:42:16.120
So let's talk now about what you discovered about MSNBC and NBC in particular, because this
01:42:22.620
was really, you know, I don't know whether you would have won the defamation claim against
01:42:27.280
them, even though we now know what they reported was untrue.
01:42:29.840
But they did try to cross some T's and dot some I.
01:42:33.520
So when I was reading up on the case, I was like, how did they win this?
01:42:37.000
And then I got to the page that explains how you won it.
01:42:40.460
But just to set it up, they did try to do some things.
01:42:44.660
They reached out, right, to the doctor for comment.
01:42:49.060
And they included, I think, his denial in the ultimate report that it wasn't true.
01:42:55.760
Um, but that, as it turns out, wasn't sufficient because why?
01:43:01.220
Well, they did include his, um, his denial, which was general.
01:43:06.620
Um, and one of the things to keep in mind here, and that was very frustrating for Dr.
01:43:14.040
He can't go digging through his medical records and throw them up on the screen and say, see
01:43:25.020
Um, he cannot talk about specific things that happen with them.
01:43:27.700
And so that general denial was, was all he could do.
01:43:31.820
Um, but what, what was true and what we just got worse as we were peeling back the layers
01:43:37.680
during discovery is this whole thing started with, um, Julia Ainsley and Jacob Stoverhoff
01:43:42.720
were writing, working together on an, on an article that was going to be for, um, NBC News
01:43:48.260
online and they were calling, um, immigration lawyers in Georgia, obviously speaking to
01:43:54.620
Don Wooten and what they found in the course of doing that is that the immigration lawyers
01:43:59.720
were telling them, you know, when this story broke, we started calling our colleagues.
01:44:04.500
One of the immigration lawyers that they talked to was, um, a leader in this 15,000 plus
01:44:09.840
member, um, association of immigration lawyers all across the country.
01:44:13.920
And she had access to all the ones there on the Southeast and Georgia in particular.
01:44:17.600
They were not seeing high numbers of hysterectomies.
01:44:20.760
And they told the reporters at MSNBC, that's unclear whether it was Jacob that they told
01:44:26.020
or Julia, but they told one of them, we are not seeing it.
01:44:29.980
We are asking people to report to us and we are not seeing it, um, going to air.
01:44:34.220
They really only had hard evidence of one hysterectomy.
01:44:40.040
Um, and, and they had that from an immigration lawyer who told them, and she had cancer.
01:44:46.960
Now they said they had more than that, but, but they never did.
01:44:50.920
That's what ice was saying is that there were two, two reported out from ice, um, and that
01:44:55.660
they were, uh, approved through their internal procedures to be, to be necessary.
01:45:00.000
And then you had standards who was looking at that article standards and practices.
01:45:04.940
We've talked about them with my audience there.
01:45:06.980
It's at NBC, it's pretty rigorous where you go through this team of lawyers and sort of
01:45:10.660
professional journalists who make sure or try that you don't defame people in your reporting.
01:45:16.860
And especially when you have a report like this, that's incendiary.
01:45:19.400
I mean, you're setting this guy on fire with these allegations.
01:45:26.220
And I, and I, I personally felt sorry for Christopher Scholl was the deputy head of standards at the
01:45:30.900
time and he was clearly pushing back and he was saying, we have this one source.
01:45:37.320
She has no direct knowledge because she, she told even Jacob Soboroff, I didn't go with
01:45:44.460
I mean, never set foot onto the campus of Irwin County detention center.
01:45:48.440
The women were brought to his private medical office.
01:45:51.820
Don Wooten said the alleged whistleblower, I didn't go there.
01:45:58.260
And the deputy head of standards is pointing this out guys.
01:46:00.680
Hey, we have one source with no direct knowledge.
01:46:06.100
We've got these folks saying, maybe we found one.
01:46:09.680
You've got, I say, and there's two, we don't have it.
01:46:13.380
And there's evidence that we developed that, that standards never actually approved that
01:46:20.760
online news report, which ended up being the basis for all the on air.
01:46:27.440
But there's, there's some emails later where the deputy head of standards is saying, these
01:46:32.980
articles shouldn't go out without standards, seeing a final version, and they should not
01:46:37.220
be considered approved based on answers to questions, which is all there was back and
01:46:41.760
All these emails, questions, answers, questions, answers, but then more questions.
01:46:45.200
And then all of a sudden the news article is up and Julia Ainsley's on deadline White House.
01:46:50.640
And then from there, you know, it goes to Chris Hayes.
01:46:55.400
Was the original article on NBC.com or MSNBC.com?
01:47:04.600
And those warnings from standards and practices were issued prior to them posting that article
01:47:12.440
Prior to posting the article online and prior to any on air, including the deadline White
01:47:19.040
And then you also had, you had Chris Hayes behind the scenes internally with standards
01:47:24.780
saying, you know, this whole thing went viral because it sort of brings up all these
01:47:29.440
Third Reich, Jim Crow, Mississippi hospitalization experiments.
01:47:40.460
It brings up all these bad historical implications, but that's not true here.
01:47:45.460
That same night he goes on his show and he says, this story went viral because of the
01:47:51.900
historical ramifications of any kind of coerced sterilization of an immigrant population.
01:47:57.040
So the exact same thing that he said, this is not internally, he told the viewers, that's
01:48:03.820
why this is such a big story, because this is what it makes us think of.
01:48:07.220
It was very, very reckless and very disappointing to me to see that, see it happen this way.
01:48:14.580
Here he is having that same nurse on his show again, after all these warnings from standards
01:48:26.420
I had several detained women on numerous occasions that would come to me and say, Ms.
01:48:36.500
I had no answers as to why they had those procedures.
01:48:40.620
And one lady walked up to me here this last time around between October of 19 until July
01:49:00.520
And she says, everybody that I talked to has had a hysterectomy.
01:49:08.400
I mean, I don't have an answer for why that they would come to me and they would say, is
01:49:20.020
Now, in that interview, did Chris Hayes express strong skepticism?
01:49:30.120
Like, was there anything to mitigate the damage in those allegations?
01:49:36.340
It would have been one thing to say, OK, here's what Don Wooten is saying.
01:49:40.240
But we haven't been able to verify from anyone who was actually in the room.
01:49:47.520
We're being skeptical here, which internally they were saying, standards was saying to Chris
01:49:58.180
There were, I don't remember if it was Chris Hayes or other on-air talent or his producers
01:50:04.380
And our hero is here to share the truth with us, just really putting her up on a pedestal
01:50:09.260
and then calling Dr. Amin a so-called medical professor, a professional, so-called medical
01:50:14.780
That's how things were going behind the scenes.
01:50:16.800
So they're definitely saying one thing behind the scenes, and then they're saying another
01:50:23.540
So you've got Nicole Wallace at Deadline White House.
01:50:29.660
And then after that, you've got Rachel Maddow, which really took it to the next level.
01:50:33.580
And we alluded to it earlier when she made this really an election issue and said, this
01:50:38.840
is the Trump administration's mistreatment of immigrants.
01:50:44.500
And going through the child separation policy and going through tracking of immigrant women's
01:50:50.300
menstrual cycles when they're in detention, and now Dr. Amin, the next chapter.
01:50:54.140
And that was such a terrible, outlandish thing to say.
01:50:59.040
But even more so because earlier that day, when she was internal records during discovery
01:51:04.600
revealed, she had been having her production meeting with her team.
01:51:08.400
And she starts out saying, if it's true, we should go with it.
01:51:15.300
I think there's a lot of jumping to conclusions.
01:51:16.980
And then according to the document, eight minutes later, she is saying, this is going
01:51:24.520
And this is going to be the chapter of this immigration situation with no evidence that
01:51:37.040
And so many people look up to her as a smart and hardworking and thorough journalist.
01:51:41.380
And for her to be so flippant about Dr. Amin and what he did here just was really too much.
01:51:49.060
Did she explain in the deposition why the change of heart in eight minutes?
01:51:56.880
And in fact, for her and some of the other folks that we deposed on air talent, but also
01:52:03.300
producers, what struck me was how flippant folks were about, that was a long time ago.
01:52:17.460
And yeah, maybe it was a flashpoint in time for you.
01:52:28.300
Maybe you can move on from it in a second and put it out of your mind and not worry
01:52:34.560
He had to live with the death threats, the bomb threats, the constant calls to his office,
01:52:40.100
the following of him, the name calling, some of the most vile things to be called.
01:52:45.780
His own staff, he had several Hispanic women working for him.
01:52:55.780
And they took also flack in their own communities and with their family and friends because they
01:53:05.980
They knew that how these women were treated, which was well when they were in Dr. Amin's
01:53:16.560
Can you tell the story, Stacey, of what happened with his son, who was off to the Cleveland
01:53:24.120
Dr. Amin's son, his middle name is Mahindra, the same as Dr. Amin's first name,
01:53:32.820
And, um, when all of the, the news hit and Dr. Amin was very scared about what was going
01:53:38.620
to happen to him and others, he immediately thought of his son and he called his son.
01:53:41.640
He said, you might get calls because your name is so close to mine.
01:53:44.780
Um, and if you get calls, just tell them you don't know me, just tell them that you don't
01:53:49.560
know me, that it's just a coincidence that you have the same name because he was so concerned
01:53:53.900
that his son who had just gotten his dream job was going to be affected negatively, um,
01:53:58.860
about this so much so that he was just like, pretend like you don't know me.
01:54:03.580
I mean, Dr. Amin is a father of four, um, caring husband, doctor, father, and, and to
01:54:15.340
Especially in light of what you just said, which is they had doubts.
01:54:21.760
They did that because they thought it was a story that was going to work for team blue
01:54:25.740
and for their own ratings, notwithstanding their knowledge that there were serious holes
01:54:36.060
That's really kind of how it sounds like I've ruined a lot of people since Dr.
01:54:42.060
Um, look, I have empathy for news organizations because we're all in a position of trying to report
01:54:52.340
And that really makes a villain out of the actors you've mentioned is that they knew or
01:55:03.500
If they had her word, they couldn't get in touch with Dr.
01:55:07.680
They didn't get a denial and they, they reported it straight as look, she's filed this whistleblower
01:55:14.900
We're going to continue to try to reach out to him and get comment, whatever.
01:55:18.060
But they didn't, they actually did go beyond that.
01:55:20.400
And when they got there, they learned that the story had a tons of holes in it.
01:55:25.920
And then even then you could potentially avoid liability.
01:55:29.040
If you went on the air and said, here are the allegations and here are all the holes in
01:55:33.540
Like that too could potentially spare you, but just going with these are the allegations.
01:55:40.680
And without reporting any of the serious problems you've discovered behind the scenes, that's
01:55:45.100
what got you to defamation because for some reason they decided to treat him as a public
01:55:49.760
figure, even though it wasn't, but whatever, it's not important.
01:55:52.000
Um, so you had a higher burden and bringing a defamation claim, um, against MSNBC and NBC.
01:55:58.780
And you had to prove actual malice on their part that they knew what they were saying was
01:56:04.380
false or behaved in reckless disregard of its truth or falsity.
01:56:08.600
And I think that latter point is that's where all these messages came in.
01:56:12.820
You, you submitted in the case, um, text messages between Julia Ainsley, who you mentioned in
01:56:17.700
Jacob's Jacob Soboroff, she texts to him saying, but only two hysterectomies, or do you think
01:56:27.500
She's trying to say, maybe they referred others and we don't have a record of them.
01:56:30.380
And Soboroff answers, I think it's possible or likely lots of lawyers saying it.
01:56:35.700
Um, then you've got this one source, an immigration lawyer named Sarah Owings, who told Soboroff
01:56:41.700
that she and her colleagues were not finding evidence of a large number of hysterectomies.
01:56:47.120
The Rachel Maddow meeting that you just outlined that guy, you mentioned from standards and
01:56:51.200
practices, Chris Scholl, you say standards weighed in on this prior to the airing of the
01:56:55.380
reports, but this is from a follow-up segment that Chris Hayes was going to do two days after
01:57:00.320
the original report where standards, this guy, Chris Scholl is jumping up and down saying that
01:57:07.620
The quotes are, uh, Scholl saying, we don't know if the doctor did anything wrong here.
01:57:16.100
Scholl doubted the credibility of that nurse Wooten in the same call quote, and the whistleblower
01:57:26.820
Scholl admitted in the deposition, the network did not know the truth.
01:57:29.560
And as to televising the accusations, he said, we would have to approach this with a great
01:57:34.040
deal of transparency with viewers and say, look, we don't know the truth.
01:57:37.980
That's my understanding too, Stacey, that like, when you've got somebody making, you know,
01:57:43.040
whistleblower allegations like that, and you've got a strong denial on the other side, you
01:57:47.320
investigate it and you find a bunch of reasons to doubt the allegations.
01:57:49.920
It's a judgment call as to whether you tank the story entirely, but in some instances,
01:57:58.760
Like if it's big enough and it's like serious enough, you might put it on the air anyway,
01:58:02.320
but you would have to outline all the doubts that had been found in your reporting about
01:58:07.780
it so that the viewers knew to keep a very healthy dose of skepticism on the allegations.
01:58:16.620
I mean, that's really what the guy from standards was saying is that if we're going to do this,
01:58:20.140
we've got to, we've got to caveat it with this and this and this, and then it's worth
01:58:26.100
And he acknowledges during one of those internal calls too with Chris Hayes and his producers,
01:58:31.000
hey, we can get to the bottom of this and we can find out.
01:58:33.580
But by the time we find out, we're not going to want to do the story anymore.
01:58:37.460
I mean, really just sort of acknowledging how they were rushing here.
01:58:43.800
I mean, the media, the media has an important job and I know it's got to be hard.
01:58:48.480
And, and I've had cases that have come to me and I've started looking at them and I'm
01:58:54.440
But when you find out facts that tell you it's not, when you're in the media and you
01:58:59.400
have, you think you have this great story, but then you find out facts that tell you,
01:59:03.500
that show to you that it's not, you have to stop.
01:59:10.980
I think Julia Ainsley and Jacob Soboroff, they had done this book on, or Soboroff had
01:59:18.220
They had won some awards for reporting in that.
01:59:22.280
They wanted it so much that even though their own sources, their own immigration lawyers
01:59:30.920
Even though ICE was saying two hysterectomies, even though this was not a firsthand account,
01:59:35.580
they just couldn't stop themselves from doing it.
01:59:38.940
And then those text messages that you showed, some of those go into the night after the
01:59:44.900
And you have them even saying, gosh, I've got to know if it's true.
01:59:50.320
Do we think that the attorneys that did talk to us and told us that they found one, do we
01:59:56.980
I've heard mixed things about Don Woot and the alleged whistleblower.
02:00:03.120
It's a hard job, but when you learn better, when you know better, you do better.
02:00:10.980
If it's okay, I wanted to real quickly, you mentioned how we had to meet that actual malice
02:00:21.020
So I have to pat ourselves on the back for that for our team.
02:00:24.820
Right, because you would have expected that this judge could have thrown your case out
02:00:28.460
And that's really what I think led to the settlement, right?
02:00:30.180
The judge did not throw out the case at summary judgment.
02:00:32.500
In fact, you got summary judgment on the critical facts of your case, which is, it is not true
02:00:40.520
We got, we got, it's so rare for a plaintiff to get summary judgment.
02:00:43.560
We got summary judgment on several of the statements being false as a matter of law.
02:00:47.220
And she said, no evidence of mass hysterectomies, no evidence of high numbers of hysterectomies.
02:00:57.520
If the case had continued, we'd be in trial right now or next week.
02:01:00.180
Um, but we had to prove actual malice here, even though Dr.
02:01:03.840
Amin is not a public figure because Georgia has a very, um, strict anti-SLAPP statute,
02:01:09.400
um, strategic lawsuit against public participation is what SLAPP stands for, for the viewers
02:01:14.680
Um, and so when you have statements on air or in publications about issues of public concern,
02:01:20.380
which this was deemed to be that you have to reach that actual malice standard, um,
02:01:29.040
There's been some, we could get nerdy on the law.
02:01:30.860
There's been a little bit of changes since, since that happened.
02:01:33.020
And I have some disagreement about how that was applied here, but that's why it wasn't
02:01:36.880
because he was a public figure, but because in, in this case, the court had deemed this
02:01:43.220
And so we had to meet that higher standard, which is very, very hard.
02:01:49.140
Well, NBC saw it coming because once they lost at summary judgment and you were barreling
02:01:54.740
toward trial, I think they understood exactly how this is going to go over in front of a
02:02:00.800
And I've, I've heard you say you're very happy with the settlement.
02:02:06.300
Well, the settlement terms themselves are confidential, so I really can't.
02:02:09.500
Um, but I can say that Dr. Amin is very happy to be able to move on from this.
02:02:13.840
I mean, this is, we filed this case in the fall of 2021.
02:02:17.000
So this has been going on for a very long time for him.
02:02:20.060
Um, and so he's very glad to be able to move on from it and, and very glad that, that you
02:02:24.700
and some others have been interested in sharing his story because it's, um, it's been so hurtful
02:02:32.120
And so to be able to, to have the truth come out, to be able to get that, um, that accountability,
02:02:38.980
um, for the truth, uh, just means so much to him.
02:02:42.200
And I appreciate you letting us tell that story.
02:02:56.100
Um, I don't, other than when I told him he needed to wear, um, a business casual outfit,
02:03:01.840
at least for his deposition, I've never seen the man not in scrubs.
02:03:07.200
He's coming in scrubs because he's, he'll, he'll take a break and he'll go, he'll get
02:03:13.140
He just wants to know, when can I get back to seeing patients?
02:03:18.720
The community, um, fortunately still loves him down there.
02:03:23.020
Um, he, he had some trouble for a while, but everybody, um, luckily it seems like everyone's
02:03:28.000
come back around and he'll, he'll never know all the naysayers that are out there.
02:03:35.440
And yeah, all he wants to do is practice medicine.
02:03:38.300
There's, there never was a lawsuit against the nurse, right?
02:03:43.040
There actually is a pending lawsuit against her.
02:03:45.380
We have a, um, state court case against, um, Sinclair Broadcasting and Don Wooten, um, jointly
02:03:52.240
that's pending right now in Tift County, uh, Superior Court.
02:03:59.020
Cause I saw, she spoke out to the guardian or at least the guardian offered a, an article
02:04:04.500
about her in 2022 and, uh, she, she's blaming a very low dejected mental state on, on her
02:04:12.420
time as a whistleblower saying, uh, post whistleblowing, I am on antidepressants.
02:04:19.640
At one time I was suicidal, couldn't pay the bills, still can't pay the bills.
02:04:28.160
I'm back trying to figure out how I'm going to make ends meet, et cetera.
02:04:40.380
It's in a, we we've got a procedural issue that we've got to work through before we get
02:04:46.080
And so a lot is still sort of paused, but I do think it's worthy, uh, of note that the
02:04:51.440
government accountability project, which were her lawyers throughout the, the media frenzy,
02:04:56.580
um, and, and it was a representative of the government accountability project that was
02:05:00.400
on air with her at Chris Hayes, the government accountability project.
02:05:03.380
If you go to their website and you scroll down to the bottom of their homepage, you will
02:05:09.300
Um, basically retracting anything bad they've ever said about Dr.
02:05:12.760
Amin and his medical practices, accusing him of mass hysterectomies, everything like that.
02:05:16.780
I don't see anything like that from Don Wooten.
02:05:18.960
We'll see if we ever get there, but at least, um, the lawyers that were with her at this
02:05:22.980
crucial time back in the fall of 2020, they have retracted it all.
02:05:28.020
You don't get that every day in practicing defamation law.
02:05:31.420
Thank you so much for coming on and telling his story and all the best to both you and
02:05:42.480
Speaking of good doctors, uh, we're going down to interview one exclusively Dr.
02:05:47.320
Marty McCary, the new head of the FDA praise Jesus will be on this show tomorrow.
02:05:54.500
You guys have seen him on this show as Johns Hopkins doctor who pushed back against some
02:06:01.080
He came on to talk about his book, which is very Maha friendly.
02:06:04.640
And now I'm dying to talk to him about what he has found in the first couple of weeks,
02:06:14.420
He's an honest broker and there aren't a lot of them in, you know, these medical policy setting