Debut episode of The Megyn Kelly Show: Live from the University of Alabama, host Meghan Kelly is joined by Elizabeth Vargas, Stu Bergeer, and Eliana Johnson to discuss the fourth and final Republican presidential debate.
00:00:00.540Welcome to The Megyn Kelly Show, live on Sirius XM Channel 111 every weekday at New East.
00:00:11.800Hey everyone, I'm Megyn Kelly. Welcome to The Megyn Kelly Show, live from the University of Alabama.
00:00:17.140We are here in the spin room. We're right next door on the debate stage in just a few hours.
00:00:22.780Four GOP candidates for president will go head-to-head in the final GOP debate of 2023 and maybe of the entire presidential cycle.
00:00:33.100We're showing you the spin room here. Right now it's empty because the media hasn't arrived in droves, but they'll be here shortly.
00:00:39.040And when I come to you later on tonight, post the debate, because we'll be doing a live show right here, it's going to be jam-packed.
00:00:46.640We're going to have to have the headphones on. It gets crazy and it's fun and it's a very unique event.
00:00:51.080I hope you will share it with us. I'm, of course, going to be one of the co-moderators, as I've told you, along with NewsNation's Elizabeth Vargas
00:00:57.440and one of our favorite EJs, Free Beacon editor Eliana Johnson. That's fun, right?
00:01:03.140It's live at 8 p.m. Eastern, 7 p.m. Central. I have to remember this for my getting ready purposes.
00:01:09.0407 p.m. Central, 7 p.m. But 8 p.m. Eastern on NewsNation.
00:01:13.380Now, NewsNation is a startup cable channel that's trying to be sort of down the middle on its programming,
00:01:20.200not go too far right, not go too far left. But it's a startup, so you may not even know where it is on your cable channel.
00:01:26.000If you would like to figure that out so you can watch the debate, go to joinnn.com,
00:01:32.740and that'll tell you where your channel is on your cable. Okay? Joinnn.com.
00:01:37.160You can also listen to the debate live on Sirius XM Triumph Channel 111, where we broadcast from every day live.
00:01:44.000And it will be streaming on Rumble as well. So we've got you covered. Make sure you tune in. Check it out.
00:01:50.580Believe me, it's going to be good. So excited for all of you to join us.
00:01:54.780And I also want to tell you, again, a little bit more about our post-debate spin room special.
00:01:59.260We're going to come right over here, right after the debate.
00:02:01.340And this will be my very first reaction to what we just witnessed.
00:02:04.020I'll tell you everything I thought, how I thought the candidates did, what went into those questions we were doing.
00:02:10.040And we'll actually be interviewing some of the candidates right here live.
00:02:13.820So that actually could be a little awkward.
00:02:16.380Because we've got some tough questions for them, and we'll see.
00:02:19.580We'll see who's willing to show up and talk about what just happened on the stage,
00:02:23.740who's man or woman enough to do it, and who isn't.
00:03:22.260The news organization is actually making news.
00:03:24.080So it takes an extraordinary amount of poise, preparation, professionalism, and diligence.
00:03:29.420And America should know, no one is better at this than you.
00:03:32.440The amount of time and effort that you put into it, and the way that you do it, and your incisive, legal mind, it's just a pleasure to work with you again.
00:04:11.020And we've got the gang back together, not Chris and Brett, of course, because there are different networks, but Steyrwalt and Salmon and yours truly, along with Eliana and Elizabeth and some other teammates sitting in there.
00:04:22.620And that's the magic that makes the questions go from good to great.
00:06:06.960Make them ideally debate and get them off of their talking point.
00:06:11.080So there's so much that has to go into this question.
00:06:13.980They all start off two paragraphs long.
00:06:16.040And then over time, you just edit, edit, edit.
00:06:18.740And ideally, you get it down to, like, three lines so that they can be the star when you're done.
00:06:23.120But you can't just say, like, hey, write a question on this the morning of.
00:06:27.180It goes through so much vetting and tightening and research.
00:06:29.440And then right when you're on the one-yard line, a researcher says, oh, actually, I found something really interesting that this candidate said about this topic six months ago or a year.
00:06:37.480And you're like, oh, OK, now we have to come back in, see what we can save, see what we have to throw away.
00:06:42.740And it takes real emotional maturity because, as your husband would know, the editor's saying is you have to kill your darlings.
00:07:03.060But our plan in an ideal world is to kill our darlings and to let the little darlings slide by the wayside as the candidates take over the show.
00:07:11.060You know, that's what we consider a win.
00:09:05.060I do not know which one we will get to see on the debate stage or what he's thinking about his future.
00:09:09.300At the center of the stage, you have two people who are in the finals to be the opponent of Donald Trump.
00:09:16.060And I think that we're here in Alabama.
00:09:18.060We're on the campus of the University of Alabama.
00:09:20.300The football analogies write themselves.
00:09:22.700This is who gets to go to the championship.
00:09:24.660These two are playing each other for the last spot to face Donald Trump because there can't be two.
00:09:30.800If there are two, if there's two at 12%, that's not a problem for Donald Trump.
00:09:35.740And he'll just blow past them if they can't sort themselves out.
00:09:39.420The way I think about it is there's about a third of the Republican Party that's pretty interested in having an alternative to Donald Trump.
00:11:38.180But also we see that the rictus smile, the seasick smile that Ron DeSantis, that he favors, where he just, he looks, it looks like somebody just stepped on his toes.
00:11:53.320And so he's been trying to be likable and affable, and he's trying to steer away in there.
00:11:57.800If I'm Haley, I want DeSantis on the attack, because Nikki Haley has thrived in her political career when dudes are attacking her in politics.
00:12:08.260She's the they go low, we go high, the dignity, the Thatcherite dignity in the face of what many women would think of as sexist kind of attacks.
00:12:54.440Does he question who she is as a person?
00:12:56.220Or does he disagree with her on policy?
00:12:58.640If he's going for her on personal attacks, this is going to be a real goat rodeo, not just in this debate for them, but over the next 50 days into Iowa.
00:13:08.220And they'll basically wreck each other.
00:13:10.160They could wreck each other going there.
00:13:11.740If he takes the higher road and talks about her policies as governor and talks about policy disagreements that they've had on the trail,
00:13:18.340then maybe Republicans who don't want Trump can keep hope alive that this will be resolved.
00:14:15.500So you make the forward progress on the basis of beating expectations.
00:14:19.260Now, all of the big money donors have come in.
00:14:21.960All of the Republican, what used to be the Republican establishment, is swinging in behind Nikki Haley, folks who used to back Ron DeSantis and thought DeSantis was the best bet.
00:14:30.040So now she's freighted with all these expectations, not just from her supporters financially, but also from the electorate.
00:14:47.480And the temptation for her will be to overswing, to go to do to try to have that old magic where she stuns them with the with the uppercut and does this stuff and is too spunky.
00:14:58.860So she's got the the rocks that she has to steer between are being too stiff.
00:15:43.340And depending on how Ramaswamy, how he comports himself and the energy that he brings, she might be she might want that other moment, that one more moment.
00:16:17.380Yeah. So I haven't heard any promises exactly about this debate.
00:16:21.100But if you were Vivek, what would your goal be for tonight?
00:16:24.260Like what who would you be attacking if anyone?
00:16:27.180Well, the the money figuratively and maybe literally is on attacking Haley.
00:16:32.980Right. Because for the MAGA nation, if DeSantis can play the role against Haley that Christie played against Rubio in 2016, then he gets a hero.
00:16:43.160He gets a brevet promotion to colonel on the MAGA battlefield.
00:16:47.340No, no, no. If if Ramaswamy, sorry, if Ramaswamy can really punish her, if he can get her off her message, if he can draw her into a fight and insult her and it she and she breaks down up there, not fully.
00:17:02.440But if she has a bad outing because Ramaswamy is harassing her, Ramaswamy gets huge status in Trump land.
00:18:14.320Now they have their little things that they want to do and they have the gimmicks that they're going to try and the stuff that they want to do.
00:18:18.740So in this building later today, there will be those final moments where their campaigns are like, now, remember, whatever you do, don't say this and make sure you do say that.
00:18:29.980So they're going to be coming in armed.
00:18:49.620That's the fight I'm kind of here for.
00:18:50.840Like, I realize those two are probably not going to win the nomination, but you never know.
00:18:55.400But that would be a great intellectual battle with just enough meanness, I think, to keep it like kind of you'd be on the edge of your seat.
00:19:03.160And it's the real ideological fight that divides the Republican party.
00:19:06.380You have a traditional conservative in Chris Christie and you have a sort of more MAGA nationalistic cat in Vivek Ramaswamy.
00:19:13.340And those are two different visions, two contrasting visions.
00:19:16.500And the other thing is, one of the reasons Christie was so hard on Rubio is that he thought that Rubio didn't deserve it, that he was too young, that he was too untested.
00:19:25.680Chris Christie says, I'm a former federal prosecutor, two-term governor of a blue state.
00:20:05.800Then there was this car explosion, this car incident at the border with Canada.
00:20:11.240And Vivek tweeted out very quickly, like, these idiots mocked me and I told you it happened.
00:20:18.240And I will say, when I saw that, I thought, hold on, cowboy, because, you know, we've been in the news business long enough to know, like, don't react too quickly, especially on something like that.
00:22:49.440And it's her super PAC, so she can't really refuse it.
00:22:51.880So it's a part of the shell game that we play with campaign finance laws in this country.
00:22:57.260But Trump is already saying, while globalists, special interest donors from both parties forge an unholy alliance to beat us, I'm calling on our grassroots donors like you to fight back in a fundraising email.
00:23:40.940And if you were rich, if I was rich, I wouldn't give any money to any, I want to make it clear, I wouldn't give any money to a politician ever.
00:23:48.420That's because we're in the I want to puke party.
00:23:51.580But if you're a rich dude or dudette and you have a lot of money, what's a quarter million dollars?
00:23:57.200And if you make life a little harder for Donald Trump and you throw it in there and maybe you can slow him down and maybe all Nikki Haley is is a speed bump on Trump's drive.
00:24:04.960But if you can make it a little harder for Trump, then they're going to make it a little harder for Trump.
00:24:09.140If I am Ramaswamy, I am going to parrot Trump's attack.
00:25:51.080Those little things, I don't know they matter to voters, but that is a good way to blow through money really fast by not cutting corners and sort of being fiscally.
00:25:58.720Indulge me in this, which is to say, being the other guy and having to scramble and scrape to work your way in makes you better at what you do.
00:26:09.180I remember that feeling at Fox a long time ago.
00:26:12.080I feel that feeling on News Nation where it's like, okay, we can do this.
00:26:24.680It makes people work harder and try harder, and Haley has benefited from that, whereas DeSantis was bloated and it was too much and too much legacy, and he didn't get tough and fight.
00:26:35.260So tonight, maybe he gets tough and fights.
00:26:37.720If one of these guys or gals manages to pull this out somehow, you know, has a great debate, gets momentum, something happens to change the race between now and Iowa, and maybe wins,
00:26:49.260maybe comes in as strong enough second to Trump that people are looking at them anew, it is possible that they run it, somehow they win it, and Joe Biden drops out.
00:27:02.240Because he made news yesterday by saying at a private fundraiser that he doesn't think he'd be running if Donald Trump were not likely to be the nominee.
00:27:15.260And then he attempted to clarify it last night, and it was not a clarification.
00:28:00.100And by the way, there's a weird thing that happened.
00:28:03.940In 2022, Democrats were getting ready for a shellacking.
00:28:07.020They were getting ready for just the typical midterm beatdown.
00:28:10.900But Donald Trump and a bunch of weirdo candidates on the Republican side changed the race, changed the nature of the race from being a referendum on the party in power into a choice election.
00:28:22.380Do we want the Biden Democrats, the inflation?
00:28:24.600And it messed things up for Republicans.
00:28:27.160That was good news for Joe Biden, but maybe long-term bad news for the Democratic Party.
00:28:31.880Because if the Democrats had taken the beating that they were expected to take in 2022, Biden and the pressure on Biden to say, OK, I'm going to step aside and let somebody else come in here.
00:28:43.760But then he said, well, you know, maybe it's working.
00:28:47.000I still got some magic kernels in my pocket.
00:28:48.660And Trump is enough of a threat to unite Democrats around him and to go back to all of, you know, the Atlantic articles and all of that other stuff.
00:28:56.880The the the raison d'etre, the whole point of Joe Biden's political life of his presidency is that he is not Donald Trump.
00:29:05.120And they hope that will be sufficient this time.
00:29:07.120That's not an exciting message for Democrats.
00:29:08.780But I tell you, they're going to be so terrified by by the time we get to August of next year, if it's Donald Trump on the Republican side, the Democrats will be so terrified of Donald Trump, who says things like I'll only be a dictator for one day.
00:29:23.400They'll be so first day, the first day, just with those just first day that he will so terrified Democrats that they probably will unite.
00:29:31.060OK, the other thing is on that Trump town hall that Hannity had last night, Trump was asked about Biden and whether he thinks he's going to make it.
01:00:45.800It's not surprising here to see their reaction, though, and that's what's odd.
01:00:51.400I mean, when you look at, if you haven't seen the video, you look at her, the people, all the presidents of these universities and the facial expressions they're making, and there's almost a tone of, you know, Congresswoman, you're talking to the wrong people.
01:01:10.700I can't, they're not going to say what she wants them to say.
01:01:14.720It's almost like they felt they were above her in answering this question in some weird way.
01:01:19.660And this is what's really disturbing about where we're going here, because, you know, universities are filled with kids who believe all of this stuff.
01:01:26.780They've been taught under the tutelage of people like the woman answering the questions there.
01:01:35.100When you look at the, a bunch of really negative polls just came out about Joe Biden, which is, you know, not exactly breaking news.
01:01:40.740And a lot of conservatives, and when I saw it too, I don't think Joe Biden's been a good president.
01:01:44.900So I'm glad to see his poll numbers go down.
01:01:46.900But when I looked at the details of them, it actually felt like bad news.
01:01:51.220And the reason why is because it wasn't because they were saying, hey, Joe Biden's too old or he's incompetent or his policies, generally speaking for the country, have been bad.
01:01:59.980He's not controlling the border, all the things that I would critique on Joe Biden.
01:02:03.700It was younger voters who were turning on Biden because he was too pro-Israel.
01:02:09.860And, you know, if you know anything about Joe Biden, he has magically found himself basically in the center of the Democratic Party for half a century.
01:02:18.660He will move wherever he needs to move to try to please voters within some very loose guardrails.
01:02:25.180And I worry that this this sort of attitude is going to become even more prominent among Democrats as they see polling go the wrong direction.
01:02:34.980And I think that's a bad, bad news, not just for Jews, but for everybody.
01:02:39.940So, Dave, this is not a popular position, but I have to defend free speech here.
01:02:47.260Sure. I don't think it is unconstitutional for these students to chant hateful slogans on campus.
01:02:58.340Now, too much targeted and so on can run you afoul of the civil rights laws for the reasons I just stated.
01:03:05.220If you're if you're targeting Jews in a way that makes them feel unsafe.
01:03:08.100But just just saying a slogan, just like a march, saying something like even globalize the Intifada.
01:03:14.320And I realize it's terrible. I understand what you're saying, but that's America.
01:03:19.120That's the same reason the KKK was allowed to march in our streets to say all the terrible things about black people.
01:03:24.140They were allowed to do that. The First Amendment does not exist to protect speech that you like.
01:03:29.660It exists to protect speech you do not like.
01:03:32.160So having said that, there are limits.
01:03:36.300You you cannot what they're doing on these campuses is scaring Jewish kids by surrounding them, by having die ins on campus.
01:03:44.380And when the Jews walk by, harassing them, laying hands on them by storming through study halls where they're minding their own business,
01:03:50.960studying for class and getting in their face with flags and hateful slogans.
01:03:55.220That's different. And my problem with these women who testified yesterday, Dave, and I'm interested in your take, is F them for being so cavalier about it.
01:04:04.900F them for showing absolutely no empathy for what the Jewish students are going through.
01:04:34.600Well, no. And look, I agree with you completely that that it's legal to do that and it's protected by the First Amendment.
01:04:40.280But institutions are allowed to protect themselves. Right.
01:04:43.600I mean, we know for certain and must and just just to reiterate, Dave, they must under the under Title seven.
01:04:50.240The universities have an obligation to protect minority students like Jews, Jews from having their activities interfered with because of their Judaism, because of who they are.
01:05:00.440Yeah. I mean, look, what what what jumped what jumped out to me with the with those women yesterday, the presidents of the Ivy League universities,
01:05:07.020is these are the leaders of what's what are supposed to be our most important institutions of learning.
01:05:12.840And they don't understand or don't seem capable of basic discourse.
01:05:17.960They just repeat these nonsense shibboleths over and over that don't mean anything.
01:05:24.380And we're all supposed to say, oh, well, you know, you're the president of Harvard, I guess, you know, it's context dependent or did speech become conduct?
01:05:35.020The answer is no, no, you're not allowed to target Jewish students and and attack them with words for being Jews and be a student at our university.
01:05:49.600And the reason that they're not capable of saying it is because they are completely caught up in this hierarchy of oppression.
01:05:56.160They view Jews as oppressors. And listen, I think at the end of the day, they're probably OK with a certain level of anti-Semitism.
01:06:04.780I mean, I don't like to say that. I just think it's true.
01:06:07.820I couldn't agree with you more. It's it's obvious that they've proven it day after day on these college campuses, which has just been absolutely horrifying.
01:06:15.420This is some of what the guy we just played, Eyal Yacalbi, who is amazing.
01:06:20.220What a spokesman. And I'm so glad that he gave his testimonial and is not going to back down.
01:06:24.780He's at UPenn. So here's just a little bit of the UPenn students marching just over the weekend.
01:06:31.720We showed yesterday what they did at Cornell. Here's another Ivy League in SOT 9.
01:06:35.420Something very creepy about it. It's creepy about the accent.
01:07:04.480It's creepy in this context. All of it creeps me out.
01:07:07.720And the problem is you've got these students doing this while not far away in Philly.
01:07:13.600You've got a Jewish person's falafel restaurant targeted because he's Jewish outside of Goldie's,
01:07:23.840an anti-Semitic mob in Philly attacked this man rhetorically because he's a Jew.
01:18:25.480But Representative Jayapal, we played her yesterday from Washington State.
01:18:32.480The sexual violence really needs to be contextualized, you know, because she wanted to both sides it.
01:18:37.480You have to contextualize them gang raping women, eight, nine different men to the point where the women are begging to just be put out of their misery.
01:19:00.480I'm just saying her sin's far worse than his.
01:19:03.480Here is, our team translated, like did the voices because it's, I think in Hebrew, a female eyewitness describing the rape scene in Israel.
01:19:15.480We've talked about it on the show before, but here's an eyewitness, which, hello, folks who are supporting Hamas in the law, we would call this evidence.
01:19:24.480Because we keep hearing there's no evidence of any of the sexual violence.
01:22:21.480But there were also a lot of people who like made jokes and and had, you know, bad dates.
01:22:27.480And these things were turned into international incidents where here we're supposed to ignore the actual international incident that is going on when you're talking about sexual violence being used this way.
01:22:40.480I feel like I don't understand the world sometimes.
01:22:43.480You know, when I was when I was a kid, you'd see the videos of people with different water fountains and you'd look back at like this period of racism and you'd say, how is that even possible?
01:22:54.480What an idiotic thing to judge people based on the color of their skin.
01:22:58.480And I think until fairly recently, I undersold the idea that that anti-Semitism was it was as active as it is in the United States.
01:23:07.480I don't think I understood it. I knew it was active around the world.
01:23:10.480I knew it was a real thing. I knew these old hatreds don't go away at some level.
01:23:14.480But I am shocked to see how people gathering in the thousands, tens of thousands in the West and justifying these things and saying the same types of stuff that you saw in Charlottesville, which everybody that I know on the right immediately denounced.
01:23:31.480We can't get those words out of anyone seemingly on the left these days.
01:23:36.480And the fact that these hatreds still exist and can this stuff can be justified is so objectively dumb.
01:23:44.480Like, I can't even it's hard to even pick apart intellectually because it's such a idiotic viewpoint.
01:23:51.480If you're basing these things on racial and anti-Semitic tropes that you've, I don't know, learned on the Internet or have been taught in major universities, you need to rethink your life because you're doing life wrong.
01:24:03.480Hmm. It's amazing. Hamas hit the goldmine because they launched their disgusting terrorist attack just at the time when this, as you said, Dave, oppressor, oppressee narrative had taken over the West.
01:24:20.480And I don't know that Hamas had calculated that in when predicting what kind of support it might get.
01:24:26.480I think they just want to kill Jews, you know, period. Like, it's all bonus if they get extra support.
01:24:31.480But, man, they timed it so right because you look at that Gallup poll.
01:24:34.480We talked about it yesterday that comes out and the Democratic Party has totally shifted on this issue.
01:24:38.480It's been happening for a while, but it has totally shifted on this issue.
01:26:14.480Solid majorities of Republicans, men, adults 55 and older, and whites, white adults at least, approve of Israel's military actions in Gaza.
01:26:24.480However, more than 6 out of 10 Democrats, so it's 6 out of 10 Democrats, 67% of people, not just Democrats, 67% of people under 35, 64% people of color, 52% of women disapprove of Israel's actions in Gaza.
01:26:45.480It's amazing how these groups have been brainwashed into thinking Israel is the devil.
01:28:17.480But I'll tell you, that wasn't the biggest news coming out of the climate change situation.
01:28:21.480We saw in The New York Post the other day this exclusive where there's a real question about John Kerry, our climate czar, fighting against the greenhouse gases, left a little of his own.
01:28:34.480Now, I ask you, you're the perfect guest for this.
01:28:53.480More coal fired power plants permitted anywhere in the world.
01:28:57.480I find myself getting more and more militant because I do not understand how adults who are in position of responsibility can be avoiding responsibility for taking away those things that are killing people on a daily basis.