Trump s running mate comes under fire for comments he made in 2011 about childless cat ladies. Now, Sen. J.D. Vance, R-Ohio, is here to respond to the controversy. He says the comments were meant to be taken out of context.
00:00:00.540Welcome to The Megyn Kelly Show, live on Sirius XM Channel 111 every weekday at noon east.
00:00:12.180Hey everyone, I'm Megyn Kelly. Welcome to The Megyn Kelly Show.
00:00:15.360As the Democratic Party ousts President Joe Biden and elevates Vice President Kamala Harris to the top of its ticket without a single vote having been cast for her in that role,
00:00:24.460in just a matter of hours, the media suddenly turning all of its focus seemingly to Senator J.D. Vance, Trump's running mate.
00:00:33.540Donald Trump's number two coming under intense criticism for comments he made three years ago about, quote, childless cat ladies,
00:00:43.980because this is what Americans who can't pay their mortgages care about.
00:00:47.980Senator Vance is here to respond to this controversy, but first we want to start by walking you through how it all began.
00:00:53.560Going back now to July 2021, Mr. Vance had just launched his campaign for senator in the great state of Ohio,
00:01:02.560and he gave a speech to a conservative organization called the Intercollegiate Studies Institute.
00:01:07.680This was a speech essentially about declining birth rates, and they're bad, by the way, in the United States.
00:01:13.380They're at a 17-year low, and they continue to go in the wrong direction.
00:01:17.060And what it means for the future of this country.
00:01:21.300Mr. Vance talked about how he wanted to see the Republican Party as a pro-family party.
00:01:26.840He discussed the importance of children and brought up the fact that many top Democratic leaders don't have any kids,
00:01:34.920questioning what kind of a message the party as a whole is sending to young Americans.
00:01:41.880I want to take aim at the left, specifically the childless left,
00:01:48.300because I think the rejection of the American family is perhaps the most pernicious and most evil thing that the left has done in this country.
00:01:56.380Consider all of the next gen of the Democrat Party.
00:07:42.540It's not just Senator J.D. Vance, Republican and running mate to Donald Trump saying that.
00:07:47.600Just recently, there was a long piece, June 10th, 2024, in the New York Times and another one in the New Yorker highlighting a book that's called What Are Children For?
00:08:00.260on Ambivalence and Choice, in which the authors, leftists, liberals, got deep into this very problem and chastised their own side for the reluctance to have children and the messaging to young women about priorities.
00:08:19.700The honest liberals will admit themselves that somehow the Democrats are running away from family as one of their previous old core values.
00:08:31.760I'll just give you a couple of excerpts from the New York Times piece by these two authors, Anastasia Berg and Rachel Wiseman.
00:09:26.620We've seen it from the hardcore environmentalists on the left in particular, urging people not to have children because they don't see a future for the country or the world.
00:09:40.880Yeah, Megan, and I think it's profoundly weird and dangerous rhetoric because, you know, I think most parents would say professional achievements, whether you're a mom or dad, all that stuff eventually fades away.
00:09:51.040The thing that you're most proud of is having kids, what your kids do, the relationship that you have with your family.
00:09:57.940That is what I think brings the most meaning to life is family, not all these weird little accomplishments and degrees and everything else, right?
00:10:07.440It's family that really brings the most meaning to our lives.
00:10:10.880And, Megan, this comment that I made was actually motivated in part by a conversation I had with my wife where, you know, she at the time had two babies.
00:10:20.500And she was talking about how she felt this incredible professional pressure to not have kids because it set back her professional advancement.
00:10:28.160And what a weird society that we've set up where moms who want to work, the thought that a lot of them are having is, I can't have more babies because it's going to be bad for my career.
00:10:37.880How about we make the workplace more accommodating to working moms and working dads so that we can promote a real culture of life?
00:10:45.100You started your monologue, Megan, talking about how we have the lowest birth rate.
00:10:50.160And basically in our history in this country, what our young moms and dads are telling us is they don't feel comfortable in this society bringing new life into the world.
00:11:00.920And it's interesting when I raise this issue about we don't have enough babies, a lot of liberals and a lot of people on the left will say, well, we can just replace American children with immigrants.
00:11:10.860Well, look, there's nothing against immigrants.
00:11:12.660Obviously, I'm married to the daughter of immigrants, but if your society is not having enough children to replace itself, that is a profoundly dangerous and destabilizing thing.
00:11:21.820You look across history, that's a real problem.
00:11:24.500So I just think that we have to say, Megan, having kids is good.
00:11:29.060Being a parent changes your perspective on the world.
00:11:31.580That is not a bad thing to stand up for parents.
00:11:52.700He talks about how this person, Jay, talks about how the messaging from leftists around children is all about their economic value, how much they're going to cost, what kind of a burden they're going to be,
00:12:04.580as opposed to the goodness they bring into the world and our lives.
00:12:11.440We should talk about them as a universal and immutable good.
00:12:16.220So that's exactly what you did in those remarks, J.D., and I understood it completely.
00:12:20.940And I think even the left, if they're honest, understands that piece of it.
00:12:25.300Here's where I think it gets controversial and where, you know, your attacks are coming in from.
00:12:29.940It was this piece where you then talked about the relative value of voting, of a person's voting rights, a parent versus somebody who isn't.
00:12:41.260Here's that piece of the original remarks and so forth.
00:12:45.140The Democrats are talking about giving the vote to 16-year-olds, but let's do this instead.
00:12:49.680Let's give votes to all children in this country, but let's give control over those votes to the parents of those children.
00:12:59.940When you go to the polls in this country as a parent, you should have more power,
00:13:10.820you should have more of an ability to speak your voice in our democratic republic than people who don't have kids.
00:13:15.800Let's face the consequences and the reality.
00:13:18.660And all the usual suspects will criticize me about this in the coming days.
00:13:22.500Well, doesn't this mean that non-parents don't have as much of a voice as parents?
00:13:28.560Doesn't this mean that parents get a bigger say in how our democracy functions?
00:14:30.500But they've taken this incredibly out of context.
00:14:33.380They say that I'm opposed to IVF or that I'm criticizing people who have fertility problems.
00:14:38.300Megan, I said explicitly in my remarks that I wasn't talking about people who couldn't have children.
00:14:44.240I was talking about people who have turned anti-child into the ethic of their entire party.
00:14:49.740That's a fundamentally different thing, and it's obvious that the Democrats don't want to own up to the fact that their party has become very anti-family.
00:14:56.900You have Hollywood celebrities saying, oh, well, J.D. Vance, what if your daughter suffered fertility problems?
00:15:02.400Well, first of all, that's disgusting because my daughter is two years old.
00:15:06.260And second of all, if she had fertility problems, as I said in that speech, I would try everything I could to try to help her because I believe families and babies are a good thing.
00:15:16.440That's the whole point is if you believe families and babies are a good thing, you should be trying to promote life.
00:15:22.140You should try to promote the fact that we want to have a good family policy in this country.
00:15:27.660That is what's so profoundly wrong about where the Democrats have gone.
00:15:31.160And I think we have to fight back against this, Megan.
00:15:33.120I think a lot of people, you know, the media has been attacking me and this is how it goes.
00:15:42.960Just to, you know, I would like to talk about the IVF because I, as far as I understand it, you oppose the Democrats bill on IVF, like allowing it in all states, but also providing funding through everybody's insurance for it, which is more controversial.
00:15:58.220But you supported Ted Cruz's and Katie Britt's bill to protect IVF, if my memory is correct.
00:16:04.840But I guess I'll just ask you now, where do you stand on IVF?
00:16:07.860Well, first of all, Megan, I know beautiful children.
00:16:10.820I mean, kids that play at my house with my kids that have been brought into the world through IVF.
00:16:15.200Of course, we want to make it easier for moms and dads to choose life if, of course, they're in a terrible situation where they have fertility problems.
00:16:22.900I think the problem with the Democrats' approach on this is they're trying to take away religious liberty.
00:16:27.400And you just go back to Kamala Harris, Megan.
00:16:29.040This is a person, of course, who has tried to say that members of the Knights of Columbus should not serve in public office.
00:16:35.180This is a person who's tried to say that Catholic hospitals and Christian hair hospitals should have to do IVF in the way the Democrats want them to do it.
00:16:44.040I'm talking about religious liberty here.
00:16:46.000I think we have to protect the rights of Christian hospitals to operate the way that they want to operate.
00:16:51.500But, of course, that's totally consistent with promoting fertility treatments for parents who need it.
00:16:56.300And I believe in this stuff, again, because I believe babies are a profound moral good.
00:17:22.960But it's yet another instance in which you see all these left-wing politicians, people rush to play the victim in response to these comments, right?
00:17:33.820Like Mark Kelly and Gabby Giffords, who were not included in the scope of your remarks.
00:17:40.200But they've rushed, of course, because he's being considered reportedly for her VP, for her running mate.
00:17:45.520And so they ran out to offer the following comment.
00:17:48.740And, you know, Jennifer Aniston was another, like, taking issue, as I mentioned in the intro, as if your comments were about her personally.
00:17:55.080But I'll say something to Jennifer Aniston.
00:17:57.640I don't know what your child's situation is, but you should read this piece in the New York Times.
00:18:02.740You should read this piece that says as follows.
00:18:05.440Liberal conventional wisdom encourages people to spend their 20s on journeys of personal and professional self-discovery and self-fulfillment.
00:18:12.280Children are treated as a bonus round, something to get to only after completing a long list of achievements, getting a degree, forging a satisfying and well-established career, buying a house, cultivating the ideal romantic partnership, and making the point that this is an empty life.
00:18:27.340If that without the ultimate goal of children, you are not, they write as follows, having children remains the most basic and accessible way for most of us to affirm the value of our lives and that of others.
00:18:38.300And if you realize that too late, you might be feeling bitter.
00:18:42.000You might find yourself in a situation where you have no choice but IVF, because your most fruitful childbearing years have passed you.
00:18:48.340It's a choice every woman has to make.
00:18:50.480It's not anybody else's fault if you choose to pursue a career and find yourself in that situation.
00:18:55.320As frankly, I did, but I got lucky and IVF worked for me.
00:18:59.660Okay, so in any event, I want to go back because Gabby Giffords and Mark Kelly are taking aim at you, saying as follows.
00:19:06.920Gabby Giffords, of course, was shot in a terrible mass shooting incident in which she was the target several years ago, and she's married to Mark Kelly, former astronaut, now senator.
00:19:16.720She writes, Vice President Kamala Harris is a proud mom of two remarkable stepchildren, and so am I.
00:19:24.580Captain Mark Kelly and I were trying to have a baby through IVF before I was shot, and that dream was stolen from us.
00:19:30.100To suggest we are somehow lesser is disgraceful.
00:19:52.680The point is that her party has pursued a set of policies that are profoundly anti-child.
00:19:57.560These people want to conflate the personal situation here with the fact that I'm making an argument that our entire society has become skeptical and even hateful towards the idea of having kids.
00:20:08.540I mean, you have young women and young men who say, we don't want to have children because of climate change.
00:20:13.600We don't want to have children, of course, because housing prices are too expensive, and that's a concern I take seriously and I think is a very real problem.
00:20:20.080But people have to remember that when you look back on your life, you talk to people, the thing that they remember most is not their career or their education, it's their family.
00:20:29.800And I just want us to be a country that's pro-family.
00:20:33.000Of course, what happened to Gabby Giffords was terrible.
00:20:40.420But why are they pursuing a set of policies that make having families harder?
00:20:45.160Why are they wanting to mask toddlers years into the pandemic?
00:20:48.360Why are they saying that we should get rid of the child tax credit, which lowers taxes for working families with children?
00:20:55.400They are creating an anti-family and anti-child society.
00:20:59.740And I think it's important for Republicans to fight back against this, Megan, and not take the bait here.
00:21:04.580We wish the best for these people's families, but they should not use their families as a pretext to pursue all these ridiculous anti-family policies for the rest of Americans.
00:21:13.300Well, I was going to say, in defense of Kamala Harris and other childless leftists, plenty of leftists with children tried to mask our children interminably and did not care about their own kids suffering or ours.
00:21:26.980Last comment on this, then we'll move on.
00:21:32.180That reportedly has many conservative women outraged, though when I clicked on the Newsweek article suggesting as much, I saw three quoted.
00:21:44.660Look, Megan, I've heard from a lot of conservative women and frankly, a lot of liberal women who said, I'm actually glad that you pointed out that there's become something profoundly anti-family in our public policy and in our public conversation.
00:21:56.260Obviously, it was a sarcastic comment.
00:22:42.560But because I'm proud of it and because I supported my wife, Megan, I've seen the fact that it's hard to be a working mom,
00:22:49.380that the corporate world is fundamentally hostile to working mothers and working fathers because we have made stupid and bad choices as a country.
00:23:00.940And I think it's shameful for the Democrats to hide behind their personal circumstances when they have supported policies that have made it harder on working moms and dads.
00:23:10.020And they're still this very day doing the exact same thing.
00:23:15.800Joy Reid, in that montage of media reaction I played, suggested that what your comments get to is that the only valid version of America is a white woman who stays at home.
00:23:29.260So that's your position, according to her.
00:23:31.460You only value white, stay-at-home moms.
00:24:16.680If you don't have children, you do not have a future.
00:24:19.140You cannot import the next generation.
00:24:21.400You've got to actually have stable, healthy, happy families.
00:24:25.620President Trump and I, our entire agenda is about promoting it, promoting schools that are good for kids,
00:24:31.520bringing down housing costs so that if young families want to start a family, they can afford to.
00:24:35.800These are the things that are important in our public policy and in our discourse.
00:24:40.140I'm going to keep on fighting for them, Megan.
00:24:41.980I'm actually glad the left has attacked me over this because I think it started an important conversation about how our society became so profoundly anti-family.