The Megyn Kelly Show - November 20, 2026


Meghan Markle's Dad Ruled Competent, Scientist Wins Case, and Clavicular Charged, with Geragos, Merchant, and Frei | Ep. 1446

Mullin Clashes with Lawmakers, Peltola Flips Alaska, FDA Nominee Overton Pulled: AM Update 11⧸19

Episode Stats


Length

1 hour and 45 minutes

Words per minute

171.54

Word count

18,088

Sentence count

1,125


Transcript

Transcript generated with Whisper (turbo).
00:00:00 Ugh, come on.
00:00:01 Keep it down.
00:00:02 Ugh, I'm changing our tire. Can't you help?
00:00:04 I'm your debt, not roadside assistance.
00:00:07 It's time to break up with your debt.
00:00:10 Farber Debt Solutions. Licensed Insolvency Trustees.
00:00:13 Get the truth about debt.
00:00:15 In communities across Canada,
00:00:18 hourly Amazon employees earn an average of over $26 an hour.
00:00:24 Employees also have the opportunity to grow their skills and their paycheck
00:00:28 by enrolling in free skills training programs for in-demand fields
00:00:32 like software development and information technology.
00:00:36 Learn more at aboutamazon.ca.
00:00:45 Welcome to The Megyn Kelly Show,
00:00:47 live on Sirius XM Channel 111 every weekday at New East.
00:00:51 hey everyone i'm megan kelly welcome to the megan kelly show happy friday we have a packed kelly's
00:01:02 court for you today with thomas markle senior officially getting a ruling on whether he is
00:01:07 competent to stand trial more lawmakers in the uk calling for russell brand to be kicked off of
00:01:14 youtube it's amazing the amount of pressure they are trying to exert on an american company i keep
00:01:20 saying it. We fought a whole war so we don't have to listen to these people. And they continue to
00:01:23 follow us over here thinking that they can control us. It's a no. Also, the social media
00:01:29 influencer known as Clavicular indicted on rape charges. We'll take a look at those. Joining me
00:01:35 now, defense attorney and co-host of In the Well on the MK True Crime channel, Mark Garagos,
00:01:41 defense attorney and co-host of the MK True Crime show, Ashley Merchant. You can find both of those
00:01:45 shows by subscribing to our MK True Crime show on YouTube and all podcast platforms. Also with
00:01:51 us today, former litigator and Rumble creator, Viva Frye. As we head into the thick of sick
00:01:59 season, keeping your family healthy and resilient is a top priority. That is why a daily routine
00:02:04 often starts with beekeepers naturals. They are reinventing the medicine cabinet with clean,
00:02:09 effective health solutions that replace harsh chemicals and synthetic dyes with natural
00:02:15 ingredients that you can actually trust. Their secret weapon, Propolis. This is the protective
00:02:21 substance bees use to safeguard their hive from germs, and it's packed with over 300 essential
00:02:27 vitamins and antioxidants to support cellular health. There's their Propolis Immune Support
00:02:33 Throat Spray for proactive daily immune defense, or their Propolis Throat Soother, powered by
00:02:40 slippery elm and menthol, it delivers immediate icy cooling relief. Today, Beekeepers Naturals
00:02:46 is giving exclusive early access to their Black Friday sale. Go to beekeepersnaturals.com
00:02:51 slash Megan or enter the code Megan to get 30% off your order. That's beekeepersnaturals.com
00:02:59 slash Megan or enter the code Megan at checkout for your discount. Beekeepers Naturals products
00:03:04 are also available at Target, Whole Foods, Walmart, Amazon, CVS, and Walgreens.
00:03:10 Guys, welcome to you all. Great to have you. We'll kick it off with Russell, where they are not letting up like they will continue now trying to push at every level of government to silence him.
00:03:26 You've got the prime minister himself speaking to it.
00:03:30 You've got his office issuing statements.
00:03:32 You've got the UK minister responsible for film and TV now speaking out,
00:03:38 saying you would have taken it down if it were a mass murderer, so please take it down.
00:03:44 Saying the refusal to do so could set an example.
00:03:47 Viva, the guy's name is Ian Murray.
00:03:50 Maybe if it were a mass murderer, they would.
00:03:52 I'm not sure.
00:03:52 I think even murderers get the chance to say I'm innocent and not go along with the jury verdict.
00:03:58 But this guy's weighed in another cabinet minister just weighed in the labor member of parliament just weighed in.
00:04:04 In addition to the prime minister, his office, the labor MP and housing minister, the labor deputy leader,
00:04:10 the Metropolitan Police Deputy Commissioner, all trying to lean on Google to pull entirely Russell's YouTube account,
00:04:18 which, by the way, they are using for a joint podcast that Laura and Russell had been issuing on, I think, every Sunday.
00:04:27 And now, you know, Laura's out there. We'll see whether she's going to be doing it.
00:04:30 But they want effectively they want her shut down and him shut down, even though it's already been demonetized.
00:04:35 They're not making money off of it.
00:04:37 They say, like, if it were a mass murder, they would take down his YouTube channel.
00:04:40 If there were someone who was convicted of mass murder and they would had a gardening channel, would they insist on taking down the gardening channel?
00:04:46 I mean, the whole thing is it's not even obvious. Mike Tyson was convicted back in the day. Does he not get to post anything on social media or assert his own innocence? The problem here, we look at the UK and say they've gone off the rails and they've gone past the event horizon of communism.
00:05:00 they're sort of taking a bit of the lead from what we've seen out here in the u.s when alex jones
00:05:07 was defaulted into liability and then i went to that you know that hearing in texas he was not
00:05:12 allowed to assert his innocence he was not allowed to state that he had apologized to the families
00:05:16 when donald trump was accused of eugene carroll's sexual abuse he was held liable for defamation
00:05:22 for asserting his innocence and calling her crazy so you sort of can't blame them for pushing the
00:05:26 envelope when they've seen what has happened here and been tolerated here by the democrat
00:05:31 socialists of america but it's insanity it's pretextual to silence someone and his political
00:05:36 views and his religious views because they've you know convicted him in this show trial and now they
00:05:41 say we get to take this show trial and say you no longer get to assert your innocence and let's shut
00:05:46 you down on all social media it is madness you know what we have uh over there mark is alleged
00:05:53 victims who did not participate in this trial, coming out now giving interviews on camera like
00:06:00 the once 16-year-old who was with Russell when she was 16 and he was 30, who has identified
00:06:07 herself. She went by Alice in the 2023 documentary. Now she's identified herself as Mia Ladder. She's
00:06:12 gone on cam saying it's me. But Mia Ladder's allegations were not pursued by police and
00:06:21 prosecutors in the trial against Russell. And while she now is spinning some, to me,
00:06:26 cockamamie story about how the reason they decided not to bring her claims in a criminal court was
00:06:34 that Russell appeared on this show and he appeared on Piers Morgan and said it was consensual and
00:06:43 she was within the legal age of consent. 16 is not illegal. And that they were worried because
00:06:49 in light of those appearances that the trial would turn into the quote Alice show. This sounds
00:06:55 like utter bullshit to me. I think there's something wrong with her complaint. And the
00:07:00 police and or the prosecutors did not think they could make the case with Alice slash Mia's
00:07:06 allegations. But what we now have is this Mia running around nonstop dumping on Russell,
00:07:12 pouring more fuel on the Russell fire. And I'll just give you an example as she and others try
00:07:18 to get the UK government to lean on YouTube to take away his remaining voice. Here she is in
00:07:25 Sat 3 on Tuesday. Well, we know that it's an offense for prisoners, even via third party,
00:07:31 to send messages out on social media. So I don't know if he's hoping to extend his sentence. Now
00:07:35 he's in a lovely prison facility, but he'll have lots of time to reflect on that. But I was just
00:07:43 confused by it and i was shocked and i was shocked that youtube put it out because i feel like they
00:07:49 have some kind of responsibility not to let these things be broadcast and um it was an insult to all
00:07:55 the women that stood trial and it was an insult to the jurors that gave their time it's an insult
00:08:01 to the criminal justice system well apparently he's he's if he's not using an unlawful illicit
00:08:10 device, then it's okay. So he can't do it on a phone, but he can do it if he speaks to his wife
00:08:15 when she visits him or whatever. He's found a loophole. He's found a loophole again.
00:08:22 What do you make of it? There's so much insanity that has been kind of institutionalized.
00:08:31 This is the same playbook that actually operates in America. And what you have is, is usually triggered either by a, and I, you know, somebody who does plaintiff's work, I say this self-deprecatingly, there's usually a plaintiff's lawyer who takes advantage of a claim, a claim that's been revived, that is, that should have gone stale,
00:09:00 that they passed some kind of a statue of limitations revival, that that revival, then people start to feel like, oh, I can jump on the bandwagon for whatever reason there.
00:09:14 Then that triggers a prosecutor to say, for whatever reason, in Russell's case, it was a documentary.
00:09:21 And by the way, that works both ways.
00:09:23 I admit that sometimes the documentaries can cure an injustice.
00:09:27 Sometimes they create an injustice.
00:09:29 In this case, in my opinion, it created an injustice.
00:09:34 People jump onto that and then the mob takes over.
00:09:38 We saw it with Cornell recently.
00:09:40 I mean, how shameful the New York Times sat on all of those text messages and basically
00:09:49 made a decision to treat people like they're in fifth grade and we're only going to release
00:09:54 portions of it.
00:09:56 And then you get the mob.
00:09:57 And CBS New York, too, it looks like.
00:09:59 New York. I mean, it was it's outrageous if you take a look at it. And God forbid that you point
00:10:05 that out because then it's you get damned by the mob again. And the problem is when you start
00:10:14 incarcerating people and you start taking away their liberty. And then if you want to complain
00:10:21 about your liberty being taken away, then we're going to muzzle you on top of it. It really is
00:10:27 kind of if this had been written and it was frankly in many novels as science fiction 20
00:10:34 years ago you wouldn't have believed it but we're watching it happen in real time and now we get the
00:10:40 second so-called documentary ashley which we took apart on monday for i mean multiple
00:10:48 misrepresentations in there where they didn't tell about a witness's prior inconsistent statements
00:10:54 Like, they have this one woman on camera talking all about how Russell allegedly came over to her and digitally penetrated her out of nowhere while they were having a fight.
00:11:06 And it turns out this woman had written a book under a pseudonym back in 2015.
00:11:11 I think it was 14 or 15, whatever, one of those years.
00:11:14 And she wrote about the incident.
00:11:16 It was all about Russell, though she used a different name that sounded very close to Russell Brand, but it wasn't that.
00:11:20 And in that, yes, she wrote about the incident, but in that very book she wrote, I'm actually not sure whether he intended for me to experience this in a pleasurable, exciting, sort of sexy way.
00:11:35 So she, back then, which is only seven years after it happened, she's writing like, he actually may have intended this in a way to turn me on.
00:11:43 Now, in the glare of the Klieg lights that there's been a criminal conviction, I was a victim. I was sexually assaulted. And did the so-called documentarians reveal that earlier statement to us or her interview that she gave to the Daily Mail one year later in which she said nothing?
00:12:01 In fact, what she said was he never sexually abused me.
00:12:03 Did they reveal any of that about one of their star witnesses in the documentary?
00:12:08 Not one fact, nothing, which shows how dishonest they are.
00:12:13 And now they're platforming, you know, oh, poor Mia.
00:12:16 It's like, have you done any testing of her assertions?
00:12:20 All we have is her word that this happened.
00:12:24 Literally nothing else.
00:12:25 And that's all Russell's gone to prison.
00:12:27 Right. And that's what Megan, that is exactly what this is about.
00:12:29 It's a he said, she said.
00:12:30 That's all they have.
00:12:32 And so they've convicted him in a court, and now they've taken away his liberty on a she
00:12:36 said.
00:12:36 And he's got the right to talk and say what the he said is.
00:12:40 They tried to silence him in court.
00:12:42 Now they're trying to silence him in the media.
00:12:44 If there's documentaries saying one side of the story, he's entitled to get his version
00:12:48 out.
00:12:49 And the thing is, when you take someone's liberty like this, it comes with certain restrictions,
00:12:54 but it does not take away your right to speak, your right to actually have your truth.
00:12:58 And what he's doing is he's trying to assert his truth.
00:13:01 He's trying to explain what's going on.
00:13:03 He's trying to counter essentially what happened in court when he wasn't able to get everything
00:13:08 across to the jury.
00:13:09 And so it's really the exact same thing.
00:13:11 And I really think it's just bullying at this point.
00:13:13 And Ashley, you know, what's particularly Nettleson is you mentioned in court that judge
00:13:20 did, to my mind, the cardinal sin, insinuated himself into the defense cross-examination.
00:13:27 The lawyer is on cross. This judge insinuates himself into that cross, starts making credibility calls in front of the jury.
00:13:37 So you've not only silenced somebody basically during their trial, you put your finger on the scale during the trial.
00:13:45 And now afterwards, when you can try to complain about the fact that you were railroad doesn't even do it justice, steamrolled.
00:13:52 now you're going to take away that platform on top that is i mean it's our version of the salem
00:13:59 witch trials fast forward 400 years no it's egregious particularly that this judge did that
00:14:06 and the fact that everybody just thinks it's a fair trial when a judge that's what the jury
00:14:10 really looks at they think that they're neutral you know people go into jury trials and they think
00:14:14 that the system works they believe it they believe that everything's fair and all the rules are set
00:14:18 up to be fair and they believe what the judge says anything that comes out of the judge's mouth
00:14:22 is really to them like the bible and so when you've got a judge like mark said cutting off
00:14:27 a cross-examination first of all you're not getting to the truth because you're not having
00:14:31 that cross-examination but worse than that you've got a judge who is clouded in this you know shroud
00:14:36 of of decency and all-knowing power of the law and the jury's just like oh whatever he said he
00:14:42 thinks she's you know she's telling the truth he thinks that she's guilt that you know he's guilty
00:14:46 that Russell Brand's guilty. Well, he must know something we don't know, you know, and so they
00:14:51 just go with that. And it's and Russell has the right to dispute that, to talk about what happened
00:14:56 in that trial. I just got I am worried, Viva, that that Google, well, I respect their decision
00:15:04 immensely, you know, because they own YouTube. But I'm worried that they they may not hold
00:15:09 because the UK government is not giving up. They are ratcheting up the pressure on them.
00:15:15 They are under the misunderstanding that this is an English company.
00:15:19 It's not.
00:15:20 It's an American company with all of the protections of the First Amendment that we all get over here, which over here, our government would not be permitted to do this to us, to threaten if we don't allow them to censor speech.
00:15:34 That's what's happening here.
00:15:35 But here's the thing. If Laura Brand goes on that YouTube channel on Sunday and posts another YouTube saying something like let's say it's not a message from Russell Russell. Let's say it's something like the system seems so unfair. My children miss their father. I don't I'm making things up here, but I think we're going to get another round of this.
00:15:59 Megan, it wasn't a request the first time. It was sort of a threat. And it's one of those, you have a nice shop here. It would be a shame if something happens to it. And appreciate the pretext of what they were offering by way of justification. Not that he was participating in active witness intimidation or witness harassment or interference with evidence. They were saying it's an insult to the victims.
00:16:20 i i hate to be uh insensitive insult does not dictate the law and my freedoms are not limited
00:16:27 by your sensitivities and insults if they're they're going to say next it's an insult if they
00:16:31 see a get him to the greek or forgetting sarah marshall we must take these dvds out of mass
00:16:34 production i appreciate maybe they find it to be insulting maybe they find it to be irritating that
00:16:40 the man they say raped them is protesting his innocence that's not how you govern the law and
00:16:45 unfortunately rights in the uk are treated as privileges the problem is they're gonna next
00:16:51 time not come in with such a nice request and they're gonna say we have regulatory powers and
00:16:55 we can impose fines and this and that that could be crippling but if i'm laura brand i'm not coming
00:17:00 out and indirectly trying to do it i'm coming out and saying i spoke with my husband he's asserting
00:17:05 his innocence he's saying he's railroaded and then make the uk government force google to take
00:17:10 down his youtube channel and then we'll have a public debate about that you know to me it's like
00:17:15 the fact that all these government officials who apparently have nothing better to do than to think
00:17:19 about Russell Brand's latest statement on his trial, the fact that they're all so quick to say
00:17:25 this is distressing to his victims and it needs to be shut down shows you how used to they've
00:17:34 gotten the crackdowns on free speech. It's regular. We read a stat the other day showing
00:17:40 There were 12,000 arrests a year that there's just this past year in 2025 for free speech violations, for having wrong think about this issue or that to where.
00:17:52 I mean, can you imagine the U.S. government saying, oh, a defendant continues to say he's innocent after he's been sent to prison?
00:18:01 This is an all hands on deck situation.
00:18:04 The president, members of Congress, the jailer.
00:18:08 We all need to band together. Every social media platform must band together to make sure he never says this vile thing again to, quote, re-traumatize the victim.
00:18:17 We would not do that. Even our government, which is getting sadly more tolerant of free speech crackdowns, would never go that far on something like that, where so many of the rights are ingrained in the Constitution, because we do have a free speech culture here still, Mark.
00:18:32 And one of the interesting things, I've long made the argument that years ago, decades ago, we imported kind of the tabloid cable news, back when cable news was a thing, tabloidization of criminal law.
00:18:47 And I used to say we imported that from the UK.
00:18:50 But the UK always had, at least traditionally, what they called the Contempt of Court Act.
00:18:55 So when somebody, when you reached a certain critical mass in the UK, you had this idea that you would clamp down on the coverage of it, at least to try to protect the fair trial rights of whoever was in the object of the trial of the century at the time.
00:19:11 That has not happened anymore. That is completely eroded. And this points out just how bankrupt, kind of intellectually bankrupt it is.
00:19:21 the idea because this is the exaggerated form. You are now basically saying you've got no right
00:19:28 to appeal. We are we've got a fixed game here. You get to play along. The lawyer is basically
00:19:35 to borrow the old line from many years ago. The lawyer is basically a potted plant or window
00:19:43 dressing to give us the idea that somehow you're getting due process. Once you've been convicted,
00:19:49 We'll take you out back and shoot you and we're in prison you.
00:19:54 And that's it.
00:19:54 We don't want to hear from you again because we dispense with this.
00:19:58 It's really an assault on the idea of due process.
00:20:01 It's an assault, not just on free speech, but on this idea of a Sixth Amendment right
00:20:08 to counsel.
00:20:09 That's what the interference was.
00:20:11 When that judge gets in and starts interfering with cross-examination, that is the essence
00:20:17 of, at least in the U.S., of what a trial is supposed to be. You're supposed to test
00:20:23 accusations. You're supposed to. The idea, I've seen some of these comments where they say,
00:20:28 well, the lawyer had asked the same question three different ways. Yes, that's exactly what
00:20:33 lawyers do. That is cross-examination. Right. And so the idea of a judge to jump in and say,
00:20:40 I've heard enough or, you know, stop doing this, that strikes at the very essence of what
00:20:47 due processes. This has been a railroad from the beginning. He got railroaded by that documentary
00:20:52 in 23. He got railroaded at this trial by the judge and the prosecutors and these 30-year-old
00:21:00 claims against him. And the railroading continues with this new so-called documentary on Netflix
00:21:06 and the entire UK government trying to stop him from saying the most expected, harmless things
00:21:13 like, I didn't do it. I mean, it's just ridiculous. I want to keep going. We have a lot to get
00:21:18 through. Ashley, let me start with you. Meghan Markle's father, Thomas Markle Sr., has been found
00:21:23 competent to face trial here in the United States. He's also looking at criminal charges in the
00:21:29 Philippines, whether Mexico will charge him as well. We don't know, but apparently there was a
00:21:34 cache of child sexual abuse material found in his lockers there. So here's what happened.
00:21:40 And an expert testified in this proceeding in, let's see, about his California storage facility, saying that he is mentally competent to face charges.
00:21:54 Let's see. His defense lawyer said that they would not contest the findings of Dr. Arnie.
00:22:00 Oh, sorry. Amy Gerodimus. The exam was ordered after his arrest at a senior care center in Florida.
00:22:07 It was a 90-minute interview. According to the expert, he denied the allegations against him.
00:22:12 He blamed his son, Thomas Jr., for his legal troubles, according to the expert's 15-page
00:22:16 report. Quote, reading here from an NBC6 Miami piece. Why am I here? What have I done? The
00:22:23 psychiatrist quoted him as saying, I don't have any child porn. I have no pictures of naked kids.
00:22:29 Then she goes on to say, the psychiatrist, that he said, my son hates me. He has never
00:22:35 accomplished anything. She wrote in her report that Markle Sr. did understand the charges against
00:22:42 him and would be in a position to assist his lawyer. Two key points in any competency
00:22:46 determination. The expert said he was, quote, malingering or exaggerating at times in his
00:22:53 responses during the interview. It was also reported that he repeatedly brought up the fact
00:22:59 that he's related to Meghan Markle.
00:23:02 And while at one point in the interview,
00:23:04 he tried to be confused about the fact
00:23:07 that he has three children.
00:23:09 You know, he had Thomas Jr., then he had Samantha.
00:23:12 I don't know if it was in that order, but the older two.
00:23:14 And then with a second wife, he had Meghan.
00:23:17 And in this interview, at one point, he said,
00:23:19 oh, well, I only have one daughter and one son.
00:23:22 And she just thought this guy is lying.
00:23:25 I mean, she's a trained psychiatrist.
00:23:27 She didn't buy one word of that nonsense.
00:23:29 So what does this mean?
00:23:30 That's exactly what they're trained to do.
00:23:31 I mean, malingering is lying.
00:23:33 It means you're making it up for the purpose of some benefit.
00:23:36 And he's trying to make it up so that he doesn't have to stand trial.
00:23:39 So it's not, it's different than not guilty by reason and sanity.
00:23:43 Competency to stand trial means whether or not they can even prosecute you.
00:23:46 You know, whether or not the case can even go forward.
00:23:48 You can assist in your own defense.
00:23:49 You can go to court, all of those types of things.
00:23:51 And he says he had prior strokes.
00:23:54 And I think what he was probably trying to go for was some type of a dimension defense
00:23:57 because he's in his 80s and he's got these prior strokes.
00:24:00 And if he had convinced them that he had this memory loss
00:24:03 or something like that from these strokes or dementia,
00:24:05 they never would have been able to prosecute him.
00:24:08 And so he essentially doesn't have to stand trial
00:24:10 for what's going on.
00:24:11 But I think the really interesting thing
00:24:13 is how they worded it.
00:24:14 They said he's exaggerating these symptoms,
00:24:17 you know, and he's malingering.
00:24:18 And that's significant because that means he is lying.
00:24:21 He is making them up to try to game the system somehow.
00:24:24 Mm hmm. I guess we're not surprised he's 82 years old trying to go with the GM to I'm too incompetent to answer charges of the troves of child sexual abuse material, including pictures showing him with naked underage prepubescent girls, according to the authorities.
00:24:42 He denies it. But let me give you a little color from what happened, per the Daily Mail.
00:24:48 Markle also suggested that investigators should speak to Meghan Markle about his ongoing health problems.
00:24:55 He pointed out to the psychiatrist that I might have heard of Meghan, said the mental health expert.
00:25:01 They describe her as a psychologist. Don't know if it's one has a medical degree, one doesn't.
00:25:06 Adding that he repeatedly reminded me that Meghan Markle is his daughter.
00:25:10 He mentioned her at least seven times during the assessment as he discussed his family health and personal circumstances.
00:25:18 The report states, quote, Mr. Markle said that he has been seeing a therapist but does not know that person's name.
00:25:26 He said that his sister, Megan, or his brother could help with that.
00:25:33 Then he apologized, acknowledging that he has no sister and reminded me that Megan Markle is his daughter.
00:25:40 He also said that his son, Thomas Jr., was trying to, quote, crucify him and attempted to blame him for any pictures of naked children found in two L.A. lockups, declaring, this sounds like my son is trying to set me up.
00:25:56 That's exactly, Viva, what his daughter, Samantha, who's the full blood sister to Thomas Jr., is alleging on her father's behalf.
00:26:04 She seems to be the one family member standing by him.
00:26:07 So what do you make of this? Because, you know, I'm confused. I think Megan's my sister. No, she's my daughter.
00:26:14 At some point, you know, it's like when they persecute Nazi war criminals, at some point you get to be too old for there to be any reasonable hope of justice.
00:26:22 He's 81, 82, diabetics, has prior strokes. He might not live to see a verdict regardless or serve any meaningful time.
00:26:29 So you might never have any justice in this story. The two questions I have is how does one get away with this?
00:26:34 To the extent the allegations are true, how does one get away with it for so long, having troves of storage of CSAM in various locations on the one hand?
00:26:43 And how this father could get away with it if it's in fact true and the kids and nobody know around him.
00:26:48 Flip side also, to the extent the kids are now potentially trying to throw the other brother under the bus, the allegations are such that he's in pictures with prepubescent girls.
00:26:59 that i don't know what the son looks like but that might seem hard to confuse the elderly man
00:27:04 or the father for the son okay this is a disgusting story it's wild that it involves the people that it
00:27:10 involves and it's wild that it went on for as long as it did apparently but it's probably gonna be
00:27:14 one of those stories where like with uh what's his face the porn actor ron jeremy ron jeremy
00:27:19 it's exactly what i was thinking i was exactly what i was thinking competency it's it's a strange
00:27:25 thing for him to who to be if he's malingering he's really bad at it because the last thing you
00:27:32 want to do in the interview with the psychiatrist is start denying the charges because once you
00:27:38 understand the charges you're defeating the whole idea of your not being able to be competent but
00:27:45 if to your point if he waits long enough it sounds like he's at least on the precipice
00:27:52 of kind of a slow spiral into dementia and he may end up in the ron jeremy being declared
00:28:00 uh at some point that they can't move forward on him i mean given it i mean that's what happens
00:28:05 when you sit by and you say nothing about this for eight years when your your relatives know
00:28:10 but nobody actually makes sure an investigation into you is happening i.e his daughter um here's
00:28:16 a little bit more. He told Dr. Gerodimus, as I mentioned, I think my son is crucifying me at
00:28:23 the moment. I always poke him because he never went past the eighth grade in school. He did not
00:28:27 accomplish anything. He added, I mocked him about it a lot. She reported that he was calm and
00:28:33 cooperative and made good eye contact. He said to her, you'll have to forgive me. My memory is gone.
00:28:40 Repeated this multiple times and pointed to his age. When she discussed the allegation of his
00:28:44 possession of child sexual abuse material, his face flushed. She said he told her, I don't
00:28:49 understand about the case at all. I have no idea. I don't know about the charge. I don't know. I
00:28:54 don't know. I don't know. Why am I here? What have I done? He added, I don't have any child porn. I
00:28:59 have no pictures of naked kids. I don't have pictures of naked kids. My son has pictures of
00:29:04 naked children. Whoa, what? My son, Thomas Jr., he said he had this. He showed me something.
00:29:10 I never saw the picture. He said something to that, I guess. I vaguely remember that as well.
00:29:17 I don't have any pictures of anyone to my knowledge, naked pictures. I don't have any
00:29:21 naked pictures. So now it's getting interesting because, you know, we had heard in one early
00:29:28 report that he was saying, I think my son is trying to set me up. And Samantha Markle said
00:29:33 they had a falling out. But these, you know, troves of documents and pictures have been found
00:29:41 like in L.A. Long before. Markle hasn't been there in years, and it would have been long before his
00:29:47 fallout with his son. The Daily Mail is reporting that they have confirmed Markle Jr. had no access
00:29:52 to that storage facility out in L.A. Now, he did clearly have access to the one in the Philippines.
00:29:59 I don't know about the one in Mexico, right?
00:30:00 So it's like, has the son been running around for years through himself or others surreptitiously placing naked pictures of Thomas Markle that he concocted?
00:30:10 I mean, this seems like a stretch, Ashley, to be going here.
00:30:14 And it does seem very convenient that his memory is coming back on anything that would be incriminating about Junior, but not with respect to himself.
00:30:21 Oh, it's exactly what Mark picked up on.
00:30:23 It seems very convenient because it sounds like he is assisting in his own defense.
00:30:27 I mean, that sounds like exactly what he's doing. He's giving plausible, I mean, potentially plausible, you know, who knows if they're actually plausible, but he's giving some alternative theories to how this could have happened. He seems like he's lucid enough to talk about the elements of the case. I mean, he's his own worst enemy with those statements because he is doing exactly what he's trying to say he can't do, which is assist in his own defense. And I think that totally undercuts any argument he has that he's not confident in this case.
00:30:53 Here's what here's what she wrote in the report, Mark, to your point.
00:30:56 She said, in her opinion, with reasonable medical certainty that when Markle Sr.
00:31:01 repeatedly states he does not understand or recall the allegation, he is malingering.
00:31:05 The essential feature, she writes, of malingering is the production of false or grossly exaggerated physical or psychological problems motivated by external incentives.
00:31:17 I mean, we've got half of the youth female in America who are malingerers right now with their multiple disorders.
00:31:27 Oh, I've got everything. I've got generational trauma. That's malingering.
00:31:31 OK, apparently he's got it, too. He stated excessively, I don't know, diverting attention to his age and neurocognitive disorder before providing additional information.
00:31:40 He understood the seriousness of the nature of the charges. Quote, it is my clinical opinion with reasonable medical certainty that Mr.
00:31:47 Markle is malingering because he's exaggerating a lack of recall or understanding of the charges in order to avoid a criminal prosecution.
00:31:54 So what would you guess will be the speed, Mark, with which this thing goes to trial, given that the prosecution knows very well what you guys have been saying,
00:32:03 which is age only goes in one direction. And with every passing week, he's only going to
00:32:10 probably up the malingering there. The defense is going to do everything possible to delay this.
00:32:17 There is no there's no reason to rush this. He's not going to get any better. He I don't know
00:32:23 whether he's if it's more malingering as opposed to he's not the sharpest tool in the shed.
00:32:28 It seems to me, at least, that he is somebody who may have cognitive deficits, but wasn't that brilliant to begin with, because he could have, if he was malingering and he had any ability to do so, he could have done a much better job of it.
00:32:45 I just think he doesn't quite understand the predicament he's in.
00:32:48 And given his age and kind of the condition he's in, it wouldn't surprise me in, I hate to say it, but in six months to a year, he isn't in any condition whatsoever.
00:33:05 God forbid where he's being held, I can tell you he's not going to get great health care.
00:33:10 So this is a spiral, unfortunately, that I don't think he gets out of.
00:33:15 This is dark. Okay, let's keep going. There is the case of K.J. Beerman. This is disturbing, but it's also fascinating. This is a reality TV star's son.
00:33:29 um his mother kim zolciak is married to a former atlanta falcons player and this is their son
00:33:39 kj beerman who is now 15 years old he is accused this is the mother here he is accused of going
00:33:47 into a lifetime fitness facility at age 15 it's earlier this same year and seeing a girl he knew
00:33:54 from school, who was reportedly the best friend of his girlfriend, calling her over, trying to
00:34:00 convince her to go into the co-ed sauna with him. They never made it that far in a family changing
00:34:06 room, like a place that there's co-ed access to. He allegedly sexually assaulted her. That's what
00:34:14 she claims, including forcing oral sex on her. And there's videotape of her getting there,
00:34:21 going in, leaving some 20 minutes later. She did go and report it and no DNA was found to prove
00:34:29 that there'd been an oral rape. But, you know, that's not dispositive. His defense lawyer is
00:34:35 saying this is entirely made up. This is basically somebody who's made false allegations before
00:34:40 and suggests, though he hasn't explicitly said it, that, you know, she there's something going
00:34:48 on there where like either she liked KJ and she doesn't want to admit it, or there's something
00:34:53 about the fact that she fooled around with her best friend's boyfriend that she doesn't want
00:34:58 to admit and she's turned it into a sexual assault. We'll see what the defense is. So,
00:35:02 I mean, I could stay open-minded on that and say, we'll see. We'll see where that goes.
00:35:05 But the thing is, KJ was charged in adult court where if he's found guilty because he's been
00:35:12 charged with rape. There is a mandatory sentence of 25 years, no parole, no probation, and no
00:35:21 questions asked. So this guy, this is a 15 year old, like they are not effing around here. And
00:35:27 the reason he was charged in adult court, it has come out thanks to the prosecutor is there was a
00:35:33 previous charge just a couple of years ago when he was 12 that he raped a family member that he
00:35:43 committed incest penetrative sex is how they described it of a family member there wasn't and
00:35:50 I don't know if you guys understand family law or what happens in juvie but there wasn't in that
00:35:54 case quote a conviction they said there was a probable cause finding which you know all of us
00:36:00 understand is what normally kicks off a case. They need to have probable cause in order to
00:36:05 charge you or investigate you with an arrest warrant. But this earlier case definitely got
00:36:13 to a finding of probable cause and then seems to have gone away. It was settled, I guess,
00:36:17 because he was mandated to get some therapy. And what the prosecutor is alleging now is
00:36:23 the therapy didn't work. He's escalating the behavior now to sexual assaults in public places
00:36:30 And this we object to his defense lawyer trying to move this thing back down to juvie, which was the motion that just got filed, saying you cannot try a 15 year old boy in adult court in a way that would put him in jail for the next 25 years for crimes he committed as an obvious minor who's kind of nowhere near the age of majority.
00:36:53 and those earlier crimes while they sound terrible I don't know that they were subjected
00:36:59 to the same sort of scrutiny he would have gotten in a real trial and it doesn't even sound like
00:37:04 there was quote a conviction so all of this has me feeling so unsettled about this young man
00:37:11 what he's allegedly done we don't know who his victim was but I will say his siblings who are
00:37:18 minors are not allowed to be in the same house with him or his mother, who's got custody of him
00:37:24 right now. We played soundbites earlier this week showing the volatile household that he has grown
00:37:29 up in with the parents repeatedly having such meltdown fights that the kids have been calling
00:37:34 the cops. They've been crying. The kids are upset. It sounds like a damn nightmare and a total
00:37:39 parenting fail. But what do you guys make of it? Because now K.J. Bierman, the 15-year-old,
00:37:47 has found a new lawyer and this lawyer brian steel is not effing around this is this guy's
00:37:53 the real deal garagos you know literally every lawyer on earth do you know brian steel brian
00:37:58 was co-counsel with my daughter on diddy brian also see by by the way you know who brian's lawyer
00:38:05 was in georgia she's sitting right to my i think it's ashley oh yes ashley kept brian out of jail
00:38:13 when the judge tried to remand him.
00:38:15 So, yes, I know.
00:38:17 Wait, the lawyer, Brian,
00:38:18 did something wrong in a case?
00:38:19 Oh, yeah, yeah.
00:38:20 Oh, I'm like, where do you want to start?
00:38:23 This is my backyard.
00:38:24 First of all, let me just back up a second.
00:38:26 Where he's being prosecuted,
00:38:27 guess who the prosecutor is?
00:38:28 Fonnie Willis.
00:38:29 It's her office.
00:38:30 So this is in Fulton County.
00:38:31 Is that the same Fonnie Willis
00:38:33 that is now on the governor's transition team?
00:38:36 One and the same.
00:38:38 One and the same.
00:38:39 Yes, yes.
00:38:40 So there's so many.
00:38:41 I don't know if, Megan,
00:38:42 I don't know if Megan knew that, but. Oh, there's so much here. I know I did.
00:38:46 Oh, I can. I saw the governor with her with her photograph that has like a nearly 80 percent
00:38:52 all black staff saying she did it intentionally, which is illegal. I'm sorry to introduce you to
00:38:59 the law, sweetheart, but that's illegal. You can't hire people on the basis of race.
00:39:03 Shocker, I know, because the mainstream media won't tell you that, but it's the truth.
00:39:08 So I'm not surprised to hear she's trying to resurrect the fortunes of, I call her Fannie
00:39:13 Willis.
00:39:14 Go ahead.
00:39:14 Keep going, Ashley.
00:39:15 So, I mean, Mark hit it on the head.
00:39:16 Like, there are so many different layers to this, but Fannie Willis is the one that actually
00:39:21 heads this office in Fulton County.
00:39:22 So, yeah, we'll talk about Brian Steele in a minute.
00:39:25 But, you know, talking about this case and juvenile court, Georgia, we have some really
00:39:28 draconian laws on sex cases, which most people agree with.
00:39:32 You know, that's fine.
00:39:33 But when you're talking about a 15-year-old, it is particularly egregious thinking about
00:39:37 The fact that if he's tried an adult court and he is convicted, he is facing 25 years
00:39:42 mandatory without parole.
00:39:44 I mean, nothing, you know, no chance of getting out before 25 years and a possible life sentence.
00:39:49 So that's, I mean, that's a lot.
00:39:51 And I will tell you, they're saying that this prior allegation in juvenile court is why
00:39:56 they're prosecuting him as an adult.
00:39:57 That is a bunch of crap in Fulton County.
00:39:59 They prosecute every kid as an adult in sex cases like this.
00:40:03 So yes, every single one.
00:40:04 I do these types of hearings all the time.
00:40:06 I just had one I was talking to Mark about last month that I had one just like this in Fulton County, and I got it transferred to juvenile court.
00:40:12 Happens all the time.
00:40:13 So what they do is they indict it as an adult because they're allowed to, and then the defense has to try to get it transferred back to juvenile court.
00:40:19 And they typically use that as a point to try to negotiate.
00:40:22 Hey, you know, if your guy will plea, like, we'll work something out, maybe 10 years in prison, something like that.
00:40:27 Because they know if we get it transferred to juvenile court, then there's a very strict time limit on how long a child can actually remain in custody.
00:40:35 But the big difference is juvenile court is focused on rehabilitation and treatment, and adult court is not.
00:40:41 It's punishment.
00:40:42 And so when you've got a kid who is amenable potentially to treatment, juvenile really is the place for that child to be because they could keep him in custody until he's 25, but they actually do mandate treatment.
00:40:53 And so this prior allegation that they have that you're talking about this probable cause, that's one where the officer swears it out.
00:41:00 It's not like a probable cause hearing where it's tested with defense lawyers and all that stuff.
00:41:04 And most of the time in juvenile court, the kid goes in and says, you know, I'm not going to contest it.
00:41:09 I'm just going to do treatment because that's typically what happens.
00:41:11 And so that's what happened in this prior case.
00:41:13 You know, there was something, something alleged.
00:41:16 And he just said, hey, I'm going to go ahead and take some some treatment, some classes, something like that.
00:41:20 And it goes away. That's what typically happens.
00:41:22 But now because they had video of it.
00:41:24 I mean, that's like there was no contesting it.
00:41:27 They he took videos of it is what the prosecutor said.
00:41:30 And the videos were still on his phone.
00:41:32 Seems like the I could be wrong about this, but my my memory is that the events happened in 2023 between K.J. and some family member, the alleged forcible incest, and that the case maybe wasn't resolved until 2025.
00:41:50 five. But he all that time had the videos still on his phone. And it sounds like they had him
00:41:55 dead to rights when he went in there and had no choice but to give it up. And understanding in
00:42:00 juvie, the penalties, I guess, will always be something rather mild, even for something as
00:42:04 disturbing as this. Oh, yeah. No, they're definitely something mild. And in juvenile
00:42:08 court, you don't get a jury trial. So you have a judge trial. So you typically don't see people
00:42:12 going to trial on these cases. You see them working it out. And the reason is they're kids.
00:42:17 They usually are in need of some type of treatment, and that's what juvenile justice system is really for.
00:42:23 And so now we've got a case where he's, you know, marginal.
00:42:26 He's 15, and I think he was just barely 15.
00:42:28 His brain's still not formed, and so the question is whether or not do we lock him up and throw away the key for the rest of his life, or do we give the kid a chance?
00:42:35 He could stay in custody in juvenile court.
00:42:37 That's definitely a possibility, and that's why this is such a vital hearing, because if the defense wins, it does stay in juvenile court, and he is only able to stay in custody for a certain amount of time.
00:42:47 But, you know, I do think it's interesting that it's this county and there's certain counties that don't always prosecute kids as adults.
00:42:54 But Fulton County tends to do that. They always have.
00:42:57 Here's here's what I want to know, Viva. Where is the prosecution against these two derelict parents?
00:43:03 Truly, I mean, both of them with the with the volatile fight, every parent knows that that's a form of abuse against the children.
00:43:10 You know, if you've ever had a fight with your spouse in front of your child, you can see almost instantaneous tears.
00:43:17 A child never wants to see that.
00:43:19 It's abusive.
00:43:20 And I'll just give you one example of how bad it got in this family.
00:43:25 I'm going to show you one old clip and then I'm going to show you a new one.
00:43:27 Here's SOT 12 first.
00:43:29 This is from December 2023, right around the time when the alleged forced incest was happening.
00:43:35 We're just having an argument.
00:43:36 About what?
00:43:37 About our life.
00:43:39 Okay, what happened?
00:43:40 this is my life it's destroyed because this right here does nothing but fuel her
00:43:46 i'm not doing this this is narcissistic behavior i'm not doing this i'm just trying to figure out
00:43:55 what there's nothing to do you shouldn't even be here who called you your kids who what kid
00:44:02 you have kids i don't know whoever's in the house
00:44:06 we've been outside this whole time what what what what was the argument about our life
00:44:12 what our life and it's destroyed why why is it getting so heated because our life is destroyed
00:44:19 what don't you understand there's no money there's no house she wants we're getting divorced one day
00:44:28 we're not the next okay other men what do you want just calm down calm down but i don't have a
00:44:34 life. What's going on? I just like, he's just been screaming at me for like two hours, like
00:44:41 a crazy person, like a crazy person. Okay. So there's that. And here's what they were doing
00:44:49 on their reality TV show. She wasn't enough that she was on the Real Housewives of Atlanta.
00:44:54 Then she launched a spinoff called Don't Be Tardy, uh, in which she, this Kim Zolciak,
00:45:00 the husband there who used to play for the Atlanta Falcons, Croy Bierman, the father, K.J.,
00:45:05 and she's the mother of K.J., and they've got two other younger kids, and then they've got two,
00:45:10 she's got, I think, two older daughters she brought into the marriage.
00:45:13 This is a clip from Don't Be Tardy when K.J., our now 15-year-old defendant, was just a little boy.
00:45:19 Watch this, dot 10.
00:45:20 It is loaded with camping supplies.
00:45:24 You can fit our whole family in there.
00:45:26 That's a really great place to have sex or hide presents.
00:45:30 in my house, when you have six kids and a lot of staff.
00:45:38 This is paradise right here for me.
00:45:41 The pool I have at 98 degrees right now
00:45:43 because I hate cold water.
00:45:44 I put some bling in the pool too.
00:45:47 But it's pretty cool, it's really private,
00:45:48 nobody can see in the pool,
00:45:49 so we can skinny dip when we want.
00:45:53 When y'all aren't around.
00:45:58 This is the basketball court.
00:46:00 That the boys love.
00:46:01 Right, Cash and K.J.?
00:46:02 Okay, show me.
00:46:05 Come on.
00:46:06 Go, K.J., go, K.J., go, go, go, go, go.
00:46:11 And it's so sad to me.
00:46:12 There he is as a little boy.
00:46:14 And look, no one knows for sure what happened to K.J.,
00:46:17 but if he molested a sibling or a family member,
00:46:22 the odds are overwhelming that he was molested himself.
00:46:25 And I just, like, this whole thing gives me the feeling
00:46:28 that we are prosecuting the wrong person somebody hurt this kid before he started hurting other
00:46:35 family members and now as a result of that history and clearly it's as a result of that history
00:46:41 he's looking at 25 years in prison because this girl made an allegation against him and i again
00:46:46 i don't weigh in on whether that charge looks good or bad it sounds like the defense attorney
00:46:50 feels very confident he can defend the case don't know zero reason to doubt her claim other than
00:46:56 what the defense is saying so but this is just you look at the history viva and it's infuriating
00:47:00 it looks like degeneracy it looks like hyper sexualization if not of the children in the
00:47:05 presence of children the only yes but i would issue the caution you don't want to criminalize
00:47:10 degeneracy and you don't want to criminalize bad parenting because then you'll get into situations
00:47:14 of you know a nanny government criminalizing a mother who let her five-year-old kid go to a pond
00:47:19 to pick up feathers or who left a 14 year old in charge of a 10 year old it looks like clear
00:47:25 degenerate behavior and true i mean at some point you say hurt people hurt people
00:47:30 but at some point in time you don't care why the person hurts somebody you know hard judges will
00:47:36 judge hard and so we're where are we are where we are at the moment you can try to like avoid that
00:47:41 moment in the future for other people with this kid in particular hyper sexualized potentially
00:47:46 molested who knows you started off with these allegations against a 15 year old girl and
00:47:51 everyone said okay we'll take this as a case on its own and judge it on its merits then you find
00:47:55 out that there was alleged forced incest earlier on. And then you say, okay, is this kid now just
00:48:01 a menace to society for the rest of his life? Blame the parents all you want. What do you do
00:48:04 with this kid? Do you try him as an adult or do you try to rehabilitate him and see if he relapses
00:48:08 a third time when he's 18? But it is just disgusting. These reality shows make everyone
00:48:13 look happy and successful. And by and large, the people doing these flexes are the most degenerates
00:48:18 behind closed doors or behind, you know, behind their own homes. But it does have an impact on
00:48:23 the kids. But at some point in time, I don't care why the kid turned into a criminal. If the kid's
00:48:27 a criminal, it needs to be dealt with as a criminal. The only question is how. I know.
00:48:31 You know, Megan, that's the reality. That's actually a really good, the observation about
00:48:35 the parents being somewhat responsible is a really good reason to send it to juvenile court.
00:48:40 And the point is, in juvenile court, the parents here in Georgia, they're actually part of the
00:48:44 process. And so they actually are served with notice. They have to attend court. They're
00:48:49 mandated to participate if the case goes to juvenile court. Different in adult court. In adult
00:48:53 court, they don't ever have to show up. They don't have to do anything. So there is some precedent for
00:48:58 it sending to juvenile court, the case being sent to juvenile court, because then the parents have
00:49:02 to actually be involved in whatever the punishment is. I mean, they don't go to jail, but they can
00:49:06 be mandated to be part of like family therapy, you know, treatment. They have to actually go to
00:49:10 court and face reality if they're responsible for what's happening. Can they be made to get
00:49:14 some therapy? I think it feels like the parents need some psychiatric interventions like ASAP.
00:49:19 One of the interesting things about juvenile court, to Ashley's point, is that, yes, you can require certain things.
00:49:25 You get a there is at least theoretically a collaborative kind of program to it.
00:49:34 Oh, Lord. I'm just trying to picture that.
00:49:36 Well, I understand. But I look in California, 25 years ago, we had what was called Prop 21,
00:49:45 where you could do direct filing in certain cases, specifically murder of 15 and 16 year olds that I took that up to the court of appeal to have it invalidated, because I think that a lot of times what happens is if that's what you're going to do, if you're going to start direct filing in adult court of 13, 14 and 15 year olds, then you better be prepared to throw them away forever.
00:50:12 And if that's what you want to do as a policy, I understand there are a lot of people who have that urge, but I just think it's kind of short sighted.
00:50:23 You know, my father used to say was my hero. You want to stop crime?
00:50:28 Just put all males at 16 or 25 in custody and you'll stop crying.
00:50:35 That's, you know, it's true. It's not generally the women who are doing it.
00:50:38 We're up against a break. But Ashley, tell us quickly what happened with Brian Steele, KJ's new lawyer.
00:50:43 Yeah, so he got in trouble during the YSL, the young thug trial, and he was being held in contempt and the judge was locking him up.
00:50:50 And I at the time was the president of the Georgia Association of Criminal Defense Lawyers.
00:50:53 And we have a group that goes and defends lawyers.
00:50:56 And so I was the one that took it upon myself to represent Brian.
00:51:00 And we won. We got it overturned at the Supreme Court.
00:51:03 So he never had to spend a day in jail, but he is my forever client.
00:51:07 And by the way, just so you remember, I fell in love with Ashley when she cross-examined
00:51:14 in the Fonnie Willis trial, if you will, because I call her Fonnie Willis.
00:51:19 Yes, same.
00:51:19 But she really showed her chops when she faced down that judge as Brian was undressing,
00:51:27 basically to go into custody.
00:51:29 That's where Ashley is forever memorialized.
00:51:32 He was, and I'm not going to lie.
00:51:34 But it sounds like, look, as we saw from their, you know, immense property, it appears these two
00:51:40 do have means. I'm sure playing for the Atlanta Falcons and the stints on reality TV have given
00:51:45 them some decent cash. So Brian Steele doesn't come cheap, undoubtedly. And he's now KJ's lawyer
00:51:51 and good for KJ because he's going to need a good one. You know how much I love a great true crime
00:51:57 podcast? Well, I want to tell you about one that's making a return this month on a horrifying
00:52:03 family annihilator story full of shocking twists. The award-winning team behind the
00:52:09 Father Wants Us Dead podcast is back for season two, this time covering the story of Paul Canero,
00:52:17 or Uncle Paul. In 2018, firefighters responded to a burning mansion in the upscale small town
00:52:24 of Colts Neck, New Jersey. They made a shocking discovery. A family of four had been massacred,
00:52:29 and not by a stranger, but by a loved one. The reporters take you inside a world of brotherly
00:52:35 love, betrayal, money, and murder as they try to answer the question at the heart of this case,
00:52:41 why? The first season of Father Wants Us Dead was called one of the best true crime podcasts
00:52:46 by Entertainment Weekly. I agree. Now enjoy this new season, Father Wants Us Dead, season two,
00:52:54 Uncle Paul. It's available now on Apple, Spotify, and wherever you get your podcasts.
00:52:59 go and binge it today. Our sponsor, the Electronic Payments Coalition, says Washington politicians are
00:53:06 always getting in your wallet, and now they're messing with your credit card. They say your
00:53:10 credit card and the security it offers are under attack, and that Senators Dick Durbin and Roger
00:53:15 Marshall want to change the nation's payment system to benefit corporate megastores like
00:53:19 Walmart and Target at the expense of everyday Americans. Credit cards can keep your payments
00:53:25 secure and provide rewards that families use to help make everyday purchases more affordable.
00:53:29 The Electronic Payments Coalition says the Durbin Marshall mandates would let corporate megastores
00:53:34 cut corners on credit card processing, routing transactions over cheaper, untested networks
00:53:40 with weaker security and fewer protections. Find out more at guardyourcard.com
00:53:45 and consider telling Congress to guard your card.
00:53:59 second my team goes up big with early payout and can cash out at any time before the game ends
00:54:04 come on steve bet 365 the home of winning early must be 19 and older ontario only please play
00:54:12 responsibly if you or someone you know has concerns about gambling visit connects ontario.ca
00:54:15 or call 1-866-531-2600 terms and conditions apply in communities across canada hourly amazon
00:54:23 employees earn an average of over $26 an hour. Employees also have the opportunity to grow their
00:54:31 skills and their paycheck by enrolling in free skills training programs for in-demand fields
00:54:36 like software development and information technology. Learn more at aboutamazon.ca.
00:54:44 now a deep dive into one of the most explosive me too cases ever to surface and then fall apart
00:55:00 and whether the man at the center of it deserves to get his job back david sabatini was once one
00:55:06 of the most celebrated scientists in america a professor at mit and a pioneering researcher
00:55:12 at the prestigious Whitehead Institute for Biomedical Research,
00:55:16 a lab affiliated with the university.
00:55:18 This is how the Boston Globe described his impact
00:55:21 in an article published in 2023.
00:55:23 Quote, the best young scientists from across the world
00:55:26 yearned to work in his lab,
00:55:29 an electric place that untangled cellular mysteries
00:55:32 critical in the study of neurodegenerative diseases,
00:55:35 cancer, diabetes, and aging.
00:55:37 Many believed Sabatini was on his way
00:55:40 to eventually winning the Nobel Prize.
00:55:42 But then over the course of several weeks in 2021,
00:55:46 his career came crashing down.
00:55:49 At the center of the scandal was a relationship Sabatini had
00:55:52 with a fellow scientist, Kristen Knauss.
00:55:57 Sabatini and Knauss first met in 2012.
00:56:01 But in March of 2018,
00:56:03 they ended up having a sexual relationship
00:56:05 after a night of drinking.
00:56:08 At the time, he was 50 and separated from his wife.
00:56:11 She was 30 and single.
00:56:14 Per the Boston Globe, quote,
00:56:15 they continued to see each other for occasional sex
00:56:18 and kept their meetings secret.
00:56:20 They agreed that they were not an exclusive couple.
00:56:23 Over roughly the next year and a half,
00:56:25 they slept together about 10 to 15 times,
00:56:28 according to accounts each later gave to investigators.
00:56:31 A few months after their first encounter,
00:56:34 Whitehead, the lab they both worked for,
00:56:36 amended its rules to take a hard stance against even consensual relationships,
00:56:42 even if the faculty members held similar titles, which these two did at the time.
00:56:48 Despite knowing this, Sabatini and Naus carried on their sexual relationship.
00:56:54 Eventually, Naus began texting Sabatini that she wanted to be an actual couple.
00:57:01 But unfortunately for him, Sabatini did not.
00:57:06 During one text exchange, Sabatini told her he was pursuing another woman named Lena.
00:57:14 Naus, texting Sabatini, wrote, quote, I get anxious when I don't hear back from you.
00:57:20 My only thought is for me to pull away and cut contact.
00:57:24 Sabatini responded, quote, you need to chill out and let fate take its course.
00:57:29 Things with Lena have been interesting.
00:57:31 Yes, we've kissed, but nothing's happened.
00:57:33 I need to spend more time with her to understand what we mean to each other.
00:57:37 A few weeks later, Sabatini told Naus he was in a serious relationship with Lena,
00:57:43 whom he would eventually marry.
00:57:45 Well, being upfront with Naus did not go the way that Sabatini planned.
00:57:49 Naus eventually came to view the relationship in a different light,
00:57:54 believing Sabatini had exploited and sexually harassed her.
00:58:00 She met with a Title IX lawyer and other university officials.
00:58:04 She claimed that while they basically had the same titles at the university,
00:58:08 their age difference, the fact that he had once mentored her,
00:58:12 and his stature at the university made for a power imbalance.
00:58:18 Around this same time, she texted a friend, quote,
00:58:21 I am out for blood at this point.
00:58:24 In January 2021, Whitehead launched an investigation into Sabatini.
00:58:30 In the end, investigators concluded that Sabatini had violated Whitehead's sexual harassment policy when it came to this relationship.
00:58:38 They also concluded that his lab had developed a problematic culture involving sexualized discussions and fear of retaliation.
00:58:48 retaliation. Before this incident, the Boston Globe reported Sabatini had no prior misconduct
00:58:55 allegations during his 24-year career at Whitehead. Sabatini disputed the findings that there'd been
00:59:02 any sort of violation, arguing the investigation had misrepresented both his relationship with
00:59:08 Knauss and the broader laboratory environment. In August 2021, Sabatini resigned from Whitehead
00:59:15 after learning that Whitehead was preparing to fire him.
00:59:19 His lab was immediately dismantled, years of research gone, his reputation in tatters.
00:59:27 MIT launched its own investigation, but relied on the investigative report produced by Whitehead.
00:59:33 And in April 2022, Sabatini resigned from MIT as well, after administrators recommended revoking his tenure.
00:59:42 The professional punishment was so severe and so swift, Sabatini recently told the Daily Mail he tried to take his own life.
00:59:52 But in October 2021, Sabatini decided to go on offense.
00:59:57 He sued Kristen Knauss for defamation, claiming the false allegations had destroyed his livelihood and maintaining what she was saying about him was indeed entirely false.
01:00:12 that she had grossly mischaracterized their relationship at every turn.
01:00:18 Last month, a jury reached a verdict in that case.
01:00:22 After a three-week trial, a jury of seven women and six men found
01:00:26 Naus had defamed Sabatini and interfered with his work.
01:00:31 He was awarded $6 million in damages plus prejudgment interest,
01:00:37 bringing the total to just under $10 million and counting.
01:00:42 According to the Boston Globe, the amount of interest grows by over $3,000 a day.
01:00:47 She is appealing the decision.
01:00:50 Since the verdict, Naus' deposition testimony and text messages have come to light.
01:00:57 And they are devastating to her and the narrative she tried to spin.
01:01:04 In messages to friends, she once described her campaign to get back at Sabatini as covert
01:01:10 operation dethroned. She told a friend, quote, my lawyer straight up told MIT, you have a rapist
01:01:15 on your faculty. She referred to the backlash against him as being Weinsteined out of science,
01:01:22 comparing him to convicted rapist Harvey Weinstein. She also joked about buying a Lambo,
01:01:28 meaning a Lamborghini, if she won a settlement because she had countersued Sabatini.
01:01:34 As far as the depositions, in this first clip we're about to show you, Naus has questioned about once texting Sabatini that she couldn't wait to wake up and feel like she's being gang raped.
01:01:48 You wrote, I can't wait to wake up tomorrow and feel like I've been gang raped. Ice down your perineum, mighty one. What is that supposed to mean?
01:01:59 We had been at the gym earlier and had done a bunch of squats.
01:02:03 It's referring to the fact that I'm looking forward to feeling sore from being at the gym.
01:02:08 Feeling like you've been gang raped?
01:02:11 That's what that means?
01:02:13 I think I was just referring to feeling like I had been like just roughed up at the gym.
01:02:21 Ah.
01:02:22 Now she was also asked about texting Sabatini about liking rough sex
01:02:27 and about texting a friend about wanting Sabatini to thrust harder into her.
01:02:32 Watch this.
01:02:33 You would tell Dr. Sabatini that you really liked sex to be hard, right?
01:02:41 Objection.
01:02:42 I would have to see the cases in which I said that.
01:02:45 I'm asking you, did you say it?
01:02:48 I imagine I would, you know, say that I was open to more, like, rougher sex.
01:02:55 And you wrote something along those lines in text messages to Marty Taylor about your asking a sexual partner other than Dr. Sabatini to thrust harder into the left or something.
01:03:10 I believe I was actually referring to Dr. Sabatini, but I certainly wasn't going to tell that to Marty.
01:03:17 Okay, but you talked about that, wanting a sexual partner to thrust harder on a text message with this man who you're saying you were sort of afraid of.
01:03:29 Yeah, good point.
01:03:32 Naus was also questioned about picking and choosing which text exchanges she would give to investigators.
01:03:40 She conveniently left out the messages that showed the sex with Sabatini was entirely consensual.
01:03:49 Watch.
01:03:50 Why are you trying to confirm the number of his room at 135 in the morning?
01:03:56 He told me you can knock and I wanted to confirm that I knocked on the right door.
01:04:00 Why did you want to knock on his door?
01:04:03 I said I'm about to walk by your room and he said you can knock.
01:04:07 You wanted to have sex with him, did you not?
01:04:09 Objection.
01:04:10 I don't recall or remember what my motive was this.
01:04:14 I mentioned in that moment, I mentioned I'm walking by your room,
01:04:17 and he said, you can knock, and I decided I would knock.
01:04:22 I came into his room, and evidently we did end up having sex.
01:04:27 Why do you say evidently? You don't remember?
01:04:30 No, I do remember that we did, and it's clear from the text messages that we did.
01:04:35 Did you give this text chain to the White House investigators in connection with your conversations about what happened at the Whitehead retreat?
01:04:46 No, I didn't.
01:04:48 Right.
01:04:50 Now, she was also asked about once texting Sabatini about how, quote, insanely revved she was to have sex with him, her alleged abuser.
01:05:00 But again, failed to give investigators full context about that when they came knocking.
01:05:07 And you omitted a whole lot of other stuff that was in these text chains when you gave it to Hickley Allen, did you not?
01:05:15 There are surely texts before and after, but I didn't intentionally omit them.
01:05:22 Well, let's look at the rest of it.
01:05:25 The top, David Sabatini, damn you, left me crazy.
01:05:29 your response as you do for me on a daily basis and then you wrote tuck your parents in and get
01:05:35 an uber i can demethylate soft sweet side what does demethylate mean so when genes are repressed
01:05:45 they're methylated and so i think what i'm referring to here is i can be i can be soft
01:05:54 and sweet david writes back sunday or friday kristin says god damn it now i'm crazy revved
01:06:02 been insanely revved the past week fuck you too david yeah me with the pain down there
01:06:09 i read all that correctly yes and you're saying it's an accident that you didn't include everything
01:06:16 that led up to it that we just read i believe again they wanted evidence that he was requesting
01:06:22 sex in the Whitehead Institute and I just went and found this and grabbed that you didn't want
01:06:28 them to see you talking about being revved up and clearly wanting sex yourself I think I actually
01:06:36 produced text where I am exhibiting that I was feeling that way in other exchanges I was not
01:06:43 trying to hide that and in fact there's other parts here where he's proposing the office that
01:06:49 I didn't include either. I just found one part and took it. It's unbelievable. She was also asked
01:06:57 about once texting Sabatini a message that read, he too, after sex, basically insinuating she had
01:07:04 just sexually assaulted him. Then you write, in hindsight, it was quite aggressive.
01:07:10 um slash he too what did that mean again i was i think i was making a joke about the fact that
01:07:21 i was more forward in that encounter that i was stopping by his room in contrast to you know
01:07:29 up until this point he was always coming to my apartment this is incredible that is far from the
01:07:36 only evidence showing Naus's deliberate plot to destroy Sabatini, who remains to this moment
01:07:43 fired from the lab, no longer with MIT, where she still has a job. How is that possible?
01:07:53 Back with me now, Ashley Merchant, Viva Frye, and Mark Garagos. I mean, thank God that Sabatini
01:08:00 filed that civil lawsuit against her and got all of those admissions on cam and got all of her text
01:08:07 messages proving how malicious she was against him behind the scenes viva rarely could a man accused
01:08:16 find that kind of a treasure trove of admissions and she has been thoroughly discredited and
01:08:23 disgraced but is still employed unlike david sabatini you know megan when johnny depp sued
01:08:29 amber heard and i said you know these things always get ugly for everyone involved and yet
01:08:34 somehow johnny depp just you know revealed evidence proving his total innocence and that
01:08:38 he was a victim in all of this this would be one of those cases as well where it's it's always
01:08:42 risky especially when you're sort of when you're boning staff and you have sex with people you work
01:08:47 with did you say boning rarely used description here on the show shipping but in the legal sense
01:08:54 i don't know who's gonna get that one um look it's always dangerous to have sex with staff
01:09:01 period you invite this type of trouble it doesn't mean you deserve it but the pathological nature
01:09:06 of this woman to say like evidently we just had sex it's what a sociopath does they never do
01:09:12 anything yes oh yeah i went by his room and sex was had i mean it's not like i consented to it
01:09:17 and then for it afterwards and this idea of the arguing the balance uh imbalance of power which
01:09:24 which there's probably that dynamic as well there's also the imbalance of power of youth
01:09:28 of attraction of what a woman and a young attractive woman can hold over older men that
01:09:33 it's not like they don't have their respective forces in this relationship but it was i mean
01:09:38 grotesque uh totally unjust she has not yet gotten what she deserved and good luck for him to collect
01:09:44 the six million bucks from her i don't know if she has insurance that's going to cover it but i
01:09:47 don't think he's going to get much of that six or ten million dollars now they he alleged ashley in
01:09:53 his suit against her. Dr. Knauss not infrequently made sexual, gender-based, or dirty comments to
01:10:02 Dr. Sabatini by text. Now, we saw some of that in the exchanges I just played. In one exchange,
01:10:07 she suggested, quote, testicle toss or cornhole as games for the Whitehead lab. She wrote such
01:10:15 comments to others, including a visiting postdoc in the Sabatini lab to whom she commented that
01:10:22 she had a need, quote, for more dick in my life, end quote, forgive me, and sent him pictures of
01:10:28 wallpaper decorated with penises. Despite this, the investigators did not make any finding that
01:10:34 Dr. Knauss had violated the Whitehead sexual harassment policy. So this, they think all of
01:10:42 that was fine for her to do, but he wasn't allowed to have a consensual, obviously consensual
01:10:48 sexual relationship with this fully empowered 30-year-old.
01:10:53 It's a joke. This is absolutely ridiculous. And she is still being protected by this university.
01:10:58 I mean, they've got to come up with some better system for vetting these claims.
01:11:02 And it goes back to Russell Brand, Cornell 7. We've been talking about this a lot. These he
01:11:06 said, she says are really taking over our newsfeed right now. And this is just an example of how
01:11:12 patently unfair the entire system is, from the criminal justice system all the way to the sexual
01:11:18 harassment, to these Title IXs, everything. It's he said, she said. There is an intense power
01:11:23 dynamic. And unfortunately, all of the rules, because we had such a history of the rules being
01:11:29 one way and women not really being heard, now we've gone so far awry the other way that you've
01:11:35 got situations like this, where she's the one that's really doing a lot towards him, and he's
01:11:41 the one that suffers. It's absolutely insane. And I think as a society, we have to take a really
01:11:45 close look at how we're handling these types of claims and stop just believing the she said.
01:11:50 That's not enough. Mark, he recently gave an interview with Fox 25 Boston and said something
01:11:59 very interesting. Because I'm telling you, as Viva said, she'd have to be like a sociopath,
01:12:04 this woman and she does she is definitely giving bunny boiler vibes um and listen to sabatini
01:12:11 talking about where he made his mistake with this woman uh in this interview he just gave
01:12:16 what do you regret do you regret this was a younger scientist who looked up to you do you
01:12:24 regret ever having a relationship with her i certainly regret having a relation for her 100
01:12:28 100%. I also, really, the biggest procedural mistake that we both made was that when the
01:12:35 Whitehead Institute changed their policy and said that if you run a lab, which she ran a lab,
01:12:40 I ran a lab, you cannot date anyone in the building. This happened in August of 2021. We
01:12:45 had started dating in April of 2021. Sorry, 2018. Sorry, April of 2018. And they changed the rules
01:12:52 in August of 2018. They just sent an email saying this. She and I discussed this. I said,
01:12:59 we have to end this. She said, no one knows. It doesn't matter. That was a fundamental mistake
01:13:03 at that point. But she violated the same rule. She was also a lab head.
01:13:08 Wait, this is actually what I wanted to read to you because it was a statement he gave to
01:13:12 the Daily Mail. Listen to this. He says, I think if I had to pick a red flag, the number one would
01:13:18 be that she criticized pretty much everyone, from her students, to her friends, to her faculty
01:13:22 members, to people in my lab, to her mentor, to her parents. I realize now that if someone does
01:13:28 that, they're probably also turning against you at times. I thought we were friends. We had frank
01:13:33 discussions. I obviously criticize people too. It's a normal thing to dish on other people with
01:13:37 someone you're really close to, but maybe the degree of that from her was much greater than I
01:13:42 realized her reactions to things that other people did were really strong, and I didn't quite capture
01:13:49 that. He added that Naus would also tell him that, quote, other faculty members were sexually
01:13:55 harassing her. I should have thought more carefully about that. That was a red flag because you don't
01:14:01 say that about people. I mean, these are red flags that other men should take into account,
01:14:06 like right now as we speak. I'm sure this is happening to somebody else, but this is not
01:14:12 a well person, in my opinion. I, you know, I, I don't know that I would go so far as to say
01:14:18 sociopath or not. Well, I just think it's part of the grift. We're kind of in, you know, I see it
01:14:25 all the times I've been, I've defended people against it all the time. There is this kind of
01:14:31 grift machine where you make the allegation, you tell them you've got until, you know, 10 days to
01:14:38 either engage in a confidential mediation, or you're going to get out of it, or you're going
01:14:44 to go public. You understand what the various kind of hot buttons are to push. You get, I'm sure
01:14:52 Ashley has cross-examined experts like I have, where the expert gets up there and just any reaction
01:14:58 after any kind of sexual encounter is fair game for it's a power dynamic or it's this kind of a
01:15:08 unfair dynamic in some way. There is no wrong reaction that you can't cast in these kinds of
01:15:17 harassment type settings. And we've reached a point where the sublime has become the ridiculous.
01:15:23 And this is a perfect example. And and I told some of the young lawyers in my office, watch this, these depositions, because this lawyer does a very and I wish I knew her name to give her a shout out because she does do a good job.
01:15:37 She does a really good job of doing it the way you should. You don't need to hassle or mock her, which is what I would do.
01:15:43 All you've got to do is just ask her the questions that are so ridiculous.
01:15:48 Oh, you just walked by the room and you wanted to know what the number was.
01:15:52 And did you happen to have sex?
01:15:54 I don't know if I'd say I mean, the grift gets exposed the more you just ask the questions, which are utterly ridiculous.
01:16:02 The problem is most people, to your point, until they're cornered, until they've lost everything, don't have the ability to fight back and don't have a lawyer.
01:16:14 Mark, you you and I both know David Sabatini was probably in the fetal position just telegraphing.
01:16:20 I'm sorry. I'm sorry, because he did have an affair, which was against the rules with a colleague.
01:16:26 And he knew all men know how vulnerable they are when someone with whom they actually have had a sexual relationship is now playing this card.
01:16:35 And more should seriously consider the Johnny Depp, David Sabatini route and fight back.
01:16:42 Like, this guy's never going to get his millions because she doesn't have that kind of money, as far as I know, although she did.
01:16:47 Well, the only downside from her father.
01:16:49 Yeah, the only way I'd criticize it, maybe it's because I don't know enough, is I would have included the employer here.
01:16:55 I would have included somebody with a deep pocket or somebody to tap an insurance policy here because the employer enabled all of this by the shenanigans they engaged in.
01:17:09 and basically making it so it was one sided.
01:17:13 I mean, there is I guess he did name Whitehead, but for some reason it got thrown out.
01:17:17 I don't know why. But I mean, that doesn't stop MIT from doing the right thing right now,
01:17:21 which is this woman should go. She's obviously not an honest broker.
01:17:26 How can they have her teaching at MIT?
01:17:28 And David Sabatini should be restored to his tenured position immediately.
01:17:34 There's a lot of pressure on the university to do this.
01:17:37 I only hope that they will. I want to give you one soundbite, Mark, that we didn't play of
01:17:42 the cross-examination at deposition of Knauss by this lawyer on the subject of how she was
01:17:50 very selective in giving her messages over to investigators. Like, somehow she only found
01:17:56 relevant the ones that didn't make her look awful. She's like the New York Times. You only
01:18:01 release what suits the narrative. And it happens all the time. Wait, let's watch. This is where
01:18:09 she got cross-examined about that favored practice of hers, SOT 16.
01:18:14 Did you give this text change to the investigators in connection with your conversations
01:18:21 about what happened at the Whitehead retreat? No, I didn't. You didn't want the Whitehead
01:18:30 investigators to know that you actually at the Whitehead retreat went into Dr. Sabatini's room
01:18:37 at night and had sex with him. Do you recall that after this encounter you communicated to Dr.
01:18:45 Sabatini that I know what I want and I go after it? I believe I said that to him in a text message.
01:18:53 And that was about showing up at his room at 1 30 in the morning to have sex with him was it not?
01:18:58 Now, this chat exchange you also did not give to the Hinkley-Allen investigators, correct?
01:19:07 That is correct.
01:19:08 And then you put in another small excerpt that is just the two, the back and forth,
01:19:15 where Dr. Sabatini says, agree about being careful, and you said, I can do that,
01:19:20 but I think most other things I have to respectfully decline.
01:19:23 you left it at
01:19:26 I'm too young and vulnerable
01:19:28 right?
01:19:30 that is where it ends
01:19:31 and then where Dr. Sabatini says to you
01:19:34 okay, up to you
01:19:35 you didn't give them that part
01:19:37 I didn't include that, no
01:19:39 because you didn't want
01:19:43 the white investigators to see
01:19:45 that Dr. Sabatini wasn't coercing you
01:19:47 in that instance, correct?
01:19:49 I was trying to make my own judgments
01:19:51 about what was relevant. So you just cut and pasted a text chain, as it were, screenshotting
01:19:58 the parts that you liked and not screenshotting the parts you didn't like.
01:20:06 Devastating. Like I say, that lawyer gets props from me. I would not have been able to restrain.
01:20:12 It's Lisa Arrowwood, Mark. I would not have been able to restrain myself about her definition of
01:20:18 irrelevance means anything that looks bad for me, I'm going to exclude. And when I was joking
01:20:25 about the New York Times, all you got to do is take a look at this Cornell situation. It's the
01:20:30 exact same thing that the journalists do. They cherry pick. And this is, by the way, for people
01:20:35 who don't know what cherry pick means, this is the definition of cherry picking what looks good
01:20:42 and doesn't undermine your narrative and it's a it's repulsive i'll just push back
01:20:47 you know in terms of diagnosing her as a narcissist or whatever look this there's
01:20:52 social and clinical diagnoses she's clearly socially a narcissist where it's deny attack
01:20:57 reverse victim and offender and she's always the victim you know the sabatini did in fact
01:21:03 miss some red flags when all someone does is complain about other people prior employers
01:21:07 prior relationships when it's always someone else's fault you know they're going to be saying
01:21:11 that about you in the future and so he didn't it's a red flag of all red flags you know the
01:21:16 expression if you run into one bad driver before noon it's probably then if you run into five it's
01:21:20 you like he he should have known that from the get-go and he ignored it probably because he was
01:21:25 just he was blinded by sex with a young woman and i can make it simpler this violates one of
01:21:31 my cardinal rules and i literally tell this probably at least once a week in my office i
01:21:35 have a rule. Don't F crazy. Like literally. Yeah. Yeah. I mean, don't. That's what my therapist
01:21:43 says. He doesn't say F. He says, stay away from crazy. Oh, well, I say the whole thing. And even
01:21:46 on the show, like when I'm doing my like segments, I try to stay away from like things I think are
01:21:52 truly crazy. Like people I think are truly crazy. And sometimes you can't like this is this case.
01:21:56 We've been trying to get to this for a while now, but yes, it's true. And you know, I think most men
01:22:02 have a sliding scale where the hotter the woman, the more crazy they'll deal with.
01:22:08 100%. I've had that conversation so many times.
01:22:10 I think that's universally true, right? But like, still not worth it. Like reassess, reassess.
01:22:16 Plenty of women out there.
01:22:18 And this woman, so we're laughing now because thank God David Sabatini did restore his good
01:22:24 name. But it has been no laughing matter, as you guys know. And Ashley, listen to him. Listen to
01:22:29 him talking in that same Fox 25 Boston interview about what happened to him. Here's SOT 18 into
01:22:38 19, I think it is. Watch. I lost all the positions I had, whether they were the scientific ones,
01:22:46 MIT, HHMI, which was my major funder, Whitehead, all those positions I lost. I lost all the
01:22:53 positions I had at biotech companies that either I had started or I was on their scientific advisory
01:22:59 boards i lost all the shares that i would have gotten i lost every position for example i had
01:23:05 with journals in which i was on their editorial boards i lost that i lost control of all the
01:23:10 manuscripts they were writing i was stripped of those manuscripts not only my communications with
01:23:15 the editors were disconnected but they literally removed all my affiliations i appear on those
01:23:20 papers just as a name with no phone number no email no address just this hanging name which
01:23:25 is worse than what they do if you die. If you die, they put your affiliation and they put an
01:23:29 asterisk deceased. I lost everything. There was nothing left of my normal life. Nothing. As I
01:23:38 told you, I don't wish her ill. I also, the irony of the situation is that whatever she's going
01:23:44 through, which I'm sure is not pleasant, I am probably one of the few people in the world who
01:23:49 know what she's going through. And if it's at all what I went through, it is beyond horrible.
01:23:54 and you wouldn't wish that on your worst enemy.
01:24:00 You know, the difference is I am happy for our success in this.
01:24:04 People are happy for me.
01:24:06 I am not celebrating her destruction.
01:24:09 I'm celebrating our doing well.
01:24:12 And when I was destroyed, she celebrated my destruction.
01:24:18 I mean, I just feel so, yeah, you can't help but feel so bad for him.
01:24:23 And he clearly has gone through some therapy to be able to almost, it sounds like, almost forgive her.
01:24:27 It's crazy.
01:24:28 But he deserves every dime that he can get out of her.
01:24:32 What's going to happen, Ashley?
01:24:33 Because she doesn't have $10 million as far as we know.
01:24:36 She's, you know, with interest now, it's $10 million.
01:24:39 They do say, my information at least, is that she did come into this, like I said, this inheritance.
01:24:45 So, I don't know.
01:24:47 You can get an inheritance unless a trust has been set up just so.
01:24:51 Right.
01:24:51 So he should get some remuneration.
01:24:53 And he can dock her wages.
01:24:55 He could.
01:24:55 He could definitely dock her wages.
01:24:56 And I think that's probably where he would see the most from it.
01:24:59 He's not ever going to recover the judgment that he got.
01:25:01 I mean, hopefully it'll give him some peace.
01:25:03 He can't take her home.
01:25:04 She's got homestead protection in Massachusetts.
01:25:07 So she's allowed to.
01:25:07 I know he already did that.
01:25:09 Yeah.
01:25:09 So take her home.
01:25:10 Now I get it.
01:25:11 Yeah, I was with you.
01:25:12 I was with you, Megan.
01:25:13 I thought I don't think he's taking her home, even if he's forgiven.
01:25:16 Oh, yeah.
01:25:17 Cannot take her house.
01:25:19 Cannot take her house.
01:25:20 Yes, yes, yes.
01:25:21 um here's here's one other thing the the damage goes on he tried to get a job at myu which
01:25:31 normally would have been on its knees thanking god that it was getting this kind of a scholar
01:25:36 from mit but instead look what happened when word got out that they were just thinking about hiring
01:25:43 david sabatini i'm showing video here of throngs of students and others standing out there
01:25:50 half of them have masks on um with their anti david sabatini signs like word had spread that
01:25:59 this guy was some sort of a predator i mean the the line of people standing there to protest him
01:26:03 goes on and on and on and ultimately myu announced sabatini would not be joining its faculty there
01:26:11 were they reportedly this is april of 2022 200 students and faculty that was four years ago
01:26:17 it's not going to change yeah i doubt that mob is wait and here and here's one other thing guess
01:26:23 what he's doing now he's he has a new lab thanks to bill ackman and an anonymous donor who pledged
01:26:30 25 million to fund his research he had to move to prague oh my god he's now in pro like he he was
01:26:38 chased right out of the country because of this woman's vindictive streak because she was in my
01:26:45 opinion, pissed off about Lena. That's what I think this is about. He found a hotter,
01:26:52 more attractive model and married her. Hell has no fury like a one scorned. That's the other phrase.
01:26:57 Yeah. Kristen Naus was determined to make sure he understood that doesn't happen to her,
01:27:03 in my opinion. It's infuriating, Viva. Well, look, it's terrible. Not like that mob of students who
01:27:09 were protesting in 2022 are going to be familiar with the latest updates. He's going to carry that
01:27:14 stigma around with him because many people are just high level information or i should say high
01:27:18 level information low information uh viewers who will not know of the defamation case i do wonder
01:27:24 if she did have some liability insurance that might be able to pay some of this off but the
01:27:29 bottom line the power lies in the accusation the punishment is the process and him getting whatever
01:27:34 form of justice later on it's never going to undo that that lingering memory and the pressure
01:27:40 campaigns that will be waged against any future employer that bring him on even though he's been
01:27:43 totally exonerate. Let me just give you one final thing. I mean, I know the evidence that she lied
01:27:49 here is overwhelming, but just a couple of other pieces of color. She went and got therapy and the
01:27:55 notes were subpoenaed and her therapy notes were introduced in court. They showed her telling her
01:28:03 therapist that she wanted to continue receiving, quote, validation from such a powerful figure in
01:28:10 my career. When she began her casual relationship with Sabatini, which by the way, I don't know if
01:28:15 you picked up on it, but in that soundbite made clear, she went to his hotel room. She texted him
01:28:19 like wanting to come over. He agreed to let her, but she pursued him. It wasn't him coming on to
01:28:24 her. It was the opposite. And then she goes on to say, my pursuit of obtaining an unavailable man
01:28:31 is the ultimate validation of my perfection.
01:28:36 That's what was going on here.
01:28:38 And also, again, in my opinion,
01:28:41 his rejection of her in favor of Lena
01:28:44 was a bridge too far.
01:28:46 Hello, Glenn Close.
01:28:48 We see you've been exposed.
01:28:50 And by the way, if your child's going to MIT,
01:28:53 I would not allow this person
01:28:54 to go into this woman's classroom.
01:28:56 She does not seem to be playing with a full deck.
01:28:59 Cozy Earth has been an absolute game changer
01:29:01 in my home, making the bed and the couch infinitely more comfy. Now that cozy season is officially
01:29:06 here and the nights are getting colder, there are two specific pieces I need to tell you about.
01:29:11 First up, their bamboo sheet set, which can fix your hot sleeping. Stay perfectly cool,
01:29:16 sleep straight through the night without kicking off the covers, and getting out of bed in the
01:29:20 morning is going to be harder than ever in the best sense. Then there is their bubble cuddle
01:29:24 blanket. The weight, drape, and ultra plush texture are unreal. Everyone in your house is
01:29:30 going to love it. If you want to elevate your everyday living space, this is the ultimate
01:29:34 upgrade. Best of all, you can try Cozy Earth completely risk-free. They've got a 100-night
01:29:40 sleep trial and a 10-year warranty. Cozy Earth's biggest sale of the year ends soon,
01:29:46 December 3rd. Head on over to CozyEarth.com. Use the code Megan for 35% off home and sleepwear.
01:29:53 That's CozyEarth.com, code Megan. And when they ask to check out where you heard about them,
01:29:57 let them know we sent you. Getting sick is bad enough, but why does it happen at the worst
01:30:02 possible time? Your busiest week at work, the middle of the night, or when you're out of town,
01:30:07 and that's when the problems begin. Your doctor's booked, urgent care is packed,
01:30:12 and then there's the pharmacy, because the biggest problem isn't always treatment,
01:30:16 it is access. And with cold and flu season officially here, I'd rather be ready than
01:30:21 stuck waiting for care. That is why there's the medical emergency kit from the wellness company.
01:30:26 It's like an urgent care and drugstore at home.
01:30:29 It contains essential prescription medications in your name for over 30 common conditions,
01:30:34 including strep throat, sinus infections, pneumonia, stomach bugs, and more.
01:30:40 Plus access to telehealth doctors standing by for questions.
01:30:45 Don't wait until you are running a fever and scrambling to figure out what to do.
01:30:49 Be prepared now with the medical emergency kit.
01:30:52 Save $45 right now with promo code MK at UrgentCareKit.com slash MK.
01:30:57 That's UrgentCareKit.com slash MK, promo code MK.
01:31:03 I finished a 5K in 94th place, right after a man wearing jeans.
01:31:09 Then a volunteer gave me a medal.
01:31:11 But I don't want participation trophies, unless they're from Bet365.
01:31:16 With their daily prize matcher game, I win by matching gold coins, cherries, and more.
01:31:19 Take that, denim man
01:31:22 Thanks, Bet365
01:31:24 Must be 19 or older, Ontario only
01:31:26 Please play responsibly
01:31:27 If you have questions or concerns about your gambling
01:31:28 or the gambling of someone close to you
01:31:30 please go to connexontario.ca
01:31:31 TNC Supply
01:31:49 from people like Mark Halperin, Link Lauren, Maureen Callahan, Emily Drushinsky, Jesse Kelly,
01:31:55 Real Clear Politics, and many more. It's bold, no BS news only on the Megyn Kelly channel,
01:32:01 Sirius XM 111, and on the Sirius XM app.
01:32:08 On today's Kelly's Court Show, we're going to look at who may be getting criminally charged next
01:32:14 on prediction market calci. Traders are putting their money on who will be charged with a federal
01:32:18 crime in the final six weeks of 2026. Ilhan Omar leads the pack at 12%, though that's down from 50%
01:32:26 a month ago. I'm sure that's because of the midterm elections, although the Congress should
01:32:31 not be deciding whether she gets criminally charged. Ashley's favorite prosecutor, Fannie
01:32:35 Willis, comes in at number two at 9%. Jensen Wong, formerly of NVIDIA, is at 6%. And indeed,
01:32:43 there is a chance. Now, if you listen to Andy McCarthy's latest podcast, he thinks there's
01:32:46 pretty good evidence that Jensen Wong was selling chips to China intentionally behind the back of
01:32:54 the U.S. government without the spy, the alleged spy lover, even being involved. It was an
01:32:59 interesting discussion. Check it out. And by the way, also check out Kalshi because they're our
01:33:04 sponsor and they reflect what traders actually believe. It's real time odds on everything from
01:33:09 the midterm elections to who's going to get charged next. Give it a try by using code Megan
01:33:13 Kelly or click the link in the description. New users get 25 bucks free when they trade 25 bucks.
01:33:19 Okay, back with me now. Viva, Mark, and Ashley. Okay, so there's this guy named, he goes by
01:33:26 Clavicular, but his name is Brayden Peters. And he is an influencer who's become famous for,
01:33:33 quote, looks maxing. And this is where men get a bunch of procedures to look as hot as possible,
01:33:42 or as we call it, behave like women.
01:33:45 He is known by everybody.
01:33:48 Like I asked my son, do you guys know who this is?
01:33:50 He's like, oh yeah, everybody knows who that is.
01:33:52 Like, so like he's got a lot of fame with the teenage set.
01:33:55 Here's just a random soundbite of him from March
01:33:58 talking about some of his procedures, SOT 22.
01:34:02 My name is Clavicular.
01:34:04 I'm 20 years old.
01:34:06 I believe in looks maxing.
01:34:07 the idea of maximizing physical attractiveness by any means necessary in order to ascend
01:34:14 in the morning if my jaw looks a little weak i'll bone smash to strengthen it
01:34:22 my ratios are nearly golden now
01:34:25 his ratios he like has a ratio for like the eyes to the nose to the jaw like he's got a hammer on
01:34:33 his face in that video. Well, Brayden has just been charged with rape. He's just been indicted.
01:34:42 He had originally just been facing a criminal complaint, and now they've actually gotten an
01:34:46 indictment against him in Cape Cod. And they are alleging that at the home of his grandmother,
01:34:52 when he was 19 last year, he raped a 17-year-old. So two-year age difference between the two of them
01:34:59 at the time, twice in this Cape Cod home.
01:35:04 They also, this woman has filed a civil lawsuit against him
01:35:08 in which she originally claimed she was sexually assaulted by him
01:35:11 and she was also accusing him of injecting her
01:35:15 with some alleged fat-dissolving substance,
01:35:19 saying he didn't disclose that it wasn't FDA-approved.
01:35:21 I mean, what did you think was happening there?
01:35:23 It was like a 19-year-old influencer.
01:35:25 Here's the video we're showing the audience.
01:35:27 This is the complainant in the lawsuit.
01:35:29 After the fact, she claimed she didn't fully understand what he was doing to her, and she objected.
01:35:36 She claims after this on-camera live stream they did that she fell asleep, that when she woke up, I think the next morning, he was on top of her having sex with her.
01:35:48 And she claimed that that was not consensual.
01:35:51 Yeah, she said they made out on the couch when the stream ended.
01:35:53 She fell asleep in his bed.
01:35:55 The next morning, she woke up to Mr. Peters having sex with her.
01:35:58 She stated that because it was already occurring, she did not tell him to stop
01:36:02 and said she didn't consent, that she had no intention of having sex with him
01:36:08 and that this was not by consent.
01:36:11 Now, he has got text messages from her.
01:36:15 Hold on a second.
01:36:17 Saying, okay, stand by.
01:36:19 Hold on, I got to read these.
01:36:21 Allegedly, I want you, not going to lie, NGL.
01:36:25 I'm tired of being, like, independent.
01:36:28 I mean, I like it, but I just need a man to relax with.
01:36:32 We could keep everything private, too, like no social media.
01:36:36 And he responded, I've been pretty busy.
01:36:39 And she wrote, yeah, I get that.
01:36:41 When you get more settled, let me know.
01:36:44 And he responded, can you help me set up Kik, et cetera.
01:36:48 And I believe these were after.
01:36:50 Robert, is this correct?
01:36:51 This came after?
01:36:52 Yeah, this is after the alleged rape.
01:36:56 I want you, not going to lie.
01:36:57 And his civil lawyer is pointing out, it took her a year to come forward with these allegations.
01:37:04 She alleged sexual assault in a civil lawsuit.
01:37:07 Then she dropped that complaint and got and went criminal with it.
01:37:12 And they're basically saying this is a shakedown, Garagos.
01:37:16 Yeah, so what happens for people who don't know is if you get a criminal conviction,
01:37:20 that is beyond a reasonable doubt.
01:37:23 The civil then just flows from that.
01:37:25 It's just damages from that or restitution or a combination of both.
01:37:30 Somebody figured at this point that there was a problem with the civil because in the civil, she conceded that she didn't say no and she had excuses.
01:37:42 And so now that apparently is the flavor of the month with sexual crimes prosecutors.
01:37:48 We just say not saying no is not enough.
01:37:52 You have to affirmatively say yes.
01:37:54 that traditionally has not been the law.
01:37:57 It's a, in my opinion, a bridge too far
01:38:00 because you can always, after the fact,
01:38:03 reinvent a lack of consent.
01:38:05 Yes.
01:38:06 And like, honestly, like how on earth
01:38:09 is he going to disprove Viva this claim
01:38:12 that like she was asleep when it started?
01:38:15 You know, like they were in bed together.
01:38:18 She didn't say no.
01:38:20 She continued the relationship for another year.
01:38:24 she never claimed it was rape or went to the cops then suddenly i i don't know what the catalyst was
01:38:31 but the story shifted and now all he can do is go into court and say this isn't true
01:38:37 this sort of goes back to the russell brand situation and maybe even the sabatini that
01:38:42 sometimes you don't get what you deserve but you certainly get what you're asking for in terms of
01:38:46 engaging in reckless behavior that leaves you open to this type of ex post facto accusation
01:38:52 First of all, you know, getting an underage girl drunk and then having sex with them.
01:38:56 And I appreciate 19 to 17 is that Romeo age of the limit.
01:39:00 It's not a teacher.
01:39:01 It's not a person of a position of authority.
01:39:03 You're dealing with an idiot who's engaging in reckless behavior and then expecting everybody
01:39:07 he engages in this reckless behavior with to be totally reliable and not, you know, turn
01:39:12 on him and stab him in the back a year later because they might feel miffed at the way
01:39:15 the relationship went.
01:39:17 Kids need to be taught to not lead reckless, stupid lives, and then they won't open themselves
01:39:21 up to these types of accusations true or false or unprovable as they might be and it seems that a
01:39:26 whole hell of a lot of parents are just not instilling that lesson in their kids you know
01:39:30 ashley we know that clavicular as he goes by online is somewhat troubled i mean obviously
01:39:37 all the looks maxing and like breaking your jaw and all this this is strange um but he also had
01:39:44 what appeared to be an overdose situation not long ago um he on february 7th in an interview
01:39:51 with the New York Times went through some of the substances he's taking. Listen to this,
01:39:54 that 22B. What do you take every day? So right now I'm on a very low dose of test. I'm on around
01:40:01 like 220 milligrams. I've been like lowering my dose, you know, throughout the past couple of
01:40:08 months. So that's my TRT dose. I'm on 25 milligrams of Accutane. I'm on 12 milligrams of
01:40:17 redditrutide. I'm on 10 milligrams of nabivalol. What's that? It's a beta blocker. I usually take
01:40:24 melanotan too. I haven't taken it in like a little bit, but that's, I just want to make sure that
01:40:30 that's in there. I do take melatonin too. That's a phenomenal antioxidant. I'll do a lot of L-glutathione.
01:40:38 So that's another antioxidant that's already produced endogenously. And that helps with a lot
01:40:42 of dopamine toxicity that helps with any liver toxicity from drinking i'll take nad plus uh
01:40:50 which is extremely good for the health of your cells uh it's good for your i've used anabar
01:40:56 because that down regulates something called the glucocorticoid receptor
01:41:00 who's this doctor prescribing all of these what is going on i mean i know a lot of half of those
01:41:08 are not like glutathione that's a supplement you can just get but all the testosterone and
01:41:12 the retitrutide and the, you know, Accutane. I mean, he's on some serious medications. Like who
01:41:17 is who is monitoring this? I mean, it's crazy. He's literally going on TV publicizing all of
01:41:22 these medications he's on and nobody seems to be paying attention to it. But, you know, this this
01:41:27 case, one of the concepts we have legally is this whole concept of constructive force. And that's
01:41:32 what a lot of rape charges are when you have sex with someone who's asleep. They say, oh, well,
01:41:35 if they didn't consent actively, it's constructive force. And that is a bunch of crap because that
01:41:41 is where we're ending up with all of these types of cases. Um, and it goes back, it goes back to
01:41:45 my mantra. Don't have crazy. He messed around. You can tell from these texts that that's what's
01:41:51 happening. She wanted a relationship. He didn't respond appropriately. She's texting, Hey, I want
01:41:56 to settle down. I want a guy, blah, blah, blah, blah. And he's like, Oh, I'm busy. I mean, that's
01:42:01 what he did wrong. I'll say this in her defense. Okay. And I don't know, you tell me Gary goes,
01:42:07 whether any of this will come in. But part of his like looks maxing thing is, in my opinion,
01:42:14 to be very dismissive of women and very controlling of women. And like women are
01:42:18 second class citizens around him, in my opinion, from watching him where he orders them around.
01:42:22 There's a video I saw just this week. I don't know. I guess I'm on the clavicular
01:42:26 algorithm now because I've been preparing for our segment where he is with his current girlfriend
01:42:33 who I guess he had been kissing somebody else
01:42:37 and he's trying to kiss his girlfriend
01:42:38 and she's trying to stop him
01:42:40 and he's literally forcing the kiss
01:42:43 and she's kind of like trying to get away from him
01:42:45 and he won't stop
01:42:46 and he just treats her like he's a shit.
01:42:50 Yeah, I just, like that kind of,
01:42:52 those statements, those behaviors,
01:42:54 does that stuff come in?
01:42:55 Because it would help her case.
01:42:57 Yeah, and I would like to publicly
01:43:00 thank your producer
01:43:03 Allison for forcing that into my
01:43:05 feed as well
01:43:06 in preparation
01:43:07 yes that
01:43:11 would come in
01:43:12 absolutely that will come in because
01:43:15 that's going to be
01:43:16 evidence that most
01:43:18 judges I think would let in
01:43:20 as probative meaning it's
01:43:22 going to show something and support
01:43:25 it so yes it will come in
01:43:26 be careful what you wish for
01:43:29 unfortunately
01:43:29 Well, he should take the Russell Brand lesson, Viva, that you've been jumping up and down about.
01:43:35 Like, you treat people like this, even if it's not a rape, as they allege against Russell, it's likely to come back to haunt you.
01:43:43 It is. You're playing with fire. The bottom line is it's too late to live together now.
01:43:48 Anyhow, but you get involved with drugs, alcohol, underage people.
01:43:53 Don't be surprised. You are playing with your life behind bars because people might not even be sympathetic to you, even if you are innocent.
01:43:59 So sometimes your sole purpose in life is to serve as a warning to others, clavicular in life, in what he's doing, in what he's valuing, in terms of his own body, what makes him valuable on earth.
01:44:09 It's a bad lesson everyone else should learn from.
01:44:11 Amen.
01:44:12 Great to see you all.
01:44:13 Thanks so much for doing two hours with us today.
01:44:15 Good to see you.
01:44:16 Thank you.
01:44:16 Thanks.
01:44:17 All of you have a great weekend, and we will see you Monday.
01:44:20 Thanks for listening to The Megyn Kelly Show.
01:44:23 No BS, no agenda, and no fear.
01:44:29 It may be fall, but winter is coming.
01:44:35 BetMGM Casino is putting a spin on the iconic television show Game of Thrones.
01:44:40 You can now play the Game of Thrones casino game at BetMGM Casino.
01:44:44 Forge your path to the throne with dragon fire and over 4,000 ways to win and more.
01:44:50 Journey through Westeros and discover casino excitement like you've never seen before.
01:44:55 Download the BetMGM Casino app and check out the Game of Thrones casino game.
01:45:01 Will you be next to take the Iron Throne?
01:45:03 BetMGM and GameSense remind you to play responsibly.
01:45:06 19 plus to wager, Ontario only.
01:45:09 Please play responsibly.
01:45:10 If you have questions or concerns about your gambling or someone close to you,
01:45:14 please contact Connects Ontario at 1-866-531-2600 to speak to an advisor free of charge.
01:45:22 BetMGM operates pursuant to an operating agreement with iGaming Ontario.