On today's episode of The Megyn Kelly Show, host Meghan Kelly is joined by Henry Olson, senior fellow at the Ethics and Public Policy Center at the Grand Canyon University, to discuss Trump's final campaign rally in Pennsylvania.
00:00:00.520Welcome to The Megyn Kelly Show, live on Sirius XM channel 111 every weekday at noon east.
00:00:12.160Hey everyone, I'm Megyn Kelly. Welcome to The Megyn Kelly Show.
00:00:15.960It's here. Election day. It is finally here.
00:00:21.820And we have a packed show for you coming tonight.
00:00:24.560I'll be joined by more than 20 of your favorite guests, plus some very special guests.
00:00:29.440Well, they're all very special. Live on Sirius XM Triumph channel 111 and also at youtube.com slash Megyn Kelly.
00:00:37.160We begin at 8, as we believe that's the earliest we're actually going to know anything.
00:00:41.620And we will be covering all the election news results with instant analysis and reaction.
00:00:47.120We'll have data gurus, campaign gurus, politics gurus, culture gurus.
00:00:51.440We've got everybody. All the gurus are here.
00:00:53.100Later today on this show, I'm going to be taking your calls and I'll give you a behind-the-scenes look at my time with Donald Trump last night.
00:01:02.860His final Pennsylvania rally last night, his penultimate rally of his last campaign ever.
00:03:45.500Anyway, a little bit more on that after our first guest today, because I really have been wanting to talk to this guy.
00:03:50.540And I'm going to bring him to you, and then we'll pick this conversation up about last night.
00:03:54.240And today, on the back end of our conversation, with Henry Olson.
00:03:58.000He's senior fellow at the Ethics and Public Policy Center and host of the Beyond the Polls podcast.
00:04:05.160Grand Canyon University, a private Christian university in beautiful Phoenix, Arizona,
00:04:10.600believes we are endowed by our creator with certain unalienable rights to life, liberty, and the pursuit of happiness.
00:04:16.640GCU believes in equal opportunity and that the American dream starts with purpose.
00:04:21.100By honoring your career calling, you can impact your family, friends, and your community.
00:04:25.440Change the world for good by putting others before yourself.
00:04:29.160Whether your pursuit involves a bachelor's, master's, or doctoral degree,
00:04:32.560GCU's online, on-campus, and hybrid learning environments are designed to help you achieve your unique academic, personal, and professional goals.
00:04:39.640With over 340 academic programs as of June 2024, GCU meets you where you are and provides a path to help you fulfill your dreams.
00:05:38.880Michigan is the hardest nut for him to crack.
00:05:41.560But I think that if everything goes according to plan, that we'll know who the president is on Wednesday morning and that president will be Donald Trump.
00:05:51.480So walk us through it, because it seems in reading your analysis, you think Georgia and I think North Carolina are going to be the two most important.
00:06:00.360And that's a very solid and important base for Trump.
00:07:26.220So how does that factor into your polls?
00:07:30.400You know, it is getting more bluer because people moving into the state.
00:07:36.640But then you've got to balance that with what we know about or what the polls are saying is happening in the African-American community, is that if Trump really does get 15, 16, 17 percent of the black vote as opposed to 9 percent, they're a large share of the Democratic base there.
00:07:53.900That means that Trump's margin from 2020 goes up by two points or more just because of the shift in the black vote.
00:08:02.980So that more than offsets the demographic advantage of having more out-of-staters move in.
00:08:09.400And you can see Trump focusing on that.
00:08:11.180He had two rallies in North Carolina in 60 percent plus African-American communities.
00:08:16.940I can't remember in my lifetime a Republican candidate spending the last two weeks of the presidential campaign in heavily African-American communities in the South.
00:08:28.020They wouldn't do that if they didn't see that they had the numbers and that they wanted to make sure that that's there because if it's there, North Carolina should be for the taking.
00:08:37.060An interesting update from Raleigh News and Observer in North Carolina about the counties impacted out in the western part of the state by the hurricane, Hurricane Helene.
00:08:48.440According to the paper, turnout in these 25 western counties was stronger than the rest of the state in the early vote at 58.9 percent, about 2 percent higher than statewide turnout, which is amazing given all the worries we had about whether those poor folks dealing with enough were going to be able to get their vote.
00:09:06.580This seems, anecdotally, to be following a pattern we're seeing at least in Nevada, North Carolina, and maybe it's other states too, of big numbers out of rural communities, which is considered to be good for Trump.
00:09:23.260It's pretty much everywhere you're looking at with early voting in Trump-friendly communities, rural communities, but also Republican suburban communities is up.
00:09:34.000You know, you take a look at Nevada, Democrats typically lead the early vote there.
00:09:38.880Over 40,000 more registered Republicans have voted early in Nevada.
00:09:43.160That's the first time in at least 20 years.
00:09:46.800Over 200,000 more Republicans have voted early in Arizona.
00:10:04.180So it's not just rural, it's Republican.
00:10:06.640And that's been repeated across the country, and Democrats have to hope for a big Election Day turnout, or this could be much worse than they think it's going to be.
00:10:14.120Okay, so in Georgia, too, the numbers are that active voters are turning out early in rural Georgia.
00:10:21.740So we said that was true in North Carolina, it's true in Nevada.
00:10:37.460So you hear about all this surge in the rural communities and Republicans showing up to do early voting in greater numbers than ever before.
00:10:46.080And then on the other side, you hear about the surge in women.
00:11:13.140Because it's not unusual to have more women in the electorate.
00:11:18.200No, I mean, we know that because women live longer, that women—more women will vote than men, that usually 52 percent of the national electorate will be female.
00:11:29.140But the key thing is not looking at how many women have voted early in an absolute.
00:11:33.520It's comparing it to the past, is they say that Dobbs has created this female groundswell that's going to turn millions of women into voters.
00:11:43.960And the fact is, the female share of the vote in North Carolina is basically unchanged from four years ago.
00:11:51.780The female share of the vote in Georgia is up a couple of tenths of a percent.
00:11:57.660This is normal Election Day voting that's taking place.
00:12:02.480So we're not seeing evidence of what the Democrats are talking about in this early vote.
00:12:07.740Women are voting at about the same rate that they voted in the past.
00:12:11.760And that's just inconsistent with this, oh my gosh, Gobs was the earthquake that shook American politics argument that they're trying to make to analysts and pundits.
00:12:22.240Well, how do you square that with what the New York Times reported about Pennsylvania, about how Democrats were feeling giddy about some alleged new surge in voter registrations for young women, Democrats?
00:12:33.840Yeah, so it's a little complicated, but this one word summation of that is overrated.
00:12:43.980So let me go through the complicated part.
00:12:46.960What they showed is that 35,000 or so people who didn't vote in 2020 are female Democrats, and that's a significant number.
00:12:56.680But when you add the female and the male votes together and you add the Democrats and you add the female and the male votes Republican, it's a net 19,000 vote gain.
00:13:07.780That's not much in a state that will cast 7 million votes.
00:13:11.280And then what's more telling, I think, is that among the registered independents, there's no difference in turnout rate between men and women.
00:13:18.520So what that means is that, yes, female Democrats are turning out, but we also know that the Democratic Party is more female than male.
00:13:26.620One analyst said that those Pennsylvania numbers simply reflected the fact that 60 percent of the Democratic Party is female now.
00:13:32.820And if you were going to have a big Dobbs effect, wouldn't you expect that registered independent women would be surging out to vote?
00:14:27.420She said, in particular, older women who grew up with Roe v. Wade as the law of the land and are ticked off that it's been taken away saying, look, you know, we thought we dealt with this already.
00:14:39.280And so the question was, you know, did she see something in the electorate that may be part of a pattern that no other pollster has seen?
00:14:49.300Well, the thing is that states don't move independently of each other.
00:14:55.680If this was happening, we'd be seeing it happening elsewhere.
00:14:59.160You know, we'd be seeing it happen in the early vote, for example.
00:15:02.020And the Iowa early vote does not show a massive Democratic or a massive female swing.
00:15:07.800We'd be seeing it in things like the national congressional committees.
00:15:12.520There are three congressional districts there that, if this were true, Democrats would pick up.
00:15:17.700Instead, what you don't see is last-minute buys in one of the congressional districts.
00:15:22.760What you don't see is data from other states that have similar demographies showing that type of swing.
00:15:29.480In other words, what you have to believe, if you believe the seltzer poll, is that Iowa is this little petri dish all unto itself.
00:15:36.480And she's the only one to have figured out that there's this chemical reaction going on.
00:15:42.120And no other scientist doing similar experiments anywhere else has found this.
00:15:46.700I suggest she just has a bad data set and that that's more likely the cause.
00:15:52.140Because literally no other piece of data, either that we have or that we can infer from the way congressional committees are creating the campaigns or campaigns are sending their candidates around.
00:16:03.040Don't you think that Kamala Harris would have sent Tim Walls to Iowa once if their data said they were going to pick up Iowa?
00:16:11.120Every pollster has a bad poll from time to time.
00:16:17.260So now what are you seeing in terms of the early vote?
00:16:20.720Because people on Team Trump believe that we are seeing a relatively low turnout in the urban areas and potentially with black voters and a relatively high turnout in the rural areas.
00:16:34.580And we assume those are mostly Trump voters.
00:16:57.820But the most rural congressional district, congressional district nine, the most MAGA congressional district in the state has more early votes today than they had four years ago.
00:17:10.280The African-American district, which is centered on Norfolk and Hampton Roads, congressional district three, has 60 percent of the early vote that it had four years ago.
00:17:19.980You know, you take a look at the most African-American county in urban Atlanta, Clayton County.
00:17:25.660It's got a much lower early vote than it had four years ago.
00:17:29.820So these are trends that we're seeing.
00:17:31.900African-Americans are much less likely to vote early than they were a few years ago.
00:17:36.280Rural Republicans and rural voters generally are much more likely to vote early.
00:17:40.440And a lot of them are new voters, too, is that Pennsylvania and Nevada and North Carolina allow same-day registration.
00:17:49.240If you show up to vote in person in all three of those states, more people registered in October as Republicans than as Democrats because more new voters came out.
00:18:01.040And that's an indication that they're not just cannibalizing the old voters.
00:18:15.300So explain why that's good for Trump, because I think people are getting used to the narrative that Trump is doing much better with black men than any other Republican voter.
00:18:24.940So is it just that the black vote overwhelmingly is still Democratic?
00:18:57.980But if there are fewer blacks turning out, then every black person who doesn't turn out is like 70 percent or 80 percent likely to vote for Kamala Harris.
00:19:06.920So that means they're losing votes with a low turnout, even though the people who turn out are likelier than the past to vote for Donald Trump.
00:19:15.200So, you know, you always hope that everybody votes.
00:19:17.760And it could very well be that African-Americans are streaming to the polls today as we speak.
00:19:22.500But in the early vote total, it was very clear across the country that African-Americans are voting at lower rates than they did before.
00:19:30.640And combined with a shift on the margin to Donald Trump, that is a very, very dangerous red light over the Harris campaign team bus.
00:19:41.220We we haven't seen Jackie Henrich, a Fox News reporter, was pointing out on X that we haven't seen a lot of touting of the early vote stats, numbers, you know, demographics from team Harris.
00:19:56.680And she was raising the point that normally they would like.
00:20:00.300But the Biden White House knows how to tout promising data that they're seeing in polls.
00:20:05.140I mean, they've been through this a few times.
00:20:06.460And I thought that was kind of interesting because we are seeing a lot, some from the Trump war room, some from Elon Musk, who's very tight, of course, with Trump and has his own polling going.
00:20:17.300I have to say, I saw some of the polling yesterday when I was with the Trump team.
00:20:23.740I wonder if you read anything into that or if you take away the same conclusion as Jackie Henrich.
00:20:29.320Yeah. Yeah. Look, I think the New York Times story that you cited earlier shows they know how to get their message out to their friends in the press.
00:20:43.380The fact that you don't hear it means they don't have it.
00:21:06.8602022, John Fetterman won the early vote by 700,000 over Dr. Oz.
00:21:14.380That offset Dr. Oz's win on Election Day.
00:21:16.900As of Monday, it looked like the Democrats had about a 400,000 vote early margin over Republicans.
00:21:25.180Even if you assumed 100 percent of registered independents voted for Kamala Harris, that's a 600,000 vote early vote margin.
00:21:34.480In other words, her expected early vote margin is 100,000 votes lower in Pennsylvania than John Fetterman's in a race that will have a million more voters.
00:21:44.240That's why you don't hear the numbers.
00:21:46.020That's a bad number for her, and they're not going to play it up.
00:21:49.880And the Trump campaign has been doing its bit to talk about the truth about early voting, which is the data in every swing state are better for Republicans than they were two or four years ago.
00:22:14.900Well, I mean, it's not to say that Republicans will win the early vote in all these states.
00:22:18.980Republicans will lose the early vote in Pennsylvania, but it's kind of like the black vote.
00:22:23.360You know, if you lose the black vote by 15 points less, that's a net gain.
00:22:27.640If Republicans come out of Pennsylvania only down 600,000 votes, that means the Democrats have to rely on election day turnout to win those votes back.
00:22:38.660And if they can't get a record high or close to record high turnout, that means lack of enthusiasm is dooming their candidate.
00:22:45.720A 600,000 vote margin should be a danger sign for them.
00:22:52.120And the fact is Republicans not only are coming out early, as I said earlier, new people who are Republicans are registering and coming out early.
00:23:01.320There's a lot of data, and I won't bore you or your listeners with all of it.
00:23:05.400But every state that you can track it, you see, it's not just the old voters moving the time that they vote.
00:23:11.520It's new voters who are coming out and voting likely Republican, assuming that people who register as Republican or live in 75 percent Republican areas are, in fact, Republican.
00:23:25.140Because that's always something we look at on election night.
00:23:28.180When you get those exit polls, you always look to see who the late breakers go for.
00:23:33.600And I saw at least one report with Team Harris claiming that the late breakers are going for her, that they really feel somehow Trump did damage to his campaign at that MSG rally.
00:23:45.500And they've seen something that suggests they're winning late breakers.
00:23:54.180Well, you know, the data are interpretive.
00:23:57.780You know, not a whole lot of people ask those questions in polls.
00:24:02.620The polls that do ask that question tend to back up what the Harris campaign is talking about.
00:24:08.980And, you know, if that's true, that's another – that is a good fact for them.
00:24:13.500But, again, you have to ask, when you're talking about the expectation setting game, what are you talking about?
00:24:20.840And if you're saying the people who are deciding late will swing the election to us, that implicitly means the people who were deciding earlier weren't enough to win.
00:24:31.060So, yes, the data appear to be backing that up.
00:24:34.700We know from other polls that there shouldn't be that many late breakers, late deciders.
00:24:41.020We've seen a lot of polls saying 95 percent of each side's supporters for months have said they are rock solid in their votes.
00:24:49.160So a late break in her direction of two or three percent only matters on the margin.
00:24:54.220But if they're depending on that to set the expectation, the implicit admission is that they were behind on the people who had already decided as of last Friday.
00:25:05.840All right. Let's spend a minute on Nevada, where John Ralston for days now has been updating – this is this reporter out there who everybody puts a lot of stock into on predicting what's going to happen – for days has been saying it's bad.
00:25:21.840It doesn't look great for the Democrats.
00:25:23.280Democrats, I haven't seen this many Republican votes in early voting, like, ever.
00:25:27.980And if the Republicans have over a 40,000-vote lead in the early voting going into, like, today, we're pretty much at the Fat Lady Sings point.
00:25:40.040Um, then as of, I think it was yesterday, he said the Republicans had either a 42 or 44,000-vote lead, but he did not say the Fat Lady was singing.
00:25:51.000And then his final election analysis, which comes out today, says Trump has about a 30,000-vote lead right now.
00:26:01.880And now that would have been factored in, because he was saying as of yesterday, if they had had over 40,000, which they did, then it would have been over.
00:26:07.500But now he's saying, okay, now today it's down to 30.
00:26:09.540You're expecting it to go down as more mail-in ballots come in, because those are more Democrat.
00:26:13.980And he says he probably has about 30,000-vote lead right now.
00:26:17.620Still a lot of Clark County mail ballots to be counted.
00:27:42.520What he says in another section of his prediction is that he's willing to bet that the Reid machine, the machine that was built up by the late Senate Majority Leader Harry Reid, will turn out the votes.
00:27:53.860He doesn't know where they'll turn out.
00:27:55.580He doesn't know when they'll turn out.
00:27:56.740But he says, I've seen it before, even though it's not happening now, I believe they will get the votes.
00:28:04.020And I think he wasn't willing to bet against the power brokers in Las Vegas, who are all part of that machine.
00:28:10.240You know, you take a look at the data, and there are data people who are looking at the frequency of voting of people in Nevada.
00:28:18.860How many people have never voted before?
00:28:21.640How many people have voted in one or two of the last general election?
00:28:24.780And then the fact is, Nevada Republicans, registered Republicans, are leading in all of those categories.
00:28:31.180They're not just cannibalizing out 65-year-old voters who've been voting for in Nevada elections since they moved there 40 years ago.
00:29:54.920Well, I have to wonder, because he says right there in what I read, you know, he's got, he's just got a gut feeling that she's going to bring home more votes.
00:30:02.660I mean, I think to a lot of the audience, that's going to sound like, oh, there's some funny business in the Harry Reid machine.
00:31:30.540You know, if I thought based on the weight of the data that Harris was going to win, I would say it.
00:31:36.600But it is very, to put it, but it is very, very difficult to call this election.
00:31:43.240And what that means is you often rely, unless you're really a deep weeds person, on a feeling.
00:31:51.060And it's very hard to go against your confirmation bias.
00:31:54.100It's very hard to go against your feelings.
00:31:56.060The other thing I will say, though, and that is that since Franklin Roosevelt, there has not been a presidential election where there are more Americans who said they were Republicans than Democrats.
00:32:09.060You can go back to the exit poll era and see that you can go back to partisan identification survey in the 60s and the 50s and the 40s, 90 years where it's been one way.
00:32:22.660This could be the first election where more people will tell pollsters that they are Republican than Democrat.
00:32:30.600And when a century of history is about ready to crumble before your eyes, I do not blame anyone who refuses to jump, who says, I'm going to go with history over what could be happening.
00:32:43.600It's just human nature, as Ronald Reagan said in National Review in 1964, human nature avoids change and bends over backwards to avoid radical change.
00:32:54.400A Republican plurality American electorate is radical change.
00:32:57.980I do not doubt and cast aspersions on anyone who wants to bet in their final predictions against radical change.
00:33:15.200Because there we saw pollsters were also, they weren't seeing the huge female vote that was going to come out and rail against Dobbs.
00:33:26.740The numbers were very good for Republicans in those polls.
00:33:29.560I mean, it was in a way like a 2016 situation where you went out that night on those midterms, and all the data, especially right-track, wrong-track feelings, were in favor of the Republicans.
00:33:40.940And then, boom, the voters dropped the hammer.
00:33:46.980So, if the voters, if we didn't see in the polls prior to 2022 the anger of, you know, the people who gave the Dems that election,
00:33:56.140and I realize the Republicans did win the House, but not by the margins they expected, then what's our assurance that we're not seeing it, that, you know, that we're missing it again?
00:34:05.880Well, what I would say is the early vote data in 2024 are much different than the early vote data in 2022.
00:34:15.980The registration data since 2022 all favors Republicans.
01:02:27.420And had a really sweet, reflective, and I definitely believe sincere closing message to those who are in attendance, who, as I pointed out an hour ago, are like groupies in the way that a groupie follows a rock band.
01:02:42.580And, you know, a lot of the same faces go to these rallies, and they just adore the former president.
01:02:47.780I want to take a moment to thank the millions of hard-working men and women who are the heart and soul of this, the greatest movement of all time.
01:02:58.000Because it's you much more so than me, frankly.
01:03:20.200This is a great campaign that's now it's nine years.
01:03:24.000But you've given your time, your money, and your whole heart for this cause, and your support means more than anything you can even understand.
01:03:52.840I want to tell you this just in from Charlie Kirk, who, as you know, is part of the Get Out the Vote effort for Team Trump, along with a PAC organized by Elon and some other groups.
01:04:02.120Charlie just tweeted out the following.
01:04:03.700Turnout is mixed and not where we want it to be.
01:04:07.600Turnout is mixed and not where we want it to be.
01:05:15.420I mean, I've heard like Mark Halpin really thinks that we should be looking at Wisconsin as Trump's best blue wall state.
01:05:21.000Team Trump feels they realize Pennsylvania could absolutely go either way, but they feel good about their chances in Pennsylvania.
01:05:26.380But if he just takes one, as as you know, our first guest was saying, if he if he can somehow lock up North Carolina and Georgia early and then just take one, like if he just gets Pennsylvania, then he's good to go.
01:05:39.080Um, you know, he might take Nevada as well.
01:06:52.020Those blue wall states, they don't count very fast, Aaron.
01:06:54.320I also think that the swing states that Trump wins, we're going to get he's going to he's going to tip all those senators from those swing states.
01:07:04.160And lastly, but lastly, but not least, I just want to thank you for all the work and hard and hard job you do.
01:07:10.700And I used to listen to Rush and you're my first choice to listen to.
01:08:03.040There's just a couple of things I wanted to say.
01:08:05.080First of all, your rally speech yesterday was fantastic.
01:08:08.460And I just wanted to commend you for your moral courage and standing up in this moment and especially being able to put aside that history with Trump.
01:08:17.400You know, I saw the whole thing unfold in 2015, 2016.
01:08:21.200And it takes a lot of character to put that kind of thing aside for what really matters to the country.
01:08:31.120It was something when I went out on that debate stage in August of 15 with Trump.
01:08:38.520I don't know what it was, but I even before I asked the question, I felt like I could feel the tectonic plates shifting beneath me.
01:08:49.340Just that something massive was happening there that night and I think it was just about Trump, his ascension, his becoming president, what he would do for the country, the change he would make in the world.
01:09:04.820And I was at the leading edge of it that night and I felt it.
01:10:20.120Hopefully that lands in a good place too.
01:10:21.760But it is nice to know he and I are good, especially because I do respect him so much.
01:10:26.420And I really admire his policies and I would love to have a good relationship with him, even though I am going to have to hit him from time to time, especially if he wins, Edward.
01:10:35.920Well, that that debate moment, I didn't really like him that much.
01:10:39.360And then that debate moment is what just totally turned me into a Trump guy.