On this episode of The Megyn Kelly Show, Meghan talks to three of her favorite guests: Michael Moynihan, Matt Welch and Camille Foster of Freethink Media, and James Golden, the former producer for Rush Limbaugh's show for 30 years.
00:00:00.500Welcome to The Megyn Kelly Show, your home for open, honest, and provocative conversations.
00:00:11.720Hey everyone, I'm Megyn Kelly. Welcome to The Megyn Kelly Show and happy Monday.
00:00:16.440Hope you had a nice time with your family over Thanksgiving. I certainly did.
00:00:20.340We actually went across the pond to London for a bit.
00:00:24.320Have never done that before with a fam and it was truly wonderful.
00:00:28.000It was so wonderful. More on that this week because I'm going to show you something really cool that happened.
00:00:34.400But now it's time to panic. Let's just kick the show off today with widespread panic.
00:00:39.640That certainly seems to be the message that we're getting from the headlines out there now regarding the new COVID variant.
00:00:45.620Doesn't it seem like these media folks are enjoying it? It seems like they're like, ah, yes, another variant. Ah, yes. Right?
00:00:53.160I'm like, would you calm down? Calm down.
00:00:56.560At the same time, of course, Dr. Fauci refuses to rule out more lockdowns.
00:01:02.640He loves to lock us down. Fauci loves the lockdowns, telling us to prepare for the worst and also to trust him because he, quote, represents science.
00:01:12.140Those days are gone, Doc. Sorry to tell you. I don't know if you're the last to know, but we don't trust you anymore.
00:01:16.680The left trusts you implicitly and does whatever you say, but the rest of the country no longer trusts you because you've misled us so many times.
00:01:23.960There's a lot to get to this afternoon. In our second hour, we're going to be joined by James Golden.
00:01:29.960I'm looking forward to talking to him. You may know him better as Bo Snurdly, the longtime producer for Rush Limbaugh and a big part of Rush's show for 30 years.
00:01:40.040He's got a new book out on Limbaugh's legacy. He's been deeply affected by Rush and I loved reading it.
00:01:46.380It really brought back some memories of my own of Rush, who I knew well.
00:01:49.380So we'll talk to him in just a bit. But first, I'm so happy to have back with me now three of my favorite guests.
00:01:55.400They are the hosts of the Fifth Column podcast, Michael Moynihan, who's a correspondent for Vice News Tonight, Matt Welch, who is editor at large for Reason Magazine, and Camille Foster of Freethink Media.
00:02:09.060Welcome, guys. Great to have you back.
00:02:13.040All right. So just for the audience at home, it's Michael, the people watching on YouTube, Michael's on the left, Matt's in the middle and Camille's on the right.
00:02:20.020Am I wrong? Doesn't it seem like there's a bit of celebration in the media? It's like, ah, another variant. Yes, I feel it. I feel it from Fauci. I feel it from the media. Like, would you calm, calm down?
00:02:31.120I think folks are afraid we would enjoy all of our Turkey Day festivities a little bit too much.
00:02:35.520So to have something awful that they can throw over the whole thing, like a wet blanket, you can't pass that up.
00:02:41.240Doesn't matter if we don't know how infectious it is. Doesn't matter if we don't know how deadly it is.
00:02:45.100It doesn't matter if there aren't many people who are even necessarily positively confirmed cases that are infected with this variant.
00:02:51.940Or if it's in the United States, we should all panic. We should all freak out right now. And lockdowns are imminent.
00:02:56.200I feel like it's almost the new Russiagate. You know, it's like another tidbit of indication.
00:03:00.520That's what happened with me. I typically, because it's my job to pay attention to the news, I try to pay attention to the news.
00:03:06.520So over Thanksgiving, I said, you know what? I am going to pay attention to my lovely, beautiful 10-year-old daughter and my friends and my family for the first time in 10 years.
00:03:16.840That's the first time she's met me. And so we're really excited about this. And I'm going to not pay attention to the news, right?
00:03:21.580So I start paying attention yesterday and I just was like, oh my God, it's all over. So I get how people panic about this stuff.
00:03:30.360So if your interaction with this is mostly headlines. So then I start reading a little more and I was like, oh, okay.
00:03:35.020So you notice this in the markets too. The markets tanked in response to this. And then pre-market this morning and so far today, roaring back because they were like, oh yeah, that's just, that's a bit hype.
00:03:44.740I mean, it's very early indications and we'll have to consult Dr. Science about this sometime soon, but I haven't seen anything that suggests that it is more deadly, that it sounds like we're doing Delta all over again, except it's a little bit more infectious than Delta.
00:04:02.560Well, what did we do last time? What happened when Delta happened? We forgot everything we'd learned the previous 12 months.
00:04:08.720We're like, oh my God, we're going to have to close schools because, you know, think about the kids. Well, the kids are still very comparatively not infectious, not, and thankfully they don't get hurt comparatively to the rest of the population.
00:04:23.160It's crazy. The numbers are still less than 700 people under the age of 18 in America out of the 775,000 people who've died were kids.
00:04:32.380So we're doing it all over again. If there is no difference ultimately in how much this affects people, right? The deadliness of it.
00:04:41.180We're living in a world now where we have vaccines and we have therapeutics and we know we should know by now that we shouldn't freak out, especially about kids.
00:04:49.320And people are just starting the engines back up again. It's Matt.
00:04:51.980Yeah, I think it was you, Matt, was pointing out that more kids died of pneumonia last year than died of COVID.
00:04:59.300And yet we don't impose anywhere near these crazy restrictions on our schools because of pneumonia.
00:05:03.760All right. It's like we've lost the thread. But the glee over it to me, I was saying, it's almost like the way they loved Russiagate so much.
00:05:12.900Any incremental information on Russiagate would lead the news every night on the left wing channels because they were looking for confirmation of their worldview, you know, of their having already settled on a narrative and a story that they liked.
00:05:30.780And I almost feel like the approach to these new variants is the new version of that.
00:05:35.140They they've decided to panic over COVID. They've decided that anybody who downplays it in any way is a denier, right, as opposed to just to quote some someone we all love, a person of reason.
00:05:46.900Right. And and I see it in the reporting. And so to me, it's upsetting that we've gotten to this place where it's like it's an it's a chance to affirm your worldview as a Democrat in order to celebrate when you celebrate a new variant.
00:05:59.320Yeah. And if you're at all concerned about COVID and you think that Americans should take a pandemic seriously or that people around the world should take things seriously, then you should be concerned about hysteria related to to health security theater or public health theater, because people can't take the reporting seriously.
00:06:17.460They certainly can't take the guidance of public officials seriously if they are freaking out about absolutely everything.
00:06:23.620And if the media coverage is driven more by a desire to sensationalize or to to to cater to particular political biases, then it is actual tangible evidence that there is something that we should all be concerned about.
00:06:36.320You know what else is problematic about these things?
00:06:39.140You know what else is problematic? It's a slow news week. It always is over the Thanksgiving holiday.
00:06:43.060Yeah. And that means the media, especially cable news, but also papers.
00:06:47.220They've got to fill the headlines. They've got to fill the paper. They've got to fill the hour after hour.
00:06:50.640And this is what they do. They'll just take it, report on every little line item and blow it up like, you know, the plague has returned.
00:06:58.300In fairness, there is, you know, three countries have have stopped travelers from entering the country anymore.
00:07:04.080Right. Israel and Japan and and Mulvania. I think it was the third.
00:07:07.840But I want to I want to give one shout out to the contrary voice out there in the in the MSM wilderness, which is David Leonhardt from The New York Times, who's who has been like this this this very morning said it's not science based to preemptively freak out at everything before.
00:07:28.060Or, you know, and actually that's that's deleterious to mental health.
00:07:31.320If you do that, we don't know yet whether it's more dangerous. So maybe maybe calm down.
00:07:35.360But he's like he's the one who's like trying to tell neurotic upper class lefties that that it's OK not to completely be irrational, crazy people.
00:07:45.180Well, the terrifying thing about that and the David Leonhardt thing is that he has been a voice of calm and reason.
00:07:52.660And, you know, when he was writing writing about economics, The New York Times, I used to throw the paper out the window.
00:07:57.740And now I'm like, oh, this is interesting. But the incredible thing about how much this has been a culture war waged on both sides in the mainstream media.
00:08:06.200We hear often about people, you know, they're not masking and they're protesting and they're Trump people.
00:08:11.640The culture wars rage in a much more kind of sharper way from the left.
00:08:16.580And you can see that within The New York Times. I've heard this from people that there is anger at David Leonhardt for actually being calm and rational.
00:08:24.580And it's a very, very simple equation here. Why do people freak out about this?
00:08:28.480And why do people freak out about the new variants when they know nothing? It's it's a very, very simple thing.
00:08:33.140It's they're pointing their finger at people who have taken the masks off and say, everybody, calm down.
00:08:37.960We hate Fauci and say, see, here's another one. Here's another one. And you're not doing anything.
00:08:42.020If you don't take this seriously, look, it's going to get bigger and it's going to expand and it's going to envelop us all and kill us all.
00:08:47.000And that is the simple equation for these people. They don't care about the actual science behind it, because science, of course, is not a word that means anything anymore.
00:08:54.360I mean, Anthony Fauci has become he was appointed by science. He's apparently a science.
00:08:59.420He's gone to the University of Science over there. I'm going to start doing that. I'm just going to start saying I am journalism. I am law.
00:09:07.540Yes, that's it. You've been saying it quietly over here with your face on it that says she's journalism.
00:09:14.040What kind of a weird way of defending your positions is that I just so.
00:09:18.500So but just a little fact check for people out there who are wondering about the Omicron variant here.
00:09:26.160The here's what the she's the director of the South African Medical Association.
00:09:30.420She's the person who jumped up and down, sounded the alarm and said, hey, we got a new one.
00:09:34.960Dr. Angelique Cozy, quote, it's all speculation at this stage.
00:09:39.220It may be it's highly transmissible. But so far, the cases we're seeing are, quote, extremely mild, extremely mild.
00:09:47.820So we have no evidence to believe this is any more dangerous than the earlier variants, nor even necessarily more transmissible.
00:09:56.020Scott Gottlieb, former FDA commissioner, came out citing her and said, look, so far, the symptoms seen are mostly mild.
00:10:02.060We have not seen a spike in hospital admissions.
00:10:04.100And then he criticized all these travel bans we're seeing, saying there is too much we don't know, too much we don't know to impose economically, socially ruinous policies on South Africa and other nations.
00:10:16.280Ready, fire, aim is not prudent public health policy.
00:10:20.220Vaccine testing requirements requirements for incoming travelers could be prudent.
00:10:24.120Outright travel bans can hurt more than help.
00:10:28.820And yet, as you point out, those bans are everywhere now against these South African nations.
00:10:32.240The United States, Canada, Russia, Italy, Belgium, France, Germany, Japan, Malta, the Netherlands, Hong Kong.
00:10:37.260I could go on. Israel plans to ban all foreigners for two weeks after one case was confirmed there between seven and 10 suspected others.
00:10:46.020They're tracking people on their iPhones if they've got it.
00:10:48.880There's a legal challenge already to that.
00:10:52.480We want to have this illusion that there's a button that we can push to make the thing go away.
00:11:18.260And especially that there's a button that the bad people that we don't like aren't pushing so that we can blame them for this traumatic virus that's killing people.
00:11:29.780It's a bad instinct that we should have.
00:11:32.800The instinct should be, what can we do?
00:11:36.340Well, we know that probably the best thing for people to be is vaccinated.
00:11:41.220OK, so like what can you do as a government to speed up that process?
00:11:46.700Well, you can do a hell of a lot more than the FDA has done, not just of vaccines, but also of testing.
00:11:50.820Right. Like if if if we should have had easily affordable, easy to get home testing kits to everybody such a long time ago, we don't.
00:12:01.860Right. And that doesn't feel to stupid culture war political people like a button to push.
00:12:08.340And yet that's the thing that we need to be thinking about is how do you get vaccines more widely distributed and approved quicker?
00:12:15.520And then how do you get the diagnostics available? But it doesn't fulfill our stupid animal desires to punch somebody in the face and have a cultural argument about it.
00:12:26.080Yeah, it's also I mean, we don't have many conversations about what has worked and what hasn't at this point.
00:12:30.740And we have enough time and enough data that one would think, you know, for the first six months, I lived in Sweden for many years.
00:12:36.660I followed that debate very closely that people were saying, can you believe what the Swedes are doing?
00:12:41.620They're saying let her rip, don't wear masks, et cetera. Now, can we go back to the data of countries that shut down, countries that didn't, countries that had tight lockdowns, countries that were looser, countries that demanded masking and said that, you know, this is your choice and see what has happened.
00:12:55.680Because when you look at this stuff, it's not clear that any one thing has actually worked really well, travel bans included.
00:13:02.400So, I mean, this reaction and to be clear, this could be bad.
00:13:06.000We don't know. And the message, and I think that we're all kind of in agreement on this, is that there's no data to suggest that it is.
00:13:11.380But that doesn't mean that it won't be. But so far right now, to Scott Gottlieb's comment of like, do not, you know, panic first and then see what happens later. It's complete nonsense.
00:13:22.240But we've gotten to that place of where panicking feels good. It feels like an affirmation that our earlier predictions of doom and gloom were right, right? Before we know anything. And then you've got Fauci out there. I mean, once again, refusing to rule out lockdowns.
00:13:38.240It's like I we're I don't you you're going to tell me I'll play the soundbite. But my position is we're not doing that again. Americans are not going to do that again.
00:13:49.160Maybe his acolytes on the far left will. But the rest of the country won't. But here's what he said to George Stephanopoulos.
00:13:58.060Do we expect to be seeing more lockdowns again, new lockdowns, more mandates?
00:14:02.220You know, I don't know, George, it's really too early to say we just really need to, as I've said so often, prepare for the worst.
00:14:14.800Would we do it? I don't think we'll do it again.
00:14:16.400It's not too early to say you you do lockdowns when you don't understand anything and when there's no vaccine, we understand a lot more.
00:14:25.520And there's a vaccine and a booster and great therapeutics. There's all kinds of stuff to mitigate this.
00:14:30.880Now, you don't do lockdowns. They don't work. I'm not going to bang the pot again at seven o'clock.
00:14:35.040No, he's become done with the pot at talking about these things in the most urgent way imaginable as opposed to it.
00:14:42.120And I actually rewound and went back and looked at some of the earliest responses to COVID.
00:14:47.080Stuff that people would say now, oh, we moved too slow. We weren't fast enough.
00:14:50.460We should have locked down immediately. As you just mentioned, Moynihan, the countries that did lock down very early on, it's possible that they saved some lives early on.
00:14:58.260It's also the case that New Zealand and Australia are still struggling with COVID despite those early lockdowns.
00:15:04.480And it just seems as though this is our new reality and you cannot lock down in perpetuity.
00:15:09.520So knowing what we know now, it seems like some of that early restraint was probably appropriate.
00:15:16.020And what we could do with is a great deal more of that early restraint.
00:15:19.140And Fauci early on was on board with the restraint train. Don't freak out. Don't panic. Be prudent.
00:15:24.920Those are precisely the things that he could be saying now. And you're absolutely right, Matt.
00:15:29.940If you watch that whole 15-minute segment, it's a sequence of questions where is it more infectious? We don't know.
00:15:35.400Is there evidence that it's just kind of like breaking through and more people are going to die? We don't know.
00:16:26.160Rest of the country, people aren't really wearing masks.
00:16:28.220But if you look, and this is the utter stupidity of these myths, that there's some sort of kind of Trump virus amongst these people and sort of brain virus.
00:16:56.320But yet, for some reason, tens of thousands, if not in some places, hundreds of thousands of people on the streets saying, we're not doing this again.
00:17:21.320So Joe Biden, speaking of things that, you know, we haven't learned from Joe Biden, ripped on Trump for his travel ban.
00:17:27.900The day after Trump implemented it, Joe Biden tweeted out, and I quote, we are in the midst of a crisis with the coronavirus.
00:17:36.800We need to lead the way with science, not Donald Trump's record of hysteria, xenophobia and fear mongering.
00:17:43.480Then he also promised that he would eradicate COVID if we elected him.
00:17:47.000So he's been elected and here he is, not even a year into office, implementing what?
00:17:54.060A travel ban, a travel ban against several of these South African countries, although he was criticized by some for saying, it's going to kick in in a couple of days.
00:18:03.100We're going to let everybody travel in for the next 72 hours, but then we're going to ban.
00:18:07.500And some people are saying, how does that work?
00:18:10.220Aren't we supposed to like, you know, we're shutting it down?
00:18:14.320I don't know. But you tell me whether there's been a bit of a double standard by the president when it comes to these bans and even by the media.
00:18:20.280We're now trying to defend his ban, whereas they thought Trump's was racist.
00:18:24.460I mean, the ban makes so much less sense now, again, because we have all this stuff that we didn't have back then.
00:18:30.980The place I don't think the bans were a good idea to begin with from an American point of view, but the place where made the most sense is a place like New Zealand, right?
00:18:38.540Or Australia. You have an island country.
00:18:40.920You don't have a vaccine. I'm like, all right, maybe let's cut down on the incoming visitors while we try to figure something out.
00:19:18.020Politics is annoying in the sense that I mean, remember that Mitt Romney was brutalized for saying Russia was our greatest geopolitical enemy.
00:19:26.840People were like, can you believe this, Cold Warrior?
00:19:41.060And nobody is actually offering that assessment of how well Joe Biden is doing in numbers, in rhetoric and in policy, because there's actually, you know, there's no future in it for them.
00:19:51.360They know it's going to kind of even out with what they saw with Donald Trump and they prefer not to talk about it.
00:19:55.520Can we just spend one minute on the loony New York governor, Kathy Hochul?
00:19:59.880She's already declared a state of emergency.
00:20:02.660This allows non-essential procedures in the hospitals to be postponed in order to increase capacity, despite no evidence that we need any increased capacity.
00:20:11.540She says she did it to deal with, key words, staffing shortages and to boost bed capacity amid an anticipated anticipated spike in new cases.
00:20:23.720Because it doesn't sound like the CDC necessarily is, the WHO, Scott Gottlieb doesn't seem to necessarily be.
00:20:30.860And by the way, new cases doesn't mean new hospitalizations.
00:20:33.720And you guys tell me whether staffing shortages caused by her vaccine mandate are what she's really looking to cover for here.
00:20:40.380Well, I mean, that is, that is the, the ultimate sort of gotcha, isn't it?
00:20:44.700Like the staffing shortages induced by your policies that were supposed to be this precautionary thing.
00:20:50.720Everyone who works in a hospital has to be vaccinated.
00:20:53.580If, if any population, if there's any population I'm not uniquely concerned about with respect to their voluntary decision not to get vaccinated,
00:21:01.980it's probably the people who have been dealing directly with COVID for almost two years now.
00:21:08.220I would like for as many people as possible to get vaccinated.
00:21:11.500It seems quite clear to me that there are plenty of people who are actively making the decision not to get vaccinated.
00:21:18.260And some of them are probably doing so in response to the mandates.
00:21:22.900I mean, they, they have my sister and in law and brother, both work in the healthcare industry, both vaccinated.
00:22:16.520That 3%, you have a staffing shortage.
00:22:19.300You have absolutely no increase really of hospitalizations happening in New York.
00:22:23.940Although there is the regional, the predictable regional and seasonal surge of COVID cases.
00:22:29.160But that little 3% means that you have to have, or the governor thinks you have to have an emergency order of your own creation.
00:22:36.840And this is going to replicate all over the place in California, all over the country.
00:22:41.200People are doing these vaccine mandates, including of students in K through 12 students all over California, which is crazy.
00:22:47.120They're going to kick students out of school over the next couple of months, tens of thousands, and send them into remote learning, which we know is terrible.
00:22:57.500Which is going to make them more at risk probably too.
00:22:59.620And we're doing this just because we want to see that we pressed that button called science and did this thing that wasn't really scientifically based.
00:23:39.040And then now we have the guy, we have so many great governors of the state in New York, is that, you know, we're just, we know what's going to happen.
00:23:46.220So we're declaring a state of emergency.
00:23:48.140State of emergencies, like executive orders, should be used sparingly.
00:23:51.480And we should not put that much power into the hands of people when there's actually no impending crisis other than one that's been created.
00:24:02.140Because we still, if you have a kid in New York City Public School, and I know a couple of you guys do, you still have your kids eating lunch outside still with a mask on, socially distanced, in what last Wednesday was 39 degree weather.
00:24:17.340In a state of emergency, but they don't get to eat at all because you do have to take your mask down for two seconds.
00:24:21.200But what happens, Reagan, as you know, is that they're now just, like, closing schools.
00:24:25.660My favorite is that they were doing this around, just coincided with Veterans Day, which was on a Thursday.
00:24:31.580So that Friday became a mental health day for a whole lot of students to help you cope with COVID.
00:24:37.360Nothing to do with the mental health of teachers who wanted a four-day weekend.
00:24:40.520But we're seeing these preemptive and also staffing shortage-led closures all over the country.
00:24:47.420There's been a huge spike everywhere, and especially in blue states, places where the teachers' unions have more sway and can dictate terms a lot more.
00:25:21.040Do you think people are mad in Virginia in November?
00:25:24.260If they reimpose school lockdowns and closures and things like that, there's going to be a lot of otherwise really good Democrats who eyes are going to pop out of their skulls and look for anyone to vote for except for those people.
00:25:36.460Well, and that's a good place to pause it because we hold that talk.
00:25:39.860We'll kick it off there when we come back after a quick break because there was some polling and apparently a big meeting amongst these top-notch Democrats trying to predict what's going to happen with the party.
00:25:49.320And they're – speaking of panic, they're there.
00:25:52.660More with the guys of the fifth column in just a minute.
00:26:04.320I don't want to move on from COVID and the latest variant without talking about Fauci because to me he's getting more political in his statements.
00:26:14.380I realize it must be very irritating to get attacked all the time.
00:26:16.900But, you know, it comes with a job, especially in times like these.
00:26:20.640And here he was on one of the weekend shows over the summer – I mean, over the weekend, Sunday, trying to respond to attacks by Ted Cruz on him.
00:26:33.020My job has been totally focused on doing what I can with the talents and the influence I have to make scientific advances to protect the health of the American public.
00:26:46.560So anybody who spends lies and threatens and all that theater that goes on with some of the investigations and the congressional committees and the Rand Pauls and all that other nonsense, that's noise, Margaret.
00:28:14.820When you do it repeatedly, what the hell is wrong with you?
00:28:18.620Like either you just don't get it or like something is actually off in here.
00:28:23.500Like it's very strange to have someone talk in that particular way.
00:28:26.900And we call this fallacy appeal to authority.
00:28:29.680We know that that is not an adequate substitute for actually having a conversation on the basis of facts.
00:28:37.140And it is all nakedly partisan and nakedly political.
00:28:40.760And it's not as though in his ongoing feud with Rand Paul, Dr. Fauci has been extremely forthcoming.
00:28:48.560It is fair to say that people are being partisan and political on multiple sides.
00:28:52.420But his comments publicly about gain-of-function research and the difference between what he has funded and what others have funded or what others have talked about is less than honest and less than forthright.
00:29:05.880And it is the case that it is almost certainly not true that there's any connection between the stuff that Fauci was funding to the tune of what, like $200,000, $250,000.
00:29:15.700It's very unlikely that that is what caused the pandemic.
00:29:19.680But if you were more candid about this from the outset, this wouldn't be an issue.
00:30:20.240When are you Mr. Science and when are you not?
00:30:22.900I think it's unbelievably manipulative to actually say that there is one thing called science and I am the representative of it.
00:30:30.120And if you question that, you're somebody that hates science.
00:30:33.340There's a lot of this around, particularly in this city and people that I know, that wields science as this kind of, you know, talismanic thing that I believe in it and you don't.