The Megyn Kelly Show - July 07, 2026


Platner Allegation EXPOSES the Media, and the Tyler Robinson Defense REVEALED, with Bevan, Halperin, Aronberg, Holloway, Geragos, Eiglarsh, and Spilbor | Ep. 1354

Topics
Hosted by
Guests
Mentioned
Trump's Patriotic 250 Speech, Illegal Haitian Truck Crash, Paul Pelosi Hit-and-Run: AM Update 7⧸6 The Robinson-Twiggs DNA Evidence, and Assassination Culture, with Jack Posobiec, Sean Davis, and Sohrab Ahmari | Ep. 1355

Episode Stats


Length

2 hours and 31 minutes

Words per minute

175.83

Word count

26,626

Sentence count

1,487

Harmful content

Misogyny

24

sentences flagged

Toxicity

42

sentences flagged

Hate speech

18

sentences flagged


Summary

Summaries generated with gmurro/bart-large-finetuned-filtered-spotify-podcast-summ .

On this episode of The Megyn Kelly Show, Meghan talks about the latest in the Tyler Robinson case, and gives her thoughts on the latest allegations of sexual assault against Bernie Sanders by a woman he once dated. Plus, the latest on Tim Hortons and more!

Transcript

Transcript generated with Whisper (turbo).
Misogyny classifications generated with MilaNLProc/bert-base-uncased-ear-misogyny .
Toxicity classifications generated with s-nlp/roberta_toxicity_classifier .
Hate speech classifications generated with facebook/roberta-hate-speech-dynabench-r4-target .
Topics generated with Qwen2.5-3B-Instruct.
Hosts, guests, and mentioned names generated with spaCy (en_core_web_sm), reconciled against Wikidata.
00:00:00 Frozen lasagna, medium power, 15 minutes.
00:00:06 Sounds like Ojo time.
00:00:08 Let's play.
00:00:10 Feel the fun with PlayOjo, the online casino with all the latest slots and live casino games.
00:00:13 What you win is yours to keep.
00:00:15 No wagering requirements, instant payouts, and no minimum withdrawals.
00:00:18 Hey, I just won!
00:00:19 Woohoo!
00:00:19 Feel the fun, PlayOjo.
00:00:22 Honey, forget about lasagna.
00:00:23 Let's celebrate.
00:00:24 19 plus Ontario only.
00:00:25 Please play responsibly.
00:00:25 Concerned about your gambling or that of someone close to you?
00:00:27 Call 1-866-531-2600 or visit connexontario.ca.
00:00:30 All right, full-time thoughts.
00:00:31 Craig, who stood out?
00:00:33 Brazil's lime cheesecake started bright, didn't let up.
00:00:35 Nah, for me, Italian cappuccino was the standout in the box.
00:00:38 But if we're talking decadent performance, that's all France.
00:00:41 Chocolate creme brulee had the richest finishes.
00:00:43 Canadian fireworks really showed up big too.
00:00:45 And Mexico's caramel churro ice cap.
00:00:48 Gave me chills.
00:00:49 We are, of course, talking about Tim's taste of the Globe Liner.
00:00:52 New globally inspired Timbits and ice cap flavors
00:00:54 available at Tim Hortons for a limited time.
00:00:56 picks them up today. And while you're at it, check out Footy Prime Daily.
00:01:00 Welcome to The Megyn Kelly Show, live on Sirius XM Channel 111 every weekday at New East.
00:01:12 Hey, everyone, I'm Megyn Kelly. Welcome to The Megyn Kelly Show. It's day two of the
00:01:16 Tyler Robinson preliminary hearing in Provo, Utah, where prosecutors are seeking to persuade a judge
00:01:22 that there is probable cause to believe that Tyler Robinson assassinated Charlie Kirk at Utah Valley
00:01:28 University on September 10th of last year. We will have the latest in just a moment. We've been
00:01:33 watching it. It's been on for the past hour. We are streaming it on our YouTube channel. For those
00:01:38 of you who would like to follow along, youtube.com slash Megan Kelly in its entirety. And we are
00:01:44 going to be doing substantive coverage of what happened yesterday and this morning in about 20
00:01:50 minutes or so. I'm going to start with a different story here on our show. But we've got to bring you
00:01:56 more about this item that was in our AM Update podcast this morning. Graham Plattner, this whole
00:02:03 thing is imploding. His campaign is imploding. He was the darling of the Democrat Party. He easily
00:02:09 won the primary to take on Republican Susan Collins in the main Senate race. And Republicans
00:02:14 have been very worried about this race it's extremely tight extremely tight and susan collins 0.95
00:02:21 is you know she's a stalwart she always seems to manage to pull out these contests they like her
00:02:27 in maine because she's moderate and so are they uh including the republicans but this guy's sort
00:02:34 of an insurgent candidate he's he's trumpy in the way that he's outside the mainstream he doesn't
00:02:41 look like the other candidates he doesn't talk like them he he's more of a populist though a
00:02:48 leftist populist whereas trump was more of a republican populist and he has a very very good
00:02:56 chance of unseating her or did until recently i mean he's been again kind of like trump like
00:03:04 teflon he surrounded uh he survived the scandals like that surrounding his nazi tattoo he had made
00:03:13 several controversial comments on reddit prior to running allegedly sexted with i mean we were told
00:03:20 about a dozen women who were not his wife that the campaign said no more than six okay okay but while
00:03:27 he was married and he only got married in 2023. So this is not ancient history and generally
00:03:35 mistreating his previous romantic partners. There was a big New York Times expose on how
00:03:42 those romantic interludes went beyond, you know, bad romances to where one woman, Lindsay Fifield,
00:03:51 who's a conservative said she had been locked in a room by him she'd been she had her arm twisted
00:03:59 in a way that was painful and forceful and some other allegations that came out which were quickly
00:04:04 dismissed by most Democrats who didn't really care and now he's facing allegations of sexual
00:04:11 assault from a woman he once dated and I have to say just having read the allegations she's 0.68
00:04:16 alleging that he raped her. There's really no distinction. I don't know why they're not using
00:04:21 the R word. And she is talking about it in a way that's a little odd. You know, like when asked,
00:04:28 did you say no? She had language like, you know, I used language of non-consent. She's got a sort 0.85
00:04:36 of ethereal way of addressing the issue of consent. But it seems clear if you read her full
00:04:45 comments and then listened to her on with Jake Tapper yesterday. She, she's saying consent was
00:04:51 not there and that that was communicated. Um, and it's causing an avalanche of defectors now
00:04:58 from Graham Plattner. I mean, I think everyone, but Bernie Sanders has abandoned him now just
00:05:04 about all the people like who had endorsed him and who were standing by him. Even my old pal
00:05:09 crystal ball, who I really like, she's on the opposite side of the aisle, uh, versus yours
00:05:14 truly, but she's awesome. She's smart. We go way back. She'd been standing by Graham Plattner. 0.99
00:05:20 She really likes that populist leftist thing. And she today said, yeah, he's got, he's got to drop
00:05:25 out. Uh, political first reporting yesterday that 41 year old Maine resident, Jenny Razincott is the 0.97
00:05:31 woman alleging Plattner forced her to have sex with him while they were in a relationship, but 0.84
00:05:37 she did not want to have sex with him. He's fall down drunk. She had told him not to come over. 0.56
00:05:40 It was one of those situations. And he he did. He came over. He followed her around the apartment, got her into her bed in her bedroom and forced himself on her.
00:05:52 That's what she said. She also sat down, as I mentioned, with CNN yesterday and said this to Jake Tapper.
00:05:59 This has obviously been very difficult for you to talk about for five years.
00:06:04 and even when you're telling the story
00:06:09 you don't
00:06:11 use the word
00:06:12 so let me just be
00:06:14 and I apologize
00:06:16 let me be as
00:06:18 direct as I can
00:06:21 did 1.00
00:06:23 Graham Planner rape you 0.97
00:06:24 by definition yes 0.99
00:06:27 absolutely
00:06:29 because he had
00:06:31 non-consensual sex with you 0.86
00:06:32 forced himself on you 0.90
00:06:35 after you had told him no
00:06:38 and fought him off
00:06:39 he violated multiple layers of consent
00:06:42 that night
00:06:43 by coming into my home
00:06:45 when I asked him not to
00:06:47 and by advancing on me
00:06:50 when I told him not to
00:06:52 and furthermore
00:06:54 another incident that I had told him not to do
00:06:56 with protection
00:06:58 yeah
00:06:59 so yeah
00:07:01 by the way that my nervous system reacted to this experience. Absolutely.
00:07:08 Plattner's calling any accusation of non-consensual behavior, quote, categorically false.
00:07:13 That's what he said when the New York Times piece hit two. But yesterday, as this news
00:07:18 was breaking, we got news that he was canceling campaign events. And then he released a statement
00:07:24 about how he is contemplating his political future. The most important part of this statement
00:07:30 is the last sentence. Listen here. Any accusation of non-consensual behavior is categorically false.
00:07:38 Over the last 10 months, I have been deeply humbled by the faith Mainers have put in me.
00:07:43 You have welcomed me into your homes, into your places of work, into your restaurants, 1.00
00:07:48 into your houses of worship. You have shown that a different kind of politics,
00:07:53 one that puts the interests of people over corporations, is not just possible, but is
00:07:59 inevitable. So, regardless of the inaccuracy of the reporting, but mindful of the political
00:08:05 reality it will inflict, we are taking the time to reflect on the best path forward for the state
00:08:10 that I love, the people that I love, the movement I belong to, and the goal of defeating Susan Collins.
00:08:18 Taking time to reflect on the path forward is classic language for we're out. He didn't say
00:08:27 were out. He may just be considering getting out. There hasn't been an announcement that he's out,
00:08:31 but taking time to consider the path forward is not good. If you're saying that as a candidate
00:08:37 for office, you're in a lot of trouble. Now, the deadline for him actually to bail for the
00:08:43 Democrats to replace him as well on the ballot is July 13th. Saturday's the 11th because it's my
00:08:49 mom's 85th birthday. And then so, yeah, the 12th is Monday. Sorry, 13th is Monday. And so that is
00:08:58 the deadline by which Democrats must replace him on the ballot if they wish to replace him on the
00:09:04 ballot. And many, as I said, prominent Democrats are calling for him to drop out right now with
00:09:09 main scene as a key opportunity to flip a Senate seat. They see Susan Collins is vulnerable.
00:09:15 One person who has not yet commented is Senator Bernie Sanders, who previously endorsed
00:09:19 Plattner.
00:09:20 He's probably the biggest power player in making Plattner, and the loss of his endorsement
00:09:26 would be devastating.
00:09:29 Joining me now to break it all down, this scandal and the pain it's causing within the
00:09:35 Democratic Party are two of the best.
00:09:36 Tom Bevin, who's co-founder and president of Real Clear Politics and co-host of the
00:09:41 Real Clear Politics show on SiriusXM right here on the MK channel. And our pal, Mark Halperin,
00:09:47 who is host of Next Up on the MK Media Podcast Network, which also airs on the MK channel on
00:09:53 SiriusXM. When you sign your insurance policy for some brokers, that's the finish line, handshake,
00:09:59 they get their commission, and then they're kind of done with you. You may not hear from them again
00:10:03 until it's time for renewal, in which case, once again, they're your best friend. That's annoying.
00:10:07 But your business runs all year, and so do the gaps and the risk, and things happen.
00:10:12 And this is why I want to tell you about SuperSure.
00:10:14 If your company has more than 25 employees, whether you're the owner, the CFO, or the
00:10:19 HR manager, it can be too complex to just buy a policy online.
00:10:23 SuperSure is the super agency built just for you.
00:10:27 It's licensed in every state for your business insurance and employee benefits, with year-round
00:10:32 support for you and your team.
00:10:33 at supersure.com you can access tools like fine print facts which translates your current policy
00:10:39 into plain english so you see what's covered and what's not plus a business value calculator so
00:10:45 that you can estimate what your business is worth and know what actually needs protecting
00:10:49 go to supersure.com slash megan one super agency one powerful platform all your policies in one
00:10:57 place supersure.com slash megan paid for by supersure insurance agency llc a licensed
00:11:03 Insurance Agency. Guys, welcome. What a hot mess, Mark Halperin. Put it in perspective for us.
00:11:10 Well, what matters, of course, in the end, besides the drama of just the Maine race,
00:11:14 is what this does to impact the chance the Democrats can control the Senate after the
00:11:19 midterms. If they can't win Maine, the math becomes very difficult for them. This was their
00:11:24 in one or two of their top pickup opportunities. In terms of Plattner, I think this raises real
00:11:30 questions for the Democratic Party about credibility and honesty and fidelity to
00:11:35 principle. And it also raises questions in terms of the timing of whether they actually will end
00:11:41 up with a weaker candidate, as flawed as Plattner was. If you look at the people they might pick,
00:11:45 they may be decreasing their chances of winning the seat as opposed to enhancing their chances.
00:11:52 What do you make of it, Tom? Because this is not only the implosion of a candidate,
00:11:56 it's also a serious black eye for the press because the New York Times had this woman
00:12:05 that she was in their initial piece but not with this story and it looks like if you're going to
00:12:13 be really charitable to the New York Times she didn't tell them the full story she's out she's
00:12:18 coming out now saying I didn't tell the full story then because I wasn't ready but they had
00:12:23 this bird in hand and apparently weren't interested enough to coax this out of her or did coax it out
00:12:29 of her and weren't interested in coaxing it such that they could get it in print, which, as you
00:12:35 know, is another layer for any good reporter. And now another woman, that woman, Lindsay Fifield, 0.64
00:12:41 the conservative who was featured in The New York Times, is coming out now and ripping The Times a
00:12:46 new one saying your piece wound up being a cover up. It was it was designed to run cover for him.
00:12:55 It was not designed to elicit the truth. And it's no accident that you failed to and that it took
00:13:02 Politico a couple of weeks later to actually print what happened to this other woman.
00:13:07 Yeah, I mean, this is one of the things all the Graham Plattner supporters are up in arms. I think
00:13:12 the media has has just done a hit job, you know, based on the establishment backing. Right. And
00:13:20 then folks on the right are saying, look, you saw people like Jody Cantor going on CNN and
00:13:26 defending Plattner in the face of that initial Times article. I mean, you have all of the you
00:13:32 had the media and the Democrats. They were certainly they were willing to overlook all of
00:13:36 these things the tattoo the reddit post the you know port-a-potty masturbation thing i mean all 0.73
00:13:42 of this crazy stuff including these allegations about him being not just sort of a bad boyfriend 0.66
00:13:47 but actually putting his hands on women and roqana and everybody was willing to sort of look past
00:13:54 that because they were able to say look this is a conservative woman they can't say that anymore
00:13:58 and obviously uh now now some some line has been crossed here that that even democrats as you
00:14:04 mentioned, pretty much everybody except for Bernie Sanders at this point has called on Plattner to
00:14:09 get out of the race. And so I think he is. What's interesting about what Mark just said, it's going
00:14:13 to be fascinating to watch this play out because if you look at the betting markets, the odds of
00:14:19 Democrats winning that seat actually popped up. They might end up because Plattner was, he had
00:14:24 so much baggage, but he also had this enthusiasm among the sort of left-wing base. And if they put
00:14:31 somebody in that seat, if Democrats end up picking someone and putting someone in that seat
00:14:35 who doesn't have that support, the party's going to be split in half heading into the general
00:14:40 election, which is not a good place to be. Here is that Jody Cantor soundbite. She's not the woman
00:14:47 who wrote the New York Times article on Plattner, but she is responsible, she and Megan Toohey,
00:14:53 for the New York Times Me Too coverage. They're the ones who broke all the big stories, Harvey
00:14:58 Weinstein, etc. And this is Jody Cantor talking about The Times' coverage on this issue.
00:15:04 Well, let's talk about what they may or may not be willing to overlook. The accusations against
00:15:10 Graham Plattner are not classic Me Too accusations. They're not about a boss and a young female
00:15:18 employee being subjected to sexual advances. They were mostly made in the context of consensual
00:15:27 relationships there are these like very sensational uh texts about sex there are allegations from
00:15:33 former girlfriends that are not the way my colleagues reported them were not like classic
00:15:38 abuse allegations they were mostly like being his boyfriend gave me a view into him and i did not
00:15:47 like what i saw his character was scary he had this nazi tattoo etc there was one allegation of
00:15:54 crossing a line physically, but I think that means
00:15:58 that these are pretty different accusations
00:16:01 than say the ones that President Trump faced.
00:16:04 And of course, in the Access Hollywood tape,
00:16:06 President Trump bragged about grabbing women
00:16:11 against their will.
00:16:12 And so I think it speaks to the kind of confusion
00:16:15 of the long post-MeToo moment in which
00:16:19 like gender-related accusations get bundled together,
00:16:22 but they're actually very different.
00:16:25 Very different, very different, Mark, from Trump.
00:16:27 I'm breathless listening to that.
00:16:29 If you couple that with what I can only see as a catch-and-kill attempt by writing the original story, coupled with Lindsay's very well-documented Twitter posts about how the Times reported this story in a way that seemingly intended to downplay the damage it would do to Graham Plattner.
00:16:47 There should be New York Times employees, if it passed with prologue for them, they should be out in front of 8th Avenue protesting their own paper.
00:16:58 They should be calling for a thorough investigation of how such a thing could happen because this is, by their standards,
00:17:07 it's a massive failure to protect the rights of victims, accused, accusers.
00:17:14 And and I just it's just mind boggling to me that The New York Times can can operate with impunity and no accountability to what seems clear to be an attempt to, as they often do, favor one party over the other.
00:17:27 it was it was a catch and kill that's how it i mean the the irony right that's that's the name
00:17:32 of ronan farrell's book on um what the national inquirer did to protect well trump and harvey
00:17:40 winestream and and some others and not just the national inquirer but that he talked about that
00:17:45 practice of catching and then killing the story you get it and then you kill it to protect the
00:17:50 subject of it and the new york times seems to have clearly done this in the case of graham platner
00:17:55 And under the auspices of an expose. Right. But now we know, Tom, that the expose was very limited, given what Lindsay Fifield had told them, because she's ripping them to high heavens and has been since that piece broke.
00:18:10 and given what we now know this jennifer rassacott had to tell that she had this and look
00:18:18 i've i've probably interviewed more me too victims than jody canter and megan tooey
00:18:24 um i know these women very well not the ones in this story but i women who have these stories
00:18:29 and i guarantee you the times knew rassacott's story i guarantee there's no way rassacott did
00:18:35 not tell the two women who interviewed her the full story. She she probably just said, I'm not
00:18:40 I'm not ready to go there yet. Like this. I only want you to print the following in The New York
00:18:45 Times. That's my guess. She's saying publicly now I wasn't ready to tell the full story publicly
00:18:51 when I spoke with The Times. And I really thought they had Lindsay and they had another girl,
00:18:55 so they didn't really need me. But my point is simply, if you know in your head that this is
00:19:01 what the full allegation is, your piece sounds different. You know, I mean, you don't go lightly
00:19:07 on him. You've got somebody who says he raped me, who's just too scared to say it. So if that's the
00:19:14 case, I'd love to hear from this Jennifer Roscott on whether she actually did tell the full story
00:19:18 to the Times and just didn't give permission to print it because then they are truly villainous.
00:19:24 Then those women wrote that catch and kill knowing that he had a credible allegation of 1.00
00:19:30 rape against him and still in a way to catch and kill it. Can I just read to you, Tommy, 0.94
00:19:36 you mentioned this, this Lindsey Fyfelder, Mark, you did. She's she had this devastating post on
00:19:43 X yesterday, and I read it in part. She she's mad about what they've done to her and what they're
00:19:49 doing now in general. I actually understand why Democrat leaders don't take our stories serious
00:19:54 or didn't take our stories seriously when the Times reported them in June, but are now. It was
00:19:59 by design. The line most shared from the piece was the claim that the Times, quote, could not
00:20:04 corroborate my story despite talking to two of my friends. Just FYI for listening audience,
00:20:10 Lindsay's story included the following three paragraphs. Mr. Plattner could be rough with her, 0.85
00:20:16 Ms. Feithfield said, particularly when they were drinking, leaving her shaken and sometimes afraid.
00:20:22 In the interviews, Ms. Feithfield grappled with how to process her experiences. She was quick to
00:20:27 you know, that he never hit me, never punched me. But she said he regularly grabbed her by the
00:20:32 shoulders, sometimes hard enough to leave marks, and on one occasion, yanked her out of a cab by
00:20:37 her wrist after an argument when she wanted to stay in the car. During one argument, she recalled,
00:20:44 he twisted her arm behind her back, shoved her into a bedroom, held the door closed from the
00:20:50 other side so she couldn't get out, telling her to remain there until she was calm. Eventually,
00:20:54 Miss Fifield said she fell asleep and left the next morning. It hurt, she said. It didn't cause
00:20:59 an injury. It didn't break my arm. So they were quick to make sure they printed Fifield's down
00:21:07 playing of the incident. Right. Without reporting, for example, that's kidnapping. If it's true what
00:21:13 he what he did to Fifield, it's kidnapping under the law, not to mention assault. That is it's a
00:21:18 battery an unwanted touching is a battery in any event back to five fields x post she says um okay
00:21:24 they were quick to print up point out that they could not corroborate my story despite talking
00:21:28 to two of my friends i gave them contact info for five friends they called the two who i clarified
00:21:35 would not know about the abuse but would be able to affirm our relationship timeline events etc
00:21:40 they simply did not call the other three i also gave them the names of all my former roommates
00:21:46 who remembered him stalking our row house,
00:21:49 which was about five houses down from his
00:21:51 and waiting for me to return.
00:21:53 By the way, that's very relevant now
00:21:55 because this Jennifer Rassacott is saying
00:21:57 he broke into her home and was lying in wait for her.
00:22:01 Lindsay continues,
00:22:02 I gave them screenshots of messages
00:22:04 between these roommates and I discussing it, she says.
00:22:08 I gave the names of the other men I dated
00:22:11 who might've remembered him following us around the hill
00:22:13 and showing up on my stoop
00:22:15 after we walked home from dates to confront us, I gave them emails to my landlord urgently ending
00:22:20 my lease and moving to an apartment across town and diary entries talking about it, all time
00:22:25 marked. I told them that during premarital counseling, I had spoken to my ex-fiance about
00:22:30 the abuse because I had to explain to him why I reacted with such terror anytime he lost his
00:22:35 temper. They said, oh no, we don't need to bother him or my priest. Besides, I had written about it
00:22:42 in my diary in detail, they reassured me. As the weeks dragged down, I stopped trying to give them
00:22:48 evidence because the amount I had already given them seemed to overwhelm them, and I thought it
00:22:52 meant they clearly had more than enough to verify my every claim. My friends might not have known
00:22:56 the details of the abuse, but they affirmed that, yes, I had told them he was abusive long before he
00:23:00 ran for Senate. Besides, they assured me my part in their reporting would be small. She wound up
00:23:05 being the poster girl for the whole piece. I thought my details would only serve to affirm
00:23:09 jenny and the other anonymous woman jenny and i having never met or spoken both shared with these
00:23:15 reporters terrifyingly similar details of intimate partner violence coercive control and cycles of
00:23:20 abuse slash love bombing the third unnamed woman in the story did as well but tell me again how
00:23:25 they quote could not corroborate tom that is devastating well it's even more insidious than 0.98
00:23:31 that because the difference between the two is that lindsey fivefield was a republican was a
00:23:38 conservative and this Jenny Rassica was a liberal. I mean, she basically said, look, I agree with
00:23:43 Graham Plattner's policies, but I don't like him as a person. And so when the New York Times did
00:23:48 that and made Lindsay the feature and focus of that story, that allowed all these Democrats and
00:23:55 everybody else in the media to dismiss it as the Plattner campaign came out and said, look,
00:23:58 this is just a disgruntled, you know, this is a hatchet job from the right wing, the MAGA crowd,
00:24:03 all of that if they had reported the fact that there were also credible allegations from from
00:24:08 another woman who who was from the other side of the aisle it would have been much much harder for
00:24:13 them to to play that game and do it that way and that's why i think a lot of democrats now are
00:24:18 looking at this and they've that's the difference between the two cases megan i i went it's such a
00:24:23 good point sorry i went and reread the new york times story yesterday and the whole thing is so
00:24:27 insidious not just as lindsey points out the things they didn't include but just based on
00:24:32 what they included. This is the lead they wrote. This is literally the lead of a story about
00:24:37 accusations, as you said, of serious accusations. On Tuesday evening, after a whirlwind day in
00:24:42 Washington, Graham Plattner, the Democratic nominee for Senate in Maine, rushed home.
00:24:47 Rumors were spreading from Portland to the Potomac. It's like a featurey lead about how
00:24:52 Plattner is dealing with the accusations. I rewrote the lead just based on what they put
00:24:55 in the piece, not the stuff that they buried. This would have been my lead. Democratic Senator
00:25:00 grand planner is facing allegations that he physically assaulted and held captive a former
00:25:05 girlfriend during a volatile relationship according to a new york times investigation
00:25:09 that's the lead and the story and the story is written is filled with quotes from oh other
00:25:16 girlfriends really liked him said he was a really nice guy can you imagine them inserting that in
00:25:20 the story about donald trump this this is right this is this is such a scandal this piece and and
00:25:27 And I can see why Lindsay feels so betrayed by cooperating with them.
00:25:32 And I question why she did, because it was clear based on her account of how they treated it, they were not trying to write the real story.
00:25:41 It's just phenomenal that they tried to get away with this.
00:25:44 And they would have, potentially, had it not been for someone else deciding that she needed to come forward.
00:25:51 Yeah. 1.00
00:25:51 I mean, to quote one of my mom's favorite movies, Animal House, you fucked up. 1.00
00:25:56 You trusted us. 0.99
00:25:57 That's what that's that's what the New York Times is saying to Lindsay. Right. It's like, too bad you took a risk. You never should have done that. But it is infuriating. And in a way, I mean, not in a way, in fact, Tom, it backfired because the Democrats could have had the truth about Graham Plattner.
00:26:14 He denies it. It may or may not be true. OK, I must say that for the record. But they could have had this story in full about Graham Plattner weeks ago in much more time before the election to get another candidate in there to clearly and easily get him off the ballot before that July 13th deadline.
00:26:33 but they decided to play the game of delusion and dilution and now here we are with less than a week
00:26:41 to go before his name has to come off that ballot or stay on there for the general election and he's
00:26:47 just considering the path forward not agreeing to step down yeah i mean as if the nazi tattoo
00:26:53 wasn't enough like they could have gotten rid of this guy like a year ago months ago months ago
00:26:58 right? And all of the other, the Reddit posts and all that stuff. I mean, it is astonishing
00:27:02 for all of the people who live in Maine that the Democrats decided to get behind this guy
00:27:10 and hitch their wagon and their credibility to this guy and then stick with him through all of
00:27:15 these things. It has been remarkable to see. And now it is a problem. They are going to pay a price
00:27:23 for it, not just in Maine, but for all the other races. And you had El Syed endorsed him in 0.92
00:27:27 Michigan. He's now distancing himself. The only person, the most prominent Democrat who did not
00:27:34 endorse him, interestingly, was AOC. She did not get behind this guy. And I find that kind of
00:27:41 interesting. But as you said, Bernie's been all in, has been up there campaigning for him even
00:27:46 after that New York Times piece came out. He hasn't said anything yet. And so, look, I think
00:27:52 he has to get out i don't know i guess there's a slim chance that he could he could try and ride
00:27:57 this thing out but it looks like pulling trump well yeah exactly we all thought trump was going
00:28:03 to drop out after the access hollywood tape and he came out double barreled it and said f off no
00:28:09 locker room talk i'm in i saw mika brzezinski sort of grilling adam wren the politico reporter about
00:28:15 now now there's no there's no police report right there's no you know like what documentation do
00:28:22 you have like do you have the dms i know i mean theoretically i don't remember her asking any of
00:28:26 that about the trump accusers right she definitely doesn't look like she's believing all women um but
00:28:32 i guess theoretically he could say look you know this is a he said she said situation i say it
00:28:37 doesn't happen she said it did and he could try and go that route but it looks like the momentum
00:28:41 is is swinging pretty heavily against him it would be hard for him to i think to to ride it out at
00:28:46 this point i think sanders may have called for him to get out oh did he just now just now i think
00:28:51 I've seen reports on that, but let's see.
00:28:54 Wait, while you check that, let's play a little of that Morning Joe exchange you just referenced, Tom Bevin.
00:28:59 Here it is, 4B.
00:29:00 Correct me if I'm wrong.
00:29:01 And there's not a legal case playing out here for due process to see itself through.
00:29:07 So my question to you, given the very high standards political has before they write something like this and publish it,
00:29:16 what aspects of this story brought it to the level of publishable?
00:29:21 Yeah, you're correct here, Mika. There is no police report in this case. We spent a lot of
00:29:29 time talking to Jenny, asking her for cooperating evidence. Were you able to see the interactions
00:29:36 between Graham Plattner and this alleged victim? Did you actually physically see them? Did she
00:29:42 produce them for you? She attempted to uncover them, but was unable to.
00:29:51 Willie. She was Jenny in that New York Times piece. She appeared in the piece a few weeks
00:29:58 ago. So what's your sense of why she decided she wanted to go into more detail with you at this
00:30:03 point? Yeah, Willie. She was frustrated with how that article landed. Yeah, you're right, Mark.
00:30:12 I'm seeing it, too. It broke six minutes ago. Senator Bernie Sanders on the main U.S. Senate
00:30:17 race. Quote, I have spoken with Graham Plattner about the best path forward for Maine in light
00:30:21 with these very serious allegations, I have recommended that he step aside. So does that,
00:30:29 is that, is that it, Mark? When you have Sanders actually join the chorus? Yeah, it's pretty big
00:30:34 deal. Fellow New Englander, leader of the movement, as pointed out, just one of his major backers. So
00:30:40 look, a planner can look at the Donald Trump and Bill Clinton examples and say, if I fight and win,
00:30:47 I go for broke and I'm a U.S. senator and I can survive. If I get out, I'm probably done as a as a not just a political figure in Maine, but as a member of polite society in Maine.
00:30:58 But no financial support, no backing of Sanders. I thought he had close to no chance to go on, as Tom said.
00:31:06 But now I think it's now I think it's probably literally no chance.
00:31:10 Because we already saw that he was losing his funding, the National Democratic Senatorial Campaign, I think it was, or one of those formal fundraising groups already said we're out.
00:31:22 All the other supporters have said we're out.
00:31:24 As I said, even sort of the grassroots, more podcasty type influencers are saying we're out.
00:31:30 And now you have Sanders saying we're out.
00:31:31 I would say if you did a poll in Maine right now in the wake of the allegations, I think he'd be within five points of Collins.
00:31:39 I did a focus group with Maine voters and they just don't care.
00:31:42 No, I agree.
00:31:43 I agree.
00:31:44 I agree.
00:31:44 Which is why that's on the other side of the ledger.
00:31:47 If you're Graham Plattner and deciding what do you do here.
00:31:51 But the only other guy they're talking about so far, at least, is this Troy Jackson, who's a former state senator in Maine.
00:31:59 He lost the Democratic primary last month for Maine governor.
00:32:03 And he's been floated as somebody who could succeed Plattner.
00:32:06 Reading here from the Washington Examiner.
00:32:08 He called for Plattner to drop out, saying, I'm the best person to replace him.
00:32:13 However, OK, however, guys, here's what Progressive Victory just posted.
00:32:22 We began asking our contacts on the ground in Maine about Troy Jackson earlier today after seeing many suggestions that he should replace Plattner.
00:32:29 In our discussions, we have received troubling information not only about Jackson's behavior, but the behavior of many prominent Maine Democrats toward women more broadly,
00:32:36 both as a result of the credibility of the sources and in the interest of not seeing our movement make the same mistake twice.
00:32:43 We are choosing to share some of this now as Maine Senate president in a state Senate caucus meeting several years ago.
00:32:50 Troy Jackson, in a heated disagreement, struck a female colleague with a bottle.
00:32:54 He threw at her. There are many witnesses and it appears this is a widespread open secret within Maine politics and not an isolated incident.
00:33:03 This information is still developing. We'll provide more as we get it. I should note for the record, that's not been responded to by this Troy Jackson. It appears to be an allegation that was not made in any sort of official or formal setting. So we will assume he denies it for now. But the vetting thing is not going well, Tom Bevan. It's not it didn't go well with Platt. And maybe maybe this is the reason why. Who could forget these idiots who found Graham Plattner to begin with?
00:33:30 And then we're so proud of themselves. Did the media rounds only to have all normies recoil in a horror that these are the people picking our political candidates? Look at these two. 1.00
00:33:41 We paid a nice firm, a whole chunk of money and got some stuff back. Some of what you've seen on the news, we got back. Other stuff we didn't.
00:33:52 Did the vetting process turn up the tattoo that became so controversial?
00:33:58 No.
00:33:58 the reddit posts did that turn up in the vetting process
00:34:02 the firm sent us a thing and it had some of the posts but it didn't have all of them
00:34:14 and what did you think about that how did you how did you think your way through
00:34:21 the fact that he had posted these things on social media i said none of this will or should
00:34:27 stop him from becoming a U.S. senator? Oh, my gosh. I'm sorry. They might want to ask for a
00:34:36 refund for that OPPO research firm that they hired because they didn't do a very good job.
00:34:43 Of course, of course they didn't. Have you ever seen a bigger loser? I mean, you could just tell 0.96
00:34:49 just his affect, the way he speaks, his defense of the vetting process. I don't know if he's
00:34:56 connected with progressive victory, Mark Halpern, but they seem to be doing a better job in stopping
00:35:01 certain other possibilities in their tracks so that they don't make this mistake. I mean,
00:35:07 I think the biggest winners today are obviously Maine Republicans and Republicans nationwide
00:35:11 who've got to be feeling this seat, notwithstanding what that betting poll showed
00:35:15 is a bit more secure for Team Red than it was two months ago.
00:35:20 Well, you just imagine whoever the Maine Democrats pick, even if they somehow could
00:35:23 pick somebody on Tuesday if Plattner gets out. It's a challenge to stand up a Senate campaign,
00:35:29 even if you run a gubernatorial campaign this year. Standing up a federal Senate campaign,
00:35:34 hiring everybody in the middle of the summer, fundraising, scheduling, and then going through
00:35:40 vetting, it's a crapshoot. Is it possible someone could get all that done and not have vetting
00:35:46 issues and put a campaign up against Susan Collins, who, by the way, her and her team are 0.96
00:35:51 killers. They're not they're not lackadaisical. They know how hard it will be for her to win the 0.99
00:35:56 seat no matter what, because the nature of the state. So good luck to whoever it is. And they
00:36:01 better be clean as a whistle, because you can rest assured their own vetters may not find stuff. But
00:36:06 the James Blair and the Republicans will find it all. It's really not great to replace the one
00:36:12 who's allegedly kidnapping and assaulting and raping women with one who threw a bottle 0.83
00:36:18 at another woman in a heated disagreement. 0.96
00:36:23 I don't know where it hit her,
00:36:24 but there are apparently many witnesses, again,
00:36:26 reports of this group as an open secret.
00:36:29 So last but not least,
00:36:30 this is not on the subject of Graham Plattner,
00:36:32 but it is on the subject of Mitch McConnell.
00:36:35 There is a report out today
00:36:36 that Mitch McConnell's been hospitalized
00:36:39 for the past few weeks.
00:36:40 And there's a woman who broke the story
00:36:43 who's an independent journalist.
00:36:45 I'll try to find her name here.
00:36:46 I had it a second ago.
00:36:47 And she is reporting today that that Mitch McConnell may be in a coma. He may be in a coma right now. And that as that news hit, his wife, Elaine Chao, final former labor secretary under Trump, flew to China to meet with the Chinese vice president.
00:37:10 Okay, so he was found unconscious and required CPR at his Washington, D.C. home following an apparent cardiac arrest.
00:37:19 Reading here from a Daily Beast report that's based on this woman's and I think another's reporting.
00:37:25 And now this woman, her name is Desiree Townsend.
00:37:29 Again, she's the one who initially reported accurately he was found unconscious at his home,
00:37:33 is saying yes that she's now hearing uh that he is in some sort of vegetative regitative state
00:37:42 uh and possibly no brain activity and that she's now waiting at the hospital for when his family
00:37:49 quote eventually decides to move him off of life support it he is still a sitting u.s senator he
00:37:55 stepped down as majority leader but he's still sitting u.s senator and there's speculation mark
00:38:00 Calperin that the reason possibly, this is Steve Bannon's theory, that they don't want to announce
00:38:05 this is that he believes the senator's office is trying to avoid triggering a special election
00:38:11 that would allow outgoing Kentucky Republican Representative Thomas Massey to run as an
00:38:17 independent. There's some timing issue if this comes out about McConnell before August 3rd about
00:38:24 whether we can have a special election that might allow Massey to run or whether it would just go
00:38:28 right to November in the general. And I don't know how that would affect Massey. But can we
00:38:33 just start on the issue about McConnell and the reporting there? What do you know and what do
00:38:37 you think? Well, they've been very unforthcoming about what exactly has happened. We know he's
00:38:42 had health issues in the past. I talked to someone today who I think knows more than he was willing
00:38:47 to tell me, but I wouldn't be surprised if Senator McConnell didn't come back to the Senate
00:38:52 and and all this stuff about about who will replace him is is going to be very much on his
00:38:58 mind in the mind of his team. They're extremely proprietary about that seat.
00:39:03 I got to say, I'm I'm sad about this. I know there are a lot of Republicans who don't like
00:39:08 Mitch McConnell because he's been a Trump antagonist in more recent years. But the Mitch
00:39:13 McConnell I know is the one who got Supreme Court justice and appellate court justice after one
00:39:20 after the other through at a time when the Democrats were completely obstruction oriented
00:39:29 around judges and he accomplished some heroic feats around judges that he really should be
00:39:36 applauded and remembered for. And look, you can't have your whole legacy be defined on whether you
00:39:42 were on the right side of Trump. You know, it's just bullshit. Like he served honorably for 1.00
00:39:47 decades, became a leader in Republican politics. He was a gentleman, but fought very hard when it
00:39:54 came to judicial nominees. Forgive me for speaking of him in the past tense. There's no report that
00:39:59 he has died. It's just I understand he's obviously struggling right now. So but if this does become
00:40:05 a battle for, you know, legacy and the seat, Tom Bevin, it's not like this is going to go
00:40:11 blew this seat, but Thomas Massey actually potentially getting in to like, what a switcheroo
00:40:19 that would be. I mean, I don't know if Trump would feel any better about Massey than he did
00:40:23 about McConnell. No, that would be like one of those stories that, you know, Hollywood would
00:40:27 reject because it seemed too far-fetched if that's how the whole thing worked out. But
00:40:32 I agree with you. Mitch McConnell had a really interesting arc over the last few years of his
00:40:36 career because when he was in the same he's a master tactician he he was able to get the supreme
00:40:42 court justices through and you remember like there were all these memes of him going around and like 0.63
00:40:47 with narcos and all these things like he was he was like dark cocaine mitch and all that fear the
00:40:53 turtle all those things and then he subsequently the sort of the the the attitude flipped and he
00:41:00 became uh among the least well-liked if you look at his favorability ratings they went absolutely
00:41:05 into the tank, in part driven by Republicans. And so he became one of the least liked members
00:41:11 of the establishment by the MAGA base, even despite his successes and accomplishments.
00:41:17 Look, I started my primetime show at Fox News. The very first guest ever was Ted Cruz. And my
00:41:26 first question to him was, what's it like to be the most hated man in America? I have a long track
00:41:31 record of liking and having a friendship with the least liked people in Washington. And I don't know
00:41:38 if this is to my credit or to my shame, but I wear it as a badge of honor. It's good to get along
00:41:43 with people if you can. Guys, thank you both so much. Good to see you both. Thanks, Megan.
00:41:47 Yeah, you as well. All right, coming up next, we will have the latest on the Tyler Robinson
00:41:52 hearing. We've been monitoring it all morning. I'm going to summarize for you the major points
00:41:56 that came out yesterday. I can see clearly a couple of places that they're going on this.
00:42:00 It's fascinating how much the prosecution is showing. I mean, truly, like my only conclusion is that they must be worried about the public PR battle and the jury pool because they don't have to be doing all this. And yet they are. And they just released some really like gripping video. It was moments before air and I was sitting there eating an apple, like staring at it and eating my apple, not able to speak.
00:42:28 Doug came by. I'm like, I can't talk now. We're going to show it to you and talk about its meaning
00:42:32 next. Don't go away. Every season change seems to come with the same realization,
00:42:37 a closet full of clothes and absolutely nothing to wear. Haven't you been there? Between work,
00:42:43 travel, your family commitments and everything else, you might not have the time or frankly,
00:42:47 the desire to spend hours shopping. Or maybe you are like me where I do have the desire,
00:42:53 but I don't have the skill. Like left to my own devices, I really don't have a lot of style.
00:43:01 So I rely on other people to help me. And this is why I'm so excited to tell you about Daily Look.
00:43:06 It is the number one highest rated premium personal styling service for women. With Daily
00:43:12 Look, you get your own dedicated personal stylist, a real person, not an algorithm,
00:43:16 who curates a box based on your body shape, preferences, and lifestyle. And you get the
00:43:22 same stylist every time so she gets to know you and your preferences and what's already in your
00:43:27 closet. You can try up to 12 premium pieces at home, keep what you love, and send back the rest
00:43:33 with free shipping both ways. It's time to get your own personal stylist with Daily Look. Head
00:43:39 to dailylook.com to take your style quiz and use code MEGAN for 50% off your first order. But let
00:43:45 me tell you something, with or without the 50%, you should try this because it pays for itself.
00:43:51 you buy a couple of like nice outfits that once you get home don't look good or you never wear
00:43:57 and you've wasted your money and for this the low low price of using the folks at dailylook.com
00:44:03 you can avoid those costs and get stuff you actually love and will wear all the time all
00:44:10 right so that's dailylook.com for 50 off and make sure you use our promo code megan which will
00:44:16 ensure you get your discount all right and then they'll know we sent you frozen lasagna medium
00:44:23 power 15 minutes sounds like ojo time let's play feel the fun with play ojo the online casino with
00:44:32 all the latest slots live casino games what you win is yours to keep no wagering requirements
00:44:37 instant payouts and no minimum withdrawals hey i just won feel the fun play ojo honey forget about
00:44:43 lasagna let's celebrate 19 plus Ontario only please play responsibly concerned about your
00:44:47 gambling or that of someone close to you call 1-866-531-2600 or visit connectsontario.ca
00:44:50 all right full-time thoughts Craig who stood out Brazil's lime cheesecake started bright didn't let
00:44:56 up nah for me Italian cappuccino was to stand out in the box but if we're talking decadent
00:45:00 performance that's all France chocolate creme brulee had the richest finishes Canadian fireworks
00:45:05 really showed up big too and Mexico's caramel churro ice cap gave me chills we are of course
00:45:10 talking about Tim's taste of the globe lineup.
00:45:13 New globally inspired Timbits and IceCat flavors
00:45:15 available at Tim Hortons for a limited time.
00:45:17 Pick some up today and while you're at it,
00:45:19 check out Footy Prime Daily.
00:45:23 Now we want to get to day two
00:45:25 of the Tyler Robinson preliminary hearing.
00:45:29 And I just want to update you on what happened yesterday.
00:45:34 Okay, and then I'll tell you what happened this morning.
00:45:35 And then we're going to bring in our panel
00:45:37 and we will discuss it.
00:45:38 But our friend Jack Posobiec, who has been doing great work with Turning Point in the wake of Charlie's death, as he did prior, is there at the trial and did a wonderful report online yesterday for the post-millennial about what happened in court.
00:45:55 We, of course, checked it ourselves, as we always do.
00:45:58 We trust Jack, and he was right about his reporting.
00:46:01 But, you know, it's always good since more eyes are better.
00:46:05 And I want to tell you what happened.
00:46:08 some of the highlights, okay? And then we'll get to the stunning video that was just released.
00:46:12 Okay, first yesterday to testify was Officer Chris Bagley. He was there because he served as
00:46:19 a Utah Valley University officer on the day of the shooting. Now, that in and of itself is
00:46:25 interesting because they failed. UVU police failed to keep Charlie safe and to keep that roof secure.
00:46:33 and i was told directly by my friends at turning point that the reason the turning point security
00:46:42 team was not patrolling the roof or doing drones taking a look at the roof is because they were
00:46:49 told by the local cops that they were on it and we heard the head of the security team for charlie
00:46:55 say that to sean ryan he went on his show and said something to that effect that that the locals had
00:47:02 it. And this guy was the local. This is, this is the UVU officer who was there the day of the
00:47:11 shooting. And by the way, once you know that it makes the Nestor cross-examination, she's the
00:47:17 lawyer for Tyler Robinson, of him yesterday come into more clear focus. Because do you remember,
00:47:24 like this guy was used to set up the scene to talk about the shooting, to talk about the
00:47:32 aftermath and then what he did to find the the scene of the shooting the evidence he saw there
00:47:42 and so on so he's an important witness to talk about this is this is the evidence we found at
00:47:46 the scene and how it all went down and she it seems clear to me was trying to diminish him 0.97
00:47:52 by saying you you don't know your ass from your elbow you get you you know ultimately she's going 0.98
00:47:58 to argue. This guy, he couldn't keep Charlie safe. He's got a lot to cover up for. He's got a lot to 0.99
00:48:04 answer for. Should we really be putting a lot of stock in his word? Because he's the one who failed
00:48:10 to secure the entire scene because she did get after him yesterday in a soundbite. We played
00:48:14 on the lack of security on the roof. And, you know, did you really know that? I can't remember
00:48:22 the specifics of it, but we listened to it yesterday. In fact, we'll just play it. Okay,
00:48:25 here's her cross of this guy bagley sat 36 um the machines you walk through a tsa in the airport
00:48:33 where it checks to see if you're carrying any anything metal what we all had to go through
00:48:36 to get in the courtroom were there any machines like that set up or being used on campus that day
00:48:41 no and as far as you know no mags were there any drones that were flying above campus that day
00:48:51 not enough and did anyone ever talk to you about covering anything near or on top of or
00:48:59 in the low c building were you ever signed that area before the shooting no do you know who was
00:49:06 i don't and when you got up to the roof that afternoon was anybody around that was law
00:49:15 enforcement no nobody on the roof no nobody on the stairway nobody on the walkway no okay
00:49:24 and in the state of utah is a campus a gun-free zone are students allowed to have guns on campus
00:49:36 it's an open carry state so yes that actually is important by the way that utah is an open carry
00:49:42 state and UVU is an open carry campus. And therefore it's fine to have, you don't need a
00:49:47 license so different. Let me tell you from Connecticut. Um, but you don't need a license
00:49:52 because it's a free state, uh, to carry a gun. We have a whole thing. It's called the second
00:49:56 amendment. So these crazy leftists would have us get a license to have our free speech next. 0.99
00:50:03 Uh, that's also an important amendment. In any event, this guy testified about being a UVU
00:50:08 officer on the day of the shooting. He testified, uh, he, he was shown a number of images depicting
00:50:14 the campus, the buildings and the surrounding area. Uh, of course the defense objected to
00:50:19 everything and, uh, it, they were overruled. He said he was securing, um, the area above the tent
00:50:27 that was covering Charlie. Uh, he came in to do a shift for this special event. He observed Charlie
00:50:32 arrive on campus, do a meet and greet. He saw there's several, several thousand people there
00:50:36 in attendance. He heard a shot fired at 12.23 p.m. local time, which is 2.23 p.m. Eastern.
00:50:46 Cannot forget that moment here, experiencing it ourselves. He said he saw Kirk lean to the left,
00:50:53 going further under the tent. Then everybody started getting up and starting to run in more
00:50:58 of a chaos kind of situation. He said he recognized the noise as gunfire. He left his post. He began
00:51:03 fighting against the crowd, flowing against him, so I can help stop an individual that's probably
00:51:07 shooting, and he's looking for the shooter. By the time he got to the bottom of the stairs,
00:51:10 someone said, or the radio, we had a shooter in custody. As Bagley recounted the events
00:51:15 of the shooting, Erica Kirk left the room. This was actually kind of a stunning development.
00:51:22 I know that Erica's going to leave, and Charlie's family's going to leave. His sister is there too,
00:51:27 not just his parents. When they get into the details of the shooting, none of them wants
00:51:31 to take that in. God bless them. Why should they have to? But Tyler Robinson is sitting in that
00:51:36 courtroom and he was reportedly laughing at the beginning of the hearing, not during the testimony,
00:51:43 but laughing. Picture it. And all the reports are that Erica burst out into tears before the
00:51:48 hearing even got going. And Tyler Robinson is sitting there laughing. I mean, I just can't
00:51:54 Imagine this dynamic of Erica having to sit feet away from the man accused of murdering
00:52:01 her husband, Charlie's poor parents and sister, same.
00:52:06 And soon, it could be today, it could be tomorrow, we haven't been told exactly when, they're
00:52:10 going to play that videotape of Luna, Lance Twiggs, the lover, furry trans person of the
00:52:18 defendant, Tyler Robinson.
00:52:19 And Tyler Robinson is going to see his trans furry lover testify against him.
00:52:26 And it'll be the first time they've seen each other, I believe, since the crime and since Robinson's arrest. 0.73
00:52:34 And he will have to sit there and listen to this lover sell him up the river.
00:52:39 And that will be quite a moment inside that courtroom.
00:52:41 so Bagley went on talked about how he began assessing whether anyone else was injured
00:52:50 didn't see any other injuries he did testify that he saw an empty pistol holder that was sitting on
00:52:56 top of the grass but then realized that there was a rifle shot he could see the low c building that
00:53:04 had a direct line of sight so he went there to see what was going on because he said he thought he
00:53:10 heard the shot come from the east he was later pressed on the fact that that wasn't in his report
00:53:15 that he had heard it come from the east but he added that yesterday and this would be in essence
00:53:20 what brought him to the scene of the shooting but it would also be his excuse for why he did not pick
00:53:26 up that holder the empty pistol holder and i'm sure the defense is going to make something out
00:53:31 of the fact that there was an empty pistol holder there that may have had evidence on it dna etc
00:53:36 What was never retrieved? More on that and the stunning videotape right after this break.
00:53:41 Are you feeling sluggish, bloated, not quite like yourself? This affects so many of us.
00:53:47 Life constantly bombards us with silent threats, processed foods, seed oils, artificial light,
00:53:53 nonstop stress, all of which can disrupt gut health, drain your energy, and weaken your immune
00:53:59 health while you're not even paying attention. When that happens, it's not that your body's
00:54:04 broken. It's that it might be missing the right inputs. This is why you need to know about Armra
00:54:09 Cholestrum. This thing's packed with more than 400 bioactive nutrients that they say can work
00:54:15 at a foundational level to fortify gut health. So many of our issues start with poor gut health
00:54:20 that can support immune health. They say it can also fuel recovery after a workout and promote
00:54:26 whole body vitality. Doesn't that sound good? Strong gut integrity can support metabolism,
00:54:33 skin and hair health. Yes. If you're having problems there, it could begin in your gut
00:54:37 and even performance and recovery, which is why cholesterol has long been valued
00:54:42 by some elite athletes. If you are looking to take back control of your health from the inside out,
00:54:47 consider Armra. And they have a special deal for you right now. Go to armra.com slash Megan
00:54:53 or enter MEGYN to get 30% off your first subscription order. That's armra.com slash MEGYN.
00:55:03 I'm going to bring in our panel in a minute, but first I just want to continue telling you
00:55:08 what happened yesterday and get you up to speed on where we are. I was in the midst of completing
00:55:13 Officer Bagley's testimony. He was a UVU campus officer at the time of the Charlie shooting and
00:55:22 was describing that he had seen an empty pistol holder that was sitting just on top of the grass.
00:55:28 he would later testify that he lost track of it and it disappeared. I'm sure the defense will want
00:55:33 to make something of that, but it is relevant that Utah is an open carry state. So it's not,
00:55:38 it's not like there was a shooting and, and now I found an empty holster and it must have come from
00:55:45 this empty holster. It's, it's Utah, it's open carry. There's probably holsters everywhere.
00:55:49 And in the chaos of a mass evacuation in a scary, dangerous event, it wouldn't be entirely shocking
00:55:56 to find somebody's on the ground. Perhaps somebody even pulled their weapon to protect themselves.
00:56:02 But if you're the defense lawyer, of course, you're going to make something of that. I mean,
00:56:05 I'd be arguing that's the real shooter. It wasn't my client who had that. And it wasn't a rifle.
00:56:11 It was a pistol. So that's where they're going. More back to Bagley. He described
00:56:17 going over to the low C center, right? He claimed that he saw, he believed he heard the shot come
00:56:23 from the east. That's where the low C center was. And that's the building on which the shooter,
00:56:27 Tyler Robinson, the accused shooter was accused of being when he fired these alleged shots.
00:56:33 He said he got there and he discovered a red and black screwdriver. He was shown a photograph from
00:56:40 the top of the low C center from which he said you could see the grass courtyard area and where
00:56:44 Charlie had been speaking. He described images shown in the courtroom of gravel. So they showed
00:56:50 the judge these images of gravel on the roof that had been disrupted of the Losi Center. At the very
00:56:56 top of the Losi Center, Bagley said he could observe what looks like a sniper pad, a person
00:57:01 that has been laid in a prone position with the markings of elbows, knees, and feet in the gravel
00:57:05 in the line of sight where Charlie's tent was. After his findings on the rooftop, Bagley said
00:57:11 he asked dispatch to look at the camera system to see if anyone was on the roof at the time of the
00:57:16 shooting. Now he's looking for corroborative evidence to what he's seeing in the gravel and
00:57:20 this screwdriver, which he thinks may be relevant. And he says, dispatch says there had been a man
00:57:26 on the roof and described that he ran to the edge, dropped down, crawled, got in a prone position
00:57:32 toward the direction of the tent. He then went to the police department in a nearby building to look
00:57:36 at the footage himself. At that moment, I realized I had more crimes, a bigger crime scene than I
00:57:41 needed to contain that I needed to contain and preserve for that moment. So you can see this
00:57:46 guy Bagley is important. Um, he went on to say that he went to the Northeast side of the building
00:57:50 outside the building. He saw impressions of the shoe print inside the grass and also up above on
00:57:58 the Northeast side of the building. I could see on the cement where someone had scuffed there,
00:58:03 then dropped down to the shoe imprint. He's attempting to lay down the evidence of the path
00:58:10 that the defendant he is arguing took um kathy nester cross-examined him in the way that we
00:58:18 showed you there zeroing in on that holster you know what happened to it bagley said he did not
00:58:24 know um and that no one had taken custody of it um then came david hull he is currently with the
00:58:35 utah department of public safety he was working as a state bureau of investigation um major crimes
00:58:43 division investigator at the time of the shooting and and they need hull to get in all the videos
00:58:49 that they have of who they say is tyler robinson that day and that's he started that yesterday
00:58:55 afternoon and that's he's still on the stand that's what he spent this morning doing so now
00:58:59 we're getting up to speed to current moment. He testified that he was directed to go down to the
00:59:06 university following the shooting. So Bagley's our guy to get us through the actual shooting.
00:59:10 And this guy came on the scene right after for, to investigate among the data gathered from
00:59:15 the general public, because he testified that they received multiple videos from the general public
00:59:20 were through tips and social media. Okay. Were videos taken at the scene, multiple videos
00:59:27 collected by the team were played in the courtroom, including clips of Charlie at the beginning of
00:59:30 the event, a video showing the moment Charlie was shot, as well as Charlie in the moments after he
00:59:36 was shot. There was a stunning moment in which they played the judge seeing Charlie get shot.
00:59:47 And I think I mentioned this yesterday, but he, you can't hear the audio. You can hear a little
00:59:54 bit. You can hear the shot go off, but you can see the judge, Judge Graff, react. He winces.
01:00:01 He is just, you see the judge's humanity. He winces when you can hear the shot and you can
01:00:07 see him, yeah, struggling to contain his emotions as the SOP plays out. In fact, no, it was on AM
01:00:14 update. We didn't play it here. Can we play it now? Let's go ahead and play this video only on
01:00:20 the monitors and if there's sound associated with it the sound to be played as well you may proceed
01:00:26 the listening audience you can see the judge at the moment of the shot and if you listen to
01:00:44 turn the sound up you can hear the shot and he he jumps the way you do like a jump scare in a movie
01:00:51 and then you can see him push his chair back it's an instinctive protective mechanism right like
01:00:57 push your chair back from the screen like we all want to when we see that video you don't want
01:01:01 anything to do with it you don't want to be seeing it you don't want it to be true and then he comes
01:01:06 back in toward the laptop it's all very subtle but it's happening and then you can see the judge
01:01:11 kind of put his tongue to the side of his mouth. It's stress, that stress and anxiety
01:01:17 manifesting in him. And he's a consummate professional. He's holding it completely
01:01:23 together, but you can just see his humanity and a judge, a distinguished judge trying to control it
01:01:29 and control his emotions because he is a human inside that robe. He has a job to do, but he's a
01:01:36 human. He's a human being who clearly has empathy for poor Charlie and what happened to him, and
01:01:41 that comforts me to know that. Back to David Hull, again, who was with the State Bureau of
01:01:48 Investigation Major Crimes Division on the day of the shooting, who talked about the multiple videos,
01:01:54 and he talked about the medical examiner who was at the scene who told him that he had pronounced
01:01:59 Charlie dead. He testified that the Utah Medical Examiner's Office conducted an autopsy late in
01:02:05 the evening of September 10th, and that the cause of death was listed in the autopsy report. He first
01:02:13 said as a murder, the manner of death, a gunshot wound to the neck. The defense lawyer objected
01:02:20 that the cause of death was actually listed as homicide, not murder, which is a legal distinction.
01:02:25 Murder has to be proven in a court, and the comment was corrected. Hull said on the night
01:02:32 of September 11th, the next night, Thursday, we received word from Washington County that an
01:02:36 individual in the area had reached out to law enforcement and was wanting to turn themselves
01:02:41 in for the incident at UVU. He said the name that they were given from Washington County was Tyler
01:02:46 Robinson. After receiving the name, they put together a workup of his driver's lessons and
01:02:51 other records to get some info on him, his car, and so on. After that information, they were able
01:02:56 to use video to try to track where Tyler Robinson went and that they were able to establish that
01:03:02 Tyler Robinson, quote, had been on campus approximately four times throughout the day, twice before the shooting, the time of the shooting, and after the shooting, later in the evening, into the early hours of the 11th.
01:03:15 There was testimony about something, I think it was 12.38 a.m. that night.
01:03:21 so he was there twice before at the time of the shooting and then into the wee hours of
01:03:27 between the 10th and the 11th when asked if the man on the videos was in the courtroom 0.98
01:03:33 he was about to point out Tyler Robinson the defense objected which is such a bullshit
01:03:37 objection but in any event ultimately he was allowed to identify that the man sitting in
01:03:42 the courtroom as Tyler Robinson was the man who was on those videos and he also recounted footage
01:03:48 that was gathered from nearby neighborhoods,
01:03:50 including ring doorbell footage
01:03:52 showing a vehicle consistent
01:03:54 with the one identified as belonging to Robinson
01:03:56 parking across the street.
01:03:57 Again, in the early hours of September 11th,
01:03:59 what we would learn from Hull
01:04:02 is that Tyler Robinson was there.
01:04:04 It reminded me, frankly, of Brian Kohlberger
01:04:06 who stalked the location of his crime
01:04:11 prior to committing it,
01:04:12 of course was there while committing it
01:04:14 and then went back again after.
01:04:17 That's what they're saying Tyler Robinson did as well.
01:04:20 It appears clear Tyler Robinson was there repeatedly at least four times that day.
01:04:24 They'll argue about whether he pulled the trigger, but they're setting up that he was there repeatedly.
01:04:30 And then today we got to the videos that they found of Robinson, of who they say is Robinson.
01:04:37 You look at these videos, you can't clearly tell it's Robinson.
01:04:40 They're going to have to prove that.
01:04:42 But there's definitely video of the same guy first in a maroon shirt and gray shorts on the campus and later in an outfit change. And they've got video of what they say is Tyler Robinson's car because now they know it's registered to him and to his mother. There was testimony by Hull to that effect. He's getting cross examined now.
01:05:00 But I want to show you first our compilation of the video we were watching just as we came to air.
01:05:07 And I should also tell you, there was a fight late yesterday about whether the prosecution's compilation of all these videos, where they highlighted the man who we're supposed to focus on, they blurred the faces of some people, they made it more user-friendly, was objected to by the defense.
01:05:24 she objects to everything she's getting fucking annoying um objected to and they didn't allow it
01:05:31 in yesterday now today they they laid the foundation by showing all the raw videos 0.87
01:05:35 and then they asked the judge if they could then introduce the compilation video which is a shorter
01:05:40 summary that that's more user-friendly she objected again and he sustained the objection so
01:05:45 well at least we we the media are not going to be able to see the compilation video so he he can see
01:05:51 it. But for some reason, they don't want to make it easier for the media to see it. We'll do our
01:05:57 own. Sorry to disappoint you, Ms. Nestor, but we're pretty good in the TV world of taking raw
01:06:03 video and zeroing in. I think you're probably going to be happier with what the prosecution
01:06:07 did, frankly, because we're under no obligation as the prosecutor is to keep it completely
01:06:12 objective and admissible. So whatever. We did what we could in the time we had before this
01:06:20 just aired an hour and 20 minutes ago, but here's three minutes of what they showed the court on
01:06:25 the videos of who they say is Tyler Robinson all over the UVU campus that day. What are we seeing
01:06:33 here, Agent Hall? That's the vehicle that is believed to belong to Mr. Robinson arriving in
01:06:38 the parking garage on campus. At what time in the morning? Well, what time of the day? It's
01:06:43 approximately 8.30 in the morning on September 10th, 2025. And what leads you to believe that
01:06:49 this particular vehicle belongs to Mr. Robinson?
01:06:53 Information that was provided regards to driver's license and Department of Motor Vehicle records.
01:07:01 The vehicle fits the description of a vehicle owned by Mr. Robinson.
01:07:04 Is there anything unique about that vehicle that stands out to you?
01:07:07 The shape of the vehicle is very distinct, but predominantly the wheels were very distinctive on this version of the vehicle.
01:07:15 Now what do we see?
01:07:17 The driver of the vehicle exits the vehicle and then walks on foot to exit the parking garage.
01:07:25 It's the individual in the red T-shirt and the shorts and the shoes.
01:07:33 And do you believe you recognize who that person is?
01:07:35 Yes.
01:07:36 Who is that?
01:07:37 I believe that it's Tyler Robinson.
01:07:39 All right.
01:07:39 Where does he go from there?
01:07:42 He heads out of the parking garage on foot into the campus.
01:07:46 and actually goes to the quad area of the campus.
01:07:50 At that time, he makes contact with some representatives from TPUSA.
01:07:56 By quad area?
01:07:58 Sorry, the amphitheater is what I've previously referred it to.
01:08:02 So he goes up on campus, visits the amphitheater area, the courtyard or quad.
01:08:07 Correct.
01:08:07 And then what do we see here now?
01:08:09 He returns on foot back to the same vehicle.
01:08:12 And what time is he returning back to the vehicle?
01:08:15 It's about 9.25 a.m.
01:08:25 And where is this parking structure located on campus?
01:08:28 It's just off of Campus Drive.
01:08:31 It's a short walk from the amphitheater.
01:08:35 What do we see now?
01:08:38 That's the vehicle exiting with Mr. Robinson driving the vehicle.
01:08:44 now what have we seen this is mr robinson returning to the campus on foot from um the
01:08:54 neighborhood to the northeast you can see he's wearing the same clothing as in the previous video
01:08:59 and he's carrying a blue backpack describe the clothing uh it's a maroon colored t-shirt uh with
01:09:07 uh gray or olive colored shorts and then converse shoes
01:09:12 and what time did he return to campus uh just after 10 a.m and does he leave the parking
01:09:23 structure eventually uh he does yes and during this visit do you know where he goes after he
01:09:29 leaves the the parking structure yes we were able to track his movements on campus he went to
01:09:34 Chick-fil-A, um, in the Sorenson building, uh, purchased some food, sat and ate the food.
01:09:42 Okay. So that's him prior to the murder. And then they showed video of a figure
01:09:49 on the roof of the low C building and video that has been publicly released. This is there. You
01:09:58 can see a figure running on the top right of your screen running across. This is him post
01:10:02 shooting, allegedly. And here now, for listening audience, it's a figure who appears to throw
01:10:08 something down. He's on the edge of the roof. This has been made public prior to this, so you may be
01:10:13 familiar with it. And he drops to the ground into the grass where the officer had said he found a
01:10:19 footprint and runs. So this is what Officer Bagley said he witnessed when he went to the dispatch
01:10:26 center and said, you know, I found evidence of some guy on the roof. What do you have? And the
01:10:31 dispatch saying, oh yeah, no, we've got that too. So they, they found the video. All right,
01:10:35 let's bring in our panel now and get their reactions. Dave Ehrenberg is here. So is Phil
01:10:40 Holloway. They are co-hosts of the MK true crime show on the MK media podcast network.
01:10:44 Go and subscribe just by typing in MK true crime in your podcast feed and it will come up.
01:10:50 Guys, thank you for being back with me. So Dave, just give us your impression. I've given the
01:10:55 audience a lot here on what, on what's gone on yesterday and today. Give us your impression on
01:11:00 what exactly is happening, what the prosecution is building and what the defense is trying to
01:11:04 undermine. Megan, good to be back with you. And Phil, this is the longest preliminary hearing
01:11:10 that I've ever seen for something like this, where all you have to do is establish probable
01:11:14 cause. I mean, this should be done in hours. But I think you're right that the reason why
01:11:19 the prosecution is just using overwhelming force here, I mean, shock and awe is to debunk the
01:11:25 conspiracy theories out there, especially since the defense leaned into a ballistics report that
01:11:30 was inconclusive. The prosecution so far has not challenged that. They've tried to like look away
01:11:36 from the inconclusive ballistics into all the other evidence that's there, like his multiple
01:11:42 confessions, his position on the roof, the video where he's running away. I mean, they've got a lot
01:11:48 of evidence against this guy and they don't need to show it but they are because they're aware
01:11:55 of the gravity of this moment how many conspiracy theories are out there some of it has been pushed
01:12:00 by the defense themselves and they want to get ahead of it phil what do you make of my comment
01:12:06 that this guy's giving brian kohlberger vibes with the multiple visits before and even going back
01:12:14 after midnight, the day, the evening of the crime, like after the crime was committed.
01:12:22 Yeah, that's an excellent point. And to echo Dave's very well-stated comments there,
01:12:29 the prosecutor is showing way more of their cards than they, in my view, than they need to or they
01:12:35 should. It's kind of like when you play poker, you don't show the rest of the table what you're
01:12:40 holding in your hand, by giving this much detail and this much evidence, you're just giving
01:12:45 the defense the opportunity to pick it apart for trial. But that being said, what they're showing
01:12:51 is premeditation. They're showing deliberation. They're showing what they really would need to
01:12:57 show to get the death penalty in this case. Now, this, of course, isn't the trial. This is not the
01:13:01 penalty phase or anything like that. But it gives us a little bit of a preview of what we're going
01:13:06 to see when there is a trial. And if you have this much premeditation, deliberation, preparation,
01:13:14 consciousness of guilt, the fleeing from the scene, things of that nature, all of that goes to show
01:13:21 that this was cold. This was calculated. This is the abandoned and malignant heart that we use
01:13:28 to describe what malice is. This was truly a malicious act. The videos themselves, I think we
01:13:35 could do for purposes of the prelim. We could do with less of that, but the confession that we have
01:13:41 yet to get to, you know, that's corroborated by these videos. So I agree with Dave to bring this
01:13:47 all together. I think they could have done this in about an hour or two. You show the video of the
01:13:52 shooting of Charlie Kirk. You show some of these videos for context like we've seen, and then you
01:13:58 get to the confession, and then you put a big bow on it and say, okay, we're getting ready for trial
01:14:03 now because we've established probable cause. A crime probably was committed. Well, clearly that
01:14:08 shows that a crime was committed and that this defendant is probably the one who committed it.
01:14:14 That's it. That's all you need to prove. This should be over in just a matter of hours,
01:14:18 but it's dragging on and on and on, and it gives the defense more opportunities to chip away and
01:14:23 to prepare their defense for trial. I just want to point out to the listening audience, now we're
01:14:28 looking at a different video that was shown of who they say is tyler robinson wearing a different
01:14:33 outfit now he's in the outfit that the fbi says the shooter was wearing and he's he's walking
01:14:40 funny there's speculation that that's because he's got a long gun down his pants um he's walking
01:14:45 kind of funny like with a limp he's no longer wearing the gray shirts and shorts and the maroon
01:14:50 t-shirt and the testimony in court is that this is after the shooting after the shooting or before
01:14:57 the shooting we're trying to figure this out forgive me um because we grab this video and
01:15:01 enhance it like zoomed in just so you could see it better um but it must be it's got to be before
01:15:07 the shooting because i i believe this is the video from which they made the pictures that we
01:15:13 identified tyler robinson and the allegation is that after the shooting he jumped off of the
01:15:17 rooftop and dropped the gun down below and then buried it or hit it in the woods so this my
01:15:23 deduction is it's got to be on his way to the shooting but the here's the question i have for
01:15:28 you dave erenberg the prosecution needs to prove they want to prove that this was him that he
01:15:32 he stalked his prey you know he he showed up at nine at 8 30 a.m the morning of charlie's
01:15:40 appearance that he was there for an hour they said he it took him he arrived at 8 30 and he left at
01:15:47 925. And in that time he went to the quad and he made contact with a TPA, TP USA representative.
01:15:55 Maybe he's asking exactly when Charlie's expected, you know, who knows that poor
01:15:59 turning point rep will probably wind up being a witness and had no idea, right. Who they're
01:16:06 talking to or who they're giving information to. Um, and then he returns, they said a little after
01:16:12 10 a.m. we saw the car pulling out of the garage at 9 25 a little after 10 a.m. they said he
01:16:18 returned on foot but they said he returned on foot with the same outfit that maroon tee and
01:16:25 the gray shorts and that he went to chick-fil-a at the sorenson center on campus and then returned
01:16:33 back on campus like on proper campus no longer carrying the backpack and i believe that's when
01:16:39 he changed his outfit and got rid of the backpack. That we need to shore up because that was not
01:16:44 clear to me from what I heard. But it's one thing to tell the judge and eventually the jury, Dave,
01:16:49 that's Tyler Robinson. There he is. And it's another to prove it, right? Because if you're
01:16:55 Nestor, she's questioning everything. She is not giving the prosecution any gimmies. It's actually
01:17:01 annoying. But on this, she should question, right? She should say, how do you know it's Tyler
01:17:06 robinson now on the on the car they've they've got the registration they can see the plates and
01:17:11 the car the officer testified is registered to tyler and his mother and there was testimony
01:17:16 that she bought it for him um so i guess that's halfway there then you got to prove that's
01:17:22 actually him getting out of it so how do they do all that if you're the prosecutor as you have been
01:17:27 for years how do you do that step by step megan first they identified his dodge challenger and
01:17:35 And then because they ran his license plate, they had driver's license details.
01:17:38 So they know that that's his car.
01:17:40 And then you had Agent Hull who testified that the person in the video showed a distinctive limp that you can see yourself.
01:17:52 And then you want to try to tie it to him.
01:17:56 And once that Robinson turned himself in, they could correlate that the timeline matched the digital footprint, including the cell phone data and the specific route that was identified via the Google map records.
01:18:12 So the fact that he was there on campus four times that day, that does give the Koberger vibe.
01:18:18 Someone who's scouting it out and then comes back over and over again. 0.94
01:18:22 And I just think that you just have to put all this stuff together and with all the totality of the evidence to show that this is the guy.
01:18:31 The defense is doing the right thing by asking all these questions, although, yeah, she's getting a little annoying.
01:18:35 But she is using this as a way to get the cards, as Phil said, from the prosecution.
01:18:42 The prosecution is showing so much evidence. They're giving the defense a great amount of stuff that they wouldn't normally have.
01:18:48 So this hearing can actually benefit the defense more than the prosecution because they're getting all this good info, even though they don't have twigs in person.
01:18:57 Oh, yeah. Yeah. Yeah, exactly. Well, they're not going to they're not going to be able to talk to twigs, but they're going to hear what he what he has to say.
01:19:05 I mean, to me, it's interesting because, Phil, all this stuff like. Doesn't the defense already have access to all of this, right?
01:19:12 The prosecution doesn't get surprises.
01:19:14 They have to turn everything over to the defense.
01:19:17 And so it's different to hear them stitch it together and to hear their narrative.
01:19:21 But the defense should not be surprised by any of these exhibits.
01:19:25 No, they're not surprised by the evidence or the exhibits.
01:19:28 But here's what they don't have until there's a hearing.
01:19:31 They don't have sworn testimony from these witnesses under oath.
01:19:35 And let me explain just a minute, if I may, why that could backfire on the prosecution.
01:19:41 because these are witnesses that are going to come forward at trial, okay?
01:19:45 There's going to be a transcript of this preliminary hearing
01:19:48 and the testimony from these witnesses.
01:19:51 If their story is any different, if their testimony varies one iota at trial,
01:19:57 the defense is going to whip out the printed transcript of this particular testimony,
01:20:03 and they're going to, even if it's just innocuous,
01:20:06 if it's something just a minor misstatement or something like that,
01:20:10 They're going to try to show the jury that they said one thing during the preliminary hearing and then something else during the trial, and they're going to try to impeach them potentially with any prior inconsistent statements.
01:20:22 The other thing that it does is it gives the defense sort of the opportunity to see how witnesses testify.
01:20:30 How do they do on cross-examination?
01:20:31 What's their demeanor?
01:20:32 How are they going to play to a jury?
01:20:34 So this really does give the defense a lot to work with.
01:20:39 We have a group text amongst our MK Truth Crime hosts, and we've been talking about this case.
01:20:46 And our friend and colleague Mark Garagos commented that this length of a preliminary hearing is good for the defense.
01:20:54 And he's not wrong.
01:20:55 He's absolutely right.
01:20:57 This was a mistake to do it the way they're doing it for this to go on for so long.
01:21:03 They need to just get the core evidence out there.
01:21:06 They have to prove that a crime probably was committed and that this guy probably did it.
01:21:12 And that's it.
01:21:12 They could do it like we were talking about just in a matter of a few hours.
01:21:16 The other thing they could have done is they could have sent this to a grand jury for a grand jury indictment so that that would be a judicial determination of probable cause.
01:21:25 But by doing it in this fashion, not only are they frustrating us in the media because we can't see all the evidence that the judge is seeing,
01:21:33 but they're giving the defense lots to work with when it comes to trial preparation.
01:21:38 No, but listen to this, Phil.
01:21:40 The failure to use a grand jury and to go for a preliminary hearing
01:21:44 where you have to lift the dress way up
01:21:46 has boggled the minds of a lot of lawyers, including this one.
01:21:50 But we actually did take a deep dive into it.
01:21:52 We had been told yesterday that it's not favored in Utah.
01:21:55 They don't use grand juries a lot.
01:21:57 And then we did a deep dive, and here is what we found.
01:21:59 In Utah's criminal justice system, grand jury indictments are rare.
01:22:04 The Utah Supreme Court laid this out in a 2015 decision.
01:22:08 The vast majority of felony cases are prosecuted by information, that is, by a prosecutor filing charges directly in district court.
01:22:17 The historical role of the grand jury is now generally played by the district court itself, which holds preliminary hearings to review the state's evidence and reject unjustified prosecutions.
01:22:27 A prosecutor wishing to prosecute by indictment must first persuade a special panel of five district judges.
01:22:35 This is if you want to go jury, grand jury, that there is good cause to summon a grand jury.
01:22:40 If the panel then summons the grand jury, the prosecutor may then ask the jurors to return an indictment and charge the defendant without a preliminary hearing.
01:22:48 But they make it intentionally difficult.
01:22:50 Well, for some reason, they really don't like impaneling grand juries in Utah, which is why they do the preliminary hearing.
01:22:57 And once you've said, you know, you're going to ask the district court to give you an indictment, the defendant has the right to demand the preliminary hearing.
01:23:06 And that's, you know, Bob's your uncle. You're off to the races, which is what happened here.
01:23:10 I don't know why they don't like the grand jury, but they don't like it in Utah.
01:23:13 That's why the prosecution is doing it this way.
01:23:15 um i want to go back to these videos because this video that we're going to see here we showed part
01:23:23 of it just a moment ago of him now in a different outfit this is the outfit that was released by the
01:23:29 fbi as being worn by charlie's killer and this is the these are the pictures this is the video
01:23:37 of the still shots that were used to identify who is this shooter the fbi put it out on september
01:23:45 11th saying, this is our shooter. Does anybody know who this is? And it would turn out that
01:23:49 Tyler Robinson's own mother and father saw it and both said, oh my God, that's our son.
01:23:56 They both started texting him. The mother saying, where are you? He claimed he was sick, homesick,
01:24:02 and that he had been the day before. The father saying, send me a picture of grandpa's gun right
01:24:08 now because he knew the FBI had released the picture that law enforcement had it, had recovered
01:24:13 the gun and the father recognized it. And they were also worried because they saw the pictures
01:24:18 of the shooter and they said, geez, that looks a lot like Tyler. You know, it's like the same way
01:24:22 we've been looking at porch guy in the Nancy Guthrie case saying, we don't know who the hell
01:24:26 that is. But if you were married to that dude, you would know you, you know, when it's your family
01:24:31 member, your spouse, your kid, your dad, you know, in a way that strangers don't. So now we're seeing
01:24:39 the actual videotape from which these still images were were taken and and this is what
01:24:46 was played in court just as we were coming to air and we'll hear the narrative about the videotape
01:24:51 we showed you tyler robinson allegedly in the maroon shirt and the gray shorts parking coming
01:24:57 in at 8 30 leaving at 9 25 then he came back at 10 and now there's the here's the testimony about
01:25:04 the video of who they say is Tyler wearing the same outfit as the shooter here. The images that
01:25:09 we have are from from my viewing and seeing Mr. Robinson on the video. It's the same person.
01:25:20 He's noticeably wearing different clothing. He is wearing different clothing. And he also is
01:25:25 walking with a gate or a limp in this video with the gate or what? Limp.
01:25:34 Now, what do we see?
01:25:36 It says Mr. Robinson coming up the stairs of the parking structure.
01:25:42 Again, he seems to be having issues walking.
01:25:51 And again, were you able to track Mr. Robinson when he leaves this parking structure?
01:26:00 Yes, we were able to.
01:26:01 Okay.
01:26:02 So when he leaves...
01:26:04 Okay, so then they continue, and the testimony is that this is prior to the shooting. I mean, Dave, this is actually quite eerie. We're sort of doing a forensic analysis of it, but what they're arguing is that he was on his way to murder our friend who was out there asking questions, who had kissed his wife Erica goodbye early that morning while she was still in bed.
01:26:25 He left so early, who couldn't sleep the night before, who had a feeling about something possibly happening, who had been under nonstop security threats, who was not well served, unfortunately, by good-hearted men who were supposed to protect him that day, who didn't anticipate the rooftops, notwithstanding Butler 14 months earlier.
01:26:50 And Tyler Robinson, according to the police and the prosecution, had murder on his mind and was limping because that long gun given to him by his grandpa was running down his pant leg and would be one of the reasons he would get caught.
01:27:07 because he, you know, if you believe the text messages between Tyler and his lover, Lance
01:27:12 Twiggs, he hid it in the woods on his escape and couldn't get back to it. The cops got turned on
01:27:19 to the woods too soon. And so he wasn't able to get back. And maybe that's why he went back there
01:27:25 because if memory serves, we weren't aware that they had the gun until the next day, you know,
01:27:30 So it could be at 12.38 a.m. on the wee hours of Thursday the 11th.
01:27:37 That's what he was doing back there, trying to clean up after himself and couldn't manage to do it.
01:27:41 Yeah, Megan, a quick question, if I can joke.
01:27:43 Didn't, wasn't there some, as I recall, some of the statements that he made to Twigs were of the effect that, you know, I need to go back for my rifle.
01:27:54 As I recall, that was what the conversation was, and we're going to hear more about that, of course, when we hear from Twigs.
01:27:59 But that will, or at least through his statement.
01:28:02 And then, of course, at trial, we'll hear from Twiggs and anybody else.
01:28:06 But that, I think, explains why he went back.
01:28:08 And, you know, it makes sense that if you're going to sort of preposition items that you may need for an assassination,
01:28:16 you might make multiple trips to go get your spot set up, get your sniper's den set up,
01:28:21 and then have to leave in a hurry and then go back to clean up your mess.
01:28:25 So this all actually makes pretty good sense to me.
01:28:27 yes he is lamenting in his text exchange with lance twigs how he wasn't able to get his rifle
01:28:34 and he thought that was the only thing that could identify him um there was also testimony
01:28:39 the well dave i wanted to get you to respond to my my other point about how eerie it is and how
01:28:44 they're setting it up and how you know it's all so forensic and antiseptic and yet you know exactly
01:28:49 what these actions allegedly produced this had to take some real planning you know he had different
01:28:55 outfits he was limping when he had the gun on him and then later he's not he's wearing something
01:28:59 different later on and then he had to try to find out how to get the gun back even message twigs at
01:29:05 some point about how they'll be together later on uh in in life so this took planning and that
01:29:12 means premeditation and that means the death penalty and it is quite telling that this judge
01:29:18 had every opportunity to take the death penalty off the table because he is holding the prosecutors
01:29:24 in contempt for speaking too much, for giving a statement to TMZ, which I think is overplayed.
01:29:30 I don't think the judge should do that, but okay. But instead of sanctioning the prosecution by
01:29:35 taking the death penalty off the table, he's refusing to do that. He's leaving it open to
01:29:39 other sanctions. And that tells you that I think that this is going to be a capital case and that
01:29:45 it's very likely that this defendant gets the ultimate punishment. Yes, yes. And if they prove
01:29:53 this case beyond a reasonable doubt. That's exactly what he should get. Um, there should be
01:29:58 absolutely no mercy for him. He had none for Charlie. Here is, um, some of what was in that
01:30:03 text exchange that they say is between Lance Twiggs and Tyler Robinson. Um, as he starts to
01:30:11 panic that, hold on a second, that, that the gun has been left there. Let's see. Says I'm stuck in
01:30:20 Or, um, I am still okay. He starts off with September 10th, the day of the murder. Lance
01:30:27 Twiggs received a text message from Tyler Robinson, which said, drop what you're doing.
01:30:31 Look under my keyboard. He looked under the keyboard. He found a note that stated I had
01:30:34 the opportunity to take out Charlie Kirk and I'm going to take it. Police found a photograph of
01:30:38 the note, I believe on Lance Twiggs phone. Then the following text exchange took place.
01:30:44 After reading the note, Lance Twiggs responded, what you're joking, right? Robinson, I am still
01:30:49 okay, my love, but I'm stuck in Orem for a little while longer yet. Shouldn't be long until I can
01:30:54 come home, but I got to grab my rifle still. To be honest, I had hoped to keep this secret till
01:30:58 I died of old age. I'm sorry to involve you. Roommate, you weren't the one who did it, right?
01:31:03 Robinson, I am. I'm sorry. Roommate, I thought they caught the person. Robinson, no, they grabbed
01:31:08 some crazy old dude, then interrogated someone in similar clothing. I had planned to grab my rifle
01:31:14 from my drop point shortly after, but most of that side of town got locked down. It's quiet,
01:31:19 almost enough to get out, but there's one vehicle lingering. Roommate, why? Robinson, why did I do
01:31:24 it? Roommate, yeah. Robinson, I had enough of his hatred. Some hate can't be negotiated out.
01:31:31 If I am able to grab my rifle unseen, I will have left no evidence. Going to attempt to retrieve it
01:31:36 again. Hopefully they have moved on. I haven't seen anything about them finding it. Again,
01:31:41 And they didn't release the timestamp on this, but one might assume it's prior to 1238 a.m.
01:31:46 on the 11th, which is when they said he did.
01:31:49 He is on video again.
01:31:52 Roommate, how long have you been planning this, Robinson?
01:31:54 A bit over a week, I believe.
01:31:56 I can get close to it, but there's a squad car parked right by it.
01:31:59 I think they already swept that spot, but I don't want to chance it.
01:32:02 He goes on.
01:32:03 I'm wishing I had circled back and grabbed it as soon as I got to my vehicle.
01:32:07 I'm worried what my old man would do if I didn't bring back grandpa's rifle.
01:32:10 I don't even know if it had a serial number, but it wouldn't trace to me. I worry about Prince.
01:32:16 I had to leave it in a bush where I changed outfits. Didn't have the ability or time to
01:32:20 bring it with. I might have to abandon it and hope they don't find Prince. How the fuck am I
01:32:25 going? Will I explain losing it to my old man? Only thing I left was the rifle wrapped in a 0.99
01:32:31 towel. And then goes on to say, remember how I was engraving bullets. The effing messages are
01:32:37 mostly a big meme, blah, blah, blah, blah, blah. Judging from today, I'd say grandpa's gun does
01:32:43 just fine. Ugh, I know. See what I mean? All they got to do is show the video of the assassination
01:32:52 and then some context and then get into that particular text message confession with all
01:32:59 those details. And then you've got probable cause. It's like right there with a bow on it. And so
01:33:05 I just am still scratching my head why this is going to be something that takes
01:33:09 an entire week. I've handled prelims that take five minutes. I've handled them that take a few
01:33:14 hours. But we certainly are not accustomed, at least not in my neck of the woods anyway,
01:33:20 to preliminary hearings that go on for days and days and days. That would be called a trial.
01:33:25 But this is just a bit of overkill, if you ask me, pardon the pun. But for a preliminary hearing,
01:33:31 this is just too much. This has got to be for the benefit of someone other than that judge,
01:33:37 does it not, Dave? Absolutely. That is for the public. It's for all of us. And it's trying to
01:33:43 quell the conspiracy theories that think that foreign governments are behind them. They're
01:33:46 showing this guy has admitted it. There's no ties to anyone else. He did it for a clear motive. He
01:33:52 was upset at Charlie Kirk for stuff he said. He decided to play God, take matters into his own
01:33:57 hands and he wanted to win the affections of twigs and live happily ever after together he
01:34:02 thought he'd get away with it he was already uh you know pretty much just saying oh his concern
01:34:08 was not necessarily that they'd find the gun and tie it to him and he would get convicted it was
01:34:11 oh my father is going to be upset that grandpa's gun is not back oh wow so yeah not good i mean
01:34:19 like i how do we like i don't know maybe i'm just being naive but it's like how does somebody who
01:34:27 was relatively high functioning up to this point become so cavalier about murder like oh i've been
01:34:36 planning it for like a week like a week earlier he got the idea to murder charlie kirk in this
01:34:43 and i don't use this favorably but you know what i mean spectacular fashion and then he does it
01:34:50 and then it's like oh the grandpa's rifle works great like he's not by anybody else's account
01:34:58 some massive sociopath running around torturing animals phil like isn't that one of the biggest
01:35:04 mysteries around this case and one of one of the reasons why people have doubts about whether he
01:35:09 in fact is the shooter it's like what how did this guy who according to that one video we saw
01:35:15 of his mom shortly before he went off to college had, I think he had gotten a scholarship. Now he
01:35:20 didn't last at the university to which he'd gotten the scholarship, but he wasn't, you know, prior to
01:35:26 this year leading up to the shooting, he seems to have been rather high functioning. And it, you
01:35:31 really do have to ask yourself, how, how did this happen? Well, in my opinion, the thing that
01:35:35 happened to Tyler Robinson that transformed him from a relatively high functioning individual to
01:35:42 a brazen assassin was the normalization of political violence and the violent rhetoric
01:35:52 that we hear from so many, particularly on the left, who may take issue with anything that
01:35:59 conservatives have to say. Look, it's no secret whatsoever that Charlie Kirk inspired lots of
01:36:06 people to think about things and to talk about things. And what he did in life was to try to
01:36:12 get people talking to each other so that they can have a free exchange of ideas. But for so many
01:36:18 people, that's just not tenable. They want to hear something that someone else says, and if it's
01:36:24 different from their point of view, then they believe that it's okay to commit acts of violence
01:36:31 or to talk about violence against those people. So that, to me, is the simple explanation. I think
01:36:38 it's the one that makes the most sense because, to your point, Megan, there's got to be something
01:36:43 that causes someone to snap that way. He doesn't apparently have any other psychiatric disabilities
01:36:49 or disorders. He doesn't seem to be like a sociopath. He's not like some of the serial
01:36:54 killers that we've seen. He's not like a Koberger type in that sense. This is all about the 0.59
01:37:00 normalization, in my opinion, of political violence, and this is how it plays out.
01:37:06 Megan, this is Luigi Mangione. I mean, this is the same type of thing.
01:37:11 I know. I was thinking of him, too.
01:37:12 Yeah. And not only so when you're surprised about how people can be so radicalized, Luigi Mangione from Ivy League schools, no priors.
01:37:20 And look what happens to him. And then you see today all these ghouls who are hanging outside the courtroom praising Luigi Mangione and worshiping him, knowing that he did this.
01:37:30 It's not like they're saying he didn't do it. He's innocent. No, they're saying, no, this is deserved.
01:37:34 This is justified in today's political climate.
01:37:37 That line, some hate can't be negotiated out.
01:37:41 Just chilling.
01:37:43 You know, it's like to believe that and think you have you have the right to end someone's life because they're too hateful to be here.
01:37:54 And then to have watched the left defend this for the past 10 months, that Lucy Rodriguez pretending to shoot herself in the neck, she's still teaching children in Chicago.
01:38:07 That behavior wasn't too extreme for them to fire her.
01:38:12 There is just a collection of people out there that finds this kind of political violence acceptable.
01:38:18 It's so deeply disturbing.
01:38:20 I wish it were just the shooters.
01:38:22 I wish it were, but it's not.
01:38:23 There's a collection, like you say, of those who show up at the Luigi hearings who think it's fine, of those who have celebrated Charlie's murder, who at heart think it's fine and actually applaud it, actually are in favor of it.
01:38:36 It's sick.
01:38:37 Dave, thank you for helping to put people like that behind bars for many, many years.
01:38:41 Phil, thanks to you as well.
01:38:42 Everybody check them out on MK True Crime, wherever you get your podcasts for free.
01:38:48 We're going to come back with more on the hearing with Mark Garagos, Mark Eiglarsh,
01:38:52 and Jonna Spilbore.
01:38:54 All three of these practice in the criminal arena have been on both sides, at least Mark
01:39:00 Eiglarsh has.
01:39:02 And we'll get their take on where this is going and show you the latest that's happening
01:39:06 inside the courtroom.
01:39:07 Our sponsor, the Electronic Payments Coalition, says Washington politicians are always getting
01:39:13 in your wallet, which you know, and now they're messing with your credit card too.
01:39:18 They say your credit card and the security it offers are under attack and that Senators
01:39:22 Dick Durbin and Roger Marshall want to change the nation's payment system to benefit corporate
01:39:28 megastores like Walmart and Target at the expense of everyday Americans.
01:39:33 Credit cards can keep your payments secure and provide rewards that families use to help
01:39:38 make everyday purchases much more affordable.
01:39:41 We all love that.
01:39:42 The Electronic Payments Coalition says the Durbin-Marshall mandates would let corporate
01:39:46 megastores, cut corners on credit card processing, routing transactions over cheaper, untested
01:39:52 networks with weaker security, and fewer protections. Find out more about this whole
01:39:57 situation at guardyourcard.com and consider telling Congress to guard your card.
01:40:16 of casino games. What you win is yours to keep.
01:40:19 No wagering requirements, instant payouts,
01:40:20 and no minimum withdrawals. Hey, I just won!
01:40:23 Woohoo! Feel the fun,
01:40:24 play, oh Joe. Honey, forget about
01:40:26 lasagna. Let's celebrate. 19 plus Ontario
01:40:28 only. Please play responsibly. Concerned about your gambling or that of someone
01:40:30 close to you? Call 1-866-531-2600
01:40:32 or visit connexontario.ca.
01:40:34 Alright, full-time thoughts. Craig, who stood out?
01:40:36 Brazil's lime cheesecake started bright,
01:40:38 didn't let up. Nah, for me, Italian cappuccino
01:40:40 was the standout in the box. But if we're
01:40:42 talking decadent performance, that's all 0.70
01:40:44 France. Chocolate creme brulee had the richest
01:40:46 finishes. Canadian fireworks really showed up big too. And Mexico's caramel churro ice cap gave me
01:40:52 chills. We are of course talking about Tim's taste of the globe lineup. New globally inspired Tim
01:40:57 bits and ice cap flavors available at Tim Hortons for a limited time. Pick some up today and while
01:41:01 you're at it, check out Footy Prime Daily. Hey everyone, it's me, Megan Kelly. I've got some
01:41:07 exciting news. I now have my very own channel on Sirius XM. It's called the Megan Kelly channel
01:41:13 And it is where you will hear the truth, unfiltered, with no agenda and no apologies.
01:41:18 Along with The Megyn Kelly Show, you're going to hear from people like Mark Halperin, Link Lauren, Maureen Callahan, Emily Drushinsky, Jesse Kelly, Real Clear Politics, and many more.
01:41:27 It's bold, no BS news, only on The Megyn Kelly Channel, Sirius XM 111, and on the Sirius XM app.
01:41:34 we are back now with mark garagos co-host of in the well on our mk media podcast network
01:41:44 mark iglarsh and jana spillbar who host positively legal you can find it all on our mk true crime
01:41:51 youtube channel mk true crime just type that in and all these shows will come up jana we were
01:41:56 going to get your take on where things stand as of right now katherine nester cannot have
01:42:02 a realistic expectation that this case is not going to be bound over for trial. So what I think
01:42:09 she's doing, which is pretty clear from this dog and pony show, she is simply setting up now
01:42:16 testimony that will become useful when and if this case goes to trial to sort of have police
01:42:23 officers and other witnesses tripping over their tongues based on maybe testifying differently at
01:42:28 trial than they are now. Now, we don't want that to happen when you're prosecuting this case. But
01:42:34 when you get down this granular and you try to get this nitty gritty with these witnesses who
01:42:39 are going to have a long time before this case goes to trial, who will have to review their
01:42:43 testimony in transcripts before the case goes to trial, that's just an opportunity to chip away
01:42:49 in front of what is really going to matter here. And that's a jury. And that goes to the
01:42:54 identification of Tyler Robinson, too. She's probably preserving those objections because
01:42:59 that's an argument better made or that's evidence better laid before a jury. Do they have the right
01:43:06 guy? That's that argument is going to fall flat in front of this judge, but it may not fall flat
01:43:11 in front of 12 strangers down the road. You know, I was asking my earlier panel,
01:43:19 How do they prove that this is Tyler Robinson in these videos, arriving at the campus at
01:43:25 830, leaving at 925, coming back a little after 10 on foot, coming in an outfit change,
01:43:32 now limping because prosecutors are going to argue he's got a long gun down the leg
01:43:37 of his pants and then ultimately on that roof.
01:43:40 And one of the things we haven't really seen anything about or heard anything about is
01:43:46 cell phone evidence or the data from the car. You know, like we saw in Alec Murdoch. You know,
01:43:55 we heard so much about that crime thanks to his car. Your car is spying on you these days. So
01:44:01 what do you make of that? How how helpful do you anticipate those other items could be?
01:44:06 Okay, so I equate the video that we're seeing now to I don't know, like bloodshot eyes in a DUI case
01:44:13 That in and of itself wouldn't necessarily prove anything beyond a reasonable doubt.
01:44:17 It's just one piece of the puzzle.
01:44:20 The other evidence, like the DNA and the confession, will definitely go a long way towards increasing the chances of him being convicted at trial, assuming there is one.
01:44:29 The absence of cell phone data either is because they haven't yet put it in or they better as hell have an explanation from one of their experts as to why for some reason they don't have it in this case, because people have come to expect it.
01:44:44 Well, especially because we know he was texting with Lance Twiggs, I mean, allegedly later that evening about allegedly having done it.
01:44:52 So, I mean, if that's true, he should have had his cell phone or a laptop on him, both of which would be potentially traceable.
01:44:58 and should tell us exactly where he was and when.
01:45:03 Shouldn't they, Mark Garagos?
01:45:04 It's very hard to hide your tracks these days.
01:45:09 That's correct, which is in most people who have a couple of neurons firing,
01:45:14 if you're committing a crime, you're not going to take your phone with you
01:45:19 or you're going to have what prosecutors love to call a burner phone with you
01:45:24 that doesn't have a smartphone feature of some kind that's traceable.
01:45:29 But if he planned this, the prosecutor is going to argue if they don't have cell phone evidence
01:45:36 or if the phone is sitting in one particular spot during the time that the shooting took place,
01:45:43 they're going to say he didn't take it with him.
01:45:46 And that'll be the explanation for it.
01:45:48 If they have the cell phone evidence in the data and the triangulation and the pinging off the towers and also the GPS feature, then they may just use that coming later on as kind of the coup de grace.
01:46:03 They may have a so-called summary witness who will lay it all out at the end.
01:46:08 But I think that's coming later. I think you're right, because it's not listed on the items that they anticipate introducing at this preliminary hearing, which, again, they only need to convince this judge that they have probable cause to believe that Tyler Robinson committed this crime.
01:46:22 They don't have to prove it beyond a reasonable doubt.
01:46:24 The standards of evidence are relaxed.
01:46:27 It's just a much different proceeding than an actual jury trial would be, and the standard
01:46:31 is different too.
01:46:32 Here's another video.
01:46:33 This is a testimony that was received not long ago showing another piece of the trail.
01:46:40 We showed earlier the video of him allegedly arriving at 8.30 and then leaving at 9.25,
01:46:45 and now here's more testimony from this witness who's been walking us through all the videos
01:46:51 they have allegedly of tyler robinson check it out and and what time is this it's just afternoon
01:46:59 about 12 15 on what day on december sorry december september 10th 2025 what what just happened or
01:47:08 what did we just see happen the individual actually kind of rolls over the railing onto
01:47:14 to the roof of the Loci building.
01:47:15 All right, go ahead, sir.
01:47:20 And again, in the top left corner,
01:47:21 the individual is now seen running across
01:47:23 the rooftop of the Loci building
01:47:26 to what would be the southwest corner of the building,
01:47:31 crouching down and then crawling
01:47:33 to the corner of the building.
01:47:38 And this is at what time?
01:47:42 Around 12.23.
01:47:44 i think the time stamp on the video is 12 22 on the 10th on september 10th yes 2025
01:47:52 we're clear this is the roof of the low sea building correct okay can you still see that
01:47:58 individual uh yes you can laying prone that is playing prone i mean wait what'd you say garagos
01:48:07 that individual both the questions and the answers but to describe the individual
01:48:12 Mm hmm. But we've seen the close up video of the individual and he's wearing the same outfit as, you know, the one that they would later say is the shooter.
01:48:24 And please help us identify him who they say is Tyler Robinson.
01:48:27 I just think like there's going to be there's this is how it's done, is it not?
01:48:32 I mean, you guys tell me, but like if you're a prosecutor, you've got to cobble together bit by bit.
01:48:38 Tyler Robinson's car re-entered the UVU campus at whatever, right before 1215.
01:48:44 The shooting happened at 1223.
01:48:45 They've got him on the roof for this figure who now looks exactly like Tyler Robinson, who's returned.
01:48:51 We've got his vehicle.
01:48:52 Perhaps they have vehicle of him or video of him getting out of his vehicle.
01:48:56 I'm not exactly sure whether they I haven't seen that.
01:48:58 I've only seen him show up in his vehicle at 830, leave at 925 that they said he came back at 10 a.m.
01:49:03 And then he came back again. He left and then came back. It could have been on foot.
01:49:08 But in any event, they're trying to establish that it's him. He changed his outfit.
01:49:11 Now he's got the long gun. It's down his pants.
01:49:13 Now we've got video of somebody who looks an awful lot like that figure who was just limping on camera,
01:49:17 who looks exactly like him on top of a roof, lying down, lying prone.
01:49:22 And they're going to have the moment of the shooting as well.
01:49:24 we've shown them just today we've shown on the audience of the video of the shooter then running
01:49:29 off the roof jumping down i mean this is very unusual jonna to have the entire crime
01:49:34 on tape like this is kind of a prosecution dream yeah it is because you can't swing a dead cat
01:49:42 without being on video these days and this is a classic circumstantial case and the fact that
01:49:48 it's a capital case doesn't change that i mean how often do we have uh criminal cases where we
01:49:54 see the person shoot the victim. It does happen sometimes, but it doesn't happen always. There
01:49:59 are plenty of other crimes where we have to piece it together because nobody is an eyewitness to the
01:50:04 actual event that is the crime. And this is going to be one of them. And again, here we here we are
01:50:10 in the in the preliminary stage, literally, of this case where, you know, I'm a little surprised
01:50:16 that the prosecutor isn't holding back something. They should really be doing a bare bones and not
01:50:22 allowing a five-day dog and pony show for the defense to set this up the way they're doing it.
01:50:27 I'm surprised that the prosecution is kind of playing into the defense's hand here that way.
01:50:31 There we go. Megan, that's the point. Two things that are very unusual. One,
01:50:36 Jonna making some metaphor about swinging a cat. I don't know what she's doing in her spare time.
01:50:41 Sorry. I don't get that. And number two, in reality, in real life, and Garagos, I'm sure,
01:50:49 would say the same and jonna this would be a two-hour hearing hearsay's admissible let's just
01:50:55 get through it did the crime probably occur is it probably him that's the lowest standard probable
01:51:01 cause we're done now i was okay with it because i was like god there's a lot of conspiracy theorists
01:51:09 out there they all think he's not guilty and then they start doing this trial and then the feedback
01:51:14 we're getting on social media and at my law firm where they're calling calling my assistant saying
01:51:19 I'm a nut for giving legal analysis, suggesting that there might be evidence that he's guilty.
01:51:24 People are either not watching or they don't want to hear. So what's the point? If it's not
01:51:29 helping the public, then get through it in two hours and prove it to a jury, which is the only 0.58
01:51:34 thing that damn matters. But interesting, you know, to the end, to the end on Kohlberger,
01:51:39 we had Kohlberger truthers. You know, the guy pleaded guilty to quadruple homicide.
01:51:46 and still we had truthers who were like no it wasn't him i was like yeah i in my experience
01:51:55 you just a true conspiracy theorist and not everybody who doubts tyler robinson's guilt
01:52:01 is a conspiracy theorist some some are but a true conspiracy theorist can never be convinced
01:52:06 out of the conspiracy it does not matter what you show to them so you raise an interesting point
01:52:12 that if if this really is for conspiracy theorists in the truest sense of that term,
01:52:18 they're wasting their time. But if it's for jury pool members who may just be confused or have
01:52:25 doubts and the prosecution's convinced if they see some of this tape, they won't have them and
01:52:30 could potentially serve once the jury is chosen. Maybe it's different. You know, I mean, that's a
01:52:35 miscarriage of justice. That shouldn't happen. The purpose should not be to poison the potential
01:52:40 jury pool. If it's to, you know, or I think they'd argue on poison. It shouldn't. It should
01:52:47 have nothing to do with that. It shouldn't. It shouldn't be to influence the jury pool in any
01:52:53 respect. That's not due process. Period. Go ahead, Garagos. Well, the the interesting thing is
01:53:00 I've I've evolved, if you will, on cameras in the courtroom. I now fervently believe that you should
01:53:09 have cameras in the courtroom for trials. I think that it's vital, especially what I call
01:53:15 supersized trials like this. You should have cameras in the courtroom. I think, and I agree
01:53:21 with Jonna and Mark, and actually Phil was also talking about it along with Dave, the prosecution
01:53:28 could put this case on in minutes. I wouldn't even say hours. I mean, I used to have a friend
01:53:35 who was a DA who used to see how few questions he could ask in order to get somebody held to
01:53:42 answer. And I think his winning one was, what happened next? What happened next?
01:53:47 Please hold the answer. But I think the prosecution's calculation is that they want
01:53:55 to make this appear to be a slam dunk case for whatever reason. I won't go into their motives,
01:54:01 because all this does is give the defense the ability to engage in what the defense should be
01:54:09 doing, which is exactly what they are doing during this preliminary hearing. What I do,
01:54:14 I'm sure what Mark and Jonna do. You presented with a series of witnesses, you're going to
01:54:20 question, you're going to test, you're going to push. However, to also their point, this is not
01:54:27 the trial. So it is improper to try to influence a jury pool. But from a defense standpoint,
01:54:35 that jury pool is overwhelmingly already has a prejudgment rate of guilt. The one kind of niche,
01:54:43 if you will, is kind of the, you call them the truthers, I would just call them the tinfoil 0.95
01:54:50 hat wearers who generally until they hear the words out of somebody's mouth do not believe it 0.98
01:54:58 no matter what you present and even then right ai generated not real yeah or or just like forced
01:55:06 into it under threat of what i don't know how people say kohlberger didn't you know it's like i
01:55:11 i'm done i don't feel the need to reason with those people you know it's like okay good take
01:55:16 care like believe whatever the hell you want i don't care he's in jail that's the important thing
01:55:20 It's actually, I think, to their point, I think the I think this backfires on the prosecution in a lot of ways.
01:55:27 Ultimately, it may not make any difference, but it certainly is not moving the ball forward for them in terms of those who believe he's guilty aren't going to come away from this having their minds changed.
01:55:40 those who i know conspiracy well that's that's what makes me sad because you know like i see
01:55:47 some of my friends like fervently retweeting some of these segments and these videos being like
01:55:52 you see and they're not showing it to their audience on x or elsewhere to show them what's
01:55:58 happening at the hearing to say this is what the prosecution has this is how they're stitching
01:56:02 together the case they're tweeting it to say this disproves this piece of whatever conspiracy theory
01:56:09 This disproves this. It's like you are wasting your time and your breath. Like one thing I know
01:56:17 from 20 plus years in news is there is no disproving a conspiracy theory in the mind of a
01:56:25 true conspiracy theorist. It's not possible. They will just continue moving the goalposts.
01:56:32 And then when you ask them to sit across from you and explain how it all went down,
01:56:38 like how was this person controlled by whom how would they argue this how how did they get control
01:56:45 what is the evidence of it how like they can't do it they will just get out of bounds because
01:56:50 it's just the way the mind works and part of the issue is we've had so many conspiracy theories
01:56:58 come true over the past few years you know like we we did find out that covid was from a lab
01:57:06 And it wasn't from a pangolin in some wet market. We were lied to about that. We did find out that
01:57:12 the vaccine caused myocarditis and other issues, especially in young teenage boys, which we were 0.98
01:57:18 fucking lied to about it. We did find out that the six foot rule of not getting close to one 0.89
01:57:22 another was totally made up and had no basis in science trademarked. We did find out that
01:57:28 Jay Bhattacharya was not some conspiracy theorist. He was a legitimate doctor who was raising real
01:57:34 concerns about whether we should just do focused protection on the elderly and not quarantine
01:57:39 masses, the masses across America and the globe. Like COVID in particular was it was an experience
01:57:45 in which conspiracy theories wound up all being true. And the real nutcases were the ones in
01:57:55 government power lying to us. There's a real hangover from that. Right. And like people
01:58:01 disbelieving official narratives. It's so true. As one who was litigating during that entire 0.62
01:58:10 COVID period, I mean, I remember the restaurants, outdoor restaurants, and having to fight that
01:58:17 fight and sue the government. And to quote Gorsuch, this idea that this case out of Boston,
01:58:23 Jacobson, U.S. Supreme Court case became a towering presence. The problem that COVID presented
01:58:29 is that people who are already had mental health issues,
01:58:34 it amplified those issues.
01:58:36 And people who didn't have mental health issues,
01:58:40 who were trying to rationally examine stuff,
01:58:44 were basically kind of forced in or lumped in with the others.
01:58:48 And it is unfortunate, COVID, to your point,
01:58:52 I mean, that was one of the best 90 seconds summaries
01:58:55 I've heard since listening to Carola talk about it,
01:58:58 The COVID did an enormous amount of damage to the U.S., and specifically in California, where I am.
01:59:10 California just became kind of unmoored from reality and rationality.
01:59:16 I mean, when you think back to bulldozing the beaches or arresting a guy on a paddleboard,
01:59:22 I mean, it sounds insane now, but at the time it was, you know, you were pilloried if you disagreed with it.
01:59:30 And that lays the foundation for now kind of this taking a circumstantial evidence case, which, by the way, the law says it.
01:59:39 There are two reasonable interpretations, the one that points towards innocence.
01:59:43 But we've lost kind of this ability collectively to believe what is reasonable or rational at a
01:59:52 certain level. There's a couple of other things just just to add, you know, the Epstein
01:59:57 controversy where people believe that there really was some elite cabal covering up for
02:00:03 other elites so that they wouldn't go down. And then there was a revolt when the administration
02:00:07 didn't want to release any more Epstein documents, but it was done. And look what happened.
02:00:11 A bunch of people went down. You know, that U.K. official, I don't remember his name, but he fell. The U.K.s had actually a lot more accountability on Epstein than we have over here in America. But look what happened with Bill Gates. He got humiliated. Some others got exposed. Obama's former White House counsel got exposed.
02:00:33 Like bit by bit, we did learn. No, there is a cabal of people who are very connected to him and seem like dirtbags who did deserve to be exposed.
02:00:43 And with more and more pushing, they were. But we were all told that's a conspiracy theory, too, about Jeffrey Epstein's like, OK, this is like it's just annoying.
02:00:54 And look, the thing on Israel, like that's underlying this whole thing.
02:00:58 And I feel like I'm in a unique position to speak to this because it's like Charlie and
02:01:04 I were completely aligned on Israel all along and up to the day he was killed, where we 0.59
02:01:09 were very, very pro-Israel, but we were starting to have doubts because of their behavior in 0.67
02:01:13 Gaza and how extended and egregious it was and just how the overkill, again, to use that
02:01:18 same word. 0.70
02:01:19 And we hadn't abandoned Israel as supporters, but we were becoming more critical.
02:01:23 And we both felt a need to make room in the GOP for Israel skeptics, which is what young Republicans feel that they're they're very skeptical, not of Israel and the Israeli people, but of this government and its behavior.
02:01:36 And Charlie was having doubts about Israel and was under pressure not to, not to abandon
02:01:44 Israel as a cause and is in writing.
02:01:48 And on the record with me on this show and elsewhere, not appreciating, appreciating
02:01:53 being called an anti-Semite, saying he might have to leave the Jewish cause entirely, saying
02:01:59 he wasn't going to submit to the pressure from certain Jewish donors to not waver at
02:02:04 all in Israel and that he didn't appreciate that at all. Correspondence directly with Netanyahu.
02:02:08 And so, look, understandably, some people are going to say, did they have a motive here?
02:02:15 I think that's a fair question. But now when we're getting into real live court,
02:02:20 where, as you three know better than anyone, we have to deal in evidence. This is not an OK time
02:02:27 for who who might have been on Charlie's bad side, who might have been threatened by Charlie,
02:02:32 who might have been mad at Charlie. We have to talk about evidence at this stage. It is time to
02:02:38 put up or shut up. And what we see is no evidence, no evidence that will lead us to believe anyone
02:02:46 other right now than Tyler Robinson was responsible for this cause. But I understand the skeptics. I
02:02:52 do, because I, as Charlie's friend, want every leaf to be turned over. And I've been fine with
02:02:59 doing that all along. But you know, this is where the rubber meets the road, right guys, where it's
02:03:04 like, in lots of cases, you have theories about who hated the decedent, who besides my client
02:03:12 wanted him dead. How could I potentially do a head fake or like point direction, you know,
02:03:18 for the jury members over there instead of at my guy. And the court won't allow you to do that
02:03:24 unless you have a good faith basis to do it
02:03:28 or actual evidence to justify it.
02:03:30 You can't just do wild goose chase over here
02:03:33 because I've got a suspicion.
02:03:35 That's just not how it works.
02:03:36 And in our discussions here,
02:03:38 I think it's really important we stay fact-based.
02:03:41 What's admissible?
02:03:42 What can they admit?
02:03:44 What is his defense team actually arguing?
02:03:47 They have a greater reason than anyone,
02:03:50 podcaster or otherwise,
02:03:51 to get the attention off of Tyler Robinson. And we haven't heard anything from that defense team,
02:03:58 which does seem talented about it not being Tyler. So anyway, thoughts on it, Megan, can I put I want
02:04:05 to put my tinfoil hat on for a minute and I never have a tinfoil hat. But just for argument's sake,
02:04:09 in terms of the evidence in this case and what will come forth, the one the chum, for lack of
02:04:16 a better word that i think conspiracy theorists can sink their teeth into that we know so far
02:04:21 are the weird text messages why because they're too detailed for somebody who wants to commit a
02:04:29 heinous crime and get away with it to be texting your your furry lover all of the details of the
02:04:35 grandfather's gun and this and here's where i put it and look under your keyboard and do all that
02:04:39 stuff when you know damn well as a 23 year old you know damn well that this information is gettable
02:04:45 Why would you almost give yourself up digitally if somebody weren't putting you up to?
02:04:53 Now, I don't believe that is the case.
02:04:55 But if I were a conspiracy theorist, I'm going to be hanging my hat on those text messages because there's just too much there there.
02:05:04 Also, so I have a dear friend who I love.
02:05:07 She's she's a doll and she tends to think more conspiratorially on some of these issues.
02:05:13 And she she keeps me abreast of what she's hearing and she thinks on this.
02:05:18 And I actually really appreciate it because it's a good window into, you know, how people who are very skeptical of the theory that Tyler Robinson did this are thinking.
02:05:27 And she just texted me that these messages are not believable and no one believes this is why he was taken out.
02:05:34 Um, it literally goes on from there, but those messages are a problem for people, um, who want
02:05:42 to convince us it was Tyler Robinson because they do, they sound fake. They just sound, they do,
02:05:47 they sound fake. They sound fake. And to John's point, guys, they do have, it's like a prosecution's
02:05:54 dream. It's my rifle. This is where I hit it. Remember when I engraved the bullets with the
02:06:01 following memes like it's it's exactly what you'd write if you wanted to ensure his conviction
02:06:06 well and then layer over that somebody else was there who gets carried off and arrested
02:06:14 who later confesses layer over that there are pre-existing chats that are memorialized in some
02:06:23 fashion which look to be a conspiratorial and you i i would not be so sure that in jury selection
02:06:36 you that a stealth juror this is usually the defense's worst nightmare but in this case it
02:06:43 could be just like in luigi the prosecution's worst nightmare they get a juror on yes not going
02:06:49 to buy anything that the prosecution is selling because it just looks too neat too convenient
02:06:55 and doesn't kind of answer all of the questions i have a theory megan let me tell you something
02:07:01 i have a theory they that i know i know a few people who are you know like my this one friend
02:07:07 who's very well off she's very successful um who i met years ago she was q anon she was part of q
02:07:17 like she believed all the theories about like the pizza place and the democrat like all of it
02:07:22 and um like pretty much every conspiracy theory and i never knew that eyeglarsh until she had a
02:07:28 dinner party at her house and we all went and she kind of started confiding in me and i remember
02:07:32 being shocked i'm like she she believes every single one of them i know a few people who are
02:07:37 like this and they are brilliant they are very successful this is not like there is a very good
02:07:45 chance a few of these will wind up wind up in the jury pool and being considered for the actual jury
02:07:51 here. This is something the prosecution absolutely has to be paying attention to. Sure. You listen,
02:07:58 we think we know people. We only know what they show us. And even then, you really never get down
02:08:05 to it. My theory in this case is that these defense lawyers are doing their job ensuring due process
02:08:12 by challenging every piece of evidence, by making all the right objections.
02:08:18 But, Megan, you're thinking, and many people are thinking, well, so what does this lead to?
02:08:22 What type of successful defense is that somehow leading to?
02:08:26 And I don't think that they even think that it's going to lead to that.
02:08:30 They're defining winning by doing everything they can to challenge the evidence.
02:08:34 And then ultimately, not not possibly, but when this judge says I'm finding probable cause, which is 100 percent certainty, they will then proceed to buy their, you know, their their their protective knee coverings, get down on their knees and beg the prosecution to consider waiving the death penalty.
02:08:55 And that, to me, would be a victory for the defense.
02:08:58 Prosecution has no reason, though, to do that.
02:09:01 I disagree.
02:09:02 unless erica kirk and charlie's parents wanted them to it starts there i haven't heard that
02:09:10 they're tremendous advocates for the death penalty so the fact that that door is even
02:09:14 cracked open a little bit means that there's a possibility that the door's not cracked open
02:09:19 erica kirk has said i don't want that on my conscience i don't want to be involved in that
02:09:24 okay like i'm leaving that that that means it's open megan in our business unless if you have a
02:09:30 victim saying, no, anything less than the death penalty, like the Parkland, Marjory Stoneman
02:09:35 Douglas parents, they wanted the death penalty for Nicholas Cruz. That was it. There was no
02:09:40 discussion about resolving it to a life sentence, which ultimately probably would have saved them a
02:09:44 lot of time and energy. In this particular case, there are more generic reasons. I don't disagree
02:09:50 with Jonna and those who think that the evidence is overwhelming. They'll get the conviction. But
02:09:54 you've got 12 jurors, all who must unanimously find that the aggravating circumstances are
02:10:01 greater than the mitigators. And death is very different. It's very unique. It takes one Utah
02:10:07 juror to say, yeah, I think that what he did was abhorrent, but I think you should live out his 0.88
02:10:13 days in jail, be worse for him, let him rot in prison. I'm not going to send him to death row
02:10:17 or whatever their reasons are. And so it's not a slam dunk. It's not a guarantee. What is a
02:10:23 guarantee is him saying I'm guilty. I'm waiving all my appeals. I don't want to have any more
02:10:29 notoriety. Not that he would say that, but we're saying that to him. Good riddance. Go away. No
02:10:34 more expense. No more time. No more energy. Guaranteed life sentence. And then he'll probably
02:10:39 think he's going to do it. I don't think he's going to I don't think he's going to do that
02:10:42 because his lawyer should talk. He thinks he's got a shot. I think he's got a shot. And I also
02:10:48 If you read those text messages, if that's really Tyler Robinson writing, he doesn't give a shit about dying. 0.98
02:10:53 He's like, if you read this, I'm either dead or I'm heading to prison for a long time. 0.99
02:10:58 I think he was prepared to die that day. 0.99
02:11:00 Go ahead, Garagos. 0.99
02:11:01 Things change.
02:11:02 The lawyers are not going to let him do it because absent agreement by DOJ.
02:11:08 Remember, unlike Luigi, where you have the federal backstop to the state, there is no double jeopardy.
02:11:16 If he pleads the DOJ to a life, the DOJ can come in instantly and just use that and go
02:11:23 go for broke.
02:11:25 And they would work that out, Garagos.
02:11:27 They would all work that out.
02:11:28 He wouldn't plead unless he knew that he's getting a pass in the fence.
02:11:30 This Department of Justice agreed to the pass.
02:11:35 I to me, that's they already.
02:11:37 I they won't.
02:11:39 Don Jr. is sitting in the front row of this preliminary hearing right now with his new
02:11:44 bride watching every moment.
02:11:46 He was extremely close with Charlie. There's zero chance. Imagine. Imagine a scenario worse than a five day preliminary hearing. Imagine five, 10 years down the road after he's convicted, after he's given the death penalty. The appellate court reverses based upon something that was done in jury selection, whatever it is. And then we come back and we do it all over again. That's possible.
02:12:09 Who cares?
02:12:10 Oh, OK.
02:12:11 So what?
02:12:11 Who cares?
02:12:12 Like, remember the outrage when Kohlberger was allowed to plead and didn't get the death
02:12:16 penalty, which he clearly deserved. 1.00
02:12:18 That was utter bullshit. 1.00
02:12:20 We can't be put in that same position. 1.00
02:12:22 Go ahead, Garagos.
02:12:22 I'm just going to say, remember the reason that the feds did not get involved in they
02:12:27 publicly said it's not like I'm talking directly to somebody who's confiding in me.
02:12:32 They said Utah's got a death penalty, unlike New York, where similar to California, the
02:12:38 death penalty basically does not exist. We came in in New York because of that. We didn't come in
02:12:45 to Utah because they mean it when they say they've got a death penalty. That's the backstop. That's
02:12:51 the only reason they didn't take federal jurisdiction over this. And Megan, a win for 0.62
02:12:58 the defense here is simply not getting a unanimous death verdict. That is a win for the defense.
02:13:04 I don't think they know they know they don't have a prayer of an acquittal. I don't see that happening any at any point. But if they have one juror who can't sentence to death, that is a win. And that might be a long plea, as we like to call it. And maybe that's the angle of this defense team at this point.
02:13:22 If I if I were the defense lawyer, I'd be going for jury nullification. I'd be going for hung jury. All I need is one who thinks that Tyler Robinson was manipulated, whether it was by the CIA and an MK Ultra, which I've seen that by Israel, who, you know, somehow swooped in and got and controlled his mind or he wasn't actually the shooter because there was the exploding microphone, whatever.
02:13:47 There's a lot of theories out there that I'm the defense lawyer.
02:13:50 I'm 100 percent going for that.
02:13:52 Like, I've got to find the one jury and I'd have to have a consultation with jury consultants.
02:13:57 Like, what should I look for?
02:13:59 Like, and Megan, raise your hand if you think we didn't land on the moon.
02:14:02 And you know what?
02:14:03 Like, I'd be looking for jurors who are like, yeah, Megan, you know why?
02:14:06 You know why there's typically two different lawyers on a death penalty case? 0.59
02:14:11 Because the one who would have to argue the garbage that you just talked about, the most 0.95
02:14:15 ridiculous theories which will land him with a conviction within an hour there'd have to be a 0.99
02:14:21 different person than to get up there and make arguments about why he should live instead of die 0.94
02:14:27 because the first lawyer explain this garagos made this point yesterday and we didn't really
02:14:31 flesh it out keep keep going why so describe exactly the position you'd be putting yourself
02:14:36 in so if you stood up there and your main defense was basically did like head fake over to mk ultra
02:14:42 the CIA, the FBI, Israel, whatever. Okay. I had a death case recently. I litigated it for five
02:14:48 years. Death, death, death. These Florida prosecutors wanted death. And quite frankly,
02:14:52 the facts probably warranted them. It was really that bad. It wasn't until the 11th hour,
02:14:58 ultimately, when we did motions and showed that like they're doing, they're talented lawyers,
02:15:04 they're fighters, whatever, that maybe that greased the wheels and ultimately we got what
02:15:08 wanted. But I couldn't have been the one if we actually went to trial to then make the arguments
02:15:13 about how he had a lack of prior record, how he had mental illness, how he said, God bless you
02:15:18 to a few people and helped them across the street, whatever you're going to throw out there to
02:15:21 mitigate. I shouldn't have been that same one because with the same mouth that that spewed
02:15:26 bullshit to try to convince them that they're innocent. I can't be the one trying to save his 0.99
02:15:31 life. Well, that far, I would say you're zealously defending in a guilt phase, and that's what the
02:15:38 client is entitled to, a zealous defense. And you're arguing they haven't proved their case.
02:15:45 I'm giving you an alternative explanation. I'm telling you this. I'm telling you that.
02:15:49 If a jury rejects that, which they must in order to get to the penalty phase,
02:15:54 they basically, there's an idea. You are the voice of the client. They've given you,
02:15:59 you're there they've already given you their verdict so to speak on your authenticity and
02:16:06 everything else then to get up and say hey i was just kidding let's talk about let's talk about
02:16:13 this that and the other thing and why you should um uh it's it's an impossible human situation i
02:16:19 think to navigate correct but wait why is it inconsistent to say uh okay tyler robinson didn't
02:16:26 do it. He didn't do it. Somebody else did it. Don't believe those tapes. We can't tell who that
02:16:31 is. This is bullshit. There's no hard proof. Somebody could have stolen that gun. His DNA's 1.00
02:16:36 on it because it's his gun, not necessarily because he shot it. And then they say, we disagree. He's
02:16:43 guilty. And then you get to the death penalty phase and you say, why is it inconsistent to say
02:16:48 Tyler Robinson is actually a really sweet guy. He spent, you know, 22 of his 23 years being a good
02:16:57 citizen, loving son, university. He got, he got manipulated, you know, by the internet. He got,
02:17:05 you know, pulled into assassination culture and, you know, don't hold that against him because
02:17:11 look, he was a boy scout and he did all these nice things. Because your credibility by that
02:17:14 point is out the window. You've challenged good, decent, honorable police officers. You're trying
02:17:21 to make X look like Y. Creating reasonable doubt could be really challenging, especially when
02:17:28 things are so straightforward and you have to convince jurors that they're not. What you're
02:17:32 seeing is not actually that straightforward. Someone manufactured the words that were allegedly
02:17:37 sent to his boyfriend. And then all of a sudden, you get up there with that same mouth and then
02:17:43 talk about actual things that he doesn't have a prior record, that he had some mental illness.
02:17:49 And here's the expert that claims that he that whatever you're going to put up there to mitigate,
02:17:53 it's very hard to do it with the same voice that that that minutes ago they were insulted by,
02:18:00 you know. But Megan, the the inconsistency. I'm just kind of laughing, picturing you.
02:18:04 I've never seen you uncomfortable. It would be kind of funny to see you actually feeling
02:18:09 uncomfortable. I wouldn't show it just on the inside because of that. But you're making your
02:18:14 case. I get it. I'm getting it. Go ahead, John. The inconsistency is baked into the cake, right?
02:18:19 Because when you have these death penalty cases and I'm trying to remember, I don't know if it's
02:18:23 Jody Arias or one of them and maybe even Scott Peterson, Garagos, where you put up a defense
02:18:28 because you truly believe that your client is innocent. And then in order to save their life,
02:18:33 they have to present the mitigating evidence or it's not going to happen. You have to you have
02:18:37 to the client sometimes themselves have to say, oh, yeah, I'm really sorry. After you spent days
02:18:43 or weeks or months trying to convince a jury that they're completely innocent in order to live,
02:18:49 they have to now kind of admit their guilt is still trying to convince us that Scott Peterson
02:18:55 is innocent. We can't use that as an example. He still thinks he's going to be home in time
02:19:01 for Christmas. Wait, I wanted to tell you guys something is happening in court right now that
02:19:05 relevant to the very discussion that we're having. Um, there, there's a debate about whether they can
02:19:13 read, um, the testimony of, okay, I want to make sure it's a pastor. The prosecution wanted to read
02:19:25 the testimony of pastor David Englehart about Christian belief. The, this is via the Federalist
02:19:32 and its correspondent in court reckon these from Englehart about Christian belief, the beliefs and
02:19:39 goals of Turning Point USA and the religious and political beliefs of Charlie Kirk. The defense
02:19:44 objected. This is another defense lawyer named Novak who says the state is using this testimony
02:19:51 in a way to get the quote victim targeting enhancement to lay the groundwork for Robinson's
02:19:58 reasons for targeting Kirk specifically. Novak argues that political expression is outside the
02:20:03 statutory relevance needed, which is separate and distinct from a personal attribute. Do you
02:20:08 understand what he's saying? Does anybody know what that means? For the special, I assume for
02:20:12 the special circ, and he's saying the special circumstance that's attached to the murder,
02:20:17 which makes him death penalty eligible. And he's arguing that you can't use.
02:20:22 Like a personal attribute would be he's gay and he got targeted for being gay or he's black and
02:20:27 he got targeted for being black, as opposed to he was a Christian who was religious. I think that's
02:20:33 okay. I get it. I think that's what the argument is over. And then here's the quote from defense
02:20:39 attorney Novak. I understand in today's world that there is a crossover between religion and
02:20:44 politics. I think we can all acknowledge that, but the legislature and the information here are
02:20:49 focused on political expression. So I'm concerned that this affidavit statement of Mr. Englehart
02:20:55 goes far beyond the scope of what would be admissible if the state has it to prove that
02:20:59 Mr. Robinson targeted Mr. Kirk because of Mr. Robinson's belief or perception concerning Mr.
02:21:06 Kirk's political expression. This is not a case about religion, Novak said. Novak said the evidence
02:21:12 the state needs to provide is not what Kirk believed, but rather what was in Mr. Robinson's
02:21:19 head. So he did not want the affidavit to come in. And it looks like he has succeeded in that
02:21:28 because the update was Judge Graff for now has sustained Novak's objection, meaning the state
02:21:36 prosecutor cannot read directly from Englehart's testimony. Quoting from it in open court, I fear
02:21:41 does risk issues to the constitutional rights of the parties, said the judge. They're talking about
02:21:46 closing the court down so that prosecutor mcbride can refer directly to the testimony the state does
02:21:52 not want to do so mcbride says he believes the defense is trying to shut down the openness of
02:21:56 the proceedings so that the public cannot hear it news media attorney because we also have our
02:22:01 own lawyer and they're arguing for our rights uh raymond is arguing that just because an exhibit
02:22:05 could be inadmissible does not mean the public cannot see it my god there's so many layers to
02:22:09 this this is crazy but this is all about the death penalty right this is all about whether this i
02:22:16 I admire this. That would make it a death penalty. And I like this. I like this judge putting aside
02:22:22 whether I'm OK with the ruling because I don't have all the facts surrounding it. I love that
02:22:26 he's calling balls and strikes and not just appearing to be a judge who's ready to do that,
02:22:32 pretending to do that, and then just ruling in favor of the prosecution for everything.
02:22:36 He really does seem to want to hear from both sides. He does seem like he cares about the rule
02:22:42 of law and i admire him not everything should come in well i have to say it's been it's it's
02:22:47 been actually very telling because usually this nester objects to everything the woman that's her 0.99
02:22:51 job that's her job and no it's annoying though if she does this in front of a jury they're going to 1.00
02:22:56 hate her because juries don't like a non-stop i realize she's got a life to save yeah and delay
02:23:01 works in her favor the every day this thing goes on is another day he's alive it's different but i
02:23:05 know. But like I'm I'm a jury and I hate her. I'm just saying, like, she's alienating. You ain't 0.94
02:23:13 making it on, babe. But she but then he says the judge says, OK, I'll hear argument. You know,
02:23:23 she may. And she's like, I stand on my objection. She has no argument. It's like the prosecution's
02:23:29 like, great, let's argue it. I'm happy to argue. She's doing her job. She's doing her job so that
02:23:34 not if, but when he possibly gets death, they're going to go back and say, did he have
02:23:38 effective assistance of counsel? And yeah, she's making all the possible legal objections.
02:23:44 And then this is all good.
02:23:45 Her job be to like, give him, give him that defense by not doing, not crossing every T
02:23:49 or dotting every I like surreptitiously blowing things. So he could argue. I basically, what is
02:23:54 it? I AC go ahead, Garrett goes. Yeah, but no, it's not. It's not our job to purposely take a
02:24:00 dive though right we just got to make sure she'll get lucky like like alec murdoch and they'll have
02:24:06 a court clerk who will unduly influence the jury and that's a good strategy count on that yeah go
02:24:13 ahead john we you know let's hope that the angle here isn't to get rid of the the thing that makes
02:24:19 this an aggravated murder because without that there is no death penalty and then the defense
02:24:24 will have one at the end of this what is going to be a lengthy prelim so hopefully the prosecution
02:24:29 has more than one ground for its aggravation in the way that it charged this case.
02:24:35 Yeah. Hey, were there kids in attendance? How old were they? Okay, there you go. Isn't that one?
02:24:40 Yeah. Well, that's what I mean. He killed them across a crowd. That should be one.
02:24:44 So there should be other choices for the prosecution here.
02:24:49 Yeah. Besides whatever Christian affiliation or one's political beliefs,
02:24:53 which clearly is the motivation. If Tyler did this, it's in writing. But yeah, they have on
02:25:00 the witness list, I think a picture of a mother with a baby in a baby stroller. So they clearly
02:25:07 are going to try to argue that children were present at the time that this disgusting event
02:25:15 happened. So we won't be surprised if we see that. So, all right. In sum, we think the prosecution's
02:25:21 getting it done. They could have gotten it done in two hours. Everything beyond that is probably
02:25:26 an attempt to manipulate the public narrative, which I think is unacceptable. I think it's
02:25:31 unpoisoning the poisoned well just to try to get us back to neutral in the same way the prosecutor
02:25:36 felt he had to come out to say, wait a minute, the Daily Mail report about the bullet not matching
02:25:41 is not correct. It couldn't conclusively be matched, but it wasn't not matched either.
02:25:48 we just couldn't tell it was blown to such smithereens that we weren't able to say one
02:25:52 way or another i think he's trying to do that in his presentation here to unpoison the poisoned
02:25:58 well as opposed to poison it or put his finger on the scale for himself so that's where it stands 0.78
02:26:04 we think it will be held over hey wait wait megan hates the defense lawyer you didn't include that 0.98
02:26:09 in the summation we covered that um yes megan thinks that if she i do she's very annoying right 1.00
02:26:13 And if she objects like that in front of the jury, she'll turn them all off. 1.00
02:26:16 Got that right.
02:26:18 And she says, um, every two seconds.
02:26:20 She's not articulate. 0.98
02:26:21 She's not.
02:26:21 I mean, it's just not impressed with her.
02:26:22 I don't like unimpressive.
02:26:23 All right.
02:26:23 Just add that to the to the summation of what we've discussed.
02:26:27 Yeah.
02:26:27 And she blew it on that on that. 1.00
02:26:29 What's the woman who poisoned her husband? 1.00
02:26:31 The fentanyl poisoner. 1.00
02:26:33 Oh, yeah.
02:26:35 Corey Richens.
02:26:36 She represented her.
02:26:36 Corey Richens.
02:26:37 Corey Richens.
02:26:38 Yeah.
02:26:39 She blew that one. 1.00
02:26:40 That was probably.
02:26:41 I don't know if that was winnable.
02:26:43 But I think Garagos could have walked out with a with an acquittal.
02:26:46 There we go. But she she couldn't defense.
02:26:49 She's doing a more than workmanlike job. Number one.
02:26:52 There we go. It's also it's incredibly stressful for a lawyer to be on camera performing, even correct.
02:27:01 But that adds another layer to it. So not for us.
02:27:05 Megan, did I ever tell you one time I had a judge chastise me for objecting too much?
02:27:10 she actually told me to stop objecting i didn't listen but i don't blame her yeah i must have
02:27:17 annoyed her too yeah i don't i don't blame her it's like at that point you just have to have
02:27:23 like blanket blank i get it you object to literally every question your rights are preserved for
02:27:27 appeal sit down and be quiet and let the thing go forward at one point this judge is going to
02:27:32 have to do that to nestor because this cannot keep going like this i i realize you know delay
02:27:37 is in her favor but it's gotten to the point of like you want to you want to give her a little
02:27:40 a little backhand um okay i gotta go you guys thank you all so much for your commentary everybody
02:27:46 be sure to check out mk true crime and subscribe to in the well with garagos and matt murphy and
02:27:52 positively legal uh as well as our mk true crime show which is sort of the name brand there anyway
02:27:58 lots of true crime offerings and they've been all over this case um this week and will continue to
02:28:05 be as well. I got to say, it's been, it's been kind of crazy to watch Erica have to sit through
02:28:12 this and have to deal with all of this. And I really, really wish that the people who have
02:28:19 doubts about Erica Kirk would just keep them quiet this week. I mean, whether you like her
02:28:26 or you don't like her, hopefully the human inside of you can see how difficult this is
02:28:31 for her and the family to sit in there and have to listen to this and have to be feet away from
02:28:39 Tyler Robinson. And then soon the videotape of the lover and they're removing themselves for
02:28:46 the most graphic pieces of the testimony, but they're hearing enough. This is going to be
02:28:51 intensely upsetting. And every night Erica goes home to Charlie's two children who have no father
02:28:58 and still has to struggle with helping them understand what happened to him.
02:29:04 It's just beyond human what is being asked of the family.
02:29:08 And I beg for you to keep them in your prayers.
02:29:12 Infuse them with strength, with some sort of serenity to get through this,
02:29:17 with the ability to keep this in perspective.
02:29:21 You know, as Erica said from the beginning,
02:29:22 that the real judgment is going to come from God,
02:29:25 not from this judge, not from the eventual jury.
02:29:28 and that's really what Tyler Robinson should be thinking about each night. That's what should
02:29:35 disturb his sleep night after night, answering to his maker. You know, his lawyer may be able
02:29:41 to spare him some penalty here or possibly in his best case scenario, even a finding of guilt,
02:29:47 though I doubt it. But Tyler Robinson and anybody else who is connected with this crime are going
02:29:53 to have to answer to their maker eventually. And from that, they cannot be spared. None of us can.
02:29:58 Anyway, I'm thinking a lot about Charlie this week, as I know you have. It's very hard to talk
02:30:06 about this case forensically without remembering it's Charlie. Talking about Charlie, you guys
02:30:12 know that better than anybody. The listeners to this show, the viewers of this show saw more of
02:30:18 Charlie than virtually any other audience did besides his own. All these people out there
02:30:26 talking about Charlie, you saw him regularly. You listened to him regularly. If you watch and
02:30:33 listen to this show and you knew a lot about Charlie Kirk, his character, his personality,
02:30:38 what mattered to him. And I'm sure you're feeling it too. I'm sure you're feeling an intimate
02:30:43 connection to this case because you do feel that connection to him. This is like, you know,
02:30:49 the guests who come on this show are like family. They're family, like family to me. And I'm sure
02:30:53 you feel that as well. So keep his family in your mind and in your prayers. And thank you for that.
02:30:59 Thank you for trusting us with the coverage of it as well. We will continue to stream the entire
02:31:04 preliminary hearing on our YouTube channel. That's youtube.com slash Megan Kelly. And we'll be back
02:31:09 tomorrow with more legal analysis and other news. We'll see you then. Thanks for listening to the
02:31:15 Megan Kelly show. No BS, no agenda, and no fear.
02:31:23 You