00:21:31On cross-examination, the prosecution asks Scheipz whether there is a greatest sin, a sin above others, and in a courtroom where a man is on trial for murdering his family, allegedly because he could not bear the shame of their lowered station or their descent into perceived debauchery, the minister thinks about it for a few seconds and then quotes C.S. Lewis.
00:21:56Pride, he says, pride is the greatest sin.
00:21:59On April 12, 1990, after seven days of testimony, the jury of nine men and three women steps out
00:22:07of the courtroom to decide John List's fate. Everyone expects the verdict to be quick.
00:22:13Reporters have a betting pool going. Some predict it will take less than 60 minutes,
00:22:17but that's not what happens. There is a holdout on the jury, a lone person who still is not
00:22:24convinced about John List's state of mind. The jurors send the judge a note asking him to define
00:22:30willful, premeditated, and deliberate. Then another note, and another. Then they ask for
00:22:36two packs of cigarettes. The jury deliberates for six hours the first day and then goes home
00:22:42to sleep on it. Could this one holdout really deadlock the case? Could the man who signed and
00:22:47dated a five-page detailed confession and tucked it in a drawer next to the murder weapons actually
00:22:53go free on a hung jury? By lunch the next day, the jury has reached a verdict. What turns the
00:23:01holdout, the foreman tells reporters afterward, is a single line in John List's letter. The line
00:23:07where List explains that he had originally planned the murders for November 1st, All Saints Day,
00:23:13because he thought it an appropriate day for his family to get to heaven, then that travel
00:23:18arrangements delayed him. A man who reschedules is a man who deliberated. The jury declares him
00:23:25guilty on five counts of murder in the first degree. John List hears it stone-faced, staring
00:23:31straight ahead, motionless. Because New Jersey had no death penalty on its books in 1971,
00:23:39the sentence is capped at life without parole. The irony, of course, is that John List did not
00:23:45actually spend his life in prison, he has gotten away with his crimes for 18 years of freedom.
00:23:52On May 1st, 1990, Superior Court Judge William Wertheimer hands down the maximum punishment
00:23:58available to him. He will later reread his sentencing statement aloud for the New Jersey
00:24:04media podcast covering the List case, Father Wants Us Dead. His acts stand as a permanent,
00:24:10pathetic, and profane example of the potential of man's inhumanity to man.
00:24:15They will not be soon or easily forgotten, and the name of John Amell List will be0.91
00:24:20eternally synonymous with concepts of selfishness, horror, and evil.
00:24:25Judge Wertheimer calls List a man without honor.
00:24:28He tells the courtroom that after 18 years, five months, and 22 days, it is time for the
00:24:33voices of Helen, Alma, Patricia, Frederick, and John Jr. to speak from the grave.
00:24:40But I thought it was appropriate that each of the victims had their own sentence.
00:24:44I ran consecutively so he wasn't going to get out. Five consecutive life terms, one after the other
00:24:52and one for each member of the family so that justice for one victim is not folded into justice
00:24:58for anyone else. List is offered the chance to speak. He stands and takes it. I remain truly
00:25:06sorry for the tragedy that happened in 1971. I feel that due to my mental state at the time